P u rsuan t t o 5 T H C IR . R. 47. 5, t h e courtha s det erm i n ed that t h i s opi n i on * shou l d n otbe pu bl i shedan d i s not preceden texcept u n der t h e l i m i t ed c i r c um s t anc e s s e tf

o r t h i n 5 T H C IR . R. 47. 5. 4. 

### INTHE UNITED S TATESCOU RT OFAPPEALS

FORTHEFIFTH CIRCU IT

N o. 08- 30599 Su m m ar y Cal endar

UN I TE D S TA TE S OF AM ERI CA P l ai n t if f

- A pp el l ee

v. D A N N YM D A U G H E R TY , al soknow n as D an D augher t y D e fe nda nt
- Appe l l ant

A pp ealf

rom t h e U n i t ed S t ates D i st ri ctC ou rt f orthe E as t er n D i st r i c tof Loui si ana U SD C N o. 2: 07- C R

- 184- 1

B e fo r e G A R Z A , D e M O S S , a n dC L E M E N T , C ir c u it J u d g e s . P E R C U R IA M: * D a n n y M
. D a u gh ertyplea d edgu i l ty, pu r s u a n t t o aplea ag ree m en t, to t h ree c ou n t s of

produ ct i on of

chi l d p ornograp h y an d on e coun tof possess i on of
c hi l d p o r no gr ap hy. H e w asse nt e nc e d t o a t o t alof 2 10 m o nt hs o f

i m pr i s o nm e nt
an d to a l i fe t erm of

sup ervi sed rel ease. In h i s agreem en t , D au gh ert y reserved t h e ri gh tt o a pp ealthe di st ri ctcou rt ’ s den i alof hi s m ot i on t o sup press evi den ce. H e a r gue s t hatt he di s t r i c tc o ur te r r e d b y f i ndi ng t hatt h e sei z ur e o f t he United States Court of App eals

Fifth Circuit 

### F I LE D Ma rch 26, 2009 Cha rl es R. F ulb ru g e II I ClerkN o. 08- 30599

2 com pu t er andha rd drive f rom hi s r esi den ce fel lw i t h i n t h e pl ai n vi ew doct ri n e. H e al so asser t s th at th e di st ri ctcourterr ed i n f i n di n g t h at p ro b a b le c au se exi st ed to sei ze t h e com pu t er andha rd drive. I n r evi ew i ng t he deni al of a m ot i on t o suppr es s, t he di st r i c tc our t ’ s fac t ual f i n di n gs are r evi ew ed f or cl ear error an d it s l egal concl u si on s, . . . are r evi ew ed d e n o v o .” Un i t ed S t ate s v. Ja cqu i n ot , 2 5 8 F
. 3 d 4 2 3 , 4 2 7 -28 (5th C i r. 2 0 0 1 ). A fac t ualf

i ndi ng i s notc l ear l y er r oneo us i f i ti s pl ausibl e i n l i ghtof t he r ec or d as
aw h o le
. I

d. Th e evi den ce presented ata sup pressi on hea ri n g m u stbe vi ew ed i n the l i gh t m ost fav ora b l e to th e p rev a i l i n g pa rty, i n this case , the G ov ern m en t. I d. A s t o hi s argum en tregardi n g pl ai n vi ew , t h e di st ri ctcourtdeter m i n ed t hatt he s e i z u r eo f

th epo r no gr ap hi ci m ag e s c o nt ai ne d i n t he a lbum s f o und i ns i de D au gh ert y’ s r esi den ce f el lw i t h i n t h e pl ai n vi ew d oct ri n e, b u tn otthe com pu t er a n dh a r dd r iv e . R a th e r , t h e d is tr ic t c o u r t d e te r m in e dth a t t h e s e p o r n o g r a p h ic im a g e s , c o m b in e dw it h D a u g h e r t y ’s c h a n g e in d e m e a n o ru p o n t h e o ff ic e r ’s di scovery of

t h e i m ages, an d h i s r epea t ed att em pts t o tu rn o ff t h e l ap t op com pu t er, provi dedt h e of f i cers w i t h suff

i ci en t proba bl e cau se t o sei ze t h e l ap t op a n dh a rddr ive pe n d i n g a sea rch w a rra n t. D au gh ert y al so c on t en ds t h at th e di st ri ct cou rt ’ s probable cau se de t e r m i nat i o n was e r r o neous be c aus e t he r e w as no e vi de nc e t hatl i nke d the p orn og ra p h i c i m a ge s t o h i s com p u ter. H e fur th er co n ten d s th a t his de sire t o t ur n o f f hi s c o m put e r “ c o ul d hav e be e n ba s e d o n c o m pl e t e l y l e git i m at e c o nc e r ns

. . . [s in c e ] [c ]o m p u te r s co n ta in aw e a lth o f p r iv a te in fo r m a tio n .” D aughe r t y’ s ar gum e ntl ac ks m e r i t
. Tes t i m o ny att he sup pr e s s i o n he ar i ng sup ported a f

i n di n g t h at i t w as ap pa rent t h at t h e pornog raph i c i m ages h adbeen dow n l oad ed f

rom a com pu t er du e t o t h e i n t ernet andem ai ladd ress pri n t ed on t h e backsi de of

the i m ages. D au gh ert y ad m i t t ed ow n ershi p of t h e albu m s w h ere t h e i m ages w ere f

ou n d. A s s oon as he w as con f ronted w i t h t h e albu m s, D a u g h e r tya tt e m p te ds e v e r a l tim e s to tu r n o ff th e la p to p t h a t w a s o n inh isN o. 08- 30599

3 of f i ce. Fu rt h erm ore, he becam e vi sibl y n ervous as of f ice rs searc h ed h i s of f i ce t hat c o nt ai ne d t he c o m put e r e quipm e nt
. The e vi de nc e i nt r o duc e d att he he ar i ng ref l ect s th at th ere w as a fairpr o babi l i t y t h at th e com pu t er D au gh ert y att em pted t o t u rn of

f contai n ed m ore porn ograp h i c i m ages. A ccor di n gl y, t h e di st ri ctcourt di d no tc l e ar l y e r ri n it s pr o babl e c aus e de t e r m i nat i o n a nd i n de nyi ng D a u g h e r ty ’ s m o tio n to s u p p r e s s . Se ei d. T h e ju d g m e n t o f th e d is tr ic t c o u r t is AF F I RMED.