07/28/201 0 1G:2 0 FAX202493514 2 

### FA A > DM S 001/OO G

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 :12 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 ? 1 ? 2 ? ? 2 4 2 b ? 6 2 7 2 8 Charle s M
. rinkel , 5B N10167 3 KLftGANA , CATHCAK T i MCCARTH Y 180 1 Avenu e o f th e Stars , 3te . 60 0 Lo s Angeles , C A9006 7 310.553.663 0 - 310.407.229 5 (Fax )

Attorne yto r Respondent(s ) •••"••< tfUL /



### . ^ 7201 0

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D. C
i nLh e MaLLa r oL" : ORIGINA L PRODUCTIONS , LLC ,

Responden t FA ADOCKE T NO . CP10ALOOO 2 (Civi l Penalt yAction ) DM S No . FA A2010-062 1 Judge : Honorabl eRichar dc . cioodw-l n

ANSWE RT O COMPIAIW T Respondenc , ORIGINA L PKODUCiiONS , LLC , b yan d throug hit s attorne yo f record , an d pursuant , l a1 4 CFP . §13.209 , hereb y ,nriTiiMRr." i t-.h

RComplain t o f

i-h e FedF^ra l A^riatio nAdministratio n dflLcr dJul y2 , 2 010 . A.- s I " p^r-.l

nn'.irnbi=rRH . pn.Ta.g-rap ho f the . Complaint , Responden t an.fswer, ? a ? f o.l.l.ciw,'? : 1 . Deny . 2 . Deny . 3 . Deny . 4 . Admi t t-.ha

t T.,ithiu

mB&LLerie a ar e identifie dunde r th e Hazardou s Material s Table . :iJ >

AtJSWL K

T O COMFLAIN T 

### a^fin/^a ^07/28/201 0 ie:2 0 FA X202493514 2 

### FA A + DM S 0002/00 6

3

7

9 1 0 1 1 1 2

1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 ?.?
. 2 3 7 4 ?.r j

2 / ? 0 5 . Admi L tha t Lif e Savin g Appliances , SGI I Inflating , ar e

iHp,Til,.-i.tie

d unde r th e Hazardou s Marerial s Taln.lR . 6 . DPTiy , 7 . Admi t tha i "Alcoholi c Beverages " ar e Identifie d urirJe r th e Hei^ardoui ? Material s T^ble . 6 . Deny . 9 . Deny . 10 . Dcny
11 . Dcny
12 . Deny . 13 . Deny . 14 . Deny . 15 . Dsny . 16 . Dsny . 17 . Deny . 18 . Deny , 19 . Deny . 20 . D«;iy . 21 . Deny . Respondiin t furthe r dtnie.' i eac han d ever yvlolario n o f Inwa s state d i n paragr.^ph s (a ) throug h(v ) . A S affirmativ e defenses , Responden t allege s a s follow.? ; Fo r a F1 r.q

t Affirmativ e Defense ; Th e rir.tion

s a s allege d i n th e Complaint wer e i n far. t rflrried ou t b ya . thir d part ywh o wa s no t employe d byRespandent , hu t rathe r wai i actin g a s a n indspenden t contractor .

ANSWE RT O COMPLAIN T07/28/201 0 1G:2 0 FAX202493514 2 FA A -* • DM S @1003/00 G

1 2 3

L
• J 6 7 8 9 •10 1 1 1 2 1 3 .U l 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 0 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2A 2. 4 2 G 2 7 2 9 Fo r Q Secon d AttirmBtiv e Defense :

Th e Complain t fail s t o se t i'Orthfact s t o suppor t a civi l penalt yi n th e amoun t o f $195,000 . Fo r a Thir d Affirma_tivc_pe_fen_3e : Acivi l penalt yi n th e amoun t o f ?195,00 0 i s no t appropriat e i n thi s case . Fo r a Third_Affirmative_Defen3e : Responden t ha d n o knowledg e o f an yviolation s o f Hazardou s Materia l Regulations , an d di d no t ratif yan yconduc t o f other s wh.lc hwoul d mak e i t liabl e fo r civi l penalties . fo r a Fourt hAffirmativ e Defense : I n th e even t i t i s determine d tha t violation s o r Hazardou s Materia l Rogulation e di d i nfac t occur , mitigatin g circumstance s exis t e o a t o warran t eithe r n o civi l penalty , o r a r th e ver y least , a civi l penalt ymuc hles s tha nth e ?195,000.0 0 soughr . b y Ch e Complaint . Fo r a Fift hAffirinatlv e Defense

Th e revenue s earne d b yResponden t i nconjunctio n wit hth e activitie s t o whic hth e allege d violation s occurre d amoun t t o onl yapproximatel y350,000 , malcin g th e sanctio n o f .•;" ; 19.5,00 0 unnecessaril yan d unreasonabl yburdensome , oppressive , an d unconstitutional . / / / / / y IJJ II/ / / / / / /

- AMSWE RT O COMPLAIN T07/28/201 0 18:2 0 FAX202493514 2 FA A + DM S E1004/00 6

1 7

. 3 / \ F J 6 7 

### e 9 1 0 1 1 ^7
. \ ^ 1 4 l b 1. 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 OX ) 2 1 2 2 23 2 4

2 6 2 7 2 8 WHEREFORE , Responden t respectfull yrequest s that there , b e n o penalt yassesse d agains t Respondent . Alternatively , i f violation s ar e foun d t o hav e occurre d fo r whic hRe.?ponden t i. s l.ia.blf!; , that th e penalt yD C significantl yreduced . MAGZ\5lA , CATHCABT,^^-^Ci7ARTH Y

DA T 

# ED:^2/-/fe > CHARLE S M . FINKE L Attorne yfo r Re.'^pondent

ANSWE RT O COMPLAIN T07/28/201 0 18:2 0 FA X202493514 2 

### FA A + DM S glOOS/OO G

1 2 3 4 5 6 / 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 IS ) 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 gROO F O F SERVIC E STAT E O F CALIFORNIA , COUNT YO F LO. ^ ANGFLE. 5 1 a mertiployedi n th e Count yo f Ln s Angeles , Stat e o f Ca l .i..r'nrnla . I a move r th e ag e o f I Ran d no t a part yt o Lhrs with-i. naction ; m ybu.iTnea s addres s i s 160 1 Avenu e o f th e .stars , Suit e <i00 , Lo s Angele.q , Californi a 90057-.bg.0t) . O nJul y21 , 2010 , i .^etr^a dth e forogoin qdocumen t describe d as : ANSWE RT O COMPLAIN T o nal l intereste dparlie s i n thi s actio nb yplacin g tru e copie s thereo f enclo.^pr i i n seale denvelop e (s ) addresse da s followa : SE E ATTACHE D MAILIN GLIS T [X ] B YMAIL ; i s m"readil ylamiliar " wit hth e firm'.- i practic e o f collectio nan d p.rnrep.si.n g correspondenc e fo r mailing . Unde r tha t practice , i t woul db e deposite dKit hth e U.S . pn.sta l .servic e o n tha t sam e H^ ywit hpostag e thereo nfull yprepai d R t Lo s Angeles , Californi a i n th e ordinar ycours e o f bu.-^lneaB . Ia mawar e tha t n nmotio nn f th e part yserved , np.r\r\c: ei s presume dinvali di f posta l cancellatio ndat e o r postage , mete r dat e i ^mor p tha non e da yafte r dat e o f lippo.si L fo r mailin g i n affidavit . t ] B YJTAX : I n addition , i f a chec)< . mar k i s place dnex t t o a FA> f number , I cause dal l page.' S o f th e above-entitle ddocumen t (a ) l.c i h p ,?en

L t o th e recipien t (s ) note dvi a electroni c tran.'sfc r (K.AX ) a t th e respectiv e fa xnumber s Indicate dabove . [ ] B XPERSONA L SERVICE : I f a n a.?tcri..•^ ^ i s place dbefor e an y name , I delivere dsuc henvelop e b yhan dt o th e recipien t noted .

Execute do n Jul y21 , 2010 , a t Lo s Angelas , California . fX ] jS.tat* : 1 decl.ii.r F unde r penalt yo f perjur yunde r th e law s o ± th e fStat Go f Californi a tha t th e abov e .1 ^tru e an d correct . I 1 Federal : I declar e tha t I a memploye di n th e offic e o f a membe r o f th e ba r o f thi. ' servic e wa s made . 

### Charle s H/'Finlcp l07/28/201 0 18:2 0 FA X202493514 2 FA A + DM S 121008/00 8

3 4

7

9 1 0 1 1 1 2 ] 3 I' ] 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 20 2 1 2 2

2 4 2 5 ? 6 2 7 MAILIN GLIS T

Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Wilbu r mrighi : Buildin g -Suit e 2W100 0 Wa.shington , DC 2059 1 Attn : Hearin g Dockel ; Clerk , AGC-^3 0 (Certifie d Mai l - Retur n Receipt Requested ) (Origina l an d On e Copy ) Nrinmi

. T.'^pdfl , F.'sq

. 

### Lierr c Creen , F.sq
. Ot-fic e n fth p Regiona l Counse l H.U

. BO

X9<iUU 7 Lo s Angele."^ , CA90009-200 7 (Copy ) Th e Honorabl e R.i.clM.rr i C . Goodwi n Oflic Go f Hearing.^ , M-2U 120 0 Ne wJ'ftr.'=ie

yAveni.i(? , fl.tl
. Eas t Buildin g Groun d floo r Roo m F12-32 0 Washington , D C 2 0 5 9 0 (Copy )

2 8