RE:2010ICRtestdataConradChinto:LauraK.McAfee08/14/201201:47PMChuckFrench,DarcieSmith,“BethFriedman’,JamesHagedorn,Cc:“Robertson,James”,JonathanAverback,jskonrady,nelson.brad,“RichardLunn”,thillier,“Jarrett,JamesF”,‘Chakrabarty,RenuM”8cc:ConradChinHistoriThismessagehasbeenforwarded.GoodafternoonLauraIpromisedyouIwillsharewithyouonouruniverseofavailabletestdataforthethreeFelmanfurnaces,whichwewillthenusetoestimatethebaselinestackemissions.MycontractoratEC/Rhascompletedthistask,andthefileisattached.First,aboutthe“significantconcernsabouttheICRdata”thatFelmanhasraised“fromthebeginning”,IassumeyouarereferringtotheFurnace#22010ICRdata.Wedonotknowwhatyourconcernsare.WealsodonothaveanydocumentationaboutthisconcernuntillastFriday.IfFelmancanprovidethedocumentationtous,Iwouldappreciateit.ForFurnace#2,wehaveatotalof2testdata,withtestsconductedin2009and2010respectively.Inreviewingthe2010Furnace#2ICRdata,wenoticedtheaverageparticulateemissionwas4.65lb/hr.Thisisalmosttwotimeshigherthanthe2009testsat2.06lb/hr.However,the2010testhadanaveragegrainloadingof0.001,andthisemissionconcentrationissimilartotheothertwofurnaces.Withoutmorespecificsonyourconcerns,weintendtoaveragethetwotestsincalculatingthestackemissionsforFurnace#2.WealsohavethreetestsforFurnace#5(10/2007,11/2008,and11/2009).ForFurnace#7,wehavethreetestsaswell(10/2007,11/2008,and11/2009).TheOctober2007testforFurnace#7hadunusuallyhighemissions(134lb/hr).Weconcludedthistestdataisinvalid,andwillnotincludethistestinourdatabase.Weintendtoaverageallthevalidtestsforthetwofurnaces.WealsohavetestsummariesforFurnaces#5and7testedinNovember,2010.ThetestsummarieswereprovidedbyWVDEP.WehavebeendiscussingwiththeWVcolleaguesonthetestresults.Wethinktheremighthavebeensomemix-upontheairflowcalculations.Ifweareabletocorrectthecalculations,wewillincludetheNovember2010tests.Otherwise,wewillexcludethem.Insummary,weareplanningtheprojectactivitiesbasedontheassumptionofaDecemberpromulgationdeadline.Unlessyoucanprovidethedetailsonwhythe2010ICRtestisinvalidbythisThursday,wewillincludeitinourdatabase.Thankyouandbestregards,iiFelmanPMData82012.xlsxConradK.ChinMailCodeD243-02MetalsandMineralsGroupSectorPoliciesandProgramsDivisionOfficeofAirQualityPlanningandStandardsU.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency919-541-1512(voice)

# Felman Furnaces #2, 5, 7

Run Number Date Sampling Location Furnace Load

(MW) PM

Concentration

(gr/dscf) PM Emissions

(lb/hr) Average Test

PM

Concentration

(gr/dscf) Average Test

PM Emissions

(lb/hr) Average Test

(lb/hr/MW)

1 5/21/2009 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 7.42 0.000338 1.33

2 5/21/2009 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 8.03 0.000650 2.36

3 5/21/2009 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 9.97 0.000652 2.49 0.000547 2.06 0.243

1 7/9/2010 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 18.00 0.001044 6.20

2 7/9/2010 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 18.00 0.000541 2.59

3 7/10/2010 Furnace #2 Baghouse Outlet 18.00 0.001631 5.15 0.001072 4.65 0.258

1 10/29/2007 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 12.69 0.002617 7.03

2 10/30/2007 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 13.34 0.000664 1.81

3 10/30/2007 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 13.47 0.000793 1.95 0.001358 3.60 0.273

1 11/17/2008 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 16.74 0.000499 1.44

2 11/17/2008 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 16.74 0.000166 0.31

3 11/17/2008 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 16.74 0.000287 0.30 0.000317 0.68 0.041

1 11/18/2009 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 14.76 0.001411 4.80

2 11/18/2009 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 14.99 0.001430 4.92

3 11/18/2009 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet 15.04 0.000254 0.93 0.001032 3.55 0.238

1 11/9/2010 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.001944 0.11

2 11/9/2010 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.001565 0.09

3 11/9/2010 Furnace #5 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.001154 0.07 0.001554 0.09

----

1 11/18/2008 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 18.60 0.000216 0.80

2 11/18/2008 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 18.60 0.000383 1.10

3 11/18/2008 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 18.60 0.000675 1.80 0.000425 1.23 0.066

1 11/17/2009 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 14.91 0.002457 7.95

2 11/17/2009 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 13.83 0.001524 5.08

3 11/17/2009 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet 13.70 0.001118 3.73 0.001700 5.59 0.395

1 11/10/2010 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.000487 0.02

2 11/10/2010 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.000519 0.02

3 11/10/2010 Furnace #7 Baghouse Outlet

---- 0.000808 0.05 0.000605 0.03

----