Table 27. Estimated rail transportation rates for coal, state to state, EIA data

Origin State Destination State 2008 2009 2010 2008-2010 2009-2010

Alabama Alabama $14.43 $13.59 $15.46 3.5 13.8

Alabama Georgia $19.13 $19.58 $22.30 8.0 13.9

Alabama Kentucky - W - - -

Alabama New Jersey W - - - -

Alabama Pennsylvania - W - - -

Arizona Arizona W W W W W

Colorado Alabama $34.52 $30.35 $27.67 -10.5 -8.8

Colorado Arizona $28.20 W - - -

Colorado Arkansas W - - - -

Colorado California - $37.53 $51.30 - 36.7

Colorado Colorado $14.16 $8.47 $9.02 -20.2 6.6

Colorado Georgia W - - - -

Colorado Illinois - - W - -

Colorado Indiana - W $20.68 - W

Colorado Iowa $45.74 - - - -

Colorado Kentucky $24.47 $21.37 $23.83 -1.3 11.5

Colorado Michigan $38.75 $46.69 $43.49 5.9 -6.9

Colorado Mississippi $49.97 $42.82 $46.57 -3.5 8.8

Colorado Nevada W $23.80 $24.06 W 1.1

Colorado Oklahoma - W - - -

Colorado Tennessee $24.46 $23.13 $25.23 1.5 9.1

Colorado Utah W W W W W

Colorado Virginia - W W - W

Colorado Wisconsin $48.05 $53.51 $60.02 11.8 12.2

Illinois Alabama W W - - -

Illinois Florida $22.90 W - - -

Illinois Georgia W - $34.77 W -

Illinois Illinois W W $8.35 W W

Illinois Indiana $11.18 $12.60 $13.12 8.3 4.1

Illinois Iowa W - - - -

Illinois Michigan W $4.79 $5.73 W 19.6

Illinois Minnesota W - - - -

Illinois Mississippi - - W - -

Illinois Missouri W - W W -

Illinois Ohio W - - - -

Illinois South Carolina - - $24.46 - -

Illinois Tennessee W - - - -

Illinois Wisconsin - W $11.29 - W

Indiana Alabama - W W - W

Indiana Florida - - W - -

Indiana Georgia $31.28 $32.16 W W W

Indiana Indiana $3.81 $3.54 $4.69 11.0 32.4

Indiana Iowa W - - - -

Indiana Kentucky W W W W W

Nominal Dollars per Ton Annual Percent Change

1
Origin State Destination State 2008 2009 2010 2008-2010 2009-2010

Nominal Dollars per Ton Annual Percent Change

Indiana Michigan W - - - -

Indiana Minnesota - W W - W

Indiana New York - - W - -

Indiana South Carolina W - - - -

Indiana Tennessee - W W - W

Indiana Wisconsin W $28.30 - - -

Kentucky Alabama $15.61 $13.94 $12.60 -10.1 -9.6

Kentucky Delaware $16.20 W - - -

Kentucky Florida $24.86 $32.06 $31.49 12.6 -1.8

Kentucky Georgia $24.47 $22.80 $27.22 5.5 19.4

Kentucky Indiana $13.21 W - - -

Kentucky Kentucky $7.62 $7.79 $10.66 18.3 36.8

Kentucky Maryland $24.43 $23.69 $25.15 1.4 6.1

Kentucky Massachusetts W - - - -

Kentucky Michigan $14.51 $16.31 $15.17 2.3 -7.0

Kentucky Mississippi W W $29.37 W W

Kentucky Missouri $9.35 $24.82 W W W

Kentucky New Jersey W - - - -

Kentucky New York W W - - -

Kentucky North Carolina $22.22 $21.61 $23.14 2.0 7.1

Kentucky Ohio $14.41 W - - -

Kentucky Pennsylvania $26.06 W - - -

Kentucky South Carolina $13.08 $18.35 $19.19 21.1 4.6

Kentucky Tennessee $13.82 $13.18 $14.32 1.8 8.7

Kentucky Virginia $18.89 $17.91 $19.67 2.0 9.8

Kentucky West Virginia - - $14.71 - -

Maryland Maryland - W - - -

Missouri Missouri - - W - -

Montana Arizona $24.65 $21.49 W W W

Montana Colorado - W - - -

Montana Indiana $34.46 $30.79 $7.76 -52.5 -74.8

Montana Michigan $15.34 $12.08 $13.22 -7.2 9.5

Montana Minnesota $13.77 $15.73 $16.01 7.8 1.8

Montana New York $39.36 $35.89 - - -

Montana North Dakota $15.00 W W W W

Montana Ohio $46.27 $39.98 $33.48 -14.9 -16.3

Montana Oregon - W W - W

Montana Pennsylvania $39.17 $39.71 W W W

Montana Texas - - W - -

Montana Washington W W W W W

Montana Wisconsin - W W - W

New Mexico Arizona $7.45 $9.83 $9.45 12.6 -3.8

North Dakota North Dakota $3.77 $4.09 $4.29 6.7 5.0

Ohio Maryland - - W - -

Ohio Michigan $20.31 $14.16 $5.23 -49.3 -63.1

2
Origin State Destination State 2008 2009 2010 2008-2010 2009-2010

Nominal Dollars per Ton Annual Percent Change

Ohio New York W - $27.93 W -

Ohio North Carolina - W - - -

Ohio Ohio - W $7.79 - W

Ohio Pennsylvania $18.52 $21.65 $23.38 12.3 8.0

Pennsylvania Delaware W - W W -

Pennsylvania Florida - $38.51 $40.19 - 4.4

Pennsylvania Georgia - W - - -

Pennsylvania Indiana $19.61 $15.46 $16.99 -6.9 9.9

Pennsylvania Maryland $20.89 $20.35 $20.98 0.2 3.1

Pennsylvania Michigan $12.19 $12.79 $12.84 2.7 0.4

Pennsylvania New Hampshire $43.41 $39.83 W W W

Pennsylvania New Jersey $27.14 $32.44 W W W

Pennsylvania New York $21.62 $24.01 $25.27 8.1 5.3

Pennsylvania North Carolina - W - - -

Pennsylvania Ohio $13.58 $11.14 $10.73 -11.1 -3.7

Pennsylvania Pennsylvania $11.83 $12.75 $14.91 12.3 16.9

Pennsylvania South Carolina $13.23 $13.97 $14.59 5.0 4.5

Pennsylvania Virginia - $22.27 W - W

Pennsylvania West Virginia $11.18 $9.47 $9.87 -6.1 4.2

Pennsylvania Wisconsin - W $19.19 - W

Tennessee Alabama - W - - -

Tennessee Georgia $24.30 $24.23 $25.41 2.3 4.9

Tennessee North Carolina W - - - -

Tennessee South Carolina $14.15 - - - -

Tennessee Tennessee - W $12.42 - W

Tennessee Virginia - - W - -

Utah Alabama $28.66 $27.46 $26.21 -4.4 -4.5

Utah California $29.36 $32.51 $37.04 12.3 13.9

Utah Kentucky W W W W W

Utah Michigan W - - - -

Utah Missouri $32.55 $29.15 $30.42 -3.3 4.4

Utah Nebraska W W - - -

Utah Nevada $14.24 $14.24 $15.89 5.6 11.6

Utah Tennessee $25.47 $24.95 $25.24 -0.5 1.1

Utah Wisconsin W W - - -

Virginia Alabama $24.35 W W W W

Virginia Florida W $24.34 $27.65 W 13.6

Virginia Georgia $25.58 $24.61 $26.98 2.7 9.6

Virginia Maryland - W - - -

Virginia Mississippi $29.13 $23.71 $26.98 -3.8 13.8

Virginia New Hampshire W W W W W

Virginia New Jersey $29.43 $28.14 $30.64 2.0 8.9

Virginia North Carolina $21.63 $19.39 $19.85 -4.2 2.4

Virginia Ohio W $11.82 $10.70 W -9.5

Virginia Pennsylvania W - - - -

3
Origin State Destination State 2008 2009 2010 2008-2010 2009-2010

Nominal Dollars per Ton Annual Percent Change

Virginia South Carolina $12.35 $11.66 W W W

Virginia Tennessee $8.24 $9.66 $14.13 31.0 46.3

Virginia Virginia $13.11 $10.15 $10.44 -10.7 2.9

West Virginia Alabama $22.21 W - - -

West Virginia Delaware $15.09 W W W W

West Virginia Florida $30.78 $28.14 $32.02 2.0 13.8

West Virginia Georgia $27.78 $25.41 $30.09 4.1 18.4

West Virginia Indiana $20.94 $16.83 W W W

West Virginia Kentucky $14.55 $8.74 $6.85 -31.4 -21.6

West Virginia Maryland $20.89 $21.76 $20.52 -0.9 -5.7

West Virginia Massachusetts - $11.34 W - W

West Virginia Michigan $17.72 $17.20 $19.27 4.3 12.0

West Virginia Mississippi W W W W W

West Virginia New Hampshire $43.48 $41.45 $43.09 -0.5 4.0

West Virginia New Jersey W W - - -

West Virginia New York $14.44 $17.03 $22.43 24.7 31.8

West Virginia North Carolina $23.01 $19.63 $21.65 -3.0 10.3

West Virginia Ohio $19.78 $11.59 $10.51 -27.1 -9.4

West Virginia Pennsylvania $18.72 $16.49 $15.99 -7.6 -3.0

West Virginia South Carolina $15.37 $23.35 $24.59 26.5 5.3

West Virginia Tennessee $11.00 $10.14 $19.21 32.2 89.5

West Virginia Virginia $20.56 $18.53 $19.14 -3.5 3.3

West Virginia West Virginia $10.74 $8.87 $8.51 -11.0 -4.0

West Virginia Wisconsin W - W W -

Wyoming Alabama $21.13 $18.81 $20.40 -1.7 8.4

Wyoming Arizona $21.81 $19.35 $21.69 -0.3 12.1

Wyoming Arkansas $19.75 $17.91 $18.27 -3.8 2.0

Wyoming Colorado $11.35 $11.38 $11.49 0.6 1.0

Wyoming Florida W - - - -

Wyoming Georgia $26.08 $24.16 $25.18 -1.7 4.2

Wyoming Illinois $14.94 $14.71 $15.76 2.7 7.2

Wyoming Indiana $22.46 $19.99 $20.29 -5.0 1.5

Wyoming Iowa $10.19 $9.72 $10.12 -0.4 4.1

Wyoming Kansas $13.60 $13.15 $14.22 2.2 8.1

Wyoming Kentucky $23.17 $18.74 $17.91 -12.1 -4.5

Wyoming Louisiana $33.67 $30.66 $32.36 -2.0 5.6

Wyoming Maryland $62.74 W W W W

Wyoming Michigan $18.45 $18.57 $18.99 1.4 2.2

Wyoming Minnesota $17.55 $18.11 $20.55 8.2 13.5

Wyoming Mississippi W $30.07 $38.80 W 29.0

Wyoming Missouri $14.89 $12.79 $13.99 -3.1 9.4

Wyoming Montana W $10.54 $10.61 W 0.7

Wyoming Nebraska $8.15 $9.92 $10.87 15.5 9.6

Wyoming Nevada $24.45 $24.19 $28.91 8.7 19.5

Wyoming North Dakota W W W W W

4
Origin State Destination State 2008 2009 2010 2008-2010 2009-2010

Nominal Dollars per Ton Annual Percent Change

Wyoming Ohio $27.33 $25.67 $30.92 6.4 20.5

Wyoming Oklahoma $13.51 $18.22 $17.83 14.9 -2.1

Wyoming Oregon W W W W W

Wyoming South Dakota $20.88 $20.23 $21.42 1.3 5.9

Wyoming Tennessee $23.54 $21.39 $22.52 -2.2 5.3

Wyoming Texas $13.89 $14.39 $20.17 20.5 40.1

Wyoming Washington W $25.57 $27.15 W 6.2

Wyoming West Virginia - W W - W

Wyoming Wisconsin $18.87 $19.39 $19.99 2.9 3.1

Wyoming Wyoming $6.74 $5.61 $5.29 -11.5 -5.7

 - = No deliveries reported

W = Data Withheld

Source: Form EIA-923 Power Plant Operations Report

5