4,-»t»» npis n 

## \ J 

# CEIVE l Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H 281 6 0refiel d Roa d Allentown , PA . 1810 4 

# m1 8 m SARIN G DOCKE T

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . Ic^ ^ Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Laur a Ponto , Latony a William s Complainant s M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t Honorabl e Judg e Ronni e Yode r Docket : 2010-121 1

MOTIO N FO R MOR E DEFINIT E STATEMEN T 119.6 9 SHUTDOW N AN D HUMA N FACTOR S AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE L B . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo rM R Helicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l sinc e 2007 ) who m aver s an d file s th e followin g Motio n fo rmor e definit e statemen t i n regar d t o a n allege d civi l penalt ydurin g a perio d MR H wa s shu t down . 1 . Complainant s hav e chose n t o no t addres s specifi cpertinen t item s presente d i n enumerate d paragraph s an d a s suc h hav e completel yevade d an d circumvente d thes e item s perhap s i n a malfeasan t manne rt o impai rth e dignit yo f th e court , resultin g indubitabl yan d injuriousl yi n redundanc yi n th e proceedings .

# 2 . Thi s i s anothe rexampl e o fho wcomplainant s hav e refuse d t o addres s thi s matte rrequirin g a mor e directe d metho d o f pleadin g compliance . 3 . M s William s reference d alleg e violatio n date s fo rcit e fo rNovembe r2 , 200 7 t o Jul y24,2008 , a tim e durin g whic h MR H ha d shu t dow n operation s an d wa s n o longe rperformin g flights , du e t o Huma n factor s affectin g th e singl e pilo t operato ri n goo d fait h an d i n accordanc e with :

119.69 Managemen t

Personne l Require dfor Operation s Conducte dunde r

Par t 13 5 o f thi s Chapter , (a

) D R Helicopters , LL

C must have sufficien

t qualified managemen

t andtechnica

l personnel t

o ensur e the safet y of it s operations . DRHelicopters , LL C must have qualified personnel serving i

nthe followin

g or equivalen t positions : (1 ) Directo

r of Operations . (2) Chie

f Pilot . (3 ) Directo

r o f Maintenance . 4 . Thes e Huma n Factors include d a protracte d divorce , custod ybattles , mino rchildre n o n psychotropi cdrug s an d a t ris k o f suicide , emotiona l upheaval , workloa d an d tim e restraint s o frespondent s cardiolog ypractic e an d financia l devastatio n (Exhibi t 1,2,3) . 5 . Responden t wa s th e Directo ro fOperations , Chie fPilot an d th e Maintenanc e Schedule ran d terminate d th e operation s i n as t o no t pu t th e publi c a t undu e risk . 6 . MR H i n goo d judgmen t terminate d operation s i n Jun e 200 7 (Exhibi t 4) . 7 . This premis e warrant s ye t anothe rreaso n t o rende rth e allege d civi l penalt ymoot , demonstratin g anothe rprocedura l defec t an d substantiate d prosecutoria l overreaching . 2 -

# 8 . I t appear s i n thi s proces s M s William s an d M s Pont o ar e malfeasant ,

hav e abuse d thei rdiscretion , or e i n breac h o f dut yan d conduc t t o caus e harm , ar e i n abus e o fprocess , expendin g needlessl ygovernmen t funds , havin g n o legall ycognizabl e caus e o f action , attemptin g t o migrat e an d cobblin g togethe rcolorabl e changin g argument s t o mak e thei rallege d violatio n appea r warranted , whil e holdin g steadfas t a t al l cost s an d withou t humility , dignity , mora l o rethica l appropriat e behaviors . 9 . Complainant s havin g a t bes t lega l insufficiency , a cas e voi d a b initio , makin g conclusionar ystatements , compressin g man yquestions , attemptin g t o impai rth e dignit yo f th e court , b ywittingl yan d willfull ymakin g incredibl e allegations , no t lookin g a t th e perspectiv e i n whol e i n regar d t o huma n aspects , namel yth e curren t stat e o f th e responden t unde rattack . Thes e action s take n agains t th e responden t mount s t o "beatin g a ma n wh o is airead ydown" , behavior s tha t ar e unconscionabl e a t an ylevel . 10 . I n al l an d bes t effort s fo rjudicia l economy , th e cas e therefor e shoul d b e dismisse d t o allo wth e administration s effort s b e properl ydirecte d t o othe r area s o rhig h volume , larg e operatio n violatio n case s mos t pertinen t t o th e publi csafet yo fou rcountry . WHEREFORE , th e responden t pray s tha t thi s Honorabl e Court wil l dismis s thi s cas e as th e complain t i s moo t an d shoul d b e stricke n fo rth e tim e perio d referenced .

# Respectfull ySubmitted ,

Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC . Dat e

- 4

# Page 1 o f 9 Logou t M

yAccoun t Searc h Men u Ne wCivi l Searc h Refin e Searc n Bscl <



## REGISTE RO FACTION S CAS ENO . 2006-FC-126 8 i_ocatio n : Judicia l Record s Image s Hel p

Gal l France s Roeshma n Formerl yKnow n A s Gal l R Sell g V S Michae l § B Sell g § § § § Cas e Type : Divorc e Subtype : Divorc e Dat e Filed : 10/10/200 6 Location : Civi l Record s PART Y INFORMATION Defendan t Sellg , Michae l B

281 6 0refieldR d Orefield , PA1810 4 Lea d Attorney s Josep h C Bernstein , Es q Retaine d 610-770-1400{W ) Plaintif f Roeshman , Gal l France s

Formerl yKnow n A s Selig , Gai l R 32 5 N 28t h St Allentown , P

A1810 4 Anthon yM Mulr , Es q Retaine d 610-434-7138(W ) EVENT S & ORDER S OFTHECOUR T 12/20/200 6 

### 03/06/200 7 05/09/200 7 05/10/200 7 05/22/200 7

05/22/200 7 01/30/200 8 06/11/200 8 07/31/200 8

09/03/200 8 10/20/200 8 12/22/200 8 01/21/200 9 06/03/200 9



### 06/03/200 9 HEARING

S Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) PlAiNTIf F AN D DEFENDANT S PETITIO N Result : Fina l Orde rEntere d Mediatio n (12:3 0 PM ) (Judicia l OfTice rKlein . Do n S , Esq ) Result : Mediatio n l-lel d Wit h Agreemen t Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) REMOVA L O F BE E HIVE S FRO M PROPERTY . Result : Hearin g Complete d Custod yConferenc e (10:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rVanGilder , Donal d L ) Result : Conferenc e Hel d - Interi m Orde r Custod yContemp t (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 03/20/200 7 Continue d t o 05/09/200 7 - Continue d b yJudg e - Selig , Michae l B 05/09/200 7 Rese t b yCour t t o 05/22/200 7 Result : Hearin g Complete d Contemp t (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) PLAINTIF F AN D DEFENDANT S PETITIO N FO R CONTEMP T Result : Matte rt o b e Settled/Withdraw n - Famil y Exception s t o Master' s Repor t (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rVarricchio , Michel e A ) Result : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Hearin g Complete d CANCELE D Custod yConferenc e (2:0 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Cas e Staye d 07/23/200 8 Continue d t o 07/25/200 8 - Continue d b yJudg e - Roeshman , Gai l France s 07/25/200 8 Rese t b yCour t t o 07/31/200 8 CANCELE D Custod yTria l (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Cas e Staye d 07/23/200 8 Continue d t o 07/25/200 8 - Continue d b yJudg e - Roeshman , Gai l France s 07/25/200 8 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/03/200 8 Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelief/Custod y(9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Hearin g Complete d Custod yConferenc e (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Custod yConferenc e Hel d - Matte rt o Procee d t o Tria l Exception s t o Master' s Repor t (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Hearin g Complete d Custod yTria l (1:3 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 12/22/200 8 Rese t b yCour t t o 02/05/200 9 02/05/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 03/11/200 9 03/11/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 06/03/200 9 Result : Tria l Complete d b yJudg e Custod yContemp t (1:3 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) T O B E COMPLETED . 

# ^A^t t \ httD://publicaccess.lehighcountv.ore/CaseDetail.asDx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

# Page 2 of9

07/22/200 9 07/22/200 9 04/05/201 0 04/05/201 0 04/14/201 0 04/14/201 0 05/10/201 0 09/14/201 0

09/14/201 0

11/15/201 0 12/22/200 8 Rese t b yCour t t o 02/05/200 9 02/05/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 03/11/200 9 03/11/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 06/03/200 9 Result : Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) DEFENDANT S PETITIO N FO R REVIEW . Result : Matte rt o b e Settled/Withdraw n - Famil y Motio n fo rSanction s (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rRoberts , Joh n E . Ill ) Hearin g (1:0 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rRoberts , Joh n E , III ) Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 04/16/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 04/14/201 0 Result : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) TRANSFE R OWNERSHIP . Result : Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (1:0 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rRoberts , Joh n E . Ill ) Petitio n fo rBifurcatio n (10:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 07/09/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 07/28/201 0 07/28/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 Result : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (10:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 07/09/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 07/28/201 0 07/28/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 Result : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 10/06/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 11/19/201 0 11/19/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 11/15/201 0 Result : Hearin g Complete d 10/10/200 6 10/18/200 6 10/24/200 6 11/16/200 6 11/30/200 6 12/05/200 6 12/08/200 6 12/08/200 6 12/11/200 6 12/11/200 6 12/15/200 6 12/19/200 6 01/02/200 7 01/11/200 7 01/16/200 7 01/19/200 7 01/19/200 7 OTHE REVENT S

Complain t Notic e t o Defen d 8 i Clai m Right s Coun t I , 3301(c ) divorce . Coun t I I support , alimon ypendent e lit e & alimony . Coun t II I equitabl e distribution . Coun t I V counse l fees , cost s & expense s Pra e fo rAppearanc e fo rdftbyC S Mille rEs q Acceptanc e o fServic e o fcomplain t o n behal fo fdftbyC S Mille rEs q o n 10/17/06 . Pra e fo rAppearanc e fo rDft b yHarol d J Funt , Esq . Certificat e o fCompletio n o fCop e Progra m fo rPIt f o n 11/18/0 6 Pra e fo rwithdrawa l o fAppearanc e b yS Mille rEs q fo rdf t wit h certificatio n tha t H J Fun t Es q ha s entere d hi s appearanc e fo rsame . Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f file d b ydf t Rul e t o appea r& sho wcaus e Now12/8/06 , upo n motio n ofH J Fun t Esq , att yfo rdft a rul e i s issue d upo n pIt ft o sho wcaus e wh yth e petitio n fo rspecia l relie f shoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 12/20/0 6 a t 9:3 0 am , O R 5B,LCCH . B yth e court : /s/A M Blac k J . Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f an d exclusiv e possessio n t o resid e i n th e marita l residence . File d byplt f Rul e t o appea r& sho wcaus e Now12/11/06 , upo n motio n o fA M Muir , att yfo rpItf , a rul e i s issue d upo n df t t o sho wcaus e wh yth e petitio n fo rspecia l relie fshoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 12/20/0 6 a t 9:3 0 am , O R 5B,LCCH . B yth e court : /s/A M Blac k J . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to dfl' s petitio n fo rspecia l relief . File d b ypItf . Answe r to petitio n fo rspecia l relie fan d fo rexclusiv e possessio n t o resid e i n th e marita l residence . File d b ydft . Custod yAgreemen t an d order : No w12/20/06 , th e partie s ar e directe d t o compl ywit h th e term s o fth e attache d agreemen t whic h i s hereb yadopte d a s a n orde ro fcourt . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J . Copie s mid/dkt d 1/2/0 7 Motio n fo rAppointmen t o fa Maste r file d b yHarol d Funt , Es q Master' s Appointmen t Order : Joh n Robert s II I Es q i s appointe d Maste ri n Divorce . /S/A M Blac k J . Afd t o fConsent , Waive ro fCounselin g & Non-iVlilitar yServic e forplt f Waive ro fNotic e o fIntentio n t o Reques t Entryo fDi vDecre e rile d byplt f 

# http://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

## Pag e 3 of 9

02/02/2007 02/05/2007 02/07/2007 02/07/2007 02/07/2007 02/13/200 7 02/23/200 7 02/23/200 7 02/26/200 7 02/27/200 7 02/28/200 7 

### 03/14/2007 03/15/200 7 

### 03/22/2007 03/26/2007 03/29/200 7 04/16/200 7 04/17/200 7 04/17/200 7 04/17/200 7 04/17/200 7 

### 05/03/2007 05/15/2007 05/18/200 7 

### 05/23/2007 05/24/2007 05/24/2007 06/01/200 7 06/12/200 7 06/19/200 7 

### 06/22/2007 07/06/200 7 07/09/200 7 Answe r- Repl y- Respons e

t o petitio n fo rspecia l relief . File d b ypIt f Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f file d b ydf t Dft' s answe rt o complain t an d counterclai m coun t I equitabl e distributbn , coun t I I custod y Schedulin g Orde rt o Appea rRe ; Custody/yisltatio n Addresse d T

o pIt forderin g hirn/he rt o appea rfo ra mediatio n o n 3/6/0 7 a t 12:3 0 pm . B yth e Court : /S/ED R Orde rfo rMediatio n wit h Do n S Klei n Es q o n 3/6/0 7 a t 12:3 0 pm . Cost s t o b e a s follows : Paymen t b yPIt f$50.00 ; Paymen t b yDft $50.00 . Subsequen t paymen t b yPItf$30.00 ; Paymen t b yDft $30.00 . B yth e Court : /S / ED R Transcrip t o fStipulatio n Agreemen t an d order : No w2/5/07 , th e withi n agreemen t i s hereb yadopte d a s a n orde ro fcourt . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J . Petitio n file d b ydf t regardin g contemp t fo rcustod y Rul e & Schedulin g Orde r No w2/23/07 , upo n motio n ofH J Fun t Esq , attyfo rdf t a rul e i s issue d upo n th e pIt ft o sho wcaus e wh yth e petitio n fo rcontemp t Shoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 3/28/0 7 a t 9:3 0 am , O R 5B,LCCh . B yth e court : /s/E D Reibma n J . Affidavi t o fService : o fanswe ran d counterclaim . File d byH J Fun t Es q Maste rOrder : Th e following.i s recommend.e d b yMaste ri n Divorce . Se e orig . /S/ED R Affidavi t o fServjce : o fpetitio n fo rcivi l contempt . File d byH J Fun t Es q Petitio n fo rSpecja l Relie f an d emergencyrelie fan d contemp t fo rdisbodienc e o f court orde ro f 2/13/07 . File d b ydft . Certificat e o fCompletio n o fCop e Progra m fo rOf t o n 3/7/0 7 Sheriff s Retur n Answe r- Repl y- Respons e f o dft' s petitio n fo rcivi l contempt . File d byplt f Applicatio n fo rContinuanc e 3/28/0 7 contemp t plu s petitio n fo remergencyrelie f i s grante d an d cas e i s continue d t o next availabl e lis t t o 5/9/0 7 a t 9:3 0 am , C R 5S . /s/J B Johnso n J . Pra e fo rAppearanc e fo rdf t b yL S Gardne rEs q Motio n to compe l discovery . File d b ydf t Orde r Wo w4/17/07 , dft' s motio n t o compe l fo rpitf' s failur e t o answe rdft' s interrogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o fdocument s i s grante d an d pIt fshal l answe rdft' s intenogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o f document s withi n 2 0 day s o fth e dat e o fthi s order . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/L J Brenne rJ . Motio n to compe l discovery . File d byplt f Orde r Wo w4/17/07 , pitf s motio n t o compe l fo rdft' s failur e t o answe rpitf' s firs t se t o f interrogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o f document s i s grante d an d df t shal l answe rpItf s firs t se t o f interrogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o fdocument s withi n 2 0 day s o fth e dat e o f thi s order . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/L J Brenne rJ . Pra e fo rwithdrawa l o fAppearanc e b yH J Fun t Es q fo rdf t Agree d Fina l Orde r Transcrip t o fAgreemen t & Order : Now , 5/9/07 , th e partie s ar e directe d t o compl ywit h th e tenn s o fsai d agreemen t whic h i s hereb y adopte d a s a n orde ro fcourt . Ahearin g wil l b e hel d o n 5/22/0 7 a t 9:0 0 am , C R 5B,LCCH . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J . Agree d Interi m Order : Wo w5/18/07 , th e partie s shal l withi n 1 5 day s o f th e dat e o fthi s orde rmake arrangement s t o presen t themselve s an d th e childre n fo r psychologica l evaluation . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/E D Reibma n J . Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelie f file d byplt f Orde r Wo w5/22/07 , dft' s peitio n fo rcivi l contemp t i s denied . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Agree d Fina l Orde r Transcrip t o fAgreemen t & Order : Now , 5/22/07 , th e partie s ar e directe d t o compl ywit h th e term s o f sai d agreement . Th e ora l motio n o fpIt ft o withdra whe rpetitio n fo remergencyrelie f i s grante d an d sai d motio n i s withdraw n an d dft' s petitio n fo rspecia l emergency relie fan d contemp t i s grante d an d sai d motio n shal l 6 0 marite d withdrawn . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J . Answe r to dft' s counterclai m file d bypltf . Exhibit s P- 1 an d D- 1 t o D- 4 file d Notic e o fAppea l t o Superio rCour

t b ydf t fro m th e orde rentere d o n 5/24/07 . Afd t o f service : withi n mentione d document s serve d upo n AM Mui rEsq , Ho n J B Johnson , court administratio n an d cour t reporting . Reques t fo rtranscrip t directe d t o th e officia l cour t reporter . Cop yo f docke t entrie s attached . Cop ymi d o n 6/19/0 7 t o Appellat e court an d C k # 154 7 i n th e am t o f$60.0 0 b yI.S . Orde r Wo w6/22/07 , df t i s directe d t o fil e o frecor d an d serv e a cop yo n th e tria l judg e withi n 1 4 day s fro m th e entr yo fthi s order , a concis e statemen t o fmatter s complaine d o fo n appeal . PIt f shal l respond t o th e dft' s statemen t withi n 1 0 day s o fi t bein g filed . Se e orig . B y th e court:/s/ J B Johnso n J . Statemen t o fmatter s complaine d o fo n appeal . File d b ydft . Petitio n t o Withdra wCounse l 8 1 Order : Wo w7/9/07 , L S Gardne rEs q i s Vt/ithdraw n a s Counse l fo rdft i n th e above captione d matte r/S/L J Brenne rJ . 

## http://publicaccess.lehiehcounty.ore/CaseDetail.asDX?CaseTD=49692 2 17/16/901 0

# Page 4 of 9 07/09/200 7 07/18/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/30/200 7 08/03/200 7 08/03/200 7 08/06/200 7 08/07/200 7 08/07/200 7 08/13/200 7 08/15/200 7 09/21/200 7 09/28/200 7 10/17/200 7 11/05/200 7 11/06/200 7 11/27/200 7 11/28/200 7 11/28/200 7 11/28/200 7 12/18/200 7 12/18/200 7 12/18/200 7 12/28/200 7 12/28/200 7 01/24/200 8 01/25/200 8 01/25/200 8 01/29/200 8 

### Q1/31/200 S 01/31/200 8 03/04/200 8 03/05/200 8 03/05/200 8 03/05/200 8 Pra e fo rwithdrawa l o fAppearanc e

b yL S Gardne rEs q fo rdft Pra e fo rAppearanc e fo rdf t a s pro-s e Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelie f file d byplt f Orde r Wo w7/25/07 , pItf s petitio n fo remergencyrelie f i s grante d an d th e df t i s hereb yenjoine d fro m subpoenain g o rotherwis e requestin g medical , psychologica l and/o rpsychiatri crecord s o fth e pIt fan d th e mino rchildren . Th e reques t fo ratt yfee s o n thi s petitio n i s denied . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelie f an d contemp t file d b ypItf . Orde r Wo w7/25/07 , pltf s petitio n fo remergencyrelie fan d contemp t i s granted . Dft i s ordere d t o pa ya fin e i n th e am t o f$500.00 . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . (footnot e added ) Appellat e Cour t Docke t NumberReceive d Wo. 179 3 EDA200 7 Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 8/3/0 7 a t 12:5 9 pm . Testimon yhear d 5/22/0 7 befor e th e Honorabl e J B Johnso n J . Cour t reporter/Mar

yS Millsap s Cm/RPR . Exhibit s mentione d bu t no t filed . Statemen t Pa . R.C.P . 1925(a ) statement . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J . Copie s mId/dkt d 8/3/07 . Pra e fo rAppearanc e fo rdf t b yJ C Bernstei n Es q Cas e Transmitte d t o Superio rCour

t o fPAvi a certifie d mai l # 716 0 3901 984 2 666 0 1984( 1 envelope) . Lis t o fDocke t entrie s fo rCas e fmaile d t o Anthon yM Mui rEs q o n 08/07/07 . Retur n Car d Wo. 716 0 3901 984 2 666 0 1984 file d Acknowledgmen t from Superio rCour

t o freceivin g recor d o n 8/8/0 7 Maste rOrder : Th e followin g i s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s/ED R Maste rOrder : Th e followin g I s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s/ED R 330 1 (d ) Affidavi t & notic e t o pItf . File d b ydf t Dft' s 330 1 (D ) Counter-Afd t & Notic e t o PIt f File d b yPIt f Maste rOrder : Th e followin g < s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s/ED R Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r3/3/0 8 a t 9:3 0 am . /s/ED R Appellat e Cour t Docke t NumberReceive d 179 3 ED A200 7 Orde r from Superio rCourt . No w9/14/07 , df t ha s faile d t o compl ywit h thi s Court' s directives . Accordingl yth e appea l a t No . 179 3 EDA200 7 i s hereb ydismissed . Pe rCuriam . Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 3/3/0 8 a 9:3 0 a m Petitio n file d b ydf t regardin g appointmen t o fguardia n a d lite m fo rminor(s) . Propose d Orde r(afte rhearing ) Repor t o fHearin g Office r Exception s file d b ydf t Argumen t Schedulin g Order : Wow, 12/28/07 , a n argumen t i s schedule d o n 1/30/0 8 a t 9:3 0 am.C R 58 , B yth e Court : /S/ E D Reibma n J . copie s serve d b yC.A . Offic e Brie f i n respons e t o dft' s brie fi n suppor t o fexception s t o report o f custod yhearin g office . File d b ypItf . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to dft' s exception s t o Report & Propose d Orde ro f Custod yHearin g Office rFile d b yPItf . Answe r• Repl y- Respons e to dft' s Petitio n fo rAppointmen t o fGuanJia n A d Lite m fo rminors . File d b yPItf . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to ne wmatte rt o exceptions . File d b ydft A|3Pli5ati9 n f9 rCpntmuanc e fo r1/30/0 6 hearin g i s refused . /s/J B Johnso n J . Answe r (amended ) t o ne wmatte rt o petitio n fo rG.A.L . an d exception s t o repor t o fcustod yhearin g office rFile d b ydft . Maste rOrder : Th e followin g i s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . 7s/ ED R Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 3/31/0 8 a t 9:3 0 a m Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r3/31/0 8 a t 9:3 0 am . /s/ED R Fina l Order : Wo w2/27/08 , dft' s petitio n fo rappointmen t o fguardia n a d lite m i s denied . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/M AVarricchi o J . (footnot e 

# http://publicaccess.lehighcounty.ore/CaseDetail.asDx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

# Page 5 o f 9

04/03/200 8 04/03/200 8 04/11/200 8 04/17/200 8 04/17/200 8 04/25/200 8 04/29/200 8 05/08/200 8 05/08/200 8 05/20/200 8 05/27/200 8 06/06/200 8 06/20/200 8 06/25/200 8 06/25/200 8 07/03/200 8 07/08/200 8 07/14/200 8 07/14/200 8 07/25/200 8 07/29/200 8 07/30/200 8 07/31/200 8 08/04/200 8 09/08/200 8 09/08/200 8 09/24/200 8 09/26/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 added )

CAt o plac e matte ro n th e Custod yTria l Lis t fo rHr g /S/WE F Orde r Wo w4/3/08 , th e officia l court reports , Dian e Snel l i s t o produce , certifyan d fil e th e transcrip t i n thi s matter , conducte d o n 1/30/08 . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/M AVarricchi o J . Orde ro fCas e Management/Custod yTria l Attachmen t Wo w4/10/0 8 APre-trial/Settlemen t Conferenc e shal l tak e plac e o n 7/23/0 8 a t 9:0 0 a m wit h Custod yTria l immediatel yfollowin g a t 9:3 0 am , C R SB./S/J B Johnso n J . Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 5/15^ 8 a M .0 0 p m Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r5/15/0 8 a t 1:00 p m /s / WE F Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 4/25/0 8 a t 1:33 pm . Testimon yhear d 1/30/0 8 befor e th e Honorabl e M AVanicchi o J . Cour t reporter/Dian e Snell . PItf s exhibit s 1 & 2 an d dft' s exhibit s 1-

3 attached . Applicatio n fo rContinuanc e 7/23/0 8 pre-tria l conferenc e an d tria l i s grante d an d cas e i s continue d t o 7/25/0 8 a t 10:0 0 am . /s/J B Johnso n J . Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f file d b ydf t Rul e & Schedulin g Orde r Wo w5/8/08 , a rul e i s issue d upo n pIt ft o sho wcaus e wh yth e emergenc ypetitio n fo rspecia l relie fshoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 6/11/0 8 a t 9:3 0 am , C R 58 . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Orde ro fCas e Management/Custod yTria l Attachmen t Now , 5/20/08 , APre-trial/Settlemen t Conferenc e shal l tak e plac e o n 7/31/0 8 a t 2:0 0 p m wit h Custod yTria l immediatel yfollowin g o n 9/3/0 8 a t 9:30am./S/J B Johnso n J . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to petitio n fo rspecia l relie fan d ne wmatte rFile d b ypIt f Answe r to ne wmatte ri n answe rt o petitio n fo rspecia l relie f File d b ydft . Orde r Wo w6/20/08 , Dft' s petitio n fo rspecia l relie f i s granted . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s / J B Johnso n J . (footnot e added ) Copie s mi d 6/20/08 . Dkt d 6/23A}8 . Petitio n file d b ypIt fregardin g reconsideration . Memorandu m o fla wi n suppor

t o fpetitio n fo rreconsideratio n o fth e cour t orde rentere d 6/20/08 . File d b ypItf . Answe r to petitio n fo rreconsideration , ne wmatte ran d motio n fo rsanctions . File d b ydft . Orde r Wo w7/7/08 , pItf s petitio n fo rreconsideratio n i s denied . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Copie s mId/dkt d 7/8/08 . Notic e o fAppea l t o Superio rCour

t fro m th e orde rdate d 7/7/0 8 file d b ypItf . Affidavi t o fService : o fnotic e o fappeal . File d b yA M Mui rEs q Petitio n fo rContempt : file d b ydf t Petitio n Hied b ypIt fregardin g applicatio n fo rsta ypendin g appeal . StatemenfOpinlo n Date d 7/29/08 . /S/ J B Johnso n J . Copie s Mi d 7/30/08 . Dkt d 7/31/0 8 Notic e o fDocketin g Appea l i n Superio rCour

t unde rDkt #206 9 EDA200 8 Orde r No w7/31/08 , pItf s petitio n i s grante d an d th e 6/20/0 8 orde ri s staye d unti l th e pendin g appea l i s closed . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Copie s mi d 8/4/08 . Dkt d 8/5/0 8 Orde r Now , thi s 9/5/0 8 i t appearin g tha t th e Superio rCour t o f Pennsylvania , b yorde rdate d 8/26/08 , quashe d th e appea l o f th e 7/7/0 8 orde r b yvirtu e o fth e attache d Order . Se e Original . B yth e Court/s/J.B.Johnson , J . copie s mi d 9/8/08 , dkt d 9/9/08 . Schedulin g Order : (Amended. ) No w9/5/08 . pre-trial/settlemen t conferenc e i s schedule d o n 12/22/0 8 @ 9:0 0 a.m . befor e honorabl e J.B . Johnso n i n courtroo m 5B . custod ytria l schedule d 12/22/0 8 @ 9:3 0 a.m . before honorabl e J.B . Johnso n i n courtroo m 58 . /S/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 9/8/0 8 dktd . 9/9/08 . Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelie f (special ) File d b ydft Schedulin g Order : Ahearin g i s schedule d fo r10/20/0 8 a t 9:3 0 am , C R 58 . /S/JB J Appellat e Cour t Docke t Numbe rReceive d 206 9 EDA200 8 Orde r from Superio rCour

t o fPA . No wdft' s motio n t o quas h appea l i s granted . Pe rCuriam . Exhibit s from dat e o fseparatio n hearing s o n 3/3/08 , 3/31/0 8 an d 5/15/0 8 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 3/3/0 8 a t 9:3 7 a m Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 3/31/0 8 a t 9:3 7 am , Volum e I I Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 5/15/0 8 a t 1:1 5 pm . Volum e II I Maste rOrder : Th e followin g i s recommende d 

# http://publicaccess.lehighcountv.org/CaseDetail.asDX?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

## Pag e 6 o f 9

10/06/200 8 10/17/200 8 10/17/200 8 10/17/200 8 10/22/200 8 10/29/200 8 10/29/200 8 10/31/200 8 11/05/200 8 11/05/200 8 11/05/200 8 11/14/200 8 12/22/200 8 12/24/200 8 01/06/200 9 01/07/200 9 01/16/200 9 02/03/200 9 02/11/200 9 02/19/200 9 03/03/200 9 03/04/200 9 03/19/200 9 03/19/200 9 04/15/200 9 04/20/200 9 04/27/200 9 05/12/200 9 05/28/200 9 05/29/200 9 06/04/200 9 06/04/200 9 b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F Orde r Wow , thi s 9/29/0 8 i t i s ordere d tha t a transcrip t o f th e proceeding s i n th e abov e captione d cas e o n 7/31/0 8 shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requesto rSe e Original . B yth e Court , /s/J.B . Johnson , J . Divorc e Exception s to orde ro f10/3/08 . File d b ydf t Answe r to petitio n fo remergencyrelie fan d ne wmatte rFile d b ypit f Answe rt o Custod ypleadin g to ne wmatte rt o petitio n fo rspecia l relie fFile d b ydft . Orde r Wo w10/20/08 , dft' s petitio n fo remergencyspecia l relie f wil l b e deferre d fo rconsideratio n unti l 12/22/08 . Se e orig . Byth e court : /s/ J 8 Johnso n J . Copie s mi d 10/22/08 . Dkt d 10/24/0 8 Orde r Wow , thi s 10/20/08 , upo n consideratio n o fth e IDft . ' s Petitio n fo rEmergence ySpecia l Relief , PItf . ' s repl ytheret o an d Ne wMatter , i t i s Ordere d tha t sai d petitio n an d repl ywil l b e deferre d fo rconsideratio n unti l tim e o ftria l o n 12/22/08 . Se e Original . B yth e Court , /s / J . 8 . Johnson , J . Copie s mId/dkt d 10/29/08 . Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 10/29/0 8 a t 8:5 7 am . Testimon yhear d 7/31/0 8 befor e th e Honorabl e J B Johnso n Cour t reporter ; Mar

yS Millsap s Motio n File d b ydft . Regardin g reconsideratio n Answe r to motio n fo rreconsideratio n o forde ro f10/20/08 . File d b ypItf . Orde r Wow , Thi s 11/5/08 , I t i s Ordere d tha t Dft . ' s motio n fo rcontemp t i s deferre d fo rconsideratio n unti l tim e o ftria l o n 12/22/08 . Se e Original . B yth e Court , /s / J . B . Johnson , J . copie s mi d 11/5/08 . dkt d 11/6/08 . Orde r Wow , thi s 11/5/0 8 i t i s Ordere d tha t Dft . ' s Motio n fo rReconsideratio n o fth e Orde ro f10/20/08 , i s Denied . Se e Original . B yth e Court . /s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 11/5/08 . dkt d 11/6/08 . Rul e & Scheduling.Orde r Wo w11/14/08 , upo n motio n ofJ C Bernstei n Es q a rul e i s issue d upo n pIt ft o sho wcaus e wh yexception s t o th e orde ro f10/3/0 8 shoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 1/21/0 9 a t 9:3 0 am , C R 58 . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Finding s o fFac t an d Conclusion s o fLa w an d memorandu m o flaw . File d b ydft . (proposed ) Interi m Orde r Wow , thi s 12/23/0 8 i t i s Ordered , PItf . shal l exercis e sol e lega l custod yo fchild . Se e Original . B yth e Court/s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mId/dkt d 12/24/08 . Brie f i n suppor t o fexceptions . File d b ydf t Orde ro fCas e Management/Custod yTria l Attachmen t Wo w1/7/09 , Custod ytria l shal l resum e o n 2/5/0 9 @ 9:3 0 a.m . i n courtroo m 5b . Se e Original . B yth e Court . /s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mld1/7/09 . dkt d 1/8/09 . Brie f i n oppositio n t o exception s t o a 10/3/0 8 orde ro fcourt . File d b ypItf . Orde r Wow, thi s 2/2A}9 , i t i s Ordere d dft . ' s exception s t o orde rfile d 10/17/08 , are denied . Se e Original . B yth e Court . /s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 2/3/09 , dkt d 2/2/09 . Orde r Wow, thi s 2/10/09 , i t i s Ordered , tha t a transcrip t o f trial s hel d i n above captione d cas e shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requestor . Se e Original . B yth e Court . /s/J.B . Johnson , J . copie s mi d 2/11/0 9 dkt d 2/12/09 . Maste rOrder : Th e followin g I s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r5/19/0 9 AN D 5/20/0 9 @ 9:3 0 A.M . /s / WE F Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 5/19/0 9 an d 5/20/0 9 a t 9:3 0 a m Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 5/28/0 9 a t 9:3 0 a m Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r5/28/0 9 a t 9:3 0 am . /s / WE F Orde r Wow, thi s 4/14/09' Ai s Ordered , PItf.' s petitio n fo rReconsideratio n i s Denied . SeeOriginal . B yth e Court./s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mld/dktd4/15A)9 . Chang e o fAddres s file d b ydf t Orde r Wow, thi s 4/27/09 , i t i s Ordered , PItf' s motio n i s Denie d an d thi s Court' s 4/1/0 9 Orde rdenyin g th e pItf s petitio n a t docke t # 2006-FC 126 8 i s hereb yVacated . Se e Original . B yth e court , /s/J.B.Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 4/27/0 9 dkt d 4/28/09 . Pretria l Statemen t File d b yDft . Maste rOrder : Th e followin g i s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F Maste rOrder : Th e followin g i s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 6/4/0 9 a t 3:1 0 pm . Testimon yhean S 12/22/0 8 befor e th a Honorabl e J 8 Johnso n J . Cour t reporter ; Mar

yR Millsaps , RPR-CMR . (volum e 1 ) Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 6/4/0 9 a t 3:1 0 pm . Testimon yhear d 12/23/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e J 8 Johnso n J . Cour t reporter ; Mar

yR Millsaps , RPR-CMR . (Volum e 2 ) 

## http://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0 

# W -

# Page 7 o f 9

06/04/200 9 06/17/200 9 06/26/200 9 06/26/200 9 06/29/200 9 07/02/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/17/200 9 07/20/200 9 07/21/200 9 07/22/200 9 07/24/200 9 07/29/200 9 07/31/200 9 08/07/200 9 09/04/200 9 09/16/200 9 09/16/200 9 09/23/200 9 10/05/200 9 10/21/200 9 10/21/200 9 10/27/200 9 11/09/200 9 11/24/200 9 11/24/200 9 11/24/200 9 12/02/200 9 12/03/200 9 12/04/200 9 12/04/200 9 01/05/201 0 01/05/201 0 Fina l Custod yOrder :

Wo wthi s 6/3/0 9 i t i s Ordere d mothe rshal l exercis e sol e lega l custod yo fth e child.Se e Origina l B yth e Court . /s/J.B . Johnson , j copie s mi d 6/4/0 9 dkt d 6/5/09 . Orde r Wo w6/16/09 , a transcrip t o fth e benc h opinio n hel d o n 6/3/0 9 shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requesto rSe e orig . B yth e court : /s/J B Johnso n J . Copie s mi d 6/18/09 . Dkt d 6/19/0 9 Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r9/9/09 , 9/10/09 , 9/11/0 9 /s / WE F Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 9/9/09 , 9/10/09 , 9/11/0 9 Maste rOrder : Th e followin g I s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F copie s mi d 6/29/0 9 dkt d 7/1/0 9 Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 7/2/0 9 a t 3:5 1 pm . Testimon yhear d 6/3/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e J 8 Johnso n J . Cour t reporte rMar

yS Millsaps . RPR-CM R Rul e & Schedulin g Orde r Wow, thi s 7/7/09 , upo n motio n o fJ O Bernstein , Esq . a rul e i s issue d upo n th e PItf t o sho wcaus e wh yDft' s motio n fo rsanction s shoul d no t b e granted . Rul e Returnabl e o n 7/22/0 9 @ 9:3 0 a.m . i n C R 1C . B yth e Court/s/ J B Johnson , J . Motio n File d b yDf t Regardin g Motio n fo rSanction s Reques t Deman d fo rRevie wfile d b yDf t Rul e & Schedulin g Orde r Wow , thi s 7/7/09 , upo n motio n ofJ C Bernstein , Esq . a rul e i s issue d upo n PIt ft o sho wcaus e wh yDft' s deman d fo rrevie wshoul d no t b e granted . Rul e returnabl e o n 7/22/0 9 @ 9:3 0 a.m . i n C R 1C . B yth e Court/s/ J B Johnson , J . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to Dft' s deman d fo rrevie wo fa court orde ro n 6/29/0 9 File d b yPIt f Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to Dft' s motio n fo rsanction s File d b yPItf . Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 5/27/0 9 Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to PItf s Ne wmatte ran d Counte rpetitio n t o deman d fo rrevie wFile d b yDft Stipulatio n An d Orde rNo wthi s 7/22/09 , i t i s Ordere d attache d agreemen t o fth e partie s i s adopte d an d entere d a s a n orde ro fcourt . Se e Origina l B yth e Court/s/ J B Johnson , J . Copie s mId/dkt d 7/24/0 9 Orde r Wo w7/28/09 , pitfi s prohibite d fro m presentin g an yevidenc e regardin g th e valu e o fth e marita l residenc e unti l sh e allow s dft' s appraise raccess . PIt fI s directe d t o fil e a pre-tria l statemen t withi n 1 0 day s o fth a dat e o fthi s onler . Seeorig . B yth e court:/s/ J B Johnso n J . Copie s mi d 7/29/09 . Dkt d 7/30/0 9 Pretria l Statemen t File d b yPIt f Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 5/28/200 9 Orde r Wow, thi s 9/2/0 9 i t i s Ordered , tha t a transcrip t o f th e proceeding s i n th e above-captlone d cas e o n 7/22/09 , shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requesto rwit h conditions . Se e Origina l B yth e Court/s/ J B Johnson , J copie s mi d 9/4/0 9 dkt d 9/9A3 9 Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 11/4/09 . 11/5/09 . 12/2/09 . 12/3/09 . Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r11/4/09,11/5/09 , 12/2/09 , 12/3/0 9 @ 9:3 0 a.m . /s / WE F copie s mi d 9/16/0 9 dkt d 9/17/0 9 Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 9/23/0 9 Testimon yhear d 7/22/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e J B Johnson . J Cour t reporte rElizabet h Rocchino . Exhibit s liste d bu t no t attache d Notic e o fElectio n to . Retake.Nam e from Gai l R Seli g t o Gai l France s Roeshma n Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 9/9/0 9 Volum e 3 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 9/10/0 9 Volum e 4 Exhibit s Dft' s #1, 2 fro m hearin g o n 7/22/0 9 Maste rOrder ; Th e followin g i s recommende d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F copie s mId/dkt d 11/9/0 9 Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 11/24/0 9 Testimon yhear d 6/3/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e JB J Cour t reporte rMar

yMillsap s Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 11/24/0 9 Testimon yhear d 3/11/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e JB J Cour t reporte rMar

yMillsap s Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 11/24/0 9 Testimon yhear d 2/5/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e JB J Cour t reporte rMar

yMillsap s Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 11/4/09 , Volume s Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 11/5/0 9 Volum e 6 Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 1/1 3 an d1/14/1 0 @ 9:3 0 a.m . Master' s Hearin g Order ; AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r1/1 3 an d 1/14/0 9 /s / WE F copie s mi d 12/4/0 9 dkt d 12/7/0 9 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 12/2/0 9 Volum e 7 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 

# http://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

# rag e 0 o i y

02/16/201 0 02/17/201 0 03/01/201 0 03/01/201 0 03/23/201 0 03/23/201 0 03/30/201 0 04/06/201 0 04/07/201 0 04/07/201 0 04/12/201 0 04/26/201 0 04/26/201 0 05/04/201 0 05/17/201 0 05/17/201 0 06/04/201 0 06/04/201 0 06/07/201 0 06/07/201 0 

### 06/22/201 0 06/24/201 0 06/25/201 0 07/01/201 0 07/13/201 0 07/14/201 0 07/22/201 0 08/02/201 0 08/12/201 0 08/17/201 0 08/17/201 0 08/20/201 0 09/15/201 0 09/15/201 0 09/22/201 0 10/01/201 0 10/05/201 0 10/07/201 0 12/3/0 9 volum e 8

Master' s Hearin g Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r4/5/1 0 @ 9:3 0 a.m . /s / WE F copie s mi d 2/16/1 0 dkt d 2/17/1 0 Master' s Notic e settin g hearin g dat e o n 4/5/10 % 9:3 0 a.m . Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 1/1V10(^9:40a.m . Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n 1/14/1 0 @9:45a.m . Petitio n to //sfmarita l hom e fo rsale . File d b ypit f Rul e t o Sho wCaus e Rul e returnabl e fo r4/16/1 0 a t 9:3 0 a.m . /s/JB J Rul e t o Sho wCaus e fo r4/14/1 0 a t 9:3 0 a.m . /s / WEF . copie s mi d b yC.A . Answe rt o Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f file d b ydf t Petitio n fo rtransfe ro fownership . File d b ydft Rul e t o Sho wCaus e fo r4/14/1 0 a t 9:3 0 a.m . /s/JB J Answe r to dff s petitio n fo rtransfe rFile d b yAMuir , Es q ORDE R Wow, Apri l 26 . 201 0 th e transcrip t o fora l argumen t b e provide d t o requeste rwit h sai d condition s Se e orig . B yth e court : /s/JB J copie s mi d & dkt d 4/26/1 0 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hearin g hear d o n Apri l 5 , 201 0 a t 9:3 5 a.m . Volum e II . Cour t Reporter : Bonni e Becke r ORDE R Wow, 5/3/1 0 ordere d tha t Raymon d C . Geiger , J ri s appointe d t o perfor m rea l estat e appraisal s fo r//i s rea l property . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s / JB J copie s mi d & dkt d 5/4/1 0 Petitio n fo rBifurcatio n file d b ydft . Rul e 8 > Schedulin g Orde r Note s o fTestimon yfile d hear d o n 4/14/1 0 befor e th e Honorabl e Judg e Bria n J . Johnson . Cour t Reporter : Mar

yR . Millsaps , RPR-CMR . Transcrip t o fMaster's . Hearin g hear d o n May10 , 201 0 a t 1:1 0 p.m . befor e Maste rJoh n Roberts , III . Cour t Reporter : Bonni e Becker . RP R Rul e & Schedulin g Orde r Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f fo rdivorce . File d b yatt yBernstein . Exhibit s attached . Answe rto.Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f an d Ne wMatte rfile d b ypitf . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e to dft' s petitio n fo rbifurcatio n an d ne wmatte rFile d b ypitf . Affidavi t regardin g divorc e expenses . File d b ydft . Answe r- Repl y- Respons e b ydf t t o ne wmatte ro fpltf s repl yt o dft' s petitio n fo rbifurcation . Hearin g Schedulin g Orde r (Amended ) ORDE R Wow, 7/9/1 0 ordere d tha t df t i s directe d t o sig n agreemen t o fsal e alon g wit h th e seller' s disclosur e form . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s / JB J Copie s mi d 7/14/1 0 dkt d 7/15/1 0 Affidavi t o flega l expenses . File d b ypitf . Hearin g Schedulin g Orde r (Amended ) ORDE R Wow, 8/12/1 0 ordere d tha t orde rdate d 7/30/1 0 i s vacated . Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/JBJ . Copie s mi d 8/12/1 0 Dkt d 8/13/1 0 Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f File d b yatt yBernstein . Exhibit s attache d Rul e 8 i Schedulin g Orde r Affidavi t o fLega l Expenses . File d b ydft . ORDE R Wow, 9/14/1 0 ordere d tha t petitio n fo rbifurcatio n i s denied . Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/JBJ . copie s & 23 6 notic e mi d 9/15/1 0 & dkt d 9/16/1 0 ORDE R Wow, 9/14/1 0 ordere d tha t ora l motio n byplt fi s grante d an d Defendant' s Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie fi s denied . Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/JB J copie s & 23 6 notic e mi d 9/15/1 0 & dkt d 9/16/1 0 ORDE R Wow , 9/20/1 0 ordere d tha t a transcrip t o fth e proceeding s o n 9/14/1 0 shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o Requesto rbase d o n conditions . Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/JBJ . Copie s an d Rul e 23 6 Notic e Mi d 9/22/1 0 Dkt d 9/23/1 0 Answe rt o Petitio n fo rSpe.cia l Relie f file d b yatt yMui r Pra e t o Attach/Substitut e exhibi t t o Repl yo fPlaintif ffile d o n 10/1/10 . File d b yattyMui r Custod yHearin g Schedulin g Order ; (Amended ) /S/JBJ . Copie s an d Rul e 23 6 Notic e Mi d 10/6/1 0 Dkt d 10/8/1 0 

# http.7/publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

## Pag e 9 of 9

10/11/201 0 10/25/201 0 11/17/201 0 ORDE R

Wow. 10/6/1 0 ordere d tha t a hearin g o n thi s petitio n i s continue d unti l 11/15/1 0 a t 9:3 0 a.m . Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/JBJ . Copie s an d Rul e 23 6 Notic e Mi d 10/11/1 0 Dkt d 10/12/10 . Note s o fTestimon yfile d o n 10/25/1 0 @ 2;5 2 pm . Testimon yhear d 9/14/1 0 befor e th e Honorabl e Judg e Bria n Johnson . Cour t reporte rMar

yR Millsaps . ORDE R Wow, 11/15/10 , Ordere d tha t upo n agreemen t o fth e partie s throug h counsel , th e withi n mentione d item s shal l b e provide d t o th e Divorc e Master , Joh n Roberts , Esquire , fo rhi s consideration . Se e orig . B yth e court : /s / JBJ . Copie s &23 6 notic e mi d 11/17/10 . Dkt d 11/18/10 . FINANCIA LINFORMATIO N

01/11/200 7 01/11/200 7 02/14/200 7 02/14/200 7 02/23/200 7 02/23/200 7 06/19/200 7 06/19/200 7 08/02/200 7 08/02/200 7 07/25/200 8 07/25/200 8 Defendan t Sellg , Michae l B

Tota l Financia l Assessmen t Tota l Payment s an d Credit s Balanc e Du e a s o f12/16/201 0 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2007-078 7 Transactio n Assessmen t Paymen t Receip t # 2007-0317 6 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2007-0379 3 Transactio n Assessmen t Paymen t Receip t # 2007-01242 5 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2007-01593 6 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2008-01602 3 Mosebac h Fun t Dayto n & Duckwort h P C Mosebac h Fun t Dayto n & Duckwort h P C Funt , Harol d J Gardner , Lind a Shay Lifelin e Cardiolog y Bernstein , Josep h C , Es q 902.5 0 902.5 0 0.0 0 250.0 0 (250.00 ) 50.0 0 (50.00 ) 24.7 5 (24.75 ) 55.0 0 (55.00 ) 500.0 0 (500.00 ) 22.7 5 (22.75 )

10/10/200 6 10/10/200 6 03/06/200 7 03/06/200 7 07/14/200 8 07/14/200 8 Plaintif fRoeshman , Gai l France s

Tota l Financia l Assessmen t Tota l Payment s an d Credit s Balanc e Du e a s o f12/16/201 0 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2006-02137 3 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t # 2007-0451 0 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t #2008-01479 1 Scobiionko Selig , Gai l R Scobiionko & Scobiionko Mui rBartholome w& Melma n 430.0 0 430.0 0 0.0 0 325.0 0 (325.00 ) 50.0 0 (50.00 ) 55.0 0 (55.00 )



## http://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=49692 2 12/16/201 0