02/22/2013 12:18 FAX 2024835142**VZ/14/~UlJ 10:5~**  FAX 3107256816 FAA AWP-7

Western-Pacific Region**~** OMS

P.O. Box 92001 141002/011**~002**

U.S.**D~partment** ofT ransportalion Office of [he Regional Counsel Los Angeles, C.A, 90009·2007

Fecler.ll Aviation AdlniniStration Telephone: (310) 725·7117 Facsimile: (31 O)**~gfi-681.?**
FEB 14 2013



### CERTIFlED MA..IL- RETURN R'[CEIPT REOUES':tE2 

### and FACSWILE

Federal A-viation Administration 800 

### Independence Avenue, SW 

### 'Washington, DC 20591 Attu: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 

### Wilbur Wright Building

-- Suite 2Wl 

### 000

Re: In the Matter of Bradley**Lawren.~e** Good; FAA Case No. 2013WP0:0008 ···-•1;'""• <·.,**!'·~·~···,:·,)** :::·' '

.. " '

········'r''



### Enclosed is a copy 

### of a request for hearing dated January 29,2013, 

### received by O\lr 

### office on 

### February 8, 2013, and 

### the original and one copy of the Complaint in the 

### above-referenced 

### proceeding.

I request that 

### the hearing in this matter be 

### held 

### in the 

### Los Angeles, California 

### area 1 

### and expect that the hearing 

### will last one (1) day.



### Please address all communications 

### for the Regional 

### Counsel of the Western-Pacific Region,
to the undersigned, at: Office of the Regional Counsel, A WP-7.6, 

### Federal Aviation. Administration.**We~nemwPacific** 

### Region, P. Q. 

### Box 92007, Los Angeles, CA**90009~2007,** 

### Telephone: (310) 

### 72Sw7117,**FAX~** (310) 725"6816.


### Sincerely,

NAOMI 

### TSUDA

By:

s: Request 

### for Hearing; Complaint; Certificate 

### of Service



### NOTE TO RESPONDENT: SECTION 13.209 OF THE CP RULES OF PRACTICE REQUIRE THAT A WIUTTEN ANSWER TO THE COMPLAINT BE FILED NOT LATER THAN 30 DAYS AFTER SERVICEOF THE COMPLAINT. AS AN**~LTERNATIVE** TO FILING 

### AN ANSWER, A MOTION MAY 

### BE 

### FILED PURSUAN

.. f fO**SEC~f'ION** l3.208(D) OR SECTION**l3.218(F)(1~4)** OF THE RULES 01"' PRACTICE.02/22/2013 12:18 FAX 2024835142 FAA AWP-7 -l- OMS**v~~~~~,v~~ ~v;~~**  rAA**J~U/~~U~lU**

Date:

'ro:

CC:

From.:



### Ca.se #= 

### January 29, 2012



### Lierre M. 

### Green (originw) Attorney AWP-7.6, FM Office of the Regional 

### Ccmnsel P.O. Box 92007 Los Angeles, CA 90009-:2007

Attn: 

### Hearing Docket**Cl!~rk AGC~430,**  

### WUbur Wright Building, Suite 2Wl000 BOO 

### Independence Ave., SW Washington, D.C. 20591

Michael Shannon {Legal Counsel) 301 E. Colorado, Suite 320 

### Pasadena, CA 91101

Bradley Lawrence Good 

### 385 E. 

### Green St., #2611 Pasadena 1 

### CA 911 

### o 1 

### Email: bgood@ourgroup.org

2013WP010008**~003/011 ~003** 

In 

### reply to the 

### Notice of Pr.oposed Civll Penalty, I elect to 

### procee:d, as indicated 

### in the 

### attached document.

Bradley 

### Lawrence Good

## RECt~lVED 

# l

FEB

-- S 1.0\3 

# l

RI:!G!ON11L. COUNSr::::t 

## j02/22/2013 12:18 FAX 2024835142 02/14/2013 10:59 FAX 3107256816 FAA 

### AWP-7 -!- OMS 141004/011**~004**

.•.



### u.s.**De~artment** of Transportation

Fedetal Aviation Administration

JJ'N 1 7 2013**Western~Pac:ific** Region Office of thG! Regional Counsel P.O. Box 92007 Los Angeles, CA**90009~2007 T~lephone:**  (310) 725-71 i7 Facsimile: (310) 725-6810



### Ca'!la No. 

### 2013WP01 0008

q::RTIFIED MAlL- RETURN**B,E.~EIPT** REQUESTED 

### AND U.S. FIRST**CLAS~MAIL** 

### Bradley Lawrence Good 385 East Colorado 

### Blvd .• # 

### 2611 p,,sauc..'!la, CA 91101



### NOTICE OF**PROPOS:Ji~D** 

### CIVIL PENALTY



### BfiSed 011 

### a report of investigation, it 

### appears that:



### l. On or about November 11, 2012, at approximately 2325 1ooal, you pointed a laser El.t 

### an aircraft.

2. 

### The aircraft you pointed the laser at was a Bell 

### model OH-5 aircraft, civil registration number N96BM, which was flying in the vicinhy of North 

### Raymond A venue, in 

### Pasl:ldena, California.

3. The: beam of light illuminated the c:ockpit ofN96BM.

4. The beam oflight interfered with a crewmember in the performance:: 

### of the crewmember's duties aboard N96BM.

For these reasons, it appears you violated the following Federal Aviation Regulation (Title 14. Cc1de 

### ofFederal Regulations):

Section 9l.ll, 

### which states that no perso11 

### may assault, 

### threaten, intin'lidate) 

### or interfere 

### 'With a crevvmember 

### in the perfomla.nce ()f 

### the crcwmembel"'s duties aboard an aircraft being 

### operaTed.

Under 49 U.S.C. Section 46301(a), 

### you are subject to a. civil penalty fol' tl'lc violations noted. The maximum penalty for each violation is $11,000.00. We propose 

### w asses::; a civil penalty in**rh~·** 

### amount of $7,700.00 for the violations alleged.

Em:1osed is information. on your options in responding to this Notice.**Th~;** opti(mS include 

### pa.1tici:pating in an infom1al 

### conference with an FAA 

### attomcy, and submission of infi)rmation to rbe FAA for consideration. You must submil, in 'W'Jiting. your 

### choice of tbe :;tltemativas 

### explained on !he enclosed infonnation form. on 

### or before 30 days 

### after you receive tl1is Notice.02/22/2013 12:18 FAX 2024835142 02/14/2013 10:59 FAX 3107256816



### Bradley Lawrence Good FAA 

### AWP-7 -t OMS 141005/011 

### l4l 005

2

l f you fail to submit your choice 'Within that time, you will have no further Tight to participate in 

### the informal procedures.

ln the allcmative, 

### you may pay 

### yout civil penalty 

### with a credit card over the Tnte111ct. 

### To pay**electronically~** 

### visit the web site at 

### http://www.pa:r.:gov. Under 

### the "Search Public 

### Forms'' 

### option located on the left side of the page, 

### type FWP-'FINE1 and press "Go." On the page entitled "Search Public**Forms~"** 

### st."''oll to the bottom of the page and enter "Next Page." Click on "FAA Civil Penalty 

### Payments -Western-Pacific Rcgio;n," follow the prompts 

### to complete the**r(~quested** 

### information and click

.. 

### submit" to pay by 

### credit card.

Please direct all communications in this matter to Lieue M. Green, Attorney, A**VIP~7.6,** FAA, 

### ·Office of the Regional 

### Counsd, P.O. BOX**92007~** 

### Los Angeles, 

### CA 90009;.2007, tclcpho11e

number (310) 725-7117.

NAOMI TSUDA Regional 

### Counse



### By:



### cc: VNY FSDO, A WP-23002/22/2013 12:18 FAX 2024835142**U~/1~/~Ulj** 10;59 FAX 3107256816 FAA AWP-7 "' OMS

REPLY TO NOTICE OF PROPOSED CIVIL PENALTY 141008/011 !gJ 006



### For 

### Companies, Security 

### Cases, and 

### Individuals: Other than 

### those acting in the capacity of a 

### pilot, mechanic, 

### flight engineer 

### or repairman

Regional Counsel for the Western-Pacific Region r=ederal Aviation Administration, AWP-7. 

## i.P P.O. Box 92007 Los Angeles. CA 90009-2007

Subject: 

### _Notice of Proposed Civil**P~na.Jri**
In reply to your Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty, l elect to proceed as indicated 

### by my check mark beside the numbered 

### paragrap11(s) beJow:

1. [ ] I hereby submit the amount of the proposed civil penalty with the understanding**th~t** an order asse.ssing civil penalty 

### wit I be issued 

### in thm amount without further 

### notice, and that I 

### waive 

## -my ·right to a· 

### hearing.

2. [ ] I hereby submit evidence and information, demonstrating that a violation of the regulations did not occur or that the amount of 

### the penalty is not warranted 

### by the circumstances.

3 [ ] I hereby subrnit information and records showing that I am financially unable to pay the proposed civil penalty, or that payment of the 

## penaity would 

### prevent me from continuing in business.

' ¥• • ' 

## ., . I '"I, ' • .r
4. [ 

## 1 I 

### hereby request that a civil penalty be assessed 

### in the amount of$**~~--** and I submit the reasons for the reduction of the 

### proposed amount 

### My request constitutes my agreement that ifthis offer is accepted. by the FAA; an**O~der** /l.ssessing Civil Penalty in that amount 

### may be issued without 

### furthe!r notice arid I 

### waive my right to a hP.aring.

5. [ ] I hereby request an informal conference that will be held**a~** the Office of the Regional Counsel (Hawthorne,**California)~** a mutually convenient location, or telephonically in order to discuss this matter with the attorney in charge of this case and to present evidence and information on my behalf. Please indicate your choice

6. [ ]I hereby request 

### that the FAA impose a civil penalty without making the findings of violations, and submit 

### my reasons. 

### My request constitutes 

### my agreement that 

### if this offer is accepted, a Compromise Order will be issued in that amount and I waive 

### my right to a 

### hearing. -· 

### ED 

## 1 RECE\V**AWP~7** I'""OfitM 2150-25 (312012 Edition)

REG\ONJ\L :,OUNSfl.. .l02/22/2013 12:20 FAX 2024835142**~-· ~~'·v~v** **~u.u~** rna**~~ur~ooo~a** FAA AW'P-7 -t OMS



### 2. 141007/011
@ OOi



### 7. [ ] I

### h~reby claim 

### entitlement to a 

### waiver of 

### penalty under tne Aviation Safety Reporting Program and enclose evidence that a 

### timely report 

### was filed. As to the 

### allegations of 

### fact and violations:

7a. [ ] I request that an 

### Order Assessing Civil Penalty be issueC: an waive m•t right to a hearing.

7b. [ ] I request a 

### hearing in 

### thrs 

### matter in 

### accordance with paragraph 8.



### B. [

# ~ I hereby request

# ~ hearing in 

### accordance 

### with Subpart 

### G of 

### Part 13 of the 

### Federal Aviation 

### Regulations with 

### the understanding 

### that a C m 

### laint#'ill be filed. I 

### request that 

### the hearing be held in

### Q*'c~ tJF

### ~**~--** lOt'\ · (. 

### I arn sendrng this 

### request both to the FAA attorney and to the Fede Aviation Administration, 800 Independence Ave., SW, Washington, D.C. 20591, Attention: Hearing Docket Clerk, 

### AC"£-430, WilburWr' Buil

. , Suite 2W1000.



### Name:

Address:



### Telephone: 

# ,i\f"' 

# 1-**~"** 

# -**~.l** 0

# ~
Date: 

# --d Aw"\ 

# ,._q , ?--Ol

### ~ 

### Case No.: 

## .).lS!t"J.WfO 1 

## OOo<g

[ ] I request that 

### future documents in 

### this case be sent to:

Name:

-------------

Address:

## --------------~-------

Tek;;!phone: -----------.........;...-.**AWP~7** FORM 2150·25,**P~ge** 2 of 2 (3/2()12 Edition)ptEASEPRESSFIIY.tLYPL.f...-.:.--:.-,__.. :.·.-.PRIORITYNlAllREQUIREDU.<;.0(I'Ut"''I'UII'UI'""'-!....1'.)I..0<:•1-QPRIOR11YMIJIL==PAlOUlCf'tto'=IUA.£A0IIJAN29,'!3AKOUIIIJ-I$830Cl!:lllljnq-1'9!125ttiTEDSTIJTESPOSTIJLSERVICEltRateMailingEnvelope.-·-atusps.com1..eur.A'ff.A\lleib"OI).·€,.tl'4lt0JR."'AT10NALRf:S1RIC1101VSAPPL\1forms-amreqtdmd.Consulttilellational'MallMar.uafflMWiatpe.usps.go11lit.aretailassociatefDrtle1B1/s.23QS?495&£50·To:!Desti.r:ata.im:RECEIVED..."11til.....G-,.n...r-._.l\L.,......,'('P'\•...JIAIFEB82013,.Cfi/W(..l,.'W?...1'..COUI\ISF.LJFf.,?(i.Cl-AL.'1I)R,_.,..,\;oootw1t\:ftl'\'6oJle-'IO&Y.til1110".,co1cAVJ-SoLc,.....,..........,..,.,.,.;;;..,....'"'_jPS00001000014a"\.P;eass•1-I'U'c"""I..,:»-IIr;lII[!iIIII::>x;..C.I'U1-0CI'U-"'"'"l'o.CO001+-"'"'"Q:I'U>....,'1:1:»-I-l"'D3:1!§1[§1I.0g0coQO"'j0II02/22/2013 12:20 FAX 2024835142**v~~~~~~V~u ~1:vv**  rAA**J!U(~~ij~}~** FAA 

### AWP-i**~** OMS



### U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION OFFICE OF HEARINGS WASHINGTON, DC

In tht Matter 

### of Bradley Lawrence Good: 

### FAA DOCKET UNASSIGNED

FAA CASE NO. 2013WP010008 Respondent



### JUDGE NOT ASSIGNED

CO.MPLA Ttf[

The Complainant 

### files its Complaint, pursuant to Rule 208 

### of the Rules of Practice

(14 C-F 

### .R. 13 208), and states as 

### follows:

I.

Respondent, Bradley 

### Lawrence Good, was 

### advised through a 

### Notice of 

### Proposed 141008/011

141009



### Civil Penalty, dated January 17, 2013, 

### that the FAA 

### proposed to assess a civil penalty 

### hl the



### amount of $7, 700.00. 

### On Januazy 29, 20l3r 

### Respondent 

### submitted a written r·equest 

### for a hearing.

II.



### L · 

### On o:r 

### about November 

### 11, 2012, at approximately 

### 2325 local, Respondent 

### pointed a laser. at a11 

### a.ircraft.

2. The aircraft the Respondent painted the 

### laser at wa.s tt 

### Bell model 

### OI·l-5 ail-craft, civil registration number N96BM, wltich was flying 

### in 

### th¢ vicinicy 

### of 

### North Raymond Avenue, 

### in Pasadena, California.

3. The 

### bean1 of 

### light illuminated the cockpit ofN96BM.

4. Tlle 

### beam of light interfered 

### with a crewmember in the**perfo11nanc~:.:** 

### of the crewmember's duties aboard N968M.



### III.02/22/2013 12:20 FAX 2024935142

v•t .a.."::l '-VJ.oJ**~.L•** UV l"n...A. U.LUJ**..:::~00!\)** 

## --· --

.**~-** 

## --··--- FAA AWt'-7**~** OMS



### By reason ofrl1c 

### foregoing facts and circumstances, Respondent violated the 

### following

section of the 

### Federal Aviation Regulations (Title 14. CoU.e ·of Federal Reg\dations):**~010/011** [(j 010



### 3

Section 91.11, which states that no person may assault, 

### threaten, intimidate, 

### or in.terferc with a crew:member 

### in the pertbm1ance 

### of the crewmember's duties aboard



### an aircraft being operated.

IV.

1. Pursuant 

### to Thle 49 U.S.C. Seetion 46301 (a), Respondent 

### is subje(;t to 

# a civil



### pr.:nalty not to exceed $11,000.00 for each of the violations alleged.

2. Under the facts and circumstances 

### of this case, a civil penalty of $7,700.00 is

appropriate.

WHEREFORE, the Complainant, respectfully requests that the Adm1nistrative Law


### Judge enter an order that Respondent be assessed a 

### civil penalty in the amount of$7,700.00.

Respectfully submitted.

DATED: FE!3 

### 14 201302122 /2013 12:20 FAX

. 2024835142**U~/14/~0lJ** 11:00 

### FAX al07256S16 FAA 

### AWP-7



### CERTIFIQA_ TE 

### OF**SERVTC~** -1- OMS



### I hereby certifythat 

### on tl:ris date I have placed in the United

## Stt~tes mail, postage**~011/011** 

### l4l 011

4

prepaid, cenificd mail -return 

### receipt requested, the

## execut~:d ocigjnal 

### and one copy 

### of the


### Complaint, and 

### one copy 

### by 

### facsimile, addre:;sed as follows;

Federal 

### Aviation Administration 800 Independence A venue, SW Washington,DC 20591 Attll: Hearing OocketClerk, AGC·430 Wilbur Wright Building-Suite 2WI 000 

### .Facsimile: (202) r193w5l42



### I further certify that 

### on this date I

## have~ placed 

### in the United States 

### mail, postage
prepaid, certified mail

### ~ return receipt requested,

### ~nd regular mail, a true copy of 1 he 

### Complaint. addrt:ssed as follows:



### Dated:**Bradl~:y** Lawrence Good 

### 385 East Colorado Blvd., 

### # 

### 261.1 Pasadena, CA 911 0 I

and Michael Shazmon, Esq. 301 

### E.**Colorado~** Suite 320 Pasadena, CA 91101

FEB 14 2013

### ~ 

# 7

# JeffK~ , .egal Tec.hn.idail Office ofthe Regional Cuunsel Federal 

### Aviat.ion Administration Westem-Pacific Region 

### Lawndale. California