Final December 2010 

STi\Tr: OF WASH INGTON 

DEPARTMENT O F ECOLOGY 

1'0 8ox 47600 o Olympia, WA 9[]504-7600 o 360-407-6000 

711 for Washing/on /?clay Service o l'crsons 111ilh a speech disability Cilll call {)77-f/33-634 7 

July 7, 2010 

Mr. Don Sorensen, Refinery Manager 

Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

I 0200 West March Pojnt Road 

P. 0. Box 700 

Anacortes, W A 98221 

Dear Mr. Sorensen: 

Regional Haze Best Available Retr·ofit Technolot,ry (llART) Detet·mination 

Best Available Retrofit Technology (BART) is required to reduce the regional haze impacts of 

emissions of your facility. The enclosed Order #7838 contains our BART determination for your 

facility including a schedule for compli ance. 

If you have questions or requests relating to t!Jjs order, please contact Alan Newman at 

(360) 407-6810 or alan.newman@ecy.wa.gov. 

Sincerely, 

2/£ cjk 

Jeff Johnston, Ph.D. 

Manager, Science and Engineering Section 

Ajr Quality Program 

jj/te 

Enclosure 

By certitied mail 

cc: Toby Allen, NWCAA 

Alan Newman, Ecology 

Rebecca Spurling, Tesoro Refining and Marketing 
STATE OF WASIDNGTON 

DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY 

IN THE MATTER OF AN 

MINISTRA TIVE ORDER AGAINST: 

Tesoro Refming and Marketing Co. 

] 

] 

] 

] 

----~----------------------1 

TO: n Sorensen, Refmery Manager 

Tesoro fining and Marketing Con1pany 

1 0200 We March Point Road 

P. 0. Box 70 

Anacortes, W A 8221 

ORDER NO. 7838 

Final December 2010 

This is an Administrative Orde eqmrmg your company comply with WAC 173-400-151 by 

taking the actions which are desc · ed below. Chapter 0.94 RCW authorizes the Washington 

State Department of Ecology's Air ality Program cology) to issue Administrative Orders to 

require compliance with the requireme s of ChaP, r 70.94 RCW and regulations issued to 

implement it. 

Ecology has determined that portions of yo ility are subject to the provisions of the federal 

and state visibility protection program (W C 17 00-151 and 40 CFR Part 51, Subpart P). The 

rules require that the State determine w at technolo · s and level of emission control constitutes 

Best Available Retrofit Technology ART) for the eh ·ble emission units at your facility. The 

rules also require the installation a use of those emissio controls on the BART-eligible 

emission units. The emission co trois are to be installed as peditiously as possible, but in no 

event can the State allow the o start operation later than five ears after the State's Regional 

Haze SIP amendment is apg oved by the United States Environm tal Protection Agency (EPA). 

FINDINGS 

The Tesoro Refmi and Marketing Company operate an oil refmery on M 

Washington Stat that contains emission units that are subject to BART. 

-eligible emission units at the Tesoro refinery are: 

rocess heaters and boilers 

1. F-1 03, Crude Oil Distillation 

2. p.: 104, Gasoline Splitter/Reboiler 

3. F-304, CO Boiler #2 

4. F-654, Catalytic Feed Hydrotreater 

5. F-6600, Naphtha Hydrotreater 

L- 154 
Te ro Refining and Marketing Company 

B Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 010 

6. F- 601, Naphtha Hydrotreater 

7. F-6 2, Naphtha Hydrotreatcr 

8.. F-665 Catalytic Reformer · 

9. F-6651, atalytic Reformer 

10. F-6652, C lytic Reformer 

11. F-6653, Cata ic Reformer 

12. F-6654, Cataly · Reformer 

13. F-6655, Catalytic eformer 

b. Other units 

1. X-819, Flare 

2. CWT #2, Cooling Water To er 

3. CWT #2a, Cooling Water To 

B. BART enlission limitations for the BART-e · 

following technologies or a combination of 

Final December 201 0 

a. -6600, F-6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, 

b. Restricted use of fuel oil in 

c. Use of existing burners r control of nitrogen oxides on 

d. Use of the existing ue Gas Scrubber (FGS) to control sulfur 

particulate matter tnissions from Unit F-304. 

e. of the current, upgraded refinery fuel gas sulfur treat nt system for 

control of lfur dioxide emissions from all proc~ss. heaters and boilers eled with 

refmery el gas. 

f. Co nued operation of CWT #2 and #2a as currently permitted. 

Unit F- 04, CO Boiler #2, exhausts to the same pruticulate and S02 emission control devi (the 

Flue as Scrubber) with Unit F-302, CO Boiler #1. Currently installed enlissions monitorin 

de Ices monitor the enlissions of the Flue Gas Scrubber. Tesoro proposed and Ecology has 

cepted continuation ofmomtoring the emissions from the Flue Gas.Scrubber for compliance 

with the BART limitation for articulate and S02 from Unit F-304. 

L • 155 
Final December 2010 

YOU ARE ORDERED: To instaU and operate emission control equipment in accordance with 

the following conditions: 

BART EMISSION LIMITATIONS 

"" 1. Particulate Matter Emissions 

'- 1.1. Unit F-304 shall n1eet the following emission limitation: 

~ 1.1.1. Particulate matter less than 10 micron in diameter (PM10) emitted from the Flue 

Gas Stack shall not exceed 0.1 I grains/dscf, 1-hour average, corrected to seven 

percent oxygen, and 

'- 1.1.2. 1.0 lb PM/1 000 lb coke burnt off in the Catalyst Regenerator. 

" 1.2. For Units F-104, F-654, F-6600, F-6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F-6652, F-6653, 

F6654, F-6655, and X-819, (all other BART-eligible units), emissions shall not exceed 

0.05 grain/dscf (0.11 g/m3), 1-hour average, corrected to seven percent oxygen. 

"" 1.3. For Unit F-1 03, particulate matter emissions shall not exceed 0.05 grain/dscf (0.11 

g/m3), 1-hour average, (corrected to seven percent oxygen), except when burning fuel 

·oil as allowed by Condition 3..1. When burning fuel oil,.particulate emissions shall not 

exceed 0.10 grain/dscf, 1-hour average, corrected to seven percent oxygen. 

"'- I .4. For Units CWT #2 and #2a, particulate matter emissions shall not exceed 0.10 

grain/dscf (0.23 g/m3), 1-hour average. 

~ 1.5. Compliance with the particulate emission limits above will be determined as follows: 

"\l 1.5.1. For Unit F-304 

"-' 1.5.1.1. Compliance wi11 be demonstrated through use and continuous operation of 

the Flue Gas Scrubber as described in the unit's Operation and 

L- 156 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BAR~ Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 2010 

Page 4 of 15 

Maintenance Manual, including all unit start-up, shutdown, and 

malfunction procedures. 

v 1.5.1.2. Compliance with Condition 1.1.1 will be determined upon request of 

NWCAA or Ecology for emissions testing using EPA methods in 40 CFR 

Part 60 Appendix A. Particulate testing will use EPA Methods 5 and 202. 

~ 1.5.1.3. Compliance with Condition 1.1.2 will be determined upon request of 

NWCAA or Ecology for emissions testing using EPA methods in 40 CFR 

Part 60 Appendix A. Particulate testing will use EPA Method 5B. 

""'-' 1.5.2. For Unit F-.103, when burning oil, visually observe stacks on a daily basis to 

qualitatively assess whether enussions are visible. The frequency may be 

reduced to weekly if no visible emissions are observed for 30 consecutive days. 

Tesoro shall revert to daily observations of individual stacks if any visible 

emissions are noted during the observation. 

~ 1.5.3. For Unit F-103, when burning fuel gas and for Units F-104, F-654, F-6600, F6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F-6652, F-6653, F6654, F-6655, X-819 when 

burning gaseous fuels, visually observe stacks monthly to qualitatively assess 

whether emissions are visible. The frequency may be reduced to quarterly if no 

visible emissions are observed for six consecutive months. Tesoro shall revert 

to monthly observations of individual stacks if any visible emissions are noted 

during the observation. 

'\1 1.5.4. If visible emissions are observed from Units F-103, F-104, F-654, F-6600, F6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F-6652, F-6653, F-6654, F-6655, or X-819, 

reduce emissions to zero as soon as possible. If emissions cannot be reduced to 

zero, the pem1ittee may monitor by Ecology Method 9A no later than 24 hours 

after detection and daily thereafter until opacity is shown to be less than 20 

percent or the pennittee will conduct a Method 5 assessment within 30 days. 

~ 1.5.5. Keep records of all observations available for inspection . 

.J 1.5.6. For Units F-103, F-104, F-654, F-6600, F-6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F6652, F-6653, F6654, and F-6655, and upon request ofNWCAA or Ecology 

compliance with Condition 1. 2 and 1.3 will be determined using EPA methods 

in 40 CFR Part 60 Appendix A. Particulate testing will use EPA Methods 5. 

L- 157 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

-- 2. Nitrogen Dioxide Emissions 

~ 2.1. Unit F-103 

Final December 2010 

Page 5 of 15 

~ 2.1.1. Starting no later than the date in Condition 5, emissions of nitrogen dioxide 

from Unit F-103 is limited to: 

2.1.1.1. 59.1 tons/yr, rolling annual (365 days) total cal~ulated daily~ 

-.... 2.1.2. ·Compliance will be determined by us~ of a continuous emission monitoring 

system meeting the criteria of Condition 9.3 or a source-specific emission factor 

developed and periodically revised per Conditions 9.4 and 9.5. 

~ 2.1.3. Emissions testing utilizing EPA Reference Method 7E will be performed within 

180 days of the start of operation of the NOx control system. 

-., 2.2. · Units F-104, F-304, F-654, F-6600, F-6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F-6652, F-6653, 

F-6654, F-6655, X-819 

2.2.1. No nitrogen dioxide emission lhnitations are applicable to these units. 

-, 3. Sulfur Dioxide Emissions 

·3.1. Unit F-103 

- 3.1.1. Starting no later than the date in Condition 5, Unit F-103 is to be fired by 

refmery fuel gas meeting the requirements of Condition 3.4 below, or natural 

gas. Fuel oil may be used when the conditions in Condition 3 .1.2 are met. 

- 3.1.2. Fuel oil may be used only in the following circumstances: 

~3.1.2.1. Curtailment of natural gas supply, or 

- 3. I .2.2. Periods with limited refmery fuel gas availability such as start-up and 

shutdown of major refmery process units, while maj~r refmery process 

tmits are not operating and producing refmery gas, and emergency 

conditions as necessary to maintain safe operations or equipment 

shutdown, or 

' 3.1.2.3. Test firing on fuel oil is allowed for up to 24 hours per calendar year. 

L- 158 
Final December 2010 

Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

Page 6 of15 

July 7, 2010 

, 3.2. Unit F-304 

"' 3 .2.1. Starting no later than the date in Condition 5, emissions of sulfur dioxide in the 

stack from the Flue Gas Scrubber treating the exhaust from Units F-304 and F302 is to meet the following: 

'- 3.2.1.1. Not exceed, 25 ppmv (dry basis, 0%02, 365-day rolling average), or 

""' 3 .2.1.2. 50 ppmv ( dl)' basis, 0% 02, 7 -day rolling average). 

""'- 3.2.1.3. Compliance to be den1onstrated by a continuous emissions monitor 

meeting the criteria of Condition 8.1. 

~ 3.2.1.4. Bypassing of the Flue Gas Scrubber 

~ 3.2.1.4.1. Bypassing of the Flue Gas Scrubber is to be minimized. 

'- 3.2.1.4.2. Sulfur dioxide emission when the Flue Gas Scrubber is bypassed 

shall not exceed 1 000 ppmdv, 1-hour average, corrected to seven 

percent oxygen. Compliance with the 1 000 ppmdv limitation must 

be demonstrated by use of a continuous emissions monitor or mass 

balance calculation. The mass balance calculation must assume all 

sulfur entering Units F-302 and F-304 (CO Boilers #1 and #2) is 

oxidized to so2 and discharged to the atmosphere unless 

demonstrated otherwise by process data and/or analytical methods 

at representative operating conditions. 

" 3.2.1.4.3. Records and data used to determine compliance with this provision 

shall be kept for at least five years and made available to NWCAA 

or Ecology on request. 

~ 3.2.1.4.4. Sulfur dioxide emissions during bypass of the Flue Gas Scrubber 

shall be minimized to the extent reasonably practicable by methods 

such as FCCU feed rate reduction, FCCU feed sulfur content 

reduction, catalyst utilization, and/or other actions. These 

procedures are to be incorporated into the. FCCU operations and 

maintenance procedures. 

\. 3.2.1.4.5. Records must be taken during each Flue Gas Scrubber bypass 

event. The records shall contain the date and time of the beginning 

and end of the bypass event, all actions taken to reduce so2 

L- 159 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 2010 

Page 7 of 15 

emissions during the bypass, all actions required to restart the Flue 

Gas Scrubber and end bypassing. The record may take the form of 

a checklist. Records of each bypass event shall be retained at the 

facility for at least five years and be tnade available to NWCAA or 

Ecology upon request. 

"' 3.3. Units F-104, F-654, F-6600, F-6601, F-6602, F-6650, F-6651, F-6652, F-6653, F-6654, 

F-6655 

"'\, 3.3.1. Starting no later than the date in Condition 5, these units shall only fire refinery 

gas meeting the criteria in Condition 3.4 or natural gas. 

~ 3.4. Refmery fuel gas requiren1ents 

"'\1 3.4.1. Refmery fuel gas from blend drum V-213 shall not contain greater than 0.10 

percent by volume H2S, 365-day rolling average, measured according to 

Condition 8.3 of tllis order. 

"'-. 3.4.2. Bypass of acid gas from the amine regenerator C-1120 system away from the 

normal processing flow to General Chemical shall be recorded and reported the 

NWCAA (i.e., any period that PC5265A is opened). A root-cause analysis shall 

be conducted and recorded for any bypass event. 

SCHEDULE FOR COMPLIANCE 

~ 4. Particulate Matter Emissions 

"" 4.1. For all units, compliance with the emission limitations is required on the issuance date 

of thls Order. 

"-l 5. Schedule for Compliance with Sulfur Dioxide Emissions Limitation 

~ 5.1. For all units, compliance with the emission limitations is required on the issuance date 

of this Order. 

"-~ 6. Schedule for Compliance with Nitrogen Dioxide Emissions Limitations 

\.1 6.1. Compliance with the nitrogen dioxide emission limitation for Unit F -103 is to be 

achieved as follows: 

L- 160 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 201 0 

Page 8 of 15 

"'-~ 6.1.1. Submittal ofNotice of Construction application to NWCAA for the installation 

ofNOx controls on Unit F-103 no later than June 30, 2014. The facility may 

submit a request fbr an extension to Ecology no later than 90 days prior to this 

date. Ecology will respond to the facility in writing whether it will accept or 

deny the extension request. 

~ 6.1.2. Start of construction for installation ofultra-low-NOx burners in Unit F-103, no 

later than March 1, 2015. The facility may submit a request for an extension to 

Ecology no later than 90 days prior to this date. Ecology will respond to the 

facilitY in writing whether it will accept or deny the extension request. 

"\J 6.1.3. Start operation of emission controls installed to meet the NOx emission 

limitation no later than September 30, 2015. The facility may submit a request 

for an extension to Ecology no later than 90 days prior to this date. Ecology 

will respond to the facility in writing whether it will accept or deny the 

extension request. 

\s 6.1 .4. Compliance with the 365-day rolling average emission limit begins on the 365th 

day after the date the emission controls start operation unless the criteria of 

Condition 14 are invoked. 

MONITORING AND RECORDKEEPING REQUIREMENTS 

"~ 7. Particulate Matter {PMto) 

'- 7.1. For Unit F-304, Flue Gas Scrubber Stack 

' 7.1.1. Particulate emissions stack test results shall be submitted to NWCAA and 

Ecology upon request. 

- 7.1.2. Emissions testing shall use EPA Methods 5 and 202 to demonstrate compliance 

with Condition· I .1.1. 

'" 7.1.3. Emissions testing shall use the procedures of40 CFR 63.1564(c) and 63.1572 to 

demonstrate compliance with Condition 1. 1 .2. 

4 

7.1.4. Visual emissions tnonitodng data shall be recorded and retained at the facility 

available for review by NWCAA or Ecology inspectors. 

7 .1.5. Visible emissions observation records are to be retained at the facility for at 

least five years. 

L- 161 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

~ 7.2. For all other BART-eligible emission units 

Final December 2010 

Page 9 of15 

~ 7.2.1. Particulate emissions stack test results shall be submitted to NWCAA and 

Ecology upon request. 

- 7.2.2. Emissions testing shall use EPA Method 5. 

"- 7 .2.3. Visual emissions monitoring data shall be recorded and retained at the facility 

available for review by the NWCAA or Ecology inspectors. 

' 7.2.4. Visible emissions observation records are to be retained at the facility for at 

least five years. · 

"""""'8. Sulfur Dioxide 

"' 8.1. UnitF-103 

-..... 8.1.1. A record of all hours of operation using fuel oil shall be kept. The record shall 

record the day and time of the start of use of fuel oil, the day and time fuel oil 

use ends, and the reason fuel oil is used. 

"" 8.1.2. The records are to be retained at the facility for at least five years and be made 

available to NWCAA or Ecology upon request. 

"" 8.2. Unit F-304 

~ 8.2.1. A continuous etnission monitor system (CEM) shall be installed, calibrated, 

maintained, and operated to measure oxygen and S02 concentrations in the Flue 

Gas Scrubber stack. 

"""' 8.2.2. The monitors shall meet the more stringent of the specifications of 40 CFR Part 

60 Appendices B and F, or the NWCAA Regulation 367 and Appendix A. 

-...... 8.2.3. S02 emissions data from the CEM shall be maintained as calendar day average 

concentrations (ppmdv). The daily averages shall be used to calculate and 

record 7-day and 365-day rolling averages. The daily average S02 

concentrations and calculations of the 7 -day and 3 65-day averages shall be 

retained at the facility for at least five years and made available to NWCAA or 

Ecology on request. 

L- 162 
Tesoro Reflning and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

----..., 8.3. Refmery fuel gas systen1 

Final December 201 0 

Page 10 of 15 

-.... 8.3.1. A continuous emissions monitoring system (CEMS) for hydrogen sulflde 

concentration shall be installed, calibrated, maintained, and operated measuring 

the outlet stream of the fuel gas blend drum subsequent to all unmonitored 

incoming sources of sulfur cmnpounds to the system and prior to any fuel gas 

combustion device. The monitor shall be certified in accordance with 40 CFR 

Part 60 Appendix B and operated in accordance with 40 CFR Part 60 Appendix 

F and the NWCAA Regulation 367 and Appendix A. 

"8.3.2. Record the calendar day average H2S concentration of the refinery fuel gas as 

measured by the CEM required in Condition 8.3.1. The daily averages shall be 

used to calculate the 365-day rolling average. Records of the daily average H2S 

concentration and 365-day rolling averages are to be retained at the facility for 

at least five years and be made available to NWCAA or Ecology upon request. 

"""-. 9. Nitrogen Dioxide Emissions 

'>J 9.1. Unit F-103 

" 9.1.1. Nitrogen dioxide emissions are to be quantified by means of a continuous 

emission monitoring system,· consisting of a continuous nitrogen oxides monitor 

and a continuous flow rate monitor meeting the requirements of Condition 9.3, 

or 

'- 9.1.2. Development of a unit-specific emissions factor. The method to develop and 

update the emission factor is described in Conditions 9.4 and 9.5 below. 

~ 9 .2. All other BART -eligible units 

"-.J 9 .2.1. No monitoring and recordkeeping requirements. 

~ 9.3. Nitrogen oxides and flow continuous monitor requirements 

~ 9.3 .1. The monitor shall meet the more stringent of the specifications of 40 CFR Part 

60 Appendices Band F, or the NWCAA Regulation 367 and Appendix A. 

\1 9.3.2. :J;:ach calendar day's average nitrogen oxides emissions will be calculated and 

recorded daily. 

L- 163 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 2010 

Page 11 of 15 

' 9.3.3. The rolling annual total nitrogen oxides emissions shall be recalculated and 

recorded daily. 

'--- 9.4. If used, a unit-specific emissions factor, expressed as lb!MMBTU of fuel frred shall be 

based on the following: 

""9.4.1. Minimum of four discrete NOx stack tests utilizing the emission test method 

given in 40 CFR Part 60, Appendix A, Method 7E. 

""' 9.4.2. Each of the four tests is to be no closer than three weeks apart or as specified in 

the source testing plant submitted to NWCAA and Ecology and approved by 

both agencies. 

" 9 .4.3. The frrst test is the initial compliance test specified in Condition 2.1.3. 

- 9.4.4. Each source test must include information on production rate through the unit, 

fuel frring rate, specific gravity of the refmery fuel gas, and heat content of the 

refmery fuel gas. For Unit F-103, the information recorded will include 

whether fuel oil was used during the test and the nitrogen and sulfur content ~f 

the fuel oil. 

..... 9.4.5. Each stack test shall be conducted at normal operating rate. 

-. 9.4.6. ·The supporting information and the emission factor (or factors if multiple 

operating rates have been tested) developed shall be submitted to NWCAA and 

Ecology within 60 days of the last of the emission tests. Ecology and NWCAA 

n1ust concur with the appropriateness of the factor proposed. 

- 9.5~ If the NOx emissions frmn Unit F-103 are determined by a unit-specific emission 

factor, nitrogen oxide emissions shall be tested at least once each calendar year utilizing 

40 CFR Part 60, Appendix A, Method 7E. The information specified in Condition 

9.4.4 shall be collected as part of each emission test, and with all previous emissions 

and process information collected, is used to recalculate the unit-specific emission 

factor for use in the following calendar year. 

REPORTING REQUIREMENTS 

10. The test report for the initial NOx emission control system performance testing required by 

Condition 2.1 shall be submitted to Ecology and to NWCAA within 45 days of completion. 

L- 164 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 201 0 

Page 12 of.15 

11. Docwnentation of completion of each milestone in Condition 6 will be provided by Tesoro 

by certified mail to Ecology and to NWCAA within 30 days of completion. 

12. Continuous emission monitoring data and/or emission factor based emissions shall be 

submitted to Ecology and to NWCAA on a semiannual basis, January through June and July 

through December. The semiannual report shall be provided within 45 days of completion of 

the reporting period. The submittal shall be electronically in a format acceptable to 

NWCAA. Reporting to Ecology will end when Tesoro has demonstrated compliance with 

the BART emission limits in tlris order applicable to a specific unit for a continuous 36-

month period. 

13. Continuous Emission Monitoring Quality Control Testing 

13.1. Data quality control testing shall be perfornied at least once per calendar quarter. This 

entails Cylinder Gas Audits and Relative Accuracy Audits. 

13.2. A Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) test shall be performed at least once per year 

on every CEM system required by this Order. 

13.3. All RATA tests shall assess the ability of the entire system from stack probe to data 

acquisition system output. 

13.4. Tesoro shall notifY Ecology and NWCAA when annual RATA testing is scheduled to 

occur, no later than 30 days prior to the testing date. 

13.5. Tesoro shall provide Ecology and NWCAA a copy of the RATA test results in an 

electronic format within 45 days of completion of the RATA test. 

13 .6. Tesoro shall provide NWCAA the results of all quarterly cylinder gas audits performed 

with the next quarterly data assess1nent report submitted to NWCAA. 

. . If the request is submitted before installation of the control techno 

L- 165 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 2010 

Final December 201 0 

Page 13 of15 

14.1.1. Tesoro documents the technical difficulties and reasons why the limit canno e 

achieved. 

Tesoro provides documentation of all work with the equipment vend 

r staller, if one is involved, to achieve the emission limitation. 

14.1.3. Teso proposes an alternative control technology and emissi 

. BART r this unit, including an ev~uation of the visibili nprovement 

achievab through implementation of the proposed limi ion compared to the 

effect of the imitation currently in this Order. 

14.2. If the request is submitt after the unit has been in oper ron, but no sooner than 12 

months after the start of o ration, Tesoro's request st contain: 

14.2.1. All information collect by Tesoro and i vendor or equipment installer to 

determine reasons for fai ·e to n1eet tl etnission limitation, including but not 

limited to: 

14.2.3. Copies of all continuous e 

14.2.4. Documentation of op 

14.2.5. Fuels used and ult.imate analysis informat n to be provided for at least one 

14.2.6. Tesoro pr oses as BART an en1ission limitation bas on the capabilities of 

the con ol equipment as installed on the unit (includin asis for it) for the 

revis emission linlitation. The request shall include an aluation of the 

vi · ility hnprovernent achievable through implementation the proposed 

mitation compared to the improven1ent provided by the limit 

this Order. 

may request this compliance Order be rescinded after all of the following o cur: 

.1. All BART units at the plant have continuously complied with the emissions limi 

in Conditions 1, 2, and 3 for a period of three years after the date in Condition 6. 

L- 166 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BART Compliance Order #7838 

uly 7, 2010 

Final December 2010 

Page 14 of 15 

. The emission linutations in.~hls Order have been incorporated into one or re 

nforceable orders or permits issued under the criteria ofRCW 70.94.15 or 70.94.153 

NWCAA regulations implementing these provisions. 

15.3. Thee 'ssion limitations in the enforceable orders or permits have 

into the ·r Operating Permit issued by NWCAA to Tesoro. 

16. By issuance of thls rder, the requirements of Order 5071 have b n complied with and it is 

rescinded. 

Within 20 days of receipt oft · s Order, you may request a del in the submittal date. Any such 

request must be acco1npanied b a written justification fort delay. 

Failure to comply with thls Order m result in the issu ce of civil penalties or other actions, 

whether administrative or judicial, to e orce the te of thls Order. 

You have a right to appeal this Order. To a 

o File your appeal with the Pollution C 

receipt" of this document. Filing 

hours. 

I Hearing Board withln 30 days of the "date of 

al receipt by the Board during regular office 

o Serve your appeal on the De rtment of Ecology 'thin 30 days of the "date of receipt" 

of this document. Service 1ay be accomplished by y of the procedures identified in 

WAC 371-08-305(10). ' ate of receipt" is defmed at CW 43.21B.001(2). · 

If you appeal, you must: 

o Include a copy ·this docmnent with your Notice of Appeal. 

o Serve and fil your appeal in paper form; electronic copies are not 

To file your apP, al with the Pollution Control Hearing Board: 

The ollution Control Hearings Board 

P . -Box 40903 OR 

lympia, W A 98504-0903 

L- 167 

Deliver your appeal in person t · 

The Pollution Control Hearings Bo 

4224-6th A venue SE Rowe Six, Bldg 

Lacey, WA 98503 
Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 

BAR Compliance Order #7838 

July 7, 10 

eal on the Department of Ecology: 

Mail appeal to: 

Departn1ent of Ecolo 

Appeals Coordinator 

P.O. Box 47608 

Olympia, W A 98504-7608 

And send a copy of your appeal pack 

Alan Newman 

Department of Ecology 

Air Quality Program 

P.O. Box 47600 

Olympia, W A 98504-7600 

OR 

For additional information, go to the Environme 

http://www.eho.wa.gov. 

Department of Ecology 

Appeals Coordinator 

300 Desmond Drive -i 

~acey, WA 98503 

To find laws and agency rules, go to the W. shington State Leg1 

http://www l.leg. wa.gov/CodeReviser. 

Final December 201 0 

Page 15 of15 

Your appeal alone will not stay the fectiveness of this Order. Stay r uests must be submitted 

in accordance with RCW 43.21B. 0. These procedures are consistent 

Chapter 43.21B RCW. 

L- 168