Index of Comments Received on Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking 

Docket No. EPA-R09-OAR-2009-0598 

Commenter Affiliation Date Document # 

Robert Wagner 8/28/09 0037 

Norman Fichthorn UARG 9/3/09 0038 

John Slaughter 8/25/09 0039 

Rachell Hoopes 8/26/09 0040 

David Steele WEST Associates 8/31/09 0042 

David Modeer CAP 9/1/09 0043 

Richard Hayslip SRP 9/1/09 0044 

Mark Schiavoni APS 9/2/09 0045 

Norman Fichthorn UARG 9/3/09 0046 

Gary Yaquinto AIC 9/4/09 0047 

Mark Camrud 9/7/09 0048 

Erik Bakken TEP 9/9/09 0055 

Glenn Hamer AZ Chamber of Commerce 9/9/09 0056 

Carla Sonntag NM Utility Shareholders Alliance 9/9/09 0057 

William Hagler 9/10/09 0058 

James Sims Western Business Roundtable 9/11/09 0059

Kim Ground 9/14/09 0060 

David Modeer CAP 9/15/09 0061 

Mark Schiavoni APS 9/15/09 0062 

Richard Hayslip SRP 9/15/09 0063 

Norman Fichthorn UARG 9/16/09 0069 

Benjamin Grumbles ADEQ 9/18/09 0070 

James Martin CDPHE 9/25/09 0071 

Seth Cohen New Mexico AG Office 9/28/09 0072 

John Suthers Colorado AG Office 9/28/09 0073 

Ann Kirkpatrick U.S. Congress - AZ 9/16/09 0074 

William Sharer New Mexico State Senate 9/18/09 0075

Kris Dixon 9/28/09 

Raul Grijalva U.S. Congress – AZ 10/7/09 0077 

Janice Brewer Governor of AZ 10/13/09 0078 

John Lewis Inter Tribal Council of AZ, Inc 10/13/09 0079 

Ed Pastor U.S. Congress - AZ 10/14/09 0080 

Harry Mitchell U.S. Congress – AZ 10/15/09 0081 

Ann Kirkpatrick, 

Trent Franks, Jeff 

Flake, Gabrielle 

Giffords 

U.S. Congress – AZ 10/15/09 0082 

Ben Lujan, Harry 

Teague, Ann 

Kirkpatrick 

U.S. Congress – AZ 10/15/09 0083 

Warde Nichols Arizona House of Representatives 10/16/09 0084 
Roger Irwin 10/19/09 0085 

Jeff Bingaman U.S. Senate – NM 10/19/09 0089 

Kirk Adams AZ House of Representatives 10/21/09 0090 

Robert Burns AZ State Senate 10/21/09 0091 

Michael Curtis AZ Municipal Power Users Assoc 10/22/09 0092 

Christopher 

Deschene 

AZ House of Representatives 10/23/09 0093 

John Kyl, John 

McCain, John 

Shadegg 

U.S. Senate and U.S. House of 

Representatives 

10/23/09 0094 

Carla Sonntag NM Utility Shareholders Alliance 10/23/09 0095 

Andy Janeczek 10/24/09 0096 

Orestuf 10/24/09 0097 

Karsten Crouse 10/24/09 0098 

Jodi Foran League of Women Voters of 

Montezuma County 

10/25/09 0099 

Jodi Foran Montezuma Climate Action 

Network 

10/25/09 0100 

Bill Vana 10/25/09 0101 

Tom Buschatzke City of Phoenix 10/26/09 0108 

Alisa Gardiner 10/26/09 0109 

Stephanie Huss League of Women Voters of La 

Plata County 

10/26/09 0110 

Karen Lovelien and 

Fred Boshardt 

 10/26/09 0111 

Janet Rees 10/26/09 0112 

Joe Ward 10/26/09 0113 

Jim D’Arezzo Biofriendly 10/27/09 0115 

Nancy Norem Public Service Company of NM 10/27/09 0116 

Steven Olson AZ Municipal Water Users 10/27/09 0117 

Cynthia Ortman 10/27/09 0118 

Gary Yaquinto AZ Investment Council 10/27/09 0119 

Alice Boyd 10/28/09 0120 

Michael Cochran 10/28/09 0121 

Mike Eisenfeld San Juan Citizens Alliance 10/28/09 0122 

Norman Fichthorn UARG 10/28/09 0123 

Eric Massey ADEQ 10/28/09 0124 

William Hagler 10/28/09 0125 

Richard Hayslip Salt River Project 10/28/09 0126 

Charles Roybal 10/28/09 0127 

Robert Lynch Irrigation and Electrical Districts 

Assoc of Arizona 

10/28/09 0128 

Douglas Miller CAP 10/28/09 0129 

William Rhodes Governor, Gila River Indian 

Community 

10/28/09 0130 
Chris Udall Agribusiness Council of AZ 10/28/09 0131 

Jeff Biggs City of Tucson Water Dept. 9/14/09 0150 

Glenn Hamer AZ Chamber of Commerce 9/15/09 0151 

Gary Yaquinto AZ 9/15/09 0152 

David Crockett S. Arizona Water Users Assoc 9/17/09 0153 

Keith Johns San Juan County, NM 9/17/09 0154 

Carol Spencer and 

Margaret McDaniel 

San Juan Economic Development 

Service 

9/21/09 0155 

John Johnson 10/1/09 0156 

Thomas and Diane 

Metzger 

 10/5/09 0157 

Mary Felter The Hopi Tribe 10/12/09 0158 

John Lewis Inter Tribal Council of AZ, Inc 10/13/09 0159 

John Camper Tucson Metropolitan Chamber of 

Commerce 

10/19/09 0160 

Boyd Dunn City of Chandler, AZ 10/19/09 0161 

David Crockett S. Arizona Water Users Assoc 10/21/09 0162 

Jeff Biggs City of Tucson Water Dept. 10/22/09 0163

Loren Brown 10/22/09 0164 

James Cavanaugh Mayor, City of Goodyear 10/23/09 0165 

John Lewis Mayor, City of Gilbert 10/23/09 0166 

Mary Felter Acting CEO, The Hopi Tribe 9/11/09 0167

James Doyle Metro Water District 9/15/09 0168 

Joe Shirley, Jr. President, Navajo Nation 9/16/09 0169 

Rick Cables and 

Corbin Newman 

USDA Forest Service, Rocky 

Mountain Region 

10/26/09 0170 

David Godlewski S. AZ Home Builders Assoc 10/26/09 0171 

Michael Guymon Metropolitan Pima Alliance 10/26/09 0172 

Marshall Brown City of Scottsdale, Water 

Resources 

10/23/09 0173 

Dean Martin Arizona State Treasurer 10/26/09 0174 

Peter Spehar 10/20/09 0175 

Mary Uhl NMED 10/27/09 0177 

Lorri Gray-Lee US DOI, Bureau of Reclamation 10/28/09 0178 

Wally Murphy US DOI, Fish and Wildlife Service 11/3/09 0190 

66 letters Various 0191 

1766 letters National Parks Conservation 

Association 

Various 0192 

291 letters Sierra Club Members Various 0193 

4400 letters Sierra Club Various 0194 

Ed Fox Arizona Public Service (APS) 10/28/09 0195 

Amy Atwood et al. Consortium of 11 Environmental 

Groups 

10/28/09 0196 

James Doyle Metropolitan Domestic Water 

Improvement District 

10/14/09 0197 
Philip Saletta Town of Oro Valley 9/28/09 0200 

David Modeer Central Arizona Project 12/18/09 0206 

Ned Norris, Jr. Tohono O’Odham Nation 12/11/09 0207

Michael Snyder National Park Service 11/20/09 0208 

Joe Shirley, Jr. President, Navajo Nation 3/1/10 0209 

William Rhodes Gila River Indian Community 2/23/10 0210 

Leroy Shingoitewa The Hopi Tribe 3/1/10 0211 

Ned Norris, Jr. Tohono O’Odham Nation 3/1/10 0212 

Leroy Shingoitewa The Hopi Tribe 3/1/10 0213 

Robert Palmquist Ak-Chin Indian Community 3/1/10 0214 

John Jacobson 0216 

Ed Helbing 0217 

Scott Michlin San Juan United Way 0218 

Richard Hayslip Salt River Project 0219 

Eladio Knipping Electric Power Research Institute 0220 

Glenn Kellow BHP Billiton 10/28/09 0221 

David Steele West Associates 10/28/09 0222 

Norman Fichthorn Hunton and Williams 0223 

Anonymous 0224 

Lin Sloan 0225 

Vincent Yazzie 0226 

Erik Bakken Tucson Electric Power Company 10/28/09 0227 

Allen Wollscheidt 0228 

Anonymous 0229 

Eladio Knipping Electric Power Research Institute 0230 

Mary Uhl New Mexico Environment 

Department 

10/27/09 0231 

Larry Echo Hawk Bureau of Indian Affairs 3/5/10 0235 

Clean Energy Group 3/16/10 0236 

Peter Yucupicio Pasqua Yaqui Tribe 12/14/09 0237 

Kate Waite 12/11/09 0238 

John Mullen 12/09/09 0239 

Sandra L. Doty 12/09/09 0240 

Gordon R. Briggs 12/13/09 0241 

Elizabeth J. RohnNelson 12/09/09 0242 

April Riggons 12/31/09 0243 

Diane Enos Salt River Pima Maricopa Indian 

Community 

3/1/10 0244