P. 1



# OAR Box 1850 Prepped by Ollie Stewart



## Document

Number: 

# 79 ) IV-C- 2

Docket Number: 

# A-90-0 7

Printed 11/18/2008 11:09:28 AM Sheet 79 of 161P. 2

03-;j:5.'9 4 07:3 6 ©202280318 8 EPA-' C CD 'lOOO/OO t 

## fr-?O-0~7

UNITE D STATE S E.NV1RONMENTA L PROTECTION AGENC Y WA^INGfTON , D.C . 2046 0



## MA Y 2 4 

## 1994 

# 7

) i l JLiXl l

EP A AI R DOCKET OFHCEO F PREVENTION

, PESTTODeS AfJ

D TCDGCSUBSTA»4CES 

## Dr
. L
. S
. Andrew s ARC O Chemica l Cocnp.an y 380 1 Wes t Cheste r Pik e Newtow n Square , P A1907 3 Dea r Dr
. Andrews : Yo u recentl yreceive d a lette r date d Marc h3 , 199 4 fro mJoseph Carra , Deput yDirecto r o f th e Offic e o f Pollution Preventio n an d Toxics , whic hinvite d industr yt o ente r int o discussion s wit hEPA regarding th e testing o f the fue l oxygenate s ethy l tertiary-buty l ethe r (ETBE ) (CA

S No
. 637-92-3 ) an

d tertiajryamy

l methy l ethe r (TAME ) (G2^ S No
. 994-05-8)
. W e wis ht o clarif ya statemen t mad e i n tha t letter

. A t th e oxyfuel s meeting i n researc hTriangl e Par k o n Decembe r 7-8 , 1993 , industr

yparticipant s raise d a concern t o EPAtha t mino r difference s i n protocol s betwee n testin g voluntaril yagreed t o unde r th e Toxi c Substance s Contro l Ac t (TSCA ) .an d testin

g t o b e require d unde r th e soo n promulgate d fina l rul e o n fuel " an d fue l additive s testing unde r section 21 1 (b ) o f the Clean Ai r Ac t (CAA ) , migh t resul t i n th e nee d t o repea t testing

. I n respons e t o thi s concern w e include d th e followin g statemen t i n th e Marc h3rd letter : "Dat a collecte d unde r eithe r a voluntar yagreemen t o r require d testing pro-gra munde r TSCAwoul d b e deeme d applicabl e t o an d consisten t wit htesting requirement s fo r ETBE/TAME promulgate d unde r sectio n 21 1 o f th e Clea n Ai r Act. " Th e inten t o f thi s statemen t wa s tp communicat e tha t repetitiv e tes t .in

g shoul d no t b e require d unde r differen t testin g program s merel ybecaus e o f mino r difference s i n protocols.

. Thi s statemen t di d no t mea n tha t ETB E o r TAM E woul d b e exemp t fro m testing unde r sectio n 21 1 (b ) o f th e CA Aan d shoul d no t b e construe d a s such

. Unlik e testing o f pur e substance s unde r TSCAsectio n 4 , th e mai n thrus t o f the fuel s .an d fue l additive s testin g progra

m unde r sectio n 211(b ) o f th e CA Ai s th e toxicologi c evaluatio n o f th e whol e comple x mixture s o f emission s resulting fro m fuel/additive combustio n and evaporation

. Unde r the draf t fina l rul e promulgatiji g sectio n 21 1 (b) , dat a o n the pur e compound s woul d no t generall yb e acceptabl e .substitute s fo r the test s require d o n th e comple x emissio n mixtures

.

@ RecydaoTRecyciabl a PiWidwft h SeyfCandalrko npaparthat carta-BtftaaaHK . recycled fiber

R = 9S?

- 202260816 8 05-25-9 4 08:46A M P00 3 »1 4P. 3

05/25

- 94 07:3 7 •S'202230816 8 EPA/CC D '• 3 004/00 4



## An yquestion s regarding thi s matte r shoul d b e directe d t o Mr
. Brian Ri-ede l a t (202 ) 260-032 1 o r Mr
. Gar yTim ma t (202 ) 260

- 7335
.

Sincerely >

Charle s M
. Auer , Directo r Chemica l Contro l Divisio n

R = 96 % 202260816 8 05-25-9 4 08:46A M P00 4 81 4P. 4

05;25 . 9 4 07:5 4 ©202260816 8 EPA/CC D 1002/00 7

Monaoaa dAl-Deghaitha r SAB1C Metr o cente r l statio nPlac e Stamford , c t 0690 2
Or . L.S . Andrew s ARC O chemica l compan y 380 1 wes t Cheste r Pik e Newtow nsquare , P A

1907 3
Dr . Michae l G . Bir d Toxicology

Associat o Exxo nBiomedica l Sciences , Incorporate d MCtXlCT S Road / CN335 0 Eae t Millstone , Ne w Jorse y 08875-235 0
or . Willia

m o . Broddl e 6t - Dir.. , Toxicology an dProduc t Safet y Conoco , incorporate d 1'OS tOffic eBO

X 2197 , MA102 4 Hemeton , T X7/36 2 Hr . Jane s Bruc e Manager , industria l Hygien e Citg o jpetroieu

m corporatio n 610 0 Sout hval e Avenu e Tulsa , oxianaa a 7410 2
Or . Luci-an

o caprin o institut o Paraacologl a Modic a Universit y

o f sav e "L a sapienza " Pja z L a A

Mor o Rom e 0018 5
Or . Kennet hI . o-arme r Senir o Researc h'i'oiclooloqie t Shel l oi l Compan

y On e Shel l Pias a Pos t Offic e Bo x432 0 Houston , Texa s 7701 7
Dr . Bria nC . Davi s M-uiager , Fuel s Produc t Managemen t So nRefinin g andMarketin g company Ta nPen nCente r 180 1 Marke t btroc t Philadelphia , *>

A i»i03-i«9 9

202260816 8 05-25-9 4 09:04A M P00 2 » 15. P. 5

05-;25'9 4 07:5 4 ©202260816 8 EPA/CC D l l 003/00 7

Georg e Dixi e 

### Eoh aHaa s Lndup-tslanc e Kai l West*. Philadelphia , P

A 1910 5 Dr . Rober tT . Dra w&• Healt h « Environmenta l J-lr.iancttDepartmen t America nPetroleu m Tns-titu e 122 0 L Street , N.W . Washington , D C 20005-401 3
Dr . Fieldin g Dougla s Scientifi c Services , loc . P.O . BOX53 3 Fron t Royal , V

A 2263 0
Ms . Caro l Fairbrothe r Exo nCo . U.S.A . Environmenta l & Safet y D«=sp«rtan«n

t 80 0 Bel l Stree t Houston , T X
Mr . Frederic kH . Flor , Jr . Marke t Are a Manage r Roh m andHaa s Compan

y independenc e Mal l Wes t Philadelphia , P A

1910 S
Mr . Joh nM . Fo x Presiden t Mar kWes t Hydrocarbo nPartners , Ltd , 561 3 DT C Parkway , Suit e 4 0 Boglawood , C O 8011 1

Dr . Gar y

Ginsber g TR C Environmenta l Corporatio n

. bwatersid e crossin g Windsor , C T 0609 5
Mr . Larr y

Q . Goodwi n Manager , Tocnnica l s-srvice s Texa s Petrochemica l Corporatio n 860 0 par kPlac e Boulevar d Houeton , T-sxa

s 7701 7
Mr . Stanle y

euseow A B B Lum.mu

s crest , inc . 161 5 Broa dstree t Bloom , N

J0700 3

202260816 8 05-25-9 4 09:04A M P00 3 81 5P. 6

05 - 25 - 9 4 07:3 4 ©202280816 8 EPA. . CC D S ] 004/00 :

Mr . J . -SUQIAX I Hubbar d Rnnin-ys s Manage r Teacac o Chemica l Compan y 104 0 Pos t Oa kBoulevar d Houston , T X7705 6

Hr . Joh nJohnso n Coasta l Refillin g an dMarketing , inc . 9 Gre-anva y

Plaz a Houston , T X77046-099 5 Juh a Kekalain-e n Nest a Canada , Inc . 30 1 Bas t ocea nBoulevar d Suit e 30 0 Lon g Beach , C A

9080 2
Dr . Danie l w . Kell y Phillip s Petroleu m Compan y EES , industria l Hygiene -an dToxicolog y 42 0 Keele r Avenue , 1 2 C- l Buildin g Bartlesville , O K7400 4 Mr . Joh nKneis s Oxygenate dFuel s Associatio n 133 0 Connecticu t Avenue , N W Suite 30 0 Washington , o c aooji-ivo a Mr . Richar di-ambert h Manage r o f Petrochemica l Product s vaier o Refinin g compan y Suite 90 0 120 0 smit hstroo t Houston , T X7700 2
Dr . Fre dMaraeh i Phillip s Petroleu m compan

y 12C 1 Phillip s Buildin g bartlesville , O K7400 4
Mr . tlwynSL. Parti n Brow nandHoo t Braun 1020 0 Bellatr e Bouicva.r d Buildin g 91-1U1S33 H Houston , T X77072-520 6
Mr . car y

R . patto n Licsnsin g specialis t Phillip s Petroleu

m compan

y 24 3 Paten t Librar y Building , PRCJ Bartlesvillem

O K7400 4

202260816 8 05-25-9 4 09:04A M P00 4 81 50 5 ••2. 5 ."9 4
* *

!

/

1

1

i 07.5 5 ©202230816 3 EPA . 

### CC D

Ms . R-amon

a 0 . Panso n SunRwflniru j an

dMarketin g Compan y Ta nPen nCHnte r 180 1 Marke t Strvu-t

t Philadelphia , P A

19103-1G9 9

Mr . EdwardPrate r DiannndShamroc kCorporatio n 983 0 Colonnade . Boulevar d Pos t Offic e Bo xG9G0OO Sa nAntnnio , Texa s 78269-600 0
Mr . RaymondJ . Papcia k Tuy/tco, incorporate d Pos t Offic e Ro v

2770 7 Houston , Texa s 77227-770 7
Mr - Willia

m Pie l Busines s Developmen t Manage r ARC O Chemica l Compan y 380 1 Wes t Cheste r Pik e Newtow nSquare , P A

1907 3
Mr . FrederickL . Potte r Informatio nResources , Inc . 49 9 Sout hCapito l .Stree t •Suit e *?0 Washington , D C 2000 3
R . Bre t Rhineamit h Har kWen t Hydrocarbon s Partners , Lt d 561 3 DT C Parkway , Suit e 40 0 Enijlewoad , C O BOll l
Or . Gerhar dK . Raabe Mobi l Med5ca l Departmen t Penningto n& Rocky Hil l Roa d Buildin g 1 9 Pennington , NJ08534-213 0 Hi" . Qaorg e Ros e Senio r Vic e Presiden t Globa l Octanr a Corporatio n Suit e 568 0 100 0 Louisian a St.roA t Houston , TJ

C ITOO i
Mr . Charle s J . Pork h BAIVIA V

EnviroBmenta l Fuel s 272 7 Wort hLoo pWes t P.O . Bo x432 4 Houston , T X7700 8

202260816 8 P. 7
®003-00 7

-

05-25-9 4 09:04A

M P00 5 81 5P. 8

05/25-9 4 07:5 5

_202280816 8 EPA/CC D@006--00 7

Dr . C . Schrain-er Toxicolog y

Divisio n Mobi l Oi l corporatio n poe t Offic e Bo x102 9 Princeton , « JUBMJ-iua y Mr . Lawrence A . smit h Researc hDirecto r c o lec h 1010 0 Bay

Are a Boulevar d Pasadena , T X7750 7 Mr . K . Le e Tucc i Manager , sale s an dMarketiii g Unite dCatalysts , inc . 122 7 sout h12t hstree t P.O . BO X3337 0 LOUicvillC , K£

4023 2 Or . Mar y

Jan e Vo nAllma n Texaco , incorporate d Poe t Officio BO X50 9 Beacon , Hew

Yor k1250 8
Dr . Michae l well s senio r Toxicologi c AOOC O corporatio n MCA90 1 20 0 tas t Randolph . Driv e Chicago , Illinoi s 60601-712 5 Mr . Ronal dc whit e Director , Oxygenate s & .fuel s Texa s tfetroahemical Corporatio n 870 7 Kat y

Freewa y Suit e 30 0 Houston , T X7702 4
Mr . w.s . Whitne y ARC O chemica l compan y 380 1 wes t Cheste r Pik e Newtow nsquare . i-

A 1907 3 fir . Fre dT . William s Enro nCorporatio n 140 0 smit hstree t P.O . BO X118 8 Houston , T X77251-118 8

or . K . M . Hilkenlel d Leader , Petroluem andwealt hKickAssessmen t chevro nRcocare handTechnology compan

y 100 3 Wes t Cuttin g Boulevar d Richmond , C A

948U4-UUS 4

202260816 8 05-25-9 4 09:04A M P00 6 81 5P. 9

0 5 - ? 5 • ' 9 4 07:5 5 'S202280816 8 EPA,CC D S1007.-00 "

Mr . Pahrisi o Bichieh i Vic ePresident , MTB E Sale s Er.nfi.m J fl.P.A. c / o America nAgi p 66 6 Fift h Avenu e Me wYork , N

Y 1010 3
Mr . Geof * Wiili g VALER O 12U U Smit h Street , f'JU U Souscoa , T S 77UU

2

202260816 8 05-25-9 4 09:04A M P00 7 81 5