EXHIBIT 10.9



 Exhibit 10.9 
 SPECIFIC TERMS IN THIS EXHIBIT HAVE BEEN REDACTED BECAUSE CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR THOSE TERMS HAS BEEN REQUESTED. THE REDACTED MATERIAL HAS BEEN SEPARATELY FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE
COMMISSION, AND THE TERMS HAVE BEEN MARKED AT THE APPROPRIATE PLACE WITH THE WORD “[REDACTED]”. 
 CRUDE
OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY/DELIVERY 
 AND SERVICES AGREEMENT 

between 

STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC. 
 and 
 PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC 







 TABLE OF CONTENTS 

 

							
	 	  	 	  	Page	 
	 1.
	  	 CONTRACT PARTIES
	  	 	1	  
			
	 2.
	  	 DEFINITIONS AND CONSTRUCTION
	  	 	1	  
			
	 3.
	  	 TERM OF OIL SUPPLY AND SERVICES
	  	 	15	  
			
	 4.
	  	 QUALITY
	  	 	16	  
			
	 5.
	  	 ACQUISITION OF OIL
	  	 	17	  
			
	 6.
	  	 NOMINATIONS
	  	 	23	  
			
	 7.
	  	 TITLE; CONTROL; RISK OF LOSS
	  	 	24	  
			
	 8.
	  	 STORAGE FACILITIES
	  	 	26	  
			
	 9.
	  	 PRICE AND PRICING
	  	 	26	  
			
	 10.
	  	 PAYMENT AND THE EPQ PROCESS
	  	 	33	  
			
	 11.
	  	 RECONCILIATION OF MONTH END VOLUMES AND ADJUSTMENT
	  	 	35	  
			
	 12.
	  	 PETTY CASH BANKS
	  	 	36	  
			
	 13.
	  	 VESSEL, BERTH AND SUPPLY PORT
	  	 	37	  
			
	 14.
	  	 SHIPPING AND LIGHTERING
	  	 	41	  
			
	 15.
	  	 DETERMINATION OF QUANTITY AND QUALITY
	  	 	42	  
			
	 16.
	  	 LAYTIME AND DEMURRAGE
	  	 	44	  
			
	 17.
	  	 UNSCHEDULED DISRUPTION TO NORMAL REFINERY OPERATIONS
	  	 	46	  
			
	 18.
	  	 FORCE MAJEURE
	  	 	46	  
			
	 19.
	  	 CREDIT CONDITIONS
	  	 	48	  
			
	 20.
	  	 TAXES, DUTIES AND CHARGES
	  	 	50	  
			
	 21.
	  	 INSURANCE
	  	 	51	  
			
	 22.
	  	 REPRESENTATIONS, WARRANTIES AND COVENANTS
	  	 	52	  
			
	 23.
	  	 AUDITING AND INSPECTION RIGHTS
	  	 	57	  
			
	 24.
	  	 DEFAULT, SUSPENSION AND TERMINATION
	  	 	58	  
			
	 25.
	  	 OBLIGATIONS AT TERMINATION
	  	 	61	  
			
	 26.
	  	 INDEMNIFICATION AND CLAIMS
	  	 	63	  
			
	 27.
	  	 DAMAGES
	  	 	66	  
			
	 28.
	  	 ASSIGNMENT
	  	 	66	  
			
	 29.
	  	 NOTICES AND ADDRESSES
	  	 	66	  
			
	 30.
	  	 WARRANTIES; DISCLAIMER
	  	 	67	  


  
 -i-










 TABLE OF CONTENTS 

(Continued) 
  


							
	 	  	 	  	Page	 
	 31.
	  	 APPLICABLE LAW, LITIGATION AND ARBITRATION
	  	 	68	  
			
	 32.
	  	 HSE, DRUG AND ALCOHOL POLICY
	  	 	70	  
			
	 33.
	  	 MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEETS.
	  	 	71	  
			
	 34.
	  	 VOICE RECORDING
	  	 	71	  
			
	 35.
	  	 DISPOSAL
	  	 	71	  
			
	 36.
	  	 CONFIDENTIALITY
	  	 	72	  
			
	 37.
	  	 SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY
	  	 	73	  
			
	 38.
	  	 ANTI-CORRUPTION AND FACILITATION PAYMENTS
	  	 	73	  
			
	 39.
	  	 CONFLICT OF INTEREST
	  	 	74	  
			
	 40.
	  	 MISCELLANEOUS
	  	 	74	  


  
 -ii-









 APPENDICES 

 

					
	 APPENDIX 1
	  	–	    	 FORM OF ESTIMATED PERIOD QUANTITY (EPQ) STATEMENT

			
	 APPENDIX 2
	  	–	    	 INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENTS

			
	 APPENDIX 3
	  	–	    	 PAYMENT DIRECTION AGREEMENT

			
	 APPENDIX 4
	  	–	    	 REFINERY DESCRIPTION

			
	 APPENDIX 5
	  	–	    	 STORAGE FACILITIES USE PROVISIONS

			
	 APPENDIX 6
	  	–	    	 GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF SERVICE

			
	 APPENDIX 7
	  	–	    	 LIST OF MUTUALLY AGREED GRADES

			
	 APPENDIX 8
	  	–	    	 REQUIREMENTS SCHEDULE

			
	 APPENDIX 9
	  	–	    	 GRADE PECKING ORDER

			
	 APPENDIX 10
	  	–	    	 CARGO CONFIRMATION NOTICE

			
	 APPENDIX 11
	  	–	    	 COMMENCEMENT INVENTORY ACQUISITION

			
	 APPENDIX 12
	  	–	    	 TERMINATION OF DELIVERIES NOTICE

			
	 APPENDIX 13
	  	–	    	 SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS

			
	 APPENDIX 14
	  	–	    	 CARGO BANKS AND HEDGE MONTHS SPREADSHEET

			
	 APPENDIX 15
	  	–	    	 CARGO TABLE SPREADSHEET

			
	 APPENDIX 16
	  	–	    	 FORM OF DELAWARE CITY TANK LEASE

			
	 APPENDIX 17
	  	–	    	 FORM OF BUYER’S INVENTORY STATEMENT

			
	 APPENDIX 18
	  	–	    	 FORM OF PETTY CASH SPREADSHEET

			
	 APPENDIX 19
	  	–	    	 REFINERY MARINE TERMS

			
	 APPENDIX 20
	  	–	    	 STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT

			
	 APPENDIX 21
	  	–	    	 HSE AND ETHICS POLICY



  
 -iii-










	1.	CONTRACT PARTIES 

 THIS CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY, DELIVERY AND SERVICES AGREEMENT is made and entered into this 16th day of December 2010 (“Effective Date”) between: 

Buyer: 

PBF Holding Company LLC 
 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd Floor 
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887 

Seller: 

Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc. 
 1055 Washington Boulevard – 7th Floor 
 Stamford, CT 06901 

WHEREAS, Buyer is in the process of acquiring Valero Refining Company-New Jersey (“Refinery Project Company”), which
owns the Refinery (as hereinafter defined); and 
 WHEREAS, Buyer and Seller each desire to enter into an agreement, pursuant to
which Seller shall (a) purchase from third parties or Affiliates of Seller and then subsequently sell to Buyer crude oil and feedstock, (b) provide certain commodity-related services to Buyer, and (c) extend a line of credit, each for
use by Buyer in connection with the procurement of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock for the Refinery; and 
 WHEREAS, on the
Delivery Commencement Date, immediately after the closing of the acquisition of Refinery Project Company by Buyer, Buyer shall assign its rights and obligations in this Agreement to Refinery Project Company as set forth in Clause 28 below whereupon
Refinery Project Company shall become “Buyer” for all purposes hereunder; and 
 WHEREAS, Buyer and Seller wish to
cooperate with one another to seek out and make use of opportunities associated with optimizing the Refinery’s use of various grades and types of crude oil and feedstock. 
 NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and the respective promises, conditions and agreements contained herein, and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which are
hereby acknowledged, the Parties hereby agree as follows: 
  

	2.	DEFINITIONS AND CONSTRUCTION 

 (a) Definitions. For purposes of this Agreement, the following terms shall have the meanings indicated below and shall include the plural and singular forms of the terms: 

“Acquisition Discussion” means the technical dialogue between Buyer and Seller covering all relevant issues pertinent to
the decisions needed to allow Seller to acquire the optimal Cargo to cover its appropriate Requirement. 







 “Actual Refinery Slate” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(a)(ii).

 “Additional Acceptable Security” has the meaning given such term in Clause 19(b)(v). 

“Adjusted IF Volume” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(1). 

“Adjustment” has the meaning given such term in Clause 11(a). 

“Affiliate” means, with respect to a given Person, any other Person (i) that directly or indirectly (through one or
more intermediaries) controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, such first mentioned Person, (ii) that beneficially owns or holds more than 50% of the interest of such first mentioned Person, or (iii) for which more than
50% of the interest therein is beneficially owned or held by such first mentioned Person. For the purposes of this definition, “control” when used with respect to any specified Person means the right or power to direct or cause the
direction of the management and policies of such Person, directly or indirectly, whether through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise, and the terms “controlling” and “controlled” have meanings correlative
to the foregoing. 
 “Agreed Delivery Route” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(c)(iv). 

“Agreement” or “this Agreement” means this Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement,
including the Appendices hereto, as it may be amended, modified, supplemented, extended, renewed or restated from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof. 
 “API” means American Petroleum Institute. 

“ASTM” means American Society for Testing and Materials. 

“Bankrupt” means, with respect to a Person if such Person (i) dissolves, other than pursuant to a consolidation,
amalgamation or merger, (ii) becomes insolvent or is unable to pay its debts or fails or admits in writing its inability generally to pay its debts as they become due, (iii) makes a general assignment or arrangement for the benefit of its
creditors, (iv) has instituted against it a proceeding seeking a judgment of insolvency or bankruptcy or any other relief under any similar Law affecting creditor’s rights, or a petition is presented against it for its winding-up or
liquidation, (v) institutes a proceeding seeking a judgment of insolvency or bankruptcy of such Person or any other relief under any bankruptcy or insolvency Law or for reorganization relief under the winding-up or liquidation for such Person,
(vi) has a resolution passed for its winding-up or liquidation, other than pursuant to a consolidation, amalgamation or merger, (vii) seeks or becomes subject to the appointment of an administrator, provisional liquidator, conservator,
receiver, trustee, custodian or other similar official for all or substantially all of its assets, (viii) has a secured party take possession of all or substantially all of its assets, or has a distress, execution, attachment, sequestration or
other legal process levied, enforced or sued on or against all or substantially all of its assets, (ix) files an answer or other pleading admitting or failing to contest the allegations of a petition filed against it in any proceeding of the
foregoing nature, (x) has a proceeding against it seeking reorganization, arrangement, composition, readjustment, liquidation, dissolution, or similar relief under any Law, if 120 days after the commencement of such proceeding it has not been
dismissed, or if within 90 days after the 

  
 -2-









 
appointment, without its consent or acquiescence, of a trustee, receiver, or liquidator of it or of all or any substantial part of its properties, the appointment is not vacated or stayed, or
within 90 days after the expiration of any such stay, the appointment is not vacated, or (xi) takes any other action to authorize any of the actions set forth above. 
 “Bankruptcy Code” means Chapter 11 of Title 11, US Code, as amended. 
 “Barrel” or “Bbl” means a volume of 42 Gallons corrected for temperature to 60° F, and atmospheric pressure unless stated otherwise. 

“Base Rate” means the lesser of (i) LIBOR plus [REDACTED]% and (ii) the maximum rate of interest permitted by
Law. 
 “Berth” means the mooring, dock, anchorage, wharf, submarine line, single point or single buoy or
single berth mooring facility, offshore location, offshore facility, alongside barges, lighters or any other mooring facility. 

“Blended Price” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b). 

“Business Day” means any Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday or Friday on which commercial banks are open for business
(including dealings in foreign exchange and foreign currency deposits) in New York, New York. 
 “Buyer” has
the meaning given such term in Clause 1. 
 “Buyer’s Credit Agreement” means collectively: Term Loan and
Credit Agreement and Revolving Credit Agreement, each by and between PBF Holding Company LLC, DCRC, Paulsboro Refining Company LLC and the other Guarantors Party thereto, and UBS Securities LLC, Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas, Morgan Stanley
Funding, Inc. and UBS AG, Stamford Branch; and Senior Secured Note Agreement by and between Paulsboro Refining Company LLC, Paulsboro Natural Gas Pipeline Company LLC, PBF Energy Company LLC and PBF Holding Company LLC, and Valero Energy
Corporation, including any amendment, renewal, modification or replacement thereof. 
 “Buyer’s Guarantor”
means PBF Energy Company LLC. 
 “Buyer’s Requirements Schedule” has the meaning given such term in Clause
6. 
 “Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(a)(i).

 “Calculated Payment Obligation” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(b). 

“Capital Leases” means, with respect to any Person, any lease of any property by such Person which would, in accordance
with GAAP, be required to be classified and accounted for as a capital lease on the balance sheet of such Person. 

  
 -3-









 “Cargo” means a specifically identified volume of Oil ascertained within
the nomination process provided for herein, Supplied to, or to be Supplied to Buyer, whether located in the Storage Facilities, in any Statoil Storage Facility, on a Vessel, in a third party facility, in a pipeline or at any other location or
facility. 
 “Cargo Bank” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(a)(iii). 

“Cargo Bank Differential” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b)(ii). 

“Cargo Bank Hedge-Month” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(a)(iii)(4). 

“Cargo Bank Withdrawal” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(a)(ii). 

“Cargo Basis Differential” means the differential amount agreed to by the Parties relative to the Cargo Bank
Hedge-Month. 
 “Cargo Confirmation Notice” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(f)(iii). 

“Cargo Final Price” means the estimated per Barrel Price for Oil delivered by Seller hereunder, calculated as the price
per Barrel for the Cargo agreed on by Seller and Buyer [REDACTED]. 
 “Change in Law” has the meaning given
such term in Clause 31(g). 
 “Closing Inventory” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(a)(i).

 “Code” has the meaning given such term in Clause 20(b). 

“Commercial Services” has the meaning given such term in Clause 3(a)(ii). 

“Commodity Exchange Act” means 7 U.S.C. § 1, et seq. 

“Completion of Supply” means, in respect of a Cargo, the final disconnection of the transfer hose(s)/arms(s) of the
Vessel carrying such Cargo following Supply. 
 “Confidential Information” means all information (whether
written, oral, visual, electronic or delivered by any other means) furnished either before or after the date hereof, either directly or indirectly, in connection with the performance of this Agreement by one Party (the “Disclosing
Party”) or any of its directors, officers, employees, Affiliates, representatives (including without limitation a Disclosing Party’s real estate agents/brokers, financial advisors, attorneys and accountants), agents, or Affiliated,
subsidiary or parent companies (the “Disclosing Party Representatives”) to the other Party (the “Receiving Party”) or any of its directors, officers, employees, Affiliates, representatives (including without
limitation its real estate agents/brokers, financial advisors, attorneys, accountants and consultants), agents, or Affiliated, subsidiary or parent corporations (individually and collectively, the “Receiving Party Recipients”) and
all analyses, compilations, forecasts, studies or other documents prepared by Receiving Party Recipients which contain any such information. Each of (i) the fact that such information has been delivered to the Receiving Party or Receiving Party
Recipients, (ii) this 

  
 -4-









 
Agreement, and (iii) the other agreements entered into in connection with this Agreement, are “Confidential Information”. Notwithstanding the foregoing, “Confidential
Information” shall not include any information which: (a) at the time of disclosure is in the public domain; (b) after disclosure to the Receiving Party Recipients enters the public domain, except as a result of any Receiving Party
Recipient’s breach of this Agreement or any other agreement of confidentiality, it being understood and agreed, that information that is public or has, to the Receiving Party’s knowledge, become public through an unauthorized disclosure by
a third party under a confidentiality obligation with respect to such information shall not be deemed to be public information or otherwise generally available to the public; or (c) is independently obtained by Receiving Party Recipients free
from any obligation of confidentiality. 
 “Consolidated Average EBITDA” means the consolidated EBITDA of the
PBF Entities. 
 “Credit Default” has the meaning given such term in Clause 24(c). 

“Credit Usage” has the meaning given such term in Clause 19(b)(ii). 

“Daily Default Pricing Volume” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(c)(i)(1). 

“Day 1” has the meaning given such term in Clause 10(c)(i). 

“Day 2” has the meaning given such term in Clause 10(c)(ii). 

“DCRC” means Delaware City Refining Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company. 

“Default” has the meaning given such term in Clause 24(a). 

“Default Interest Rate” means the lesser of (i) LIBOR plus [REDACTED]% and (ii) the maximum rate of interest
permitted by Law. 
 “Defaulting Party” has the meaning given such term in Clause 24(a). 

“Delaware City Tank Lease” has the meaning given such term in Clause 8(c). 

“Delivered” or “Delivery” or “Deliver” means when the Oil passes the title transfer
point from Seller to Buyer. 
 “Delivered Volume” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(a)(i). 

“Delivery Commencement Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 3(b). 

“Delivery Month” means the month in which Oil was actually Delivered to Buyer at the Refinery. 

“Direct Payment Excess” has the meaning given such term in Clause 10(e). 

“Disclosing Party” has the meaning given such term in the definition of “Confidential Information”.


  
 -5-









 “Disclosing Party Representatives” has the meaning given such term in the
definition of “Confidential Information”. 
 “Dispute” has the meaning given such term in
Clause 31(b). 
 “Dollars” or “USD” or “US Dollars” or
“$” means dollars of the US. 
 “EBITDA” means, with respect to any Person, and for any period
of its determination, the consolidated net income of such Person for such period, plus the consolidated interest expense and income and franchise taxes of such Person for such period, plus the consolidated depreciation and amortization of such
Person for such period, less extraordinary gains and interest income, as determined in accordance with GAAP. 

“Effective Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 1. 

“Environmental Law” means any Law that governs or purports to govern the protection of Persons, natural resources or the
environment (including the protection of ambient air, surface water, groundwater, land surface or subsurface strata, endangered species or wetlands), occupational health and safety and the manufacture, processing, distribution, use, generation,
handling, treatment, storage, disposal, transportation, release or management of solid waste, industrial waste or hazardous substances or materials, as may be amended or modified from time to time. 

“EPQ” means estimated period quantity. 
 “EPQ Form” means an EPQ form prepared per the format set forth in Appendix 1. 
 “EST” means the applicable, local Eastern Time in New York, New York. 
 “Estimated Credit Usage” has the meaning given such term in Clause 19(b)(iii). 
 “Event of Default” has the meaning given such term in Clause 24(a). 
 “Execution Method” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(f)(i). 
 “Feedstock” means vacuum gas oil (VGO), straight run fuel oil and other similar hydrocarbons. 
 “FIFO” means the first-in first-out accounting principle for the valuation of inventories and the calculation of TVM Payments. 

“Final Quality Differential” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b)(ii)(1). 

“Force Majeure” has the meaning given such term in Clause 18(a). 

“GAAP” means generally acceptable accounting principles in the US, applied on a consistent basis. 

  
 -6-









 “Gallon” means a US standard gallon of 231 cubic inches at 60° F at
atmospheric pressure. 
 “Governmental Authority” means any federal, state, regional, local, or municipal
governmental body, agency, instrumentality, authority or entity established or controlled by a governmental or subdivision thereof, including any legislative, administrative or judicial body, or any Person purporting to act therefor. 

“GPO” or “Grade Pecking Order” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(a)(v). 

“Grade” has the meaning given such term in Clause 4(b). 

“Guarantors” means each Person required to guaranty the obligations of Buyer or any of its Affiliates under this
Agreement, including Buyer’s Guarantor. 
 “Hazardous Substances” means any pollutant, contaminant,
petroleum or petroleum product, dangerous or toxic substance, hazardous or extremely hazardous chemical, or otherwise hazardous material or waste regulated under Environmental Laws, including crude oil and feedstock. 

“Hedge-Month” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b)(ii)(2). 

“Hedge-Month Pool” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b)(iii). 

“HSE” means health, safety and environmental. 
 “HSE Diligence” has the meaning given such term in Clause 23(b). 

“ICC” has the meaning given such term in Clause 40(e). 

“IF Conclusion Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(i)(2). 

“IF Determination Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(1). 

“IF Ending Price” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(i)(2). 

“IF Exposure” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(iv)(2). 

“IF Market Value” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(1). 

“IF Starting Volume” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(i)(1). 

“IF Storage Fee” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(iv)(1). 

“Indemnified Party” has the meaning given such term in Clause 26(a)(iii). 

“Indemnifying Party” has the meaning given such term in Clause 26(a)(iii). 

  
 -7-









 “Independent Inspector” means a company that is approved by US Customs and
Border Protection and that is mutually acceptable to the Parties for reporting the measurement of quality and quantity of Oil. 

“Indigenous Feedstock” means Feedstock produced in the Refinery, transferred to Seller and subsequently transferred back
to Buyer to be processed further within the Refinery, and which may from time to time be sold to third parties by Seller at Buyer’s direction in accordance with Clause 9(e) as if such transactions involved Oil; provided that, notwithstanding
the foregoing, all Feedstock located in the Indigenous Feedstock Tanks on the Delivery Commencement Date which is included in the Initial Inventory shall be “Indigenous Feedstock” whether produced in the Refinery or elsewhere. 

“Indigenous Feedstock Tank” means the storage tank(s) listed on Appendix 4 that will be used for storing
Indigenous Feedstock as such list my be modified from time-to-time in accordance with the terms of Clause 5(d) of Appendix 5. 
 “Initial TLA” has the meaning set forth in Clause 14(e). 

“Intercreditor Agreement(s)” means the Intercreditor Agreement(s) substantially in the form attached hereto as Appendix
2. 
 “Inventory” or “Inventories” means the Oil inventories that Seller owns and intends to
sell to Buyer under this Agreement, wherever located, including at the Refinery, in any Statoil Storage Facility, carried upon Vessels and/or injected into or received from pipelines or other transport. 

“Inventory Assessment” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(a)(i). 

“ISGOTT” means International Safety Guide for Oil Tankers and Terminals, as published by the International Chamber of
Shipping, the Oil Companies International Marine Forum and the International Association of Ports and Harbors. 
 “ISPS
Code” has the meaning given such term in Clause 13(a)(iii). 
 “Knowledge” means, with respect to
a Party, the actual knowledge of the officers and directors of such Party, after making reasonable inquiry with respect to the particular matter in question, and “Know” has the correlative meaning. 

“Law” means (i) any law, statute, regulation, code, ordinance, license, decision, order, writ, injunction,
decision, directive, judgment, policy, decree of any Governmental Authority and any judicial or administrative interpretations thereof, (ii) any agreement, concession or arrangement with any Governmental Authority and (iii) any license,
permit or compliance requirement, in each case as amended or modified from time to time. 
 “Liabilities” means
any losses, claims, charges, damages, deficiencies, assessments, interests, penalties, costs and expenses of any kind (including reasonable attorneys’ fees and other fees, court costs and other disbursements), including any liabilities directly
or indirectly arising out of or related to any suit, action, cause of action, proceeding, judgment, settlement or judicial or administrative order and any liabilities with respect to Environmental Law. 

  
 -8-









 “LIBOR” means the rate of interest (expressed as a percentage per annum)
for deposits in USD for a three-month period as provided by the British Bankers Association interest settlement rates (or the successor thereto) as of 11:00 a.m. (London time) on the date of determination, or, if such rate is not available, a
reasonably comparable and available published rate as reasonably agreed by the Parties. 
 “Liens” means any
lien (including judgment liens and liens arising by operation of law), mortgage, pledge, assignment, security interest, charge or encumbrance of any kind (including any agreement to give any of the foregoing) and any option, call, trust or other
preferential arrangement having the practical effect of any of the foregoing. 
 “Lightering” means the
operation wherein Oil is transferred from one Vessel to another at an approved and recognized offshore location so as to allow the first Vessel (the “Mother Vessel”) to reach a draft which allows it to safely proceed to and berth at
the Supply Port. 
 “Loading Terminal “ means the port of loading of the Vessel for the applicable Oil being
Supplied. 
 “Long-Term Debt” means, with respect to any Person or group of Persons on a consolidated basis,
without duplication, in each case excluding the current liabilities of such Person, (i) indebtedness of such Person for borrowed money, (ii) obligations of such Person evidenced by bonds, debentures, notes, or other similar instruments,
(iii) obligations of such Person to pay the deferred purchase price of property or services (other than trade debt and normal operating liabilities incurred in the ordinary course of business), (iv) obligations of such Person as lessee
under Capital Leases, (v) obligations of such Person under or relating to letters of credit, guaranties, purchase agreements, or other creditor assurances assuring a creditor against loss in respect of indebtedness or obligations of others of
the kinds referred to in clauses (i) through (iv) of this definition, and (vi) nonrecourse indebtedness or obligations of others of the kinds referred to in clauses (i) through (v) of this definition secured by any Lien on
or in respect of any property of such Person. For the purposes of determining the amount of any Long-Term Debt, the amount of any Long-Term Debt described in clause (v) of the definition of Long-Term Debt shall be valued at the maximum amount
of the contingent liability thereunder and the amount of any Long-Term Debt described in clause (vi) that is not covered by clause (v) shall be valued at the lesser of the amount of the Long-Term Debt secured or the book value of the
property securing such Long-Term Debt. 
 “LP” means a linear program computer model which simulates refinery
operations and is used to perform economic analysis that includes crude selection and optimization. 
 “LVEF”
has the meaning given such term in Clause 15(d). 
 “Material Adverse Change” means, with respect to a Party,
an event, change, development, effect, condition, or circumstance, which individually or in the aggregate with other events, changes, developments, effects, or circumstances, has resulted in or could be reasonably expected to result in a material
adverse change in the business, operations, assets, properties, financial condition or prospects of such Party. 

  
 -9-









 “Month” means a calendar month. Where a specified Month is defined as
Month “M”, Month M-1 shall mean the Month prior to Month M and Month M+1 shall mean the Month subsequent to Month M. 
 “MonthEnd” has the meaning given such term in Clause 11(a). 

“Monthly Quality and Basis Differential” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(b)(i). 

“Mother Vessel” has the meaning given such term in the definition of “Lightering”. 

“MSCG” means Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc. 

“MSCG Sales Agreement” means that certain Products Offtake Agreement to be effective as of the Delivery Commencement
Date and entered into between Refinery Project Company and Morgan Stanley, together with all amendments, modifications and successor or replacement agreements entered into from time to time with respect thereto 

“MSDS” has the meaning given such term in Clause 33(a). 

“MTSA” has the meaning given such term in Clause 13(a)(iii). 

“Non-Defaulting Party” has the meaning given such term in Clause 24(a). 

“NOR” means Notice of Readiness. 
 “Normal Refinery Operations” means periods of time when the Refinery is operated in a routine manner with all operating units on-line. Normal Refinery Operations exclude maintenance
turnarounds and shutdown periods. 
 “NSV” means net standard volume of Oil. 

“NYMEX” means the New York Mercantile Exchange. 

“Off-Taker” or “Off-Takers” means the company or companies that purchase the Refined Products produced
at the Refinery. 
 “Oil” means crude oil and/or Feedstock, but shall not include Indigenous Feedstock.

 “Opening Inventory” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(a)(i). 

“Optimization Account” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(g)(ii). 

“OSP” means the Official Selling Price as defined by the third party supplier of certain Oil for the relevant time
period and destination, as applicable. 
 “Part Cargo” means a Cargo Delivered on a Vessel such that the volume
of the Cargo does not substantially fill the Vessel. 

  
 -10-









 “Party” means each of Buyer and Seller, and “Parties”
means collectively, both Buyer and Seller. 
 “PBF Entities” has the meaning given such term in
Clause 19(b)(ii)(1). 
 “PBF Holding Company” means PBF Holding Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability
company. 
 “PBF Line of Credit” means a $50,000,000 line of credit from Seller to Buyer, subject to the
conditions in Clause 24(c). 
 “PDA” means a Payment Direction Agreement substantially in the form attached
hereto as Appendix 3. 
 “Person” means an individual, corporation, partnership, limited liability company,
joint venture, trust or unincorporated organization, joint stock company or any other private entity or organization, including a Governmental Authority. 
 “Petty Cash Bank” has the meaning given such term in Clause 12(d). 
 “Pre-Adjustment Payments” has the meaning given such term in Clause 11(b). 
 “Predicted Refinery Slate” has the meaning given such term in Clause 9(a)(i). 
 “Pricing Day” means a day on which Buyer instructs to price Oil to be Delivered hereunder in accordance with Clause 9(c)(i)(1). 

“Production Week” means, each period from Friday at 12:00 noon until the following Friday at 12:00 noon during the term
of this Agreement; provided, however, the first Production Week shall commence on the Delivery Commencement Date and shall continue until 12:00 noon on the first Friday following the Delivery Commencement Date. 

“Property Taxes” means any and all tangible personal property taxes, ad valorem property taxes or the like imposed on
the value of the Oil held for sale by Seller to Buyer under this Agreement. 
 “Proposed Storage Site” has the
meaning set forth in Clause 8(b). 
 “Provisional Invoice” has the meaning given such term in Clause
10(c)(iii). 
 “Provisional Price” has the meaning given such term in Clause 10(c)(iii) and shall be based on
the estimated price of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock that make up the EPQ. 
 “PSI” means pounds per square
inch. 
 “Qualified Institution” shall mean a major U.S. commercial bank or foreign bank with a U.S. branch
office having an asset base of at least $[REDACTED] billion, with such bank having a Credit Rating of at least [REDACTED] by S&P or [REDACTED] by Moody’s Investor Services, Inc., or otherwise acceptable to the Party receiving such
collateral, as such party shall determine in its sole discretion. 

  
 -11-









 “Receiving Party” has the meaning given such term in the definition of
“Confidential Information”. 
 “Receiving Party Recipients” has the meaning given such term in the
definition of “Confidential Information”. 
 “Refined Products” means finished gasoline, heating oil,
diesel, jet fuel and “Specialty Grades,” as defined in the MSCG Sales Agreement as of the date hereof. 

“Refined Products Percentage” has the meaning set forth in Clause 19(d)(ii). 

“Refinery” means the petroleum processing and refining facilities located in Paulsboro, New Jersey 08066, including all
storage tanks (including the Storage Facilities), docks, platforms, pipelines, and any other associated equipment or facilities, as further described in Appendix 4. 
 “Refinery Project Company” has the meaning given such term in the recitals hereto. 
 “Refinery Subsidiaries” means subsidiaries of PBF Holding Company, including Refinery Project Company once acquired by PBF Holding Company, that own or operate a refinery that is being
supplied Oil by Seller, including the Refinery. 
 “Replacement Grade Peeking Order” or “RGPO”
has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(a)(x). 
 “Requirement” has the meaning given such term in Clause
4(a). 
 “ROB” has the meaning given such term in Clause 15(d). 

“Saudi Arabian” shall mean the Saudi Arabian Oil Company, organized under the Laws of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

 “Saudi Contract” has the meaning set out on Appendix 13. 

“Seller” has the meaning given such term in Clause 1. 

“Shareholders Equity” means shareholders’ equity determined in accordance with GAAP. 

“Shipping Services” has the meaning given such term in Clause 3(a)(iii). 

“SMA” has the meaning given such term in Clause 31(e). 

“Specified Buyer Price” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(2). 

“Specified Seller Price” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(1). 

  
 -12-









 “Standby Letter of Credit” means any commercial or standby letter of credit
issued for the account of Seller pursuant to the terms of this Agreement. 
 “Statoil Storage Facility” means
any facility in which Seller or its Affiliates owns, leases or otherwise has storage rights, including, if applicable, after execution of the Delaware City Tank Lease, the facilities leased thereunder. 

“Storage Facilities” means the storage tanks described on Appendix 4, as such list may be modified from time-to-time in
accordance with the terms of Clause 5(d) of Appendix 5, and which Storage Tanks Seller has exclusive rights all as provided for herein and in Storage Facilities Use Provisions attached hereto as Appendix 5. Appendix 4 shall reflect any storage tanks
to be used to store Indigenous Feedstock. 
 “Supplied” or “Supply” or
“Supplies” means or refers to when the Oil passes the flange connection between a Vessel’s permanent discharge manifold and the receiving pipeline or hose at the Supply Port. 

“Supplied Volume” has the meaning set forth in Clause 11(a)(ii). 

“Supply Point Method” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(f)(ii). 

“Supply Port” means the customary dockage, anchorage or place where a Vessel may safely lie in connection with Supply of
a Cargo to the Refinery. 
 “Tank Heels” means the greater of: (i) the volume of Oil or Indigenous
Feedstock below the lowest suction in a tank, unless the tank is equipped with a regular side entry pipe in which case “Tank Heels” means the volume below the middle of the lowest suction in such tank, or (ii) the volume of Oil or
Indigenous Feedstock required to safely float a roof in a floating roof tank. 
 “Taxes” means any and all
(i) US federal, state and local taxes, duties, fees and charges of every description, including all fuel, excise, environmental, spill, gross earnings, gross receipts and sales and use taxes, however designated (except for taxes on income),
paid or incurred with respect to the purchase, storage, exchange, use, transportation, resale, importation or handling of the Oil or Indigenous Feedstock held for sale by Seller or Buyer under this Agreement and (ii) Property Taxes. 

“Termination Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 25(a)(i). 

“Termination of Deliveries Notice” has the meaning given such term in Clause 7(f). 

“TH Conclusion Date” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(i)(2). 

“TH Ending Price” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(i)(2). 

“TH Exposure” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(iii)(2). 

“TH Market value” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(ii)(2). 

  
 -13-









 “TH Starting Volume” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(i)(1).

 “TH Storage Fee” has the meaning set forth in Clause 5(j)(iii)(1). 

“Third Party Claim” has the meaning given such term in Clause 26(b). 

“Time Chartered Vessel” means a Vessel chartered for a fixed period of time instead of for a certain number of voyages
or trips. 
 “TLA” has the meaning set forth in Clause 14(e). 

“Transparent Contractual Terms” means the contractual terms derived using either the Execution Method or the Supply
Point Method. 
 “Trigger Event” has the meaning set forth in Clause 19(d)(ii). 

“TVM” means the time value of money. 
 “TVM Payment” has the meaning given such term in Clause 19(g)(i). 

“TVM Payment Date” means, with respect to a given Production Week, the first Thursday following the end of such
Production Week, provided, that if such TVM Payment Date is not a Business Day, the TVM Payment Date shall mean the next following Business Day. 
 “TVM Statement Delivery Date” has the meaning given such term in Clause 19(g)(ii). 
 “Type” has the meaning given such term in Clause 4(b). 

“UCC” means the Uniform Commercial Code in effect in the relevant state jurisdiction. 

“Valero” means Valero Marketing and Supply Company, a Delaware corporation. 

“Vessel” means a tankship, barge or other water-borne conveyance, as applicable, used for the Supply of a Cargo, whether
owned or chartered or otherwise obtained by Seller to transport Oil for the benefit of Buyer. 
 “VGO
Feedstock” has the meaning given such term in Clause 5(i)(ii)(3). 
 “Win3” has the meaning given such
term in Clause 6(e). 
 “Win5” has the meaning given such term in Clause 6(d). 

“Win8” has the meaning given such term in Clause 6(a). 

“Worldscale” means the applicable standard freight rate stated in the most recent edition of the New Worldwide Tanker
Nominal Freight Scale jointly published by Worldscale Association (London) Limited and Worldscale Association (NYC) Inc., or if Worldscale Association (London) Limited and Worldscale Association (NYC) Inc. shall no longer publish the New Worldwide
Tanker Nominal Freight Scale, the equivalent replacement scale used in the shipping industry, expressed in USD per metric ton for the route specified. 

  
 -14-









 “WTI” means West Texas Intermediate Oil, with specifications in accordance
with the NYMEX futures contract. 
 “Year” means a period of 12 consecutive Months. 

(b) Construction. 
 (i) All headings herein are intended solely for convenience of reference and shall not affect the meaning or interpretation of the provisions of this Agreement. 

(ii) Unless expressly provided otherwise, the word “including” as used herein does not limit the preceding words
or terms. 
 (iii) Unless expressly provided otherwise, all references to days, weeks, months, quarters and years
mean calendar days, weeks, months, quarters and years, respectively. For purposes of this Agreement, a calendar day shall begin at 12:00 midnight and end at 11:59 p.m. 

(iv) Unless expressly provided otherwise, references herein to “consent” mean the prior written consent of the
Party at issue, which shall not be unreasonably withheld, delayed or conditioned. 
 (v) Unless expressly
provided otherwise, all references to time in this Agreement are EST. 
  

	3.	TERM OF OIL SUPPLY AND SERVICES 

 (a) Beginning on the Delivery Commencement Date, and continuing through the term of this Agreement and subject to the provisions of this Agreement: 

(i) Except with respect to purchases, if any, to be completed by Buyer under the terms of the Saudi Contract, Seller will
have the exclusive right to, and will, provide Oil for Delivery to the Refinery and Buyer will purchase such Oil in accordance with the terms set forth herein. 
 (ii) With respect to the Saudi Contract, Seller and Buyer shall comply with the terms of Appendix 13 with respect to such purchases of Oil and the subsequent delivery to and storage at the Refinery.
Appendix 13 shall set out the terms regarding (1) the mechanism by which title to such crude oil will be acquired and by whom, (2) how pricing and TVM Payments will be calculated, (3) the timing and process as to how such Oil will be
handled pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, and (4) such other details as Seller deems reasonably necessary to accomplish the foregoing. 
 (iii) Seller shall provide Buyer with certain operational services (the “Commercial Services”) and certain shipping-related services (the “Shipping


  
 -15-









 
Services”) with respect to all purchases and sales of Oil reasonably necessary to enable Buyer to perform the manufacturing and operational processes at the Refinery as detailed in
Appendix 6. 
 (b) This Agreement shall be binding on the Parties from the Effective Date hereof; however, the supply of Oil,
Commercial Services, Shipping Services and related services shall commence on the later of December 17, 2010, or the date that Buyer or its Affiliate acquires Refinery Project Company and assigns its rights and obligations under this Agreement
to Refinery Project Company pursuant to an assignment in form and substance acceptable to Seller (the “Delivery Commencement Date”) and shall continue for an initial term ending on September 30, 2011, and shall continue
thereafter for successive one-Year extension periods commencing on each October 1 thereafter until this Agreement is terminated (i) by a termination in accordance with Clause 24, or (ii) by either Party giving 6 months prior notice
that it has elected to terminate this Agreement; provided, that no Party shall have the right to give such a notice of election to terminate under this subpart (ii) prior to April 17, 2011. 

 

	4.	QUALITY 

 (a) Oil
Requirements. The Parties will agree upon the Oil supply requirements of the Refinery in accordance with the process described in Clause 5. Such Oil supply requirements are referred to herein as the Requirements. Each
“Requirement” shall be an identified volume of a specified Type and a corresponding Supply time period (e.g. 500,000 Barrels of Type A Oil to be Supplied in the window of 1-10 January 2011). 

(b) Oil Types. Oil Supplied and Delivered under this Agreement will be grouped in the following general categories, referred to
herein as “Types”. 
 (i) Type A: sour crude oil with a sulfur content equal to or
greater than zero point eight percent by weight (0.8% weight), as per ASTM. Type A Oil Requirements typically will be covered by the Kirkuk Grade of Oil as a base case, with other light and medium sour crudes as optimization alternatives,
including, but not limited to, sourcing from the Urals and Vasconia. 
 (ii) Type B: sweet crude oil
with a sulfur content less than zero point eight percent by weight (0.8% weight), as per ASTM. Type B Oil Requirements typically will be covered by crude oil Grades sourced from the East Coast Canadian Grand Banks as a base case, with light and
medium sweet crudes as optimization alternatives, including, but not limited to, sourcing from the North Sea and Angola. 
 (iii) Type C: Crude oil specifically required to produce approved lube oils: initially to be covered by the Arab Light and/or Arab Medium Grades of crude oil. 

(iv) Type D: Feedstocks, for example vacuum gasoil or straight run fuel oil. 

Within each Type of Oil described herein there are multiple “Grades”. For example the Oil Grades Kirkuk, Urals and Vasconia could each
be Type A Oil. Some Grades may meet the specifications of more than one Type. To avoid any misunderstanding the Parties shall clearly communicate which Requirement or Type a proposed Grade or Cargo is to cover. A summary of Grades approved by Seller
for sale hereunder, and their associated Type, is attached as Appendix 7. 

  
 -16-









 (c) Term Quality / Spot Quality. 

(i) Term Supply. The Parties expect that over time approximately [REDACTED]% of Oil Supplied to Buyer at the
Refinery will be sourced from term agreements entered into by Seller. Buyer will use its reasonable efforts in support of Seller’s efforts to enter into such term agreements with counterparties. To the extent Seller is unable to enter into term
agreements with specified counterparties or for specified Types or Grades, the Parties will work together to determine an appropriate arrangement for supply of the affected Type and Grade. If the Parties are able to enter an agreement with Saudi
Arabian as to the terms of the Saudi Contract that is acceptable to each Party in their sole discretion, then it is anticipated that the Saudi Contract will be for approximately [REDACTED] of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C). 

(ii) Spot Supply. The Parties agree that the balance of the Oil supplied to the Refinery will be sourced from the
spot market for Oil. 
 (d) Quality Optimization Principle. The Parties agree that a fundamental part of this Agreement
is, within the Cargo acquisition process, for (i) the flexibility of Buyer to receive different Grades within a certain Type, as generally listed in the appropriate GPO / RGPO, without disrupting Normal Refinery Operations allowing a commercial
benefit of that flexibility to Buyer, and (ii) the flexibility for Seller to be able to have a range of options among such Grades to cover the Requirements of the Refinery allowing a commercial benefit to Seller. Specifically this shall mean that
Seller shall be able to acquire different Grades at generally available market prices in order to cover a particular Requirement provided such price is reasonably acceptable to Buyer as listed in the appropriate GPO / RGPO. This principle is
understood primarily to apply during the initial acquisition process for Type A and Type B Oils. Furthermore for other Types, Buyer will make commercially reasonable efforts to allow this acquisition process and flexibility. The Parties also agree
that a fundamental objective of this Agreement is, that after a Requirement has been covered by a Cargo, in the event that either: 
 (i) Buyer’s refining economics for said Requirement change substantially, or 
 (ii) the market conditions for trading that Cargo with third parties change substantially and such change causes an economic benefit to be derivable from optimizing said Cargo into an alternative Cargo,
then the Parties shall make commercially reasonable efforts to change that Cargo into an economically beneficial alternative. If successful, the Parties shall agree on commercial terms such that, under the RGPO process, the economic benefit of the
optimization is shared in an appropriately equitable manner consistent with Clause 5. 
  

	5.	ACQUISITION OF OIL 

 (a)
Acquisition Process Steps. The process for selecting and then acquiring a Cargo of Oil to supply the Refinery shall comprise the following steps: 
 (i) Buyer and Seller shall mutually agree on the “Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule” for any Month of Delivery of Oil to the Refinery, which shall consist of a list of
Requirements with each Requirement being a volume of a Type to be delivered during a specified period in such Month, in a format following that in Appendix 8. 

(ii) The Parties shall discuss the different Grade options for each Requirement. 

(iii) The Parties shall agree on the volume, term, price and other key elements for term contract commitments, and Buyer
shall give a written mandate to Seller to enter into such term contract(s), and Seller shall enter into such term contract(s). Thereafter, the Parties shall follow the term contract procedures set forth in Clause 5(c) below, which will result in
Seller purchasing term Cargoes to cover certain Requirements in the Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule. 
 (iv) The Parties shall identify target Grades and a number of target Cargoes that shall be acceptable for each Requirement that is not to be covered by term contract volumes. 

(v) Buyer, in discussion with Seller, shall issue, and continue to update, a grade pecking order (a “Grade Pecking
Order” or “GPO”), outlining the Grades that could cover each Requirement and the corresponding differences in price at which such Grades would have equal economics for the Buyer. 

(vi) As to each target Cargo, Seller shall provide Buyer with the appropriate contractual terms in accordance with Clause
5(e)(ii). 

  
 -17-









 (vii) Thereafter, Buyer shall give an oral or written mandate to Seller in
accordance with Clause 5(e)(iii). 
 (viii) Seller shall purchase the Cargo covered by such mandate or, with
respect to a Cargo acquired from Seller or Seller’s Affiliates, make appropriate internal allocations to reflect that such Cargo will cover a Requirement hereunder. 

(ix) Seller shall send formal notification to Buyer of the purchase of the Cargo, or if the Cargo is acquired from Seller
or Seller’s Affiliates portfolio, the internal allocation of such Cargo to cover a Requirement, covered by the mandate. Details of that notification shall be as described in Clause 5(f)(iii) below. 

(x) In connection with seeking potential optimizations, following the purchase of each term or spot Cargo to cover a
Requirement, the Buyer, in discussion with Seller, shall issue, and continue to update a replacement grade pecking order (“Replacement Grade Pecking Order” or “RGPO”) for such covered Requirement outlining the
Grades that could replace the purchased Cargo and the corresponding differences in price at which such replacement Grades would have equal economics for the Buyer, which RGPO shall use the Cargo Bank Differential of the purchased Cargo as the basis
for such price differences. 
 (b) Grade Pecking Order. The GPO and RGPO (each a list of Grades and differences in price)
shall reflect the relative refining economics of different Grades for each Requirement in Buyer’s Tentative Requirement Schedule. The determination of the GPO or RGPO as applicable shall be based on: 

(i) Seller’s advice to Buyer of the volumes available of different Grades in standard Cargo sizes and corresponding
price estimates. 
 (ii) Buyer’s output from LP runs for the Refinery based on Seller’s Grade
availability lists. 
 (iii) For each Requirement, Buyer shall prepare a GPO or RGPO that contains a base Grade
and a minimum of four alternative Grades that Seller shall be reasonably able to acquire. Each alternative Grade shall have a value that reflects the difference in price delivered at the Refinery that has to be achieved by Buyer for that Grade to be
of equal value to the base Grade for that Requirement. A Requirement shall remain relevant for the GPO or RGPO from its initial identification in the Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule for a Month of Supply, up and until the end of its
Acquisition Discussion and this time may include time after a Cargo has been purchased to cover the Requirement in order to allow for possible optimizations of that Requirement. The GPO and RGPO shall be generated by Buyer in the format specified in
Appendix 9. The GPO and RGPO shall be issued once per week, in accordance with the following process steps: 

(1) Seller shall communicate to Buyer no later than noon every Tuesday pertinent information containing the availability
of different Grades and estimates of market prices for those Grades. 
 (2) Buyer shall issue the GPO/RGPO in the
correct format no later than noon on the following day (Wednesday), whereupon any previous GPO/RGPO shall be superseded. 
 (c)
Term Commitment Discussion Procedure. Subject to the provisions set forth in the term Oil supply contracts previously entered into under this Agreement, the Parties shall agree, at the appropriate times to: 

(i) The volumes to be nominated to cover Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule. 

(ii) The Requirements that shall be covered by such term volumes (after the third party supplier of Oil under such term
Oil supply contract confirms the final nomination of such Oil with the loading dates and final volume). 
 (iii)
The Final Quality Differential for such volume. If such Cargo will be Supplied under the Execution Method then the FOB price will be set in principle to match the price reached by Seller with the supplier of the term volume, which if OSP-related
will match the OSP of the respective Oil at the appropriate Loading Terminal, including any premium or discount. If the Cargo will be Supplied under the Supply Point Method then the price will be agreed between the Parties. 

(iv) The costs for Supplying a term Cargo under the Execution Method will be agreed between the Parties based on the
Agreed Delivery Route for each specific Oil term contract Cargo. The “Agreed Delivery Route” will define the salient factors attributable to that Cargo, including, but not limited to; (1) the Loading Terminal, (2) Vessel size, (3)
transportation route and (4) any Lightering requirements. For example for an Arab [REDACTED] term Cargo, the Agreed Delivery Route might be: (1) Oil Loading Terminal to be [REDACTED], (2) Cargo to be loaded on an Aframax vessel, (3) Vessel to be
routed by the most expeditious method (always allowing for carrier’s safety requirements) to Bigstone Lightering Point, (4) where one or two Lightering Vessel(s) will be taken off prior to the mother Vessel Berthing at the Refinery. Each term
contract Cargo under this Agreement will have a similar corresponding Agreed Delivery Route. If the Execution Method is used, Seller shall use [REDACTED], etc. Except as otherwise set forth in this Agreement, if the Supply Point Method is used all
supply costs up to the Supply Port are [REDACTED]. 
 (d) Acquisition Discussion. 

(i) Each Requirement will have an associated Acquisition Discussion that will commence upon Buyer advising Seller of
Buyer’s Tentative Requirement Schedule and shall end when a Cargo or Cargoes covering the Requirement are Supplied to Buyer. 
 (ii) Until Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule has become Buyer’s Requirements Schedule (as described in Clause 6), Buyer shall have the right to adjust the dates with the exception of
any Requirements covered with Cargoes, which shall not be adjusted or modified without Seller’s consent. 

  
 -18-









 (iii) As long as the relevant Acquisition Discussion has not concluded, the
GPO / RGPO shall contain the alternatives as described in this Clause 5 for each Requirement. 
 (e) Acquisition Process and
Target Cargo. 
 (i) Prior to the conclusion of the Acquisition Discussion, the Parties shall agree on
a target Cargo for that Requirement within sufficient time to allow Seller to purchase such target Cargo in accordance with Clause 5(a)(viii). Buyer acknowledges that different Grades of Oil typically trade at different periods of time ahead of when
such Cargo is to be delivered and that Seller may not be able to acquire a target Cargo if Buyer and Seller are unable to agree on a target Cargo in a timely manner. Seller shall keep Buyer apprised of such time periods. 

(ii) Seller shall advise Buyer of all pertinent commercial details necessary with respect to each target Cargo, so that
the Transparent Contractual Terms can be fully understood. If Seller is to provide the target Cargo from its or its Affiliates’ portfolio, then Seller shall notify Buyer of such fact. 

(iii) Buyer shall give an oral (by way of a recorded means including recording of a telephone conversation with or without
the consent of the other Party in accordance with Clause 34) or written mandate to Seller to fulfill the Requirement with such Cargo, such mandate shall include all of the information appropriate to fix the commercial terms for such Cargo, including
the Grade of Oil, volume to be Supplied, Supply window and price. Such mandate, whether oral or written, shall be fully binding on Buyer, and Buyer thereafter shall be required to accept Delivery of such Cargo (unless Seller fails to acquire such
Cargo) in accordance with this Agreement. 
 (iv) If Seller cannot acquire a target Cargo under the agreed
contractual terms in accordance with Clauses 5(a), the Parties shall continue the Acquisition Discussion until either (1) it concludes with revised terms for the same target Cargo, (2) it concludes with terms for an alternative Cargo of
the same Grade or (3) it concludes with terms for an alternative Cargo of an alternative Grade in the relevant GPO. This process shall continue until the Requirement is successfully covered. 

(v) At any time during the Acquisition Discussion, Seller can propose that a Requirement be covered by an alternative
Grade in the GPO / RGPO. Buyer shall accept such proposal as long as the alternate Grade Cargo will maintain equal or improved refining economics for that Requirement based on the GPO / RGPO. Furthermore, Seller may propose an alternate Grade not
included in the GPO / RGPO; however, use of such alternate Grade requires Buyer’s consent. 
 (vi) The
Parties shall make reasonable efforts to cover a Requirement with a suitable Cargo. Until the Requirement is covered by a Cargo the Seller shall continue to advise the Buyer of potential target Cargoes to fulfill such Requirement. If Seller is
unable to procure a Cargo to meet a Requirement, Buyer shall have the option to amend the Requirement so that the Seller can continue to use its reasonable efforts to procure a Cargo to cover such Requirement. If Seller cannot procure a Cargo to
cover a Requirement (either an original Requirement or an amended Requirement) Seller shall have no liability for such failure. 

(f) Transparent Contractual Terms. For any potential Cargo to be acquired by Seller, a set of Transparent Contractual Terms shall
be agreed to, thereby providing a clear mandate to Seller to purchase such Cargo. These Transparent Contractual Terms shall be established under one the following two methods, in Buyer’s option: 

  
 -19-









 (i) The “Execution Method”. Under the Execution Method, the
Transparent Contractual Terms shall include all of the terms necessary for Seller to negotiate and acquire a Cargo directly from a third party. However, the additional costs incurred to have such Cargo Supplied to the Refinery, including, but not
limited to, freight, pricing elements, outturn loss, negotiated pricing basis and period shall be agreed at the appropriate times between the Parties and added as incurred in order to establish Buyer’s final price for such Cargo. If Buyer and
Seller are unable to agree in a timely manner on such additional costs, then Seller can contract for such additional items and the related costs in a commercially reasonable manner and such costs shall be added to Buyer’s final price for such
Cargo. 
 (ii) The “Supply Point Method”. Under the Supply Point Method, the Transparent
Contractual Terms shall include all the terms necessary for the Parties to agree on a price for the Cargo supplied to an agree-upon supply point. The Supply Point Method terms shall include: 

(1) the terms on which the Cargo will be purchased from a third party, and 

(2) Seller’s offer for all other costs from the third party’s delivery point up to the agreed-upon supply point,
including the cost of any difference between the agreed pricing basis and pricing period and that negotiated with the third party. 
 Under the
Supply Point Method, any additional costs, including, but not limited to, Lightering barges in the Delaware River, outturn losses and storage costs, between the pre-defined supply point and such Cargo’s Supply to the Refinery shall be
determined in the same manner as for Cargoes delivered under the Execution Method. The Supply Point Method shall be used whenever Buyer agrees to purchase a Cargo from Seller’s or its Affiliate’s portfolio. 

(iii) Cargo Confirmation. Whether a Cargo is purchased under the Execution Method or the Supply Point Method above,
Seller shall promptly complete and communicate to Buyer a notice in the format set forth in Appendix 10 (a “Cargo Confirmation Notice”) after a Cargo has been purchased. At any point where a transaction relevant to that Cargo
is agreed to between the Parties thereafter, the Cargo Confirmation Notice shall be updated accordingly. For example, if a freight cost is negotiated and established at a time after the Cargo was purchased under the Execution Method, that freight
cost shall be added to the Cargo Confirmation Notice. This process shall continue until the entire price of the Cargo is built up and fully agreed and finalized. 

(iv) Establishment of the Final Quality Differential for a Cargo. The Final Quality Differential shall be
identified in the Cargo Confirmation Notice. This Final Quality Differential is to be used in the pricing process as described in Clause 9. This Final Quality Differential shall be set by agreement between the Parties. Any further cost items or
adjustments that are applied to the Cargo Confirmation Notice shall thereafter follow the “Petty Cash” process in Clause 12. The general principle in the Parties agreeing to the point at which the Final Quality Differential is
established and fixed shall be that further anticipated costs and adjustments are small in nature and would have a low expected probability of having a significant impact on the value of the Final Quality Differential. 

(g) RGPO Optimization and the Other Optimization Account. 

(i) Replacement Pecking Order Cargo Optimizations. To the extent any Replacement Pecking Order Cargo replaces a
Cargo originally purchased for Supply to the Refinery in Month M, which is subsequently disposed of by Seller due to an alternative Cargo or alternative Cargoes (which shall be of equivalent volume to the original purchased Cargo and may consist of
different Grades of Oil) being acquired by agreement between the Parties, the Buyer will pay for the replacement Cargo or Cargoes the price specified by Buyer in the RGPO and the Seller will retain all profit and loss associated with: (1) disposing
of the Cargo originally purchased for Supply to the Refinery and (2) the price differences between the RGPO terms and the terms executed between the Seller and the third party supplier of such replacement Cargo or Cargoes. To the extent Seller
identifies a potential replacement Cargo or Cargoes that is not on the RGPO for the current Cargo, then such RGPO can be modified to add such replacement Cargo or Cargoes upon the Parties’ mutual agreement. 

(ii) Other Optimizations. The “Optimization Account” has been established in order to capture any
profit or loss from an optimization that is proposed by Seller and agreed to by Buyer, other than optimizations in connection with the replacement of Cargoes originally purchased for Supply to the Refinery by use of the RGPO as described in Clause
5(g)(i) above. This Optimization Account shall contain separate accounts for all Cargoes concerned and show in detail any commercial activity and its result, including, but not limited to, profit or loss from the purchase and resale of a Cargo,
profit or loss from fixing and subsequent re-letting of any shipping, or other expenses arising from the optimization of a Cargo. Furthermore, any working capital considerations shall be included in the Optimization Account. Should the Parties agree
that any other economic benefit to be shared between the Parties can most easily be reflected in the Optimization Account, then such economic activity shall also be recorded accordingly. For sake of clarity, all transactions that use the
Optimization Account method for accounting for the economic result of an optimization implicitly require that all pricing and costs associated with the original transaction that was optimized be treated as though there were no optimization and be
generally unaffected by any optimization process, so that all the benefits and costs of such optimization are aggregated in the Optimization Account for sharing between the Parties. 

  
 -20-









 (h) Commencement Inventory at Paulsboro. On the Delivery Commencement Date, Seller
shall acquire the Oil and Indigenous Feedstock held in inventory at the Refinery in accordance with the procedures set forth in Appendix 11. 
 (i) Indigenous Feedstock Obligations. 
 (i) Indigenous
Feedstock Starting and Closing Volume Purchases. 
 (1) Seller will purchase all of the Indigenous Feedstock
being purchased by Buyer from Valero (the “IF Starting Volume”) in connection with the acquisition of the Refinery. The purchase of the IF Starting Volume will be made in accordance with the provisions in Appendix 11 (Commencement
Inventory Acquisition). 
 (2) Buyer shall purchase from Seller on October 17, 2011 (the “IF Conclusion
Date”) a volume of Indigenous Feedstock equal to the IF Starting volume and will pay Seller a price equal to the IF Ending Price. The “IF Ending Price” shall be equal to [REDACTED] minus the amount by which the beginning
Indigenous Feedstock purchase price is less than the [REDACTED] (For example, if the IF Starting Volume is purchased for a price equal to [REDACTED] then the IF Ending Price will be [REDACTED]. 

(3) Buyer and Seller may periodically agree upon an extension of the IF Conclusion Date and a modification to the
IF Storage Fee described in Clause 5(i)(iv)(1) that is paid to Buyer with respect to such an extension period. 

(ii) Interim Indigenous Feedstock Transactions. Unless Buyer has received a Termination of Deliveries Notice, Buyer
shall either sell to Seller daily the net amount of Indigenous Feedstock produced by the Refinery or purchase from Seller daily the net amount of Indigenous Feedstock Buyer takes from the Storage Tanks for use in normal operations of the Refinery.
Buyer will report to Seller daily the net amount of Indigenous Feedstock taken from or delivered to the Storage Tanks. All Indigenous Feedstock at any time placed in the Storage Tanks shall be owned by Seller unless and until it is sold to Buyer in
accordance with this Clause 5 or Clause 24: 
 (1) If the amount of Indigenous Feedstock on any Wednesday during
the term of the Agreement or the preceding Business Day if such Wednesday is not a Business Day (the “IF Determination Date”), is more than the Adjusted IF Volume (as defined below); then (1) Seller shall purchase such additional
Indigenous Feedstock by paying Buyer the Specified Seller Price (as defined below) and (2) such new aggregate higher Indigenous Feedstock volume will become the Adjusted IF Volume until the next purchase or sale of Indigenous Feedstock takes place
under Clause 5(i)(ii)(l) or (2) hereof. 
 The “Adjusted IF Volume” means, initially, the IF Starting Volume and
thereafter such volume as adjusted on each IF Determination Date in accordance with Clause 5(i)(ii)(l) or (2) as appropriate. 

The “Specified Seller Price” (A) for all Seller purchases of Indigenous Feedstock volumes that are in excess of the IF
Starting Volume, will be [REDACTED], and (B) for all Seller purchases of Indigenous Feedstock volumes that are not in excess of the IF Starting Volume, which therefore were previously purchased by Buyer under Clause 5(i)(ii)(2), will be [REDACTED].

 The “IF Market Value” means the current market price of such Indigenous Feedstock. 

(2) If the amount of Indigenous Feedstock on any IF Determination Date is less than the Adjusted IF Volume; then (A) Buyer
shall purchase such volume of consumed Indigenous Feedstock by paying Seller for such Indigenous Feedstock the Specified Buyer Price (as defined below) and (B) such new aggregate lower Indigenous Feedstock volume will become the Adjusted IF Volume
until the next purchase or sale of Indigenous Feedstock takes place under Clause 5(i)(ii)(l) or (2). 
 The “Specified
Buyer Price” (A) for all Buyer purchases of Indigenous Feedstock volumes that are not in excess of the IF Starting Volume, will be a fixed price equal to [REDACTED] and (B) for all Buyer purchases of Indigenous Feedstock volumes that are in
excess of the IF Starting Volume, which therefore were previously purchased by Seller under Clause 5(i)(ii)(l), will be [REDACTED]. 
 (3) Provided Buyer has not received a Termination of Deliveries Notice, Buyer may for efficient, prudent and safe operation of the Refinery and the Storage Tanks, (A) direct Seller to purchase VGO
Feedstock from a third party (“VGO Feedstock”) and such VGO Feedstock shall thereafter be used and treated for all purposes under this Agreement as Indigenous Feedstock, and/or (B) direct Seller to sell a specified volume of
Indigenous Feedstock to a third party with such sale being treated for all purposes under this Agreement as a purchase by Buyer of such Indigenous Feedstock from Seller. The terms and pricing for sales and purchases under this Clause 5(i)(ii)(3)
will be [REDACTED] except that references to an IF Market Value shall be interpreted as [REDACTED] in the third party purchase or sale contract which shall be an arms length contract negotiated by Seller on a commercially reasonable manner.


  
 -21-









 (iii) Additional IF Conclusion Date Purchases and Payment
Obligations. 
 (1) If the amount of Indigenous Feedstock on the IF Conclusion Date is less than the IF
Starting Volume then Buyer shall direct Seller to obtain from a third party VGO Feedstock delivered to the Storage Tanks which shall thereafter be treated for all purposes as Indigenous Feedstock and Buyer shall pay Seller the amount [REDACTED],
under Clause 5(i)(ii) above (provided that if the interim purchase price exceeds the price paid by Seller for such VGO Feedstock, then Buyer [REDACTED]. 
 (2) If the amount of Indigenous Feedstock on the IF Conclusion Date is more than the IF Starting Volume then Buyer shall purchase such additional Indigenous Feedstock for prices [REDACTED]. 

(iv) Indigenous Feedstock Payments, Fees and Credit Provisions. 

(1) All Indigenous Feedstock is subject to the normal service fees and TVM charges that are more fully described in Clause
19. Seller will pay Buyer on the IF Conclusion Date an “IF Storage Fee” which shall be an amount equal to the sum of the following amounts that are calculated monthly for each Month during the period from the purchase of the IF
Starting Volume to the IF Conclusion Date: [REDACTED]. 
 (2) Seller shall periodically determine the amount of
exposure, if any, it has to Buyer based on the Buyers Indigenous Feedstock purchase obligations (the “IF Exposure”) and Seller shall have the right to [REDACTED]. The “IF Exposure” shall be equal to the [REDACTED].

 (j) Tank Heel Obligations. 
 (i) Tank Heel Starting and Closing Volume Purchases. 
 (1)
Seller will purchase all of the usable Oil and usable Indigenous Feedstock that as of the Delivery Commencement Date are Tank Heels which are being purchased by Buyer from Valero (the “TH Starting Volume”) in connection with the
acquisition of the Refinery, The purchase of the TH Starting Volume will be made in accordance with the provisions in Appendix 11 (Commencement Inventory Acquisition). All other obligations to purchase Oil or Indigenous Feedstock referred to in this
Agreement shall not include the Tank Heels which shall be governed by this Clause 5(j). 
 (2) Buyer shall
purchase from Seller on October 17, 2011 (the “TH Conclusion Date”) a volume of Tank Heels equal to the TH Starting Volume and will pay Seller a price equal to the TH Ending Price. The “TH Ending Price” shall be
equal to [REDACTED] minus the amount by which [REDACTED] (For example, if the TH Starting Volume is purchased for a price equal to “[REDACTED]” then the TH Ending Price will be [REDACTED]). 

(3) Buyer and Seller may periodically agree upon an extension of the TH Conclusion Date and a modification to the TH
Storage Fee described in Clause 5(j)(iii)(1) that is paid to Buyer with respect to such an extension period. 

(ii) Interim Tank Heel Transactions. If Seller reasonably believes the volume of Tank Heels may have changed (for
example a tank in the Storage Facilities is removed from service or because more water and sediment has displaced the usable Oil or Indigenous Feedstock that constitute the Tank Heel), then Seller can obtain a measurement or assessment of the
affected Tank Heel(s): 
 (1) If such assessment shows there is more volume of Tank Heels than the TH Starting
Volume then Seller shall purchase such additional Tank Heels volume from Buyer at [REDACTED], and on the TH Conclusion Date, Buyer shall repurchase such additional volume at [REDACTED]. 

(2) If such assessment shows there is less volume of Tank Heels than the TH Starting Volume then Buyer shall purchase such
additional Tank Heels volume from Seller at [REDACTED], and on the TH Conclusion Date Seller shall repurchase such additional volume at [REDACTED]. 
 All Tank Heels at any time in the Storage Tanks shall be owned by Seller unless and until they are sold to Buyer in accordance with this Clause 5 or Clause 24. 

The “TH Market Value” means the current market price of such Tank Heel. 

(iii) Tank Heel Payments, Fees and Credit Provisions. 

(1) All Tank Heels are subject to the normal service fees and TVM charges that are more fully described in Clause 19.
Seller will pay Buyer on the TH Conclusion Date a “TH Storage Fee” which shall be an amount equal to the sum of the following amounts that are calculated for each Month during the period from the purchase of the TH Starting Volume
to the TH Conclusion Date: 
 [REDACTED] 

  
 -22-









 (2) Seller shall periodically determine the amount of exposure, if any, it
has to Buyer based on Buyer’s Tank Heels purchase obligations (the “TH Exposure”) and Seller shall have the right to [REDACTED]. The “TH Exposure” shall be equal to [REDACTED]. 

(3) For purposes of clarification, the Parties agree that all payments calculations with respect to Tank Heels payment
obligations due at or in connection with the TH Conclusion Date or the Termination Date, shall be determined [REDACTED]. 
 (iv) Line Fill. For the purposes of this Section 5(j) only, all Line Fill (as defined in Appendix 11) shall be treated as “Tank Heels,” and Buyer shall at the TH Conclusion Date purchase
the same amount of Line Fill from Seller as Seller purchased from Buyer at the Delivery Commencement Date. 
  

	6.	NOMINATIONS 

 The
following schedule outlines the process for Buyer and Seller to agree on nominations for Supply of Oil into the Refinery for any Month M. For sake of clarity, Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule/Buyer’s Requirements Schedule for
Month M are the plans for Supply of Cargoes in Month M, whereas the Predicted Refinery Slate/Actual Refinery Slate for Month M (both as defined in Clause 9) are the plans for the number of Barrels of any Grade to be Delivered in
that Month. These two plans will be separate and different from one another. The nominations for each Party shall progress in the following chronological order: 
 (a) Buyer shall nominate to Seller no later than the [REDACTED] Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule. Each nomination shall be of [REDACTED] which is the [REDACTED] that Buyer envisages acceptable
fulfillment of the Requirement to meet Buyer’s planned Refinery run schedule. Each nomination shall define the Type for that Requirement. No later than the [REDACTED], Seller shall nominate to Buyer the provisional [REDACTED] for all
Requirements in M. Buyer’s Tentative Requirements Schedule for Month M will at this point become “Buyer’s Requirements Schedule”. Changes of either dates or Types within this Buyer’s Requirements Schedule shall
only be by agreement between the Parties. 

  
 -23-









 (b) At any time when a Requirement is either first covered by a specific Cargo or optimized
from one Cargo to another Cargo, Buyer’s Requirements Schedule will be updated by replacing a Requirement (or optimized out Cargo) with the appropriate Cargo purchased. 
 (c) Buyer shall nominate to Seller no later than the [REDACTED] (i) the Deemed Volume for Month M, and (ii) the Predicted Refinery Slate for M. 

(d) For any Requirement nominated for Supply in M, then promptly after Seller has covered such Requirement with a Cargo Seller shall
contemporaneously nominate to Buyer a [REDACTED]. 
 (e) For any Cargo nominated for Supply in M, Seller shall narrow the
[REDACTED] prior to the beginning of such [REDACTED]. 
 (f) Promptly following the end of Month M, Buyer shall communicate
the Actual Refinery Slate for M based on the Delivered Oil in M. (See Clause 9). 
  

	7.	TITLE; CONTROL; RISK OF LOSS 

 (a) Until title is transferred in accordance with subclause (c) below, Seller shall continuously have and retain title at all times to all Oil and Indigenous Feedstock Seller acquires for purposes of
satisfying its Delivery obligations under this Agreement (including, without limitation, title to Oil or Indigenous Feedstock that is on the water, in transport, or in the Storage Facilities). Buyer shall not take any action that adversely affects
or encumbers in any way Seller’s title to or rights in such Oil and Indigenous Feedstock. 
 (b) To further clarify
Seller’s continuous title and ownership of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock, as described above, including the Oil and Indigenous Feedstock in the Storage Facilities, Buyer will facilitate the execution of Intercreditor Agreement(s) with any
lenders, credit buyers, secured parties, debt buyers, or any other Person which seeks to obtain or maintain (i) a material security interest in the Refinery or in any related assets, operations or contracts or (iii) any security interest,
lien or other rights in the Oil or Indigenous Feedstock. Buyer hereby authorizes Seller to make any and all filings under the UCC that are appropriate to clarify Seller’s ownership and other rights with respect to such Oil and Indigenous
Feedstock. Buyer agrees to immediately notify Seller pursuant to the notice provision herein in the event that a Lien is placed upon the Refinery by any creditor of Buyer at any time during the term of this Agreement other than as described in the
Intercreditor Agreement(s). 

  
 -24-









 (c) Title to the Oil shall pass upon the following actions being completed: 

(i) From Seller to Buyer when Oil other than Indigenous Feedstock is transferred through the Storage Facility outlet
flange. 
 (ii) From Buyer to Seller when Indigenous Feedstock is transferred through the Indigenous Feedstock
Tank inlet flange. 
 (iii) From Seller to Buyer when Indigenous Feedstock is transferred through the Indigenous
Feedstock Tank outlet flange. 
 (d) Delivery of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock to Buyer shall be considered to be taken at the
same point where title passes. 
 (e) During Normal Refinery Operation, subject to Seller’s right to suspend deliveries
(i) under Clause 19 or (ii) pursuant to a Termination of Deliveries Notice, Buyer may take deliveries of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock from the Storage Facilities solely for refining within the Refinery without prior consent of Seller.

 (f) Control of Oil 
 (i) Except with respect to the daily deliveries of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock contemplated by Clause 7(e) or as provided in Clause 3 of Appendix 5, Buyer shall not cause or permit Seller’s Oil to
be withdrawn from the Storage Facilities without prior written consent of Seller. In the event that at any time Seller provides a notice to Buyer substantially in the form of Appendix 12 (a “Termination of Deliveries Notice”), Buyer
shall immediately cease taking any further deliveries of Oil from the Storage Facilities until Seller notifies Buyer in writing that such Termination of Deliveries Notice has been canceled. Appendix 6 allows some flexibility for moving Oil and
Indigenous Feedstock in the case of an emergency. 
 (ii) Subject to the forgoing, Buyer shall for all purposes
hereunder be deemed to have custody of the (1) Oil at such time as the Oil passes the flange connection between a delivery Vessel’s permanent supply manifold and the receiving pipeline or hose at the Supply Port and (2) the Indigenous
Feedstock at all times. 
 (g) Risk of loss of the Oil shall pass from Seller to Buyer when the Oil passes the flange connection
between a delivery Vessel’s permanent supply manifold and the receiving pipeline or hose at the Supply Port, and Buyer shall have at all times risk of loss for any Indigenous Feedstock; provided, that to the extent Seller receives any
insurance proceeds under the insurance policies covering the Oil or Indigenous Feedstock described in Clause 21(c), Seller shall net from any amounts Buyer shall be responsible to indemnify Seller or any other Indemnified Party hereunder with
respect to Oil or Indigenous Feedstock where Buyer bears the risk of loss pursuant to this Clause 7(g), the amount of insurance proceeds actually received with respect to such Oil or Indigenous Feedstock. 

  
 -25-










	8.	STORAGE FACILITIES 

 (a)
Seller will, as of the Delivery Commencement Date and during the term of this Agreement, have (i) the sole and exclusive right to store Oil in the Storage Facilities pursuant to the terms and conditions of this Agreement and Appendix 5 attached
hereto, (ii) the right to access the Storage Facilities to add or remove Oil and Indigenous Feedstock, and (iii) the right to label the Storage Facilities, subject to Buyer’s reasonable approval, in such a manner as to put third
parties on notice of Seller’s rights in such tanks and the Oil stored therein. If at anytime Seller elects to remove its Oil and/or Indigenous Feedstock, Buyer shall provide access to all of the Refinery’s necessary equipment and all
assistance reasonably required to complete such removal. 
 (b) Additional Tanks. If Buyer or Seller determines that
additional off-site storage space is needed for use in connection with the operation of the Refinery, Buyer may locate and propose to Seller proposed storage space to be used for additional Oil and/or Indigenous Feedstock storage (a
“Proposed Storage Site”), together with proposed terms for acquiring such Proposed Storage Site. If such Proposed Storage Site is acceptable to Seller, including, with respect to (i) Seller’s HSE standards, (ii) other
site conditions, and (iii) commercial terms, then Seller may acquire such Proposed Storage Site (by lease or otherwise) for Buyer’s use on such terms as are mutually acceptable to the Parties. Seller shall complete its review in a timely
manner based on then-existing circumstances. Buyer shall be responsible for all costs and expenses incurred by Seller with respect to the use of such Proposed Storage Site, including lease payments or the equivalent, and expenses and Seller’s
costs incurred in negotiating the acquisition of such Proposed Storage Site for Buyer’s use, all on a pass-through basis and with prior approval of Buyer. Any Proposed Storage Site acquired by Seller pursuant to the terms of this Clause 8(b)
shall become a “Statoil Storage Facility”. 
 (c) Delaware City Storage. Seller contemplates that during the
term of the Agreement, Seller may enter into a Tank Lease Agreement in substantially the form of Appendix 16 (the “Delaware City Tank Lease”) with DCRC, which is an Affiliate of Buyer, providing Seller rights to certain storage
tanks at the Delaware City refinery. During the term of the Delaware City Tank Lease and this Agreement, Buyer shall, and shall cause DCRC to, comply with all of the terms of the Delaware City Tank Lease. 

(d) Restricted Use of Tanks. If at any time during the term of this Agreement Seller’s use of any storage tanks comprising
the Storage Facilities is materially restrained or enjoined by judicial process, terminated by municipal or other Governmental Authority or by right of eminent domain, Buyer and Seller shall cooperate to dispose of any Oil related to such storage
tanks. To the extent Buyer is not able to timely use such Oil, Seller shall use commercially reasonable efforts to sell such Oil to third parties, and the terms of Clause 9(e) shall apply to such resold Oil. 

 

	9.	PRICE AND PRICING 

 (a)
Pricing Information. To be able to calculate the price per Barrel of Oil delivered in a Month (defined in Clause 9(b) hereof as the Blended Price), the Parties will provide and keep records of the following information: 

(i) Predicted Refinery Slate Information. At or before the last Business Day of the Month prior to the delivery
Month, Buyer shall provide Seller the “Predicted Refinery Slate”, which shall be Buyer’s estimation of the volumes and 

  
 -26-









 
Grades of the Cargoes of Oil that are planned to be Delivered to the Refinery in such Month. Seller will update or amend as necessary the Predicted Refinery Slate in accordance with the
procedures in Clause 9(b)(iv). 
 (ii) Actual Refinery Slate. As soon as
reasonably practicable and in any case by no later than the 3rd Business Day of the Month following the delivery Month, Buyer shall provide Seller with the “Actual Refinery Slate” stating the volumes of each Cargo Delivered to the Refinery in such
Month. The volumes of each Cargo Delivered to the Refinery will be known as the “Cargo Bank Withdrawal”, and determination of which Cargo within a Grade has been Delivered will be determined following a FIFO principle based on
Supply dates of Cargoes of that Grade. Because volumes that are deemed to be Delivered cannot with precise accuracy reflect the Oil actually Delivered, the Parties acknowledge that actual Delivered volumes may not exactly match the deemed Delivered
volumes. Any difference between the actual Delivered volumes and the deemed Delivered volumes shall be monitored through the monthly reconciliation of inventories described in Clause 11. 

(iii) Cargo Bank. Each Cargo supplied to the Refinery shall have an associated “Cargo Bank” with a
reference number that matches the Cargo Number. The Cargo Bank shall be in the form of Appendix 14 and shall contain the following information: 
 (1) The Grade of Oil; 
 (2) The volume of Oil outturn to the
Refinery (or the most accurately available alternative until the outturn becomes available, and updated accordingly) when the Cargo was Supplied; 
 (3) The Cargo Bank Differential; 
 (4) The contract month of NYMEX
WTI futures used as the basis for calculating the Cargo Basis Differential, the “Cargo Bank Hedge-Month”; 
 (5) The monthly deemed Cargo Bank Withdrawals pertinent to that Cargo; and 
 (6) The closing balance on the Cargo Bank (equal to (2)) minus the sum of all (5) above). 
 (iv) Applicable Pricing Information. For purposes of calculation of the Blended Price per Barrel of Oil in a Month, the Parties shall use the same elements or component information that are used
for determining the Cargo Final Prices and any corrections or modifications that are required to account for difference between the estimates used in setting the Cargo Final Prices and the exact amounts that such estimates were seeking to
approximate will be addressed pursuant to Clause 12 Petty Cash Banks. 

  
 -27-









 (b) The Price Calculation for Each Delivery Month. Following delivery of the Actual
Refinery Slate by Buyer, Seller shall calculate the price per Barrel for Oil Delivered under this Agreement in such Month (the “Blended Price”), which shall be equal to the sum of the Monthly Quality and Basis Differential plus the
Pricing Element. To determine the Blended Price the following definitions and underlying calculations need to be applied. 
 (i) Determination of the Monthly Quality and Basis Differential. The “Monthly Quality and Basis Differential” for any Month of Delivery shall be determined, promptly following such
Month of Delivery, as the sum of the results from multiplying (1) and (2) below for each Cargo Bank Withdrawal in such Month: 
 (1) the Cargo Bank Withdrawals (that make up the Actual Refinery Slate for that Month) taken from each applicable Cargo Bank, and, 

(2) the Cargo Bank Differential of that Cargo Bank, divided by (the sum of the Cargo Bank Withdrawals for that Month).

 (ii) The “Cargo Bank Differential” is equal to the sum of the Final Quality Differential plus
the Cargo Basis Differential. 
 (1) Final Quality Differential. For any Cargo Supplied, the
“Final Quality Differential” shall constitute all elements agreed between the Parties applicable directly to the Supply of that Cargo (excluding any adjustments that are included in the Petty Cash Bank) that were identified as Final
Quality Differential elements in the mandate or in other communications between the Seller and Buyer. This Final Quality Differential shall be as detailed in the Cargo Table applicable to that Cargo. The Cargo Table, in the form of Appendix 15,
shall be maintained by Seller and contain a written record of all commercial agreements made between the Parties with respect to that Cargo, including Petty Cash Bank adjustments, 

(2) Cargo Basis Differential. If the pricing basis for a Cargo negotiated between Seller and a third party supplier
is based on [REDACTED] index pricing for the Cargo Bank Hedge-Month then the Cargo Basis Differential for such Cargo shall be $[REDACTED] if the pricing basis negotiated by Seller with the third party supplier is not based on [REDACTED] index
pricing for the Cargo Bank Hedge-Month (such as a transaction based on “Dated Brent” pricing) the Cargo Basis Differential will be [REDACTED]. As a part of the hedge based pricing process described in this Clause 9(b)(ii), the Parties
agree that, no later than the Business Day prior to the first day of pricing being set between the parties by Buyer nominating it is being delivered such Cargo, the third party pricing basis shall be converted to an appropriate [REDACTED] futures
contract basis, with an appropriate corresponding hedging month to be used in such pricing (the “Hedge-Month”). Should Buyer fail to follow the procedure below to designate the Hedge-Month and or set the [REDACTED] based index
pricing for the Cargo Bank Hedge-Month within the allowed time 

  
 -28-









 
period, Seller, in its sole discretion, can hedge the Cargo in the best way Seller sees fit and using the hedging futures contracts it deems most appropriate, and the actual difference between
such hedging contracts and the third party pricing basis shall be used as the Cargo Basis Differential. For any Cargo that has been acquired to cover a Requirement, Buyer shall have the option at all times (subject to the limitations detailed later
in this Clause 9) to contact Seller and request a fair market price assessment for the difference between: 

(A) the value of the pricing basis that make a part of the commercial terms negotiated in the acquisition of a Cargo, and

 (B) the value of the [REDACTED] futures contract and associated Hedge-Month which will be used as the new
pricing basis for such Cargo. 
 The chosen Hedge-Month associated with such futures contract should be either the [REDACTED]
applicable when the Cargo is due to price. The choice of which contract month will be the Hedge-Month shall be Buyer’s election. The Cargo Number and Hedge-Month shall be advised by Buyer to Seller by telephone when Buyer requests the fair
market price assessment. Promptly upon receipt of Buyer’s request (and time shall be of the essence in this respect), Seller shall seek a fair market assessment and contact Buyer by telephone to advise Buyer of that assessment. Promptly upon
receipt of market prices (and time shall be of the essence in this respect), Buyer shall accept or reject any or all of these market prices. If Buyer accepts Seller’s assessment, Buyer shall agree with Seller by telephone: 

(C) The Cargo Basis Differential, which shall be equal to the fair market price assessment, and 

(D) The Hedge-Month elected by Buyer. 
 Finally, the Cargo Basis Differential and the applicable Hedge-Month shall be recorded by Seller in the Cargo Table. 

(iii) Hedge-Month Pool. The sum of the volumes of the Cargo Bank Withdrawals (in the appropriate Delivery Month)
with a particular Cargo Bank Hedge-Month will make up the volume of the “Hedge-Month Pool” for that Month. There will be one or more Hedge-Month Pools for any Delivery Month, the total volume of which will be the volume priced for
that Month. No later than the last Business Day prior to the first day of the Delivery Month, the Parties shall agree to the following details, in the form of Appendix 14, with respect to the Hedge-Month Pools for such upcoming Delivery Month:

 (1) The [REDACTED] futures contract month for each Hedge-Month Pool; 

(2) The volume in each Hedge-Month Pool; 

  
 -29-









 (3) The total number of futures contracts held by Seller in each Hedge-Month
Pool; and 
 (4) Which Cargoes make up each Hedge-Month Pool. 

Any changes during the Delivery Month to the Hedge-Month Pools shall be made in accordance with procedures in Clauses 9(c)(i)(3) and
9(c)(ii)(4). 
 (iv) Restriction on Differences between Actual Refinery Slate and Predicted Refinery
Slate. Any differences between the volumes of the components making up the Actual Refinery Slate and the prevailing Predicted Refinery Slate, as advised when Buyer communicates the Actual Refinery Slate after the end of the Delivery Month, must
meet the following criteria: 
 (1) The volume of the Predicted Refinery Slate must equal that of the Actual
Refinery Slate, and 
 (2) The total volume of each Hedge-Month Pool for that Month must be unaffected by any
differences. 
 (c) Pricing Element. 

(i) Pricing Volume. 
 (1) The total volume of Oil estimated for delivery in the Predicted Refinery Slate divided by the total number of Pricing Days in that Month will form the “Daily Default Pricing Volume”.

 (2) For information purposes, on every Business Day, Buyer shall advise Seller of the volume of Oil that has
been Delivered to it since the previous Business Day’s delivered volume notice to the nearest 5000 Barrels. Because volumes will be reported before full and final information on the Oil Delivered is available, the Parties acknowledge that
actual Delivered volumes may not exactly match the volume notices. 
 (3) At any time during the Delivery Month,
Buyer has the option to [REDACTED]. 

  
 -30-









 (ii) Pricing Based on Futures Indexes 

(1) Buyer’s Pricing Instructions to Seller. On the Business Day prior to any day of pricing, Buyer shall
advise Seller of the volume of Oil that Buyer is to price on that day and the Hedge-Month to be used for the pricing of that volume. Should Buyer fail to advise Seller of this information, the Parties understand that the Daily Default Pricing Volume
for the current Month of Delivery and the prevailing front Month [REDACTED] contract shall be used for pricing. 

(2) Buyer’s Obligations for Pricing. It is Buyer’s obligation through its pricing instructions to Seller,
as detailed in (1) above, to ensure that, by the NYMEX closing time on the Business Day prior to the expiry day of any [REDACTED] futures contract (as set by [REDACTED]), that the Hedge-Month Pool for that futures contract shall have a zero balance.
Any futures position outstanding after that deadline will be deemed to have been closed at the settlement price for that futures contract on that day, and a corresponding equal volume new position will have been deemed to have been opened for the
next month’s [REDACTED] futures contract at the settlement price for that contract on that day. 
 (3)
Seller’s Obligations for Accurate and Timely Notices. Pricing is determined based on timely and accurate notices provided by Buyer to Seller and reference to appropriate indexes. Regardless of whether Seller acquires or fails to acquire
the specified futures and other contracts, the pricing between Buyer and Seller shall be valid and binding in accordance with Buyer’s timely hedge related pricing instructions. The price that is to be used on any futures transaction shall be
the appropriate [REDACTED] settlement price for the Business Day of the transaction. Any transaction shall duly be reflected in the futures account for that Hedge-Month Pool. 

(4) Hedging Activity Due to Refinery Operational Upsets. Buyer shall have the option to request that Seller adjust
the number of futures contracts held in any Hedge-Month Pool by contacting Seller and requesting that Seller perform a futures transaction outside the normal hedging and pricing activity as described above. This request shall be at Buyer’s
discretion for reasons including, but not limited to, unplanned changes in running plan or unscheduled shutdowns caused by Refinery upsets. Seller shall perform such transactions according to the principles above and shall not unreasonably refuse
such requests. However, Seller shall only be required to act within the following limitations: 
 (A) All
transactions shall be at achievable market prices, either settlement prices with due notice, or if Buyer requests, transactions concluded during the trading day whereby Buyer accepts Seller’s achieved transaction prices. 

  
 -31-









 (B) The total number of futures in any purchase transaction must equal the
total number of futures in a corresponding sales transaction, and vice versa: Buyer does not have the option to request Seller to take a net longer or net shorter futures position. 

Should any Hedge-Month Pool be changed by Buyer requesting and Seller accepting a non-standard hedging activity, the Parties shall agree
to a corresponding adjustment to the Cargo Basis Differential (and thereby the Cargo Bank Differential) and the Hedge-Month for any Cargo or part of Cargo that is affected by such change, in order that the Hedge-Month Pools and Cargo Banks remain in
balance and the other principles of this Agreement ate maintained. 
 (iii) Calculation of the Pricing
Element. For any Delivery Month, the Pricing Element shall be equal to [REDACTED]: 
 (1) [REDACTED]

 (2) [REDACTED] 
 The pricing element shall be calculated to 4 decimal places. 
 (d) Fair market
assessment. The fair market assessment variously referenced in this Clause 9 shall be a concept subject to certain principles, which will be adhered to by Seller. Seller shall make commercially reasonable efforts to provide Buyer with a fair and
representative indication of the current market value of the components of risk that Buyer is seeking valuation for. These values can be obtained from a reliable third-party marketer approved by both Parties (for example an investment bank), from
crude oil futures exchange brokers or from Seller’s own assessment. Furthermore Buyer understands that there is execution risk and that Seller shall reasonably provide valuations as close to market prices that it deems are executable in the
marketplace. These valuations will be volume and liming dependent due to potential liquidity limitations. 
 (e) Resold
Oil. For operational reasons Buyer may request that Seller resell a volume of Oil which has not yet been Delivered, but which has been Supplied or has been purchased by Seller to fulfill a Requirement of Seller and designated by the Parties as a
volume of Oil to be Supplied in accordance with Clause 5. Provided the resale of such of Oil is not for optimization purposes (which will be transacted pursuant to the RGPO Optimization / Other Optimization methodology described in Clause 5(g)) the
following provisions shall apply: 
 (i) Buyer will communicate to Seller a request to resell Oil, indicating the
quality, volume, and location of Oil to be resold. Seller will review the request and advise Buyer if such a resale of Oil is possible. If in Seller’s opinion a requested resale is not possible, then Buyer and Seller shall discus alternative
options. 
 (ii) If in the opinion of Seller the resale of Oil is possible the Seller shall use commercially
reasonable efforts to achieve the best commercial terms for the resale of that Oil to either a third party or to Seller or an Affiliate of Seller. In such cases where Seller or an Affiliate of Seller is to be the purchaser of the resold Oil then the
commercial terms governing such sale will be negotiated between the Patties, 
 (iii) If a resale of Oil is
successfully negotiated the volume of Oil sold will be deemed to have been Delivered to Buyer and priced to Buyer pursuant to Clause 9. The payment by Buyer for such Cargo will follow the terms included in Clause 10 including TVM charges as
applicable, Seller will make any adjustments required to the Hedge Month Pools and Cargo Banks and notify Buyer of such changes. 
 (iv) Seller will advise Buyer of the price and commercial terms achieved for the resold Oil, and Buyer will invoice Seller on the basis of these terms, less a US$[REDACTED] per Barrel service fee. For the
avoidance of doubt (1) the payment to Buyer for Oil resold to a third party purchaser will be due promptly following Seller’s receipt of payment from such third party purchaser, and Seller shall not be a guarantor or surety with respect to such
third party payment obligation, and (2) the payment to Buyer for Oil resold to Seller will be made in accordance with the payment terms mutually agreed between Seller and Buyer. 

  
 -32-










	10.	PAYMENT AND THE EPQ PROCESS 

 (a) Subject to Clause 10(d), payment for Oil Delivered under this Agreement shall be made in full, without discount, deduction, withholding, set-off or counterclaim upon presentation of Seller’s
commercial invoice, on or before the payment due date pursuant to the provisions of this Clause 10. 
 (b) Payment shall be made
in US Dollars by wire transfer of immediately available funds (same day funds) into Seller’s designated bank account as per this Clause 10, after receipt of Seller’s invoice and supporting documentation, delivered in accordance with Clause
29. 
 (c) Invoicing and payment shall be based upon the following schedule: 

(i) After the Delivery Commencement Date, Seller shall initiate the EPQ Process on the second to last Business Day of
each calendar week and on the final Business Day of each Month. Seller can also, at its option, initiate the EPQ process by communicating to Buyer by 12:00 noon on any Business Day (“Day 1”) the requirement for Buyer to
complete the EPQ Form; however, Seller agrees that it will only exercise such optional or non-routine EPQ process for the purposes of keeping Buyer within Buyer’s available credit limits. 

(ii) Following initiation of the EPQ process, Buyer shall conduct an electronic (computer readout sufficient) inventory of
the Storage Facilities using the regular volumetric monitoring system installed at the Refinery at 5:00 p.m. on Day 1. Buyer shall transmit the EPQ, in a format set forth in Appendix 1, to Seller so as to arrive at Seller’s normal
place of business, no later than 8:00 a.m. on the following day (“Day 2”). The EPQ shall include any necessary adjustment for over- or under-billed volumes from a previous period, as described in Clause 11. The EPQ Form
shall establish the approximate quantity Delivered between the previous EPQ Form and such EPQ Form. 

  
 -33-









 (iii) Prior to 5:00 p.m. on Day 1, Buyer and Seller shall agree on a
“Provisional Price” for the EPQ. In the event that the Parties do not agree to a Provisional Price by 5:00 p.m. on Day 1, Seller reserves the sole right to calculate the Provisional Price for the purposes of preparing a
provisional invoice (“Provisional Invoice”). 
 (iv) Seller shall process the information
detailed in the EPQ Form and, taking into account (1) any payments received from any Off-Taker pursuant to a PDA, (2) any other payments made by Buyer or on Buyer’s behalf in respect of Buyer’s obligations under this Agreement,
and (3) Buyer’s current and forecasted available capacity under the PBF Line of Credit, shall transmit a Provisional Invoice to Buyer’s normal place of business by no later than 10:00 a.m. on Day 2. 

(v) Buyer shall remit funds as per Clause 10(b) no later than 12:00 noon on Day 2; provided, that if the EPQ Form has
been prepared with respect to the last Business Day of a Month, then the payment made by Buyer shall be equal to the amount required to reduce the outstanding amount of the PBF Line of Credit to 0. If Buyer fails to remit funds by such time and such
failure is caused solely by an error or omission of an administrative or operational nature of Seller, Buyer shall remit a reasonably estimated amount of the funds due, and the Parties shall continue to proceed through the payment process in a
diligent manner to determine the correct amount of funds to be paid by Buyer on Day 2, after which Buyer shall remit to Seller additional funds for any underpayment by Buyer or Seller shall return to Buyer the amount of any overpayment by Buyer.

 (d) All payments made by Off-Takers for Seller’s account pursuant to a PDA referencing this Agreement shall be applied
to the obligations of Buyer to Seller under this Agreement. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Buyer is fully responsible for all payment obligations to Seller hereunder regardless of whether any Off-Taker fails to timely and fully make payments
directly to Buyer pursuant to the terms of a PDA, and Buyer takes all risk for non-payment, underpayment or non-timely payment by the Off-Takers. Buyer represents and warrants to Seller that, as of the Effective Date and the Delivery Commencement
Date, all receivables for Refined Products will be included in the PDA, and the only PDA that will be effective at the Delivery Commencement Date will be the PDA between MSCG, Buyer and Seller. 

(e) If at the beginning of a Business Day it appears that the net amount of cash received by Seller from Off-Takers pursuant to PDAs,
after application of such cash to any payment obligations of Buyer then outstanding, exceeds Estimated Credit Usage for the following Business Day (such amount, the “Direct Payment Excess”), then Seller shall within 2 Business Days
transfer to Buyer the Direct Payment Excess in US Dollars by wire transfer of immediately available funds into Buyer’s designated bank account; provided, that Seller shall be permitted to apply the Direct Payment Excess to any Buyer Credit
Usage on the date such repayment to Buyer would be due. 

  
 -34-










	11.	RECONCILIATION OF MONTH END VOLUMES AND ADJUSTMENT 

 (a) At the end of each Month, M (as selected in accordance with Clause 11(a)(ii), “MonthEnd”), Buyer and Seller shall expeditiously reconcile the volumes of Oil priced, Supplied and
Delivered during the Month, and calculate an economic adjustment (“Adjustment”) to the payments made in Month M, as follows: 
 (i) Delivered Volume. The Independent Inspector shall make an accurate assessment of the approximate volume of Oil in Inventory in the Storage Facilities at MonthEnd of Month M, and Buyer shall
transmit a report based on the Independent Inspector’s assessment (each, an “Inventory Assessment”) to Seller in the format shown in Appendix 17. Such Inventory Assessment shall be the “Closing Inventory” for
Month M and the “Opening Inventory” for Month M+1. The “Delivered Volume” for Month M is equal to the Opening Inventory in Month M plus the Supplied Volume in Month M minus Closing Inventory in Month
M. 
 (1) The Inventory Assessment shall be prepared on a NSV basis in accordance with then-current API/ASTM
standards and guidelines, and subject to (A) Clause 5(j) regarding interim measurement or assessments of Tank Heels and related payments and adjustments and(B) Clause 5 of Appendix 5 relating to tanks being taken out of service and a reduction
for the related Tank Heels, the deduction for the Tank Heels purchased by Seller pursuant to Appendix 11 on the Delivery Commencement Date shall remain consistent for the duration of the Agreement. 

(2) The costs and expenses of the preparation of such Inventory Assessment, including any fees paid to the Independent
Inspector, shall be shared equally by the Parties. 
 (ii) MonthEnd date Selection. At a time reasonably
close to MonthEnd, Buyer and Seller shall assess the likelihood of Vessels actively transferring Oil in or out of the Storage Facilities at or close to MonthEnd and shall deem the day of such MonthEnd so as to avoid having to determine the Inventory
during such transfer of Oil. The “Supplied Volume” shall be the total NSV recorded by an Independent Inspector(s) for all Vessels Supplying Oil during the Month M between such deemed MonthEnds. 

(b) Adjustment. The Seller shall compare the total amount paid by or on behalf of Buyer in M, including any amount that Seller has
received from an Off-Taker pursuant to a PDA (collectively, the “Pre-Adjustment Payments”), to the amount that should have been paid to Seller (“Calculated Payment Obligation”), for the Delivered Volume for M. The
Parties acknowledge that the Calculated Payment Obligation may include quantities of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock that was Delivered in Month M but was originally priced in anticipation of delivery in M-1, M or M+1. 

  
 -35-









 (c) If the Calculated Payment Obligation for M is greater than the
Pre-Adjustment Payments for M, then Buyer will pay Seller the amount of such underpayment. If the Pre-Adjustment Payments for M are greater than the Calculated Payment Obligation for Month M, then Seller will refund to Buyer the amount of such
overpayment. The amount of any such underpayment or overpayment shall be due and payable (together with interest at the Base Rate charged from the 15th day of Month M until the reconciliation payment is made) on the same date that payment is due with respect to the next
EPQ delivered by Seller in accordance with Clause 10 following completion of the above-described calculation of the Calculated Payment Obligation. 
 (d) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, any amounts not paid when due under this Agreement shall bear interest from and including the date payment was originally to be made but
excluding the date payment is actually made at the Default Rate. Interest shall be computed for the actual number of days elapsed on the basis of a year consisting of 360 days. Acceptance of late payments shall not constitute a waiver of rights to
interest and shall in no circumstance be considered as an agreement to provide extended credit. 
  

	12.	PETTY CASH BANKS 

 (a)
When each Requirement is filled by a Cargo, Buyer and Seller shall work together to agree on the following components of the Cargo Final Price for that Cargo. Not withstanding if the components remain an estimate or not, 10 days prior to the Month
of Delivery of that Cargo, Buyer and Seller agree to use the latest estimates, or the best information available to finalize all components of the Cargo Final Price including, without limitation: 

(i) Final Quality Differential at point of acquisition by Seller; 

(ii) estimated freight; 
 (iii) estimated Taxes including any charges pursuant to Clause 20; 
 (iv) estimated demurrage; 
 (v) estimated outturn loss; and

 (vi) estimated Cargo insurance. 
 (b) The Parties acknowledge that this Cargo Final Price is final only in the sense that it will be used for invoicing purposes between the Parties and does not fully reflect the value of the Oil upon
Delivery. The difference in the actual value of the Oil and the value contained in the Cargo Final Price will be taken into account by the Petty Cash Bank. 
 (c) The Petty Cash Bank shall contain the continuous detailed outstanding account for elements of the price of Oil not contained in the Cargo Final Price, including, but not limited to: 

(i) Freight outside of the Cargo Final Price; 

(ii) Taxes outside of the Cargo Final Price; 

  
 -36-









 (iii) Demurrage outside of the Cargo Final Price; 

(iv) Outturn loss outside of the Cargo Final Price; 

(v) Supplier and vendor costs. 
 (d) The construction of the “Petty Cash Bank” shall follow the format set out in Appendix 18. 
 (e) When the Petty Cash Bank value exceeds $500,000 (either in favor of Buyer or Seller) or, if no other payment was made pursuant to this subclause (e) during such calendar quarter, on
March 30, June 30, September 30 and December 30 of each year (or if such day is not a Business Day, on the next Business Day thereafter) the balance of the Petty Cash Bank shall be paid down to $0 by the owing Party.

  

	13.	VESSEL, BERTH AND SUPPLY PORT 

 (a) Vessel. 
 (i) Oil relating to this Agreement
shall be Supplied on Vessels acceptable to Buyer. Buyer shall accept such nominated Vessel, and such acceptance shall not be unreasonably withheld. Buyer shall, within one Business Day after having received Seller’s nomination of a Vessel,
notify Seller of: 
 (1) All instructions regarding customary Refinery documentation required at the Supply Port.

 (2) The intended Berth at the Supply Port, with instructions to enable the Vessel to prepare and submit
necessary information to the customs or border authorities in a timely manner so as to enable compliance with regulatory requirements as may be applicable. 
 (3) Whether the Vessel is acceptable to Buyer. If the Vessel is not acceptable to Buyer, Buyer shall notify Seller of the specific reason or reasons for such unacceptability so that Seller may take such
reasonable corrective action to correct such unacceptability, if possible. 
 (ii) Seller shall instruct all
Vessels to comply with Buyer’s then-current rules and regulations and to comply with all applicable Laws in force at the Supply Port, including the U.S. Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended, the U.S. Federal Oil Pollution Control Act
of 1990 and regulations issued pursuant thereto. Buyer shall provide Seller with an electronic copy of its rules and regulations and any amendments thereto. Seller shall ensure that all Vessels secure and carry on board the vessel a current U.S.
Coast Guard Certificate of Financial Responsibility (Water Pollution). Vessels shall also have onboard any other Federal and/or state proof of financial responsibility certificate that may be required at the Refinery, as communicated by Buyer to
Seller in a manner that reasonably allows the Vessel owner to obtain such certificate in a timely manner. Seller shall exercise due diligence to 

  
 -37-









 
ensure that any Vessel shall fully comply or hold waivers for non-compliance with all applicable US Customs and Border Protection regulations in effect as of the date of Berth. Seller shall
provide all required Customs information to the US Customs and Border Protection and Buyer prior to a Vessel’s arrival. 
 (iii) Seller shall arrange that each Vessel shall comply with the requirements of the International Code for the Security of Ships and of Port Facilities and the relevant amendments to Chapter XI of
SOLAS (“ISPS Code”) and the US Maritime Transportation Security Act of 2002 (“MTSA”). Each Vessel shall, when required, submit a Declaration of Security to the appropriate authorities prior to arrival at the Supply
Port. Notwithstanding any prior acceptance of any Vessel by Buyer, if at any time prior to the passing of risk such Vessel ceases to comply with the requirements of the ISPS Code and the MTSA, then: 

(1) Buyer shall have the right not to berth such nominated Vessel. 

(2) Seller shall be obliged to substitute such nominated Vessel with a Vessel complying with the requirements of the ISPS
Code and the MTSA 
 (iv) Seller may substitute a different Vessel of a similar size and characteristics provided
that Seller fulfills its obligations under this Clause 13. 
 (v) Notwithstanding any prior acceptance of any
Vessel by Buyer, Buyer has the right to reject a Vessel on reasonable grounds if it has been involved in any material incident subsequent to approval that could be construed to have a negative impact on its performance, or more recent information
regarding the Vessel becomes available to Seller at any time after such prior acceptance. 
 (vi) Seller shall
use reasonable efforts to ensure that all Vessels used by Seller shall provide for the replacement of the master, officers or crew of the Vessel should (i) Seller have reason to complain of their performance and (ii) the owner of such
Vessel, after due investigation, finds the complaint justified. 
 (vii) Seller shall supply to Buyer copies of
bills of lading or other shipping papers as reasonably requested by Buyer. 
 (b) Berth and Supply Port.

 (i) Buyer shall exercise due diligence to provide free of charge, a safe Berth or Berths at the Supply Port
which Vessels can safely reach and leave and at which Vessels can lie and transfer cargo always afloat and always within the limits of possible air draft(s) or other physical or material restrictions. 

(ii) Seller warrants to Buyer that all Seller-designated loading ports, facilities, or terminals for this Agreement are in
compliance and will remain in compliance with the ISPS Code and similar Laws pertaining to the security of ports, facilities, or terminals. Buyer warrants to Seller that all Buyer-designated unloading ports, facilities, or terminals for this
Agreement are in compliance and will remain in compliance with the ISPS Code and similar Laws pertaining to the security of ports, facilities, or terminals. 

  
 -38-









 (iii) This Agreement is based on Buyer’s confirmation that any Vessel
can safely transit to, lie alongside and transfer cargo with a draught up to and including 40 feet fresh water. In the event that the permissible draught is reduced to less than 40 feet fresh water, then any reasonable associated costs, including
possible deadfreight, will be for Buyer’s account so long as Seller takes reasonable measures to mitigate its damages and follows the reasonable recommendations of Buyer. Any reasonable costs associated with the Supply of the Oil into a port
other than the Supply Port, or to a Berth other than at the Refinery at the Supply Port, shall, unless for a reason attributable to the Vessel or Seller, be for the account of Buyer. 

(iv) Any costs for normal cargo transfer not designated by Worldscale as freight, or any additional costs that occur
subsequent to this Agreement being initiated, shall be for the account of Buyer. 
 (v) Any costs or expenses in
respect of any Vessel including demurrage or any additional charge, fee or duty levied in respect of such Vessel at the Supply Port and actually incurred by Seller resulting directly from the failure of the Supply Port to comply with the
requirements of the ISPS Code and, if located within the US and US territories or waters, with the MTSA, shall be for the account of Buyer, including but not limited to the time required or costs incurred by Seller in taking any action or any
special or additional security measures required by the ISPS Code or MTSA; provided, however, Buyer’s liability to Seller for any costs, losses or expenses incurred by Seller in respect of any Vessel, the charterers, or the Vessel owners
(excluding consequential damages) resulting from the failure of the Supply Port to comply with the requirements of the ISPS Code and, where located within the US and US territories or waters, with the MTSA, shall be limited to the payment of
demurrage and costs actually incurred by Seller in accordance with the provisions herein, except to the extent such failure was due to Buyer’s willful breach of these provisions or applicable Law. 

(vi) Except as otherwise expressly set forth in this Agreement, Buyer will be responsible for the costs of any actions of
third parties with respect to loading/lifting procedures that are outside of the direct control of Seller, including vessels arriving at the Refinery late due to mechanical difficulties, weather conditions, ship owner directive or otherwise,
provided that Seller will use reasonable commercial efforts to minimize costs to Buyer relating to any such event or circumstance. 
 (vii) Buyer shall have the right to shift the Vessel from one Berth to another within its Refinery, or to anchorage. Any expenses incurred in such shifting or anchoring of a Vessel shall be for the
account of Buyer. Any expenses incurred where the shifting of the Vessel within the Refinery is directed or mandated by any Person (including the US Coast Guard, US Customs Service and Border Protection, the applicable port authority, or any other
Governmental Authority having proper jurisdiction over either the Vessel or its crew) other than Buyer shall be for the Vessel’s Account and shall be applied pursuant to the terms of the method of acquisition selected by the Parties in
accordance with Clause 5. 

  
 -39-









 (viii) The cost of all pumping of Oil or cargo from the Vessel to the
Storage Facilities shall be arranged by and be at the cost of the Vessel. All wharfage or dock fees incurred for delivery or receipt of cargo shall be borne by the Vessel, including all duties and other charges on the Vessel, including those
incurred by tugs and pilots, other port costs, such as harbor maintenance fees, and taxes on freight shall be for the Vessel’s account. Additionally, the Vessel shall pay any marine charge incurred by Buyer, including but not limited to,
booming of the Vessel during marine transfers of cargo when such booming is required by Law, and tie up and release of Vessels and oil spill fees. The allocation of such costs borne by the Vessel shall be applied pursuant to the terms of the method
of acquisition selected by the Parties in accordance with Clause 5. 
 (c) War Risk to Cargo & Vessel.
Seller reserves the right to refuse at any time, without being considered in breach of this Agreement: 
 (i) to
direct any Vessel to undertake or to complete a voyage to the Supply Port if such Vessel is required in the performance of such voyage: 
 (1) to transit, or to proceed to, or to remain in, waters so that the Vessel concerned (x) would be involved in a breach of any institute warranties (if applicable) or (y) would, in
Seller’s reasonable opinion, risk such Vessel’s safety; or 
 (2) to transit, or to proceed to, or to
remain in, waters where there is war or terrorist activity (de facto or de jure) or threat thereof. 
 (ii) prior
to the commencement of loading a Cargo acquired for Buyer, to direct any Vessel to undertake the voyage to the intended Supply Port if such Vessel is required in the performance of the terms of this Agreement to transit waters which, in
Seller’s reasonable opinion, would involve abnormal delay; or 
 (iii) to undertake any other activity in
furtherance of a voyage to the Supply Port which in the opinion of the Vessel’s master or owner could place the Vessel, its cargo or crew at risk. 
 However, at Buyer’s request, if Seller agrees to direct a Vessel to undertake or to complete the voyage despite the conditions referred to in subclauses (i), (ii) or (iii) above, then Buyer
shall reimburse Seller, in addition to the price payable under this Agreement, for costs incurred by Seller in respect of any additional insurance (Cargo or Vessel) premium and any other sums that Seller may be required to pay to the Vessel’s
owner including any sums in respect of any amounts deductible under such owner’s insurance and any other costs and/or expenses incurred by Seller. 

  
 -40-









 (d) The Parties shall additionally adhere to the Refinery Marine Terms set forth in Appendix
19. Subject to Clause 40(d), Appendix 19 contains terms in addition to those in Clauses 13, 14, 15 and 16 related to marine activities at the Refinery’s dock. 
  

	14.	SHIPPING AND LIGHTERING 


(a) Seller will only provide Shipping Services to Buyer in relation to the Supply of Oil pursuant to this Agreement. All shipping of Oil
will be performed on Vessels which are acceptable to Seller in its reasonable discretion in consideration of Seller’s vetting policy in effect at the time. For Cargoes shipped using the Supply Point Method all shipping considerations upstream
of the Supply Port are for the account of Seller. For Cargoes shipped using the Execution Method all Shipping Services will be provided under the following provisions: 

(i) As part of the acquisition process when freight is fixed for a Cargo, at the appropriate time the Parties shall
discuss the freight market and opportunities prior to fixing a Vessel with respect to a Cargo. 
 (ii) Seller
shall at its sole discretion accept or reject charterparties for use in the Vessel fixtures. The terms of the performing Vessel charterparty will be the basis for the freight rate, and any claims, costs, charges, including demurrage, which will be
passed through to Buyer. 
 (iii) In the event that the Seller wishes to use a Time Chartered Vessel or re-let a
Vessel it already has on charter then the Parties will agree on a rate for the Vessel based on the prevailing market rate using BITRA publications as a guide. Additionally, when a Time Chartered Vessel is used for shipping a Cargo, a demurrage rate
will be agreed between the Parties for the voyage. 
 (iv) The Parties acknowledge that freight costs can be
optimized and that the benefits will be shared between the Parties pursuant to Clause 5(g)(ii). For example, for a Cargo shipped using the Execution Method: 
 (1) If a reasonable demurrage claim with respect to a Vessel used to ship a Cargo is successfully negotiated down by Seller to a lower dollar amount then the savings will be shared in an appropriately
equitable manner; or 
 (2) If Seller identifies a co-load opportunity, then the freight savings in comparison to
the original freight option will be assessed using the relevant BITRA Worldscale assessment for the Loading Terminal and will be shared in an appropriately equitable manner, or if there are any losses as a result of such a co-load, such losses will
be shared in an appropriately equitable manner. 
 (b) Buyer anticipates a transit and alongside draft restriction of 40 feet
fresh water at the Supply Port. In order to reach this safe draft, the Mother Vessel may have to lighter at a recognized and approved safe offshore location. Seller shall engage and maintain contract(s) with a company or companies which engage in
and are approved and recognized for Lightering operations. Lightering operations shall be conducted in compliance with all applicable Law, and in strict compliance with Seller’s HSE policy. 

  
 -41-









 (c) The cost of the Lightering operation shall be applied pursuant to the terms of the
method of acquisition selected by the Parties in accordance with Clause 5. 
 (i) Under the Execution Method
of supply as set forth in Clause 5, all costs related to the Lightering operation shall be consistent with the terms as outlined under the Execution Method Clause and shall be performed under Seller’s Lightering contract(s). 

(ii) Under the Supply Point Method of supply as set forth in Clause 5, Lightering costs shall be as agreed to at the
appropriate times between the parties. 
 (d) Should the draft restriction as noted above not be the same as the anticipated
draft described in subclause (b) above, thus requiring Seller to lighter a higher volume from the Mother Vessel to allow for safe transit and berthing, the cost of the additional Lightering shall be for Buyer’s account. The cost of the
Lightering may consist of a per Barrel transfer fee, fuel surcharge fee, Mother Vessel and service Vessel demurrage, any additional costs related to additional waiting time for a Mother Vessel, and/or additional inspection and analysis costs for
Vessels at discharge. 
 (e) On or about the Delivery Commencement Date, Seller intends to enter into a term Lightering contract
(the “Initial TLA”) with a third party which will include, among other things, a minimum volume requirement. From time to time throughout the term of this Agreement, Seller may enter into one or more additional term Lightering
agreements (each, a “TLA”). Buyer shall by separate written instrument in its reasonable discretion consent to the terms of the Initial TLA and each TLA, each such consent to provide that Buyer shall be financially responsible for
any costs, fees or expenses incurred by Seller resulting from Seller not utilizing the minimum volume requirement under the Initial TLA or any subsequent TLA. 
 (f) Any partial Lightering or Lightering to extinction, at sea or at a place outside a designated port, shall be conducted in accordance with the latest Oil Companies International Marine Forum guidelines
for ship-to-ship transfers and with port authority approval, if applicable. 
 (g) Any Lightering Vessel utilized by either
Seller or Buyer shall be subject to the approval of the other Party. 
  

	15.	DETERMINATION OF QUANTITY AND QUALITY 

 (a) The quality and quantity of product Supplied by Seller to Buyer shall be determined by an Independent Inspector. The Independent Inspector’s determinations as to quantity, quality and line
displacements shall be binding on both Parties and shall form the basis for invoicing, except for cases of manifest error or fraud. The costs of any Independent Inspector engaged pursuant to the terms of this Agreement shall be [REDACTED]. If the
Parties are ever unable to agree on an Independent Inspector, Seller shall have the right, in good faith, to designate an entity as the Independent Inspector, provided such entity has been approved by US Customs. Each Party shall provide or cause to
be provided to the Independent Inspector all necessary rights of access. 

  
 -42-









 (b) Seller reserves the right to have, at Seller’s cost, a representative to attend the
Supply and to witness all aspects of the measurement of the Oil outlined below, including, but not limited to, witnessing of shore tank gauging, meter setting and any analysis. Buyer shall arrange necessary clearance for Seller’s representative
to gain access to all areas necessary to conduct such witnessing. Such clearance shall not be unreasonably denied. 
 (c) The
quantity determined will reflect full deduction for sediment and water, measured in accordance with the latest API/ASTM standards and methods in effect at the time of Supply, as determined from a representative sample drawn by an automatic in-line
sampler. In the event that an automatic in-line sampler is not available, malfunctions during the transfer, the Independent Inspector cannot verify the integrity of the sampler or the sampler container before or after Supply, or the Independent
Inspector determines that the samples drawn by such sampler are not representative of the product on board the Vessel on arrival at the Supply Port (including, but not limited to, making a comparison with total of Vessel’s arrival composite
sample analysis results and Vessel’s arrival freewater), then sediment and water deduction shall be determined from Vessel’s arrival volumetrically correct composite sample and Vessel’s arrival free water. 

(d) The measurement of the quantity of Oil shall be carried out at the Supply Port in accordance with the latest API standards in effect
at the time of Supply. The quantity of Oil shall be determined by proven meters in the immediate vicinity of the Berth, at the Supply Port. If meters are unavailable, not proven, not functioning correctly, or determined by the Independent Inspector
to be inaccurate or not to represent the volume Supplied by the Vessel or the line displacement as detailed below is not performed, then the outturn quantity shall be based on static shore tank measurements at the Supply Port, with receiving shore
tanks in conditions recommended in API for determining accurate measurement, and meeting the criteria specified below. If the shore tanks(s) are active, do not meet the criteria below, or the Independent Inspector cannot verify the shore tank
measurements prior to or after Supply, or the Independent Inspector determines that these shore tank measurements are inaccurate or are not representative of the volume Supplied by the Vessel, or the receiving tanks are located at a location other
than the Storage Facilities where the Vessel is berthed, or Seller’s representative is unable to witness any aspect of the measurement, then the Vessel’s arrival figure, less any remaining on board quantities (“ROB”),
adjusted by the Vessel’s load experience factor (“LVEF”) as calculated by the Independent Inspector, shall be used to determine the Supplied quantity. 
 (e) In the event that the Supplied quantity is to be based on shore tank measurements, then all shore tanks taking Supply shall be static and shall contain sufficient Oil, prior to Supply, to ensure that
the floating roofs are afloat and clear of the “critical zone” by a minimum of 6 inches. 
 (f) In the event that the
Supplied quantity is to be based on shore tank measurements, or if meters are to be used, but are not located in the immediate vicinity of the Berth, then, at the commencement of Supply, after opening shore tank gauges have been established, the
Independent Inspector shall monitor the performance of a line displacement consisting of the Vessel pumping Oil to the furthest shore tank taking Supply. The line displacement is to be 

  
 -43-









 
carried out in accordance with API guidelines. The Independent Inspector’s conclusions regarding the results of the line displacement shall be binding on both Parties, except for cases of
manifest error or fraud, and the final shore outturn volume shall, if the results of the line displacement are found to be outside the “precision of measurement” limits detailed in API, be credited to the outturn, as necessary. In cases
when the line is found to be slack, the entire difference between the volume that the shore tank receives and the volume that the vessel Supplies shall be credited to the final outturn volume. 

(g) The Refinery shall confirm the line displacement volumes before the Supply resumes. The Refinery personnel present at Supply are
required to have the necessary authority to agree to all measurements carried out in relation to the line displacement. Any delays incurred while in dispute after the first line displacement, including the carrying out of a second displacement at
Buyer’s option, and until Supply has resumed, are for Buyer’s account. 
  

	16.	LAYTIME AND DEMURRAGE 


Buyer has two methods of requesting Seller to provide a Cargo to meet Buyer’s Requirement, the Execution Method and the Supply Point
Method. 
 (a) As used herein, “demurrage” means the time in excess of the laytime allowed to Buyer calculated
as per this Clause 16 and/or the agreed damages payable by Buyer to Seller for the excess time for Time Chartered Vessels as will be agreed upon pursuant to Clause 14(a)(iii). 
 (b) For the Execution Method, Buyer’s liability for demurrage will be directly to the ship-owner through Seller. Seller shall negotiate in a commercially reasonable manner directly with the owner of
the Vessel on behalf of the Parties. The cost of demurrage shall be estimated as per Clause 12 and shall form a component of the Cargo Final Price. Any additional or rebated demurrage different from that estimate shall be accrued to the Petty
Cash Bank as described in Clause 12. The final agreed settlement of demurrage with the owner shall be used to determine any addition or deduction from the Petty Cash Bank; provided that if Seller negotiates the owner’s claim so that the
total liability is reduced, the amount apportioned to the Petty Cash Bank shall be [REDACTED]% of such liability reduction. 

(c) For the Supply Point Method, Buyer’s liability for demurrage will be directly to Seller through the following method:

 (i) Laytime allowed to Buyer for Seller to make Supply of the Cargo shall be [REDACTED] hours, unless the
Cargo is a Part Cargo. In the event the Cargo is a Part Cargo, the laytime shall be pro rata portion of the total laytime allowed for a full Cargo in accordance with this Clause 16. The laytime allowed under this Agreement shall include Sundays and
holidays and nighttime, unless working on Sundays, holidays or during night is prohibited by the Laws in force at the place of Supply. 
 (ii) Laytime shall not commence until a valid NOR is tendered by the master or owner of the Vessel to Buyer or the owner or operator of the Refinery or any of their representatives (as the case may be)
upon arrival at the customary anchorage or the place where the Vessel is ordered to wait for Supply, whichever is applicable. 

  
 -44-









 (iii) For Vessel tendering NOR in accordance with this Clause 16 within the
[REDACTED] as detailed in Clause 6, laytime shall commence at the earlier of (1) [REDACTED] or (2) when the Vessel is securely moored at the Berth. 

(iv) If Vessel tenders NOR outside the [REDACTED], the commencement of laytime shall be either: 

(1) For a Vessel tendering NOR prior to the [REDACTED]; laytime shall commence at the earlier of (A) [REDACTED] or
(B) when the Vessel is securely moored at the Berth, or 
 (2) For a Vessel tendering NOR after [REDACTED],
and without prejudice to Buyer’s rights under this Agreement laytime shall commence when the Vessel is securely moored at the Berth, and Buyer shall make best efforts to berth the Vessel as soon as possible after arrival 

(v) The following shall not count as laytime, or as demurrage if the Vessel is on demurrage: 

(1) [REDACTED] 
 (2) [REDACTED] 
 (3) [REDACTED] 

(4) [REDACTED] 
 (vi) Seller warrants that all Vessels shall be capable of Cargo transfer within [REDACTED] or can maintain an average backpressure of [REDACTED] at the Vessel’s manifold provided the Storage
Facilities permit. Time lost as a result of Vessel being unable to transfer the Cargo as warranted above shall be adjusted as per the ASDEM pumping performance calculation. 

(vii) In the event of a Force Majeure, any increase in the expense of laytime or demurrage, as applicable, shall be borne
equally by the Parties. 
 (viii) Laytime shall cease upon Completion of Supply. 

(ix) If the laytime is exceeded, Buyer shall, subject to the provisions of this Clause 16, pay demurrage to Seller in
respect of the excess time. In the event that there is any delay in the process of Supply at the Supply Port for any reason whatsoever, the rights of Seller against Buyer in respect of such delay, shall be limited to a claim for demurrage in
accordance with the provisions of this Clause 16. 
 (x) The demurrage to be paid shall be calculated at the
agreed demurrage rate per day pro rata for part of a day. If no demurrage rate is agreed to between the Parties, the demurrage rate shall be: 
 (1) the “Average Freight Assessment Rate” of Worldscale appropriate to the size of the Vessel and current on the date of Completion of Supply, or 

  
 -45-









 (2) the market rate for the appropriate/applicable size of Vessel on the
date of Completion of Supply as shall be assessed by a mutually agreed independent and reputable broker. 
 (xi)
Buyer’s obligation to pay demurrage shall be absolute and not subject to qualification by the provisions of Clause 18. In no event shall Buyer be liable for a demurrage claim if such claim, supported by appropriate documentation, is not
received by Buyer in writing within [REDACTED] of Completion of Supply. 
  

	17.	UNSCHEDULED DISRUPTION TO NORMAL REFINERY OPERATIONS 

 Unscheduled downtime at the Refinery due to an event of Force Majeure shall be handled in accordance with Clause 18. During any period of unscheduled downtime not caused by an event of Force Majeure,
Buyer shall make reasonable attempts to take Delivery of Oil under this Agreement. Should unscheduled downtime not caused by an event of Force Majeure exceed [REDACTED], Buyer is entitled to request the rescheduling of future Cargoes. However,
Seller shall not be required to reschedule or delay any Cargo that has been accepted by Buyer for Supply within a [REDACTED] period immediately following the date Buyer gives Seller notice of unscheduled downtime. Further, Buyer shall not make any
such rescheduling request primarily for the purposes of commercial gain. 
 The Parties agree to take reasonable actions in
order to minimize any losses to Buyer for Cargoes already committed to prior to any such unscheduled downtime at the Refinery not caused by an event of Force Majeure. 
  

	18.	FORCE MAJEURE 

 (a)
Neither Seller nor Buyer shall be responsible for any failure to fulfill their respective obligations, in whole or in part, under this Agreement if fulfillment has been prevented or curtailed by Force Majeure, and the affected Party shall be
relieved of liability for failing to perform, wholly or in part, from the inception of such event of Force Majeure and during the continuance thereof. The foregoing right shall not be construed to limit or restrict either Party’s right to
invoke any other subsequent Force Majeure event (even if the other, subsequent Force Majeure event relates to events or circumstances similar or identical to the events or circumstances underlying the subject Force Majeure event) or other Force
Majeure event which occurs during all or any portion of the subject Force Majeure event. For purposes hereof, “Force Majeure” means any circumstances whatsoever that are beyond the reasonable control of Seller or Buyer, as the case
may be, including without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, but not limited to: 
 (i) compliance
with any order, demand or request of any Governmental Authority; 
 (ii) any strike, lockout or labor dispute;


  
 -46-









 (iii) adverse weather, perils of the sea, or embargoes; 

(iv) fires, earthquakes, lightning, floods, explosions, storms, and other acts of natural calamity or acts of God;

 (v) accidents at, closing of, or restrictions upon the use of mooring facilities, docks, ports, pipelines,
harbors or other navigational or transportation mechanisms; 
 (vi) disruptions, breakdowns, explosions or
accidents which may have a materially adverse effect on storage facilities, refineries, Storage Facilities, Vessels, lightering equipment or other facilities; and 

(vii) acts of war, hostilities (whether declared or undeclared) civil commotion, blockades, terrorism, sabotage or acts of
the public enemy; 
 provided, however, that nothing contained herein shall relieve either Party of any of its obligations to make
payments due to the other Party under this Agreement, which obligations are absolute. 
 (b) The Party seeking relief under
(a) of this Clause 18 (the “Affected Party”) shall advise the other Party in writing as soon as practicable of the circumstances causing the failure to fulfill its obligations and shall thereafter provide such information as is
available regarding the progress and possible cessation of those circumstances, including, to the extent feasible, the details and the expected duration of the Force Majeure event and the volume of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock affected. The Affected
Party shall notify the other Party when the Force Majeure event is terminated. Subject to the provisions of Clause 17, performance of obligations under this Agreement shall be resumed as soon as reasonably possible after such circumstances have
ceased. 
 (c) The Affected Party shall use all reasonable efforts to, and the other Party shall use all reasonable efforts to
assist the Affected Party in its efforts to, (i) attempt to prevent a Force Majeure and (ii) mitigate the effects of any Force Majeure. To the extent Seller is the Affected Party, mitigation efforts with respect to Clause 18(c)(ii) may
[REDACTED]. 
 (d) Notwithstanding subclause (a) above the Affected Party shall [REDACTED]. 

(e) Notwithstanding subclause (a) above, but subject to Clause 16(c)(vii), Buyer shall [REDACTED]. 

(f) In the event that either Party sends a proper notice of an event of Force Majeure and such event of Force Majeure is not remedied
within 120 days from the date that notice of such event is given, and so long as such event is continuing, the Party receiving the notice of Force Majeure may terminate this Agreement by written notice to the Party that sent the notice of Force
Majeure, and neither Party shall have any further liability to the other in respect of this Agreement except for the rights and remedies previously accrued under this Agreement. 

  
 -47-










	19.	CREDIT CONDITIONS 

 (a)
Guaranties. On the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provide a parent guaranty from Buyer’s Guarantor to Seller in an amount, for a term, and in a format acceptable to Seller. Additionally, prior to any assignment or transfer of
any rights or obligations of Buyer under this Agreement, Buyer shall provide to Seller its written guaranty of all of Buyer’s obligations, which guaranty shall be in an amount, for a term, and in a format acceptable to Seller. Buyer shall
insure that any and all guaranties required under this Clause 19 shall continue to be in full force and effect throughout the term of this Agreement. 
 (b) Credit Line. 
 (i) Seller has agreed to [REDACTED].

 (ii) Buyer shall not at any time [REDACTED]. 

(1) any and all amounts [REDACTED], plus 

(2) the [REDACTED], plus 
 (3) [REDACTED], plus 
 (4) [REDACTED], plus 

(5) [REDACTED], plus 
 (6) [REDACTED], plus 
 (7) [REDACTED]. 

(iii) Seller shall endeavor to [REDACTED]. 

(iv) If at any time it appears that the [REDACTED]. 

(v) Any of the following shall constitute “Additional Acceptable Security”: 

(1) An additional federal funds wire transfer of USD to pay down amounts owed to Seller, 

(2) A Standby Letter of Credit in the form attached hereto as Appendix 20 issued by a Qualified Institution. 

(vi) Subject to the Parties’ mutual agreement, Seller may provide an additional line of credit to Buyer which would
be above the PBF Line of Credit, on such terms, including payment of a fee, as mutually agreed by the Parties. Seller has no obligations to provide such additional line of credit. 

(c) Financial Covenants. At all times Buyer shall ensure that the following financial covenants shall be satisfied. Buyer shall
provide consolidated financial statements with respect to its ultimate parent company which shall also be a guarantor under this Agreement. Each of these financial covenants set forth herein shall be based on the consolidated financial information
of such ultimate parent company guarantor and all of its subsidiaries. 
 (i) Minimum Shareholder’s Equity,
excluding goodwill and intangibles, shall be greater than $150,000,000 as measured quarterly. 
 (ii) The ratio
of Long-term Debt (excluding bank revolving working capital debt) to Shareholders Equity (excluding goodwill and intangibles) shall be less than 1 to 1 as measured quarterly. 

(iii) At all times on or after the completion of the first 4 quarters of operation under this Agreement, the sum of
(1) the rolling 4 quarter Consolidated Average EBITDA plus (2) cash on hand shall be greater than $80,000,000. 

Buyer’s current ultimate parent company guarantor is Buyer’s Guarantor, and Buyer covenants that there shall be no change to its
ultimate parent company unless the new ultimate parent company executes a parent company guaranty of Buyer’s obligations under this Agreement in substantially the form of the current ultimate parent company’s guaranty, and the new ultimate
parent company’s consolidated financials will satisfy the above described financial covenants. 
 All accounting terms not
specifically or completely defined herein shall be construed in conformity with, and all financial data (including financial ratios and other financial calculations) required to be submitted pursuant to this Agreement shall be prepared in conformity
with, GAAP applied on a consistent basis, as in effect from time to time, applied in a manner consistent with that used in preparing audited financial statements. If at any time any change in GAAP would affect the computation of any financial ratio
or requirement set forth in this Agreement, and either Buyer or Seller shall so request, the Parties shall negotiate in good faith to amend such ratio or requirement to preserve the original intent thereof in light of such change in GAAP;
provided, that, until so amended (1) such ratio or requirement shall continue to be computed in accordance with GAAP prior to such change therein and (2) Buyer shall provide to Seller financial statements and other documents
required under this Agreement or as reasonably requested hereunder setting forth a reconciliation between calculations of such ratio or requirement made before and after giving effect to such change in GAAP. 

  
 -48-









 (d) Payment Direction Agreement. 

(i) [REDACTED]. 
 (ii) Buyer agrees to [REDACTED]. 
 (e) Reporting. Buyer shall provide or
cause to be provided to Seller: 
 (i) The Guarantors’ consolidated unaudited monthly, and quarterly
financial statements within 30 days and 60 days, respectively, after the end of such period; provided that the 60-day period shall be equal to the lesser of (1) 60 days or (2) the number of days following the end of the applicable period
after which such financial statements are required to be reported or delivered under applicable Law. 
 (ii) The
Guarantors’ consolidated audited annual financial statements within 120 days of the fiscal year end of the Guarantors. 
 (iii) The Refinery Subsidiaries’ consolidated unaudited monthly, and quarterly financial statements within 30 days and 60 days, respectively, after the end of such period; provided that the 60-day
period shall be equal to the lesser of (1) 60 days or (2) the number of days following the end of the applicable period after which such financial statements are required to be reported or delivered under applicable Law. 

(iv) A simultaneous copy of all notices that are provided to Buyer’s lenders, including: 

(1) Loan covenant compliance certificates; 

(2) Financial forecasts and bank line availability; and 

(3) Certificates of good standing. 
 (f) Intercreditor Agreement(s). At all times Buyer shall ensure that the Intercreditor Agreement(s) required pursuant to Clause 7(b) are in place and in full force and effect. 

(g) TVM Payment. 
 (i) “TVM Payment” means for each Production Week, [REDACTED]: 
 TVM Payment = [REDACTED] 
 (1) “IR” means
[REDACTED]. 
 (2) “WD” means [REDACTED]. 

(3) “OIFIC” means the [REDACTED]. 

(4) “UP” means [REDACTED]. 

(ii) For each Production Week, Seller will calculate the TVM Payment payable by Buyer to Seller to compensate Seller for
the TVM. Seller will provide written notice to Buyer by 9:00 a.m. one Business Day prior to the TVM Payment Date attributable to such Production Week (the “TVM Statement Delivery Date”). To the extent certain inputs used in
calculating the TVM Payment are not yet fully ascertained or final as of the end of the day before the TVM Statement Delivery Date, Seller shall make a reasonable approximation thereof using the best available information. The TVM Payment is subject
to true-up upon the fully ascertained and final information becoming available and such true-up shall be applied as an adjustment to the amount owed by Buyer in the TVM Payment following such true-up. 

(iii) The TVM Payment will be paid by Buyer by wire transfer prior to 3:00 p.m. on the TVM Payment Date attributable to
such Production Week. 
 (iv) To the extent of any dispute with respect to a TVM Payment, Buyer shall pay any
undisputed amounts during the pending resolutions of any such disputed amounts. 
 (h) True Sale; Security
Agreement. 
 (i) Seller and Buyer intend that the sales and purchases of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock pursuant to
this Agreement shall be treated as a true sale in accordance with the terms of this Agreement. Notwithstanding the foregoing, however, if title to any Oil or Indigenous Feedstock is recharacterized as having remained with or been transferred to
Buyer other than as provided by the terms of this Agreement, or if the transaction evidenced by this Agreement is deemed to be a financing and not a true sale or determined to create, in substance, a security interest, Seller and Buyer agree that
such Oil and/or Indigenous Feedstock are and shall be subject to the lien and security interest granted by Buyer to Seller pursuant to subclause (ii) below and that Seller shall have the rights and remedies set forth in subclause
(iii) below. 

  
 -49-









 (ii) As security for the payment of the obligations of Buyer under and in connection with
this Agreement [REDACTED], together with any increases, extensions, and rearrangements of such obligations under any amendments, supplements, and other modifications hereof or thereof, Buyer hereby grants to Seller a first priority security interest
in all of Buyer’s present and future right, title and interest in and to (1) the Oil and Indigenous Feedstock; (2) all payments under any insurance, indemnity, warranty, or guaranty of or for the foregoing; and (3) all proceeds
of any of the foregoing. In connection with the foregoing, Buyer authorizes Seller to file such financing statements pursuant to the UCC as Seller deems necessary to perfect the foregoing interest. Buyer shall not grant or permit any other security
interest in any of the foregoing collateral. 
 (iii) In the event of such re-characterization, upon any Event of Default,
Seller may exercise all of the rights and remedies of a secured party under the UCC, whether or not the UCC applies to the affected collateral. Such remedies shall be cumulative with all other remedies of Seller hereunder and available at law or
equity, and no delay in enforcing the foregoing shall act as a waiver of Seller’s rights hereunder or thereunder. 
 (i)
Security Interest in Refined Products Sales Agreement. As security for the prompt and complete payment and performance in full of all obligations of Buyer to Seller hereunder, Buyer hereby grants to Seller a security interest in all of
Buyer’s right, title and interest in, to and under the following, in each case, whether now owned or existing or hereafter acquired or arising and wherever located: 

(i) All sales agreements with Off-Takers, for the Refined Products, including the MSCG Sales Agreement; 

(ii) The proceeds of Buyer’s sale of Refined Products from the Refinery, which includes all receivables of Buyer from
Off-Takers including MSCG; and 
 (iii) All rights of Buyer to guaranties delivered to Buyer by parent companies
of Off-Takers covering the payments due under sales agreements with such Off-Takers; and 
 (iv) All proceeds,
products, accessions, additions, substitutions, replacements, rents and profits of or in respect of any or all of the foregoing. 
 In connection with the foregoing, Buyer authorizes Seller to file such financing statements pursuant to the UCC as Seller deems necessary to perfect the foregoing interest. Buyer shall not grant or permit
any other security interest in any of the foregoing collateral. 
  

	20.	TAXES, DUTIES AND CHARGES 


(a) Ordinary agency fees, towage, pilotage and similar port charges, port duties and other taxes against the Vessel at the Supply Port,
shall be paid by Seller. 
 (b) Buyer shall be the importer of record and shall comply with all applicable Laws governing said
importation, procure all necessary licenses and permissions, and shall timely pay or cause to be timely paid all federal, state and local duties, taxes, imposts and customs fees 

  
 -50-









 
related to the transportation and/or importation of all Oil, including the Taxes imposed by Section 4081 and the registration and bonding requirements imposed by Section 4101 of the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”). In addition, Buyer shall comply with the information and reporting requirements imposed by Section 4102 of the Code with respect to allowing the inspection of records by
state and local Tax officers. Seller shall provide Buyer with sufficient information upon request to the extent its own records are inadequate to timely facilitate such importation and reporting. 

(c) Each Party shall be solely responsible for its own federal and state income taxes. Buyer shall be liable for and shall pay (and shall
indemnify and hold harmless Seller against) all Taxes, including sales, transfer, use, stamp, documentary, filing, recording, or similar fees or taxes or governmental charges as levied by any Governmental Authority (including any interest and
penalties) that are attributable to the transactions provided for herein. 
  

	21.	INSURANCE 

 (a)
Insurance Required for Buyer. Buyer shall, at its sole expense, carry and maintain in full force and effect throughout the term of this Agreement insurance coverages, with insurance companies rated not less than A-, IX by A.M. Best or
otherwise reasonably satisfactory to Seller, of the following types and amounts: 
 (i) Workers compensation
coverage in compliance with the Law of the states having jurisdiction over each employee and employer’s liability coverage in a minimum amount of $[REDACTED] per accident. 

(ii) Automobile liability coverage in a minimum amount of $[REDACTED]. 

(iii) Commercial general liability insurance and umbrella or excess liability insurance covering all of Buyer’s
operations, including bodily injury, property damage and contractual liability with a minimum limit of $[REDACTED] per occurrence. 
 (iv) Pollution liability coverage for “sudden and accidental pollution” liability with a minimum limit of $[REDACTED] per occurrence. 

(v) All risk” insurance covering the Refinery including full replacement cost of any Oil owned by Seller or Delivered
to Seller. 
 (b) Seller’s Insurance. Seller shall, at its sole expense, carry and maintain in full force and effect
throughout the term of this Agreement insurance coverages, with insurance companies rated not less than A-, IX by A.M. Best or otherwise reasonably satisfactory to Buyer, of the following types and amounts: 

(i) Pollution liability coverage for “sudden and accidental pollution” liability with a minimum limit of
$[REDACTED] per occurrence. 
 (ii) All risk insurance covering full replacement cost of any Oil owned by Seller
while stored in the Storage Facilities. 

  
 -51-









 (iii) Cargo insurance on Oil while on board sea going vessels at [REDACTED]%
of their full CIF value based on Institute Cargo Clauses (A) “All Risks.” 
 (c) Additional Insurance
Requirements. 
 (i) Seller will ensure that Vessels carry the liability and pollution insurance required by
all applicable Laws. 
 (ii) Seller will only charter Vessels with an IACS Classification and such Vessel is to
maintain such class during its full charter period. All Vessels nominated to load or discharge at the Supply Port shall have a valid and full entry with an International Group Associations P&I Club thus carrying a current limit of $[REDACTED]
for pollution liabilities and related clean up costs. 
 (iii) The Parties shall cause their respective insurance
carriers to furnish to the other Party insurance certificates, in a form and from a party reasonably satisfactory to the other Party, evidencing the existence of the coverages and endorsements required. The certificates shall specify that no
insurance shall be canceled or materially changed during the term of this Agreement unless the other Party is given 30 days notice prior to cancellation or prior to a material change becoming effective. Each Party shall promptly provide the other
Party with renewal certificates. 
 (iv) Seller shall be named as an “additional insured as its interests
may appear” on each of Buyer’s insurance policies described in subclause (a) above. 
 (v) The
insurance policies described in subclauses (a) and (b) above shall include an endorsement that the underwriters waive all rights of subrogation against the other Party, and shall be primary and non-contributory with respect to any
insurance or self-insurance that is maintained by the other Party. 
 (vi) Each Party shall notify the other
Party if any self-insured retentions or deductibles exist in the foregoing policies, and all self-insured retentions or deductibles that exist in the foregoing policies shall be the sole responsibility of the Party responsible for providing such
policy. 
 (vii) The mere purchase and existence of insurance does not reduce or release either Party from any
Liability incurred or assumed under this Agreement. 
  

	22.	REPRESENTATIONS, WARRANTIES AND COVENANTS 

 (a) Mutual Representations and Warranties. Buyer and Seller each represents and warrants to the other as of the Effective Date, the Delivery Commencement Date and as of each Delivery that:

 (i) There are no suits, proceedings, judgments, ruling or orders pending, or to its Knowledge, threatened, by
or before any court or any Governmental Authority that materially and adversely affect its ability to perform, or the rights of the other Party, under this Agreement. 

  
 -52-









 (ii) It is duly organized, validly existing and in good standing under the
Laws of the jurisdiction of its formation, and it has the legal right, power and authority and is qualified to conduct its business and perform its obligations hereunder. 

(iii) The making and performance by it of this Agreement is within its powers and has been duly authorized by all
necessary action on its part. 
 (iv) This Agreement constitutes a legal, valid and binding act and obligation of
it, enforceable in accordance with its terms, subject to bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization and other Laws affecting creditor’s rights generally. 
 (v) No Event of Default under Clause 24 with respect to it or, to its Knowledge, event, which with notice and or a lapse of time would constitute such an Event of Default, has occurred and is
continuing, and no such event or circumstance would occur as a result of its entering into or performing its obligations under this Agreement. 
 (vi) It is an “Eligible Contract Participant” as defined in Section 1a(12) of the Commodity Exchange Act, as amended. 

(vii) It is a “forward contract merchant,” as defined in Section 101(26) of the Bankruptcy Code, in respect
of this Agreement and each sale of Oil hereunder, and each sale of Oil hereunder is a forward contract for purposes of the Bankruptcy Code. 
 (viii) It is a “master netting agreement participant,” as defined in Section 101(38B) of the Bankruptcy Code, in respect of this Agreement and each sale of Oil hereunder, and each sale of
Oil hereunder is a master netting agreement for purposes of the Bankruptcy Code. 
 (ix) Neither it nor any of
its Affiliates has been contacted by or negotiated with any finder, broker or other intermediary in connection with the sale of Oil hereunder who is entitled to any compensation with respect thereto. 

(x) All governmental and other authorizations, approvals, consents, notices and filings that are required to have been
obtained or submitted by it with respect to this Agreement and its performance hereunder and the consummation by it of the transactions contemplated hereby have been obtained or submitted and are in full force and effect, and all conditions of any
such authorizations, approvals, consents, notices and filings have been complied with. 
 (xi) The execution,
delivery and performance of this Agreement do not violate or conflict with (a) any Law applicable to it, (b) any provision of its constitutional documents, (c) any order or judgment of any court or Governmental Authority applicable to
it or any of its assets or (d) any contractual restriction binding on or affecting it or any of its assets, except to the extent such conflict or violation has not and could not be reasonably expected to cause a Material Adverse Change.


  
 -53-









 (xii) It possesses all necessary permits, authorizations, registrations and
licenses required to perform its obligations hereunder and to consummate the transactions contemplated hereby, except to the extent such conflict or violation has not and could not be reasonably expected to cause a Material Adverse Change.

 (xiii) It is not bound by any other agreement that would preclude its execution, delivery, or performance of
this Agreement. 
 (b) Representations of Buyer. Buyer represents and warrants to Seller as of the Delivery Commencement
Date and as of each Delivery, and to its Knowledge, as of the Effective Date, that: 
 (i) The Storage Facilities
are structurally sound and safe and Buyer does not Know, and has no reason to Know, of any leaks in the storage tanks, pipelines, or other equipment or of any other situation at the Storage Facilities which could cause environmental danger or be
detrimental to the environment or to Seller’s interests. 
 (ii) The Storage Facilities are being maintained
and operated in accordance with standard industry practices, all practices, methods, acts, standards and criteria employed and in force at the Refinery and all Environmental Laws and all other applicable Laws. Buyer specifically warrants that the
Storage Facilities will operate in compliance with the oil spill response plan as may be required under the foregoing Laws. 
 (iii) Buyer has all operational and health and safety manuals relevant to the maintenance and operation of the Storage Facilities in compliance with standard industry practices and that all relevant
personnel responsible for the maintenance and operation of the Storage Facilities are, and at all times during the term of this Agreement will be, familiar with the procedures set forth in such manuals. Buyer further represents all personnel
responsible for the maintenance and operation of the Storage Facilities are, and at all times during the term of this Agreement will be, routinely trained on health and safety and disaster procedures in accordance with standard industry practices.

 (iv) Except as permitted pursuant to the Intercreditor Agreement(s), there are no Liens on the Storage
Facilities or any property that is necessary for Buyer’s performance of this Agreement. 
 (c) Mutual Covenants.

 (i) Each Party shall, in the performance of its duties under this Agreement, comply in all material respects
with all Laws, including all Environmental Laws. Buyer and Seller each shall maintain the records required to be maintained by Environmental Law and shall make such records available to the other upon their request. Buyer and Seller each shall also
immediately notify the other of any violation 

  
 -54-









 
or alleged violation with respect to the Oil sold or purchased under this Agreement, and, upon request shall provide the other with all evidence of environmental inspections or audits by any
Governmental Authority with respect to such Oil. 
 (ii) All reports or documents rendered by Buyer or Seller to
the other shall, to the best of its knowledge and belief, accurately and completely reflect the facts about the activities and transactions to which they relate. Buyer and Seller each promptly shall notify the other if at any time it has reason to
believe that the records or documents previously furnished by such Party are no longer are accurate or complete. 

(iii) During the first full year of the term of this Agreement neither Party shall, without the prior written consent of
the other Party, suffer or permit any change in more than 50% of the direct or indirect ownership of such Party, (2) sell all or substantially all of its assets, or (3) have one or more subsidiaries sell all or substantially all of their
assets, if such sale would have a material effect on the ownership or operation of the Refinery. After the first full year of the Term, if either Party shall suffer or permit any change in more than 50% of the direct or indirect ownership of such
Party, (2) sell all or substantially all of its assets, or (3) have one or more subsidiaries sell all or substantially all of their assets and such sale could have a material effect on the ownership or operation of the Refinery, then the
other Party shall have the option to terminate this Agreement on the effective date of any such transaction. The Party entering into the transaction shall give notice to the other Party within five (5) Business Days of entering into definitive
agreements for the transaction, which notice shall also be no less than 60 days prior to the anticipated effective date of the transaction. 
 (d) Covenants of Buyer. 
 (i) From and after the Delivery
Commencement Date, Buyer shall (1) maintain all material licenses, permits and franchises required by any Governmental Authority, (2) cause or ensure that any material subsidiary of Buyer’s Guarantor maintains and renews, all material
licenses, permits and franchises required by any Governmental Authority. 
 (ii) Buyer shall ensure that no Lien,
through Buyer’s or its Affiliate’s action or inaction, shall attach to Oil owned by Seller. 
 (iii)
Prior to the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provide Seller with a copy of the current commitment for title insurance and on the Delivery Commencement Date a copy of a bring down certificate issued to Buyer in each case in form and substance
reasonably satisfactory to Seller and reflecting an obligation of an acceptable title insurance company to issue a title insurance policy evidencing that (i) the use and operation of the Refinery in the manner contemplated herein does not
violate in any material respect any instrument of record or agreement affecting the Refinery, and (ii) Buyer holds good and marketable title to the Refinery, free and clear of all Liens, except for those Liens governed by the respective
Intercreditor Agreement(s). 

  
 -55-









 (iv) As soon as reasonably practicable after the Effective Date and prior to
the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provide or cause Valero and its affiliates to provide Seller with full information with regard to all third party contracts (including the Oil supply and the vessel and transportation contracts), that
Seller determines are to be assigned to, assumed by or conveyed to Seller in connection with this Agreement, which information shall include copies of relevant contracts and agreements and full descriptions of related business terms and
arrangements. Buyer shall ensure that all such contracts shall be assigned to Seller on the Delivery Commencement Date pursuant to one or more assignments in form and substance reasonably acceptable to Seller. 

(e) HSE Covenants of Buyer. Buyer represents and warrants as of the Delivery Commencement Date, and covenants throughout the term
of this Agreement that: 
 (i) Buyer is and shall be in material compliance with Environmental Law applicable to
operations at the Refinery and has not received any formal notification that it is not presently so in compliance. 
 (ii) The Refinery is and shall remain structurally sound and safe, and Buyer does not Know of any leaks in the storage tanks, pipelines or other equipment or of any other situation at the Refinery that
could cause significant environmental danger, generate significant environmental Liabilities or have a significant detrimental impact on the environment or to Seller’s interests. 

(iii) Buyer shall maintain and operate the Refinery in good serviceable condition and in a manner that materially complies
with reasonable and prudent industry standards adopted and used in petroleum refineries and with all Laws, including all Environmental Law. 
 (iv) Buyer shall maintain and operate the Refinery in accordance with HSE Standards acceptable to Seller, using API (including API-653), Coast Guard, ISGOTT and other industry standards as a guide.

 (v) Buyer is and shall remain in material compliance with all Laws regarding worker occupational safety and
training. 
 (vi) Buyer is and shall remain in material compliance with all Laws relating to marine oil
pollution. 
 (vii) All tanks used for the storage and throughput of Seller’s Oil are and shall continue to
be above ground. 
 (viii) Buyer promptly will provide Seller with notice of any changes to the representations
and covenants in this subclause (e). 
 (ix) Upon request from Seller, Buyer promptly will provide Seller
with copies of all of Buyer’s non-privileged environmental auditing materials that Buyer has in its possession or control with respect to the Refinery. 

  
 -56-









 (x) In the event of any Oil, Feedstock, Refined Products or Hazardous
Substances spill or discharge reportable under Law, or other environmental pollution occurring at the Refinery or the Storage Facilities or in a location that could impact the storage, transfer, delivery, transportation or receipt of Oil or
Indigenous Feedstock, Buyer shall take all steps (if any) required under Law, including undertaking measures to prevent or mitigate resulting pollution damage. Even if not required by Law, Buyer nevertheless may determine to undertake such measures
to prevent or mitigate pollution damage as it deems appropriate or necessary or is required by any Governmental Authority. Buyer shall notify Seller as soon as practicable of any such operations, and shall perform such operations in accordance with
applicable plans and any other Law or National Contingency Plan, or as may be directed by the US Coast Guard or any other Governmental Authority. 
 (xi) In the event that a Party incurs costs to clean up or contain a spill or discharge or to prevent or mitigate resulting pollution damage, such Party reserves any rights provided by Law to recover such
costs from the other Party, as well as any third party. In the event a third party is legally liable for such costs and expenses, each Party shall cooperate with the other Party for the purpose of obtaining reimbursement. Each Party shall also
cooperate with the other Party for the purpose of obtaining reimbursement from any other applicable entity or source under Law. 
  

	23.	AUDITING AND INSPECTION RIGHTS 

 (a) Auditing. Each Party shall keep and maintain true and correct books, records, files, and accounts of all information reasonably related to the transactions contemplated by this Agreement,
including all measurement and test results, all information used to determine price adjustments, and calculate invoices, and all invoices, statements, and payment records. Each Party and its duly authorized representatives shall have the right to
inspect or audit such other Party’s records at any reasonable time or times during the term of this Agreement or within 3 years after the termination of this Agreement. 
 (b) Inspection Rights. Prior to the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provide Seller or Seller’s designated agents sufficient access to the Refinery for Seller to update its previously
completed health, safety and environmental vetting survey (the “HSE Diligence”). During the term of this Agreement, Seller shall have the right, during Buyer’s normal business hours and after reasonable advance notice to Buyer
so as not to disrupt Buyer’s operations: to make periodic operational and HSE inspections of the Refinery and to conduct physical verifications of the amount of Oil stored at the Refinery upon one Business Day’s notice. Seller shall have
the right to conduct physical inspections of the storage facilities at the Refinery for a period of 90 days following the Termination Date. During any inspections, Seller shall comply with all applicable rules and regulations of the Refinery, as
well as any applicable Law. Buyer shall provide Seller or its designated agents with such materials, documents, governmental certificates and agreements as Seller or its designated agents may request from time to time to conduct the HSE Diligence.


  
 -57-










	24.	DEFAULT, SUSPENSION AND TERMINATION 

 (a) Events of Default. Upon the occurrence of any of the events listed below (each, an “Event of Default” or “Default”) with respect to a Party (the
“Defaulting Party”), the other Party (the “Non-Defaulting Party”) may, in its sole discretion, and in addition to any other legal remedies it may have, in law or equity, upon giving notice to the Defaulting Party
(i) suspend its performance under this Agreement, including, the suspension of Seller’s Supply of Oil and Buyer’s taking Delivery of Oil, (ii) terminate this Agreement, or (iii) if Buyer is the Defaulting Party, Seller may
(1) reduce the PBF Line of Credit to zero, (2) deliver a Termination of Deliveries Notice and/or (3) enter upon Buyer’s property and immediately remove all Oil from the storage facilities at the Refinery: 

(i) Any Party fails to make payment when due under this Agreement; provided, however, that no Default or Event of Default
shall be deemed to have occurred if the relevant failure is caused solely by an error or omission of an administrative or operational nature; provided further that (a) funds were available to such Party to make the relevant payment when due and
(b) such payment is made within one Business Day after notice of such failure is given to such Party. 

(ii) Any Party fails to perform, breaches or repudiates any obligation or covenant to the other Party under this
Agreement, other than an Event of Default described in Clause 24(a)(i) above or Clauses 24(a)(iii) through (xiv) below, or breaches any representation, or warranty in any material respect under this Agreement, that, if capable of being
cured, is not cured to the satisfaction of the other Parties, within 5 Business Days from notice to such Party that corrective action is needed, or longer than 5 Business Days if the Party that fails to perform, breaches or repudiates demonstrates
to the other Party within 5 Business Days after receiving notice that corrective action is needed, to the reasonable satisfaction of the other Party, that such cure will be successful and such Party provides a reasonable estimate of the time
necessary in order to complete the curative actions; 
 (iii) A Party or a Guarantor becomes Bankrupt;

 (iv) A Party fails to perform, breaches or repudiates Clause 22(c)(iii); 

(v) A Party fails to give adequate assurances of its ability to perform within 5 Business Days upon a reasonable request
therefor by the other Party; 
 (vi) A Party ceases, or threatens to cease, to carry on its business or a major
part thereof, or a distress, execution, or other process is levied or enforced upon or against any significant part of the property of such Party that has a material adverse effect on a Party’s business or a major part thereof, or the other
Party reasonably determines that any of the foregoing events is reasonably likely to occur; 
 (vii) Buyer or any
material subsidiary of Buyer’s Guarantor directly or indirectly suffers the imposition of any restraining order or suspension in connection with any proceeding (judicial or administrative) with respect to any material license, permit or
franchise which has a material adverse impact on Buyer’s business or a major part thereof; 

  
 -58-









 (viii) Buyer fails to maintain a guaranty required under this Agreement in a
form reasonably acceptable to Seller and covering all obligations due under this Agreement, or such Guaranty is for any reason partially or wholly revoked or invalidated or otherwise ceases to be in full force and effect, or a Guarantor denies that
it has any further liability or obligation thereunder; 
 (ix) Buyer fails at any time to satisfy all of the
collateral requirements that are set forth in Clauses 19(a), (b), (f) and (g); 
 (x) Except as
otherwise agreed by the Parties, any event of default or automatic early termination event under any other agreement or contract that may from time to time be entered into between Buyer and Seller, including the Intercreditor Agreement(s);

 (xi) Any early termination event occurs with respect to any other crude oil supply contract between Seller or
any Affiliate of Seller and any Affiliate of Buyer; 
 (xii) Any automatic early termination event or material
event of default under Buyer’s Credit Agreement or the Guaranty; 
 (xiii) A Material Adverse Change with
respect to Buyer or any Guarantor; and 
 (xiv) Buyer fails to provide Seller with the full amount of Additional
Acceptable Security required in accordance with Clause 24(c). 
 In the case of an Event of Default described in this Clause 24 above, the
Non-Defaulting Party shall have the right at any time upon and for 10 Business Days after (and so long thereafter during the continuation of such Event of Default) to terminate this Agreement. In addition to the foregoing, in the case of an Event of
Default described in this Clause 24 above that occurs as the result of acts or omissions of Buyer, Seller shall have the immediate right to deliver a Termination of Deliveries Notice and Buyer shall immediately comply with its obligations as set out
in Clause 24(d). 
 (b) Remedies. The Non-Defaulting Party’s rights under this Clause 24 shall be in addition to,
and not in limitation or exclusion of, any other rights that it may have (whether by agreement, operation of law or otherwise), including any rights and remedies under the UCC. The Non-Defaulting Party may enforce any of its remedies under this
Agreement successively or concurrently at its option. No delay or failure on the part of a Non-Defaulting Party to exercise any right or remedy to which it may become entitled on account of an Event of Default shall constitute an abandonment of any
such right, and the Non-Defaulting Party shall be entitled to exercise such right or remedy at any time during the continuance of an Event of Default. All of the remedies and other provisions of this Clause 24 shall be without prejudice and in
addition to any right to which any Party is at any time otherwise entitled (whether by operation of law, in equity, under contract or otherwise). 

  
 -59-









 The Parties recognize and agree that if any of the provisions of this Agreement are not
performed in accordance with their specific terms or are otherwise breached, immediate and irreparable harm or injury would be caused for which money damages would not be an adequate remedy. Accordingly, the Parties agree that, in addition to other
remedies, each Party shall be entitled to an injunction restraining any violation or threatened violation of the provisions of this Agreement or to specific performance or other equitable relief to enforce the provisions of this Agreement. In the
event that any action should be brought in equity to enforce the provisions of this Agreement, neither Party shall allege, and each Party hereby waives the defense, that there is adequate remedy at law. The Parties further agree that resort to the
dispute resolution provisions contained in this Agreement shall not bar or restrict any Party from seeking any of the foregoing injunctive or equitable relief. 
 (c) Termination of PBF Line of Credit. Upon the occurrence of any of the events listed below, (each, a “Credit Default”) with respect to Buyer, Seller may, in its sole discretion,
and in addition to any other legal remedies it may have, in law or equity, upon giving notice to Buyer reduce the PBF Line of Credit to zero: 
 (i) Buyer or any of Buyer’s Affiliates fails to make any payment in respect of indebtedness of more than $[REDACTED] when due (whether by scheduled maturity, required prepayment, acceleration,
demand, or otherwise) and such failure continues and is not discharged within 5 Business Days; and 
 (ii) Buyer
fails to comply with the terms of Clauses 19, (c), (d) and (e). 
 In the case of the occurrence of any Credit Default,
Seller may notify Buyer that the PBF Line of Credit has been reduced to zero. Within 1 Business Day after receipt of such notice by Buyer, Buyer shall provide Seller with Additional Acceptable Security in an amount equal to at least the total amount
that will be owed to Seller hereunder through the next Business Day, and Buyer shall continue to provide Additional Acceptable Security in an amount equal to at least the total amount that will be owed to Seller hereunder through the next Business
Day for the remaining term of this Agreement. 
 (d) Termination of Deliveries Notice. If Seller delivers to Buyer a
Termination of Deliveries Notice, Buyer shall immediately cease taking any Deliveries of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock and all rights of Buyer to take deliveries of Oil and Indigenous Feedstock from the Storage Facilities shall terminate. With respect
to the delivery of a Termination of Deliveries Notice, Buyer acknowledges Seller will suffer irreparable harm should Buyer, following delivery of a Termination of Deliveries Notice, continue to take quantities of Oil and that there is no adequate
remedy at law with respect to such failure to comply. Buyer acknowledges that a temporary restraining order and temporary injunction are appropriate remedies for a failure by Buyer to comply with a Termination of Deliveries Notice and as such, Buyer
waives any requirement that Seller post a bond in the event that Seller seeks either a temporary restraining order or temporary injunction as a result of Buyer failing to comply with a Termination of Deliveries Notice. 

(e) Indemnification. The Defaulting Party shall indemnify and hold harmless the Non-Defaulting Party for all Liabilities incurred
as a result of the Event of Default or in the exercise of any remedies under this Clause 24, including any damages, losses and expenses 

  
 -60-









 
incurred in obtaining, maintaining or liquidating commercially reasonable hedges relating to the Oil sold and purchased hereunder, all as determined in a commercially reasonable manner by the
Non-Defaulting Party. 
 (f) Seller Termination Option. If Buyer (i) fails to acquire Refinery Project Company by
February 1, 2011 or (ii) fails to assign this Agreement to Refinery Project Company pursuant to an assignment acceptable to Seller immediately after closing of the acquisition of Refinery Project Company, then Seller shall have the right
at anytime thereafter to terminate this Agreement. 
 (g) Buyer Termination Option. If Buyer does not close the
acquisition of Refinery Project Company, Buyer shall have the right to terminate this Agreement by providing notice of termination to Seller promptly after such acquisition has been terminated, along with evidence of the termination of the
acquisition of Refinery Project Company; provided, that (i) such termination shall not affect the obligation of the Parties with respect to that certain Memorandum of Understanding dated September 23, 2010, Re: Delaware City Refinery and
Paulsboro Refinery between Buyer, Seller and DCRC and (ii) if Buyer or any of its Affiliates shall acquire the Refinery or Refinery Project Company within 6 months of such termination, Seller shall have the right to, and Buyer shall, and shall
cause its Affiliates to, enter into an agreement on terms equivalent to those in this Agreement, with such revisions as may be agreed upon by Seller. 
  

	25.	OBLIGATIONS AT TERMINATION 


(a) Action Upon Termination. Upon expiration or termination of this Agreement for any reason, the Parties agree and shall undertake
to do the following: 
 (i) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, on the date of expiration of this
Agreement or the date of early termination (the “Termination Date”), Buyer shall purchase from Seller: 
 (1) all Inventories located at the Refinery or held on Buyer’s behalf at a Statoil Storage Facility, as well as any Oil nominated for Supply to Buyer, subject to the provisions of subclause
(b) below. Any Oil and Indigenous Feedstock, other than the IF Staring Volume and Tank Heels, which are addressed by subclauses (2) and (3) below, both in-tank and in transit will be sold back to Buyer at the appropriate fully
Delivered ex-tank price pursuant to this Agreement, including any accrued TVM Payment charge. 
 (2) All
Indigenous Feedstock at the Refinery or held on Buyer’s behalf at any Statoil Storage Facility, and the price for such Indigenous Feedstock shall be the same as would apply under Clause 5(i)(i)(2) and Clause 5(i)(iii) as if such Termination
Date were the IF Conclusion Date except that: (A) the IF Ending Price will be based on the Month in which the Termination Date occurs, and (B) Buyer will pay Seller an amount equal to the loss caused by Seller receiving such adjusted IF
Ending Price rather than the compensation Seller would have received from being paid on the IF Conclusion Date in accordance with the original terms of this Agreement. 

  
 -61-









 (3) All Tank Heels at the Refinery or held on Buyer’s behalf at any
Statoil Storage Facility, and the price for such Tank Heels shall be the same as would apply under Clause 5(j)(i)(2) and Clause 5(j)(ii) as if such Termination Date were the TH Conclusion Date except that: (A) the TH Ending Price will be based
on the Month in which the Termination Date occurs, and (B) Buyer will pay Seller an amount equal to the loss cause by Seller receiving such adjusted TH Ending Price rather than the compensation Seller would have received from being paid on the
TH Conclusion Date in accordance with the original terms of this Agreement. 
 Seller shall prepare and provide Buyer with an
invoice for the sale of such Inventories. In each case, title to the Inventories shall pass from Seller to Buyer upon receipt of payment into Seller’s designated account. 
 A full reconciliation of book stock, in accordance with the same procedures used in Clause 11 for reconciliation of month end volumes, will be conducted by Seller to ensure that all volumes are properly
accounted for and any outstanding payments due are identified and promptly settled. 
 (ii) If this Agreement is
terminated by Seller because of a Default by Buyer, Seller shall calculate within 10 days of the Termination Date (or within such longer period as is necessary under the circumstances) all damages incurred by Seller, including damages, losses and
expenses incurred by Seller in liquidating all Inventories including any hedging losses, all as determined in a commercially reasonable manner by Seller, and Buyer shall be required to compensate Seller for all such damages, losses and expenses upon
demand. Seller shall be entitled to deduct any such damages from any deposits or other available credit support or collateral. 
 (iii) If this Agreement is terminated due to a Default by Seller, Buyer shall calculate within 10 days of the Termination Date (or within such longer period as is necessary under the circumstances) all
damages incurred by Buyer, as determined in a commercially reasonable manner by Buyer, and Seller shall be required to compensate Buyer for all such damages upon demand. 

(iv) An estimate of all amounts owing between the Parties under this Agreement shall be paid on the Termination Date;
provided that if any amounts required to be calculated cannot be determined as of the Termination Date, the Parties shall rely on a good faith estimate prepared as of the Termination Date and thereafter shall make a final settlement to true-up any
such amounts when they become ascertainable. Any such true up payment shall be due within 10 days after submission of the final invoice from Seller. 
 (b) Nominated Volumes. 
 (i) If this Agreement is terminated
due to a Default by Buyer, Seller shall have the option to sell to Buyer any volumes of Oil nominated by Buyer but not yet Delivered at such payment terms as it determines are appropriate in its sole discretion or to sell such volumes to a third
party. Buyer shall compensate Seller for any resulting commercially reasonable additional costs, damages, losses or expenses. 

  
 -62-









 (ii) If this Agreement is terminated due to a Default by Seller, Buyer shall
have the option either: (1) to take Delivery of any or all volumes of Oil nominated by Buyer but not yet Delivered (applying the payment terms that would have been applied if there had not been a termination); or (2) to cancel such
volumes. Seller shall compensate Buyer for any resulting additional costs, damages, losses or expenses. 
 (iii)
In either event, if nominated volumes are sold to Buyer, the purchase price shall be the price that would have applied had the nominated volumes been timely Delivered prior to the date of termination of this Agreement. 

(c) Failure to Repurchase Oil. If Buyer fails to pay Seller for the Inventories on the Termination Date, Seller may elect at its
sole discretion to sell any or all of the Inventories to third parties pursuant to such terms and conditions as it deems appropriate in its sole discretion. Seller shall notify Buyer of this election and the instructions for delivery of the Oil to
Seller or Seller’s consignees. 
 (i) If Seller elects to sell the Oil to third parties pursuant to this
Clause 25, then Seller shall be entitled to a reasonable period of time from the Termination Date to remove the Oil from the Refinery or other storage facilities. Seller shall have reasonable access to such storage facilities for the purpose of
removing its Oil or effectuating any third-party sales. 
 (ii) Buyer shall indemnify and hold harmless Seller
against any Liabilities incurred in connection with its failure to purchase the Inventories in accordance with this Clause 25, including any losses and expenses incurred in obtaining, maintaining or liquidating commercially reasonable hedges or
related trading positions, all as determined by Seller in a commercially reasonable manner. 
  

	26.	INDEMNIFICATION AND CLAIMS 


(a) Indemnification. 
 (i) To the fullest extent permitted by Law and except as specified otherwise elsewhere in this Agreement, Buyer shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless Seller, its affiliates, and their directors,
officers, employees, representatives, agents and contractors from and against any Liabilities accruing at any time during or following Supply of the Oil to the Storage Facilities (1) (A) arising out of or relating to injury, disease, or
death of any person or damage to or loss of any property, fine or penalty, to the extent caused by Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors, in performing its obligations under this
Agreement or (B) arising out of or relating to violations of Law including Environmental Law, (2) arising out of or in connection with the transshipment or the import, storage, custody, transfer, or export of Oil, including any Liabilities
directly or 

  
 -63-









 
indirectly arising out of or related to (A) any loss, spill, discharge or Release of the Oil or Hazardous Substances; (B) any act or omission in connection with or related to this
Agreement on the part of Buyer its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors, or any vessel or barge, receiving connection, receiving facilities and/or transport, arranged or furnished by or for the
account of Buyer; (C) Liabilities arising out of or in connection with the operation of the Storage Facilities by Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors, any emissions or discharges
from the Storage Facilities or the delivery, custody or storage of Oil or other products of any other party; or (D) any breach or violation of Environmental Laws by Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives,
agents or contractors and (3) relating to any loss, contamination or damage to the Oil or Indigenous Feedstock in the custody of Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors, stored in
the Storage Facilities storage tanks, or while it is in the process of being imported into or exported out of storage, which have been caused by (A) the negligence or willful misconduct on the part of Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees,
representatives, agents or contractors, (B) a breach of any representation, warranty, covenant or other responsibility under this Agreement by Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors
or (C) failure by Buyer, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents or contractors, to exercise due diligence in accordance with the standard of care applicable in the industry. 

(ii) To the fullest extent permitted by Law and except as specified otherwise elsewhere in this Agreement, Seller shall
defend, indemnify and hold harmless Buyer and its Affiliates, and their directors, officers, employees, representatives, agents and contractors, from and against any Liabilities accruing at any time prior to the Supply of the Oil to the Storage
Facilities arising out of or relating to (1) injury, disease, or death of any person or damage to or loss of any property, fine or penalty, to the extent caused by Seller, its Affiliates or their employees, directors, officers, representatives,
agents or contractors in performing its obligations under this Agreement; (2) violations of Law including Environmental Law; or (3) the transshipment or the import, storage, custody, transfer, or export of Oil by Seller prior to Supply,
including any Liabilities directly or indirectly arising out of or related to any loss, spill, discharge or Release of the Oil or Hazardous Substances. 
 (iii) In addition to the other indemnification obligations set forth in this Clause 26 and elsewhere in this Agreement, each Party (the “Indemnifying Party”) shall indemnify and hold the
other Party (the “Indemnified Party”), its Affiliates, and their employees, directors, officers, representatives, agents and contractors, harmless from and against any and all Liabilities arising from (1) the Indemnifying
Party’s breach of this Agreement, (2) the Indemnifying Party’s failure to comply with Law with respect to the sale, transportation, storage, handling or consumption of Oil, except to the extent that such liability results from the
Indemnified Party’s gross negligence or willful misconduct or (3) any material inaccuracy in or breach of any of the Indemnifying Party’s representations and warranties made herein at the time such representations and warranties were
made. 

  
 -64-









 (iv) A Party’s obligation to indemnify the other Party pursuant hereto
shall not be nullified or otherwise effected by the allocation of risk of loss pursuant to Clause 8 hereof, or the transfer of title to the Oil pursuant to Clause 7 hereof, at the time any such Liabilities arise. 

(v) The Parties’ obligations to defend, indemnify, and hold each other harmless under the terms of this Agreement
shall not vest any rights in any third party (whether a Governmental Authority or private entity) other than those Persons who are expressly designated hereunder as Persons to be indemnified by a Party, nor shall they be considered an admission of
liability or responsibility for any purposes other than those enumerated in this Agreement. 
 (b) Claims. Upon receipt
by the Indemnified Party of notice of any claim, demand, suit or proceeding brought against it that might give rise to an indemnity claim under this Agreement (such claim, demand, suit or proceeding, a “Third Party Claim”), the
Indemnified Party shall as soon as practicable send to the Indemnifying Party a notice specifying the nature of such Third Party Claim and the amount or estimated amount thereof if known (which amount or estimated amount shall not be conclusive of
the final amount, if any, of such claim, demand or suit); provided, however, that any delay or failure by the Indemnified Party to give notice to the Indemnifying Party shall not relieve the Indemnifying Party of its obligations
hereunder except to the extent, if at all, that the Indemnifying Party shall have been materially prejudiced by reason of such delay or failure. The Indemnifying Party shall have the right to assume the defense, at its own expense and by its own
counsel, of any Third Party Claim; provided, however, that such counsel is reasonably acceptable to the Indemnified Party and the Third Party Claim could not (i) result in a conflict of interest between the Indemnified Party and
the Indemnifying Party or (ii) involve a criminal or quasi-criminal charge. Notwithstanding an Indemnifying Party’s election to appoint counsel to represent an Indemnified Party in connection with a Third Party Claim, an Indemnified Party
shall have the right to employ separate counsel at its own expense provided, however, that the Indemnifying Party and its counsel shall have control of the defense of the Third Party Claim. If requested by the Indemnifying Party, the Indemnified
Party agrees to reasonably cooperate with the Indemnifying Party and its counsel in contesting any claim, demand or suit that the Indemnifying Party defends, or, if appropriate and related to the claim, demand, suit or proceeding in question, in
making any counterclaim against the Person asserting the Third Party Claim, or any cross-complaint against any Person. All reasonable costs and expenses incurred in connection with the Indemnified Party’s cooperation shall be borne by the
Indemnifying Party. No Third Party Claim may be settled or compromised (x) by the Indemnified Party without the prior consent of the Indemnifying Party or (y) by the Indemnifying Party without the prior consent of the Indemnified Party
unless such settlement would result in no payment or other obligation from the Indemnifying Party. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an Indemnifying Party shall not be entitled to assume responsibility for and control of any judicial or administrative
proceeding if such proceeding involves an Event of Default by the Indemnifying Party under this Agreement which shall have occurred and be continuing. 

  
 -65-










	27.	DAMAGES 

 (a) The
Parties’ liability for damages under this Agreement is limited to direct, actual damages only and neither Party shall be liable for, except when claimed by a third party and covered under Clause 26 above, lost profits or other business
interruption damages, or special, consequential, punitive, exemplary damages, in tort, contract or otherwise, of any kind, arising out of or in any way connected with the performance, the suspension of performance, the failure to perform, or the
termination of this Agreement. Each Party acknowledges the duty to mitigate damages hereunder. 
 (b) To the maximum extent
permissible by Law, Seller shall not be responsible in any respect whatsoever for any loss, damage or injury resulting from any hazards inherent in the nature of the Oil delivered under this Agreement. 

 

	28.	ASSIGNMENT 

 (a) This
Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the Parties hereto, their respective successors and permitted assigns. 
 (b) Except as specifically provided herein, neither Party shall assign, transfer or otherwise dispose of any of its rights or obligations hereunder, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent
of the other Party, which consent may be given and/or conditioned in such Party’s discretion; provided, however, that, (i) on the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall assign its rights and obligations under this Agreement to
Refinery Project Company pursuant to an assignment agreement in form and substance reasonably satisfactory to Seller, which shall include a bring-down as of the Delivery Commencement Date of all representations, warranties and covenants made by
Buyer hereunder by Refinery Project Company; (ii) Seller may assign this Agreement to an Affiliate of Seller without the consent of Buyer, and (iii) subject to the terms of the Intercreditor Agreement(s), either Party shall be entitled to
pledge their respective rights under this Agreement as collateral security to internationally recognized financial institutions without the consent of the other Party. Any assignment or transfer made shall be done so expressly subject to this
Agreement with such assignee agreeing in writing to be bound by the terms of this Agreement. The assigning Party shall remain liable hereunder for due and proper performance of all provisions of this Agreement, including any provisions governing the
credit aspects of this Agreement. 
 (c) Any assignment by Buyer hereunder shall be contingent on such assignee’s
compliance with Clauses 19(a) and 19(c). 
 (d) Any attempted assignment, transfer or other disposition in violation of this
Clause 28 shall be null and void ab initio. 
  

	29.	NOTICES AND ADDRESSES 


Any notices, statements, requests or other communications to be given to either Party pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing and,
except to the extent provided in the other provisions of this Agreement, shall be given by messenger, telecopy or other electronic transmission, or registered or certified mail, postage prepaid, return receipt requested, addressed


  
 -66-









 
to such Party at its address, telecopy number shown below, or at such other address as either Party shall have furnished to the other by notice given in accordance with this Clause 29. Any
notice delivered or made by messenger, telecopy, or mail shall be deemed to be given on the date of actual delivery as shown by messenger receipt, the addressor’s telecopy machine confirmation or other verifiable electronic receipt, or the
registry or certification receipt; provided that if notice is actually delivered on a day which is not a Business Day, notice shall be deemed given on the next Business Day after such delivery. 

 

			
	If to Seller:	  	Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.
		  	1055 Washington Boulevard – 7th Floor
		  	Stamford, CT 06901
		  	Attention: Crude Oil Operations
		  	Fax Number: (203) 978-6958
		  	Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900
		  	E-mail: uscrudeops@statoil.com
		
	With a copy (which	  	Statoil Marketing and Trading (US) Inc.
	shall not constitute	  	1055 Washington Blvd. – 7th Floor
	notice) to:	  	 Stamford, CT 06901

Attention: General Counsel

		  	Fax Number: (203) 978-6952
		  	Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900
		
	If to Buyer:	  	PBF Holding Company LLC
		  	1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
		  	Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887
		  	Attention: Executive Vice President, Commercial
		  	Fax Number: (973) 455-7562
		  	Telephone Number: (973) 455-7500
		  	E-mail: dlucey@pbfenergy.com
		
	With a copy (which	  	PBF Holding Company LLC
	shall not constitute	  	1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
	notice) to:	  	 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887

Attention: General Counsel

		  	Fax Number: (973) 455-7562
		  	Telephone Number: (973) 455-7500

  

	30.	WARRANTIES; DISCLAIMER 


Seller warrants good and marketable title to the Oil sold to Buyer under this Agreement, free and clear of all Liens arising by, through
or under Seller and, subject to any deficiencies that are taken into account through the Final Quality Differential, warrants the Oil sold to Buyer under this Agreement conforms to the quality specifications for the Grade of Oil Delivered by Seller.
EXCEPT AS EXPRESSLY OTHERWISE PROVIDED IN THIS AGREEMENT, SELLER EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES, WHETHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ORAL OR WRITTEN, INCLUDING ANY 

  
 -67-









 
REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY WITH RESPECT TO (A) ANY INFRINGEMENT OF ANY PATENT, TRADEMARK OR COPYRIGHT; OR (B) THAT THE OIL SOLD TO BUYER WILL (I) BE MERCHANTABLE OR FIT FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE, (II) CONFORM TO MODELS OR SAMPLES, OR (III) MEET CERTAIN SPECIFICATIONS. 
  

	31.	APPLICABLE LAW, LITIGATION AND ARBITRATION 

 (a) Except as otherwise expressly provided in this Clause 31, the existence, validity, interpretation and enforcement of this Agreement, and any controversy, claim or dispute hereunder, whether in
contract, tort, equity or otherwise, shall be governed by, construed and enforced in accordance with the Laws of the State of New York, without giving effect to its conflict of laws principles, and the federal Laws of the United States applicable
therein. The United Nations convention on contracts for the international sale of goods (1980) shall not apply. 
 (b) The
Parties shall attempt in good faith and within 10 days following receipt from either Party of a written notice of any cause of action, controversy, claim, counterclaim, demand, dispute or other matter in question arising out of or in connection with
this Agreement, or the alleged breach thereof, or in any way relating to the subject matter of this Agreement or the relationship between the Parties created by this Agreement, including any question regarding the existence, validity, or termination
of this Agreement (each, a “Dispute”), to resolve by mutual agreement such Dispute by direct dialogue between senior management of both Parties during which period the applicable statute of limitations shall be tolled, regardless of
whether some or all of such Disputes allegedly (i) are extra-contractual in nature, (ii) sound in contract, tort, or otherwise, (iii) are provided by statute, common law or otherwise, or (iv) seek damages or any other relief,
whether at law, in equity or otherwise. If a resolution is not achieved within 30 days from the initiation of such discussions, the matter shall be settled as provided in this Clause 31. 

(c) Except as provided for in subclauses (d), (e) and (f) below, each Party irrevocably: (i) submits to the exclusive
jurisdiction of the US Federal District Court for the Southern District of New York located in the Borough of Manhattan or, if such court declines to exercise or does not have jurisdiction, in any New York state court in the Borough of Manhattan or
any other Federal court in the State of New York, and to service of process as provided by New York Law, and (ii) waives any objection which it may have at any time to the laying of venue of any proceedings brought in any such court, waives any
claim that such proceedings have been brought in an inconvenient forum and further waives the right to object, with respect to such proceedings, that such court does not have jurisdiction over such Party. Further, each Party waives, to the fullest
extent permitted by applicable Law, any right it may have to a trial by jury in respect of any proceedings relating to this Agreement. Nothing in this Agreement precludes either Party from bringing proceedings in any other jurisdiction in order to
enforce any judgment obtained in any proceedings referred to in this Clause 31, nor will the bringing of such enforcement proceedings in any one or more jurisdictions preclude the bringing of enforcement proceedings in any other jurisdiction. Either
Party may file a copy of this Clause 31(c) with any court as written evidence of the knowing, voluntary and bargained agreement between the Parties irrevocably to waive any objections to jurisdiction, venue or to convenience of forum. 

  
 -68-









 (d) Any Dispute (other than such as described in subclauses (e) and (f) below)
where the amount in controversy does not exceed $[REDACTED] which the Parties are unable to resolve by mutual agreement, as provided in Clause 31(b) above, shall be settled by arbitration in New York, New York before 3 disinterested arbitrators in
accordance with the international arbitration rules of the American Arbitration Association; provided, however, that the Parties may elect to proceed with only one arbitrator by mutual agreement. Each Party shall appoint one arbitrator
and the third arbitrator, who shall act as chairman, shall be appointed by the other two arbitrators chosen by the Parties, and if they cannot reach mutual agreement, then by the American Arbitration Association, provided that each arbitrator
shall be knowledgeable and experienced in the international sale and purchase of crude oil. The arbitration shall be conducted in English, the arbitral award shall be final and binding on both Parties without appeal to any court, and judgment upon
the award rendered by the arbitrators may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. 
 (e) Any Dispute that may arise
in connection with or as a result of Clause 16 or Clause 15 where the amount in controversy does not exceed $[REDACTED] which the Parties are unable to resolve by mutual agreement, as provided in subclause (b) above, shall be settled
by the “Shortened Arbitration Procedure” of the Society of Maritime Arbitrators, Inc. (“SMA”) in New York, New York pursuant to the “Rules for the Shortened Arbitration Procedure of the Society of Maritime
Arbitrators, Inc.” then in force. The arbitration shall be conducted in English and the arbitral award shall be final and binding on both Parties without appeal to any court, and judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrators may be
entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. In addition to the choice of law described in subclause (a) above, any such Dispute shall also be governed by, construed and enforced under the maritime Law of the US without giving effect to
its conflict of laws principles, and in the case of any conflict between New York Law and the maritime Law of the US, the maritime Law of the US shall control. 
 (f) Any Dispute that may arise in connection with or as a result of Clause 16 or Clause 15 where the amount in controversy equals or exceeds $[REDACTED] but is less than $[REDACTED] which the
Parties are unable to resolve by mutual agreement, as provided in subclause (b) above, shall be settled by arbitration in New York, New York pursuant to the “Maritime Arbitration Rules” of the SMA then in force before 3 disinterested
arbitrators; provided, however, that the Parties may elect to proceed with only one arbitrator by mutual agreement. Each Party shall appoint one arbitrator and the third arbitrator, who shall act as chairman, shall be appointed by the
other two arbitrators chosen by the Parties, and if they cannot reach mutual agreement, then by the SMA, provided that all 3 arbitrators shall be knowledgeable and experienced in the international sale and purchase of crude oil and further
that all 3 arbitrators shall be members of the SMA. The arbitration shall be conducted in English and the arbitral award shall be final and binding on both Parties without appeal to any court, and judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrators
may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. In addition to the choice of law described in subclause (a) above, any such Dispute shall also be governed by, construed and enforced under the maritime Law of the US without giving
effect to its conflict of laws principles, and in the case of any conflict between New York Law and the maritime Law of the United States, the maritime Law of the United States shall control. 

  
 -69-









 (g) The Parties agree that if at any time during the term of the Agreement, any Laws are
changed or new Laws have become or are due to become effective, whether by Law or by response to the insistence or request of any Governmental Authority or any Person purporting to act for a Governmental Authority (a “Change in
Law”), and the material effect of such Change in Law is (i) not covered by any other provision of the Agreement; and (ii) has or will have a material and substantial adverse regulatory effect on Seller or Buyer, then the affected
Party shall have the option to notify the other Party of such event. The Party providing such notice shall provide as much notice as possible and include in such notice the change(s) and related consequences causing the issues covered by the notice.
Thereafter, the Parties shall promptly negotiate in good faith and shall make such changes as are necessary to mitigate the consequences of the Change in Law. 
  

	32.	HSE, DRUG AND ALCOHOL POLICY 

 The Parties represent that they are fully conversant with one another’s respective HSE policy and the ethical standards and requirements as provided to each other under separate cover, as the same
may be amended from time to time, or as set forth in Clause 22(e) and on Appendix 21. All business between the Parties under this Agreement will be conducted in a commercially reasonable and responsible manner to further the Parties’ objective
that the operations involve a minimal level of risk to people, the environment and equipment. The shared targets for the operation of the trade are zero personnel injuries, zero spills and environmental damage and zero equipment damage. 

Each Party shall notify the other of any incidents in connection with its performance under this Agreement related to HSE issues
including any pollution incidents that require notice to any Governmental Authorities, further investigation or other response action under applicable Environmental Laws. 
 Each Party agrees to issue HSE performance data in connection with its performance under this Agreement not older than 6 months upon reasonable request of the other Party covering any recordable incidents
during the relevant period. Such reports shall provide a brief description of the incident and appropriate follow-up action taken. 
 The Party responsible for employing a Vessel for the transport of Oil under this Agreement warrants to the other Party that at all times the operator of such Vessel will strictly observe the HSE
provisions, policy or guidelines in force at any terminal or place that it is required to use in the execution of this Agreement and, if relevant, the ports or places where such terminals are situated and the roads or railway network used for the
transport and conduct its performance of the transport in accordance with any such regulations in force at such place or port. 

Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, the Party responsible for the employment of a Vessel warrants that the operator of
such Vessel shall strictly adhere to the drug and alcohol policy envisaged under the Oil Companies International Maritime Forum guidelines issued in June 1995 as may be amended from time to time, and any other Laws applicable to such Vessel’s
delivery of Oil in connection with this Agreement. 

  
 -70-









 Should a Vessel, or the employees, representatives or sub-contractors utilized by the
operator of such Vessel on such Vessel fail to observe all of the guidelines and/or directions of the applicable terminal or national or regional legislation pertaining to HSE that results in losses, damages, costs, expenses or fines or any other
costs against the Party not providing the transport, the Party who has undertaken the provision of transport shall indemnify the other Party in respect of such losses, damages, costs, expenses, fines.  

 

	33.	MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEETS. 

 (a) Seller shall provide Buyer with a copy of a current Material Safety Data Sheet (“MSDS”) for the Oil delivered under this Agreement. 

(b) From and after the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall be responsible for any consequences that result from the failure to
properly use the information provided on an MSDS. 
 (c) From and after the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provide
persons responsible for the management of HSE matters within its own organization with a copy of the MSDS. 
 (d) From and after
the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall provides its employees with appropriate information and training to enable them to handle and use the Oil delivered under this Agreement in a manner which does not endanger their health or safety.

  

	34.	VOICE RECORDING 

 Each
Party may electronically record all telephone conversations between them, with or without the use of a warning tone, and that, to the extent permitted by Law, any such recordings may be submitted in evidence to any court or in any proceeding for the
purpose of establishing the formation or existence of a transaction and the terms thereof. Each Party shall obtain the consent of its employees and agents to such recording to the extent required by Law. Notwithstanding the foregoing, either Party
reserves the right to object to the admissibility of any recording on the grounds of authenticity, relevance, and/or materiality, and neither Party waives its rights to such objections. 

 

	35.	DISPOSAL 

 Buyer shall not
knowingly resell, resupply or redeliver, directly or indirectly, the Oil to an embargoed country in contravention of applicable trade embargo requirements of the Kingdom of Norway or the US or any other country from which this Agreement is executed.

 At any time Seller may require Buyer to provide any relevant documents for the purpose of verifying the final destination of
Oil delivered to Seller under this Agreement, and Buyer undertakes to advise Seller, upon request, of the destination of the Oil. If at any time before delivery of the Oil, importation of the Oil at the designated delivery Storage Facilities is
prohibited by order of the Governmental Authorities of the country in which the Oil has been produced or loaded or is to be imported, then Buyer shall arrange for delivery at an acceptable alternative port that is not subject to any such
prohibition. Any resulting additional costs incurred by Seller as a result of such alternative Delivery shall be refunded promptly to Seller by Buyer. 

  
 -71-









 In the event the Oil is disposed of by Buyer to a third party in whole or part, Buyer shall
ensure that all end users of the Oil abide by the provisions set forth herein of this Clause 35 and without delay provide Seller with all relevant information as Seller may require related to such alternative disposal including name of end user,
name of refinery and any other relevant information Seller may reasonably deem necessary. 
 Buyer’s failure to comply with
any of the provisions of this Clause 35 shall entitle Seller (without prejudice to any other rights and remedies it may have under this Agreement) to cancel this Agreement, suspend further deliveries of Oil under this Agreement or dispose of any
undelivered Oil as it deems fit. 
  

	36.	CONFIDENTIALITY 

 All
Confidential Information supplied by the Disclosing Party Representatives to the Receiving Party or the Receiving Party Recipients is confidential and is the sole and exclusive property of the Disclosing Party or is property to which the Disclosing
Party has rights and an obligation to keep confidential and is being furnished to the Receiving Party or the Receiving Party Recipients in reliance by the Disclosing Party of the undertakings made in this Clause 36. 

Each Receiving Party, on behalf of itself and the Receiving Party Recipients, (a) will keep the Confidential Information
confidential and will not disclosure any Confidential Information in any manner whatsoever except as otherwise provided herein; and (b) will not use any Confidential Information other than in connection with this Agreement; provided, however,
that Receiving Party may reveal the Confidential Information to Receiving Party Recipients: (i) who need to know the Confidential Information for the purpose of this Agreement; (ii) who are informed of the confidential nature of the
Confidential Information; and (iii) who agree to act in accordance with the terms of this Clause 36. A Receiving Party will be responsible for any breach of this Clause 36 by any of its Receiving Party Recipients. Upon a Disclosing Party’s
request, the Receiving Party shall return to the Disclosing Party or destroy all copies of any written data supplied as part of Confidential Information (including notes, extracts, summaries or other such materials prepared by the Receiving Party
based in whole or in part upon the Confidential Information) to the extent permitted by applicable Law. 
 Buyer acknowledges
that certain Receiving Party Recipients of Seller also have responsibility for trading and/or marketing products or transactions that are the same as, similar to or correlated with, the transactions contemplated by this Agreement. It is not
Buyer’s intent to restrict in any way or alter such Receiving Party Recipient’s trading or marketing activities. 

Each Receiving Party acknowledges and agrees that remedies at law may be inadequate to protect a Disclosing Party against any actual or
threatened breach of this Clause 36 by a Receiving Party or Receiving Party Recipients, and, without prejudice to any other rights and remedies otherwise available to such Disclosing Party, and upon an offer of proof by the Disclosing Party of an
actual or threatened breach of this Clause 36, the Receiving Party agrees to the granting of injunctive relief in the Disclosing Party’s favor without proof of actual damages. In the event of litigation relating to this Clause 36, if a court of
competent jurisdiction determines in a final order that this Clause 36 has been breached by a Receiving Party, then such Receiving Party will reimburse the Disclosing Party for its costs and expenses (including, without limitation, reasonable legal
fees and expenses) incurred in connection with all such litigation. 

  
 -72-










	37.	SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY 

 Each
Party represents and warrants that it has entered into this Agreement in a commercial capacity and that with respect to this Agreement it is in all respects subject to civil and commercial Law. Each party irrevocably and unconditionally, and to the
fullest extent permitted by Law, waives any rights of sovereign immunity which it may have now or subsequently acquire in respect of its position or any property and/or assets (present or subsequently acquired and wherever located) belonging to it.

  

	38.	ANTI-CORRUPTION AND FACILITATION PAYMENTS 

 (a) In connection with this Agreement and the business resulting therefrom Buyer and Seller shall respectively comply with all applicable Laws, relating to bribery, corruption and money laundering of:

 (i) The Kingdom of Norway, 

(ii) The US, and 
 (iii) Any other country in which this Agreement is partly or wholly executed. 

(b) Each Party shall not, directly or indirectly, in connection with this Agreement and the business resulting therefrom, offer, pay,
promise to pay, or authorize the giving of money or anything of value to a government official (including but not limited to employees of a government oil company), to any officer or employee of a public international organization, to any political
party or official thereof or to any candidate for political office, or to any person, while knowing or being aware of a high probability that all or a portion of such money or thing of value will be offered, given or promised, directly or
indirectly, to any government official, to any officer or employee of a public international organization, to any political party or official thereof, or to any candidate for political office, for the purpose of: (a) influencing any act or
decision of such official, officer, employee, political party, party official, or candidate in his or its official capacity, including a decision to fail to perform his or its official functions; or (b) inducing such official, officer,
employee, political party, or candidate to use his or its influence with the government or instrumentality thereof (including but not limited to a government oil company) or organization to affect or influence any act or decision of such government
or instrumentality or organization, or to obtain an improper advantage in order to assist such party in obtaining or retaining business for or with, or directing business to such party or any other person in relation to this Agreement. 

(c) The Parties shall use commercially reasonable efforts to insure that relevant third parties used for fulfilling the Parties’
respective obligations under this Agreement also comply with all applicable Laws relating to bribery, corruption and money laundering of: 
 (i) The Kingdom of Norway, 

  
 -73-









 (ii) The US, and 

(iii) Any other country in which this Agreement is partly or wholly executed. 

(d) A Party may terminate this Agreement in accordance with Clause 24 if the other Party is in breach of the above. 

(e) All financial settlements, billings and reports in connection with this Agreement shall properly reflect the facts related to any
activities and transactions handled for the account of the other Party. The data may be relied upon as being complete and accurate in any further recordings and reporting made by the Parties or any of their representatives, for whatever purpose.

  

	39.	CONFLICT OF INTEREST 


Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, no director, employee or agent of either Party, its subcontractors or vendors, shall give
or receive from any director, employee or agent of the other Party or any Affiliate of the other Party any commission, fee, rebate, gift or entertainment of significant cost or value in connection with this Agreement. In addition, no director,
employee or agent of either Party, its subcontractors or vendors, shall enter into any business arrangement with any director, employee or agent of the other Party or any Affiliate of the other Party who is not acting as a representative of such
Party or its Affiliate without prior written notification thereof to the other Party. Any representative(s) authorized by either Party may audit the applicable records of the last 3 years of the other Party for the sole purpose of determining
whether there has been compliance with this Clause 39. 
  

	40.	MISCELLANEOUS 

 (a) If any
provision of this Agreement shall be (in whole or in part) determined to be invalid, illegal or unenforceable in any jurisdiction by a court of competent jurisdiction, then for such period that the same is invalid, illegal or unenforceable as to
such jurisdiction, such provision shall be deemed to be deleted from this Agreement without invalidating the remaining portions of this Agreement or affecting or impairing the validity or enforceability of such provision in any other jurisdiction.
It is also the intention of the Parties that in lieu of each clause or provision of this Agreement that is illegal, invalid or unenforceable, there be added, as a part of this Agreement, a clause or provision as similar in terms to such illegal,
invalid or unenforceable clause or provision as may be possible and be legal, valid and enforceable. 
 (b) Any modification of,
consent, waiver, amendment or addition to this Agreement shall be effective only if made in writing, specifically referencing this Agreement, signed by both Parties. 
 (c) Except as expressly provided in this Agreement, this Agreement shall not be construed so as to confer any right or benefit upon any Person other than the Parties to this Agreement, and their
respective permitted successors and assigns. 

  
 -74-









 (d) This Agreement contains the entire agreement between the Parties with respect to the
subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior proposals, negotiations, understandings and representations, whether written or oral, relating to the subject matter hereof. 
 (e) In the event of a conflict between provisions in the main body of this Agreement and in the Appendices, the provisions in the main body of this Agreement shall control. In the event of any conflict
between the provisions in this Agreement (including the Appendices) and the provisions in any other document or agreement entered into by the Parties in connection herewith, the terms of this Agreement shall control in the event of any conflict
unless such other document or agreement provides expressly otherwise. 
 (f) The Parties acknowledge that they and their counsel
have reviewed and revised this Agreement and that no presumption of contract interpretation or construction shall apply to the advantage or disadvantage of the drafter of this Agreement. 

(g) Where not inconsistent with any of the terms defined herein, the terms as published by the International Chamber of Commerce
(“ICC”) in the ICC Official Rules for the Interpretation of Trade Terms edition of 2000 shall apply. 
 (h)
From and after the Effective Date, each Party, and will cause their respective Affiliates to, execute and deliver such further instruments and documents and take such other action as may reasonably be requested by any Party hereto to carry out the
purposes and intents hereof, including to secure Seller’s security interest in the Oil Delivered hereunder and the proceeds thereof. 
 [Signature Page(s) Follow] 

  
 -75-









 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Agreement as of the date
first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	 /s/ Richard Martin Jones

	Name:	 	Richard Martin Jones
	Title:	 	President
	
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	 /s/ Jeffrey Dill

	Name:	 	Jeffrey Dill
	Title:	 	Secretary



  
 -76-









 SPECIFIC TERMS IN THIS EXHIBIT HAVE BEEN REDACTED BECAUSE CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR THOSE TERMS HAS BEEN
REQUESTED. THE REDACTED MATERIAL HAS BEEN SEPARATELY FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, AND THE TERMS HAVE BEEN MARKED AT THE APPROPRIATE PLACE WITH THE WORD “[REDACTED]”. 

FIRST AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND 
 SERVICES AGREEMENT 
 THIS FIRST AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK
SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND SERVICES AGREEMENT made and entered into as of January 7, 2011, by and between Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc., a Delaware corporation (“Seller”), and Paulsboro Refining Company LLC, a Delaware limited
liability company (“Buyer”), amends that certain Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement between Seller and Buyer (as assignee from PBF Holding Company LLC) dated December 16, 2010 (the “Original
Agreement”) 
 WITNESSETH: 
 WHEREAS, the parties hereto desire to modify the terms of the Original Agreement pursuant to the terms hereof (defined terms not defined herein are defined in the Original Agreement). 

NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the parties
hereto agree as follows: 
 1. Appendices. Appendix 13 is hereby amended by replacing the entirety of Appendix 13
with the Appendix 13 attached hereto, and incorporated herein by reference, as Exhibit A. 
 2. Definitions.

 (a) Clause 2(a) is hereby amended by adding the following after the definition of “Saudi Arabian”
and before the definition of “Saudi Contract”: 
 “Saudi Cargo” has the meaning set
out on Appendix 13. 
 (b) Clause 2(a) is hereby amended by adding the following before the definition of
“Acquisition Proposal”: 
 “Account agreement” has the meaning set out on Appendix 13.

 3. No Other Modification. Except as specifically set forth above, the Original Agreement shall remain in full
force and effect in all respects. 
 (Signature page follows) 







 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Amendment as of the date
first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US)
INC.
		
	By:	 	 





	Name:	 	 Richard Martin Jones

	Title:	 	 President

	
	PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	 





	Name:	 	 Jeffrey Dill

	Title:	 	 Secretary



 [Signature Page to First Amendment to Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement]








 Exhibit A 

APPENDIX 13 – SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS 
 On or about the date of the execution of that certain First Amendment to this Agreement, Buyer is entering into a contract (the “Saudi Contract”), in substantially the form
of Attachment I to this Appendix 13, with Saudi Arabian providing for the supply of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C) from Saudi Arabian to Buyer, with Seller executing the Saudi Contract as “BUYER’S ASSIGNEE” for the limited purposes
set forth therein. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Clause 14(a) of this Agreement, Seller shall provide [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] per Barrel with respect to all volumes of Oil purchased by Buyer from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi
Contract (each such volume, a “Saudi Cargo”). Shipping Services for each Saudi Cargo (which shall be calculated and paid for by Buyer in the same manner as for the Cargoes being sold by Seller under the Agreement)
shall be set using the “Delivery Method” unless otherwise agreed upon by the Parties. 
 Buyer shall sell and transfer
title to each Saudi Cargo to Seller DES Paulsboro (title to such Oil transferring to Seller when such Oil is transferred to a lightering Vessel controlled by Seller with such Oil to be delivered to the Storage Facilities) at the same price Buyer
purchases such Saudi Cargo from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract; provided that Seller and Buyer may mutually agree on a separate delivery point. Buyer shall deliver to Seller such acceptable documentation as may be requested by Seller with
respect to each such sale. Seller may purchase futures contracts on the Saudi Cargoes in connection with Oil pricing terms set forth in the Saudi Contract, in the same manner as for other Cargoes owned by Seller pursuant to Clause 9 and the other
provisions of the Agreement, and the pricing for the subsequent resale of such Cargo by Seller to Buyer upon Delivery from Seller to Buyer shall be based on such futures contract pricing. 

Upon receipt of each invoice from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract, Buyer shall immediately deliver an exact copy of such invoice
to Seller. Buyer and Seller shall use reasonable efforts to arrange with Saudi Arabian to permit direct payment by Seller to Saudi Arabian of Buyer’s obligations for each Saudi Cargo (in lieu of Seller paying Buyer and Buyer remitting the same
amount to Saudi Arabian), but this arrangement does not and shall not create any direct obligation of Seller to Saudi Arabian. If Buyer and Seller are unable to arrange for direct payment from Seller to Saudi Arabian, Seller shall pay all amounts
due Buyer with respect to Saudi Cargoes into a controlled Buyer account, pursuant to which Seller shall be party to an account agreement (the “Account Agreement”). The Parties agree that the arrangements described in this Appendix
13 apply first Saudi Cargo and may be amended further for future Saudi Cargoes. 
 Payment for each Saudi Cargo shall be due
from Seller to Buyer one Business Day after delivery of good title to such Oil from Buyer to Seller DES Paulsboro or at such other location as is mutually agreed by the Parties, free and clear of all Liens, except for the lien held by the bank that
is party to the Account Agreement. Such Saudi Cargo shall be included in the calculation of OIFIC and the TVM Payment pursuant to Clause 19(g) of the Agreement when Payment becomes due from Seller to Buyer pursuant to this Appendix 13.


  
 Appendix 13

 Page 1 








 If there are any adjustments to the price of any Saudi Cargo under the Saudi Contract after
payment becomes due from Seller to Buyer hereunder (including any adjustment relating to a provisional invoice delivered by Saudi Arabian to Buyer under the Saudi Contract): (a) if the adjustment results in Saudi Arabian making a payment to Buyer
and Seller has title to all or any portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Buyer shall immediately remit the portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned
by Seller upon receipt from Saudi Arabian, and the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil; and (b) if the adjustment results in Buyer making an additional payment to Saudi Arabian, (i) if Seller has title to all or any
portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Seller shall pay the portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned by Seller either directly to Saudi Arabian or
into the controlled Buyer account (in the same manner as described above for the initial payment), and the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil, or (ii) if the adjustment relates to a Saudi Cargo which has been
Delivered in its entirety by Seller to Buyer, such adjustment shall be solely for the account of Buyer. 
 Buyer shall be fully
liable for all obligations, and Seller shall have no obligation to Buyer except as specifically set forth herein, with respect to (i) any payment owing from Buyer to Saudi Arabian (ii) any breach by Buyer of the Saudi Contract, (iii) any termination
of the Saudi Contract other than a termination resulting from Seller’s failure to perform its obligations under the Saudi Contract as “Buyer’s Assignee,” or (iv) any failure or refusal of Saudi Arabian to provide Oil to Buyer or
Seller. Clause 40(c) of the Agreement expressly applies to this Appendix 13, and Saudi Arabian shall in no way be deemed a third party beneficiary of this Agreement, including this Appendix 13. 

As security for the prompt and complete payment and performance in full of all obligations of Buyer to Seller hereunder (including the
hedges and other obligations Seller undertakes in reliance on Buyer’s obligations to sell the Saudi Cargoes to Seller and to later repurchase such Saudi Cargoes in accordance with the terms of the Agreement), Buyer hereby grants to Seller a
security interest in all of Buyer’s right, title and interest in, to and under the following, in each case, whether now owned or existing or hereafter acquired or arising and wherever located: 

(i) All Saudi Cargoes; and 
 (ii) All proceeds, insurance claims and proceeds, products, accessions, additions, substitutions, replacements, rents and profits of or in respect of any or all of the foregoing. 

In connection with the foregoing, Buyer authorizes Seller to file such financing statements pursuant to the UCC as Seller deems necessary
to perfect the foregoing interest. Buyer shall not grant or permit any other security interest in any of the foregoing collateral, except that, subject to the execution of an intercreditor agreement in form and substance satisfactory to Seller,
Buyer may grant a senior security interest in such collateral to Buyer’s third party letter of credit provider (initially UBS AG, Stamford Branch) to secure Buyer’s obligations with respect to letters of credit required to be posted by
Buyer to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract. 

  
 Appendix 13

 Page 2 








 Buyer shall not take any action that would cause Seller to incur an indemnity obligation
pursuant to the Saudi Contract. If Seller under the Saudi Contract is required to defend, indemnify or hold harmless Saudi Arabian or any other party or otherwise becomes liable under the Saudi Contract as a result of the actions or inactions of
Buyer, Buyer shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless Seller for all obligations incurred by Seller thereby. 
 The Parties
acknowledge that the Saudi Contract includes provisions which the Parties desire to amend to clarify ambiguity, and therefore the Parties agree to use their reasonable efforts to affect an amendment of the Saudi Contract to clarify that (a)
Seller’s indemnity obligations in Section 6.6 of the Saudi Contract for Buyer’s actions only relate to “BUYER’s failure to comply with the aforesaid standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures of
SUMED” (bold language to be added) and (b) Seller’s only liability to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract shall be for its own actions or inactions as lifter of the Saudi Cargoes or for the indemnity in Section 6.6 of the Saudi Contract
by adding a provision similar to the following therein; 
 “Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, (a) BUYER’s
ASSIGNEE shall only be liable to SELLER for (i) BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s performance of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s crude oil lifting obligations hereunder and (ii) the indemnification obligations of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE set forth in Section
6.6, and (b) upon the termination of this Agreement, BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s only obligations to SELLER shall be for those obligations which accrued prior to such date of termination, including any incurred under Section 6.6.” 

  
 Appendix 13

 Page 3 








 ATTACHMENT I TO APPENDIX 13 

FORM OF SAUDI CONTRACT 
 [attached] 
 Attachment I to Appendix 13 

Page 1 








 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 CRUDE OIL SALES AGREEMENT 

This is to confirm the Agreement among: 
  

	1.	Parties: 

  

					
	SELLER	 	-	 	SAUDI ARABIAN OIL COMPANY, A COMPANY WITH LIMITED LIABILITY ORGANIZED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA;
			
	BUYER	 	-	 	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE; and
			
	BUYER’s
 ASSIGNEE
	 	-	 	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE

 RECITALS 
 WHEREAS, SELLER desires to sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s Supplier, to deliver to BUYER, and BUYER desires to purchase from SELLER and accept delivery from SELLER, or from SELLER’s
Supplier, a certain quantity of Arabian crude oil of the specification set forth hereinafter; 
 WHEREAS, BUYER desires to assign
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to take delivery of and receive the sold crude oil hereunder and to perform all of BUYER’s crude oil lifting obligations as set forth herein on behalf of BUYER; and 

WHEREAS, SELLER consents to the said assignment subject to the terms and conditions listed herein. 

NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereby agree as follows: 
  

	2.	Term of Agreement: 

 This Agreement shall be effective as of January 1st, 2011 and shall continue in effect through and including December 31st, 2011 with automatic one-year extensions thereafter
unless terminated at the option of either party, other than for cause or in accordance with Paragraph 4.2 below, upon at least sixty (60) days written notice prior to the expiration of the original term or, if applicable, any subsequent
anniversary date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 1 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	3.	Grade, Quantity and Quality: 

  

	 	3.1	Subject to availability and the production policies determined by the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, SELLER shall sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s
Supplier to deliver, to BUYER and BUYER shall buy and lift or receive, or cause BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to lift or receive, from SELLER a total of [REDACTED] barrels per day of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, minus up to ten percent (-10%) at
BUYER’s or SELLER’s option, or plus up to ten percent (+10%) if BUYER so requests and SELLER agrees. Additional volumes of crude oil of similar or different grades may be delivered under this Agreement as the parties may from time to
time agree. 

  

	 	3.2	The availability of each grade of crude oil specified in Paragraph 3.1 will be advised by SELLER from time to time in accordance with the production policies of the
Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Subject to availability, and unless otherwise mutually agreed, the quantities of each grade of crude oil to be lifted or received and purchased by BUYER during the term of this Agreement shall be spread
over the term of this Agreement as evenly as practicable. 

 Deliveries during BUYER’s planned refinery
maintenance or turnaround shall be reduced to such quantities as the parties may mutually agree. In such case, after the period of refinery maintenance and turnaround, deliveries shall be increased from time to time as the parties may mutually
agree, so that BUYER fulfills its obligation to lift or receive and buy the full contractual volume by the end of each annual period during the Agreement beginning with the effective date. 

 

	 	3.3	Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained elsewhere in this Agreement and without prejudice to any other rights or remedies available to SELLER hereunder, if
at any time BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, for any reason other than force majeure (as defined in Paragraph 12.6) or a reason attributable to SELLER, fail to lift or receive and purchase quantities of crude oil in accordance with this Paragraph 3,
SELLER may at one time or from time to time thereafter, at its sole discretion, and upon notice to BUYER, reduce any or all quantities and grades of crude oil which BUYER would have otherwise been entitled to lift and buy. 


 

	 	3.4	The quality of each grade of crude oil delivered hereunder shall be the usual quality of that grade being made available by SELLER at the time of loading of the crude
oil at the SELLER’s loading port in Saudi Arabia. SELLER warrants that it has good and marketable title to the crude oil, free and clear of all charges, liens and encumbrances but THERE ARE NO GUARANTEES OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF
MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR SUITABILITY OF THE CRUDE OIL, FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE, WHICH EXTEND BEYOND THE DESCRIPTION OF THE CRUDE OIL AND ANY SPECIFICATIONS THEREFOR CONTAINED IN THIS AGREEMENT. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 2 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	4.	Price: 

  

	 	4.1	 The Price barrel of each Cargo of Arab [REDACTED] crude oil sold hereunder on [REDACTED] basis shall be the [REDACTED], as calculated below, plus or
minus a [REDACTED]. The [REDACTED] price shall be calculated as the arithmetic average of the [REDACTED], for all the quotation days inclusive during the period from the [REDACTED] of the month [REDACTED] to the Scheduled Month of Delivery, through the [REDACTED].



  

	 	4.2	On or before the fifth (5th) day of each month, SELLER shall notify BUYER of the price differential per barrel of each grade of crude oil to be sold under this
Agreement during the following month (the “Scheduled Month of Delivery”). Within five (5) calendar days after receipt of SELLER’s notification as set forth in the preceding sentence, BUYER may elect to terminate this Agreement by
delivering written notice thereof to SELLER. Unless BUYER elects to terminate this Agreement in accordance with the immediately preceding sentence, the price differential notified by SELLER shall apply. Termination by BUYER in accordance with this
Paragraph 4.2 shall be effective as of the first day of the month following SELLER’s receipt of BUYER’s notice; provided, however, that termination under this or any other provision of this Agreement shall not affect the parties’
rights and obligations with respect to deliveries of crude oil under this Agreement which were made prior to the effective date of termination; and further provided that in the event of termination hereunder or expiration of the Agreement, this
Agreement shall remain in effect with respect to all cargoes of crude oil for which delivery has been confirmed pursuant to Paragraph 6 herein. The differential applicable to such cargoes shall be the differential that was in effect during the month
prior to termination. 

  

	 	4.3	Should completion of physical loading of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE occur before or after the Scheduled Month of Delivery, the price of such
cargo, unless otherwise mutually agreed, shall be calculated using the differential that would apply if completion of physical loading of the said vessel has occurred in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. 


 

	5.	Payment: 

  

	 	5.1	Payment for each parcel of crude oil sold shall be made in the full amount of SELLER’s telexed invoice without discounts or deductions by BUYER to SELLER via
electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to SELLER’s account as follows: 


JPMorgan Chase, New York [REDACTED] 
 under direct [REDACTED] advice to 
 JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

for the account of JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 3 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 Account no. [REDACTED] for further credit to 

The Saudi Arabian Oil Company (Saudi Aramco) 
 Account no. [REDACTED] 
 SELLER shall invoice BUYER on or
before the [REDACTED] day from and including the completion of loading date and BUYER’s payment to SELLER shall be made not later than the [REDACTED] day from and including the bill of lading date. 

If any payment hereunder falls due on a Saturday or a New York banking holiday other than a Monday, payment shall be effected on the
preceding bank business day. If the payment falls due on a Sunday or Monday New York banking holiday, then payment shall be effected on the next bank business day. 
  

	 	5.2	All invoices for crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be sent to BUYER by telex, facsimile, courier or mail (at SELLER’s discretion) in accordance with the
following: 

 John E. Luke 
 Treasurer 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 

Tel.: 973-455-7518 
 Email: john.luke@pbfenergy.com 
 With duplicate copy to: 

John Barone 

Corporate Controller 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 
 Tel.: 973-455-7517 

Email: john.barone@pbfenergy.com 
  

	 	5.3	If it is impossible or impracticable for SELLER to calculate the price for any parcel of crude oil sold hereunder prior to issuance of an invoice therefor, SELLER shall
send to BUYER a provisional invoice and BUYER shall pay said invoice in accordance with Paragraph 5.1. SELLER’s provisional invoice shall be based upon (i) SELLER’s best estimate of the price(s) as provided in Paragraph 4 with
reference to the reference crude(s) and differential(s) applicable to such parcel and (ii) SELLER’s best estimate of the quantity of crude oil delivered, if SELLER has not received inspection report(s) by independent inspector(s) in
accordance with Paragraph 7. 

  

	 	5.4	 As soon as the total amount due for any parcel is determined with reference to price(s) determined under Paragraph 4 and quantity of crude oil
delivered as shown in the inspection report(s) received by SELLER, SELLER shall issue an invoice, which shall set forth adjustments for parcels provisionally invoiced, the settlement date of which shall be the fifth (5th) day after the day of
issuance thereof or the date payment is due pursuant to Paragraph 5.1, whichever is later. Said invoice shall be paid on or before the settlement date by BUYER/SELLER, 



  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 4 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
as appropriate. Said invoice shall include any applicable adjustment(s) due to BUYER or SELLER, the difference between the provisional price and the final price, and a further amount equal to
such difference (i) multiplied by the rate set forth in Paragraph 5.5, (ii) multiplied by the number of days between the date of provisional payment and the settlement date, (iii) divided by 360 days. 


 

	 	5.5	Any amount not paid by either party when due shall bear interest from the date upon which payment was due through the date of payment at a rate equal to the one
(1) month British Bankers Assoc., London interbank offered rate (L.I.B.O.R.) for U.S. Dollar deposits as shown on Reuters screen, reference page ‘LIBOR01’ fixed at 11.00 a.m., London time, on the first banking day of the month in
which payment was due plus one percent (1%). Interest at the rate set forth above, determined on the first banking day of the month in which BUYER’s payment is due, shall also be payable by the party who owes any adjustment pursuant to
Paragraph 5.4, on the amount of such adjustment, from the date on which BUYER’s payment is due through the date such adjustment is paid. All payments of interest by either party under this Agreement shall be made in the full amount due, free of
any withholding tax imposed by any government. 

  

	 	5.6	Any payments by SELLER to BUYER shall be made by electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to BUYER’s account as follows:


 JPMorgan Chase - NY 
 395 North Service Road 
 Melville, New York 11747 

United States 

ABA #021 000 021 
 For further credit to the account of: 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 

Account #844041749 
 Contact: Ms. Barbara Pirozzi 
 Fax: 866-914-7380 

Tel.: 631-755-5180 
 Email: Barbara.pirozzi@jpmchse.com 
  

	 	5.7	For crude oil to be lifted or received under this Agreement, a BUYER shall establish and deliver to SELLER at least ten (10) days prior to the scheduled date of
arrival of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal, an irrevocable standby Letter of Credit issued or confirmed by a bank acceptable to SELLER in accordance with the attached Form L (02/18/08). All bank charges
incurred in connection with the establishment of letters of credit, including without limitation, opening, amendment and correspondent charges, confirmation and all related banking fees, commissions or expenses shall be for BUYER’s account. In
addition, BUYER shall bear all costs of demurrage or any other fees or charges arising from BUYER’s failure to provide a Letter of Credit or confirmation thereof acceptable to SELLER by the date specified. BUYER’s provision of a Letter of
Credit is an express condition precedent to SELLER’s obligation to deliver and sell crude oil under this Agreement. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 5 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	6.	Delivery: 

  

	 	6.1	Subject to agreement of the parties and to the procedures set forth herein, delivery and receipt of the crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be based on FOB
vessels to be supplied by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal at [REDACTED], operated by SUMED (“SELLER’s Supplier”). 

  

	 	6.2	SELLER agrees to deliver or cause to be delivered crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE agree to receive the same or cause the
same to be received from SELLER in accordance with monthly lifting schedules agreed upon; provided, however, that SELLER, while according nondiscriminatory treatment to buyers, shall not be required to furnish a quantity of any grade of crude oil
exceeding the capacity of its facilities. BUYER’s ASSIGNEE performance hereunder shall not relieve BUYER of any of its obligations under this Agreement as further provided in Paragraph 6.7 below. 


 

	 	6.3	SELLER, at its discretion, may cause its affiliate, Bolanter Corporation N.V. (“Bolanter”), or such other third party affiliated with SELLER as SELLER shall
designate in writing (“Third Party Affiliate”), to perform SELLER’s obligation to deliver crude oil under this Paragraph 6, provided SELLER’s so doing shall not relieve SELLER of any of its obligations under this Agreement.


  

	 	6.4	 BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule by the fifth (5th) day of each month preceding the Scheduled Month of Delivery. BUYER shall also submit at this time a provisional
nomination schedule for the first fifteen (15) days of the month following the Scheduled Month of Delivery. If the fifth (5th) day is a non-working day in London, then the BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule and a provisional
nomination schedule by the nearest preceding working day in London. The requested monthly lifting schedule and provisional nomination schedule shall contain a preferred one (1) day date for each lifting. SELLER shall attempt to accommodate
BUYER’s proposed schedule but shall only guarantee lifting dates during the last ten (10) days of the Scheduled Month of Delivery, using its best efforts to provide lifting dates during the five (5) days preceding the last ten
(10) days in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. The vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port on the accepted date if it arrives at the customary anchorage within one (1) day before
or one (1) day after the date accepted by SELLER. 


 Any subsequent revisions requested by the BUYER and
accepted by the SELLER shall be limited to a one (1) day acceptance range and the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port only on the accepted date. 

 

	 	6.5	 SELLER shall authorize SUMED to deliver the crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall arrange with SUMED to




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 6 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
lift and receive delivery of the crude oil. Delivery and lifting of crude oil at [REDACTED] shall be subject to and in accordance with the standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices
and procedures of SUMED. BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE also agree to comply with the operation, lifting, and nomination procedures and obligations required of SELLER, pursuant to the Long Term Transportation Agreement between Bolanter and SUMED
(the “Transportation Agreement”). 

  

	 	6.6	BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless SELLER, Bolanter, and any Third Party Affiliate from and against all claims, demands and
liabilities of any kind whatsoever asserted against SELLER, Bolanter, or any Third Party Affiliate by any party as a result of BUYER’s failure to comply with the aforesaid terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures, or as a
result of deballasting of dirty ballast water by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 

  

	 	6.7	Since SELLER is neither the terminal operator nor in control of any of the terminal operations, it is expressly understood and agreed that SELLER will not be liable to
BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE for any demurrage, unless such demurrage is caused by SELLER’s failure to make the crude oil available for delivery. In those instances in which demurrage is incurred because of SELLER’s failure, BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall present its claim for reimbursement to SELLER at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for demurrage claims set out in the applicable terminal regulations. Where BUYER’s demurrage
claim does not arise from SELLER’s failure, as an accommodation to BUYER, SELLER will present to the terminal operator, on behalf of BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, any claim for demurrage that is presented by BUYER to SELLER at least sixty
(60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for such demurrage claims, as set out in the applicable terminal regulations. After SELLER, on BUYER’s behalf, has presented a demurrage claim to the terminal operator, SELLER will
follow up and make reasonable efforts, short of arbitration or litigation, to effect recovery. SELLER will promptly remit to BUYER any monies received from the terminal operator in whole or partial satisfaction of the demurrage claim of BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE with the terminal operator. 

  

	 	6.8	Notwithstanding anything else to the contrary elsewhere in the Agreement, should SELLER in its sole judgment determine that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has failed in any
respect to perform in accordance with its obligations under this Agreement, or that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has become bankrupt or insolvent or otherwise unable to meet its financial obligations, BUYER shall continue to be directly liable to SELLER
for the performance of the obligations assigned to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE hereunder. Notwithstanding the foregoing, all Bills of Lading issued hereunder shall name BUYER as consignee. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 7 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	7.	Measurement and Inspection 

  

	 	7.1	BUYER shall arrange for a mutually acceptable independent inspector to verify the quality and quantity of the crude oil delivered to BUYER or to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE,
and shall cause said inspector to promptly provide to SELLER a copy of the inspector’s report and all other documentation relating to the inspection. The cost of such inspection shall be shared equally by BUYER and SELLER.


  

	 	7.2	The net quantity of crude oil delivered for title transfer and used by SELLER for the purpose of invoicing and for BUYER’s payment shall be determined by using
meters at SELLER’s delivery sites where provable meters are available. Alternatively, SELLER’s delivery tank volumes as measured by manual tank gauges in accordance with API standards shall be the basis for the total delivered quantity.


  

	 	7.3	The net quantity of crude oil delivered shall be calculated by deducting from the total quantity, as determined above, both free water and suspended sediment and water
(S&W) after completion of cargo transfer. Whenever possible, and provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of SELLER’s delivery sites referenced hereinabove, both free water and suspended S&W shall be determined from
S&W analysis of a representative sample taken from an automatic inline sampler. Alternatively, if such a sample is not possible, or if the independent inspector determines that the sampler did not perform in accordance with API MPMS Chapter 8.2,
the free water deduction shall be based on the free water increase of BUYER’s vessel’s tanks measured immediately before and after cargo receipt and the suspended S&W deduction shall be determined from analysis made on a composite
sample composed of individual samples taken from BUYER’s vessel’s tanks after cargo receipt. Provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of the delivery sites referenced herein, all gross volumes determined hereunder shall
be adjusted to 60 degrees F by applying API-IP Table 6A volume correction factors and S&W deductions used in determining Net Standard Volume shall be based on Water by Karl Fischer ASTM 
(D-4928) and Sediment by Filtration (D-4807).


  

	 	7.4	NOTICE OF ANY CLAIM BY EITHER PARTY, EITHER AS TO SHORTAGE IN QUANTITY OR BASED ON THE CONTENTION THAT THE CRUDE OIL DELIVERED IS NOT THE USUAL QUALITY OF THAT GRADE
BEING MADE AVAILABLE BY SELLER AT THE TIME OF LOADING OF THE CRUDE OIL AT SELLER’S LOADING PORT IN SAUDI ARABIA SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE OTHER PARTY, IN WRITING, WITH FULL SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION, WITHIN NINETY (90) DAYS AFTER THE
DELIVERY DATE. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE DEEMED A WAIVER OF ANY SUCH CLAIM. WITH RESPECT TO ANY SUCH CLAIM FOR WHICH A PARTY GIVES NOTICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION, THAT PARTY SHALL COMMENCE A PROCEEDING
PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH 10 WITHIN TWO (2) YEARS FROM THE DELIVERY DATE OR THE CLAIM SHALL BE FOREVER BARRED. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 8 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	8.	Title and Risk of Loss: 


Title to and risk of loss of all crude oil sold hereunder shall pass to BUYER at the point at which the loading terminal’s loading
line connects with the permanent hose connection of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 
  

	9.	Termination for Cause: 


SELLER or BUYER shall have the right to terminate this Agreement upon written notice to the other party in the event of a material breach
(including without limitation anticipatory breach) by the other party of any of its terms, but without prejudice to the rights of either party theretofore accrued with respect to this Agreement (including without limitation the right of either party
to damages arising from such breach or prior breaches hereof). Material breach by BUYER shall include, without limitation, BUYER’s failure to lift and buy crude oil as required in Paragraph 3 hereof or BUYER’s failure to comply with any of
the Payment provisions of paragraph 5. The delay or failure on the part of either party hereto to insist, in any one instance or more, upon strict performance of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement, or to exercise any right or privilege
herein conferred shall not be construed as a waiver of any such terms, conditions, rights or privileges, but the same shall continue and remain in full force and effect. All rights and remedies are cumulative. 

 

	10.	Disputes: 

 Any dispute,
controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this Agreement, together with any amendments thereto which may be issued from time to time, or the breach or termination or invalidity thereof, which is not settled by agreement between the parties
shall be finally settled in accordance with the Arbitration Regulations and the Rules for Implementation of the Arbitration Regulations for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia by three neutral and impartial arbitrators, one to be appointed by each party and
the third to be appointed by the two so chosen. The arbitrators shall base their award only upon the evidence presented to them, the terms of this Agreement and the laws of Saudi Arabia. This arbitration provision shall be specifically enforceable
by either party under the Regulations, and the arbitrators’ award shall be final and binding on the parties. 
  

	11.	Destination: 

 The country
of destination of the crude oil delivered hereunder shall be a country in North America and the delivery of such shall be subject to the export laws and regulations of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The country of destination of crude oil delivered
hereunder shall be confirmed and attested to by BUYER to SELLER not later than one hundred and twenty days (120) days after the Bill of Lading date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 9 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	12.	Other Terms: 

  

	 	12.1	This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the successors and assigns of the parties to this Agreement; however, neither party may assign or
transfer this Agreement, either in whole or in part, without first obtaining the written consent of the other, which shall not be unreasonably withheld. 

  

	 	12.2	In no event shall either party be liable in connection herewith or with respect to operations related hereto, whether in tort, contract or otherwise, for special,
indirect or consequential damages. 

  

	 	12.3	Except as otherwise required to implement this Agreement, BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE undertake to treat the contents of this Agreement as strictly confidential.
For violation of this undertaking by BUYER OR BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, SELLER shall have the right to immediately cancel this Agreement, without any liability as a result of such cancellation, upon giving notice to BUYER. 


 

	 	12.4	This Agreement, and any amendments hereto, consisting of this signed document, any attachments hereto and other documents referred to herein, is intended by the parties
as a final expression of their agreement and is intended also as a complete and exclusive statement of the terms of their agreement. 

  

	 	12.5	Subject to Paragraph 10, the laws and regulations of the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia shall govern the interpretation and performance of this Agreement and
any further agreements of that may result from it. 

  

	 	12.6	Each party shall be relieved from the performance of any obligation, other than the obligation to make payments for amounts due hereunder, during the time and to the
extent performance of such obligation is prevented or restricted as a result of a force majeure event, The term “force majeure” as used in this Agreement shall mean any act, event, cause or occurrence rendering a party unable to perform
its obligations which is not within the reasonable control of such party. BUYER and SELLER specifically agree that SELLER’s inability to perform all, or any part, of this Agreement due to Government action or directive shall constitute a force
majeure event; however, the term force majeure shall not apply to those events which merely make it more difficult or costly for BUYER to perform its obligations hereunder. BUYER and SELLER further agree that at the conclusion of any force majeure
event, neither BUYER nor SELLER shall have any obligation to each other with respect to any quantities of crude oil not delivered as a consequence of such force majeure event. No condition of force majeure shall operate to extend the term of this
Agreement. 

  

	 	12.7	 If at any time SELLER determines that reasonable grounds for insecurity have arisen with respect to BUYER’s performance of any of BUYER’s
obligations under this Agreement, SELLER may demand adequate assurance of due performance by BUYER, and until SELLER receives such assurance SELLER may suspend its performance of obligations under this Agreement. BUYER’s




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 10 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
failure to provide within a reasonable time not exceeding ten (10) days such assurance of due performance as is adequate under the circumstances will constitute a material breach of this
Agreement. 

  

	 	12.8	Dues and other charges on the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading port and terminal shall be for BUYER’s account. The amount of any
taxes, duties, imposts, fees, charges and dues of every description imposed or levied by any governmental, local or port authority on the crude oil supplied hereunder, or on its export, delivery, transportation, ownership, sale or use, or on any
vessel used in its transportation, in respect of any stage after such crude oil passes the tankship’s permanent hose connection at the loading port, shall be for BUYER’s account. 


 

	 	12.9	The parties hereto contemplate that all the crude oil purchased under this Agreement shall be processed by BUYER and accordingly, the parties contemplate that the BUYER
will not resell the crude oil purchased under this Agreement in its original form or blend it with other crude oils for purpose of resale. 

  

	 	12.10	 Compliance with ISPS CODE: 

  

			
	12.10.1	 	SELLER and BUYER shall comply with the International Code for the Security of Ships and Port Facilities and relevant amendments to Chapter XI of the International Convention for
the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 (SOLAS), hereinafter (ISPS Code), in accordance with Form-I of this Agreement, which shall govern the parties rights and obligations with respect to such compliance.
		
	12.10.2	 	In the event of any conflict between this Agreement and its Form-I (ISPS CODE TERMS AND CONDITIONS), the terms and conditions of Form-I shall prevail.


 * * * * * * * * 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 11 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 IN WITNESS of this Agreement, the parties have caused it to be signed on the dates shown below in three
copies, each of which shall serve as an original. 
  

									
	 For and on behalf of BUYER:
 REPRESENTED BY:
	 		 	For and on behalf of SELLER:
	 		 	REPRESENTED BY:
			
	 




	 		 	 





	(Name)	 		 		 	Mohammed H. Khazindar
	(Title)	 		 		 	Manager, Crude Oil Sales and Marketing Department
					
	Date:	 	 1/5/11
	 		 	Date	 	 1/29/11

					
	Witness:	 	 




	 		 	Witness:	 	 





					
	Date:	 	 1/5/11
	 		 	Date	 	 1/17/2011

				
	 For and on behalf of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE:
 REPRESENTED BY
	 		 		 	
				
	 




	 		 		 	
	(Name)	 	R.M. Jones	 		 		 	
	(Title)	 	PRESIDENT	 		 		 	
					
	Date:	 	 6/1/11
	 		 		 	
					
	Witness:	 	 




	 		 		 	
					
	Date:	 	 1/4/11
	 		 		 	

  
 



 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 12 of 12









 SPECIFIC TERMS IN THIS EXHIBIT HAVE BEEN REDACTED BECAUSE CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR THOSE TERMS HAS BEEN
REQUESTED. THE REDACTED MATERIAL HAS BEEN SEPARATELY FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, AND THE TERMS HAVE BEEN MARKED AT THE APPROPRIATE PLACE WITH THE WORD “[REDACTED]”. 

SECOND AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND 
 SERVICES AGREEMENT 
 THIS SECOND AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK
SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND SERVICES AGREEMENT made and entered into as of April 26, 2011, by and between Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc., a Delaware corporation (“Seller”), and Paulsboro Refining Company LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company (“Buyer”), amends that certain Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement between Seller and Buyer (as assignee from PBF Holding Company LLC) dated December 16, 2010 as amended by that
certain First Amendment to Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement dated January 7, 2011 (collectively, the “Original Agreement”). 
 WITNESSETH: 
 WHEREAS, the parties hereto desire to modify the terms
of the Original Agreement pursuant to the terms hereof (defined terms not defined herein are defined in the Original Agreement). 
 NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the parties hereto agree as follows: 

1. Appendices. Appendix 13 is hereby amended by replacing the entirety of Appendix 13 with the Appendix 13 attached hereto,
and incorporated herein by reference, as Exhibit A. 
 2. No Other Modification. Except as specifically set
forth above, the Original Agreement shall remain in full force and effect in all respects. 
 [Signature page
follows] 







 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Amendment as of the date
first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	 





	Name:	 	 Charles O’Brien II

	Title:	 	 SECRETARY & GENERAL COUNSEL

	
	PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	 





	Name:	 	 Jeffrey Dill

	Title:	 	 Secretary



 [Signature Page to Second Amendment to Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement]








 Exhibit A 

APPENDIX 13 – SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS 
 On or about the date of the execution of that certain First Amendment to this Agreement, Buyer entered into a contract (the “Saudi Contract”), in substantially the form of Attachment I to
this Appendix 13, with Saudi Arabian providing for the supply of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C) from Saudi Arabian to Buyer, with Seller executing the Saudi Contract as “BUYER’S ASSIGNEE” for the limited purposes set forth therein.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Clause 14(a) of this Agreement, Seller shall provide [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] per Barrel with respect to all volumes of Oil purchased by Buyer from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract (each such
volume, a “Saudi Cargo”). Shipping Services for each Saudi Cargo (which shall be calculated and paid for by Buyer in the same manner as for the Cargoes being sold by Seller under the Agreement) shall be set using the “Delivery
Method” unless otherwise agreed upon by the Parties. 
 Buyer shall sell and transfer title to each
Saudi Cargo to Seller on the earlier of (i) the 23rd day
after the Bill of Lading date or (ii) arrival of such Saudi Cargo DES Paulsboro (the “Saudi Title Transfer Date”) at the same price Buyer purchases such Saudi Cargo from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract; provided that Seller
and Buyer may mutually agree on a separate delivery point. Buyer shall deliver to Seller on the Business Day after the Saudi Title Transfer Date the original Bill of Lading corresponding to such Saudi Cargo with appropriate endorsements to Seller
together with such other acceptable documentation as may be requested by Seller with respect to each such sale. Seller may purchase futures contracts on the Saudi Cargoes in connection with the Oil pricing terms set forth in the Saudi Contract, in
the same manner as for other Cargoes owned by Seller pursuant to Clause 9 and the other provisions of the Agreement, and the pricing for the subsequent resale of such Cargo by Seller to Buyer upon Delivery from Seller to Buyer shall be based on such
futures contract pricing. 
 Upon receipt of each invoice from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract, Buyer shall immediately
deliver an exact copy of such invoice to Seller. Buyer and Seller shall use reasonable efforts to arrange with Saudi Arabian to permit direct payment by Seller to Saudi Arabian of Buyer’s obligations for each Saudi Cargo (in lieu of Seller
paying Buyer and Buyer remitting the same amount to Saudi Arabian), but this arrangement does not and shall not create any direct obligation of Seller to Saudi Arabian. If Buyer and Seller are unable to arrange for direct payment from Seller to
Saudi Arabian, Seller shall pay all amounts due Buyer with respect to Saudi Cargoes into a controlled Buyer account, pursuant to which Seller shall be party to an account agreement (the “Account Agreement”). The Parties agree that
the arrangements described in this Appendix 13 may be amended further for future Saudi Cargoes. 
 Payment for each Saudi Cargo
shall be due from Seller to Buyer one Business Day after delivery of good title to such Oil from Buyer on the Saudi Title Transfer Date, free and clear of all Liens, except for any lien held by the bank that is party to the Account Agreement. Such
Saudi Cargo shall be included in the calculation of OIFIC and the TVM Payment pursuant to Clause 19(g) of the Agreement when payment becomes due from Seller to Buyer pursuant to this Appendix 13. 

  
 Appendix 13

 Page 1 








 If there are any adjustments to the price of any Saudi Cargo under the Saudi Contract after
payment becomes due from Seller to Buyer hereunder (including any adjustment relating to a provisional invoice delivered by Saudi Arabian to Buyer under the Saudi Contract); (a) if the adjustment results in Saudi Arabian making a payment to Buyer
and Seller has title to all or any portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Buyer shall immediately remit the portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned
by Seller upon receipt from Saudi Arabian, and the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil; and (b) if the adjustment results in Buyer making an additional payment to Saudi Arabian, (i) if Seller has title to all or any
portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Seller shall pay the portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned by Seller either directly to Saudi Arabian or
into the controlled Buyer account (in the same manner as described above for the initial payment), and the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil, or (ii) if the adjustment relates to a Saudi Cargo which has been
Delivered in its entirety by Seller to Buyer, such adjustment shall be solely for the account of Buyer. 

Buyer shall be fully liable for all obligations, and Seller shall have no obligation to Buyer except as specifically
set forth herein, with respect to (i) any payment owing from Buyer to Saudi Arabian (ii) any breach by Buyer of the Saudi Contract, (iii) any termination of the Saudi Contract other than a termination resulting from Seller’s failure to perform
its obligations under the Saudi Contract as “Buyer’s Assignee,” or (iv) any failure or refusal of Saudi Arabian to provide Oil to Buyer or Seller. Clause 40(c) of the Agreement expressly applies to this Appendix 13, and Saudi Arabian
shall in no way be deemed a third party beneficiary of this Agreement, including this Appendix 13. 
 As security for the prompt
and complete payment and performance in full of all obligations of Buyer to Seller hereunder (including the hedges and other obligations Seller undertakes in reliance on Buyer’s obligations to sell the Saudi Cargoes to Seller and to later
repurchase such Saudi Cargoes in accordance with the terms of the Agreement), Buyer hereby grants to Seller a security interest in all of Buyer’s right, title and interest in, to and under the following, in each case, whether now owned or
existing or hereafter acquired or arising and wherever located: 
 (i) All Saudi Cargoes; and 

(ii) All proceeds, insurance claims and proceeds, products, accessions, additions, substitutions, replacements, rents and
profits of or in respect of any or all of the foregoing. 
 In connection with the foregoing, Buyer authorizes Seller to file
such financing statements pursuant to the UCC as Seller deems necessary to perfect the foregoing interest. Buyer shall not grant or permit any other security interest in any of the foregoing collateral, except that, subject to the execution of an
intercreditor agreement in form and substance satisfactory to Seller, Buyer may grant a senior security interest in such collateral to Buyer’s third party letter of credit provider (BNP) to secure Buyer’s obligations with respect to
letters of credit required to be posted by Buyer to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract. 

  
 Appendix 13

 Page 2 








 Buyer shall not take any action that would cause Seller to incur an indemnity obligation
pursuant to the Saudi Contract. If Seller under the Saudi Contract is required to defend, indemnify or hold harmless Saudi Arabian or any other party or otherwise becomes liable under the Saudi Contract as a result of the actions or inactions of
Buyer, Buyer shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless Seller for all obligations incurred by Seller thereby. 
 The Parties
acknowledge that the Saudi Contract includes provisions which the Parties desire to amend to clarify ambiguity, and therefore the Parties agree to use their reasonable efforts to affect an amendment of the Saudi Contract to clarify that (a)
Seller’s indemnity obligations in Section 6.6 of the Saudi Contract for Buyer’s actions only relate to “BUYER’s failure to comply with the aforesaid standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures of
SUMED” (bold language to be added) and (b) Seller’s only liability to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract shall be for its own actions or inactions as lifter of the Saudi Cargoes or for the indemnity in Section 6.6 of the Saudi
Contract by adding a provision similar to the following therein: 
 “Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, (a)
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall only be liable to SELLER for (i) BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s performance of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s crude oil lifting obligations hereunder and (ii) the indemnification obligations of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE set forth
in Section 6.6, and (b) upon the termination of this Agreement, BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s only obligations to SELLER shall be for those obligations which accrued prior to such date of termination, including any incurred under Section 6.6.”


  
 Appendix 13

 Page 3 








 ATTACHMENT I TO APPENDIX 13 

FORM OF SAUDI CONTRACT 
 [attached] 
 Attachment I to Appendix 13 

Page 1 








 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 CRUDE OIL SALES AGREEMENT 

This is to confirm the Agreement among: 
  

	1.	Parties: 

  

					
	SELLER	 	-	 	SAUDI ARABIAN OIL COMPANY, A COMPANY WITH LIMITED LIABILITY ORGANIZED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA;
			
	BUYER	 	-	 	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE; and
			
	BUYER’s
 ASSIGNEE
	 	-	 	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE

 RECITALS 
 WHEREAS, SELLER desires to sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s Supplier, to deliver to BUYER, and BUYER desires to purchase from SELLER and accept delivery from SELLER, or from SELLER’s
Supplier, a certain quantity of Arabian crude oil of the specification set forth hereinafter; 
 WHEREAS, BUYER desires to assign
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to take delivery of and receive the sold crude oil hereunder and to perform all of BUYER’s crude oil lifting obligations as set forth herein on behalf of BUYER; and 

WHEREAS, SELLER consents to the said assignment subject to the terms and conditions listed herein. 

NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereby agree as follows: 
  

	2.	Term of Agreement: 

 This Agreement shall be effective as of January 1st, 2011 and shall continue in effect through and including December 31st, 2011 with automatic one-year extensions thereafter
unless terminated at the option of either party, other than for cause or in accordance with Paragraph 4.2 below, upon at least sixty (60) days written notice prior to the expiration of the original term or, if applicable, any subsequent
anniversary date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 1 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	3.	Grade, Quantity and Quality: 

  

	 	3.1	Subject to availability and the production policies determined by the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, SELLER shall sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s
Supplier to deliver, to BUYER and BUYER shall buy and lift or receive, or cause BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to lift or receive, from SELLER a total of [REDACTED] barrels per day of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, minus up to ten percent (-10%) at
BUYER’s or SELLER’s option, or plus up to ten percent (+10%) if BUYER so requests and SELLER agrees. Additional volumes of crude oil of similar or different grades may be delivered under this Agreement as the parties may from time to
time agree. 

  

	 	3.2	The availability of each grade of crude oil specified in Paragraph 3.1 will be advised by SELLER from time to time in accordance with the production policies of the
Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Subject to availability, and unless otherwise mutually agreed, the quantities of each grade of crude oil to be lifted or received and purchased by BUYER during the term of this Agreement shall be spread
over the term of this Agreement as evenly as practicable. 

 Deliveries during BUYER’s planned refinery
maintenance or turnaround shall be reduced to such quantities as the parties may mutually agree. In such case, after the period of refinery maintenance and turnaround, deliveries shall be increased from time to time as the parties may mutually
agree, so that BUYER fulfills its obligation to lift or receive and buy the full contractual volume by the end of each annual period during the Agreement beginning with the effective date. 

 

	 	3.3	Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained elsewhere in this Agreement and without prejudice to any other rights or remedies available to SELLER hereunder, if
at any time BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, for any reason other than force majeure (as defined in Paragraph 12.6) or a reason attributable to SELLER, fail to lift or receive and purchase quantities of crude oil in accordance with this Paragraph 3,
SELLER may at one time or from time to time thereafter, at its sole discretion, and upon notice to BUYER, reduce any or all quantities and grades of crude oil which BUYER would have otherwise been entitled to lift and buy. 


 

	 	3.4	The quality of each grade of crude oil delivered hereunder shall be the usual quality of that grade being made available by SELLER at the time of loading of the crude
oil at the SELLER’s loading port in Saudi Arabia. SELLER warrants that it has good and marketable title to the crude oil, free and clear of all charges, liens and encumbrances but THERE ARE NO GUARANTEES OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF
MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR SUITABILITY OF THE CRUDE OIL, FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE, WHICH EXTEND BEYOND THE DESCRIPTION OF THE CRUDE OIL AND ANY SPECIFICATIONS THEREFOR CONTAINED IN THIS AGREEMENT. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 2 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	4.	Price: 

  

	 	4.1	 The Price barrel of each Cargo of Arab [REDACTED] crude oil sold hereunder on [REDACTED] basis shall be the [REDACTED], as calculated below, plus or
minus a [REDACTED]. The [REDACTED] price shall be calculated as the arithmetic average of the [REDACTED], for all the quotation days inclusive during the period from the [REDACTED] of the month [REDACTED] to the Scheduled Month of Delivery, through
the [REDACTED]. 


  

	 	4.2	On or before the fifth (5th) day of each month, SELLER shall notify BUYER of the price differential per barrel of each grade of crude oil to be sold under this
Agreement during the following month (the “Scheduled Month of Delivery”). Within five (5) calendar days after receipt of SELLER’s notification as set forth in the preceding sentence, BUYER may elect to terminate this Agreement by
delivering written notice thereof to SELLER. Unless BUYER elects to terminate this Agreement in accordance with the immediately preceding sentence, the price differential notified by SELLER shall apply. Termination by BUYER in accordance with this
Paragraph 4.2 shall be effective as of the first day of the month following SELLER’s receipt of BUYER’s notice; provided, however, that termination under this or any other provision of this Agreement shall not affect the parties’
rights and obligations with respect to deliveries of crude oil under this Agreement which were made prior to the effective date of termination; and further provided that in the event of termination hereunder or expiration of the Agreement, this
Agreement shall remain in effect with respect to all cargoes of crude oil for which delivery has been confirmed pursuant to Paragraph 6 herein. The differential applicable to such cargoes shall be the differential that was in effect during the month
prior to termination. 

  

	 	4.3	Should completion of physical loading of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE occur before or after the Scheduled Month of Delivery, the price of such
cargo, unless otherwise mutually agreed, shall be calculated using the differential that would apply if completion of physical loading of the said vessel has occurred in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. 


 

	5.	Payment: 

  

	 	5.1	Payment for each parcel of crude oil sold shall be made in the full amount of SELLER’s telexed invoice without discounts or deductions by BUYER to SELLER via
electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to SELLER’s account as follows: 


JPMorgan Chase, New York [REDACTED] 
 under direct [REDACTED] advice to 
 JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

for the account of JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 3 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 Account no. [REDACTED] for further credit to 

The Saudi Arabian Oil Company (Saudi Aramco) 
 Account no. [REDACTED] 
 SELLER shall invoice BUYER on or
before the [REDACTED] day from and including the completion of loading date and BUYER’s payment to SELLER shall be made not later than the [REDACTED] day from and including the bill of lading date. 

If any payment hereunder falls due on a Saturday or a New York banking holiday other than a Monday, payment shall be effected on the
preceding bank business day. If the payment falls due on a Sunday or Monday New York banking holiday, then payment shall be effected on the next bank business day. 
  

	 	5.2	All invoices for crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be sent to BUYER by telex, facsimile, courier or mail (at SELLER’s discretion) in accordance with the
following: 

 John E. Luke 
 Treasurer 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 

Tel.: 973-455-7518 
 Email: john.luke@pbfenergy.com 
 With duplicate copy to: 

John Barone 

Corporate Controller 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 
 Tel.: 973-455-7517 

Email: john.barone@pbfenergy.com 
  

	 	5.3	If it is impossible or impracticable for SELLER to calculate the price for any parcel of crude oil sold hereunder prior to issuance of an invoice therefor, SELLER shall
send to BUYER a provisional invoice and BUYER shall pay said invoice in accordance with Paragraph 5.1. SELLER’s provisional invoice shall be based upon (i) SELLER’s best estimate of the price(s) as provided in Paragraph 4 with
reference to the reference crude(s) and differential(s) applicable to such parcel and (ii) SELLER’s best estimate of the quantity of crude oil delivered, if SELLER has not received inspection report(s) by independent inspector(s) in
accordance with Paragraph 7. 

  

	 	5.4	 As soon as the total amount due for any parcel is determined with reference to price(s) determined under Paragraph 4 and quantity of crude oil
delivered as shown in the inspection report(s) received by SELLER, SELLER shall issue an invoice, which shall set forth adjustments for parcels provisionally invoiced, the settlement date of which shall be the fifth (5th) day after the day of
issuance thereof or the date payment is due pursuant to Paragraph 5.1, whichever is later. Said invoice shall be paid on or before the settlement date by BUYER/SELLER, 



  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 4 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
as appropriate. Said invoice shall include any applicable adjustment(s) due to BUYER or SELLER, the difference between the provisional price and the final price, and a further amount equal to
such difference (i) multiplied by the rate set forth in Paragraph 5.5, (ii) multiplied by the number of days between the date of provisional payment and the settlement date, (iii) divided by 360 days. 


 

	 	5.5	Any amount not paid by either party when due shall bear interest from the date upon which payment was due through the date of payment at a rate equal to the one
(1) month British Bankers Assoc., London interbank offered rate (L.I.B.O.R.) for U.S. Dollar deposits as shown on Reuters screen, reference page ‘LIBOR01’ fixed at 11.00 a.m., London time, on the first banking day of the month in
which payment was due plus one percent (1%). Interest at the rate set forth above, determined on the first banking day of the month in which BUYER’s payment is due, shall also be payable by the party who owes any adjustment pursuant to
Paragraph 5.4, on the amount of such adjustment, from the date on which BUYER’s payment is due through the date such adjustment is paid. All payments of interest by either party under this Agreement shall be made in the full amount due, free of
any withholding tax imposed by any government. 

  

	 	5.6	Any payments by SELLER to BUYER shall be made by electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to BUYER’s account as follows:


 JPMorgan Chase - NY 
 395 North Service Road 
 Melville, New York 11747 

United States 

ABA #021 000 021 
 For further credit to the account of: 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 

Account #844041749 
 Contact: Ms. Barbara Pirozzi 
 Fax: 866-914-7380 

Tel.: 631-755-5180 
 Email: Barbara.pirozzi@jpmchse.com 
  

	 	5.7	For crude oil to be lifted or received under this Agreement, a BUYER shall establish and deliver to SELLER at least ten (10) days prior to the scheduled date of
arrival of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal, an irrevocable standby Letter of Credit issued or confirmed by a bank acceptable to SELLER in accordance with the attached Form L (02/18/08). All bank charges
incurred in connection with the establishment of letters of credit, including without limitation, opening, amendment and correspondent charges, confirmation and all related banking fees, commissions or expenses shall be for BUYER’s account. In
addition, BUYER shall bear all costs of demurrage or any other fees or charges arising from BUYER’s failure to provide a Letter of Credit or confirmation thereof acceptable to SELLER by the date specified. BUYER’s provision of a Letter of
Credit is an express condition precedent to SELLER’s obligation to deliver and sell crude oil under this Agreement. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 5 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	6.	Delivery: 

  

	 	6.1	Subject to agreement of the parties and to the procedures set forth herein, delivery and receipt of the crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be based on FOB
vessels to be supplied by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal at [REDACTED], operated by SUMED (“SELLER’s Supplier”). 

  

	 	6.2	SELLER agrees to deliver or cause to be delivered crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE agree to receive the same or cause the
same to be received from SELLER in accordance with monthly lifting schedules agreed upon; provided, however, that SELLER, while according nondiscriminatory treatment to buyers, shall not be required to furnish a quantity of any grade of crude oil
exceeding the capacity of its facilities. BUYER’s ASSIGNEE performance hereunder shall not relieve BUYER of any of its obligations under this Agreement as further provided in Paragraph 6.7 below. 


 

	 	6.3	SELLER, at its discretion, may cause its affiliate, Bolanter Corporation N.V. (“Bolanter”), or such other third party affiliated with SELLER as SELLER shall
designate in writing (“Third Party Affiliate”), to perform SELLER’s obligation to deliver crude oil under this Paragraph 6, provided SELLER’s so doing shall not relieve SELLER of any of its obligations under this Agreement.


  

	 	6.4	 BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule by the fifth (5th) day of each month preceding the Scheduled Month of Delivery. BUYER shall also submit at this time a provisional
nomination schedule for the first fifteen (15) days of the month following the Scheduled Month of Delivery. If the fifth (5th) day is a non-working day in London, then the BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule and a provisional
nomination schedule by the nearest preceding working day in London. The requested monthly lifting schedule and provisional nomination schedule shall contain a preferred one (1) day date for each lifting. SELLER shall attempt to accommodate
BUYER’s proposed schedule but shall only guarantee lifting dates during the last ten (10) days of the Scheduled Month of Delivery, using its best efforts to provide lifting dates during the five (5) days preceding the last ten
(10) days in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. The vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port on the accepted date if it arrives at the customary anchorage within one (1) day before
or one (1) day after the date accepted by SELLER. 


 Any subsequent revisions requested by the BUYER and
accepted by the SELLER shall be limited to a one (1) day acceptance range and the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port only on the accepted date. 

 

	 	6.5	 SELLER shall authorize SUMED to deliver the crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall arrange with SUMED to




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 6 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
lift and receive delivery of the crude oil. Delivery and lifting of crude oil at [REDACTED] shall be subject to and in accordance with the standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices
and procedures of SUMED. BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE also agree to comply with the operation, lifting, and nomination procedures and obligations required of SELLER, pursuant to the Long Term Transportation Agreement between Bolanter and SUMED
(the “Transportation Agreement”). 

  

	 	6.6	BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless SELLER, Bolanter, and any Third Party Affiliate from and against all claims, demands and
liabilities of any kind whatsoever asserted against SELLER, Bolanter, or any Third Party Affiliate by any party as a result of BUYER’s failure to comply with the aforesaid terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures, or as a
result of deballasting of dirty ballast water by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 

  

	 	6.7	Since SELLER is neither the terminal operator nor in control of any of the terminal operations, it is expressly understood and agreed that SELLER will not be liable to
BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE for any demurrage, unless such demurrage is caused by SELLER’s failure to make the crude oil available for delivery. In those instances in which demurrage is incurred because of SELLER’s failure, BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall present its claim for reimbursement to SELLER at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for demurrage claims set out in the applicable terminal regulations. Where BUYER’s demurrage
claim does not arise from SELLER’s failure, as an accommodation to BUYER, SELLER will present to the terminal operator, on behalf of BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, any claim for demurrage that is presented by BUYER to SELLER at least sixty
(60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for such demurrage claims, as set out in the applicable terminal regulations. After SELLER, on BUYER’s behalf, has presented a demurrage claim to the terminal operator, SELLER will
follow up and make reasonable efforts, short of arbitration or litigation, to effect recovery. SELLER will promptly remit to BUYER any monies received from the terminal operator in whole or partial satisfaction of the demurrage claim of BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE with the terminal operator. 

  

	 	6.8	Notwithstanding anything else to the contrary elsewhere in the Agreement, should SELLER in its sole judgment determine that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has failed in any
respect to perform in accordance with its obligations under this Agreement, or that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has become bankrupt or insolvent or otherwise unable to meet its financial obligations, BUYER shall continue to be directly liable to SELLER
for the performance of the obligations assigned to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE hereunder. Notwithstanding the foregoing, all Bills of Lading issued hereunder shall name BUYER as consignee. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 7 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	7.	Measurement and Inspection 

  

	 	7.1	BUYER shall arrange for a mutually acceptable independent inspector to verify the quality and quantity of the crude oil delivered to BUYER or to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE,
and shall cause said inspector to promptly provide to SELLER a copy of the inspector’s report and all other documentation relating to the inspection. The cost of such inspection shall be shared equally by BUYER and SELLER.


  

	 	7.2	The net quantity of crude oil delivered for title transfer and used by SELLER for the purpose of invoicing and for BUYER’s payment shall be determined by using
meters at SELLER’s delivery sites where provable meters are available. Alternatively, SELLER’s delivery tank volumes as measured by manual tank gauges in accordance with API standards shall be the basis for the total delivered quantity.


  

	 	7.3	The net quantity of crude oil delivered shall be calculated by deducting from the total quantity, as determined above, both free water and suspended sediment and water
(S&W) after completion of cargo transfer. Whenever possible, and provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of SELLER’s delivery sites referenced hereinabove, both free water and suspended S&W shall be determined from
S&W analysis of a representative sample taken from an automatic inline sampler. Alternatively, if such a sample is not possible, or if the independent inspector determines that the sampler did not perform in accordance with API MPMS Chapter 8.2,
the free water deduction shall be based on the free water increase of BUYER’s vessel’s tanks measured immediately before and after cargo receipt and the suspended S&W deduction shall be determined from analysis made on a composite
sample composed of individual samples taken from BUYER’s vessel’s tanks after cargo receipt. Provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of the delivery sites referenced herein, all gross volumes determined hereunder shall
be adjusted to 60 degrees F by applying API-IP Table 6A volume correction factors and S&W deductions used in determining Net Standard Volume shall be based on Water by Karl Fischer ASTM 
(D-4928) and Sediment by Filtration (D-4807).


  

	 	7.4	NOTICE OF ANY CLAIM BY EITHER PARTY, EITHER AS TO SHORTAGE IN QUANTITY OR BASED ON THE CONTENTION THAT THE CRUDE OIL DELIVERED IS NOT THE USUAL QUALITY OF THAT GRADE
BEING MADE AVAILABLE BY SELLER AT THE TIME OF LOADING OF THE CRUDE OIL AT SELLER’S LOADING PORT IN SAUDI ARABIA SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE OTHER PARTY, IN WRITING, WITH FULL SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION, WITHIN NINETY (90) DAYS AFTER THE
DELIVERY DATE. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE DEEMED A WAIVER OF ANY SUCH CLAIM. WITH RESPECT TO ANY SUCH CLAIM FOR WHICH A PARTY GIVES NOTICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION, THAT PARTY SHALL COMMENCE A PROCEEDING
PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH 10 WITHIN TWO (2) YEARS FROM THE DELIVERY DATE OR THE CLAIM SHALL BE FOREVER BARRED. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 8 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	8.	Title and Risk of Loss: 


Title to and risk of loss of all crude oil sold hereunder shall pass to BUYER at the point at which the loading terminal’s loading
line connects with the permanent hose connection of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 
  

	9.	Termination for Cause: 


SELLER or BUYER shall have the right to terminate this Agreement upon written notice to the other party in the event of a material breach
(including without limitation anticipatory breach) by the other party of any of its terms, but without prejudice to the rights of either party theretofore accrued with respect to this Agreement (including without limitation the right of either party
to damages arising from such breach or prior breaches hereof). Material breach by BUYER shall include, without limitation, BUYER’s failure to lift and buy crude oil as required in Paragraph 3 hereof or BUYER’s failure to comply with any of
the Payment provisions of paragraph 5. The delay or failure on the part of either party hereto to insist, in any one instance or more, upon strict performance of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement, or to exercise any right or privilege
herein conferred shall not be construed as a waiver of any such terms, conditions, rights or privileges, but the same shall continue and remain in full force and effect. All rights and remedies are cumulative. 

 

	10.	Disputes: 

 Any dispute,
controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this Agreement, together with any amendments thereto which may be issued from time to time, or the breach or termination or invalidity thereof, which is not settled by agreement between the parties
shall be finally settled in accordance with the Arbitration Regulations and the Rules for Implementation of the Arbitration Regulations for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia by three neutral and impartial arbitrators, one to be appointed by each party and
the third to be appointed by the two so chosen. The arbitrators shall base their award only upon the evidence presented to them, the terms of this Agreement and the laws of Saudi Arabia. This arbitration provision shall be specifically enforceable
by either party under the Regulations, and the arbitrators’ award shall be final and binding on the parties. 
  

	11.	Destination: 

 The country
of destination of the crude oil delivered hereunder shall be a country in North America and the delivery of such shall be subject to the export laws and regulations of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The country of destination of crude oil delivered
hereunder shall be confirmed and attested to by BUYER to SELLER not later than one hundred and twenty days (120) days after the Bill of Lading date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 9 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	12.	Other Terms: 

  

	 	12.1	This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the successors and assigns of the parties to this Agreement; however, neither party may assign or
transfer this Agreement, either in whole or in part, without first obtaining the written consent of the other, which shall not be unreasonably withheld. 

  

	 	12.2	In no event shall either party be liable in connection herewith or with respect to operations related hereto, whether in tort, contract or otherwise, for special,
indirect or consequential damages. 

  

	 	12.3	Except as otherwise required to implement this Agreement, BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE undertake to treat the contents of this Agreement as strictly confidential.
For violation of this undertaking by BUYER OR BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, SELLER shall have the right to immediately cancel this Agreement, without any liability as a result of such cancellation, upon giving notice to BUYER. 


 

	 	12.4	This Agreement, and any amendments hereto, consisting of this signed document, any attachments hereto and other documents referred to herein, is intended by the parties
as a final expression of their agreement and is intended also as a complete and exclusive statement of the terms of their agreement. 

  

	 	12.5	Subject to Paragraph 10, the laws and regulations of the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia shall govern the interpretation and performance of this Agreement and
any further agreements of that may result from it. 

  

	 	12.6	Each party shall be relieved from the performance of any obligation, other than the obligation to make payments for amounts due hereunder, during the time and to the
extent performance of such obligation is prevented or restricted as a result of a force majeure event, The term “force majeure” as used in this Agreement shall mean any act, event, cause or occurrence rendering a party unable to perform
its obligations which is not within the reasonable control of such party. BUYER and SELLER specifically agree that SELLER’s inability to perform all, or any part, of this Agreement due to Government action or directive shall constitute a force
majeure event; however, the term force majeure shall not apply to those events which merely make it more difficult or costly for BUYER to perform its obligations hereunder. BUYER and SELLER further agree that at the conclusion of any force majeure
event, neither BUYER nor SELLER shall have any obligation to each other with respect to any quantities of crude oil not delivered as a consequence of such force majeure event. No condition of force majeure shall operate to extend the term of this
Agreement. 

  

	 	12.7	 If at any time SELLER determines that reasonable grounds for insecurity have arisen with respect to BUYER’s performance of any of BUYER’s
obligations under this Agreement, SELLER may demand adequate assurance of due performance by BUYER, and until SELLER receives such assurance SELLER may suspend its performance of obligations under this Agreement. BUYER’s




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 10 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 


	 	
failure to provide within a reasonable time not exceeding ten (10) days such assurance of due performance as is adequate under the circumstances will constitute a material breach of this
Agreement. 

  

	 	12.8	Dues and other charges on the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading port and terminal shall be for BUYER’s account. The amount of any
taxes, duties, imposts, fees, charges and dues of every description imposed or levied by any governmental, local or port authority on the crude oil supplied hereunder, or on its export, delivery, transportation, ownership, sale or use, or on any
vessel used in its transportation, in respect of any stage after such crude oil passes the tankship’s permanent hose connection at the loading port, shall be for BUYER’s account. 


 

	 	12.9	The parties hereto contemplate that all the crude oil purchased under this Agreement shall be processed by BUYER and accordingly, the parties contemplate that the BUYER
will not resell the crude oil purchased under this Agreement in its original form or blend it with other crude oils for purpose of resale. 

  

	 	12.10	 Compliance with ISPS CODE: 

  

			
	12.10.1	 	SELLER and BUYER shall comply with the International Code for the Security of Ships and Port Facilities and relevant amendments to Chapter XI of the International Convention for
the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 (SOLAS), hereinafter (ISPS Code), in accordance with Form-I of this Agreement, which shall govern the parties rights and obligations with respect to such compliance.
		
	12.10.2	 	In the event of any conflict between this Agreement and its Form-I (ISPS CODE TERMS AND CONDITIONS), the terms and conditions of Form-I shall prevail.


 * * * * * * * * 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 11 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 

 

 IN WITNESS of this Agreement, the parties have caused it to be signed on the dates shown below in three
copies, each of which shall serve as an original. 
  

									
	 For and on behalf of BUYER:
 REPRESENTED BY:
	 		 	For and on behalf of SELLER:
	 		 	REPRESENTED BY:
			
	 




	 		 	 





	(Name)	 		 		 	Mohammed H. Khazindar
	(Title)	 		 		 	Manager, Crude Oil Sales and Marketing Department
					
	Date:	 	 1/5/11
	 		 	Date	 	 1/29/11

					
	Witness:	 	 




	 		 	Witness:	 	 





					
	Date:	 	 1/5/11
	 		 	Date	 	 1/17/2011

				
	 For and on behalf of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE:
 REPRESENTED BY
	 		 		 	
				
	 




	 		 		 	
	(Name)	 	R.M. Jones	 		 		 	
	(Title)	 	PRESIDENT	 		 		 	
					
	Date:	 	 6/1/11
	 		 		 	
					
	Witness:	 	 




	 		 		 	
					
	Date:	 	 1/4/11
	 		 		 	

  
 



 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC – [REDACTED] – 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 12 of 12









 THIRD AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND 

SERVICES AGREEMENT 
 THIS THIRD AMENDMENT TO CRUDE OIL/FEEDSTOCK SUPPLY/DELIVERY AND SERVICES AGREEMENT made and entered into as of July 28, 2011, by and among Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc., a Delaware
corporation (“Seller”), Paulsboro Refining Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (“Buyer”) and PBF Holding Company LLC (“Buyer’s Parent”), which is also a guarantor of Buyer’s
obligations under the Original Agreement (as defined below) and hereby agrees to the direct obligations applicable to Buyer’s Parent as set forth in this Amendment and the attachments hereto, amends that certain Crude Oil/Feedstock
Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement between Seller and Buyer (as assignee from PBF Holding Company LLC) dated December 16, 2010 (including all previous amendments, the “Original Agreement”). 

W I T N E S S E T H: 
 WHEREAS, the parties hereto desire to modify the terms of the Original Agreement pursuant to the terms hereof (defined terms not defined herein are defined in the Original Agreement).

 NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby
acknowledged, the parties hereto agree as follows: 
 1. Appendices. Appendix 13 is hereby amended by
replacing the entirety of Appendix 13 with the Appendix 13 attached hereto, and incorporated herein by reference, as Exhibit A. 
 2. Joint Obligations and Cooperation. Buyer’s Parent and Buyer undertake various responsibilities in Appendix 13 and in other documents with regard to the Saudi Contract (as
defined in Appendix 13) and the transactions related thereto. Regardless of whether any specific obligation is specified as being applicable to Buyer or to Buyer’s Parent, both Buyer and Buyer’s Parent shall be jointly and severally liable
for such obligations and shall pledge and grant security interests as their respective rights, title and interests may appear. Buyer and Buyer’s Parent also agree to cooperate and take all appropriate actions under or with respect to the Saudi
Contract to enable and facilitate Buyer’s and Buyer’s Parent’s performance of their obligations with respect to the Saudi Contract, the Saudi Cargoes and the Original Agreement. 

3. No Other Modification. Except as specifically set forth above, the Original Agreement shall remain in full force
and effect in all respects. 
 [Signature page follows] 







 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Amendment as of the date
first above written. 
  

					
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
			
	By:	 	  
	 	
	Name:	 	 Richard Martin Jones
	 	
	Title:	 	 President
	 	
		
	PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC	 	




			
	By:	 	  
	 	
	Name:	 	  
	 	
	Title:	 	  
	 	
		
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC	 	
			
	By:	 	  
	 	
	Name:	 	  
	 	
	Title:	 	  
	 	


 [Signature Page to Third Amendment to Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement]








 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Amendment as of the date
first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  

	
	PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  

	
	PBE HOLDING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  



 [Signature Page to Third Amendment to Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement]








 Exhibit A to Third Amendment 

APPENDIX 13 – SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS 
 On or about the date of the execution of that certain First Amendment to this Agreement, PBF Holding Company LLC, the 100% owner of Buyer (“Buyer’s Parent”), entered into a contract
(the “Original Saudi Contract”), in substantially the form of Attachment I to this Appendix 13, with Saudi Arabian providing for the supply of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C) from Saudi Arabian to Buyer’s Parent, with Seller
executing the Saudi Contract as “BUYER’S ASSIGNEE” for the limited purposes set forth therein. In conjunction with the Third Amendment to this Agreement, Buyer’s Parent is entering into a Crude Oil Sales Agreement with a side
letter entitled “Freight Protection for [REDACTED],” substantially in the form of Attachment II to this Appendix 13 (the “Spot Saudi Agreement”), with Saudi Arabian providing for the spot purchase of Arabian [REDACTED] and
Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, with Seller named in the Crude Oil Sales Agreement shown in Attachment II as “BUYER’S ASSIGNEE” for the limited purposes set forth therein. Furthermore, Buyer’s Parent anticipates potentially
entering into future agreements similar to that shown in Attachment II. Buyer shall provide notice to Seller of any such future agreements and after Seller reviews such future agreement(s) and confirms (such confirmation not to be unreasonably
withheld, conditioned or delayed) in writing that it is substantially similar to Attachment II and is reasonably acceptable to Seller, then such future agreement(s) shall be a “Future Spot Saudi Agreement” for purposes of this
Appendix 13 and the Agreement. As used below and throughout the Agreement, the “Saudi Contract” shall include the Original Saudi Contract, the Spot Saudi Agreement and the Future Spot Saudi Agreement(s). Notwithstanding anything to
the contrary in Clause 14(a) of this Agreement, Seller shall provide all Shipping Services (with a $[REDACTED] per Barrel service fee) and insurance at $[REDACTED] per Barrel with respect to all volumes of Oil purchased by Buyer from Saudi Arabian
under the Saudi Contract (each such volume, a “Saudi Cargo”). Shipping Services for each Saudi Cargo (which shall be calculated and paid for by Buyer in the same manner as for the Cargoes being sold by Seller under the Agreement)
shall be set using the “[REDACTED]” unless otherwise agreed upon by the Parties. 
 Buyer’s
Parent shall sell and transfer title to each Saudi Cargo to Seller on the earlier of (i) either the 23rd day after the Bill of Lading date if the applicable Saudi Contract requires payment to Saudi Arabian by the 25th day after the Bill of Lading date, or on the 28th day after the Bill of Lading date if the applicable Saudi Contract
requires payment to Saudi Arabian by the 30th day after
the Bill of Lading date, or (ii) arrival of such Saudi Cargo DES Paulsboro or a separately agreed upon delivery point (the “Saudi Title Transfer Date”), at the same price Buyer’s Parent purchases such Saudi Cargo from
Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract; provided that Seller and Buyer’s Parent may mutually agree on any other separate delivery point or transshipment point, including Buyer’s Affiliates’ facility at Delaware City, Delaware or
Seller’s South Riding Point terminal and storage facility located on Grand Bahama Island, The Bahamas. If the Saudi Title Transfer Date would otherwise occur on a non-Business Day, then the Saudi Title Transfer Date and the concurrent transfer
of title to Seller for any such applicable Saudi Cargo shall take place on the preceding Business Day. In the event of any Future Spot Saudi Agreements as defined above, the Saudi Title Transfer Date shall be no later than the last Business Day that
is at least two days prior to the date required for payment by Saudi Arabian. Buyer’s Parent shall deliver to Seller on the Business Day after the Saudi Title Transfer Date the 

  
 Appendix 13

 1 








 
original Bill of Lading corresponding to such Saudi Cargo with appropriate endorsements to Seller together with such other acceptable documentation as may be requested by Seller with respect to
each such sale. Seller may purchase futures contracts on the Saudi Cargoes in connection with the Oil pricing terms set forth in the Saudi Contract, in the same manner as for other Cargoes owned by Seller pursuant to Clause 9 and the other
provisions of the Agreement, and the pricing for the subsequent resale of such Cargo by Seller to Buyer upon Delivery from Seller to Buyer shall be based on such futures contract pricing. 

Upon receipt of each invoice from Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract, Buyer’s Parent shall immediately deliver an exact copy of
such invoice to Seller. Buyer’s Parent and Seller shall use reasonable efforts to arrange with Saudi Arabian to permit direct payment by Seller to Saudi Arabian of Buyer’s obligations for each Saudi Cargo (in lieu of Seller paying
Buyer’s Parent and Buyer’s Parent remitting the same amount to Saudi Arabian), but this arrangement does not and shall not create any direct obligation of Seller to Saudi Arabian. If Buyer’s Parent and Seller are unable to arrange for
direct payment from Seller to Saudi Arabian, Seller shall pay all amounts due Buyer’s Parent with respect to Saudi Cargoes into a controlled account, pursuant to which Seller shall be party to an account agreement (the “Account
Agreement”). The Parties agree that the arrangements described in this Appendix 13 may be amended further for future Saudi Cargoes. 
 Payment for each Saudi Cargo shall be due from Seller to Buyer’s Parent one Business Day after delivery of good title to such Oil from Buyer’s Parent on the Saudi Title Transfer Date, free and
clear of all Liens, except for any lien held by the bank that is party to the Account Agreement. Such Saudi Cargo shall be included in the calculation of OIFIC and the TVM Payment pursuant to Clause 19(g) of the Agreement when payment becomes due
from Seller to Buyer’s Parent pursuant to this Appendix 13. 
 To the extent there are any adjustments to the price of any
Saudi Cargo under the Saudi Contract after payment becomes due from Seller to Buyer’s Parent hereunder (including any adjustment relating to a provisional invoice delivered by Saudi Arabian to Buyer’s Parent under the Saudi Contract):
(a) if the adjustment results in Saudi Arabian making a payment to Buyer’s Parent and Seller has title to all or any portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Buyer’s Parent shall
immediately remit the portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned by Seller upon receipt from Saudi Arabian, and the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil; and (b) if the
adjustment results in Buyer’s Parent making an additional payment to Saudi Arabian, (i) if Seller has title to all or any portion of such Saudi Cargo (because such Oil has not yet been Delivered by Seller to Buyer), Seller shall pay the
portion of such funds allocable to the portion of the Saudi Cargo (up to 100%) owned by Seller either directly to Saudi Arabian or into the controlled Buyer’s Parent account (in the same manner as described above for the initial payment), and
the amount shall result in an adjustment to the price basis for such Oil, or (ii) if the adjustment relates to a Saudi Cargo which has been Delivered in its entirety by Seller to Buyer, such adjustment shall be solely for the account of
Buyer’s Parent. 
 Buyer and Buyer’s Parent shall be fully liable for all obligations, and Seller shall have no
obligation to Buyer or Buyer’s Parent except as specifically set forth herein, with respect to (i) any payment owing from Buyer’s Parent to Saudi Arabian (ii) any breach by Buyer’s Parent of


  
 -2-









 
the Saudi Contract, (iii) any termination of the Saudi Contract other than a termination resulting from Seller’s failure to perform its obligations under the Saudi Contract as
“Buyer’s Assignee,” or (iv) any failure or refusal of Saudi Arabian to provide Oil to Buyer’s Parent, Buyer or Seller. Clause 40(c) of the Agreement expressly applies to this Appendix 13, and Saudi Arabian shall in no way be
deemed a third party beneficiary of this Agreement, including this Appendix 13. 
 As security for the prompt and complete
payment and performance in full of all obligations of Buyer’s Parent and Buyer to Seller hereunder (including the hedges and other obligations Seller undertakes in reliance on Buyer’s Parent and Buyer’s obligations to sell the Saudi
Cargoes to Seller and to later repurchase such Saudi Cargoes in accordance with the terms of the Agreement), Buyer’s Parent and Buyer hereby grant to Seller a security interest in all of its right, title and interest in, to and under the
following, in each case, whether now owned or existing or hereafter acquired or arising and wherever located: 

(i) All Saudi Cargoes; and 
 (ii) All proceeds, insurance claims and proceeds, products, accessions, additions, substitutions, replacements, rents and profits of or in respect of any or all of the foregoing. 

In connection with the foregoing, Buyer’s Parent and Buyer authorize Seller to file such financing statements pursuant to the UCC as
Seller deems necessary to perfect the foregoing interest. Neither Buyer’s Parent nor Buyer shall grant or permit any other security interest in any of the foregoing collateral, except that, subject to the execution of an intercreditor agreement
in form and substance satisfactory to Seller, Buyer’s Parent may grant a senior security interest in such collateral to Buyer’s Parent’s third party letter of credit provider (BNP) to secure Buyer’s Parent’s obligations with
respect to letters of credit required to be posted by Buyer’s Parent to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract. 
 Neither
Buyer’s Parent nor Buyer shall take any action that would cause Seller to incur an indemnity obligation pursuant to the Saudi Contract. If Seller under the Saudi Contract is required to defend, indemnify or hold harmless Saudi Arabian or any
other party or otherwise becomes liable under the Saudi Contract as a result of the actions or inactions of Buyer’s Parent or its affiliates, Buyer’s Parent and Buyer shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless Seller for all obligations
incurred by Seller thereby. 
 The Parties acknowledge that the Saudi Contract includes provisions which the Parties desire to
amend to clarify ambiguity, and therefore the Parties agree to use their reasonable efforts to affect an amendment of the January 1, 2011, Saudi Contract to clarify that (a) Seller’s indemnity obligations in Section 6.6 of the
Saudi Contract for Buyer’s Parent’s actions only relate to “BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s failure to comply with the aforesaid standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures of SUMED” and
(b) Seller’s only liability to Saudi Arabian under the Saudi Contract shall be for its own actions or inactions as lifter of the Saudi Cargoes or for the indemnity in Section 6.6 of the Saudi Contract by adding a provision similar to
the following therein: 

  
 -3-









 “Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, (a) BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall only
be liable to SELLER for (i) BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s performance of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s crude oil lifting obligations hereunder and (ii) the indemnification obligations of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE set forth in Section 6.6,
and (b) upon the termination of this Agreement, BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s only obligations to SELLER shall be for those obligations which accrued prior to such date of termination, including any incurred under Section 6.6.”


  
 -4-









 ATTACHMENT I TO APPENDIX 13 

FORM OF SAUDI CONTRACT 
 [attached] 








 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  

 CRUDE OIL SALES AGREEMENT 

This is to confirm the Agreement among: 
  

	1.	Parties: 

  

					
	SELLER	 	-	  	SAUDI ARABIAN OIL COMPANY, A COMPANY WITH LIMITED LIABILITY ORGANIZED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA;
			
	BUYER	 	-	  	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE; and
			
	 BUYER’s

ASSIGNEE
	 	-	  	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF DELAWARE

 RECITALS 
 WHEREAS, SELLER desires to sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s Supplier, to deliver to BUYER, and BUYER desires to purchase from SELLER and accept delivery from SELLER, or from SELLER’s
Supplier, a certain quantity of Arabian crude oil of the specification set forth hereinafter; 
 WHEREAS, BUYER desires to assign
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to take delivery of and receive the sold crude oil hereunder and to perform all of BUYER’s crude oil lifting obligations as set forth herein on behalf of BUYER; and 

WHEREAS, SELLER consents to the said assignment subject to the terms and conditions listed herein. 

NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereby agree as follows: 
  

	2.	Term of Agreement: 

 This Agreement shall be effective as of January 1st, 2011 and shall continue in effect through and including December 31st, 2011 with automatic one-year extensions thereafter
unless terminated at the option of either party, other than for cause or in accordance with Paragraph 4.2 below, upon at least sixty (60) days written notice prior to the expiration of the original term or, if applicable, any subsequent
anniversary date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 1 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	3.	Grade, Quantity and Quality: 

  

	 	3.1	Subject to availability and the production policies determined by the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, SELLER shall sell and deliver, or cause SELLER’s
Supplier to deliver, to BUYER and BUYER shall buy and lift or receive, or cause BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to lift or receive, from SELLER a total of [REDACTED] barrels per day of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, minus up to ten percent (-10%) at
BUYER’s or SELLER’s option, or plus up to ten percent (+10%) if BUYER so requests and SELLER agrees. Additional volumes of crude oil of similar or different grades may be delivered under this Agreement as the parties may from time to
time agree. 

  

	 	3.2	The availability of each grade of crude oil specified in Paragraph 3.1 will be advised by SELLER from time to time in accordance with the production policies of the
Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Subject to availability, and unless otherwise mutually agreed, the quantities of each grade of crude oil to be lifted or received and purchased by BUYER during the term of this Agreement shall be spread
over the term of this Agreement as evenly as practicable. 

 Deliveries during BUYER’s planned refinery
maintenance or turnaround shall be reduced to such quantities as the parties may mutually agree. In such case, after the period of refinery maintenance and turnaround, deliveries shall be increased from time to time as the parties may mutually
agree, so that BUYER fulfills its obligation to lift or receive and buy the full contractual volume by the end of each annual period during the Agreement beginning with the effective date. 

 

	 	3.3	Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained elsewhere in this Agreement and without prejudice to any other rights or remedies available to SELLER hereunder, if
at any time BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, for any reason other than force majeure (as defined in Paragraph 12.6) or a reason attributable to SELLER, fail to lift or receive and purchase quantities of crude oil in accordance with this Paragraph 3,
SELLER may at one time or from time to time thereafter, at its sole discretion, and upon notice to BUYER, reduce any or all quantities and grades of crude oil which BUYER would have otherwise been entitled to lift and buy. 


 

	 	3.4	The quality of each grade of crude oil delivered hereunder shall be the usual quality of that grade being made available by SELLER at the time of loading of the crude
oil at the SELLER’s loading port in Saudi Arabia. SELLER warrants that it has good and marketable title to the crude oil, free and clear of all charges, liens and encumbrances but THERE ARE NO GUARANTEES OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF
MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR SUITABILITY OF THE CRUDE OIL, FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE, WHICH EXTEND BEYOND THE DESCRIPTION OF THE CRUDE OIL AND ANY SPECIFICATIONS THEREFOR CONTAINED IN THIS AGREEMENT. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 2 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	4.	Price: 

  

	 	4.1	The price per barrel of each Cargo of Arab [REDACTED] crude oil sold hereunder on [REDACTED] basis shall be the Argus Sour Crude Index Price (“ASCI”), as
calculated below, plus or minus a differential to be provided to BUYER as provided in Paragraph 4.2 below. The ASCI price shall be calculated as the arithmetic average of the ASCI prices published in Argus Crude Report (“Argus”), for all
the quotation days inclusive during the period from the [REDACTED] of the month [REDACTED] to the Scheduled Month of Delivery, through the [REDACTED]. 

  

	 	4.2	On or before the fifth (5th) day of each month, SELLER shall notify BUYER of the price differential per barrel of each grade of crude oil to be sold under this
Agreement during the following month (the “Scheduled Month of Delivery”). Within five (5) calendar days after receipt of SELLER’s notification as set forth in the preceding sentence, BUYER may elect to terminate this Agreement by
delivering written notice thereof to SELLER. Unless BUYER elects to terminate this Agreement in accordance with the immediately preceding sentence, the price differential notified by SELLER shall apply. Termination by BUYER in accordance with this
Paragraph 4.2 shall be effective as of the first day of the month following SELLER’s receipt of BUYER’s notice; provided, however, that termination under this or any other provision of this Agreement shall not affect the parties’
rights and obligations with respect to deliveries of crude oil under this Agreement which were made prior to the effective date of termination; and further provided that in the event of termination hereunder or expiration of the Agreement, this
Agreement shall remain in effect with respect to all cargoes of crude oil for which delivery has been confirmed pursuant to Paragraph 6 herein. The differential applicable to such cargoes shall be the differential that was in effect during the month
prior to termination. 

  

	 	4.3	Should completion of physical loading of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE occur before or after the Scheduled Month of Delivery, the price of such
cargo, unless otherwise mutually agreed, shall be calculated using the differential that would apply if completion of physical loading of the said vessel has occurred in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. 


 

	5.	Payment: 

  

	 	5.1	Payment for each parcel of crude oil sold shall be made in the full amount of SELLER’s telexed invoice without discounts or deductions by BUYER to SELLER via
electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to SELLER’s account as follows: 


JPMorgan Chase, New York [REDACTED] 
 under direct [REDACTED] advice to 
 JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

for the account of JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 3 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  

 Account no. [REDACTED] for further credit to 

The Saudi Arabian Oil Company (Saudi Aramco) 
 Account no. [REDACTED] 
 SELLER shall invoice BUYER on or before the [REDACTED] day
from and including the completion of loading date and BUYER’s payment to SELLER shall be made not later than the [REDACTED] day from and including the bill of lading date. 
 If any payment hereunder falls due on a Saturday or a New York banking holiday other than a Monday, payment shall be effected on the preceding bank business day. If the payment falls due on a Sunday or
Monday New York banking holiday, then payment shall be effected on the next bank business day. 
  

	 	5.2	All invoices for crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be sent to BUYER by telex, facsimile, courier or mail (at SELLER’s discretion) in accordance with the
following: 

 John E. Luke 
 Treasurer 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 

Tel.: 973-455-7518 
 Email: john.luke@pbfenergy.com 
 With duplicate copy to: 

John Barone 

Corporate Controller 
 Fax: 973-455-7560 
 Tel.: 973-455-7517 

Email: john.barone@pbfenergy.com 
  

	 	5.3	If it is impossible or impracticable for SELLER to calculate the price for any parcel of crude oil sold hereunder prior to issuance of an invoice therefor, SELLER shall
send to BUYER a provisional invoice and BUYER shall pay said invoice in accordance with Paragraph 5.1. SELLER’s provisional invoice shall be based upon (i) SELLER’s best estimate of the price(s) as provided in Paragraph 4 with
reference to the reference crude(s) and differential(s) applicable to such parcel and (ii) SELLER’s best estimate of the quantity of crude oil delivered, if SELLER has not received inspection report(s) by independent inspector(s) in
accordance with Paragraph 7. 

  

	 	5.4	 As soon as the total amount due for any parcel is determined with reference to price(s) determined under Paragraph 4 and quantity of crude oil
delivered as shown in the inspection report(s) received by SELLER, SELLER shall issue an invoice, which shall set forth adjustments for parcels provisionally invoiced, the settlement date of which shall be the fifth (5th) day after the day of
issuance thereof or the date payment is due pursuant to Paragraph 5.1, whichever is later. Said invoice shall be paid on or before the settlement date by BUYER/SELLER, 



  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 4 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	 	
as appropriate. Said invoice shall include any applicable adjustment(s) due to BUYER or SELLER, the difference between the provisional price and the final price, and a further amount equal to
such difference (i) multiplied by the rate set forth in Paragraph 5.5, (ii) multiplied by the number of days between the date of provisional payment and the settlement date, (iii) divided by 360 days. 


 

	 	5.5	Any amount not paid by either party when due shall bear interest from the date upon which payment was due through the date of payment at a rate equal to the one
(l) month British Bankers Assoc., London interbank offered rate (L.I.B.O.R.) for U.S. Dollar deposits as shown on Reuters screen, reference page ‘LIBOR01’ fixed at 11:00 a.m., London time, on the first banking day of the month in
which payment was due plus one percent (1%). Interest at the rate set forth above, determined on the first banking day of the month in which BUYER’s payment is due, shall also be payable by the party who owes any adjustment pursuant to
Paragraph 5.4, on the amount of such adjustment, from the date on which BUYER’s payment is due through the date such adjustment is paid. All payments of interest by either party under this Agreement shall be made in the full amount due, free of
any withholding tax imposed by any government. 

  

	 	5.6	Any payments by SELLER to BUYER shall be made by electronic transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to BUYER’s account as follows:


 JPMorgan Chase - NY 
 395 North Service Road 
 Melville, New York 11747 

United States 

ABA #021 000 021 
 For further credit to the account of: 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 

Account #844041749 
 Contact: Ms. Barbara Pirozzi 
 Fax: 866-914-7380 

Tel.: 631-755-5180 
 Email: Barbara.pirozzi@jpmchse.com 
  

	 	5.7	For crude oil to be lifted or received under this Agreement, BUYER shall establish and deliver to SELLER at least ten (10) days prior to the scheduled date of
arrival of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal, an irrevocable standby Letter of Credit issued or confirmed by a bank acceptable to SELLER in accordance with the attached Form L (02/18/08). All bank charges
incurred in connection with the establishment of letters of credit, including without limitation, opening, amendment and correspondent charges, confirmation and all related banking fees, commissions or expenses shall be for BUYER’s account. In
addition, BUYER shall bear all costs of demurrage or any other fees or charges arising from BUYER’s failure to provide a Letter of Credit or confirmation thereof acceptable to SELLER by the date specified. BUYER’s provision of a Letter of
Credit is an express condition precedent to SELLER’s obligation to deliver and sell crude oil under this Agreement. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 5 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	6.	Delivery: 

  

	 	6.1	Subject to agreement of the parties and to the procedures set forth herein, delivery and receipt of the crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be based on FOB
vessels to be supplied by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading terminal at [REDACTED], operated by SUMED (“SELLER’s Supplier”). 

  

	 	6.2	SELLER agrees to deliver or cause to be delivered crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE agree to receive the same or cause the
same to be received from SELLER in accordance with monthly lifting schedules agreed upon; provided, however, that SELLER, while according nondiscriminatory treatment to buyers, shall not be required to furnish a quantity of any grade of crude oil
exceeding the capacity of its facilities. BUYER’s ASSIGNEE performance hereunder shall not relieve BUYER of any of its obligations under this Agreement as further provided in Paragraph 6.7 below. 


 

	 	6.3	SELLER, at its discretion, may cause its affiliate, Bolanter Corporation N.V. (“Bolanter”), or such other third party affiliated with SELLER as SELLER shall
designate in writing (“Third Party Affiliate”), to perform SELLER’s obligation to deliver crude oil under this Paragraph 6, provided SELLER’s so doing shall not relieve SELLER of any of its obligations under this Agreement.


  

	 	6.4	 BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule by the fifth (5th) day of each month preceding the Scheduled Month of Delivery. BUYER shall also submit at this time a provisional
nomination schedule for the first fifteen (15) days of the month following the Scheduled Month of Delivery. If the fifth (5th) day is a non-working day in London, then the BUYER shall submit a monthly lifting schedule and a provisional
nomination schedule by the nearest preceding working day in London. The requested monthly lifting schedule and provisional nomination schedule shall contain a preferred one (1) day date for each lifting. SELLER shall attempt to accommodate
BUYER’s proposed schedule but shall only guarantee lifting dates during the last ten (10) days of the Scheduled Month of Delivery, using its best efforts to provide lifting dates during the five (5) days preceding the last ten
(10) days in the Scheduled Month of Delivery. The vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port on the accepted date if it arrives at the customary anchorage within one (1) day before
or one (1) day after the date accepted by SELLER. 


 Any subsequent revisions requested by the BUYER and
accepted by the SELLER shall be limited to a one (1) day acceptance range and the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall be deemed to have arrived at the load port only on the accepted date. 

 

	 	6.5	 SELLER shall authorize SUMED to deliver the crude oil to BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall arrange with SUMED to




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 6 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	 	
lift and receive delivery of the crude oil. Delivery and lifting of crude oil at [REDACTED] shall be subject to and in accordance with the standard terms, conditions, port limitations, practices
and procedures of SUMED. BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE also agree to comply with the operation, lifting, and nomination procedures and obligations required of SELLER, pursuant to the Long Term Transportation Agreement between Bolanter and SUMED
(the “Transportation Agreement”). 

  

	 	6.6	BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless SELLER, Bolanter, and any Third Party Affiliate from and against all claims, demands and
liabilities of any kind whatsoever asserted against SELLER, Bolanter, or any Third Party Affiliate by any party as a result of BUYER’s failure to comply with the aforesaid terms, conditions, port limitations, practices and procedures, or as a
result of deballasting of dirty ballast water by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 

  

	 	6.7	Since SELLER is neither the terminal operator nor in control of any of the terminal operations, it is expressly understood and agreed that SELLER will not be liable to
BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE for any demurrage, unless such demurrage is caused by SELLER’s failure to make the crude oil available for delivery. In those instances in which demurrage is incurred because of SELLER’s failure, BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE shall present its claim for reimbursement to SELLER at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for demurrage claims set out in the applicable terminal regulations. Where BUYER’s demurrage
claim does not arise from SELLER’s failure, as an accommodation to BUYER, SELLER will present to the terminal operator, on behalf of BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, any claim for demurrage that is presented by BUYER to SELLER at least sixty
(60) days prior to the expiration of the time limitation for such demurrage claims, as set out in the applicable terminal regulations. After SELLER, on BUYER’s behalf, has presented a demurrage claim to the terminal operator, SELLER will
follow up and make reasonable efforts, short of arbitration or litigation, to effect recovery. SELLER will promptly remit to BUYER any monies received from the terminal operator in whole or partial satisfaction of the demurrage claim of BUYER or
BUYER’s ASSIGNEE with the terminal operator. 

  

	 	6.8	Notwithstanding anything else to the contrary elsewhere in the Agreement, should SELLER in its sole judgment determine that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has failed in any
respect to perform in accordance with its obligations under this Agreement, or that BUYER’s ASSIGNEE has become bankrupt or insolvent or otherwise unable to meet its financial obligations, BUYER shall continue to be directly liable to SELLER
for the performance of the obligations assigned to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE hereunder. Notwithstanding the foregoing, all Bills of Lading issued hereunder shall name BUYER as consignee. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 7 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	7.	Measurement and Inspection 

  

	 	7.1	BUYER shall arrange for a mutually acceptable independent inspector to verify the quality and quantity of the crude oil delivered to BUYER or to BUYER’s ASSIGNEE,
and shall cause said inspector to promptly provide to SELLER a copy of the inspector’s report and all other documentation relating to the inspection. The cost of such inspection shall be shared equally by BUYER and SELLER.


  

	 	7.2	The net quantity of crude oil delivered for title transfer and used by SELLER for the purpose of invoicing and for BUYER’s payment shall be determined by using
meters at SELLER’s delivery sites where provable meters are available. Alternatively, SELLER’s delivery tank volumes as measured by manual tank gauges in accordance with API standards shall be the basis for the total delivered quantity.


  

	 	7.3	The net quantity of crude oil delivered shall be calculated by deducting from the total quantity, as determined above, both free water and suspended sediment and water
(S&W) after completion of cargo transfer. Whenever possible, and provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of SELLER’s delivery sites referenced hereinabove, both free water and suspended S&W shall be determined from
S&W analysis of a representative sample taken from an automatic inline sampler. Alternatively, if such a sample is not possible, or if the independent inspector determines that the sampler did not perform in accordance with API MPMS Chapter 8.2,
the free water deduction shall be based on the free water increase of BUYER’s vessel’s tanks measured immediately before and after cargo receipt and the suspended S&W deduction shall be determined from analysis made on a composite
sample composed of individual samples taken from BUYER’s vessel’s tanks after cargo receipt. Provided that it is consistent with the terms and conditions of the delivery sites referenced herein, all gross volumes determined hereunder shall
be adjusted to 60 degrees F by applying API-IP Table 6A volume correction factors and S&W deductions used in determining Net Standard Volume shall be based on Water by Karl Fischer ASTM (D-4928) and Sediment by Filtration (D-4807).


  

	 	7.4	NOTICE OF ANY CLAIM BY EITHER PARTY, EITHER AS TO SHORTAGE IN QUANTITY OR BASED ON THE CONTENTION THAT THE CRUDE OIL DELIVERED IS NOT THE USUAL QUALITY OF THAT GRADE
BEING MADE AVAILABLE BY SELLER AT THE TIME OF LOADING OF THE CRUDE OIL AT SELLER’S LOADING PORT IN SAUDI ARABIA SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE OTHER PARTY, IN WRITING, WITH FULL SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION, WITHIN NINETY (90) DAYS AFTER THE
DELIVERY DATE. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION SHALL BE DEEMED A WAIVER OF ANY SUCH CLAIM. WITH RESPECT TO ANY SUCH CLAIM FOR WHICH A PARTY GIVES NOTICE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION, THAT PARTY SHALL COMMENCE A PROCEEDING
PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH 10 WITHIN TWO (2) YEARS FROM THE DELIVERY DATE OR THE CLAIM SHALL BE FOREVER BARRED. 


  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 8 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	8.	Title and Risk of Loss: 


Title to and risk of loss of all crude oil sold hereunder shall pass to BUYER at the point at which the loading terminal’s loading
line connects with the permanent hose connection of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE. 
  

	9.	Termination for Cause: 


SELLER or BUYER shall have the right to terminate this Agreement upon written notice to the other party in the event of a material breach
(including without limitation anticipatory breach) by the other party of any of its terms, but without prejudice to the rights of either party theretofore accrued with respect to this Agreement (including without limitation the right of either party
to damages arising from such breach or prior breaches hereof). Material breach by BUYER shall include, without limitation, BUYER’s failure to lift and buy crude oil as required in Paragraph 3 hereof or BUYER’s failure to comply with any of
the Payment provisions of Paragraph 5. The delay or failure on the part of either party hereto to insist, in any one instance or more, upon strict performance of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement, or to exercise any right or privilege
herein conferred shall not be construed as a waiver of any such terms, conditions, rights or privileges, but the same shall continue and remain in full force and effect. All rights and remedies are cumulative. 

 

	10.	Disputes: 

 Any dispute,
controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this Agreement, together with any amendments thereto which may be issued from time to time, or the breach or termination or invalidity thereof, which is not settled by agreement between the parties
shall be finally settled in accordance with the Arbitration Regulations and the Rules for Implementation of the Arbitration Regulations for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia by three neutral and impartial arbitrators, one to be appointed by each party and
the third to be appointed by the two so chosen. The arbitrators shall base their award only upon the evidence presented to them, the terms of this Agreement and the laws of Saudi Arabia. This arbitration provision shall be specifically enforceable
by either party under the Regulations, and the arbitrators’ award shall be final and binding on the parties. 
  

	11.	Destination: 

 The country
of destination of the crude oil delivered hereunder shall be a country in North America and the delivery of such shall be subject to the export laws and regulations of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The country of destination of crude oil delivered
hereunder shall be confirmed and attested to by BUYER to SELLER not later than one hundred and twenty days (120) days after the Bill of Lading date. 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 9 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


	12.	Other Terms: 

  

	 	12.1	This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the successors and assigns of the parties to this Agreement; however, neither party may assign or
transfer this Agreement, either in whole or in part, without first obtaining the written consent of the other, which shall not be unreasonably withheld. 

  

	 	12.2	In no event shall either party be liable in connection herewith or with respect to operations related hereto, whether in tort, contract or otherwise, for special,
indirect or consequential damages. 

  

	 	12.3	Except as otherwise required to implement this Agreement, BUYER and BUYER’s ASSIGNEE undertake to treat the contents of this Agreement as strictly confidential.
For violation of this undertaking by BUYER OR BUYER’s ASSIGNEE, SELLER shall have the right to immediately cancel this Agreement, without any liability as a result of such cancellation, upon giving notice to BUYER. 


 

	 	12.4	This Agreement, and any amendments hereto, consisting of this signed document, any attachments hereto and other documents referred to herein, is intended by the parties
as a final expression of their agreement and is intended also as a complete and exclusive statement of the terms of their agreement. 

  

	 	12.5	Subject to Paragraph 10, the laws and regulations of the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia shall govern the interpretation and performance of this Agreement and
any further agreements that may result from it. 

  

	 	12.6	Each party shall be relieved from the performance of any obligation, other than the obligation to make payments for amounts due hereunder, during the time and to the
extent performance of such obligation is prevented or restricted as a result of a force majeure event. The term “force majeure” as used in this Agreement shall mean any act, event, cause or occurrence rendering a party unable to perform
its obligations which is not within the reasonable control of such party. BUYER and SELLER specifically agree that SELLER’s inability to perform all, or any part, of this Agreement due to Government action or directive shall constitute a force
majeure event; however, the term force majeure shall not apply to those events which merely make it more difficult or costly for BUYER to perform its obligations hereunder. BUYER and SELLER further agree that at the conclusion of any force majeure
event, neither BUYER nor SELLER shall have any obligation to each other with respect to any quantities of crude oil not delivered as a consequence of such force majeure event. No condition of force majeure shall operate to extend the term of this
Agreement. 

  

	 	12.7	 If at any time SELLER determines that reasonable grounds for insecurity have arisen with respect to BUYER’s performance of any of BUYER’s
obligations under this Agreement, SELLER may demand adequate assurance of due performance by BUYER, and until SELLER receives such assurance SELLER may suspend its performance of obligations under this Agreement. BUYER’s




  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 10 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  


					
		  	failure to provide within a reasonable time not exceeding ten (10) days such assurance of due performance as is adequate under the circumstances will constitute a
material breach of this Agreement.
		
	12.8	  	Dues and other charges on the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE at the loading port and terminal shall be for BUYER’s account. The amount of any
taxes, duties, imposts, fees, charges and dues of every description imposed or levied by any governmental, local or port authority on the crude oil supplied hereunder, or on its export, delivery, transportation, ownership, sale or use, or on any
vessel used in its transportation, in respect of any stage after such crude oil passes the tankship’s permanent hose connection at the loading port, shall be for BUYER’s account.
		
	12.9	  	The parties hereto contemplate that all the crude oil purchased under this Agreement shall be processed by BUYER and accordingly, the parties contemplate that the BUYER
will not resell the crude oil purchased under this Agreement in its original form or blend it with other crude oils for purpose of resale.
		
	12.10	  	Compliance with ISPS CODE:
			
		  	12.10.1	  	SELLER and BUYER shall comply with the International Code for the Security of Ships and Port Facilities and relevant amendments to Chapter XI of the International Convention for the
Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 (SOLAS), hereinafter (ISPS Code), in accordance with Form-1 of this Agreement, which shall govern the parties rights and obligations with respect to such compliance.
			
		  	12.10.2	  	In the event of any conflict between this Agreement and its Form-I (ISPS CODE TERMS AND CONDITIONS), the terms and conditions of Form-I shall prevail.

 * * * * * * * * 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 11 of 12










 TRIPLICATE ORIGINAL 
  

 IN WITNESS of this Agreement, the parties have caused it to be signed on the dates shown below in three
copies, each of which shall serve as an original. 
  

							
	For and on behalf of BUYER:	  	For and on behalf of SELLER:
	REPRESENTED BY:	  	REPRESENTED BY:
		
	  
	  	  

	(Name)	  	Mohammed M. Khazindar
	(Title)	  	Manager, Crude Oil Sales and Marketing Department
				
	Date:	 	  
	  	Date	 	  

				
	Witness:	 	  
	  	Witness:	 	  

				
	Date:	 	  
	  	Date	 	  


  

			
	 For and on behalf of BUYER’s ASSIGNEE:
 REPRESENTED BY:

	
	  

	(Name)	 	
	(Title)	 	
		
	Date:	 	  

		
	Witness:	 	  

		
	Date:	 	  


  
 



 

  

			
	 PBF HOLDING LLC - [REDACTED] - 01 02 11 (ses)
	 	Page 12 of 12









 ATTACHMENT II TO APPENDIX 13 

FORM OF SPOT SAUDI AGREEMENT 
 [attached] 








 DRAFT 

 

 CRUDE OIL SALES AGREEMENT 

This is to confirm the Agreement between us as follows: 
  

	1.	Parties: 

  

					
	SELLER	  	-	  	SAUDI ARABIAN OIL COMPANY, A COMPANY WITH LIMITED LIABILITY ORGANIZED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
			
	BUYER	  	-	  	 PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY
 COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

			
	BUYER
 ASSIGNEE
	  	-	  	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

  

	2.	Term of Agreement: 

 This
Agreement shall be effective as of July 14, 2011 and shall continue in effect until the parties have completed all of their obligations hereunder. 
  

	3.	Grade, Quantity and Quality: 

  

	 	3.1	SELLER shall deliver and sell to BUYER and BUYER shall buy and lift from SELLER, or cause BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to buy and lift from SELLER, on a day from
August 15 to August 17, 2011, inclusive (the “Accepted Lifting Date Range”) a total of [REDACTED] barrels of Saudi Arabian crude oil, of which [REDACTED] barrels shall be Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, and [REDACTED] barrels shall
be Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil, minus up to ten percent (10%) at BUYERS’s or SELLER’s option, or plus up to ten percent(10%) if BUYER so requests and SELLER agrees. 


 

	 	3.2	 The quality of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil and Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil delivered hereunder shall be the usual quality of that grade SELLER makes
available at SELLER’s Marine Loading Terminal at [REDACTED] (“Loading Port”), at the time the crude oil is delivered. SELLER warrants that it has good and marketable title to the crude oil, free and clear of all charges, liens and
encumbrances but THERE ARE NO GUARANTEES OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, OF MERCHANTABILITY, 



  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 1 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	 	
FITNESS OR SUITABILITY OF THE CRUDE OIL, FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE, WHICH EXTEND BEYOND THE DESCRIPTION OF THE CRUDE OIL AND ANY SPECIFICATIONS THEREFOR CONTAINED IN THIS AGREEMENT.


  

	4.	Price: 

  

	 	4.1	The price per barrel of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil to be sold hereunder shall be the [REDACTED], as calculated in Paragraph 4.3 below, minus a differential of
[REDACTED] per barrel. 

  

	 	4.2	The price per barrel of Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil to be sold hereunder shall be the [REDACTED], as calculated in Paragraph 4.3 below, minus a differential of
[REDACTED] per barrel. 

  

	 	4.3	The [REDACTED] shall be calculated as the arithmetic average of the [REDACTED] published in the Argus Crude Report for such grade for all the quotation days, inclusive,
during the period from the [REDACTED] of the month [REDACTED] to the scheduled month of delivery, through the [REDACTED] of the scheduled month of delivery. 


 

	 	4.4	Should completion of physical loading of the vessel nominated by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE occur before or after the scheduled month of delivery, the price of such
cargo, unless mutually agreed otherwise, shall be calculated using the differential that would apply if completion of physical loading of the vessel has occurred in the [REDACTED]. 


 

	5.	Payment: 

  

	 	5.1	Payment for this cargo of crude oil sold shall be made in the full amount of SELLER’s invoice without discounts or deductions by BUYER to SELLER via electronic
transfer in immediately available funds in U.S. Dollars to SELLER’s account as follows: 

 JPMorgan Chase,
New York [REDACTED] 
 Under direct [REDACTED] advice to 

JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 
 For the account of JPMorgan Chase, London [REDACTED] 
 Account no. [REDACTED] for
further credit to 
 The Saudi Arabian Oil Company (Saudi Aramco) 

Account no. [REDACTED] 

  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 2 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 

 For the cargo of crude oil delivered under this Agreement, SELLER shall present to the
BUYER the SELLER’s invoice and the Bill of Lading, and BUYER’s payment to SELLER shall be made not later than [REDACTED] from and including the Bill of Lading date. 
 If any payment hereunder falls due on a Saturday, Sunday, or a banking holiday in New York, then payment shall be effected on the next bank business day. 

 

	 	5.2	All invoices for crude oil sold under this Agreement shall be sent to BUYER by telex, facsimile, courier or mail (at SELLER’s discretion) in accordance with the
information contained in BUYER’s acceptance telex. 

  

	 	5.3	If it is impossible or impracticable for SELLER to calculate the price for the cargo of crude oil sold hereunder prior to issuance of an invoice for the cargo, SELLER
shall send to BUYER a provisional invoice, and BUYER shall pay said invoice in accordance with paragraph 5.1. SELLER’s provisional invoice shall be based upon (i) SELLER’s good faith estimate of the price(s) as provided in Paragraph 4
with reference to the reference crude(s) and differential(s) applicable to the cargo and (ii) SELLER’s best estimate of the quantity of crude oil delivered. 


 

	 	5.4	Any amount not paid by BUYER when due shall bear interest from the date upon which payment was due through the date of payment at a rate equal to one percent
(1%) above the one (1) month London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) for U.S. Dollar deposits offered by the National Westminster Bank at 11:00 a.m., London time, on the first banking day of the month in which payment was due. Such
payments of interest shall be made in the full amount due, free of any withholding tax imposed by any government. 

  

	 	5.5	For the cargo of crude oil to be lifted or received under this agreement, BUYER shall establish and deliver to SELLER at least ten (10) days prior to the Accepted
Lifting Date Range, an irrevocable standby Letter of Credit issued or confirmed by a bank acceptable to SELLER in accordance with the attached FORM L (02/18/08). All bank charges incurred in connection with the establishment of letters of credit,
including, without limitation, opening, amendment and correspondent charges, confirmation and all related banking fees, commissions or expenses shall be for BUYER’s account. In addition, BUYER shall bear all costs of demurrage or any other fees
or charges arising from BUYER’s failure to provide a Letter of Credit or confirmation thereof acceptable to SELLER by the Accepted Lifting Date Range. BUYER’s provision of a Letter of Credit is an express condition precedent to
SELLER’s obligation to deliver and sell crude oil under this agreement. 


  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 3 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	6.	Independent Inspection and Measurement 

  

	 	6.1	SELLER shall arrange, at its expense, an independent inspector to verify the quality and quantity of crude oil delivered to BUYER and shall cause said inspector to
provide promptly to BUYER a copy (or copies as requested by BUYER) of inspector’s summary report only. Should BUYER require more detailed loading information, BUYER shall have the right to equally share the cost of the inspection with SELLER,
and SELLER shall cause said inspector to provide to BUYER a copy of the inspector’s full report and other documentation relating to the inspection. 

  

	 	6.2	The quantity of crude oil shipped and sold hereunder shall be determined using, at SELLER’s option, either custody transfer meter measurements carried out by
SELLER, or shore tank measurements gauged by SELLER immediately before and after loading. In determining the net volume of crude oil shipped, adjustment in volume to sixty degrees Fahrenheit, owing to differences in temperature, shall be made in
accordance with ASTM IP Petroleum Measurement Table 6, American Edition 1952, prepared jointly by the American Society for Testing Materials and the Institute of Petroleum (or, subject to prior Saudi Arab Government approval, the currently effective
tables superseding the same). 

  

	 	6.3	Test of quality, unless otherwise mutually agreed, shall be made according to the latest Standard or Tentative Standard Methods of the American Society for Testing
Materials that may be available in official publications of the Society at the time such tests are made (the testing methods being subject to the approval of the Saudi Arab Government). 


 

	 	6.4	SELLER shall, at its own expense, take and retain samples of shipments of crude oil and shall furnish suitable storage accommodations for such samples. Samples shall be
kept for a period of not less than ninety (90) days provided that SELLER shall keep samples up to a period of not more than one (1) year if so specifically requested and justified in writing by BUYER in each instance, subject to
SELLER’s approval, which shall not be unreasonably withheld. 

  

	 	6.5	The determination of quantity and quality, as provided in this Paragraph 6, shall be final and binding on both BUYER and SELLER, and the quantity and quality so
determined shall be deemed to be the quantity and quality shipped and sold. 


  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 4 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	7.	Delivery: 

  

	 	7.1	Delivery and lifting shall be free on board (F.O.B.) at the Loading Port in accordance with the Terms and Conditions Governing Deliveries of Bulk Crude Oil by Saudi
Aramco as “SELLER” at [REDACTED], dated [REDACTED] as SELLER may amend such Terms and Conditions from time to time. 

  

	 	7.2	In connection with F.O.B. delivery at the Loading Port; BUYER shall have the right to appoint at its expense an independent inspector to witness the quantity and
quality measurements of crude oil performed by SELLER in accordance with appropriate measurement standards and procedures in use at the loading terminal. 

  

	 	7.3	Dues and other charges on BUYER’s vessel(s) at the loading port and terminal shall be for BUYER’s account. The amount of any taxes, duties, imposts, fees,
charges, and dues of every description imposed or levied by any governmental, local or port authority on the crude oil supplied hereunder, or on any vessel used in its transportation, in respect of any stage after such crude oil passes the
tankship’s permanent hose connection at the loading terminal, shall be for BUYER’s account. 

  

	8.	Title and Risk of Loss: 


Title to and risk of loss of all crude oil sold hereunder shall pass to BUYER at the point at which the loading terminal’s loading
line connects with the vessel’s permanent hose connection,. It is expressly understood that the passage of title and risk of loss as aforesaid is not conditioned upon delivery or receipt of Bills of Lading. 

 

	9.	Destination: 

 The country
of destination of crude oil delivered hereunder shall be the State of Delaware in the United States of America for the Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil and the State of New Jersey in the United States of America for the Arabian [REDACTED] crude oil,
subject to the export laws and regulations of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The final country destination of crude oil delivered hereunder shall be confirmed and attested to by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE to SELLER not later than [REDACTED] days
after BUYER’s or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE’s payment for such cargo. The parties hereto contemplate that all crude oil purchased under this 

  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 5 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	 	
Agreement shall be processed by BUYER or BUYER’s ASSIGNEE and accordingly, the parties contemplate that neither the BUYER nor BUYER’s ASSIGNEE will resell the crude oil purchased under
this Agreement in its original form or blend it with other crude oils for purpose of resale. 

  

	10.	Termination for Cause: 


SELLER or BUYER shall have the right to terminate this Agreement upon written notice to the other party in the event of a material breach
(including without limitation anticipatory breach) by the other party of any of its terms, but without prejudice to the rights of either party theretofore accrued with respect to this Agreement (including without limitation the right of either party
to damages arising from such breach or prior breaches hereof). Material breach by BUYER shall include, without limitation, BUYER’s failure to lift and buy crude oil as required in Paragraph 2 hereof or BUYER’s failure to comply with any of
the Payment provisions of Paragraph 5. The delay or failure on the part of either party hereto to insist, in any one instance or more, upon strict performance of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement, or to exercise any right or privilege
herein conferred shall not be construed as a waiver of any such terms, conditions, rights or privileges, but the same shall continue and remain in full force and effect. All rights and remedies are cumulative. 

 

	11.	Disputes: 

 Any dispute,
controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this Agreement, or the breach or termination or invalidity thereof, which is not settled by agreement between the parties shall be finally settled in accordance with the Arbitration Regulations and
the Rules for Implementation of the Arbitration Regulations for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, together with any amendments thereto which may be issued from time to time, by three neutral and impartial arbitrators, one to be appointed by each party
and the third to be appointed by the two so chosen. The arbitrators shall base their award only upon the evidence presented to them, the terms of this Agreement and the laws of Saudi Arabia. This arbitration provision shall be specifically
enforceable by either party under the Regulations, and the arbitrators’ award shall be final and binding on the parties. 

  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 6 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	12.	Other Terms: 

  

	 	12.1	This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the successors and assigns of the parties to this Agreement; however, neither party may assign or
transfer this Agreement, either in whole or in part, without first obtaining the written consent of the other. 

  

	 	12.2	In no event shall either party be liable in connection herewith or with respect to operations related hereto, whether in tort, contract or otherwise, for special,
indirect or consequential damages. 

  

	 	12.3	Except as otherwise required to implement this Agreement, BUYER undertakes to treat the contents of this Agreement as strictly confidential, except as may be required
by law. For violation of this undertaking by BUYER, SELLER shall have the right to immediately cancel this Agreement, without any liability as a result of such cancellation, upon giving notice to BUYER. 


 

	 	12.4	This Agreement, and any amendments hereto, consisting of this signed document, any attachments hereto and other documents referred to herein, is intended by the parties
as a final expression of their agreement and is intended also as a complete and exclusive statement of the terms of their agreement. 

  

	 	12.5	The laws and regulations of the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia shall govern the interpretation and performance of this Agreement and any further Agreements
that may result from it. 

  

	 	12.6	Each party shall be relieved from the performance of any obligation, other than the obligation to make payments for amounts due hereunder, during the time and to the
extent performance of such obligation is prevented or restricted as a result of force majeure event. The term “force majeure” as used in this Agreement shall mean any act, event, cause or occurrence rendering a party unable to perform its
obligations which is not within the reasonable control of such party. BUYER and SELLER specifically agree that SELLER’s inability to perform all, or any part, of this Agreement due to Government action or directive shall constitute a force
majeure event; however, the term force majeure shall not apply to those events which merely make it more difficult or costly for BUYER to perform its obligations hereunder. BUYER and SELLER further agree that at the conclusion of any force majeure
event, neither BUYER nor SELLER shall have any obligation to each other with respect to any quantities of crude oil not delivered as a consequence of such force majeure event. No condition of force majeure shall operate to extend the term of this
Agreement. 


  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 7 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	










 DRAFT 

 


	 	12.7	If at any time SELLER determines that reasonable grounds for insecurity have arisen with respect to BUYER’s performance of any BUYER’s obligations under this
Agreement, SELLER may demand adequate assurance of due performance by BUYER, and until SELLER receives such assurance SELLER may suspend its performance of obligations under this Agreement. BUYER’s failure to provide within a reasonable time
not exceeding ten (10) days such assurance of due performance as is adequate under the circumstances will constitute a material breach of this Agreement. 


 

	 	12.8	Compliance with ISPS CODE: 

  

	 	(a)	SELLER and BUYER shall comply with the International Code for the Security of Ships and Port Facilities and relevant amendments to chapter X1 of the International
Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974 (SOLAS), hereinafter (ISPS Code), in accordance with Form-I of this Agreement, which shall govern the parties rights and obligations with respect to such compliance. 


 

	 	(b)	In the event of any conflict between this Agreement and its Form-I (ISPS CODE TERMS AND CONDITIONS), the terms and conditions of Form-I shall prevail.


 IN WITNESS of this Agreement, the parties have caused it to be signed on the dates shown below in two (2) copies, each of
which shall serve as a duplicate original. 
  

							
	For and on behalf of BUYER: 	  	For and on behalf of SELLER: 
	REPRESENTED BY:	  	REPRESENTED BY:
				
	By:	 	  
	  	By: 	 	  

		 		  		 	Mohammad H. Khazindar
				
	Title:	 	  
	  	Title:	 	Manager, Crude Oil Sales and Marketing Department
				
	Date:	 	  
	  	Date:	 	  



  

			
	 F.O.B. Crude Sales Agreement (Spot) – PBF Holding
	  	Page 8 of 8
	 (20 july 11) (whm)
	  	









  

			
	 : Saudi Arabian Oil Company

: Crude Oil Sales and Marketing Department

:TN-1030, Tower Building

: Dhahran 31311, Saudi Arabia
	  	 :Te1: (+966-3)874-5322
 : Fax:
(+966-3) 873-2173


  
 



 
 July 20, 2011 
 COSMD - 117/2011 
 Freight Protection for [REDACTED]

 Dear Mr. XXXXX, 

Please be advised that Saudi Aramco will add freight protection to your [REDACTED] lifting of Arabian [REDACTED] and Arabian [REDACTED] grades of crude
oil made pursuant to our Spot/Letter Agreement (COSMD-117/2011 dated July 20, 2011) which is destined for your refining facility in the State of Delaware, United States of America, in the case of the Arabian [REDACTED], and your refining
facility in the State of New Jersey, United States of America, in the case of the Arabian [REDACTED]. It is expressly understood that Saudi Aramco reserves the right to prospectively revoke this freight protection at any time by giving you written
notice of said revocation. 
 Recognizing that the cost of shipping crude oil from [REDACTED] to the U.S. Gulf is subject to monthly
fluctuations, Saudi Aramco freight protection is designed to adjust upward or downward the price of [REDACTED] crude oil for the U.S. Gulf destination. 
 Saudi Aramco freight protection is calculated as follows: 
 First, the monthly average cost of
shipping crude oil from [REDACTED] to [REDACTED] is assessed by the [REDACTED]. The [REDACTED] assessment is based on the movement of cargoes of one or two grades of non-heat crude oil in [REDACTED]. The [REDACTED] monthly assessment is made in
terms of $ per metric ton. 
 Second, Saudi Aramco adjusts the [REDACTED] monthly assessment from [REDACTED] using a Saudi Aramco monthly
calculated percentage factor to reflect the cost of shipping crude oil from [REDACTED]. The percentage factor used reflects the [REDACTED], [REDACTED], or the [REDACTED]. 







 Third, the difference is calculated between the [REDACTED] monthly assessment adjusted by the monthly
calculated percentage factor and the Base Freight Rate from [REDACTED]. The Base Freight Rate is $[REDACTED] per metric ton. 
 Fourth,
the calculated difference is converted from $ per metric to $ per barrel using the following densities: 
  

					
	 	  	Barrels/Metric Ton	 
	 Arabian [REDACTED]
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Arabian [REDACTED]
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 

 As an example, the [REDACTED] monthly assessment for May 2011 was $[REDACTED] per metric ton. The Saudi Aramco calculated
monthly percentage factor for May 2011 was [REDACTED]%. The calculated difference with the Base Freight Rate was $[REDACTED] per metric ton. The freight protection for Arab [REDACTED] and Arab [REDACTED] for May 2011 was $[REDACTED] per barrel and
$[REDACTED] per barrel respectively. 
 The freight protection methodology is subject to revision from time to time as deemed necessary and
appropriate. 
  

	
	Regards,
	
	  

	 Mohammad H. Khazindar, Manager
 Crude Oil Sales & Marketing Department



 ASK 
  

	cc:	SPII, New York 

 Operations
Accounting Department 
 Customer File 
 Letter Book 







 SPECIFIC TERMS IN THIS EXHIBIT HAVE BEEN REDACTED BECAUSE CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR THOSE TERMS HAS BEEN
REQUESTED. THE REDACTED MATERIAL HAS BEEN SEPARATELY FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, AND THE TERMS HAVE BEEN MARKED AT THE APPROPRIATE PLACE WITH THE WORD “[REDACTED]”. 

APPENDICES 
  

					
			
	APPENDIX 1	 	–	  	FORM OF ESTIMATED PERIOD QUANTITY (EPQ) STATEMENT
			
	APPENDIX 2	 	–	  	INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENTS
			
	APPENDIX 3	 	–	  	PAYMENT DIRECTION AGREEMENT
			
	APPENDIX 4	 	–	  	REFINERY DESCRIPTION
			
	APPENDIX 5	 	–	  	STORAGE FACILITIES USE PROVISIONS
			
	APPENDIX 6	 	–	  	GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF SERVICE
			
	APPENDIX 7	 	–	  	LIST OF MUTUALLY AGREED GRADES
			
	APPENDIX 8	 	–	  	REQUIREMENTS SCHEDULE
			
	APPENDIX 9	 	–	  	GRADE PECKING ORDER
			
	APPENDIX 10	 	–	  	CARGO CONFIRMATION NOTICE
			
	APPENDIX 11	 	–	  	COMMENCEMENT INVENTORY ACQUISITION
			
	APPENDIX 12	 	–	  	TERMINATION OF DELIVERIES NOTICE
			
	APPENDIX 13	 	–	  	SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS
			
	APPENDIX 14	 	–	  	CARGO BANKS AND HEDGE MONTHS SPREADSHEET
			
	APPENDIX 15	 	–	  	CARGO TABLE SPREADSHEET
			
	APPENDIX 16	 	–	  	FORM OF DELAWARE CITY TANK LEASE
			
	APPENDIX 17	 	–	  	FORM OF BUYER’S INVENTORY STATEMENT
			
	APPENDIX 18	 	–	  	FORM OF PETTY CASH SPREADSHEET
			
	APPENDIX 19	 	–	  	REFINERY MARINE TERMS
			
	APPENDIX 20	 	–	  	STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT
			
	APPENDIX 21	 	–	  	HSE AND ETHICS POLICY








 APPENDIX 1 – FORM OF ESTIMATED PERIOD QUANTITY (EPQ) STATEMENT 

 
 



 

  
 Appendix 1

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 2 – INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENTS 

Set out on Attachment I is that certain Intercreditor Agreement between UBS AG, Stamford Branch, Statoil Marketing & Trading
(US) Inc., PBF Holding Company LLC, Delaware City Refining Company LLC and Paulsboro Refining Company LLC. 
 Set out on
Attachment II is that certain Intercreditor Agreement between Valero Refining and Marketing Company, Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc., PBF Holding Company LLC and Paulsboro Refining Company LLC. 

  
 Appendix 2

 Page 1 








 ATTACHMENT I TO APPENDIX 2 

INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENT 
 Dated as of December     , 2010 
 by and among 

STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., 
 UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH, 
 as Revolving Agent, 

UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH, 
 as Term Loan Agent, 
 PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, 

DELAWARE CITY REFINING COMPANY LLC 
 and 
 PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC, 

as Borrowers, 

and 
 THE
OTHER LOAN PARTIES HERETO 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 1 








 This INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENT, dated as of December     , 2010 (as
amended, restated, supplemented or otherwise modified from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof, this “Agreement”), by and among STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC. (“Statoil”), UBS AG,
STAMFORD BRANCH, in its capacity as Revolving Agent, for itself and on behalf of the Revolving Lenders (as defined below) (the “Revolving Agent”), UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH, in its capacity as Term Loan Agent, for itself and on behalf
of the Term Loan Lenders (as defined below) (the “Term Loan Agent” and together with the Revolving Agent, the “Lenders Agents”), PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC (“Holdings”), DELAWARE CITY REFINING COMPANY
LLC (“DCR”) and PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC (“PBF” and together with Holdings and DCR, the “Borrowers”), and the other Loan Parties (as defined below) party hereto. 

RECITALS: 

A. Statoil has entered into that certain oil supply agreement, dated as of the date hereof (as amended, restated, supplemented or
otherwise modified from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof, the “Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement”), by and among Statoil and Holdings under which Statoil has agreed to supply crude oil and feedstocks to, and provide
related services to, Holdings and purchase the crude oil and feedstocks in the tanks at, and on the water for, the Paulsboro Facility.  
 B. The Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement provides for the filing of UCC financing statements to perfect the ownership and security interest of Statoil with respect to certain Statoil Assets and Collateral.

 D. The Borrowers, the other Loan Parties party thereto, the Revolving Agent and the financial institutions from time to time
party thereto as lenders (collectively, the “Revolving Lenders”) are parties to that certain Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of the date hereof (as amended, restated supplemented or otherwise modified from time to time in
accordance with the terms hereof, the “Revolving Credit Agreement”). 
 E. To secure the Borrowers’ and
the other Loan Parties’ obligations to the Revolving Lenders and the Revolving Agent under the Revolving Credit Agreement and the other Revolving Loan Documents (as hereinafter defined), the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties have granted to
the Revolving Agent for the benefit of the Revolving Agent and the Revolving Lenders a Lien on many of the assets of the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties. 
 F. The Borrowers, the other Loan Parties party thereto, the Term Loan Agent and the financial institutions from time to time party thereto as lenders (collectively, the “Term Loan
Lenders” and together with the Revolving Lenders, the “Lenders”) are parties to that certain Term Loan Credit Agreement, dated as of the date hereof (as amended, restated supplemented or otherwise modified from time to time
in accordance with the terms hereof, the “Term Loan Credit Agreement” and together with the Revolving Credit Agreement, the “Credit Agreements”). 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 2 








 G. To secure the Borrowers’ and the other Loan Parties’ obligations to the Term
Loan Lenders and the Term Loan Agent under the Term Loan Credit Agreement and the other Term Loan Documents (as hereinafter defined), the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties have granted to the Term Loan Agent for the benefit of the Term Loan Agent
and the Term Loan Lenders a Lien on many of the assets of the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties. 
 H. The parties hereto
wish to set forth certain agreements with respect to the Statoil Assets and Collateral (as hereinafter defined) and with respect to the Lenders Collateral (as hereinafter defined). 

NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and the mutual covenants contained herein, and for other good and valuable
consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, it is hereby agreed as follows: 
 ARTICLE 1.
DEFINITIONS. 
 1.1 Certain Defined Terms. As used in this Agreement, the following terms shall have the following
meanings (such meanings to be equally applicable to both the singular and plural forms of the terms defined): 

“Affiliate” means, when used with respect to a specified Person, another Person that directly, or indirectly through one
or more intermediaries, Controls or is Controlled by or is under common Control with the Person specified; provided, that with respect to Statoil, “Affiliates” shall mean only those Affiliates that have current or future rights
under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or any related agreement, instrument or document. 
 “Certain Hydrocarbon
Assets” means crude oil, feedstock, indigenous feedstock and other hydrocarbon inventory of the same type sold to the Loan Parties by Statoil and/or its Affiliates and all proceeds of such crude oil, feedstock, indigenous feedstock or other
hydrocarbon inventory of the same type (it being understood and agreed that immediately upon any payment in cash to the Loan Parties in respect of such crude oil, feedstock, indigenous feedstock or other hydrocarbon inventory of the same type, such
proceeds shall cease to be “Certain Hydrocarbon Assets”). For the avoidance of doubt, Certain Hydrocarbon Assets shall not include Intermediate Products. 
 “Certain MSCG Receivables” means accounts originated by the sale of Refined Products sold by the Loan Parties to MSCG and/or its Affiliates under the Paulsboro Morgan Stanley Off-Take
Agreement (it being understood and agreed that upon collection of such accounts by virtue of payment in cash in respect thereof to any Loan Party, the proceeds of such accounts will cease to be “Certain MSCG Receivables”). 

“Claims” means the Revolving Lenders Claims, the Term Loan Lenders Claims or the Statoil Claims, as applicable.

 “Control” means the possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to direct or cause the direction of the
management or policies of a Person, whether through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise, and the terms “Controlling” and “Controlled” shall have meanings correlative thereto. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 3 








 “Disposition” means, with respect to any assets of any Borrower or any
other Loan Party, any liquidation of such Borrower or such other Loan Party or its assets, the establishment of any receivership for such Borrower or such other Loan Party or its assets, a bankruptcy proceeding of such Borrower or such other Loan
Party (either voluntary or involuntary), the payment of any insurance, condemnation, confiscation, seizure or other claim upon the condemnation, confiscation, seizure, loss or destruction thereof, or damage to, or any other sale, transfer,
assignment or other disposition of such assets. 
 “Enforcement” means collectively or individually, for:
(a) Statoil or any of its Affiliates during the continuance of a Statoil Event of Default (i) to demand payment in full of or accelerate any of the obligations, including, without limitation, any payment obligations, of any Borrower or any
other Loan Party to Statoil or (ii) to commence the judicial or nonjudicial enforcement of any right or remedy or to commence any action to enforce any provision under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement; (b) any of the Revolving Agent or
the Revolving Lenders during the continuance of a Revolving Lenders Event of Default (i) to demand payment in full of or accelerate the indebtedness of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party to the Revolving Lenders and Revolving Agent
or (ii) to commence the judicial or nonjudicial enforcement of any of the default rights and remedies under any of the Revolving Loan Documents; and (c) any of the Term Loan Agent or the Term Loan Lenders during the continuance of a Term
Loan Event of Default (i) to demand payment in full of or accelerate the indebtedness of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party to the Term Loan Lenders and Term Loan Agent or (ii) to commence the judicial or nonjudicial enforcement of
any of the default rights and remedies under any of the Term Loan Documents. 
 “Enforcement Notice” means a
written notice delivered in accordance with Section 2.5 which notice shall: (i) if delivered by Statoil, state that a Statoil Event of Default has occurred and is continuing and that Statoil intends to commence an Enforcement,
specify the nature of the Statoil Event of Default that caused Statoil to intend to take such action, and state that an Enforcement Period has commenced; (ii) if delivered by the Revolving Agent, state that a Revolving Lenders Event of Default
has occurred and is continuing and that the payment in full of the Revolving Lenders Claims has been demanded or the indebtedness of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party to the Revolving Lenders has been accelerated, specify the nature of
the Revolving Lenders Event of Default that caused such demand and acceleration, and state that an Enforcement Period has commenced; (iii) if delivered by the Term Loan Agent, state that a Term Loan Event of Default has occurred and is
continuing and that the payment in full of the Term Loan Lenders Claims has been demanded or the indebtedness of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party to the Term Loan Lenders has been accelerated, specify the nature of the Term Loan Event of
Default that caused such demand and acceleration, and state that an Enforcement Period has commenced. 
 “Enforcement
Period” means the period of time following the receipt by both Lenders Agents, on the one hand, or Statoil, on the other hand, of an Enforcement Notice delivered by the other until the earliest of the following: (1) the Statoil Claims
have been 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 4 








 
satisfied in full, Statoil has no further obligations under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement and the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement has been terminated (other than, in each case, for any
Unasserted Contingent Obligation); (2) the Lenders Claims have been satisfied in full, the Lenders have no further obligations under the Credit Agreements and the other Loan Documents and the Credit Agreements and the other Loan Documents have
been terminated (other than, in each case, for any Unasserted Contingent Obligation); and (3) all of the parties hereto agree in writing to terminate the Enforcement Period. 

“Intermediate Products” shall mean hydrocarbons intermediate products and blendstocks. For the avoidance of doubt,
Intermediate Products shall not include Certain Hydrocarbon Assets or Refined Products. 
 “Lenders” mean the
Revolving Lenders and the Term Loan Lenders. 
 “Lenders Claims” means the Revolving Lenders Claims and the
Term Loan Lenders Claims. 
 “Lenders Collateral” means the Revolving Lenders Collateral and the Term Loan
Lenders Collateral. In no event shall the “Lenders Collateral” include any of the Statoil Assets and Collateral. 

“Lenders Interests” means the Revolving Lenders Interests and the Term Loan Lenders Interests. 

“Lien” means, with respect to any property, (a) any mortgage, deed of trust, lien, pledge, encumbrance, claim,
charge, assignment, hypothecation, ownership right or interest, security interest or encumbrance of any kind or any arrangement to provide priority or preference or any filing of any financing statement under the UCC or any other similar notice of
lien under any similar notice or recording statute of any governmental authority, including any easement, right-of-way or other encumbrance on title to real property, in each of the foregoing cases whether voluntary or imposed by law, and any
agreement to give any of the foregoing; (b) the interest of a vendor or a lessor under any conditional sale agreement, capital lease or title retention agreement (or any financing lease having substantially the same economic effect as any of
the foregoing) relating to such property; and (c) in the case of securities, any purchase option, call or similar right of a third party with respect to such securities. 
 “Loan Documents” means the Revolving Loan Documents and the Term Loan Documents. 
 “Loan Parties” means the Revolving Loan Parties and the Term Loan Parties. 
 “MSCG” means Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc., and its successors and assigns (including any changed counterparty). 

“Paulsboro Facility” means Paulsboro’s petroleum refinery, terminalling facility and all related assets and
properties located in Paulsboro, New Jersey. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 5 








 “Paulsboro Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreement” means that certain Products
Off-Take Agreement, dated as of December 14, 2010, between MSCG and Holdings (with Holdings assigning its rights and obligations immediately to Paulsboro upon the Closing of the Acquisition), as such agreement may be replaced, superseded,
amended (including as to changes of counterparty), modified or supplemented from time to time. 
 “Paulsboro Oil Supply
Agreement” shall have the meaning given to such term in the Recitals to this Agreement. 
 “Person”
means any individual, partnership, corporation (including a business trust), joint stock company, limited liability company, trust, unincorporated association, joint venture or other entity. 

“Proceeds” has the meaning ascribed to such term in the UCC. 

“Refined Products” means finished gasoline, heating oil, lube oil, specialty grades, slurry, diesel fuel, and jet fuel
for onward sale to MSCG pursuant to the Paulsboro Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreement. For the avoidance of doubt, for purposes of this Agreement, the term “Refined Products” excludes intermediate products, components of gasoline, heating
oil, lube oil, diesel fuel or jet fuel and all other products other than those specifically listed above in this definition. 

“Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement” means that certain Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement, dated as of
the date hereof, by and between the Term Loan Agent and the Revolving Agent. 
 “Revolving Lenders” shall mean
the Lenders from time to time party to the Revolving Credit Agreement, the Revolving Agent and each other Secured Party (as defined in the Revolving Security Agreement). 
 “Revolving Lenders Claims” means all of the indebtedness, obligations and other liabilities of the Borrowers and the other Revolving Loan Parties now or hereafter arising under, or in
connection with, the Revolving Credit Agreement and the other Revolving Loan Documents, including, but not limited to, all sums now or hereafter loaned or advanced to or for the benefit of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party, all
reimbursement obligations of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party with respect to letters of credit and guarantees issued thereunder for its account, all guarantee obligations of the Revolving Loan Parties, any interest thereon (including,
without limitation, interest accruing after the commencement of a bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding relating to any of the Revolving Loan Parties, whether or not such interest is an allowed claim in any such proceeding), any obligations
under any hedging agreement and/or treasury services agreement with any counterparty that is a secured party pursuant to any Revolving Loan Documents, any reimbursement obligations, fees or expenses due thereunder, and any costs of collection or
enforcement, and, in all events, shall include any and all “Secured Obligations” (as such term is defined in the Revolving Credit Agreement). 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 6 








 “Revolving Lenders Collateral” means all property and interests in
property, now owned or hereafter acquired or created, of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party in or upon which a Revolving Lenders Interest is granted or purported to be granted by such Borrower or such other Revolving Loan Party to the
Revolving Lenders or the Revolving Agent under any of the Revolving Loan Documents and all Proceeds thereof, in each case, other than property and assets comprising the Statoil Assets and Collateral; provided, however, that, upon the
payment of cash or cash equivalents to any account owned by Statoil of any amounts in respect of any property or interests in property, now owned or hereafter acquired or created, of any Borrower or any other Revolving Loan Party in or upon which a
Revolving Lenders Interest is granted or purported to be granted by such Borrower or such other Revolving Loan Party to the Revolving Lenders or the Revolving Agent under any of the Revolving Loan Documents and all Proceeds thereof, in each case,
other than property and assets comprising the Statoil Assets and Collateral, then such cash and/or cash equivalents shall cease to be “Revolving Lenders Collateral”. 
 “Revolving Lenders Event of Default” means an “Event of Default” as defined in the Revolving Credit Agreement. 

“Revolving Lenders Interest” means, with respect to any property or interest in property, now owned or hereafter
acquired or created, of any Borrower or any of the other Revolving Loan Parties, any Lien (regardless of the priority thereof) of the Revolving Agent or the Revolving Lenders on such property or interest in property, provided, that, the parties
agree that the Revolving Lenders Interest shall not cover or encumber in any way the Statoil Assets and Collateral. 

“Revolving Loan Documents” means “Loan Documents” as such term is defined in the Revolving Credit Agreement.

 “Revolving Loan Party” means “Loan Party” as such term is defined in the Revolving Credit
Agreement. 
 “Statoil Assets and Collateral” means: (i) Certain Hydrocarbon Assets; (ii) Certain
MSCG Receivables; (iii) oil and feedstock to be sold to the Borrowers or the other Loan Parties by Statoil prior to the time at which title thereto passes from Statoil to such Borrowers or other Loan Parties by passing through the outlet flange
of the storage tanks and entering the Paulsboro Facility, and all payments under insurance, indemnity, warranty, or guaranty of, or for any of, the foregoing; (iv) contract rights in respect of the refined products sale contracts with MSCG
solely to the extent related to the Certain MSCG Receivables; (v) oil and feedstock stored in the tanks located at the Paulsboro Facility which is owned by Statoil or has been sold by Statoil to a Borrower or any other Loan Party and any other
oil and feedstock located at tanks that are used in connection with the operation of the Paulsboro Facility; and (vi) Proceeds with respect to any of the foregoing; provided, however, that, upon the payment of cash or cash
equivalents to any Borrower or any other Loan Party of any amounts in respect of any items set forth in clauses (i) through (vi) inclusive of this definition, such cash and/or cash equivalents proceeds shall cease to be
“Statoil Assets and Collateral”. For the avoidance of doubt, notwithstanding the foregoing or any other provisions of this Agreement, the Revolving Loan 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 7 








 
Documents, the Term Loan Documents and/or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, and without limiting the generality or scope of the definitions of “Revolving Lenders Collateral” or
“Term Lenders Collateral”, Statoil Assets and Collateral shall not include (a) propane, refinery grade propylene, normal butane, asphalt, decant oil, petcoke, sulfur, extracts or other finished goods inventory of the Paulsboro
Facility (that are not Refined Products), (b) any accounts receivable arising from the sale of any of the inventory or other property described in the preceding clause (a) or (c) any Proceeds of any such inventory, accounts
receivable or other property described in the preceding clauses (a) or (b). 
 “Statoil
Claims” means all amounts, obligations and other liabilities of any Borrower or any other Loan Party to Statoil now or hereafter arising under, or in connection with, the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement including time value of money and any
interest thereon (including, without limitation, interest accruing after the commencement of a bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding relating to any of the Borrowers or Loan Parties, whether or not such interest is an allowed claim in any
such proceeding), any reimbursement obligations, fees or expenses due thereunder, and any costs of collection or enforcement in each case as provided for under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or applicable law. 

“Statoil Event of Default” means the occurrence of any event (including, without limitation, any default) or the breach
of any provision under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement which would enable Statoil to exercise any right or remedy, demand any payment, declare any breach or take any other action in respect of the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement. 

“Statoil Interest” means, with respect to any Statoil Assets and Collateral now owned or hereafter acquired or created
of the Borrowers or the other Loan Parties or Statoil or its Affiliates, any security interest of Statoil or any of its Affiliates in, or any Lien or ownership right or interest of Statoil or any of its Affiliates on, such Statoil Assets and
Collateral. 
 “Term Loan Lenders” shall mean the Lenders from time to time party to the Term Loan Credit
Agreement, the Term Loan Agent and each other Secured Party (as defined in the Term Loan Security Agreement). 
 “Term
Loan Lenders Claims” means all of the indebtedness, obligations and other liabilities of the Borrowers and the other Term Loan Parties now or hereafter arising under, or in connection with, the Term Loan Credit Agreements and the other Term
Loan Documents, including, but not limited to, all sums now or hereafter loaned or advanced to or for the benefit of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party, all reimbursement obligations of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party with respect
to letters of credit and guarantees issued thereunder for its account, all guarantee obligations of the Term Loan Parties, any interest thereon (including, without limitation, interest accruing after the commencement of a bankruptcy, insolvency or
similar proceeding relating to any of the Term Loan Parties, whether or not such interest is an allowed claim in any such proceeding), any obligation under any hedging agreement and/or treasury services agreement with any counterparty that is a
secured party pursuant to any Term Loan Documents, any reimbursement obligations, fees or expenses due thereunder, and any costs of collection or enforcement, and, in all events, shall include any and all “Secured Obligations” (as such
term is defined in the Term Loan Credit Agreement). 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 8 








 “Term Loan Lenders Collateral” means all property and interests in
property, now owned or hereafter acquired or created, of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party in or upon which a Term Loan Lenders Interest is granted or purported to be granted by such Borrower or such other Term Loan Party to the Term Loan
Lenders or the Term Loan Agent under any of the Term Loan Documents and all Proceeds thereof, other than property and assets comprising the Statoil Assets and Collateral; provided, however, that, upon the payment of cash or cash
equivalents to any account owned by Statoil of any amounts in respect of any property or interests in property, now owned or hereafter acquired or created, of any Borrower or any other Term Loan Party in or upon which a Term Loan Lenders Interest is
granted or purported to be granted by such Borrower or such other Term Loan Party to the Term Loan Lenders or the Term Loan Agent under any of the Term Loan Documents and all Proceeds thereof, in each case, other than property and assets comprising
the Statoil Assets and Collateral, then such cash and/or cash equivalents shall cease to be “Term Lenders Collateral”. 
 “Term Loan Lenders Event of Default” means an “Event of Default” as defined in the Term Loan Credit Agreement. 

“Term Loan Lenders Interest” means, with respect to any property or interest in property, now owned or hereafter
acquired or created, of any Borrower or any of the other Term Loan Parties, any Lien (regardless of the priority thereof) of the Term Loan Agent or the Term Loan Lenders on such property or interests in property, provided, that, the parties agree
that the Term Loan Lenders Interest shall not cover or encumber in any way the Statoil Assets and Collateral. 
 “Term
Loan Documents” means “Loan Documents” as such term is defined in the Term Loan Credit Agreement. 

“Term Loan Party” means “Loan Party” as such term is defined in the Term Loan Credit Agreement. 

“UCC” means the Uniform Commercial Code as from time to time in effect in the State of New York. 

“Unasserted Contingent Obligations” means taxes, costs, indemnifications, reimbursements, damages and other claims
liabilities in respect of which no written assertion of liability or no claim or demand for payment has been made at such time. 

1.2 References to Terms Defined in the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement and the Loan Documents. Whenever in Section 1.1
a term is defined by reference to the meaning ascribed to such term in the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or in any of the Loan Documents, then, unless otherwise specified herein, such term shall have the meaning ascribed to such term in the
Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or Loan Documents. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 9 








 ARTICLE 2. INTERCREDITOR PROVISIONS. 

2.1 Agreements with Respect to Statoil Assets and Collateral. Notwithstanding any provision of the UCC, any applicable law,
equitable principle or decision or any of the Loan Documents or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, each of the Revolving Agent (for itself and on behalf of each of the Revolving Lenders) and the Term Loan Agent (for itself and on behalf of each of
the Term Loan Lenders) hereby agrees that, unless and until the Statoil Claims have been paid and satisfied in full in cash and the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement has terminated (other than Unasserted Contingent Obligations), neither of the Lenders
Agents nor any of the Lenders shall have any Lenders Interest in any of the Statoil Assets and Collateral. In addition, each of the Revolving Agent (for itself and on behalf of each of the Revolving Lenders) and the Term Loan Agent (for itself and
on behalf of each of the Term Loan Lenders) hereby agrees that, unless and until the Statoil Claims have been paid and satisfied in full in cash and the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement has terminated (other than Unasserted Contingent Obligations),
Statoil may receive direct payments from MSCG or its successors or assigns in respect of Certain MSCG Receivables. 
 2.2
Agreements with Respect to Lenders Collateral. Notwithstanding any provision of the UCC, any applicable law, equitable principle or decision or any of the Loan Documents or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, Statoil (for itself and on behalf
of its Affiliates) hereby agrees that, unless and until the Lenders Claims have been paid and satisfied in full in cash and the Credit Agreements and the other Loan Documents have terminated (other than Unasserted Contingent Obligations), neither
Statoil nor any of its Affiliates shall have any Statoil Interest in any of the Lenders Collateral. 
 2.3 Respective
Interests in Statoil Assets and Collateral and Lenders Collateral. 
 (a) Statoil agrees that: (i) it does not have and
shall not have any Statoil Interest in any of the Lenders Collateral; and (ii) it shall not request or accept, directly or indirectly (by assignment or otherwise) from any Borrower or any other Loan Party any collateral or other security for
payment of any Statoil Claims (other than the Statoil Assets and Collateral) and hereby releases any Statoil Interest in any such collateral or other security except that Statoil may accept the issuance of a letter of credit by a Loan Party in favor
of Statoil pursuant to the Paulsboro Statoil Oil Supply Agreement. 
 (b) The Revolving Agent (for itself and on behalf of each
Revolving Lender) agrees that neither the Revolving Agent nor the Revolving Lenders have, nor shall they have, any Revolving Lenders Interest in the Statoil Assets and Collateral. 

(c) The Term Loan Agent (for itself and on behalf of each Term Loan Lender) agrees that neither the Term Loan Agent nor the Term Loan
Lenders have, nor shall they have, any Term Loan Lenders Interest in the Statoil Assets and Collateral. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 10 








 2.4 Certain Turnover Provisions. 

(a) In the event that Statoil or any of its Affiliates now has or hereafter obtains possession of any Lenders Collateral, Statoil or such
Affiliate thereof, as the case may be, shall immediately deliver to the Revolving Agent (or as the Revolving Agent may reasonably direct) such Lenders Collateral in whatever form possessed by Statoil or such Affiliate thereof (and until delivered to
the Revolving Agent such Lenders Collateral shall be held in trust for the Lenders Agents). Any assets received by the Revolving Agent under this Section 2.4(a) shall be received by the Revolving Agent subject to the terms of the
Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement. 
 (b) In the event that either Lenders Agent or any Lenders now or hereafter
obtains possession of any Statoil Assets and Collateral, such Person shall immediately deliver to Statoil (or as Statoil may reasonably direct) such Statoil Assets and Collateral in whatever form possessed by such Lenders Agent (and until delivered
to Statoil such Statoil Assets and Collateral shall be held in trust for Statoil). 
 2.5 Enforcement Actions. Each of
the Revolving Agent, Term Loan Agent and Statoil agrees to use reasonable efforts to give an Enforcement Notice to the others prior to or concurrently with commencement of Enforcement (but failure to do so shall not prevent such Person from
commencing Enforcement or affect its rights hereunder nor create any cause of action or liability against such Person). Subject to the foregoing, each of the parties hereto agrees that during an Enforcement Period: 

(a) Statoil may at its option and without the prior consent of the other parties hereto, take any action to
(i) liquidate the Statoil Assets and Collateral or to foreclose or realize upon or enforce any of its rights with respect to the Statoil Assets and Collateral or (ii) take any other action of Enforcement. 

(b) The Revolving Agent or the Revolving Lenders may, at their option and without the prior consent of the other parties
hereto, take any action to accelerate payment of the Revolving Lenders Claims, foreclose or realize upon or enforce any of their rights with respect to the Revolving Lenders Collateral, or take any other actions as they deem appropriate in respect
of the Revolving Lenders Collateral or the Revolving Lenders Claims. 
 (c) The Term Loan Agent or the Term Loan
Lenders may, at their option and without the prior consent of the other parties hereto, take any action to accelerate payment of the Term Loan Lenders Claims, foreclose or realize upon or enforce any of their rights with respect to the Term Loan
Lenders Collateral, or take any other actions as they deem appropriate in respect of the Term Loan Lenders Collateral or the Term Loan Lenders Claims. 
 2.6 Agency for Perfection. Statoil and the Lenders Agents hereby severally appoint each other as agent for purposes of perfecting by possession their respective ownership interests and Liens on the
Lenders Collateral and the Statoil Assets and Collateral described hereunder. In the event that Statoil obtains possession of any of the Lenders Collateral, Statoil shall promptly notify the Lenders Agents of such fact, shall hold such Lenders
Collateral in trust 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 11 








 
and shall promptly deliver Lenders Collateral to the Revolver Agent. Any Lenders Collateral delivered to the Revolving Agent under the provisions of this Section 2.6 shall be
delivered to the Revolving Agent subject to the terms and provisions of the Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement. In the event that any Lenders Agent obtains possession of any of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, such Lenders Agent shall
promptly notify Statoil of such fact, shall hold such Statoil Assets and Collateral in trust and shall deliver such Statoil Assets and Collateral to Statoil. 
 2.7 UCC Notices. In the event that any party hereto shall be required by the UCC or any other applicable law to give notice to the other of an intended Disposition of Statoil Assets and Collateral
or Lenders Collateral, respectively, such notice shall be given in accordance with Section 3.1 hereof and ten (10) days’ notice shall be deemed to be commercially reasonable. 

2.8 Independent Credit Investigations. Neither Statoil, the Revolving Agent, the Revolving Lenders, the Term Loan Agent nor the
Term Loan Lenders nor any of their respective directors, officers, agents or employees shall be responsible to the other or to any other person, firm, corporation or entity for the solvency, financial condition or ability of any Borrower or any
other Loan Party to repay or otherwise honor the Statoil Claims, the Revolving Lenders Claims or the Term Loan Lenders Claims, or for the worth of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, the Revolving Lenders Collateral or the Term Loan Lenders
Collateral, or for statements of any Borrower or any other Loan Party, oral or written, or for the validity, sufficiency, existence or enforceability of the Statoil Claims, the Revolving Lenders Claims, the Term Loan Lenders Claims, the Paulsboro
Oil Supply Agreement, the Revolving Credit Agreement, the other Revolving Loan Documents, the Term Loan Credit Agreement, the other Term Loan Loan Documents, Statoil’s interest in the Statoil Assets and Collateral, the Revolving Agent’s
and Revolving Lenders’ interest in the Revolving Lenders Collateral or the Term Loan Agent’s or Term Loan Lenders’ interest in the Term Loan Lenders Collateral. The Revolving Lenders, the Revolving Agent, the Term Loan Lenders, the
Term Loan Agent and Statoil have entered into their respective agreements with the Borrowers and the other applicable Loan Parties based upon their own independent investigations. None of the Revolving Lenders, the Revolving Agent, the Term Loan
Lenders, the Term Loan Agent or Statoil makes any warranty or representation to any other party hereto nor does it rely upon any representation of any other party hereto with respect to matters identified or referred to in this
Section 2.8. 
 2.9 Turnover of Identifiable Cash Proceeds. (a) In the event, and only in the event,
that Revolving Lenders Collateral or Term Loan Lenders Collateral shall contain identifiable cash proceeds of Statoil Assets and Collateral, the provisions of this Section 2.9(a) shall apply. Revolving Agent agrees that if Statoil
demonstrates to Revolving Agent that identifiable cash proceeds of Statoil Assets and Collateral have become part of the Revolving Lenders Collateral, and such demonstration is made to Revolving Agent within five Business Days of such identifiable
cash proceeds of Statoil Assets and Collateral becoming part of the Revolving Lenders Collateral, then in such instance, and solely in such instance, Revolving Agent shall promptly turn over such identifiable cash proceeds to Statoil. Term Loan
Agent agrees that if Statoil demonstrates to Term Loan Agent that identifiable cash proceeds of Statoil Assets and Collateral have become part of the Term Loan Lenders Collateral, and such 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 12 








 
demonstration is made to Term Loan Agent within five Business Days of such identifiable cash proceeds of Statoil Assets and Collateral becoming part of the Term Loan Lenders Collateral, then in
such instance, and solely in such instance, Term Loan Agent shall promptly turn over such identifiable cash proceeds to Statoil. (b) In the event, and only in the event, that Statoil Assets and Collateral shall contain identifiable cash
proceeds of Revolving Lenders Collateral, the provisions of this Section 2.9(b) shall apply. Statoil agrees that if Revolving Agent demonstrates to Statoil that identifiable cash proceeds of Revolving Lenders Collateral have become part
of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, and such demonstration is made to Statoil within five Business Days of such identifiable cash proceeds of Revolving Lenders Collateral becoming part of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, then in such instance,
and solely in such instance, Statoil shall promptly turn over such identifiable cash proceeds to Revolving Agent. (c) In the event, and only in the event, that Statoil Assets and Collateral shall contain identifiable cash proceeds of Term Loan
Lenders Collateral, the provisions of this Section 2.9(c) shall apply. Statoil agrees that if Term Loan Agent demonstrates to Statoil that identifiable cash proceeds of Term Loan Lenders Collateral have become part of the Statoil Assets
and Collateral, and such demonstration is made to Statoil within five Business Days of such identifiable cash proceeds of Term Loan Lenders Collateral becoming part of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, then in such instance, and solely in such
instance, Statoil shall promptly turn over such identifiable cash proceeds to Term Loan Agent. 
 2.10 Amendments to Loan
Documents, the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or to this Agreement. (i) The Revolving Agent agrees to use reasonable efforts to give, concurrently with the execution and delivery of any written amendment, waiver or other modification to the
Revolving Loan Documents with respect to the Revolving Lenders Collateral, prompt notice to Statoil of the same. (ii) The Term Loan Agent agrees to use reasonable efforts to give, concurrently with the execution and delivery of any written
amendment, waiver or other modification to the Term Loan Documents with respect to the Term Loan Lenders Collateral, prompt notice to Statoil of the same. (iii) Statoil agrees to use reasonable efforts to give, concurrently with the execution
and delivery of any written amendment, waiver or other modification to any Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement with respect to the Statoil Assets and Collateral, prompt notice to each Lenders Agent of the same; provided, however, that in
the case of each of the preceding clauses (i), (ii) and (iii), the failure to give notice shall not create a cause of action against any party failing to give such notice or create any claim or right on behalf of any third
party or affect any such amendment or modification. Each party hereto shall, upon reasonable request of any other party hereto, provide copies of all such modifications or amendments and copies of all other agreements, instruments, filings or
documentation relevant to the Statoil Assets and Collateral or the Lenders Collateral. All modifications or amendments of this Agreement must be in writing and duly executed by an authorized officer of each party hereto to be binding and
enforceable. 
 2.11 Marshalling of Assets. Nothing in this Agreement will be deemed to require either Statoil or any
Lenders Agent to marshal the applicable Lenders Collateral (or any other collateral) or the Statoil Assets and Collateral, as applicable, upon the enforcement of a Lenders Agent’s or Statoil’s remedies under the applicable Loan Documents
or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, as the case may be. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 13 








 2.12 Reliance on Power and Authority to Act. 

(a) Statoil shall be entitled to rely on the power and authority of the Revolving Agent to act on behalf of all of the Revolving Lenders
to the extent the provisions hereof have the Revolving Agent so act. 
 (b) Statoil shall be entitled to rely on the power and
authority of the Term Loan Agent to act on behalf of all of the Term Loan Lenders to the extent the provisions hereof have the Term Loan Agent so act. 
 (c) Each of the Lenders Agents and each Lender shall be entitled to rely on the power and authority of Statoil to act on behalf of itself and its Affiliates to the extent the provisions hereof have
Statoil so act. 
 2.13 Effect Upon Loan Documents and Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement. By executing this Agreement, the
Borrowers and the other Loan Parties agree to be bound by the provisions hereof as they relate to the relative rights of the Lenders and the Lenders Agents, on the one hand, and Statoil, on the other hand, with respect to the property of the
Borrowers and the other Loan Parties. Each Borrower and each other Loan Party acknowledges that the provisions of this Agreement shall not give it any substantive rights as against the Lenders Agents or the Lenders and that nothing in this Agreement
shall (except as expressly provided herein) amend, modify, change or supersede the terms of the Loan Documents as between the Borrowers, the other Loan Parties, the Lenders Agents and the Lenders. Each Borrower and each other Loan Party acknowledges
that the provisions of this Agreement shall not give it any substantive rights as against Statoil and that nothing in this Agreement shall (except as expressly provided herein) amend, modify, change or supersede the terms of the Paulsboro Oil Supply
Agreement as among Statoil and the applicable Loan Parties. Each of Statoil, the Revolving Agent (for itself and on behalf of each Revolving Lender) and the Term Loan Agent (for itself and on behalf of each Term Loan Lender) agrees, that, as among
themselves, to the extent the terms and provisions of the other Loan Documents or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement are inconsistent with the terms and provisions of this Agreement, the terms and provisions of this Agreement shall control.

 2.14 Nature of the Lenders Claims and Modification of Loan Documents; Nature of Statoil Claims. (a) Statoil
acknowledges that the Revolving Lenders Claims and other obligations and liabilities owing under the Revolving Loan Documents are revolving in nature and that the amount of any such revolving indebtedness which may be outstanding at any time or from
time to time may be increased or reduced and subsequently reborrowed. Subject to the terms of this Agreement, the terms of the Credit Agreements and the other Loan Documents may be modified, extended or amended from time to time, and the amount
thereof may be increased or reduced, all without notice to or consent by Statoil and without affecting the provisions of this Agreement. Without in any way limiting the generality of the foregoing, Statoil hereby agrees that the maximum amount of
the Lenders Claims and other obligations and liabilities owing under the Loan Documents may be increased at any time and from time to time to any amount. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 14 








 (b) The terms of the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement and the amounts and obligations owing
thereunder may be modified, extended or amended from time to time, all without notice to or consent by the Lenders Agents and without affecting the provisions of this Agreement. 

2.15 Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement. For the avoidance of doubt, each party hereto (i) acknowledges the existence
of the Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement and (ii) agrees that the Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement shall govern and control all matters with respect to the Lenders Collateral as between the Revolving Agent and Revolving
Lenders, on the one hand, and the Term Loan Agent and Term Loan Lenders, on the other hand. In addition, the parties hereto agree that, in the event of any conflict between the provisions of this Agreement and the terms or provisions of the
Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement with respect to the Lenders Collateral, the Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement shall govern and control solely as between the Revolving Agent and the Revolving Lenders, on the one hand, and the Term
Loan Agent and the Term Loan Lenders, on the other hand. All parties hereto agree that the Revolver-Term Loan Intercreditor Agreement is not binding in any way upon Statoil or its Affiliates. 

2.16 Further Assurances. Each of the parties agrees to take such actions as may be reasonably requested by any other party,
whether before, during or after an Enforcement Period, in order to effect the rules of distribution and allocation set forth above in this Article 2 and to otherwise effectuate the agreements made in this Article 2, including, to the
extent that such party has the ability to do so, allowing removal of and access to their respective assets and collateral. 

ARTICLE 3. MISCELLANEOUS 
 3.1 Notices. All notices and other communications provided for hereunder shall, unless otherwise stated herein, be in writing (including communication by facsimile copy) and mailed, telexed,
transmitted or delivered, as to each party hereto, at its address set forth under its name on Annex A hereto or at such other address as shall be designated by such party in a written notice to the other parties hereto. All such notices and
communications shall be effective upon receipt, or, in the case of notice by mail, five (5) days after being deposited in the mails, postage prepaid, or in the case of notice by facsimile copy, when verbal confirmation of receipt is obtained,
in each case addressed as aforesaid. 
 3.2 Agreement Absolute. Statoil shall be deemed to have entered into and
continued with the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement in express reliance upon this Agreement, the Revolving Lenders and the Revolving Agent shall be deemed to have entered into and continued with the Revolving Credit Agreement and the other Revolving
Loan Documents in express reliance upon this Agreement, and the Term Loan Lenders and the Term Loan Agent shall be deemed to have entered into and continued with the Term Loan Credit Agreement and the other Term Loan Documents in express reliance
upon this Agreement. This Agreement may not be amended or otherwise modified, unless such amendment or other modification is agreed to in writing by all of the parties hereto. This Agreement shall be applicable both before and


  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 15 








 
after the filing of any petition by or against any Borrower or any other Loan Party under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code and all references herein to the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties shall be
deemed to apply to a debtor-in-possession for such party and all allocations of payments between the Lenders, on the one hand, and Statoil, on the other hand, shall, subject to any court order to the contrary, continue to be made after the filing of
such petition on the same basis that the payments were to be applied prior to the date of the petition. 
 3.3 Successors and
Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. The successors and assigns of the Borrowers and the other Loan Parties shall include a
debtor-in-possession or trustee of or for such party. The successors and assigns of the Revolving Lenders, the Revolving Agent, the Term Loan Lenders, the Term Loan Agent and Statoil, as the case may be, shall include any successors and assigns
appointed under the terms of the Revolving Loan Documents, the Term Loan Documents or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, as applicable. Any such successor or assign shall be subject in all respect to this Agreement. 

3.4 Beneficiaries. The terms and provisions of this Agreement shall be for the sole benefit of the parties hereto, the Lenders,
the Affiliates of Statoil, and their respective successors and assigns, and no other Person shall have any right, benefit or priority by reason of this Agreement. 
 3.5 GOVERNING LAW; JURISDICTION. THIS AGREEMENT SHALL BE GOVERNED BY AND CONSTRUED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE INTERNAL LAWS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK. EACH PARTY HERETO HEREBY CONSENTS AND AGREES THAT
THE STATE OR FEDERAL COURTS LOCATED IN NEW YORK COUNTY, CITY OF NEW YORK, NEW YORK SHALL HAVE EXCLUSIVE JURISDICTION TO HEAR AND DETERMINE ANY CLAIMS OR DISPUTES BETWEEN THE PARTIES HERETO PERTAINING TO THIS AGREEMENT OR TO ANY MATTER ARISING OUT OF
OR RELATING TO THIS AGREEMENT. 
 3.6 WAIVER OF JURY TRIAL. BECAUSE DISPUTES ARISING IN CONNECTION WITH COMPLEX FINANCIAL
TRANSACTIONS ARE MOST QUICKLY AND ECONOMICALLY RESOLVED BY AN EXPERIENCED AND EXPERT PERSON AND THE PARTIES WISH APPLICABLE STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS TO APPLY (RATHER THAN ARBITRATION RULES), THE PARTIES DESIRE THAT THEIR DISPUTES BE RESOLVED BY A
JUDGE APPLYING SUCH APPLICABLE LAWS. THEREFORE, TO ACHIEVE THE BEST COMBINATION OF THE BENEFITS OF THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND OF ARBITRATION, THE PARTIES HERETO WAIVE ALL RIGHT TO TRIAL BY JURY IN ANY ACTION, SUIT, OR PROCEEDING BROUGHT TO RESOLVE ANY
DISPUTE, WHETHER SOUNDING IN CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, AMONG THE PARTIES HERETO ARISING OUT OF, CONNECTED WITH, RELATED TO, OR INCIDENTAL TO THE RELATIONSHIP ESTABLISHED AMONG THEM IN CONNECTION WITH, THIS AGREEMENT OR THE TRANSACTIONS RELATED
THERETO. 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 16 








 3.7 Section Titles. The article and section headings contained in this Agreement are
and shall be without substantive meaning or content of any kind whatsoever and are not a part of the agreement between the parties hereto. 
 3.8 Severability. Any provision of this Agreement that is prohibited or unenforceable in any jurisdiction shall, as to such jurisdiction, be ineffective to the extent of such prohibition or
unenforceability without invalidating the remaining provisions hereof or thereof or affecting the validity or enforceability of such provision in any other jurisdiction. 
 3.9 Execution in Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts and by different parties hereto in separate counterparts, each of which when so executed shall be deemed
to be an original and all of which when taken together shall constitute one and the same agreement. Delivery of an executed signature page by telecopy machine shall be as effective as delivery of a manually signed, original signature page.

 [Signature Pages Follow] 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 17 








 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be executed by
their respective officers thereunto duly authorized, as of the date first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 18 








  

			
	UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH,
	  as Revolving Agent
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 19 








  

			
	UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH,
	  as Term Loan Agent
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 20 








  

			
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC,
	as a Borrower
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	 DELAWARE CITY REFINING COMPANY LLC,
 as a Borrower

		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	 PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC,
 as a Borrower

		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 21 








  

			
	PBF POWER MARKETING, LLC,
	as a Loan Party
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	 DELAWARE PIPELINE COMPANY LLC,
 as a Loan Party

		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	 PBF INVESTMENTS LLC,
 as a Loan Party

		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	 PAULSBORO NATURAL GAS PIPELINE COMPANY LLC,
 as a Loan Party

		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 2 
 Page 22 








 Annex A 
 to 
 Intercreditor Agreement 

Notice Addresses 
  

			
	 Entity
	  	 Notice Address

	Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.	  	 Statoil Marketing and Trading (US) Inc.
 1055 Washington Blvd. – 7th Floor
 Stamford, CT 06901
 Attention: General Counsel
 Fax Number: (203) 978-6952

Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900

		
	 UBS AG, Stamford Branch,
 as
Revolving Agent
	  	 UBS AG, Stamford Branch
 677
Washington Boulevard
 Stamford, Connecticut 06901
 Attention: Mary E. Evans
 Telecopy: (203) 719 – 3029

		
	 UBS AG, Stamford Branch,
 as
Term Loan Agent
	  	 UBS AG, Stamford Branch
 677
Washington Boulevard
 Stamford, Connecticut 06901
 Attention: Mary E. Evans
 Telecopy: (203) 719 – 3029

		
	 PBF Holding Company LLC,

Delaware City Refining Company LLC and
 Paulsboro
Refining Company LLC,
 as Borrowers
	  	 PBF Holding Company LLC
 One
Sound Shore Drive, Suite 303
 Greenwich, Connecticut 06830
 Attention: Jeffrey Dill
 Telecopy: 973-455-7562

		
	 PBF Power Marketing, LLC,

Delaware Pipeline Company LLC,
 PBF Investments
LLC and
 Paulsboro Natural Gas Pipeline Company LLC,
 as Loan Parties
	  	 PBF Holding Company LLC
 One
Sound Shore Drive, Suite 303
 Greenwich, Connecticut 06830
 Attention: Jeffrey Dill
 Telecopy: 973-455-7562



  
 Annex A to
Attachment I 
 Page 1 








 ATTACHMENT II TO APPENDIX 2 

INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENT 
 Dated as of December     , 2010 
 by and among 

STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC., 
 VALERO REFINING AND MARKETING COMPANY, 
 PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC,

 and 

PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 1 








 This INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENT, dated as of December     , 2010 (as
amended, restated, supplemented or otherwise modified from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof, this “Agreement”), by and among STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC. (“Statoil”), VALERO
REFINING AND MARKETING COMPANY, a Delaware corporation (“Valero”), PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC (“Holdings”) and PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC (“Paulsboro” and together with Holdings,
“PBF”). 
 RECITALS: 
 A. Statoil has entered into that certain Crude Oil / Feedstock Supply / Delivery and Services Agreement, dated as of December     , 2010 (as amended, restated, supplemented or
otherwise modified from time to time in accordance with the terms hereof, the “Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement”), by and among Statoil and Holdings under which Statoil has agreed to supply crude oil and feedstocks to, and provide
related services to, Holdings and purchase the crude oil and feedstocks in the tanks at, and on the water for, the Paulsboro Facility with Holdings assigning its rights and obligations to Paulsboro immediately upon the closing of the Acquisition (as
defined below). 
 B. The Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement provides for the filing of UCC financing statements to perfect the
ownership and security interest of Statoil with respect to certain Statoil Assets and Collateral (as defined below). 
 C. Prior
to the date hereof, Valero has entered into that certain Stock Purchase Agreement with Holdings dated September 24, 2010, pursuant to which Valero has agreed to sell, and Holdings has agreed to purchase, all of the issued and outstanding common
stock of Valero-Refining Company-New Jersey, which is the predecessor entity to Paulsboro (the “Acquisition”), on the terms and conditions set forth therein. 
 D. As part of the purchase price for the Acquisition, Valero has agreed to accept a senior secured promissory note in the principal amount of $160,000,000.00 issued by PBF and delivered to Valero upon
closing of the Acquisition pursuant to the terms of that certain Senior Secured Note Agreement by and among Paulsboro, Valero, Paulsboro Natural Gas Pipeline Company LLC, PBF Energy Company LLC and Holdings, dated as of the date hereof (the
“Seller Note Agreement”). 
 E. The Seller Note Agreement and Collateral Documents provide for the filing of
UCC financing statements to perfect the security interest of Valero with respect to certain Valero Collateral (as defined below). 
 F. The parties hereto wish to set forth certain agreements with respect to the Statoil Assets and Collateral and the Valero Collateral. 

NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and the mutual covenants contained herein, and for other good and valuable
consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, it is hereby agreed as follows: 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 2 








 ARTICLE 1. DEFINITIONS. 

1.1 Certain Defined Terms. As used in this Agreement, the following terms shall have the following meanings (such meanings to be
equally applicable to both the singular and plural forms of the terms defined): 
 “Acquisition” shall have the
meaning ascribed to such term in the recitals to this Agreement. 
 “Certain Hydrocarbon Assets” means, any and
all crude oil, feedstock, indigenous feedstock and other hydrocarbon inventory and all proceeds of such inventory (it being understood and agreed that upon purchase of specified hydrocarbons and payment in full in cash by PBF the hydrocarbon
proceeds (such as Refined Products), will not be included as “Certain Hydrocarbon Assets”). 
 “Certain MSCG
Receivables” means accounts originated by the sale of Refined Products sold by PBF to MSCG or another offtaker under the Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreements or similar offtake agreements (it being understood and agreed that following
collection of such accounts by virtue of payment in cash in respect thereof to Statoil, to the extent Statoil pays to PBF a portion of those proceeds then such portion of the proceeds received from Statoil will cease to be “Certain MSCG
Receivables”). 
 “Claims” means the Valero Claims or the Statoil Claims, as applicable. 

“Collateral Documents” shall have the meaning ascribed to such term in the Seller Note Agreement. 

“Copyright License” means any and all rights now owned or hereafter acquired by Paulsboro under any written agreement
granting any right to use any Copyright or Copyright registration. 
 “Copyrights” means all of the following
now owned or hereafter adopted or acquired by Paulsboro: (a) all copyrights and general intangibles of like nature (whether registered or unregistered), all registrations and recordings thereof, and all applications in connection therewith,
including all registrations, recordings and applications in the United States Copyright Office or in any similar office or agency of the United States, any state or territory thereof, or any other country or any political subdivision thereof, and
(b) all reissues, extensions or renewals thereof. 
 “Disposition” means, with respect to any assets of
Paulsboro, any liquidation of Paulsboro or its assets, the establishment of any receivership for Paulsboro or its assets, a bankruptcy proceeding of Paulsboro (either voluntary or involuntary), the payment of any insurance, condemnation,
confiscation, seizure or other claim upon the condemnation, confiscation, seizure, loss or destruction thereof, or damage to, or any other sale, transfer, assignment or other disposition of such assets. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 3 








 “Enforcement” means collectively or individually, for: (a) Statoil
during the continuance of a Statoil Event (i) to demand payment in full of or accelerate any of the obligations, including, without limitation, any payment obligations, of PBF to Statoil or (ii) to commence the judicial or nonjudicial
enforcement of any right or remedy or to commence any action to enforce any provision under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement; and (b) Valero (i) to demand payment in full of or accelerate the indebtedness of PBF to Valero or (ii) to
commence the judicial or nonjudicial enforcement of any of the default rights and remedies under the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents. 
 “Enforcement Notice” means a written notice delivered in accordance with Section 2.5 which notice shall: (i) if delivered by Statoil, state that a Statoil Event has
occurred and that Statoil intends to commence an Enforcement, specify the nature of the Statoil Event that caused Statoil to intend to take such action, and state that an Enforcement Period has commenced; (ii) if delivered by Valero, state that
a Valero Event has occurred and that the payment in full of Valero’s Claims has been demanded or the indebtedness of any party hereto has been accelerated, specify the nature of the Valero Event that caused such demand and acceleration, and
state that an Enforcement Period has commenced. 
 “Enforcement Period” means the period of time following the
receipt by Valero, on the one hand, or Statoil, on the other hand, of an Enforcement Notice delivered by the other until the earliest of the following: (1) the Statoil Claims have been satisfied in full, Statoil has no further obligations under
the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement and the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement has been terminated; (2) the Valero Claims have been satisfied in full, Valero has no further obligations under the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral
Documents and the Seller Note Agreement and the Collateral Documents have been terminated; and (3) all of the parties hereto agree in writing to terminate the Enforcement Period. 

“Equipment” means all “equipment,” as such term is defined in the Uniform UCC, now owned or hereafter acquired
by Paulsboro, wherever located and, in any event, including all of Paulsboro’s machinery and equipment, including processing equipment, spare parts, conveyors, machine tools, data processing and computer equipment, including embedded software
and peripheral equipment and all engineering, processing and manufacturing equipment, office machinery, furniture, materials handling equipment, tools, attachments, accessories, forklifts, molds, dies, stamps and other equipment of every kind and
nature, trade fixtures and fixtures not forming a part of real property, together with all additions and accessions thereto, replacements therefor, all parts therefor, all substitutes for any of the foregoing, fuel therefor, and all manuals,
drawings, instructions, warranties and rights with respect thereto, and all products and proceeds thereof and condemnation awards and insurance proceeds with respect thereto, in each case other than Titled Collateral. 

“Holder” shall have the meaning ascribed to such term in the Seller Note Agreement. 

“Intellectual Property” means any and all Licenses, Patents, Copyrights, Trademarks, and the goodwill associated with
such Trademarks. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 4 








 “License” means any Copyright License, Patent License, Trademark License or
other license of rights or interests relating to Intellectual Property now held or hereafter acquired by Paulsboro. 

“Lien” means, with respect to any property, (a) any mortgage, deed of trust, lien, pledge, encumbrance, claim,
charge, assignment, hypothecation, ownership right or interest, security interest or encumbrance of any kind or any arrangement to provide priority or preference or any filing of any financing statement under the UCC or any other similar notice of
lien under any similar notice or recording statute of any governmental authority, including any easement, right-of-way or other encumbrance on title to real property, in each of the foregoing cases whether voluntary or imposed by law, and any
agreement to give any of the foregoing; (b) the interest of a vendor or a lessor under any conditional sale agreement, capital lease or title retention agreement (or any financing lease having substantially the same economic effect as any of
the foregoing) relating to such property; and (c) in the case of securities, any purchase option, call or similar right of a third party with respect to such securities. 
 “MSCG” means Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc. and any successors and assigns (including as a result of change of counterparties to the Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreements). 

“Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreements” means (i) those certain products off-take agreements and other agreements
entered into in connection therewith by and among MSCG and Holdings (with Holdings assigning its rights and obligations immediately to Paulsboro upon the closing of the Acquisition) relating to the purchase of refined oil products inventories
located at the Paulsboro Facility, the exclusive purchase of production of finished Refined Products and the purchase and sale back to PBF of intermediate products and blendstocks and (ii) all modifications, amendments and replacements of such
off-take agreements between Holdings and MSCG or a subsequent off-taker. 
 “Oil” means crude oil, feedstock
and indigenous feedstock. 
 “Patent License” means rights under any written agreement now owned or hereafter
acquired by Paulsboro granting any right with respect to any invention on which a Patent is in existence. 

“Patents” means all of the following in which Paulsboro now holds or hereafter acquires any interest: (a) all
letters patent of the United States or of any other country, all registrations and recordings thereof, and all applications for letters patent of the United States or of any other country, including registrations, recordings and applications in the
United States Patent and Trademark Office or in any similar office or agency of the United States, any State, or any other country, and (b) all reissues, continuations, continuations-in-part or extensions thereof. 

“Paulsboro Facility” means Paulsboro’s petroleum refinery, terminalling facility and all related assets and
properties located in Paulsboro, New Jersey. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 5 








 “Person” means any individual, partnership, corporation (including a
business trust), joint stock company, limited liability company, trust, unincorporated association, joint venture or other entity. 
 “Proceeds” means “proceeds,” as such term is defined in the UCC, including (a) any and all proceeds of any insurance, indemnity, warranty or guaranty payable to Paulsboro
from time to time with respect to any of the Valero Collateral, (b) any and all payments (in any form whatsoever) made or due and payable to Paulsboro from time to time in connection with any requisition, confiscation, condemnation, seizure or
forfeiture of all or any part of the Valero Collateral by any governmental authority, (c) any claim of Paulsboro against third parties (i) for past, present or future infringement of any Patent or Patent License, or (ii) for past,
present or future infringement or dilution of any Copyright, Copyright License, Trademark or Trademark License, or for injury to the goodwill associated with any Trademark or Trademark License in respect of any Valero Collateral or required in
connection with the operation of the Paulsboro Facility, (d) any recoveries by Paulsboro against third parties with respect to any litigation or dispute concerning any of the Valero Collateral including claims arising out of the loss or
nonconformity of, interference with the use of, defects in, or infringement of rights in, or damage to, Valero Collateral, (e) all amounts collected on, or distributed on account of, other Valero Collateral, including dividends, interest,
distributions and instruments with respect to investment property and pledged stock, and (f) any and all other amounts, rights to payment, accounts (as “accounts” are defined in the UCC) or other property acquired upon the sale,
lease, license, exchange or other disposition of Valero Collateral and all rights arising out of Valero Collateral. 

“Refined Products” means finished gasoline, heating oil, diesel, jet fuel and specialty grades produced for sale to MSCG
or another offtaker pursuant to the Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreements or similar offtake agreements. 
 “Seller Note
Agreement” shall have the meaning ascribed to such term in the recitals to this Agreement. 
 “Statoil Assets
and Collateral” means: (i) Certain Hydrocarbon Assets; (ii) Certain MSCG Receivables; (iii) Oil to be sold to PBF by Statoil prior to the time at which title thereto passes from Statoil to PBF by passing through the outlet
flange of the storage tanks at the Paulsboro Facility; (iv) contract rights in respect of the Refined Products sale contracts that are related to Certain MSCG Receivables; (v) Oil stored in the tanks located at the Paulsboro Facility or
other storage facilities which is owned by Statoil or has been sold by Statoil to PBF and other nearby Oil located at tanks that are used in connection with the operation of the Paulsboro Facility; and (vi) proceeds with respect to any of the
foregoing, except that cash proceeds paid to PBF with respect to the Morgan Stanley Off-Take Agreements but which are not proceeds of or related to the Certain MSCG Receivables, will cease to be “Statoil Assets and Collateral”. For the
avoidance of doubt, notwithstanding the foregoing or any other provisions of this Agreement and/or the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, Statoil Assets and Collateral shall not include any Valero Collateral. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 6 








 “Statoil Claims” means all amounts, obligations and other liabilities of
PBF or any of its affiliates to Statoil now or hereafter arising under, or in connection with, the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement including time value of money and any interest thereon (including, without limitation, interest accruing after the
commencement of a bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding relating to PBF or any of its affiliates, whether or not such interest is an allowed claim in any such proceeding), any reimbursement obligations, fees or expenses due thereunder, and
any costs of collection or enforcement in each case as provided for under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or applicable law. 

“Statoil Event” means the occurrence of any event (including, without limitation, any default) or the breach of any
provision under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement which would enable Statoil to exercise any right or remedy, demand any payment, declare any breach or take any other action in respect of the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement. 

“Statoil Interest” means, with respect to any Statoil Assets and Collateral now owned or hereafter acquired or created
of PBF or Statoil, any security interest of Statoil in, or any Lien or ownership right or interest of Statoil on, such Statoil Assets and Collateral. 
 “Titled Collateral” means all property owned by Paulsboro used in connection with the operation of the Paulsboro Facility for which the title to such property is governed by a certificate
of title or certificate of ownership, including, without limitation, all motor vehicles (including, without limitation, all trucks, rail cars, trailers, tractors, service vehicles, automobiles and other mobile equipment) for which the title to such
motor vehicles is governed by a certificate of title or certificate of ownership. 
 “Trademark License” means
rights under any written agreement now owned or hereafter acquired by Paulsboro granting any right to use any Trademark. 

“Trademarks” means all of the following now owned or hereafter existing or adopted or acquired by Paulsboro:
(a) all trademarks, trade names, corporate names, business names, trade styles, service marks, logos, other source or business identifiers, prints and labels on which any of the foregoing have appeared or appear, designs and general intangibles
of like nature (whether registered or unregistered), all registrations and recordings thereof, and all applications in connection therewith, including registrations, recordings and applications in the United States Patent and Trademark Office or in
any similar office or agency of the United States, any state or territory thereof, or any other country or any political subdivision thereof; (b) all reissues, extensions or renewals thereof; and (c) all goodwill associated with or
symbolized by any of the foregoing. 
 “UCC” means the Uniform Commercial Code as from time to time in effect
in the State of Delaware. 
 “Valero Claims” means all amounts, obligations and other liabilities of PBF or any
of its affiliates to Valero now or hereafter arising under, or in connection with, the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents including any interest thereon (including, without limitation, interest accruing after the commencement
of a bankruptcy, insolvency or similar proceeding relating to PBF or any of its affiliates, whether or not such interest is an allowed claim in any such proceeding), any reimbursement obligations, fees or expenses due thereunder, and any costs of
collection or enforcement in each case as provided for under the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents or applicable law. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 7 








 “Valero Collateral” means, collectively, all of Paulsboro’s right,
title, and interest in, to and under all of the personal property and other assets described below, whether now owned by or owing to, or hereafter acquired by or arising in favor of Paulsboro (including under any trade names, styles or derivations
thereof), and whether owned or consigned by or to, or leased from or to, Paulsboro and regardless of where located, to the extent subject to a Lien or security interest in favor of Valero, including, but not limited to: 

all of property, plant and Equipment comprising the Paulsboro Facility and used in connection with the operation of the
Paulsboro Facility; 
 all spare parts and precious metal catalysts used in connection with the operation of the
Paulsboro Facility; 
 all Intellectual Property used in connection with the operation of the Paulsboro
Facility; 
 Titled Collateral; and 
 to the extent not otherwise included, all Proceeds, insurance claims and other rights to payments of any of the foregoing and products of the foregoing and all accessions to, substitutions and
replacements for, and rents and profits of, each of the foregoing. For the avoidance of doubt, notwithstanding the foregoing or any other provisions of this Agreement and/or the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents, the Valero
Collateral shall not include any Statoil Assets and Collateral. 
 “Valero Event” means the occurrence of any
event (including, without limitation, any default) or the breach of any provision under the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents which would enable Valero to exercise any right or remedy, demand any payment, declare any breach or
take any other action in respect of the Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents. 
 “Valero
Interest” means, with respect to any Valero Collateral now owned or hereafter acquired or created by PBF, any security interest of Valero in, or any Lien on or ownership right or interest of Valero in, such Valero Collateral. 

1.2 References to Terms Defined in the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement and the Seller Note Agreement. Whenever in
Section 1.1 a term is defined by reference to the meaning ascribed to such term in the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or in the Seller Note Agreement, then, unless otherwise specified herein, such term shall have the meaning ascribed to
such term in the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement or the Seller Note Agreement. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 8 








 ARTICLE 2. INTERCREDITOR PROVISIONS. 

2.1 Respective Interests in Statoil Assets and Collateral and Valero Collateral. 

(a) Statoil agrees that it does not have and shall not at any time have any Statoil Interest in any of Valero Collateral. 

(b) Valero agrees that it does not have and shall not at any time have any Valero Interest in the Statoil Assets and Collateral.

 2.2 Certain Turnover Provisions. 
 (a) In the event that Statoil now has or hereafter obtains possession of any Valero Collateral, Statoil shall promptly deliver to Valero such Valero Collateral in whatever form possessed by Statoil (and
until delivered to Valero such Valero Collateral shall be held in trust for Valero). 
 (b) In the event that Valero obtains
possession of any Statoil Assets and Collateral, Valero shall promptly deliver to Statoil (or as Statoil may reasonably direct) such Statoil Assets and Collateral in whatever form possessed by Valero (and until delivered to Statoil such Statoil
Assets and Collateral shall be held in trust for Statoil). 
 2.3 Enforcement Actions. Valero and Statoil agree to use
reasonable efforts to give an Enforcement Notice to the other prior to or concurrently with commencement of Enforcement (but failure to do so shall not prevent such Person from commencing Enforcement or affect its rights hereunder nor create any
cause of action or liability against such Person). Subject to the foregoing, each of the parties hereto agrees that during an Enforcement Period: 
 (a) Statoil may, at its option and without the prior consent of the other parties hereto, take any action to (i) liquidate the Statoil Assets and Collateral or to foreclose or realize upon or enforce
any of its rights with respect to the Statoil Assets and Collateral or (ii) take any other action of Enforcement. 
 (b) Valero may, at its option and without the prior consent of the other parties hereto, take any action to accelerate payment of Valero Claims or any other obligation or liability arising under the
Seller Note Agreement or any of the Collateral Documents, foreclose or realize upon or enforce any of its rights with respect to the Valero Collateral, or take any other actions as it deems appropriate in respect of the Valero Collateral or the
Valero Claims. 
 2.4 Agency for Perfection. Statoil and Valero hereby severally appoint each other as agent for purposes
of perfecting by possession their respective ownership interests and Liens on the Valero Collateral and the Statoil Assets and Collateral described hereunder. In the event that Statoil obtains possession of any of the Valero Collateral, Statoil
shall promptly and in any event within 3 business days notify Valero of such fact, shall hold such Valero Collateral in trust and shall promptly deliver such Valero Collateral to Valero. In the event that Valero


  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 9 








 
obtains possession of any of the Statoil Assets and Collateral, Valero shall promptly and in any event within 3 business days notify Statoil, shall hold such Statoil Assets and Collateral in
trust and shall promptly deliver such Statoil Assets and Collateral to Statoil. 
 2.5 UCC Notices. In the event that any
party hereto shall be required by the UCC or any other applicable law to give notice to the other of an intended Disposition of Statoil Assets and Collateral or Valero Collateral, respectively, such notice shall be given in accordance with
Section 3.1 hereof and ten (10) days’ notice shall be deemed to be commercially reasonable. 
 2.6
Limitation on Liability of Parties to Each Other. Except with respect to liability for breach of an obligation under this Agreement, no party hereto shall have any liability to any other party hereto. 

2.7 Marshalling of Assets. Nothing in this Agreement will be deemed to require either Statoil or Valero to marshal the applicable
Valero Collateral (or any other collateral) or the Statoil Assets and Collateral, as applicable, upon the enforcement of Valero’s or Statoil’s remedies under the applicable Seller Note Agreement, any of the Collateral Documents or the
Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement, as the case may be. 
 2.8 Effect Upon Seller Note Agreement, Collateral Documents and
Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement. By executing this Agreement, PBF agrees to be bound by the provisions hereof as they relate to the relative rights of Valero on the one hand, and Statoil, on the other hand, with respect to the property of PBF,
Statoil and Valero. PBF acknowledges that the provisions of this Agreement shall not give it any substantive rights as against Valero and that nothing in this Agreement shall amend, modify, change or supersede the terms of the Seller Note Agreement
or any of the Collateral Documents as between the Valero and PBF. PBF acknowledges that the provisions of this Agreement shall not give it any substantive rights as against Statoil and that nothing in this Agreement shall amend, modify, change or
supersede the terms of the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement as among Statoil and PBF. Statoil and Valero agree that, as among themselves, to the extent the terms and provisions of the Seller Note Agreement, any of the Collateral Documents or the
Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement are inconsistent with the terms and provisions of this Agreement, the terms and provisions of this Agreement shall control. 
 2.9 Cooperation and Further Assurances. Each of the parties agrees to take such actions as may be reasonably requested by any other party, whether before, during or after an Enforcement Period, in
order to effect the rules of distribution and allocation set forth above in this Article 2 and to otherwise effectuate the agreements made in this Article 2, including allowing removal of and access to their respective assets and
collateral. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 10 








 ARTICLE 3. MISCELLANEOUS 

3.1 Notices. All notices and other communications provided for hereunder shall, unless otherwise stated herein, be in writing
(including communication by facsimile copy) and mailed, telexed, transmitted or delivered, as to each party hereto, at its address set forth under its name on Annex A hereto or at such other address as shall be designated by such party in a
written notice to the other parties hereto. All such notices and communications shall be effective upon receipt, or, in the case of notice by mail, five (5) days after being deposited in the mails, postage prepaid, or in the case of notice by
facsimile copy, when verbal confirmation of receipt is obtained, in each case addressed as aforesaid. 
 3.2 Agreement
Absolute. Statoil shall be deemed to have entered into and continued with the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement in express reliance upon this Agreement and Valero shall be deemed to have entered into and continued with the Seller Note Agreement or
any of the Collateral Documents in express reliance upon this Agreement. This Agreement may not be amended or otherwise modified, unless such amendment or other modification is agreed to in writing by all of the parties hereto. This Agreement shall
be applicable both before and after the filing of any petition by or against PBF under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code and all references herein to PBF shall be deemed to apply to a debtor-in-possession for such party and all allocations of payments
between Valero, on the one hand, and Statoil, on the other hand, shall, subject to any court order to the contrary, continue to be made after the filing of such petition on the same basis that the payments were to be applied prior to the date of the
petition. 
 3.3 Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each of the
parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. Any such successor or assign shall be subject in all respect to this Agreement. In the event that the supply products and services provided under the Paulsboro Oil Supply Agreement shall be
replaced, substituted or restated, each of the parties hereto agrees, at the request of Statoil or the replacement supplier of products and services, to execute and deliver a new intercreditor agreement with such Person on substantially the same
terms as herein provided. In the event that the Holder provided under the Seller Note Agreement shall be replaced, substituted or restated, each of the parties hereto agrees, at the request of Valero or the replacement Holder, to execute and deliver
a new intercreditor agreement with such Person on substantially the same terms as herein provided. 
 3.4 Beneficiaries.
The terms and provisions of this Agreement shall be for the sole benefit of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns, and no other Person shall have any right, benefit or priority by reason of this Agreement. 

3.5 GOVERNING LAW; JURISDICTION. THIS AGREEMENT SHALL BE GOVERNED BY AND CONSTRUED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE INTERNAL LAWS OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK. EACH PARTY HERETO HEREBY CONSENTS AND AGREES THAT THE STATE OR FEDERAL COURTS LOCATED IN NEW YORK COUNTY, CITY OF NEW YORK, NEW YORK SHALL HAVE EXCLUSIVE JURISDICTION TO HEAR AND DETERMINE ANY CLAIMS OR DISPUTES BETWEEN THE
PARTIES HERETO PERTAINING TO THIS AGREEMENT OR TO ANY MATTER ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO THIS AGREEMENT. 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 11 








 3.6 WAIVER OF JURY TRIAL. BECAUSE DISPUTES ARISING IN CONNECTION WITH COMPLEX
FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS ARE MOST QUICKLY AND ECONOMICALLY RESOLVED BY AN EXPERIENCED AND EXPERT PERSON AND THE PARTIES WISH APPLICABLE STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS TO APPLY (RATHER THAN ARBITRATION RULES), THE PARTIES DESIRE THAT THEIR DISPUTES BE RESOLVED
BY A JUDGE APPLYING SUCH APPLICABLE LAWS. THEREFORE, TO ACHIEVE THE BEST COMBINATION OF THE BENEFITS OF THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND OF ARBITRATION, THE PARTIES HERETO WAIVE ALL RIGHT TO TRIAL BY JURY IN ANY ACTION, SUIT, OR PROCEEDING BROUGHT TO RESOLVE
ANY DISPUTE, WHETHER SOUNDING IN CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, AMONG THE PARTIES HERETO ARISING OUT OF, CONNECTED WITH, RELATED TO, OR INCIDENTAL TO THE RELATIONSHIP ESTABLISHED AMONG THEM IN CONNECTION WITH, THIS AGREEMENT OR THE TRANSACTIONS
RELATED THERETO. 
 3.7 Section Titles. The article and section headings contained in this Agreement are and shall be
without substantive meaning or content of any kind whatsoever and are not a part of the agreement between the parties hereto. 

3.8 Severability. Any provision of this Agreement that is prohibited or unenforceable in any jurisdiction shall, as to such
jurisdiction, be ineffective to the extent of such prohibition or unenforceability without invalidating the remaining provisions hereof or thereof or affecting the validity or enforceability of such provision in any other jurisdiction. 

3.9 Execution in Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts and by different parties hereto in
separate counterparts, each of which when so executed shall be deemed to be an original and all of which when taken together shall constitute one and the same agreement. Delivery of an executed signature page by telecopy machine shall be as
effective as delivery of a manually signed, original signature page. 
 [Signature Pages Follow] 

  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 12 








 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be executed by
their respective officers thereunto duly authorized, as of the date first above written. 
  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:
	Title:



  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 13 








  

			
	VALERO REFINING AND MARKETING COMPANY
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:
	Title:



  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 14 









			
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	
	
	PAULSBORO REFINING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	



  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 2 
 Page 15 








 Annex A 
 to 
 Intercreditor Agreement 

Notice Addresses 
  

			
	 Entity
	 	 Notice Address

	Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.	 	 Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.
 1055 Washington Boulevard – 7th Floor
 Stamford, CT 06901

Attention: General Counsel
 Fax Number: (203)
978-6952
 Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900

		
	Valero Refining and Marketing Company	 	 c/o Valero Energy Corporation

One Valero Way
 San Antonio, Texas
78249
 Attention: Executive Vice President and General Counsel
 Telephone: (210) 345-2246
 Facsimile: (210) 345-2622

		
	 PBF Holding Company LLC and

Paulsboro Refining Company LLC
	 	 PBF Holding Company LLC
 1
Sylvan Way, 2nd Floor
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887
 Attention: General Counsel
 Fax Number: (973) 455-7562

Telephone Number: (973) 455-7500



  
 Annex A to
Attachment II 
 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 3 – PAYMENT DIRECTION AGREEMENT 

This PAYMENT DIRECTION AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) dated as of December 17, 2010, by and among Morgan Stanley Capital
Group Inc. (“MSCG”), Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc. (“Statoil”) and PBF Holding Company LLC (“PBO”). 
 1. Certain Defined Terms. As used in this Agreement, the following terms shall have the following meanings (such meanings to be equally applicable to both the singular and plural forms of the terms
defined): 
 “Additional Termination Event” has the meaning assigned to such term in the Off-Take Agreement. 

“Base Barge Price” means, with respect to any delivery by PBO of Refined Products to MSCG, [REDACTED], where: 

(a) “[REDACTED]” means, [REDACTED]. 
 (b) “[REDACTED]” means [REDACTED]: 
 (i) [REDACTED].

 (ii) [REDACTED]. 
 “Business Day” means a day on which banks are open for general commercial business in New York, New York. 
 “Delivery Day” means with respect to any Refined Products, the day of delivery of such Refined Products to MSCG pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement. 

“Event of Default” has the meaning assigned to such term in the Off-Take Agreement. 

“Feedstock” means vacuum gas oil (VGO), straight run fuel oil and other similar hydrocarbons. 

“Final Payment Amount” means for any Delivery Day, the greater of: 

(a) zero dollars; and 
 (b) (i) the sum for all grades of Refined Products delivered by PBO to MSCG on such Delivery Day of the number of gallons of each grade of such Refined Product delivered to MSCG on such Delivery Day
multiplied by the applicable Final Price per gallon of such grade minus (ii) the Provisional Payment Amount for such Delivery Day. 

“Final Payment Day” means the applicable day determined in accordance with Annex C attached hereto. 

“Final Price” means with respect to a Refined Product, [REDACTED]. 
 “Indigenous Feedstock” means Feedstock produced in the Refinery, together with all Feedstock located in the indigenous feedstock tanks at the Refinery on the date Statoil commences
deliveries under the Supply Agreement whether such Feedstock was produced in the Refinery or elsewhere. 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 1 








 “Initial Inventory” means the volumes of Products and ethanol sold to MSCG on the Closing
Date (as defined in the Off-Take Agreement). 
 “Intermediate Products” means the intermediate products sold by PBO to MSCG
pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement. 
 “Lubes” means lube base oils sold by PBO to MSCG pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement.

 “MS Guaranty” means that certain Guarantee of Morgan Stanley dated as of the date hereof, executed by Morgan Stanley in
favor of PBO, as amended, supplemented or restated from time to time. 
 “MS Products” means the product inventories purchased
from time to time by MSCG from PBO pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement, including, without limitation, the Initial Inventory but excluding Oil and Indigenous Feedstock which has not been refined into light finished products, Intermediate Products,
Lubes or Slurry. 
 “MS Receivables” means (a) for Refined Products other than Specialty Grades, all of PBO’s rights
to payment from MSCG of the Provisional Payment Amount and the Final Payment Amount with respect thereto, (b) for Specialty Grades, all of PBO’s rights to payment from MSCG with respect thereto and (c) all proceeds of the amounts
specified in (a) and (b) of this definition. 
 “Off-Take Agreement” means that certain Products Offtake Agreement
dated as of December 14, 2010, between MSCG and PBO, as amended, supplemented or restated from time to time in accordance with this Agreement, a redacted copy of which is attached hereto as Annex B. 

“Oil” means crude oil and/or Feedstock but shall not include Indigenous Feedstock. 

“Products” has the meaning assigned to such term in the Off-Take Agreement. 
 “Provisional Overpayment Amount” means for any Delivery Day the amount, if any, by which the Provisional Payment Amount for such Delivery Day exceeds the sum for all grades of Refined
Products delivered by PBO to MSCG on such Delivery Day, of the number of gallons of each grade of such Refined Product delivered to MSCG on such Delivery Day multiplied by the applicable Final Price per gallon of such grade. 

“Provisional Payment Amount” means for any Delivery Day, the sum for all grades of Refined Products delivered by PBO to MSCG on such
Delivery Day, of the number of gallons of each grade of such Refined Product delivered to MSCG on such Delivery Day multiplied by the applicable Provisional Price per gallon of such grade. To the extent the Provisional Payment Day for a relevant
Delivery Day occurs on or before such relevant Delivery Day, the Provisional Payment Amount shall be based on the actual volumes delivered on the Delivery Day immediately preceding such relevant Delivery Day as specified in the Daily Report of
Delivered Volumes (as defined in the Off-Take Agreement) for such preceding Delivery Day. 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 2 








 “Provisional Payment Day” means the applicable day determined in accordance with Annex C
attached hereto. 
 “Provisional Price” means [REDACTED]. 
 “Refined Products” means finished gasoline, heating oil, diesel, and jet fuel produced for sale to MSCG pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement. For the avoidance of doubt, for purposes of
this Agreement, the term Refined Products includes Specialty Grades but excludes Intermediate Products, Lubes, Slurry, components of gasoline, heating oil, diesel or jet fuel and all other products other than those specifically listed above in this
definition. 
 “Refinery” means PBO’s Paulsboro, New Jersey refinery. 

“Slurry” means slurry sold by PBO to MSCG pursuant to the Off-Take Agreement. 
 “Specialty Grades” means customized products that are not included in the grades of Products encompassed in Schedule 1 to the Off-Take Agreement. 

“Supply Agreement” means that certain Crude Oil / Feedstock Supply / Delivery and Services Agreement dated as of December 17, 2010,
between Statoil and PBO with respect to the Refinery. 
 2. Security Interest. PBO has granted Statoil a security interest in the
following: 
 (a) all rights of PBO in and to proceeds of PBO’s sale of Refined Products from the Refinery, including all
of the MS Receivables; 
 (b) all rights of PBO under the Off-Take Agreement to enforce payment of the MS Receivables from MSCG
and all other rights under the Off-Take Agreement to collect the MS Receivables; 
 (c) all rights of PBO under the MS Guaranty
and all other supporting obligations with respect to the MS Receivables. 
 As between Statoil and MSCG (i) MSCG acknowledges and consents
to the grant of such security interests (described in 2(a), (b) and (c) above) by PBO to Statoil, (ii) Statoil acknowledges and agrees that MSCG has title to the MS Products, and except for its interest in the MS Receivables, Statoil
claims no interest in the MS Products, and (iii) MSCG acknowledges and agrees that Statoil has title to or first priority liens on all Oil, Indigenous Feedstock and MS Receivables; and MSCG claims no interest in such items. 

The Off-Take Agreement permits PBF Holding Company LLC to assign its rights and obligations under the Off-Take Agreement to Paulsboro Refining Company
LLC subject to delivery to MSCG of a guaranty of PBF Holding Company LLC. From and after the date of such assignment and the delivery of a guaranty in form and substance acceptable to Statoil from PBF Holding Company LLC of the obligations under
this Agreement, for the purposes of this Agreement, “PBO” shall mean Paulsboro Refining Company LLC. 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 3 








 3. Direct Payment. PBO hereby irrevocably directs MSCG to make all payments on the MS Receivables
directly to the Statoil account designated on Annex A hereto (the “Payment Account”). MSCG acknowledges such payment direction and agrees (a) to pay all Provisional Payment Amounts on the corresponding Provisional
Payment Day as set forth in Annex C, (b) to pay all Final Payment Amounts on the corresponding Final Payment Day as set forth in Annex C, (c) to make all other payments owing on the MS Receivables by the time specified in the Off-Take
Agreement, and (d) to make all such payments described in the foregoing subsections (a), (b) and (c) directly to Statoil into the Payment Account. Any changes to these payment instructions shall be honored by MSCG only if given in
writing by Statoil. All payments on the MS Receivables made by MSCG to the Payment Account or as otherwise directed by Statoil hereunder shall be treated for all purposes as satisfying MSCG’s payment obligations to PBO in respect of the MS
Receivables. MSCG also agrees and covenants that upon receipt of written instructions from PBO, MSCG also will make direct payment to Statoil in accordance with this Section 3 of any amounts owed by MSCG to PBO pursuant to the Off-Take
Agreement that are not included in MS Receivables, provided that MSCG’s obligation to make direct payment to Statoil with respect to any such other amounts shall be subject to all claims, defenses, offsets and other rights that MSCG may have
with respect to its obligation to pay such other amounts. 
 4. Offsets. For so long as this Agreement is in effect, MSCG agrees not to
exercise or claim any right of offset or other similar right against PBO or Statoil with respect to the MS Receivables other than the offsets and other rights described in the Off-Take Agreement. However, in no event shall MSCG reduce by reason of
offset or otherwise (whether any such right arises under the Off-Take Agreement, other contractual provisions or common law), any amounts required to be paid hereunder by MSCG to Statoil in respect of MS Receivables owing for Refined Products which
are delivered to MSCG prior to or on the business day on which Statoil receives written notice from MSCG of the occurrence of an Event of Default, an Additional Termination Event or termination of the Off-Take Agreement, except that MSCG may reduce
any amounts owing on MS Receivables payable to Statoil hereunder by the amount of any Provisional Overpayment Amount attributable to any Delivery Day occurring prior to the day of such reduction. Nothing contained herein shall limit MSCG’s
rights of offset against PBO for amounts owing by MSCG to PBO (and not payable to Statoil hereunder) or its rights to exercise any other remedies that MSCG may have against PBO. 
 5. Assignment, Amendment and Termination of Off-Take Agreement. 
 (a) MSCG
or PBO as applicable shall deliver not less than 10 Business Days prior written notice to Statoil of any proposed assignment by MSCG or PBO of the Off-Take Agreement. Neither MSCG nor PBO shall assign its rights under the Off-Take Agreement in any
manner that would materially and adversely affect Statoil’s rights hereunder without Statoil’s prior written consent. Notwithstanding the foregoing, any assignment by MSCG of its rights under the Off-Take Agreement that is expressly
subject to the terms of this Agreement shall not require Statoil’s prior written consent; provided, however, if Statoil reasonably determines that any such assignment would materially and adversely affect Statoil’s rights hereunder, then
Statoil shall have the unilateral right to terminate the Supply Agreement and/or this Agreement under the provisions thereof and hereof applicable to a default by the non-Statoil parties. 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 4 








 (b) MSCG and PBO shall not, without Statoil’s prior written consent, amend the Off-Take
Agreement in any manner that would: (i) alter the terms of MSCG’s payment obligations, PBO’s enforcement rights with respect to the MS Receivables or any defined term used herein that is defined by reference to the Off-Take Agreement;
(ii) modify the methodology for determining Other Costs or any other factor that would modify the calculation of the Base Barge Price; (iii) modify the timing of MSCG’s payment obligations or (iv) modify MSCG’s offset or
similar rights. 
 (c) MSCG shall deliver to Statoil written notice of any default, or Event of Default, by PBO under or any
Early Termination Event with respect to or any early termination of the Off-Take Agreement contemporaneously with any notice thereof delivered to PBO. 
 (d) PBO shall deliver to Statoil written notice of any default, or Event of Default, by MSCG under or any Early Termination Event with respect to or any early termination of the Off-Take Agreement
contemporaneously with any notice thereof delivered to MSCG. 
 6. No Default. MSCG and PBO each hereby agree and acknowledge that as of
the date hereof, there are no defaults, Events of Default, Early Termination Events or events that with the passage of the applicable grace or cure period would constitute a default, Event of Default or Early Termination Event under the Off-Take
Agreement. 
 7. Conflict. To the extent there is any conflict between the terms of this Agreement and the Off-Take Agreement, this
Agreement shall control. 
 8. Further Assurances. The parties hereto agree that from and after the date hereof, each of them will
execute and deliver such further instruments and take such other action as may reasonably be requested by any party hereto to carry out the purpose and intent hereof. 
 9. Governing Law. The provisions of this Agreement and the documents delivered pursuant hereto shall be governed by and construed and enforced in accordance with the laws of the State of New York
(without regard to any conflicts-of-law rule or principle that would require the application of the laws of another jurisdiction). 
 10.
Jurisdiction, Venue and Forum. Each of the parties hereto (a) consents to submit itself to the personal jurisdiction of the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York, any court of the State of New York and any other
Federal court sitting in the State of New York in the event any dispute arises out of this Agreement or the transactions contemplated hereby, (b) agrees that it will not attempt to deny or defeat such personal jurisdiction by motion or other
request for leave from any such court and (c) agrees that it will not bring any action relating to this Agreement or the transactions contemplated hereby in any court other than the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York (or,
if the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York shall be unavailable, any court of the State of New York or any other Federal court sitting in the State of New York). Each party hereto waives any objection to convenience of forum or
venue laid in such courts. The parties hereto agree that any one or all of them may file 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 5 








 
a copy of this Section 10 with any court as written evidence of the knowing, voluntary and bargained agreement between the parties irrevocably to waive any objections to jurisdiction,
venue or to convenience of forum. 
 11. No Third Party Beneficiaries. Except as expressly provided in this Agreement, this Agreement
shall not be construed so as to confer any right or benefit upon any person or entity other than the parties to this Agreement, and their respective permitted successors and assigns. 
 12. Severability. Any provision of this Agreement that is invalid, illegal or unenforceable in any jurisdiction shall, as to such jurisdiction, be ineffective to the extent of such invalidity,
illegality or unenforceability without invalidating the remaining provisions hereof or affecting or impairing the validity or enforceability of such provision in any other jurisdiction. It is also the intention of the parties that in lieu of each
clause or provision of this Agreement that is illegal, invalid or unenforceable, there be added, as a part of this Agreement, a clause or provision as similar in terms to such illegal, invalid or unenforceable clause or provision as may be possible
and be legal, valid and enforceable. 
 13. Term. This Agreement shall continue until the earlier of the following to occur:
(a) MSCG receives written notice from Statoil of the termination or expiration of the Supply Agreement, (b) termination or expiration of the Off-Take Agreement and Statoil’s receipt of the required notice thereof as provided in
Section 4 above, subject, however, to the obligations of MSCG to make payments to Statoil hereunder continuing until payment in full thereof with respect to MS Receivables owing for Refined Products delivered to MSCG prior to or on the business
day on which Statoil receives written notice from MSCG of an Event of Default or Additional Termination Event as provided in Section 4 above, and (c) termination of this Agreement by the mutual agreement of all of the parties hereto.
Statoil shall deliver prompt written notice to MSCG of the expiration or termination of the Supply Agreement. 
 14. Amendment. Any
amendment or waiver of this Agreement shall be effected solely by an instrument in writing executed by all of the parties hereto. 
 15.
Headings. The headings and captions used or contained in this Agreement are for convenience of reference only and shall not affect the interpretation or construction of this Agreement. 
 16. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which together shall constitute one and the same instrument.
Facsimile or other electronic copies (such as .pdf files delivered by electronic mail) of signatures shall constitute original signatures for all purposes of this Agreement and any enforcement hereof. 

[Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank] 

  
 Appendix 3

 Page 6 








 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Agreement as of the date
first above written. 
  

			
	MORGAN STANLEY CAPITAL GROUP INC.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  

	
	Notice Address:
	
	Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc.
	2000 Westchester Avenue, Floor 01
	Purchase, New York 10577-2530
	Attention: Randall O’Connor
	Phone: 914-225-1466
	Facsimile: 914-225-9298
	E-mail: randall.o’connor@morganstanley.com
	
	With a copy to:
	
	Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc.
	2000 Westchester Avenue, Floor 01
	Purchase, New York 10577-2530
	Attention: Kenneth Carlino
	Phone: 914-225-1417
	Facsimile: 914-225-9299
	E-mail: kenneth.carlino@morganstanley.com



  
 Appendix 3

 Page 7 








  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  

	
	Notice Address:
	
	Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.
	1055 Washington Boulevard – 7th Floor
	Stamford, CT 06901
	Attention: Crude Oil Operations
	Fax Number: (203) 978-6958
	Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900
	E-mail: uscrudeops@statoil.com
	
	With a copy (which shall not constitute notice) to:
	
	Statoil Marketing and Trading (US) Inc.
	1055 Washington Blvd. – 7th Floor
	Stamford, CT 06901
	Attention: General Counsel
	Fax Number: (203) 978-6952
	Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900



  
 Appendix 3

 Page 8 








  

			
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  

	
	Notice Address:
	
	1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
	Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887
	Attention: Executive Vice President, Commercial
	
	With a copy to:
	
	 PBF Holding Company LLC

 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887
Attention: General Counsel




  
 Appendix 3

 Page 9 








 ANNEX A 

PAYMENT ACCOUNT INFORMATION 
 JP Morgan Chase Bank 
 ABA No.: [REDACTED] 
 SWIFT: [REDACTED] 
 Account No.: [REDACTED] 

  
 Annex A to
Appendix 3 
 Page 1 








 ANNEX B 

REDACTED OFF-TAKE AGREEMENT 
 [Attached] 

  
 Annex B to
Appendix 3 
 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 4 – REFINERY DESCRIPTION 

Set out on Attachment I are diagrams of the Refinery, including: (i) the Paulsboro Refinery Plot Plan, Drawing No. 95-0-AA-16B;
and (ii) the Building & Unit Location Plan, that reflect the storage tanks comprising the Storage Facilities, dock location, locations of berths, locations of transfer points, locations of platforms, locations of pipelines and other
key assets. 
 As of the Delivery Commencement Date the Storage Facilities consist of the specific Storage Tanks more fully
described on Attachment II (and reflected on Attachment I), as such list of storage tanks may be updated from time-to-time to in accordance with the terms of Clause 5(d) of Appendix 5. 

  
 Appendix 4

 Page 1 








 ATTACHMENT I TO APPENDIX 4 

[REDACTED] 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 4 
 Page 1 








 [REDACTED] 

  
 Attachment I
to Appendix 4 
 Page 2 








 ATTACHMENT II TO APPENDIX 4 
 Paulsboro Crude and Feedstock Tankage 
  

															
	Tank Numbers Crude	  	 	  	Shell Cap	 	 	Heels	 	 	Working Cap	 
	 S74
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S75
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S76
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S77
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S78
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S79
	  		  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
					
	 Other
	  		  				 				 			
	 T1969
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S65
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S66
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S68
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 S70
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T41
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T412
	  	 VGO
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T1474
	  	 Coker Feed
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T2504
	  	 Coker Feed
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T2041
	  	 Coker Feed
	  				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T2042
	  	 Coker Feed
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T2043
	  	 Coker Feed
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T640
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T641
	  	 Stop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T3592
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T54
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T1320
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T1919
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 T1920
	  	 Slop
	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 


  
 Attachment II
to Appendix 4 
 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 5 – STORAGE FACILITIES USE PROVISIONS 

The following terms and conditions set forth the terms and conditions governing Seller’s sole and exclusive right to store Oil and
Indigenous Feedstock in the Storage Facilities: 
 1. USAGE AND OPERATION 

(a) Exclusive Use. Subject to the provisions of this Agreement and this Appendix, Seller shall, as of the Delivery Commencement
Date and during the term of this Agreement, have the sole and exclusive right to store Oil and Indigenous Feedstock in the Storage Facilities. 
 (b) Buyer Restrictions and Rights. Nothing herein shall restrict Buyer’s right and ability to operate the Refinery, including the Storage Facilities, provided, however, that: 

(i) Except as expressly provided for in Clause 7(e) of this Agreement, Buyer shall not cause or permit any Oil and
Indigenous Feedstock to be withdrawn from the Storage Facilities without the prior written consent of Seller. 

(ii) Buyer will not commingle any crude oil or Feedstocks with Seller’s Oil and Indigenous Feedstock without the
prior written consent of Seller. 
 (iii) With respect to a request by Buyer to add any storage tanks to the
Storage Facilities pursuant to Clause 5(d) below, such request by Buyer shall be deemed to constitute a representation from Buyer that such additional storage tank(s) are (i) owned in fee by Buyer, (ii) are free and clear of any Liens
other than those expressly permitted pursuant to the terms of the Intercreditor Agreements, and (iii) in full compliance with all of the applicable covenants and obligations set out herein. 

2. COVENANTS OF BUYER 

(a) Buyer shall maintain and operate, at its sole cost and expense, the Storage Facilities in a manner that fully complies with
(i) all applicable Laws and Regulations; and (ii) standard industry practice. With respect to the operation of the Storage Facilities, Buyer shall make all repairs and perform all maintenance in a reasonably timely manner. 

(b) Buyer shall ensure that the Storage Facilities adhere to its current maintenance standards. Buyer shall maintain its ISO 9000:2000,
ANSI/ISO/ASQ Q9001-2000 accreditation by the International Standards Organization during the term of this Agreement. 
 (c) At
any time during this Agreement Seller shall have the right to enter the Storage Facilities and to inspect, examine and inquire concerning all aspects of the Refinery, Storage Facilities and the Oil and Indigenous Feedstock stored therein, including,
without limitation, docking facilities, storage tanks, and pipelines, measuring equipment, and any other physical or operational aspects of the Storage Facilities or any of Seller’s products stored in the Storage Facilities; provided that, if
no Event of Default has occurred with respect to Buyer, Seller shall provide reasonable prior notice to Buyer and adhere to Buyer’s HSE procedures for the Refinery. Seller shall not exercise its rights hereunder if such exercise will:
(i) cause or exacerbate any dangerous, emergency or unsafe conditions at the Storage Facilities, or (ii) obstruct or interfere with the operations of the Storage Facilities in a manner inconsistent with standard industry practices.


  
 Appendix 5

 Page 1 








 (d) Buyer shall not introduce into any of the Storage Facilities or add any chemical
substances to Seller’s Oil and Indigenous Feedstock, including any substances designed to minimize or reduce Tank Heel levels, without the express prior written authorization of Seller. 

(e) Buyer shall not subcontract any part of the work under this Agreement relating to the Storage Facilities without the prior written
consent of Seller in its sole discretion. If Buyer subcontracts any part of the work under this Agreement relating to the Storage Facilities with Seller’s consent, Buyer shall require its subcontractors to maintain insurance required in this
Agreement to the extent applicable to the Storage Facilities. If requested by Seller, Buyer shall have its subcontractors furnish the same evidence of insurance required of Buyer. 
 3. EMERGENCIES 
 In the event that Buyer reasonably believes that there are,
or are about to be, emergency or urgent circumstances which could have a material adverse impact on the Refinery, the Refinery site, the operation of the Refinery, or the health and safety of any person or the environment (“Emergency
Circumstances”), regardless of the cause of such Emergency Circumstances and without assuming any duty hereunder to do so, Buyer may take such steps and actions as it, in its sole discretion, deems reasonable to protect against such
circumstances occurring or to minimize, reduce or avoid their adverse impact including the immediate lifting, removal, relocation and commingling of Oil of different Grades. Any such steps which Buyer takes shall not, on their own, constitute a
Default of the terms of this Agreement provided, however, Buyer shall not be absolved of any responsibility or liability hereunder resulting from any breach of the terms of this Agreement which caused such emergency or urgent circumstances. Buyer
shall promptly notify Seller of any steps or actions so taken. Buyer shall compensate Seller for any Liabilities resulting from any such steps or actions taken hereunder. 
 4. SUBLETTING AND RELEASE OF SELLER’S CAPACITY 
 During the term of
this Agreement, neither Party may further assign, sublet, sublicense, grant or release any storage capacity in the Storage Facilities except in connection with a permitted assignment under this Agreement. 

5. TANKS BEING TAKEN OUT OF SERVICE / CHANGING SERVICE 
 During the term of this Agreement certain of the tanks constituting Storage Facilities may be required to come out of service for maintenance or other reasons. 

(a) Cleaning of tanks and the safe disposal of any sludge, oil or other hazardous substances from tanks which are taken out of service
whether before or after the termination of this Agreement is the sole responsibility of Buyer. Buyer warrants to Seller that Buyer will dispose of such material in a lawful and safe manner. Buyer shall be solely responsible for any and all costs
associated with such disposal and shall indemnify Seller against any and all liabilities arising from the disposal of such materials. 

  
 Appendix 5

 Page 2 








 (b) Prior to removing from service a tank comprising part of the Storage Facilities the
Parties shall meet to discuss and agree to the measurement of any quantities of usable Oil and/or Indigenous Feedstock that constitutes Tank Heels that need to be transferred between tanks constituting Storage Facilities, the measurement or
assessment of such Tank Heels and whether the actual net Tank Heel volume following such operations will be less or more than the TH Starting Volume as adjusted by any prior interim Tank Heel purchases and sales. If there will be a net reduction in
the Tank Heel volume following such operations Buyer shall purchase such reduction quantity of Tank Heel volume pursuant to the terms of Clause 5(j)(ii)(2), with the volume of such Tank Heels purchase being treated as an interim purchase by Buyer.
If a measurement or assessment indicates that Buyer has not yet purchased the full amount of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock that has been used, then Buyer shall purchase and pay for such used Oil and/or Indigenous Feedstock at a price equal to the
then-applicable price for such Oil or Indigenous Feedstock as specified in the applicable Cargo Bank for Oil applying the FIFO accounting practice to determine which Oil is being purchased and applying the Provisions of Clause 5(i) with respect to
interim Indigenous Feedstock purchases. 
 (c) When returning a tank to service that has been removed from service pursuant to
Clause 5(b) of this Appendix 5, the Parties shall meet to discuss and agree to a quantity of Tank Heels that will be used to re-float the tank and such quantity of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock shall be treated as Tank Heels for all purposes
hereunder. Such new Tank Heels will be purchased by Seller pursuant to the provisions of Clause 5(j)(ii)(1), with the volume of such new Tank Heels treated as an interim purchase by Seller and will be subject to Clauses 5(j) and 25 at the TH
Conclusion Date and at termination of the Agreement. 
 (d) To the extent Buyer desires to change service for any tank
constituting part of the Storage Facilities or add or remove a tank from the Storage Facilities, Seller must provide its written consent. Upon the granting of Seller’s consent, Attachment II to Appendix 4 shall be automatically deemed to
reflect such modifications. To the extent applicable, the Parties shall also meet and agree prior to the granting of any such consent to any of the matters set forth in subclause (b) above. 

  
 Appendix 5

 Page 3 








 APPENDIX 6 – GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF SERVICE 

The Commercial Services and Shipping Services under this Agreement will be rendered in accordance with the following: 

1. COMMERCIAL SERVICES 

(a) Commercial Services Provided 
 The Commercial Services shall include the following: 
 (i) Onward
transportation of Oil as required to Supply Oil to the Refinery; 
 (ii) Storage of Oil in the Storage Facilities
until such time the Oil is delivered to Buyer (with Buyer providing all maintenance and operation of the Storage Facilities); 
 (iii) Information services, including the provision of information that helps Buyer run the Refinery LP and plan and schedule Refinery operations; 

(iv) Operational, shipping, financial, contractual and other administrative services related to the activities as detailed
in (i)-(iii) above, which include the conduct of commercial contract negotiations, resolving any trading disputes with third parties and contractual compliance matters with third parties. 

(b) Commercial Services Actions. Seller: 
 (i) shall perform its duties in both a reasonable and prudent manner; 
 (ii) shall act as a principal in the market in front of third parties for purchases and sales of Oil under this Agreement; 

(iii) shall be the only face to market for the execution of all Commercial Services; 

(iv) shall use reasonable efforts to secure optimal pricing of the Oil purchased or sold under this Agreement and to
minimize delivery-related costs for Oil purchased under the Execution Method; 
 (v) shall allocate the necessary
resources to support and to interface with Buyer in the provision of the Commercial Services hereunder; 
 (vi)
may enter into commercial commitments with third parties in connection with the performance of the Commercial Services, with all commercial terms being agreed to at its reasonable sole discretion, in line with Buyer’s mandate; 

(vii) may conduct any re-sale of any Oil purchased as part of this Agreement in line with its credit control procedures in
effect at the time of such disposal. The costs of a third party credit default under such re-sale of Oil shall be for Buyer’s account unless caused by the gross negligence or willful misconduct of Seller. 

  
 Appendix 6

 Page 1 








 (c) Commercial Services Actions. Buyer: 

(i) shall maintain an organizational structure to support and interface with Seller in the conduct of this Agreement;

 (ii) may maintain such market knowledge as it sees fit independently of Seller, but will refrain from seeking
bids / offers / indications or otherwise contracting in the market directly or via intermediates for any of the Commercial Services covered under this Agreement except if compelled to do so due to the gross negligence or willful misconduct of
Seller; 
 (iii) acknowledges and accepts that Seller will only contract with third party companies which have
been compliance cleared by Seller, with such clearance not to be unreasonably withheld; 
 (iv) acknowledges that
Seller cannot be obliged to use contractors or service providers which do not meet Seller’s HSE requirements. 
 2. SHIPPING SERVICES

 (a) Shipping Services Provided 
 Seller shall be the sole and exclusive face to the market for the provision of Shipping Services in relation to the Supply of Oil under this Agreement. Such Shipping Services shall include: 

(i) the provision of shipping market availability and price information to Buyer; 

(ii) the negotiation and execution of all shipping agreements including lightering services into the Delaware River, other
than with respect to (1) the Hess Tanks and (2) any Excluded Term Contracts in accordance with the Agreement; 
 (iii) shipping operational services including managing logistics in relation to each Cargo from the Loading Terminal to the Supply Port, liaising with terminals, ship owners, and appointing Independent
Inspectors for quality and quantity testing and certification; 
 (iv) quality control and loss control services
including overseeing independent inspection services and providing reasonable technical support and advice in relation to any Oil quality claims and any recovery actions against ship owners; 

(v) any vetting requirements including all Vessels used; and loadports as required by Seller’s vetting policy. Buyer
acknowledges that Seller shall not be obliged to use Vessels, service providers or call at loadports which are not in compliance with Seller’s vetting policy. 

  
 Appendix 6

 Page 2 








 (b) Pre-Commencement Meetings. Prior to the Delivery Commencement Date the Parties
shall meet to coordinate the start-up process with respect to this Agreement. The Parties shall coordinate all matters necessary or convenient to the operations leading up to the Delivery Commencement Date, including the following:
(i) identification of potential third party suppliers and (ii) review of potential Vessels to confirm their acceptance by Seller, which acceptance shall not be unreasonably withheld. 

  
 Appendix 6

 Page 3 








 APPENDIX 7 – LIST OF MUTUALLY AGREED GRADES 

List of approved crude oils 

					
	 Crude
	 	 Country
	 	 Loadport

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	
	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	
	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]
	 	 [REDACTED]

		 		 	 [REDACTED]

		 		 	 [REDACTED]



  
 Appendix 7

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 8 – REQUIREMENTS SCHEDULE 

 

									
	Buyers tentative requirement schedule	  		  		  		  	date

					
	  	  	mbd
Jan	  	mbd
Feb	  	mbd
Mar	  	mbd
Apr
	 Type A
	  		  		  		  	
	 Kirkuk
	  		  		  		  	
	 Urals
	  		  		  		  	
	 Vasconia
	  		  		  		  	
	 Basra
	  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	
	 Type B
	  		  		  		  	
	 Terra Nova
	  		  		  		  	
	 Hibernia
	  		  		  		  	
	 Azeria
	  		  		  		  	
	 Dalia
	  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	
	 Type C
	  		  		  		  	
	 Arab light
	  		  		  		  	
	 Arab medium
	  		  		  		  	
	 Kirkuk
	  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	
	 Type D
	  		  		  		  	
	 M100
	  		  		  		  	
	 VGO
	  		  		  		  	
	  		  		  		  	
		  		  		  		  	


  
 Appendix 8

 Page 1 








  

			
	 PAULSBORO CRUDE RUNOUT

LUBE CRUDE
	 	 PAULSBORO CRUDE RUNOUT

CRACKING CRUDE


 [REDACTED] 

  
 Appendix 8

 Page 2 








 APPENDIX 9 – GRADE PECKING ORDER 

CRUDE EVALUATION TABLES 
  

			
	Date of Issue	  	“date”
	Period Valid    (days)	  	7

 GRADE PECKING ORDER (GPO) 
 For 15 Day Period ending     “date1” 
  

															
	 Type A
 Grade 
	 	Max volume
at value	  	Seller price
Indication
refinery gate	  	Buyer
LP run
margin	  	 Type B
 Grade
	  	Max volume
at value	  	Seller price
Indication
refinery gate	  	Buyer
LP run
margin
	 Base
	 		  		  		  	Base 	  		  		  	
	 Alt 1
	 		  		  		  	Alt 1	  		  		  	
	 Alt 2
	 		  		  		  	Alt 2	  		  		  	
	 Alt 3
	 		  		  		  	Alt 3	  		  		  	
	 Alt 4
	 		  		  		  	Alt 4	  		  		  	
	 etc
	 		  		  		  	etc	  		  		  	

 For 15 Days Period ending     “date2”

  

															
	 Type A
 Grade 
	 	Max volume
at value	  	Seller price
Indication
refinery gate	  	Buyer
LP run
margin	  	 Type B
 Grade
	  	Max volume
at value	  	Seller price
Indication
refinery gate	  	Buyer
LP run
margin
	 Base
	 		  		  		  	Base 	  		  		  	
	 Alt 1
	 		  		  		  	Alt 1	  		  		  	
	 Alt 2
	 		  		  		  	Alt 2	  		  		  	
	 Alt 3
	 		  		  		  	Alt 3	  		  		  	
	 Alt 4
	 		  		  		  	Alt 4	  		  		  	
	 etc
	 		  		  		  	etc	  		  		  	

  
 More Periods in future give more tables. Suggest minimum
15 day periods to allow flexible buying. 
 REPLACEMENT GRADE PECKING ORDER (RGPO) 

Table contains value of alternative grade in row vs Grade of crude currently covering requirement in column. If no value is shown, grade is not an allowed
alternative 
  

													
	 Covered requirement
 Date range allowed
 Grade
	  	 1
	  	 2
	  	 3
	  	 4
	  	 5
	  	 6

	 A 
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 B
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 C
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 D
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 E
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 F
	  		  		  		  		  		  	
	 G
	  		  		  		  		  		  	

 SPECIAL REFINERY NOTES 
 Freeform text highlighting special needs attributable to certain requirements. 

  
 Appendix 9

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 10 – CARGO CONFIRMATION NOTICE 

 
  
 Seller hereby confirms the covering of a Requirement in accordance with Clause 5 “Acquisition of Oil” as set forth in the Crude Oil/Feedstock Supply/Delivery and Services Agreement between the
Parties dated December [    ], 2010, with the Cargo of Oil per the following Transparent Contractual Terms: 
  

			
	 CONTRACT DATE:
	  	XXXXXX
		
	REQUIREMENT NO.:	  	XXXXXX
		
	QUALITY:	  	XXXXXXXXXX
		
	QUANTITY:	  	XXXXXXXX (US BBLS)
		
	TOLERANCE:	  	XXXXX
		
	TOLERANCE OPTION:	  	SELLER’S
		
	PLACE OF DELIVERY:	  	XXXXXXX BY VESSEL (DES), AT ONE SAFE BERTH
		
	PERIOD OF DELIVERY:	  	XXXXXXX
		
	PRICE AND CURRENCY:	  	
		
	BASIS:	  	XXXXXXXX
	DIFFERENTIAL:	  	XXXXXXXX
	PERIOD:	  	XXXXXXXX
		
	PAYMENT TERM:	  	XXXXXXX
		
	ACQUISITION METHOD:	  	EXECUTION METHOD / SUPPLY POINT METHOD
		
	CREDIT TERMS:	  	XXXXXXX
		
	OTHER TERMS:	  	
	
	FURTHER COMMERCIAL AGREEMENTS PERTAINING TO THIS CARGO:

 Regards, 

Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc. 
  

			
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	


  
 Appendix 10

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 11 – COMMENCEMENT INVENTORY ACQUISITION 

This Appendix 11 sets forth the procedures whereby Seller will (i) purchase from or on behalf of Buyer the Initial Inventory (as
hereinafter defined in Section 6 of this Appendix 11) held at the Refinery on the Delivery Commencement Date which is being purchased from Valero and (ii) commit to purchase from or on behalf of Buyer the Oil and Indigenous Feedstock designated as
“Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit” in Exhibit F (as hereinafter defined) when Supplied to the Storage Facilities by Valero. This Appendix 11 constitutes Buyer’s written mandate for Seller to purchase the volumes of Oil and Indigenous
Feedstock acquired hereunder by Seller and under the Tri-Party Agreement from Valero. 
 1. PBF-VALERO INVENTORY SALES AGREEMENT

 On the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer is entering into a Feedstock and Product Inventory Sales Agreement (the
“ISA”) with Valero in the form of “Exhibit F to Stock Purchase Agreement” which is attached to this Appendix 11 as Annex A (“Exhibit F”). Capitalized terms used but not otherwise defined in the Agreement
or this Appendix 11 have the meanings given such terms in Exhibit F. 
 2. REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES 

Buyer represents and warrants to Seller as of the Effective Date, as of the Delivery Commencement Date and as of the date of any purchase
of Initial Inventory by Seller pursuant to this Appendix 11 that (a) Exhibit F is a true, correct and complete copy of the agreement between Buyer and Valero with respect to the ISA and (b) there are no provisions in the Stock Purchase Agreement
between Buyer and Valero Refining and Marketing Company (an affiliate of Valero) dated September 24, 2010 (the “SPA”) with respect to any matter that would cause the terms of the SPA to control in accordance with Section 6.14 of the
ISA. 
 3. TRI-PARTY AGREEMENT; COVENANTS 
 (a) Concurrently with the execution of this Agreement, Buyer, Seller and Valero are entering into an agreement (the “Tri-Party Agreement”) providing that (i) at Buyer’s instruction
Seller shall on the Delivery Commencement Date pay the Initial Inventory Purchase Price (as hereinafter defined) directly to Valero on behalf of Buyer, (ii) Valero shall deliver title to the Initial Inventory, with special warranty of title
described in Section 2 of the ISA, directly to Seller as Buyer’s assignee, (lit) when payment to Valero from Buyer becomes due for volumes of Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit, Seller, at Buyer’s instruction, shall pay such amounts directly to
Valero on behalf of Buyer, (iv) Valero shall deliver title to such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit, with special warranty of title described in Section 4.2 of the ISA, directly to Seller instead of Buyer, and (v) Seller will purchase directly from
Valero certain Cargoes of Oil. 
 (b) Except to the extent consented to by Seller, Buyer shall (i) ensure that the ISA is in the
same form as Exhibit F, and (ii) not amend, modify or waive any term, right or obligation arising under the ISA. 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 1 








 (c) Buyer shall promptly (and in any event within one Business Day after receipt) deliver to
Seller copies of all notices, correspondence or other written materials that are either received or delivered by Buyer or Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative that pertain to the transactions contemplated by the ISA, including any
notices, correspondence or other written materials from third parties, including Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc., which are to acquire from Buyer other inventory included within the scope of the ISA. 

(d) Buyer shall promptly (and in any event within one Business Day after becoming aware) notify Seller of: (i) any breach or
non-performance by Valero under the ISA, (ii) any other event or circumstance which may delay, restrict, or limit in any way a payment under the ISA, and (iii) any proposed modification, amendment restatement or termination of the ISA or of rights
or obligations related thereto. 
 (e) On the Delivery Commencement Date, (i) Seller shall, (1) at Buyer’s instruction,
purchase from Valero the Initial Inventory and (2) commit to purchase, when Supplied to the Storage Facilities, the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit, and (3) deliver to Buyer a Cargo Confirmation Notice for each Cargo of Oil included in the Unpaid Crude
Oil In-Transit. 
 4. PRE-DELIVERY COMMENCEMENT DATE CONSULTATION 

Prior to the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall advise Seller on a regular basis as to the volume, anticipated price and status of
the Initial Inventory that Buyer is to purchase from Valero pursuant to the ISA (and that Seller is to purchase hereunder). Prior to the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall consult with Seller regarding the Cargoes of Oil (and the Vessels
carrying such Cargo) that will be designated as Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit in accordance with Section 4 of the ISA, and Seller reserves the right to reject any such Cargo that does not meet the requirements of Clause 9 of this Appendix 11.

 5. INVENTORY COMMITTEE AND INVENTORY SCHEDULE 
 (a) At least 3 Business Days prior to the Delivery Commencement Date, Buyer shall advise Seller of (i) the person that Buyer intends to nominate as Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative pursuant
to Section 3.1.1 of the ISA and (ii) the company that Buyer and Valero agree upon for the Petroleum Inspection Company. 
 (b)
Buyer may not designate a different Inventory Committee representative or agree on a new Petroleum Inspection Company without the consent of Seller. 
 (c) Buyer shall regularly consult with Seller regarding Buyer’s and Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative’s discussions and negotiations pursuant to Section 3 and Exhibit A of the ISA.
Buyer shall promptly (and in any event within one Business Day after receipt) deliver copies of all reports and other documents received by Buyer or Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative pursuant to Section 3 of the ISA and shall consult
with Seller regarding the contents of such reports and other documents. 
 (d) Buyer shall provide Seller with prior notice of
any inspections or meeting to be held pursuant to the ISA and will provide Seller the ability to observe any such inspection or meeting. 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 2 








 (e) Buyer shall, and shall cause Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative to, only
approve an Inventory Schedule that contains sufficient detail regarding all amounts allocated to IF Starting Volume, Initial Oil Inventory, Crude Line Fill, Feedstock Line Fill and Tank Heels as is necessary for the Parties to determine the amount
of the Final Feedstock and Product Inventory Sales Amount and Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment allocable to the Initial Inventory. 
 (f) Buyer shall, and shall cause Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative to, only make such approvals and take such actions pursuant to the ISA with the consent of Seller, including (i) approval
of the Inventory Schedule, (ii) challenges of the Inventory Report pursuant to Section 3.1.4 of the ISA; (iii) disputing or approving the Feedstock and Product Sales Statement pursuant to Section 3.1.5 of the ISA; (iv) decisions with respect to
arbitration of disputes pursuant to Section 3.1.5 of the ISA; (v) determination of methodology in accordance with Section B of Appendix A of the ISA; and (vi) sign-off on the Gauge Ticket in accordance with Section E of Appendix A of the ISA. In
addition, with respect to (ii), (iii) and (iv) above, Buyer shall, and shall direct Buyer’s Inventory Committee representative to, take any actions reasonably requested by Seller in connection with such actions. 

6. INITIAL INVENTORY 

(a) The “Initial Inventory” consists of the Feedstock and Products Inventory which are purchased on Buyer’s behalf
from Valero pursuant to the ISA that are identified as “Crude Oil” and “Feedstocks” on Part II to Exhibit A of the ISA, including Tank Heels and the Hess VGO, but excludes any “Crude Oil” or “Feedstocks”
located (i) in the Hess VGO Terminal - Baltimore or (ii) downstream of the outlet flange of the Storage Facilities. The Initial Inventory specifically excludes the hydrocarbon products identified as “Distillate,” “Gasoline,”
“Intermediates,” “LPGS,” “Lube Plant,” “Residual” and “Other” on Part II to Exhibit A of the ISA. 
 (b) The Initial Inventory includes the following components: 
 (i)
The IF Starting Volume, including any Tank Heels associated therewith; 
 (ii) The volume of crude oil which is
Refinery OSBL Line Fill located in Dock to S-79 tank (4,474 Barrels), as designated on Exhibit C to the ISA (the “Crude Line Fill”); 
 (iii) The volume of FCC Charge / VGO which is Refinery OSBL Line Fill located in Dock to S-70 tank (1,087 Barrels), as designated on Exhibit C to the ISA (the “Feedstock Line Fill,” and
collectively with the Crude Line Fill, the “Line Fill”); 
 (iv) The volume of Oil included in
the Initial Inventory which is not Line Fill (“Initial Oil Inventory”), including any Tank Heels associated therewith. 
 7.
INITIAL PRICING; CONVEYANCE; IN-TRANSIT INVENTORY 
 (a) The Initial Inventory shall be measured, and the price paid by
Seller to or on behalf of Buyer for the Initial Inventory shall be determined, in accordance with the procedures described in Section 3 to Exhibit F and in accordance with this Clause 5 of this Appendix 11, subject to adjustment in accordance with
Clause 8 of this Appendix 11. 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 3 








 (b) Buyer shall cause Valero to prepare the Excel spreadsheet accompanying the Estimated
Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount in sufficient detail to allow the Parties to determine the amount of the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount that is allocable to the Initial Inventory and which is payable on the
Delivery Commencement Date (such amount the “Initial Inventory Purchase Price”), which amount excludes any amounts which will become payable at a future date with respect to In-Transit Inventory, including such detail as necessary
to determine the amounts allocable to the IF Starting Volume, Initial Oil Inventory, Crude Line Fill, Feedstock Line Fill and Tank Heels associated with each storage space at the Storage Facilities. 

(c) On the Delivery Commencement Date, Seller shall pay to Valero the Initial Inventory Purchase Price on behalf of Buyer in accordance
with the Tri-Party Agreement, and Buyer shall cause Valero to sell assign, transfer and deliver unto Seller, its successors and assigns forever, all of Valero’s right, title, and interest in and to all of the Initial Inventory and shall deliver
to Seller such documentation as may be reasonably requested by Seller. 
 (d) On each delivery of Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit,
Buyer shall direct Seller to purchase the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit from Valero in accordance with the Tri-Party Agreement, and concurrently therewith Buyer shall cause Valero to sell assign, transfer and deliver unto Seller, its successors and
assigns forever, all of Valero’s right, title, and interest in and to such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit and shall deliver to Seller such documentation as may be reasonably requested by Seller. In accordance with the Tri-Party Agreement, Seller
shall pay Valero directly for Buyer’s obligations to Valero for the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit when due, and Valero shall deliver title with special warranty to Seller when such oil is Supplied to the Storage Facilities. 

8. PURCHASE PRICE ADJUSTMENT 
 (a) Upon final determination of the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount and Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment in accordance with the ISA, the Patties shall allocate any
Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment in accordance with this Clause 8 of this Appendix 11. All amounts shall be paid or received in accordance with the timing for such payments described in Section 3.1.6 of the ISA and shall be allocated
as follows: 
 (i) With respect to the Initial Oil Inventory other than Tank Heels, 

(1) With respect to any Oil in the Initial Oil Inventory which has been Delivered to Buyer by Seller as of the date of
final determination of the Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment (the “Delivered Initial Oil Inventory”), 
 (A) If the adjustment amount allocable to the Delivered Initial Oil Inventory would result in a payment by Valero to Buyer under the ISA, Buyer shall receive such amount from Valero in accordance with the
ISA; 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 4 








 (B) If the adjustment amount allocable to the Delivered Initial Oil
Inventory would result in a payment by Buyer to Valero under the ISA, Buyer shall pay such amount to Valero in accordance with the ISA; and 
 (C) There shall be no adjustment to the price paid as between Buyer and Seller (which was based on the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount) with respect to the Delivered Initial Oil
Inventory. 
 (2) With respect to any Oil in the Initial Oil Inventory other than Tank Heels, if any, which has
not been Delivered to Buyer by Seller as of the date of final determination of the Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment (the “Undelivered Initial Oil Inventory”) plus any adjustment for the measured volume of Oil in the
Initial Oil Inventory (the “Volume Adjustment”), 
 (A) If the sum of (i) the adjustment amount
allocable to the Undelivered Initial Oil Inventory and (ii) the Volume Adjustment would result in a payment by Valero to Buyer under the ISA, Buyer shall direct Valero to pay such amount directly to Seller, and such amount shall reduce the amount
allocated to the price of the Undelivered Initial Oil Inventory; or 
 (B) If the sum of (i) the adjustment
amount allocable to the Undelivered Initial Oil Inventory and (ii) the Volume Adjustment would result in a payment by Buyer to Valero under the ISA, Seller shall pay such amount to Valero, and such amount shall increase the amount allocated to the
price of the Undelivered Initial Oil Inventory. 
 (ii) With respect to the IF Starting Volume other than Tank
Heels, 
 (1) If the adjustment amount allocable to the IF Starting Volume would result in a payment by Valero to
Buyer under the ISA, Buyer shall direct Valero to pay such amount directly to Seller, and such amount shall reduce the amount allocated to the IF Starting Volume; or 

(2) If the adjustment amount allocable to the IF Starting Volume would result in a payment by Buyer to Valero under the
ISA, Seller shall pay such amount to Valero, and such amount shall increase the amount allocated to the IF Starting Volume. 
 (iii) With respect to Tank Heels, 
 (1) If the adjustment amount
allocable to Tank Heels would result in a payment by Valero to Buyer under the ISA, Buyer shall direct Valero to pay such amount directly to Seller, and such amount shall reduce the amount allocated to Tank Heels for such volumes; or 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 5 








 (2) If the adjustment amount allocable to Tank Heels would result in a
payment by Buyer to Valero under the ISA, Seller shall pay such amount to Valero, and such amount shall increase the amount allocated to Tank Heels for such volumes. 

(iv) With respect to Line Fill, there shall be no adjustment and the deemed volumes of Line Fill used for the Estimated
Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount shall be the same as those used for the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. To the extent there is an adjustment in the volume of Line Fill in the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory
Sales Amount, as between Buyer and Seller, the Parties will allocate such volume change to Initial Oil Inventory or IF Starting Volume, as appropriate, and the purchase price adjustment shall be calculated in accordance with Clause 8(a)(i) and
8(a)(ii) of this Appendix 11 above. 
 (v) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Appendix 11, if an
Event of Default has occurred as of the date of determination of the Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment and Buyer is the Defaulting Party, 
 (1) Buyer shall direct Valero to make any payments that would otherwise be made to Buyer in accordance with this Clause 8 of this Appendix 11 directly to Seller; 

(2) If Buyer fails to direct Valero to make a payment to Seller that Seller is entitled to receive directly in accordance
with this Clause 8 of this Appendix 11, Seller may (A) direct Valero to make such payment to Seller and (B) deliver a copy of this Appendix 11 to Valero as evidence of Seller’s entitlement to such payment; and 

(3) Seller shall have no obligation to make any payments to Valero with respect to obligations of Buyer, including with
respect to Clauses 8(a)(i)(2)(B), 8(a)(ii)(2) and 8(a)(iii)(2) above. 
 (b) The amounts to be paid or received by Buyer and
Seller with respect to Valero in accordance with Clause 8(a) of this Appendix 11 may, at the discretion of the Parties, be netted in such a manner to result in a fewer number of payments or receipts by the Parties. Additionally, Seller may at its
sole discretion require payment from Buyer in lieu of Buyer directing Valero to make any payment to which Seller is entitled hereunder. 
 9.
ACCEPTANCE OF VESSELS 
 All shipping of Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit will be performed on Vessels which are acceptable to
Seller in its reasonable discretion in consideration of Seller’s vetting policy in effect at the time. Seller reserves the right to reject any Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit on the basis that the Vessel carrying such Oil does not pass
Seller’s vetting policy. In the event any Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit is rejected by Seller in accordance with this Clause 9 of this Appendix 11, the Parties shall work together to resolve the issue, at the sole cost and expense of Buyer. If
the issue cannot be resolved to Seller’s reasonable satisfaction, Seller will not purchase such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit. 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 6 








 10. EXCLUDED VOLUMES; VOLUMES PURCHASED UNDER SEPARATE TERMS 

Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Appendix 11 or in the ISA: 
 (a) The Hess VGO (as defined in Exhibit F) will be purchased from Valero on 3 vessels in the water and not at the Hess VGO Terminal - Baltimore, subject to Clause 9 of this Appendix 11. Seller has no
obligation to purchase any “Crude Oil in-Transit Inventory” (as defined in Exhibit F) other than the Hess VGO, if any, or any Oil at the Hess VGO Terminal – Baltimore; 

(b) Seller will take assignment by separate written agreement from Valero of BP North America Petroleum Contract 4200085621 with Valero
regarding a volume of vacuum gasoil; and 
 (c) Seller will, by separate written agreement, purchase from Valero a Cargo of
vacuum tower bottoms on a delivered basis to the Refinery’s Storage Facilities, in accordance with the pricing terms of Shell Trading (US) Company Purchase Order. 4300423622 with Valero. 
 11. ISA 
 (a) All costs incurred with respect to the ISA, other than the
Initial Inventory purchase obligations expressly imposed on Seller pursuant to this Appendix 11, shall be solely for the account of Buyer. 
 (b) As between Seller and Buyer, notwithstanding the terms of the ISA, in the event of the conflict between any terms of the SPA and the ISA that could adversely affect Seller, the terms of the ISA shall
apply instead. 
 (c) The provisions of Clause 40(c) of the Agreement expressly apply to this Appendix 11, and there are no
third party beneficiaries of this Appendix 11. For the avoidance of doubt, Valero shall have no rights with respect to the Agreement or this Appendix 11, and Seller shall not be subject to any terms of the ISA and SPA. 

12. OTHER FEES 
 The
Initial Inventory, the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit and the Cargoes of Oil purchased directly from Valero pursuant to the Tri-Party Agreement are each subject to the normal $[REDACTED]. per Barrel service fee and insurance of $[REDACTED] per Barrel,
and shall be included in the calculation of the TVM Payment when Seller becomes responsible for payment for such Initial Inventory, Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit and other Cargoes. 

  
 Appendix 11

 Page 7 








 ANNEX A TO APPENDIX 11 

FORM OF EXHIBIT F TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT 
 [Attached] 

  
 Annex A to
Appendix 11 
 Page 1 








 EXHIBIT F 
 TO 
 STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT 

FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCT INVENTORY SALES AGREEMENT 
 THIS FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCT INVENTORY SALES AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”), is made and entered into as of December 17, 2010 (the “Effective Date”), by and
between VALERO MARKETING AND SUPPLY COMPANY, a Delaware corporation (“Seller”) and PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the “Buyer”) (collectively, the
“Parties”). 
 RECITALS 
 A. Buyer, and Valero Refining and Marketing Company, a Delaware corporation (“VRMC”), have entered into a Stock Purchase Agreement, dated as of September 24, 2010 (the
“SPA”), pursuant to which VRMC will sell and transfer, and Buyer will purchase and acquire, the Shares (as defined in the SPA) and, as such, Buyer will indirectly acquire the Refinery (as defined in the SPA) and certain related,
tankage and logistics assets (collectively, the “Refinery Logistics Assets”). VRMC is an affiliate of Seller. 

B. Seller has historically provided feedstock to the owner of the Refinery for use in its operations, and Seller has maintained title to
and ownership of the products produced by the Refinery (such feedstocks and products are more particularly defined herein as the “Feedstock and Products Inventory”). In connection with consummation of the transactions contemplated
by the SPA, Seller desires to sell to Buyer, and Buyer desires to purchase from Seller, all of Seller’s right, title, and interest in and to the Feedstock and Products Inventory and subsequently the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit. At Closing,
Buyer may concurrently sell or assign the Feedstock and Products Inventory to certain third parties who will directly pay Seller for such inventory that they purchase from Buyer, provided, however, Buyer shall remain responsible for all Closing
payments to Seller. 
 C. Seller and Buyer desire to enter into this Agreement to set forth their agreements regarding the
protocols to be used for measuring the quantity and quality of the Feedstock and Products Inventory and certain other inventories of feedstocks consumed and products produced at the Refinery, and to establish the prices to be paid by Buyer to Seller
for the Feedstock and Products Inventory. 
 D. As a condition precedent to Closing under the SPA, Buyer and VMRC require the
execution of this Agreement. 
 NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises, the mutual promises and covenants
contained herein and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Parties, subject to the terms and conditions hereinafter set forth, agree as follows: 

  
 - 1 -









 SECTION 1: DEFINITIONS 

1.1 Definitions. The following terms shall have the following meanings for the purposes of this Agreement: 

1.1.1 “Affiliate” has the same meaning as that term is defined in the SPA. 

1.1.2 “Argus” means the various daily reports published by Argus Media Group including the Argus International Crude
Report and the U.S. Products Report. 
 1.1.3 “Agreement” has the meaning set forth in the introductory
paragraph immediately preceding the Introduction. 
 1.1.4 “Asphalt Terminals” means the following asphalt
terminals: the Apex Terminal in Baltimore, MD and the Kinder Morgan Terminal in Richmond, VA. 
 1.1.5 “Bath
Butane” has the meaning set forth in Section 5.1 hereof. 
 1.1.6 “Barrel” means 42 United States
standard gallons of 231 cubic inches at 60 degrees Fahrenheit and one atmosphere of pressure (14.696 PSIA). 
 1.1.7
“Business Day” has the same meaning as that term is defined in the SPA. 
 1.1.8 “Buyer” has
the meaning set forth in the introductory paragraph immediately preceding the Introduction. 
 1.1.9 “Closing”
has the same meaning as that term is defined in the SPA. 
 1.1.10 “Closing Date” shall be December 17,
2010. 
 1.1.11 “Crude Oil In-Tankage” means all volumes of crude oil and refinery feedstock that Seller has
title to on or before the Inventory Transfer Time which are located within the Refinery Tankage and the Third-Party Tankage or Storage. 
 1.1.12 “Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory” means those volumes of crude oil and feedstock that Seller either has title to or has purchased on or before the Inventory Transfer Time that are
scheduled for delivery to the Refinery, the Refinery Tankage, or the Third-Party Tankage or Storage, but which have not, as yet, been delivered to the Refinery, any Refinery Tankage, or any Third-Party Tankage or Storage as of the Inventory Transfer
Time and which will include, without limitation, Seller’s crude oil and feedstock as is located, in pipelines, barges, and vessels but excludes Unpaid Crude-Oil In-Transit. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, the Parties assume
that on the Inventory Transfer Time that there will be no Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory except for the Hess VGO. 
 1.1.13
“Effective Date” has the meaning set forth in the introductory paragraph immediately preceding the Introduction. 

  
 - 2 -









 1.1.14 “Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount” means the
amount specified in a notice from Seller to Buyer no later than three (3) Business Days prior to the Closing, being Seller’s reasonable good faith estimate of the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, as determined in
accordance with the procedures set forth in Section 3 and Exhibit A of this Agreement. Such notice shall also include Seller’s calculations used to determine the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, which
shall be provided in an Excel spreadsheet. 
 1.1.15 “Feedstock and Products Inventory” means all
(i) In-Tankage Inventory, (ii) In-Transit Inventory, (iii) Refinery OSBL Line Fill and (iv) any volumes of the Products identified in Part II of Exhibit A which are in the physical possession of Seller or Company
and located within the Refinery as of the Inventory Transfer Time; in all cases which, as of the Inventory Transfer Time shall be subject to the physical inventory procedures set forth in Exhibit A hereto and the pricing adjustments set forth
in Section 3. The definition of Feedstock and Products Inventory herein shall not mean nor include, and expressly excludes, all Refinery and Unit Process Chemicals and Catalyst, Unit Fill and the Retained Feedstock and Products.

 1.1.16 “Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment” has the meaning set forth in Section 3.1.6 of
this Agreement. 
 1.1.17 “Feedstock and Products Sales Statement” has the meaning set forth in
Section 3.1.5 of this Agreement. 
 1.1.18 “Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount” means the
amount of the Feedstock and Products Inventory as determined in accordance with the procedures described in Section 3 and Exhibit A of this Agreement. 
 1.1.19 “Final Inventory Report” has the meaning set forth in Section 3.1.4 of this Agreement. 
 1.1.20 “Finished Product In-Tankage” means all volumes of finished or refined Products that Seller has title to and are located within the Refinery Tankage and the Third-Party Tankage or
Storage as of the Inventory Transfer Time. 
 1.1.21 “Finished Product In-Transit” means all volumes of
finished or refined Products that Seller has title to which are, as of the Inventory Transfer Time, located in the Jet Pipeline, NuStar Pipeline or the Plains Pipeline, or in the case of lubes and petcoke Products, in any railcars, barges, tank
trucks or other facilities outside the Refinery and have not yet been delivered to any Third Party Tankage or Storage or customer, if sold to such customer on a delivered basis, or in the case of certain lube Products to be transloaded, which have
not yet been transloaded at the transload terminal or facility. 
 1.1.22 “Gallon” means one standard United
States gallon of 231 cubic inches at 60 degrees Fahrenheit and one atmosphere of pressure (14.696 PSIA). 
 1.1.23 “Hess
VGO” means approximately 123,386 bbls of VGO loaded on three separate barges and in transit to the Refinery from the Hess Terminal in Baltimore, Md. 

  
 - 3 -









 1.1.24 “In-Transit Inventory” means the Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory and
the Finished Product In-Transit. 
 1.1.25 “In-Tankage Inventory” means the Crude Oil In-Tankage and the
Finished Product In-Tankage. 
 1.1.26 “Inventory Committee” has the meaning set forth in Section 3.1.1 of
this Agreement. 
 1.1.27 “Inventory Schedule” has the meaning set forth in Section 3.1.1 of this
Agreement. 
 1.1.28 “Inventory Transfer Time” means 00:00:01 A.M., local time, on the Closing Date.

 1.1.29 “Jet Line” means the jet fuel pipeline which runs from the Refinery to the Philadelphia Airport which
is owned and operated by Buckeye Pipeline. 
 1.1.30 “NuStar Line” means the product line which runs from the
Refinery to the NuStar Terminal. 
 1.1.31 “NuStar Terminal” means the refined product distribution terminal
owned by NuStar and located adjacent to the Refinery at 7 North Delaware Street, Paulsboro, NJ. 
 1.1.32
“OPIS” means Oil Price Information Service. 
 1.1.33 “Parties” and “Party”
have the meanings set forth in the introductory paragraph immediately preceding the Introduction. 
 1.1.34 “Plains
Line” means the ethanol pipeline which runs from the Plains Terminal to the NuStar Terminal. 

1.1.35 “Plains Terminal” means the ethanol distribution terminal owned by Plains and located
adjacent to the Refinery at 3rd Street and Billingsport,
Paulsboro, NJ. 
 1.1.36 “Platt’s” means Platt’s Oilgram Price Report. 

1.1.37 “Permitted Liens” has the same meaning as that term is defined in the SPA. 

1.1.38 “Petroleum Inspection Company” has the meaning set forth in Section 3.1.1 of this Agreement. 

1.1.39 “Products” means all crude oil, feedstock, and products that are currently used and/or produced in the ordinary
course of the business conducted at the Refinery. 
 1.1.40 “Refinery” has the same meaning as that term is
defined in the SPA. 

  
 - 4 -









 1.1.41 “Refinery Butane” means all normal butane and isobutane that Seller
has title to which is, as of the Inventory Transfer Time, stored in railcars located within the boundaries of the Refinery or in-transit for storage at the Refinery. 
 1.1.42 “Refinery OSBL Line Fill” means the Products that Seller has title to which are, as of the Inventory Transfer Time, located in any pipeline or lateral located within the boundaries
of the Refinery, but outside the battery limits of the refining or processing units within the Refinery, as further identified by product and volume on Exhibit C attached hereto. The definition of Refinery OSBL (outside battery limits) Line
Fill expressly excludes any In-Transit Inventory and In-Tankage Inventory. 
 1.1.43 “Refinery Tankage” means
and includes all tankage (and in the case of certain specialty products, all staging areas, sulfur pits or other storage facilities) which is used for the storage of Products and is located within the boundaries of the Refinery; including any
segment of any pipe or conveyor used to move such Products into and out of such tankage or facilities which is attached to, and is situated only in the immediate vicinity of, such tankage or facilities. 

1.1.44 “Retained Feedstock and Products” means all of the following types of Products: (i) those volumes of refined
Products that Seller either has title to or has sold to any third party on or before the Inventory Transfer Time and which have already been either loaded or removed from and delivered out of the Refinery Tankage and the Refinery as of the Inventory
Transfer Time, but in all cases excluding any Finished Product In-Transit or refined Products located within the Third-Party Tankage or Storage; (ii) those volumes of asphalt Products in transit to or located at the Asphalt Terminals as of the
Inventory Transfer Time; and (iii) the Refinery Butane, as of the Inventory Transfer Time. 
 1.1.45
“Seller” has the meaning set forth in the introductory paragraph immediately preceding the Introduction. 

1.1.46 “SPA” has the meaning set forth in the Introduction. 

1.1.47 “Tank Heels” means the greater of: a) volume of Product below the lowest suction in a tank, unless the tank is
equipped with a regular side entry pipe in which case “Tank Heels” means the volume below the middle of the lowest suction in such tank, or b) the volume required to safely float a roof in a floating roof tank. 

1.1.48 “Third-Party Tankage or Storage” means each of the third-party owned and/or operated storage tanks, underground
storage caverns or in the case of petcoke, dry bulk storage facilities described on Exhibit B. The term “Third-Party Tankage or Storage” includes any segment of any pipe or in the case of Petcoke any gondolas, chutes or conveyors
used to move such Products into and out of such tankage or storage which is attached to, and is situated only in the immediate vicinity of, such tankage or storage. 
 1.1.49 “Unit Fill” means all volumes of Products that Seller has title to which is, as of the Inventory Transfer Time, located at or contained in any part or portion of any refining or
processing unit located within the boundaries of the Refinery, but excludes the Refinery OSBL Line Fill and any products contained in the Refinery Tankage. 

  
 - 5 -









 1.1.50 “Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit” means those volumes of crude oil and
feedstock on vessels that Seller has purchased or contracted to purchase but which have not been paid for by Seller as of the Inventory Transfer Time and are scheduled for delivery to the Refinery, the Refinery Tankage, or the Third-Party Tankage or
Storage, but which have not, as yet, been delivered to the Refinery, any Refinery Tankage, or any Third-Party Tankage or Storage as of the Inventory Transfer Time, and which are designated as “Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit” on Exhibit
F. 
 All capitalized terms used, but that are not otherwise defined, in the body of this Agreement shall have the meanings
ascribed to such terms in the SPA. 
 SECTION 2: ASSIGNMENT AND CONVEYANCE 

2.1 Assignment and Conveyance. Seller hereby SELLS, ASSIGNS, TRANSFERS, and DELIVERS unto Buyer (or its designated
assignee), its successors and assigns forever, all of Seller’s right, title, and interest in and to all of the Feedstock and Products Inventory and Unit Fill TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, all of Seller’s right, title, and interest in and to the
Feedstock and Products Inventory and Unit Fill, together with all and singular the rights and appurtenances thereto in anywise belonging, unto Buyer (or its designated assignee) and Buyer’s (or its designated assignee’s) successors and
assigns forever. Seller, for itself, its successors and assigns, covenants and agrees to warrant and forever defend good title to the Feedstock and Products Inventory, free and clear of all liens, against the claims of all parties claiming the same
by, through, or under Seller, but not otherwise. 
 2.2 Warranties and Representations of Seller; Disclaimer of
Warranties. EXCEPT FOR THE FOREGOING LIMITED SPECIAL WARRANTY OF TITLE, THIS CONVEYANCE IS MADE AND ACCEPTED WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION WHATSOEVER, EXPRESS, IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR OTHERWISE, REGARDING THE FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCTS
INVENTORY AND UNIT FILL INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTY AS TO THE CONDITION OR MERCHANTABILITY OF SUCH COMMODITY OR FITNESS OF ANY SUCH COMMODITY FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ALL OF WHICH ARE HEREBY DISCLAIMED. BUYER SHALL ACCEPT ALL OF THE
FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCTS INVENTORY AND UNIT FILL IN ITS “AS IS, WHERE IS” CONDITION AND “WITH ALL FAULTS. 

SECTION 3: TIMELINE 
 3.1 Timeline. The Parties anticipate that the following events will occur in the manner and sequence set forth as follows: 

3.1.1 Inventory Committee. An inventory committee (the “Inventory Committee”) consisting of a representative of
each of Buyer and Seller and a mutually agreeable independent petroleum inspection company (the “Petroleum Inspection Company”) shall be established to prepare and conduct the physical inventory measurement pursuant to the
procedures set forth in Exhibit A. As of the Effective Date of this Agreement, Buyer and Seller shall each designate their respective Inventory Committee representatives, and the 

  
 - 6 -









 
representatives shall agree upon and appoint the Petroleum Inspection Company. Promptly upon appointment of the Petroleum Inspection Company, Seller shall provide Buyer and the Petroleum
Inspection Company with all information relating to the Feedstock and Products Inventory, including tank and product types, which is necessary to design and carry out an effective physical inventory in the manner set forth in Exhibit A. The
Inventory Committee shall use this information to develop a mutually agreed upon gauging and sampling schedule by location and tank (the “Inventory Schedule”). The Inventory Schedule shall be approved by the Inventory Committee no
later than five (5) Business Days prior to Closing. The physical inventory measurement shall then be conducted in accordance with the Inventory Schedule and the provisions of Exhibit A. 

3.1.2 Delivery of Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. No later than three (3) Business Days prior to the
Closing, Seller shall deliver to Buyer the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. 
 3.1.3 Payment of
Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. At the Closing, in consideration of Seller’s assignment and conveyance of the Feedstock and Products Inventory, Buyer shall pay to Seller, by wire transfer or delivery of other
immediately available funds, the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. 
 3.1.4 Inventory Report.
Within ten (10) Business Days after the Closing Date, the Petroleum Inspection Company shall provide the Parties with a physical inventory report setting forth the quantity (which shall be temperature, API gravity, bottom sediment &
water (BS&W), and pressure corrected) and qualitative laboratory results of the Feedstock and Products Inventory (excluding In-Transit Inventory, Refinery OSBL Line Fill, and Retained Feedstock and Products). 

During a fifteen (15) day review period following receipt by both Parties of the physical inventory report, either Party may
question the calculations and/or laboratory results set forth therein and the members of the Inventory Committee shall resolve any outstanding quantity and quality disputes. At the end of such review period and following resolution of all quantity
and quality disputes, the quantity and quality entries set forth in the adjusted physical inventory report, for each of the Feedstock and Products Inventory, will become the official quantity and quality measurements of the Feedstock and Products
Inventory as of the Inventory Transfer Time and the physical inventory report, as may be revised pursuant to the foregoing, will become the “Final Inventory Report”. 

3.1.5 Feedstock and Products Sales Statement. On or before ninety (90) days after the Closing Date, Seller shall calculate
the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount by using (i) the quantity and quality measurements set forth in the Final Inventory Report prepared in accordance with Section 3.1.4 and Exhibit A, and
(ii) with respect to any Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory, bills of lading, shore meters or other appropriate statements evidencing the volume thereof. The various quantities set forth therein shall be multiplied by the relevant price formulas
set forth in Part II of Exhibit A, and Seller shall deliver to Buyer a statement (the “Feedstock and Products Sales Statement”) setting forth the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, together
with supporting calculations and documentation used to determine the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount. Unless Buyer gives 

  
 - 7 -









 
notice to Seller on or before thirty (30) calendar days after Buyer’s receipt of the Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Statement that Buyer disputes the Final Feedstock and
Products Inventory Sales Amount specified in the Feedstock and Products Sales Statement, the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount shall be as specified in the Feedstock and Products Sales Price Statement. If Buyer gives timely notice
to Seller that it disputes the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Price (or the final quantity or price of In-Transit Inventory) specified in the Feedstock and Products Sales Price Statement, Seller and Buyer shall consult in good faith
and use all reasonable efforts to agree upon the calculation of the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Price. If Seller and Buyer have not agreed on the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Price within fifteen (15) calendar
days after Seller’s receipt of Buyer’s dispute notice, either Seller or Buyer shall have the right to submit such matters as remain in dispute to Grant Thornton or Baker O’Brien (depending on the issues in dispute) as Seller and Buyer
shall mutually agree, for final resolution, which resolution shall be binding upon Seller and Buyer, and judgment upon which may be entered in any court having jurisdiction over the Party against which such determination is sought to be enforced.
Such firm’s determination shall be in the form of a written opinion as is appropriate under the circumstances and shall confirm that it was rendered in accordance with this Section 3.1.5 and Exhibit A. The fees and expenses of such
firm for its services in resolving such dispute shall be borne equally by Seller and Buyer. 
 3.1.6
Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment. Upon final determination of the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount pursuant to Section 3.1.5, a true-up adjustment including interest at the Applicable Rate from the
Closing Date will be made in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1.6 (the “Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment”). If the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount is greater than the
Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount paid by Buyer at Closing, Buyer shall make an additional payment to Seller in an amount equal to the amount by which the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, as finally agreed
upon pursuant to Section 3.1.5, exceeds the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, which payment shall be made by wire transfer or delivery of other immediately available funds on or before the fifth (5th) Business Day after the final determination of the Feedstock
and Products Sales Amount Adjustment. If the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount is less than the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount paid by Buyer at Closing, Seller shall make a payment to Buyer in an amount
equal to the amount by which the Estimated Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount exceeds the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount, as finally agreed upon pursuant to Section 3.1.5, which payment shall be made by
wire transfer or delivery of other immediately available funds on or before the fifth (5th) Business Day after the final determination of the Feedstock and Products Sales Amount Adjustment. 
 3.1.7 Access to Records and Audit. From the Closing Date through sixty (60) days after the Buyer’s receipt of the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Price Statement, the Parties
shall afford each other access, at all reasonable times, to the relevant personnel, properties and books and records, and working papers for the purpose of auditing and verifying the accuracy of the physical inventory and feedstock and product
inventory sales prices. 

  
 - 8 -









 SECTION 4: CRUDE OIL IN-TRANSIT 

4.1 Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory. The Parties expressly agree the deliveries of Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory shall be included
as part of the Feedstock and Products Inventory. The Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory shall be deemed to include (i) crude oil cargo of any ship (whether or not loaded prior to the Closing Date) that has been identified and agreed by
representatives of Seller and Buyer prior to the Closing Date for delivery to the Refinery and the Refinery Tankage following the Closing Date which Seller or any Affiliate of Seller has paid for on or before the Closing Date, (ii) the Hess VGO
and (iii) subject to the requirements of the Agreement, the crude oil cargo of any ship to be processed at the Refinery (A) that Seller or any of its Affiliates purchases (or enters into a contract to purchase) and pays the seller of such
crude oil on or prior to the Closing Date for processing at the Refinery in the ordinary course of business of the Company, and (B) in respect of which prior to the Closing Date, Seller has provided the Buyer with written notice. For purposes
of clarification, it is agreed that the entire cargo of any ship that has started but not completed delivery of crude oil as of the Inventory Transfer Time shall be considered Crude Oil In-Tankage, provided that Seller or any Affiliate of Seller has
paid the seller of such crude oil prior to the Inventory Transfer Time. Each cargo of Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory purchased and paid for by Seller or any of its Affiliates on a delivered basis shall be considered as part of the Feedstock and
Products Inventory only to the extent of actual outturn volume, which results from the completed delivery of such Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory to the Refinery and the Refinery Tankage, respectively. The actual outturn volume for Crude Oil
In-Transit Inventory purchased on a delivered basis will be based on tank gauges at the appropriate facilities and the protocols and procedures applicable to the quantification and valuation of such Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory upon the conclusion
of the delivery of such In-Transit Inventory to the Refinery and the Refinery Tankage in the same manner in which is applicable to Crude Oil In-Tankage as of the Inventory Transfer Time. Each cargo of Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory purchased on a
FOB basis shall be considered as part of the Feedstock and Products Inventory only to the extent of volume reflected in the bill of lading for such Crude Oil In-Transit Inventory. 

4.2 Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit. The Parties expressly agree the deliveries of Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit shall not be included
as part of the Feedstock and Products Inventory as of the Inventory Transfer Time but will be sold and transferred to Buyer (or its designated assignee) on the terms and conditions set forth in this Section 4.2. The Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit
shall be limited to (i) crude oil and feedstock cargo of any ship (whether or not loaded prior to the Closing Date) that has been scheduled on Exhibit F attached hereto and will be delivered to the Refinery and the Refinery Tankage following
the Closing Date, and (ii) subject to the requirements of the Agreement, the crude oil and feedstock cargo of any ship to be processed at the Refinery (A) that Seller or any of its Affiliates purchases (or enters into a contract to
purchase) prior to the Closing Date for processing at the Refinery in the ordinary course of business of the Company, and (B) is more fully described on Exhibit F. Seller hereby agrees to sell and deliver to Buyer, and Buyer hereby agrees to
purchase and receive from Seller all such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit on the following terms and conditions: 
  

	 	(a)	 All Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit shall be purchased by Buyer (or its designated assignee as such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit is discharged at the
Refinery. Title to and risk of loss of the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit 



  
 - 9 -










	 	
sold hereunder shall pass from Seller to Buyer (or its designated assignee) as such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit passes the last permanent flange connection between the cargo intake manifold of
the delivering vessel and the delivering hose at the docks at the Refinery. The actual outturn volume for Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit purchased will be based on tank gauges at the appropriate facilities and the protocols and procedures applicable to
the quantification and valuation of such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit upon discharge of such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit at the Refinery and the Refinery Tankage in the same manner in which is applicable to Crude Oil In-Tankage.


  

	 	(b)	The price for the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit will be based on the same valuation formulae (for each type of in-transit crude oil which makes up the Unpaid Crude Oil
In-Transit) set forth in Exhibit A; provided however, (i) that if the actual freight protection costs are not available at the time of delivery, Seller shall invoice Buyer based on the estimated freight protection costs, with an
adjustment being made between Seller and Buyer when the actual freight protection costs are known; and (ii) the payment terms for such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit will be the earlier of 10 days after completion of discharge or 15 days after
Notice of Readiness (10/15 COD/NOR). All payments shall be made without offset, discount, deduction or counterclaim by wire transfer of immediately available funds to Seller at such account as Seller may designate in writing. Any amount payable by
Buyer hereunder shall, if not paid when due, bear interest from the payment due date until, but excluding the date payment is received by Seller, at the Applicable Rate. Buyer may direct a third party to make payment to Seller on Buyer’s
behalf, but Buyer shall remain responsible for making such payments to Seller. On delivery of Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit to Buyer (or its designated assignee), Seller shall SELL, ASSIGN, TRANSFER and DELIVER unto Buyer (or its designated assignee),
its successors and assigns forever, all of Seller’s right, title and interest in and to all of such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, all of Seller’s right, title and interest in and to such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit,
together with all and singular the rights and appurtances thereto in anywise belonging, unto Buyer (or its designated assignee) and Buyer’s (or its designated assignee’s) successors and assigns forever. Seller shall deliver to Buyer (or
its designated assignee) such bills of lading or any other documentation reasonably requested by Buyer (or its designated assignee) to evidence the foregoing. 


 

	 	(c)	 Seller represents and warrants to Buyer (or its designated assignee) that as of the date of delivery of the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit hereunder,
Seller shall have good title to the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit sold and delivered, free and clear of any liens or encumbrances, other than taxes that are due by Buyer (or its designated assignee). After delivery, Seller, for itself, its successors
and assigns, covenants and agrees to warrant and 



  
 - 10 -










	 	
forever defend good title to such Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit, free and clear of all liens (other than taxes that are due by Buyer), against the claims of all parties claiming the same by,
through or under Seller, but not otherwise. EXCEPT FOR THE FOREGOING WARRANTY OF TITLE, THIS CONVEYANCE IS MADE AND ACCEPTED WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION WHATSOEVER, EXPRESS, IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR OTHERWISE, REGARDING THE UNPAID CRUDE OIL
IN-TRANSIT INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTY AS TO THE CONDITION OR MERCHANTABILITY OF SUCH COMMODITY OR FITNESS OF ANY SUCH COMMODITY FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ALL OF WHICH ARE HEREBY DISCLAIMED. BUYER SHALL ACCEPT ALL OF THE UNPAID CRUDE
OIL IN-TRANSIT IN ITS “AS IS, WHERE IS” CONDITION AND “WITH ALL FAULTS. 

  

	 	(d)	All other terms and conditions for the sale and delivery of the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit, to the extent not inconsistent with the terms of this Agreement, shall be
governed by ChevronTexaco Global Trading General Provisions DES (Named Port of Destination) Sales, dated January 1, 2002 which are made a part of, and incorporated into this Section 4.2 of the Agreement. Marine movements of the Unpaid
Crude Oil In-Transit into the docks at the Refinery shall be in accordance with the Valero Marketing and Supply Company Marine Provisions Effective July 15, 2009. 


SECTION 5: BUTANE SUPPLY 
 5.1 Bath Butane. The Parties acknowledge that Seller has entered into a buy sell arrangement with Plains Marketing Canada, LP (“Plains”) whereby Seller has sold to Plains under
Sales Contract number 40249582 (the “Plains Sales Contract”) [REDACTED] barrels of Mixed Butane (approximately [REDACTED] barrels per month during the period April 1, 2010 through August 31, 2010) for storage at
Plain’s Bath NY Storage Facility (the “Bath Storage Facility”), and Seller is obligated to purchase from Plains under Purchasing Contract number 4200079667 (the “Plains Purchase Contract”) [REDACTED] barrels of
Mixed Butane (approximately [REDACTED] barrels per month during the period beginning October 1, 2010 through February 28, 2010 for use by the Refinery) from storage at the Bath Storage Facility. The Plains Sales Contract and the Plains
Purchase Contract will not be assigned to Buyer at Closing; however, Buyer hereby agrees to purchase from Seller and Seller hereby agrees to sell to Buyer the remaining volumes of Mixed Butane (the “Bath Butane”) to be sold under
the Plains Purchase Contract pursuant to the terms and conditions set forth on Exhibit D attached hereto. 
 5.2
Refinery Butane. From and after the Closing Date, Seller shall store at the Refinery and sell to Buyer the Refinery Butane under the terms and conditions set forth in Exhibit E attached hereto. 

SECTION 6: MISCELLANEOUS 

  
 - 11 -









 6.1 Assignment. The provisions of this entire Agreement shall be
binding upon the respective successors and permitted assigns of each of the Parties hereto. Neither Party may assign this Agreement to a third party without the prior written consent of the other Party, which consent may not be unreasonably
withheld, delayed, or conditioned; provided, however, that without the consent of the other Party, (a) either Party may assign its rights and obligations under this Agreement to its parent entity, subsidiary, or
Affiliates, and (b) Buyer may assign its rights and obligations under this Agreement, in whole or in part, to Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc. (“MSCG”) and Statoil Marketing and Trading (US) Inc. (“SMT”),
provided that MSCG and SMT assume such assigned obligations under this Agreement and Buyer shall remain liable for the performance of all of the terms, conditions and covenants of this Agreement. Buyer’s right, title and interest in the
Feedstock and Products Inventory and the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit shall be assigned to SMT and MSCG as shall be specified by Buyer in writing to Seller. 
 6.2 Notices. All notices and other communications that are required to be or may be given pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly given if
delivered in person or by courier or mailed by registered or certified mail (postage prepaid, return receipt requested) to the relevant Party hereto at the following addresses or sent by facsimile to the following numbers: 

If to Seller: 
  

			
	Valero Marketing and Supply Company
	One Valero Way
	Mail Station B2E-183
	San Antonio, Texas 78249-1616
	Attention:	 	Executive Vice President – Corporate Development
	Telephone:	 	(210) 345-2410
	Facsimile:	 	(210) 345-2270

 If to Buyer: 
  

			
	 PBF Holding Company LLC
 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887

	Attention:	 	Senior Vice President – General Counsel
	Telephone:	 	(973) 455-7500
	Facsimile:	 	(973) 455-7560

 or to such other address or facsimile number as Seller or Buyer may, from time to time, designate in a written notice
given in accordance with this Section 5.2. Any such notice or communication shall be effective (a) if delivered in person or by courier, upon actual receipt by the intended recipient, (b) if sent by facsimile transmission, upon
actual receipt if received during the recipient’s normal business hours, or at the beginning of the recipient’s next business day after receipt if not received during recipient’s normal business hours, or (c) if mailed, upon the
earlier often (10) days after deposit in the mail and the date of delivery as shown by the return receipt therefore. 

  
 - 12 -









 6.3 Choice of Law; Dispute Resolution. This Agreement shall be
construed, interpreted and the rights of the parties determined in accordance with the laws of the State of New York, exclusive of its conflict of laws principles. All controversies or disputes arising out of and related to this Agreement shall be
resolved in accordance with the dispute resolution procedures set forth in Exhibit D of the SPA. 
 6.4
Jurisdiction; Consent to Service of Process; Waiver. Each of the Parties hereto agrees, subject to Section 5.6, that it shall bring any action or proceeding in respect of any claim arising out of
or related to this Agreement, whether in tort or contract or at law or in equity, exclusively in any federal or state court in the State of New York and solely in connection with such claims, if any, (i) irrevocably submits to the exclusive
jurisdiction of such courts, (ii) waives any objection to laying venue in any such action or proceeding in such courts, (iii) waives any objection that such courts are an inconvenient forum or do not have jurisdiction over it and
(iv) agrees that service of process upon it may be effected by mailing a copy thereof by registered or certified mail (or any substantially similar form of mail), postage prepaid, to it at its address specified in Section 5.2 of the
Agreement. The foregoing consents to jurisdiction and service of process shall not constitute general consents to service of process in the State of New York for any purpose except as provided herein and shall not be deemed to confer rights on any
Person (as such term is defined in the SPA) other than the Parties hereto. Each of the Parties hereto knowingly and intentionally, irrevocably and unconditionally waives trial by jury in any legal action or proceeding relating to this Agreement and
for any counterclaim therein. 
 6.5 Availability of Equitable Relief. Each of the Parties hereto
recognizes that irreparable injury will result from a breach of any provision of this Agreement and that money damages will be inadequate to fully remedy the injury. In order to prevent such irreparable injury, the arbitrators selected pursuant to
Section 6.3 shall have the power to grant temporary or permanent injunctive or other equitable relief. Notwithstanding Section 6.3, prior to the appointment of the arbitrators, a party hereto may, subject to this
Section 6.5, seek temporary injunctive relief from any court of competent jurisdiction; provided that the party seeking such relief shall (if arbitration has not already been commenced) simultaneously commence arbitration in
compliance with the dispute resolution procedures. Such court ordered relief shall not continue more than 10 days after the appointment of the arbitrators (or in any event for longer than 60 days). 

6.6 Amendment. This Agreement may not be amended except by an instrument in writing executed and delivered by the
Parties hereto. 
 6.7 Severability. In the event any portion of this Agreement shall be found by a court
of competent jurisdiction to be unenforceable, that portion of this Agreement will be null and void and the remainder of this Agreement will be binding on the Parties as if the unenforceable provisions had never been contained herein. 

6.8 Waivers; Limitation of Liability. The delay or failure of any Party to enforce any of its rights under this
Agreement arising from any default or breach by the other Party shall not constitute a waiver of any such default, breach, or any of the Party’s rights relating thereto. No custom or practice which may arise between the Parties in the course of
operating under this Agreement will be construed to waive any Parties’ rights to either ensure the other Party’s strict 

  
 - 13 -









 
performance with the terms and conditions of this Agreement, or to exercise any rights granted to it as a result of any breach or default under this Agreement. Neither Party shall be deemed to
have waived any right conferred by this Agreement or under any applicable law unless such waiver is set forth in a written document signed by the Party to be bound, and delivered to the other Party. No express waiver by either Party of any breach or
default by the other Party shall be construed as a waiver of any future breaches or defaults by such other Party. 
 IN NO EVENT
SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER FOR ANY INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE, EXEMPLARY OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LOST PROFITS, ARISING UNDER THIS AGREEMENT OR THE TRANSACTIONS CONTEMPLATED HEREBY. 

6.9 Time of the Essence. Time is of the essence in this Agreement. If the date specified in this Agreement for
giving any notice or taking any action is not a Business Day (or if the period during which any notice is required to be given or any action taken expires on a date which is not a Business Day), then the date for giving such notice or taking such
action (and the expiration date of such period during which notice is required to be given or action taken) shall be the next day which is a Business Day. 
 6.10 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterparts and by the different Parties hereto in separate counterparts, each of which when executed shall be deemed to
be an original but all of which taken together shall constitute one and the same agreement. Signed counterparts of this Agreement may be delivered by facsimile and by scanned PDF image; provided that each Party hereto uses commercially reasonable
efforts to deliver to each other Party hereto original signed counterparts as soon as possible thereafter. 
 6.11 Further
Assurances. Both Seller and Buyer agree to execute and deliver, from time to time, such other and additional instruments, notices, transfer orders and other documents, and to do all such other and further acts and things as may be
necessary to more fully and effectively transfer and assign the Feedstock and Products Inventory to Buyer. 
 6.12 Third
Party Consents. The assignment and conveyance set forth in this Agreement shall not constitute an assignment or transfer of any of the Feedstock and Products Inventory if an attempted assignment thereof without the prior consent of a
third party would result in a termination thereof, unless and until such consent shall have been obtained, at which time such asset(s) shall be and is hereby deemed to be transferred and assigned to Buyer in accordance herewith. 

6.13 Entire Agreement. This Agreement, together with the Exhibits attached hereto and any portion of the SPA
containing a defined term incorporated herein by reference, all of which are hereby incorporated by reference, contains the entire agreement between the Parties and supersedes any prior agreement pertaining to the subject matter of this Agreement.

 6.14 Conflict of Terms. If the terms of this Agreement conflict with terms of the SPA with respect to
any matter, then the terms of the SPA will control. 

  
 - 14 -









 The Parties hereto have executed this Agreement on the date first above written, to be
effective as of the Closing Date. 
  

			
	VALERO MARKETING AND SUPPLY COMPANY
		
	 By:
	 	  

		 	S. Eugene Edwards, Executive Vice President
	
	PBF HOLDING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	  

	Title:	 	  



 [Signature Page to Feedstock and Product Inventory Sales Agreement] 

Signature Page 







 EXHIBIT A 
 FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCTS 
 MEASUREMENT PROCEDURES AND PRICING

 The Feedstock and Product Inventory Sales Agreement (the “Agreement”) to which this Exhibit A
(“Exhibit A”) relates and forms a part, provides that the Feedstock and Products Inventory will be measured and valued in accordance with this Exhibit A. 

Part I of this Exhibit A sets forth the procedures for conducting the physical inventory of the Feedstock and Products
Inventory (other than the In-Transit Inventory, which shall be estimated or otherwise calculated in accordance with the specific applicable provisions hereof but not subject to a physical inventory as of the Closing, and the Refinery OSBL Line Fill
which shall be based on the volumes set forth in Exhibit C) and located at and within the Refinery, the Refinery Tankage and the Third-Party Tankage or Storage as of the Inventory Transfer Time. 

Part II of this Exhibit A sets forth the valuation formulae and procedures for valuing the Feedstock and Products Inventory
(including the In-Transit Inventory, but excluding any Unit Fill) in order to determine the Estimated Feedstock and Products Sales Amount, Feedstock and Products Sales Statement, and the Final Feedstock and Products Inventory Sales Amount.

 All capitalized terms used in this Exhibit A that are not otherwise defined herein shall have the meanings ascribed to
such terms in the Agreement. 
 Part I. Physical Inventory Procedures 

 

	(A.)	INDEPENDENT INSPECTION: 

 All gauging, temperature measurment, sampling, testing and net volume calculations will be done by the Petroleum Inspection Company with the participation of Buyer’s and Seller’s Inventory
Committee representatives using a mutually agreed upon gauging and sampling schedule by tank (the “Inventory Schedule”). The Inventory Schedule will be mutually developed between the Buyer, Seller and Petroleum Inspection Company. All
three parties shall have the right to participate in the physical inventory measurement by observing the gauging, temperature readings, sampling, etc. In addition, Buyer and Seller shall each have the right to have its own independent accountants,
consultants, or agents present during the physical inventory, at such respective Parties’ sole cost and expense. Inspection/Testing costs for the Petroleum Inspection Company, including, travel, laboratory, and incidental costs (such as
bottles, bombs, seals, etc.), shall be shared on a 50/50 basis (i.e., 50% by the Seller and 50% by the Buyer) by the Parties. Any additional requests (outside of the inventory process) to the Petroleum Inspection Company will be billed to the
requesting party at 100%. 
  

	(B.)	QUANTIFICATION PROCEDURES: 

 In determining the quantities of the various Products to be inventoried, all volumes shall be determined on the basis of the Inventory Transfer Time and as of the completion of delivery to the Refinery,
the Refinery Tankage, and the Third-Party Tankage or Storage (with respect to any cargo or tender of In-Transit Inventory). Non-usable and non-merchantable quantities are 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 1 








 
materials such as water, sludge and other foreign contaminants commonly referred to as basic sediment and water (“BS&W”) and shall be excluded for purposes of determining the
quantities. BS&W will be determined by using Karl Fisher methodology or Water by Distillation summed with Sediment by Extraction or Membrane Filtration. 
  

	(C.)	INVENTORY MEASUREMENT PROTOCOL: 

 All gauging, sampling, and analysis related to the determination of quality and quantity of the Feedstock and Products Inventory shall be done in accordance with the latest API Manual of Petroleum
Measurement Standards as published by the American Petroleum Institute (the “API Manual”), ASTM test methods, or by currently accepted industry standards or procedures. The specific standards to be used shall be determined by the
Inventory Committee prior to the Closing. Tanks with floating roofs shall contain sufficient Product to fully “float” the roof when it is being gauged. Tanks equipped with steam coils or other means of heating product will have the heat
shut off at least one (1) hour prior to gauging. Tank mixers will be shut off at least two (2) hours prior to gauging. 
  

	(D.)	CERTIFICATION OF EQUIPMENT: 

 The Petroleum Inspection Company will standardize, calibrate and certify all gauging tapes and temperature devices used in the transfer of all Feedstock and Products Inventory. The Petroleum Inspection
Company will provide quality assurance documentation for its laboratory used for the physical inventory process. The Petroleum Inspection Company shall make all calibration and certification records available to any Party for review. All Parties may
witness the verification of the portable electronic thermometers prior to their use. All laboratory equipment used for testing of the inventory samples will also be calibrated/standardized in accordance with industry and manufacturers procedures.

 Prior to the Closing Date, the Inspector will inspect the Refinery’s laboratory testing equipment and procedures for the
quality tests scheduled to be done by that laboratory, to verify that they are adequate to comply with the ASTM Standards. Both parties may witness the verification, If the Inspector determines the equipment and procedures to be acceptable to
perform the required testing, without objection from either Buyer or Seller, the test results from the laboratory may be accepted without further observation of the testing. If the Refinery’s laboratory capacity is not sufficient or if the
equipment and procedures are determined to be inadequate to comply with the ASTM Standards, an independent laboratory’s costs shall be shared equally (50:50 basis) by the Buyer and Seller. 

 

	(E.)	ACCEPTANCE AND REVIEW; INVENTORY COMMITTEE: 

 The Parties shall be deemed to have accepted the accuracy of the gauging and temperature measurements of a tank as recorded by the Petroleum Inspection Company on the gauge ticket (to be mutually
developed) (the “Gauge Ticket”) if the Parties’ respective Inventory Committee representatives “sign-off” on the Gauge Ticket. Additional sampling will be taken by the Petroleum Inspection Company upon the request of
either Party at the sole expense of the requesting Party. All inventory measurements (such as gauges, temperature determinations, and 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 2 








 
water cuts) shall be resolved to the best of their abilities by Buyer, Seller and Inspector at the time measurements are taken. Any disputes will be resolved by noon the following working day.

  

	(F.)	QUALITATIVE PROCEDURES: 

 The determination of the quality of some Products must be performed utilizing special laboratory equipment. Samples of such Products shall be jointly taken as described in subsequent sections, and such
tests shall be conducted in a mutually acceptable laboratory. The results of the tests so run shall be binding on both Parties. 

All testing conducted in the Refinery laboratory is to be witnessed by a chemist employed by the Petroleum Inspection Company. Both Buyer
and Seller may have representatives witness all testing. 
 All issues related to measurement procedures such as sampling,
temperature readings, and gauging shall be resolved to the best of their abilities by the Parties’ representatives at the time the measurement is taken. Any remaining disputes shall be resolved by noon the following working day (or in the case
of quality disputes, promptly following receipt of test results) by a majority vote of the members of the Inventory Committee. 
  

	(G.)	PRE-CLOSING INVENTORY PROCEDURES: 

 Prior to the Inventory Transfer Time, Seller’s personnel shall determine which of the Refinery Tankage shall be active and inactive, and which tanks will contain inventory and which will be empty, as
of the Inventory Transfer Time. The Inventory Schedule will take into account the determination of active and inactive tankage and will provide for performing the physical inventory of both active and inactive tankage prior to the Inventory Transfer
Time. The Inventory Schedule will be subject to the approval of the Inventory Committee, and shall indicate the following for each tank to be inventoried: 
  

	 	•	 	 Storage tank location, tank number, tank type, size, capacity (shell and working); 



 

	 	•	 	 Status at closing (active or inactive); 


  

	 	•	 	 Product stored including classification as sweet, sour, type of crude, etc.; 



 

	 	•	 	 Tank reference gauge height; 


  

	 	•	 	 Method of Tank gauging (ullage or innage) based on the Tank calibration table; and 



 

	 	•	 	 Tank Heels (volume). 



Prior to closing, the Inspector will perform a pre-closing survey of the crude oil and heavy fuel (“Black Oil”) tanks at the Facility to
measure the actual gauge height, to compare the actual manual gauge to the automatic gauge, and to determine the amounts of solids and sludge accumulated on the bottoms of the tanks. The results of the survey will be made available to all parties
prior to Closing. Upon joint agreement by both Parties, this pre-closing survey may be waived for specific products, tanks or Facilities. 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 3 









	(H.)	PHYSICAL INVENTORY PROCEDURES: 

  

	 	(i)	General: 


Tanks with floating roofs shall not be in the critical zone of the floating roof when it is being gauged. Tanks equipped
with steam coils or other means of heating product will have the heat shut off at least one (1) hour prior to gauging. Tank mixers shall be shut off at least two (2) hours prior to gauging. Temperature measurements will be obtained at the
time of gauging, except as otherwise provided herein. 
 To the extent applicable, the Parties will cooperate in
order to develop mutually acceptable procedures to address measurement of Product that is in the midst of delivery to the Refinery or the Refinery Tankage as of the Inventory Transfer Time. 

 

	 	(ii)	Nonmoving Tanks (Inactive Tanks): 

 All Refinery Tankage that is standing with no movement in or out as of the Inventory Transfer Time will be gauged and sampled prior to the Inventory Transfer Time in accordance with the Inventory
Schedule. All valves in and out of the tank will be closed and sealed at the time of gauging. The Petroleum Inspection Company will seal the tank valves and will be responsible for recording seal numbers and checking of seals. The Petroleum
Inspection Company will provide a measurement and seal report identifying all valves and seals by tank and manifold valve. If it is necessary to break seals to transfer Product into or out of a sealed gauged tank, prior notification and confirmation
must be obtained from the Inventory Committee in order to keep accurate records of the proceedings. 
 Once
physical inventory operations have started, no tank switching, changes or movements shall be made without written notification to Buyer, Seller, and the Petroleum Inspection Company’s representatives. If tankage seals are broken, tankage must
be resealed when movement stops. Said tankage must then be regauged, resampled and temperature determined anew. Otherwise, it will be gauged as an active tank. 
 Inactive tanks that are required for thermal relief of connecting pipelines will be gauged using the inactive tanks’ automatic gauge readings. Each automatic gauge will be calibrated as close to the
Inventory Transfer Time as possible. The automatic gauge reading will be monitored every 10 minutes for 90 minutes before and after the Inventory Transfer Time to confirm that there was no movement into or out of said inactive tank. In cases where
the automatic gauge readings indicate tank movement, the tank will be gauged as an active tank. 
  

	 	(iii)	Moving Tanks (Active Tanks): 

 Active Refinery Tankage that must have movements in or out during the physical inventory quantification process as of the Inventory Transfer Time will be manually gauged during a period in which the
active tanks are temporarily inactive, as close to the Inventory Transfer Time as possible. The physical inventory of the active Refinery 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 4 








 
Tankage will be obtained using the applicable procedures prescribed herein and must coincide with the “closing” of rack meters where appropriate. 

Refinery Tankage that will remain active during the inventory period will be measured as close to the Inventory Transfer
Time as possible. The gross inventory measurement will be compared against the tanks’ automatic gauges. The volume difference between the two measurements, in gross inches or fractions thereof, will be recorded on the tanks’ physical
inventory worksheet. The Petroleum Inspection Company report will identify each tank by number, location and description. 
  

	 	(iv)	Loaded Tank Trucks and Rail Cars: 

 All outbound loaded trucks and rail cars which have been ticketed for sale at the Inventory Transfer Time, other than such trucks and rail cars constituting Finished Product In-Transit, will be considered
as a Seller account receivable unless previously paid and will not be part of the Feedstock and Products Inventory. Except for the Retained Feedstock and Products, all loaded trucks and railcars which have not been ticketed for sale will be part of
the Feedstock and Products Inventory. 
  

	 	(v)	Sulfur: 


Sulfur, if any will be sold pursuant to this Agreement, will be measured in accordance production records maintained by
the Seller, or through other means agreeable by the Inventory Committee and Petroleum Inspection Company. 
  

	 	(vi)	Finished Product In-Transit: 

 Finished Product In-Transit will be measured in accordance with inventory records maintained by Seller, as confirmed by the Inventory Committee. 

 

	 	(vii)	Unit Fill: 


Unit Fill will not be measured. 
  

	 	(viii) 	Sampling, Testing, and Retention of the Inventory Samples: 

 1. Intermediates and Heavy Oil Products: A minimum of two sample sets consisting of one quart zone samples from the upper, middle, and lower liquid zones (as those terms are defined or used in the
API Manual) will be obtained per tank per API Manual or ASTM D4057 (Standard Practice for Sampling of Petroleum and Petroleum Products). In the chosen laboratory, a one quart volumetric blend will be prepared for the inventory quality analyses. The
number of sample sets and volume of laboratory blend shall be adjusted based on the defined inventory quality analyses. 
 2.
Light Oil Products: A minimum of two sample sets consisting of one quart average sample will be obtained per tank per the API Manual or ASTM D4057 (Standard Practice for Sampling of Petroleum and Petroleum Products).


  
 Exhibit A,
Page 5 








 
At the Inventory Committee’s discretion and approval the amount/volume of sample obtained will be increased dependent on required laboratory analyses. 

3. Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) Samples: All inventory LPGs will have two sample sets consisting of a liquid phase sample and a
vapor phase sample obtained per the API Manual, ASTM D1265 (Practice for Sampling Liquefied Petroleum (LP) Gases (Manual Method) or ASTM D3700 (Standard Practice for Obtaining LPG Samples Using a Floating Piston Cylinder). One set of the sealed
samples will be retained a minimum of two (2) weeks by the Petroleum Inspection Company. 
 4. Petroleum Coke and
Sulfur: Petroleum coke and sulfur, if any, will be sampled in accordance with ASTM D346 (Collection and Preparation of Coke Samples for Laboratory Analysis), ASTM D2234 (Collection of Gross Sample of Coal) or other mutually agreed procedure.

 5. Lubes: A minimum of two sample sets consisting of one quart average sample will be obtained per tank per the API
Manual or ASTM D4057 (Standard Practice for Sampling of Petroleum and Petroleum Products). At the Inventory Committee’s discretion and approval the amount/volume of sample obtained will be increased dependent on required laboratory analyses.

 6. Asphalt: Asphalt will be sampled in accordance with ASTM D 140 (Standard Practice of Sampling Bituminous Materials).

 7. Additive Tanks: If Product additive tanks contain diluents blended with the additives, then prior to the Closing
Date the Facilities’ personnel will provide the Parties the blending/dilution ratios for additives in the tanks. 
 8.
Retention: Of the sample sets obtained during the physical inventory process, one half (1/2) of each set will be sealed and retained by the Petroleum Inspection Company. The unused portion(s) of the analyzed sample sets will also be
sealed and retained. These sealed samples will be maintained by the Petroleum Inspection Company for a minimum period of ninety (90) days or a mutually agreed retention time, LPG samples will be retained as specified in 3. above. At the time of
disposal, the Petroleum Inspection Company will properly dispose of samples and appropriate “cradle to grave” documentation forwarded to Seller and Buyer. All retained samples shall be made available to either Buyer or Seller after a three
day notice is given and approved by the other party. 
  

	 	(ix)	Measurement: 

 All measurements taken during the physical inventory process will be performed by the Petroleum Inspection Company. The following will be measured, recorded/obtained and documented by the Petroleum
Inspection Company on the individual Gauge Ticket: (1) tank location, identification, and type, (2) date and time of measurements, (3) product type within tank, (4) manual gauge recorded in appropriate units and fractional units,
(5) measurement method, that is, innage or ullage, (6) 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 6 








 
temperature readings, (7) free water measurement recorded in appropriate units, (8) Tank Heels, (9) the tanks automatic reading, and (10) tank pressure as applicable to
pressurized tanks or vessels. 
 Duplicate calculations will be made in determining the net inventory contained
in each tank at 60 degrees F or the appropriate temperature base for each Product in inventory and in each tank. Seller will make a set of calculations based on “normal” inventory calculation methods at the respective Facilities. The
second set of measurements will be made independently by the Inspector. The Inspector’s final calculation after review by Buyer and Seller will determine the net inventory. 

 

	(I.)	METER READINGS – LOADING RACKS AND PIPELINES: 

  

	 	(i)	Inactive Systems: 

 Meter readings shall be obtained on all inactive metered systems (tank truck rack, rail car rack and pipeline) in advance of the Inventory Transfer Time. The Petroleum Inspection Company will secure these
systems by sealing the same and inserting meter tickets in these meters to ensure that no Product is moved through these systems during the physical inventory process and the Petroleum Inspection Company report will clearly identify the date and
time. 
 The last tickets used to record Product sales, incoming receipts, Product shipments, and other Product
movements will be legibly photocopied and retained by Buyer, Seller, and the Petroleum Inspection Company. 
  

	 	(ii)	Active Systems: 

 Meter readings shall be obtained on all active metered systems coincident with the physical inventory measurements obtained on the storage tank(s) by supplying said metered systems. New meter tickets
shall be inserted at this time. Where practical and non-interfering with normal refinery operations, active tanks shall be shut down immediately prior to and during the physical inventory. 

The last tickets used to record Product sales or other Product transactions through the meters will be photocopied and
retained by Buyer, Seller, and the Petroleum Inspection Company. 
  

	(J.)	POST-INVENTORY PROCEDURES: 

 (i) Both of the Parties’ representatives shall sign the Gauge Ticket or gauge worksheet for each tank inventoried, which shall include the calculation of gross observed volume and Net Standard
Volume. The Buyer’s and Seller’s signature on the Gauge Ticket or gauge worksheet shall indicate agreement with all physical measurements recorded on the ticket or sheet. 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 7 








 (ii) Similarly, the Parties’ representatives shall identify and acknowledge all closing
meter readings, as well as the last rack sale, Product shipment, and Product receipt prior to the physical inventory. 
 (iii) An
inspection shall be made to assure that all systems previously closed and sealed remained inactive during the physical inventory and that no Product movements occurred through these systems. At this time all seals will be removed by the Petroleum
Inspection Company. 
  

	(K.)	CALCULATION OF FINAL INVENTORY QUANTITY: 

 The Petroleum Inspection Company will tabulate the data from the signed individual tank Gauge Tickets and using current tank calibration tables will determine the total observed volume for each tank
(“Total Observed Volume”). Correcting for Free Water, applying roof corrections, applying tank shell corrections, and using the most current CTL and CPL correction factors, the Total Observed Volumes will be corrected to Gross
Standard Volumes and then to Net Standard Volumes. Volumes within LPG inventory tanks will be corrected for vapor. The Petroleum Inspection Company will produce a final report reporting its conclusions of its calculation of the Inventory Quantity
and Quality. The final report is due by the Petroleum Inspection Company to the parties no later than ten (10) business days after Closing. After review and signature of all parties, the Petroleum Inspection Company’s final calculation
will be the Final Inventory Quantity. Volumes within Residual Tanks will be corrected to Net Standard Volume only for the BS&W exceeding 1.0% by volume. For purposes of this Exhibit D, the term (i) “Gross Standard Volume”
means the volume at 60 degrees Fahrenheit and one atmosphere of pressure (14.696 PSIA), including suspended sediment and water, as calculated by the most recent standards under the API Manual, (ii) “Net Standard Volume” means
the volume at 60 degrees Fahrenheit and one atmosphere of pressure (14.696 PSIA) after deducting BS&W from the Gross Standard Volume, (iii) “CTL” means the Correction for the effect of Temperature on Liquid, and
(iv) “CPL” means the Correction for the effect of Pressure on Liquid. 

  
 Exhibit A,
Page 8 








  
 FEEDSTOCK AND PRODUCTS SALES PRICE 

MEASUREMENT PROCEDURES AND PRICING 
 Part II. Inventory Valuation 
 Unless otherwise noted, all inventories will price using the
agreed upon prices effective for [REDACTED] day pricing event [REDACTED] Closing using [REDACTED] unique pricing days for each respective formula,. 
 All volumes of Product making up the Feedstock and Products Inventory that do not meet the relevant quality specifications shall be subject to downward price adjustments in an amount to be determined by
the Parties as specified in each “fallback” formula for each price group. 
 All Tank Heels shall price at the price for the component
in each tank less $[REDACTED]/Bbl. 
  

					
	 PBF Product Name
	  	 Valero Product Name
	  	 Pricing Methodology

	 Crude Oil
	  		  	
	TERRA NOVA	  	TERRA NOVA	  	In Tank: Price to be based on the average daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for Terra Nova as published by [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the
Closing date. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] price, the average [REDACTED] differential, Valero’s actual,
[REDACTED], actual [REDACTED], and [REDACTED] costs,
			
		  		  	In Transit: Price to be based on the average of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for Terra Nova as published by [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation
days [REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for Terra Nova, the [REDACTED] price, Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual, [REDACTED], and [REDACTED]
costs.
			
	VASCONIA	  	VASCONIA	  	In Tank: Price to be the differential between Vasconia and the [REDACTED] futures contract for the [REDACTED] completed by Valero for Vasconia crude. Price will be the average of
the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement price, Valero’s [REDACTED] for [REDACTED], Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual,
[REDACTED] and [REDACTED] costs.
			
		  		  	In Transit: Price to be the differential between Vasconia and








  

					
		  		  	the [REDACTED] futures contract for the [REDACTED] completed by Valero for Vasconia crude. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days
[REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] differential, the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement price, Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual [REDACTED], and [REDACTED] costs.
			
	URALS	  	URALS	  	In Tank Basis: Price to be based on the average daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] as published by [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the
Closing date. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] price, the average [REDACTED] differential, a spot market
[REDACTED] (provided by three (3) independent Ship Brokers see Note 1), and [REDACTED] costs. Freight assessment to be done on assumption of [REDACTED]/mbbls on an Aframax vessel. [REDACTED] costs for [REDACTED]mbbls at $[REDACTED]/bbl. [REDACTED]
times Aframax market demurrage assessment as deemed by independent Ship Brokers. Freight assessment to be calculated for [REDACTED]MT basis [REDACTED] assessment from broker panel consisting of McQullling, Galbraith, and Clarksons London for the
period [REDACTED] to Closing Date (consistent with pricing).
			
		  		  	In Transit FOB: Price to be based on the average of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Cargo
Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED], the [REDACTED] price, Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual [REDACTED], plus [REDACTED] costs.
			
		  		  	In Transit DBS or CFR: Price to be based on the average of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the
Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] the [REDACTED] price, a spot market [REDACTED] (provided by three (3) independent Ship Brokers see Note 1), and [REDACTED] costs. DES
cargoes will have no deemed losses. Freight assessment to be done on assumption of [REDACTED]mbbls on an Aframax vessel. [REDACTED] costs for [REDACTED]mbbls at $[REDACTED]/bbl. [REDACTED] times Aframax market demurrage assessment as deemed by
independent Ship Brokers. Freight









					
			
		  		  	assessment to be calculated for [REDACTED] MT basis [REDACTED] assessment from broker panel consisting of McQuilling, Galbraith, and Oarksons London for the period [REDACTED]
cargo discharge date.
			
	ARABIAN LT	  	ARABIAN LT	  	In Tank: Price will be the average of the [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED], the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED]
settlement, the [REDACTED] for the Port of loading applicable to the month of Closing, Valero’s last paid [REDACTED] actual [REDACTED] costs [REDACTED] plus [REDACTED] costs.
			
		  		  	In-Transit: Price to be based on the average of the [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of
the [REDACTED] settlement, the [REDACTED] for the Port of loading applicable to the month of Closing, Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual [REDACTED], plus [REDACTED] costs.
			
	KIRKUK	  	KIRKUK	  	 In Tank: Price will be the average of the [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive.
Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] settlement, the [REDACTED] applicable to the month of Closing, Valero’s last [REDACTED], actual [REDACTED] plus [REDACTED] costs and the applicable [REDACTED].

 
 In-Transit: Price to be based on the average of the [REDACTED] Index for the
[REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of [REDACTED] settlement, the [REDACTED] applicable to the month of Closing, Valero’s actual [REDACTED], actual [REDACTED], plus
[REDACTED] costs, and the applicable [REDACTED].

			
	HIBBRNIA	  	CRD-HIBERNIA	  	 In Tank: Price to be based on the average daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for Hibernia as published by [REDACTED] for
the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED], the average [REDACTED]
differential, Valero’s actual [REDACTED] for the last purchase of that grade, acutal [REDACTED], and [REDACTED] costs.
  
 In Transit: Price to be based on the average of the daily price










					
			
		  		  	differential relative to [REDACTED] for Hibernia as published by [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to
be the sum of the daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for Hibernla, the [REDACTED] price, Valero’s actual [REDACTED] actual [REDACTED], and [REDACTED] costs,
			
	ISTHMUS	  	ISTHMUS	  	in Tank: Price to be based on the average daily price differential for Isthmus relative to [REDACTED] as published by [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the
Closing date, which includes the applicable K factor. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] futures contract
settlement price, the average [REDACTED] differential for Isthmus, Valero’s actual [REDACTED] for the last purchase of that grade, actual [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] costs.
			
		  		  	In Transit: Price to be based on Valero’s paid price differential between Isthmus and the [REDACTED] futures contract at the time the cargo priced. Price will be the average of
the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Cargo Discharge date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the Isthmus differential, the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement price, Valero’s actual [REDACTED] actual
[REDACTED] and [REDACTED] costs.
			
	CPC BLEND	  	CPC BLEND	  	In Tank Delivered Basis: Price to be based on the average daily price differential relative to [REDACTED] for [REDACTED] for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date.
Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique quotation days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the [REDACTED] price, the average [REDACTED], a spot market [REDACTED] (to be provided by
three (3) independent Ship Brokers, see Note l), and [REDACTED] costs to include applicable [REDACTED] Freight assessment to be calculated using [REDACTED] vessels ([REDACTED] mbbls) from [REDACTED] with [REDACTED] for of [REDACTED] days.
Freight calculation basis [REDACTED] MT utilizing broker panel consisting of McQuilling.Galbraith, and Ciarksons London for the period [REDACTED] Closing Date (consistent with pricing)
			
	M-100	  	M-1OO	  	In Tank Delivered Basis: Price to be based on Valero’s [REDACTED] between Delivered US Gulf Coast M-100 and the [REDACTED]
futures









					
			
		  		  	contract. Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, Inclusive. Daily Price to be the sum of the M-100 differential,
the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement price, , plus [REDACTED] costs.
			
	Distillate	  		  	
			
	FINISHED HEATING OIL	  	HEATING OIL #2 FUEL	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED]cpg. If Sulfur is
[REDACTED] ppmw, a sulfur price de-escalator shall apply, as attached for “Heating Oil”. See Note 2.
			
	HEATING OIL	  	HEATING OIL #2 FUEL UNDYED	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED]cpg. If Sulfur is
[REDACTED] ppmw, a sulfur price de-escalator shall apply, as attached for “Heating Oil”. See Note 2.
			
	MARINE DIESEL	  	MARINE DIESEL	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED]cpg, plus or minus a
quality adjustment, as attached for “Marine Diesel”.
			
	FINISHED JET	  	MOBILJBTA	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED]cpg. See Note
2
			
	FINISHED LSD	  	LS DIESEL FUEL	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED]. See Note 2.
			
	Feedstocks	  		  	
			
	FCC FEED	  	FCC CHARGB INV(HVY)	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or minus a quality adjustment,
as attached for “FCC Feed”.
			
	CKUDBSLOP	  	TS 7 HY GAS O1L	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], as calculated
herein.
			
	COKBRFEBD/VTB	  	COKER CHARGB	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or minus
a









					
			
		  		  	quality adjustment, as attached for “Coker Feed/VTB”.
			
	PDA FEED/VTB	  	345 RESID	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or mlnus a quality adjustment,
as attached for “PDA Feed/VTB”
			
	SLOP	  	API WET SLOP	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], as calculated
herein.
			
	SLOP DRYING	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], as calculated
herein.
			
	TBX-PAWBTSLOP	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], as calculated
herein.
			
	RO API SLOP	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], as calculated
herein.
			
	FCC FEED (BALTIMORE)	  	FCC FEED (BALTMORE)	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED], plus or minus a quality adjustment,
as attached for “FCC Feed”.
			
	Gasoline	  		  	
			
	RBOB	  	RBOB10.0UNLV2	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] see Note 2.
			
	PBOB	  	RBOB10.0PREV2	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] see Note 2.
			
	CBOB	  	CBOB REG 7.8 RVP	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be[REDACTED] see Note 2.
			
	CBOB REG 12.9	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, Inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] see Note
2.









					
			
	CBOB_SUP	  	CBOB SOP 12.9	  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be
[REDACTED] less.
 See Note 2.

			
	CBO BSUP7. 8 RVP	  		  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be
[REDACTED] less.
 See Note 2.

			
	Intermediates	  		  	
			
	LT. STRAIGHT RUN	  	TR180 EP GASO	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] futures contract settlement price
less [REDACTED] cpg. If the octane [(R+M)/2] is greater than or equal to [REDACTED] , the discount shall be [REDACTED] cpg. See Note 3.
			
	RAW FCC NAPHTHA	  	FCC GASOLINE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus an octane and RVP adjustment as
attached for “RAW FCC NAPHTHA”.
			
	SOURNAPHTHA	  	NAPHTHA	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement
price less [Redacted] cpg. See Note 3.
			
	400 EP NAPHTHA	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement
price less [REDACTED] cpg. See Note 3.
			
	SWEET NAPHTHA	  	PRETREAT	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement
price less [REDACTED]cpg. See Note 3.
			
	ALKYLATE	  	ALKYLATE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus an octane and RVP adjustment as
attached for “ALKYLATE OR REFORM ATE”,
			
	RBFORMATE	  	REFORMATS	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] an octane and RVP adjustment as
attached for “ALKYLATE ORREFORMATE”.
			
	CHD1 FEED	  	CHDLGO	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED] cpg quality
adjustment less [REDACTED] cpg location basis.









					
			
	SOUR ST RUN KBRO	  	500EPKEROSINE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less [REDACTED] cpg quality
adjustment less [REDACTED] cpg location basis.
			
	LPGS	  		  	
			
	PROPANE	  	C3C0MM PROPANE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily price to be [REDACTED] plus
$[REDACTED]/Bbl.
			
	PPMIX	  	PP-MIX PROPANE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for (the [REDACTED] unique days
			
	PROPYLBNE	  		  	[REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be: [REDACTED] minus [REDACTED] Bbl plus [REDACTED], where A= [REDACTED] B= [REDACTED]
			
	OFFSPBC PROPANE	  	OFF SPEC PROPANE	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus [REDACTED] or minus a BTU based
quality adjustment.
			
	ISOBUTANE	  	IC4 ISO BUTANB PURCH	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus
$[REDACTED]/Bbl.
			
	NORMAL BUTANE	  	C4MIX	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus
$[REDACTED]/Bbl.
			
	BB MIX/ALKY FEED	  	FCC BB STOCK	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] multiplied by
[REDACTED]
			
	Lube Plant	  		  	
			
	LUBE DISTILLATE	  	339, DIST	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or minus quality adjustment, as
attached for “Lube Distillate”.
			
	6154 DIST	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or minus quality adjustment, as
attached for “Lube Distillate”.
			
	318 DIST	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price
			
		  		  	









					
			
		  		  	to be [REDACTED] plus or minus quality adjustment, as attached for “Lube Distillate”.
			
	6336 DIST	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] plus or minus quality adjustment, as
attached for “Lube Distillate
			
	LUBE MISC.	  	6287 LHDT CHG	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the price for [REDACTED] as calculated
herein.
			
	6051 LHDT CHARGE	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the price for [REDACTED] as calculated
herein.
			
	LUBE EXTRACT	  	LUBE EXTRACT 130VIS	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	LUBE EXTRACT 100VIS	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	LUBE EXTRACT 45VIS	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	345 FURF EXT	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	LUBE EXTRACT	  	318 FURF EXT	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	339 FURF EXT	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Pricefor the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average of: [REDACTED]
			
	LUBE BASE OIL	  	6154 STOCK	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, Inclusive. Daily
Price









					
			
		  		  	
			
		  		  	contract settlement price plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.
			
	6336 STOCK	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the [REDACTED] futures contract settlement
price plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.
			
	339 STOCK	  		  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily
Price
 contract settlement price plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.

			
	VP850 Stock	  		  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily
Price
 contract settlement price plus [REDACTED] $/bbl.

			
	318 STOCK	  		  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily
Price
 contract settlement price plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.

			
	345 STOCK	  		  	 Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily
Price
 contract settlement price plus [REDACTED] $/bbl.

			
	LUBERAFFINATE	  	850 Furf Raff	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive, Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality) plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.
			
	6336 RAFF	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality) plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.
			
	LUBERAFFINATE	  	6154 FURF RAFF	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the dosing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality) plus [REDACTED]$/bbl.
			
	339 FURP RAFF	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality) [REDACTED]$bbl.
			
	318 FURF RAFF	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality)









					
			
		  		  	plus [REDACTED]
			
	345 RAFF	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the volumetric weighted average of the
individual [REDACTED] prices (as calculated herein and adjusted for quality) plus [REDACTED] $/bbl.
			
	Residual	  		  	
			
	FCCSLURRY/DECANT CLAR SLURRY OIL	  		  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be [REDACTED] less
$[REDACTED]/BBL.
			
	ASPHALT	  	ASPHALT CMNTPG64-22	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily price to be one hundred percent (100%) of the mean of the
[REDACTED] , Density factor for converting prices from short tons to barrels to be [REDACTED] Bbl/short ton.
			
	DAO	  	PD 345 RAFF	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing date, inclusive. Daily Price to be the average [REDACTED], as calculated herein,
less $[REDACTED]/bbl.








 Other 
  

			
	 Ethanol
	  	Price will be the average of the Daily Price for the [REDACTED] unique days [REDACTED] the Closing Date, Inclusive, Daily Price to be [REDACTED]
		
	 Sulfur
	  	[REDACTED], minus $[REDACTED/bbl for freight.
		
	 Petcoke at Refinery
	  	[REDACTED] minus $[REDACTED] per Wet Metric Ton using the [REDACTED] Pace Index.
		
	 Petcoke Port Contractors (Port of Wilmington)
	  	[REDACTED] using the [REDACTED] Pace Index. Valero to retain ownership of any inventory of Petcoke located in the barn at the Port Contractors - Facility B1 - 310 Pigeon Point
Road, New Castle, Delaware.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 10 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS 
  

			
	HEATING OIL	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Sulfur above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] cents per gallon, pro rata.
		
		  	Example; If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be;
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
	MARINE DIESEL	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Sulfur above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] cents per gallon, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	2) If API gravity at [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit is less than [REDACTED], the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] degree API gravity below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per gallon, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the API gravity is [REDACTED], the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for API gravity at or greater than [REDACTED].
		
		  	3) If Cetane Index is less than [REDACTED], the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] Cetane Index below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per gallon, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Cetane Index is [REDACTED], the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Cetane Index at or greater than [REDACTED].


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 11 








 QUALITY ADJUSTER (2) 
  

			
	FCC FEED	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	Sulfur Adjustment = [REDACTED]
		
		  	Example: If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] wt.% the adjustment shall be: (using prices from 09/14/2010):
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.
		
		  	2) If API gravity at [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit is less than [REDACTED], the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] degree API gravity below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the API gravity is [REDACTED], the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for API gravity at or greater than [REDACTED].
		
		  	3) If Nitrogen is is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Nitrogen above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Nitrogen is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Nitrogen at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	4) If Analine Point is less than [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] degree Fahrenheit below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Analine Point is [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Analine Point at or greater than [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit.
		
		  	5) If Vanadium is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Vanadium above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro
rata.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 12 








  

			
		  	Example: If the Vanadium is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Vanadium at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 13 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (3) 
  

			
	FCC FEED (cont)	  	6) If Nickel is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Nickel above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by $[REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Nickel is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Nickel at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	7) If Sodium is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Sodium above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Sodium is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sodium at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	8) If Conradson’s Carbon (CCR) is greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] wt% Conradson’s Carbon between [REDACTED] wt.% and [REDACTED] wt.%, the price shall be reduced by $[REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Conradson’s Carbon is [REDACTED] wt.%, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	For every [REDACTED] wt.% Conradson’s Carbon greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the price shall be reduced by $[REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Conradson’s Carbon is [REDACTED] wt.%, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Conradson’s Carbon at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 14 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (4) 
  

			
	COKER FEED/VTB	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED]wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	Sulfur Adjustment = [REDACTED]
		
		  	Example: If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] wt.% the adjustment shall be: (using prices from 09/14/2010):
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 15 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (5) 
  

			
	PDA FEED/VTB	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	Sulfur Adjustment = [REDACTED]
		
		  	Example: If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] wt.% the adjustment shall be: (using prices from 09/14/2010):
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 16 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (6) 
 RAW FCC NAPHTHA 
 1) OCTANE ADJUSTMENT, RELATIVE TO ARGUS NYH CBOB 83.5 BARGE MEAN: 

A = [REDACTED] 
 B = [REDACTED] 

OCTANE ADJUSTMENT = A * B 
  

			
	EXAMPLE:	  	
		  	 [REDACTED] = [REDACTED] CPG

		  	 [REDACTED] = [REDACTED] CPG

		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED]

  

			
		  	A = [REDACTED] = [REDACTED]
		
		  	B = [REDACTED]

 OCTANE ADJUSTMENT = A * B = [REDACTED] 
 2) RVP ADJUSTMENT, RELATIVE TO ARGUS NYH CBOB 83.5 BARGE MEAN: 
 A = [REDACTED] 

B = [REDACTED] 
 RVP ADJUSTMENT = A * B

  

			
	EXAMPLE:	  	 [REDACTED] = [REDACTED] 

[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] 
 [REDACTED] = [REDACTED]

 [REDACTED] = [REDACTED] 


  

	
	A = [REDACTED]
	 B = [REDACTED]



  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 17 








 RVP ADJUSTMENT = A * B = [REDACTED] 

  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 18 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (7) 
 ALKYLATE OR REFORMATE 
 1) OCTANE ADJUSTMENT, RELATIVE TO ARGUS NYH 87 M PROMPT BARGE MEAN:

 A = [REDACTED] 
 B = [REDACTED]

 OCTANE ADJUSTMENT = A * B 
  

					
			
		  	EXAMPLE:	  	
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] CPG
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] CPG
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED]
			
		  	A = [REDACTED]	  	
			
		  	B = [REDACTED]	  	
		
	 OCTANE ADJUSTMENT = A * B = [REDACTED]
	  	
	
	 2) RVP ADJUSTMENT, RELATIVE TO ARGUS NYH 87 M PROMPT BARGE MEAN:

			
	 A = [REDACTED]
	  		  	
			
	 B = [REDACTED]
	  		  	
			
	RVP ADJUSTMENT = A * B	  		  	
			
		  	EXAMPLE:	  	
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED]
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] CPG
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] PSI
			
		  		  	[REDACTED] = [REDACTED] PSI
			
		  	A = [REDACTED]	  	


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 19 








 B = [REDACTED] 
 RVP ADJUSTMENT = [REDACTED] 

  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 20 








 QUALITY ADJUSTERS (8) 
  

			
	LUBE DISTILLATE	  	1) If Sulfur is greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	Sulfur Adjustment = [REDACTED]
		
		  	Example: If the Sulfur is [REDACTED] wt.% the adjustment shall be: (using prices from 09/14/2010):
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sulfur at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.
		
		  	2) If API gravity at [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit is less than [REDACTED], the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] API gravity below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the API gravity is [REDACTED], the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for API gravity at or greater than [REDACTED].
		
		  	3) If Nitrogen is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Nitrogen above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Nitrogen is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Nitrogen at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	4) If Analine Point is less than [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] degree Fahrenheit below [REDACTED], the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Analine Point is [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Analine Point at or greater than [REDACTED] degrees Fahrenheit.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 21 









			
		
		  	5) If Vanadium is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Vanadium above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Vanadium is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Vanadium at or loss than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
	QUALITY ADJUSTERS (9)	  	
		
	LUBE DISTILLATE (cont)	  	6) If Nickel is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Nickel above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Nickel is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Nickel at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	7) If Sodium is greater than [REDACTED] parts-per-million (ppm) by weight (ppmw), the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] ppmw Sodium above [REDACTED] ppmw, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Sodium is [REDACTED] ppmw, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Sodium at or less than [REDACTED] ppmw.
		
		  	8) If Conradson’s Carbon (CCR) is greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the following adjustment shall be added to the price:
		
		  	For every [REDACTED] wt% Conradson’s Carbon between [REDACTED] wt.% and [REDACTED] wt.%, the price shall be reduced by $[REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Conradson’s Carbon is [REDACTED] wt.%, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	For every [REDACTED] wt.% Conradson’s Carbon greater than [REDACTED] wt.%, the price shall be reduced by [REDACTED] per barrel, pro rata.
		
		  	Example: If the Conradson’s Carbon is [REDACTED] wt.%, the adjustment shall be:
		
		  	 [REDACTED]

		
		  	No adjustment shall apply for Conradson’s Carbon at or less than [REDACTED] wt.%.


  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 22 








 NOTES 
 NOTE 1: 
 Where required, freight assessments shall be obtained and averaged via
the following three (3) independent Ship Brokers. 
 1. Poten 

2. McQuilling 

3. Dietze 
 NOTE 2: 

In the event that more than one price posting or assessment for the applicable is available, the price posting or assessment applicable to
the product delivered shall apply. In the event a price posting or assessment for the product delivered does not exist, the parties make appropriate adjustments to the closest price posting or assessment to compensate for quality differences. (I.E.
Gasoline RVP during transition periods.) 
 NOTE 3: 
 All references to the Front Month Nymex RBOB futures contract are valid if and only if the Front contact month at Closing precedes the April 2011 Nymex RBOB futures contract. 

  
 Part II to
Exhibit A, Page 23 








 DEEMED SECONDARY COSTS 
 Deemed Secondary Costs 
 Secondary Costs 

 

																																					
	 	  	Arab Light	 	 	Kirkuk	 	 	Urals	 	 	Terra
[Illegible]	 	 	Illbernia	 	 	[Illegible]	 	 	CPC	 	 	[Illegible]	 	 	[Illegible]	 
	 Import Duties, S/bbl
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	—  	  
	 Custom Fee, Per Entry
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 
	 Inspection, S/bbl
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 
	 Insurance, S/bbl
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 
	 Oil Spill Tax, S/bbl
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 
	 Letter of Credit Cost, S/bbl
	  	$	—  	  	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  	 	$	—  	  
	 New Jersey Spill Compensation & Control Tax
	  	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 	 	$	[REDACTED	] 
	 Harbor Maintenance Fund, % of crude cost
	  	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 
	 Deemed [Illegible] Losses, % of crude cost
	  	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 	 	 	[REDACTED	]% 








 EXHIBIT B 
 LIST OF THIRD-PARTY TANKAGE OR STORAGE 
  

	1.	Hess VGO Terminal – Baltimore, MD 

  

	2.	NuStar Terminal 

  

	3.	Plains Terminal 

  

	4.	Gordon Terminal Service Co. of NJ, Inc. – Bayonne, NJ 

  

	5.	Port Contractors – Outside Bins – Port of Wilmington 

 The following location is used for lubes transloading 
 Transflo Terminal Services
Inc. – Baltimore MD (CSX transloading) 

  
 Exhibit B









 EXHIBIT C 
 REFINERY OSBL LINE FILL 
 Crude Oil 

Dock to S-79 tk. — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Crude
charge pump station to CU#6 — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Crude charge pump station to CU#7 — [REDACTED] bbls. 

FCC charge / VGO 
 Dock to S-70 tk.
— [REDACTED] bbls. 
 FCC charge pump station to FCC — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 CCR charge 
 Dock Naphtha line to S-81 tk. — [REDACTED] bbls. 

CCR charge pump station to CCR — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Distillate 
 CHD #1 to S-51 tk. — [REDACTED] bbls. 

Dock to S-51 tk. (10” line) – [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Dock to S-51 tk. (16” line) – [REDACTED] bbls. 
 S-51 tk. to NuStar Sales Terminal —
[REDACTED] bbls. 
 1911 chain valve to NuStar Sales Terminal (1600’ X 8” pipe) — [REDACTED] bbls. 

Jet 
 Dock to S-33 tk. — [REDACTED]
bbls. 
 CHD #2 to 2808 tk. — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 G-122 to NuStar Sales Terminal (1700’ x 8” pipe) — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Jet pumping
station to Phila. Airport — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Gasoline 
 2941 tk. to BPL pumping station at Paulsboro — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Dock to 2941 tk. —
[REDACTED] bbls. 
 2173 tk. to NuStar Sales Terminal — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Premium 
 VP3574 pump to NuStar Sales Terminal — [REDACTED] bbls. 

  
 Exhibit C









 Ethanol 
 Plains through the Tee to Nustar tank 1972 — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Lube lines 

#2 line to XOM — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 #3 line
to XOM — [REDACTED] bbls. 
 #4 line to XOM — [REDACTED] 
 #5 line to XOM — [REDACTED] 
 #6 line to XOM — [REDACTED] bbls. 

#7 line to XOM — [REDACTED] bbls. 

LPG 
 Coker OM to LPG tankage:

 BB – [REDACTED] bbls. 
 C3
– [REDACTED] bbls. 
 Deprop to OM tankage 
 BB – [REDACTED] bbls. 
 C3 – [REDACTED] bbls. 

CCR to OM tankage 
 C3 – [REDACTED] bbls.

 FCC to OM tankage 
 PP –
[REDACTED] bbls. 
 Alky to OM tankage 

C3 – [REDACTED] bbls. 

  
 Exhibit C









 EXHIBIT D 
 BUTANE SUPPLY TERMS 
  

			
	Seller:	  	Valero Marketing and Supply Company
		
	Purchaser:	  	Company
		
	Product:	  	Mixed Butane
		
	Quantity:	  	[REDACTED] barrels less that amount which has been delivered to the Refinery prior to the Closing Date.
		
	Delivery:	  	 As mutually scheduled via Buyer’s railcars FOB the Refinery

		
	Term:	  	 Beginning on the Closing Date and ending on February 28, 2011

		
	Price:	  	[REDACTED]


  
 Exhibit D









 EXHIBIT E 
 REFINERY BUTANE STORAGE AND SALE TERMS 
 From and after the Closing Date,
until the earlier of (ii) 60 days following the Closing Date, or (ii) such time as all volumes of Refinery Butane have been consumed or exhausted (the “Refinery Butane Term”), Buyer shall (a) allow Seller the right to
store the Refinery Butane at the Refinery, and (ii) purchase from Seller the Refinery Butane on the following terms and conditions: 
 1.
Refinery Butane Storage. Buyer hereby agrees to (i) provide, operate and maintain at the Refinery sufficient track siding and other necessary facilities for the receipt, storage and delivery of railcars containing the Refinery Butane;
(ii) receive any railcars of Refinery Butane which are in-transit as of the Closing Date; (iii) store at the Refinery all railcars of Refinery Butane; and (iv) deliver on a ratable basis the Refinery Butane from the railcar storage to
the Refinery. The Refinery shall have daily railcar switching and adequate railcar spots to receive and unload the Refinery Butane. Buyer agrees to provide a safe area for the purpose of storing and unloading all Refinery Butane. The dedicated area
of the Refinery for storage of the railcars containing the Refinery Butane shall be available and accessible twenty-four (24) hours per day, seven (7) days per week. Buyer shall not charge Seller for the receipt, storage or handling of the
Normal Butane since this arrangement is conducted as an accommodation to Buyer. 
 2. Refinery Butane Sale and Purchase. Buyer shall
purchase from Seller all volumes of Refinery Butane on a ratable basis on the terms and conditions set forth herein. If at the end of the Refinery Butane Term, there are remaining volumes of Refinery Butane, Buyer shall purchase all such remaining
volumes on the terms and conditions set forth herein. Buyer further agrees that it will purchase and use all Refinery Butane first before it purchases or uses any other normal butane or isobutene at the Refinery. 

3. Reports. On a daily basis during the Refinery Butane Term, an inventory reflecting (i) the number of rail cars containing Refinery Butane
and volume of Refinery Butane received at the Refinery during the preceding day, (ii) the number of rail cars containing Refinery Butane and volume of Refinery Butane stored at the Refinery on the preceding day, and (iii) the number of
rail cars containing Refinery Butane and volume of Refinery Butane unloaded at the Refinery during the preceding day will be determined and reported by Buyer to Seller using Buyer’s Operator’s standard reporting format (the “Daily
Activity Report”). Each Daily Activity Report shall also include a breakdown between Isobutane and Normal Butane and reflect the applicable bill of lading for each railcar. 
 4. Title and Risk of Loss. Title to the Refinery Butane will remain with Seller until such time as the Refinery Butane passes the receiving flange between the railcar and the unloading assembly at
the Refinery (the “Refinery Butane Delivery Point”). Buyer shall have care, custody, control and risk of damage or loss of the Refinery Butane from the time the railcar is received at the Refinery. 

  
 Exhibit E-1









 5. Delivery. All Refinery Butane sold hereunder shall be delivered to Buyer at the Refinery Butane
Delivery Point. There shall be no split cargos or partial deliveries of Refinery Butane. Buyer shall be obligated to pay for the entire volume of Refinery Butane as reflected on the applicable bill of lading. 

6. Quantity of Refinery Butane. The volume of Refinery Butane shall be determined by the bill of lading for each railcar, which bill of lading
shall be provided to Buyer upon delivery of the Refinery Butane. 
 7. Refinery Butane Price. The Refinery Butane shall be sold to Buyer
at the prices set forth below: 
 (a) Isobutane Price will be the average of the Daily Price on the Delivery Date, inclusive.
Daily Price to be OPIS Isobutane Sarnia posting Mean [REDACTED] $[REDACTED]/bbl. 
 (b) Normal Butane Price will be the average
of the Daily Price on the Delivery Date, inclusive. Daily Price to be OPIS TET Normal Butane Mt Belvieu Mean [REDACTED] $[REDACTED]/bbl. 
 8.
Invoicing and Payment Terms. 
 (a) Seller shall submit a weekly summary invoice, together with a copy of the applicable
bill of lading for each rail car of Refinery Butane delivered to Buyer during each one week billing period within two (2) Business Days after the end of each such billing period, and Buyer agrees to pay Seller within ten (10) days
following delivery of the invoice. Each such weekly invoice will be based upon on weekly cycles (Monday through Sunday) during the month. The first and last cycle will start on the first day of the month and end on the last day of the month. If the
first day of the month is not a Monday, the cycle will start on the first calendar day and end on Sunday. If the last day of the month is not a Sunday, the final cycle will end on the last calendar day. Each invoice shall, with respect to the
relevant billing period, include all bills of lading. Seller shall deliver each invoice to Buyer via facsimile or electronic transmission, unless otherwise agreed by the Parties. The Parties agree to work together in good faith to arrange for each
invoice to be sent via electronic data interchange (“EDI”). 
 (b) All payments shall be made without offset,
discount, deduction or counterclaim by wire transfer of immediately available funds to Seller at such account as Seller may designate in writing. Any amount payable by Buyer hereunder shall, if not paid when due, bear interest from the payment due
date until, but excluding the date payment is received by Seller, at the Applicable Rate. 
 (c) Invoice Address. Until
such times that the Parties use EDI, all invoices shall be transmitted to the following address: 
 VALERO MARKETING AND SUPPLY
COMPANY 
 One Valero Way 
 Mail Station F3R-118B 
 San Antonio, Texas 78249 

Attention: Bulk Finished Product Accounting – Carrie Tate 

  
 Exhibit E-2









 Telephone: (210) 345-2051 

Facsimile: (210) 444-8512 
 9.
Specifications. The Refinery Butane to be sold hereunder shall meet the specification set forth by the GPA for commercial butane or isobutene as the case may be. 
 10. Warranty. Seller represents and warrants to Buyer that as of the date of delivery of the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit hereunder, Seller shall have good title to the Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit
sold and delivered, free and clear of any liens or encumbrances, other than taxes that are due by Buyer and governmental and statutory liens securing payments not yet due and payable EXCEPT FOR THE FOREGOING WARRANTY OF TITLE, THIS CONVEYANCE IS
MADE AND ACCEPTED WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY OR REPRESENTATION WHATSOEVER, EXPRESS, IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR OTHERWISE, REGARDING THE UNPAID CRUDE OIL IN-TRANSIT INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTY AS TO THE CONDITION OR MERCHANTABILITY OF SUCH
COMMODITY OR FITNESS OF ANY SUCH COMMODITY FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ALL OF WHICH ARE HEREBY DISCLAIMED. BUYER SHALL ACCEPT ALL OF THE UNPAID CRUDE OIL IN-TRANSIT IN ITS “AS IS, WHERE IS” CONDITION AND “WITH ALL FAULTS. 

11. Other Terms. All other terms and conditions for the sale and delivery of the Refinery Butane, to the extent not inconsistent with the terms of
this Agreement, shall be governed by the General Terms and Conditions attached as Exhibit C to the Offtake Agreement which are made a part of, and incorporated into this Exhibit E. 

  
 Exhibit E-3









 EXHIBIT F 
 UNPAID CRUDE OIL IN-TRANSIT 
  

																			
	 	  	 Crude
	  	Volume	 	  	Purchase
Basis	  	 Window
	  	 Title Date
	  	 ETA Paulsboro
	  	 Payment
Terms
	  	 Est Payment Date

									
	1.	  	Urals***	  	 	735,000	  	  	CFR	  	Dec 10-15	  	Dec 12th	  	Dec 12th	  	10 days	  	December 22nd
	2.	  	Vasconia	  	 	500,000	  	  	FOB	  	Dec 17-21	  	Dec 19th	  	Dec 24-27	  	15 days	  	January 4th
	3.	  	Terra Nova	  	 	630,000	  	  	FOB	  	Jan 4-5	  	Jan 5th	  	Jan 9-10th	  	15 days	  	January 20th
	4.	  	Vasconia	  	 	500,000	  	  	FOB	  	Jan 7-2	  	Jan 8th	  	Jan 24-25	  	15 days	  	February 2nd
	5.	  	Kirkuk	  	 	1,000,000	  	  	FOB	  	Nov 30	  	Dec 3rd	  	Dec 21-23	  	30 days	  	January 3rd
	6.	  	Arab Light	  	 	730,000	  	  	FOB	  	Dec 15-17	  	Dec 16th	  	Jan 3-5	  	25 days	  	January 10th
	7.	  	Kirkuk	  	 	1,000,000	  	  	FOB	  	Dec 25	  	Dec 27th	  	Jan 14-16	  	30 days	  	January 27th
	8.	  	Arab Light	  	 	730,000	  	  	DES	  	Jan 7-9	  	Jan 8th	  	Jan 25-27	  	25 days	  	February 1st
	9.	  	Arab Light**	  	 	730,000	  	  	FOB	  	Jan 17-19	  	Jan 18th	  	Feb 5-7	  	25 days	  	February 11th
	10.	  	Kirkuk	  	 	1,000,000	  	  	FOB	  	Jan 27	  	Feb 1st	  	Feb 20-21	  	30 days	  	March 5th

  

	*	These cargos are not Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit but are described herein for the purpose of identifying commitments which Seller has made for the purchase of Crude Oil
for processing at the Refinery following the Closing Date. Pursuant to the Tri-Party Agreement of even date herewith between Seller, Buyer and SMT, Seller will sell this Crude Oil to SMT on an FOB basis at the load port. SMT will arrange for and
charter vessel. SMT will pay Seller for such cargos on the same terms and conditions as Seller is required to pay its supplier, which terms are set out on Exhibit C to the Tri-Party Agreement. 


	**	These cargo commitments/contracts are Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit but Seller, Buyer and SMT each anticipate that Buyer and/or SMT will enter into a new term contract
(the “Buyer/SMT Saudi Contract”) with Saudi Arabian Oil Company (“Aramco”). If the Buyer/SMT Saudi Contract is entered into prior to loading, Seller, Buyer and SMT shall use commercially reasonable efforts to have these cargos
transferred from Seller’s contract with Aramco to the Buyer/SMT Saudi Contract in a timely manner that allows SMT to charter vessels to carry such cargos in a commercially reasonable manner. If they are so transferred, these cargo
commitments/contracts shall not be purchased by Valero and shall cease to be Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit. If (a) the Buyer/SMT Saudi Contract is not executed prior to the loading date or (b) the parties are unsuccessful in their efforts to
transfer the cargo commitments/contracts to the Buyer/SMT Saudi Contract in a timely manner that allows SMT to charter vessels for such cargos in a commercially reasonable manner by the loading date, these cargo commitments/contracts shall remain
Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit and be delivered to Buyer/SMT in the same manner as all other Unpaid Crude Oil In-Transit 


	***	Pricing shall be deemed on December 20-23 for this cargo. 


  
 Exhibit F-1









 APPENDIX 12 – TERMINATION OF DELIVERIES NOTICE 

[LETTERHEAD OF STATOIL] 
 [             , 20    ] 
 PBF Holding Company LLC 
 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor, 

Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887 
 Attention: Executive
Vice President, Commercial 
 Fax Number: (973) 455-7562 
 Telephone Number: (973) 455-7500 
 E-mail: dlucey@pbfenergy.com 

 

	 	Re:	Termination of Deliveries Notice Affecting Crude Oil / Feedstock Supply, Delivery and Services Agreement dated December [    ], 2010 between Statoil
Marketing & Trading (US) Inc. (“Seller”) and PBF Holding Company LLC (“Buyer”) (the “Supply Agreement”) 

 Dear Mr. [                    ]: 
 This Termination of Deliveries Notice (“Notice”) is to advise you that pursuant to the Supply Agreement an Event of Default has occurred and is continuing with Buyer as Defaulting Party.

 As a result of the foregoing, Seller has elected to send this Termination of Deliveries Notice. Pursuant to Clause 24(d) of the Supply
Agreement, Buyer shall immediately cease taking Deliveries of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock and all rights of Buyer to take such Deliveries is hereby terminated. If Buyer does not immediately cease taking Deliveries of Oil or Indigenous Feedstock and
provide confirmation of such shutdown to Seller to be received within one (1) hour from delivery of this Notice, Seller may seek injunctive relief via a temporary restraining order and / or a temporary and permanent injunction. 

Confirmation of shutdown must be sent via telecopy or other electronic transmission to the following: 

Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc. 

1055 Washington Boulevard – 7th Floor 

Stamford, CT 06901 
 Attention: Crude Oil
Operations 
 Fax Number: (203) 978-6958 
 Telephone Number: (203) 978-6900 
 E-mail: uscrudeops@statoil.com 

  
 Appendix 12

 Page 1 









			
	Very truly yours,
	
	Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.
		
	By:	 	  

	Name:	 	
	Title:	 	


  

			
	cc:	  	PBF Holding Company LLC
		  	1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
		  	Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887
		  	Attention: General Counsel
		  	Fax Number: (973) 455-7562
		  	Telephone Number: (973) 455-7500


  
 Appendix 12

 Page 2 








 APPENDIX 13 – SAUDI CONTRACT ARRANGEMENTS 

As of the Effective Date, the Parties have not entered into a contract with Saudi Arabian providing for the supply of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C), and
the Parties do not anticipate entering into such contract on or before the Delivery Commencement Date. 
 The Parties shall continue to
negotiate with each other and with Saudi Arabian in good faith for a reasonable period of time in an attempt to enter into an acceptable term contract for the supply of Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C) for refining at the Refinery which provides that
Seller may lift and take title to such Oil FOB loadport from Saudi Arabian. Any such contract with Saudi Arabian (the “Saudi Contract”) shall be in form and substance acceptable to each Party in its sole discretion after
negotiations in good faith. 
 In the event the Parties determine after a reasonable time that Saudi Arabian will not enter into the Saudi
Contract in the form described in the foregoing paragraph: 
 (a) Buyer shall enter into the Saudi Contract, which shall be in form and
substance acceptable to each Party in its sole discretion after negotiations in good faith, providing that (i) Buyer shall purchase such Arab [REDACTED] crude from Saudi Arabian, (ii) Buyer shall be solely responsible for posting any credit support
to Saudi Arabian, including any letters of credit, and (iii) Seller shall act as “Buyer’s Assignee” with certain rights with respect to loading and shipping the crude that permit Seller to handle Shipping Services in the same manner
as all other Cargoes under this Agreement; and 
 (b) The Parties shall enter into an agreement on terms reasonably acceptable to the Parties,
providing (i) that Buyer will (1) sell and transfer title to each Cargo of crude lifted under the Saudi Contract to Seller DES Paulsboro, and (2) deliver acceptable documentation to Seller with respect to each such sale, (ii) Buyer shall grant a
lien on such Cargoes of Oil to Seller to provide security for the hedges and other obligations Seller undertakes in reliance on Buyer’s obligations to sell the Oil to Seller and to later repurchase such Oil in accordance with the terms of the
Agreement (the Parties understand that Seller may also grant a lien on such Cargoes to the provider of the LC under the Saudi Contract and Seller’s lien granted pursuant to this Clause (b)(ii) shall be subordinated to the position of the LC
holder) (iii) Seller shall provide Shipping Services with respect to such Cargoes, (iv) how pricing and TVM Payments will be calculated, (v) the timing and process as to how such Oil will be handled pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, (vi) that
such Oil will except as otherwise set forth in such agreement, be handled in the same manner as all other Oil under the Agreement, and (vii) such other details as the Parties deem reasonably necessary to accomplish foregoing. 

Buyer shall be fully liable for all obligations, and Seller shall have no obligation to Buyer, with respect to (i) any breach by Buyer of the Saudi
Contract, (ii) any termination of the Saudi Contract other than a terminations resulting from Seller’s failure to perform its obligations under the Saudi Contract “Buyer’s Assignee”, (iii) any failure or refusal of Saudi Arabian
to provide Oil to Buyer or Seller, or (iv) any failure by the Parties to enter into the Saudi Contract. 
 Until such time as the Saudi Contract
is in place, Seller shall have no obligation to supply Buyer with any Arab [REDACTED] Crude (Type C). The Parties shall attempt to identify alternative Cargoes and shall comply with the terms of Clauses 5(e)(iv) through (vi). 

  
 Appendix 13

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 14 – CARGO BANKS AND HEDGE MONTHS SPREADSHEET 

CARGO AND HEDGE MONTH BANKS 
  

																																							
	  	  	 	 	  	 	 	  	 	 	  	 	  	 	 	 	 	 	 	Predicted/Actual Refinery State	 	 	 	 
	 	  	 	 	  	 	 	  	 	 	  	 	  	 	 	 	 	 	 	RUN MONTH
Withdrawals	 	 	 	 
	  	  	 	 	  	 	 	  	CARGO BANKS	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	  	  	 	 	  	HEDGE-MONTH	 	  	Number	 	  	Grade	  	CBDiff /	 	 	Volume	 	 	JAN	 	 	FEB	 	 	MAR	 	 	Cargo
balance	 
	 Cargo bank
	  	g	 	  	  	 	FEB	  	  	 	1	  	  	Kirkuk	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Cargo bank
	  	g	 	  	  				  	 	2	  	  	Saudi Light	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Cargo bank
	  	g	 	  	  				  	 	3	  	  	Urals	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 Cargo bank
	  	g	 	  	  				  	 	4	  	  	Kirkuk	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  				  	 
	Hedge-Month Total Feb WTI 
	  
	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 			
	 Hedge month
	  	 	{	  	  				  	 	5	  	  	Terra Nova	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	 bank (MAR)
	  	  	 	MAR	  	  	 	6	  	  	Saudi Light	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  				  	 	7	  	  	Hibernia	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  	 
	Hedge-Month Total Mar WTI
	  
	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 
	[REDACTED
	] 
	 	 
	[REDACTED
	] 
	 			
	 Hedge month

bank (APR)
	  	 
	{
	  
	  				  	 	8	  	  	Vasconia	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	  	  	 	APR	  	  	 	9	  	  	Saudi Light	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
	  	  				  	 	10	  	  	Terra Nova	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  	  	 	Hedge-Month Total Apr WTI	  	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 			
		  				  				  	 	11	  	  	Kirkuk	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  				  	 	MAY	  	  	 	12	  	  	Hibernia	  	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 
		  				  	 	Hedge-Month Total May WTI	  	 				 				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 			
		  				  				  	 	TOTAL RUNS	  				 				 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 	 	[REDACTED	] 	 			


  
 Appendix 14

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 15 – CARGO TABLE SPREADSHEET 

CARGO TABLE 
 Cargo Details

  

							
	Description	  	 Cargo number
 Grade

Volume
 Execution / Supply Point

Trade location
 Delivery terms
	  		  	

 Monthly Quality and Basis Differential / Hedge-Month 

 

							
	Price details	  	 Differential (at price point)

Pricing basis
 Pricing period
	  	A	  	
				
	Conversion	  	Hedge-Month	  		  	
		  	Conversion differential	  	C	  	
		  	Notes	  		  	
				
	Costs (from price point) Estimated	  	 Freight
 Demurrage

Lightering
 Outturn loss differential

Taxes etc total
 Other
	  		  	
	Total estimated costs	  	E	  	
	Total estimated costs per outturn barrel	  	B	  	

 Total price differential Delivered: FQD = A+B      Final Quality Differential 

Hedge-Month Conversion:             CBD = C
          Cargo Basis Differential 
 Monthly Quality and Basis Differential =
FQD+CBD 
 Petty Cash Adjustments 
  

							
	Actual costs	  	Freight	  		  	
		  	Demurrage	  		  	
		  	Lightering	  		  	
		  	Outturn loss differential	  		  	
		  	Taxes etc total	  		  	
		  	Other	  		  	
		  	Other	  		  	
	Total actual costs	  	D	  	
	Total estimated costs	  	E	  	
	Total Petty Cash Adjustment (USD) D-E	  		  	
	Petty cash reference #	  		  	


  
 Appendix 15

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 16 – FORM OF DELAWARE CITY TANK LEASE 

This Delaware City Tank Lease (“Agreement”) is executed on [December     , 2010] (“Effective
Date”) by and between Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc., a Delaware corporation (“Statoil”), and Delaware City Refining Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (“Storage Provider”). Storage Provider and
Statoil hereinafter are referred to individually as a “Party” or collectively as the “Parties.” This Agreement is being executed in connection with that certain Crude Oil / Feedstock Supply / Delivery and Services Agreement
between Statoil and PBF Holding Company LLC (the “Crude Supply Agreement”) dated December [    ], 2010. Capitalized terms used but not defined in this Agreement shall have the meanings ascribed such terms in the
Crude Supply Agreement. 
  

	1.	USAGE AND OPERATION 

  

	 	(a)	Exclusive Use. Subject to the provisions of this Agreement, Statoil shall, for the Term of this Agreement, have (i) the sole and exclusive right to store Vacuum
Gas Oil (“VGO”) in the storage tank(s) owned by Storage Provider at the Delaware City Refinery and described as follows
[                    ] (“DCR Storage Tank”), (ii) the right of ingress and egress over the properly of Storage Provider to access
the DCR Storage Tank to add or remove VGO, (iii) the right to label the DCR Storage Tank, subject to Storage Provider’s reasonable approval, in such a manner as to put third parties on notice of Statoil’s rights in such tank(s) and the VGO
stored therein, and (iv) the right to make any and all filings under the UCC that are appropriate to clarify Statoil’s ownership and other rights with respect to such VGO. Storage Provider agrees to immediately notify Seller pursuant to the
notice provision herein in the event that a Lien is placed upon the Delaware City Refinery by any creditor of Storage Provider at any time during the Term. If at anytime Statoil elects to remove its VGO, Storage Provider shall provide access to all
necessary equipment and all assistance reasonably required to complete such removal. 

  

	 	(b)	Storage Provider Restrictions and Rights. Nothing herein shall restrict Storage Provider’s right and ability to operate the DCR Storage Tank, provided,
however, that: 

  

	 	(i)	Except under express instructions from Statoil, Storage Provider shall not cause or permit any VGO to be withdrawn from the DCR Storage Tank. All VGO removed from DCR
Storage Tank shall be for the sole account of Statoil. 

  

	 	(ii)	Storage Provider will not commingle any other product with Statoil’s VGO without the prior written consent of Statoil. 


 

	 	(iii)	On a daily basis, Storage Provider shall provide Statoil with all services necessary to allow Statoil to accept VGO from and load VGO onto vessels, inspect such VGO,
transfer by pipeline such VGO to and from the DCR Storage Tank, and otherwise comply with its obligations relating to VGO as set out in the Crude Supply Agreement. 


  
 Appendix 16

 Page 1 









	2.	TERM 

 This Agreement
shall become effective on the Effective Date and except as otherwise agreed to by the Parties, shall run coterminous with the term of that certain Crude Supply Agreement (the “Term”). 

 

	3.	STORAGE FEES AND PAYMENT 


The services that Storage Provider is providing to Statoil hereunder are services that Statoil needs to receive in order to comply with
its obligations under the Crude Supply Agreement. As such, the fees that would be due to Storage Provider for the services it will provide hereunder have been factored into the fee structure set out in the Crude Supply Agreement. Storage Provider
acknowledges the foregoing, and represents that it has received adequate consideration for the execution and compliance of this Agreement from PBF Holding Company LLC, its ultimate parent. As a result of the foregoing and notwithstanding anything
herein to the contrary, Storage Provider shall provide to Statoil all services as required hereunder at no cost to Statoil. 
  

	4.	STORAGE PROVIDER COVENANTS 

  

	 	(a)	Storage Provider shall maintain and operate the DCR Storage Tank in a manner that fully complies with (i) all applicable Laws and Regulations; and (ii) standard
industry practice. With respect to the operation of the DCR Storage Tank, Storage Provider shall make all repairs and perform all maintenance in a reasonably timely manner. 


 

	 	(b)	Storage Provider shall ensure that the DCR Storage Tank adheres to its current maintenance standards. 


 

	 	(c)	At any time during this Agreement Statoil shall have the right to enter the DCR Storage Tank facility and to inspect, examine and inquire concerning all aspects of the
Delaware City Refinery, DCR Storage Tank and VGO stored therein; provided that, if no Event of Default has occurred with respect to Storage Provider, Statoil shall provide reasonable prior notice to Storage Provider and adhere to Storage
Provider’s HSE procedures for the Delaware City Refinery. Statoil shall not exercise its rights hereunder if such exercise will: (i) cause or exacerbate any dangerous, emergency or unsafe conditions at the Delaware City Refinery, or (ii)
obstruct or interfere with the operations of the Delaware City Refinery in a manner inconsistent with standard industry practices. 

  

	 	(d)	Storage Provider shall not introduce into the DCR Storage Tank or add any chemical substances to Statoil’s VGO, including any substances designed to minimize or
reduce Tank Heel levels, without the express prior written authorization of Statoil. 


  
 Appendix 16

 Page 2 









	 	(e)	Storage Provider shall not subcontract any part of the work under this Agreement relating to the DCR Storage Tank without the prior written consent of Statoil in its
sole discretion. If Storage Provider subcontracts any part of the work under this Agreement relating to the DCR Storage Tank with Statoil’s consent, Storage Provider shall require its subcontractors to maintain insurance required in this
Agreement to the extent applicable to the DCR Storage Tank. If requested by Statoil, Storage Provider shall have its subcontractors furnish the same evidence of insurance required of Storage Provider. 


 

	 	(f)	With respect to Storage Provider’s ownership and operation of the Delaware City Refinery, Storage Provider hereby covenants to comply with all of the provisions
set out in Clauses 22(d)(i) and (ii) and 22(e) of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 


 

	5.	EMERGENCIES 

 In the event
that Storage Provider reasonably believes that there are, or are about to be, emergency or urgent circumstances which could have a material adverse impact on the DCR Storage Tank, the Delaware City Refinery, the operation of the Delaware City
Refinery, or the health and safety of any person or the environment (“Emergency Circumstances”), regardless of the cause of such Emergency Circumstances and without assuming any duty hereunder to do so, Storage Provider may take such steps
and actions as it, in its sole discretion, deems reasonable to protect against such circumstances occurring or to minimize, reduce or avoid their adverse impact including the immediate lifting, removal and relocation of VGO. Any such steps which
Storage Provider takes shall not, on their own, constitute a Default of the terms of this Agreement provided, however, Storage Provider shall not be absolved of any responsibility or liability hereunder resulting from any breach of the terms of this
Agreement which caused such emergency or urgent circumstances. Storage Provider shall promptly notify Statoil of any steps or actions so taken. Storage Provider shall compensate Statoil for any Liabilities resulting from any such steps or actions
taken hereunder. 
  

	6.	INSURANCE 

 During the
Term, (i) Statoil, with respect to the DCR Storage Tank, will carry and maintain insurance coverage in accordance with Clauses 21(b)(i) and (ii) of the Crude Supply Agreement; and (ii) Storage Provider, with respect to the Delaware City Refinery,
will carry and maintain insurance coverage in accordance with Clause 21(a) of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the
“Buyer”. 
  

	7.	SUBLETTING AND RELEASE OF STORAGE PROVIDER’S CAPACITY 

 During the Term, neither Party may further assign, sublet, sublicense, grant or release any storage capacity in the DCR Storage Tank except in connection with a permitted assignment under Clause 28 of the
Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 

  
 Appendix 16

 Page 3 









	8.	TANKS BEING TAKEN OUT OF SERVICE / CHANGING SERVICE 

 During the Term, certain tank(s) constituting the DCR Storage Tank may be required to come out of service for maintenance or other reasons. 

 

	 	(a)	Cleaning of tank(s) and the safe disposal of any sludge, oil or other hazardous substances from tank(s) which are taken out of service whether before or after the
termination of this Agreement is the sole responsibility of Storage Provider. Storage Provider warrants to Statoil that Storage Provider will dispose of such material in a lawful and safe manner. Storage Provider shall be solely responsible for any
and all costs associated with such disposal and shall indemnify Statoil against any and all liabilities arising from the disposal of such materials. 

  

	 	(b)	To the extent Storage Provider desires to change service for any tank constituting part of the Storage Facilities or add or remove a tank from the Storage Facilities,
Statoil must provide its written consent. With respect to a request by Storage Provider to add any additional storage tank(s) as a DCR Storage Tank, such request by Storage Provider shall be deemed to constitute a representation from Storage
Provider that such additional storage tank(s) (i) are owned in fee by Storage Provider, (ii) are free and clear of any Liens other than those expressly permitted pursuant to the terms of the Intercreditor Agreements, and (iii) are in full compliance
with all of the applicable covenants and obligations set out herein. 

  

	9.	REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES 

 In connection with each Party’s performance of its obligations hereunder, both Parties hereby make all of the representations and warranties as are set out in Clause 22(a) of the Crude Supply
Agreement, and Storage Provider hereby makes all of the representations and warranties as are set out in Clause 22(b) of the Crude Supply Agreement. Furthermore, both Parties hereby agree to comply with the covenants as are set out in Clause 22(c)
of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 

 

	10.	NOTICES 

 Any notice made
under this Agreement will be in writing either delivered personally by overnight courier to the relevant address set forth below, faxed with uninterrupted transmission confirmed by transmission report to the number set forth below or by electronic
mail to the email address indicated below. Either Party may change their notice address, electronic mail address or fax number upon notice to the other Party at least ten (10) days in advance of the effective date of the change. 

 

			
	 If to Statoil:
	  	 If to Storage Provider:

		
	 Statoil Marketing & Trading (US) Inc.
 1055 Washington Boulevard - 7th Floor
 Stamford, CT 06901
	  	 Delaware City Refining Company LLC
 1 Sylvan Way, 2nd floor
 Parsippany, NJ 07054-3887

	Attention: Crude Oil Operations	  	Attention: Executive Vice President,
	Fax Number: (203) 978-6958	  	Commercial
	Phone Number: (203) 978-6900	  	Fax Number: (973) 455-7562
		  	Phone Number: (973) 455-7500
	Email: uscrudeops@statoil.com	  	Email: dlucey@pbfenergy.com


  
 Appendix 16

 Page 4 









	11.	SHIPPING AND LIGHTERING 


In connection with each Party’s performance of its obligations hereunder, the Parties will comply with all of the obligations as are
set out in Clause 14 of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 

 

	12.	DCR STORAGE TANK OPERATIONS 

 Control and operation of the DCR Storage Tank will rest exclusively with Storage Provider. Storage Provider will be an independent contractor with respect to all services it provides under this Agreement.
This Agreement is made as an accommodation to Statoil, and in no event will Storage Provider’s services be deemed to be those of a public utility or common carrier. 

 

	13.	COMPLIANCE WITH LAW 

 Each
Party will comply with all applicable Laws in all material respects in the performance of this Agreement. Storage Provider will prepare, file and maintain copies of all reports required by Law to be filed with any federal, state or local
governmental authority concerning the receipt, delivery, storage, handling, and blending of VGO, and Storage Provider promptly will provide a copy of any such reports to Statoil upon their preparation. 

 

	14.	CONDITION OF DCR STORAGE TANK 

 Storage Provider shall provide all necessary maintenance services and repairs as are necessary to keep the DCR Storage Tank in a clean and safe operating condition in accordance with good industry
practice and applicable Law. At any time during the Term, Statoil may enter and inspect the DCR Storage Tank in accordance with Clause 23(b) of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the
“Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 
  

	15.	AUDITING 

 In connection
with each Party’s performance of its obligations hereunder, the Parties will adhere to the auditing provisions in Clause 23(a) of the Crude Supply Agreement. 
  

	16.	DEFAULT, SUSPENSION AND TERMINATION 

 The Parties will adhere to Clause 24 of the Crude Supply Agreement with regards to all issues relating to Default by either Party under this Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be
considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 

  
 Appendix 16

 Page 5 









	17.	HSE, DRUG AND ALCOHOL POLICY 

 In connection with each Party’s performance of its obligations hereunder, the Parties will adhere to all HSE, drug and alcohol provisions in Clause 32 of the Crude Supply Agreement. 

 

	18.	LIABILITY 

  

	 	(a)	Force Majeure. The Parties will adhere to Clause 18 of the Crude Supply Agreement with respect to potential responsibility for nonperformance of any obligation
under this Agreement based on an event of Force Majeure. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 


 

	 	(b)	Indemnification. In connection with each Party’s performance of its obligations hereunder, each Party agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the
other Party in accordance with Clause 26 of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil shall be considered the “Seller”, Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer” and DCR Storage Tank shall be
considered “Storage Facilities”. 

  

	 	(c)	Confidentiality. The Parties will adhere to the confidentiality requirements in Clause 36 of the Crude Supply Agreement. For purposes of the foregoing, Statoil
shall be considered the “Seller” and Storage Provider shall be considered the “Buyer”. 

  

	19.	MISCELLANEOUS 

  

	 	(a)	No Waiver. No waiver by either Party of any right hereunder at any time will serve to waive the same right at any future date. 


 

	 	(b)	Amendment. No amendment to this Agreement will be effective unless made in writing and signed by both Parties. 


 

	 	(c)	Severability. If any provision of this Agreement is partially or completely unenforceable pursuant to Law, that provision will be deemed amended to the extent
necessary to make it enforceable, if possible. If not possible, then that provision will be deemed deleted. If any provision is so deleted, then the remaining provisions will remain in full force and effect. 


 

	 	(d)	Conflict of Interest. Neither Party will pay any commission, fee, or rebate to an employee of the other Party or favor an employee of the other Party with any
gift or entertainment of significant value. 

  

	 	(e)	Governing Law. This Agreement will be governed and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of New York, without reference to the choice of law
principles thereof. 


  
 Appendix 16

 Page 6 









	 	(f)	Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of which will be deemed an original and part of one and the same document.


  

	 	(g)	Entire Agreement. This Agreement represents the entire agreement of the Parties with respect to the matters addressed herein. 


 

	 	(h)	Miscellaneous. References in this Agreement to “days,” “months” or “years” will mean to calendar days, months and years unless
otherwise indicated. The word “including” does not limit the preceding words or terms. All section titles and headings in this Agreement are merely for convenience, and will not limit in any way the interpretation of this Agreement. No
provisions of this Agreement will be construed against or interpreted to the disadvantage of any Party by reason of such Party having drafted such provision. Except as otherwise provided herein, the remedies provided in this Agreement are
cumulative, not exclusive, and in addition to all other remedies in either Party’s favor at law or in equity. 


  
 Appendix 16

 Page 7 








 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Agreement as of the date first above written.

  

			
	STATOIL MARKETING & TRADING (US) INC.
		
	By:	 	 
	Name:	 	 
	Title:	 	 
	
	DELAWARE CITY REFINING COMPANY LLC
		
	By:	 	 
	Name:	 	 
	Title:	 	 



  
 Appendix 16

 Page 8 








 APPENDIX 17 – FORM OF BUYER’S INVENTORY STATEMENT 

Buyer’s Monthly Statement of Inventory 
 Paulsboro Refinery 
  

							
		  	Inventory Conducted at 2300	  	 	31-Oct-10	  
			
		  	Total Oil in Crude Tank Field, M:	  	 	[REDACTED]	  
		  	Month End Inventory, M-1:	  	 	[REDACTED]	  
		  	Difference:	  	 	[REDACTED]	  
		  	Oil Supplied by Seller in M:	  	 	[REDACTED]	  
		  	Delivered Quantity in M:	  	 	[REDACTED]	  


 



			
	 Cargo Supplied in M
	  	Volume
	 M-345
	  	[REDACTED]
	 M-345
	  	[REDACTED]
	 M-897
	  	[REDACTED]
	 M-854
	  	[REDACTED]
	 Total:
	  	[REDACTED]




  

			
	 EPQ Number
	  	EPQ Quantity
	 4356
	  	[REDACTED]
	 5677
	  	[REDACTED]
	 5678
	  	[REDACTED]
	 6899
	  	[REDACTED]
	 7890
	  	[REDACTED]
	 3467
	  	[REDACTED]

 
 

  

					
		  	Total EPQ Volume for M:	  	[REDACTED]
		  	Quantity Delivered in M:	  	[REDACTED]
		  	EPQ/Delivered Difference:	  	[REDACTED]

  

			
	Signed:	 	



  
 Appendix 17

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 18 – FORM OF PETTY CASH SPREADSHEET 

Buyer’s Petty Cash Account 
  

											
		 		  	Petty Cash Opening Account:	  		  	
		 		  	Running Total:	  		  	

  

											
	 	 	Cargo
Number	  	 Description
	  	Cost	 	 DCF Location
	  	 Comment

	1	 		  		  	[REDACTED]	 	General/Paulsboro/Jan 2011	  	
	2	 		  		  		 		  	
	3	 		  		  		 		  	
	4	 		  		  		 		  	
	5	 		  		  		 		  	
	6	 		  		  		 		  	
	7	 		  		  		 		  	
	8	 		  		  		 		  	
	9	 		  		  		 		  	
	10	 		  		  		 		  	
	11	 		  		  		 		  	
	12	 		  		  		 		  	
	13	 		  		  		 		  	
	14	 		  		  		 		  	
	15	 		  		  		 		  	
	16	 		  		  		 		  	
	17	 		  		  		 		  	
	18	 		  		  		 		  	
	19	 		  		  		 		  	
	20	 		  		  		 		  	
	21	 		  		  		 		  	
	22	 		  		  		 		  	
	23	 		  		  		 		  	
	24	 		  		  		 		  	
	25	 		  		  		 		  	
	26	 		  		  		 		  	
	27	 		  		  		 		  	
	28	 		  		  		 		  	
	29	 		  		  		 		  	
	30	 		  		  		 		  	
						
		 		  	Running Total:	  		 		  	
		 		  	Buyer’s Paydown:	  		 		  	
		 		  	Balance:	  		 		  	Transferred
		 		  		  		 		  	


  
 Appendix 18

 Page 1 








 APPENDIX 19 – REFINERY MARINE TERMS 

1. PRE-ARRIVAL INFORMATION 
 In addition to the notice requirements contained in the Agreement, Seller, or the owner or master of a Vessel chartered by Seller, shall: 

(a) Give notice in writing to Buyer, or the operator of the Refinery, of the estimated time of arrival (“ETA”) of any scheduled
Vessel at [REDACTED] before the expected arrival at the Refinery. 
 (b) Promptly notify Buyer, or the operator of the Refinery,
in writing about a new ETA if the ETA advances or recedes by [REDACTED] or more after the [REDACTED] ETA notice has been given. 

(c) Furnish, as reasonably requested by Buyer, additional data in writing, about the Vessel’s dimensions, equipment and
certificates, as well as the nature and estimated duration of the anticipated cargo handling and other operations at the Refinery based on Vessel’s pumping capabilities, such information to be actually received by Buyer not later than
[REDACTED] before the Vessel’s arrival at the Refinery. 
 2. DOCKED VESSEL OPERATIONS 

Buyer may instruct Seller to direct a Vessel to vacate its Berth if the Vessel fails to comply with Buyer’s rules and regulations or
if there is a deficiency in the Vessel’s safety or environmental systems. If the Vessel does not vacate the Berth in a reasonable time following said instructions, Seller agrees to indemnify Buyer in accordance with Clauses 26 and 27 of the
Agreement for any Liabilities Buyer incurs or is required to pay third parties as a result thereof, upon receipt of proper supporting documents. 
 3. SAFE BERTH AND PASSAGE 
 (a) If a Vessel cannot, in Buyer’s
reasonable opinion, maintain its mooring safely at the dock, and the Vessel is causing the unsafe condition, then Buyer at its sole discretion may order hold-in tugs, and the cost of such tugs shall be for the Vessel’s account. Dockage and
service fees, including mooring, booming and gangway use, will be charged to the Vessel. In addition, all duties and other charges on the Vessel, including those incurred for tugs and pilots, and other port costs shall be for the Vessel’s
account, unless required by Buyer. 
 (b) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Appendix or Agreement, Buyer does not
warrant the safety or draft of public channels, fairways, approaches thereto, anchorages or other publicly-maintained area either inside or outside the port area where the Vessel may be directed. Buyer shall not be liable for (i) any loss,
damage, injury or delay to Vessel resulting from the use of such waterways not caused by Buyer’s sole fault or sole negligence or which could have been avoided by the exercise of reasonable care on the part of the Vessel or its master, or
(ii) any damage to Vessel at the Refinery caused by other vessels passing in the waterway. 

  
 Appendix 19

 Page 1 








 (c) Buyer warrants to Seller that (i) Buyer shall provide two jetties for import and
export of crude oil and Feedstock fitted with mechanical cargo transfer loading arms and insulation flanges for Berthing as specified in this Clause 3(c) of this Appendix 19 and (ii) one jetty (the “Number 1 Berth”) shall meet
the requirements listed in subclause (i) below and the second jetty (the “Number 2 Berth”) shall meet the requirements listed in subclause (ii) below: 

(i) Number 1 Berth: (1) maximum 1200 feet length overall (“LOA”), (2) maximum 280,000
deadweight tonnage (“DWT”), and (3) maximum draft of 40 feet freshwater, with minimum 400 feet LOA due to bumper configuration. 
 (ii) Number 2 Berth: (1) maximum 900 feet LOA, (2) maximum 150,000 DWT, and (3) maximum draft of 32 feet 10 inches freshwater, with no minimum LOA. 

4. SHORE TANK AVAILABILITY 
 Buyer has the right to restrict or modify Berthing times based on the availability of shore tank ullage. Buyer will make every effort to communicate to Seller any anticipated issues with shore tank or
ullage. Any delay or cost resulting from such restriction or modification, including demurrage, shifting costs, pilotage and additional tugs, shall be solely for Buyer’s account. 
 5. POLLUTION PREVENTION AND RESPONSIBILITY 
 In the event of an escape or
discharge of Oil, cargo or bunkers from a Vessel that causes or threatens to cause pollution or damage, Buyer will promptly take whatever measures are necessary to prevent, mitigate and clean up such release or damage. Buyer shall keep Seller
advised of the nature and results of any such measures taken, and, if time permits, the nature of the measures intended to be taken. 
 6.
HOSES AND SIMULTANEOUS DISCHARGE 
 (a) Hoses/Arms between the Vessel and the shore flanges shall be furnished by Buyer.
Flanges for hose connection should be at or near the Vessel’s dockside rail and should comply with OCIMF recommendations and US Coast Guard regulations. Use of crossover hoses/jumpers is not allowed without prior authorization from Buyer.

 (b) Vessel cargo hoses, including marine vapor recovery and offshore manifold crossover hoses (or jumpers), must be tested
annually and be in service for less than 5 years. Documentation of annual hydrostatic testing and service age must be aboard the Vessel and available to Buyer on request. Any time lost due to verification of compliance shall be for the account of
Seller. 
 (c) If requested by Buyer, Vessel shall discharge more than one grade simultaneously whenever technically capable of
doing so. 

  
 Appendix 19

 Page 2 








 7. AMERICAN TANKER RATE SCHEDULE / WORLDSCALE REFERENCE 

All terms, conditions and differentials as set forth in the current revised American Tanker Rate Schedule / Worldscale Reference on the
date of the Vessel loading or discharging, as applicable, and amendments thereto, shall apply insofar as they are not in conflict with any of the above written provisions. 

  
 Appendix 19

 Page 3 








 APPENDIX 20 – STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT 

BENEFICIARY: 
 GENTLEMEN: 

WE HEREBY ESTABLISH THIS IRREVOCABLE LETTER OF CREDIT NO.
[                    ] IN YOUR FAVOR FOR DRAWINGS UP TO USD
[                    ] EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY. THIS LETTER OF CREDIT WILL EXPIRE WITH OUR CLOSE OF BUSINESS ON
[             , 20    ] (“EXPIRY DATE”)[A date not less than 6 months following the issuance date]. 
 FUNDS UNDER THIS LETTER OF CREDIT NO. [                    ] ARE AVAILABLE AGAINST BENEFICIARY’S
SIGNED DRAFT (DEMAND FOR PAYMENT) DRAWN ON UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH ACCOMPANIED BY THE ORIGINAL OF THIS LETTER OF CREDIT INCLUDING ANY SUBSEQUENT AMENDMENT(S) AND BENEFICIARY’S STATEMENT PURPORTEDLY SIGNED BY AN AUTHORIZED SIGNER, STATING THE
FOLLOWING: 
 “I, [        ] AN AUTHORIZED SIGNER FOR (insert beneficiary), HEREBY DEMAND PAYMENT
OF USD [                    ] UNDER UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH LETTER OF CREDIT NO.
[                    ], SINCE (insert applicant), DEFAULTED IN COMPLYING WITH THE TERMS OF A CERTAIN AGREEMENT SIGNED BETWEEN (insert beneficiary)
AND (insert applicant).” 
 Or 

“I, [        ] AN AUTHORIZED SIGNER FOR (insert beneficiary), HEREBY DEMAND PAYMENT OF USD
[                    ] UNDER UBS AG, STAMFORD BRANCH LETTER OF CREDIT NO.
[                    ], BECAUSE (insert applicant) IS REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN THIS LETTER OF CREDIT IN PLACE, BUT THE LETTER OF CREDIT’S EXPIRY
DATE HAS NOT BEEN EXTENDED AT LEAST 30 DAYS OR MORE PRIOR TO THE CURRENT EXPIRY DATE.” 
 SPECIAL CONDITIONS: 

 

	 	A)	All bank charges and commissions shall be for the applicant’s account. 


 

	 	B)	Spelling and typographical errors are not to be construed as a discrepancy. 


 

	 	C)	Partial and multiple drawings are permitted. 

  

	 	D)	Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, telecopy documents and faxes in lieu of originals are acceptable for purposes of this letter of credit.



  
 Appendix 20

 Page 1 









	 	E)	The Expiry Date shall be automatically extended for an additional one year period, 45 calendar days prior to the currently applicable Expiry Date, unless at least 45
calendar days prior to the original Expiry Date and any amended or renewal Expiry Date, we notify the Beneficiary in writing by certified mail that there will be no (further) renewals or extensions. 


EACH DEMAND HEREUNDER WILL BE HONORED BY [    ] P.M. ON THE BANKING DAY ON WHICH SUCH DEMAND WAS RECEIVED IF THE DEMAND IS RECEIVED
BY [10:00] A,M, AND WILL BE HONORED BY [    ] P.M. ON THE BANKING DAY FOLLOWING THE DAY ON WHICH SUCH DEMAND WAS RECEIVED IF THE DEMAND IS RECEIVED AFTER [10:00] A,M, PAYMENTS SHALL BE MADE BY US IN UNITED STATES DOLLARS, IN
IMMEDIATELY AVAILABLE FUNDS AND IN FULL WITHOUT ANY DEDUCTION OR WITHOLDING (WHETHER IN RESPECT OF SET OFF, COUNTERCLAIM, DUTIES, PRESENT OR FUTURE TAXES, CHARGES OR OTHERWISE WHATSOEVER). 

WE SHALL HONOR ANY SIGHT DRAFT(S) PRESENTED UNDER THIS LETTER OF CREDIT, PROVIDED SUCH DRAFT(S) AND ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS CONFORM TO
THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS HEREOF. DRAFT(S) AND STATEMENT MAY BE SUBMITTED (a) IN PERSON AT [list physical address of appropriate branch of the issuing bank OR (b) BY OVERNIGHT COURIER SERVICE ADDRESSED TO UBS AG. 299 PARK AVENUE, 26TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY 10171, ATTN: LETTER OF CREDIT SERVICES.

 THIS LETTER OF CREDIT SHALL BECOME IMMEDIATELY DUE AND PAYABLE IF WE SHALL COMMENCE ANY CASE, PROCEEDING OR OTHER ACTION UNDER ANY EXISTING
OR FUTURE LAW OF ANY JURISDICTION RELATING TO BANKRUPTCY, INSOLVENCY, AND REORGANIZATION. ARRANGEMENT. SCHEME OF ARRANGEMENT, ADJUSTMENT, WINDING-UP, LIQUIDATION, DISSOLUTION, COMPOSITION OR OTHER RELIEF WITH RESPECT TO OUR DEBTS, OR SEEK
APPOINTMENT OF A LIQUIDATOR, PROVISIONAL LIQUIDATOR, RECEIVER, ADMINISTRATOR, TRUSTEE, CUSTODIAN, OR OTHER INSOLVENCY OFFICIAL FOR ALL OR ANY SUBSTANTIAL PART OF OUR ASSETS; OR TAKE ANY ACTION IN FURTHERANCE OF, OR INDICATING OUR CONSENT TO,
APPROVAL OF, OR ACQUIESCENCE IN, ANY OF THE ACTS SET FORTH ABOVE. 
 THIS STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT IS SUBJECT TO THE ISP98 (INTERNATIONAL
STANDBY PRACTICES, INTERNATIONAL CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, PARIS PUBLICATION NO. 590). 
 As to matters not governed by ISP98 the construction,
validity and performance of this Standby Letter of Credit shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the law of the State of New York and any dispute shall be submitted to the exclusive jurisdiction of the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York located in the Borough of Manhattan, New York, or, if such court declines to exercise or does not have jurisdiction, in any New York State court in the Borough of Manhattan. 

  
 Appendix 20

 Page 2 








 APPENDIX 21 – HSE AND ETHICS POLICY 

Seller has previously delivered under separate cover certain of Seller’s HSE policies as set forth in the report prepared by Seller regarding that
certain Terminal Vetting carried out by Seller on August 17, 2010, with respect to the Refinery. 
 Seller has delivered under separate
cover Seller’s Ethics Policy as set forth in that certain Ethics Code of Conduct. 

  
 Appendix 21

 Page 1