**Step 2 (HRI) Step 4a Nuclear** 

State Coal Rate (lb/MWh)NGCC Rate

(lb/MWh)O/G rate

(lb/MWh)Other Emissions

(lbs) Hist Coal Gen

(MWh) Hist NGCC

Gen. (MWh)Historic OG

steam Gen. (MWh) Other Gen.

(MWh) NGCC Capacity

(MW ) Under

Construction NGCC Capacity (MW) Adj. Coal Rate

(lbs/MWh)Redispatche

d Coal Gen. (MWh) Redispatch

O/G steam Gen. (MWh) Redispatched

NGCC Gen. (MWh) Other Emissions

(lbs) Other Gen.

(MWh) 2012 NGCC

Capacity Factor* Post Redispatch

Assumed NGCC Capacity Factor for Existing FleetNuclear

Generation Under Construction and "At Risk" (MWh)2020 Existing and

Incremental RE2021 Existing and

Incremental RE2022 Existing and

Incremental RE2023 Existing and

Incremental RE2024 Existing and

Incremental RE2025 Existing and

Incremental RE2026 Existing and

Incremental RE2027 Existing and

Incremental RE2028 Existing and

Incremental RE2029 Existing and

Incremental RE2020 EE

Potential 2021 EE

Potential 2022 EE

Potential 2023 EE

Potential 2024 EE

Potential 2025 EE

Potential 2026 EE

Potential 2027 EE

Potential 2028 EE

Potential 2029 EE Potential

(%) State Generation

as % of sales 2012 Total MWh 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029**Interim Goal (2020 - 2029**  **average) Final Goal** 

**(2030 and thereafter)**  Alabama 2,264 877 0 046,045,17653,492,096 0 0 10,333 0 2,12836,001,107 063,536,165 0 0 59% 70% 2,329,528 4,596,883 5,214,381 5,914,827 6,709,365 7,610,632 8,632,966 9,792,631 11,108,072 12,600,217 14,292,801 1.36% 2.11% 3.00% 4.01% 5.13% 6.19% 7.15% 8.01% 8.79% 9.48% 150.63% 92,654,857 1,228 1,214 1,197 1,178 1,158 1,138 1,119 1,099 1,079 1,059 **1,147 1,059**  Alaska 2,852 1,149 01,179,006,934 215,407 2,204,942 0 741,853 589 0 2,681 0 02,420,3491,179,006,934 741,853 43% 47% 61,595 68,633 76,475 85,213 94,950 105,799 117,887 131,357 146,365 163,089 1.22% 1.95% 2.82% 3.82% 4.93% 6.02% 7.01% 7.91% 8.72% 9.45% 95.58% 6,898,283 1,198 1,179 1,156 1,132 1,105 1,081 1,058 1,038 1,020 1,003 **1,097 1,003**  Arizona 2,268 901 1,563 024,335,93026,782,325 1,033,871 0 11,202 0 2,132 0 052,152,127 0 0 27% 53% 1,818,486 2,150,930 2,282,026 2,421,112 2,568,676 2,725,233 2,891,333 3,067,555 3,254,519 3,452,877 3,663,325 5.24% 6.28% 7.22% 8.07% 8.83% 9.50% 10.10% 10.61% 11.05% 11.42% 142.51% 80,700,600 778 766 755 745 736 728 720 714 708 703 **735 703**  Arkansas 2,276 896 1,446 028,378,83115,651,185 860,470 0 5,588 0 2,14010,218,693 309,83934,361,954 0 0 32% 70% 842,037 2,288,229 2,479,266 2,686,252 2,910,519 3,153,509 3,416,786 3,702,042 4,011,114 4,345,990 4,708,823 1.52% 2.31% 3.24% 4.28% 5.42% 6.46% 7.41% 8.26% 9.03% 9.71% 113.99% 50,378,720 1,089 1,076 1,061 1,046 1,029 1,014 999 985 972 960 **1,023 960**  California 2,714 896 1,4056,428,478,795 933,15781,298,98910,403,921 5,077,211 20,765 1,855 2,551 0 092,636,06714,457,570,62914,040,053 45% 49% 1,034,648 37,968,066 40,282,168 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 4.95% 6.04% 7.03% 7.93% 8.74% 9.46% 10.11% 10.67% 11.15% 11.56% 71.07% 279,029,345 627 609 599 592 586 581 577 573 570 567 **588 567**  Colorado 2,226 934 5,177 034,385,542 8,811,706 618 0 3,315 200 2,09222,548,824 40520,648,637 902,733,483 966,240 30% 70% 7,845,383 8,323,548 8,830,857 9,369,086 9,940,119 10,545,955 10,839,820 10,839,820 10,839,820 10,839,820 3.92% 5.08% 6.14% 7.09% 7.96% 8.73% 9.42% 10.03% 10.55% 11.01% 89.08% 57,717,063 1,247 1,223 1,200 1,178 1,158 1,138 1,126 1,120 1,115 1,111 **1,161 1,111**  Connecticut 3,146 811 1,764 0 99,46115,299,704 335,267 0 2,749 0 2,957 0 015,734,432 0 0 63% 65% 971,137 1,071,108 1,205,972 1,357,818 1,528,783 1,721,274 1,938,001 2,182,018 2,456,759 2,766,092 3,114,375 4.71% 5.86% 6.92% 7.88% 8.76% 9.55% 10.25% 10.87% 11.42% 11.88% 106.16% 31,707,213 663 646 630 616 602 589 577 565 553 541 **598 541**  Delaware 2,137 979 1,432 0 1,406,502 5,179,270 1,076,070 0 1,193 0 2,009 184,879 141,4457,335,518 0 0 49% 70% 247,757 290,517 340,658 399,452 468,394 549,235 644,028 755,181 885,519 1,038,351 1.14% 1.86% 2.73% 3.72% 4.83% 5.94% 6.96% 7.89% 8.72% 9.47% 45.09% 12,384,433 973 963 951 938 924 908 892 876 859 841 **912 841**  Florida 2,289 868 1,5294,224,487,40444,537,196133,320,41910,025,973 2,242,659 29,485 1,157 2,1524,131,158 929,984182,822,4469,076,056,7577,832,358 51% 70% 1,623,104 7,489,632 8,495,713 9,636,940 10,931,468 12,399,889 14,065,563 15,954,987 18,098,217 20,529,346 22,109,614 2.03% 2.91% 3.92% 5.03% 6.08% 7.04% 7.90% 8.68% 9.37% 9.98% 90.20% 237,246,975 851 840 827 813 799 786 773 761 748 739 **794 739**  Georgia 2,295 843 0 040,972,09037,591,123 0 0 8,355 0 2,15727,190,604 051,372,609 0 0 51% 70% 19,220,561 5,427,968 6,157,106 6,984,188 7,922,373 8,986,583 10,193,748 11,563,072 12,230,636 12,230,636 12,230,636 1.76% 2.60% 3.56% 4.63% 5.73% 6.74% 7.64% 8.46% 9.19% 9.83% 87.75% 140,815,385 967 952 934 915 895 877 858 846 840 835 **892 835**  Hawaii 2,118 0 1,695 305,429,092 1,502,308 0 4,093,831 220,526 0 0 1,9911,502,3084,093,831 0 305,429,092 220,526 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1.29% 2.04% 2.92% 3.93% 5.05% 6.13% 7.11% 8.00% 8.80% 9.52% 96.24% 10,363,058 1,464 1,448 1,430 1,411 1,389 1,369 1,352 1,336 1,322 1,310 **1,383 1,310**  Idaho 0 858 0 0 0 1,639,922 0 0 620 0 1,639,922 0 0 30% 30% 3,185,880 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3.80% 4.98% 6.06% 7.04% 7.93% 8.73% 9.44% 10.07% 10.62% 11.10% 46.83% 25,492,620 266 259 253 248 243 239 236 233 230 228 **244 228**  Illinois 2,334 945 0 079,166,165 7,870,423 0 0 3,396 0 2,19466,157,723 020,878,865 0 0 26% 70% 5,305,342 10,562,949 11,194,781 11,864,407 12,574,087 13,326,217 14,123,337 14,968,137 15,863,470 16,812,358 17,818,004 4.36% 5.53% 6.60% 7.57% 8.46% 9.26% 9.97% 10.61% 11.16% 11.63% 126.99% 154,319,858 1,504 1,471 1,441 1,414 1,389 1,365 1,344 1,324 1,305 1,287 **1,384 1,287**  Indiana 2,158 953 01,889,893,75187,213,26812,839,309 0 1,087,863 2,768 0 2,02983,034,543 017,018,0341,889,893,7511,087,863 53% 70% 4,474,098 4,741,720 5,025,350 5,325,946 5,644,522 5,982,154 6,339,982 6,719,214 7,121,130 7,547,086 3.20% 4.33% 5.49% 6.56% 7.53% 8.42% 9.22% 9.93% 10.56% 11.11% 102.84% 113,071,949 1,708 1,684 1,660 1,638 1,618 1,599 1,582 1,566 1,552 1,539 **1,615 1,539**  Iowa 2,251 894 2,422 033,055,156 1,437,496 305,111 0 1,264 0 2,11626,779,114 247,1817,771,468 0 0 13% 70% 277,784 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 4.65% 5.78% 6.82% 7.77% 8.62% 9.39% 10.08% 10.69% 11.21% 11.66% 113.03% 49,141,853 1,398 1,382 1,367 1,353 1,341 1,331 1,322 1,313 1,307 1,301 **1,341 1,301**  Kansas 2,364 0 1,560 027,979,593 0 1,632,997 0 0 0 2,22227,979,5931,632,997 0 0 0 542,728 7,238,913 7,843,267 8,498,076 8,884,938 8,884,938 8,884,938 8,884,938 8,884,938 8,884,938 8,884,938 1.22% 1.95% 2.83% 3.83% 4.95% 6.05% 7.05% 7.96% 8.78% 9.52% 110.28% 43,319,516 1,707 1,666 1,623 1,590 1,571 1,554 1,537 1,523 1,511 1,499 **1,578 1,499**  Kentucky 2,166 0 0 084,358,283 0 0 0 0 640 2,03683,515,019 0 843,2642,804,414,9763,091,968 551,118 625,149 709,125 804,382 912,434 1,035,001 1,174,033 1,331,740 1,510,633 1,713,556 1.91% 2.78% 3.77% 4.87% 5.96% 6.95% 7.85% 8.66% 9.38% 10.02% 97.18% 95,736,032 1,934 1,915 1,894 1,871 1,849 1,829 1,810 1,793 1,778 1,763 **1,844 1,763**  Louisiana 2,324 969 1,581 024,300,39319,771,18214,254,748 0 6,508 0 2,18411,538,7676,768,70640,018,850 0 0 35% 70% 985,225 3,348,948 3,628,541 3,931,477 4,259,703 4,615,333 5,000,652 5,418,141 5,870,485 6,360,593 6,891,619 1.14% 1.85% 2.71% 3.69% 4.78% 5.88% 6.88% 7.78% 8.60% 9.33% 90.08% 91,094,022 1,174 1,158 1,141 1,121 1,100 1,080 1,061 1,043 1,027 1,011 **1,092 1,011**  Maine 0 848 2,635 0 0 4,053,378 59,067 0 1,389 0 0 0 04,112,445 0 0 33% 34% 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 5.37% 6.47% 7.48% 8.39% 9.22% 9.96% 10.62% 11.20% 11.70% 12.13% 132.52% 12,429,295 415 409 403 398 393 389 385 382 380 378 **393 378**  Maryland 2,161 975 1,544 016,297,835 676,556 2,892,354 0 289 0 2,03115,364,2922,726,6791,775,773 0 0 27% 70% 787,533 1,697,995 1,991,053 2,334,691 2,737,638 3,210,129 3,764,169 4,413,830 5,175,617 5,982,069 5,982,069 4.21% 5.38% 6.45% 7.44% 8.33% 9.13% 9.85% 10.48% 11.04% 11.51% 60.82% 66,455,750 1,544 1,497 1,451 1,407 1,364 1,322 1,279 1,236 1,195 1,187 **1,348 1,187**  Massachusetts 2,083 888 1,757 0 2,268,13323,603,160 329,883 0 6,625 0 1,958 0 026,201,176 0 0 41% 45% 316,260 2,962,380 3,335,378 3,755,339 4,228,179 4,760,555 5,359,963 6,034,843 6,794,698 7,650,227 8,613,477 4.43% 5.60% 6.68% 7.66% 8.56% 9.37% 10.09% 10.73% 11.29% 11.77% 74.77% 59,467,355 739 719 700 681 663 645 628 611 593 576 **656 576**  Michigan 2,256 998 1,586 053,210,78018,499,951 774,872 0 5,008 0 2,12141,091,564 598,38830,795,650 0 0 42% 70% 1,827,909 4,775,710 5,061,374 5,364,125 5,684,984 6,025,037 6,385,430 6,767,380 7,172,177 7,601,187 8,055,859 4.59% 5.74% 6.80% 7.77% 8.64% 9.43% 10.14% 10.76% 11.30% 11.77% 103.89% 112,690,037 1,410 1,384 1,360 1,339 1,319 1,301 1,284 1,269 1,255 1,242 **1,316 1,242**  Minnesota 2,318 877 1,591 021,989,584 5,715,510 29,243 0 2,768 0 2,17910,699,001 14,22817,021,108 0 0 24% 70% 840,190 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 4.80% 5.92% 6.95% 7.89% 8.73% 9.49% 10.17% 10.76% 11.28% 11.72% 82.84% 73,094,474 972 956 941 928 917 907 898 890 884 879 **917 879**  Mississippi 2,494 848 1,388 0 7,503,11431,813,677 4,402,778 0 7,894 150 2,344 0 043,719,5695,318,387,0626,561,648 46% 63% 631,874 2,498,626 2,834,265 3,214,992 3,646,861 4,136,743 4,692,430 5,322,763 5,458,430 5,458,430 5,458,430 1.40% 2.17% 3.07% 4.09% 5.22% 6.28% 7.24% 8.11% 8.89% 9.59% 98.63% 52,021,589 783 773 761 748 734 721 707 700 696 692 **732 692**  Missouri 2,085 890 0 072,939,512 4,854,569 0 0 2,079 0 1,95965,012,570 012,781,511 0 0 27% 70% 549,657 1,638,287 1,736,283 1,840,140 1,950,210 2,066,863 2,190,495 2,321,521 2,460,385 2,607,555 2,763,528 1.58% 2.38% 3.33% 4.39% 5.54% 6.60% 7.56% 8.43% 9.22% 9.92% 99.47% 88,626,254 1,705 1,689 1,670 1,649 1,627 1,607 1,589 1,573 1,558 1,544 **1,621 1,544**  Montana 2,481 0 0 014,447,406 0 0 0 0 0 2,33214,447,406 0 0 0 0 1,598,643 1,696,078 1,799,452 1,909,126 2,025,485 2,148,935 2,279,910 2,418,867 2,566,294 2,722,706 3.36% 4.51% 5.63% 6.65% 7.57% 8.41% 9.15% 9.81% 10.39% 10.90% 207.68% 14,904,523 2,037 2,004 1,972 1,943 1,915 1,888 1,863 1,839 1,815 1,793 **1,907 1,793**  Nebraska 2,181 1,097 1,755 024,660,983 423,638 37,524 0 468 0 2,05022,208,869 33,7932,879,483 0 0 10% 70% 574,830 1,856,032 2,010,986 2,178,877 2,360,784 2,557,879 2,771,428 3,002,806 3,253,501 3,525,125 3,819,427 2.20% 3.13% 4.18% 5.34% 6.41% 7.38% 8.27% 9.06% 9.78% 10.40% 113.44% 33,143,117 1,724 1,696 1,666 1,635 1,605 1,577 1,551 1,526 1,502 1,479 **1,596 1,479**  Nevada 2,275 890 1,459 0 4,133,66223,783,256 279,983 0 6,381 0 2,138 0 028,196,901 0 0 42% 50% 3,761,262 3,990,506 4,233,722 4,491,761 4,765,528 5,055,980 5,364,135 5,691,072 6,037,935 6,405,939 2.95% 4.02% 5.18% 6.24% 7.20% 8.07% 8.85% 9.54% 10.16% 10.69% 96.67% 37,821,930 759 745 731 718 705 693 682 671 661 652 **702 652**  New Hampshire 2,382 878 1,889 0 1,281,341 6,946,869 72,614 0 1,506 0 2,239 0 08,300,824 0 0 53% 63% 575,615 2,219,730 2,499,219 2,813,899 3,168,200 3,567,113 4,016,253 4,521,944 4,822,223 4,822,223 4,822,223 2.84% 3.90% 5.08% 6.19% 7.21% 8.14% 8.98% 9.74% 10.41% 11.00% 194.97% 11,686,618 637 616 593 571 548 526 504 491 488 486 **546 486**  New Jersey 2,441 973 1,473 0 2,602,99020,015,730 173,972 0 5,832 0 2,294 0 022,792,692 0 0 39% 44% 1,616,037 2,421,244 2,839,129 3,329,137 3,903,716 4,577,463 5,367,492 6,293,872 7,380,138 8,653,883 10,147,466 1.25% 1.99% 2.87% 3.88% 5.00% 6.10% 7.11% 8.02% 8.84% 9.58% 76.19% 80,689,388 803 779 751 722 691 661 632 604 576 548 **677 548**  New Mexico 2,341 907 1,313 011,353,987 5,730,957 2,208,001 0 1,662 0 2,2007,594,3191,476,86110,221,765 0 0 39% 70% 3,261,076 3,459,834 3,670,706 3,894,431 4,131,791 4,383,618 4,650,794 4,721,996 4,721,996 4,721,996 3.10% 4.19% 5.32% 6.35% 7.28% 8.11% 8.86% 9.52% 10.10% 10.60% 150.06% 24,919,278 1,197 1,173 1,150 1,127 1,107 1,087 1,068 1,058 1,053 1,048 **1,107 1,048**  New York 2,226 974 1,366 418,527,550 4,156,14344,002,77712,502,558 309,900 9,848 0 2,092 27,582 82,97360,550,923 418,527,550 309,900 51% 70% 2,410,637 8,344,248 9,394,883 10,577,805 11,909,671 13,409,233 15,097,608 16,998,568 19,138,880 21,548,682 24,261,905 4.42% 5.59% 6.67% 7.65% 8.55% 9.35% 10.08% 10.72% 11.28% 11.76% 93.05% 153,914,184 763 737 713 691 669 648 628 609 589 570 **662 570**  North Carolina 2,059 851 0 050,607,83815,195,335 0 0 4,709 2,249 1,93533,884,577 031,918,5969,248,929,14310,865,369 37% 70% 2,295,625 4,476,628 5,077,973 5,760,095 6,533,848 7,411,538 8,407,128 9,536,455 10,817,485 11,668,176 11,668,176 2.37% 3.32% 4.39% 5.51% 6.53% 7.45% 8.28% 9.02% 9.68% 10.26% 86.12% 137,704,068 1,183 1,159 1,134 1,108 1,084 1,060 1,037 1,015 999 992 **1,077 992**  North Dakota 2,368 0 0 028,186,691 0 0 0 0 0 2,22628,186,691 0 0 0 0 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 1.39% 2.16% 3.07% 4.10% 5.24% 6.32% 7.30% 8.19% 8.99% 9.71% 259.49% 15,822,199 1,852 1,846 1,838 1,829 1,820 1,811 1,803 1,795 1,789 1,783 **1,817 1,783**  Ohio 2,126 963 2,219 086,473,07520,907,183 321,602 0 4,343 539 1,99979,993,008 297,50227,411,3502,506,741,5782,604,017 55% 70% 993,077 3,286,937 3,854,232 4,519,438 5,299,452 6,214,090 7,286,586 8,544,185 10,018,835 11,747,996 13,775,594 4.17% 5.35% 6.43% 7.42% 8.32% 9.13% 9.86% 10.51% 11.07% 11.56% 85.97% 163,906,374 1,573 1,544 1,517 1,491 1,466 1,441 1,417 1,392 1,366 1,340 **1,455 1,340**  Oklahoma 2,305 892 1,382 029,102,16029,943,376 8,488,758 0 8,035 0 2,16614,034,4014,093,67049,406,223 0 0 42% 70% 11,742,785 12,723,153 13,785,369 14,936,266 15,579,318 15,579,318 15,579,318 15,579,318 15,579,318 15,579,318 1.86% 2.71% 3.69% 4.79% 5.88% 6.88% 7.79% 8.60% 9.33% 9.97% 114.44% 63,797,105 996 977 958 937 922 916 910 904 900 896 **931 896**  Oregon 2,080 862 0 0 2,640,25911,424,291 0 0 3,435 0 1,955 0 014,064,550 0 0 38% 47% 9,131,577 9,688,134 10,278,613 10,905,080 11,569,730 12,274,890 12,567,372 12,567,372 12,567,372 12,567,372 4.66% 5.77% 6.78% 7.69% 8.52% 9.26% 9.92% 10.49% 10.99% 11.41% 111.21% 50,195,189 475 455 437 420 405 391 383 380 377 375 **410 375**  Pennsylvania 2,134 902 1,515 087,052,56250,028,719 1,638,387 0 9,582 0 2,00578,328,8941,474,20258,916,572 0 0 59% 70% 4,480,395 8,430,147 9,885,114 11,591,196 13,591,732 15,937,543 18,688,219 21,913,638 25,695,734 30,130,587 35,330,855 4.67% 5.81% 6.85% 7.79% 8.65% 9.42% 10.11% 10.71% 11.24% 11.69% 142.20% 155,577,427 1,337 1,310 1,284 1,258 1,231 1,203 1,175 1,145 1,113 1,080 **1,214 1,080**  Rhode Island 0 918 0 0 0 8,140,017 0 0 1,961 0 8,140,017 0 0 47% 47% 163,746 184,363 207,576 233,713 263,140 296,272 333,576 375,577 422,866 476,110 3.90% 5.11% 6.22% 7.24% 8.17% 9.02% 9.78% 10.45% 11.04% 11.56% 97.63% 8,287,230 867 855 844 834 824 815 806 798 790 782 **822 782**  South Carolina 2,164 848 1,730 028,460,31811,209,394 405,616 0 2,839 0 2,03422,299,838 317,81717,457,673 0 0 45% 70% 20,340,660 3,548,749 4,025,451 4,566,189 5,179,564 5,875,334 6,664,566 7,559,815 8,575,324 9,675,568 9,675,568 2.32% 3.26% 4.32% 5.45% 6.47% 7.40% 8.23% 8.98% 9.65% 10.23% 115.08% 83,622,303 921 904 885 865 847 829 811 794 777 772 **840 772**  South Dakota 2,266 1,131 0 0 2,923,161 27,096 0 0 324 0 2,130 958,046 01,992,211 0 0 1% 70% 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1.60% 2.41% 3.36% 4.42% 5.57% 6.62% 7.57% 8.44% 9.21% 9.91% 82.32% 12,615,449 870 856 839 821 803 787 773 761 750 741 **800 741**  Tennessee 2,244 813 0 034,373,696 6,548,897 0 0 1,601 0 2,11031,076,520 09,846,073 0 0 47% 70% 10,416,619 1,384,846 1,570,872 1,781,886 2,021,247 2,292,760 2,600,746 2,950,104 3,346,391 3,795,911 4,305,814 2.21% 3.14% 4.18% 5.33% 6.38% 7.33% 8.19% 8.97% 9.65% 10.26% 71.81% 103,619,721 1,353 1,332 1,308 1,283 1,260 1,239 1,218 1,199 1,181 1,163 **1,254 1,163**  Texas 2,239 970 1,3779,150,882,510138,705,138148,010,27820,911,868 5,627,228 37,548 0 2,10466,698,23310,055,753230,873,2989,150,882,5105,627,228 45% 70% 2,291,006 46,879,906 50,793,762 55,034,373 59,629,020 64,607,260 70,001,117 75,845,290 82,177,376 85,962,502 85,962,502 1.78% 2.62% 3.59% 4.68% 5.78% 6.79% 7.70% 8.52% 9.26% 9.91% 98.12% 392,523,451 1,049 1,029 1,007 985 962 941 920 899 886 881 **956 881**  Utah 2,071 884 1,867 027,332,140 5,447,362 120,348 0 1,953 0 1,94720,797,210 91,57412,011,066 0 0 32% 70% 1,393,353 1,478,276 1,568,375 1,663,965 1,765,381 1,872,979 1,987,135 2,108,248 2,236,743 2,373,069 3.62% 4.82% 5.91% 6.91% 7.81% 8.62% 9.34% 9.98% 10.54% 11.03% 127.29% 31,955,593 1,446 1,428 1,410 1,395 1,380 1,366 1,354 1,342 1,332 1,322 **1,378 1,322**  Virginia 2,433 909 1,652 013,641,55223,070,350 343,908 0 4,346 1,928 2,2877,600,565 191,61329,263,6328,466,572,7789,314,554 60% 70% 1,645,275 4,458,736 5,228,273 6,130,626 7,188,717 8,429,425 9,884,268 11,192,008 11,192,008 11,192,008 11,192,008 1.23% 1.96% 2.82% 3.81% 4.91% 5.98% 6.95% 7.83% 8.62% 9.33% 58.01% 115,890,388 990 967 942 913 883 852 826 818 812 806 **881 806**  Washington 2,432 995 0 0 3,735,730 5,665,045 0 0 3,485 0 2,286 0 09,400,775 0 0 19% 31% 506,700 10,407,602 11,041,931 11,714,921 12,428,930 13,186,456 13,990,153 14,842,834 15,747,484 16,707,272 17,725,558 4.24% 5.39% 6.43% 7.38% 8.24% 9.01% 9.69% 10.29% 10.81% 11.26% 107.69% 99,270,908 381 356 334 315 299 285 272 261 250 241 **299 241**  West Virginia 2,064 0 0 070,074,636 0 0 0 0 0 1,94070,074,636 0 0 0 0 2,451,206 2,874,262 3,370,334 3,952,023 4,634,107 5,433,912 6,371,756 7,471,464 8,760,972 10,273,036 1.77% 2.62% 3.60% 4.70% 5.83% 6.86% 7.81% 8.66% 9.43% 10.11% 233.30% 33,131,616 1,860 1,842 1,822 1,799 1,774 1,748 1,720 1,691 1,659 1,624 **1,754 1,624**  Wisconsin 2,363 846 1,798 032,112,72110,244,273 47,668 0 2,977 0 2,22124,062,122 35,71818,306,822 0 0 39% 70% 546,885 4,066,362 4,309,595 4,567,377 4,840,579 5,130,122 5,436,985 5,762,203 6,106,875 6,472,163 6,859,301 4.68% 5.82% 6.87% 7.83% 8.70% 9.48% 10.17% 10.79% 11.33% 11.79% 83.97% 73,988,479 1,382 1,356 1,332 1,311 1,290 1,271 1,254 1,237 1,222 1,208 **1,286 1,208**  Wyoming 2,331 0 0 042,907,427 0 0 0 0 220 2,19142,617,555 0 289,872 964,017,6481,062,864 5,535,669 5,873,061 6,231,016 6,610,788 7,013,706 7,441,182 7,894,712 8,375,884 8,886,383 9,427,996 1.61% 2.42% 3.35% 4.41% 5.53% 6.55% 7.48% 8.32% 9.07% 9.73% 256.15% 18,245,903 1,899 1,881 1,862 1,841 1,819 1,798 1,777 1,756 1,735 1,714 **1,808 1,714**  **Step 3a & 3b (Redispatch) Step 6&7 (State Goal Phase I & II (lbs/MWh))**  **Step 5 (Demand Side EE - % of avoided MWh) Step 4b Renewable (MWh)** 

## Step 2 (HRI) **Step 4a Nuclear**

State Coal Rate

(lb/MWh)NGCC Rate

(lb/MWh)O/G rate

(lb/MWh)Other Emissions

(lbs) Hist Coal Gen.

(MWh) Hist NGCC

Gen (MWh)Historic OG

steam Gen. (MWh) Other Gen.

(MWh) NGCC Capacity

(MW ) Under

Construction NGCC Capacity (MW) Adj. Coal

Rate (lbs/MWh)Redispatche

d Coal Gen. (MWh) Redispatch

O/G steam Gen. (MWh) Redispatche

d NGCC Gen. (MWh) Other

Emissions (lbs)Other Gen.

(MWh) 2012 NGCC

Capacity Factor* Post Redispatch

Assumed NGCC Capacity Factor for Existing FleetNuclear

Generation Under Construction and "At Risk" MWh2020 Existing and

Incremental RE2021 Existing and

Incremental RE2022 Existing and

Incremental RE2023 Existing and

Incremental RE2024 Existing and

Incremental RE2020 EE

Potential 2021 EE

Potential 2022 EE

Potential 2023 EE

Potential 2024 EE

Potential State Generation

as % of sales2012 Total MWh 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024**Interim Goal (2020 - 2024**  **average) Final Goal** 

**(2025 and thereafter)**  Alabama 2,264 877 0 046,045,17653,492,096 0 0 10,333 0 2,17340,539,404 058,997,868 0 0 59% 65% 2,329,528 4,596,883 5,214,381 5,914,827 6,709,365 7,610,632 1.07% 1.65% 2.34% 3.11% 3.86% 150.63% 92,654,857 1,301 1,287 1,272 1,255 1,237 **1,270 1,237**  Alaska 2,852 1,149 01,179,006,934 215,4072,204,942 0 741,853 589 0 2,738 0 02,420,3491,179,006,934 741,853 43% 47% 0 61,595 68,633 76,475 85,213 94,950 0.94% 1.49% 2.15% 2.91% 3.69% 95.58% 6,898,283 1,205 1,1901,171 1,151 1,131 **1,170 1,131**  Arizona 2,268 901 1,563 024,335,93026,782,3251,033,871 0 11,202 0 2,177 0 052,152,127 0 0 27% 53% 1,818,486 2,150,930 2,282,026 2,421,112 2,568,676 2,725,233 3.52% 4.23% 4.87% 5.46% 5.98% 142.51% 80,700,600 797 787 779 771 763 **779 763**  Arkansas 2,276 896 1,446 028,378,83115,651,185 860,470 0 5,588 0 2,18512,600,888382,06931,907,529 0 0 32% 65% 842,037 2,288,229 2,479,266 2,686,252 2,910,519 3,153,509 1.24% 1.86% 2.57% 3.37% 4.10% 113.99% 50,378,7201,165 1,1541,1401,126 1,113 **1,140 1,113**  California 2,714 896 1,4056,428,478,795 933,15781,298,98910,403,9215,077,211 20,765 1,855 2,605 0 092,636,06714,457,570,62914,040,053 45% 50% 1,034,648 37,968,066 40,282,168 41,150,704 41,150,704 41,150,704 3.55% 4.27% 4.94% 5.54% 6.08% 71.07% 279,029,345 638 623 614 610 606 **618 606**  Colorado 2,226 934 5,177 034,385,5428,811,706 618 0 3,315 200 2,13724,092,716 43319,104,717902,733,483 966,240 30% 65% 0 7,845,383 8,323,548 8,830,857 9,369,086 9,940,119 3.32% 4.05% 4.72% 5.32% 5.87% 89.08% 57,717,063 1,307 1,287 1,267 1,248 1,229 **1,268 1,229**  Connecticut 3,146 811 1,764 0 99,46115,299,704 335,267 0 2,749 0 3,020 8,602 28,99815,696,832 0 0 63% 65% 971,137 1,071,108 1,205,972 1,357,818 1,528,783 1,721,274 3.61% 4.36% 5.05% 5.68% 6.25% 106.16% 31,707,213 677 664 652 640 628 **652 628**  Delaware 2,137 979 1,432 01,406,5025,179,2701,076,070 0 1,193 0 2,051 481,732368,5586,811,553 0 0 49% 65% 0 247,757 290,517 340,658 399,452 468,394 0.86% 1.40% 2.05% 2.80% 3.59% 45.09% 12,384,433 1,029 1,019 1,009 996 983 **1,007 983**  Florida 2,289 868 1,5294,224,487,40444,537,196133,320,41910,025,9732,242,659 29,485 1,157 2,19715,116,2613,402,891169,364,4369,076,056,7577,832,358 51% 65% 1,623,104 7,489,632 8,495,713 9,636,940 10,931,468 12,399,889 1.75% 2.46% 3.25% 3.99% 4.65% 90.20% 237,246,975 933 921 909 897 885 **909 885**  Georgia 2,295 843 0 040,972,09037,591,123 0 0 8,355 0 2,20330,860,076 047,703,137 0 0 51% 65% 19,220,561 5,427,968 6,157,106 6,984,188 7,922,373 8,986,583 1.48% 2.14% 2.90% 3.66% 4.36% 87.75% 140,815,385 1,0301,015 999 982 965 **998 965**  Hawaii 2,118 0 1,695 305,429,0921,502,308 04,093,831 220,526 0 0 2,0331,502,3084,093,831 0305,429,092 220,526 0 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1,046,927 1.01% 1.58% 2.25% 3.02% 3.79% 96.24% 10,363,058 1,479 1,467 1,453 1,437 1,422 **1,452 1,422**  Idaho 0 858 0 0 01,639,922 0 0 620 0 1,639,922 0 0 30% 30% 0 3,185,880 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3,196,687 3.28% 4.02% 4.70% 5.32% 5.88% 46.83% 25,492,620 270 265 261 257 254 **261 254**  Illinois 2,334 945 0 079,166,1657,870,423 0 0 3,396 0 2,24167,649,070 019,387,518 0 0 26% 65% 5,305,342 10,562,949 11,194,781 11,864,407 12,574,087 13,326,217 3.52% 4.26% 4.95% 5.58% 6.15% 126.99% 154,319,858 1,568 1,543 1,519 1,497 1,475 **1,521 1,475**  Indiana 2,158 953 01,889,893,75187,213,26812,839,309 01,087,863 2,768 0 2,07284,250,117 015,802,4601,889,893,7511,087,863 53% 65% 0 4,474,098 4,741,720 5,025,350 5,325,946 5,644,522 2.89% 3.69% 4.42% 5.09% 5.70% 102.84% 113,071,949 1,759 1,7401,723 1,706 1,691 **1,724 1,691**  Iowa 2,251 894 2,422 033,055,1561,437,496 305,111 0 1,264 0 2,16127,329,142252,2587,216,363 0 0 13% 65% 277,784 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 8,565,921 3.58% 4.32% 4.99% 5.61% 6.17% 113.03% 49,141,853 1,457 1,445 1,435 1,425 1,417 **1,436 1,417**  Kansas 2,364 0 1,560 027,979,593 01,632,997 0 0 0 2,26927,979,5931,632,997 0 0 0 542,728 7,238,913 7,843,267 8,498,076 8,884,938 8,884,938 0.94% 1.49% 2.16% 2.92% 3.70% 110.28% 43,319,516 1,747 1,709 1,668 1,639 1,625 **1,678 1,625**  Kentucky 2,166 0 0 084,358,283 0 0 0 0 640 2,08083,796,107 0 562,1762,804,414,9763,091,968 0 551,118 625,149 709,125 804,382 912,434 1.63% 2.32% 3.11% 3.86% 4.55% 97.18% 95,736,032 1,9841,968 1,9501,933 1,918 **1,951 1,918**  Louisiana 2,324 969 1,581 024,300,39319,771,18214,254,748 0 6,508 0 2,23113,340,4057,825,55737,160,361 0 0 35% 65% 985,225 3,348,948 3,628,541 3,931,477 4,259,703 4,615,333 0.85% 1.39% 2.04% 2.78% 3.56% 90.08% 91,094,022 1,233 1,219 1,2041,186 1,169 **1,202 1,169**  Maine 0 848 2,635 0 04,053,378 59,067 0 1,389 0 0 0 04,112,445 0 0 33% 34% 0 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3,611,728 3.61% 4.36% 5.05% 5.68% 6.25% 132.52% 12,429,295 426 422 417 413 410 **418 410**  Maryland 2,161 975 1,544 016,297,835 676,5562,892,354 0 289 0 2,07415,472,0152,745,7971,648,932 0 0 27% 65% 787,533 1,697,995 1,991,053 2,334,691 2,737,638 3,210,129 3.47% 4.22% 4.90% 5.53% 6.10% 60.82% 66,455,7501,597 1,558 1,519 1,481 1,441 **1,519 1,441**  Massachusetts 2,083 888 1,757 02,268,13323,603,160 329,883 0 6,625 0 1,999 0 026,201,176 0 0 41% 45% 316,260 2,962,380 3,335,378 3,755,339 4,228,179 4,760,555 3.55% 4.30% 4.99% 5.63% 6.21% 74.77% 59,467,355 749 732 716 699 683 **716 683**  Michigan 2,256 998 1,586 053,210,78018,499,951 774,872 0 5,008 0 2,16643,259,681629,96128,595,961 0 0 42% 65% 1,827,909 4,775,710 5,061,374 5,364,125 5,684,984 6,025,037 3.59% 4.34% 5.02% 5.65% 6.22% 103.89% 112,690,037 1,482 1,462 1,4441,427 1,411 **1,445 1,411**  Minnesota 2,318 877 1,591 021,989,5845,715,510 29,243 0 2,768 0 2,22511,913,179 15,84315,805,315 0 0 24% 65% 840,190 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 7,888,544 3.58% 4.32% 4.99% 5.61% 6.17% 82.84% 73,094,4741,046 1,0341,023 1,0141,005 **1,024 1,005**  Mississippi 2,494 848 1,388 07,503,11431,813,6774,402,778 0 7,894 150 2,394 0 043,719,569614,655,831 724,680 46% 63% 631,874 2,498,626 2,834,265 3,214,992 3,646,861 4,136,743 1.12% 1.71% 2.40% 3.18% 3.93% 98.63% 52,021,589 783 773 761 749 736 **760 736**  Missouri 2,085 890 0 072,939,5124,854,569 0 0 2,079 0 2,00165,925,535 011,868,546 0 0 27% 65% 549,657 1,638,287 1,736,283 1,840,140 1,950,210 2,066,863 1.29% 1.92% 2.65% 3.46% 4.20% 99.47% 88,626,2541,757 1,742 1,727 1,7101,694 **1,726 1,694**  Montana 2,481 0 0 014,447,406 0 0 0 0 0 2,38214,447,406 0 0 0 0 0 1,598,643 1,696,078 1,799,452 1,909,126 2,025,485 3.01% 3.77% 4.47% 5.11% 5.69% 207.68% 14,904,5232,0872,0602,0352,0101,987 **2,036 1,987**  Nebraska 2,181 1,097 1,755 024,660,983 423,638 37,524 0 468 0 2,09422,414,234 34,1052,673,806 0 0 10% 65% 574,830 1,856,032 2,010,986 2,178,877 2,360,784 2,557,879 1.91% 2.67% 3.47% 4.21% 4.89% 113.44% 33,143,117 1,771 1,746 1,7201,695 1,671 **1,721 1,671**  Nevada 2,275 890 1,459 04,133,66223,783,256 279,983 0 6,381 0 2,184 0 028,196,901 0 0 42% 50% 0 3,761,262 3,990,506 4,233,722 4,491,761 4,765,528 2.67% 3.46% 4.19% 4.85% 5.45% 96.67% 37,821,930 762 750 739 728 718 **739 718**  New Hampshire 2,382 878 1,889 01,281,3416,946,869 72,614 0 1,506 0 2,287 0 08,300,824 0 0 53% 63% 575,615 2,219,730 2,499,219 2,813,899 3,168,200 3,567,113 2.56% 3.38% 4.14% 4.84% 5.49% 194.97% 11,686,618 639 619 598 578 557 **598 557**  New Jersey 2,441 973 1,473 02,602,99020,015,730 173,972 0 5,832 0 2,343 0 022,792,692 0 0 39% 44% 1,616,037 2,421,244 2,839,129 3,329,137 3,903,716 4,577,463 0.96% 1.52% 2.20% 2.96% 3.74% 76.19% 80,689,388 808 786 762 736 708 **760 708**  New Mexico 2,341 907 1,313 011,353,9875,730,9572,208,001 0 1,662 0 2,2478,205,5741,595,7329,491,639 0 0 39% 65% 0 3,261,076 3,459,834 3,670,706 3,894,431 4,131,791 2.81% 3.58% 4.28% 4.92% 5.50% 150.06% 24,919,278 1,253 1,233 1,213 1,1941,176 **1,214 1,176**  New York 2,226 974 1,366 418,527,5504,156,14344,002,77712,502,558 309,900 9,848 0 2,1371,106,6343,328,98856,225,857418,527,550 309,900 51% 65% 2,410,637 8,344,248 9,394,883 10,577,805 11,909,671 13,409,233 3.54% 4.30% 4.99% 5.62% 6.20% 93.05% 153,914,184 809 787 766 745 725 **766 725**  North Carolina 2,059 851 0 050,607,83815,195,335 0 0 4,709 2,249 1,97736,940,574 028,862,5999,248,929,14310,865,369 37% 65% 2,295,625 4,476,628 5,077,973 5,760,095 6,533,848 7,411,538 2.09% 2.87% 3.64% 4.34% 4.98% 86.12% 137,704,068 1,243 1,222 1,2001,179 1,158 **1,200 1,158**  North Dakota 2,368 0 0 028,186,691 0 0 0 0 0 2,27328,186,691 0 0 0 0 0 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 5,459,957 1.11% 1.70% 2.39% 3.18% 3.95% 259.49% 15,822,199 1,8941,889 1,883 1,876 1,870 **1,882 1,870**  Ohio 2,126 963 2,219 086,473,07520,907,183 321,602 0 4,343 539 2,04182,129,018305,44625,267,3962,506,741,5782,604,017 55% 65% 993,077 3,286,937 3,854,232 4,519,438 5,299,452 6,214,090 3.47% 4.22% 4.91% 5.54% 6.12% 85.97% 163,906,3741,6341,612 1,5901,569 1,547 **1,590 1,547**  Oklahoma 2,305 892 1,382 029,102,16029,943,3768,488,758 0 8,035 0 2,21316,766,4974,890,59045,877,207 0 0 42% 65% 0 11,742,785 12,723,153 13,785,369 14,936,266 15,579,318 1.57% 2.26% 3.03% 3.79% 4.49% 114.44% 63,797,105 1,056 1,038 1,018 999 986 **1,019 986**  Oregon 2,080 862 0 02,640,25911,424,291 0 0 3,435 0 1,996 0 014,064,550 0 0 38% 47% 0 9,131,577 9,688,134 10,278,613 10,905,080 11,569,730 3.55% 4.27% 4.92% 5.52% 6.06% 111.21% 50,195,189 485 468 452 437 423 **453 423**  Pennsylvania 2,134 902 1,515 087,052,56250,028,7191,638,387 0 9,582 0 2,04882,459,4811,551,94254,708,245 0 0 59% 65% 4,480,395 8,430,147 9,885,114 11,591,196 13,591,732 15,937,543 3.58% 4.32% 5.00% 5.62% 6.18% 142.20% 155,577,427 1,403 1,3801,357 1,332 1,307 **1,356 1,307**  Rhode Island 0 918 0 0 08,140,017 0 0 1,961 0 8,140,017 0 0 47% 47% 0 163,746 184,363 207,576 233,713 263,140 3.35% 4.11% 4.82% 5.47% 6.06% 97.63% 8,287,230 871 863 855 847 840 **855 840**  South Carolina 2,164 848 1,730 028,460,31811,209,394 405,616 0 2,839 0 2,07723,529,292335,33916,210,696 0 0 45% 65% 20,340,660 3,548,749 4,025,451 4,566,189 5,179,564 5,875,334 2.04% 2.81% 3.58% 4.29% 4.94% 115.08% 83,622,303 962 946 930 914 898 **930 898**  South Dakota 2,266 1,131 0 02,923,161 27,096 0 0 324 0 2,1751,100,347 01,849,910 0 0 1% 65% 0 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1,818,850 1.32% 1.95% 2.69% 3.49% 4.22% 82.32% 12,615,449 914 902 889 874 861 **888 861**  Tennessee 2,244 813 0 034,373,6966,548,897 0 0 1,601 0 2,15531,779,810 09,142,782 0 0 47% 65% 10,416,619 1,384,846 1,570,872 1,781,886 2,021,247 2,292,760 1.93% 2.68% 3.47% 4.20% 4.86% 71.81% 103,619,721 1,402 1,382 1,363 1,3441,326 **1,363 1,326**  Texas 2,239 970 1,3779,150,882,510138,705,138148,010,27820,911,8685,627,228 37,548 0 2,14981,028,65712,216,278214,382,3489,150,882,5105,627,228 45% 65% 2,291,006 46,879,906 50,793,762 55,034,373 59,629,020 64,607,260 1.50% 2.17% 2.93% 3.70% 4.40% 98.12% 392,523,451 1,108 1,089 1,068 1,048 1,027 **1,068 1,027**  Utah 2,071 884 1,867 027,332,1405,447,362 120,348 0 1,953 0 1,98821,651,383 95,33511,153,133 0 0 32% 65% 0 1,393,353 1,478,276 1,568,375 1,663,965 1,765,381 3.19% 3.94% 4.63% 5.25% 5.82% 127.29% 31,955,593 1,503 1,4901,477 1,465 1,453 **1,478 1,453**  Virginia 2,433 909 1,652 013,641,55223,070,350 343,908 0 4,346 1,928 2,33610,288,388259,37426,508,0488,466,572,7789,314,554 60% 65% 1,645,275 4,458,736 5,228,273 6,130,626 7,188,717 8,429,425 0.95% 1.50% 2.16% 2.91% 3.67% 58.01% 115,890,388 1,0741,051 1,026 998 968 **1,023 968**  Washington 2,432 995 0 03,735,7305,665,045 0 0 3,485 0 2,335 0 09,400,775 0 0 19% 31% 506,700 10,407,602 11,041,931 11,714,921 12,428,930 13,186,456 3.45% 4.18% 4.85% 5.45% 6.00% 107.69% 99,270,908 394 373 354 337 322 **356 322**  West Virginia 2,064 0 0 070,074,636 0 0 0 0 0 1,98270,074,636 0 0 0 0 0 2,451,206 2,874,262 3,370,334 3,952,023 4,634,107 1.49% 2.16% 2.93% 3.71% 4.44% 233.30% 33,131,616 1,902 1,885 1,866 1,845 1,823 **1,864 1,823**  Wisconsin 2,363 846 1,798 032,112,72110,244,273 47,668 0 2,977 0 2,26825,367,814 37,65616,999,192 0 0 39% 65% 546,885 4,066,362 4,309,595 4,567,377 4,840,579 5,130,122 3.60% 4.34% 5.02% 5.65% 6.22% 83.97% 73,988,479 1,462 1,441 1,422 1,403 1,386 **1,423 1,386**  Wyoming 2,331 0 0 042,907,427 0 0 0 0 220 2,23742,714,179 0 193,248964,017,6481,062,864 0 5,535,669 5,873,061 6,231,016 6,610,788 7,013,706 1.33% 1.96% 2.69% 3.47% 4.19% 256.15% 18,245,903 1,9441,926 1,908 1,888 1,869 **1,907 1,869**  **Step 4b - Existing and New Renewable (MWh) Step 5 (Demand Side EE - % of avoided MWh)**  **Steps 6&7 (State Goal Phase I & II) Steps 3a & 3b (Redispatch)** 

# These are not the Proposed or Alternative State Goals. The actual state goals include useful thermal output (UTO) and convert that into a MWh figure that is included in the state goal's denominator.

The rates in the preceding worksheets rely on the same data and calculations, but do not go through the process of including useful thermal output. The MWhs in the denominator reflect solely elecrtricity provided to the grid and deliberately exclude useful thermal output. The reason for providing these rates is twofold: 1) to help states understand their goals and the role (or lack of role) that useful thermal output plays, 2) EPA power sector modeling is based around net electricity generation and does not include useful thermal output - and can therefore provide a comprable state goal on which EPA can conduct its power sector modeling. Therefore, these parallel goals are calculated to reflect the same stringency, but simply do not fold the useful thermal output in the denominator. This allows EPA to model the state goals in a dispatch model based solely on net electricity generation. See the "Goal Computation" TSD for further discussion. For most states, the numeric difference between the Actual State goals (that include UTO), and those listed in this workbook (excluding UTO) is zero or negligible given the lack of covered cogeneration units in the state.

# These are not the Proposed or Alternative State Goals. The actual state goals include useful thermal output (UTO) and convert that into a MWh figure that is included in the state goal's denominator. The rates in the preceding worksheets rely on the same data and calculations, but do not go through the process of including useful thermal output. The MWhs in the denominator reflect solely elecrtricity provided to the grid and deliberately exclude useful thermal output. The reason for providing these rates is twofold: 1) to help states understand their goals and the role (or lack of role) that useful thermal output plays, 2) EPA power sector modeling is based around net electricity generation and does not include useful thermal output - and can therefore provide a comprable state goal on which EPA can conduct its power sector modeling. Therefore, these parallel goals are calculated to reflect the same stringency, but simply do not fold the useful thermal output in the denominator. This allows EPA to model the state goals in a dispatch model based solely on net electricity

For most states, the numeric difference between the Actual State goals (that include UTO), and those listed in this workbook (excluding UTO) is zero or negligible given the lack of covered cogeneration units

# The rates in the preceding worksheets rely on the same data and calculations, but do not go through the process of including useful thermal output. The MWhs in the denominator reflect solely elecrtricity provided to the grid and deliberately exclude useful thermal output.