,17+(81,7('67$7(6',675,&7&2857

6287+(51',675,&72)2+,2

($67(51',9,6,21

3+,/,3&+$59$7RQEHKDOIRIKLPVHOI

DQGRWKHUVVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHG

3ODLQWLII

Y

7+(6287+$5'&25325$7,21et al.

'HIHQGDQWV

&$6(12&90+:

-8'*(0,&+$(/+:$7621

0$*,675$7(-8'*(&+(/6(<0

9$6&85$

'()(1'$177+(6287+$5'&25325$7,21¶6

027,2172&203(/

8QGHU )HGHUDO 5XOH RI &LYLO 3URFHGXUH  'HIHQGDQW 7KH 6RXWKDUG &RUSRUDWLRQ

36RXWKDUG ́ PRYHV IRU DQ RUGHU FRPSHOOLQJ 3ODLQWLII 3KLOLS - &KDUYDW WR SURYLGH FRPSOHWH

UHVSRQVHVWR6RXWKDUG¶V,QWHUURJDWRU\1RVDQGDQG5HTXHVWVIRU3URGXFWLRQ1RV

DQG$VPRUHIXOO\VWDWHGLQWKHDWWDFKHGPHPRUDQGXPWKHVHUHTXHVWVVHHNLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW

3ODLQWLII¶V7&3$OLWLJDWLRQDFWLYLWLHV2LQIRUPDWLRQUHOHYDQWWRZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIIODFNVVWDQGLQJWR

VXH 6RXWKDUG DQG WR ZKHWKHU 3ODLQWLII ZRXOG EH DQ LQDGHTXDWH DW\SLFDO SURSRVHG FODVV

UHSUHVHQWDWLYH

8QGHU 6' 2KLR&LY5  6RXWKDUG FHUWLILHVWKDWLW KDV H[KDXVWHG DOO H[WUDMXGLFLDO

PHDQV IRU UHVROYLQJ WKLV GLVSXWH ZLWKRXW &RXUW LQYROYHPHQW  See 0HHWDQG&RQIHU

&RUUHVSRQGHQFHDWWDFKHGDV([KLELWV&±(

 

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 1 of 13 PAGEID #: 326




5HVSHFWIXOO\VXEPLWWHG

/s/ Douglas A. Vonderhaar 

5DQG/0F&OHOODQ7ULDO$WWRUQH\

'RXJODV$9RQGHUKDDU

.DWKHULQH5-RKQVWRQ

%DNHU	+RVWHWOHU//3

&LYLF&HQWHU'ULYH6XLWH

&ROXPEXV2KLR

7HOHSKRQH

)DFVLPLOH 

UPFFOHOODQ#EDNHUODZFRP

GYRQGHUKDDU#EDNHUODZFRP

NMRKQVWRQ#EDNHUODZFRP

Attorneys for Defendant 

The Southard Corporation

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 2 of 13 PAGEID #: 327




,17+(81,7('67$7(6',675,&7&2857

)257+(6287+(51',675,&72)2+,2

($67(51',9,6,21

3+,/,3&+$59$7RQEHKDOIRIKLPVHOI

DQGRWKHUVVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHG

3ODLQWLII

Y

7+(6287+$5'&25325$7,21et al.

'HIHQGDQWV

&$6(12&90+:

-8'*(0,&+$(/+:$7621

0$*,675$7(-8'*(&+(/6(<0

9$6&85$

0(025$1'80,168332572)'()(1'$177+(6287+$5'

&25325$7,21¶6027,2172&203(/

, ,1752'8&7,21$1'%$&.*5281'

33KLOLS&KDUYDWKDVQRWEHHQVK\LQWDNLQJRQWKHUROHRIDSULYDWHDWWRUQH\JHQHUDOXQGHU

WKH7HOHSKRQH&RQVXPHU3URWHFWLRQ$FW ́Charvat v. EchoStar Satellite, LLC)G

WK&LU  +H DGPLWVWKDW KHLV D SODLQWLIILQ IRXU DOOHJHG 7&3$ FODVV DFWLRQV FXUUHQWO\

SHQGLQJDFURVVWKHFRXQWU\See 3O¶V)LUVW'LVF5HVSDWWDFKHGDV([KLELW$2QHIHGHUDOFRXUW

UHIHUUHGWRKLVSUDFWLFHVDQGRSHUDWLRQDVDQ3HQWHUSULVH ́Desai v. ADT,&DVH1R&

86'LVW/(;,6DW
±1',OO0D\UHIHUHQFLQJ3ODLQWLII¶VFDVHV

DVRIWKDWWLPHDQGFRQFOXGLQJWKDW3>W@KLVVHHPVWRKDYHEHFRPHDELWRIDQHQWHUSULVH IRU0U

&KDUYDW ́

7KHVHIDFWVDUHQRWPHUHWULYLD7KH\DUHUHOHYDQWWRZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIIPD\ODFNVWDQGLQJ

DQGZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIIZRXOGEHDQDGHTXDWHW\SLFDOFODVV UHSUHVHQWDWLYH2DQGLQWXUQZKHWKHU

DQ\IXWXUHPRWLRQIRUFODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQVKRXOGEHGHQLHG7KDWLVZK\LQLWVGLVFRYHU\UHTXHVWV

6RXWKDUGVRXJKWLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW3ODLQWLII¶V7&3$OLWLJDWLRQDFWLYLW\







5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ1RZDVWHPSRUDOO\OLPLWHGWR\HDUVDQG,QWHUURJDWRU\1RVDQGZHUHOLPLWHGWR

HLJKW\HDUV

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 3 of 13 PAGEID #: 328




,QWHUURJDWRU\1R,GHQWLI\HYHU\VHWWOHPHQWRUDZDUGPRQHWDU\RURWKHUZLVH

WKDW\RXKDYHUHFHLYHG>ZLWKRU@

ZLWKRXWILOLQJDODZVXLW5HODWHGWRDQ\DOOHJDWLRQ

RUFKDUJHWKDW\RXPDGHWKDWD3HUVRQYLRODWHGWKH7&3$RUDQ\RILWVLPSOHPHQWLQJ

UHJXODWLRQVDQGIRUHDFK,GHQWLI\WKHDPRXQWRIDQ\VHWWOHPHQWRUDZDUGWKDW\RX

UHFHLYHGDQGWKH3HUVRQZKRSDLGLW6RXWKDUG¶V)LUVW6HWRI'LVFRYHU\5HTXHVWV

DWWDFKHGDV([KLELW%DW

,QWHUURJDWRU\ 1R  ,GHQWLI\ RQ DQ DQQXDO EDVLVWKHWRWDO DPRXQW RI PRQH\

LQFOXGLQJZDJHVDQGSD\PHQWWR\RX5HODWLQJWROLWLJDWLRQRUWKUHDWHQHGOLWLJDWLRQ

<RXKDYHUHFHLYHGIRUWKHSDVWHLJKW\HDUVDQGIRUHDFKVRXUFHRIPRQH\LGHQWLI\

ZKRSDLG<RXWKHUHYHQXHDQG<RXUMRERUWLWOHLIDQ\Id.

,QWHUURJDWRU\1R,GHQWLI\RQDQDQQXDOEDVLVWKHQXPEHURIKRXUVLQWKHSDVW

HLJKW \HDUV WKDW <RX KDYH VSHQW PRQLWRULQJ <RXU WHOHSKRQH FDOOV RU ORJV

FRUUHVSRQGLQJZLWKWHOHPDUNHWHUVDQGSDUWLFLSDWLQJLQ7&3$ODZVXLWVId. DW

,QWHUURJDWRU\1R,GHQWLI\DOOOLVWVHUYVZHEVLWHVLQWHUQHWIRUXPVDQGRWKHU

GLVFXVVLRQ JURXSV FKDW URRPV RU DQ\ RWKHU VLWH WKDW \RX KDYH SDUWLFLSDWHG LQ

YLHZHGRURWKHUZLVHDFFHVVHGVLQFHWKDWUHIHUVRUUHODWHVWRWKH7&3$IdDW



5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ1R)RUHYHU\WHOHSKRQHQXPEHU,GHQWLILHGLQUHVSRQVH

WR,QWHUURJDWRU\1RSURGXFHHYHU\'RFXPHQWWKDWUHIOHFWVD5HFRUGRUORJRI

FDOOVPDGHWRDQGIURPHDFKQXPEHUIRUWKHODVWIRXU\HDUVIdDW

5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ1R3URGXFHDOORI<RXUIHGHUDODQGVWDWHWD[UHWXUQV

IURPWRWKHSUHVHQWIdDW

$OO RI WKLV GLVFRYHU\ LV DLPHG DW GHWHUPLQLQJ 3ODLQWLII¶V ILQDQFLDO LQFHQWLYHV WR VROLFLW RU EDLW

WHOHPDUNHWHUVDQG3ODLQWLII¶VHIIRUWVDQGPHDQVLQIXUWKHUDQFHRIWKDWJRDO

3ODLQWLIIKRZHYHUUHIXVHVWRSURYLGHDQVZHUVDQGUHVSRQVHVWRWKHVHUHTXHVWV3ODLQWLII

ZRQ¶WHYHQHQJDJHLQFRQVWUXFWLYHGLDORJXHUHJDUGLQJWKHVHWRSLFV,QVWHDG3ODLQWLIIVWRQHZDOOHG

DQG VWDWHG GXULQJ WKH PHHWDQGFRQIHU SURFHVV WKDW 3ZKLOH EHLQJ FRPSOHWHO\ LUUHOHYDQW WKH

GLVFRYHU\UHTXHVWVDUHKLJKO\EXUGHQVRPH ́0LVQ\¶V/WUWR9RQGHUKDDUDWWDFKHGDV

([KLELW'see also ([$ DW ±    (YHQ DIWHU 6RXWKDUGH[SODLQHGLWV UHOHYDQFH





7KLVUHYLVLRQDPHQGVDW\SRLQWKH,QWHUURJDWRU\7KLVUHYLVLRQGRHVQRWDIIHFWWKHDQDO\VLVEHFDXVH3ODLQWLII

FDWHJRULFDOO\REMHFWVWRUHVSRQGLQJWRGLVFRYHU\RQWKHVHWRSLFV

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 4 of 13 PAGEID #: 329




SRVLWLRQDQGLGHQWLILHGFDVHODZ

DQGD UXOLQJ IURPWKLV&RXUW VXSSRUWLQJ SURGXFWLRQ3ODLQWLII

QHYHUUHIXWHGLW2DQGQHYHUVXEVWDQWLDWHGLWVEXUGHQREMHFWLRQSee 9RQGHUKDDU/WU

WR0LVQ\DWWDFKHGDV([KLELW& 9RQGHUKDDU(PDLOWR0LVQ\DWWDFKHGDV([KLELW(

,QVWHDG3ODLQWLIIGLUHFWHG6RXWKDUGWRDGHFODUDWLRQKHILOHGLQDVHSDUDWH7&3$ODZVXLWOLWLJDWHG

E\WKHVDPHFRXQVHODVKHUHZKHUHLQKHQRWHGWKDW3KHZRXOGQHHGWRVSHQGRYHURQHKXQGUHG

KRXUV WR UHVSRQG WR WKH GLVFRYHU\ EHLQJ UHTXHVWHG RQ KLV VWDWXV DV D VRFDOOHG μSURIHVVLRQDO

SODLQWLII¶ ́See (['DW

:KLOH3ODLQWLIIFRPSODLQVGLVFRYHU\LVEXUGHQVRPHKHIDLOVWRDUWLFXODWHZK\LWLVXQGXO\

EXUGHQVRPHZKLFKLVWKHUHOHYDQWVWDQGDUGSurles ex rel. Johnson v. Greyhound Lines, Inc.

)GWK&LU0RUHRYHU3ODLQWLIILVLQGHHGD3SURIHVVLRQDO ́RU3DGYRFDWH ́ZKR

KDVDVLJQLILFDQWILQDQFLDOLQFHQWLYHLQKLV7&3$OLWLJDWLRQ7KDW3ODLQWLIILVD3SURIHVVLRQDO ́LVQRW

SHMRUDWLYHLQVWHDGLWPHDQVKLVDFWLRQVLQIXUWKHUDQFHRIKLVHQWHUSULVHVXEMHFWKLPMXVWOLNHDQ\

RWKHUEXVLQHVVWRGLVFRYHU\WKDWPDQ\FRXUWVLQFOXGLQJWKLVRQHKDYHGHHPHGUHOHYDQWWRWKHFODVV

FHUWLILFDWLRQTXHVWLRQ3ODLQWLII¶VUHIXVDOWRSURYLGHWKLVGLVFRYHU\LVXQMXVWLILHG

,, /$:$1'$5*80(17

$ 6RXWKDUGVHHNVLQIRUPDWLRQUHOHYDQWWRVWDQGLQJDQGFODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQ

8QGHU5XOHDSDUW\LVHQWLWOHGWRLQIRUPDWLRQWKDWLVUHOHYDQWWRDQ\FODLPDQGGHIHQVH

)HG5&LY3E7KHVWDQGLQJDQG5XOHLVVXHVWRZKLFKWKHGLVFRYHU\DERYHLVDLPHG

DUHUHOHYDQWWRWKLVSXWDWLYHFODVVDFWLRQ6RXWKDUGVKRXOGEHSHUPLWWHGGLVFRYHU\LQWRWKHVHLVVXHV





7KHGLVSXWHGGLVFRYHU\UHTXHVWVDUHUHOHYDQWEHFDXVHWKH\JRWR3ODLQWLII¶VVWDWXVDVDSURIHVVLRQDO7&3$SODLQWLII

ZKLFKPD\UHQGHUKLPDQLQDGHTXDWHRUDW\SLFDOUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIKLVDOOHJHGFODVVSee, e.g., Stoops v. Wells Fargo 

Bank1$)6XSSG±:'3D

 Johansen v. Modernize, Inc.&DVH1RFY86'LVW/(;,6DW
6'2KLR0DU

ILQGLQJWKDWLQIRUPDWLRQUHODWHGWRSODLQWLII¶VVWDWXVDVD33URIHVVLRQDO3ODLQWLII ́FRXOGEHUHOHYDQWWRKLV

VWDQGLQJWREULQJD7&3$ODZVXLW

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 5 of 13 PAGEID #: 330




 6WDQGLQJ

 

 $SODLQWLIIODFNVVWDQGLQJZLWKRXWD3OHJDOO\SURWHFWHGLQWHUHVW ́WRDVVHUWStoops v. Wells 

Fargo Bank, N.A.  ) 6XSS G   :' 3D  TXRWLQJLujan v. Defenders of 

Wildlife868QGHUWKH7&3$WKDWOHJDOO\SURWHFWHGLQWHUHVWLVUHOLHIIURP

3WKHSUROLIHUDWLRQRILQWUXVLYHQXLVDQFH>WHOHPDUNHWLQJ@FDOOVWR>SODLQWLIIV¶@KRPHV ́Id. TXRWLQJ

Mims v. Arrow Fin. Servs., LLC86LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQVRPLWWHG%XWD

SODLQWLIIZKRZDQWVRUWULHV WREHFDOOHGSHUKDSVVRWKDWKHFDQILOHDQDOOHJHG7&3$FODVVDFWLRQ

KDVQRVXFKLQWHUHVWWRSURWHFW7KDWSODLQWLIIODFNVVWDQGLQJSee id.DW±

7KHStoops SODLQWLIIIRUH[DPSOHPDGHDEXVLQHVVRXWRI7&3$OLWLJDWLRQVKHILOHGDWOHDVW

HOHYHQ 7&3$ ODZVXLWV VHQW PRUH WKDQ WZHQW\ GHPDQG OHWWHUV WR SRWHQWLDO 7&3$ GHIHQGDQWV

ERXJKWPXOWLSOHFHOOSKRQHVDQGWUDFNHGKHUFDOOVRQDORJId.DW±6KHZDQWHGWKHFDOOV2

LIVKHJRWHQRXJKRIWKHPVKH3ZDVKRSHIXOO\JRLQJWRDVN>KHU@ODZ\HUVWRGR>GDPDJHV@WUHEOLQJ

ZLWKNQRZLQJDQGZLOOIXO ́DOOHJHG7&3$YLRODWLRQVId. )RUWKHVHUHDVRQVDQGPRUHWKHSODLQWLII

ODFNHG ERWK FRQVWLWXWLRQDO DQG SUXGHQWLDO VWDQGLQJ WR VXH  Id. DW  see also Johansen v. 

Modernize, Inc.1R86'LVW/(;,6DW
6'2KLR0DUGLUHFWLQJ

3ODLQWLII WR UHVSRQG WR GLVFRYHU\ UHTXHVWV UHODWLQJ WR KLV DFWLYLWLHV DV D SRWHQWLDO 33URIHVVLRQDO

3ODLQWLII ́

 6LPLODUO\3ODLQWLIIKHUHLVDSUROLILF7&3$ILOHUZKRDSSHDUVWRWUDFNDOORIKLVFDOOV,WDOVR

DSSHDUVWKDW3ODLQWLII¶VSUDFWLFHXSRQUHFHLYLQJZKDWPLJKWEHDWHOHPDUNHWLQJFDOOLVWRLQTXLUH

DERXWWKHVHUYLFHVRUSURGXFWVDQGUHIUDLQIURPWHOOLQJWKHFDOOHUWRVWRSFDOOLQJDOOLQWKHKRSHVRI

EDLWLQJDGGLWLRQDOFDOOV6RXWKDUGLVHQWLWOHGWRNQRZLIDGGLWLRQDOVLPLODUIDFWVH[LVWDVWR3ODLQWLII

See Marsico v. Sears Holding Corp.)$SS¶[WK&LUQRWLQJWKHH[WUHPHO\

EURDGVFRSHRIGLVFRYHU\SHUPLWWHGWRDOOSDUWLHVWR3GHILQHDQGFODULI\ ́LVVXHVIRUWULDO6RXWKDUG

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 6 of 13 PAGEID #: 331




VHHNV 3ODLQWLII¶V FDOO ORJV DQG UHFRUGV 5HTXHVW IRU 3URGXFWLRQ 1R  WD[ UHWXUQV WR JDXJH

3ODLQWLII¶VILQDQFLDOLQWHUHVWLQSRWHQWLDOO\JHQHUDWLQJFODLPVDQGGDPDJHV5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ

1R SUHOLWLJDWLRQ 7&3$ VHWWOHPHQWV ,QWHUURJDWRU\ 1R  UHYHQXH VRXUFHV ,QWHUURJDWRU\

1R WLPH VSHQW RQ WHOHPDUNHWLQJ FDOOV DQG 7&3$ OLWLJDWLRQ ,QWHUURJDWRU\ 1R  DQG

SDUWLFLSDWLRQZLWK7&3$OLVWVHUYVZHEVLWHV,QWHUURJDWRU\1R7KLVLQIRUPDWLRQLVUHOHYDQWWR

ZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIIODFNVDSURWHFWHGLQWHUHVWDQGVWDQGLQJWRVXHXQGHUWKH7&3$DQGZKHWKHUKH

FRXOGEHDQDGHTXDWHFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH

 &ODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQ

 &ODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQPXVWEHGHQLHGLI3ODLQWLII¶VFODLPVDQGGHIHQVHVDUHQRW3typicalRIWKH

FODLPVRUGHIHQVHVRIWKH>DOOHJHG@FODVV ́)HG5&LY3DHPSKDVLVDGGHG6RWRRLI

3ODLQWLIIZLOOQRW3IDLUO\DQGadequatelySURWHFWWKHLQWHUHVWVRIWKH>DOOHJHG@FODVV ́)HG5&LY

3 D HPSKDVLV DGGHG $ SODLQWLII ZKR EDLWV GHIHQGDQWVLQWRPDNLQJ DOOHJHGO\ 7&3$

YLRODWLQJFDOOVLVQHLWKHUW\SLFDOQRUDGHTXDWHSUHFOXGLQJFODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQSee Nghiem v. Dick’s 

Sporting Goods, Inc.)5'±&'&DO

 7RPDQXIDFWXUHD7&3$FDVHWKHNghiem SODLQWLIIVLJQHGXSIRUWKHGHIHQGDQW¶VPRELOH

DOHUWVEHFDXVHKHZDQWHG WKHGHIHQGDQWWRPHVVDJHKLPId. DW7KHVHDFWLRQVUHQGHUHGWKH

SODLQWLIIDQLQDGHTXDWHSURSRVHGFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHEHFDXVHDFODVVDFWLRQZRXOGKDYHFHQWHUHG

RQLVVXHVDQGGHIHQVHVXQLTXHWRWKHSODLQWLIIId.DW±7KHGHIHQGDQWVZRXOGDUJXHWKDWWKH

SODLQWLIIGLGQRWVXIIHUDQLQYDVLRQRISULYDF\ IRUH[DPSOHDQGWKH\ZRXOGODXQFK3DWWDFNVRQ

>SODLQWLII¶V@FKDUDFWHUDQGKLVPRWLYDWLRQVIRUILOLQJDQGOLWLJDWLQJWKHODZVXLW ́Id.DW7KH

SODLQWLIIDOVRZDVDQDW\SLFDOSXWDWLYHFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHGXHWRKLVH[WHQVLYHH[SHULHQFHZLWK

DQGNQRZOHGJHRI7&3$ODZVXLWVId.DWSee Johansen v. Nat’l Gas & Elec. LLC1R

FY86'LVW/(;,6DW
6'2KLR'HF*UDKDP-VWDWLQJ

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 7 of 13 PAGEID #: 332




WKDWSODLQWLIIIHLJQLQJLQWHUHVWLQGHIHQGDQW¶VVHUYLFHV3FDVWVHULRXVGRXEWV ́RQWKHSODLQWLII¶VDELOLW\

WRVHUYHDVDQDGHTXDWH7&3$FODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH

 3ODLQWLIIKDVVLPLODULIQRWPRUHH[WHQVLYHH[SHULHQFHDQGNQRZOHGJHKHUHSee Charvat 

v. EchoStar)GDWsee also ([$DW±GLVFORVLQJIRXUSHQGLQJDOOHJHG7&3$FODVV

DFWLRQVLQZKLFK&KDUYDWSURSRVHVWRVHUYHDVFODVV UHSUHVHQWDWLYH0RUHRYHU3ODLQWLII IHLJQV

LQWHUHVWLQVHUYLFHVWRVROLFLWDGGLWLRQDOFDOOVSee 'HI¶V0RWIRU3DUWLDO-RQWKH3OHDGLQJVSS

±'RF3ODLQWLII¶VFDOOORJVDQGUHFRUGV5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ1RWD[UHWXUQVWR

JDXJH 3ODLQWLII¶V ILQDQFLDO LQWHUHVW LQ SRWHQWLDOO\ JHQHUDWLQJ FODLPV DQG GDPDJHV 5HTXHVW IRU

3URGXFWLRQ 1R SUHOLWLJDWLRQ 7&3$ VHWWOHPHQWV ,QWHUURJDWRU\ 1R  UHYHQXH VRXUFHV

,QWHUURJDWRU\1RWLPHVSHQWRQWHOHPDUNHWLQJFDOOVDQG7&3$OLWLJDWLRQ,QWHUURJDWRU\1R

DQGSDUWLFLSDWLRQZLWK7&3$OLVWVHUYVZHEVLWHV,QWHUURJDWRU\1RDUHDOOUHOHYDQWWRWKLV

H[SHULHQFHDQG NQRZOHGJH2DQGWRZKHWKHUDGGLWLRQDO IDFWVH[LVWFRQFHUQLQJ3ODLQWLII¶V7&3$

WDFWLFVZKLFKPD\EHGHVLJQHGWREDLWFDOOVWRWULJJHUWKH7&3$DQGRULQFUHDVHKLV3GDPDJHV ́

7KLVUHOHYDQWGLVFRYHU\PD\DOORZ6RXWKDUGWRPRXQWGHIHQVHVVLPLODUWRWKRVHLQNghiemWKDW

3ODLQWLIILVDQLQDGHTXDWHDQGDW\SLFDOSURSRVHGFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH

% 6RXWKDUGVHHNVGLVFRYHU\SURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHQHHGVRIWKHFDVH

3ODLQWLIIKDVQRWHYHQDWWHPSWHGWRPHHWKLVEXUGHQWRVKRZWKDWWKHGLVFRYHU\VRXJKWLV

XQGXO\EXUGHQVRPHRULVRWKHUZLVHQRWGLVFRYHUDEOHXQGHU5XOHESee William Powell Co. 

v. Nat’l Indem. Co.1RFY86'LVW/(;,6DW
±6'2KLR$SU

,QVWHDG3ODLQWLIIKDVEORFNHGDQ\LQTXLU\ZKDWVRHYHU

7KH 5XOH E IDFWRUV2LPSRUWDQFH RI WKH LVVXHV DW VWDNH DPRXQW LQ FRQWURYHUV\

SDUWLHV¶UHODWLYHDFFHVVWRUHOHYDQWLQIRUPDWLRQLPSRUWDQFHRIWKHGLVFRYHU\LQUHVROYLQJWKHLVVXHV





6RXWKDUGZDVZLOOLQJWRZRUNFRRSHUDWLYHO\ZLWK3ODLQWLIIWROLPLWLWVGLVFRYHU\DVDSSURSULDWHEXWLWZDVSUHYHQWHG

IURPGRLQJVRE\3ODLQWLII¶VUHIXVDOWRDUWLFXODWHWKHEXUGHQRUSURYLGHDQ\LQIRUPDWLRQZKDWVRHYHU

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 8 of 13 PAGEID #: 333




DQG ZKHWKHU WKH EXUGHQ RU H[SHQVH RI WKH SURSRVHG GLVFRYHU\ RXWZHLJKV LWV OLNHO\ EHQHILW2

HVWDEOLVKWKDWWKHGLVFRYHU\LVSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHQHHGVRIWKHFDVHSee id.DW
±)LUVWWKH

GLVFRYHU\LVDLPHGDWLPSRUWDQWLVVXHVRIZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIIODFNVVWDQGLQJDQGZKHWKHU3ODLQWLIILV

DQLQDGHTXDWHRUDW\SLFDOSXWDWLYHFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH,I3ODLQWLIILVDQLQDGHTXDWHSXWDWLYHFODVV

UHSUHVHQWDWLYHWKHQDFODVVZLOOQRWEHFHUWLILHG$QGLI3ODLQWLIIODFNVVWDQGLQJWKHQWKLVFDVHZLOO

EHGLVPLVVHGHQWLUHO\6HFRQGWKHDPRXQWLQFRQWURYHUV\LVVLJQLILFDQW3ODLQWLIIDOOHJHVWKDWKLV

SURSRVHGFODVVPHPEHUVQXPEHU3DWOHDVWLQWKHWKRXVDQGV ́3O¶V)LUVW$P&RPSO'RF

DW:KLOH6RXWKDUGGHQLHVWKDWLWYLRODWHGWKH7&3$DQGGLVSXWHV3ODLQWLII¶VFODVVDOOHJDWLRQV

LIDFODVVZHUHFHUWLILHGWKHQ6RXWKDUGPLJKWKDYHWRGHIHQGDJDLQVWOLDELOLW\WR3WKRXVDQGV ́RI

SHRSOH  3ODLQWLII DOVR DOOHJHV 3ZLOOIXO ́ YLRODWLRQV RI WKH 7&3$ ZKLFK SURYLGHV IRU VWDWXWRU\

GDPDJHVRISHUFDOO3O¶V)LUVW$P&RPSO'RFDW$VVXPLQJDFODVVRI

SHRSOHDQGGDPDJHVIRUD3ZLOOIXO ́YLRODWLRQRIWKHVWDWXWHPHDQVDPLQLPXPRIPLOOLRQ

LQGDPDJHV7KDWDPRXQWGZDUIVWKHFRVWWR3ODLQWLIIRIFROOHFWLQJKLVGRFXPHQWVDQGLQIRUPDWLRQ

DERXW KLV FDOO ORJV DQG UHFRUGV SUHOLWLJDWLRQ VHWWOHPHQWV UHYHQXH VRXUFHV DQG WLPH VSHQW RQ

WHOHPDUNHWLQJFDOOVDQG7&3$OLWLJDWLRQ

)LQDOO\WKHUHTXHVWHGLQIRUPDWLRQLVLQ3ODLQWLII¶VSRVVHVVLRQDQGZLWKRXWLW6RXWKDUGZLOO

EH KDPSHUHG LQ LWV DELOLW\ WR DVVHUW VWDQGLQJ DQG FODVV FHUWLILFDWLRQ GHIHQVHV  7KLV UHTXHVWHG

GLVFRYHU\LVSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHQHHGVRIWKHFDVH

& 3ODLQWLII¶VERLOHUSODWHREMHFWLRQVGRQRWH[FXVHKLPIURP6RXWKDUG¶VGLVFRYHU\

UHTXHVWV

 %HFDXVH6RXWKDUG KDVPHWLWV EXUGHQ RIHVWDEOLVKLQJWKDWLW VHHNV UHOHYDQW SURSRUWLRQDO

GRFXPHQWVDQGLQIRUPDWLRQ3ODLQWLIIEHDUVWKHEXUGHQRIUHVLVWLQJSURGXFWLRQRIWKRVHGRFXPHQWV

DQGLQIRUPDWLRQWilkinson v. Greater Dayton Reg’l Transit Auth.1RFY86

'LVW/(;,6DW
6'2KLR$XJ$QG3ODLQWLIIFDQQRWPHHWWKDWEXUGHQ

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 9 of 13 PAGEID #: 334




ZLWK ERLOHUSODWH REMHFWLRQV WKDW 3DQ LQWHUURJDWRU\ RU UHTXHVW IRU SURGXFWLRQ LV RYHUO\ EURDG

EXUGHQVRPHRSSUHVVLYHDQGLUUHOHYDQW ́Id.DW
±

 <HWERLOHUSODWHLVDOOWKDW3ODLQWLIIRIIHUV3ODLQWLII¶VREMHFWLRQVWR,QWHUURJDWRU\1RV

DQGZKLFKVHHN3ODLQWLII¶VSUHOLWLJDWLRQ7&3$VHWWOHPHQWVUHYHQXHVRXUFHVDQGWLPHVSHQWRQ

WHOHPDUNHWLQJFDOOVDQG7&3$OLWLJDWLRQPHUHO\VWDWHWKH\DUHLUUHOHYDQW3XQGXO\EXUGHQVRPH ́

DQG3QRWUHDVRQDEOHLQWHUPVRIWHPSRUDOVFRSH ́See ([$DW±3ODLQWLIIREMHFWVWR5HTXHVW

IRU3URGXFWLRQ1RDVLUUHOHYDQWDQGXQGXO\EXUGHQVRPHEXWOLNHZLVH IDLOVWRH[SDQGRQLWV

ERLOHUSODWHREMHFWLRQSee ([$DW3ODLQWLIIDOVRREMHFWVWR,QWHUURJDWRU\1RDVLUUHOHYDQW

DQGXQGXO\EXUGHQVRPHSee ([$DW3ODLQWLIIKRZHYHUIDLOVWRVXEVWDQWLDWHDQ\RIWKHVH

REMHFWLRQV,QVWHDGKHFLWHVWRD1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI,OOLQRLVRSLQLRQCharvat v. Travel Services

ZKLFKGRHVQRWLQYROYHLQWHUURJDWRULHVRUUHTXHVWVIRUSURGXFWLRQVLPLODUWRWKRVHDWLVVXHLQWKLV

FDVHDQGZKLFKSUHGDWHVWKHUHFHQWFDVHODZGHYHORSPHQWVLQStoops DQGNghiemE\WZR\HDUV

$QGLQTravel Services0U&KDUYDWKDGDOUHDG\SURGXFHGDPDMRULW\RIWKHGRFXPHQWVWKDWDUHLQ

GLVSXWHKHUHSee Charvat v. Travel Servs. et al.1R&'RFDW1',OO$SU

DWWDFKHGDV([KLELW)

 ,QUHVSRQVHWR5HTXHVWIRU3URGXFWLRQ1RZKLFKVHHNV3ODLQWLII¶VFDOOORJVDQGUHFRUGV

3ODLQWLII DGGV D ELW PRUH ERLOHUSODWH WR KLV SUHYLRXV REMHFWLRQV WKDW LW ZRXOG EH 3XQGXO\

EXUGHQVRPHWRFRPSLOHDOORIWKHVHUHFRUGV ́([$DW±3ODLQWLIIGRHVQRWDUJXHWKDWWKHVH

GRFXPHQWVDUHQRWLQKLVFXVWRG\RUFRQWURO)HG5&LY3D6R3ODLQWLII¶VREMHFWLRQVGR

QRWFKDQJHWKDW6RXWKDUGVHHNVUHOHYDQWSURSRUWLRQDOGLVFRYHU\

' 3ODLQWLII¶VIDLOXUHWRSURSHUO\UHVSRQGWRGLVFRYHU\UHTXHVWVHQWLWOHV6RXWKDUG

WRUHDVRQDEOHDWWRUQH\¶VIHHVXQGHU)HG5&LY3J

$WWRUQH\VRUWKHSDUWLHVSHUVRQDOO\DUHUHTXLUHG3WRFHUWLI\WKDWGLVFRYHU\UHVSRQVHVDQG

REMHFWLRQVDUHVXSSRUWHGE\QRQIULYRORXVDUJXPHQWDQGDUHQRWDLPHGWRKDUDVVFDXVHGHOD\RU

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 10 of 13 PAGEID #: 335




GULYHXSOLWLJDWLRQFRVWV ́Jones v. Ill. Cent. R.R. Co.)GWK&LUsee also

)HG5&LY3J7KHUHIRUH5XOHJGHPDQGV3WKDWWKHDWWRUQH\PDNHD UHDVRQDEOH

LQTXLU\LQWRWKHIDFWXDOEDVLVRIKLVUHVSRQVHUHTXHVWRUREMHFWLRQ ́)HG5&LY3DGYLVRU\

FRPPLWWHH¶VQRWHV

:KHQGHWHUPLQLQJZKHWKHUDSDUW\RUDQDWWRUQH\KDVPDGHDUHDVRQDEOHLQTXLU\DFRXUW

DSSOLHVDQREMHFWLYHVWDQGDUG)HG5&LY3DGYLVRU\FRPPLWWHH¶VQRWHVRQDPHQGPHQWV

Brown v. Tellermate Holdings Ltd.1RFY86'LVW/(;,6DW
6'

2KLR-XO\,IDQDWWRUQH\YLRODWHV5XOHJZLWKRXWD3VXEVWDQWLDOMXVWLILFDWLRQ ́WKHFRXUW

3PXVW LPSRVH DQ DSSURSULDWH VDQFWLRQ ́ ZKLFK PD\ LQFOXGH 3DQ RUGHU WR SD\ WKH UHDVRQDEOH

H[SHQVHVLQFOXGLQJDWWRUQH\¶VIHHVFDXVHGE\WKHYLRODWLRQ ́)HG5&LY3JJones

)G DW 5XOH J VSHFLILFDOO\ HQFRXUDJHVWKHLPSRVLWLRQ RI VDQFWLRQVLQ RUGHUWR 3FXUE

GLVFRYHU\ DEXVH ́  )HG 5 &LY 3 J DGYLVRU\ FRPPLWWHH¶V QRWHV RQ  DPHQGPHQWV

McGuire v. Metro Life Ins. Co.1RFY86'LVW/(;,6DW
 ('

0LFK$SU

3ODLQWLIIODFNVDQ\OHWDORQHVXEVWDQWLDOMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUKLVIODWUHIXVDOWRUHVSRQGWRWKLV

GLVFRYHU\6RXWKDUGVSHFLILHGWKHUHDVRQVLWVRXJKWWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ7KRVHUHDVRQVSHUWDLQWRWKH

FRUHRIWKLVFDVH2FODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQ2DQG IXQGDPHQWDOLVVXHVRIVWDQGLQJ6RXWKDUGLGHQWLILHG

FDVHODZWKDWVTXDUHO\VXSSRUWVLWVUHDVRQLQJ6RXWKDUGDOVRLGHQWLILHGDUXOLQJIURPWKLV&RXUW

DJDLQVW DQRWKHU SUROLILF 7&3$ SODLQWLII DOVR UHSUHVHQWHG E\0U &KDUYDW¶V FRXQVHO KHUH WKDW

RUGHUHG WKH SODLQWLII WR UHVSRQG WR YLUWXDOO\ LGHQWLFDO GLVFRYHU\ UHJDUGLQJ KLV 7&3$ OLWLJDWLRQ

DFWLYLWLHV  ,Q UHVSRQVH 3ODLQWLII RIIHUV RQO\ ERLOHUSODWH2KH GRHV QRW GLVWLQJXLVK 6RXWKDUG¶V

DXWKRULWLHVRURIIHUDQ\UHDVRQHGEDVLVZKDWVRHYHUIRUUHIXVDO

3ODLQWLIIODFNVVXEVWDQWLDOMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUKLVUHIXVDOWRSURYLGHUHOHYDQWDQGGLVFRYHUDEOH

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 11 of 13 PAGEID #: 336




LQIRUPDWLRQ3ODLQWLII¶VUHIXVDOKDVLQFUHDVHGOLWLJDWLRQFRVWVDQGUHVXOWHGLQWKLVPRWLRQWRFRPSHO

6RXWKDUGWKHUHIRUHUHTXHVWVWKHIHHVDQGFRVWVLWLQFXUUHGLQKDYLQJWRGUDIWWKLVPRWLRQ

,,, &21&/86,21

 3ODLQWLII¶V 7&3$ SUROLILF OLWLJDWLRQ PD\ GHSULYH KLP RI VWDQGLQJ DQG UHQGHU KLP DQ

LQDGHTXDWHDW\SLFDOSXWDWLYHFODVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH7KH&RXUWVKRXOGDOORZ6RXWKDUGGLVFRYHU\LQWR

WKHVHGHIHQVHVJUDQWLWVPRWLRQWRFRPSHODQGDZDUGIHHVIRUWKLVPRWLRQ

      5HVSHFWIXOO\VXEPLWWHG

/s/ Douglas A. Vonderhaar 

5DQG/0F&OHOODQ7ULDO$WWRUQH\

'RXJODV$9RQGHUKDDU

.DWKHULQH5-RKQVWRQ

%DNHU	+RVWHWOHU//3

&LYLF&HQWHU'ULYH6XLWH

&ROXPEXV2KLR

7HOHSKRQH 

)DFVLPLOH 

UPFFOHOODQ#EDNHUODZFRP

GYRQGHUKDDU#EDNHUODZFRP

NMRKQVWRQ#EDNHUODZFRP

Attorneys for Defendant 

The Southard Corporation

 

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 12 of 13 PAGEID #: 337




&(57,),&$7(2)6(59,&(

,KHUHE\FHUWLI\WKDWRQ)HEUXDU\,HOHFWURQLFDOO\ILOHGWKHIRUHJRLQJZLWKWKH&OHUN

RIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUWIRUWKH6RXWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRWKURXJKWKH&0(&)V\VWHP

WKHUHE\DXWRPDWLFDOO\VHUYLQJDOOUHJLVWHUHGSDUWLHV

/s/ Douglas A. Vonderhaar 

Counsel for Defendant

The Southard Corporation 

Case: 2:18-cv-00190-MHW-CMV Doc #: 38 Filed: 02/01/19 Page: 13 of 13 PAGEID #: 338