## Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (1 of 4)



# Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs

**Landfill Option Total Cost:**  **Scenario 2B MWC Option**  **Total Cost**

**Total Capital Investment**  **($) Total Annual Cost** 

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total**

**Annual Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Capital**

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr)**

LADeltech HB-507 Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas Flue Gas Recirculation CO oxidation catalyst, fabric filter $2,111,113 $533,006 $123,896 $89,587 $2,235,009 $622,593n/a n/a n/a n/a $2,235,009 $622,593 LADeltech HB-512 Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas Flue Gas Recirculation CO oxidation catalyst, fabric filter $5,384,706 $1,237,710 $123,896 $89,587 $5,508,602 $1,327,297n/a n/a n/a n/a $5,508,602 $1,327,297 MDSeverstalSparrows 1BLR Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas No Equipment CO oxidation catalyst, fabric filter, SNCR $18,264,374 $3,949,452 $249,050 $134,227 $18,513,424 $4,083,679n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,513,424 $4,083,679 MEPioneerPlastics Boiler #5/Thermal Oxidizer Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas No Equipment CO oxidation catalyst, fabric filter, SNCR $5,787,718 $1,354,042 $134,196 $92,787 $5,921,914 $1,446,829n/a n/a n/a n/a $5,921,914 $1,446,829 WAEmeraldKalama U-2 Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas Collectors, Settling Chambers, Separators - General CO oxidation catalyst $526,381 $218,879 $98,396 $79,887 $624,777 $298,766n/a n/a n/a n/a $624,777 $298,766 WAEmeraldKalama U-7 Energy recovery unit - Liquid/Gas Collectors, Settling Chambers, Separators - General none $0 $0 $98,396 $79,887 $98,396 $79,887n/a n/a n/a n/a $98,396 $79,887
ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator none

$0 $0 $223,076 $122,254 $223,076 $122,254n/a n/a n/a n/a $223,076 $122,254 ARDomtarIndustries PB1 Energy recovery unit - Solids Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI $9,440,356 $2,361,564 $272,876 $146,854 $9,713,232 $2,508,418n/a n/a n/a n/a $9,713,232 $2,508,418 ARDomtarIndustries PB2 Energy recovery unit - Solids Wet Scrubber LBMS, DIFF, ACI $31,596,873 $9,992,006 $241,076 $151,154 $31,837,949 $10,143,160n/a n/a n/a n/a $31,837,949 $10,143,160 ARDomtarIndustries PB3 Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber $40,233,740 $15,234,135 $265,376 $155,754 $40,499,116 $15,389,890n/a n/a n/a n/a $40,499,116 $15,389,890 ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72) Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator fabric filter,tune-up, wet scrubber, ACI $3,597,265 $839,007 $114,876 $91,554 $3,712,141 $930,561n/a n/a n/a n/a $3,712,141 $930,561 CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#1

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$16,367,578 $4,292,447 $241,076 $150,654 $16,608,654 $4,443,102n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,608,654 $4,443,102 CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#2

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$15,468,205 $4,041,252 $241,076 $150,654 $15,709,281 $4,191,906n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,709,281 $4,191,906 CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#3

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$16,034,510 $4,169,853 $241,076 $150,654 $16,275,586 $4,320,507n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,275,586 $4,320,507 LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 2 Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

$39,817,175 $15,240,342 $265,376 $156,254 $40,082,551 $15,396,596n/a n/a n/a n/a $40,082,551 $15,396,596 LAIPMansfield 1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / EQT005 Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, wet scrubber, fabric filter, ACI $21,828,359 $6,842,866 $272,876 $147,654 $22,101,235 $6,990,521n/a n/a n/a n/a $22,101,235 $6,990,521 LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, fabric filter, ACI $29,503,126 $10,747,704 $272,876 $147,654 $29,776,002 $10,895,358n/a n/a n/a n/a $29,776,002 $10,895,358 MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1 Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, wet scrubber

$381,643 $212,501 $89,376 $71,754 $471,019 $284,255n/a n/a n/a n/a $471,019 $284,255 MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, DIFF

$6,676,672 $1,912,946 $83,076 $84,254 $6,759,748 $1,997,200n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,759,748 $1,997,200 OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Venturi Scrubber DIFF, ACI

$36,650,262 $10,214,792 $241,076 $150,654 $36,891,338 $10,365,446n/a n/a n/a n/a $36,891,338 $10,365,446 ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber $10,465,420 $2,857,139 $265,376 $157,054 $10,730,796 $3,014,193n/a n/a n/a n/a $10,730,796 $3,014,193 TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI $12,471,715 $2,691,554 $83,076 $81,354 $12,554,791 $2,772,908n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,554,791 $2,772,908 TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, fabric filter, ACI $10,948,275 $2,888,681 $114,876 $87,854 $11,063,151 $2,976,535n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,063,151 $2,976,535 TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 Energy recovery unit - Solids Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI $11,151,955 $2,797,316 $83,076 $86,554 $11,235,031 $2,883,870n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,235,031 $2,883,870 TNPackagingCorpCounce Combination Boiler #2Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Electrostatic Precipitator CO oxidation catalyst, DIFF

$29,391,524 $8,954,349 $241,076 $141,354 $29,632,600 $9,095,703n/a n/a n/a n/a $29,632,600 $9,095,703 TNTempleInland2426 5000F Energy recovery unit - Solids Mechnical Dust Collector, Wet Scrubber DIFF, caustic, ACI $17,677,787 $4,941,897 $241,076 $151,254 $17,918,863 $5,093,151n/a n/a n/a n/a $17,918,863 $5,093,151 TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02 Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Venturi Scrubber fabric filter, ACI

$31,552,076 $7,404,993 $248,576 $141,754 $31,800,652 $7,546,747n/a n/a n/a n/a $31,800,652 $7,546,747 **Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, Reporting, and**  **Recordkeeping Costs: Scenario 2A**  **Lowest Cost Option FacilityID**  **UnitID Subcategory**  **Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and**  **Recordkeeping Costs Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring,**  **Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs Existing Control Device**  **Consolidated MACT Controls** 

## Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (2 of 4)

**Landfill Option Total Cost:**  **Scenario 2B MWC Option**  **Total Cost**

**Total Capital Investment**  **($) Total Annual Cost** 

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total**

**Annual Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Capital**

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total MACT Floor Control,**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs:**  **Scenario 2A Lowest Cost Option**  **FacilityID UnitID**  **Subcategory Control Costs**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT**  **Controls**

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber CO oxidation catalyst, ACI, DIFF+caustic

$19,885,386 $5,473,369 $241,076 $146,754 $20,126,462 $5,620,124n/a n/a n/a n/a $20,126,462 $5,620,124 WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber LBMS, DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

$24,147,744 $6,921,863 $265,376 $152,354 $24,413,120 $7,074,218n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,413,120 $7,074,218 WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - Solids Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber fabric filter, tune-up, ACI

$15,853,342 $3,804,447 $248,576 $141,254 $16,101,918 $3,945,701n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,101,918 $3,945,701 WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - Solids Dry Electrostatic Granular Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF+wet scrubber

$16,475,116 $4,998,612 $265,376 $155,854 $16,740,492 $5,154,466n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,740,492 $5,154,466 WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - Solids Dry Electrostatic Granular Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF+wet scrubber

$16,977,238 $5,152,230 $265,376 $155,854 $17,242,614 $5,308,084n/a n/a n/a n/a $17,242,614 $5,308,084
CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 1Incinerator

Unknown fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $1,413,774 $350,709 $115,350 $89,527 $1,529,124 $440,236n/a n/a -$66,988 -$62,358 $0 -$66,988 CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 2Incinerator

Unknown fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $1,412,248 $351,133 $115,350 $89,627 $1,527,598 $440,761n/a n/a -$67,425 -$62,761 $0 -$67,425 CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 3Incinerator

Unknown fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $1,493,879 $372,845 $115,350 $89,527 $1,609,229 $462,372n/a n/a -$66,056 -$61,500 $0 -$66,056 CTPfizer FB-IN-01 Incinerator VENTURI SCRUBBER, TRAY TOWER SCRUBBER, Wet ESP fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI $2,019,002 $643,790 $80,750 $80,727 $2,099,752 $724,517n/a n/a -$2,464 $44,813 $0 -$2,464 ILF&MStateBank Incinerator Incinerator

No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $2,826,504 $507,685 $115,350 $83,727 $2,941,854 $591,412n/a n/a -$746 -$746 $0 -$746 ILFlintHillsResources HB-2301 Incinerator Fabric Filter afterburner retrofit, improve fabric filter $302,739 $130,642 $55,250 $65,227 $357,989 $195,869n/a n/a $179 $70,740 $0 $179 ILFlintHillsResources MB-1012 Incinerator Fabric Filter ACI, improve fabric filter $35,065 $119,444 $55,250 $74,527 $90,315 $193,971n/a n/a $770,561 $1,353,927 $90,315 $193,971 ILFlintHillsResources NB-800 Incinerator Fabric Filter improve fabric filter $0 $8,608 $55,250 $65,227 $55,250 $73,835n/a n/a -$32,160 $17,125 $0 -$32,160 ILPolyOne CE4 Incinerator

No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $3,045,728 $530,186 $115,350 $83,727 $3,161,078 $613,913n/a n/a -$8,960 -$8,951 $0 -$8,960 INCovanceLabsGreenfield 241-1A Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $2,688,970 $684,972 $115,350 $89,327 $2,804,320 $774,299n/a n/a -$48,268 -$32,568 $0 -$48,268 KSCNHWichita Ace Burn-off OvenIncinerator Unknown afterburner retrofit, fabric filter, SNCR, ACI $2,871,485 $707,052 $91,050 $83,927 $2,962,535 $790,979n/a n/a $129,480 $265,400 $0 $129,480 LAShellChemical F-T701 Incinerator Wet Scrubber and Wet Electrostatic Precipitator afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, fabric filter $4,142,114 $1,022,515 $91,050 $83,927 $4,233,164 $1,106,443n/a n/a $1,598,621 $2,708,637 $4,233,164 $1,106,443 NCGlaxoSmithKline MWI-2 Incinerator Dry Scrubbing (General), Fabric Filter wet scrubber, SNCR, improve fabric filter, ACI $1,582,312 $424,176 $89,850 $84,127 $1,672,162 $508,304n/a n/a $42,006 $150,120 $0 $42,006 NDCNHAmerica INC-1 Incinerator

No Equipment afterburner retrofit, wet scrubber, fabric filter, SNCR, ACI $2,953,530 $637,295 $115,350 $86,327 $3,068,880 $723,622n/a n/a -$13,092 -$11,682 $0 -$13,092 NJNovartis 34 Incinerator Dry Scrubbing (General), Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, wet scrubber, SNCR, ACI $1,108,815 $247,093 $89,850 $79,827 $1,198,665 $326,921n/a n/a -$19,687 $16,046 $0 -$19,687 OKPioneerTelephone MS200 Incinerator

Unknown fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $3,630,492 $596,538 $115,350 $83,727 $3,745,842 $680,265n/a n/a -$14,649 -$14,542 $0 -$14,649 PAAshlandNevilleIsland PR TOX Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, ACI, SNCR $2,248,920 $598,313 $91,050 $87,927 $2,339,970 $686,240n/a n/a $225,263 $451,439 $0 $225,263 PASmithKlineBeecham 003 Incinerator

Fabric Filter, Venturi Scrubberimprove fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, SNCR, ACI $380,071 $75,224 $65,550 $71,927 $445,621 $147,151n/a n/a -$40,962 -$35,602 $0 -$40,962 SCEastmanColombia 1560-0008, ID #15Incinerator Wet Scrubber afterburner retrofit, fabric filter, ACI $1,486,299 $649,557 $80,750 $84,727 $1,567,049 $734,285n/a n/a $1,460,242 $2,499,242 $1,567,049 $734,285 TXBASFFreeport IN-4702 Incinerator No Equipment SNCR, fabric filter, wet scrubber $2,193,081 $495,268 $115,350 $83,727 $2,308,431 $578,996n/a n/a $283,157 $548,335 $0 $283,157 TXBASFFreeport IN-5500 Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, wet scrubber $11,515,274 $3,303,695 $105,050 $80,527 $11,620,324 $3,384,222n/a n/a $1,261,506 $2,172,472 $0 $1,261,506 TXReichhold Thermal Oxidizer Incinerator No Equipment afterburner retrofit, ACI, wet scrubber, fabric filter $2,778,010 $873,071 $105,050 $87,727 $2,883,060 $960,799n/a n/a -$6,600 $48,285 $0 -$6,600 TXSterlingChemTexasCity 53H3 Incinerator Unknown fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber $1,353,335 $452,279 $105,050 $89,827 $1,458,385 $542,107n/a n/a -$22,068 $37,822 $0 -$22,068

## Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (3 of 4)

**Landfill Option Total Cost:**  **Scenario 2B MWC Option**  **Total Cost**

**Total Capital Investment**  **($) Total Annual Cost** 

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total**

**Annual Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Capital**

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total MACT Floor Control,**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs:**  **Scenario 2A Lowest Cost Option**  **FacilityID UnitID**  **Subcategory Control Costs**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT**  **Controls**

VATransInd 50825 Incinerator

No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet scrubber $2,992,517 $540,822 $115,350 $84,027 $3,107,867 $624,850n/a n/a -$12,004 -$11,715 $0 -$12,004 WABoeingDevelopmentalCenter 9-67 data-destroy incinerator Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit, SNCR $1,518,552 $263,847 $91,050 $78,127 $1,609,602 $341,974n/a n/a -$16,415 -$8,169 $0 -$16,415 WVDuPontWashingtonWorks T71ME Incinerator Wet scrubber fabric filter, ACI $903,378 $318,632 $80,750 $84,827 $984,128 $403,459n/a n/a $107,962 $258,198 $0 $107,962 AKAlyeskaPumpStation5 35-IN-1 Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit, ACI, fabric filter $858,981 $156,030 $80,750 $75,527 $939,731 $231,558 $142,503 $92,810 $1,220,258n/a $142,503 $92,810 AKAlyeskaPumpStation7 37-IN-1 Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit, ACI, fabric filter $858,981 $184,575 $80,750 $77,527 $939,731 $262,102 $142,503 $129,717 $4,968,154 n/a $142,503 $129,717 AKChugachElectricBeluga EU No. 9 Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit, ACI, fabric filter $898,930 $197,669 $80,750 $77,527 $979,680 $275,197 $154,379 $133,792 $4,968,154 n/a $154,379 $133,792 AKCoeur Incinerator Small, remote No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $160,288 $80,750 $77,027 $852,478 $237,315 $55,250 $128,241 $6,804,920 n/a $55,250 $128,241 AKCookInletPipeline-DriftRiver Drift River Terminal Incinerator Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $77,560 $15,199 $55,250 $65,227 $132,810 $80,427 $132,810 $91,769 $1,207,836 n/a $132,810 $80,427 AKEntechAlaska Incin # 1 Small, remote No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit $854,301 $160,036 $80,750 $74,927 $935,051 $234,963 $935,051 $255,679 $2,226,096 n/a $935,051 $234,963 AKHeclaGreensCreekJuneau Consumat IncineratorSmall, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit, ACI, fabric filter $858,981 $225,524 $80,750 $80,027 $939,731 $305,551 $142,503 $116,282 $2,736,965n/a $142,503 $116,282 AKKuparukCentral Production H-250 (EU 35) Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $87,253 $33,767 $55,250 $65,227 $142,503 $98,994 $142,503 $325,842 $24,471,689n/a $142,503 $98,994 AKKuparukCentral Production H-347 (EU 36) Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $87,253 $35,719 $55,250 $65,227 $142,503 $100,946 $142,503 $327,794 $24,479,397n/a $142,503 $100,946 AKPioneerNR I-5 incinerator Small, remote No Equipment ACI, fabric filter $771,728 $202,192 $80,750 $80,027 $852,478 $282,219 $55,250 $110,597 $4,857,918n/a $55,250 $110,597 AKTeckComincoAlaskaIncRedDogMineMI-2 Small, remote No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $190,429 $80,750 $79,127 $852,478 $269,556 $55,250 $292,075 $24,559,294 n/a $852,478 $269,556 AKTeckComincoAlaskaIncRedDogMineMI-3 Small, remote No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $149,855 $80,750 $76,227 $852,478 $226,083 $55,250 $104,934 $4,284,511 n/a $55,250 $104,934 AKUOCCTradingBay R-H-0800 Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $85,072 $16,198 $55,250 $65,227 $140,322 $81,425 $140,322 $85,413 $418,929 n/a $140,322 $81,425 AKXTOEnergy INCINERATOR Small, remote No Equipment ACI, fabric filter $771,728 $139,169 $80,750 $75,527 $852,478 $214,696 $55,250 $69,543 $453,059 n/a $55,250 $69,543

CACAPortlandCementColton K-1 Waste-burning kiln Collectors, Settling Chambers, Separators - General, Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, RTO, ACI $7,784,105 $112 $429,667 $227,421 $8,213,772 $2,873,014n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,213,772 $2,873,014

CACAPortlandCementColton K-2 Waste-burning kiln Collectors, Settling Chambers, Separators - General, Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, RTO, ACI $11,728,958 $85 $429,667 $227,421 $12,158,625 $4,754,789n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,158,625 $4,754,789

CALehighSouthwestReddingPlant In-Line Kiln/Raw Mill (S260) Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI, $18,123,393 $155 $453,967 $233,521 $18,577,360 $5,870,809n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,577,360 $5,870,809

FLCemexMiami Cement Kiln Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI, SNCR $31,858,481 $10,592,862 $464,267 $235,721 $32,322,748 $10,828,583n/a n/a n/a n/a $32,322,748 $10,828,583

IALafargeBuffalo Kiln 1 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, wet scrubber $10,671,531 $2,505,294 $453,967 $223,421 $11,125,498 $2,728,715n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,125,498 $2,728,715

IALehighCementMasonCity 302.203 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, Fabric Filter, Flue Gas Desulfurization (General), Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) wet scrubber, improve fabric filter $11,825,103 $2,777,095 $453,967 $223,421 $12,279,069 $3,000,515n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,279,069 $3,000,515 MDLehighCementUnionBridge E02-001 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, ACI $163,424 $2,398,483 $429,667 $227,421 $593,090 $2,625,904n/a n/a n/a n/a $593,090 $2,625,904

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 19 Waste-burning kiln low-NOx burners, Fabric Filterimprove fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $15,149,891 $4,523,792 $453,967 $232,021 $15,603,858 $4,755,813n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,603,858 $4,755,813

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 20 Waste-burning kiln low-NOx burners, Fabric Filterimprove fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $15,543,973 $4,654,623 $453,967 $232,021 $15,997,939 $4,886,643n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,997,939 $4,886,643

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 21 Waste-burning kiln low-NOx burners, Fabric Filterimprove fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $15,822,156 $4,747,332 $453,967 $232,021 $16,276,123 $4,979,353n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,276,123 $4,979,353

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 22 Waste-burning kiln low-NOx burners, Fabric Filterimprove fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $23,638,720 $7,409,038 $453,967 $232,021 $24,092,687 $7,641,058n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,092,687 $7,641,058

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 23 Waste-burning kiln low-NOx burners, Fabric Filterimprove fabric filter, RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $23,595,088 $7,394,503 $453,967 $232,021 $24,049,054 $7,626,523n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,049,054 $7,626,523 PALafargeWhitehallPlant Kiln 2 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $12,214,293 $3,169,462 $453,967 $230,321 $12,668,260 $3,399,783n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,668,260 $3,399,783 PALafargeWhitehallPlant Kiln 3 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $9,238,614 $2,306,990 $453,967 $229,221 $9,692,581 $2,536,211n/a n/a n/a n/a $9,692,581 $2,536,211

PALehighCementEvansville 121 Waste-burning kiln Cyclone: Single, Dry Limestone Injection, Fabric Filter wet scrubber, ACI, improve fabric filter $5,711,188 $2,453,068 $453,967 $233,521 $6,165,155 $2,686,589n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,165,155 $2,686,589

PALehighCementEvansville 122 Waste-burning kiln Cyclone: Single, Dry Limestone Injection, Fabric Filter wet scrubber, ACI, improve fabric filter $5,913,519 $2,092,050 $453,967 $233,521 $6,367,486 $2,325,570n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,367,486 $2,325,570 PALehighCementYork 200 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator fabric filter, RTO $11,518,519 $3,261,638 $455,167 $227,521 $11,973,686 $3,489,159n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,973,686 $3,489,159

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 1 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $6,414,103 $2,427,703 $455,167 $237,121 $6,869,269 $2,664,824n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,869,269 $2,664,824

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 2 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $7,794,327 $2,957,077 $455,167 $237,121 $8,249,493 $3,194,197n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,249,493 $3,194,197

## Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (4 of 4)

**Landfill Option Total Cost:**  **Scenario 2B MWC Option**  **Total Cost**

**Total Capital Investment**  **($) Total Annual Cost** 

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total Capital** 

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Annual**

**Cost ($/yr)**  **Total**

**Annual Cost ($/yr)**  **Total Capital**

**Investment ($)**  **Total Annual Cost**

**($/yr) Total MACT Floor Control,**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs:**  **Scenario 2A Lowest Cost Option**  **FacilityID UnitID**  **Subcategory Control Costs**  **Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs**  **Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT**  **Controls**

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 3 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $8,049,178 $3,055,143 $455,167 $234,132 $8,504,345 $3,289,274n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,504,345 $3,289,274

TXHolcimMidlothianPlant Kiln 1 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter, Selective NonCatalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR), Wet Scrubber improve fabric filter, RTO, improve wet scrubber $18,542,582 $6,140,216 $429,667 $217,821 $18,972,248 $6,358,036n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,972,248 $6,358,036

TXHolcimMidlothianPlant Kiln 2 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter, Selective NonCatalytic Reduction (NH3 Or Urea Injection) (SNCR), Wet Scrubber improve fabric filter, RTO, improve wet scrubber $19,535,985 $6,547,436 $429,667 $217,821 $19,965,652 $6,765,257n/a n/a n/a n/a $19,965,652 $6,765,257

UTHolcimDevilsSlide Kiln 1 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter RTO, wet scrubber, ACI, improve fabric filter $25,805,705 $9,102,907 $453,967 $232,521 $26,259,671 $9,335,428n/a n/a n/a n/a $26,259,671 $9,335,428 **$900,732,516 $259,570,058**  **$20,305,339 $12,512,851**  **$921,037,855 $284,892,806**  **$859,140,295 $270,337,904**