8E -i

APPEN DIX 8E. AV

ERAGE TRA

NSFORMER DESIGN

PROP ERTIES FROM LIF

E-CYCLE C OST MODEL TABLE OF CONTENTS 8E.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................... 8E-1 8E.2 TABLES OF AVERAG E TRANSFORMER DESIGN PROPERTIES ........... 8E-1 8E.3 HISTOGRAMS OF TRANSFORMER DESIGN EFFICI ENCIES .............. 8E-5 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 ......................... 8E-5 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 ......................... 8E-8 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 ........................ 8E-12 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 ........................ 8E-15 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 ........................ 8E-19 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 ........................ 8E-22 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine10 ....................... 8E-25 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 ....................... 8E-29 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 ....................... 8E-32 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 ................. 8E-36 LIST OF TABLE S Table 8E.2.1 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 1

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-1 Table 8E.2.2 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 2

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-1 Table 8E.2.3 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 3

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-2 Table 8E.2.4 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 4

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-2 Table 8E.2.5 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 5

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-2 Table 8E.2.6 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 9

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-2 Table 8E.2.7 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 10

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-3 Table 8E.2.8 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 11

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-3 Table 8E.2.9 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 12

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-3 Table 8E.2.10 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for De sign Line 13

Represe ntative U nit ............................................. 8E-48E -ii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Baseline ............................................... 8E-5 Figure 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 1 ............................... 8E-5 Figure 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 2 ............................... 8E-6 Figure 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 3 ............................... 8E-6 Figure 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 4 ............................... 8E-7 Figure 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 5 ............................... 8E-7 Figure 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 1 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 6 ............................... 8E-8 Figure 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Baseline ............................................... 8E-8 Figure 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 1 ............................... 8E-9 Figure 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 2 ............................... 8E-9 Figure 8E.3.11 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-10 Figure 8E.3.12 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 4 .............................. 8E-10 Figure 8E.3.13 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 5 .............................. 8E-11 Figure 8E.3.14 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 2 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 6 .............................. 8E-11 Figure 8E.3.15 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-12 Figure 8E.3.16 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 1 .............................. 8E-12 Figure 8E.3.17 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 2 .............................. 8E-13 Figure 8E.3.18 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 3 .............................. 8E-13 Figure 8E.3.19 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 4 .............................. 8E-14 Figure 8E.3.20 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Cand

idate Sta ndard Level 5 .............................. 8E-148E -iii

Figure 8E.3.21 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 3 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-15 Figure 8E.3.22 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-15 Figure 8E.3.23 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-16 Figure 8E.3.24 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-16 Figure 8E.3.25 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-17 Figure 8E.3.26 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-17 Figure 8E.3.27 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-18 Figure 8E.3.28 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 4 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-18 Figure 8E.3.29 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-19 Figure 8E.3.30 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-19 Figure 8E.3.31 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-20 Figure 8E.3.32 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-20 Figure 8E.3.33 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-21 Figure 8E.3.34 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 5 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-21 Figure 8E.3.35 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-22 Figure 8E.3.36 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-22 Figure 8E.3.37 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-23 Figure 8E.3.38 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-23 Figure 8E.3.39 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-24 Figure 8E.3.40 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-24 Figure 8E.3.41 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 9 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-258E -iv

Figure 8E.3.42 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-25 Figure 8E.3.43 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-26 Figure 8E.3.44 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-26 Figure 8E.3.45 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-27 Figure 8E.3.46 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-27 Figure 8E.3.47 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-28 Figure 8E.3.48 Distributi on of Eff iciencie s for Des ign Line 10 Representa tive Unit, Candidate Standard Leve l 6 ............................................ 8E-28 Figure 8E.3.49 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-29 Figure 8E.3.50 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-29 Figure 8E.3.51 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-30 Figure 8E.3.52 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-30 Figure 8E.3.53 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-31 Figure 8E.3.54 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-31 Figure 8E.3.55 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 11 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-32 Figure 8E.3.56 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-32 Figure 8E.3.57 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-33 Figure 8E.3.58 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-33 Figure 8E.3.59 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-34 Figure 8E.3.60 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-34 Figure 8E.3.61 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-35 Figure 8E.3.62 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 12 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-358E -v

Figure 8E.3.63 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-36 Figure 8E.3.64 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 1 ................................... 8E-36 Figure 8E.3.65 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 2 ................................... 8E-37 Figure 8E.3.66 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 3 ................................... 8E-37 Figure 8E.3.67 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 4 ................................... 8E-38 Figure 8E.3.68 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 5 ................................... 8E-38 Figure 8E.3.69 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design L ine 13 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Leve l 6 ................................... 8E-398E -1

APPEN DIX 8E. AV

ERAGE TRA

NSFORMER DESIGN

PROP ERTIES FRO M LIFECYCLE COST M ODEL 8E.1 INTRODUC TION In this supplementary

technical support document (TSD) appendix, the Department provides additiona l informa tion regarding

the adva nce notic e of prop osed rule making ( ANOPR) life- cycle cost (LCC) cal culat ion re sult s. At t he Sep tembe r 28, 2 004 pu blic m eetin g, stake hold ers req ueste d the f ollo wing sp ecifi c info rmati on fro m the LC C anal ysis: th e average efficiency and average costs and pric es for the baseline and each of the f ive candidate standard levels fo r the thir teen re present ative uni ts analy zed. Following tha

t model, the

Department is providing the same information on the six candidate standard levels analy zed for the notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR). 8E.2 TABLES OF A

VERAGE TR

ANSFORM

ER DESIGN

PROP ERTIES Table 8E.2.1 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 1

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 1,088 1,122 1,173 1,325 1,612 1,847 2,375 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.0 99.1 99.1 99.2 99.4 99.5 99.6 Core Los s (W) 127.9 108.2 107.0 103.9 34.1 39.9 50.3 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 576.5 553.3 487.5 371.0 494.4 325.6 186.5 Table 8E.2.2 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 2

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 619 636 640 644 650 720 1,530 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 98.7 98.8 98.9 98.9 98.9 99.0 99.5 Core Los s (W) 87.8 74.9 74.1 74.4 74.2 67.3 33.4 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 308.4 301.9 298.8 290.1 283.3 243.9 115.38E -2

Table 8E.2.3 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 3

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 4,252 4,321 4,441 4,753 5,646 10,649 11,458 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5 99.6 99.7 99.8 Core Los s (W) 749.7 690.4 676.6 672.6 573.9 263.8 272.9 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 3698.0 3218.3 3018.5 2648.6 2405.0 1583.6 1433.8 Table 8E.2.4 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 4

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 2,718 2,843 3,086 3,900 4,340 5,418 6,041 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 98.9 99.1 99.2 99.3 99.5 99.6 99.6 Core Los s (W) 420.0 366.9 349.2 198.0 132.0 150.8 154.7 Coil L oss a t 50% L oad ( W) 1639.9 1427.7 1238.3 1366.0 1192.2 702.9 580.3 Table 8E.2.5 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 5

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer

Selling Price ($) 10,808 1 1 ,151 11,600 12,203 13,613 26,916 26,917 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.4 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5 99.7 99.7 Core Los s (W) 1958.7 1915.6 1879.7 1867.1 1707.9 807.4 807.4 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 10877.7 9528.2 8922.3 8350.8 7929.5 5414.2 5414.7 Table 8E.2.6 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 9

Represe ntative Unit8E -3 Candidate Standard Level Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 5,379 5,423 5,522 5,830 7,038 9,620 9,619 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 98.8 98.9 99.0 99.1 99.3 99.4 99.4 Core Los s (W) 991.1 886.2 748.3 699.3 587.8 480.5 480.3 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 4334.5 4195.6 4140.8 3344.5 2368.7 1718.8 1719.8 Table 8E.2.7 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 10

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 20,368 21,273 21,869 23,008 24,723 32,903 32,900 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.2 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5 Core Los s (W) 3492.7 3182.6 2937.9 2664.3 2449.6 2303.3 2303.5 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 12751.5 10920.1 10691.9 10102.5 8979.8 5705.3 5705.5 Table 8E.2.8 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 11

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 7,812 8,127 8,379 8,907 9,824 10,679 10,679 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 98.4 98.7 98.8 98.9 99.0 99.1 99.1 Core Los s (W) 1195.1 935.6 894.4 819.7 738.7 672.2 672.0 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 6273.4 5554.8 4803.4 4131.5 3331.0 3099.4 3100.2 Table 8E.2.9 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 12

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 68E -4

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 22,594 22,955 23,215 23,820 25,707 36,379 36,396 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.2 99.2 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.5 99.5 Core Los s (W) 3492.8 3221.3 3084.2 2981.6 2781.3 2387.6 2385.9 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 12518.9 11938.9 11465.3 10533.4 8850.1 5342.1 5343.4 Table 8E.2.10 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 13

Represe ntative Unit Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6 Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 28,492 28,623 29,060 30,007 34,915 48,134 48,138 Efficiency

at 50% Load (%) 99.3 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.5 99.6 99.6 Core Los s (W) 4358.5 4315.2 3798.7 3550.2 3147.3 2910.1 2909.9 Coil Loss a

t 50% L oad ( W) 14280.1 13981.9 14532.5 13365.1 10270.0 6421.8 6421.18E -5 Figure 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Repr esentat

ive Unit, B aseline

Figure 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 1 8E.3 HISTOGRAM S OF TRAN SFORMER DESIGN EFFICIENC IES 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 18E -6 Figure 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 2

Figure 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 38E -7 Figure 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 4

Figure 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 58E -8 Figure 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 6

Figure 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 2 Repr esentat

ive Unit, B aseline 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 28E -9 Figure 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Le

vel 1

Figure 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 28E-10 Figure 8E.3.11 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.12 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 48E-11 Figure 8E.3.13 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.14 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 68E-12 Figure 8E.3.15 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.16 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 38E-13 Figure 8E.3.17 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.18 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 38E-14 Figure 8E.3.19 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.20 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 58E-15 Figure 8E.3.21 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.22 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Baseline 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 48E-16 Figure 8E.3.23 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1

Figure 8E.3.24 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 28E-17 Figure 8E.3.25 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.26 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 48E-18 Figure 8E.3.27 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.28 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 68E-19 Figure 8E.3.29 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.30 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 58E-20 Figure 8E.3.31 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.32 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 38E-21 Figure 8E.3.33 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.34 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 58E-22 Figure 8E.3.35 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.36 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 98E-23 Figure 8E.3.37 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.38 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 38E-24 Figure 8E.3.39 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.40 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 58E-25 Figure 8E.3.41 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.42 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Baseline 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line108E-26 Figure 8E.3.43 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 1

Figure 8E.3.44 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 28E-27 Figure 8E.3.45 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 3

Figure 8E.3.46 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 48E-28 Figure 8E.3.47 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 5

Figure 8E.3.48 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 68E-29 Figure 8E.3.49 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.50 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 1 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 118E-30 Figure 8E.3.51 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 2

Figure 8E.3.52 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 38E-31 Figure 8E.3.53 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 4

Figure 8E.3.54 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 58E-32 Figure 8E.3.55 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 6

Figure 8E.3.56 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Baseline 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 128E-33 Figure 8E.3.57 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 1

Figure 8E.3.58 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 28E-34 Figure 8E.3.59 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 3

Figure 8E.3.60 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 48E-35 Figure 8E.3.61 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 5

Figure 8E.3.62 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 68E-36 Figure 8E.3.63 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.64 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 1 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 138E-37 Figure 8E.3.65 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 2

Figure 8E.3.66 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 38E-38 Figure 8E.3.67 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 4

Figure 8E.3.68 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 58E-39 Figure 8E.3.69 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative Unit, Candid ate Standa rd Level 6