APPENDIX G 

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 1 of 39 PAGEID #: 7162
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P001 9/14/2011 Email from M. Dittoe to T. Judy, M. Lenzo, and C. Hawley, 

subject FW: Media Gaggle 9/14

LWV

P002 12/15/2011 Email from H. Mann to P. Halle, RE: RE: SP003 11/3/2011 Email from H. Mann to H. Pelger, subject FW: New 

Congressional Districts

S

P004 7/23/2016 C. Bensen Curriculum Vitae (Dkt. 59-2) BP005 2010 Presentation, "Election Data for Redistricting" LEP006 10/4/2011 Invoice for POLIDATA LLC BP007 2/16/2012 Invoice for POLIDATA LLC BeP008 6/1/2011 Email from M. Braden to C. Bensen, subject FW: BRP009 8/10/2011 Email from C. Bensen to H. Mann, M. Lenzo, and M. Thomas, 

subject RE:

JU

P010 8/11/2011 Email from C. Bensen to H. Mann, M. Braden, subject Re: (Case 

34304) Export equivalency file (6143525819)

P011 8/15/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, T. Horgan, Maptitude 

Technical Support, subject FW: TEST of Congressional districts as DBF

Be

P012 9/16/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, (no subject) BP013 7/10/2011 Email from C. Bensen to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, et al., subject 

Ohio Apportionment and Redistricting political data

Be

P014 7/22/2011 Example of Calculations for Election Averages EA11 to EA16 BeP015 7/22/2011 [Metadata] Example of Calculations for Election Averages 

EA11 to EA16

Bense

P016 10/4/2018 Screenshot of Polidata folder BL

Po

P017 10/4/2018 Screenshot of Polidata > Clark 07-24-11 folder BLESSING0

07-

P018 7/24/2011 Maptitude screenshot, Map1 - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) BLESSING0

07-2

1 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 2 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P019 9/14/2011 Chart, District/Pop BENSE

dvw_aggs

sep1

P020 Example of Calculations for Election Averages EA11 to EA16 BeP021 7/24/2011 Maptitude screenshot, Map1 - 2010 Final Counties (Ohio) BLESSING0

07-24

P022 9/14/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, (no subject) BP023 9/2/2011 Email from A. Kincaid to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, and T. Whatman, 

subject New Idea Redraft

LWV

P024 10/26/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, subject FW: Ohio

Congressional District Shapefile

Be

P025 11/9/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, subject test of indexes BeP026 Chart, District Indexes B

P027 Chart, District Indexes BP028 12/14/2011 Chart, District Indexes B

dvw_agg

h

P029 12/15/2011 Measures of Compactness B

[mtr_comp

e

P030 12/15/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, subject RE: BeP031 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 as passed Test 2 BENSEN_

Shape File

P032 7/15/2011 Email from M. Braden to M. Salling, H. Mann, C. Bensen, et al., 

subject RE: conference call

BR

P033 12/15/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, (no subject) BP034 12/15/2011 Email from H. Mann to C. Bensen, (no subject) B

2 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 3 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P035 8/29/2011 Email from H. Mann to B. Hansen, subject Out of Office: 

Weekly Redistricting Meeting

P036 8/3/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Policy Widgets, LLC

LWV

P037 7/5/2011 Email from V. Flasher to R. DiRossi and J. Licursi, subject Re: 

Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data

Bl

P038 7/5/2011 Email from J. Licursi to V. Flasher, R. DiRossi, et al., subject Re: 

Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data

Bl

P039 7/10/2011 Email from C. Bensen to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, et al., subject RE: 

Ohio Apportionment and Redistricting political data

Bl

P040 Final political index used DIRP041 Chart, District Indexes B

P042 Chart, District Indexes BP043 Screenshot of documents in BLESSING0012635 folder BP044 10/28/2009 Subcontract between Cleveland State University and Ohio 

University

LE

P045 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio)

BLESSIN

Revised 

P046 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 16)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P047 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 1)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P048 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 2)

BLESSIN

Revised De

3 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 4 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P049 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 3)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P050 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 4)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P051 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 5)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P052 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 6)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P053 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 7)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P054 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 8)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P055 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 9)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P056 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 10)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P057 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 11)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P058 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 12)

BLESSIN

Revised De

4 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 5 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P059 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 13)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P060 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 14)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P061 Maptitude screenshot, HB 369 Map Revised December 

14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 15)

BLESSIN

Revised De

P062 Screenshot of documents in Polidata > Clark 07-24-11 folder BLESSING0

P063 Maptitude screenshot, Map 1 - 2010 Final Census Blocks 

(dataview Block 4015)

BLESSING0

07-24-1

P064 Ohio House Republican Caucus, William G. Batchelder, Speaker

- Map Talking Points

S

P065 5/12/2011 Discussion Points for Mark Braden Meetings LW

P066 6/2/2011 Proposed Agenda for Mark Branden Visit LWP067 Script & Agenda for Thursday, June 2 Meetings LWV

P068 7/5/2011 Email from K. Rench to B. Hansen and H. Mann, subject RE: 

redistricting meetings

HA

P069 7/1/2011 Email from H. Mann to R. DiRossi, M. Lenzo, et al., subject 

Weekly Reidstricting Meetings

P070 6/1/2011 Memorandum from H. Mann to W. Batchelder, et al., subject 

Proposed schedule for Congressional redistricting hearings

SE

P071 7/15/2011 Wyndham Cleveland at Playhouse Square, Group Rooming List LWP072 9/14/2011 Email from H. Mann to J. Renacci, subject Numbers LW

P073 Turner-Austria Option Talking Points LW

5 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 6 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P074 11/2/2009 Memorandum from Mark Salling to Ohio Legislative Task on 

Redistricting Reapportionment and Demographic Research and the Ohio Legislative Services Commission, subject Status of Development of 2011 Redistricting Database

B

P075 6/6/2011 Memorandum from Mark Salling to Ohio Legislative Task on 

Redistricting Reapportionment and Demographic Research and the Ohio Legislative Services Commission, subject Status of Development of 2011 Redistricting Database

BR

P076 9/2/2011 Email from A. Kincaid to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, T. Whatman, 

subject New Idea Redraft

LWV

P077 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes P078 Chart, Ohio Changes P079 Chart, Ohio Changes P080 11/1/2011 Email from H. Mann to R. DiRossi, M. Lenzo and T. Judy, 

subject I2:0901-0130-map0.pdf

LW

P081 Chart/Map - District/Member LWVOH_0P082 Chart, CD 9 Ideas P083 11/3/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to M. Braden, subject Re: Updated Fact 

Sheet

BR

P084 11/2/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to M. Braden, subject Congressional 

Index comparison

P085 9/21/2011 Email from S. Chabot to S. Towns, subject Re: Update... CP086 Cho CV P087 10/18/2018 Cho Initial Expert Report P088 11/26/2018 Cho Rebuttal Report P089 10/18/2018 Cho source code [confidential under protective order] Cho Depo 

p

P090 10/5/2018 Cooper Declaration, Initial Report C

P091 11/30/2018 Cooper Declaration Errrata and Exhibits C

6 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 7 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P092 11/26/2018 Cooper Supplemental Declaration and Exhibits C

P093 11/27/2018 Cooper Second Supplemental Declaration CP094 10/5/2018 Subpoena to Testify (Ray DiRossi) DP095 6/15/2018 Subpoena to Produce Documents (Ray DiRossi) DP096 10/7/2011 Ohio Campaign for Accountable Redistricting, Letter from J. 

Slagle to R. DiRossi and H. Mann, subject Transparency Report; Public Records Request

LWV

P097 5/12/2011 Discussion Points for Mark Braden Meetings LW

P098 5/31/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice REDISTRICTING: SOFTWARE DEMO - 

MAPTITUDE

D

P099 6/16/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice CONFIRMED: LEGISLATIVE TASK 

FORCE ON REDISTRICTING

D

P100 7/5/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice CONFIRMED: President Niehaus call 

with Congressman LaTourette

D

P101 7/1/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to H. Mann, subject Re: HOLD for 

redistricting software training

LW

P102 8/1/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Capital Advantage, LLC

LWV

P103 8/4/2011 Termination Agreement DP104 7/7/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject 2:45 p.m. CONFIRMED: 

REDISTRICTING TRAINING

D

P105 7/8/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: 

REDISTRICTING TRAINING

D

P106 7/7/2011 Redistricting Meetings Agenda LWVP107 5/1/2010 Slide from presentation, "Drawing the Lines" DiP108 8/30/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meet with 

Tom Whatman - DC

D

P109 7/12/2011 Double Tree Guest Suites Invoice LWP110 9/15/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meet with 

Niehaus at Bunker

D

P111 8/4/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to C. Morefield and H. Mann, subject Re: 

Plotter

Di

7 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 8 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P112 11/15/2011 2011 Political Indexes DIRP113 11/15/2011 Chart, The State Indexes DP114 Congressional map drawing contest - winning maps DIR

P115 Chart, HB319 Indexes DP116 Chart, HB319 Indexes DP117 9/26/2011 Bill Signings: HB 218 & HB 319 GOP118 9/2/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meet with 

Leadership on Redistricting Bill

D

P119 9/2/2011 Email from A. Kincaid to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, T. Whatman, 

subject New Idea Redraft

LWV

P120 9/5/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meet with 

Speaker and others re: Redistricting

D

P121 9/6/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meet with 

President Niehaus re: Apportionment and Redistricting

D

P122 9/8/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Senate 

Leadership Meeting

D

P123 9/9/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Senate 

Leadership Meeting

D

P124 9/10/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to K. Faber, subject (no subject) LW

P125 9/11/2011 Email from T. Niehaus to R. DiRossi, subject Redistricting 

"tweaks"

LW

P126 9/12/2011 Emails from R. DiRossi to T. Niehaus, subject Proposed map for 

LSC

LWV

P127 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Whatman, subject Stivers maps LWP128 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to A. Kincaid, subject Ohio final map with 

possible Stivers addition

LWV

P129 9/12/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Meeting at 

bunker about rollout

D

P130 9/14/2011 Email from H. Mann to R. DiRossi, subject Numbers LW

P131 12/15/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to H. Pelger, subject Re: RE: S

8 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 9 of 39 PAGEID 
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P132 11/2/2011 R. DiRossi meeting notice, subject CONFIRMED: Brief 

Leadersheip on Congressional Maps

D

P133 Political Indexes - Proposed Congressional Districts DP134 11/2/2011 Chart, The State Indexes DP135 11/10/2011 Chart, Plan Comparison DP136 7/14/2011 Email from J. McClelland to L. Obhof, subject Niehaus Names 

Members to Senate Select Committee on Redistricting 

SE

P137 7/15/2011 Email from E. Bittner to L. Obhof, subject FW: Senate Select 

Committee on Redistricting

SE

P138 9/21/2011 Transcript, Ohio State Senate Session FP139 12/14/2011 Transcript, Ohio State Senate Session FP140 8/10/2011 2010 Ohio Common and Unified Redistricting Database, 

Technical Documentation Version 3, prepared for The Legislative Services Committee of the Ohio General Assembly by Dr. Mark Salling

C

P141 11/2/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to C, Glassburn and A. Budish, subject 

Re: counter - Draft Presentation, attaching presentation, "Redistricting Discussion"

SMC-KM-0

P142 Major Map Files from 2010-2011 CP143 Metadata and list of files produced in Memorex USB\Offers 

folder in Glassburn Production

Gla

P144 Maptitude screenshot, 319 original.map - Block Split - Block - 

Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 1)

GLA

P145 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 16)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P146 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 1)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

9 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 10 of 39 PAG

 7171
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P147 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview 

District 2)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P148 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 3)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P149 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 4)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P150 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 5)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P151 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 6)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P152 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 7)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P153 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 8)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P154 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 9)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P155 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 10)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P156 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 11)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

10 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 11 of 39 PAG

 7172
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P157 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview 

District 12)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P158 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 13)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P159 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 14)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P160 Maptitude screenshot, OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map - 

Block Split - Block - Block Group - Tract - BOE County (dataview District 15)

GLASSBUR

ADOPTE

P161 2010-2011 11-4 Identified P162 2010-2011 11-4-11 Identified P163 2010-2011 11-08-11 Mod Identified P164 2010-2011 11-08-11 retry Identified P165 2010-2011 11-8-11 R Mod Identified P166 2010-2011 319 Identified P167 2010-2011 319 Original Identified P168 2010-2011 369 dec 14 Identified P169 2010-2011 CongDraft Identified P170 2010-2011 CongressDraft Identified 

11 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 12 of 39 PAG

 7173
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P171 2010-2011 My Ohio Congressional Draft Identified P172 2010-2011 My Ohio Congressional Identified P173 2010-2011 Dem Congress 2 (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified P174 2010-2011 Dem Congress 3 (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified P175 2010-2011 Dem Congress 4 (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified P176 2010-2011 Dem Congress 5 (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified 

P177 2010-2011 Dem Congress Nov (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified P178 2010-2011 Dem Congress 1 (Dem Congress Proposal10182011) Identified P179 2010-2011 DemCounterDATA_NOV1_2011 Identified P180 2010-2011 DemCounterDATA_NOV1_2011_HUFF Identified P181 2010-2011 Congress646 Identified P182 2010-2011 Counter 2 Identified P183 2010-2011 Huffman R Cong Identified P184 2010-2011 Huffman Sykes Identified P185 2010-2011 Huffsykes Identified P186 2010-2011 New District 16 Identified 

12 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 13 of 39 PAG

 7174
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P187 2010-2011 Balanced Plan Identified 

P188 2010-2011 Balanced Plan 1 Identified P189 2010-2011 DemBalanced Identified P190 2010-2011 Nov 1 Counter Identified P191 2010-2011 Nov 4 2011 Identified P192 2010-2011 Nov 18 Identified P193 2010-2011 11-5 Identified P194 2010-2011 11-6 Identified P195 2010-2011 Nov 18 D Identified P196 2010-2011 Nov 2 Identified P197 2010-2011 Nov 3 Identified P198 2010-2011 Nov 8 Identified P199 2010-2011 OH_CD_Current Identified P200 2010-2011 OH_CD_Empty Identified P201 2010-2011 OH_CD_Political_EastToEast Identified P202 2010-2011 OH_CD_Political_Empty Identified 

13 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 14 of 39 PAG

 7175
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P203 2010-2011 OH_CD_Political_Training110805 Identified 

P204 2010-2011 OH_CD_Political_VRA2CD11 Identified P205 2010-2011 OH_CD_Training110805 Identified P206 2010-2011 R First Offer Identified P207 2010-2011 RandallCongressa Identified P208 2010-2011 Rep Congress Final Identified P209 2010-2011 Rep Congress Final2 Identified P210 2010-2011 Rep Congress Final3 Identified P211 2010-2011 Republican Congress Identified P212 2010-2011 Republican Offer_Nov1_2011 Identified P213 2010-2011 Republican New Identified P214 2010-2011 Republican New1 Identified P215 2010-2011 RepublicanNewDATA Identified P216 2010-2011 RepublicanNewDATA_NOV_1_2011 Identified P217 2010-2011 RepublicanNewDATA_NOV1 Identified P218 2010-2011 RepublicanNewDATA_NOV1_2011 Identified 

14 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 15 of 39 PAG

 7176
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P219 2010-2011 CONGRESSIONAL PLAN EQUIVALENCY FILE Identified 

P220 2010-2011 OFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL Identified P221 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\Memorex USB\Offers

Identified 

P222 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response

Identified 

P223 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Democratic Responses

Identified 

P224 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Democratic Responses\Nov 18 Files (DEM)

Identified 

P225 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Democratic Responses\Nov 2 Files

Identified 

P226 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Democratic Responses\Nov 5 Files

Identified 

P227 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Democratic Responses\Nov 6 Files

Identified 

P228 11/29/2018 Directory of Y: \OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

,production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 18

Identified 

15 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 16 of 39 PAG

 7177
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P229 11/29/2018 Directory of Y: \OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 18\NOV 18

Identified 

P230 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 18\Nov 18 D Backups

Identified 

P231 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 2

Identified 

P232 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 2\NOV1_2011REVISI0N 

(sent nov2)

Identified 

P233 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 2\NOV1_2011REVISION (sent nov2)\Nov 2 D Backups

Identified 

P234 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 5

Identified 

P235 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 5\11-5

Identified 

P236 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 5\Nov 5 Backups

Identified 

P237 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 6

Identified 

16 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 17 of 39 PAG

 7178
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P238 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 6\11-6

Identified 

P239 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Democratic Response\Nov 6\Nov 6 Backups

Identified 

P240 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans

Identified 

P241 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 18

Identified 

P242 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 18\Nov 18 Backups

Identified 

P243 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 18\Nov Modified (minus Renacci)

Identified 

P244 11/29/2018 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 3

Identified 

P245 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 3\Nov 3 Backups

Identified 

P246 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 3\NOV MODIFIED

Identified 

P247 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 8

Identified 

17 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 18 of 39 PAG

 7179
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P248 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 8\2011-11-08 REVISIONS TO MAP

Identified 

P249 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Nov 8\Nov 8 Backups

Identified 

P250 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Republican Plans

Identified 

P251 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Republican Plans\Nov 18 Files

Identified 

P252 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Republican Plans\Nov 3 Files

Identified 

P253 Directory of Y:\OPRI\20181129_Glassburn 

Production\Files\MemorexUSB\Offers\Republican Plans\Republican Plans\Nov 8 Files

Identified 

P254 10/5/2018 Handley Initial Expert Report Ha

P255 7/15/2018 Email from B. Hansen to C. Sulecki, subject FWD: did you 

attend

HA

P256 12/17/2018 "Trying to Thread the Needle: The Effects of Redistricting in a 

Georgia Congressional District" by Hood and McKee

H

P257 12/17/2018 Political Subdivision Split Between Districts Data H

P258 12/17/2018 "Unwelcome Constituents: Redistricting and Countervailing 

Partisan Tides" by Hood and McKee

H

P259 12/17/2018 "Partisan Classification of Ohio's Congressional Districts, 2012" 

Indexes

H

18 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 19 of 39 PAG

 7180
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P260 12/17/2018 "Partisan Classification of Ohio's Congressional Districts, 2012" 

With Races

H

P261 12/17/2018 Ohio House Republican Caucus "How the Problem Started" MCGP262 12/17/2018 "Partisan Classification of Ohio's Congressional Districts, 2012" 

with Unified Index

H

P263 12/17/2018 "Races Used in Hood Ohio Partisan Distribution Figures" HP264 12/17/2018 "2014 Statewide Races" in Hood Figure 7 HP265 12/17/2018 2002 Races by County HP266 11/12/2018 rdcy_OH_2002_2010_2x.DBF PrevioP267 11/12/2018 rdst_OH_2002_2010_2x.DBF PrevioP268 11/12/2018 VTD 2004-2010.xls PrevioP269 11/12/2018 VTD 2012-2016.xls PrevioP270 7/15/2011 Email from A. Meden to GOP_All and Dem_All, subject House 

Subcommittee on Redistricting Regional Hearings Announcement

H

P271 9/15/2011 Transcript, Ohio House Session HuP272 9/8/2011 Email from A. Meden to Undisclosed recipients, subject State 

Government & Elections Committee Notice

G

P273 9/13/2011 Announcment of Committee Meeting HuP274 9/13/2011 Announcment of Committee Meeting HuP275 9/21/2011 Transcript, Ohio State House Session HuP276 11/3/2011 Transcript of Video Recorded Session, Ohio House of 

Representatives

Hu

P277 12/14/2011 Rules and Reference Committee Minutes HuP278 H.B. 369, Rep. Matt Huffman, Sponsor Testimony Hu

P279 4/8/2010 RSLC Announces Leadership Additions, Jankowski and Fehrer 

to Further Strengthen RSLC Team

R

P280 6/15/2010 Email from C. Jankowski to T. Reynolds and E. Gillespie, subject 

REDMAP Political Report Draft

P281 6/1/2010 REDMAP Political Report: June 2010 RP282 7/1/2010 REDMAP Political Report: July 2010 R

19 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 20 of 39 PAG

 7181
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P283 9/1/2010 REDMAP Political Report: September 2010 RP284 9/21/2010 REDMAP September Political Report, Breakfast Briefing, 

Washington, DC

P285 Redistricting Majority Project REDMAP: A program of the 

Republican State Leadership Committee

R

P286 Draft Memorandum from C. Jankowski, subject RSLC 

Redistricting

P287 Draft Letter from JCJ Email Text P288 Letter from C. Jankowski to Legislative Leaders JanP289 3/30/2011 Appointment Record, subject Meeting with Tom Hofeller, Dale 

Oldham & Mike Wild, Organizer: Scott Ward

P290 2012 Spreadsheet, 2012 Cycle Redistricting Budget P291 2/29/2012 Letter from C. Jankowski to T. Hofeller re termination of 

agreement between SGLF and Geographic Strategies LLC

P292 1/27/2012 SGLF Request for Payment with Invoice attached SP293 1/3/2013 Memorandum from C. Jankowski to Interested Parties, subject 

REDMAP Impact on Today's House GOP Majority

RS

P294 Mailer from Congressman Bill Johnson, Ohio Leadership 

Briefing

JO

P295 11/16/2010 Email from M. Weaver to B. Johnson, subject Redistricting JOP296 4/25/2011 Email from M. Smullen to B. Johnson, P. Hashem, M. Weaver, 

M. Van Blargan, and D. Locke, subject redistricting / fundraising talking point

JO

P297 8/1/2011 Memorandum from Communications Counsel, Inc., M. Weaver 

and M. Dole, to the Johnson For Congress Team, subject Political budget 2012

P298 7/14/2011 Email from M. Smullen to B. Johnson, subject Redistricting JOP299 7/18/2011 Email from M. Weaver to B. Johnson, subject Tom Niehaus JO

20 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 21 of 39 PAG

 7182
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P300 2012 NRCC Presentation, "Redistricting, Strengthening the Majority 

in 2012"

P301 Excel spreadsheet from Douglas Johnson D. JoP302 8/18/2011 Email from J. McNulty to J. Jordan, R. Yonkura, subject 8/18 

AUGLAIZE FR BRIEFING

JO

P303 8/15/2011 Email from J. McNulty to J. Jordan, subject 8/15 MORROW 

BRIEFING

JO

P304 7/28/2011 Email from M. Smullen to B. Johnson, M. Weaver and P. 

Hashem, subject Dispatch article

JOH

P305 7/15/2018 Email from B. Hansen to C. Sulecki, subject Fwd: did you 

attend

HA

P306 8/1/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Capital Advantage, LLC

LWV

P307 8/3/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Policy Widgets, LLC

LWV

P308 7/11/2011 Email from H. Mann to T. Judy, R. DiRossi, et al., subject 

Congressional Redistricting Regional Hearing Schedule

G

P309 7/20/2011 Congressional redistricting timeline LWP310 2012 NRCC Presentation, "Path to Victory and National Mood" P311 5/19/2011 Chart, District 12 Indices 

P312 5/19/2011 [Metadata] Chart, District 12 Indices TIBER

P313 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes P314 3/31/2011 [Metadata] Chart, Ohio Changes NRCP315 9/2/2011 Email from A. Kincaid to R. DiRossi, H. Mann, T. Whatman, 

subject New Idea Redraft

LWV

P316 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes P317 3/31/2011 [Metadata] Chart, Ohio Changes BRADP318 3/31/2011 Screenshot of Excel Formula for Average from Chart, Ohio 

Changes

BRADEN0

P319 11/19/2018 Ohio Map, District 9 P320 11/19/2018 [Metadata] Ohio Map, District 9 BRADP321 Ohio Map, District 11 

21 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 22 of 39 PAG

 7183
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P322 [Metadata] Ohio Map, District 11 BRADP323 Ohio Map, Hamilton County 

P324 [Metadata] Ohio Map, Hamilton County BRAD

P325 Ohio Map, Northeast P326 [Metadata] Ohio Map, Northeast BRADP327 Ohio Map P328 [Metadata] Ohio Map BRADP329 Chart, District Indices LW

P330 Chart, Ohio Changes LWP331 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes LWP332 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to A. Kincaid, subject Ohio final map with 

possible Stivers addition

LWV

P333 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes P334 3/31/2011 [Metadata] Chart, Ohio Changes NRCP335 10/3/2011 Chart, HB319 Indexes DP336 Maptitude screenshot, 10-27-11 Adam New Map.map - 2010 

Final Census Blocks (Ohio)

BLESSING0

P337 11/2/2011 Chart, The State Indexes DP338 11/5/2011 Chart, HB369/HB319 BLP339 10/19/2011 Chart, HB319 P340 10/19/2011 Chart, HB319 Excel Formula for Average NRCC00P341 11/2/2011 Chart, HB319 Indexes DP342 Subpoena to Produce Documents (Michael Lenzo) LP343 7/29/2011 Email from M. Lenzo to M.Hardenbrook, J. Barron, H. Mann 

and M. Grodhaus, subject Apportionment Board Records Officer

LW

P344 10/7/2011 Letter from J. Slagle to R.DiRossi and H. Mann re Transparency 

Report; Public Records Request

L WV

P345 11/21/2011 Letter from M. Lenzo to J. Slagle LWVP346 Presentation, "Drawing the Lines" LEP347 1/12/2011 Letter from T. Hofeller to Colleague L

22 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 23 of 39 PAG

 7184
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P348 5/12/2010 PowerPoint Presentation, GOP Redistricting Conference, 

Section 5 of the Federal Voting Rights Act, Presentation by Marguerite Mary Leoni

LE

P349 2011 2011 RNC Redistricting Legal and Technical Reference 

Materials

LE

P350 Twelve Points of Redistricting Awareness LEN

P351 9/28/2010 Presentation, "What I've Learned About Redistricting - The 

Hard Way!"

LE

P352 9/1/2011 Email from H. Mann to R. DiRossi , M. Lenzo, and T. Judy, 

subject FW: I2-0901-0130-map0.pdf

LW

P353 map Bates stamped LWVOH_00018251 LWP354 Compromise Proposal to Draw Fair Congressional Districts SMP355 11/3/2011 Email from S. Bender to K. McCarthy, subject RE: final release SMP356 11/30/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to M. Szollosi, subject Talking Points 

for Blade

SM

P357 12/22/2011 Email from R. Routt to G. Boas and A. Hoyt, subject HB 

369/HB319 Statistical comparison

S

P358 Chart, HB319 and HB369 Comparison SP359 12/12/2011 Ohio Redistricting Transparency Report, The Elephant In the 

Room 

LWV

P360 Presentation, "Ohio Redistricting Competition" LWP361 Ohio's Gerrymandering Problem: Why Haven't We Fixed this 

Yet?

LW

P362 5/4/2017 Proposal from J. Morgan to K. Barlow to provide the City of 

Placentia with map drawing services for redistricting new council districts, and J. Morgan Curriculum Vitae

M

P363 7/7/2011 Redistricting Meetings Agenda LWVP364 7/31/2011 Invoice for Applied Research Coordinates Ltd MP365 8/31/2011 Invoice for Applied Research Coordinates Ltd MP366 9/29/2011 Invoice for Applied Research Coordinates Ltd M

23 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 24 of 39 PAG

 7185
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P367 8/17/2018 Screenshot of Morgan document production folder M

Produc

P368 8/17/2018 Screenshot of Morgan document production ccBlock_oh_r07 

folder

Morgan D

Typ

P369 8/17/2018 Maptitude screenshot, Map1 - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) MO

2018>ccB

P370 Presentation, "Drawing the lines" LEP371 12/4/2011 Email from Jenna Mann to Bob Latta, subject 12.14.11-

Proposed Congressional Map

P372 6/26/2011 Email exchange between Jim Renacci and Tom Whatman, 

subject Ohio

R

P373 12/3/201 Email from Jim Renacci to James Slepian and Katelyn Barlage, 

subject I have an idea

R

P374 3/17/2011 Email exchange between Jim Renacci and James Slepian, no 

subject

RE

P375 7/8/2011 Email exchange betweeen Thomas Queen and Jim Renacci, 

subject Obhof

R

P376 11/13/2011 Email exchange between James Slepian and Jim Renacci, 

subject Google Alert - jim renacci

R

P377 3/4/2011 Email exchange between Jim Renacci, James Slepian and 

Katelyn Barlage, no subject

RE

P378 8/11/2011 Email from Mike Turner to Peggy Lehner and Ryan Dwyer, 

subject Montgomery Co TPs, enclosing Montgomery County Redistricting TPs

TU

P379 3/20/2011 Email exchange between Betsy Hawkings, Mike Turner, Adam 

Murka and Ryan Dwyer, subject redistricting meeting followup

T

P380 9/9/2011 Email from Mike Turner to scl@mail.house.gov, subject 

Redistricting

T

24 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 25 of 39 PAG

 7186
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P381 2/9/2011 Email exchange between Betsy Hawkings, Nick Raines and 

Mike Turner, et al., subject Ohio Chiefs lunch today

T

P382 4/29/2011 Email exchange between Betsy Hawkings and Mike Turner, 

subject Redistricting scuttlebutt

T

P383 9/2/2011 Map file, "Four-Way Split 9-2-11.map" BLESSI

Maptitud

Fou

P384 9/30/2010 Calendar entries for September 1, 2010 to September 30, 

2010

BO

P385 9/13/2011 Email from Heather Mann to Michael Lenzo, subject 

Congressional Redistricting Talking Points, enclosing "Congressional Redistricting Talking Points"

LW

P386 Assignment letter from Mike DeWine and Michael Hall to 

Mark A. Johnson, Baker & Hostetler, LLP, enclosing retention agreement

P387 8/29/2018 Affidavit of Non-Party Thomas B. Whatman in support of his 

Assertion of First Amendment Privilege

P388 12/14/2011 Transcript, Ohio State House SessionP389 House Bill # Rep. Matt Huffman, Sponsor Testimony 

P390 9/22/2010 REV_000P391 REV_000P392 2010 REV_000

P393 9/6/2011 REV_0002

P394 9/8/2011 REV_000

P395 9/23/2010 REV_000

25 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 26 of 39 PAG

 7187
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P396 9/29/2010 REV_000P397 9/15/2011 REV_000

P398 12/14/2011 REV_000

P399 12/14/2011 REV_000

P400 10/27/2011 REV_0002

P401 10/21/2011 REV_000

P402 10/31/2011 REV_00023P403 REV_0002P404 REV_00023P405 "319" Map Files [Glassburn Volume I Production] Glassbu

P406 "OFICIAL 269 ADOPTED FINAL" Map Files [Glassburn Volume I 

Production]

Glassbu

P407 9/9/2011 Email from T. Judy to H. Mann, Fwd: Talking Points LW

P408 4/19/2012 REV_000

P409 12/15/2011 REV_000

P410 9/16/2011 REV_000

26 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 27 of 39 PAG

 7188
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P411 9/26/2011 REV_000

P412 4/25/2012 REV_000

P413 4/19/2012 REV_000

P414 2/6/2012 REV_000P415 2018 LWVO Agenda for Action 2017-2019 LWVP416 2017 LWVO Agenda for Action 2016-2018 LWVP417 10/2/2018 Chart, LWVO Active Members for State LP418 6/30/2018 Chart, LWVO Balance Sheet and Statement of Equity L

P419 7/19/2011 OCAR Press Release, "Redistricting Competition Begins Today" LW

P420 2018 APRI Trumbull County Membership List O

P421 8/11/2011 Email from Mark Salling to John Barron, et al., subject June 

(and early July) 2011 Redistricting Database progress report, enclosing July-early August progress report

BR

P422 10/22/2011 Email exchange between Mark Salling and John Barron, et al., 

subject September 2011 Redistricting Database project 

progress report

S

P423 7/15/2011 Email from Mark Salling to Heather Mann, Mark Braden, Clark 

Bensen, Mike Lenzo, and Ray DiRossi, subject conference call, attaching census_versus_boe_MCDPlace_population_MS.xls

BR

P424 8/8/2011 Email exchange between Mike Lenzo, Clark Bensen, Troy Judy, 

Ray DiRossi and Heather Mann, subject Redistricting database

JU

27 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 28 of 39 PAG

 7189
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P425 4/26/2018 Video, https://www.cityclub.org/forums/2018/04/26/ohioballot-beat-the-bipartisan-congressional-redistricting-reformamendment-issue-1 M

P426 12/28/2018 Cho Supplemental Expert Report 

P427 20/20/2018 Cho Errata P428 11/11/2016 A Massively Parallel Evolutionary Markov Chain Monte Carlo 

Algorithm for Sampling Complicated Multimodal State Spaces. Wendy Tam Cho & Yan Y. Liu. SC18: The International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis

P429 9/15/2018 Sampling from Complicated and Unknown Distributions: 

Monte Carlo and Markov Cain Monte Carlo Methods for Redistricting. Wendy Tam Cho & Yan Y. Liu. Physica A 506:170–178. 

P430 2018 Cain, Bruce E., Wendy K. Tam Cho, Yan Y. Liu and Emily Zhang. 

2018. "A Reasonable Bias Method for Redistricting: A New Tool for an Old Problem." William & Mary Law Review 59(5):1521-1557.

P431 2017 Cho, Wendy K. Tam. 2017. "Measuring Partisan Fairness: How 

well does the Efficiency Gap Guard Against Sophisticated as well as Simple-Minded Modes of Partisan Discrimination?" University of Pennsylvania Law Review Online 166.

P432 2018 Cho, Wendy K. Tam. 2018. "Algorithms Can Foster a More 

Democratic Society." Nature 558:487.

P433 2001 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Albert H. Yoon. 2001. "Strange 

Bedfellows: Politics, Courts, and Statistics: Statistical Expert Testimony in Voting Rights Cases." Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 10(2):237-264.

28 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 29 of 39 PAG

 7190
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P434 2005 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Albert H. Yoon. 2005. "Panethnicity 

Revisited: Asian Indians, Asian American Politics, and the Voting Rights Act." UCLA Asian Pacific American Law Journal 10:8-30.

P435 2015 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Yan Y. Liu. 2015. A High-Performance 

Approach for Solution Space Traversal in Combinatorial Optimization. SC15: The International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis.

P436 2016 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Yan Y. Liu. 2016a. A Scalable 

Evolutionary Algorithm with Intensification and Diversification

Protocols Designed for Statistical Models. SC16: The International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis.

P437 12/1/2016 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Yan Y. Liu. 2016b. "Toward a

Talismanic Redistricting Tool: A Fully Balanced Computational Method for Identifying Extreme Redistricting Plans." Election. Law Journal 15(4):351-366

P438 2017 Cho, Wendy K. Tam and Yan Y. Liu. 2017. Massively Parallel 

Evolutionary Computation for Empowering Electoral Reform: Quantifying Gerrymandering via Multi-objective Optimization and Statistical Analysis. SC17: The International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis.

P439 2012 King, Douglas M., Sheldon H. Jacobson, Edward C. Sewell and 

Wendy K. Tam Cho. 2012. "GeoGraphs: An Efficient Model for Enforcing Contiguity and Hole Constraints in Planar Graph Partitioning." Operations Research 60(5):1213-1228.

29 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 30 of 39 PAG

 7191
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P440 2018 Liu, Yan Y. and Wendy K. Tam Cho. 2018. "Spatially Explicit 

Evolutionary Computation for Largescale Spatial Optimization." Technical Report.

P441 7/28/2015 Liu, Yan Y., Wendy K. Tam Cho and Shaowen Wang. 2015. A 

Scalable Computational Approach to Political Redistricting Optimization. In Proceedings of the 2015 Annual Conference on Extreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment. XSEDE15: Scientific Advancements Enabled by Enhanced Cyberinfrastructure St. Louis, MO: pp. 6:1--6:2.

P442 4/4/2016 Liu, Yan Y., Wendy K. Tam Cho and Shaowen Wang. 2016. 

"PEAR: A Massively Parallel Evolutionary Computation Approach for Political Redistricting Optimization and Analysis." Swarm and Evolutionary Computation 30:78-92.

P443 6/1/1973 Tufte, Edward R. 1973. “The Relationship between Seats and 

Votes in Two-Party Systems.” American Political Science Review 67(2):540–554.

P444 10/18/2018 oh_presc2 P445 10/18/2018 cg1216.csv PrevioP446 10/18/2018 com08.r PrevioP447 10/18/2018 plaintiffs.r PrevioP448 10/18/2018 run0.txt – run63.txt PrevioP449 11/26/2018 dat12.txt P450 11/26/2018 rebuttal.r P451 12/28/2018 com.r PrevioP452 12/28/2018 dat18.txt PrevioP453 12/28/2018 pdat.txt PrevioP454 10/5/2018 Cooper Initial Expert Report Appendix 

P455 9/28/2018 PROPOSED_REMEDIAL_PLAN.DBF P456 10/5/2018 Cooper Report Appendix.pdf COP457 10/5/2018 OCURD_data(m.salling@csuohio.edu).zip C

30 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 31 of 39 PAG

 7192
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P458 10/5/2018 OCURD_documentation(m.salling@csuohio.edu).zip C

P459 10/5/2018 OCURD_shapes(m.salling@csuohio.edu).zip CP460 10/5/2018 OH.dbf CP461 10/5/2018 OH.prj C

P462 10/5/2018 OH.shp CP463 10/5/2018 OH.shx C

P464 10/5/2018 2010_VTDS_2012_2014_2016 election_data.xlsx CP465 11/27/2018 2011_Incumbent_addresses_11_27.zip CP466 11/27/2018 HYPO1A.dbf C

P467 11/27/2018 HYPO2A.dbf C

P468 11/30/2018 2018-11-30 Incumbent Addresses PreviouP469 11/30/2018 Nov30.DBF Previou

P470 12/28/2018 2018_DATA.DBF Previou

P471 12/28/2018 New Incumbent address.xlsx Previou

P472 10/5/2018 OH data.sav P473 11/12/2018 Effgaps2.csv excel PreviouP474 10/5/2018 "USHouse_Data_updated.RData" W

P475 10/5/2018 "declination_data" W

P476 12/28/2018 Warshaw Supplemental Report ("An Evaluation of the Partisan 

Bias in Ohio’s 2011 Congressional Plan and its Effects on Representation: Updated based on 2018 Elections")

Previous

P477 8/14/2012 REV_000P478 9/15/2011 REV_000

P479 4/19/2012 REV_000

P480 12/20/2011 REV_000

P481 7/26/2018 REV_000

31 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 32 of 39 PAG

 7193
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P482 12/20/2011 REV_000

P483 7/26/2018 REV_000

P484 12/20/2011 REV_000

P485 7/26/2018 REV_000

P486 11/6/2011 REV_000P487 9/9/2011 REV_000P488 9/9/2011 REV_000

P489 9/9/2011 REV_000P490 9/9/2011 REV_000

P491 9/9/2011 REV_000P492 9/9/2011 REV_000

P493 9/9/2011 REV_000

P494 9/9/2011 REV_000

P495 9/9/2011 REV_000

P496 9/22/2011 REV_000

32 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 33 of 39 PAG

 7194
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P497 12/14/2011 REV_000

P498 12/14/2011 REV_000

P499 12/14/2011 REV_000

P500 9/16/2011 REV_000P501 12/14/2011 REV_000

P502 7/13/2011 Email from C. Boor to H. Mann, S. Marangoni and R. Kapala, 

subject Double Tree Suites Reservation

LW

P503 11/28/2011 Vouchers for payment for vendors Capital Advantage LLC and 

Policy Widgets LLC

LWV

P504 10/5/2018 analysis_ushouse.R WA

P505 10/5/2018 cces_OH.R WAP506 10/5/2018 cces2014_trustrep.r WAP507 10/5/2018 dataassembly_ushouse.R WAP508 10/5/2018 remedial_plan_analysis.R WAP509 11/26/2018 PrePost2011_Ohio.R WAP510 11/26/2018 rebuttal_competitiveness.R WAP511 11/26/2018 remedial_plan_analysis_imputations.R WAP512 12/28/2018 analysis_ushouse_2018.R PreviousP513 12/28/2018 dataassembly_ushouse_2018.R PreviousP514 12/28/2018 remedial_analysis_2018.R PreviousP515 8/1/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Capital Advantage, LLC

LWV

P516 8/3/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Policy Widgets, LLC

LWV

P517 9/11/2011 Email from C. Widener to T. Niehaus and M. Schuler, subject 

Fw: clark county

LW

33 of 38

CONFIDENTIAL

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 34 of 39 PAG

 7195
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P518 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Niehaus, subject Proposed map for 

LSC

LWV

P519 9/11/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Niehaus, subject Map 2 of 4 LW

P520 9/12/2011 Email from M. Schuler to H. Mann and T. Judy, (no subject) LWP521 9/20/2011 HB 318/HB 319 Senate Government Oversight & Reform

Committee File

Nie

P522 10/12/2011 Statement from Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted NieP523 12/14/2011 Transcript, Ohio State Senate Session NieP524 10/5/2018 Report of David Niven, Ph.D., "Dividing Neighbors and 

Diminishing Voices: An Analysis of Ohio's Congressional Districts"

N

P525 Oct. 2018 David Niven Curriculum Vitae N

P526 11/26/2018 Report of David Niven, Ph.D., "Response to Dr. Thornton and 

Dr. Brunell"

N

P527 9/20/2011 HB 318/HB 319 Senate Government Oversight & Reform

Committee File

O

P528 9/21/2011 Transcript, Ohio State Senate Session OP529 10/19/2011 Email from M. Rowe to A. Hoyt, R. Routt, et al., subject DRAFT 

COPY: Letter to Niehaus and Batchelder

S

P530 11/3/2011 Email from R. Routt to Senator Cafaro, et al., subject Re: 

Proposed Batchelder Maps and info, attaching maps

SM

P531 11/3/2011 Email from R. Routt to Senator Cafaro, et al., subject Re: 

Proposed Batchelder Maps and info, attaching maps

SM

P532 11/3/2011 Email from R. Routt to Senator Cafaro, et al., subject Re: 

Proposed Batchelder Maps and info, attaching maps

SM

P533 12/15/2011 Email from R. Routt to E.Stockhausen, subject RE: 11th 

Congressional District

S

P534 11/3/2011 Email from S. Cherry to R. Routt, subject Re: Redistricting Plan 

for LSC drafting

S

P535 10/28/2011 Email from R. Routt to E. Kearney, C. Tavares, et al., subject 

Proposed Republican draft concept map

S

34 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 35 of 39 PAG

 7196
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P536 12/22/2011 Email from R. Routt to G. Boas and A. Hoyt, subject HB 

369/HB319 Statistical comparison

P537 7/15/2018 Email from B. Hansen to C. Sulecki, subject Fwd: did you 

attend

HA

P538 5/12/2011 Discussion Points for Mark Braden Meetings LW

P539 Meeting Notice: "FW: Weekly Redistricting Meeting" P540 7/7/2011 Redistricting Meetings Agenda LWVP541 8/1/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Capital Advantage, LLC

LWV

P542 8/3/2011 Consulting Agreement between Republican Members of the 

Legislative Task Force and Policy Widgets, LLC

LWV

P543 8/16/2011 Email from Ray DiRossi to Matt Schuler, subject Tuesday at 

redistricting office

LW

P544 Maptitude screenshot, HB 319 As Enacted - Congressional 

Districts.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio)

BLESSIN

Enacted 

P545 Maptitude screenshot, HB 319 As Enacted - Congressional 

Districts.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks (Ohio) (dataview District 15)

BLESSIN

Enac

Dis

P546 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Niehaus, subject Proposed map for 

LSC

LWV

P547 2011 Ohio Redistricting Competition Rules and Scoring S

P548 Feb. 2012 Ohio Redistricting Transparency Report, The Elephant In the 

Room (2nd edition)

S

P549 11/17/2010 Email from A. Kuhn to S. Stivers forwarding email from D. 

DiSanto, subject Ohio Republican Delegation Meeting -- Thursday, Nov. 18

S

P550 1/8/2011 Email from K. Stivers to S. Stivers forwarding email exchange 

with J. Husted, subject line Congratulations

S

P551 3/22/2011 Email from M.B. Carozza to S. Stivers and A. Kuhn, subject 

Checking In

S

35 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 36 of 39 PAG

 7197
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P552 6/1/2011 Email from C. Whetstone to S. Stivers, M.B. Carozza and A. 

Kuhn, subject line redistricting

S

P553 8/15/2011 Email from L. Crotty to S. Stivers, M.B. Carozza, and A. Kuhn, 

subject For Approval: Fin Com Agenda, attaching Stivers August 16, 2011 Finance Committee Meeting Agenda

ST

P554 9/10/2011 Email exchange between S. Stivers, M.B. Carozza and A. Kuhn, 

subject line Checking In

ST

P555 12/7/2011 Email from L. Crotty to S. Stivers, subject Calls Today and 

Ingram Tracker, attaching Ingram 2012 Tracker spreadsheet

ST

P556 3/2/2012 Email exchange between S. Stivers, C, Whetstone and A. Kuhn 

forwarding email from A. Blake, subject line Redistricting

ST

P557 9/11/2011 Email exchange between M.B. Carozza, S. Stivers and A. Kuhn, 

subject line Checking In

ST

P558 9/15/2011 Transcript, Ohio House Session SzP559 Compromise Proposal to Draw Fair Congressional Districts SMP560 11/2/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to C. Glassburn and A. Budish, subject 

Re: counter - Draft Presentation, attaching presentation "Redistricting Discussions Nov. 2, 2011"

SMC-KM-0

P561 11/23/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to A. Budish, (no subject), attaching 

spreadsheet LWV and GOP Index Composite Scores

SMC-KM-0

P562 Presentation, "Summary of Compromise Efforts to Resolve 

Redistricting Impasse, Avoid Two Different Primary Elections and Save Taxpayers $15 million"

SM

P563 11/3/2011 Email from S. Bender to K. McCarthy, subject RE: final release SMP564 11/3/2011 Transcript of Video Recorded Session, Ohio House of 

Representatives

Sz

36 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 37 of 39 PAG

 7198
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P565 11/4/2011 Email from A. Budish to K. McCarthy, subject Fw: Frustration SzP566 11/15/2011 Email from D. Ramos to A. Budish, M. Szollosi, et al., subject 

Concerns about Redistricting

SMC-KM-0

P567 11/30/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to T. Heard, et al., subject Talking 

Points fro ^_Redistricting^_ Impasse

SM

P568 11/30/2011 Email from K. McCarthy to M. Szollos, subject Talking Points 

for Blade

SM

P569 12/4/2011 The Blade Editorial, "Crossing the lines" Sz

P570 12/18/2018 R-code TrP571 10/5/2018 Warshaw Report ("An Evaluation of the Partisan Bias in Ohio’s 

2011 Congressional Districting Plan and its Effects on Representation in Congress")

Wa

P572 11/26/2018 Warshaw Rebuttal Report ("An Evaluation of the Partisan Bias 

in Ohio’s 2011 Congressional Plan and its Effects on Representation: Rebuttal Report")

Wa

P573 2018 APRI Columbus Membership List O

P574 10/18/2014 APRI Dayton Membership List OA

P575 APRI Youngstown Membership List O

P576 2018 APRI Cleveland Membership List OA

P577 2/21/2018 APRI Akron/Canton Membership List OAP578 2018 APRI Toledo Membership List OP579 1/6/2011 Email from A. Washington to all APRI chapters, subject 2010 

labor/minority debriefing

OA

P580 9/2/2011 Email from A. Kincaid to R. DiRossi, H. Mann and T. Whatman, 

subject New Idea Redraft

LWV

P581 9/11/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Whatman, subject Widener 

proposal update

LWV

P582 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Whatman, subject Stivers Maps LWP583 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to T. Niehaus, subject Proposed map for 

LSC

LWV

37 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 38 of 39 PAG

 7199
Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, et al. v. Householder, et al.

S.D. Ohio Case No. 1:18-cv-357-TSB-KNM-MHW

Plaintiffs' Ex. No. Date Description 

P584 9/11/2011 Email from T. Niehaus to T. Whatman, subject Redistricting 

"tweaks"

LW

P585 9/11/2011 Email from Chris Widener to President Niehaus and others re 

Clark County

LW

P586 Chart, Election Results (Breakdown in the districts between

Turner and Austria)

P587 9/12/2011 Email from R. DiRossi to A. Kincaid, subject Ohio final map with 

possible Stivers addition

LWV

P588 3/31/2011 Chart, Ohio Changes P589 District 16 maps P590 Chart, Ohio Changes P591 Colored Map with sixteen districts and counties 

P592 10/27/2011 Maptitude screenshot, 10-27-11 Adam New Map.map - 2010 

Final Census Blocks (Ohio)

BLESSING0

P593 Turner-Austria Option Talking Points LW

P594 Talking Points for Speaker Boehner 

P595 Spreadsheet with tables and column Turner/Austria L

P596 10/19/2011 Chart, HB319 P597 11/2/2011 Table HB 319 Unified Indexes/Proposal Unified Indexes D

P598 12/28/2018 Cooper Third Supplemental Declaration Previou

38 of 38

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-7 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 39 of 39 PAG

 7200