Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (1 of 4)

Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs

Landfill Option 

Total Cost: 

Scenario 2B

MWC Option 

Total Cost

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total 

Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

LADeltech HB-507

Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas Flue Gas Recirculation

CO oxidation catalyst, fabric 

filter $2,111,113 $533,006 $123,896 $89,587 $2,235,009 $622,593 n/a n/a n/a n/a $2,235,009 $622,593

LADeltech HB-512 Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas Flue Gas Recirculation

CO oxidation catalyst, fabric 

filter $5,384,706 $1,237,710 $123,896 $89,587 $5,508,602 $1,327,297 n/a n/a n/a n/a $5,508,602 $1,327,297

MDSeverstalSparrows 1BLR Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas No Equipment

CO oxidation catalyst, fabric 

filter, SNCR $18,264,374 $3,949,452 $249,050 $134,227 $18,513,424 $4,083,679 n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,513,424 $4,083,679

MEPioneerPlastics Boiler #5/Thermal 

Oxidizer

Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas No Equipment

CO oxidation catalyst, fabric 

filter, SNCR $5,787,718 $1,354,042 $134,196 $92,787 $5,921,914 $1,446,829 n/a n/a n/a n/a $5,921,914 $1,446,829

WAEmeraldKalama U-2

Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas

Collectors, Settling 

Chambers, Separators - 

General CO oxidation catalyst $526,381 $218,879 $98,396 $79,887 $624,777 $298,766 n/a n/a n/a n/a $624,777 $298,766

WAEmeraldKalama U-7

Energy recovery unit - 

Liquid/Gas

Collectors, Settling 

Chambers, Separators - 

General none $0 $0 $98,396 $79,887 $98,396 $79,887 n/a n/a n/a n/a $98,396 $79,887

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / 

BK02 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

$0 $0 $223,076 $122,254 $223,076 $122,254 n/a n/a n/a n/a $223,076 $122,254

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, 

ACI $9,440,356 $2,361,564 $272,876 $146,854 $9,713,232 $2,508,418 n/a n/a n/a n/a $9,713,232 $2,508,418

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Wet Scrubber

LBMS, DIFF, ACI

$31,596,873 $9,992,006 $241,076 $151,154 $31,837,949 $10,143,160 n/a n/a n/a n/a $31,837,949 $10,143,160

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

$40,233,740 $15,234,135 $265,376 $155,754 $40,499,116 $15,389,890 n/a n/a n/a n/a $40,499,116 $15,389,890

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72) Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter,tune-up, wet 

scrubber, ACI $3,597,265 $839,007 $114,876 $91,554 $3,712,141 $930,561 n/a n/a n/a n/a $3,712,141 $930,561

CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#1

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$16,367,578 $4,292,447 $241,076 $150,654 $16,608,654 $4,443,102 n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,608,654 $4,443,102

CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#2

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$15,468,205 $4,041,252 $241,076 $150,654 $15,709,281 $4,191,906 n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,709,281 $4,191,906

CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#3

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

tune-up, DIFF, ACI

$16,034,510 $4,169,853 $241,076 $150,654 $16,275,586 $4,320,507 n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,275,586 $4,320,507

LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

$39,817,175 $15,240,342 $265,376 $156,254 $40,082,551 $15,396,596 n/a n/a n/a n/a $40,082,551 $15,396,596

LAIPMansfield 1-78 - No. 1 Power 

Boiler / EQT005 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up, wet scrubber, fabric 

filter, ACI

$21,828,359 $6,842,866 $272,876 $147,654 $22,101,235 $6,990,521 n/a n/a n/a n/a $22,101,235 $6,990,521

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power 

Boiler Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, fabric filter, 

ACI

$29,503,126 $10,747,704 $272,876 $147,654 $29,776,002 $10,895,358 n/a n/a n/a n/a $29,776,002 $10,895,358

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up, wet scrubber

$381,643 $212,501 $89,376 $71,754 $471,019 $284,255 n/a n/a n/a n/a $471,019 $284,255

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up, DIFF

$6,676,672 $1,912,946 $83,076 $84,254 $6,759,748 $1,997,200 n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,759,748 $1,997,200

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI

$36,650,262 $10,214,792 $241,076 $150,654 $36,891,338 $10,365,446 n/a n/a n/a n/a $36,891,338 $10,365,446

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel 

Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

$10,465,420 $2,857,139 $265,376 $157,054 $10,730,796 $3,014,193 n/a n/a n/a n/a $10,730,796 $3,014,193

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI

$12,471,715 $2,691,554 $83,076 $81,354 $12,554,791 $2,772,908 n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,554,791 $2,772,908

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, fabric filter, 

ACI $10,948,275 $2,888,681 $114,876 $87,854 $11,063,151 $2,976,535 n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,063,151 $2,976,535

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 Energy recovery unit - 

Solids Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI

$11,151,955 $2,797,316 $83,076 $86,554 $11,235,031 $2,883,870 n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,235,031 $2,883,870

TNPackagingCorpCounce Combination Boiler #2

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

CO oxidation catalyst, DIFF

$29,391,524 $8,954,349 $241,076 $141,354 $29,632,600 $9,095,703 n/a n/a n/a n/a $29,632,600 $9,095,703

TNTempleInland2426 5000F Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, caustic, ACI

$17,677,787 $4,941,897 $241,076 $151,254 $17,918,863 $5,093,151 n/a n/a n/a n/a $17,918,863 $5,093,151

TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI

$31,552,076 $7,404,993 $248,576 $141,754 $31,800,652 $7,546,747 n/a n/a n/a n/a $31,800,652 $7,546,747

Total MACT Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs: 

Scenario 2A

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and Lowest Cost Option

Recordkeeping Costs

Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, 

Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs

Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT 

Controls
Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (2 of 4)

Landfill Option 

Total Cost: 

Scenario 2B

MWC Option 

Total Cost

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total 

Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total MACT Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs: 

Scenario 2A

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and Lowest Cost Option

Recordkeeping Costs

Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, 

Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs

Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT 

Controls

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation catalyst, ACI, 

DIFF+caustic

$19,885,386 $5,473,369 $241,076 $146,754 $20,126,462 $5,620,124 n/a n/a n/a n/a $20,126,462 $5,620,124

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

LBMS, DIFF, ACI, wet 

scrubber

$24,147,744 $6,921,863 $265,376 $152,354 $24,413,120 $7,074,218 n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,413,120 $7,074,218

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

fabric filter, tune-up, ACI

$15,853,342 $3,804,447 $248,576 $141,254 $16,101,918 $3,945,701 n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,101,918 $3,945,701

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF+wet scrubber

$16,475,116 $4,998,612 $265,376 $155,854 $16,740,492 $5,154,466 n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,740,492 $5,154,466

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Solids

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF+wet scrubber

$16,977,238 $5,152,230 $265,376 $155,854 $17,242,614 $5,308,084 n/a n/a n/a n/a $17,242,614 $5,308,084

CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 1 Incinerator

Unknown

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $1,413,774 $350,709 $115,350 $89,527 $1,529,124 $440,236 n/a n/a -$66,988 -$62,358 $0 -$66,988

CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 2 Incinerator

Unknown

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $1,412,248 $351,133 $115,350 $89,627 $1,527,598 $440,761 n/a n/a -$67,425 -$62,761 $0 -$67,425

CAArmtecdefense Scrap incinerator 3 Incinerator

Unknown

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $1,493,879 $372,845 $115,350 $89,527 $1,609,229 $462,372 n/a n/a -$66,056 -$61,500 $0 -$66,056

CTPfizer FB-IN-01 Incinerator VENTURI SCRUBBER, 

TRAY TOWER SCRUBBER, 

Wet ESP

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI $2,019,002 $643,790 $80,750 $80,727 $2,099,752 $724,517 n/a n/a -$2,464 $44,813 $0 -$2,464

ILF&MStateBank Incinerator Incinerator

No Equipment

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $2,826,504 $507,685 $115,350 $83,727 $2,941,854 $591,412 n/a n/a -$746 -$746 $0 -$746

ILFlintHillsResources HB-2301 Incinerator

Fabric Filter

afterburner retrofit, improve 

fabric filter $302,739 $130,642 $55,250 $65,227 $357,989 $195,869 n/a n/a $179 $70,740 $0 $179

ILFlintHillsResources MB-1012 Incinerator Fabric Filter ACI, improve fabric filter $35,065 $119,444 $55,250 $74,527 $90,315 $193,971 n/a n/a $770,561 $1,353,927 $90,315 $193,971

ILFlintHillsResources NB-800 Incinerator Fabric Filter improve fabric filter $0 $8,608 $55,250 $65,227 $55,250 $73,835 n/a n/a -$32,160 $17,125 $0 -$32,160

ILPolyOne CE4 Incinerator

No Equipment

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $3,045,728 $530,186 $115,350 $83,727 $3,161,078 $613,913 n/a n/a -$8,960 -$8,951 $0 -$8,960

INCovanceLabsGreenfield 241-1A Incinerator

No Equipment

fabric filter, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $2,688,970 $684,972 $115,350 $89,327 $2,804,320 $774,299 n/a n/a -$48,268 -$32,568 $0 -$48,268

KSCNHWichita Ace Burn-off Oven Incinerator

Unknown

afterburner retrofit, fabric 

filter, SNCR, ACI $2,871,485 $707,052 $91,050 $83,927 $2,962,535 $790,979 n/a n/a $129,480 $265,400 $0 $129,480

LAShellChemical F-T701 Incinerator Wet Scrubber and Wet 

Electrostatic Precipitator

afterburner retrofit, ACI, 

SNCR, fabric filter $4,142,114 $1,022,515 $91,050 $83,927 $4,233,164 $1,106,443 n/a n/a $1,598,621 $2,708,637 $4,233,164 $1,106,443

NCGlaxoSmithKline MWI-2 Incinerator Dry Scrubbing (General), 

Fabric Filter

wet scrubber, SNCR, 

improve fabric filter, ACI $1,582,312 $424,176 $89,850 $84,127 $1,672,162 $508,304 n/a n/a $42,006 $150,120 $0 $42,006

NDCNHAmerica INC-1 Incinerator

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, wet 

scrubber, fabric filter, SNCR, 

ACI $2,953,530 $637,295 $115,350 $86,327 $3,068,880 $723,622 n/a n/a -$13,092 -$11,682 $0 -$13,092

NJNovartis 34 Incinerator

Dry Scrubbing (General), 

Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, 

afterburner retrofit, wet 

scrubber, SNCR, ACI $1,108,815 $247,093 $89,850 $79,827 $1,198,665 $326,921 n/a n/a -$19,687 $16,046 $0 -$19,687

OKPioneerTelephone MS200 Incinerator

Unknown

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $3,630,492 $596,538 $115,350 $83,727 $3,745,842 $680,265 n/a n/a -$14,649 -$14,542 $0 -$14,649

PAAshlandNevilleIsland PR TOX Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, ACI, SNCR $2,248,920 $598,313 $91,050 $87,927 $2,339,970 $686,240 n/a n/a $225,263 $451,439 $0 $225,263

PASmithKlineBeecham 003 Incinerator

Fabric Filter, Venturi Scrubber

improve fabric filter, 

afterburner retrofit, SNCR, 

ACI $380,071 $75,224 $65,550 $71,927 $445,621 $147,151 n/a n/a -$40,962 -$35,602 $0 -$40,962

SCEastmanColombia 1560-0008, ID #15 Incinerator

Wet Scrubber

afterburner retrofit, fabric 

filter, ACI $1,486,299 $649,557 $80,750 $84,727 $1,567,049 $734,285 n/a n/a $1,460,242 $2,499,242 $1,567,049 $734,285

TXBASFFreeport IN-4702 Incinerator

No Equipment

SNCR, fabric filter, wet 

scrubber $2,193,081 $495,268 $115,350 $83,727 $2,308,431 $578,996 n/a n/a $283,157 $548,335 $0 $283,157

TXBASFFreeport IN-5500 Incinerator No Equipment fabric filter, wet scrubber $11,515,274 $3,303,695 $105,050 $80,527 $11,620,324 $3,384,222 n/a n/a $1,261,506 $2,172,472 $0 $1,261,506

TXReichhold Thermal Oxidizer Incinerator

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, ACI, wet 

scrubber, fabric filter $2,778,010 $873,071 $105,050 $87,727 $2,883,060 $960,799 n/a n/a -$6,600 $48,285 $0 -$6,600

TXSterlingChemTexasCity 53H3 Incinerator

Unknown

fabric filter, ACI, wet 

scrubber $1,353,335 $452,279 $105,050 $89,827 $1,458,385 $542,107 n/a n/a -$22,068 $37,822 $0 -$22,068
Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (3 of 4)

Landfill Option 

Total Cost: 

Scenario 2B

MWC Option 

Total Cost

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total 

Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total MACT Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs: 

Scenario 2A

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and Lowest Cost Option

Recordkeeping Costs

Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, 

Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs

Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT 

Controls

VATransInd 50825 Incinerator

No Equipment

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, ACI, SNCR, wet 

scrubber $2,992,517 $540,822 $115,350 $84,027 $3,107,867 $624,850 n/a n/a -$12,004 -$11,715 $0 -$12,004

WABoeingDevelopmentalCenter 9-67 data-destroy 

incinerator

Incinerator

No Equipment

fabric filter, afterburner 

retrofit, SNCR $1,518,552 $263,847 $91,050 $78,127 $1,609,602 $341,974 n/a n/a -$16,415 -$8,169 $0 -$16,415

WVDuPontWashingtonWorks T71ME Incinerator Wet scrubber fabric filter, ACI $903,378 $318,632 $80,750 $84,827 $984,128 $403,459 n/a n/a $107,962 $258,198 $0 $107,962

AKAlyeskaPumpStation5 35-IN-1 Small, remote

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, ACI, 

fabric filter $858,981 $156,030 $80,750 $75,527 $939,731 $231,558 $142,503 $92,810 $1,220,258 n/a $142,503 $92,810

AKAlyeskaPumpStation7 37-IN-1 Small, remote

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, ACI, 

fabric filter $858,981 $184,575 $80,750 $77,527 $939,731 $262,102 $142,503 $129,717 $4,968,154 n/a $142,503 $129,717

AKChugachElectricBeluga EU No. 9 Small, remote

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, ACI, 

fabric filter $898,930 $197,669 $80,750 $77,527 $979,680 $275,197 $154,379 $133,792 $4,968,154 n/a $154,379 $133,792

AKCoeur Incinerator Small, remote No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $160,288 $80,750 $77,027 $852,478 $237,315 $55,250 $128,241 $6,804,920 n/a $55,250 $128,241

AKCookInletPipeline-DriftRiver Drift River Terminal 

Incinerator

Small, remote

No Equipment afterburner retrofit $77,560 $15,199 $55,250 $65,227 $132,810 $80,427 $132,810 $91,769 $1,207,836 n/a $132,810 $80,427

AKEntechAlaska Incin # 1 Small, remote

No Equipment fabric filter, afterburner retrofit $854,301 $160,036 $80,750 $74,927 $935,051 $234,963 $935,051 $255,679 $2,226,096 n/a $935,051 $234,963

AKHeclaGreensCreekJuneau Consumat Incinerator Small, remote

No Equipment

afterburner retrofit, ACI, 

fabric filter $858,981 $225,524 $80,750 $80,027 $939,731 $305,551 $142,503 $116,282 $2,736,965 n/a $142,503 $116,282

AKKuparukCentral Production H-250 (EU 35) Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $87,253 $33,767 $55,250 $65,227 $142,503 $98,994 $142,503 $325,842 $24,471,689 n/a $142,503 $98,994

AKKuparukCentral Production H-347 (EU 36) Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $87,253 $35,719 $55,250 $65,227 $142,503 $100,946 $142,503 $327,794 $24,479,397 n/a $142,503 $100,946

AKPioneerNR I-5 incinerator Small, remote No Equipment ACI, fabric filter $771,728 $202,192 $80,750 $80,027 $852,478 $282,219 $55,250 $110,597 $4,857,918 n/a $55,250 $110,597

AKTeckComincoAlaskaIncRedDogMine MI-2 Small, remote

No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $190,429 $80,750 $79,127 $852,478 $269,556 $55,250 $292,075 $24,559,294 n/a $852,478 $269,556

AKTeckComincoAlaskaIncRedDogMine MI-3 Small, remote

No Equipment fabric filter, ACI $771,728 $149,855 $80,750 $76,227 $852,478 $226,083 $55,250 $104,934 $4,284,511 n/a $55,250 $104,934

AKUOCCTradingBay R-H-0800 Small, remote No Equipment afterburner retrofit $85,072 $16,198 $55,250 $65,227 $140,322 $81,425 $140,322 $85,413 $418,929 n/a $140,322 $81,425

AKXTOEnergy INCINERATOR Small, remote No Equipment ACI, fabric filter $771,728 $139,169 $80,750 $75,527 $852,478 $214,696 $55,250 $69,543 $453,059 n/a $55,250 $69,543

CACAPortlandCementColton K-1

Waste-burning kiln Collectors, Settling 

Chambers, Separators - 

General, Cyclone: Multiple 

(Multiclone), Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

ACI $7,784,105 $112 $429,667 $227,421 $8,213,772 $2,873,014 n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,213,772 $2,873,014

CACAPortlandCementColton K-2

Waste-burning kiln Collectors, Settling 

Chambers, Separators - 

General, Cyclone: Multiple 

(Multiclone), Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

ACI $11,728,958 $85 $429,667 $227,421 $12,158,625 $4,754,789 n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,158,625 $4,754,789

CALehighSouthwestReddingPlant

In-Line Kiln/Raw Mill 

(S260)

Waste-burning kiln

Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI, $18,123,393 $155 $453,967 $233,521 $18,577,360 $5,870,809 n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,577,360 $5,870,809

FLCemexMiami Cement Kiln

Waste-burning kiln

Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI, SNCR $31,858,481 $10,592,862 $464,267 $235,721 $32,322,748 $10,828,583 n/a n/a n/a n/a $32,322,748 $10,828,583

IALafargeBuffalo Kiln 1

Waste-burning kiln

Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, wet 

scrubber $10,671,531 $2,505,294 $453,967 $223,421 $11,125,498 $2,728,715 n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,125,498 $2,728,715

IALehighCementMasonCity 302.203

Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Fabric Filter, Flue Gas 

Desulfurization (General), 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

wet scrubber, improve fabric 

filter $11,825,103 $2,777,095 $453,967 $223,421 $12,279,069 $3,000,515 n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,279,069 $3,000,515

MDLehighCementUnionBridge E02-001 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter improve fabric filter, ACI $163,424 $2,398,483 $429,667 $227,421 $593,090 $2,625,904 n/a n/a n/a n/a $593,090 $2,625,904

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 19

Waste-burning kiln

low-NOx burners, Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI $15,149,891 $4,523,792 $453,967 $232,021 $15,603,858 $4,755,813 n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,603,858 $4,755,813

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 20

Waste-burning kiln

low-NOx burners, Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI $15,543,973 $4,654,623 $453,967 $232,021 $15,997,939 $4,886,643 n/a n/a n/a n/a $15,997,939 $4,886,643

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 21

Waste-burning kiln

low-NOx burners, Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI $15,822,156 $4,747,332 $453,967 $232,021 $16,276,123 $4,979,353 n/a n/a n/a n/a $16,276,123 $4,979,353

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 22

Waste-burning kiln

low-NOx burners, Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI $23,638,720 $7,409,038 $453,967 $232,021 $24,092,687 $7,641,058 n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,092,687 $7,641,058

MILafargeMidwestAlpena 23

Waste-burning kiln

low-NOx burners, Fabric Filter

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

wet scrubber, ACI $23,595,088 $7,394,503 $453,967 $232,021 $24,049,054 $7,626,523 n/a n/a n/a n/a $24,049,054 $7,626,523

PALafargeWhitehallPlant Kiln 2 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $12,214,293 $3,169,462 $453,967 $230,321 $12,668,260 $3,399,783 n/a n/a n/a n/a $12,668,260 $3,399,783

PALafargeWhitehallPlant Kiln 3 Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter RTO, wet scrubber, ACI $9,238,614 $2,306,990 $453,967 $229,221 $9,692,581 $2,536,211 n/a n/a n/a n/a $9,692,581 $2,536,211

PALehighCementEvansville 121

Waste-burning kiln Cyclone: Single, Dry 

Limestone Injection, Fabric 

Filter

wet scrubber, ACI, improve 

fabric filter $5,711,188 $2,453,068 $453,967 $233,521 $6,165,155 $2,686,589 n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,165,155 $2,686,589

PALehighCementEvansville 122

Waste-burning kiln Cyclone: Single, Dry 

Limestone Injection, Fabric 

Filter

wet scrubber, ACI, improve 

fabric filter $5,913,519 $2,092,050 $453,967 $233,521 $6,367,486 $2,325,570 n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,367,486 $2,325,570

PALehighCementYork 200 Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator fabric filter, RTO $11,518,519 $3,261,638 $455,167 $227,521 $11,973,686 $3,489,159 n/a n/a n/a n/a $11,973,686 $3,489,159

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 1

Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $6,414,103 $2,427,703 $455,167 $237,121 $6,869,269 $2,664,824 n/a n/a n/a n/a $6,869,269 $2,664,824

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 2

Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $7,794,327 $2,957,077 $455,167 $237,121 $8,249,493 $3,194,197 n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,249,493 $3,194,197
Table 3. Summary of MACT Compliance and Alternative Disposal Costs (4 of 4)

Landfill Option 

Total Cost: 

Scenario 2B

MWC Option 

Total Cost

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total 

Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual Cost 

($/yr)

Total MACT Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs: 

Scenario 2A

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and Lowest Cost Option

Recordkeeping Costs

Total MACT Floor Control, Monitoring, 

Reporting, and Recordkeeping Costs

Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT 

Controls

TXAshGroveMidlothian Kiln 3

Waste-burning kiln Electrostatic Precipitator, 

Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, fabric filter $8,049,178 $3,055,143 $455,167 $234,132 $8,504,345 $3,289,274 n/a n/a n/a n/a $8,504,345 $3,289,274

TXHolcimMidlothianPlant Kiln 1

Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter, Selective NonCatalytic Reduction (NH3 Or 

Urea Injection) (SNCR), Wet 

Scrubber

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

improve wet scrubber $18,542,582 $6,140,216 $429,667 $217,821 $18,972,248 $6,358,036 n/a n/a n/a n/a $18,972,248 $6,358,036

TXHolcimMidlothianPlant Kiln 2

Waste-burning kiln Fabric Filter, Selective NonCatalytic Reduction (NH3 Or 

Urea Injection) (SNCR), Wet 

Scrubber

improve fabric filter, RTO, 

improve wet scrubber $19,535,985 $6,547,436 $429,667 $217,821 $19,965,652 $6,765,257 n/a n/a n/a n/a $19,965,652 $6,765,257

UTHolcimDevilsSlide Kiln 1

Waste-burning kiln

Fabric Filter

RTO, wet scrubber, ACI, 

improve fabric filter $25,805,705 $9,102,907 $453,967 $232,521 $26,259,671 $9,335,428 n/a n/a n/a n/a $26,259,671 $9,335,428

$900,732,516 $259,570,058 $20,305,339 $12,512,851 $921,037,855 $284,892,806 $859,140,295 $270,337,904