Exhibit E-2

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 1 of 17 PAGEID #: 3160
Date Description of Services Time

4/5/2018 Team call re: next steps after filing 1.0

4/6/2018 Review order re mtn to proceed anon 0.2

4/6/2018 Review corr re retainers finalized 0.1

6/14/2018 Review corr re new opposing counsel; req for extension 0.3

6/21/2018 TC re initial disclosures, 26f report 1.0

6/22/2018 Draft 26f plan & circulate 0.5

6/22/2018 Talk w/ team & make edits re 26f 0.6

6/22/2018 Further talking w/ team re case plan 0.2

6/25/2018 26f conference w/ OC 1.2

6/28/2018 Request & review discovery from similar cases from colleagues 1.0

6/28/2018 TC re discovery, strategy 0.9

7/3/2018 Drafting discovery requests 1.7

7/5/2018 Draft discovery requests & send to FJL 2.4

7/6/2018 Read & notes on Defs' MTD 1.0

7/6/2018 Corr. to set up conf w/ team re MTD 0.1

7/9/2018 Prep for TC re MTD 0.3

7/9/2018 TC re MTD & 26f report draft 1.0

7/9/2018 Add'l strategy conversion after TC, internal only 0.3

7/9/2018 Rev 26f for changes based on TC, corr. to FJL re same 0.4

7/9/2018 Rev 26f for changes based on TC, corr. to FJL re same 0.1

7/10/2018 Corr w/ team re editing schedule for MTD opposition 0.2

7/10/2018 Research - compelled speech claim, read similar case briefing 3.0

7/10/2018 Work on draft of our disc requests to send to KNI 2.0

7/11/2018 Corr w/ KNI re edits to disc requests 0.1

7/11/2018 Call w/ KNI re discovery 0.5

7/11/2018 Review & edit discovery requests, sent FJL to discuss 0.7

7/11/2018 Review & corr w/ KNI, disc requests 1.0

7/11/2018 Corr w/ KNI re disc requests 0.4

7/11/2018 Apply all edits, send discovery to whole team 0.4

7/12/2018

Research & writing - compelled speech section of opp & state law & 

intro 4.7

7/14/2018 Research & writing, my sections opp brief complete, sent off to team 8.5

Elizabeth Bonham

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 2 of 17 PAGEID #: 3161
7/15/2018 Review & make edits to KNI, GA sections of opp brief 3.8

7/15/2018 Talk to KNI GA re opp brief reconciliation 0.5

7/15/2018 New edits to opp to MTD brief 3.6

7/15/2018 Revisions to opp brief, resolve all edits to same 4.2

7/15/2018 Corr. & send final brief to KNI 0.3

7/16/2018 Corr. w/ team re editing schedule for brief 0.2

7/16/2018 Review comments to discovery drafts 0.4

7/16/2018 Corr to KNI re discovery drafts 0.2

7/17/2018 Resolve all edits, finalize discovery documents 4.9

7/17/2018 Corr w/ KNI re discovery draft edits 0.1

7/17/2018 Corr w/ team re: setup for 26f conf, serve discovery, & serve 2.0

7/18/2018 Review all edits to opp brief before call; corr. to FJL, SJB re same 1.0

7/18/2018 TC re opposition brief 1.0

7/18/2018 Pretrial conf all parties w/ J Vasucra 1.2

7/18/2018 Review initial research re opp to stay motion 0.1

7/19/2018 Edits to MTD opp brief 2.9

7/20/2018 Additional edits, line edits, to opposition brief; sent clean to KNI 4.4

7/23/2018 Review corr. re internal-only edits to opp to MTD 0.4

7/23/2018

Revise & send new edits to MTD opp brief - internal only - state law 

sec. 1.4

7/23/2018 Corr w/ FJL, SJB to finalize brief, research new FN 0.3

7/24/2018 Schedule group call, whole team corr. 0.1

7/25/2018 Review all edits coming in - MTD opp brief 0.8

7/26/2018 Revise & respond, all final notes on MTD opp 0.6

7/26/2018 Review corr. re more edits to MTD opposition brief 0.2

7/26/2018 Review final opp to MTD brief & send off 0.5

7/26/2018 Reviewed opp to mtn to stay & sent back 1.0

7/26/2018 Talking to FJL re stay motion, corr to David Carey 0.3

7/27/2018 Total time for editing & finalizing opp to motion to stay 1.0

7/27/2018 Final proof read, to EK for finalizing - opp to stay 0.2

10/11/2018 Corr. & prep re discovery, initial disclosures 0.7

12/5/2018 Talk w/, corr., KNI re expert agr. & edit same 0.5

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 3 of 17 PAGEID #: 3162
12/6/2018 Review corr. re discovery deficiencies, strategy re same 0.1

12/21/2018 Corr. w/ team re doc review plan 0.1

1/3/2019 Working to organize docs & begin review 0.3

1/8/2019 Review first written disc. requests 0.9

1/8/2019 Corr. w/ KNI re discovery reactions 0.1

1/8/2019 Call w/ KNI to discuss discovery 0.5

1/8/2019 Corr to set up TC re discovery 0.1

1/8/2019 Further work & corr. w/ TH on doc production 0.3

1/9/2019 Work w/ Marilyn and Jeff re doc production 0.3

1/10/2019 Corr re getting counsel group together for call 0.2

1/10/2019 Started to review doc production 0.1

1/14/2019 Corr re set up TC re discovery 0.1

1/14/2019 Talk w SJB re discovery 0.5

1/14/2019 TC re discovery 1.0

1/14/2019 Initial doc/database review 0.5

1/22/2019 Talk to clients about discovery responses 0.5

1/22/2019 Further corr. w/ clients re discovery responses 0.1

1/23/2019 Review draft responses to discovery 0.5

1/23/2019 Talk to KNI about discovery responses 0.5

1/24/2019 Editing discovery responses, corr. w/ co-counsel re same 1.7

1/25/2019 Review docs & corr w/ DJC re same 0.2

1/27/2019 Talk to 2 clients re medical privacy issues 0.5

1/28/2019 Review doc production summary, attached hot docs 0.4

2/1/2019 Brief check in w/ clients 0.2

2/4/2019 Review KNI discovery responses 1.0

2/4/2019

TC (internal only) re discovery responses, made edits on call & 

circulated 1.0

2/4/2019 TC re discovery 0.5

2/8/2019 Corr. w/ co-counsel re Ettner dec 0.3

2/11/2019 Preparing deficiency letter for co-counsel review 0.5

2/15/2019 Research re redaction problems w/ doc prod, write up 0.7

2/18/2019 Review Ettner report & corr. w/ co-counsel re same 2.5

2/21/2019 Talk w/ clients re status update 0.3

2/25/2019 Talk to KNI re settlement week email & corr to internal team 0.7

2/28/2019 Call w/ OC re settlement week 1.0

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 4 of 17 PAGEID #: 3163
3/1/2019 Consult, corr. & edits to corr. re settlement week 0.7

3/13/2019 Doc review & prepare summary 1.1

3/13/2019 TC re discovery 0.6

3/20/2019 Call w/ KNI re discovery & expert prep 1.0

3/21/2019 TC re expert reports 1.0

3/22/2019 Talking to Dr Ettner 0.7

3/22/2019 Add'l edits to Ettner decl 0.9

3/25/2019

Confer w/ OC, internal corr. w/ co-counsel (call w/ KNI, corr to 

internal team) re moving case deadlines 3.0

3/25/2019 Review research & prepare for conf. w/ court 0.7

3/26/2019 Finalize Ettner report 0.4

3/26/2019 Calls w/ KNI to discuss same 0.4

3/26/2019 Prep & conf re case schedule 1.0

3/29/2019 Drafting & revisions to discovery responses, circ. to team 2.0

3/29/2019 Talk to KNI re discovery requests & follow up 1.0

4/4/2019

Research & corr. w/ co-counsel - re discovery dispute, redactions 

problem 0.9

4/10/2019 Talk to clients re status update 0.6

4/22/2019 Team call re: second set of discovery 1.0

4/26/2019 Review & respond to Defs letter re discovery 1.8

4/26/2019

Going through discovery responses w/ clients; editing; reviewed w/ 

co-counsel 2.3

5/16/2019 Discuss internally 3d set discovery reqs 0.2

5/20/2019 Discuss 3d disc requests w/ KNI 0.6

5/21/2019 Discuss w/ clients responses to 3d disc requs 0.6

5/21/2019 Team Call re written discovery requests 0.6

5/23/2019 Editing & additional corr. re discovery responses 0.4

5/23/2019 Sent disc responses to team, internal only 0.2

5/24/2019 Reivew privacy research & discuss w/ KNI 0.7

5/25/2019

Review & edit discovery responses, discuss w/ clients, obtain 

verifications 3.2

5/26/2019 Corr. re discovery plan w/ KNI 0.3

6/12/2019 Corr re deposition planning, catching up from vacation - DJC, KNI 0.2

6/13/2019 Call w/ KNI re depositions & other discovery 1.0

6/14/2019 Draft update to team re depositions, expert strategy 0.4

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 5 of 17 PAGEID #: 3164
6/14/2019 Corr w/ internal team re discovery next steps 0.2

6/21/2019 Edits for finalizing Ettner report 1.1

6/21/2019 Corr to Dr Ettner re report 0.2

6/23/2019 Review Ettner report & comments 3.0

6/24/2019 Corr w/ Dr Ettner re report 0.3

6/25/2019 Check in w Lambda re Ettner report 0.4

6/25/2019

Review of redactions log & doc prod., corr to small group for review - 

deficiency letter 2.2

6/25/2019 Edits to def letter 0.3

6/26/2019 Starting deposition prep 0.8

6/27/2019 Review & respond to OC email re discovery deficiency 0.9

6/27/2019

Review corr from OC re discovery issues; research & draft reply for 

team review 3.2

7/1/2019

Corr. w/ whole team re: notice of substitution, Ettner report, 

depositions 0.7

7/1/2019 Final review, corr., research to ready expert report 2.4

7/1/2019 Notice of supp authority 0.2

7/1/2019

Exchange of expert disclosures & review Defendant's, discuss w/ 

small group 3.0

7/2/2019

Continued discovery fight w/ OC re producing birth certificates, 

depositions - research & drafting 2.0

7/2/2019 Talk to clients re depositions 0.4

7/7/2019

Continued discovery dispute & deposition scheduling - talk to all 

clients, obtain BCs & permission, schedule depos, draft & send corr 

to OC re all 2.3

7/8/2019 Discuss depo scheduling w/ KNI 0.1

7/8/2019 Review & discuss internally Defs' "response" to notice of supp auth 0.3

7/15/2019

Review, research, & respond - Ds discovery objection re Belenker 

deposition 3.0

7/18/2019

Meet & confer corr & follow up re deposition locations, disputed 

deposition 1.7

7/18/2019 Review corr. & continue research re rebuttal experts 1.0

7/18/2019 Talk to potential expert 0.9

7/18/2019 Talk to potential expert, review materials 1.5

7/18/2019 Research re expert reports, rebuttal 2.0

7/21/2019 Internal discussion re: rebuttal experts 2.0

7/21/2019 Review potential expert report 1.0

7/21/2019 Talk w/ clients re updates 0.7

7/22/2019 Talk w/ KNI re discovery disputes 0.5

7/23/2019 Team call re rebuttal expert report 0.9

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 6 of 17 PAGEID #: 3165
7/25/2019 Internal corr & add'l research re expert rebuttal strategy 2.7

7/26/2019 Research & outline for discovery conf, conf. & follow up w/ team 2.0

7/26/2019 Research re agency deference & policy making 1.3

7/26/2019 Scheduling corr re expert rebuttal 0.5

7/28/2019 Review, edits re expert rebuttal 4.5

7/29/2019 Rev GA edits to Nick's report, circ corr. w comments 1.8

7/29/2019 Rev Nick & team's edits, recirculate (report) 1.0

7/30/2019 Finalize Nick's report, corr. w/ KNI GA re same 2.0

7/30/2019 Further corr internal re finalizing Gorton report 0.3

7/30/2019 Compare Nick's report against VM report, edit 1.0

7/30/2019 Further corr w/ team re finalizing Nick report 0.3

7/30/2019 Further revisions re Nick report 0.5

7/30/2019 Finalize rebuttal to send off 0.5

7/30/2019 Review VM rebuttal, corr w. KNI 1.0

7/31/2019 Scheduling depositions 0.1

7/31/2019 Internal corr re depositions 0.2

7/31/2019 Scheduling call w/ KNI incl. depo planning 1.0

7/31/2019 Corr w/ all team re depositions 0.2

7/31/2019 Changes to 30b6 outline 4.0

8/1/2019 Prepare exhibits for deposition, email w/ KNI 3.0

8/1/2019 Travel to columbus for 30b6 2.1

8/1/2019 Prep for 30b6; outline, all exhibits 4.0

8/2/2019 Nagy depo 6.9

8/2/2019 Drive home from columbus 2.2

8/8/2019 Review disc requests, new from OC (4th); TC re same 2.3

8/12/2019 Team call re case schedule and discovery responses

0.6

8/12/2019 Corr w/ clients re deposition scheduling & prep 0.3

8/12/2019 Corr w/ internal-only team re responding to discovery 0.5

8/12/2019 Corr w/ other affiliates, staff re scheduling depos 0.3

8/12/2019 Review further internal corr re discovery responses 0.2

8/12/2019 TC to review D 4th set disc requests 1.0

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 7 of 17 PAGEID #: 3166
8/12/2019 Corr w/ OC re extension of time, to Tess re drafting same 0.1

8/13/2019 Work w/ Tess on motion for extension of schedule 0.5

8/13/2019 Talk/corr. to OC re case schedule 0.1

8/14/2019 Finalize motion for filing w/ Tess 0.2

8/14/2019 Work on deposition prep outline - general for plffs 2.5

8/14/2019 Deposition prep outline drafted, sent to KNI 0.5

8/16/2019 Corr. w/ KNI, client, OC re confirming depo 0.1

8/16/2019 Complete depo prep outline for DJC, KNI review 3.3

8/16/2019 Corr. w/ KNI, DJC re revisions to prep 0.5

8/17/2019 Review & notes to 30b6 transcript 2.0

8/18/2019 Travel to Columbus for Stacie's prep & deposition 2.2

8/18/2019 Review additions to prep outline from GA 0.2

8/18/2019 Stacie deposition prep 3.5

8/19/2019 Final deposition prep 1.0

8/19/2019 Stacie's deposition 4.0

8/19/2019 Travel home from Stacie deposition 2.2

8/20/2019 Corr to set up video depositions 0.5

8/20/2019 Review OC corr re exhibits & depo schedule 0.5

8/20/2019 Further review of D exhibits for plaintiff depos 1.0

8/20/2019 Corr w/ client re scheduling depo & prep 0.3

8/20/2019 Review KNI outline for Ashley's depo prep, notes 0.5

8/20/2019 Review add'l docs for Ashley depo prep 0.3

8/20/2019 Prep call w/ KNI, Ashley 2.0

8/20/2019 Add'l prep for Ashley deposition, review docs 0.4

8/21/2019 Review materials advance of DOE deposition prep 2.0

8/22/2019 Corr w/ KNI & all team re issue w/ DOE depo 0.3

8/26/2019 Talk to KNI re discovery, various 0.5

8/26/2019 Work w/ Tess on scheduling rest of depos & travel 0.2

8/27/2019 Scheduling depositions w/ KNI, Tess, affiliate staff 0.5

8/27/2019 Deposition prep for Basil 2.0

8/28/2019 Corr w/ KNI re scheduling prep for depositions 0.1

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 8 of 17 PAGEID #: 3167
8/28/2019 Travel Cleveland to Denver for Basil's deposition 4.3

8/28/2019 Deposition prep for Basil w/ client, KNI 4.0

8/28/2019 Review further documents for Basil's deposition 0.5

8/28/2019 Deposition prep for Basil, document review & outline 3.0

8/29/2019

Final preparation for Basil's deposition - review supplemental 

documents & corr. re same 1.5

8/29/2019 Basil's deposition 3.0

8/29/2019 Notes & debrief after deposition 0.5

8/29/2019 Deposition summaries, notes 2.0

9/3/2019 Travel home from Denver to Cleveland 3.5

9/3/2019 Corr w/ KNI re discovery responses 0.3

9/4/2019 Review & edits to responses to discovery 2.9

9/4/2019 Corr. w/ client re experts & deposition testimony 0.4

9/4/2019 Send discovery responses to clients to talk through 0.4

9/4/2019 Corr. w/ OC re deposition notices 0.2

9/4/2019 Corr. w/ all clients re discovery responses 0.5

9/4/2019 Corr to help reschedule & set up DOE deposition 0.2

9/5/2019 Further scheduling corr re expert prep & depos 0.5

9/5/2019 Work w/ KNI, GA to finalize edits, line edits to discovery responses 1.0

9/9/2019 Finalize discovery responses, all verifications, to OC 1.0

9/9/2019 Send further supp production 0.2

9/9/2019 Talk to KNI re 30b6 notes 0.5

9/10/2019 Prep for Ettner deposition - review similar case transcripts 2.0

9/11/2019 Continued prep for expert depositions - documents from GA 1.5

9/11/2019 Small group call re expert depo prep 0.6

9/11/2019 Add'l review of 30b6 transcript for discovery follow up 1.0

9/11/2019 Review KNI depo prep outline for DOE depo 0.4

9/11/2019 Work on depo prep outline for Ettner 2.0

9/12/2019 Review & internal corr. re order denying MTD, contact all clients 1.5

9/12/2019

Further additions to Ettner depo prep outline, review sources, 

review Van Meter report 3.0

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 9 of 17 PAGEID #: 3168
9/13/2019 Consult w/ KNI re final prep for DOE deposition 0.5

9/13/2019 Write up to team re discovery status 0.3

9/16/2019 Review edits to expert deposition prep outline 0.1

9/16/2019 Review further edits to depo prep outline 0.5

9/16/2019 Review further edits to same 0.4

9/17/2019 Travel to Chicago for Ettner prep & deposition 3.3

9/17/2019 Ettner prep w/ Randi 5.0

9/17/2019 Further Ettner deposition prep 3.0

9/18/2019 Ettner deposition 7.0

9/18/2019 Travel home from Ettner deposition 3.0

9/20/2019

Begin reviewing documents for Van Meter deposition, corr. to OC re 

same 0.5

9/23/2019 Corr. w/ KNI, Tess re confirming depositions, depo costs 0.2

9/23/2019 Review, prepare for Van Meter deposition 0.5

9/24/2019 Review deposition prep outline for Van Meter 0.4

9/24/2019 Further review depo prep outline & materials 2.0

9/24/2019 Review of Van Meter materials 3.0

9/26/2019 Revisions to KNI outline for deposition & send 0.7

9/26/2019 Travel to Columbus for Van Meter prep & deposition 2.1

9/26/2019 Van Meter prep w/ KNI 10.0

9/27/2019 Van Meter deposition prep - printing outline, docs, get ready 3.0

9/27/2019 Van Meter deposition 6.6

9/27/2019 Travel home from Columbus 2.1

9/30/2019 Working w/ Tess re errata issue for Ashley 0.3

10/1/2019 Notes re potential new disc req's based on 30b6 1.0

10/1/2019 Scheduling corr. w/ Nick, Tess, KNI re expert depo prep 0.3

10/1/2019 Corr. & research re expert fees issue 0.5

10/1/2019 Review discovery to date, draft deficiency email 2.0

10/2/2019 Further corr. & research w/ KNI re expert fees 0.5

10/2/2019 Review expert agreement w/ Nick 0.4

10/3/2019 Edits to Nick's retainer incl. talk w/ FJL 0.6

10/4/2019 Finalize Nick's retainer w/ National, all 0.4

10/4/2019 Add'l work re Nick's retainer, edits & corr. 0.3

10/4/2019 Review deposition prep for Nick 0.5

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 10 of 17 PAGEID #: 3169
10/5/2019 Review new research & docs re Nick's deposition prep 0.5

10/5/2019 Add'l doc review & drafting deficiency email to OC 1.0

10/7/2019 Travel to Columbus for Nick's depo & prep 2.2

10/7/2019 Nick deposition prep in office w/ KNI 6.0

10/7/2019 Add'l deposition prep, review notes on rebuttal 2.0

10/8/2019 Add'l deposition prep 0.5

10/8/2019 Conf w/ KNI prior to deposition 0.4

10/8/2019 Nick's deposition 6.6

10/8/2019 Drive Columbus to Cleveland after deposition 2.2

10/10/2019 Write up case summary for whole team 0.5

10/10/2019 Conf w/ KNI re close of discovery 0.5

10/11/2019 Get erratas out, working w/ Tess 0.3

10/11/2019

Doc review for any add'l deficiencies, review needs against all 

productions & responses 4.0

10/18/2019 Review corr re expert fees 0.4

10/24/2019 Checking in w/ KNI after vacation - discovery updates 0.2

10/25/2019 Conf w/ KNI re all discovery updates 0.5

10/25/2019 Review OC email re discovery disputes alongside doc review 3.0

10/25/2019 Review OC privilege log alongside doc review 2.0

10/26/2019 Review all deposition transcripts 3.0

10/27/2019

Discovery documents & new corr from OC review before close of 

discovery 4.0

10/28/2019 Draft & circulate response email to OC re hot docs 0.8

10/28/2019 Review 3b6, productions, privilege log w/ KNI by phone 1.0

10/28/2019 Redraft, recirculate corr. re same 0.6

10/28/2019 Corr w/ KNI re follow up for Van Meter depo 0.3

10/28/2019 Corr w/ KNI re agenda for TC, discovery corr to OC 0.4

10/29/2019 TC re discovery updates & experts 1.0

10/30/2019 Review Van Meter errata, corr w/ KNI re same 0.4

10/30/2019 Review corr from OC re productions 0.5

11/4/2019 Work w/ KNI to set up schedule for SJ briefing 0.2

11/4/2019 Add'l corr re briefing schedule 0.5

11/4/2019 Add'l discussion & corr re briefing schedule 0.5

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 11 of 17 PAGEID #: 3170
11/4/2019 Talk w/ KNI re briefing schedule 0.3

11/6/2019 Add'l discussion re briefing schedule 0.5

11/7/2019

Scheduling call w/ OC & related review, motion to set briefing 

schedule 1.0

11/8/2019 Review & edits to briefing schedule motion 0.3

11/12/2019 Finalize & file briefing schedule motion 0.2

11/12/2019 Corr w/ small drafting group (GA, KNI) re briefing schedule 0.2

11/13/2019 Corr w/ drafting team re MSJ briefing 0.2

11/14/2019 Corr w/ co-counsel re MSJ schedule 0.2

11/15/2019

Review new anti-birth certificate legislation, litigation status in other 

jx 0.5

11/18/2019 TC with small group re MSJ briefing schedule 0.5

11/20/2019 Review & corr internal brief editing schedule 0.3

11/22/2019 Review, discuss & changes to editing schedule 0.4

11/22/2019 Call w/ KNI re MSJ approach 0.5

11/22/2019 Review Gorton transcript 1.0

12/4/2019 Review of GA section of MSJ brief 0.7

12/4/2019 Research & writing - law sec of MSJ 4.0

12/5/2019 Call w/ KNI to discuss briefing 0.5

12/5/2019 Research & writing - 1AM law sec. of MSJ 6.2

12/5/2019 Writing argument sec of MSJ, questions & corr to co-counsel 5.1

12/6/2019 Drafting for MSJ - review docs for SOF, draft SOF 6.0

12/6/2019 Review National's edits & thoughts to speech section of MSJ 2.4

12/9/2019 Corr w/ KNI re supp productions & MSJ brief 0.3

12/9/2019 Review of discovery materials, supp productions for SOF 2.0

12/12/2019 Corr w/ KNI re Van Meter errata 0.4

12/16/2019 Drafting for MSJ - non-law sections 3.5

12/16/2019 Drafting for MSJ - 1A, SOF, introduction 4.5

12/17/2019 Drafting final MSJ whole - insert facts 7.6

12/17/2019 Corr w/ KNI re editing 0.1

12/18/2019 Review KNI edits to brief, circulate internally 0.6

12/18/2019 Corr w/ co-counsel re MSJ status, further review 0.2

12/18/2019 Insert add'l edits to brief 0.9

12/18/2019 Further edits & cutting of brief 4.0

12/19/2019

Further review & send brief to internal team w/ instructions for 

editing schedule 4.5

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 12 of 17 PAGEID #: 3171
12/19/2019 Review corr from KNI re thoughts on MSJ 0.2

12/20/2019 Call w/ Malita re editing schedule 0.5

12/20/2019 Corr w/ team re changing editing schedule 0.3

12/20/2019 Further corr w/ team re editing schedule 0.5

12/20/2019 Review Peter's edits to MSJ 0.5

12/21/2019 Explain and forward Peter edits to internal team 0.7

12/22/2019 Review internal edits to, comments re MSJ draft 1.0

12/23/2019

Further review & corr, conversation re substantive legal issues in 

MSJ 2.0

12/23/2019 Further corr re organizational issues, MSJ 0.2

12/26/2019 Further internal-only corr re MSJ edits 0.2

12/27/2019 Resolve internal edits, pass to National incl. explanatory corr. 0.6

12/27/2019

Corr w/ OC, co-counsel re proposed motion to file under seal depo 

transcripts along w/ MSJs 0.4

12/27/2019 Internal discussion re motion to file under seal 0.4

12/28/2019 Review of deposition transcripts for sensitive information 0.5

12/28/2019

Review marked-up transcripts for sensitive information; draft 

proposed corr to OC for review re same 4.3

12/30/2019

Review co-counsel thoughts re protecting ct information, motion to 

seal; convey to OC 0.4

12/30/2019 Review corr from OC re motion to seal, discuss internally 0.7

1/2/2020 Corr w/ OC re meet and confer re motion to seal 0.1

1/3/2020 Phone call w/ OC re same 0.3

1/6/2020 Drafting motion to seal deposition transcripts 0.9

1/6/2020 Review OC edits, draft proposed order, recirculate 0.5

1/7/2020 Work w/ Tess - ready to file motion to seal 0.3

1/7/2020 Review new supplemental production of documents, discuss 0.7

1/8/2020 Cuts to MSJ 1.6

1/8/2020 Review notes, to-do list, circulate planning email 1.7

1/8/2020 Work w/ Tess to schedule out finalizing MSJ & related filings 0.5

1/8/2020 Corr w/ drafting team re planning email 0.4

1/8/2020 Further corr re needs for filing MSJ prep 0.5

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 13 of 17 PAGEID #: 3172
1/8/2020 Talk w/ DJC re MSJ 0.7

1/8/2020 Review newest cuts to MSJ, adjust, send to FJL for review 2.5

1/9/2020 Review FJL edits, send to Lambda (MSJ) 0.2

1/9/2020

Review J Vascura order on motion to file under seal, discussion & 

email OC 1.4

1/9/2020 Research & writing new brief on motion to seal 2.7

1/9/2020 Review & make revisions to motion to seal 1.4

1/9/2020 Proof, cite check & file motion to seal 0.9

1/10/2020 Corr w/ team re how to handle experts 2.0

1/10/2020 Corr w/ OC re filing depo transcripts 0.1

1/10/2020 Work on finalizing MSJ brief, circulate to colleagues 1.8

1/10/2020

Preparing deposition transcripts, redactions, erratas to attach to MSJ 

filing 1.5

1/10/2020 Review GA line edits to MSJ 0.3

1/10/2020 Corr w/ small group re line edits 0.5

1/10/2020 Review J Vascura order on sealing motion 0.2

1/10/2020 Continued work on redactions & review for exhibits to MSJ 2.0

1/10/2020 Continued work on redactions & review of MSJ exhibits 1.6

1/10/2020 Review Lambda's line edits to MSJ 0.8

1/11/2020

Review exhibits incl DOE transcript for pirvacy issues, AEO 

designations; notes re all exhibits 3.0

1/12/2020 Write up final thoughts re exhibit redactions to small team 0.8

1/12/2020 Corr w/ team re redactions & exhibits 0.5

1/12/2020

With KNI & clients - MSJ, exhibits, plan out for review to all clients, 

turn around revisions 2.0

1/13/2020 Further corr w/ clients re MSJ filing 0.6

1/13/2020 Working on exhibits for MSJ w/ KNI, Lambda 0.8

1/13/2020 Working w/ Tess on redactions & cleanup for exhibits 1.0

1/13/2020 Going over recent edits to MSJ brief w/KNI, reviewing 1.5

1/13/2020 Further review, addition of record citations into MSJ, w/ Kara 4.5

1/13/2020 Review and final edits to exhibits 0.8

1/14/2020 Review revised MSJ 1.0

1/14/2020 Confirm DOE exhibit is acceptable w/ client 0.3

1/14/2020 Further edits to DOE exhibit 0.6

1/14/2020 Work w/ team on initial cite checking 0.3

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 14 of 17 PAGEID #: 3173
1/14/2020 Working w/ Lambda re exhibit list, edits to exhibits 0.9

1/14/2020 Add'l edits to explanatory language in exhibits 0.3

1/15/2020 Line edits to MSJ 0.9

1/15/2020 Corr w/ co-counsel re filing plan 0.2

1/15/2020

Read edited copy of MSJ, respond to questions, create clean copy 

for circulation 4.0

1/16/2020 Circulate clean MSJ brief w/ tasks & comments to team 1.2

1/16/2020 Review KNI new comments to brief 0.3

1/16/2020

Working w/ Tess, GA, KNI, to finalize brief and all attachments for 

filing 3.3

1/16/2020 Check filed copy of MSJ 0.5

1/16/2020 Review D's MSJ, schedule call to discuss 2.0

1/21/2020 Team call re D's MSJ 0.5

2/7/2020 Corr w/ co counsel re draft review (response brief) 0.3

2/8/2020

Review draft, corr w/ internal team re new issues over response 

brief 0.4

2/8/2020 Discussion w internal team re same issue in response biref 0.7

2/8/2020 Further internal discussion re same 0.2

2/9/2020 Review all edits to response brief, incorporate 4.0

2/9/2020 Corr w/ co counsel re draft review 0.6

2/10/2020 Review supp expert production from OC 0.4

2/10/2020 Continue to merge edits in brief 3.9

2/10/2020 Talk w/co counsel re major changes 0.5

2/10/2020 Further edits from me incl. cite chceck 1.6

2/10/2020 Rev. GA KNI addl edits, incorp & corr re same 1.9

2/10/2020 Corr w/ small group re same 0.4

2/11/2020 Corr w/ GA KNI re addil edits and review 0.8

2/11/2020 Review and incorp add'l edits from GA, JK 2.0

2/11/2020 Discussion w co counsel re same 0.7

2/11/2020 Review and combine all edits, pass to FJL 3.0

2/12/2020 Review edits from FJL, SJB 2.4

2/12/2020 Corr w internal team re edits, pass to Tess 0.3

2/13/2020 Corr w Tess re brief, citation issues 0.4

2/13/2020 Rev final version of brief 1.0

2/13/2020 Pass to team, corr w/ small team re same 0.4

2/13/2020 Talk to KNI re final brief 0.1

2/17/2020 Corr w team re how to do reply 0.2

2/18/2020 Corr w team re editing schedule 0.3

2/18/2020 30 min TC re same 0.5

2/18/2020 Review GA corr, respond re outline 0.7

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 15 of 17 PAGEID #: 3174
2/19/2020 Tweak outline, forward to team for feedback 1.0

2/20/2020 Corr w/ entire team re outline 0.3

2/21/2020 Drafting reply brief 4.0

2/23/2020 Review feedback from team on draft 0.7

2/23/2020 Review add'l feedback from GA, KNI, JK 1.0

2/23/2020 Incorporate and corr w/ whole team re edits 3.0

2/23/2020 Pass draft to Peter to solicit addl feedback 0.2

2/24/2020 Add'l corr w Peter, Susan, Lambda others, re draft 0.4

2/25/2020 Review peter edits pass to internal team 2.0

2/25/2020 Corr w/ every team member passing around edits 1.2

2/25/2020 Review of add'l SJB edits 0.7

2/25/2020 Merge multiple versions 1.4

2/25/2020 Merge comments from JK 0.7

2/26/2020 Review FJL edits from last night and incorp 2.0

2/26/2020 Finalize brief, incorp all edits 2.6

2/26/2020 Corr w/ Tess re editing schedule 0.1

2/26/2020 Simultaneous cite fixing & corr w/ GA KNI for entire brief 1.8

2/26/2020

Reconcile multiple final versions & additional edits, circulate final 

final version 4.0

2/27/2020 Tess, me GA KNI all cite checking & line editing final brief 3.0

3/4/2020 Corr to team re update 0.2

4/21/2020 Corr re expert fee issues, KNI & OC 0.3

6/26/2020 Prepare notice of supp authority; related review & corr 2.0

12/7/2020 Review motion to sub defendant 0.2

1/7/2021 Help Tess w Malita PHV 0.1

1/26/2021 Talk w/ Tess re fee petition 0.2

1/26/2021 Work on fee petition - reviewing billing, drfting declarations & brief 0.3

1/26/2021 Work on fee petition - reviewing billing, drfting declarations & brief 0.1

1/26/2021 Talk w/ FJL re fee petition 0.6

1/26/2021

Fee petition - work on research & writing, corr. to team re 

declarations 2.2

1/27/2021 Fee petition - research & drafting 1.7

1/27/2021 Fee petition - research & drafting 1.3

1/27/2021 Fee petition - research & drafting 2.9

1/28/2021 Fee petition - further edits to decls & brief 1.2

1/29/2021 Talk w/ Tess re gathering billing, records for fee petition 0.4

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 16 of 17 PAGEID #: 3175
1/29/2021

Fee petition - resolving edits on brief, gathering supporting docs & 

corr to team 1.0

1/29/2021 Fee petition - finalizing decls & other records 0.1

1/29/2021 Fee petition - finalizing decls & other records 1.3

1/29/2021 Fee petition - finalizing decls & other records 0.5

1/30/2021

Fee petition - review everyone's documentation, finalize exhibits & 

brief 1.0

1/30/2021

Fee petition - review everyone's documentation, finalize exhibits & 

brief 2.0

1/31/2021

Fee petition - review everyone's corrections, add'l research & edits 

to brief 2.0

1/31/2021

Fee petition - review everyone's corrections, add'l research & edits 

to brief 2.0

2/1/2021 Fee petition - fill in all exhibits, finish brief & review 2.1

2/1/2021 Fee petition - finalize 3.0

Total Time 612.6

Hourly Rate x $ 250.00 

Lodestar Fees $ 153,150.00 

Case: 2:18-cv-00272-MHW-CMV Doc #: 87-14 Filed: 02/01/21 Page: 17 of 17 PAGEID #: 3176