Discounting Appendix Tables.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Created: 9/24/10

Updated: 3/24/2011

Purpose: Outputs from the I&E model by regulatory option

Worksheet Description

table table showing time profile of national benefits

compile

calculations to compile benefits under separate

categories as required to produced the time profile

of national benefits

File Info 1 of 21
3% Discount

Rate

7% Discount

Rate

3% Discount

Rate

7% Discount

Rate

3% Discount

Rate

7% Discount

Rate

3% Discount

Rate

7% Discount

Rate

2010 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

2011 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

2012 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

2013 $470 $448 $32 $30 $7 $7 $463 $441

2014 $1,309 $1,205 $85 $78 $20 $19 $1,288 $1,186

2015 $4,165 $3,705 $264 $235 $72 $64 $4,091 $3,638

2016 $7,461 $6,393 $458 $392 $126 $109 $7,329 $6,280

2017 $10,765 $8,882 $652 $538 $181 $150 $10,576 $8,726

2018 $13,640 $10,838 $14,443 $11,102 $14,415 $11,064 $13,400 $10,647

2019 $16,019 $12,255 $28,190 $20,863 $28,616 $21,160 $15,737 $12,040

2020 $16,464 $12,126 $44,411 $31,724 $45,435 $32,437 $16,179 $11,915

2021 $16,347 $11,590 $61,484 $42,366 $63,150 $43,496 $16,064 $11,389

2022 $16,047 $10,952 $77,979 $51,791 $80,270 $53,294 $15,769 $10,762

2023 $15,598 $10,248 $86,028 $55,095 $88,729 $56,808 $15,329 $10,070

2024 $15,144 $9,577 $93,426 $57,672 $96,529 $59,571 $14,882 $9,412

2025 $14,703 $8,951 $98,547 $58,596 $102,101 $60,695 $14,449 $8,796

2026 $14,274 $8,365 $103,581 $59,322 $107,577 $61,599 $14,028 $8,220

2027 $13,859 $7,818 $108,187 $59,674 $112,604 $62,100 $13,619 $7,683

2028 $13,455 $7,306 $108,905 $57,873 $113,471 $60,292 $13,223 $7,180

2029 $13,063 $6,828 $109,142 $55,871 $113,816 $58,257 $12,837 $6,710

2030 $12,683 $6,382 $108,273 $53,379 $112,912 $55,661 $12,464 $6,271

2031 $12,313 $5,964 $105,740 $50,188 $110,279 $52,337 $12,101 $5,861

2032 $11,955 $5,574 $102,961 $47,045 $107,385 $49,062 $11,748 $5,478

2033 $11,606 $5,209 $100,080 $44,021 $104,379 $45,906 $11,406 $5,119

2034 $11,268 $4,869 $97,165 $41,141 $101,339 $42,903 $11,074 $4,784

2035 $10,940 $4,550 $94,335 $38,449 $98,387 $40,096 $10,751 $4,471

2036 $10,622 $4,252 $91,588 $35,934 $95,522 $37,473 $10,438 $4,179

2037 $10,312 $3,974 $88,920 $33,583 $92,739 $35,022 $10,134 $3,905

2038 $10,012 $3,714 $86,330 $31,386 $90,038 $32,731 $9,839 $3,650

2039 $9,720 $3,471 $83,816 $29,333 $87,416 $30,589 $9,552 $3,411

2040 $9,437 $3,244 $81,374 $27,414 $84,870 $28,588 $9,274 $3,188

2041 $9,162 $3,032 $79,004 $25,620 $82,398 $26,718 $9,004 $2,979

2042 $8,895 $2,834 $76,703 $23,944 $79,998 $24,970 $8,742 $2,785

2043 $8,636 $2,648 $74,469 $22,378 $77,668 $23,337 $8,487 $2,602

2044 $8,385 $2,475 $72,300 $20,914 $75,406 $21,810 $8,240 $2,432

2045 $8,141 $2,313 $70,194 $19,546 $73,209 $20,383 $8,000 $2,273

2046 $7,903 $2,162 $68,150 $18,267 $71,077 $19,050 $7,767 $2,124

2047 $7,673 $2,020 $66,165 $17,072 $69,007 $17,803 $7,541 $1,985

2048 $7,450 $1,888 $64,238 $15,955 $66,997 $16,639 $7,321 $1,855

2049 $7,233 $1,765 $62,367 $14,911 $65,046 $15,550 $7,108 $1,734

2050 $7,022 $1,649 $60,550 $13,936 $63,151 $14,533 $6,901 $1,621

2051 $6,818 $1,541 $58,787 $13,024 $61,312 $13,582 $6,700 $1,515

2052 $6,619 $1,440 $57,074 $12,172 $59,526 $12,694 $6,505 $1,416

2053 $6,426 $1,346 $55,412 $11,376 $57,792 $11,863 $6,315 $1,323

Option 4: I for Facilities

with DIF > 50 MGD

Table A‐1: Time Profile of National Mean Total Benefits for the Regulatory Options at In‐Scope Facilities

(2009$, thousands)

Year

Option 1: I Everywhere

Option 3: I&E Mortality

Everywhere

Option 2: I Everywhere and

E for Facilities with DIF >

125 MGD

table 2 of 21
2054 $6,239 $1,258 $53,798 $10,632 $56,109 $11,087 $6,131 $1,236

2055 $6,057 $1,176 $52,231 $9,936 $54,475 $10,362 $5,953 $1,155

2056 $5,881 $1,099 $50,710 $9,286 $52,888 $9,684 $5,779 $1,080

2057 $5,128 $922 $42,374 $7,475 $44,184 $7,794 $5,039 $906

2058 $4,415 $765 $34,749 $5,906 $36,224 $6,156 $4,339 $751

2059 $1,120 $186 $17,101 $2,772 $17,875 $2,897 $1,101 $183

2060 $555 $89 $10,326 $1,608 $10,799 $1,682 $546 $87

2061 $270 $42 $5,135 $770 $5,371 $805 $266 $41

2062 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

2063 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

2064 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

2065 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

Total Present Valuea $453,679 $221,341 $3,108,232 $1,272,593 $3,232,893 $1,320,887 $445,825 $217,499

Annualized Valueb $17,632 $16,038 $120,794 $92,200 $125,649 $95,711 $17,327 $15,760

a

The total present value is equal to the sum of the values of the benefits realized in all years of the analysis, discounted to 2012.

b

The annualized value represents the total present value of the benefits of the regulation, distributed over a 50-year period.

Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report.

table 3 of 21
Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

2010 0 0 0 0 0 0

2011 0 0 0 0 0 0

2012 0 0 0 0 0 0

2013 12 11 2 2 1 1

2014 34 32 6 5 2 2

2015 122 109 20 18 7 6

2016 216 186 36 31 12 11

2017 310 256 51 42 18 15

2018 392 312 77 62 35 28

2019 460 352 113 86 64 49

2020 466 343 207 153 162 120

2021 462 328 306 217 266 189

2022 453 309 404 276 369 252

2023 439 289 493 325 465 306

2024 427 270 571 361 549 347

2025 414 252 604 368 590 360

2026 402 236 628 369 622 365

2027 390 220 648 366 649 367

2028 379 206 659 358 667 363

2029 368 193 666 349 680 356

2030 357 180 653 329 668 336

2031 347 168 637 309 652 316

2032 337 157 620 289 635 296

2033 327 147 602 271 616 277

2034 317 137 585 253 598 259

2035 308 128 568 236 581 242

2036 299 120 551 221 564 226

2037 290 112 535 206 547 211

2038 282 105 519 193 532 197

2039 274 98 504 180 516 184

2040 266 91 490 168 501 172

2041 258 85 475 157 486 161

2042 251 80 462 147 472 151

2043 243 75 448 138 458 141

2044 236 70 435 129 445 132

2045 229 65 422 120 432 123

2046 223 61 410 112 420 115

2047 216 57 398 105 407 107

2048 210 53 387 98 395 100

2049 204 50 375 92 384 94

2050 198 47 364 86 373 88

2051 192 43 354 80 362 82

2052 186 41 343 75 351 77

2053 181 38 333 70 341 72

2054 176 35 324 65 331 67

2055 171 33 314 61 322 62

2056 166 31 305 57 312 58

2057 145 26 267 48 273 49

2058 125 22 230 40 235 41

T&E

compile 4 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 4 Option 1 Option 2

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

12 11 113 105 9 8

34 31 219 196 17 15

119 107 320 274 25 22

211 181 414 342 33 27

302 250 502 400 40 31

383 304 488 373 13,104 10,037

449 344 473 349 25,408 18,733

454 335 460 326 36,984 26,248

450 320 446 305 47,864 32,700

442 302 433 285 58,079 38,195

429 282 421 266 60,218 38,121

416 263 408 249 62,183 37,894

404 246 396 233 63,983 37,533

392 230 385 217 65,626 37,057

381 215 374 203 67,118 36,483

370 201 363 190 65,163 34,097

359 188 352 177 63,265 31,866

349 176 342 166 61,422 29,781

338 164 332 155 59,633 27,833

329 153 322 145 57,897 26,012

319 143 313 135 56,210 24,310

310 134 304 126 54,573 22,720

301 125 295 118 52,984 21,234

292 117 286 110 51,440 19,844

283 109 278 103 49,942 18,546

275 102 270 96 48,487 17,333

267 95 262 90 47,075 16,199

259 89 254 84 45,704 15,139

252 83 247 79 44,373 14,149

244 78 240 74 43,080 13,223

237 73 233 69 41,826 12,358

230 68 226 64 40,607 11,550

224 64 219 60 39,425 10,794

217 59 213 56 38,276 10,088

211 56 207 52 37,162 9,428

205 52 201 49 36,079 8,811

199 49 195 46 35,028 8,235

193 45 189 43 34,008 7,696

187 42 184 40 33,018 7,193

182 40 178 37 32,056 6,722

177 37 173 35 31,122 6,282

171 35 168 33 30,216 5,871

166 32 163 31 29,336 5,487

162 30 159 29 28,481 5,128

141 25 128 22 22,951 3,978

122 21 100 17 17,987 3,001

Quantiative Nonuse

compile 5 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 3 Option 4 Option 1

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 113 105 15 15

0 0 219 196 52 49

0 0 320 274 181 162

0 0 414 342 365 313

0 0 502 399 552 456

13,610 10,424 487 373 725 577

26,427 19,484 473 349 871 667

38,485 27,313 459 326 927 684

49,819 34,035 446 305 926 657

60,460 39,761 433 285 912 623

62,794 39,752 420 266 888 584

64,941 39,574 408 249 862 546

66,909 39,249 396 232 837 510

68,707 38,798 385 217 813 477

70,344 38,237 374 203 789 446

68,296 35,736 363 190 766 416

66,306 33,398 352 177 744 389

64,375 31,213 342 166 722 364

62,500 29,171 332 155 701 340

60,680 27,263 322 145 681 318

58,912 25,479 313 135 661 297

57,196 23,812 304 126 642 278

55,531 22,254 295 118 623 259

53,913 20,798 286 110 605 242

52,343 19,438 278 103 587 227

50,818 18,166 270 96 570 212

49,338 16,978 262 90 554 198

47,901 15,867 254 84 537 185

46,506 14,829 247 79 522 173

45,151 13,859 240 74 507 162

43,836 12,952 233 69 492 151

42,560 12,105 226 64 477 141

41,320 11,313 219 60 464 132

40,116 10,573 213 56 450 123

38,948 9,881 207 52 437 115

37,814 9,235 201 49 424 108

36,712 8,631 195 46 412 101

35,643 8,066 189 43 400 94

34,605 7,538 184 40 388 88

33,597 7,045 178 37 377 82

32,618 6,584 173 35 366 77

31,668 6,154 168 33 355 72

30,746 5,751 163 31 345 67

29,850 5,375 159 29 335 63

24,054 4,169 128 22 293 53

18,852 3,145 100 17 253 44

Quantiative Nonuse

compile 6 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 2 Option 3 Option 4

3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 15

1 1 0 0 52

4 4 0 0 180

8 7 0 0 362

13 10 0 0 548

56 45 40 32 721

174 133 155 119 866

545 402 528 389 922

1,144 812 1,131 803 921

1,760 1,202 1,751 1,196 907

2,345 1,542 2,342 1,540 884

2,884 1,826 2,886 1,827 858

3,236 1,972 3,244 1,977 833

3,535 2,074 3,555 2,085 809

3,802 2,147 3,832 2,164 785

4,031 2,191 4,073 2,214 762

4,210 2,203 4,261 2,230 740

4,313 2,172 4,371 2,201 718

4,245 2,058 4,303 2,086 698

4,149 1,937 4,207 1,963 677

4,041 1,815 4,097 1,841 657

3,923 1,697 3,978 1,720 638

3,809 1,586 3,862 1,608 620

3,698 1,482 3,749 1,503 602

3,590 1,385 3,640 1,404 584

3,486 1,294 3,534 1,312 567

3,384 1,210 3,431 1,227 551

3,285 1,131 3,331 1,146 535

3,190 1,057 3,234 1,071 519

3,097 987 3,140 1,001 504

3,007 923 3,048 936 489

2,919 863 2,960 874 475

2,834 806 2,873 817 461

2,752 753 2,790 764 448

2,671 704 2,709 714 435

2,594 658 2,630 667 422

2,518 615 2,553 623 410

2,445 575 2,479 583 398

2,373 537 2,406 545 386

2,304 502 2,336 509 375

2,237 469 2,268 476 364

2,172 438 2,202 445 353

2,109 410 2,138 415 343

2,047 383 2,076 388 333

1,789 322 1,814 327 291

1,544 268 1,565 271 251

Commercial Fishing

compile 7 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

7% 3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

14 330 318 20 20 6

48 1,002 929 60 56 18

161 3,542 3,159 214 191 65

311 6,466 5,552 382 328 114

453 9,401 7,771 549 453 163

573 12,036 9,576 1,205 959 729

663 14,215 10,887 2,496 1,912 1,970

680 14,612 10,773 6,675 4,921 6,260

654 14,513 10,300 12,170 8,637 11,934

619 14,249 9,735 17,737 12,118 17,689

581 13,850 9,108 22,971 15,107 23,128

543 13,447 8,512 27,787 17,591 28,154

508 13,055 7,955 30,724 18,723 31,357

474 12,675 7,435 33,792 19,822 34,693

443 12,305 6,949 36,620 20,678 37,778

414 11,947 6,494 39,051 21,227 40,435

387 11,599 6,069 41,000 21,453 42,569

362 11,261 5,672 41,884 21,096 43,499

338 10,933 5,301 41,224 19,988 42,824

316 10,615 4,954 40,295 18,807 41,864

295 10,306 4,630 39,227 17,624 40,754

276 10,005 4,327 38,085 16,471 39,567

258 9,714 4,044 36,975 15,394 38,414

241 9,431 3,780 35,898 14,387 37,295

225 9,156 3,532 34,853 13,445 36,209

211 8,890 3,301 33,838 12,566 35,154

197 8,631 3,085 32,852 11,744 34,130

184 8,379 2,883 31,895 10,975 33,136

172 8,135 2,695 30,966 10,257 32,171

161 7,898 2,519 30,064 9,586 31,234

150 7,668 2,354 29,189 8,959 30,324

140 7,445 2,200 28,339 8,373 29,441

131 7,228 2,056 27,513 7,825 28,584

123 7,018 1,921 26,712 7,313 27,751

115 6,813 1,796 25,934 6,835 26,943

107 6,615 1,678 25,178 6,388 26,158

100 6,422 1,568 24,445 5,970 25,396

94 6,235 1,466 23,733 5,579 24,657

87 6,053 1,370 23,042 5,214 23,938

82 5,877 1,280 22,371 4,873 23,241

76 5,706 1,197 21,719 4,554 22,564

71 5,540 1,118 21,087 4,256 21,907

67 5,378 1,045 20,472 3,978 21,269

62 5,222 977 19,876 3,718 20,649

52 4,563 822 17,367 3,127 18,043

44 3,938 682 14,988 2,598 15,571

Recreational Fishing

compile 8 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 4 Option 1

7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

6 323 311 470 448

17 983 911 1,309 1,205

58 3,472 3,097 4,165 3,705

98 6,342 5,446 7,461 6,393

135 9,223 7,623 10,765 8,882

580 11,810 9,396 13,640 10,838

1,509 13,949 10,684 16,019 12,255

4,615 14,343 10,574 16,464 12,126

8,469 14,247 10,111 16,347 11,590

12,085 13,988 9,556 16,047 10,952

15,210 13,596 8,941 15,598 10,248

17,823 13,200 8,356 15,144 9,577

19,109 12,815 7,810 14,703 8,951

20,351 12,442 7,299 14,274 8,365

21,332 12,080 6,821 13,859 7,818

21,979 11,728 6,375 13,455 7,306

22,274 11,386 5,958 13,063 6,828

21,910 11,055 5,568 12,683 6,382

20,764 10,733 5,204 12,313 5,964

19,539 10,420 4,863 11,955 5,574

18,310 10,117 4,545 11,606 5,209

17,112 9,822 4,248 11,268 4,869

15,993 9,536 3,970 10,940 4,550

14,946 9,258 3,710 10,622 4,252

13,969 8,989 3,468 10,312 3,974

13,055 8,727 3,241 10,012 3,714

12,201 8,473 3,029 9,720 3,471

11,403 8,226 2,831 9,437 3,244

10,657 7,986 2,645 9,162 3,032

9,959 7,754 2,472 8,895 2,834

9,308 7,528 2,311 8,636 2,648

8,699 7,308 2,159 8,385 2,475

8,130 7,096 2,018 8,141 2,313

7,598 6,889 1,886 7,903 2,162

7,101 6,688 1,763 7,673 2,020

6,636 6,494 1,647 7,450 1,888

6,202 6,304 1,540 7,233 1,765

5,796 6,121 1,439 7,022 1,649

5,417 5,942 1,345 6,818 1,541

5,063 5,769 1,257 6,619 1,440

4,732 5,601 1,175 6,426 1,346

4,422 5,438 1,098 6,239 1,258

4,133 5,280 1,026 6,057 1,176

3,862 5,126 959 5,881 1,099

3,249 4,479 806 5,128 922

2,699 3,865 670 4,415 765

compile 9 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 2 Option 3 Option 4

3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

32 30 7 7 463

85 78 20 19 1,288

264 235 72 64 4,091

458 392 126 109 7,329

652 538 181 150 10,576

14,443 11,102 14,415 11,064 13,400

28,190 20,863 28,616 21,160 15,737

44,411 31,724 45,435 32,437 16,179

61,484 42,366 63,150 43,496 16,064

77,979 51,791 80,270 53,294 15,769

86,028 55,095 88,729 56,808 15,329

93,426 57,672 96,529 59,571 14,882

98,547 58,596 102,101 60,695 14,449

103,581 59,322 107,577 61,599 14,028

108,187 59,674 112,604 62,100 13,619

108,905 57,873 113,471 60,292 13,223

109,142 55,871 113,816 58,257 12,837

108,273 53,379 112,912 55,661 12,464

105,740 50,188 110,279 52,337 12,101

102,961 47,045 107,385 49,062 11,748

100,080 44,021 104,379 45,906 11,406

97,165 41,141 101,339 42,903 11,074

94,335 38,449 98,387 40,096 10,751

91,588 35,934 95,522 37,473 10,438

88,920 33,583 92,739 35,022 10,134

86,330 31,386 90,038 32,731 9,839

83,816 29,333 87,416 30,589 9,552

81,374 27,414 84,870 28,588 9,274

79,004 25,620 82,398 26,718 9,004

76,703 23,944 79,998 24,970 8,742

74,469 22,378 77,668 23,337 8,487

72,300 20,914 75,406 21,810 8,240

70,194 19,546 73,209 20,383 8,000

68,150 18,267 71,077 19,050 7,767

66,165 17,072 69,007 17,803 7,541

64,238 15,955 66,997 16,639 7,321

62,367 14,911 65,046 15,550 7,108

60,550 13,936 63,151 14,533 6,901

58,787 13,024 61,312 13,582 6,700

57,074 12,172 59,526 12,694 6,505

55,412 11,376 57,792 11,863 6,315

53,798 10,632 56,109 11,087 6,131

52,231 9,936 54,475 10,362 5,953

50,710 9,286 52,888 9,684 5,779

42,374 7,475 44,184 7,794 5,039

34,749 5,906 36,224 6,156 4,339

National Benefits

compile 10 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 1 Option 2

7% period 3 % adj factor n/a n/a

0 -2 0.94 $0.00 $0.00

0 -1 0.97 $0.00 $0.00

0 0 1.00 $0.00 $0.00

441 1 1.03 $0.48 $0.03

1,186 2 1.06 $1.39 $0.09

3,638 3 1.09 $4.55 $0.29

6,280 4 1.13 $8.40 $0.52

8,726 5 1.16 $12.48 $0.76

10,647 6 1.19 $16.29 $17.25

12,040 7 1.23 $19.70 $34.67

11,915 8 1.27 $20.86 $56.26

11,389 9 1.30 $21.33 $80.22

10,762 10 1.34 $21.57 $104.80

10,070 11 1.38 $21.59 $119.08

9,412 12 1.43 $21.59 $133.20

8,796 13 1.47 $21.59 $144.72

8,220 14 1.51 $21.59 $156.68

7,683 15 1.56 $21.59 $168.55

7,180 16 1.60 $21.59 $174.76

6,710 17 1.65 $21.59 $180.39

6,271 18 1.70 $21.59 $184.33

5,861 19 1.75 $21.59 $185.42

5,478 20 1.81 $21.59 $185.96

5,119 21 1.86 $21.59 $186.18

4,784 22 1.92 $21.59 $186.18

4,471 23 1.97 $21.59 $186.18

4,179 24 2.03 $21.59 $186.18

3,905 25 2.09 $21.59 $186.18

3,650 26 2.16 $21.59 $186.18

3,411 27 2.22 $21.59 $186.18

3,188 28 2.29 $21.59 $186.18

2,979 29 2.36 $21.59 $186.18

2,785 30 2.43 $21.59 $186.18

2,602 31 2.50 $21.59 $186.18

2,432 32 2.58 $21.59 $186.18

2,273 33 2.65 $21.59 $186.18

2,124 34 2.73 $21.59 $186.18

1,985 35 2.81 $21.59 $186.18

1,855 36 2.90 $21.59 $186.18

1,734 37 2.99 $21.59 $186.18

1,621 38 3.07 $21.59 $186.18

1,515 39 3.17 $21.59 $186.18

1,416 40 3.26 $21.59 $186.18

1,323 41 3.36 $21.59 $186.18

1,236 42 3.46 $21.59 $186.18

1,155 43 3.56 $21.59 $186.18

1,080 44 3.67 $21.59 $186.18

906 45 3.78 $19.39 $160.24

751 46 3.90 $17.20 $135.35

National Benefits (undiscounted, million

compile 11 of 21
2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

2026

2027

2028

2029

2030

2031

2032

2033

2034

2035

2036

2037

2038

2039

2040

2041

2042

2043

2044

2045

2046

2047

2048

2049

2050

2051

2052

2053

2054

2055

2056

2057

2058

Option 3 Option 4

n/a n/a

$0.00 $0.00

$0.00 $0.00

$0.00 $0.00

$0.01 $0.48

$0.02 $1.37

$0.08 $4.47

$0.14 $8.25

$0.21 $12.26

$17.21 $16.00

$35.19 $19.35

$57.56 $20.49

$82.40 $20.96

$107.88 $21.19

$122.82 $21.22

$137.63 $21.22

$149.94 $21.22

$162.72 $21.22

$175.43 $21.22

$182.09 $21.22

$188.12 $21.22

$192.23 $21.22

$193.38 $21.22

$193.95 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$194.18 $21.22

$167.09 $19.06

$141.09 $16.90

National Benefits (undiscounted, millions)

compile 12 of 21
Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

T&E

2059 30 5 56 9 57 10

2060 15 2 27 4 28 4

2061 7 1 13 2 13 2

2062 0 0 0 0 0 0

2063 0 0 0 0 0 0

2064 0 0 0 0 0 0

2065 0 0 0 0 0 0

total NPV 12,812 6,269 18,499 7,738 18,468 7,587

compile 13 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 4 Option 1 Option 2

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

Quantiative Nonuse

30 5 73 12 13,032 2,093

14 2 46 7 8,351 1,291

7 1 23 3 4,177 622

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

12,500 6,116 13,392 6,678 1,855,077 772,019

compile 14 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 3 Option 4 Option 1

3% 7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

Quantiative Nonuse

13,659 2,194 73 12 61 10

8,752 1,353 46 7 30 5

4,377 651 23 3 14 2

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

1,941,991 807,602 13,387 6,675 25,509 12,349

compile 15 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 2 Option 3 Option 4

3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

Commercial Fishing

375 63 380 63 61

182 29 184 30 30

88 14 90 14 14

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

114,919 45,713 116,176 46,121 25,374

compile 16 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

7% 3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

Recreational Fishing

10 956 159 3,638 607 3,779

5 464 75 1,766 284 1,835

2 225 35 857 133 891

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

12,283 401,965 196,045 1,119,736 447,123 1,156,257

compile 17 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 4 Option 1

7% 3% 7% 3% 7%

631 938 157 1,120 186

295 455 73 555 89

138 221 34 270 42

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

459,577 394,565 192,426 453,679 221,341

(in millions) $453.68 $221.34

compile 18 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 2 Option 3 Option 4

3% 7% 3% 7% 3%

National Benefits

17,101 2,772 17,875 2,897 1,101

10,326 1,608 10,799 1,682 546

5,135 770 5,371 805 266

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

3,108,232 1,272,593 3,232,893 1,320,887 445,825

$3,108.23 $1,272.59 $3,232.89 $1,320.89 $445.83

compile 19 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 1 Option 2

7% period 3 % adj factor n/a n/a

National Benefits (undiscounted, million

183 47 4.01 $4.49 $68.61

87 48 4.13 $2.29 $42.67

41 49 4.26 $1.15 $21.86

0 50 4.38 $0.00 $0.00

0 51 4.52 $0.00 $0.00

0 52 4.65 $0.00 $0.00

0 53 4.79 $0.00 $0.00

217,499

$217.50

compile 20 of 21
2059

2060

2061

2062

2063

2064

2065

total NPV

Option 3 Option 4

n/a n/a

National Benefits (undiscounted, millions)

$71.71 $4.42

$44.62 $2.26

$22.86 $1.13

$0.00 $0.00

$0.00 $0.00

$0.00 $0.00

$0.00 $0.00

compile 21 of 21