8E-i

APPENDIX 8E. AVERAGE TRANSFORMER DESIGN PROPERTIES 

FROM LIFE-CYCLE COST MODEL

 TABLE OF CONTENTS

8E.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................... 8E-1

8E.2 TABLES OF AVERAGE TRANSFORMER DESIGN PROPERTIES ........... 8E-1

8E.3 HISTOGRAMS OF TRANSFORMER DESIGN EFFICIENCIES .............. 8E-5

8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 ......................... 8E-5

8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 ......................... 8E-8

8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 ........................ 8E-12

8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 ........................ 8E-15

8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 ........................ 8E-19

8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 ........................ 8E-22

8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line10 ....................... 8E-25

8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 ....................... 8E-29

8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 ....................... 8E-32

8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 ................. 8E-36

LIST OF TABLES

Table 8E.2.1 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 1 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-1

Table 8E.2.2 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 2 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-1

Table 8E.2.3 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 3 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-2

Table 8E.2.4 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 4 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-2

Table 8E.2.5 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 5 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-2

Table 8E.2.6 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 9 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-2

Table 8E.2.7 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 10 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-3

Table 8E.2.8 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 11 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-3

Table 8E.2.9 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 12 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-3

Table 8E.2.10 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 13 

Representative Unit ............................................. 8E-4
8E-ii

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Baseline ............................................... 8E-5

Figure 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 ............................... 8E-5

Figure 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2 ............................... 8E-6

Figure 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3 ............................... 8E-6

Figure 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4 ............................... 8E-7

Figure 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5 ............................... 8E-7

Figure 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6 ............................... 8E-8

Figure 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Baseline ............................................... 8E-8

Figure 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 ............................... 8E-9

Figure 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2 ............................... 8E-9

Figure 8E.3.11 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-10

Figure 8E.3.12 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4 .............................. 8E-10

Figure 8E.3.13 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5 .............................. 8E-11

Figure 8E.3.14 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6 .............................. 8E-11

Figure 8E.3.15 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-12

Figure 8E.3.16 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1 .............................. 8E-12

Figure 8E.3.17 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2 .............................. 8E-13

Figure 8E.3.18 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3 .............................. 8E-13

Figure 8E.3.19 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4 .............................. 8E-14

Figure 8E.3.20 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative 

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5 .............................. 8E-14
8E-iii

Figure 8E.3.21 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-15

Figure 8E.3.22 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-15

Figure 8E.3.23 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-16

Figure 8E.3.24 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-16

Figure 8E.3.25 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-17

Figure 8E.3.26 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-17

Figure 8E.3.27 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-18

Figure 8E.3.28 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-18

Figure 8E.3.29 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-19

Figure 8E.3.30 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-19

Figure 8E.3.31 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-20

Figure 8E.3.32 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-20

Figure 8E.3.33 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-21

Figure 8E.3.34 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-21

Figure 8E.3.35 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-22

Figure 8E.3.36 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-22

Figure 8E.3.37 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-23

Figure 8E.3.38 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-23

Figure 8E.3.39 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-24

Figure 8E.3.40 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-24

Figure 8E.3.41 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-25
8E-iv

Figure 8E.3.42 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-25

Figure 8E.3.43 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-26

Figure 8E.3.44 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-26

Figure 8E.3.45 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-27

Figure 8E.3.46 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-27

Figure 8E.3.47 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-28

Figure 8E.3.48 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 10 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 6 ............................................ 8E-28

Figure 8E.3.49 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-29

Figure 8E.3.50 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-29

Figure 8E.3.51 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-30

Figure 8E.3.52 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-30

Figure 8E.3.53 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-31

Figure 8E.3.54 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-31

Figure 8E.3.55 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-32

Figure 8E.3.56 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-32

Figure 8E.3.57 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-33

Figure 8E.3.58 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-33

Figure 8E.3.59 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-34

Figure 8E.3.60 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-34

Figure 8E.3.61 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-35

Figure 8E.3.62 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-35
8E-v

Figure 8E.3.63 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative 

Unit, Baseline .............................................. 8E-36

Figure 8E.3.64 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 1 ................................... 8E-36

Figure 8E.3.65 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 2 ................................... 8E-37

Figure 8E.3.66 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 3 ................................... 8E-37

Figure 8E.3.67 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 4 ................................... 8E-38

Figure 8E.3.68 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 5 ................................... 8E-38

Figure 8E.3.69 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13 Representative Unit, 

Candidate Standard Level 6 ................................... 8E-39
8E-1

APPENDIX 8E. AVERAGE TRANSFORMER DESIGN PROPERTIES FROM LIFECYCLE COST MODEL

8E.1 INTRODUCTION

In this supplementary technical support document (TSD) appendix, the Department

provides additional information regarding the advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANOPR)

life-cycle cost (LCC) calculation results. At the September 28, 2004 public meeting,

stakeholders requested the following specific information from the LCC analysis: the average

efficiency and average costs and prices for the baseline and each of the five candidate standard

levels for the thirteen representative units analyzed. Following that model, the Department is

providing the same information on the six candidate standard levels analyzed for the notice of

proposed rulemaking (NOPR).

8E.2 TABLES OF AVERAGE TRANSFORMER DESIGN PROPERTIES

Table 8E.2.1 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 1

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 1,088 1,122 1,173 1,325 1,612 1,847 2,375 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.0 99.1 99.1 99.2 99.4 99.5 99.6

Core Loss (W) 127.9 108.2 107.0 103.9 34.1 39.9 50.3

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 576.5 553.3 487.5 371.0 494.4 325.6 186.5

Table 8E.2.2 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 2

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 619 636 640 644 650 720 1,530 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 98.7 98.8 98.9 98.9 98.9 99.0 99.5

Core Loss (W) 87.8 74.9 74.1 74.4 74.2 67.3 33.4

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 308.4 301.9 298.8 290.1 283.3 243.9 115.3
8E-2

Table 8E.2.3 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 3

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 4,252 4,321 4,441 4,753 5,646 10,649 11,458

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5 99.6 99.7 99.8

Core Loss (W) 749.7 690.4 676.6 672.6 573.9 263.8 272.9

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 3698.0 3218.3 3018.5 2648.6 2405.0 1583.6 1433.8

Table 8E.2.4 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 4

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 2,718 2,843 3,086 3,900 4,340 5,418 6,041 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 98.9 99.1 99.2 99.3 99.5 99.6 99.6

Core Loss (W) 420.0 366.9 349.2 198.0 132.0 150.8 154.7

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 1639.9 1427.7 1238.3 1366.0 1192.2 702.9 580.3

Table 8E.2.5 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 5

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 10,808 11,151 11,600 12,203 13,613 26,916 26,917 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.4 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5 99.7 99.7

Core Loss (W) 1958.7 1915.6 1879.7 1867.1 1707.9 807.4 807.4

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 10877.7 9528.2 8922.3 8350.8 7929.5 5414.2 5414.7

Table 8E.2.6 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 9

Representative Unit
8E-3

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 5,379 5,423 5,522 5,830 7,038 9,620 9,619 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 98.8 98.9 99.0 99.1 99.3 99.4 99.4

Core Loss (W) 991.1 886.2 748.3 699.3 587.8 480.5 480.3

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 4334.5 4195.6 4140.8 3344.5 2368.7 1718.8 1719.8

Table 8E.2.7 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 10

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 20,368 21,273 21,869 23,008 24,723 32,903 32,900 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.2 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.4 99.5 99.5

Core Loss (W) 3492.7 3182.6 2937.9 2664.3 2449.6 2303.3 2303.5

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 12751.5 10920.1 10691.9 10102.5 8979.8 5705.3 5705.5

Table 8E.2.8 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 11

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 7,812 8,127 8,379 8,907 9,824 10,679 10,679 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 98.4 98.7 98.8 98.9 99.0 99.1 99.1

Core Loss (W) 1195.1 935.6 894.4 819.7 738.7 672.2 672.0

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 6273.4 5554.8 4803.4 4131.5 3331.0 3099.4 3100.2

Table 8E.2.9 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 12

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6
8E-4

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 22,594 22,955 23,215 23,820 25,707 36,379 36,396 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.2 99.2 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.5 99.5

Core Loss (W) 3492.8 3221.3 3084.2 2981.6 2781.3 2387.6 2385.9

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 12518.9 11938.9 11465.3 10533.4 8850.1 5342.1 5343.4

Table 8E.2.10 Average LCC Transformer Design Properties for Design Line 13

Representative Unit

Candidate Standard Level

Base 1 2 3 4 5 6

Manufacturer Selling Price ($) 28,492 28,623 29,060 30,007 34,915 48,134 48,138 

Efficiency at 50% Load (%) 99.3 99.3 99.3 99.4 99.5 99.6 99.6

Core Loss (W) 4358.5 4315.2 3798.7 3550.2 3147.3 2910.1 2909.9

Coil Loss at 50% Load (W) 14280.1 13981.9 14532.5 13365.1 10270.0 6421.8 6421.1
8E-5

Figure 8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 1

8E.3 HISTOGRAMS OF TRANSFORMER DESIGN EFFICIENCIES

8E.3.1 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 1
8E-6

Figure 8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 3
8E-7

Figure 8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 5
8E-8

Figure 8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 1 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 2 Representative Unit, Baseline

8E.3.2 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 2
8E-9

Figure 8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design

Line 2 Representative Unit, Candidate

Standard Level 1

Figure 8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 2
8E-10

Figure 8E.3.11 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.12 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 4
8E-11

Figure 8E.3.13 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.14 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 2 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 6
8E-12

Figure 8E.3.15 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Baseline

Figure 8E.3.16 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 1

8E.3.3 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 3
8E-13

Figure 8E.3.17 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.18 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 3
8E-14

Figure 8E.3.19 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.20 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 5
8E-15

Figure 8E.3.21 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 3 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.22 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Baseline

8E.3.4 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 4
8E-16

Figure 8E.3.23 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 1

Figure 8E.3.24 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 2
8E-17

Figure 8E.3.25 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.26 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 4
8E-18

Figure 8E.3.27 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.28 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 4 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 6
8E-19

Figure 8E.3.29 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Baseline

Figure 8E.3.30 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 1

8E.3.5 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 5
8E-20

Figure 8E.3.31 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.32 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 3
8E-21

Figure 8E.3.33 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.34 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 5 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 5
8E-22

Figure 8E.3.35 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Baseline

Figure 8E.3.36 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 1

8E.3.6 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 9
8E-23

Figure 8E.3.37 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.38 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 3
8E-24

Figure 8E.3.39 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.40 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 5
8E-25

Figure 8E.3.41 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 9 Representative Unit,

Candidate Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.42 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Baseline

8E.3.7 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line10
8E-26

Figure 8E.3.43 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1

Figure 8E.3.44 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2
8E-27

Figure 8E.3.45 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.46 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4
8E-28

Figure 8E.3.47 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.48 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 10 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6
8E-29

Figure 8E.3.49 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.50 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1

8E.3.8 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 11
8E-30

Figure 8E.3.51 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.52 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3
8E-31

Figure 8E.3.53 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.54 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5
8E-32

Figure 8E.3.55 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 11 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6

Figure 8E.3.56 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Baseline

8E.3.9 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 12
8E-33

Figure 8E.3.57 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1

Figure 8E.3.58 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2
8E-34

Figure 8E.3.59 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3

Figure 8E.3.60 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4
8E-35

Figure 8E.3.61 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5

Figure 8E.3.62 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 12 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6
8E-36

Figure 8E.3.63 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Baseline

Figure 8E.3.64 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 1

8E.3.10 Distribution of Efficiencies for Design Line 13
8E-37

Figure 8E.3.65 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 2

Figure 8E.3.66 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 3
8E-38

Figure 8E.3.67 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 4

Figure 8E.3.68 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 5
8E-39

Figure 8E.3.69 Distribution of Efficiencies for

Design Line 13 Representative

Unit, Candidate Standard Level 6