Appendix I

Intervenors' Trial Exhibit List

Exhibit 

Number

Document Description Document Date Bates Number Deposition

Deposition 

Exhibit 

Number 

Objection

Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Curriculum Vitae Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 1

Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Expert Report (10/5/2018) October 5, 2018 Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 2

Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Rebuttal Expert Report (11/26/2018) November 26, 2018 Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 3

Confidential Source Code Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 4

10/12/18 - Letter from E. Zhang to P. Lewis, et al. Re: Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute v. Smith October 12, 2018 Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 5

Dr. Cho's Run Output File Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Exhibit 6

Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D. Supplemental Expert Report (12.28.18) December 28, 2018

10/9/2018 - Letter from N. Subhedar to P. Lewis, et al. Re: Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute v. Smith October 9, 2018

Native of Dr. Cho's Run Output File- File Name "run1.txt"

Errata to Wendy K. Tam Cho, Ph.D Expert Report (10/18/2018) October 18, 2018

Declaration of William S. Cooper (10/5/2018) (also Niven Exhibit 10) October 5, 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 1

Brennan Center for Justice Overview: Ohio Redistricting Reform Proposal February 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 2

Ohio U.S. House Zero Deviation 2012 Plan William S. Cooper Exhibit 3

Ohio U.S. House Proposed Remedial Plan William S. Cooper Exhibit 4

Exhibit A - Documents Re: William S. Cooper Declaration William S. Cooper Exhibit 5

Errata to Declaration of William S. Cooper (11/30/2018) November 30, 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 6

Ohio U.S. House Proposed Remedial Plan 11/30/2018 Mod November 30, 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 7

Supplemental Declaration of William S. Cooper (11/26/2018) November 26, 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 8

Second Supplemental Declaration of William S. Cooper (11/27/2018) November 27, 2018 William S. Cooper Exhibit 9

Ohio U.S. House Zero Deviation Hypothetical Plan 1A William S. Cooper Exhibit 10

Ohio U.S. House Zero Deviation Hypothetical Plan 2A William S. Cooper Exhibit 11

Demonstrative Re: 2012, 2014, 2016 AVG William S. Cooper Exhibit 12

Third Supplemental Declaration of William S. Cooper (12.28.18) December 28, 2018

Lisa Handley Expert Report (10/5/2018) October 5, 2018 Lisa Handley Exhibit 1

Lisa Handley Expert Report (U.S. v. City of Euclid) (2/1/2007) February 1, 2007 Lisa Handley Exhibit 2

Lisa Handley Rebuttal Expert Report (U.S. v. City of Euclid) (5/10/2007) May 10, 2007 Lisa Handley Exhibit 3

Lisa Handley Expert Report (U.S. v. Euclid City School District) (3/1/2009) March 1, 2009 Lisa Handley Exhibit 4

Lisa Handley Rebuttal Expert Report (U.S. v. Euclid City School District) (4/15/2009) "Declaration of Dr. Lisa 

R. Handley" April 15, 2009 Lisa Handley Exhibit 5

Analysis of 2009 Election for Euclid City School Board District Board of Education March 5, 2010 Lisa Handley Exhibit 6

Rebuttal to Engstrom Report (U.S. v. Euclid City School District) (7/22/2010) "Declaration of D. Lisa R. 

Handley" July 22, 2010 Lisa Handley Exhibit 7

2009 Paper - Legislative Studies Quarterly " Has the Voting Rights Act Outlived its Usefulness? In a Word, 

"No"" - by Lublin, Brunell, Grofman, Handley November 1, 2009 Lisa Handley Exhibit 8

David H. Niven, Ph.D. Report (10/5/2018) - Dividing Neighbors and Diminishing Voices: An Analysis of Ohio's 

Congressional Districts October 5, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 1

David H. Niven, Ph.D. Curriculum Vitae October 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 2

David H. Niven, Ph.D. Response to Thornton and Brunell (11/26/2018) November 26, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 3

Rebuttal Expert Report of Janet R. Thornton, Ph.D. (11/12/2018) November 12, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 5

Geographic Terms and Concepts - Census Tract [www.census.gov] December 18, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 6

Niven Save File Exports David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 7

Ohio Congressional District Map, 2002-2012 SOS 001054 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 8

Ohio Congressional District Map, 2012-2022 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 9

davidniven.com Website Printout December 18, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 11

HarperCollins Publishing Website - Printout Re: David Niven December 19, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 12

Niven Tweets, 12/12/2017 December 12, 2017 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 13

Niven Tweets, 11/16/2017 November 16, 2017 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 14

Niven Tweets, 3/6/2018 March 6, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 15

Niven Tweets, 11/14/2018 November 14, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 16

Niven Tweets, 6/13/2018 June 13, 2018 David Niven, Ph.D. Exhibit 17

Christopher Warshaw Expert Report (10/5/2018) "An Evaluation of the Partisan Bias in Ohio's 2011 

Congressional Districting Plan and its Effects on Representation in Congress" October 5, 2018 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 1

Figure 1 Ohio Partisan Distribution 2004 to 2010 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 2

Figure 7 Ohio Partisan Distribution 2012 to 2016 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 3

Essay by Wendy Cho "Measuring Partisan Fairness: How Well Does the Efficiency Gap Guard Against 

Sophisticated As Well As Simple Minded Modes of Partisan Discrimination" Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 4

Figure 5 Cleveland Area Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 5

Christopher Warshaw Rebuttal Report (11/26/2018) November 26, 2018 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 6

Christopher Warshaw Expert Report (11/27/2017) in League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania v. the 

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 159 MM 2017 (Pa.) November 27, 2017 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 7

Christopher Warshaw Expert Report (6/1/2018) Michigan case in League of Women Voters of Michigan v. 

Johnson , No. 2:2017cv14148 (E.D. Mich.) June 1, 2018 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 8

2017 Article of Gregory Warrington "Quantifying gerrymandering using the vote distribution" (5/15/2017) May 15, 2017 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 9

U.S. House of Representatives Roll Call Votes 114th Congress - 1st Session (2015) November 29, 2018 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 10

VoteView.com - Lindsay Graham Entry Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 11

Pew Research Center Article "From the very start, sharp partisan divisions over Obamacare" (6/25/2015) June 25, 2015 Christopher Warshaw Exhibit 12

Christopher Warshaw Supplemental Expert Report (12.28.18) December 28, 2018

Expert Report of Thomas Brunell (11/12/2018) (also Niven Exhibit 4) November 12, 2018 Thomas Brunell Exhibit 1

July 20, 2011 Columbus Regional Hearing Testimony- File Name "2011-07-20 Columbus Regional Hearing 

Testimony.pdf" July 20, 2011 DIROSSI 0000151-201

House Bill 319 Rep. Matt Huffman Sponsor Testimony- File Name "2011-09-13 Huffman Sponsor 

Testimony.docx" LENZO_000041-42

H.B. 369 Rep. Matt Huffman Sponsor Testimony Matthew Huffman Exhibit 19

Ohio House Republican Caucus, How the Problem Started- File Name "MCGREGOR000001-

MCGREGOR000007.pdf" MCGREGOR000002-7 Troy Judy Exhibit 30

OHIO House of Representatives JOURNAL Thursday, September 15, 2011, available at 

http://archives.legislature.state.oh.us/JournalText129/HJ-09-15-11.pdf September 15, 2011

OHIO House of Representatives JOURNAL Wednesday, September 21, 2011, available at 

http://archives.legislature.state.oh.us/JournalText129/HJ-09-21-11.pdf September 21, 2011

OHIO House of Representatives JOURNAL CORRECTED VERSION Wednesday, December 14, 2011, 

available at http://archives.legislature.state.oh.us/JournalText129/HJ-12-14-11.pdf December 14, 2011

OHIO SENATE JOURNAL Wednesday, September 21, 2011, available at 

http://archives.legislature.state.oh.us/JournalText129/SJ-09-21-11.pdf September 21, 2011

OHIO SENATE JOURNAL Wednesday, December 14, 2011, available at 

http://archives.legislature.state.oh.us/JournalText129/SJ-12-14-11.pdf December 14, 2011

Screenshot of Original Map Produced in Maptitude [Original_CD01] and associated native files GLASSBURN 0020 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 21

Maptitude screenshot - HB 369 Map Revised December 14th.map - 2010 Final Census Blocks 

(Ohio)(Template) [Map Revised December 14th]_001 and associated native files BLESSING0012635 Heather Blessing Exhibit 13

Demonstrative Exhibit – Maptitude Comparison of 319 to 369

File Name “FINAL HB 319.map” and associated files BLESSING0000003170

File Name "HB 319 As Enacted - Congressional Districts.map" and associated files BLESSING0000008229

File Name “HB 369 as Enacted FINAL.map” and associated files BLESSING0000002450

File Name "HB 369 Map Revised December 14th.map" and associated files BLESSING0000007750

Christopher Glassburn Production: Memorex USB \ 319 Original.map

Christopher Glassburn Production: Memorex USB \ OFFICIAL 369 ADOPTED FINAL.map

Compromise Proposal to Draw Fair Congressional Districts SMC-KM-000363-372 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 5

11/2/2011 - E-Mail chain from McCarthy to Glassburn and Budish November 2, 2011 SMC-KM-000263, 409-413 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 6

11/23/2011 - E-Mail from McCarthy to Budish November 23, 2011 SMC-KM-000184, 167-168 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 8

PowerPoint - Summary of Compromise Efforts to Resolve Redistricting Impasse SMC-KM-000155-165 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 9

11/18/2011 - E-mail chain from McCarthy to Judy November 18, 2011 JUDY 0001655 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 18

12/3/2011 - E-Mail chain from Cherry to McCarthy, Hoyt and Others December 3, 2011 SMC-AH-000067-68 Matthew Szollosi Exhibit 22

7/11/2011 - E-Mail chain from Bonier to Routt, Burke, Hoyt July 11, 2011 SMC-RR-029803 Randall Routt Exhibit 3

7/15/2011 - E-Mail Routt to Hoyt July 15, 2011 SMC-RR-031375-31378 Randall Routt Exhibit 4

7/18/2011 - E-Mail chain from Smoot to Routt July 18, 2011 SMC-RR-029783 Randall Routt Exhibit 5

7/19/2011 - E-Mail chain from Routt to Hoyt July 19, 2011 SMC-RR-031366-31368 Randall Routt Exhibit 6

7/21/2011 - E-Mail chain from Peterson to Bonier, Routt, Burke and Hoyt July 21, 2011 SMC-RR-029095-29096 Randall Routt Exhibit 7

9/8/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to Pavan September 8, 2011 SMC-RR-028740-28742 Randall Routt Exhibit 9

11/17/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to McCarthy, Rowe and Cherry November 17, 2011 SMC-KM-000204, 146-147 Randall Routt Exhibit 12

10/31/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to Hoyt October 31, 2011 SMC-AH-000137-138 Randall Routt Exhibit 15

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-9 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 1 of 2 PAGEID #: 7208
Appendix F

Intervenors' Trial Exhibit List

Exhibit 

Number

Document Description Document Date Bates Number Deposition

Deposition 

Exhibit 

Number 

Objection

11/1/2011 Maps, E-Mail, Spreadsheet November 1, 2011 SMC-RR-000447, 451, 452, 

10785, 28680, 28681 Randall Routt Exhibit 16

11/3/2011 - Email from Routt to Hoyt and Others November 3, 2011 SMC-AH-000267-000303 Randall Routt Exhibit 17

11/3/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to Hoyt and Others November 3, 2011 SMC-AH-000241-266 Randall Routt Exhibit 18

11/3/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to Hoyt and Others November 3, 2011 SMC-AH-000220-240 Randall Routt Exhibit 19

11/17/2011 - E-Mail from Hoyt to Routt and Others November 17, 2011 SMC-RR-028279-28280 Randall Routt Exhibit 20

12/9/2011 - E-Mail from Routt to Hoyt, Rowe December 9, 2011 SMC-AH-000437-438 Randall Routt Exhibit 21

12/14/2011 - Maps, E-Mail chain December 14, 2011 SMC-RR-016520, 16522, 

16673-16675 Randall Routt Exhibit 24

12/14/2011 - E-Mail chain from Routt to Peterson December 14, 2011 SMC-RR-028384-28385 Randall Routt Exhibit 25

12/22/2011 - E-Mail chain from Routt to Hoyt, Cherry, McCarthy December 22, 2011 SMC-AH-000341-346 Randall Routt Exhibit 27

OAKS Voucher Worksheet, FY 12, Voucher ID: 00004784 LENZO 0002404-2415 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 3

Overview, Objectives, Project Overview SMC-KM-000436-438 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 5

7/25/2011 - E-Mail chain from Glassburn to McCarthy and Cherry July 25, 2011 SMC-KM-000036 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 7

8/9/2011 - E-Mail from McCarthy to Budish and Cherry SMC-KM-000068 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 8

8/5/2011 - E-Mail from McCarthy to Hoyt SMC-KM-000067 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 9

10/16/2011 - E-Mail from Cherry to McCarthy and Brown October 16, 2011 SMC-KM-000226, 399 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 13

Compromise Proposal to Draw Fair Congressional Districts SMC-KM-000363-372 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 15

11/2/2011 - E-Mail from McCarthy to Glassburn and Budish November 2, 2011 SMC-KM-000263, 174-178 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 16

11/10/2011 - E-Mail from McCarthy to Glassburn November 10, 2011 SMC-KM-000195, 171-172 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 17

11/14/2011 - E-Mail from Glassburn to McCarthy November 14, 2011 SMC-KM-000291, 450, 331, 

332 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 18

PowerPoint - Summary of Compromise Efforts SMC-KM-000155-165 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 20

12/15/2011 - E-Mail chain from Routt to McCarthy and Hoyt December 15, 2011 SMC-AH-000335-336 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 24

7/16/2018 Letter to Ben Guess from K. McCarthy, Heather Taylor-Miesle July 16, 2018 Keary McCarthy Exhibit 25

7/5/2011 - E-Mail from Glassburn to M. Keary July 5, 2011 SMC-KM-000029-30 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 5

2010 Ohio Common and Unified Redistricting Database Technical Documentation, V3_08_10_2011.pdf CTRL0000012608 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 7

8/31/2011 - E-Mail from Glassburn to M. Keary, S. Cherry August 31, 2011 SMC-KM-000015-16 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 8

9/6/2011 - E-Mail chain from T. Borier to R. Routt, C. Glassburn and Others September 6, 2011 SMC-RR-0029994-29995 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 9

9/16/2011 - E-Mail from S. Cherry to Glassburn September 16, 2011 SMC-KM-000251-255, 484 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 11

Compromise Proposal to Draw Fair Congressional Districts SMC-KM-000363-372 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 12

11/2/2011 - E-Mail from K. McCarthy to Glassburn November 2, 2011 SMC-KM-000263, 409-413 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 13

Major Map Files from 2010-2011 CTRL0000011317 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 14

Listing of files produced in a folder called Memorex USB\Offers Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 15

Screenshot - Nov 2 Dmap - Block Split-Blcok-Block Group-Tract BOE County Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 16

11/10/2011 - E-Mail from K. McCarthy to Glassburn November 10, 2011 SMC-KM-000195, 171-172 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 17

11/14/2011 - E-Mail from Glassburn to K. McCarthy November 14, 2011 SMC-KM-000291, 450, 331-

332 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 18

Summary of Compromise Efforts to Resolve Redistricting Impasse... SMC-KM-000155-165 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 19

11/23/2011 - E-Mail from K. McCarthy to Glassburn November 23, 2011 SMC-KM-000278, 169 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 20

Screen Shot ADOPTED FINAL.map [OFFICIAL ADOPTED FINAL_CD16]_01-03 GLASSBURN 0051 Christopher Glassburn Exhibit 22

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-9 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 2 of 2 PAGEID #: 7209