Unite d State s Environmenta l Protectio n Agency Regio n 5 Ai r Program s Branc h Ai r & Radiatio n Divisio n 7 7 Wes t Jackso n Boulevar d Chicago , Illinoi s 6060 4 AI RPOLLUTIO N CONTRO L TITL E V PERMI T T O OPERAT E Permi t Number : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Expiratio n Date: 

### DECt S 201 / Issu e Date: MO

V 2 8 201 2 Effectiv e Date : ' DE C 2" 6 201 2 I n accordanc e wit hthe provision s o f Titl e V o f

the Clea n Ai r

Ac t an d4 0 C.F.R . Part

7 1 an dapplicabl e rule s an dregulations , NR G Backu p Generatio n Service s Lakeville , Minnesot

a i s authorize dto operat

e ai r emissio n unit s an dto conduc t other ai r pollutant

emittin g activitie s i n accordanc e wit hth e permi t condition s liste di n thi s permit . Thi s sourc e i s authorize dto operat e i n the followin g location : Treasure Islan d Resor t& Casin o Prairi e Island Indian Communit y Re d Wing , Minnesot

a Term s an dcondition s no t otherwis e define di n thi s permi t hav e th e meanin g assigne dto the mi n th e reference dregulations . Al l term s an dcondition s o f th e permi t

ar e enforceabl e b y EP A an dcitizen s under th e Clea n Ai r

Act .

Susa n Hedma n Dat e Regiona l Administrato r U . S . EP A - Regio n 5 

## /;/ 7 

## / / Z Georg e T . CzeailakX / \Dat e Actin g Directo r

j{ Ai r an dRadialiorrDivisio n U . S . EP A - Regio n 5Section : TABL E O F CONTENT S

1. 0 Sourc

e Identificatio n and Unit-Specifi c Informatio n A . Genera l Sourc e Informatio n B . Sourc e Emissio n Point s C . Potentia l Emission s 2.0 Unit-Specifi c Operatin g Conditions - Internal Combustio n Engine s A . Emissio n Limitation s an dStandard s B . Monitorin g an dTestin g Requirement s C . Recordkeepin g an dReportin g Requirement s 3. 0 Facility-Wid e Permi tCondition s A . Genera l Part

7 1 Recordkeepin g Requirement s B . Genera l Part

7 1 Reportin g Requirement s C . Permi t

Shiel d D . Performanc e Testin g E . Credibl e Evidenc e 4. 0 Par t7

1 Genera l Permi tRequirement s A . Definition s B . Annua l Fe e Paymen t C . Complianc e Statement D . Complianc e Certification s E . Schedul e o f

Complianc e F . Dut y to Provid e an dSupplemen t Informatio n G . Enforceabilit y H . Submission s I . Severabilit y Claus e J . Permi t

Action s K . Administrativ e Permi t Amendment s L . Mino r

Permi t Modification s M . Significan t

Permi t Modification s N . Reopenin g fo r

Caus e O . Property Right s P . Inspectio n an dEntr y Q . Emergenc y Provision s R . Off-Permi t

Change s S . Permi t

Expiratio n an dRenewa l T . Emission s Tradin g U . Aci dRai n Permi t

Provision s V . Operationa l Flexibilit yAbbreviation s and Acronym s

BH P Brak e Horsepowe r C A A Clea n Ai r Ac t [4 2 U.S.C . Sectio n 740 1 e t seq . C A M Complianc e Assuranc e Monitorin g C.F.R . Cod e o f Federa l Regulation s C O Carbo n Monoxid e E P A Unite dState s Environmenta l Protectio n Agency , Regio n 5 E U Emissio n Uni t Facilit y Treasur e IslandResort & Casin o ga l gallo n g gram s HA P Hazardou s Ai r Pollutan t h g mercur y hr hou r I dNo . Identificatio n Numbe r k g kilogra m l b poun d MAC T Maximu mAchievabl e Contro l Technolog y M g megagram MMBt u millio n Britis hTherma l Unit s NESHA P Nationa l Emissio n Standard s fo r Hazardou s Ai r

Pollutant s N 0 2 Nitroge n Dioxid e NO x Nitroge n Oxide s NSP S Ne w Sourc e Performanc e Standard NS R Ne w Sourc e Revie w 

### o 2 Oxyge n Owner/Operato r N R GBacku p Generatio n Service s Permitte e N R GBacku p Generatio n Service s P M Particulat e Matte r PMI O Particulat e matter les s tha n 1 0 micron s i n diamete r pp m part s pe r millio n ppmv d part s pe r million , volumetri c dr y PS D Preventio n o f Significan t

Deterioratio n PT E Potentia l to Emi t 

### so 2 Sulfu r Dioxid e tp y ton s per yea r V O C Volatil e Organi c Compound sN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 o f 2 6 1. 0 SOURC E IDENTIFICATIO N AN D UNIT-SPECIFI C INFORMATIO N (A) . General Sourc

e Informatio n Paren t Company : N R GBacku p Generatio n Service s 1768 5 Junipe r

Path , Suit e 30 1 Lakeville , Minnesot a5504 4 Facility : Treasure Islan dResor t an dCasin o 573 4 Sturgeo n Lak e Roa d Re dWing , Minnesot a5506 6 County : Goodhu e U.S . EP A Region : 5 Reservation : Prairi e Islan dIndia n Communit y Tribe : Prairi e Islan dIndia n Communit y SI C Code : 4911 , Electri c Service s AF S Plan t

I dNo. : 2 7 04 9 0008 4 Descriptio n o f

Process : NR GBacku p Generatio n Service s own s an doperate s fou r interna l combustio n diesel-fire dengine s tha t serv e th e Treasur e Islan dResort an dCasino . Th e electricit y produce di s use dfo r pea k loa dmanagemen t

an dbacku p powe r

fo r th e resort an dcasino . Electricit y i s no t sol dfo r distribution .N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t #: V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 o f 2 6 (B) . Sourc

e Emissio n Point

s Emissio n Uni tID No . Descriptio n Mode l Hea tInput (MMbtu/hr ) Dat e Installed EU-0 1 Interna l Combustio n

Engin e (diese l fired ) Caterpilla r 3516 B 16.7 6 5/25/0 1 EU-0 2 Interna l Combustio n

Engin e (diese l fired ) Caterpilla r 3516 B 16.7 6 5/25/0 1 EU-0 3 Interna l Combustio n

Engin e (diese l fired ) Caterpilla r 3516 B 16.7 6 5/25/0 1 EU-0 4 Interna l Combustio n

Engin e (diese l fired ) Caterpilla r 3516 B 16.7 6 5/25/0 1 (C) . Potentia

l Emissions Potentia l Emissio n Rate

s VO C NO x C O P M PM1 0 

### so 2 HAP s Potentia l hourl y emission s per engin e (lb/hr ) 1.1 6 37.4 4 3.0 5 0.8 7 0.7 2 0.9 1 0.02 5 Tota l potentia l emission s - 4 engine s (lb/hr ) 4.6 4 149.7 6 12.2 0 3.4 8 2.8 6 3.6 5 0.10 0 Tota l potentia l emission s - 4 engine s (tpy ) 20.3 2 655.9 5 53.4 4 15.2 4 12.5 3 15.9 7 0.43 8 Limite dpotentia l emission s - 4

engine s (tpy ) 0.2 9 41.1 8 3.3 6 0.9 6 0.7 9 1.0 0 0.02 7

2. 0 UNIT-SPECIFI C OPERATIN G CONDITION S (A) . Emissio n Limitation s an d Standard s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(1) ] Th e Permitte e shal l compl y wit hthe followin g requirements : 1 . Nitroge n Oxid e PS D BAC T Limitations : i . Tota l nitroge n oxid e (NOx ) emission s fro meac h engin e shal l no t excee d 6.5 5 g/BHP-h r

per engine , expresse das N0 2 , average dove r th e duratio n o f th e emissio n performanc e tes t o r an y thre e consecutiv e hours . [Conditio n 4.1. ao f

PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] i i . Tota l NO x emission s fro meac h engin e shal l no t excee d37.4 4 lb/h r

per engine , expresse das N0 2 , average dove r th e duratio n o f

th e emissio n performanc e tes t

o r an y thre e consecutiv e hours . [Conditio n 4.1. b o f PSD

PI-R50003-00-01 ]N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 3 o f

2 6 iii . Tota l NO x emission s fro meac h engin e shal l no t excee d10.3 0 tp y pe r engine , expresse das N0 2 , base do n a12-consecutiv e mont h rollin g sum , wit hcomplianc e detennine da t th e en do f

eac h month . [Conditio n 4.1. c o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 2 . Tota l operatin g hour s o f eac h engin e shal l no t

excee d55 0 hrs/year , base do n a12

- mont h rollin g sum , wit hcomplianc e determine da t th e en do f

eac h month . [Conditio n 4.1. do f

PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 3 . Th e Permitte e shal l operat e the turbocharge r

an daftercoole r

a t al l time s tha

t an y o f th e engine s (EU-01 , EU-02 , EU-0 3 o r EU-04 ) ar

e i n operation . [Conditio n 4.1. e o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 4 . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n lea n bur n combustio n condition s a t al l time s tha

t an y o f th e engine s ar

e i n operation . [Conditio n 4. 1 . e an d4.1. h o f PSD-PI-R50003-00

- 01 ] 5 . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n th e aftercoole r return water

temperature fo r

eac h engin e a t les s than o r

equa l to 140 degree s Fahrenheit . [Conditio n 4.1. f o f PSD

PI-R50003-00-01 ] 6 . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n the intak e manifol dpressure o f eac h engin e a

t 28. 1 to 76. 2 inche s o f

H g an d4 0 to 100 percen t load . [Conditio n 4.1. i o f PSD-PI

R50003-00-01 ] 7 . Th e Permitte e shal l retar dengin e timin g a t al l time s fo r

eac h engin e suc h tha

t the injectio n o f

fue l int o th e engin e i s delayed . Th e flas h fil e progra m#180-1736 , whic helectronicall y control s eac h engine , shal l b e se t fo r retar dengin e timing . Th e Permitte e shal l contac t th e EP A befor e modifyin g an y parameter s pertainin g t o retardin g engin e timin g fo r an y engine . [Conditio n 4. 1 . k an d4.1. 1 o f

PSD-PI

R50003-00-01 ] 8 . Th e Permitte e shal l bur n i n th e engine s diese l fue l tha t meet s the followin g standard s [4 0 C.F.R . § § 63.660 4 an d80.510(b)] : i . Sulfu r content : 1 5 pp mmaximu m i i . A minimu mcetan e inde x o f 4 0 o r amaximu maromati c content o f 3 5 volum e percent . 9 . A t al l times , includin g start-up , shut-down , an dmalfunction , the Permitte e shall , to th e extent

practicable , maintai n an doperate al l source s includin g associate dai r pollutio n contro l equipmen t regulate db y thi s pennit , i n amanner consisten t

wit h goo dai r pollutio n contro l practic e fo r minimizin g emissions . Determinatio n o f whethe r acceptabl e operatin g an dmaintenanc e practice s ar e bein g use di s base dN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 4 o f 2 6 o n informatio n availabl e to th e EPA , whic hma y include , bu t i s no t limite dto , monitorin g results , revie w o f operatin g an dmaintenanc e procedures , an d inspection s o f

the facility . I n addition , the Permitte e shal l compl y wit hthe following : [Sectio n 3. 0 o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 , 4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6605 ] i . Th e Permitte e shal l develo p an dprovid e t o eac h facilit y operato r

trainin g to orien t staf f as t o th e applicabl e term s an dcondition s o f thi s permit . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n onsit e alo g o f the time , date , an dplace , an dalis t o f attendee s for , eac h trainin g session . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n a t th e facilit y an dmake availabl e to an authorize dEP A representative , upo n request , acop y o f

the trainin g material s presente di n the trainin g sessions . i i . Th e Permitte e shal l develo p an dimplemen t standardoperatio n an d maintenanc e (O&M ) procedure s fo r eac h emissio n uni t

liste di n thi s permit . A cop y o f

th e procedure s shal l b e readil y availabl e to th e operator s maintainin g eac h emissio n unit , an dauthorize dEP A representatives . iii . Th e Permitte e shal l keep acop y o f thi s permi t

o n fil e a t the facilit y a

t al l times . 10 . Carbo n Monoxid e (CO ) Concentratio n o r Reduction : i . Th e Permitte e shal l limi t th e concentratio n o f

C O i n th e exhaus t

to 2 3 ppmv da t 1 5 percent

0 2o r reduc e C O emission s b y 70 % o r mor e a t al l time s excep t

durin g period s o f

startup . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6603(a) , Tabl e 2 d to 4 0 C.F.R . Part

63 , Subpart

ZZZZ ] i i . Th e Permitte e shal l compl y wit hthe C O concentratio n o r reductio n limi t n o late r than Ma y 3 , 201 3 unles s EP A grant s an extensio n accordin g to th e provision s o f

4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6(i) . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6595(a)(1) ] iii . Th e Permitte e wil l hav e demonstrate dinitia l complianc e i f the averag e C O concentratio n o r

averag e reductio n o f

emission s o f

C O determine dfro m the initia l performanc e tes t require di n Conditio n 2.0(B). 6 achieve s th e require dC O concentratio n o r C O percent

reduction . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6630(a) , Tabl e 5 t o 4 0 C.F.R . Part 63 , Subpar

t ZZZZ ] iv . Th e Permitte e shal l demonstrate continuou s complianc e i f performanc e testin g conducte das require di n Conditio n 2.0(B). 7 show s tha t the C O emission s concentratio n o r reductio n meet s the concentratio n o r percen t reductio n as require dConditio n 2.0(A).10.(i ) ofthi s permit . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6640(a) , Tabl e 6 to 4 0 C.F.R . Part 63 , Subpar

t ZZZZ ] 11 . Th e Permitte e shal l minimiz e eac h engine' s tim e spen t a t idl e durin g startup an d minimiz e th e engine' s startup tim e to aperio dneede dfo r appropriate an dsaf

eN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 5 o f

2 6 loadin g o f

th e engine , no t

to excee d3 0 minutes , afte r whic h tim e th e C O emissio n limitatio n i n Conditio n 2(A) . lO. i ofthi s permi t applies . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6625(h) ] (B) . Monitorin g and Testin g Requirement s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(i)(A ) throug h (C) ] 1 . Periodi c NO x Performanc e Testing . Th e Permitte e shal l conduc t aNO x performanc e tes t

every fiv e calenda

r years , startin g thre e year s afte r th e initia l complianc e tes t

conducte do n Augus t

7 , 2001 , to determin e complianc e wit hthe emissio n limit s i n conditio n 2.0(A)(1) . [Sectio n 5 o f PSD-PI-2704900084-2012

- i . I n accordanc e wit hConditio n 4.1. n o f PSD-P I R50003-00-01 , th e Pennitte e shal l determin e the NO x emissio n rate , expresse das N0 2 , usin g th e exhaus t

propertie s determine db y EP A Metho d1 9 an dexhaus t ga s measurement s specifie di n Section s 5 an d6 o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 . i i . Th e Pennitte e shal l complet e testin g i n accordanc e wit hth e performanc e testin g requirement s i n conditio n 3. 0 (F) . 2 . Annua l NO x Testing . Th e Permitte e shal l measure NO x emission s annuall y usin g aportabl e emission s analyze r to determin e complianc e wit hth e emission s limit s i n Conditio n 2.0(A)(1) . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(c ) (1) , Conditio n 6 o f PSD-PI-R50003

- i . Th e Pennitte e shal l us e th e portabl e emission s analyze r accordin g to the portabl e electrochemica l analyze r procedur e i n attachment 2 o f PSD-PI

R50003-00-01 . i i . Thi s requiremen t

doe s no t

appl y durin g the calendar year s i n whic ha performanc e tes t

i s required , onl y durin g year s betwee n th e periodi c performanc e tests . iii . Representativ e Testin g Conditions . Annua l testin g usin g aportabl e emission s analyze r

shal l b e conducte dunder condition s specifie db y th e E P A base do n representativ e operatin g condition s o f the affecte demissio n unit(s) . Th e Permitte e shal l make availabl e to th e EP A suc h record s as ma y b e necessary to determin e th e condition s o f annua l testin g usin g th e portabl e emission s analyzer . Operation s durin g period s o f startup , shutdown , an dmalfunctio n shal l no t constitut e representativ e condition s fo r suc h annua l testing . iv . Operatin g Conditions . Th e Permitte e shal l conduc t al l measurement s fo r al l emissio n unit s a

t wors t cas e operatin g (non-malfunction ) condition s fo r eac h ai r pollutan t

tha t i s require dto b e teste dunless : 02 ]

00-01 ]N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 6 o f 2 6 (a ) . Th e applicabl e requiremen t o r complianc e documen t

specifie s alternativ e operatin g condition s fo r annua l testin g usin g aportabl e emission s analyzer ; o r (b ) . Th e wors t

cas e conditio n i s no t

know n o r

calculable . I n thi s case , wors t cas e condition s shal l b e assume dto b e th e maximu m achievabl e proces s o r

operatin g rate o f

th e emission s unit . v . Measuremen t

Cycles . Eac h tes t

shal l consis t

o f a t leas t four , bu t

n o mor e tha n six , 15-minute measurement cycles . Fo r

th e purpos e o f

determinin g complianc e wit hth e applicabl e standard , th e Permitte e shal l ad dth e result s o f

al l measurement

cycle s an ddivid e th e su mb y the numbe r o f measurement

cycle s t o arriv e a

t an averag e emissio n rate . Th e Permitte e wil l us e th e resul t

as on e basi s fo r

determinin g complianc e wit hthe emissio n limi t

specifie di n thi s permit . I n th e event tha t asampl e i s accidentall y los t

o r condition s occur

i n whic hone o f

th e measuremen t cycle s mus t

b e discontinue dbecaus e o f force dshutdown , extrem e meteorologica l conditions , o r othe r circumstance s beyon dth e Permittee' s control , EP A may , i n it s sol e discretion , determin e complianc e usin g the arithmeti c mean o f

th e result s ofth e non-damage dmeasurement cycles . Th e Pennitte e shal l continuousl y monito r th e aftercoole r

wate r temperature fo r eac h engine . Th e Permitte e shal l contro l th e temperature vi athermostati c valve s tha t maintai n areturn wate r temperature o f

140 degree s Fahrenheit . [Conditio n 4.1. g o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] Th e Permitte e shal l continuousl y monito r the intak e manifol dpressure o f eac h engine . [Conditio n 4.1. j o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] Upo n reques t

b y the EPA , th e Permitte e shal l conduc t performanc e test s fo r

an y o r al l o f th e followin g pollutants : sulfu r dioxide , particulat e matter , volatil e organi c compounds , CO , an dany combinatio n o f hazardou s ai r

pollutants . Th e E P A ma y us e th e result s o f an y performanc e test s o r an y other

credibl e evidenc e to determin e whether

th e actua l emissio n level s o f th e abov e pollutant s excee d th e limite dpotentia l emissio n estimate s liste di n Conditio n 1.0(C) . Th e Permitte e shal l us e applicabl e tes t method s i n Appendi x A o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part

6 0 o r an y other metho dapprove db y EP A fo r conductin g any performanc e test s fo r th e abov e pollutants . [Conditio n 4.1. p o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-0 1 an d6 2 Fed . Reg . 831 4 (Feb . 27 , 1997) ] Th e Permitte e shal l conduc t an initia l C O complianc e tes t accordin g t o conditio n 2.0(B). 8 o r

conditio n 2.0(B). 9 ofthi s permi t withi n 18 0 day s o f

Ma y 3 , 201 3 unles s EP A grant s a n extensio n accordin g to th e provision s o f 4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6(f) . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6612(a) ]N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 7 o f 2 6 7 . Th e Pennitte e shal l conduc t aC O performanc e tes t every 8,76 0 hour s o r

3 years , whicheve r

come s first . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6615 , Tabl e 3 t o 4 0 C.F.R . Part 63 , Subpart ZZZZ ] 8 . I f th e Permitte e i s complyin g wit hth e C O reductio n requiremen t i n conditio n 2.0(A) . 10. i o f

thi s permi t

the n the Permitte e shal l measure th e 0 2an dC O a t the inle t an dthe outle t

o f th e contro l devic e usin g aportabl e C O an d0 2analyze r accordin g to AST M D6522-0 0 (2005 ) or , fo r CO , EP A Metho d1 0 o f 4 0 C.F.R . Appendi x A . Measurement s to detennin e 0 2mus t b e made a

t th e sam e tim e a s th e measurement s fo r

C O concentration . Th e C O concentratio n mus t b e a t 1 5 percen t 0 2 , dr y basis . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6612(a) , 4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6620(a) , Tabl e 4 t o 4 0 C.F.R . Part

63 , Subpar

t ZZZZ ] 9 . I f the Permitte e i s complyin g wit hth e C O concentratio n requiremen t i n Conditio n 2.0(A).10. i ofthi s permi t the n th e Pennitte e shal l do th e following : [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6612(a) , 4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6620(a) , Tabl e 4 to 4 0 C.F.R . Part 63 , Subpar t ZZZZ ] i . Selec t th e samplin g port

locatio n an dth e number o f travers e point s usin g Metho d1 o r

1 A o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part

60 , Appendi x A ; i i . Determin e th e 0 2concentratio n o f th e stationar

y RIC Eexhaus t

a t th e samplin g port

locatio n usin g Metho d3 o r 3 A o r 3 B o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part

6 0 Appendi x A , o r

AST M Metho dD6522-0 0 (2005) ; iii . Measur e moistur e content o f the stationary RIC Eexhaus t a t th e samplin g port locatio n usin g Metho d4 o f 4 0 C.F.R . Par

t 60 , Appendi x A , o r

Tes t Metho d32 0 o f

4 0 C.F.R . Part

63 , Appendi x A , o r

AST M D 6348-03 ; an d iv . Measur e C O a

t th e exhaus t

o f th e stationary RIC Eusin g Metho d1 0 o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part

60 , Appendi x A , AST M Metho dD6522-0 0 (2005) , Metho d 32 0 o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part

63 , Appendi x A , o r

AST M D6348-03 . C O concentratio n mus t

b e a t 1 5 percen t

0 2 , dry basis . Result s ofthi s tes t consis t o f the arithmeti c averag e o f the thre e 1 -hou r

o r longe r runs . 10 . Th e Permitte e shal l provid e notic e o f inten t to conduc t

aC O performanc e tes t under conditio n 2.0(B). 8 o r

conditio n 2.0(B). 9 o f

thi s permi t

a t leas t 6 0 calenda

r day s befor e th e performanc e tes t i s initiall y schedule dto begi n t o allo w EPA , upo n request , t o revie w an dapprov e th e site-specifi c tes t pla n require dunde r conditio n 2.0(B) . 1 1 an dto hav e an observe r present durin g th e test . I n th e event th e Permitte e i s unabl e t o conduc t th e performanc e tes t

o n th e dat

e specifie ddu e t o unforeseeabl e circumstance s beyon dhi s o r her control , th e Permitte e shal l notify th e Administrato r as soo n as practicabl e an dwithou t delay prio r

to th e schedule dperformanc e tes t date , an dspecif

y th e dat e whe n th e performanc e tes t i s rescheduled . [4 0 C.F.R . § § 63.6645 , 63.7(b) ]N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 . Page : 8 o f 2 6 11 . Befor e conductin g aperformanc e tes t require db y conditio n 2.0(B). 8 o r conditio n 2.0(B). 9 o f

thi s permit , th e Permitte e shal l develo p and , i f requeste db y EPA , shal l submi t

asite-specifi c tes t

pla n fo r approva l a

t leas t 6 0 calenda

r day s befor e th e performanc e tes t

i s schedule dto take place , tha t is , simultaneousl y wit hth e notificatio n o f

inten t to conduc t

aperformanc e tes t

require dunder

conditio n 2.0(B) . 1 0 o f

thi s permit . Th e tes t

pla n shal l includ e ates t progra msummary , the tes t schedule , dat aqualit y objectives , an dbot h an interna l an dexternal qualit y assuranc e (QA ) program . Dat aqualit y objective s ar e th e pretes t

expectation s o f precision , accuracy , an danalysi s o f replicat e samples . Th e interna l Q A progra m shal l include , a

t aminimum , th e activitie s planne db y th e routin e operator s an d analyst s to provid e a

n assessment

o f tes t dat aprecision . [4 0 C.F.R . § § 63.6645 , 63.7(b ) an d(c) ] (C) . Recordkeepin g an d Reportin g Requirement s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(c ) (3) ] 1 . Withi n 4 5 day s o f

completio n o f

aNO x performanc e o r annua l tes t

o r withi n 6 0 day s o f completio n o f

aC O performanc e test , th e Permitte e shal l submi t awritte n repor t to the EP A detailin g th e result s o f eac h tes t [Condition s 5 an d6 o f PSD

PI-R50003-00-01 , 4 0 C.F.R . 63.7(g)(1) ] 2 . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n records , includin g printout s o f digita l readouts , gauges , o r

meters , fo r

time s i n whic hth e flas h fil e progra m#180-173 6 i s modifie dan dan y time s i n whic hretar dengin e timin g parameter s hav e bee n changed . [Conditio n 4.1. mo f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 3 . Th e Permitte e shal l certif y tha t al l electroni c control s ar e se t fo r lo w emissio n strategy . [Conditio n 4.1. o o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 4 . I n accordanc e wit hthe recordkeepin g requirement s liste di n Sectio n 7 o f PSD-PI

R50003-00-01 , th e Permitte e shal l maintai n afil e ofth e record s tha t ar e require d to b e retaine db y thi s permi t a t th e facility . Record s include , bu t ar e no t limite d to , al l calibratio n an dmaintenanc e records , al l origina l continuou s monitorin g instrumentatio n data , an dcopie s o f al l report s require db y thi s permit . Monitorin g record s include , bu t ar e no t limite dto : i . Th e aftercoole r

return water

temperature , intak e manifol dpressure , an d any change s to flas h fil e progra m#180-173 6 fo r al l emissio n units ; i i . Hour s o f

operatio n fo r

al l emissio n units ; iii . Performanc e tes t

dat aan dresults ; iv . Result s o f

annual testin g fro mth e portabl e emission s analyzer ; v . Report s o f

exces s emissions ; vi . Change s requirin g notificatio n t o EP A unde r thi s section ; vii . Calibratio n an dmaintenanc e records , origina l stri p charts , o r computer base drecordings ; viii . Samplin g date s an dth e time s o f samplin g o r

measurement ;N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 9 o f

2 6 ix . Th e operatin g condition s tha t existe da

t the tim e o f

samplin g o r measurement ; x . Th e date s analyse s were performed ; xi . Th e locatio n where sample s were taken ; xii . Th e compan y o r

entity tha

t performe dth e samplin g an danalyses ; xiii . Th e analytica l technique s o r method s use di n th e samplin g an danalyses ; xiv . Th e result s o f

th e analyses ; an d xv . Occurrence an dduratio n o f an y startup , shutdown , o r malfunctio n i n th e operatio n o f

E U 01 , 02 , 03 , and/o r

04 o r th e facility ; any malfunctio n o f th e ai r pollutio n contro l equipment ; o r any period s durin g whic h a continuou s monitorin g syste mo r monitorin g devic e i s inoperative . 5 . Fo r eac h engin e the Permitte e mus t submi t acomplianc e repor

t semiannually . Th e firs t complianc e report

mus t cove r the perio dbeginnin g Ma y 3 , 2013 , an d endin g Jun e 30 , 2013 . Th e firs t complianc e repor

t mus t b e postmarke do r delivere dto EP A n o later than Jul y 31 , 2013 . Eac h subsequent complianc e repor

t mus t cove r th e semiannua l reportin g perio dfro mJanuary 1 throug h Jun e 3 0 o r th e semiannua l reportin g perio dfro mJul y 1 throug h Decembe r 31 . Eac h subsequent

complianc e report

mus t b e postmarke do r

delivere dto EP A n o later than Jul y 3 1 o r

Januar y 31 , whicheve r

dat e i s th e firs t

followin g th e en do f

th e semiannua l reportin g period . Eac h report mus t contai n th e following : [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6650 , Tabl e 7 to 4 0 C.F.R . Part 63 , Subpar

t ZZZZ ] i . Th e complianc e repor t mus t contai n th e Permittee' s name an daddress , a statemen t b y aresponsibl e officia l wit h tha t official s name , title , an d signature certifyin g th e accurac y o f th e conten t

o f th e report , an dth e dat

e o f the repor

t an dbeginnin g an dendin g date s o f th e reportin g period . i i . I f ther e ar e n o deviation s fro mth e emissio n limitation s liste di n conditio n 2.0(A) . lO. i o f

thi s permi t

durin g the operatin g perio dthe n th e Permitte e mus t includ e i n th e repor

t astatemen

t tha t there wer e n o deviation s fro m th e emissio n limitation s durin g th e reportin g period . iii . I f ther e ar e deviation s fro mth e emissio n limitation s liste di n conditio n 2.0(A) . 1 0 ofthi s permi t durin g th e reportin g period , th e repor t mus t contai n th e tota l operatin g tim e o f the engin e a

t whic h th e deviatio n occurre ddurin g th e reportin g perio dan dinformatio n o n the number , duration , an dcaus e o f

deviation s (includin g unknow n cause , i f applicable) , as applicable , an dth e correctiv e actio n taken . iv . I f malfunction s occurre ddurin g th e reportin g perio dthe n the repor t mus t includ e th e number , duration , an dabrie f descriptio n fo r

eac h typ e o f malfunctio n whic h occurre ddurin g th e reportin g perio dan dwhic h cause d o r ma y hav e cause dan y applicabl e emissio n limitatio n t o b e exceeded . Th e report

mus t als o includ e adescriptio n o f action s take n b y an owne r o rN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 0 o f 2 6 operato r durin g amalfunctio n o f an affecte dsourc e to minimiz e emission s i n accordanc e wit hConditio n 2.0(A).9 . 6 . Th e Permitte e shal l maintai n acop y o f eac h semiannua l complianc e report , record s o f

the occurrenc e an dduratio n o f eac h malfunctio n i n monitorin g equipment , record s o f

performanc e tests , record s o f al l require dmaintenanc e performe do n th e monitorin g equipment , an drecord s o f action s taken durin g period s o f

malfunctio n t o minimiz e emissions . Al l record s require di n thi s conditio n shal l b e kep t

readil y availabl e fo r

expeditiou s revie w fo r fiv e year s followin g the dat

e o f eac h occurrence , measurement , maintenance , correctiv e action , report , o r

record . [4 0 C.F.R . § § 63.6655 , 63.6660 ] 3. 0 FACILITY-WID E PERMI T CONDITION S Condition s i n thi s sectio n o f th e permi t

appl y to al l emission s unit s locate da t th e facility . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a) ] (A ) . General Part7

1 Recordkeepin g Requirement s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(h) ] 1 . Th e Permitte e shal l kee p record s o f require dmonitorin g informatio n tha t includ e th e following : i . Th e date , place , an dtim e o f samplin g o r

measurements ; i i . Th e date(s ) analyse s were performed ; iii . Th e compan y o r

entity tha

t performe dth e analyses ; iv . Th e analytica l technique s o r method s used ; v . Th e result s o f

suc h analyses ; an d vi . Th e operatin g condition s as existin g a t the tim e o f

samplin g o r measurement . 2 . Th e Permitte e shal l retai n record s o f al l require dmonitorin g dat aan dsuppor t informatio n fo r

aperio do f

a t leas t fiv e calenda

r year s fro mthe dat

e o f th e monitorin g sample , measurement , report , o r application . Support

informatio n include s al l calibratio n an dmaintenanc e records , al l origina l strip-chart recording s fo r continuou s monitorin g instrumentation , an dcopie s o f al l report s require db y thi s permit . (B ) . Genera l Part7

1 Reportin g Requirement s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(iii) , 6 2 Fed . Reg . 831 4 (February 24 , 1997) ] 1 . Th e Pennitte e shal l submi t to the EP A semi-annua l report s o f any require d monitorin g fo r

eac h six-mont h reportin g perio dfro mJanuar y 1 to Jun e 30 , an d fro mJul y 1 to Decembe r 31 , excep t

tha t th e firs t reportin g perio dshal l begi n o n th e effectiv e dat

e o f thi s permi t

an den do n Decembe r

31 . Al l report s shal l b e submitte dto the EP A an dshal l b e postmarke db y the 30th day followin g th e en d o f th e reportin g period . Al l instance s o f deviation s fro mpermi t requirement sN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Permi t #: V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 1 1 o f

2 6 mus t b e clearl y identifie di n suc h reports . Al l require dreport s mus t b e certifie db y aresponsibl e officia l consisten t wit h Conditio n 4.0(H)(1) o f thi s permit . [4 0 i . A monitorin g report

unde r thi s sectio n mus t

includ e th e following : (a) . Th e compan y nam e an daddress ; (b ) . Th e beginnin g an dendin g date s o f th e reportin g period ; (c ) . Th e emission s uni t

o r activit y bein g monitored ; (d) . Th e emission s limitatio n o r standard , includin g operationa l requirement s an dlimitation s (suc h as parameter ranges) , specifie d i n the permi t

fo r whic h complianc e i s bein g monitored ; (e ) . Al l instance s o f

deviation s fro mpermi t requirement s whether demonstrate db y reference dtes t method , monitoring , o r throug h any other credibl e evidence , includin g thos e attributabl e to upse t condition s as define di n thi s permit , an dth e dat e o n whic h eac h deviatio n occurre dand , a t th e source' s discretion , eithe r th e tota l duratio n o f

deviation s indicate db y suc h monitorin g o r th e actua l record s o f

deviations ; (f ) . Th e tota l tim e whe n monitorin g require db y thi s permi t wa s no t performe ddurin g th e reportin g period ; (g ) . Al l other

monitorin g results , data , o r analyse s require dto b e reporte db y th e applicabl e requirement ; an d (h ) . Th e name , title , an dsignature o f th e responsibl e officia l wh o i s certifyin g to th e truth , accuracy , an dcompletenes s o f the report . i i . An y repor

t require db y an applicabl e requiremen t tha t provide s th e sam

e informatio n describe di n conditio n 3.0(B)(1)(a ) tliroug h (h) , above , shal l satisf y th e requiremen t

under (B)(1) . iii . Deviatio n mean s an y situatio n i n whic h an emission s uni t fail s to meet

a permi t ter mo r condition . A deviatio n i s no t alway s aviolation . A deviatio n ca n b e determine db y observatio n o r throug h revie w o f

data , obtaine dfro man y testing , monitoring , o r recor dkeepin g establishe di n accordanc e wit h 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a ) (3 ) (i ) an d(a) (3 ) (ii) . Fo r asituatio n lastin g more than 2 4 hours , eac h 24-hou r perio di s considere daseparat e deviation . Th e meanin g o f deviatio n includes , bu t i s no t limite dto , an y o f th e following : [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(iii)(C) ] (a ) . A situatio n whe n emission s excee da n emissio n limitatio n o r standard ; (b ) . A situatio n where proces s o r emission s contro l devic e parameter value s indicat e tha

t an emissio n limitatio n o r standardha s no t

bee n C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(iii)(A ) an d(B) ]

met ; an dN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t #: V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 2 o f 2 6 (c) . A situatio n i n whic hobservation s o r dat acollecte ddemonstrate s noncomplianc e wit han emissio n limitatio n o r standardo r

an y wor k practic e o r

operatin g conditio n require db y th e permit . 2 . Th e Permitte e shal l promptl y repor t t o the EP A deviation s fro mpermi t requirements , includin g thos e attribute dto malfunction , emergenc y o r other upse t conditions , th e probabl e caus e o f suc h deviations , an dan y correctiv e action s o r preventiv e measure s taken . "Prompt " i s define das follows : [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3 ) (iii ) (B) ] i . An y definitio n o f

"prompt " o r

specifi c timefram e fo r

reportin g deviation s provide di n an underlyin g applicabl e requiremen t (a s identifie di n thi s permit); o r i i . Wher e th e underlyin g applicabl e requiremen t doe s no t

defin e promp t

o r provid e atimefram e fo r reportin g deviations , report s o f deviation s shal l b e submitte dbase do n th e followin g schedule : (a ) . Fo r emission s o f

ahazardou s ai r

pollutant

o r atoxi c ai r

pollutan t (as identifie di n th e applicabl e regulation ) tha t continu e i n exces s o f permi t requirement s fo r

more than an hour , th e repor t mus t b e mad e withi n 2 4 hour s o f the occurrence . (b ) . Fo r emission s o f

an y regulate dpollutan t excludin g ahazardou s ai r pollutan t o r atoxi c ai r

pollutant

tha t continu e i n exces s o f

permi t requirement s fo r

mor e than tw o hours , the report mus t b e mad e withi n 4 8 hours . (c ) . Fo r al l other deviation s fro mpermi t requirements , th e repor t shal l b e submitte dwit hth e semi-annua l monitorin g report require di n paragrap h (1 ) o f

thi s section . 3 . I f an y o f th e condition s i n Conditio n 3.0(B ) (2 ) (ii ) (a) throug h (c ) abov e ar e met , th e sourc e mus t

notif y th e EP A b y telephon e o r facsimil e base do n th e timetabl e liste di n tha

t subsection . Th e Permitte e mus t submi t awritte n notice , certifie d consisten t

wit hConditio n 3.0(B ) (4 ) withi n 1 0 workin g day s o f th e occurrence . Th e Permitte e als o mus t identif y al l deviation s reporte dunde r thi s sectio n i n th e semi-annua l repor

t require dunde r

paragrap h (1 ) o f

thi s section . 4 . An y applicatio n form , report , o r complianc e certificatio n require dto b e submitte d b y thi s permi t

shal l contai n certificatio n b y aresponsibl e officia l o f truth , accuracy , an dcompleteness . Al l certification s shal l stat e that , base do n informatio n an dbelie f

forme dafte r

reasonabl e inquiry , th e statement s an d informatio n i n th e documen t ar e true , accurate , an dcomplete . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.5(d) ]N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Penni t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 1 3 o f

2 6 (C ) . Permi tShiel d [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(f) ] 1 . Complianc e wit hth e condition s o f thi s permi t

shal l b e deeme dcomplianc e wit h an y applicabl e requirement s as o f th e dat e o f permi t issuanc e provide dtha

t suc h applicabl e requirement s ar e include dan dspecificall y identifie di n thi s permit . 2 . Nothin g i n thi s penni t shal l alte r

o r affec t th e following : i . Th e provision s o f

Sectio n 30 3 o f

th e CA A (emergenc y orders) , includin g the authority o f

th e Administrato r

under tha t section ; i i . Th e liabilit y o f

th e Permitte e fo r

an y violatio n o f

applicabl e requirement s prio r to o r a t th e tim e o f

permi t issuance ; o r iii . Th e abilit y o f

th e EP A to obtai n informatio n unde r Sectio n 11 4 o f

th e CAA . (D) . Performanc e Testin g [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a ) (3 ) (i ) an dSectio n 5 o f PSD-PI-R50003-00-01 ] 1 . Testin g Notification . Writte n notificatio n o f th e planne dtes t

dat e shal l b e postmarke do r

receive db y th e EP A a t leas t 3 0 day s befor e th e planne dtes t dat e fo r NO x performanc e testin g an da t leas t 6 0 day s befor e th e planne dtes t dat e fo r C O perfonnanc e testing . Th e EP A shal l rejec t th e result s o f

ates t i f les s than 3 0 day s notic e i s give n fo r aNO x performanc e tes t o r les s tha n 6 0 day s notic e i s give n fo r aC O performanc e tes t unles s EP A ha s provide dawritte n authorizatio n fo r ashorter notice . [4 0 C.F.R . § 63.6645(g) ] 2 . Tes t Plans . Withi n 6 0 day s afte r receivin g arequest , an da t leas t 3 0 day s befor e th e schedule ddat

e o f any tests , th e Permitte e shal l submi t acomplet e pla n fo r conductin g the sourc e test s to th e EP A fo r approval . Failur e to submi t acomplet e pla n shal l no t

alte r the dat e b y whic han y tes t

i s required . 3 . Approva l o f

Tes t Plan . I f th e propose dtes t

pla n doe s no t

contai n sufficien t

o r accurate enoug h detai l t o ensur e tha t th e performanc e tes t

meet s the requirement s o f the applicabl e requiremen t o r complianc e document , EP A may rejec t th e plan , an dthe Permitte e mus t

addres s an y o f

EPA' s comment s o n revision s an d addition s tha

t ar e necessary to mak e th e pla n complete . 4 . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t th e tes t pla n i n the followin g forma t an dinclud e th e followin g elements : Part I . Genera l information : i . Nam e an daddres s o f facility ;N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 4 o f 2 6 i i . Name , title , telephon e number , an dfacsimil e numbe r o f contac t perso n a t facility ; iii . Permi t

numbe r o r name o f other applicabl e complianc e document ; iv . Reaso n fo r

testing ; v . Schemati c drawin g o f stac k an dsampl e ports ; vi . Locatio n o f

facility ; an d vii . Name , contac t

person , telephon e number , an dfacsimil e number fo r testin g compan y contracte dto conduc t th e test . Part II . Testin g requirements : i . Lis t o f th e emissio n units , as identifie di n the applicabl e requiremen t o r complianc e document , an dpollutant s to b e tested , th e emissio n limi t fo r eac h pollutant , an dthe applicabl e rul e o r regulatio n fo r

eac h emissio n limit ; an d i i . Descriptio n o f

procedure fo r

fue l samplin g an danalysis , where applicable . Part III . Operatin g conditions : i . Lis t o f the proces s o r

operatin g rate an dcondition s o f the proces s equipmen t

an dai r pollutio n contro l equipmen t fo r th e test ; i i . Lis t o f the rang e o f

proces s o r

operatin g rate s fo r

eac h emission s unit ; an d iii . Descriptio n o f

ho w ai r pollutio n contro l an dproces s equipmen t wil l b e monitored . Part IV . Tes t methods : i . Lis t ofth e method s to b e use dt o detennine th e emissio n rat e o f eac h pollutant ; i i . Numbe r

o f tes t runs , length o f

tes t run , an dsamplin g rat

e fo r eac h method ; iii . Referenc e to any applicabl e requiremen t o r complianc e documen t requirin g us e o f

specifi c method s o r

procedures ; iv . Summary o f

reason s fo r

proposin g to us e an y alternativ e o r equivalen t method ; an d v . Fo r tes t method s other

tha n referenc e methods , statemen t o f the detectio n limi t an dth e degre e o f

accurac y o f

tha t metho da

t th e expecte demissio n rat e an dunder

the condition s o f

th e performanc e test . 5 . Operatin g Condition s fo r Perfomianc e Testing . Th e Permitte e shal l conduc t al l perfomianc e test s a

t wors t cas e operatin g (non-malfunction ) condition s fo r al l emissio n unit s fo r

eac h ai r pollutant

tha t i s require dt o b e teste dunless : i . Th e applicabl e requiremen t o r complianc e documen t

specifie s alternativ e operatin g condition s fo r performanc e testing ; o rN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 5 o f 2 6 i i . Th e wors t

cas e conditio n i s no t

know n o r

calculable . I n thi s case , wors t cas e condition s shal l b e assume dto b e th e maximu machievabl e proces s o r operatin g rat

e o f th e emission s unit . 6 . Tes t Runs . Unles s otherwis e specifie db y th e applicabl e Referenc e Tes t Method , eac h performanc e tes t

shal l consis t

o f thre e separat

e runs . Fo r

th e purpos e o f determinin g complianc e wit han applicabl e standard , th e arithmeti c mean o f result s o f

th e thre e run s shal l apply . I n th e event tha t asampl e i s accidentall y los t o r condition s occu r

i n whic hon e o f

th e thre e run s mus t

b e discontinue dbecaus e o f force dshutdown , failur e o f a n irreplaceabl e portio n o f th e sampl e train , extrem e meteorologica l conditions , o r other circumstance s beyon dth e Permittee' s control , complianc e may , upo n th e EPA' s approval , b e determine d usin g th e arithmeti c mean o f the result s o f

th e tw o other

runs . 7 . Failur e to demonstrate compliance . Upo n th e EPA' s writte n notic e tha t th e facilit y ha s faile dto demonstrate complianc e wit han applicabl e emissio n limit , th e Permittee , unles s an alternativ e schedul e i s give n i n an applicabl e requiremen t

o r complianc e document , shall : i . Submi t

t o th e EP A writte n notic e o f retesting , submi t

ates t pla n fo r th e retest , an dschedul e apretes t meetin g a

t leas t 2 1 day s i n advanc e o f

th e dat e o f th e retest . Th e pretes t

meetin g shal l b e hel da t leas t seve n day s prio r to th e dat

e ofth e retest , excep t

tha t ashorter perio dshal l b e allowe d i f the EP A i s abl e to accommodat e suc h areques t fo r ameeting ; i i . Conduc t

aretes t withi n 3 0 day s o f

receip t o f th e EP A writte n notice ; an d iii . Submi t

acomplet e report

ofth e result s o f

the retes t

withi n 4 5 day s afte r completion . 8 . Th e Permitte e ma y receiv e an extensio n to th e schedul e i f on e o f th e followin g specia l circumstance s applies : i . Seasona l o r

temporary shutdow n o f the affecte demission s units ; i i . Malfunctio n o r

breakdow n o f

th e affecte demission s units , unles s th e EP A determine s tha

t aretes t unde r suc h condition s i s warrante di n orde r t o detennin e the effec t

o f th e malfunctio n o r

breakdow n o n emission s o r wher e suc h condition s are representativ e o f pas t operatio n o f

th e emission s units ; iii . Weathe r

condition s tha

t preven t usin g th e applicabl e tes t method s o r preven t operatio n o f

th e affecte demissio n unit s a t th e require doperatin g conditions ; iv . An y other

condition s beyon dth e contro l o f th e Pennitte e tha

t preven t usin g th e applicabl e tes t method s o r

preven t operatio n o f

the affecte d emission s unit s a

t the require doperatin g conditions ; o rN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permit* : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 6 o f 2 6 v . An y other

conditio n beyon dth e contro l o f th e Permitte e tha

t prevent s completio n o f

aretes t withi n th e require dschedule . 9 . Reques t

fo r aRetes t Extension . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t to th e EP A any reques t fo r an extensio n ofth e tim e schedul e i n writin g prio r to th e dat

e b y whic h retestin g i s required . Th e reques t shal l specif

y th e reaso n wh y the extensio n i s needed , an dinclud e an alternativ e retes t schedule ; however , th e EP A shal l no t exten daretes t

dat e more tha n 3 0 day s afte r th e start-up , completio n o f maintenance , seasonal weather change , o r

other improvemen t

i n the specia l condition s liste di n thi s section . I f th e EP A grant s an extension , th e Permitte e shal l implemen t

th e alternativ e retes t

schedule . A requeste dextensio n shal l no t b e effectiv e unles s the EP A ha s give n writte n approva l ofth e extension . A retes t dat e shal l no t

b e extende dbeyon d3 0 days . 10 . Onl y regular

operatin g staf

f ma y adjus t

th e processe s o r

emissio n contro l devic e parameter s durin g acomplianc e sourc e test . N o adjustment s ar e to b e made withi n tw o hour s o f

the star t o f th e tests . An y operatin g adjustment s mad e durin g asourc e tes t

tha t ar e aresul t o f consultatio n durin g the test s wit hsourc e testin g personnel , equipment

vendors , o r

consultant s ma y render th e sourc e tes t

invalid . 11 . Withi n 4 5 day s afte r completio n o f

aNO x performanc e o r

annua l tes t

an dwithi n 6 0 day s afte r

completio n o f

aC O performanc e test , the Permitte e shal l submi t a cop y o f th e tes t result s to th e EPA . 4. 0 PAR T 7

1 GENERA L PERMI T RE Q U I RENT S (A ) . Definition s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.2 ] Term s an dcondition s hav e the meanin g assigne dto the mi n Part 7 1 unles s th e permi t otherwis e define s th e term s o r reference s other

regulation s o r

statutes . (B ) . Annua l Fe

e Paymen

t[4 0 C.F.R . § § 71.6(a)(7 ) an d71.9 ] 1 . Th e Permitte e shal l pay an annua l permi t fe e i n accordanc e wit hthe procedure s outline dbelow . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(a) ] 2 . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t a n annua l repor

t o f it s actua l emission s fo r th e precedin g calenda

r year , afe e calculatio n wor k sheet (base do n the report) , an d ful l paymen t

o f th e annual fe e eac h year . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t th e annua l repor t an dpay the annual permi t fe e eac h yea

r o n o r befor e th e anniversary dat e o f it s initia l fe e calculatio n wor k sheet , Jun e 20 t h . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t the annua l repor

t to : EP A Region 5 Ai ran d Radiatio n Divisio n Ai rProgram s Branc h (AR-18J )N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N

Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Page : 1 7 o f

2 6 Ai rPermit

s Section 7 7 WestJackso n Boulevar d Chicago , Illinoi s 6060

4 3 . Th e fe e paymen t

shal l b e i n Unite dState s currenc y an dshal l b e pai db y mone y order , ban k

draft , certifie dcheck , corporat e check , o r electroni c fund s transfe r payabl e t o th e order

o f th e U.S . Environmenta l Protectio n Agency . 4 . Th e Permitte e shal l sen dth e fe e paymen t an dacomplete dfe e filing for mto : Fo r Regula r

U.S . Posta l Servic e Mai l U.S . Environmenta l Protectio n Agenc y FOI A an d Miscellaneous Payment s Cincinnati Financ e Cente r P.O . Bo x 97907

8 St. Louis , Missour i 63197-900 0 Fo r Non-U.S . Posta l Servic e Expres s Mai l U.S . Ban k GovernmentLockbo x 97907 8 U.S . EP A FOI A and Miscellaneous Payment s 100 5 Conventio n Plaz a SL-MO-C2-G L St . Louis , Missour i 63101 5 . Th e Permitte e shal l sen dt o th e addres s liste di n conditio n 4.0(B)(2 ) o f thi s permi t afe e calculatio n workshee t an daphotocop y o f

eac h fe e paymen t

chec k (o r other confirmatio n o f

actua l fe e paid ) submitte dannuall y b y th e sam e deadlin e a s require dfo r

fe e payment . (Th e Permitte e shoul dnote tha t an annua l emission s report , require da

t th e same tim e as the fe e calculatio n workshee t b y 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(h) , ha s bee n incorporate dint o th e fe e calculatio n workshee t for ma s a convenience. ) 6 . Basi s fo r

calculatin g annua l fee : i . Th e Permitte e shal l calculat e th e annua l emission s fe e b y multiplyin g th e tota l ton s o f

actua l emission s o f

al l regulate dpollutant s (fo r fe e calculation ) emitte dfro mth e source , includin g fugitiv e emission s b y th e presumptiv e emission s fe e (i n dollars/ton ) i n effec t a t th e tim e o f calculation . (a) . "Actua l emissions " mean s th e actua l rat e o f emission s i n tp y o f an y "regulate dpollutant (fo r fe e calculation) " emitte dfro maPart 7 1 sourc e ove r

th e precedin g calenda

r year . Actua l emission s shal lN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 8 o f 2 6 b e calculate dusin g eac h emission s unit' s actua l operatin g hours , productio n rates , in-plac e contro l equipment , an dtype s o f material s processed , stored , o r combuste ddurin g th e precedin g calenda r year . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(c)(6) ] (b ) . Actua l emission s shal l b e compute dusin g method s require db y th e permi t fo r determinin g compliance , suc h as monitorin g o r sourc e testin g data . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(h)(3) ] (c ) . I f actua l emission s canno t b e determine dusin g the complianc e method s i n th e permit , the Permitte e shal l us e other federall y recognize dprocedures . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(e)(2) ] (d) . Th e ter m"regulate dpollutan t (fo r fe e calculation) " i s define di n 4 0 C.F.R . §71.2 . (e ) . Prio r t o the star

t o f eac h calenda

r year , the EP A wil l revis e fo r inflatio n an dmake availabl e the presumptiv e fe e amount . i i . Th e Permitte e shal l exclud e th e followin g emission s fro mth e calculatio n o f fees : (a ) . Th e amount

o f actua l emission s o f

eac h regulate dpollutan t (fo r fe e calculation ) tha

t the sourc e emit s i n exces s o f 4,00 0 ton s pe r

year [4 0 C.F.R . §71.9(c)(5)(i)] ; (b ) . Actua l emission s o f an y regulate dpollutant (fo r fe e calculation ) alread y include di n th e fe e calculatio n [40 C.F.R . § 71.9(c)(5)(h)] ; an d (c ) . Th e quantity o f

actua l emission s (fo r

fe e calculation ) o f insignifican t

activitie s define di n 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.5(c)( l l)(i ) o r o f insignifican t

emission s level s fro memission s unit s identifie di n th e Permittee' s applicatio n pursuan t to 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.5(c)( l l)(ii) . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(c ) (5 ) (iii) ] 7 . Th e Permitte e shal l retai n fe e calculatio n worksheet s an dother emissions-relate d dat ause dto determin e fe e paymen t fo r fiv e year s followin g submitta l o f fe e payment . Emission-relate ddat ainclude , fo r example , emissions-relate dform s provide db y th e EP A an duse db y th e Permitte e fo r fe e calculatio n purposes , emissions-relate dspreadsheets , an demissions-relate ddata , suc h a s record s o f emission s monitorin g dat aan drelate dsuppor t informatio n require dto b e kep t i n accordanc e wit h4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(3)(h) . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(i). ] 8 . Failur e o f

th e Permitte e to pay fee s i n atimel y manner shal l subjec t

the Permitte e to assessment

o f penaltie s an dinteres t

i n accordanc e wit h4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(f) . 9 . I f notifie db y th e EP A o f underpaymen t

o f fees , th e Permitte e shal l remi t ful l paymen t withi n 3 0 day s o f

receip t o f notification . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.9(j)(l ) an d(2) ] 10 . I f the Permitte e believe s tha t the EP A assesse dfe e i s i n erro r an dwishe s to challeng e suc h fee , th e Permitte e shal l provid e awritte n explanatio n o f theN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 1 9 o f 2 6 allege derro r

to the EP A alon g wit h ful l paymen t o f th e EP A assesse dfee . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.90)(3) ] (C) . Complianc e Statemen t[4 0 C.F.R . § 71 . 6(a)(6) ] 1 . Th e Permitte e mus t

compl y wit h al l condition s o f thi s Part 7 1 permit . An y noncomplianc e wit h thi s permi t constitute s aviolatio n ofth e CA A an di s ground s for : i . Enforcemen t

action ; ii . Penni t termination , revocatio n an dreissuance , o r modification ; and/o r iii . Denia l o f

apenni t renewa l application . 2 . It shal l no t b e adefens e fo r

th e Permitte e i n an enforcemen t actio n tha

t i t woul d hav e bee n necessar

y to hal t o r reduc e th e permittedactivit y i n order to maintai n complianc e wit h th e condition s o f thi s permit . [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(6)(h) ] (D) . Complianc e Certification s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(c)(5) ] 1 . Th e Pennitte e shal l submi t to th e EP A acertificatio n o f complianc e wit h al l permi t term s an dconditions , includin g emissio n limitations , standards , o r wor k practice s fo r

th e reportin g perio dfro mJanuary 1 to Decembe r 31 , excep t

th e firs t reportin g perio dshal l begi n o n th e effectiv e dat e ofthi s penni t

an den do n Decembe r

31 . Al l report s shal l b e submitte dto EP A an dshal l b e postmarke db y th e 30 t hda

y followin g th e en do f

eac h reportin g period . Th e complianc e certificatio n shal l b e certifie das to truth , accuracy , an dcompletenes s b y a responsibl e officia l i n accordanc e wit h conditio n 4.0(H)(1 ) o f thi s permit . Th e certificatio n shal l includ e the following : i . Identificatio n o f

eac h permi t

ter mo r conditio n tha

t i s th e basi s o f

th e certification ; i i . Identificatio n o f

the method(s ) o r

other mean s use dfo r

determinin g th e complianc e statu s o f

eac h ter man dconditio n durin g th e certificatio n period , an dwhethe r

suc h method s o r

other mean s provid e continuou s o r intermitten t

data . I f necessary , th e Pennitte e als o shal l identif y an y other materia l infonnatio n tha t mus t b e include di n th e certificatio n to compl y wit hSectio n 113(c)(2 ) o f th e CAA , whic h prohibit s knowingl y makin g a fals e certificatio n o r

omittin g materia l information ; iii . Th e complianc e statu s o f eac h ter man dconditio n o f th e permit , includin g whether monitorin g dat ai s continuou s an dwhether tha t dat ao r an y other credibl e evidenc e show s th e complianc e i s continuous . Th e certificatio nN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Penni t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 0 o f 2 6 shal l identif

y eac h deviatio n an dtake i t int o accoun t

i n the complianc e certification ; an d iv . A statemen

t indicatin g the complianc e statu s ofth e sourc e wit hany applicabl e enhance dmonitorin g an dcomplianc e certificatio n requirement s ofth e CAA . (E ) . Schedule o

f Compliance [4 0 C.F .R . § § 71.6(c)(3 ) an d71.5(c)(8)(iii) ] 1 . Fo r applicabl e requirement s wit hwhic hth e sourc e i s i n compliance , th e sourc e wil l continu e t o compl y wit hsuc h requirements . 2 . Fo r applicabl e requirement s tha t wil l becom e effectiv e durin g th e permi t term , th e sourc e shal l compl y as require db y th e term s o f th e applicabl e requirement . (F ) . Dut y t o Provid e an

d Supplemen

tInformatio n [4 0 C.F .R . § § 71.6(a)(6)(v ) an d 71.5(b) ] 1 . Th e Permitte e shal l furnis h t o the EPA , withi n areasonabl e time , an y informatio n tha t th e EP A may reques t

i n writin g to determin e whether caus e exist s fo r modifying , revoking , an dreissuing , o r terminatin g thi s permi t o r to determin e complianc e wit hthi s permit . Upo n EPA' s request , th e Permitte e shal l als o furnis h to th e EP A copie s o f record s tha

t ar e require dto b e kep t

pursuan t to th e term s o f thi s permit , includin g informatio n claime dt o b e confidential . Informatio n claime dto b e confidentia l shoul db e accompanie db y aclai mo f confidentialit y accordin g to th e provision s o f 4 0 C.F .R . Part

2 , Subpar

t B . 2 . Th e Permittee , upo n becomin g awar e tha t an y relevan t

fact s were omitte do r incorrec t informatio n wa s submitte di n th e permi t application , shal l promptl y submi t suc h supplementar

y fact s o r

correcte dinformation . Th e Permitte e shal l als o provid e additiona l informatio n as necessary to addres s an y requirement s tha t becom e applicabl e to th e facilit y afte r thi s permi t

i s issued . (G) . Enforceability [4 0 C.F .R . § 71.6(b) ] A l l term s an dcondition s i n thi s permit , includin g an y provision s designate dt o limi t a source' s potentia l to emit , ar e enforceabl e b y th e EP A an dcitizen s i n accordanc e wit hth e CAA . (H) . Submission

s [4 0 C.F .R . § § 71.5(d) , 71. 6 an d71.9 ] 1 . A responsibl e officia l o f th e Permitte e shal l certif y as t o th e truth , accuracy , an d completenes s o f

an y documen t

require dto b e submitte db y thi s permit . Suc h certification s shal l stat

e tha t base do n informatio n an dbelie f forme dafte r reasonabl e inquiry , th e statement s an dinformatio n i n the documen t ar e true ,N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 1 o f 2 6 accurate , an dcomplete . Excep t as otherwis e noted , th e Permitte e shal l submi t al l document s require dto b e submitte db y thi s permi t to : EP A Regio n 5 Ai ran d Radiatio n Divisio n Ai rEnforcementand Complianc e Assurance Branc h (AE-17J ) 7 7 WestJackso n Boulevar d Chicago , Illinoi s 6060

4 2 . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t copie s o f

permi t applications , application s fo r penni t amendments , an dother applicabl e permi t

infonnation , whic hinclude s bu t i s no t limite dto installatio n o f contro l equipment , replacemen t o f an emission s unit , fe e calculatio n worksheets , an dapplication s fo r renewal s an dpermi t

modification s shal l b e submitte dto :

EP A Region 5 Ai rand Radiatio n Divisio n Ai rPermit

s Section Ai rProgram s Branc h (AR-18J ) 7 7 WestJackso n Boulevar d Chicago , Illinoi s 6060

4 3 . Th e Permitte e shal l submi t al l submittal s tha

t ar e require db y th e Aci dRai n Program , 4 0 C .F.R . Part s 7 2 throug h 7 8 to :

U.S . Environmental Protectio n Agency Clea n Ai rMarkets Divisio n Arie l Rio s Buildin g (6204J ) 120 0 Pennsylvani a Avenu e N.W . Washingto n D.C . 2046 0 (I) . Severabilit

y Claus e [4 0 C .F.R . § 71 .6 (a)(5) ] Th e provision s o f

thi s permi t

ar e severable , an di n th e event o f an y challeng e to any portio n o f

thi s permit , o r

i f an y portio n i s hel dinvalid , th e remainin g permi t condition s shal l remai n vali dan di n force . (J) . Permi tAction s [4 0 C .F.R . § 71.6(a)(6)(iii) ] E P A ma y b e modify , revoke , reope n an dreissue , o r terminat e thi s permi t

fo r cause . Th e filin g o f areques t b y th e Permitte e fo r

apermi t modification , revocatio n an dreissuance , o r termination , o r

o f anotificatio n o f

planne dchange s o r

anticipate dnoncomplianc e doe s no t sta y an y permi t

condition . (K) . Administrativ e Permi tAmendment sN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 2 o f 2 6 Th e Permitte e may reques t the us e o f

administrativ e permi t

amendment

procedure s fo r

a permi t revisio n i n accordanc e wit h4 0 C.F.R . § 71.7(d) . (L) . Mino rPermi tModification s Th e Permitte e ma y reques t the us e o f

mino r permi t modificatio n procedure s fo r thos e modification s tha

t meet the requirement s containe di n 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.7(e)(1) . (M) . SignificantPermitModification s Th e Permitte e mus t

reques t the us e o f

significan t

permi t modificatio n procedure s fo r thos e modification s tha t mee t the requirement s containe di n 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.7(e)(3) . (N) . Reopenin g fo rCaus e [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.7(f) ] Th e EP A shal l reope n an drevis e th e permi t prio r to expiratio n under

any o f the followin g circumstances : 1 . Additiona l applicabl e requirement s under the CA A becom e applicabl e t o th e sourc e i f th e remainin g permi t

termi s 3 o r

more years . 2 . Additiona l requirement s (includin g exces s emission s requirements ) becom e applicabl e to an affecte dsourc e unde r th e aci drai n program . Upo n approva l b y the Administrator , exces s emission s offse t plan s shal l b e deeme dt o b e incorporate dint o the permit . 3 . EP A determine s tha t th e permi t

contain s amateria l mistak e o r tha t inaccurat e statement s were made i n establishin g th e emission s standard s o r other term s o r condition s o f

the permit . 4 . EP A determine s tha t the permi t

mus t b e revise do r

revoke dto assur

e complianc e wit hthe applicabl e requirements . (O) . Propert

y Right s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(6)(iv) ] Thi s permi t

doe s no t conve y any property right s o f an y sort , o r

an y exclusiv e privilege . (P) . Inspection and Entr y [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(c)(2) ] Upo n presentatio n o f

credential s an dothe r

document s as ma y b e require db y law , th e Permitte e shal l allo w EP A o r an authorize drepresentativ e t o perfor mthe followin g as authorize db y the CAA :N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 3 o f 2 6 1 . Ente r upo n th e Permittee' s premise s wher e aPart 7 1 sourc e i s locate do r emissions-relate dactivit y i s conducted , o r where record s mus t

b e kep t under th e condition s o f

the permit ; 2 . Hav e acces s t o an dcopy , a t reasonabl e times , an y record s tha t mus t b e kep t unde r the condition s o f

th e permit ; 3 . Inspec t

a t reasonabl e time s an y facilities , equipmen t (includin g monitorin g an dai r pollutio n contro l equipment) , practices , o r operation s regulate do r require dunder

th e permit ; an d 4 . Sampl e o r

monitor , a

t reasonabl e times , substance s o r parameter s fo r

the purpos e o f

assurin g complianc e wit hth e permi t o r applicabl e requirements . (Q) . Emergency Provisions [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(g) ] 1 . I n additio n to an y emergenc y o r upse t provisio n containe di n an y applicabl e requirement , th e Permitte e ma y see k t o establis h tha

t noncomplianc e wit ha technology-base demissio n limitatio n unde r thi s permi t

wa s du e to an emergency . T o d o so , the Permitte e shal l demonstrate th e affirmativ e defens e o f emergenc y throug h properl y signed , contemporaneou s operatin g logs , o r other relevan t evidenc e that : i . A n emergenc y occurre dan dtha t th e Permitte e ca n identif y th e cause(s ) o f th e emergency ; i i . Th e permitte dfacilit y wa s a t th e tim e bein g properl y operated ; iii . Durin g th e perio dofth e emergenc y the Permitte e too k al l reasonabl e step s t o minimiz e level s o f

emission s tha

t exceede dth e emission s standards , o r other requirement s i n thi s permit ; an d iv . Th e Permitte e submitte dnotic e o f th e emergenc y to th e EP A withi n 2 workin g day s o f

th e tim e whe n emissio n limitation s were exceede ddu e to th e emergency . Thi s notic e mus t contai n adescriptio n o f th e emergency , an y step s taken to mitigat e emissions , an dcorrectiv e action s taken. 2 . I n an y enforcemen t proceeding , th e Permitte e attemptin g to establis h th e occurrenc e o f

an emergenc y ha s the burde n o f proof . 3 . A n "emergency " mean s an y situatio n arisin g fro msudde n an dreasonabl y unforeseeabl e event s beyon dth e contro l ofth e source , includin g act s o f God , whic hsituatio n require s immediat e correctiv e actio n to restore norma l operation , an dtha t cause s th e sourc e to excee datechnology-base demissio n limitatio n unde r th e permi t

du e to unavoidabl e increase s i n emission s attributabl e to th e emergency . A n emergenc y shal l no t includ e noncomplianc e to th e extent cause dN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M N Issu e Date: Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 4 o f 2 6 b y improperl y designe dequipment , lac k o f preventive maintenance , careles s o r imprope r operation , o r

operato r error . (R) . Off-Permi tChanges [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(12) ] Th e Permitte e i s allowe dt o make certai n change s withou t apermi t revision , provide dtha

t th e followin g requirement s ar e met : 1 . Th e chang e i s no t

addresse do r

prohibite db y thi s permit ; 2 . Th e chang e mus t

compl y wit hal l applicabl e requirement s an dmay no t violat e an y existin g permi t

termo r condition ; 3 . Th e chang e canno t

b e subjec t

t o an y requiremen t

o f 4 0 C.F.R . Part s 7 2 throug h 7 8 o r modification s under

an y provisio n o f

Titl e I o f

th e CAA ; 4 . Th e Permitte e mus t provid e contemporaneou s writte n notic e t o EP A o f the change , excep t

i f th e chang e qualifie s as an insignifican t activit y under

4 0 C.F.R . § 71.5(e)(ll) . Th e writte n notic e mus t describ e eac h change , th e dat e o f the change , an y chang e i n emissions , pollutant s emitte dan dan y applicabl e requirement s tha

t woul dappl y as aresul t o f th e change ; 5 . Th e permi t

shiel ddoe s no t

appl y to change s made under thi s provision ; an d 6 . Th e Permitte e mus t keep arecor ddescribin g al l change s tha t resul t i n emission s o f an y regulate dai r

pollutan t

subjec t to any applicabl e requiremen t no t otherwis e regulate dunde r

thi s permit , an dth e emission s resultin g fro mthos e changes . (S) . Permi tExpiratio n and Renewa l [4 0 C.F.R . § § 71. 5 (a)(l)(iii) , 71.6(a)(ll) , 71.7(b) , 71.7(c)(l)(i ) an d(ii) , 71.8(d) ] 1 . Thi s permi t

shal l expir e upo n the earlie r occurrenc e o f

th e followin g events : i . Fiv e year s elapse s fro mth e dat e o f issuance ; o r i i . Th e sourc e i s issue daPart 7 0 permit . 2 . Expiratio n o f

thi s permi t

terminate s the Permittee' s righ t t o operat

e unles s a timel y an dcomplet e permi t renewa l applicatio n ha s bee n submitte da t leas t si x calenda r months , bu t

no t more than eightee n calenda r months , prio r

to the dat

e o f expiratio n o f

thi s permit . 3 . I f th e Permitte e submit s atimel y an dcomplet e permi t applicatio n fo r

renewal , consisten t

wit h4 0 C.F.R . § 71.5(a)(2) , bu t th e permittin g authority ha s faile dto issu e o r den y th e renewa l permit , the n th e permi t shal l no t expir e unti l the renewa l permi t

ha s bee n issue do r

denie dan dan y permi t

shiel dgrante dpursuan tN R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t # : V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 5 o f 2 6 t o 4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(f

) may b e extende dbeyon dth e origina l permi t termunti l renewal . 4 . I f the Permitte e ha s submitte datimel y an dcomplet e applicatio n fo r renewal , th e Permittee' s failur e to hav e aPart 7 1 permi t

i s no t aviolatio n o f

Part 7 1 unti l th e E P A take s fina l actio n o n th e permi t renewa l application . Thi s protectio n shal l ceas e to appl y if , subsequent to the completenes s determination , th e Permitte e fail s to submi t

an y additiona l informatio n identifie das bein g neede dto proces s th e applicatio n b y th e deadlin e specifie di n writin g b y EPA . 5 . Renewa l o f

thi s permi t

i s subjec t

t o the sam

e procedura l requirement s tha t appl y to initia l permi t

issuance , includin g thos e fo r publi c participation , affecte dStat e review , an dtriba l review . 6 . Th e applicatio n fo r

renewa l shal l includ e the curren t permi t number , descriptio n o f permi t revision s an doff-permi t change s tha

t occurre ddurin g th e permi t term , an y applicabl e requirement s tha t were promulgate dan dno t incorporate dint o th e permi t durin g th e permi t

term , an dother

informatio n require db y th e applicatio n form . (T) . Emissions Tradin g [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(8) ] N o Part 7 1 permi t

revisio n shal l b e required , under any approve deconomi c incentives , marketabl e permits , emission s tradin g an dother simila r program s o r

processe s fo r change s tha

t ar e provide dfo r

i n aPart 7 1 permit . (U) . Aci d Rai n Permi tProvision s [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(4) ] Th e Permitte e ma y no t

excee dan y allowance s tha t i t lawfull y hold s under

4 0 C.F.R . Part 7 2 throug h 78 . (V) . Operational Flexibility [4 0 C.F.R . § 71.6(a)(13) ] Th e Permitte e ma y make change s withi n apermitte dfacilit y withou t apermi t revision , provide dthe followin g condition s ar e met : 1 . Th e change s ar

e no t modification s under

an y provisio n o f

Titl e I ofth e CAA ; 2 . Th e change s d o no t excee dthe emission s allowe dunde r thi s permi t

(whether expresse dtherei n as arate o f emission s o r

i n term s o f

tota l emissions) ; an d 3 . Th e Permitte e notifie s th e EP A a t leas t seve n day s i n advanc e o f th e propose d changes . Th e writte n notificatio n shal l includ e abrie f descriptio n o f

the chang e withi n th e permittedfacility , th e dat e o n whic hthe chang e wil l occur , an y chang e i n emissions , an dan y permi t ter mo r conditio n tha

t i s n o longe r

applicabl e as a resul t ofth e change .N R GBacku p Generatio n Services , Re dWing , M NIssu e Date : Novembe r 26 , 201 2 Permi t #: V-PI-2704900084-2012-1 0 Page : 2 6 o f 2 6 (W) . Credibl e Evidenc e [6 2 Fed . Reg . 831 4 (February 24 , 1997) ] Notwithstandin g th e condition s o f thi s penni t

specifyin g complianc e practice s fo r applicabl e requirements , any perso n (includin g th e Pennitte e an dEPA ) may als o us e other credibl e evidenc e to establis h complianc e o r noncomplianc e wit happlicabl e requirements .