APPENDIX H 

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 1 of 7 PAGEID #: 7201
1

Appendix H

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

OHIO A. PHILIP RANDOLPH INSTITUTE, )

LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS OF OHIO, )

THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE )

DEMOCRATS, NORTHEAST OHIO YOUNG )

BLACK DEMOCRATS, HAMILTON COUNTY )

YOUNG DEMOCRATS, LINDA GOLDENHAR, )

DOUGLAS BURKS, SARAH INSKEEP, )

CYNTHIA LIBSTER, KATHRYN DEITSCH, )

LUANN BOOTHE, MARK JOHN GRIFFITHS, )

LAWRENCE NADLER, CHITRA WALKER, )

TRISTAN RADER, RIA MEGNIN, ) No. 1:18-cv-00357-TSB

ANDREW HARRIS, AARON DAGRES, )

ELIZABETH MYER,BETH HUTTON, ) Judge Timothy S. Black 

TERESA THOBABEN, ) Judge Karen Nelson Moore

and CONSTANCE RUBIN, ) Judge Michael H. Watson

) Magistrate Judge Karen L. Litkovitz

Plaintiffs, )

)

v. )

)

RYAN SMITH, Speaker of the Ohio House )

of Representatives, LARRY OBHOF, )

President of the Ohio Senate, and )

JON HUSTED, Secretary of State of Ohio, )

in their official capacities, )

)

Defendants. )

_________________________________________ )

DEFENDANTS’ INITIAL TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

Trial Exhibit # Description Case/Deposition 

Reference

D1 Map of H.B. 369 Plan

D2 Map of H.B 319 Plan

D3 Map of Enacted Congressional Plan Used in 2002 through 

2012 Election Cycles

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 2 of 7 PAGEID #: 7202
2

D4 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2002 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2002-elections-results/

D5 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2004 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2004-elections-results/

D6 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2006 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2006-elections-results/

D7 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2008 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2008-election-results/

D8 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2010 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2010-elections-results/

D9 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2012 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2012-elections-results/

D10 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2014 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2014-elections-results/

D11 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2016 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2016-official-electionsresults/

D12 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for August 

8, 2018 Special Election for Congressional District 12

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2018-official-electionsresults/

D13 Official Secretary of State Election Return Data for 2018 

General Election (Statewide and Congressional Races)

https://www.sos.state.oh.us/ele

ctions/election-results-anddata/2018-official-electionsresults/

D14 9/15/2011 - Ohio House and Senate Session Transcripts 

(Parts 1 & 2) with Errata Sheet

D15 9/21/2011 - Ohio House Session Transcript with Errata 

Sheet

D16 9/21/2011 - Ohio Senate Session Transcript with Errata 

Sheet

D17 11/3/2011 - Ohio House Session Transcript with Errata 

Sheet

D18 12/14/2011 - Ohio House Session Transcript with Errata 

Sheet

D19 12/14/2011 - Ohio Senate Session Transcript with Errata 

Sheet

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 3 of 7 PAGEID #: 7203
3

D20 Expert Report of M.V. Hood, III (11/12/2018) Hood Exhibit 1

D21 Supplemental Expert Report of M.V. Hood III 

(12/28/2018)

D22 Expert Report of Douglas Johnson, Ph.D. (11/10/2018) Johnson Exhibit 1

D23 Resume of Douglas Johnson, Ph.D. Johnson Exhibit 2

D24 Rebuttal Report of Janet R. Thornton, Ph.D. Thornton Exhibit 1

D25

Chart - "District/Plaintiff's Original Districts" Dr. Cho's 3+ 

Million Outcome for Plaintiffs Revised Districts, 

Percentage from 2008-2010 Statewide Elections

Thornton Exhibit 8

D26 Expert Report of Sean Trende (11/12/2018) Trende Exhibit 1

D27 Curriculum Vitae of Sean Trende Trende Exhibit 5

D28 2/12/2018 - E-mail from Brad Wenstrup to Burks, BatesStamped INDPLTS_0015960 Burks Exhibit 2

D29 3/7/2018 - E-mail from Douglas Burks to Rapach, Smith 

and Others, Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0015983 Burks Exhibit 3

D30 3/7/2018 - FCNL memo, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0015984-15985 Burks Exhibit 4

D31 8/23/2018 - E-mail from Douglas Burks to Wenstrup, 

Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0016034 Burks Exhibit 6

D32 2/28/2018 - E-mail from Douglas Burks to Rapach, BatesStamped INDPLTS_0016084 Burks Exhibit 9

D33 5/23/2018 - E-mail from Douglas Burks to Paul Moke, 

Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0016023-16025 Burks Exhibit 11

D34

5/23/2018 - E-mail from Douglas Burks to 

steve@careerfastrack.com, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0016093-16094

Burks Exhibit 12

D35 Address-searchable Google map of Ohio 2012 Plan Dagres Exhibit 2

D36 Address-searchable Google map of Ohio Proposed 

Remedial Plan Dagres Exhibit 4

D37 Comments from Aaron Dagres, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0013073 Dagres Exhibit 6

D38 7/14/2018 - E-Mail from Patrick Barnacle to Aaron 

Dagres, Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0002971-2995 Dagres Exhibit 14

D39

11/17/2016 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to Debbie 

Sneddon and others, Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0018871-

18874

Deitsch Exhibit 2

D40

10/31/2017 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to 

Rep48@ohiohouse.gov and Others, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0024143-24144

Deitsch Exhibit 6

D41

4/29/2018 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to 

newsroom@dailystandard.com, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0021432

Deitsch Exhibit 7

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 4 of 7 PAGEID #: 7204
4

D42

5/25/2018 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to Catherine 

Turcer and others, Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0021536-

21537

Deitsch Exhibit 8

D43

8/31/2018 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to 

mrotondorn@yahoo.com, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0021692

Deitsch Exhibit 10

D44

5/30/2018 - E-mail from Kathy Deitsch to 

adkinsandaffilies@yahoo.com, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0022390-22391

Deitsch Exhibit 12

D45

1/24/2018 - M. Griffiths' Statement to Government 

Oversight and Reform Committee, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0000173

Griffiths Exhibit 4

D46

1/22/2018 - E-Mail from Megan Griffiths to Mark Griffiths 

Re: Draft Version of M. Griffiths' 1/4/2018 Statement to 

Government Oversight and Reform Committee, BatesStamped INDPLTS_0001279-1280

Griffiths Exhibit 5

D47 11/3/2017 - Letter to the Editor - Elyria Chronicle, BatesStamped INDPLTS_0001114 Griffiths Exhibit 6

D48 M. Griffiths' Notes Re: Mileage to representatives, BatesStamped INDPLTS_0000161-162 Griffiths Exhibit 7

D49 Lorain Chronicle Letter to the Editor "Gerrymandering 

Must be Stopped", Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0001116 Griffiths Exhibit 8

D50 Warbaugh Campaign - Tally Sheet- Ohio 7th County 

(Lorain), Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0003100-3103 Griffiths Exhibit 10

D51

5/29/2018 - E-Mail chain from Alison Ricker to Hutton 

regarding the lawsuit, Bates-Stamped INDPLTS_0026808-

26809

Hutton Exhibit 1

D52 Written Statement, Larry Nadler, Bates-Stamped 

INDPLTS_0002909 Nadler Exhibit 1

D53 Notice of 30(b)(6) deposition of League of Women Voters 

of Ohio Miller Exhibit 1

D54 Ohio Redistricting Transparency Report The Elephant in 

the Room, Bates-Stamped LWVOH_00018400-18421 Miller Exhibit 2

D55 Plaintiffs' Privilege Log Miller Exhibit 3

D56 Ohio redistricting reform history, Bates-Stamped 

LWVOH_0074306 Miller Exhibit 4

D57

11/26/2012 - Letter from Dina Schoomaker and Linda 

Slocum to William Batchelder and Vernon Sykes, BatesStamped LWVOH_0022920Miller Exhibit 5

D58 11/25/2014 - Press Release, A. Henkener, C. Turcer, 

Bates-Stamped LWVOH_0086183-86184 Miller Exhibit 6

D59

Plaintiffs' responses and objections to legislative 

defendants' first set of interrogatories and first set of 

requests for production of documents

Miller Exhibit 7

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 5 of 7 PAGEID #: 7205
5

D60 4/30/2015 - E-mail chain from A. Henkener to C. Turcer, 

R. Gunther, Bates-Stamped LWVOH_0050826-50827 Miller Exhibit 8

D61 7/23/2015 - E-mail chain from A. Henkener to C. Davis, 

Bates-Stamped LWVOH_0050401-50404 Miller Exhibit 9

D62 PowerPoint- Ohio Redistricting Competition, BatesStamped LWVOH_0074117-74132 Miller Exhibit 10

D63

Brennan Center for Justice Don't Judge a Book by Its 

Cover Alone document, Bates-Stamped 

LWVOH_0044874-44875

Miller Exhibit 11

D64 Ohio redistricting competition rules and scoring 2011, 

Bates-Stamped LWVOH_0044516-44533 Miller Exhibit 12

D65 Document - Membership Surge Continues Statewide, 

Bates-Stamped LWVOH_0099889-99890 Miller Exhibit 13

D66

Individual independent contractor agreement between 

Ohio Environmental Council Action Fund, Inc. and League 

of Women Voters of Ohio, Bates-Stamped 

LWVOH_0095013-95015

Miller Exhibit 17

D67 Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Ohio State University 

College Democrats Oberdorf Exhibit 1

D68 Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Ohio A. Philip Randolph 

Institute Washington Exhibit 1

D69 11/8/2011 - Election Campaign Report, Bates-Stamped 

OAPRI_0000047 Washington Exhibit 8

D70 APRI Columbus Chapter Monthly Report, Bates-Stamped 

OAPRI_0000049 Washington Exhibit 9

D71 Letter from David Morgan to the APRI State Educational 

Conference, Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000059 Washington Exhibit 10

D72 12/9/2011 - E-mail from Delores Freeman to Andre 

Washington, Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000066 Washington Exhibit 11

D73

Plaintiff Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute's responses and 

objections to legislative defendants' first set of 

interrogatories and first set of requests for production of 

documents

Washington Exhibit 12

D74 12/9/2011 - E-mail from Kimberly Daniels to Andre 

Washington, Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000031 Washington Exhibit 13

D75

Document - The Toledo Federation of Teachers Salutes 

the Ohio A. Philip Randolph Institute, Bates-Stamped 

OAPRI_0000033

Washington Exhibit 14

D76 Letter from Andre Washington to sisters and brothers, 

Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000035-36 Washington Exhibit 15

D77 1/6/2011 - E-mail from Andre Washington to all APRI 

chapters, Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000067-68 Washington Exhibit 16

D78

A Philip Randolph Institute - People Get Ready: 2012 Is 

Coming, Our One Year Plan, Bates-Stamped 

OAPRI_0000128

Washington Exhibit 17

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 6 of 7 PAGEID #: 7206
6

D79 Document - Youngstown APRI chapter, Bates-Stamped 

OAPRI_0000135 Washington Exhibit 18

D80 Ohio Unity 2018 black voter empowerment campaign, 

Bates-Stamped OAPRI_0000145 Washington Exhibit 19

37090082.1

Case: 1:18-cv-00357-TSB-KNM-MHW Doc #: 157-8 Filed: 01/18/19 Page: 7 of 7 PAGEID #: 7207