UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

EASTERN DIVISION

BRENT RUSSCHER, 

JAMIE RUSSCHER, and 

HOLLAND COMMUNITY

HOSPITAL, a non-profit

organization, Civil Action No.: 2:17-cv-1085

Plaintiffs, HON. GEORGE C. SMITH

v. MAGISTRATE JUDGE:

ELIZABETH P. DEAVERS

OUTDOOR UNDERWRITERS, INC, a

foreign corporation,

CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT 

LLOYD'S, OF LONDON subscribing to 

policy 02HU11B0050, and

CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT 

LLOYD'S, OF LONDON subscribing to 

policy 02HU11B0068

Defendants.

Drew R. Massé (#0006665)

GALLON, TAKACS, BOISSONEAULT

& SCHAFFER CO., L.P.A.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

3516 Granite Circle

Toledo, OH 43617

(419) 843-2001

piattys@gallonlaw.com

Carole D. Bos (P33638)

Bradley K. Glazier (P35523)

BOS & GLAZIER, P.L.C.

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

990 Monroe Avenue N.W.

Grand Rapids, MI 49503

(616) 458-6814

cbos@bosglazier.com

bglazier@bosglazier.com

Jonathon L. Beck (#0076709)

Christine N. Farmer (#0093824)

YOUNG & ALEXANDER CO., L.P.A.

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Holland CommunityHospital

130 W. Second Street, Ste. 1500

Dayton, OH 45402

(937) 224-9291

jbeck@yandalaw.com

David J. Fagnilli (#0032930)

MARSHALL DENNEHEY WARNER 

COLEMAN & GOGGIN

Attorneys for Defendant

600 Superior Avenue, Ste. 1200

Cleveland, OH 44114

(216) 348-1700

ejfagnilli@mdwcg.com

PLAINTIFFS’ FIRST AMENDED SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT 

FOLLOWING JUDGMENT

00136905.WPD

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 1 of 11 PAGEID #: 304
Plaintiffs and judgment creditors,Brent Russcher and Jamie Russcher, and Holland

Community Hospital, by their attorneys, and pursuant to Ohio Revised Code § 3929.06,

state the following as their Supplemental Complaint following Judgment against defendants

Mark Thompson, et al., the insureds of defendant, Outdoor Underwriters, Inc, Certain

Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0050 and Certain

Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0068:

JURISDICTION AND VENUE

1. This is an action brought forthe injuries sustained by plaintiff Brent Russcher,

in a serious fall from a tree stand that occurred in Vinton County, Ohio.

2. In addition to the provisions of Ohio Revised Code § 3929.06, this Court

has jurisdiction pursuant to the diversity of citizenship statute, 28 U.S.C. §1332. 

Plaintiffs Brent Russcher and Jamie Russcher are citizens of the State of Michigan. 

Plaintiff Holland Community Hospital (“Holland Hospital”) is a Michigan non-profit

organization with its principal placeof business located in Holland, Michigan. Defendant

Outdoor Underwriters, Inc. (“Outdoor Underwriters”) is a corporation engaged in the

insurance business, and was, at all relevant times, licensed to conduct insurance business

in Ohio. Outdoor Underwriters has its principal place of business at 140 Stoneridge Drive,

Suite 230, Columbia, South Carolina. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London

subscribing to policy 02HU11B0050 and Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London

subscribing to policy 02HU11B0068 are, upon information and belief, British citizens that

have consented to service in the state of New York and are not citizens of the State of

Michigan.

00136905.WPD 2

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 2 of 11 PAGEID #: 305
3. This Court also has jurisdiction pursuant to the supplemental jurisdiction

statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1367, because all claims in this action are so related to claims in the

Civil Action No.: 2:14-cv-00002 that they form part of the same case or controversy under

Article III of the United States Constitution.

4. The amount in controversy exceeds this Court’s diversity jurisdictional

limit of Seventy-Five Thousand Dollars ($75,000), exclusive of interest and costs.

General Allegations

5. Plaintiffs Brent Russcher and Jamie Russcher are husband and wife and

reside in Hamilton, Michigan. The Russchers were plaintiffs in the matter of Brent

Russcher, et al. v. Mark Thompson, et al., Civil Action 2:14-cv-00002, that was filed in the

United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio (“Russcher Action”). 

6. Plaintiff Holland Community Hospital (“Holland Hospital”) is a non-profit

organization located in Holland, Michigan. Holland Hospital was a cross-claimant in the

Russcher Action. 

7. The plaintiffs sought and received a judgment against Mark Thompson in the

above-referenced Russcher action on November 13, 2017. (ECF #107). The judgment

followed an order issued by the Court on November 8, 2017 (ECF #106), awarding Brent

Russcherthe sum of $1,708,300.19 in compensatory economic damages and $350,000.00

in compensatory non-economic damages. The Court further awarded Jamie Russcher

$150,000.00 in compensatory non-economic damages and awarded Holland Hospital the

sum of $135,740.32 on its subrogation claim. (Id., PageID.1697). 

00136905.WPD 3

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 3 of 11 PAGEID #: 306
8. Mark Thompson, at all times pertinent to this complaint, resided at and

operated a hunting club business at 27684 State Route 328, New Plymouth, Ohio, 49654. 

9. Mark Thompson was the owner and operator of a sole proprietorship

business that was known as and did business as both Ohio Whitetail Adventures and Mark

and Tommy Hunt Club.

10. Mark Thompson leased 289.77 acres of land for hunting from Scioto Land

Company, LLC, through a “Hunting Licence” for the period beginning on July 1, 2011 and

ending on June 30, 2012. (Exhibit 1, p. 1 to Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Complaint).1

11. As a licensee, Mark Thompson, along with his “agents, servants, employees,

members and guests” were granted the right to hunt and fish on the leased property. 

12. Scioto Land Company, LLC was required, at the cost and expense of Mark

Thompson, to “maintain a liability insurance policy specifically applicable to the Premises

insuring Licensor and Licensee as their respective interest may appear.” (Exhibit 1, ¶ 7). 

The policy or policies were to “contain limits of no less than One Million Dollars

($1,000,000.00) for bodily injury and/or property damage per occurrence.” 

13. Defendants insured “Quality Deer Management Association Landowner and

Hunt Clubs” (“Quality Deer Management”) and Mark Thompson under a comprehensive

general liability policy of insurance (Policy No. 02HU11B0050), that included endorsements

for “Owners’, Landlord’ and Tenants’ Liability Insurance” for the period beginning on

December 9, 2011 and ending August 1, 2012. (Exhibit 2, p. 00052, 00057). 

1

All of the exhibits referenced in this First Amended Supplemental Complaint

were attached to plaintiff’s original complaint. Duplicate copies are not attached to this

complaint.

00136905.WPD 4

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 4 of 11 PAGEID #: 307
14. Thompson and Ohio White Tail Adventures were both identified as an

insured “hunt club” under the Quality Deer Management policy. (Exhibit 2, p. 00052).

15. The policy provided One Million Dollars ($1,000,000.00) in liability coverage

for a bodily injury that occurred on the property leased by Scioto Land Company, LLC to

Mark Thompson. (Exhibit 2, p. 00052, 00058). 

16. On January 12, 2012, during the period of coverage provided by the Quality

Deer Management policy, plaintiff Brent Russcher was severely injured when he fell from

a tree stand. At the time of injuries, Brent Russcher was a “member” or “guest” of Mark

Thompson and was hunting with Thompson’s permission on property located in Vinton

County, Ohio which had been leased by Scioto Land Company, LLC to Thompson. The

property is identified in Exhibit A to the Hunting License issued to Mark Thompson by the

Scioto Land Company, LLC. (Exhibit 1, Exhibit A). 

17. As further described in the First Amended Complaint filed against Mark

Thompson in this action, Thompson failed to install basic safety equipment for users of the

tree stand. (First Amended Complaint, ECF #35, ¶ 13-15). 

18. The Quality Deer Management policy required defendants to defend Mark

Thompson in any lawsuit related to an occurrence of a bodily injury on the property leased

by Scioto Land Company, LLC. The Quality Deer Management policy also required

defendants to indemnify Mark Thompson for any liability he incurred due to a bodily injury

that occurred at the leased property. (Exhibit 2, p. 00058). 

19. Defendants also insured RMK Timberlands Group (“RMK”) under a different

comprehensive general liability policy of insurance (Policy No. 02HU11B0068) (Exhibit 3). 

The policy period ran from July 1, 2011 to July 1, 2012. (Id.). 

00136905.WPD 5

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 5 of 11 PAGEID #: 308
20. The RMK policy was amended to include, as a named insured, “Scioto Land

Company and Mid Continent Timberland Fund ... as Licensor and its Hunting Clubs as

Licensees.” (Exhibit 3, p. 6). The policy provided an additional One Million Dollars

($1,000,000.00) in coverage per occurrence for bodily injuries on the property leased by

Scioto Land Company, LLC to Mark Thompson. 

21. On December 16, 2011, Mark Thompson received a “letter as receipt for [his]

2011 hunting license payment” and a copy of a “2011-2012 Executed Hunting License for

Scioto Land Company, LLC Tract #10890, along with [his] insurance card with policy

number and contact information. (Exhibit 4).

22. On January 12, 2011. Brent Russcher suffered a spinal fracture that required

intensive surgery and the fusion of five vertebrae, T-7 through T-11, while hunting on land

leased by Thompson.

23. Brent Russcher’s January 12, 2012 injuries described above triggered

coverage under both of the hunt club polices referenced above. 

24. Thompson notified Outdoor Underwriters of Brent Russcher’s injuries and

that the injuries occurred on the property Thompson leased from Scioto Land Company,

LLC and used as part of his hunting club. 

25. Russcher’s counsel also notified Attorney Jeffrey Griffith, who represented

Mark Thompson, of the claim.

26. Griffith provided notice of the claim to Barbara Barrett at CJW & Associates,

a claim management company that represented Outdoor Underwriters. 

27. On or about September 11, 2013, Barrett acknowledged receiving notice of

the Russcher claim on August 27, 2013. (Exhibit 5).

00136905.WPD 6

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 6 of 11 PAGEID #: 309
28. On October 28, 2013, Barrett sent correspondence to plaintiffs’ counsel

falsely asserting that the injury did not occur on land covered by Thompson’s policy.

(Exhibit 6).

29. Barrett did acknowledge that the injury occurred “on land owned by Scioto

Land Company and leased through F&W Forestry Services to Mark Thompson.” (Id.). But

Barrett inexplicably asserted “there is no coverage for Mark Thompson/Ohio Whitetail.”

(Exhibit 7). 

30. On January 3, 2014, plaintiffs filed their Complaint for damages against Mark

Thompson in the United States District Court, Southern District of Ohio, Eastern Division. 

(ECF #1).

31. The complaint alleged negligence and gross negligence on the part of Mark

Thompson and his hunt club business. 

32. Jamie Russcher, Brent Russcher’s wife, also brought a claim for loss of

consortium in connection with her husband’s injuries.

33. Defendants ignored the complaint filed by plaintiffs and thereby breached

their contractual obligation to provide a defense to Mark Thompson for the claims raised

in Russchers’ complaint. 

34. Instead of defending the claims raised against Thompson, with or without a

reservation of rights, defendants attempted to avoid their defense and indemnity

obligations through acts that are unlawful under Ohio law. 

35. On or about February 26, 2014, without notice to the Russchers or their

counsel, Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0050

and Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0068

00136905.WPD 7

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 7 of 11 PAGEID #: 310
presented a document titled “Policy Release” to Mark Thompson. (Exhibit 8). The Policy

Release sent by these defendants purports to “compromise any and all issues relating to

coverage under Policy 1 and Policy 2 for the claims asserted against Ohio Whitetail in the

[Russcher] lawsuit.” (Id., p. 2). In exchange for a payment of $10,000 to Thompson, the

Policy Release attempts to extinguish the Russchers’ rights to collect against Certain

Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0050 and Certain

Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0068 under the policies

they issued to Thompson. (Id.). 

36. On May 8, 2014, Mark Thompson filed a bankruptcy petition.

37. On September 19, 2014, the Court issued an Order lifting the bankruptcy

stay, and allowing this action to proceed against Thompson for any insurance that may

provide coverage. (ECF #22).

38. On December 30, 2015, Mark Thompson stipulated to his liability for the

injuries of Brent and Jamie Russcher. (ECF #73).

39. This Court ordered briefing on the issue of damages following Thompson’s

stipulation to liability. (ECF #90).

40. On November 8, 2017, this Court issued an order finding in favor of Brent

Russcher and Jamie Russcher, and against Mark Thompson, et al., pursuant to the

stipulation of liability, and awarded the sum of $2,334,040.51 to the Russcher plaintiffs,

plus post-judgment interest. (ECF #106). The order includes damages in the amount of

$135,740.32, plus post-judgment interest, to plaintiff Holland Hospital. (Id.). 

41. On November 13, 2017, the Court entered a Judgment on the November 8,

2017 Order. At least 30 days have passed since the entry of the Judgment. During this

00136905.WPD 8

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 8 of 11 PAGEID #: 311
30-day period, defendants have “not paid the [Russchers or Holland Hospital] an amount

equal to the remaining limit of liability coverage provided in [its] policy [of insurance with

Thompson].” See, Ohio Rev. Code § 3929.06(A)(2). 

42. The Policy Release attached as Exhibit 8 and executed by Thompson for the

benefit of defendants is invalid and unenforceable as a matter of Ohio law. See, Ohio Rev.

Code § 3929.05 (“No such contract of insurance shall be canceled or annulled by any

agreement between the insurance company and the assured after said assured has

become responsible for such loss, damage, or death, and any such cancellation or

annulment is void.”) See also, McPhillips v. Travelers Indemn. Co., 2009 Ohio 1262, 2009

WL 713021, ¶ 19-22 (March 19, 2009)(Exhibit 9)(“Where a third party sustains bodily injury

or death in an accident caused by the insured, it has been recognized that the rights of the

injured party arise immediately upon the happening of the accident and that the injured

party's rights cannot be destroyed by an attempted subsequent cancellation, release, or

compromise by the insured and insurer.”). 

COUNT I

Judgment Creditor Relief Pursuant to O.R.C. 3929.06

43. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference paragraphs 1 through 42 as fully set forth

herein.

44. Defendants provided liability coverage to Mark Thompson for the action filed

against him by plaintiffs Brent and Jamie Russcher which included the obligation to

indemnify Mark Thompson for any judgment or order for compensation issued by this

Court. 

00136905.WPD 9

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 9 of 11 PAGEID #: 312
45. The two policies of insurance issued by defendants provided a total of Two

Million Dollars ($2,000,000.00) of liability coverage to Mark Thompson. 

46. This Court issued a judgment in favor of the plaintiffs Brent and Jamie

Russcher and against Mark Thompson in the total amount of $2,334,040.51, of which the

sum of $135,740.32 is payable to plaintiff Holland Hospital. 

47. Defendants have failed to pay the plaintiffs the sum of $2,000,000.00, which

is that portion of the Judgment that is within the policy limits of the two policies of insurance

issued to Mark Thompson by defendants.

48. Pursuant Ohio Rev. Code § 3929.06, plaintiffs file this direct action as

judgment creditors of Mark Thompson seeking recovery of that portion of the judgment

($2,000,000) covered by insurance provided to Mark Thompson by defendants. 

49. Defendants have not paid the plaintiffs the amount of the insurance coverage

or any amount within thirty days after the entry of the November 13, 2017 Judgment. 

50. Plaintiffs’ action is, therefore, timely as provided in Oho Rev. Code §

3929.06(A)(2). 

WHEREFORE, plaintiffs respectfully request that this court enter a judgment in their

favor against defendants Outdoor Underwriters, Inc., Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of

London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0050, and Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s, of

London subscribing to policy 02HU11B0068, in an amount equal to $2,000,000, and award

such other relief which the court deems reasonable and appropriate, including postjudgment interest and attorney fees.

00136905.WPD 10

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 10 of 11 PAGEID #: 313
GALLON, TAKACS, BOISSONEAULT &

SCHAFFER CO., L.P.A.

Attorneys for Russcher Plaintiffs

Date: June 4, 2018 By: /s/ Drew R. Masse 

Drew R. Masse (#0006665)

BUSINESS ADDRESS:

3516 Granite Circle

Toledo, OH 43617

(419) 843-2001

BOS & GLAZIER, P.L.C.

Attorneys for Russcher Plaintiffs

Date: June 4, 2018 By: /s/ Bradley K. Glazier 

Carole D. Bos (P33638)

Bradley K. Glazier (P35523)

BUSINESS ADDRESS:

990 Monroe Avenue N.W.

Grand Rapids, MI 49503

(616) 458-6814

YOUNG & ALEXANDER CO., L.P.A.

Attorneys for Plaintiff Holland 

Community Hospital

Date: June 4, 2018 By: /s/ Jonathon L. Beck 

Jonathon L. Beck (#0076709)

Christine N. Farmer (#0093824)

BUSINESS ADDRESS:

130 W. Second St.

Suite 1500

Dayton, OH 45402

(937) 224-9291 

00136905.WPD 11

Case: 2:17-cv-01085-GCS-EPD Doc #: 26 Filed: 06/04/18 Page: 11 of 11 PAGEID #: 314