!"#   $# " %# & %$'   # (" %" $("&&# $# ("'# &&&#&$"##'")"#"("'#'") "# *% % #") ' $+("&&#,'$("###&("'#!"#()%#$##(-!)%'$%#+(.$"''$("(!()(#&$''"/0%"#$##*"#'$("%(!()(###")1(#(!(""#&"2!"#%#""####'$##
&%"$$("&&#("'%"")&%#'")"#"$"&' % '$%# +( .$"',# (-" & %(!()(#$'""#%"2&'%(#+("&&#("'%"%$'#&'%(!()(#*#'")")*")"$"&'%("%"("((()#'")#$##34%# '#"#  $# 



	1 561 71%68 "
  5  71%  8 "# *(( "# %$',######%'"/)$(" 4"!()  % (# %" $("&&# %"4 #"#& % 9'#  #%* "$$("!() & %4("#:$




7KH +RQRUDEOH 'DYLG ' 'RZG -U 

WKH 1RUWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ 



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	
	
	

50; <0;

>>>>>>>>>>>>

+$521 ? 2;"(

			




,7< 2) (03+,6"(

		



$$"(&'%=

&%?#.#&0

AA6B'0


C$'!

."5(C

D&C3=E"

.#







  4 3!# D; .'$%#0##D  5.G ;
 
	


	
 	



$$((#     4 3!# D
0
3 D G ; . '$%# 0## &
$$(("##+D ")("25.G;
 '$%#0##&
$$((#

.?..(4%$&%*%%

3=E/7$8(4"#$""$







.?..#



0%##""$$"(&'%#,##'##"(&%

$("&&#"$$(("#,'$("""#&"#"$$((#%)&'$%# "?"(?&) .&%'$%# +( .$"' 7H+.I8  0% '$(""(( %" % ) & '$%# %" "  ""(#'" *% #$  " &&# #2$'  % +.  "% $("&& # " *% &'"(%(%"2&("%+.4'!1	%+.!""(4$##&$'%"2&'"/
((&%$("&&#$"$"%(4$## *%% 4(4 :"'"# " 4"#"####'#   ")  1 % +. $!(#% " &'" D(( (# % (!( ""# &$'&"2!"#$%#""####'#(#(4&%1""#**'&%(4*'&4**%"#:*!("2

0% D(( #" %" % $'"( (# *( !

&&4&*)"#0%&#""#"2( &4 &% #:!("2 &'"(# *$''"/")6A1%"*)"#("  % +. '" # # " ("#  &

	
 	

$'#$%"((#$("&&#"

%(!()(#"#%)*(!%

0%!(4#%*4%

 *(( ! %  $'#'") "2 #  $'  % #%( ! "#$""&'%"("&*("((*'$()#H#%"$'*(#$" (!() # *( ("!4"'()"'$##*(##"(()'"$*%%"#*"#($%"&&("#'"'"2$'$()#2*&"((#'")"#!&"&"($'" "((() #'") "#'") " 4 *% H"$(I""4#' 56 " A	F  $&'

56J7
%


"#%"&#'"

#9%"#%'0%&"%""$"("&&'#%"#%"""#"



5%"###&%"!4

#'##%$("&&#,'$("
A 	


	
 	


*%%%"H$("&&#"((%"*"2*(%"4 &((* ")% ! " "( #'")$%&'%(#I1

5"A6!	"#	
	(!'
56AJ
A	7
%
8F%
')			%*	 +,+ 
J 5$$ 	1 1A 7.  
87 "#  #  "$$() !"# # &&""(() "( $() # '()  && & $"##'")"#8

4%"'$"$()#"#%"

#(""#"$'#&'"9#"!((#"#""5#"#'#"2"H:$# '$()#  " 4"(() $ $ &("!()I-

			&A	5		6J7	%180"((*'$()#%"(("(!()#%'##*(!" #!#""( ") & '$()# *% %"4 '"2'$"#"&&##!"#$%(#0%## " '$" #" 4 %" '") ## "  ! # & #4"( )"# "& %) "$'("
 '#
	5"67#'#

#"#&('"#H"(()I8;&#" % $("&&# * $("  " "((()#'")(#")1F!%)&(%"#(4'!;$("&&#,#(%"4!!%""'%"('""#"#(&% (") % $"( (" *( %"4 "(( 9#""-""(#%"%"!$("&*)"#




(%%"&#!(#%%#"#&"((##9"()*%$

"#("*"#%""!'"#%"%"((#'"%$#"##($("&&#,:(# &' % (# & (!( ""# ! '()"&&% "2 %" (#  0%"# 4 "&%"(( #'" % $("&&# * #(( $"($'#"(%(%%$%"%)*(!

	
 	



7KH SDUWLHV GR QRW H[SODLQ ZK\ WK

RFFXUUHG DIWHU WKH DSSDUHQW H[SLUDWLRQ GSRLQW LV QRW LPSRUWDQW WR WKLV DSSHDO$'#&'%(!()(#

*#(%%&#

0%"&$("&&#%"?

D"+"$(#"+""+% 9"( '$()' $$4'!	+("&&"("   4'!   $("&&#,%"#B"((&*%%%'%#"&$'("&% &(% %" *% %'$("&&# 4"& %'$("&"(


%'$("'

&%+.(&"0%'$(""((#%"%#$## "# *(( "#%# *%#$#!()   % ##'" ""# *% &'$##0%'$("#$&"%$&'$()#"%'"#*#9##%"% % # " !) 4 %'$$##

+("&&# &( %# 4( 

#'"  J = K6"0##KJ&"#&("'#"&('"##&("'"'%'%%""%$'#"#$"""&#'"!%'#")A%"&"('()&(%
J 	


	
 	


,I D FKDUJH LV SXUVXHG ZLWK WKH HTXLYDOHQW VWDWH DJHQF\ D SODLQWLII

KDV  GD\V LQ ZKLFK WR EULQJ D FKDUJH ZLWK WKH ((2&  86& HH 7KLV H[WHQGHG ILOLQJ SURYLVLRQ GRHV QRW DIIHFW WKH

SUHVHQW FDVH H[FHSW WKDW FHUWDLQ SUHFHGHQWV GLVFXVV D  GD\ UXOH

$OWKRXJK WKH 3GLVFULPLQDWRU\ DFW ́ LQ WKLV FDVH PD\ EH WKH FRDFKLQJ

RI SUHIHUUHG HPSOR\HHV WKH SDUWLHV DQG PRVW RI WKH FDVH ODZ DSSDUHQWO\ILQG LW PRUH FRQYHQLHQW WR LGHQWLI\ WKH SURPXOJDWLRQ RI DQ HOLJLELOLW\ URVWHUDV WKH LQLWLDO GLVFULPLQDWRU\ DFW

$SSHOODQWV DSSDUHQWO\ FRQFHGH WKDW D UXOLQJ RQ 3FRQWLQXLQJ DFWV ́

XQGHU  HH LV GLVSRVLWLYH RQ ZKHWKHU SODLQWLIIV ILOHG WLPHO\XQGHU  86&   DQG 7HQQHVVHH &RGH  D

%& (  $  0% #  /'")"$("&&#'()&("&
$$"(



 4&"#'")"0(L 

&%4(%#
&1JJ=KKAAA#9" $("&& '#'() &( " %" *%%   !

.
/156JJJ1 71%J8 
 %"&#'"'#! &( *%%*%A")#"&%"((("*&('$()'$"J=KAAA	78780%#"((  #'" "## # %" %# ' & &( #H " % ' % "(( #'") "I
5171%879'#
#-
	56	6
6

71%  88  0% $"# #'  " %" %H#'") "I  %# "#  *% %$'("&%(!()(#")10%$"# && %*4  *%% %  &H"#I*%%"#""*:$%#"( ( !# % $("&&#, '$(" *% %('"#$

	
 	

2*%*"#!$$*
	#	A567#"   %" % "$$(#*%%#4&$"H#%"#%#&#'$()'##I8

0%#!(4#%!4

% &'""((()"$H "I ! # '()#'" #"%$&%""$"($("&&#"*"# (2()  $(") " $4"( ( ;%$'("&""((4 %" HM#%(    "(N O $%#%#,I	
	71%  8 7" '"#%#"#*"#!$##&*)"#"&#$'M%&$'"%"#%"*"##&")"##%#56"
	7"'8

  " % &" %" % 

"(#&""%"%%""('""&%(#*"#% (#"("$("&&#%$'#"2&'%(!()(%'$("&%$(")"(
8*%%$("&&#"(("'#)#'*"#%("'%"%#&%#)#'4("  0%  #"%" ''!#"''!#%"#!$""(()I"%"H$(" *% %)(" &%''!#I  '
 " 1
   0%

(!()(# "(#&(%
 	


	
 	


$V WR WKH SODLQWLIIV ZKR KDG SDVVHG WKH H[DPLQDWLRQ DQG PDGH WKH

OLVW WKH FRXUW GLVPLVVHG WKHLU FKDUJHV EHFDXVH WKH FRPSODLQW KDG EHHQILOHG RYHU RQH DQG D KDOI \HDUV DIWHU H[SLUDWLRQ RI WKH OLVW  )G DW



$'#%$("&&#*"#"4("!"# % "( & $'# *"# " #$"" "4"!(#9&%&"%"$("&&#*%%(#'
 "A6J0%0% "$$( !	"
234

	!1A5		768*%*#)&&%#%"((%4"()&"4(#4:"'"%"*"###"!(#%% "2&"$'# #0%""%(%"%#"&('"#!"%")%#*"#$'(""("#"#%#$("&&#*%%"'"%(#'
"	

 "#%0%%"#

% &' " "((() " # "# " " &#'" # &' % "( "# &#'" 5#)236
	

	!)
23616656 7  A8 $("&&# "(( %" % * E2+( .$"',# 4( #4 :"'# "'# 1
A*#'")0%9#5#*"#*%%%&"%"''")#'")"#"&
%)"*%%0(L *"#'""$$("!('$"(#'
"J
0%$%(%# ,# %( %" H% $"',# (" (!() (## &( $&'"  #'"):"'"##"$"'&#'")%*%%'"()*%%("#$#*"#%&&%(##B%"#!&
JI'
"J
J0%/ % 4* %" % $"4 4  % %$*"#%$'("&%(!()(##"%"%$"',#&#"(#%*'()&&#&"(#'")'
"J	F	"

236156J6J787)&(%"#''((!()(#:$!"#*"#"%"$%"%$("&&H#%(%"4

	
 	



7KH DSSHOODQWV DOVR DSSHDU WR FRQF

FRQWLQXLQJ DFWV ZKLFK DULVHV ZKHQ GHPRQVWUDEOH SROLF\ RI GLVFULPLQDWLRQ VHQRW DSSO\ WR WKLV FDVH

0%"*"#&H

&# # '"  %# "$$"("#"##*%%##&#'")"#! 

51
1

71%8 "#'")!%"((%#'") "# &"((# *%%;*4""(#%# %" % ('"# $ !#'")"#%'#(4#" &&# & $"# #'5"17	3!	A	7A8"(			
7

88

+("&&#  %" &"

#'")""%'%)!"##&%"((()&("*(%"H"%'$'#"!4"("%"#'" % #'"2 $## '*%%$'##%$(" " *%% % (# #(( $##I%%%"%$'# "   %'#(
  &"# % ##"%"H%""($'##"&&&%"



0%:%%"#$

&'""((()"(!("#;*4%"" &**%(  ()  $ #
1 	


	
 	


	3!		&
JJ=	A7A8%$("&&*"#"!"$&##*%("'#'"%!"##&%#""(2#*"#&"%!&%#%()"%"%*(4
# # #"(() % $" % 4#) && %' "H'"("I%""((*%'"% &)"!&%*"#("#'
"		62#"%"%

'&&(%#%"''*%%*"#'""*%%*"#

0%  #" & %" H'" &

'$()'".("*""#"(")!4"!(#9&%"(&I'
 "	
	0%

  %" % $$ &# # $ % ' & %#'") "#  $ % ' " *%% %#9#&%"#!"''#$"&('
"	

0%"%"HNO%'$%"###$%&&#&"('$()'##F"%#$*%%")$#4(":##I'
7J6="		8


%$$'"##(	


J6=		67

8*%%"&(%""*"#!"##%4("%'$"),#$()""#'$()'"&(%""#
(" & % '"" $()  ! (("( " =
(##F!%$("&&%"!"$") % "( "# " %"  &(  %"#%"(( % & #"  '
 " 		J		  4'! 1 = $4 &% #"' &"&(%""#*%%"!'"$#"#'""(0%$("&&*"##"*%%%#!*"#%
"#"*'$()*%%$4##)#"#'
"			%#("'%"% &"( #"*"#"H"I!"#H%#)#)#'4#$#&&%$"#(("("" %& $$"# % #9# & &!#'"I'
"		


	
 	



7KH VSHFLILF KROGLQJ LQ /RUDQFH ZD

6HH  86&  HH

0%/%""'

#)#)#'%"#"'" & !&# H% "($#4(":##I'
"		$#4("%'#"(#$"I!"#%"#'"#""#&'"# &' '$()##%""#&&()&'%#*%


%(4"$'

7	&'
JA=AA7%(%""("'&#'"#)#)#'!#"#)#)#' *#"#

% # #  #'"!*%%$"&" $&"$"*%%"#%#"# &""(() "( #'$() #'"  *%% "# 4("



	1567"'8

()"%"&(&(*#%"

&"(!()(##0%0%"##%(%"%"($'###%""#!#9$'##%"(#""
234

	!8$("&&#%"&"("4(!) % ) & *"2  '$(&�%%(%"