# MEMORANDUM

TO: Steam Electric Rulemaking Record

FROM: Danielle Lewis, ERG

DATE: 30 September 2015

SUBJECT: Steam Electric Pollutant-Level Loadings and Removals for Each

Wastestream and Regulatory Option

ERG is providing technical support to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Office of

Water, Engineering and Analysis Division (E AD) for development of effluent limitations

guidelines and standards (ELGs) for the Steam Electric Power Generating Industry. EPA, with

the support of ERG, evaluated wastewater flow rates and pollutant con centration data from

survey responses, site visits, sampling episodes, trade associations, individual power plants,

states, previous rulemakings, a nd industry-submitted data provide d in comments to the proposed

ELG to estimate pollutant discharge loadings as sociated with the discha rge of FGD wastewater,

fly ash transport water, bottom ash transpor t water, and combustion residual leachate. 1 

# In

addition, EPA estimated the corresponding polluta nt removals associated with installing and

operating the BAT technology options evaluated as part of the final ELGs for each of these

wastestreams. ERG developed a computerized load ings model to calculate plant- and pollutantspecific pollutant discharge loadings for power plants reported to be discharging these

wastestreams.

The industry-level baseline loadings and rem ovals for each wastestream and regulatory option

are presented in both the Technical Development Document for the Effluent Limitations

Guidelines and Standards for the Steam El ectric Power Generating Point Source Category

(DCN SE05904) and the Incremental Costs and Pollutant Removals for the Final Effluent

Limitations Guidelines and Standards for th e Steam Electric Power Generating Point Source

Category (DCN SE05831). However, those reports do not present the pollutant-level loadings for

each wastestream and regulatory option. This me morandum presents the pollutant-level baseline

loadings for each wastestream, as well as the pol lutant-level removals achieved under Regulatory

Options A, B, C, D, and E. 2

1 

# All currently operating gasification generation units use evaporation treatment system s and all plants currently

generating FGMC wastes operates such that there is no pollutant discharge to surface waters. Therefore, EPA

determined that the gasification wast ewater and FGMC wastewater baselin e loadings are equal to the postcompliance loadings.

2 

# During development of the final rule, EPA decided not to base the final rule on Option F for existing sources due

primarily to the high cost of that Option, particularly in light of the costs associated with other rulemakings expected

to impact the steam electric industry (see Section VIII.C.1 of the preamble). As a result, EPA chose not to conduct

particular analyses for Option F to the same extent that it did for some of the other options considered.

# Memorandum

September 30, 2015

Page 2

As discussed in both the Technical Development Document for the Effluent Limitations

Guidelines and Standards for the Steam El ectric Power Generating Point Source Category

(DCN SE05904) and the Incremental Costs and Pollutant Removals for the Final Effluent

Limitations Guidelines and Standards for th e Steam Electric Power Generating Point Source

Category (DCN SE05831), EPA estimated pollutant loadi ngs several different ways to evaluate

the effect of the final ELG on the steam electri c industry. EPA considered other rulemakings

affecting the steam electric industr y in its analysis. Under one a pproach, EPA evaluated pollutant

loadings taking into account cha nges that plants may make to implement the coal combustion

residuals (CCR) rule (but not the Clean Powe r Plan (CPP)). Under a second approach, EPA

evaluated compliance costs and pol lutant loadings taking into acc ount changes that plants may

make to implement both the CCR rule and the CPP. 3 

# The following tables present the pollutantlevel results from the loadings analysis:

 Table 1: Industry-level ba seline loadings by pollutant for all four wastestreams

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 2: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option A

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 3: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option B

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 4: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option C

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 5: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option D

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 6: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option E

accounting for CCR and CPP;

 Table 7: Industry-level ba seline loadings by pollutant for all four wastestreams

accounting for CCR;

 Table 8: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option A

accounting for CCR;

 Table 9: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achie ved under Regulatory Option B

accounting for CCR;

 Table 10: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achi eved under Regulatory Option C

accounting for CCR;

 Table 11: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achi eved under Regulatory Option D

accounting for CCR; and

 Table 12: Industry-level pollu tant-specific removals achi eved under Regulatory Option E

accounting for CCR.

3 

# At the time it conducted th ese analyses, the CPP had not yet been fina lized, and thus EPA used the proposed CPP

for its analyses.MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 3Table 1. Industry-Level Baseline Loadings by Pollutantfor all Four Wastestreams Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEAluminum 118,841 7,688 360,548 23,324 524,108 33,905 69,150 4,473 1,072,647 69,391Ammonia as N 692,043 934 0 0 0 0 0 0 692,043 934Antimony 887 11 3,783 46 12,012 147 90 1 16,772 205Arsenic 668 2,317 11,095 38,491 7,483 25,960 892 3,096 20,138 69,865Barium 22,633 45 36,928 74 50,428 100 1,279 3 111,268 222Beryllium 164 173 898 949 32 34 0 0 1,094 1,156Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 690,857 0 136,444 0 0 0 827,301 0Boron 22,975,239 191,652 794,049 6,624 277,883 2,318 539,194 4,498 24,586,365 205,091Bromide 0 0 0 0 252,780 0 0 0 252,780 0Cadmium 6,331 144,084 790 17,976 931 21,177 238 5,406 8,289 188,642Calcium 195,056,965 5,462 17,536,777 491 31,519,935 883 9,805,566 275 253,919,243 7,110Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,849,059 0 9,254,128 0 0 0 13,103,187 0Chloride 696,822,067 16,966 3,386,141 82 11,953,111 291 9,929,281 242 722,090,599 17,581Chromium 1,254 95 5,277 399 2,902 220 48,842 3,697 58,275 4,411Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 20 10 0 0 119 61Cobalt 10,406 1,189 1,319 151 6,092 696 901 103 18,717 2,139Copper 1,352 843 8,237 5,135 6,589 4,108 178 111 16,356 10,198Cyanide, Total 93,709 104,666 782 873 154 172 0 0 94,645 105,711Fluoride 0 0 117,184 4,101 19,005 665 0 0 136,189 4,767Iron 87,537 490 144,003 806 608,737 3,409 856,440 4,796 1,696,718 9,502Lead 402 900 2,153 4,823 5,119 11,467 0 0 7,674 17,190Magnesium 330,228,328 285,824 3,294,582 2,852 14,531,764 12,578 2,833,074 2,452 350,887,748 303,705Manganese 5,646,388 579,696 20,894 2,145 586,513 60,215 65,351 6,709 6,319,145 648,766Mercury 431 47,395 209 22,966 328 36,090 25 2,707 992 109,157Molybdenum 12,260 2,470 57,710 11,625 16,253 3,274 31,947 6,435 118,171 23,804Nickel 48,396 5,271 4,877 531 7,580 826 1,079 118 61,933 6,745Nitrate Nitrite as N 9,095,156 29,104 557,144 1,783 2,539,834 8,127 0 0 12,192,134 39,015Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 442,300 0 500,363 0 0 0 942,663 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 4Table 1. Industry-Level Baseline Loadings by Pollutantfor all Four Wastestreams Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPhosphorus, Total 31,259 0 34,433 0 88,827 0 0 0 154,519 0Potassium 0 0 2,545,423 2,679 1,582,955 1,666 0 0 4,128,378 4,346Selenium 101,174 113,451 5,941 6,662 4,847 5,435 2,571 2,883 114,533 128,431Silica 0 0 1,529,633 0 2,742,290 0 0 0 4,271,923 0Silver 0 0 642 10,570 127 2,088 0 0 768 12,657Sodium 26,995,738 148 4,417,057 24 21,975,340 121 7,387,832 41 60,775,967 334Strontium 0 0 32,576 1 104,985 2 0 0 137,561 3Sulfate 0 0 61,938,208 347 147,708,853 827 42,464,536 238 252,111,596 1,412Sulfite 0 0 134,030 0 1,963,089 0 0 0 2,097,119 0Thallium 1,174 3,353 5,379 15,356 37,293 106,469 28 80 43,874 125,257Titanium 1,892 55 3,743 110 17,342 508 0 0 22,977 674Total Dissolved Solids 2,816,847,707 0 75,009,944 0 315,383,054 0 84,203,284 0 3,291,443,989 0Total Suspended Solids 1,900,994 0 3,017,426 0 8,532,059 0 835,953 0 14,286,431 0Vanadium 1,448 405 8,353 2,339 1,650 462 44,152 12,363 55,603 15,569Zinc 76,946 3,608 28,446 1,334 14,055 659 4,885 229 124,333 5,829TOTAL4,106,879,7881,548,294180,038,928185,721572,977,292344,910159,126,76860,9545,019,022,7762,139,880TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)1,288,131,0881,548,29497,471,643185,721239,671,607344,91074,087,53160,9541,699,361,8682,139,880MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 5Table 2. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option A Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 107,765 6,971 359,178 23,236 0 0 0 0 466,943 30,207Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 497 6 3,776 46 0 0 0 0 4,273 52Arsenic 132 458 11,062 38,377 0 0 0 0 11,194 38,835Barium 9,765 19 36,819 73 0 0 0 0 46,584 93Beryllium 40 42 895 946 0 0 0 0 936 989Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 689,465 0 0 0 0 0 689,465 0Boron 2,356,649 19,658 790,537 6,594 0 0 0 0 3,147,186 26,253Bromide 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Cadmium 5,944 135,274 786 17,890 0 0 0 0 6,730 153,164Calcium 18,909,155 529 17,472,810 489 0 0 0 0 36,381,964 1,019Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,841,304 0 0 0 0 0 3,841,304 0Chloride 0 0 3,375,621 82 0 0 0 0 3,375,621 82Chromium 660 50 5,258 398 0 0 0 0 5,919 448Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 0 0 0 0 99 51Cobalt 9,544 1,091 1,315 150 0 0 0 0 10,859 1,241Copper 1,005 626 8,200 5,113 0 0 0 0 9,205 5,739Cyanide, Total 0 0 780 871 0 0 0 0 780 871Fluoride 0 0 116,868 4,090 0 0 0 0 116,868 4,090Iron 77,357 433 143,467 803 0 0 0 0 220,824 1,237Lead 90 202 2,145 4,804 0 0 0 0 2,235 5,007Magnesium 0 0 3,284,018 2,842 0 0 0 0 3,284,018 2,842Manganese 4,501,063 462,109 20,810 2,137 0 0 0 0 4,521,873 464,246Mercury 418 46,022 208 22,893 0 0 0 0 626 68,916Molybdenum 0 0 57,455 11,574 0 0 0 0 57,455 11,574Nickel 47,568 5,181 4,859 529 0 0 0 0 52,427 5,710Nitrate Nitrite as N 589,835 1,887 555,340 1,777 0 0 0 0 1,145,175 3,665Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 440,231 0 0 0 0 0 440,231 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 6Table 2. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option A Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 34,343 0 0 0 0 0 34,343 0Potassium 0 0 2,537,855 2,671 0 0 0 0 2,537,855 2,671Selenium 18,866 21,155 5,925 6,644 0 0 0 0 24,791 27,799Silica 0 0 1,524,079 0 0 0 0 0 1,524,079 0Silver 0 0 640 10,548 0 0 0 0 640 10,548Sodium 0 0 4,398,353 24 0 0 0 0 4,398,353 24Strontium 0 0 32,387 1 0 0 0 0 32,387 1Sulfate 0 0 61,695,529 345 0 0 0 0 61,695,529 345Sulfite 0 0 133,760 0 0 0 0 0 133,760 0Thallium 275 785 5,365 15,316 0 0 0 0 5,640 16,102Titanium 1,031 30 3,734 109 0 0 0 0 4,764 140Total Dissolved Solids 609,820,821 0 74,723,554 0 0 0 0 0 684,544,376 0Total Suspended Solids 1,111,374 0 3,008,344 0 0 0 0 0 4,119,719 0Vanadium 285 80 8,336 2,334 0 0 0 0 8,621 2,414Zinc 75,092 3,521 28,324 1,328 0 0 0 0 103,416 4,849TOTAL637,645,232706,133179,363,833185,0900000817,009,065891,223TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)26,713,036706,13397,101,166185,0900000123,814,202891,223MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 7Table 3. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option B Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 107,765 6,971 359,178 23,236 0 0 0 0 466,943 30,207Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 497 6 3,776 46 0 0 0 0 4,273 52Arsenic 132 458 11,062 38,377 0 0 0 0 11,194 38,835Barium 9,765 19 36,819 73 0 0 0 0 46,584 93Beryllium 40 42 895 946 0 0 0 0 936 989Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 689,465 0 0 0 0 0 689,465 0Boron 2,356,649 19,658 790,537 6,594 0 0 0 0 3,147,186 26,253Bromide 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Cadmium 5,944 135,274 786 17,890 0 0 0 0 6,730 153,164Calcium 18,909,155 529 17,472,810 489 0 0 0 0 36,381,964 1,019Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,841,304 0 0 0 0 0 3,841,304 0Chloride 0 0 3,375,621 82 0 0 0 0 3,375,621 82Chromium 660 50 5,258 398 0 0 0 0 5,919 448Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 0 0 0 0 99 51Cobalt 9,544 1,091 1,315 150 0 0 0 0 10,859 1,241Copper 1,005 626 8,200 5,113 0 0 0 0 9,205 5,739Cyanide, Total 0 0 780 871 0 0 0 0 780 871Fluoride 0 0 116,868 4,090 0 0 0 0 116,868 4,090Iron 77,357 433 143,467 803 0 0 0 0 220,824 1,237Lead 90 202 2,145 4,804 0 0 0 0 2,235 5,007Magnesium 0 0 3,284,018 2,842 0 0 0 0 3,284,018 2,842Manganese 4,501,063 462,109 20,810 2,137 0 0 0 0 4,521,873 464,246Mercury 426 46,883 208 22,893 0 0 0 0 634 69,776Molybdenum 0 0 57,455 11,574 0 0 0 0 57,455 11,574Nickel 47,817 5,208 4,859 529 0 0 0 0 52,676 5,737Nitrate Nitrite as N 9,035,875 28,915 555,340 1,777 0 0 0 0 9,591,215 30,692Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 440,231 0 0 0 0 0 440,231 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 8Table 3. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option B Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 34,343 0 0 0 0 0 34,343 0Potassium 0 0 2,537,855 2,671 0 0 0 0 2,537,855 2,671Selenium 100,648 112,861 5,925 6,644 0 0 0 0 106,573 119,505Silica 0 0 1,524,079 0 0 0 0 0 1,524,079 0Silver 0 0 640 10,548 0 0 0 0 640 10,548Sodium 0 0 4,398,353 24 0 0 0 0 4,398,353 24Strontium 0 0 32,387 1 0 0 0 0 32,387 1Sulfate 0 0 61,695,529 345 0 0 0 0 61,695,529 345Sulfite 0 0 133,760 0 0 0 0 0 133,760 0Thallium 275 785 5,365 15,316 0 0 0 0 5,640 16,102Titanium 1,031 30 3,734 109 0 0 0 0 4,764 140Total Dissolved Solids 609,820,821 0 74,723,554 0 0 0 0 0 684,544,376 0Total Suspended Solids 1,111,374 0 3,008,344 0 0 0 0 0 4,119,719 0Vanadium 285 80 8,336 2,334 0 0 0 0 8,621 2,414Zinc 75,092 3,521 28,324 1,328 0 0 0 0 103,416 4,849TOTAL646,173,310825,753179,363,833185,0900000825,537,1431,010,843TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)35,241,114825,75397,101,166185,0900000132,342,2811,010,843MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 9Table 4. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option C Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 107,765 6,971 359,178 23,236 380,938 24,643 0 0 847,881 54,850Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 497 6 3,776 46 8,731 107 0 0 13,004 159Arsenic 132 458 11,062 38,3775,444 18,888 0 0 16,638 57,723Barium 9,765 19 36,819 73 36,862 73 0 0 83,445 166Beryllium 40 42 895 946 25 27 0 0 961 1,015Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 689,465 0 108,207 0 0 0 797,672 0Boron 2,356,649 19,658 790,537 6,594 204,683 1,707 0 0 3,351,869 27,960Bromide 0 0 0 0 182,481 0 0 0 182,481 0Cadmium 5,944 135,274 786 17,890 677 15,405 0 0 7,407 168,568Calcium 18,909,155 529 17,472,810 48922,999,695 644 0 0 59,381,660 1,663Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,841,304 0 6,734,616 0 0 0 10,575,919 0Chloride 0 0 3,375,621 82 8,662,808 211 0 0 12,038,429 293Chromium 660 50 5,258 398 2,145 162 0 0 8,064 610Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 16 8 0 0 115 59Cobalt 9,544 1,091 1,315 150 4,412 504 0 0 15,271 1,745Copper 1,005 626 8,200 5,113 4,835 3,015 0 0 14,041 8,754Cyanide, Total 0 0 780 871 122 137 0 0 903 1,008Fluoride 0 0 116,868 4,090 15,072 528 0 0 131,940 4,618Iron 77,357 433 143,467 803 441,537 2,473 0 0 662,360 3,709Lead 90 202 2,145 4,804 3,722 8,336 0 0 5,957 13,343Magnesium 0 0 3,284,018 2,842 10,522,202 9,107 0 0 13,806,220 11,950Manganese 4,501,063 462,109 20,810 2,137 424,191 43,550 0 0 4,946,064 507,796Mercury 426 46,883 208 22,893 242 26,673 0 0 877 96,450Molybdenum 0 0 57,455 11,574 12,028 2,423 0 0 69,483 13,996Nickel 47,817 5,208 4,859 529 5,544 604 0 0 58,220 6,341Nitrate Nitrite as N 9,035,875 28,915 555,340 1,777 1,844,884 5,904 0 0 11,436,099 36,596Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 440,231 0 363,065 0 0 0 803,296 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 10Table 4. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option C Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 34,343 0 64,531 0 0 0 98,874 0Potassium 0 0 2,537,855 2,671 1,169,469 1,231 0 0 3,707,324 3,902Selenium 100,648 112,861 5,925 6,644 3,508 3,933 0 0 110,080 123,438Silica 0 0 1,524,079 0 1,991,995 0 0 0 3,516,074 0Silver 0 0 640 10,548 101 1,656 0 0 741 12,204Sodium 0 0 4,398,353 24 15,889,704 87 0 0 20,288,057 111Strontium 0 0 32,387 1 75,788 2 0 0 108,175 2Sulfate 0 0 61,695,529 345 107,064,555 600 0 0 168,760,084 945Sulfite 0 0 133,760 0 1,419,031 0 0 0 1,552,791 0Thallium 275 785 5,365 15,31627,040 77,197 0 0 32,680 93,298Titanium 1,031 30 3,734 109 12,567 368 0 0 17,331 508Total Dissolved Solids 609,820,821 0 74,723,554 0 228,227,422 0 0 0 912,771,798 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,111,374 0 3,008,344 0 6,193,968 0 0 0 10,313,687 0Vanadium 285 80 8,336 2,334 1,308 366 0 0 9,929 2,780Zinc 75,092 3,521 28,324 1,328 10,277 482 0 0 113,693 5,331TOTAL646,173,310825,753179,363,833185,090415,120,447251,051001,240,657,5901,261,894TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)35,241,114825,75397,101,166185,090173,856,234251,05100306,198,5151,261,894MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 11Table 5. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option D Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 107,765 6,971 359,178 23,236 523,019 33,835 0 0 989,962 64,042Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 497 6 3,776 46 11,982 147 0 0 16,255 199Arsenic 132 458 11,062 38,3777,464 25,895 0 0 18,658 64,730Barium 9,765 19 36,819 73 50,296 100 0 0 96,880 193Beryllium 40 42 895 946 32 34 0 0 968 1,022Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 689,465 0 136,216 0 0 0 825,681 0Boron 2,356,649 19,658 790,537 6,594 276,968 2,310 0 0 3,424,155 28,563Bromide 0 0 0 0 251,841 0 0 0 251,841 0Cadmium 5,944 135,274 786 17,890 929 21,133 0 0 7,659 174,296Calcium 18,909,155 529 17,472,810 48931,409,918 879 0 0 67,791,882 1,898Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,841,304 0 9,221,312 0 0 0 13,062,615 0Chloride 0 0 3,375,621 82 11,909,692 290 0 0 15,285,313 372Chromium 660 50 5,258 398 2,896 219 0 0 8,815 667Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 20 10 0 0 119 61Cobalt 9,544 1,091 1,315 150 6,071 694 0 0 16,930 1,935Copper 1,005 626 8,200 5,113 6,575 4,099 0 0 15,780 9,838Cyanide, Total 0 0 780 871 154 172 0 0 934 1,044Fluoride 0 0 116,868 4,090 18,973 664 0 0 135,841 4,754Iron 77,357 433 143,467 803 606,537 3,397 0 0 827,360 4,633Lead 90 202 2,145 4,804 5,107 11,441 0 0 7,343 16,447Magnesium 0 0 3,284,018 2,842 14,478,708 12,532 0 0 17,762,726 15,374Manganese 4,501,063 462,109 20,810 2,137 584,761 60,035 0 0 5,106,634 524,281Mercury 426 46,883 208 22,893 327 36,017 0 0 961 105,793Molybdenum 0 0 57,455 11,574 16,201 3,264 0 0 73,656 14,837Nickel 47,817 5,208 4,859 529 7,560 823 0 0 60,235 6,560Nitrate Nitrite as N 9,035,875 28,915 555,340 1,777 2,534,508 8,110 0 0 12,125,723 38,802Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 440,231 0 498,558 0 0 0 938,789 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 12Table 5. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option D Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 34,343 0 88,509 0 0 0 122,852 0Potassium 0 0 2,537,855 2,671 1,577,842 1,661 0 0 4,115,697 4,332Selenium 100,648 112,861 5,925 6,644 4,832 5,419 0 0 111,405 124,923Silica 0 0 1,524,079 0 2,732,460 0 0 0 4,256,539 0Silver 0 0 640 10,548 127 2,084 0 0 767 12,632Sodium 0 0 4,398,353 24 21,894,470 120 0 0 26,292,823 144Strontium 0 0 32,387 1 104,595 2 0 0 136,982 3Sulfate 0 0 61,695,529 345 147,172,752 824 0 0 208,868,281 1,170Sulfite 0 0 133,760 0 1,955,853 0 0 0 2,089,612 0Thallium 275 785 5,365 15,316 37,192 106,178 0 0 42,832 122,280Titanium 1,031 30 3,734 109 17,279 507 0 0 22,043 646Total Dissolved Solids 609,820,821 0 74,723,554 0 314,227,692 0 0 0 998,772,068 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,111,374 0 3,008,344 0 8,501,368 0 0 0 12,621,087 0Vanadium 285 80 8,336 2,334 1,647 461 0 0 10,268 2,875Zinc 75,092 3,521 28,324 1,328 14,024 658 0 0 117,440 5,506TOTAL646,173,310825,753179,363,833185,090570,897,264344,014001,396,434,4071,354,857TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)35,241,114825,75397,101,166185,090238,810,677344,01400371,152,9581,354,857MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 13Table 6. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option E Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 107,765 6,971 359,178 23,236 523,019 33,835 49,738 3,218 1,039,700 67,259Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 497 6 3,776 46 11,982 147 0 0 16,255 199Arsenic 132 458 11,062 38,377 7,464 25,895 564 1,958 19,222 66,688Barium 9,765 19 36,819 73 50,296 100 0 0 96,880 193Beryllium 40 42 895 946 32 34 0 0 968 1,022Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 689,465 0 136,216 0 0 0 825,681 0Boron 2,356,649 19,658 790,537 6,594 276,968 2,310 0 0 3,424,155 28,563Bromide 0 0 0 0 251,841 0 0 0 251,841 0Cadmium 5,944 135,274 786 17,890 929 21,133 102 2,330 7,761 176,626Calcium 18,909,155 529 17,472,810 48931,409,918 879 0 0 67,791,882 1,898Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 3,841,304 0 9,221,312 0 0 0 13,062,615 0Chloride 0 0 3,375,621 82 11,909,692 290 0 0 15,285,313 372Chromium 660 50 5,258 398 2,896 219 36,538 2,766 45,353 3,433Chromium (VI) 0 0 99 51 20 10 0 0 119 61Cobalt 9,544 1,091 1,315 150 6,071 694 508 58 17,437 1,993Copper 1,005 626 8,200 5,113 6,575 4,099 66 41 15,846 9,879Cyanide, Total 0 0 780 871 154 172 0 0 934 1,044Fluoride 0 0 116,868 4,090 18,973 664 0 0 135,841 4,754Iron 77,357 433 143,467 803 606,537 3,397 640,059 3,584 1,467,420 8,218Lead 90 202 2,145 4,804 5,107 11,441 0 0 7,343 16,447Magnesium 0 0 3,284,018 2,842 14,478,708 12,532 0 0 17,762,726 15,374Manganese 4,501,063 462,109 20,810 2,137 584,761 60,035 0 0 5,106,634 524,281Mercury 426 46,883 208 22,893 327 36,017 16 1,763 977 107,556Molybdenum 0 0 57,455 11,574 16,2013,264 21,693 4,370 95,349 19,207Nickel 47,817 5,208 4,859 529 7,560 823 647 71 60,883 6,631Nitrate Nitrite as N 9,035,875 28,915 555,340 1,777 2,534,508 8,110 0 0 12,125,723 38,802Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 440,231 0 498,558 0 0 0 938,789 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 14Table 6. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals AchievedUnder Regulatory Option E Accounting for CCR and CPPPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 34,343 0 88,509 0 0 0 122,852 0Potassium 0 0 2,537,855 2,671 1,577,842 1,661 0 0 4,115,697 4,332Selenium 100,648 112,861 5,925 6,644 4,832 5,419 0 0 111,405 124,923Silica 0 0 1,524,079 0 2,732,460 0 0 0 4,256,539 0Silver 0 0 640 10,548 127 2,084 0 0 767 12,632Sodium 0 0 4,398,353 24 21,894,470 120 563,335 3 26,856,158 147Strontium 0 0 32,387 1 104,595 2 0 0 136,982 3Sulfate 0 0 61,695,529 345 147,172,752 824 9,530,224 53 218,398,504 1,223Sulfite 0 0 133,760 0 1,955,853 0 0 0 2,089,612 0Thallium 275 785 5,365 15,316 37,192 106,178 0 0 42,832 122,280Titanium 1,031 30 3,734 109 17,279 507 0 0 22,043 646Total Dissolved Solids 609,820,821 0 74,723,554 0 314,227,692 0 0 0 998,772,068 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,111,374 0 3,008,344 0 8,501,368 0 471,744 0 13,092,831 0Vanadium 285 80 8,336 2,334 1,647 461 32,875 9,205 43,143 12,080Zinc 75,092 3,521 28,324 1,328 14,024 658 3,306 155 120,745 5,661TOTAL646,173,310825,753179,363,833185,090570,897,264344,01411,351,41629,5741,407,785,8231,384,431TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)35,241,114825,75397,101,166185,090238,810,677344,01410,879,67229,574382,032,6301,384,431MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 15Table 7. Industry-Level Baseline Loadings by Pollutant for all Four Wastestreams Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEAluminum 134,831 8,722 424,727 27,476 775,728 50,183 79,507 5,143 1,414,792 91,525Ammonia as N 885,481 1,195 0 0 0 0 0 0 885,481 1,195Antimony 1,062 13 4,992 61 17,758 218 103 1 23,915 293Arsenic 840 2,914 13,806 47,899 11,046 38,321 1,027 3,564 26,719 92,699Barium 27,611 55 45,964 92 73,867 147 1,467 3 148,910 296Beryllium 205 216 1,107 1,170 41 43 0 0 1,352 1,429Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 911,515 0 173,313 0 0 0 1,084,828 0Boron 29,422,973 245,437 896,117 7,475 401,359 3,348 620,880 5,179 31,341,329 261,439Bromide 0 0 0 0 376,543 0 0 0 376,543 0Cadmium 7,150 162,716 868 19,749 1,375 31,302 273 6,203 9,665 219,970Calcium 249,980,167 6,999 20,868,669 584 46,195,262 1,293 11,291,087 316 328,335,185 9,193Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,078,438 0 13,618,260 0 0 0 18,696,698 0Chloride 896,906,901 21,838 4,174,591 102 17,700,964 431 11,433,544 278 930,215,999 22,649Chromium 1,505 114 6,336 480 4,181 317 56,213 4,255 68,236 5,165Chromium (VI) 0 0 131 68 25 13 0 0 156 81Cobalt 11,927 1,363 1,610 184 9,035 1,033 1,041 119 23,612 2,699Copper 1,573 981 9,294 5,795 9,602 5,987 205 128 20,674 12,890Cyanide, Total 120,513 134,604 1,032 1,152 196 219 0 0 121,741 135,975Fluoride 0 0 148,307 5,191 24,140 845 0 0 172,447 6,036Iron 100,953 565 170,464 955 900,333 5,042 991,560 5,553 2,163,311 12,115Lead 503 1,126 2,528 5,663 7,570 16,957 0 0 10,601 23,746Magnesium 425,049,836 367,895 4,035,767 3,493 21,548,715 18,651 3,262,278 2,824 453,896,596 392,863Manganese 6,556,319 673,115 24,285 2,493 872,780 89,605 75,034 7,703 7,528,418 772,918Mercury 484 53,229 256 28,218 473 52,013 28 3,112 1,241 136,572Molybdenum 15,779 3,178 65,095 13,113 23,301 4,694 36,969 7,447 141,144 28,432Nickel 54,603 5,947 5,739 625 11,090 1,208 1,244 135 72,676 7,915Nitrate Nitrite as N 11,258,466 36,027 681,148 2,180 3,762,662 12,041 0 0 15,702,276 50,247Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 490,203 0 739,628 0 0 0 1,229,831 0Phosphorus, Total 40,232 0 43,789 0 131,062 0 0 0 215,083 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 16Table 7. Industry-Level Baseline Loadings by Pollutant for all Four Wastestreams Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPoundsTWPEPotassium 0 0 3,165,082 3,332 2,275,536 2,395 0 0 5,440,618 5,727Selenium 124,309 139,393 7,487 8,396 7,204 8,079 2,968 3,329 141,969 159,196Silica 0 0 1,822,274 0 4,046,881 0 0 0 5,869,155 0Silver 0 0 847 13,946 161 2,652 0 0 1,008 16,597Sodium 34,746,729 191 5,050,770 28 32,655,222 179 8,511,798 47 80,964,519 445Strontium 0 0 33,180 1 156,387 3 0 0 189,567 4Sulfate 0 0 72,378,255 405 218,690,435 1,225 48,977,792 274 340,046,482 1,904Sulfite 0 0 176,838 0 2,918,430 0 0 0 3,095,268 0Thallium 1,472 4,201 6,860 19,586 55,315 157,920 32 92 63,679 181,799Titanium 2,286 67 4,828 142 25,686 753 0 0 32,800 962Total Dissolved Solids 3,555,133,605 0 88,248,144 0 468,091,571 0 96,959,885 0 4,208,433,205 0Total Suspended Solids 2,284,977 0 3,743,294 0 12,602,442 0 966,557 0 19,597,271 0Vanadium 1,830 512 11,021 3,086 2,095 587 51,086 14,304 66,032 18,489Zinc 86,555 4,058 32,361 1,517 20,598 966 5,620 263 145,134 6,805TOTAL5,212,961,6741,876,672212,788,020224,653848,938,275508,668183,328,19870,2746,458,016,1682,680,267TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)1,655,543,0921,876,672114,806,630224,653354,452,688508,66885,401,75670,2742,210,204,1662,680,267MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 17Table 8. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option A Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 120,547 7,798 419,221 27,120 0 0 0 0 539,768 34,918Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 569 7 4,930 60 0 0 0 0 5,500 67Arsenic 166 574 13,632 47,294 0 0 0 0 13,798 47,868Barium 11,377 23 45,384 90 0 0 0 0 56,761 113Beryllium 49 52 1,093 1,155 0 0 0 0 1,142 1,207Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 900,297 0 0 0 0 0 900,297 0Boron 3,336,557 27,832 884,259 7,376 0 0 0 0 4,220,817 35,209Bromide 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Cadmium 6,642 151,172 856 19,484 0 0 0 0 7,499 170,656Calcium 27,121,457 759 20,599,428 577 0 0 0 0 47,720,885 1,336Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,015,939 0 0 0 0 0 5,015,939 0Chloride 0 0 4,121,611 100 0 0 0 0 4,121,611 100Chromium 758 57 6,255 473 0 0 0 0 7,013 531Chromium (VI) 0 0 129 67 0 0 0 0 129 67Cobalt 10,804 1,235 1,590 182 0 0 0 0 12,394 1,416Copper 1,133 707 9,171 5,718 0 0 0 0 10,304 6,425Cyanide, Total 0 0 1,019 1,138 0 0 0 0 1,019 1,138Fluoride 0 0 146,448 5,126 0 0 0 0 146,448 5,126Iron 87,806 492 168,260 942 0 0 0 0 256,065 1,434Lead 111 249 2,495 5,589 0 0 0 0 2,606 5,838Magnesium 0 0 3,984,398 3,449 0 0 0 0 3,984,398 3,449Manganese 5,096,435 523,234 23,968 2,461 0 0 0 0 5,120,404 525,695Mercury 467 51,362 253 27,860 0 0 0 0 720 79,222Molybdenum 0 0 64,233 12,939 0 0 0 0 64,233 12,939Nickel 53,395 5,815 5,664 617 0 0 0 0 59,059 6,432Nitrate Nitrite as N 810,000 2,592 672,471 2,152 0 0 0 0 1,482,470 4,744Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 483,660 0 0 0 0 0 483,660 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 18Table 8. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option A Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 43,242 0 0 0 0 0 43,242 0Potassium 0 0 3,125,072 3,290 0 0 0 0 3,125,072 3,290Selenium 22,638 25,385 7,393 8,290 0 0 0 0 30,031 33,675Silica 0 0 1,798,775 0 0 0 0 0 1,798,775 0Silver 0 0 836 13,774 0 0 0 0 836 13,774Sodium 0 0 4,984,360 27 0 0 0 0 4,984,360 27Strontium 0 0 32,718 1 0 0 0 0 32,718 1Sulfate 0 0 71,436,397 400 0 0 0 0 71,436,397 400Sulfite 0 0 174,662 0 0 0 0 0 174,662 0Thallium 338 966 6,775 19,341 0 0 0 0 7,113 20,307Titanium 1,193 35 4,767 140 0 0 0 0 5,961 175Total Dissolved Solids 761,500,672 0 87,103,445 0 0 0 0 0 848,604,117 0Total Suspended Solids 1,282,436 0 3,695,925 0 0 0 0 0 4,978,361 0Vanadium 360 101 10,885 3,048 0 0 0 0 11,245 3,149Zinc 83,956 3,936 31,934 1,497 0 0 0 0 115,890 5,434TOTAL799,549,867804,385210,033,850221,77600001,009,583,7171,026,161TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)36,766,760804,385113,318,245221,7760000150,085,0051,026,161MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 19Table 9. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option B Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 120,547 7,798 419,221 27,120 0 0 0 0 539,768 34,918Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 569 7 4,930 60 0 0 0 0 5,500 67Arsenic 166 574 13,632 47,294 0 0 0 0 13,798 47,868Barium 11,377 23 45,384 90 0 0 0 0 56,761 113Beryllium 49 52 1,093 1,155 0 0 0 0 1,142 1,207Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 900,297 0 0 0 0 0 900,297 0Boron 3,336,557 27,832 884,259 7,376 0 0 0 0 4,220,817 35,209Bromide 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Cadmium 6,642 151,172 856 19,484 0 0 0 0 7,499 170,656Calcium 27,121,457 759 20,599,428 577 0 0 0 0 47,720,885 1,336Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,015,939 0 0 0 0 0 5,015,939 0Chloride 0 0 4,121,611 100 0 0 0 0 4,121,611 100Chromium 758 57 6,255 473 0 0 0 0 7,013 531Chromium (VI) 0 0 129 67 0 0 0 0 129 67Cobalt 10,804 1,235 1,590 182 0 0 0 0 12,394 1,416Copper 1,133 707 9,171 5,718 0 0 0 0 10,304 6,425Cyanide, Total 0 0 1,019 1,138 0 0 0 0 1,019 1,138Fluoride 0 0 146,448 5,126 0 0 0 0 146,448 5,126Iron 87,806 492 168,260 942 0 0 0 0 256,065 1,434Lead 111 249 2,495 5,589 0 0 0 0 2,606 5,838Magnesium 0 0 3,984,398 3,449 0 0 0 0 3,984,398 3,449Manganese 5,096,435 523,234 23,968 2,461 0 0 0 0 5,120,404 525,695Mercury 476 52,418 253 27,860 0 0 0 0 730 80,277Molybdenum 0 0 64,233 12,939 0 0 0 0 64,233 12,939Nickel 53,701 5,849 5,664 617 0 0 0 0 59,365 6,466Nitrate Nitrite as N 11,165,186 35,729 672,471 2,152 0 0 0 0 11,837,657 37,881Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 483,660 0 0 0 0 0 483,660 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 20Table 9. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option B Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 43,242 0 0 0 0 0 43,242 0Potassium 0 0 3,125,072 3,290 0 0 0 0 3,125,072 3,290Selenium 123,415 138,391 7,393 8,290 0 0 0 0 130,808 146,681Silica 0 0 1,798,775 0 0 0 0 0 1,798,775 0Silver 0 0 836 13,774 0 0 0 0 836 13,774Sodium 0 0 4,984,360 27 0 0 0 0 4,984,360 27Strontium 0 0 32,718 1 0 0 0 0 32,718 1Sulfate 0 0 71,436,397 400 0 0 0 0 71,436,397 400Sulfite 0 0 174,662 0 0 0 0 0 174,662 0Thallium 338 966 6,775 19,341 0 0 0 0 7,113 20,307Titanium 1,193 35 4,767 140 0 0 0 0 5,961 175Total Dissolved Solids 761,500,672 0 87,103,445 0 0 0 0 0 848,604,117 0Total Suspended Solids 1,282,436 0 3,695,925 0 0 0 0 0 4,978,361 0Vanadium 360 101 10,885 3,048 0 0 0 0 11,245 3,149Zinc 83,956 3,936 31,934 1,497 0 0 0 0 115,890 5,434TOTAL810,006,147951,616210,033,850221,77600001,020,039,9971,173,393TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)47,223,039951,616113,318,245221,7760000160,541,2841,173,393MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 21Table 10. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option C Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 120,547 7,798 419,221 27,120 473,960 30,661 0 0 1,013,728 65,579Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 569 7 4,930 60 10,845 133 0 0 16,345 200Arsenic 166 574 13,632 47,2946,751 23,421 0 0 20,548 71,290Barium 11,377 23 45,384 90 45,311 90 0 0 102,072 203Beryllium 49 52 1,093 1,155 27 28 0 0 1,169 1,235Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 900,297 0 114,946 0 0 0 1,015,243 0Boron 3,336,557 27,832 884,259 7,376 247,563 2,065 0 0 4,468,380 37,274Bromide 0 0 0 0 228,382 0 0 0 228,382 0Cadmium 6,642 151,172 856 19,484 841 19,138 0 0 8,339 189,793Calcium 27,121,457 759 20,599,428 57728,267,040 791 0 0 75,987,925 2,128Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,015,939 0 8,314,536 0 0 0 13,330,475 0Chloride 0 0 4,121,611 100 10,770,343 262 0 0 14,891,954 363Chromium 758 57 6,255 473 2,590 196 0 0 9,603 727Chromium (VI) 0 0 129 67 17 9 0 0 146 75Cobalt 10,804 1,235 1,590 182 5,495 628 0 0 17,889 2,045Copper 1,133 707 9,171 5,718 5,913 3,686 0 0 16,217 10,111Cyanide, Total 0 0 1,019 1,138 130 145 0 0 1,149 1,283Fluoride 0 0 146,448 5,126 16,010 560 0 0 162,458 5,686Iron 87,806 492 168,260 942 548,189 3,070 0 0 804,255 4,504Lead 111 249 2,495 5,589 4,625 10,359 0 0 7,231 16,198Magnesium 0 0 3,984,398 3,449 13,101,935 11,340 0 0 17,086,333 14,789Manganese 5,096,435 523,234 23,968 2,461 530,595 54,474 0 0 5,650,999 580,169Mercury 476 52,418 253 27,860 293 32,222 0 0 1,022 112,499Molybdenum 0 0 64,233 12,939 14,431 2,907 0 0 78,664 15,846Nickel 53,701 5,849 5,664 617 6,806 741 0 0 66,171 7,207Nitrate Nitrite as N 11,165,186 35,729 672,471 2,152 2,297,744 7,353 0 0 14,135,401 45,233Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 483,660 0 450,478 0 0 0 934,138 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 22Table 10. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option C Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 43,242 0 79,904 0 0 0 123,146 0Potassium 0 0 3,125,072 3,290 1,407,232 1,481 0 0 4,532,305 4,771Selenium 123,415 138,391 7,393 8,290 4,381 4,913 0 0 135,190 151,594Silica 0 0 1,798,775 0 2,467,020 0 0 0 4,265,795 0Silver 0 0 836 13,774 107 1,759 0 0 943 15,533Sodium 0 0 4,984,360 27 19,832,213 109 0 0 24,816,573 136Strontium 0 0 32,718 1 94,852 2 0 0 127,571 3Sulfate 0 0 71,436,397 400 133,079,979 745 0 0 204,516,376 1,145Sulfite 0 0 174,662 0 1,772,000 0 0 0 1,946,662 0Thallium 338 966 6,775 19,341 33,706 96,226 0 0 40,819 116,533Titanium 1,193 35 4,767 140 15,627 458 0 0 21,588 633Total Dissolved Solids 761,500,672 0 87,103,445 0 284,468,190 0 0 0 1,133,072,307 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,282,436 0 3,695,925 0 7,678,792 0 0 0 12,657,153 0Vanadium 360 101 10,885 3,048 1,390 389 0 0 12,635 3,538Zinc 83,956 3,936 31,934 1,497 12,644 593 0 0 128,534 6,026TOTAL810,006,147951,616210,033,850221,776516,413,835310,957001,536,453,8321,484,350TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)47,223,039951,616113,318,245221,776215,837,370310,95700376,378,6541,484,350MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 23Table 11. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option D Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 120,547 7,798 419,221 27,120 772,508 49,974 0 0 1,312,276 84,893Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 569 7 4,930 60 17,678 217 0 0 23,178 284Arsenic 166 574 13,632 47,29410,995 38,146 0 0 24,793 86,014Barium 11,377 23 45,384 90 73,498 146 0 0 130,259 259Beryllium 49 52 1,093 1,155 40 42 0 0 1,182 1,249Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 900,297 0 171,472 0 0 0 1,071,768 0Boron 3,336,557 27,832 884,259 7,376 398,906 3,328 0 0 4,619,722 38,536Bromide 0 0 0 0 374,619 0 0 0 374,619 0Cadmium 6,642 151,172 856 19,484 1,370 31,170 0 0 8,868 201,826Calcium 27,121,457 759 20,599,428 57745,934,978 1,286 0 0 93,655,863 2,622Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,015,939 0 13,543,330 0 0 0 18,559,269 0Chloride 0 0 4,121,611 100 17,607,153 429 0 0 21,728,765 529Chromium 758 57 6,255 473 4,159 315 0 0 11,172 846Chromium (VI) 0 0 129 67 25 13 0 0 154 80Cobalt 10,804 1,235 1,590 182 8,988 1,027 0 0 21,383 2,444Copper 1,133 707 9,171 5,718 9,556 5,958 0 0 19,860 12,382Cyanide, Total 0 0 1,019 1,138 194 217 0 0 1,213 1,355Fluoride 0 0 146,448 5,126 23,884 836 0 0 170,331 5,962Iron 87,806 492 168,260 942 895,526 5,015 0 0 1,151,591 6,449Lead 111 249 2,495 5,589 7,537 16,883 0 0 10,144 22,722Magnesium 0 0 3,984,398 3,449 21,435,447 18,553 0 0 25,419,844 22,002Manganese 5,096,435 523,234 23,968 2,461 868,756 89,192 0 0 5,989,160 614,887Mercury 476 52,418 253 27,860 470 51,742 0 0 1,200 132,019Molybdenum 0 0 64,233 12,939 23,153 4,664 0 0 87,386 17,603Nickel 53,701 5,849 5,664 617 11,034 1,202 0 0 70,399 7,667Nitrate Nitrite as N 11,165,186 35,729 672,471 2,152 3,747,130 11,991 0 0 15,584,787 49,871Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 483,660 0 735,665 0 0 0 1,219,325 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 24Table 11. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option D Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 43,242 0 130,352 0 0 0 173,593 0Potassium 0 0 3,125,072 3,290 2,261,274 2,380 0 0 5,386,346 5,670Selenium 123,415 138,391 7,393 8,290 7,170 8,040 0 0 137,979 154,722Silica 0 0 1,798,775 0 4,024,981 0 0 0 5,823,757 0Silver 0 0 836 13,774 159 2,623 0 0 996 16,397Sodium 0 0 4,984,360 27 32,485,775 178 0 0 37,470,134 206Strontium 0 0 32,718 1 155,588 3 0 0 188,306 4Sulfate 0 0 71,436,397 400 217,529,932 1,218 0 0 288,966,329 1,618Sulfite 0 0 174,662 0 2,903,328 0 0 0 3,077,990 0Thallium 338 966 6,775 19,341 55,064 157,201 0 0 62,177 177,508Titanium 1,193 35 4,767 140 25,551 749 0 0 31,511 924Total Dissolved Solids 761,500,672 0 87,103,445 0 465,644,559 0 0 0 1,314,248,676 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,282,436 0 3,695,925 0 12,534,612 0 0 0 17,512,973 0Vanadium 360 101 10,885 3,048 2,073 580 0 0 13,318 3,729Zinc 83,956 3,936 31,934 1,497 20,502 961 0 0 136,392 6,395TOTAL810,006,147951,616210,033,850221,776844,458,990506,281001,864,498,9861,679,674TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)47,223,039951,616113,318,245221,776352,565,017506,28100513,106,3001,679,674MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 25Table 12. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option E Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedAluminum 120,547 7,798 419,221 27,120 772,508 49,974 56,602 3,662 1,368,878 88,554Ammonia as N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Antimony 569 7 4,930 60 17,678 217 0 0 23,178 284Arsenic 166 574 13,632 47,294 10,995 38,146 644 2,234 25,437 88,248Barium 11,377 23 45,384 90 73,498 146 0 0 130,259 259Beryllium 49 52 1,093 1,155 40 42 0 0 1,182 1,249Biochemical OxygenDemand 0 0 900,297 0 171,472 0 0 0 1,071,768 0Boron 3,336,557 27,832 884,259 7,376 398,906 3,328 0 0 4,619,722 38,536Bromide 0 0 0 0 374,619 0 0 0 374,619 0Cadmium 6,642 151,172 856 19,484 1,370 31,170 117 2,651 8,985 204,478Calcium 27,121,457 759 20,599,428 57745,934,978 1,286 0 0 93,655,863 2,622Chemical OxygenDemand 0 0 5,015,939 0 13,543,330 0 0 0 18,559,269 0Chloride 0 0 4,121,611 100 17,607,153 429 0 0 21,728,765 529Chromium 758 57 6,255 473 4,159 315 41,626 3,151 52,797 3,997Chromium (VI) 0 0 129 67 25 13 0 0 154 80Cobalt 10,804 1,235 1,590 182 8,988 1,027 583 67 21,965 2,510Copper 1,133 707 9,171 5,718 9,556 5,958 75 47 19,935 12,429Cyanide, Total 0 0 1,019 1,138 194 217 0 0 1,213 1,355Fluoride 0 0 146,448 5,126 23,884 836 0 0 170,331 5,962Iron 87,806 492 168,260 942 895,526 5,015 735,187 4,117 1,886,778 10,566Lead 111 249 2,495 5,589 7,537 16,883 0 0 10,144 22,722Magnesium 0 0 3,984,398 3,449 21,435,447 18,553 0 0 25,419,844 22,002Manganese 5,096,435 523,234 23,968 2,461 868,756 89,192 0 0 5,989,160 614,887Mercury 476 52,418 253 27,860 470 51,742 18 2,006 1,218 134,025Molybdenum 0 0 64,233 12,939 23,1534,664 24,917 5,019 112,304 22,622Nickel 53,701 5,849 5,664 617 11,034 1,202 740 81 71,139 7,748Nitrate Nitrite as N 11,165,186 35,729 672,471 2,152 3,747,130 11,991 0 0 15,584,787 49,871Nitrogen, TotalKjeldahl (TKN) 0 0 483,660 0 735,665 0 0 0 1,219,325 0MemorandumSeptember 30, 2015Page 26Table 12. Industry-Level Pollutant-Specific Removals Achieved Under Regulatory Option E Accounting for CCRPollutantFGD WastewaterFly Ash TransportWaterBottom Ash TransportWaterCombustion ResidualLeachateTotal IndustryPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPoundsRemovedTWPERemovedPhosphorus, Total 0 0 43,242 0 130,352 0 0 0 173,593 0Potassium 0 0 3,125,072 3,290 2,261,274 2,380 0 0 5,386,346 5,670Selenium 123,415 138,391 7,393 8,290 7,170 8,040 0 0 137,979 154,722Silica 0 0 1,798,775 0 4,024,981 0 0 0 5,823,757 0Silver 0 0 836 13,774 159 2,623 0 0 996 16,397Sodium 0 0 4,984,360 27 32,485,775 178 647,060 4 38,117,194 209Strontium 0 0 32,718 1 155,588 3 0 0 188,306 4Sulfate 0 0 71,436,397 400 217,529,932 1,218 10,946,639 61 299,912,968 1,680Sulfite 0 0 174,662 0 2,903,328 0 0 0 3,077,990 0Thallium 338 966 6,775 19,341 55,064 157,201 0 0 62,177 177,508Titanium 1,193 35 4,767 140 25,551 749 0 0 31,511 924Total Dissolved Solids 761,500,672 0 87,103,445 0 465,644,559 0 0 0 1,314,248,676 0Total SuspendedSolids 1,282,436 0 3,695,925 0 12,534,612 0 541,856 0 18,054,829 0Vanadium 360 101 10,885 3,048 2,073 580 37,730 10,564 51,048 14,293Zinc 83,956 3,936 31,934 1,497 20,502 961 3,766 177 140,158 6,571TOTAL810,006,147951,616210,033,850221,776844,458,990506,28113,037,55933,8401,877,536,5461,713,514TOTAL (excludingBOD, COD, TSS,TDS)47,223,039951,616113,318,245221,776352,565,017506,28112,495,70333,840525,602,0041,713,514