ENERGY.July24,2013VIAELECTRONICMAIL:RETURNRECEIPTREQUESTED,toalicea.jezebele@epa.govandcovington.james@epa.govMs.JezebeleAlicea-VirellaUSEPAHeadquartersMr.JamesCovingtonUSEPAHeadquartersUrgent:ResubmittedRequestforReleaseofInformationFromDocketNo.EPA-HQ-OW-2009-0819***PROMPTRESPONSEREQUESTED***DearMs.Alicea-VirellaandMr.Covington:CariBoyceVIcePresidentEnvironmental&EnergyPolicy410S.WilmingtonStreetPEB12ARaleigh,NC27601Phone:(919)546-7314PerMs.Alicea-Virella'sJuly24email,DukeEnergyisresubmittingitsrequestforreleaseofinformationfromDocketNo.EPA-HQ-PW-2009-0819.Therequisitecertificationregardingconfidentialbusinessinformationisincluded.DukeEnergy'sfacilitiesprovidedinformationthatisbeingusedtoinformEPA'sdevelopmentoftheproposedrevisionoftheeffluentlimitationsguidelinesandstandardsforthesteamelectricpowergeneratingpointsource(ELGRule).ThefacilitieslistedbeloweitherrespondedtoearlierELGRulequestionnairestotheindustryorprovidedinformationtoyouthroughothermeans,suchassitevisitsorseparateinformation requests.Pleasenotetheoperatingcompanynamelistedbelowisthestation'soperatingcompanyatthetimetheELGRulequestionnairewascompleted.Thespecificfacilitiesinquestionareasfollows:OperatingCompanyNameFacilityNameNPDESNumberDukeEnergyCorporationAllenSteamStationNC0004979DukeEnergyCorporationBelewsCreekSteamStationNC0024406DukeEnergyCorporationBuckSteamStationNC0004774DukeEnergyCorporationCatawbaNuclearStationSC0004278DukeEnergyCorporationCliffsideSteamStationNC0005088DukeEnergyCorporationOconeeNuclearStationSC0000515DukeEnergyCorporationDanRiverSteamStationNC0003468DukeEnergyCorporationW.S.LeeSteamStationSC0002291DukeEnergyCorporationMarshallSteamStationNC0004987DukeEnergyCorporationMcGuireNuclearStationNC0024392DukeEnergyCorporationRiverbendSteamStationNC0004961DukeEnergyCorporationEastBendStationKY0040444Ms

. Jezebele

A
l ice a-Virella

& Mr

. James Cov in gton July 24

, 20 13 Request
for Release

of CBIInformation EPA-HQ-OW-2009-0819 Page

2 of5 Operating

Co mpan

y Name

F acility Name
NPDES Number Duk

e E n e r gy Corpo ration.

W ill ia m H

. Zi mm

e r S tation OH0048836 Duke

E n e r gy Corpora tion

Wa

l te r C. Beckjo

r d Statio

n OH0009865 Duk

e E n e r gy Co rporation

Miami For

t S t at

i on OH00098

73 Duk

e E n e r gy Co rporation

Cayuga Generati

n g S t a ti o n

I N 0002763 Duke

E n e r gy C orporation Edwardspo

r t Ge
n e r at

i ng
S t a tion

I N00027

80 Duke

E n e r gy Co rpor

a tion

R. Ga ll aghe

r Gene

r a tin g S tation

I N 0002798 Duke

E n e r gy Co rp o ration

G ib so n Ge n e r ati n g S tation

N/ A Duke

E n e r gy Corpo ration

Nob

l esv ill e Gene

r a tin g S

t a ti o n

I N0 002801 Duke

E n e r gy Corpora tion Wabash

Ri ve
r Ge
n e rati
n g Statio

n

I N0 002810 Duke

E n e r gy Co rp ora tion

H ang in g Rock

E n ergy Faci

li ty OH0127931 Duk

e Energy Corpora tion Washingto

n Energy Faci

l ity II OH0127841 Duk

e Energy
Co rp oration

Fayette Energy Facili

t y PA0218863 Progre

ss E n e r gy

, I nc

Ashevi

ll e Stea m E
l ec tric

P l ant NC000039

6 Pro gress

E n ergy

, Inc Brunswick
Stea m E
l ectric

P l a n t NC0007064 Progress

E n ergy,
In c

Ca p e Fear

S team

E
l ec tric Plant NC0003433 P r ogress Ene

r gy, In c

S h ea
r on H ar ri s N u c l ea
r Plant NC0039586 P r ogress

E nergy

, In c

H.F. Lee/Way

n e Co unty NC0003417 P r ogress

E ner gy, In c

Mayo

E
l ectric Ge
n erati

n g Pl a n t NC0038377 Pr og
r ess
E n e r gy, In c

LV

S utton

S t eam

E
l ectr

i c Plant NC0001422 Pr og
r ess E n ergy,
In c

W H Weatherspoon

Pl a nt NC0005363 Progres

s E n e r gy, In c
Roxbor

o Stea m Pl a nt NC0003425 Progre

ss E n e r gy, Inc

She rwo

o d S mith

E n e r gy Co mpl ex NA P r og
r ess Ene

r gy, In c

H

. B

. Rob in so n

SC0 00 2925 Progre

ss Ene

r gy, In c

A nclot

e
FL0002992 Pr og
r ess E n e r gy

, In c

P.L. Bartow
FLOOOOI32 Pr og
r ess
E n e r gy

, In c

Crystal

Ri ver

- Units

1, 2 a
n d 3 FL00 001 59 Progr ess
E n ergy

, In c

C r ystal River

- 4 and

5 FL0036366 Pro gress

E nerg
y, In c

H

i n es Energy
Co mpl ex

NA Pro gress Ene

r gy, Inc

Suwa nn ee
S team Plant

FL00 00183 We have ide nt if i ed ce rta in
r ecord documents

wh

i ch we be

li eve co nt ain information reported

by

, or derived from data or

i nformation

rep orted by

, one or more
of our facili ties

. EPA has redacted all or portions

of these documents

as "co nfidential
bus

i ness information

" (CB

I ) . We are requesting
that you provide

to us all informat
ion related

to the facilit

i es

l isted above (inc

l uding information
that EPA has der

i ved from inf ormat

i on obtained from our facilities andMs.JezebeleAlicea-Virella&Mr.JamesCovingtonJuly24,2013RequestforReleaseofCBIInformationEPA-HQ-OW-2009-0819Page3of5fromallothersources,andincludingfacility-specificorfacility-derivedinformationininputfilestothelisteddocuments)containedwithinthefollowingdocuments:EPA-HQ-OW-2009-0819Doc.ShortDescriptionIDNo.(DCNNo.)1959(DCNSE01825A53)FGDInputTableCurrentSystems1959(DCNSE01825A54)FGDInputTablePlannedSystems1959(DCNSE01825A55)FGDHiQhFlowAnalysis1959(DCNSE01825A73)BottomAshMDSConveyanceO&MCosts1959(DCNSE01825A74)BottomAshIntermediateStorageO&MCosts1959(DCNSE01825A75)BottomAshWetSluicingO&MCosts1959(DCNSE01825A76)BottomAshRemoteMDSCapitalCosts1959(DCNSE01825A77)BottomAshWetSluicingO&MCosts1959(DCNSE01825A78)BottomAshRemoteMDSCapitalCosts1977(SE02900)CBISteamElectricPollutantLoadingModelforFGDWastewater1984(SE02899)CBISteamElectricPollutantLoadingsModelforAshTransportWater1986(SE01756)CBIFutureProfileFGDLoads2104(SE02897)CBISteamElectricCostModel(FGDandAshTransportWater)2105(SE02898)CBISteamElectricCostModel(FGDandLeachate)2121(5E03804)CBIDataDictionaryfortheFGDandAshCostModel2157(SE02988)CBILoadsCalculationDatabaseforOptions1,2,3,4,and52159(SE03508)CBILoadsCalculationDatabaseFutureProfile-IPMOnly2191(SE03879)CBIBottomAshManagementDeterminationCalculations2195(SE03507)LoadsCalculationDatabase-QuestionnaireandIPM2197(SE03552)CBIEAReportCalculationsDatabase2201(SE03895)CBILoadsCalculationDatabaseforOptions3a,3band4a2210(SE02129)CBIMemorandumtotheSteamElectricRulemakingRecord:NewSourcePerformanceStandardsCostingMemorandumandAttachment2252,2252.1(SE01957,CBIIncrementalCostsandPollutantRemovalsforSE1957A1)ProposedELGsReportandAttachment2256(SE01957)CBIIncrementalCostsandPollutantRemovalsMs. Jezebele Alicea
-V irella

& Mr

. James Covington July 24

, 2013 Request
for Release

of CBI/nformation EPA-HQ-OW-2009-0819 Page

4 of5 Please include

all information from these documents
that relates

to our facilities

. For example

, our facilities supplied information about existing control technologies

. Through this request

, we are requesting

not on

l y the control technologies

in formation supplied

by our facilities,

but also control technologies

inf o rmat ion about our facilities derived
fro m other sources,

as well as all EPA-developed

info rmati on relating

to our contro

l technologies, including EPA

' s assessments

of future technology choices
for our facilit

i es based
on the various rule options

. For each document,

as appropriate, please also include

: (1)
a legend which explains each column heading and each abbreviation
used throughout

the entire document

; and (2)
a list of all formulas applied

in the document
and

a legend for any abbreviations
used

in the formulas. The legend and formula information

is key to understanding these documents

. We make this request without waiving any of our CBI designations. Because
you are providing the information
only to us, there

is no breach

of confidentiality

and no waiver

of CBI protections

. Furthermore,

we are not requesting
CBI information,

or CBI-derived information

, from other compan
ies that may have furnished data or information appearing

in the

li sted documents.

We are requesting
only informat
ion related

to our own facilities. I cer tifi; under penalty
of lnw that

I nm
a r esponsible corpo rate official
of Duke Energt; and nm authorized

to request

c onfidential business information

Oil behalf of my co mpany.

I certifi; that Duke Energtj

is the maj ority owne

r or tlze operator for eaclz facility (and for each unit at each fncilihJ) for wl1ich

w e are requesting

co nfid ential business infonnation.

I nm nware that there may be si gnifi cant penalties for submitting false information includin

g the possibility

of fines and imprisonment

, pursuant

to 18 U.S. C. § 1001. We have done our best
to be selective

in asking for facility-specific informat

io n
. The information we are seeking, however,

is vital to our review
of, and preparation

of comments

on

, the proposed ELG Rule

. Please forward

all requested information

to the following address: Mr. Nathan Craig Duke Energy 526 South Tryon Street Charlotte

, NC 28202 Mailing Address: EC13K

I P.O. Box 1006 Charlotte

, NC 28201-1006 If you have any questions about this request

, please call or email me.

I look forward

to your prompt response

. Thank you very much for you

r help

.Ms

. Jezebele Alicea-Virella

& Mr. James Covington July 24

, 2013 Request
for Release

of CB/Information EPA

- HQ-OW-2009

- 0819 P age

5 of5 Sincerely

, Car

i Boyce Vice President, Environmenta

l & Energy Policy