### U n it e d S t a t e s Env i r on m e n t a l P r o t ec ti on A g e n c y

, R e g i on 9

A i r D i v i s i on

T ec hn i ca l S uppo r t D o c u m e n t

f o r

E P A’ s N o ti ce o f R u l e m a k i ng

f o r t h e

C a li f o r n i a S t a t e I m p l e m e n t a ti on P l a n

P l acer C oun t y A i r P o ll u t i on C on t r o l D i s t r i c t ’ s

R u l e 242, S t a ti on a r y I n t e r n a l C o m bus ti on En g i n e s

P re p are d b y : I d a li a P é r e z

S e p t e m b er

201 1

### 1

P l a c er C o un t y A i r P o l l u t i o n C o n tr o l D i s tr i ct ( P CA P CD )

Sub m i tte d R u l e

PC A PC D R u l e 242, S t a t i on a r y I n t er n a l C o m bus ti on En g i n e s :

§ A dop t e d : A p r il 10, 2003

§ S ub mitt e d : D ece m b er 7, 2010

§ D e t er mi n e d c o m p l e t e : J a nu a r y 13, 201 1

P r e v i o u s R u l e Sub m i tt a l s

Th ere are no ou t s t a nd i n g sub mitt a l s o f R u l e 242

.

S I P -A pp r ov e d R u l e

Th ere i s no S I P -a pp r o v e d v er s i on o f R u l e 242

.

R u l e Su m m a r y

PC A PC D R u l e 242 re g u l a t e s e mi ss i ons o f n it r og e n o x i d e s (NO x ) a nd car b on m ono x i d e ( C O)

fr o m I C e n g i n e s w it h a r a t e d b ra k e ho r s e p o w er o f 50 o r g r e a t er

.

Th e e mi ss i on limit s are ( S ec ti on 301.1 ) :

En g i n e T y p e NO x ( pp m v ) C O ( pp m v )

Ri c h

- B u r n 90 2000

L e a n

- B u r n, r a t e d H P > 1 00 150 2000

L e a n

- B u r n, r a t e d H P < 1 00 300 2000

D i e s e l f i re d 600 2000

Th e r u l e l a n g u a g e i n c l u d e s e x e m p ti ons ( S ec ti on 103 ) , d ef i n iti ons ( S ec ti on 200 )

, a nd

re qu i re m e n t s f

o r a n i nsp e c ti on p l a n ( S ec ti on 302 )

. Mon it o r i n g a nd r ec o r d k e e p i n g r e qu i re m e n t s

are c on t a i n e d i n v ar i ous p r ov i s i ons i n S ec ti on 400 a nd 500.

E f f ect s o n E m i ss i o n s

Th e s t aff r e po r t do e s no t sp ec i f y t h e e x p ec t e d e mi ss i on re du c ti ons du e t o t h e im p l e m e n t a ti on o f

t h i s r u l e bu t s t a t e s t h a t t h ere i s a 0.1 t ons p e r

d a y e mi ss i on re du c ti on c o mmitm e n t i n t h e S I P f o r

t h e C on t r o l M ea su re

.

R u l e E va l u a t i o n

G e n e r a l l y

, S I P r u l e s m u s t b e e n f o r cea b l e ( s e e s ec t i on 110 (a) o f t h e A c t )

, m us t re qu i re

R ea son a b l y A v a il a b l e C o n t r o l T ec hno l og y ( R A C T ) f o r m a j o r sou r ce s i n n o n a tt a i n m e n t ar e a s

( s ee s e c ti ons 182 ( b )( 2 ) a nd 182 (f))

, a nd m us t no t re l a x e x i s ti n g re qu i re m e n t s ( s ee s ec ti ons 110 ( l )

a nd 193 )

. I n a dd iti on, S e c ti on 172 (c)( 1 ) o f t h e Cl e a n A i r A c t ( C A A) r e qu i r e s non a tt a i n m e n t

area s t o im p l e m e n t a ll re a son a b l y a v a il a b l e c on t r o l m ea su re s ( R A C M )

, i n c l ud i n g su c h r e du c ti ons

i n e mi ss i ons fr o m e x i s t i ng sou r ce s i n t h e a rea a s m a y b e ob t a i n e d t h r o u g h t h e a dop ti on, a t a

mi n im u m , o f rea son a b l y a v a il a b l e c on t r o l t e c hno l o g y ( R A C T )

, a s e x p e d iti ous l y a s p r ac ti ca b l e

.

### 2

Th e PC A PC D re g u l a t e s o z on e non a tt a i n m e n t ar e a s ( 40 C F R 81 )

, t hus, su b mitt e d R u l e 242 m us t

f u l f ill R A C T a nd R A C M re qu i re m e n ts 1



### .

G u i d a n ce a nd po li c y do c u m e n t s t h a t w e us e d t o d ef i n e sp e c i f i c R A C T, R A C M a nd

e n f o r c ea b ili t y re qu i re m e n t s i n c l ud e t h e f o ll o w i ng :

• I ssu e s R e l a ti ng t o V

O C R e gu l a ti on, C u t

po i n t s, D e f i c i e n c i e s, and D e v i a ti ons ( t h e " B l u e

B oo k " )

, U S E P A

, OAQ P S ( M a y 25, 198 8 )

.

• E P A R e g i on I X ’ s G u i d a n ce D o c u m e n t f

or C orr ec ti ng C o mm on V O C and O t h e r Ru l e

D e fi c i e n c i es (A u g us t 21, 2001, t h e “ L ittl e B l u e bo o k ”)

.

• S t a t e Im

p l e m e n t a ti on P l a ns ; G e n e ra l Pr e a m b l e f o r t h e Im p l e m e n t a ti on o

f T itl e I o f t h e

Cl e an A i r A c t

A m e nd m e n ts o f 1990, 57 F R 13498 (A p r il 16, 1992 ) ; 57 F R 18070 (A p r il

28, 1992 )

.

• S t a t e Im

p l e m e n t a ti on P l a ns ; Nit rog e n O x i d e s Su p p l e m e n t t o t h e G e n e ra l Pr e a m b l e f or

t h e Im p l e m e n t a ti on o

f T itl e I o f t h e Cl e an A i r A c t

A m e nd m e n t s o f 1990 ( t h e " NO X



### S upp l e m e n t t o t h e G e n e r a l P rea m b l e " )

, U S E P A

, 57 F R 55620 (N ov e m b er 25, 1992 )

.

• Cl e an A i r F i n e Par ti c l e Im p l e m e n t a ti on Ru le , 72 F R 20586 (A p r il 25, 20 0 7 )

• U

. S . E P A

. A lt e rna ti ve C on t ro l T ec hn i qu e s D o c u m e n t

– N O x E m i ss i ons f

ro m S t a ti onar

y

R ec i pro c a ti ng I

n t e rna l C o m bus ti on Eng i n e s. E P A- 453 /R

- 93

- 032, J u l y 19 9 3

h tt p :// www

. e p a

. g ov /tt nn a a qs / o z on e / c t g

_ a c t/ 199307_no x

_ e p a 453_ r- 93

- 032_ i n t er n a l

_ c o m bus ti on_ e n g i n e s.pdf

• C a li f o r n i a A i r R e sou r c e s B o ar d. D e t e r m i na ti on o

f R e asonab l

y A v a il ab l e C on t ro l

T ec hno l og y and B e s t

A v a il ab l e R e t ro

fit C on t ro l T

ec hno l og y f

or S t a ti onar

y Spar k-I gn it e d

I n t e rna l C o m bus ti on Eng i n e s. N ov e m b er 2001

h tt p :// www

. ar

b. ca

. g ov / ra c t b arc / r b

- i c e a ll .pdf

.

Th e 2006 R A C T S I P U p d a t e A n a l y s i s S t aff R e p o r t sub mitt e d t o E P A on Ju l y 11, 2007 s t a t e s t h a t

t h ere a re no m a

j o r sou r c e s sub

j ec t t o t h i s R u l e

. O n a

phon e c a ll w it h J ohn F i nn e ll fr o m t h e

PC A PC D on M arc h 21, 2011, w e c on f i r m e d t h a t t h ere a re no sou r ce s sub j ec t t o t h i s r u l e t h a t

e x cee d t h e m a

j o r sou r ce t h re sho l d ( 25 t p y ) . Thus, R u l e 242 i s no t re qu i re d t o m ee t R A C T f o r

NO x a nd a t t h i s tim e w e are no t m a k i n g a d e t er m i n a ti on o f it s a b ili t y t o i m p l e m e n t R A C T.

N on e t h e l e ss, w e no t e t h a t t h ere a r e m u lti p l e r u l e s f o r a i r d i s t r i c t s i n C a li f

o r n i a t h a t h a v e m o re

s t r i n g e n t e mi ss i ons limit s

, i n c l ud i n g E l D o r a do C oun t y AQ M D R u l e 233, S acra m e n t o

M e t r opo lit a n AQ M D R u l e 412 a nd S a n J o a qu i n V a ll e y A PC D R u l e 4702. A dd iti on a l l y

, t h e

A R B R A C T a nd B A RC T D e t er mi n a ti on (N o v e m b er 2001 ) s u g g e s t s m o re s t r i n g e n t limit s a s

R A C T.

C AA §172 (c)( 1 ) re qu i re s non a tt a i n m e n t ar e a s t o im p l e m e n t a ll rea son a b l y a v a il a b l e c on t r o l

m ea su re s, i n c l ud i n g su c h re du c ti ons i n e mi ss i ons fr o m e x i s ti n g sou rce s i n t h e ar e a a s m a y b e

ob t a i n e d t h r ou g h t h e a d o p ti on, a t a mi n im u m , o f R A C T, a s e x p e d iti ous l y a s p rac ti c a b l e

. I C

e n g i n e s ca n e mit d i rec t PM 2 .5 

### , a s w e ll a s S O x

, w h i c h i s a p r e c u r so r t o P M2.5, a nd NO x

, w h i c h i s

1 

### P C A P C D al s o r e g u lat e s a n o n atta i n m e n t a r ea u n d e r t h e 2006 24

- H o u r PM 2

. 5 

### Nati o n al A m b ie n t Ai r Q u al it y

Sta n d a rd ( NAAQS ). 40 C

. F

. R

. § 8 1

. 3 0 5 ( 2 01 0 ). B y Dec e m b e r 14, 20 1 2

, C ali f

or n ia m u s t s u b m it a r e v i s i o n t o t h e

State I m p l e m e n tati o n P la n ( S I P ) f or t h i s n o n a t tai n m e n t a r ea t h at pro v i d e s f or

, a m o ng o t h e r t h i ng s

, i m p l e m e n tati o n

o f all R A C M a s e x p e d iti o u s l y a s pr actica b le ( i n cl u d i n g R A C T f or e x i s ti n g s o u r ce s ). C AA § 17 2 ( a ) ( 2)( A ), (b) &

( c )(1)

, 74 F R 5 8 68 9 ( N o v

. 13

, 200 9 ). E P A w ill t a k e acti o n o n t h i s R A C M d e m o n s t r a t i o n i n a s e p a r ate r u l e m a k i n g

.

### 3

a p rec u r so r t o bo t h P M2.5 a nd o z on e . Th er e f o re

, PC A PC D m us t im p l e m e n t R A C M f o r bo il er s i f

t hos e m ea su re s w ill a d v a n ce a tt a i n m e n t o f t h e N a t i on a l A m b i e n t A i r Q u a lit y S t a nd a r d (NA A Q S )

f o r PM 2 .5 

### o r

o z on e

, w h e n c ons i d ere d c o ll ec ti v e l y w it h o t h er rea so n a b l e m e a su re s. A dd iti on a l

c on t r o l m ea su re s m a y b e re qu i re d pu r s u a n t t o C AA §172 (c ) ( 1 ) i f bo t h : ( 1 ) a dd iti on a l m ea su re s

are r ea son a b l y a v a il a b l e ; a nd ( 2 ) t h e s e a dd iti on a l r ea son a b l y a v a il a b l e m ea s u re s w ill a dv a n c e

a tt a i n m e n t i n t h e ar e a w h e n c ons i d e r e d c o ll ec ti v e l y

. I n s e p a r a t e r u l e m a k i n g s, E P A w ill t a k e

ac ti on on t h e S t a t e’ s R A C M d e m ons t ra ti on f o r P M2.5 a nd o z on e b a s e d o n a n e v a l u a ti on o f t h e

c on t r o l m ea su re s sub mitt e d a s a w ho l e a nd t h e i r o v era ll po t e n ti a l t o a dv a n c e t h e a pp li ca b l e

a tt a i n m e n t d a t e s i n t h e D i s t r i c t

. S ee 40 C F R §§ 5 1 .1010, 51.912 ( d )

. N on e t h e l e ss, w e no t e t h a t t h e

c u rre n t v er s i on o f R u l e 2 42 do e s no t re qu i re cer t a i n c on t r o l m ea su re s f o r I C e n g i n e s i n t h e

PC A PC D t h a t a pp ear t o b e " rea so n a b l y a v a il a b l e " c ons i d er i n g t ec hno l o g i c a l a nd ec ono mi c

fea s i b ili t y

, f

o r t h e r e a so n s c it e d a bov e

.

R ec o r dk e e p i n g a nd o t h e r c o m p li a n ce p r ov i s i ons i n t h e r u l e e nsu r e t h a t t h e re qu i re m e n t s a re

a d e qu a t e l y e n f

o r cea b l e

. L a s t l y , s i n ce t h ere i s c u rr e n t l y no r u l e i n t h e S I P t h a t r e g u l a t e s t h i s

sou rce c a t e g o r y f

o r PC A PC D

, t h e e mi ss i on li m it a ti ons i n t h e sub mitt e d r u l e s t re n g t h e n t h e S I P

. W e p r opos e t o d e t er mi n e t h a t ou r a pp r ov a l o f t h e sub mitt a l w ou l d c o m p l y w it h C AA s ec ti ons

110 ( l ) a nd 193, b e ca us e t h e p r opos e d S I P re v i s i o n w ou l d no t i n t erfere w it h t h e on

- g o i n g p r o ce ss

f o r e nsu r i n g t h a t r e qu i r e m e n t s f o r R F P a nd a tt a i n m e n t o f t h e NAAQ S a re m e t

, a nd t h e sub mitt a l

s t re n g t h e ns t h e S I P a s t h ere i s no r u l e f o r t h i s ca t e g o r y c u rr e n t l y i n t h e S I P a nd w ou l d i nsu re

e qu i v a l e n t o r g r ea t er e mi ss i on re du c ti ons o f NO x

.

Su gg e s te d R u l e I m p r o v e m e n t s

A lt hou g h no t c u r re n t l y b a s i s f o r r u l e d i s a p p r ov a l

, E P A rec o mm e nds t h a t t h e PC A PC D l o w er

e mi ss i on limi t s i n R u l e 2 42 t o b e c ons i s t e n t w it h S ou t h C o a s t R u l e 1110. 2 (a m e nd e d J u l y 9,

2010 ) ) a nd a n a l o g ous r u l e s i n o t h er ar e a s

.

R ec o mme nd a t i o n

E P A s t aff r e c o mm e nds a pp r ov a l o f PC A PC D S ub mitt e d R u l e 242 f o r i n c o r po ra ti on i n t o t h e

C a li f o r n i a A pp li ca b l e S I P

.

O t h er R e f

e r e n ce s

1. S ub mitt e d R u l e 24 2

2. R u l e 242 S t aff R e po r t , d a t e d A p r il 10, 200 3

3. 2006 R A C T S I P U pd a t e A n a l y s i s S t aff R e po r t

## P L AC E R C O UN T Y

A I R P O LL U T I O N C O N T R OL D I S T R I CT



# 20 0 6 R A C T S I P U P D A T E A N A LYS I S

ST A FF R EP O RT

AN ANA L YS I S O F R E A S O NAB L Y

A V A I L AB L E C O N T R OL T E C H N OL O G Y TO

U P DA T E T H E 8

- H O UR O Z O N E S T A T E

I MP L EM E N T A TI O N P L AN F O R P L AC E R

C O UN TY

A u g u s t 1 0

, 2 0 06T h i s P ag e I n t e n t i o n a ll y L e f t B l an k

### T AB L E OF C O N T E N T S

TI T LE P A GE

I N T R O D UC TIO N 5

R E A S O N FO R T H I S A N A L YS I S 5

A C T I O N R E Q U ES T E D B Y U

. S

. EP A 6

A N A L YS I S

D I S T R I C T P L A N N I N G H I S T O R Y 6

P A R T 1

– R A C T S T A ND A R D S 7

P A R T 2

– N E G A T I VE D E C L A R A T I O N S 9

P A R T 3

– S I P A PP R O V A L S T A T U S 1 1

P A R T 4

– S U MM A R Y AN D C O N C L U S I O N S 17

A PPE N D I X:

T a bl e A

- C TG R ul e A n a l y s i s T a bl e w i t h R ul e 1 9

C a t e g o r i e s A s Li s t e d i n U

. S

. EP A L e tt e r to

C A R B

, 4 /

4 / 0 6T h i s P ag e I n t e n t i o n a ll y L e f t B l an k2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 5

I N T R O D U C T I ON

P l a c er C ou n t y i s l o c a t e d i n no r t h ern C a l i f o rni a

, b o rde r i ng S a c rame n t o C o un t y t o t h e w e s t a n d t he

S t a t e o f N e v a da o n t he ea s t

. A ir q ua l i t y a t t a i nm e n t p l an n i ng i s un d er t h e j ur i s d i c t i o n o f t he P l a c e r

Co u n t y A ir Po l l u t i on C o n t rol Di s t r i c t ( Di s t r i c t )

. E l e v a t i o n s ran g e f r om nea r s e a l e v e l i n t he

w e s t er n po r t i o n o f t he C o u n t y t o 9

, 000 f e e t i n t he mo u n t a i n s o f t he S i er r a s

. P l a c e r C o un t y i s t h e

o n l y c ou n t y i n t he s t a t e t h a t i s d i v i d ed i n t o t hre e d i ff ere n t a ir b a s i n s : t he S a c ram e n t o Va l l e y A ir

B a s i n ( S V AB ) ; t h e Mou n t a i n C ou n t i e s A i r B a s i n (MC A B ) ; a nd t he La k e T a ho e A i r Ba s i n (L T A B )

. E a c h a i r b a s i n h a s i t s o w n me t eo r o l o g i c a l an d g eo g rap h i c c o n d i t i on s

. G e n era l l y

, t h e

Me d i t e rr a nea n c lim a t e i n S V A B ha s s um m er s t ha t ar e ho t a n d d r y wi t h t emp e ra t ur e s u s u a ll y i n

t he 90 s

. T he s e h o t an d dr y s umme r s a re c o n du c i v e t o o z o n e f orm a t i o n

. P r e v a ili n g wi n d s f r o m

t he w e s t t ran s p o r t o z o n e f r o m t h e S an F ran c i sc o Ba y A r ea a n d t h e S a c r a men t o Va l l e y i n t o t h e

f oo t h i ll an d mou n t a i n a r ea s.

T h e p o r t i o n s o f P l a c e r C o un t y i n S V A B a nd M C A B a re i n c l u d ed i n t he S a c ram e n t o F ed e ral

O z o ne N on

- A t t a i nme n t A r ea ( S F O N A )

, w h i c h ha s bee n d e s i gn a t e d a s “ s e r i ou s ” no n -a t t a i nmen t

f or t h e 8-h o ur o z o n e N a t i on a l A mbi e n t A ir Q u a li t y S t a n da r d ( N AA Q S )

. B e f or e t he U

. S

. E n v ir o nme n t a l P r o t e c t i on A ge n c y ( U

. S

. E PA ) po s t ed n e w 8

- hou r o z on e de s i g n a t i on s a n d n ona tt a i nm e n t c l a s s i f i c a t i o n s i n J u n e 200 4

, t he S F O N A w a s a “ s e v er e ” n on- a t t a i n men t ar e a f or t he

1

- ho u r o z on e N A A Q S

. A l t h ou g h t h e U

. S

. E P A re v o k e d t he 1

- ho u r o z o n e N A A Q S

, t h e S F O N A

s t i ll r e main s s u b j e c t t o c on t rol m e a s ure c omm i t men t s t h a t a p p li e d und e r t h e 1-h o ur o z o n e

N A A Q S

. T her e f o re

, t he Di s t r i c t i s re s po n s i b l e f or im p l em e n t i ng em i ss i o n s t an d ar d s a n d o t her

r e qu i r emen t s man d a t ed b y t he F e d er a l Cl ea n A ir A c t.

R E A S O N F O R T H I S ANA L Y S IS

S e c t i o n s 1 8 2(b) ( 2) and 1 8 2( f ) o f t h e F e der a l Cl e a n A ir A c t r e qu ir e o z on e no n -a t t a i nme n t a rea s

t o im p l e men t R ea s o n ab l y A v a i l ab l e C o n t rol T e c h n o l o g y (R A C T ) f or s o ur c e s t h a t ar e s ub j e c t t o

C on t ro l T e c h n i q u e s G u i d e li ne ( C T G ) do c um e n t s i ss ued b y U

. S

. E P A a n d f or “Maj o r S ou r c e s ” o f

V o l a t il e O rg a n i c C om p oun d s ( V O C s ) a n d O x i d e s o f Ni t ro g en (N O x )

, w h i c h are o z o ne

pr e c u r s or s

. R A C T r e qu ir e men t s a re i n c l u ded i n t he Cl ea n A ir A c t t o a ss u r e t h a t s i gn i f i c a n t

s our c e c a t eg o rie s a t Majo r So u r c e s a re c on t rol l e d t o a “r e a s on a b l e ” e x t en t

, b u t no t n e c e s s a ril y

t o B e s t A v a il a b l e C o n t r o l T e c hn o l o g y ( B A C T ) or Ma x im u m A c h i e v a b l e C on t ro l T e c h n o l o g y ”

(M A C T ) l e v e l s w h i c h a r e e x p e c t e d o f n e w s our c e s

.

U

. S

. E PA d e f i n e s R A C T a s t he l o w e s t em i ss i o n l i m i t a t i on t ha t a par t i c u l a r s our c e i s c a pa b l e o f

me e t i ng b y t h e a pp l i c a t i on o f t e c h no l o g y ( i

. e

. , d e v i c e s

, s ys t e m s

, p r o c e s s mo d i f i c a t i on

, o r o t he r

a p par a t u s o r t e c h n i qu e s t ha t re d u c e a ir p o ll u t i o n ) t h a t i s re a s o na b l y a v a il a b l e c on s i d e rin g

t e c hn o l og i c a l an d e c ono m i c f e a s i b ili t y

.

A cc ord i ng t o t he U

. S

. E P A ’ s 

### F i na l R u l e t o I m p l e m e n t t he 8

- H ou r O zo n e N A A Q S (70

F R 716 1 2

, N o v e mber 2 9

, 20 0 5) ar e a s c l a s s i f i e d a s mod e ra t e no n -a t t a i nm e n t o r h i g he r mu s t

s ubm i t a dem o n s t ra t i on t ha t t h e ir c u rre n t rul e s f u l f i ll 8 -hou r o z o n e R A C T f o r a ll C T G c a t e g or i e s

a n d a ll Ma j or

, n on- C T G S o ur c e s a s a r e v i s i o n t o t he i r St a t e I m p l em e n t a t i o n P l a n ( S I P )

. S t a t e s

c an dem o n s t ra t e t h a t R A C T i s be i n g m e t wi t h e i t h e r a ne w R A C T de t erm i n a t i o n or a c er t i f i c a t i on

t ha t p r e v i ou s l y r eq u ir ed R A C T c on t rol s r epre s e n t R A C T f or 8- h ou r o z o ne

. A r e a s m a y r e l y on

pr e v i ou s a na l ys e s wri t t e n f o r 1-h o ur o z on e p l a n s a nd U

. S

. E P A gu i da n c e do c um e n t s

. T h e R A C T

S I P s ubm i tt a l i s i n ad d i t i on t o t h e ar e a ’ s 8- h our O z o n e A t t a i nme n t D em o n s t ra t i on P l an

, w h i c h

wil l a l s o be a S I P s u b mi t t a l

. T he R A C T S I P a n a l ys i s mu s t b e s ubm i t t e d t o U

. S

. EP A b y

S e p t em b er 1 5

, 2 00 6

. T h e l a s t R A C T S I P u p da t e b y t he Di s t ri c t w a s c o mple t e d i n 19 9 7

.2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 6

AC T I O N R E Q U E S T E D B Y U .S

. E PA

O n M a r c h 9

, 2 00 6 a nd Ap r il 4

, 2 006

, An d rew S t e ck e l

, U .S

. E P A O ff i c e R u l ema k i n g C h i e f

, s e n t

re q ue s t l e t t er s t o t h e C a li f o rni a A ir R e s our c e s B o ard (C A R B )

. T h e l e t t er s c o n c e rn Di s t ri c t

re q u ir e men t s an d ou t li n ed a po ss i b l e R A C T S I P s ubm i t t a l s t r a t e g y t o d e t e rmin e w h e t h er R A C T

r e qu i r emen t s h a v e be e n m e t

. Di s t ri c t a c t i v i t i e s p e r f o rmed a s a p a r t o f t h i s a na l ys i s a re a s

f o ll o w s :

P a r t 1 R A C T St and a rd s

- I d en t i f y a l l D i s t ri c t r u l e s s u b j e c t t o t h e U

. S

. E P A C o n t rol

T e c hn i q ue s G u i de li n e s (C T G ) s our c e c a t eg o rie s wi t h i n t he Di s t ri c t a n d d e t e rmi n e i f t h e y

me e t R A C T s t an d ar d s

.

P a r t 2 N e ga t i v e D e c l a ra t i o n s

- I d en t i f y a ll C T G c a t e g or i e s f o r w h i c h t h e re are no

f a c ili t i e s i n t h e Di s t ri c t

, a n d s u bm i t N eg a t i v e D e c l a r a t i on s s t a t i n g t h a t t h ere ar e n o s u c h

f a c ili t i e s.

P a r t 3 S I P A pp r o v a l S t a t u s

– I d en t i f y a ll D i s t r i c t rul e s s u b j e c t t o t h e U

. S

. E PA C T G

s ou r c e c a t e g or i e s wi t h i n t h e D i s t ri c t a n d d e t e rmin e i f t h e y m e e t R A C T s t a n da r d s

.

P a r t 4 Su mma r y a nd C o n c l u s i on s

- Su mm a ri z e t he a bo v e pro c e ss e s t h a t t h e Di s t ri c t

u s e d t o : (1 ) d e t erm i n e t h a t t h e Di s t ri c t r e g u l a t i o n s f u l f i l l R A C T

, ( 2 ) d e t e rmin e N e g a t i v e

D e c l a r a t i o n s n ee d ed f o r c e r t a i n C T G c a t e gor i e s

, a n d (3) de t erm i n e w h i c h D i s t ri c t r u l e s

n e ed t o b e s ubm i t t e d t o U

. S

. E P A a s re v i s i o n t o t he S I P

.

T he Di s t ri c t w a s r equ e s t ed t o pr e par e a c o mple t e R A C T S I P u p da t e an a l y s i s

, c o v e rin g Ma j or

S o ur c e s

, non-M a j or S our c e s

, an d no n -C T G Maj o r S o ur c e s

. U

. S

. E P A r eq u ir e s t he Di s t r i c t ’ s

s u b mi t t a l b y Se p t e mbe r 15

, 20 0 6

. I n a dd i t i o n

, t h e Di s t ri c t i s r e qu ir e d t o im p l eme n t a n 8 -ho u r

O z o ne D emo n s t ra t i o n P l a n n o l a t e r t h a n t h e b eg i n n i ng o f t h e f i r s t o z o n e s ea s o n or p or t i on

t her e o f t h a t o cc ur s 3 0 m o n t h s a ft er t he a b o v e s ubm i tt a l d a t e

. T h i s w ou l d be Mar c h 15

, 2 00 9

. S i n c e P l a c e r C ou n t y h a s a f u ll y ear o z one s e a s o n

, t he r eq u ir e d im p l e men t a t i o n d a t e f or t he

Di s t r i c t will b e J a n uar y 1

, 2 0 09. N o t e t ha t t he im p l emen t a t i o n d a t e f o r a n y s our c e ope r a t i ng u nde r

a T i t l e V p e rmi t

, pu r s u an t t o 40 C F R Pa r t 70

, w o u l d b e g o v ern e d b y t h e r e qu i r eme n t s o f t h a t

p e rmi t. T h i s s t a ff r ep o r t r e l a t e s t o t he S ep t em b er 1 5

, 20 0 6 s ubm i t t a l.

ANA L Y S IS

D i st r i ct P l a nn i ng H i s t ory

T o im p r o v e t h e a ir qu a li t y i n P l a c er C o u n t y a n d mo v e t he re g i on t o w ar d s a tt a i n m en t o f t h e

N A A QS

, t h e Di s t ri c t h a s pr e pa r ed a nd a dop t e d s e v era l a ir q ua li t y a tt a i n men t p l an s s i n c e 19 9 1

. T he f o ll o wi n g t ab l e s ummar i z e s t h e Di s t ri c t ’ s a t t a i nme n t p l an s

. T h e D i s t ri c t ha s a l s o a dop t e d

o v e r 100 ne w r u l e s an d ame n dme n t s t o me e t t h e c o mmi t me n t s i n t h e s e a t t a i nm e n t p l an s

. T h e

a i r q ua l i t y i n P l a c er C o un t y h a s g re a t l y im p ro v e d o v er t h e pa s t s e v era l y e ar s a s t he Di s t ri c t h a s

a d op t ed a i r q u a li t y p l an s a nd r egu l a t i on s

. I n a c on t i n u a t i o n o f t h e Di s t r i c t ’ s s t r a t e g y f o r a c h i e v i ng

t he N A A QS

, t h e Di s t r i c t i s w o r k i ng wi t h o t her a i r d i s t ri c t s i n S F O N A t o s ubm i t a n 8- h our o z o ne

a tt a i n men t de m on s t ra t i o n p l a n t o U

. S

. E P A b y J u n e 1 5

, 2 00 7

, a s s pe c i f i ed b y f e de r a l

r e q u ir e men t s.

T he p l an n i n g h i s t o r y i s pro v i d ed t o s ho w t h a t Di s t r i c t ru l e s and re g u l a t i o n s ha v e b e en c o n t i nu a ll y

u n der r e v i e w a n d h a v e be e n u p da t ed on a n o n go i n g b a s i s s i n c e 1 9 92 t o i n c orp o ra t e ne w

r e g u l a t or y m e a s ure s f o r em i ss i on s o u r c e s o r t o am e nd e x i s t i ng r u l e s t o i n c re a s e t h e s t ri n gen cy o f

t he c o n t r o l m e a s ur e s

, i n k ee p i ng wi t h t e c hn o l o g y im p r o v eme n t s

. T h e s e r e v i e w s an d upd a t e s

h a v e b ee n ma n da t e d b y S t a t e a nd F ed e ral a i r q u a li t y p l a nn i n g re q u ir e men t s

. S i n c e t he p r e v i ou s

R A C T S I P a na l y s i s w a s c om p l e t ed i n 199 7

, a n u mbe r o f r u l e s w er e a do p t e d or u p da t e d

.2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 7

Di s t r i c t O z o ne P l a nn i n g Hi s t o ry

T i t l e B o a r d A dop t i on

1 9 91 P l a c er C o un t y A i r Q u a li t y A t t a i n me n t P l an Ma r c h 19 9 2

1 9 94 O z o ne A tt a i nm e n t D emon s t ra t i o n P l a n D e c em b er 1 9 94

1 9 97 T rie n n i a l P ro g re ss R e por t J u l y 19 9 8

1 9 99 S a c r ame n t o A re a R e g i o n a l Mile s t on e R epo r t * A p ril 2 0 00

2 0 00 T rie n n i a l P ro g re ss R e por t A p ril 2 0 01

2 0 02 S a c rame n t o A re a R e g i o n a l Mil e s t o n e R ep o r t * Ma y 2 0 03

2 0 03 T rie n n i a l P rog r e s s R e p or t O c t ob e r 20 0 5

S a c r ame n t o R e g i o n a l N on

- a t t a i nmen t A r ea 8- H o ur O z o ne

R a t e-o f

- P rogr e s s P l an F eb r ua r y 2 0 06

* A reg i ona l p ro g re ss rep o r t t h a t d o e s no t re q u ir e Bo a rd a d op t i o n

P a r t 1

– RAC T S t a n d a r d s : I d e n t i f y a l l D i s t r i c t ru l e s s ub j ect t o t h e U

. S

. E P A C T G s our ce

c a te gor i e s w i t h i n t h e D i st r i ct a nd d et e r m i n e i f t h e y m e et RAC T sta nd a r d s.

T h i s Di s t ri c t ana l y s i s c om p are d t he c u r ren t P rohi b i t or y R u l e s (Re g u l a t i o n 2 i n t h e D i s t ri c t R u l e

B o o k ) t o c u r ren t U

. S

. E PA gu i d an c e s t an d ar d s f o r em i ss i o n c o n t r o l m e a s ur e

. T h e pur p o s e o f

t h i s w o r k w a s t o : (1 ) de t erm i ne i f t he Di s t ri c t h ad a n a d op t ed rule f o r t he s o u r c e c a t eg o r y

, ( 2)

d e t e r mine i f t he rule’ s c o n t rol mea s ur e s s a t i s f i e d t h e re q u ir em e n t s o f t he U

. S

. E P A ’ s c o n t r o l

m e a s u re s t an d ard

, and (3 ) d e t e rmine i f a n e w rule will n e ed t o b e a do p t e d f o r e x i s t i ng e mi s s i on

s our c e s

. T h e s t a nda r d s c ompar e d w e r e C o n t r o l T e c hn i que s G u i de l i ne s (C T G ) a nd A l t e r na t e

C on t r o l T e c hn i q u e s ( A C T ) G u i d a n c e

. C A R B ’ s A l l F e a s i b l e Mea s ur e s ( A F M) h a v e a l s o b e en

i n c l u de d b y S t a f f, s i n c e a num b er o f t h e r u l e c a t ego r i e s do no t ha v e C T G s and or A C Ts

. T he

u l t im a t e pur p o s e o f t h i s s t u d y i s t he d e t e rmin a t i o n b y t h e Di s t r i c t o f w h e t h e r t h e Di s t ri c t ha s

e x i s t i n g a do p t e d rul e s t h a t m e e t o r e xc ee d t h e s t a n dar d s i n t h e c urr e n t C T G s

, A C Ts

, a n d A F M s.

T o d e t e rmin e i f Di s t ri c t rul e s f u l f i l l R A C T r e q u i r eme n t s

, S t a f f u s e d t h e f o ll o w i ng g u i d e li n e s :

Di s t ri c t rul e s t h a t ha v e b e en S I P

- a pp r o v ed b y U

. S

. E P A a re c on s i d e red t o mee t R A C T

r e qu i r emen t s b e c au s e U

. S

. E P A e v a l u a t e d t he r u l e s t o d e t e rmi n e i f t h e y f u l f ill R A C T

e s t ab l i s h ed b y C T G s

, ( A C T s ) an d U

. S

. E P A gu i d e li n e s an d po l i c i e s

. T h e re f o r e

, a n y E P A

S I P

- app r o v ed Di s t ri c t r u l e s are s a i d t o ha v e m e t R A C T req u ir e men t s

.

A s a n on- a t t a i n men t ar e a f o r t h e C a l i f o r n i a o z o n e s t a nda r d

, t h e Di s t ri c t i s req u ir ed b y

C a l i f o r n i a H ea l t h an d S a f e t y C ode (CH & S C) S e c t i o n s 4 0 914 ( a)(2 ) a n d 4 092 0

. 6 ( a) t o

im p l e men t “ A l l F ea s i b l e C on t rol M e a s ure s ” ( A F CM) a nd “ B e s t A v a il a b l e R e t ro f i t C o n t r o l

T e c h n o l o g y ” ( B A RC T )

. I n gen e ral

, A F CM and B A RC T re q u ir e men t s a r e m ore s t r i nge n t

t ha n t h o s e p r e v i ou s l y e s t a b li s h e d b y C T G s an d A C Ts

. T h e re f or e

, Di s t r i c t r u l e s t h a t

im p l eme n t e d A F CM a n d B A RC T a re s a i d t o f u l f i l l R A C T re q u ir e men t s

.

A ll C T G em i s s i on s o u r c e c a t ego r i e s w er e c om p ar e d a ga i n s t e x i s t i n g a d op t ed Di s t r i c t

ru l e s a n d a f i nd i n g w a s mad e r e gar d i ng w he t h e r t h e a d op t e d r u l e me t o r e xc ee d ed t he

a p p li c ab l e C T G R A C T req u ir em e n t s o r A F M re q u ir e men t s

. A ll A C Ts w e r e e v a l ua t ed t o2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 8

d e t e r mine w he t h e r M a j or S o ur c e s e x i s t i n t h e s ou r c e c a t e gor y a nd i f s o

, w he t he r or n o t

a Di s t ri c t r u l e s a t i s f y i ng A C T g u i de l i ne s h a s b ee n a do p t e d

.

T a b l e A

, p ro v i d e d a s a n A p pe n d i x t o t h i s r epo r t

, li s t s a ll U

. S

. E P A s ou r c e c a t e g or i e s r e que s t ed

, b o t h M a j or a nd n o n-Ma j or

, and t h e c o rre s p o nd i n g C T G

, A C T

, a n d A F M wi t h de t a i l s o f ea c h rul e

or c a t e g or y

. F o r ea c h l i s t e d rul e

, T a b l e A s h o w s t h e S t a ff ’ s de t erm i na t i o n i f t h a t r u l e m ee t s

c urr e n t R A C T r e qu ir e men t s

. A ll t h e ad o p t ed r u l e s h a v e b e en f o u nd t o s a t i s f a c t o r il y me e t R A C T

re q u ir e men t s.

T ab l e A s h o w s t ha t t her e ar e rule c a t ego r i e s l i s t ed i n t he Ap r il 4

, 2 0 06 U

. S

. E PA l e tt er f or w h i c h

n o s o u r c e s c u r ren t l y e x i s t i n t he Di s t r i c t

. T he a b s e n c e o f s our c e s o f t he s e c a t e gor i e s w a s

d e t e rmin e d b y S t a ff

, b a s e d o n a s t ud y o f t h e D i s t ri c t p erm i t b a s e

, c l a ss i f i ed ph o ne li s t i ng s

, pub l i c

no t i c e s

, n e w b u s i n e s s li c en s e re q ue s t s a n d pe r s o n a l k no wl e dge ( Se e Pa r t 2

, b e l o w w h i c h

d i sc u ss e s N eg a t i v e D e c l ara t i o n s ) S t a f f a l s o n o t e d t h a t t h e Di s t ri c t h a s o ne ne w no n -Maj o r

S o ur c e i n a C T G c a t e go r y (M e t a l P ar t s a n d P ro d u c ts ) t ha t h a s n o rul e a t t h i s t im e

. T he D i s t ri c t

R A C T S I P s u bm i t t a l pro c e s s will i n c l ud e t h e re q u ir e m en t t h a t an app r opr i a t e r u l e be wri t t e n

,

a d op t ed and app r o v ed s u b s eq u en t t o t h i s R A C T SI P s t u d y

, b u t n o l a t e r t h a n t h e P l a c e r C o u n t y

R A C T im p l em e n t a t i o n d a t e o f J an u ar y 1

, 2 0 09

.

T a b l e A p r o v i de s a n o v er v i e w o f t he r e l a t i on s h i p be t w ee n s o ur c e c a t eg o rie s

, U

. S

. E P A C T G S

a n d A T C s

, C A R B A F M s

, e x i s t i n g Di s t r i c t s o u r c e s

, Di s t ri c t T i t l e V s our c e s

, and ado p t e d Di s t ri c t

R u l e s an d ame n dme n t

, a n d A p p li c a b l e S I P A p pro v a l d a t e s

. I n d i v i d u a l f i nd i n g s f r o m T a b l e A ar e

gr o up e d t o p i c a ll y a n d s ho w n i n T a b l e s “ B ” t h rou g h “D”.

F or T a b l e A

, s e e t h e Ap p en d i x t o t h i s r ep o r t

.

Ma j or S ou r c es :

T he f o ll o wi ng T a b l e B li s t s t h e Majo r S ou r c e s t ha t ar e c u rr e n t l y i n t h e Di s t ri c t.

T a b l e B

- Ma j or S ou r c es

- P l a ce r A i r P o ll u t i o n a n d C on t ro l D i s t r i ct

Sou r ce Source Categor y Po l lutant Rul e No. Rule Title L o c at i on /

Comments

Fiberboard

Manufacturing VO C 229 Fiberboard

Manufacturing SierraPine

Ltd.

( T itle V) Boilers, Steam

Generators and

Process H eaters NO x 232 Biomass Suspension

Boilers Rocklin ( S ource

wa s Major in

VOC, before

recent installation

of n e w contr o ls.)

Paper and

Fabrics VO C 230 Plastic Produ c t s and

Materials - Paper

T reating Operations Formica

Corp. ( T itle

V) Boilers, Steam

Generators and

Process H eaters NO X 241 Boilers a t Plastic

Laminating Mfg.

Facilities Rocklin ( S ource

plans to c l o se

permanentl y

in

near f u ture)

Sierra

Pacific

Industries

( T itle V) Boilers, Steam

Generators and

Process H eaters NO X 23 3 Biomass Boilers Lincoln

Rio Bravo

( T itle V) Boilers, Steam

Generators and

Process H eaters NO X 23 3 Biomass Boilers Lincoln2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 9

T a b l e B

- Ma j or S ou r c es

- P l a ce r A i r P o ll u t i o n a n d C on t ro l D i s t r i ct

Sou r ce Source Categor y Po l lutant Rul e No. Rule Title L o c at i on /

Comments

Pacific

MDF

Products

(Pending

T itle V) Factor y Coat i n g

of F l at w ood

Paneli ng VO C 238 Factor y Coating of

Flat w o o d Pane l ing Rocklin

Pabco dba

Gladding

MacBean

(Pending

T itle V) Surface Coating VO C 240 Surface Preparation

and Cleanu p Lincoln

A l l Majo r St a t i on a r y S o u r c e s

, i n c l ud i n g Maj o r n o n- C T G S o ur c e s ha v e a d op t ed Di s t r i c t r u l e s t h a t

s a t i s f y R A C T r e qu i rem e n t s

.

P a r t 2

- N e g a t i v e D e c l a r a t i on s : I d e n t i f y a l l C T G c ate gor i e s f o r w h i c h t h e r e a r e no f a c i l i t i es

i n t h e D i s t r i c t

, a nd s ub m i t N e g a t i v e D ec l a r at i on s s t at i n g t h a t t h e r e a r e no s u c h

f a c i l i t i es.

B a c k g r ound

D u e t o t h e d e s i gn a t i o n o f p or t i o n s o f P l a c e r C o u n t y a s “m o der a t e ” o r ab o v e n on- a t t a i n men t f o r

o z o n e

, S e c t i on s 18 2 (b)( 2 ) an d 182 ( f ) o f t he F e der a l C A A re q u ir e t h e Di s t r i c t t o s u bm i t a re v i s i o n

t o t he St a t e I mpl e men t a t i o n P l an ( S I P ) t o i mpl e me n t R A C T f or ea c h c a t e go r y o f V o l a t il e O rga n i c

C omp o und ( V O C) or Ni t rog e n O x i de (N O x ) s o u r c e s c o v e red b y a C T G d o c u men t and f o r a n y

Ma j or St a t i on a r y S o ur c e no t c o v e re d b y a C T G d o c u men t. T h e S a c rame n t o V a l l e y A ir B a s i n a n d

t he M o un t a i n C oun t i e s A ir B a s i n p o r t i on s o f t he Di s t ri c t ar e p ar t o f t h e S a c ram e n t o F e de r a l

O z o ne N o n

- A t t a i nm e n t A rea ( S F O N A ) w h i c h i s de s i g na t e d a s “ s e v ere ” n on

- a t t a i nmen t f or o z o n e

.

R A C T r equ i re s t ha t a ll n o n-a tt a i nm e n t ar e a s c l a ss i f i ed a s “mo d era t e” o r abo v e h a v e R A C T i n

p l a c e f or s o ur c e c a t e g or i e s c o v e red b y a C on t ro l T e c h n i q u e s G u i d e li n e (C T G ) d o c u men t an d f o r

Maj o r S o ur c e s t ha t ar e no t s ub j e c t t o a C T G (i

. e

. a “Maj o r n on- C T G S o ur c e” )

. A “M a j or So u r c e”

o f V O C s or N O x i n P l a c er C ou n t y i s d e f i n ed a s a n em i s s i o n s o ur c e ha v i n g a p o t en t i a l t o e mi t o f

2 5 t o n s o f t he p o ll u t a n t p e r y e ar

. T h e A ir Di s t r i c t mu s t a do p t t he c on t rol mea s u r e s f or a s o ur c e

c a t ego r y i f i t ha s a s ou r c e o f e mi s s i o n s l o c a t e d wi t h i n t h e non

- a t t a i nme n t ar e a t h a t i s s u b j e c t t o a

C T G

. A l t er n a t i v e l y

, i f t he f i n d i n g i s ma d e t h a t t her e a re no e x i s t i n g s ou r c e s t h a t em i t t h e

d e s i g na t e d po l l u t an t s i n i t s a rea s u b j e c t t o a R A C T re q u ir e men t, t h e D i s t ri c t ma y ma k e a

n e ga t i v e de c l a r a t i on t o t h i s e f f e c t a n d c on s e q uen t l y t h e re q u ir e men t t o ado p t a r u l e f or t ho s e

s ou r c e s i s n o t a p p li c a b l e

. T h i s p ro c e ss i s c a ll ed “N e ga t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n”

.

T he Di s t ri c t i s re q u ir e d t o s u b mi t N eg a t i v e D e c l a ra t i o n s f or a ll C T G c a t e g or i e s f or w h i c h t h e re a re

n o s o u r c e s a b o v e t he C T G r e c o mmend e d t hr e s h o l d

, e v e n i f s u c h n e ga t i v e d e c l ar a t i o n s w er e

ma d e f or a n e a rlie r S I P

. T h i s i s ne c e ss ar y s i n c e t h ere ma y b e s our c e s i n t h e no n -a t t a i nme n t

a r ea t h a t pre v i ou s l y d i d n o t e x i s t

. A l s o

, i f t h e b oun d ar i e s o f t h e no n -a t t a i nme n t a r ea ha v e

e x p a nd e d

, t h e re ma y b e s o u r c e s i n t he ne w po r t i o n o f t h e n o n-a tt a i nm e n t a r ea w h i c h s h ou l d n o t

b e o v er l o o k ed.

T he D i s t ri c t mu s t a l s o s ubm i t a N e ga t i v e D e c l a ra t i o n t o c e r t i f y t ha t t h e re are n o M a j or no n -C T G

S o ur c e s i n t h e n on

- a t t a i nme n t a r ea

.

T he N e ga t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n m u s t g o t hr o ug h t he s a me p ub li c r e v i e w r e qu i r emen t s a s a n y o t he r S I P

s u b mi t t a l.2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 0

N e g a t i v e D ec l a r a t i on F i nd i ng s a nd S t a ff R e c o mm e nd at i on s

T h e Di s t ri c t S t a f f r e v i e w ed p erm i t da t a b a s e s

, S I C c o de s

, b u s i n e ss li c en s e ap p li c a t i on s

, t e l e p hon e l i s t i n g s

, o t he r s o u r c e da t a an d t he em i ss i o n i n v e n t o r y f o r i t s F ed e ral Cl ea n A i r P l a n

,

a n d h a s d e t erm i n ed t h a t t h e re a r e n o Majo r S t a t i on a r y s our c e s o r em i t t i n g f a c i l i t i e s f or t he C T G

c a t eg o rie s li s t ed b e l o w i n T a b l e C.

P l a c er C oun t y A ir Di s t ri c t B oa r d R e s o l u t i o n s # 9 7-3 3 and # 97- 3 4 s t a t e d t h a t t h e re w e r e no M a j or

S o ur c e s t o re g u l a t e f or VO C o r N O x i n a t o t a l o f t w e l v e s ou r c e c a t e gor i e s (7 V O C s ou r c e

c a t eg o rie s

, 5 N O x s our c e c a t ego r i e s )

. T h e n ega t i v e f i nd i n g s w e re ma d e a s p a r t o f a R A C T S I P

a n a l ys i s f o l l o wi n g t h e i ss ua n c e b y U

. S

. E PA o f de f i c i e n c y f i n d i n g s i n 1 9 94 f o r a ll o f C a li f or n i a ’ s

1 5 % R a t e

- o f

- P r o gr e s s P l an s

, i n c l u d i n g t ha t o f P l a c e r C o u n t y

. T h e N e ga t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n s f or

t he s e t w e l v e r u l e c a t eg o rie s w er e l a t er app r o v ed b y t h e U

. S

. E P A i n F e d era l R e g i s t e r N o t i c e F R

5 0 76 6

, Se p t e mbe r 2 3

, 1 99 8

. T he U

. S

. EP A c omm e n t e d t ha t a t h ir t ee n t h N e g a t i v e D e c l a r a t i on

c a t eg o r y ( S y n t he t i c O r g an i c C h e mi c a l Man u f a c t ur i n g I nd u s t r y

- Di s t ill a t i o n ) n e ed e d t o be ado p t e d

b y t he Di s t ri c t B o ar d.

S t a ff h a s rea ff irm e d t ha t t h e re a re n o e x i s t i n g Ma j or S our c e s o f e mi s s i o n s i n t he s e t w e l v e (12 )

ru l e c a t ego r i e s a n d t he N eg a t i v e D e c l a r a t i o n s f or bo t h ne w an d a f f irm e d r u l e c a t ego r i e s s h o u l d

b e s u b mi t t e d t o U

. S

. E P A f o r a p p ro v a l

. T he t w e l v e N e ga t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n rul e c a t e gor i e s

, i n c l u d i n g d a t e s a p pro v e d

, ar e li s t e d i n t he f o ll o wi n g T a b l e C

. Se v e n t e en (1 7 ) o t he r r u l e

c a t eg o rie s

, i n c l ud i n g t h e “ S y n t h e t i c O r ga n i c C h em i c a l Ma n u f a c t u rin g I n d u s t r y

– Di s t ill a t i o n”

c a t e g or y n o t e d b y U

. S

. EP A

, w er e f o un d t o h a v e n o e x i s t i ng M a j or So u r c e s i n t h e Di s t r i c t. T h e

Di s t r i c t d oe s n o t a n t i c i p a t e Maj o r So u r c e s i n t he s e r u l e c a t e go r i e s i n t he f u t u re

. S t a f f will s u bm i t

t he s e t w e n t y

- n i ne (29 ) N eg a t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n s f o r pu b li c c omme n t

, a n d Di s t ri c t B o ard

c on s i d era t i o n a n d ap p ro v a l

. I f app r o v ed b y t he Di s t r i c t B o ard t he N e g a t i v e D e c l a r a t i on s will be

s ubm i t t e d t o C A R B f or f o rwar d i n g t o U

. S

. E P A a s r eq u e s t e d r e v i s i on s t o t he S t a t e

I mpl e men t a t i o n P l a n.

Table C

- District N egati v e D e clarati o n Sub m ittal Requ i rements

Rule Title Date

Su b mitted Board

Res o lution Po l lutant

U

. S. EP A Source Categ o ries That N e e d to Ha v e Pre v ious Negati v e Declarations A f f irmed

1 Aerospace 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

2 Plastic Parts Coating - Business

Machines 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

3 Plastic P a rts Coating - Other 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

4 Ships 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

5 S y nthetic Organic Chemical

Manufacturing

- Batch Plants 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

6 S y nthetic Organic Chemical

Manufacturing

- Reactors 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

7 Utilit y

Boilers 10/9/9 7 97-3 4 NOx

8 Cement K i l n s 10/9/9 7 97-3 4 NOx

9 Glass T reat m ent 10/9/9 7 97-3 4 NOx

10 Iron and S t e e l Manufacturing 10/9/9 7 97-3 4 NOx

11 Nitric and Adipic Acid

Manufacturing 10/9/9 7 97-34 NOx2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 1

Table C

- District N egati v e D e clarati o n Sub m ittal Requ i rements

Rule Title Date

Su b mitted Board

Res o lution Po l lutant

12 Industrial W aste Water Treat m ent 10/9/9 7 97-3 3 VOC

Other U.S. E P A

So u rce Categories T hat Need to Ha v e F i rst-Time Negati v e D eclarations

1 S y nthetic Organic Chemical

Manufacturing, Distillation N/A N/A VOC

2 Large Appliances N/A N/A VOC

3 Magnet W ire N/A N/A VOC

4 Metal Furniture N/A N/A VOC

5 T raffic Marking N/A N/A VOC

6 Natural Gas/Gasoline Plants N/A N/A VOC

7 Refineries N/A N/A VOC

8 Bakeries N/A N/ A VOC

9 Eth y lene Oxide N/A N/ A VOC

10 Fertilizer N/A N/ A VOC

11 Ink and Paint Manufacturing N/A N/ A VOC

12 Leather T anning N/A N/ A VOC

13 Pesticides N/A N/ A VOC

14 Pharmaceutical Products N/ A N/

A VOC

15 Pol y ester Resin (Manufacturing) N/ A N/

A VOC

16 Rubber T ires N/ A N/

A VOC

17 Sulfuric A c i d N/ A N/

A VOC

P a r t 3

- S I P A p p ro va l S tat u s : I d e n t i f y a l l D i st r i c t ru l es s ub j e ct t o t h e U

. S

. E P A C T G s ou r c e

c a te gor i e s w i t h i n t h e D i st r i ct a nd d et e r m i n e i f t h e y m e et RAC T sta nd a r d s.

T he c u r ren t s t a t u s o f ea c h o f t he t h ir t y

- t w o (3 2 ) Di s t r i c t p r oh i b i t o r y rul e s t h a t p r e v i ou s l y w er e

a d op t ed f o r C T G /

A C T / A F M s o u r c e c a t eg o rie s w a s r e v i e w ed an d i s d i s p l a y e d i n t h e f o ll o wi n g

t ab l e s

. T h i s S I P s t a t u s s t u d y w a s n e c e s s a r y i n or d er t o de t e r mine w h i c h rule s

, i f an y

, n ee d ed t o

b e s u bm i t t e d o r r e

- s ubm i tt ed f o r S I P ap p ro v a l b y U

. S

. E P A

. T h e f o l l o wi n g l i s t s t h e S IP s t a t u s

c a t eg o rie s t ha t w er e e x am i n e d :

a

. R u l e s t h a t w e re s ub m i t t e d a nd a ppr o v ed f or S IP

. b

. R u l e s t h a t w ere s ubm i tt ed an d a ppr o v e d f or S IP a n d t h a t m u s t be r e

- s ubm i t t ed

f or a p pro v a l b e c au s e o f am e ndm e n t s t ha t p o s t

- d a t e d t h e S I P a p pr o v a l

.

c

. R u l e s t ha t h a v e no t y e t b e en s u b mi t t e d f or S I P a pp r o v a l

. d

. R u l e s t ha t w ere s ubm i t t ed f or S I P a p pro v a l a n d w h i c h a re a w a i t i n g ap p ro v a l

. (No n e w er e i n t h i s c a t e go r y ).

S t a ff e x am i ne d t h e a d op t i o n da t e s o f t he a b o v e r u l e s

, a nd t h e da t e s o f t he l a t e s t a men d me n t s

, i f

a n y

. T he n t h e d a t e o f S I P ap p ro v a l w a s c o mpar e d wi t h t he r u l e a d op t i o n h i s t o rie s

. A n y rul e t ha t

w a s l a s t ame n de d s i x m o n t h s t o a y ea r be f or e t he F ede r a l R e g i s t er S I P a pp r o v a l da t e w a s

c on s i d ere d t o n o t ne e d S I P r e s u bm i t t a l

. I n s ome c a s e s t he d a t e s w e re c l o s e a n d S t a f f

re s e ar c he d t he S I P ap p ro v a l re c o r d s t o de t erm i n e i f t h e rule

, a s c ur r en t l y ame n de d w a s t h e on e

t ha t w a s e x a mine d an d ap p ro v e d b y U

. S

. E P A

.2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 2



### T a b l e D

- 1

- D i s t r i c t R u l e H i s t o r y ( V O C a nd N O x ) a n d S I P A pp r o va l S t a t u s:

T ab l e D- 1 li s t s t h e ad o p t i on h i s t or y o f t h e D i s t ri c t r u l e s ( V O C and N O x ) a nd t h e ir S I P a p pr o v a l

s t a t u s

. T h e y are l i s t e d b y ru l e num b er. R u l e 2 27 ( P e t rol e um Dr

y Cl e a n i n g O pe r a t i on s ) i s o m i t t e d

s i n c e t here a re no s o u r

c e s i n t h e D i s t ri c t

. Dr y Cl e ane r

s i n t he Di s t ri c t no w u s e P er

c h l o r oe t h y l en e

( P E RC) s o l v

e n t

, w h i c h i s e x e m p t ed f ro m t he VO C c l

a ss i f i c a t i o n

. P E RC reg u l

a t i on s are i

n c l u d ed

i n a M A C T s t an d ard. T h e r i gh t h an d c o l u mn i nd i c a t e s i f t h e Di s t r i c t mu s t re- s u b mi t a n y e x i s t i n g

ru l e t h a t w a s am e nde d a f t er t he l a t e s t d a t e o f S I P a pp r o v a l

, i n or d er t o e n s u re t ha t t h e re v i e w wi l l

b e ba s e d u po n t h e mo s t c u rre n t a m endm e n t o f t h a t r u l e

. S t a ff re c om m en d s t h a t t he s e S I P

s ubm i t t a l s be f oun d e x e mp t f rom t he C a li f o r n i a E n v i ro n men t a l Q u a li t y A c t (C E Q A )

. T h e

pr o po s e d s ubm i tt a l s ar e e x emp t f rom C E Q A a s p e r T i t l e 1 4

, C a l f o rni a C ode o f R e gu l a t i on s

, C h a p t er 3

, A r t i c l e 1 9

, S e c t i o n 153 0 8

, A c t i o n s b y R eg u l a t or y A ge n c i e s f or t h e P r o t e c t i o n o f t h e

E n v ir o nme n t.



### T a b l e D

- 1

- D i s t r i c t R u l e H i s t o r y ( V O C a nd N O x ) a n d S I P A pp r o va l S t a t us

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

-

F R C i t at i o n N e w SI P

A pp r o va

l

R e qu i re

d?

206 Incinerator

Burning NO x N o 11/12/7 4 11/3/94 11/15/78 43

FR 53035 Y

209 Fossil F uel

- S team

Facilit y NO x N o 11/12/7 4 5/24/77 6/14/78 - 43

FR 25684 N

212 Storage of

Organic Liquids VO C N o 5/24/7 7 6/19/97 5/6/96 - 61

FR 20145 Y

213 Gasoline T ransfer

into Statio n ar y Storage

Containers VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 10/19/93 4/30/97

- 62

FR 23365 N

214 T ransfer of

Gasoline into

Vehicle Fuel

T anks VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 4/21/81 4/30/97 - 62

FR 23365 N

215 T ransfer of

Gasoline into

T ank T rucks,

T railers and

Railr o ad Tank

Cars at Loa d i ng

Facilities VO C Ye s 6/19/79 Not

amended 5/6/96 - 61 FR

20145 Y

216 Organic Solve n t

Clean i ng and

Degreasi ng

Operations VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 12/11/03 4/30/96 - 61

FR 18962 Y

217 Cutback and

Emulsified Asphalt

Paving Materials VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 9/25/90 4/30/97

- 62

FR 23365 N

218 Architectural

Coatings VO C N o 6/19/7 9 12/13/01 7/18/96 - 61

FR 37390 Y

21 9 Organic Solvents VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 5/20/85 4/30/97 - 62

FR 23365 N2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 3



### T a b l e D

- 1

- D i s t r i c t R u l e H i s t o r y ( V O C a nd N O x ) a n d S I P A pp r o va l S t a t us

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

-

F R C i t at i o n N e w SI P

A pp r o va

l

R e qu i re

d?

222 Reduction of

Animal Matter N/ A N/

A 6/19/79 Not

amended 4/30/97 - 62

FR 23365 N

22 3 Metal Can Coating VO C Ye s 9/25/9 0 10/6/94 3/23/95 - 60

FR 15241 N

225 Wood F i r ed

Appliances N/ A N/

A 6/17/86 Not

amended 4/30/97 - 62

FR 23365 N

226 Sulfur C ontent of

Fuels ( T ahoe

Onl y ) N/ A N/

A 6/19/7 9 10/19/93 4/30/97 - 62

FR 23365 N

229 Fiberboard

Manufacturing VO C N o 6/28/94 Not

amended 6/8/01 - 66 FR

30815 N

230 Plastic P roducts

and Materials -

Paper T reating

Operation VO C Ye s 6/28/94 Not

amended 12/14/94 - 59

FR 64336 N

231 Industrial,

Institutional, an d

Commercial

Boilers, Steam

Generators, and

Process H eaters NO x N o 10/17/9 4 10/9/9 7 Not Submitted Y

232 Biomass

Suspension

Boilers NO x N o 10/6/9 4 12/9/9 9 Not Submitted Y

23 3 Biomass Boilers NO x N o 10/6/94 Not

amended 4/30/96 - 61

FR 18959 N

234 Automotive

Refinish i ng

Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 4/9/9 8 Not submitted Y

23 5 Adhesive s VO C N o 6/8/9 5 4/8/04 7/18/96 - 61

FR 37390 Y

236 Wood Products

Coating

Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 8/14/97 4/30/96 - 61

FR 18962 Y

23 7 Municipal Landfills VO C N o 11/3/9 4 10/9/0 3 Not submitted Y

238 Factor y Coating of

Flat w o o d Pane l ing VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 2/18/04 2/12/96 - 61

FR 5288 Y

239 Graphic Arts

Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 4/8/04 11/13/98 63

FR 63410 Y

240 Surface

Preparation and

Clean up VO C N o 6/8/9 5 12/11/0 3 Not submitted Y

241 Boilers a t Plastic

Laminate

Manufacturing

Facilities NO x N o 4/8/99 Not

Amended Not sub m itted Y

242 Stationar y Internal

Combustion

Engines NO x N o 4/10/03 Not

Amended Not sub m itted Y2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 4



### T a b l e D

- 1

- D i s t r i c t R u l e H i s t o r y ( V O C a nd N O x ) a n d S I P A pp r o va l S t a t us

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

-

F R C i t at i o n N e w SI P

A pp r o va

l

R e qu i re

d?

243 Pol y ester Resin

Operations VO C Ye s 4/10/03 Not

Amended Not sub m itted Y

244 Semiconductor

Operations VO C N o 2/9/95 Not

Amended 7/25/96 - 61

FR 38571 N

246 Natural Gas-Fired

Water Heaters NO x N o 6/19/97 Not

Amended Not sub m itted Y

250 Stationar y Gas

T urbines NO x N o 10/17/94 Not

Amended 8/23/95 - 60

FR 43713 N



### D i s t r i c t R u l es W h i c h We r e S I P

- A pp r o ve d a nd D o N ot R e qu i r e R e

- Sub m i t t a l :

T ab l e D- 2 li s t s r u l e s t ha t w ere s u b mi t t ed f or S I P a f t e r t h e ir l a t e s t ame n dme n t d a t e a n d a pp r o v ed

. T he s e f o ur t ee n (1 4 ) rul e s h a v e be e n i n c or p ora t e d i n t o t he S I P and w i ll no t r e qu i r e re s u bm i t t a l f or

S I P a t t h i s t im e

.



### T a b l e D

- 2

- D i s tr i c t R u l es W h i c h We r e S I P

- A pp r o ve d a nd D o N ot R e qu i r e R eSub m i t t al

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t ro l l ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

- F R

C i tat i on N e w SI P

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

209 Fossil F uel

- S team

Facilit y NO x N o 11/12/7 4 5/24/77 6/14/78 -

43 FR

25684 N

213 Gasoline T ransfer

into Statio n ar y Storage

Containers VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 10/19/93 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

214 T ransfer of

Gasoline into

Vehicle Fuel

T anks VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 4/21/81 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

217 Cutback and

Emulsified Asphalt

Paving Materials VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 9/25/90 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

21 9 Organic Solvents VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 5/20/85 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

222 Reduction of

Animal Matter N/ A N/

A 6/19/79 Not

Amended 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

223 Metal Can

Coating VO C Ye s 9/25/9 0 10/6/94 3/23/95

-

60 FR

15241 N

225 Wood F i r ed

Appliances N/ A N/

A 6/17/86 Not

Amended 4/30/97

-

62 FR N2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 5



### T a b l e D

- 2

- D i s tr i c t R u l es W h i c h We r e S I P

- A pp r o ve d a nd D o N ot R e qu i r e R eSub m i t t al

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t ro l l ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

- F R

C i tat i on N e w SI P

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

23365

226 Sulfur C ontent of

Fuels ( T ahoe

Onl y ) N/ A N/

A 6/19/7 9 10/19/93 4/30/97

-

62 FR

23365 N

229 Fiberboard

Manufacturing VO C N o 6/28/94 Not

Amended 6/8/01

-

66 FR

30815 N

230 Plastic P roducts

and Materials -

Paper T reating

Operation VO C Ye s 6/28/94 Not

Amended 12/14/94 -

59 FR

64336 N

23 3 Biomass Boilers NO x N o 10/6/94 Not

Amended 4/30/96

-

61 FR

18959 N

244 Semiconductor

Operations VO C N o 2/9/95 Not

Amended 7/25/96

-

61 FR

38571 N

250 Stationar y Gas

T urbines NO x N o 10/17/94 Not

Amended 8/23/95

-

60 FR

43713 N



### D i s t r i c t R u l es W h i c h We r e S I P

- A pp r o ve d a n d N o w R e qu i r e R e

- Sub m i tt a l B eca u se

o f A m e nd m e n t s:

T ab l e D- 3 li s t s t he n i ne (9 ) ado p t e d Di s t ri c t rul e s t ha t w er e ap p ro v e d f o r S I P p re v i o u s l y

, an d t h a t

mu s t n o w b e re

- s u bm i t t e d f or S I P b e c a u s e o f am e nd m en t s t ha t p o s t

- d a t e d t h e U

. S

. E PA ’ s S I P

a p pr o v a l.



### T a b l e D

- 3

- Di s tr i c t R u l es W h i c h W e r e S I P

- A p p r o ve d a nd R e qu i r e R e

- Sub m i tt a l

B eca u se o f R ece n t A m e nd m e n ts

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our c e? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

-

FR

C i tat i on N e w SI P

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

20 6 Incinerator Burning NO x N o 11 / 12/7 4 11/3/94 11/15/78 43

FR 53035 Y

212 Storage o f Organic

Liquids VO C N o 5/24/7 7 6/19/97 5/6/96 - 61

FR 20145 Y

215 T ransfer of

Gasoline into T ank

T rucks, T railers

and Railroad Tank

Cars at Loa d i ng

Facilities VO C Ye s 6/19/79 Not

Amended 5/6/96 - 61

FR 20145 Y

216 Organic Solve n t

Clean i ng and VO C Ye s 6/19/7 9 12/11/03 4/30/96 - 61

FR 18962 Y2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 6



### T a b l e D

- 3

- Di s tr i c t R u l es W h i c h W e r e S I P

- A p p r o ve d a nd R e qu i r e R e

- Sub m i tt a l

B eca u se o f R ece n t A m e nd m e n ts

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our c e? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

-

FR

C i tat i on N e w SI P

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

Degreasi ng

Operations

218 Architectural

Coatings VO C N o 6/19/7 9 12/13/01 7/18/96 - 61

FR 37390 Y

23 5 Adhesive s VO C N o 6/8/9 5 4/8/04 7/18/96 - 61

FR 37390 Y

236 Wood Products

Coating Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 8/14/97 4/30/96 - 61

FR 18962 Y

238 Factor y Coating of

Flat w o o d Pane l ing VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 2/18/04 2/12/96 - 61

FR 5288 Y

239 Graphic Arts

Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 4/8/04 11/13/98 63

FR 63410 Y



### D i s t r i c t R u l es W h i c h N ee d t o b e Sub m i tt e d f o r S I P A pp r o va l :

T ab l e D- 4 li s t s n i ne (9) n e w er r u l e s w h i c h nee d t o b e s ubm i t t e d t o t h e U

. S

. E P A f or f ir s t

- t im e S I P

a p pr o v a l.



### T a b l e D

- 4

– D i s t r i c t R u l es W h i c h N ee d t o b e S ub m i t t e d f o r S I P A p p r o va l

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

- F R

C i tat i on S IP

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

231 Industrial,

Institutional, an d

Commercial B o i l e r s,

Steam Generators,

and Process

Heaters NO x N o 10/17/9 4 10/9/9 7 None Y

232 Biomass

Suspension Boilers NO x N o 10/6/9 4 12/9/9 9 None Y

234 Automotive

Refinish i ng

Operations VO C Ye s 11/3/9 4 4/9/9 8 None Y

23 7 Municipal Landfills VO C N o 11/3/9 4 10/9/0 3 None Y

240 Surface Preparation

and Cleanu p VO C N o 6/8/9 5 12/11/0 3 None Y

241 Boilers a t Plastic

Laminate

Manufacturing

Facilities NO x N o 4/8/99 Not

Amended None Y

242 Stationar y Internal

Combustion Engines NO x N o 4/10/03 Not

Amended None Y2 0 06 R A C T SI P U pd a t e A n a l ys i s S t aff R e p o r t

A u gu s t 1 0, 2 0 0 6

Pa g e 1 7



### T a b l e D

- 4

– D i s t r i c t R u l es W h i c h N ee d t o b e S ub m i t t e d f o r S I P A p p r o va l

R u le

N o. R u l e T i t l e P o ll u ta nt

C on t r o ll ed C TG

S our ce

? D ate

A do p t ed D at e L a st

A m e nd ed S IP

A pp r o v a l

- F R

C i tat i on S IP

A pp r o v a l

R e qu i r ed

?

243 Pol y ester Resin

Operations VO C Ye s 4/10/03 Not

Amended None Y

246 Natural Gas-Fired

Water Heaters NO x N o 6/19/97 Not

Amended None Y

P a r t 4

– S umm a r y a n d C on c l u s i on s

N e w R A C T R u l es t o B e A dop te d

- D e t a il s o f t he pro c e s s S t a f f u s e d t o e v a l u a t e t h e A p p li c a b l e

S I P s t a t u s o f t h e Di s t ri c t ’ s rule s t h a t s a t i s f y Majo r So u r c e R A C T r equ i r emen t s a r e de sc ribed i n

P a r t 1

, a b o v e

. T h e S t a ff c omp a ri s o n o f a ll c u r ren t Di s t r i c t rul e s t o t he s t a nda r d s o f a p p li c a b l e

C T G s

, A C T s

, a nd A F M s f o u nd t h a t t he Di s t ri c t ha s a d op t ed r u l e s c o r re s po n d i ng t o R A C T s our c e

c a t eg o rie s a n d t h a t s a t i s f y R A C T re q u ir e men t s

. D e t a il s o f t h e c omp a ri s on are pre s e n t e d i n T ab l e

A

, o f t he A p pe n d i x

. O ne R A C T c a t e g or y

, Me t a l P a r t s a n d P r o du c t s

, ha s n o n-Ma j or em i ss i o n

s our c e ( s )

, b u t no Di s t ri c t R u l e h a s b e en a do p t e d

. S t a ff r e c omme n d s t h a t t h e B oa r d d ir e c t t h e

d e v e l o p men t and a d op t i o n o f a r u l e t o l i mi t V O C em i ss i on s f rom t h e c oa t i n g o f me t a l p ar t s and

pr o du c t s

. A l t h o ugh t h ere ar e no Maj o r So u r c e s i n t h i s s o ur c e c a t eg o r y

, t her e are n o n-Ma j or

S o ur c e s o f V O C t h a t w ou l d be s ub j e c t t o a n e w ru l e e s t ab li s h i ng R A C T req u ir em e n t s

. T he rule

s ho u l d b e im p l e men t e d b y J a nu a r y 1

, 200 9

, a nd s h o u l d b e a d op t ed a s a r e v i s i on t o t h e S I P a n d

s ub m i t t e d t o U

. S . E P A

.

N e g at i ve D ec l a r at i o n s

- ( P a r t 2) B a s e d o n S t a f f re v i e w o f D i s t ri c t s o ur c e s

, t w e l v e ( 12) R A C T

s our c e c a t e gor i e s w ere i den t i f i ed w h ere pre v i o u s N e g a t i v e D e c l a ra t i on s (7 V O C

, 5 N O x ) o f n o

e x i s t i n g Majo r S t a t i on a r y So u r c e s t o re g u l a t e ma y b e r e a f f irm e d

. T h e N e ga t i v e D e c l ar a t i o n o f no

e x i s t i n g Majo r S t a t i o n ar y V O C S o ur c e s m a y be ma d e f o r s e v e n t e e n (17 ) a d d i t i on a l V O C R A C T

s ou r c e c a t e go r i e s

. I n a d d i t i o n

, t he S t a ff an a l y s i s f ou n d t ha t t he r e w e r e n o Majo r S t a t i o n ar y

S o ur c e s

, i n c l u d i ng Maj o r n o n- C T G So u r c e s

, f o r w h i c h Di s t ri c t rule s s a t i s f y i n g R A C T h a d n o t

b e en a do p t e d

. S t a ff re c omm e nd s t h a t t h e Di s t ri c t Bo a rd ma k e t h e d e c l ar a t i on t h a t n o e x i s t i ng

Ma j o r S t a t i ona r y S o ur c e s e x i s t f o r V O C o r N O x i n P l a c er C o un t y i n t he t w e n t y -n i ne ( 2 9) s pe c i f i ed

R A C T s ou r c e c a t e gor i e s and t h a t no M a j or non

- C T G S o ur c e s e x i s t f o r w h i c h R A C T m e a s ure s

h a v e no t be e n ad o p t ed

.. S t a f f f u r t her re c o m men d s t h a t t h e s e SI P s u b mi t t a l s b e f ou n d e x e mp t

f rom t h e C a li f or n i a En v i r onm e n t a l Q u a li t y A c t (C E QA ) p er T i t l e 1 4

, C a l i f o rni a C o de o f

R e g u l a t i o n s

, C h a p t er 3

, A r t i c l e 1 9

, S e c t i o n 1 5 308

, A c t i on s b y R eg u l a t or y A g en c i e s f o r t h e

P r o t e c t i o n o f t h e En v i r onm e n t.

S I P S tat u s

– ( Pa r t 3 ) Rul e ad o p t i on

, am e ndm e n t

, a nd S IP a p pro v a l h i s t o r y f o r t h i r t y

- t w o (32 )

Di s t r i c t pro h i b i t or y rule s w a s r e v i e w ed a n d a na l yz ed

. F o u r t e en (1 4 ) S I P

- a ppr o v e d r u l e s d o no t

re q u ir e re- s u b mi t t a l f o r S I P s t a t u s

. Ni ne (9) pre v i o u s l y S I P a p pro v e d r u l e s mu s t b e r e

- s ubm i tt ed

b e c a u s e o f ame n dme n t s t h a t po s t -da t e d t h e or i g i na l ap p ro v a l s

. Ni n e (9) ne w e r Di s t r i c t r u l e s

w er e ad o p t ed a n d n e ed t o b e s u b mi t t e d f or f i r s t

- t im e a p pr o v a l a n d r e v i s i on o f t h e S I P

. S t a ff

r e c o mmen d s t ha t t h e D i s t ri c t Bo a rd d i re c t and a ppr o v e t he s u b m i t t a l o f t he s p e c i f i ed r u l e s

, p r e v i o u s l y a d op t e d b y t h e Di s t r i c t B o ar d o f Di r e c t o r s

, t o t he U

. S

. E P A a s r e v i s i o n s t o t h e S IP

.

A p pe n d i x : T a b l e A

– C T G R u l e A na l ys i s T a b l e wi t h R u l e C a t e g or i e s a s L i s t e d i n U

. S

. E P A L e t t er t o

C A R B, 4 / 4 / 06T h i s P ag e I n t e n t i o n a ll y L e f t B l an k

## A P PE N DIX

T a bl e A

- C TG R ul e A n a l y s i s T a bl e

w i t h R ul e C a t e g o r i e s a s L i s t e d in U

. S

. EP A L e tt e r t o C A RB

, 4 / 4 / 0 6T h i s P ag e I n t e n t i o n a ll y L e f t B l an k