# RECEIVED U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION OFFICE OF HEARINGS

WASHINGTON, D.C.
In the Matter ofNortheastern Aviation Corp., Respondent Docket Nos. FAA-2012-1264

Case Nos. 2012EA110030 Administrative Law Judge J.E. Sullivan 

### DEC 11 2013 

## HEARING DOCKET

AGENCY'S SECOND SUPPLEMENT TO SUBMISSIONS UNDERFEDERAL RULE OF CNIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(l )(A)
COMES NOW the Agency, by counsel, and supplements its initial disclosures pursuant to F.R.C.P. 26(a)(l)(A), as per the Order Setting Litigation Dates and Procedures dated June 4, 2013, to add the following: DISCLOSURE UNDER F.R.C.P. 26(a)(l)(A)(ii) The documents in possession, control or custody ofthe Agency that may be used to support its claims, in addition to those already provided, are the following attached documents: ( 1) FAA Form 840-3, dated August 22, 20 11; (2) Sundance Aviation Pilot Duty and Flight Time Records for Michael Kalish, August 2011 through January 2012; (3) Northeastern Aviation Corporation Pilot Duty and Flight Time Records for Michael Kalish, January 2011 through December 2011vAugust 2011 through January 2012; and (4) One page spreadsheet documenting Mr. Kalish's Sundance flight and duty time from

### August 2011 through December 20 11.
Respectfully submitted, Alfred R. Johnson, 

### Jr. Regional Counsel



### Hy

# ~ Zachary

# MB an Attorney Federal Aviation Administration 1 

### Aviation Plaza Jamaica, NY 11434 TEL:718 553-3258 FAX: 718 995-5699 Date: December 3, 2013

2

# I. AIRMAN COMPETENCY/PROFICIENCY CHECK LOCATION DATE OF CHECK FAR Us- FRG-FOK-lSP-FRG 08/22/2011 ".lAME Of AIRMAN (fast; first, middJr;; initial) TYPE OF CHECK**_:~LI5H,** t•1ICHAEL, D FAR 136.293 IE] FAR 135,297 IE] FAR 135.299IE]

_..•._ PILOT Grade ATP MEDICAL INFORMATION Pati>o!Exam: 08/15/2011 CERTIFICATION -- 

### ---- Date-otBirth: 12/05/1949 Class: INFORMATION: Number 172964.9



## - EMPLOYED BY BASED AT (City, State) TYPE AIRPLANE (Make/Modef) BB-58 SUND't'\NCE**FARMINGD!-:.I.~E ~**  NY**~··** 1O•vice NAME OF CHECK AIRMAN SIG. OF CHECK AIRMAN FLIGHT TIME 

## I 3**tV~** MANEUVERS/PROCEDURES g,RJIDE 

# --,- PILOT A1r- Shnu- Tmg. Air- Slmu- Trng. craft !at or Oev, craft lator Dev. PREFLIGHT HELICOPTER _!"_Equipment Examination (Oral or Written) s 1. Ground**an9.~!~** Trod - 

# - ..•.**~·-·--** 2. Pretnght Inspection s 2, Hovering_Maneuvers 

## - 1- --- - 3, Taxiing s 3. Normal & Crosswind T.O. & Landing 

### - 4.**Poweq~lant** checks s 4, !-lioh Altitude Takeoffs & Landinos - I-- TAKEOFFS 5. Sim. Engine Failure 

# :--1 .5. Normal s 6. Confined Areas, Slopes, & Pinnacles 6. Instrument s 7, Raoid Deceleration (Quick Stoosi 

### - --··- 7. Crosswind s 8, Autorotations (Single Engine} - 8. With Simulated Powerolant Failure s 9. !-loverino Autorotations fSinrJie Enoinei 

### - 9. Raiecled Takeoff s JfLTail Rotor Failures (Oral) 

### - INFLIGHT MANEUVERS 11, Settling With Power (Oral and Flight) 

### - 10, Steep Turns s SEAPLANE OPERATIONS 11. Appr"'!£11 lo Stalls s i. Tax1lng,. Sailing. Docking

- '"·--··
..**~--** 

# -**~·** Specific E!!!!ht Characteristics_ s 2. Step Taxi & Turn 

### - I 13. Powerplant Failure- s 3, Glassy/Rough Water T.OJlandinos 

# - ' "" LANDINGS 4, Normal Takeoff & Landings 

### '



# - -**---~1** 14, Normal ! s 5. Crosswfnd'T.O. & Landi!}!J$ 

# :i

- -·- ' 

## - _15, From an ILS s OTHER

-

_

# _L~ i 6, Crosswind s 6. Ski Plane Ops, (when applicable) ___ I '" 

### I 17. With Simulated Powerplant(s' Failure s GENERAL 1B, Rejected Landing s 7.Judgment 

### .I s I 19. From ClrcNro Aooroach s 8, Crew Coordination I s I I EMERGENCIES AIRMAN COMPETENCY INFORMATION: 20, Nonmal and Abnonmal Procedures I s I 21. Ememencv Procedures I s I I Oemonstrnted Current KnrnNledge FAR 135.293(a) I - I ExPires (12 monihs) 07/2012 

## 4'-"'"'" Departure s Demonstrated Competency FAR t35293{b) "' (12 monlhs) 07/2012 23. !-loldino s MakefModal Expires



# --- -- 24_ Area Anival s Satisfactory D-emonstrated line Checks __?§. ILS Ancroaches s FAR 135299 Expires {12 months) 07/2()12

__ 26, Other !nstmment Approaches s Satisfactory Demonstrated !FR Profidency Aeeroaches: NDBIADF 

## - FAR 135.297 Expires (6 monlhs) 01/2012 VOR 8 Use ofAutopilot**~** {is) 0 (Is not} authorized



### -- ···-- '" 

### --- ILS s Expires {12 months) 07!1012 other ($pacify} G-PS li'RG s REMARKS 27.**CircllryJlh£roache~** s**135.293/.297/~299** BASE MONTH (JULY')**~--Missed** Approaches · s 

### -·-- 29, CommJNav, Procedures s 30. Use of Auto. Pilot s



### --- nESULT OF 

# a Approved 

## PERFOflW(N'2e

# rFM Only) 

### i=iu HECK Dfsapproved DISTRICT OFFICE FM '"OFC'-'' :/-lURE EP:S'fERN AEA-FSD0-11 John

# P.\i{~ FAA Form 841 0-3**(6~81}** FJeo.mnic Fcrrru:; WPf'l

# I I I I._,

# i ! 

# ! T**-ry-;-,,·~,** "T""T ·c-r···· ·,-.,-..,....**,~,**..., ....,,.. ·r·;···r···r· r:'r'"""""·:' 

# .=

"<

# I~**~~~[~l[\~1~ "Iii~**  >

# L,**,~,;:;'** 1216 ix

## ~~ :; f"""··r· 

### -+-: 1 +-t-f-" L.L.j .L •.. ; f··+·l 

### ++ ··H""""""'"--f ··H-!-t

### ++···!;::; c X d**z~** 1 X T iCX 

### 'iX i>,•(j'\

### " !::; " )( ii



# .**··~**

# ,,...**j"'~** I J !. 'I i rr·-r ' 1 '' ' N "ll ' ' - ' l \ j 

### I .' l ?\ ••••J
..

# _t1~ 

# lttltt.qrt ······l·I····I1T hlL

# 1+ 

# l·t·

# ·~·· i f 

# ! l 

### l ' 

## 1-t·

# ~.

# L.,.+t· - II

.... 

### .Lt 

# tLL_[,
.' §**~**

L t

## ~ 

# tn-Ll.l-lll·l .I.

# ·Ill.··II i 

# I , '

.. . tifl!ih

# i·i·+Hi~~JIC. 1· · 

# rlr -lt ,.

# l..t+lLf~l~l

i
I 

# tl

I 

# I • Q t**~** 

# .. q, m 5 "**~f** 

# " 

# .. 0**~** 

### ,. :'1 

### :<: ,.,0 :"•;:.;, :4'-i 

### ;:::r 

### g);!**~rtn** '>-I**~-rn**



# $i

### NORTI£ASTERN

0**~.f1/L1** TJON CDR!\ 

# ,-, A!RCRAFT

L_.
___t RQN Sn'r, ,).**(~Q/M4tiNT<i** Ql

'<'"'"' '"'-...-

# I**lh~ ~j'J"""''·'k**  "-'CktiN> 

### NORTrEASTERN**~>.:g** p, Al/JA'f!ON CORPAlnCRAFT**,----,-~r !~]**  

### ·--,_. 

# ,(**~~** -" ;, - ""

I**I~**

.**I~**

:

# -~· " - '

### CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that the foregoing AGENCY'S SECOND SUPPLEMEN TO SUBMISSIONS UNDERFEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(l)(A) has been sent via first class mail and facsimile to the following: Mr. 

### James Ehrig, Esq. Eckert Seamans Cherin & 

### Mellot, LLC 1717 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, 1i11 

### Floor Washington, DC 20006- FAX 202-659-6699 Judge J.E. Sullivan U.S. Administrative Law Judge Office ofHearings, M-20 U.S. Department ofTransportation 1200 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. (Ell-310) Washington, DC 20590 FAX: (202)366-7536 I hereby certify that the foregoing AGENCY'S SECOND SUPPLEMENT TO SUBMISSIONS UNDER FEDERALRULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(1)(A) has been sent via first class mail to the following: Federal Aviation Administration (Original and one copy via first class mail) 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591 Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur Wright Building- Room 2014

Date: 

### DEC - 4 2012 

# . /1
.

# ~-**~;J ~~t.**  a Hooks Paralegal Specialist Federal Aviation Administration Office ofRegional Counsel 1 Aviation Plaza Jamaica, NY 11434

3CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that the foregoing AGENCY'S SECOND SUPPLEMEN TO SUBMISSIONS UNDER FEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(1)(A) has been sent via first class mail and facsimile to the following: Mr. James Ehrig, Esq. Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellot, LLC 1717 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, 12th Floor Washington, DC 20006- FAX 202-659-6699 Judge J.E. Sullivan U.S. Administrative Law Judge Office ofHearings, M-20 U.S. Department ofTransportation 1200 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. (Ell-310) Washington, DC 20590 FAX: (202)366-7536 I hereby certify that the foregoing AGENCY'S SECOND SUPPLEMENT TO SUBMISSIONS UNDER FEDERALRULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(l)(A) has been sent via first class mail to the following: Federal Aviation Administration (Original and one copy via first class mail) 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591 Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur Wright Building- Room 2014

Date: 

### DEC
- 4 2DE / /'
I L aHooks /Paralegal Specialist

Federal Aviation Administration Office ofRegional Counsel 1 Aviation Plaza Jamaica, NY 11434

3