g 

REF ID:A41~~27· "-../ 

,.P. ll , 

E12g1neGJl1DS 

and. Besoarob 

· Jam1110 

0 

0 

· Wltll reteranoe to 101U' reoent oommmloatlon to OaptaJ.n 

PO'Oell onol~ il18 two tranalatocl mo~aaseo wblOh lJa4 been p~ b7 

tbO Amerl_o~:!~leg;rGph a.n4 !tlepbone o~ on tbe Cl»her. P'1'1t1ft8 

telegi'aph appll'atll.G made tor the Slp.Q Corgo bf that OOrnJ;arw, 

and w1 th tunher 19futeme to tbe oow ot om ot tbe mosoasee '8hich 

JOU sent ·to Mr Clm$rcl1 1 flew tOl"k, abou' \'1h10h 1 wrote JOU *'80en~ 

~ sl"1128 J.t ae l!W' opinion tbat we \\'O\\ld f1tt4 tbat JOU had not. 

G,uooeellecl 111 bna1cius the pr-S.ntltlg teieara,Pb .olp?le• u • use4 

l t. l am now coulnCecl· ·that :10\l ha'M no moral oil'. o-tber r1Sb• t.o ~ iuCh ciasm, tf tlle two meso84')ewh1oh 1011 4eo1phere4 repreaent 

the sole n'1!1 w of ~ la~e on the enen 1118eeases rol'WU4&4 . to 1011 b7 Mr Gbeft\1'41 • 

At nw roqUest,: itr Qhe.rol't! has to~ to tbJ.e of:ftce oom- p~ete copies of all tbG' oorN1,PO'l'l4ence betweeQ ·tlJO .A. i:~ am 2, ~~ on4 ~-.~f cm -. eu~3eot Of thia olpber • 1tmlU41QS oop1es of tbi seven m!t'ssaseo aent rou and; the lett• of trenem1 ttal whicb. 

euoloae4 these trea88Pillt ln ti.oh 1t wap pointed out tbe.t "1011 

WQ\\14 .ery 11•3¥ be ablo to 4tclpher meeaage~ "'10,· ~e Em4 

probabJ.7 tour;.'' Which 11 apparentl7 all sw haw 40De, baoauee 

tl*it meeeages 184.,not i,een eno1p"4 b7 the rnetbot'l Wbich tbG 

Ci)iller Bu.reau, m. 1. »~ stated. prav14e4 4bao1ute •eourlti'• . . . . 

What you bave . eocompl11)becl. ot aovse, co'ia.14. not be 4o?l8 bi 

the ol'dlzm17 ama"'1~· *'Oipb.$1'. ~"• but 1~ cena1ni, o0til4 be 

aocom,pl1ehe4 bJ our ·Oo'fernmant clphea' ex.pertr. ana. bu the o&pher 

bveam ot tore~p s.o•rnmenta. DI.le ore41 t ehmald be BS. ven ':la@ 

(trsanteatl~n for the ~emonstntton ot its capab1ll\1ee• potJ,oulait11' a~ ue al'O aware of the tact tl'ID.t lt oontn'b'1'84 ao heCi'l11J to 

GUI' 80VGl'nment81 &Ol"flot bJ WBf6 Of lamS•JW:to ponomiel Wlitoh . - left rou W4 tbo\lt What '\191'$ oomaS.cJ.eod 10\\I" best p»o;ple~ l lave no 

@'pp roved for Release by NSA on 11-19 2014 pursuantto E .0. 1352\3 
0 } 

! 

l 

! 

l 

I 

0 

REF · .ID : A41f'S)927 . ....._,, -

' 

-a- •. 

daub• ~~ tho tm> young latl.10$ Who Vleite4 ~Dgton ~ ltlW tbG 

c1plwr printer itl o~t.1on 11&l'llt higblJ 1na·tl'lnmlta1 in th& :iolu.t,\Otl 

ot '118 two olpb&N f1#"lllaJJH b:r" tbflt A.~~·· au4 t.· c~.. Please · oonve7 t·o.· them zo.v hlgbe&t approW.a,.1011 for 1Udlat -the¥ bave done •. · Bcmow:r.1 tbe toun&Sat.1.ol'l of tbe Cipher upon tlbtOb-. 'ba$o QUI' ola1m 

Of abeolu- seoreo1 baa not bomi 11~ 1>7 ~ attaok UDle&s vou· ~ ebOW ue 1n COJlQJ.!9\e tom, some evlAence ot bavlne b~ken tbe · 

otp®re Whlch -v.-e" mGll~ioned b1 ur Gbo~ ea 'be1ns 1n the form · UJed bJ. the Vmte4 lltatea 0oveftUm10:t,, oi-· 11 100 w.111 •mooed 10 

b.-e$ldiv tbe. olpb.er Whloh I em·e•tas rou to4q aa an e110lO$Ul'e to 

anotber commm.toatl o-1b · · 

!be othei' messstJft p.JePDftd on tile meoJ;2ailsclalJ. . anolpl'JflrlrJB maob1n1h 

Wh1cb 1 promlsed to a-4 ~. $it ~t. om.th.IS'!ll o~lotfh Jig time . 

le •o l~mto4 that I b$.w ve17 ~t~l,e 'o •1*114 on. the PrGPSJl'At1<* 

ot ~ t 1 but I q>eot to geif 1 t; out '?1thln · Cl1o CJa18 ._ · . - . You .rtJIJ.'9 b$ cencln that mu attitude ao t< -. all. thte ·clpber 

'bueinose 1a oO'm--4 le not antagviUetto, tm4 that .l am W1Utq to 

glve ~~·\l!lhGn o~' 1e 4-Ue• biit fl'Ol1 ~ a~:tnt Of·a · 

tiJ.tYeTmmnt oMolali; ! must neeessa.&'11¥ take lM "'•hoW •• ettitQAG 

am .. .-~_.-- .• ~ to nbut .,- Q~·uou·~ l!lab \'lbioh .. · · 

JfltJ1 be ba~d tipon f'ol·se aoeum;ptloncs or a mlouatora~ll8 of '1ID · · Pf'9blem prtteentad• lt h ne>te4 that J\Glth&l" .ot 1our Jotters refer . · to • letto:r to you 1n Wbloh mi- OhQftl.l'4l.1}G1nt.4. .out .that tJm · ·· .. · 

moseaaes iou bro• could be btolmm. 1 ""1st W.i uozie. of Wa dle•. · ~1b11 ~oh baa art.~ea, or '1bloh mtlf -.uso, w111 ~ aiW ~ .. ova:rate 

·to ·Bewr the good 1'$latlons between ~self' ~ .. 1, Vilhloh i 

bo.lS.ew bave esis•ed lltJO& 'IJll tS.IU' 'f!at t to Bl~ 

W1 th beet wJ.eb&p • 1 -r$DSln · 

Colonel oeorse JPab,_, C~cago• Ill!nole 

Poat ottsce Joz uo.-.. '85 

' 

·r--

' 

I 

J 

i 

I 

I 

'I 

i 

. I 

I' 

' 

I • 

I 

L -· 

. ' .