.. -

Elt 

,... .. 

1. T• -.tae tat. fftactlt •tlu:.t .r traP9!''1tbc V.fl. Omra= 'o•~ _ 

11 ufl~ Witlt .-oiMt•l tid'awt w ._ ffP'-rtime at •lc:bticm -ml ea 

...i.t'l~ or tbe ,.,..n1. &=ace oai:cc-«. fte a!n ,.r.p~11: flt e.. 

.... mst!CJJ'J; !a \b let--1Mt 

a. ftitth•.., iaJuat.trt..a ~e. ta 'N1af t..-neea i!IQ •~1· 

-

•· -.t'her Utt blfoftl*\l~ le '9tnr n\i1-itt..d .t!!ch 0011 

~ 'M lhp9nDd wtt11. 

•· tt.i. MOv.r-lti .i .. 1r1oatt•:tJ i.i•fnA tor a.. ~ ot 

91.tattcea .._the ftla.W •ter!al• avtaftt..4 lQ" .. n. 

a. ft i. aaettal to •hdafn a ..UJadite ~1•1 ct U• ncv.t1\r 

fll _,~ton:J1ttwr tn-. '1' ~ ~ '1'"'"4 aa1 a.a Mb .,~u, .. .n.J• 

... ._..la\elJ .,.n a. Hldc:~e -:.4.., .dta.t1ce ~ ~ )l.Mla1l>,7 O&aa• 

.. ISQ,..,8t at lh'1J\c'.at.r-ta1. T@ ... hi. In. -~ aot.t~, ~~ ... 

.nr&H_, • Jll"lO~ ntoh "'l'-''rt• ~ ~1ftl? of •lolat.toaa f)f 

11'4•t•l •1itm•1-' Ol'7P~ti,. 

'. Tlol&'tl ce. a1 hth .--.1 .. 1 eeeuri t.r at cunt =-•euri ~ ftl7 Oft!" 

& 'f!k !'Gp tm-fu &a U.. ..-f"1;;oe:nt't'$ af 0e TtoU\1(1• l• CJOD~1 

... al 1 ft..e ell'OB8t8.JJOU -.t h tdllllfkftd la CJ'tllr 't~ Hte:ml ~ t.M 

,.._..illt;r WM&l. a y-Jal.tt«&, -:::zo t118 ._ c'f a ..i .. f6 Ylc'lat1o•• -.. 

f'WJl!Hel uypte91tv!al or ~ latltl1 I~ -'4rr11ble t:c. uor ,.pte4 tat• 

SEGREI 

eclassifi ed and a roved for release b NSA on 09-20-2013 ursuantto E .0. 1352 
st~_, "° ,.._. ••fl.a61e h ._.u\!l~ perncns. 

'· AU •tanoea at ban or ..,..W Jb;:raloa.1. •~..en'," w 1 ... 

.. 'Nfb!'t$1 \J -·~ .. q fellt. .. I 

•· .Uao •en'° JIIMFSA. 

•· W'~t!~ Cteff \o Ute s.rrl• s.aqua..,~n. 

f, Ja Qe .... er Yie1.atl:.ae at ~q-, OSA. Mo ~td 

e let f:6 ..Ulllf! ftl1• whiol\ paz'ld'\ .... ,.. ~ 'o la~1ne whcJt&tiT'S 

a._ • Ttolat1~ ta <A• 'De whhth ta 1""211" 11 p1. .. oetlaq 

.-tou ~to nnlt. ta• ~a-0,, !:!I" 

'· n. 't'IGl.at!un 1e of a \ire ei;mllere4 • pNe't1H tm.\:•t-aa '° •oruttq, .a. CJ.oh waM tlmft t.a 'k am1ncd IA oQllJW\he 

WSQ ~ n~t.1qa• "'4&l4:.J'll!r. ti.be NW..tli.ia~ ctf90\. 

Ila •· 1 ti;rt..tao wSth a. ~, a ~ ~i::y;, ol u. 1'91.at.tno 

..S~• et ..,.,t.G8.cr.U'1\s rt"1A•lom ..t tile~ t'1l U'Pll0.7 la tMtr 

en!'lid!cm •• ~ D!W'9A "° tt1fla. ~tu. t 1-.prca.Um1• aw'" 

mwat.\e .. .._ori .. aln sc::•cru ~ m-=cc n;ici-t. 11?11111 h 

ew.q;M to JJ!M'SA wtth a naJJ?tn _. JD5JIP JnCeiierlct', 

I. Ille •arnr d a ~alatlr:ft th-at. 4-t.anntMn v!~l"-. 

.. *' bad fall• da- _,,·~p!l .. -' 4«e, ... tMn ~ enroP .. 

l'lde ..._Cl"lbw .-ttea. It 'be Y1alat!t.1l ta lat.mine! t..:; f&l l Wiiier a, 

.. .,S~u~ 1• rtl'~ 1q •••&£81 111.-t .. f'ollwm• 

•• ~ ._ '.llnot\"!1'1 ~ Y~ Seeortt, ~' Wtllblngt:u 

.,, •• e. tw ..-t.tce. 

•• h tlae e•U~ ""1JCU!\1e tc-r ti!c. T1 .... l1~\~ Gft for tar'~Uaa1 

If • 1Df t.s ltat.._. J..ned f ~ C..at ~ 

•• • 9ae hrrl•• ~ma.rl..-. tor hd'~tl!:dJ .. tldt4)1'l\41d ta 

.,,nu. A., 

I 

SECRET 
----- REf"r~tA 71910 

liJLUllL I •. , ........ , ........... .i-ttw ..,,, _,_ • tit wt ......... fmGl..a. 

la*kll ... ''la dwtfi'4"' ~. 0.,1 .. f1fl tM .. tq ... ) 

..,.,.,... la .. yta1,at.!• .... ~ to lllOll "' •izi. all, .. ~ 

- .. lfW IUll:Ya .i111 a !Of..,., a t•*• II U..Gl...&, la "'1tll 

... Ille ..... ebiNlflel .. •ts:. Jt .. 'liela\.t• ...... .., .... '° 

au ...._. '· ..,m. .. r~ _, ..u • .,.."'"' 11r ._ W!ria.1 

a.tiff ~. tdtJa & MW .....,_ _.. - ...... .. 

T· lta 1111'1• • ._ ...,.u.. ., au. Ttoi.u ... ~ • -. 

aU•ltr Ill •1:t\lWt'-'1a11 -., ..a. Ail- I' .... Ja-&11we an Nt-1Nl to 

1•1'' '9 tllih •'NJ'll\l" e.rrtee CbQ\oloete .._.1._, _. M!.lt 111816• 

..n. ,.,..-'.fll F•Nl•ral en••~ 1 ••• ••• .sa1,au,.. ot ••nou.-

11M6 flftwt • tltlel .. i tJt ..-u. " ... las 1ou "' ......... --

... • •••• &o6t to edri u to t1la -' ttl•la Wt. ta U. ·~· Aa 

aa1:ee fll dlt"' ~ "1*a "'pcMnllum .w...u .. 1-1 ~ ,_ ..-

• • -n'4ilio*'111 111a1RUz Q. ... , ... ~., ..-. ,rf.claU-

........ "' ..tl .... """ - Ah ....... e..nt•nlf• ... ,1... .. 

•••• .., ... -' "'9bu "• ..,.'11111 ~ --~ ., .... I. 11!\ll ~ w • sa..ti.tt-:e ol •~es ~d•-e 

1 •••• "" ~~t • ,..ru. ~ ...S.\Jnc ,.. n.ia,s.- ., llvR•l ...,,..,., ...., .• u-, _. ,.,_.. e1 YlotaU~ fll orn~t., 

tllll6 MF zwt• ta ,...m. •·i111woat .. , *M ,......_.. wttada 111111 u.n. 

""'"8-.... ...u-. 

a. WS-ata .. ,.., ul Air ....... , • .._\lp\tca lit ~ 

.. ......,,.. .. •hesa. ........ lb •• ...,.oa.t:l\tlltf'• 

la .. ._._. II he& _. Jlwai.1 1 1111'..S. .. ,, ., ... ta _. 

J 

SECREF 
•;nz 

I. a. (centtna.d) 

Vio1d.l• et N'7'p\oMe\'D'l\)'. 

"- Wfthtn \bl •v MW .... et• J.we, _.Iman• 9Uf.llM'.\ed. 

.-,.S.oel e~ .. 1• 1a lnft.U ,wt Sn MGCW:t.li09 wiih ell&J*•r 

Set BPS ,._ ~r, tlV' QJJPto.tetturltg -.S..1at.10ft ot a tne 

Nqld.11ng -~ Npoft. w DJRAr.J. aho a.;;a11"tte • bmnrt.S.-

•1• -4 repert t.e CIC. 

•• ~\l.,., eopi•" et,,,. ..... fJt biftlt.ipti.en a.re fu"nithe4 

..,,.~ 

f. .. llulo ,..em• Ifft"' ..,,..1os.n1 Ttalatton• et &rn'ffftell»lf;J ud 

~ NO!il'l\¥' ..... tollewe1 

•• ~ • ~ Jlt\'ftl\8 Aft et'llut ton \e ti• llUlde or t!!e .u.ot. 

lldc1i Meta do.1.a\S..on baa 'l9lft U.. Maarliir •t \hi 111"-Ctt md 

• Mandnat.taa '•'--_..et tibt Jll"6babllit,. \bat uach Y!oWI..,. pmd.\ ~_,,.,..,.anal t.o aftln 1ntel.U.p""• 

•• Slab a J'N~ ,....St• Gn.\V:;P. .n4 the !Im~ etr:'P\01ozic 

'£ ••le• '4t nal.ua\4t V.. ~!c•bllit.1 •d cla2'1t.Jt ot \h9 

fttu ad rw:tttRttna ~ Jflo'dc-1 n::urtt.:r .. ~ ornto-

-•S.'7 ud to ... ,_.,tm"1 IWri.lrt'2tl Sn thue 1'111••• It. 

..U. •\t.mtloei t.o '1P9a rif ....... elah ~ not tr.ft lMttn 

~11 t-.re111Hn ID4 .., ~ ..wrl~. tw -.,,1e, 

""111\hod of t.r...S.t.t.1~ ... ~ tmtleatol'• !nth• UU ••tea .. feun4 '° Mtnlt tn ... •bnoft'lall: ~ ~ ,,, -·~· 

""1-ln' \h4l .-net~~ rota1' al.S..ou snt at. ~ be~lng et 

U. .... I~ an4 \bt ..... lrtdi~•\or &ti th• ttd1 "-' ~ 

~SECfttl 
REF ID:A71910 

SECRET 

•m1s1 

t.11. (~) 

- ot u.... •• ""'• 90ITOCt mar alloritmt. ._ \h• .. uee 

t.Ucat.oP 111 ~~i.-4 a\. t.be be&lnnir~ •t the • ...,,, ad 

la ~ reput..t a\ ~ end. 

t. !Uoh a p-oce..!urs •r¥t:1 •• a ...,.. ot 9'11'\luttnc U1e ettiotm~ ..a etew• or ~alnfog ot 017~p11lc par.ionnel. an4 

et U..it' ••rw.t1•• .r Mii ~11.wkM wttli t.m ""tlAtlan.o 

ll••rnlntt ~e ha.i~..11r~, atorago Ind •• o.t cr,.ptcx .a\erial. 

D ,.-dt• oarrecUYfi aO\ian t.o b.e talwn lit SNltau.cos ot 

a1mormal.13 trequent. w1o!at.1cn•. 

.. lt. llb$tald b4t P>1nt.ed an t.hat. tM ~<ldrre 1tnl;~ t.9!rla \o 

IMru .. tlM a.Nnea9 et ~~ol to v.~ l"eqUlretQ:!ta 

et OJ7pt.oaocurl t;y and to that cd.ont. "r'ltt11 a •• !U1 pm-pouo 

"'°"1 ill \ho9q 1Dst..nces 'l!Mre \be probabU \t.7 or rJWi~"\oo 

.., kl•. 

JO. ?t ..., 'be .-i, ~ \he don di.cud.on. t.h&fr. an arrort.. baa 

..._ ..- to •&NP'- n.t&tlt.r.:r tr.to •teeort•• ard lo •.tethh __.al 

M\ttoif• or rop«\\ng \h-N0 .S..W.t.i«.s, ln aooordat'!e. .S.th the ~'J!lity 

tha\ U.. rlolat.lon will nail\ 1n dlto1ant.lan of M!lJ ro.-il•. rhia ~ 

&a uin\a!ned -.i•r • een\btt.\1114 Mn'ltttr aod l• reYi• 1 11 .,. •mt.OD"•.='hio 

...-urea &1"' introduced or •• .,, ~e \eclr.lqaet •~ devltl.ope.1. 

9"rl 'U, .uh • ~c.'1, lt. •~ - b9«t puslble 1o draw 11~ _. ~ 

"1111 tkat. th• uitr• n..s ~ report. thM• vlel.ttlm1 whioh al~• w 

Mlf21 11W1• re1V.lt. In a claclat'"atJ.oa ol OGr~S••· At.t.aehisd •• Tncl.oauioo 

1 le a .... .,., .r u.e OOl'Ppro.~toe. aet.u314 clo=lare:l by ~ru el.~ l llOY 1950 

• SECRET 
REF rn:A71910 ;- -

SECRET 

•• so. (Oont!nue~) 

- \he hHt• et 1"8pU11.S DI Y1ola\lce1 ot W7~ottf!4'.aiti(.. lt. .w. be 

9R-1 that approxkAWl.1 .U.t( et all TieJ.et.1~• ~ltd b)- INl"P 

'"'11.t. 1" ....,,.,1., • ~ ot U. ~· .t Tlol.aU.oru1 to ttn ...... 

,.n..d "1 •o~ ooulA '9 •1•1 "'1th w obJeet. 91 bol'6d!n4 in t.bD 

11.eliD£• -lJ ~ Yioht.iorti:t whioh have- \.h9 ar-t.8\ ~~bll t•~ Of 

fffttlt;ing in fift~lM. ~ a r.vtaion ~ 4htinle'h Ute m·~..,,. of 

•-&e ~·and IMmM tM peroc;.taws or then rlol.A\.1011• 11h1oh r... 

alt Sn a ~larat.1on ot Mlf'--:-:ro"":in, ~the other hattd,,. woh c ~ 

&atl'oduC4t3 Ula ria t.Mt. occedona!l;- • •1oht1on wroa1d oc4\Q", •"1•r 

.,.S•l dreu=1•tfn011• lllt\loh per~it liJIWlthn:-1..._1 pll'iar..a \Q obtaltl in-

~ ,..._ l'J • .:;. 1tzua1.1oatt~, and th9 •1ol•\~m 'lfOUld no~ lie 

nportod. t:'.'n t.m ether hand, UM u..t. ot T1olat..lon• re~ a•ab or.rPtoIPtM e111al1! M «lplr'~ .. 1,, tot.hat Yirtuall..v all v1GlaU.Cl\tt WOttl-4 he 

l'lpOl"tfltt 10' •••a&•, \!'=.• atn1ttalnc \he r1* ot elV' 111m1p,ortAd ·riolbtolone 

-4 ....-Ins raptd na'luation ol ~b _.. Tb..1.8 approach 11\t.rohlc•• \be 

II" blt.a ot 1nhrtarcice .S..Ut epn"at.~me, a ~ inc:re~aed. vol.au of 

-181" J'lpt~• .tnll1 in the. -.a of \Ill •v:t, • J.utp bcnaM is U. 

1 "'* 1ef inT1Jatlgatt ons. 

ll. Sh \he fl.Ml -.q.t., the Mtt?"'!"ir ... tlora et what. vtolet.lona ot 

th• rulA• pn:m.1nc ta. Jt17al.al -1 ~r;pto.-curit; et tll'J'Pto.:ut.ID'ial 

-.Ube ,..porkd, lad 'llllbat. ~ta '8 'bt alYC:l \ho:• Yiolalians 

~t..i.ed •• .-.qulrlng • NPQl"t1 b ba•·l on ~ tollcitd.:ng 90nal!tentton.a1 

' SECREf 
REF ID:A71910 

SEClal 

(CIAtlmtef) 

1. A MaU..a knew~ .t tha crnt..ana~o ~ .... ef U.1 

- a,et•A and ere!Ulng fer.e!4n nnt.1*"• .,.lth • ~llllly 

e4'ftll4•:1 sf.4.~ 1n tM omtanatyUo art. 

~. O....SM!"at.ion of' t.ba eft.J\ of each 'lio.ht~.,,, apen tms 

IUC11'ltq ot U.. •et«. *Oo~ttun that.1 u the tallfllrt 

of~ of 'f'itdat.1.°"11 to be NJ•ted ta &"qlll~, '"" 

• "* of tiecP1"0r1•s 4"'l.ll!'0.:1 ~ le not cort'IJ.JW-d!'l!-

lr ~iaa•O!t• 1.•. the l.tw ct &irWlhlne ret.umll ••a Sllt.o 

JiU;J. 

.. ,,...\,SJ tty of 4J11Tp\of1t1\tfrrl1Jl kving \lieoot"I aftflebl.e M 

omtiorlz .. J ,.r.scm,. ' 

•• Ae•'qrt.lon Uaaf. ff'!d7 ••sage ~r-1tt.I lr1 •l .. t.r1-1 

wn aaa,. et!Hr \h11i1 over S!PPN"ld olreult.e,. ha.a ~ .a4e 

...Uatd• tor ~\lan lr,7' llNI~ P91".-nt 

12. in "'9 but• of UM aboft 94Tlft:!~at.!en• 1 t.be •i91.at.ir.111• ~o be 

'"1*"tM -tor ea~ ll;yft9!ta h!\n ~ epeelf!ed in Chllp\.,. '.3 et UWJ 1210. 

I\ h M M eaphaaleed \hat. \be• U.Unis ilo n4t ~in .Wtio, Aa 

..S tttt.• \o •11.•.S.nat• reμo1\e et 'lial.a\!orul In oorw:.-::U.on t.hlr9dt.h. 

Aa tbo e17Ptan11ytta m *1•~~· .., ~·"'• Wit oec19ion•lls- unCOft't.S, 

Nqa~ ftJIClf"\1 of Ytolat.lane not.~' eoMtdeirod. •••rim• • 

., 

SECRET