" , 

~- REF ID:A66600 ~--· 

• OOIMF~IBJIEWJT~AL .• 

CJVILIAll lo.MPLO!L-1.Xt· FOlHt -"-) : : 

;~Jnut.~11 of :ieeUni' U.:rdl 

! 3 L.eeeatu· l 9LE.. RC4\p'- 1.1? lrJ. 

'.t.. C~lon•t·Je~rG =~ Li~\y 

Lt.. -~ x~l .;a~"'' e. 1: -~•r 

··-= ~ :- - •!:'!~-' l. Jone-• ••. - ... ... •e • ·!' '9 u. ~ r. .... • lirOIJ"l• -

Lt. ~~efllr ~. ll~ 

:.r. ::. . r.atUeck 

ilr. lltree -:-• Soee 

J.T. a. E!r.tov 

&r1' • .:rotn r •• tulliva:i ~r. r. r. Rot-lett. 

::r. t. Q. Sts::-Un, C._11jne~ 

, ' 

'..",£-. {\e•11~ •c"Vt•rt! t.Mt- i.b• .-taut.el ot tbe !l'•rt.!nr 1, :'°.c'Vf'l'al-l'l· &re h'!Dg Itel~ 

pra,,1nv. npd.r or tt:• ditto rr.:-bin•. 'l1lf' 111.tnutes er the l!!fftf n~ 1 '!l.ovcrt•r were 

noi. a~\? 1NS •Ill 'ff n11ir 1:1. 

: • JilL!"CHWl Cl SJ, 

1' ... 

iLr. iterUG ac?v11a!: tl2t t:c hlic! buoJ·e4 a'l'Ou~ :-· .... flC'tct~e-'• a:a1ur11 to ti!• 

l•t.tera ot 15 l~Bottr and /,. Ltat:~•hP'I' 19(61 U.• 1ctte1" h-1n;. th GMJ'lfl 1111.b 

ni·erencr to tso epceJf1c c!wft, ·, inf askK t-hetht!r tOEr' ~hen aorudt'•red lits 

Nafut.&.t.lon ot t"!e chcr~e-• •e su "r ic1e?it t.o arop U·_. c.-1c e.ne "he'Ll.•1' an on.1 htmrl'D8 

r.cNld 't!e ftCIUll':IC!. !:r. !t.1"1 In ~zpletftl'C! th1 t !.:r. nf'tC!:.f'r hr.c lncl!cetec! t.a h:laa 

l.hot St n• ·c!h"~jeul t t01" b5 n t·• an&•f"I" the ohr.ri"PI" t•cct'BI' t:e hl:C. not "" the · · tpretncat'lon. c!tafLc. hkJ. r.h 1~llf'r he had recu••t.Pc tc aee t.1-~· dnttr., ~:,. •. net.cher 

1'f'plit'd t.ht.t he ~td not. L'r. &t·rl:ln •f!virec! ::r. '1e\cher \o eek for t..'ie drafts 

'llt.loh wl'I' p:iTar. to hf.:. Jrrlll!•.t•l11 h.- eo1:lc! he.Te IHlr: th•11 the Eell'ii de7 119 rcce:lv'd 

Ute letter hi~ '=• ••Jced f ,,r thf;~ at that t.il1e. In 1.he dl•cu111:1o'!'t •hich tollnedt 

Board a:at•r1 :1nc:Icat.ec! '.htt ~·r, Uetcher'a rc;al.1 •• "IP.P7 conh1!D1 •-' 111coJJ•reat 

enc: :aot condckrec!: 1utt1.:Jent •:Hei- t.11 tho cbr.r~•· ther•tore es onl r..earsns •ould 

l• a..cc11a17. l'r. Ur1.1..Sn rill Snforr: t~,.. ll•tctier. t.het then •ill bl' an onl !:earln« o.."I lfcnc:a7, 26 teoi•tcr 19'1: at lJC'O lloura. Ir. ll•tch•r w:lll lwe nprr•ntrd 1'y 

~.oun1el ot "!I nn ~~~-co •DC! tt".e hi rt' nq"'••t• t.t:11. t. ;;j.. Leet er 1 Yr. ft.utf•r ind aa 

"'iuer fOT" _,•lch .r.·, ll•tcl••J" wrote th..- r~cJtie&tta111 11bould l!e prtiH'nt 1t. the 

hear!ng. JI!'. Bowlet. wne•ted tt .. t pllota•tetlo aopi•• of ::.r. il•t.chC"r'• ft'?lJ' 'be 

•Ce for- tmra! llft.'tf.•s. Col. lrler a1h'd t:hethPI' the Vet.f'!'Anf ~:rau, Ar.t"rlcan Ll'i;10D9 

ttv11 Sel'Yh:e CCll'l"l:•Jon, flt.a. muld eonciuet • .t'Urt.l:er 1n'H•&t1fl! t1on 1r the 8an'l'"t! 1u1• 

teinr tl-C' c"erp.r •nt! :•r. Swrlin n;tlled thrt. th17 w!ll flr::t nvlflto 1.!lfl ee1e wcor'<!1 

am~ tr .on th• 'tr''JE of t.he- e1:lt!enco thf"7 fC'f'l our ~ee11~on h u11Ju.•t1r1•d t.m1 w111 

•ke 1\111.':cr 1·. 11 elltft:c tt.or.. r.·r. Starlfn ac!v:l••c! thet L"r. ithoecea •111 act an YoUng. 

ftl:.Der et. t."• 11ral i'Nr!n1 o., :;.onee1 in pl.Ice of tr. F.ullbick in \l»:t tl!r. latf.t:.l" 11 

Cti .. t of U!• 61vl1~o!'I to P.l:icll r?·. IJeteher .11 1r1i~"nft!. L"r. :ShmCt'I ls fe:r1U.ar f'1lb 

the C:ctei • 1f '' • ~••· eclassified and a roved for release b NSA on 06-30-2014 ursuantto E.O. 1352 

~GAL11 '"' . 1'Clk A Pi10Jll'l:JE t~1 llX.:f.ft 6Cll:.1.UU. I 

., . 

ln •.tpl.7 1.o 1;1". rs.nr.ov•a .taqllll"J' reprllrt.1 th• cutr •~ expect. t.o noecive- S.:h•c!\ole B, 

r.·r. tt r1fr. ineicct.u• the.t. hi! !lui talbd to II lf'lll-'!11' or t.~c C'vn ~Pnict Ccn.irsiori 

... ~o .d~ thr+ .. thou£·! ibt CSvtl Srrv:lcl' lb:le• ire •1t111\.1fti: tbr .Prrc1.cent •: F1~tu1·e, ?a' ui t1~ fa,],.P. n1 .-.cvin Ccn.""i"reaJcr.cl r.prl'(nt11l r'-~(!~ •!l! mun ~.rt>-.. r. ir.1~~ lf · -· 

COia!R!]IEltJIT_~A_L ________ _ 
·, 

REF ID:A66600 

GOIMFuiffi~mlnAiL . 9 

th!• h I.ti• ea•, :..rs-. St.arU.n fOJll att.Npt to obtain appraa.l of !ehrch:le & authoritJ' 

JCJ" •11 pa11t.1cne •••!rat'd nclvllvr.17 to ~1'1'.J" COll'wntcatJor.• 1•le111,ener 1ct'1Yltle1 

prior to lot• l'ra•1Dl"'llt.1 1 apprav11l of t.h• ocaplete CS•ll !•me. liulca. tr. E111Jcov ~i11'HO Ml\ t.hct Sn tb~ aer.t.t'D!• hold Sn hf1 J.i•i•!oa In •••et.ton wltA- •pecilll qa.l• 

.i.flt'flUCD lt.enderd• \o 1twc!7 pmtfllon1 •nd t17 t.o dN!de wb.1~ mee abclull! te !D• 

oluded llKer 1peci1l eon•ldent!ona tor ftl'kln kW• or expPl"!tMt~, U.., .. d tomad ~L t!IJttJeult. to tnow nere to dn• I hard end flit l:lllP 88 to wllSell ,job are ot tbe 

tyge for eslch 1peetal CTJPtagl'apbta tnlnlnc SOt:ld be at p.t1'tftea1eir wtve. 2D •111' 

-~ftll\n:\l•t poaltlo!ll 1 for ••P.ple, or eww t7;dfti! Jeb, a JmcnrW~• of t.he nr1r - :t·r. ':'."ncJ 11 YCT:J Sapol"lant for "trieS•CJ'· ln 'fl~ er \1-!1 altm-Uon, "Gr. &lntaw 

• ;..... t1t111 the •l1tple1t 1olt:tton to U:r prot.1• .. t~t. h to rvcerst. \!:!' t. doa~l• ti• ~ .... tXi!f .... 1~ .tt.hlr. t.!ic "PftCF (or «tt•Swl•at H'Jp\ wortr •• rigp1ted ,,. Captain 

~li"t-11 •haulc! l'I" mat~ tor all pa!tlcne •1thin t~• Afrn!CJ, .. tt.f:r \.hon t17 to l!at ~rtaia •ilffiflo GM'~. :.~r •. Et.arll• lndlmted, !:oTOner, \bit lie did not \hl"lc I.be 'ar.W.•lt,..., mald lfO •1011~ 'l.l_U1 •• la cn:ntSn, d01;tll' tSn ,_. nprlcnce !• Joba llh!c• ..... ca::i-cm Ulraapoui tJJe acowe111111at., ,, typht• •• al!r.5nt•trr.\ln •ed~n\8. 'h~ 

t-.t!Hor \hr' ai- dll ll&H to et.Sc;. to ,So\·1 1n 1 1pechlfal!i mte1017. 'r· SSllkn tur• 

;.1.1 . .r ata~l!!G u. t 1\ ••tftd to .hll! Q1t. tt• ~S1to17 or 1p1etel ~11r1c:- Uyn ~tltnc•.n!• 

'le a •r 1:.iN h:btary, enf he eon1!•nid 'ldz.U.er ell i.be•e etl.Dd•l'CI• ..-:ld die •• eaan · •• t.he lll:C'l'Cf!IUIJ' 11 l!eo~rcd at. •• end s.r all our quelSISeat!on• wu1d llav• to be. re• 

t.Titton •llJD1'• ii-. lt&rl1n aid t.llrt •11 fnc!1as1Jona point t.o Lhe ~ct tat we cannot. aonU!ND u'IMin- Schedule & no!: la11y-,,r 1 ane, tlaoua:b n t:Ul ccmt!nue to 1:1e S.t · untll in1\nctSon1 an rece:lvK t.o c!iec:ont.Snuc, ·1.-. sill hive t.o CeaSde on t,be qual:l• 

fleet.ion •tamlan• to be uled '-hcrun..r. .:r. ltc.1'11n further npl.a!n,.,., Sa npl,7 to 

J.r. lulltwek'• 1nc;'D117 nlat.!v• to '\.lie tt•Ulad• or Mtt.'Jn;: up qwUtScettaa1, that 

uader ~ah.Sale .E. R a11 hire •D70D• mo St ca&11tied. Ae t.o wllat q8ltftect.laa· •t•n• 

dari• will be used, thlt l'ftlri bf. an arnnpr.ient wr11ecS aut wtften t.he A1119nq and 

1.hc G!Yll kmn to-=ileton. Ir.• ••t. to conttmae to u• t>.e pn••nt. &ehtthlle I. 

ataad•nl• .a~ Selaed'Jl• I! w aJll 1mY• to •Ire aa •creenea\ with \be eo-s .. son to 

c.o ro. If Y• decide upan .n•• atand11rda 1 • ~11 l:lke.S• mve t.o wrk wt aa •rNn«e• 

amt. to t.tte •\Ul Ut.~dlct5on ,,r tl:e 1 !1rftC1' ana tlle Car .. tePlon, then N •n blN 

•l\JOae wr:o 18tl1fi•1 t.hoee queUfS•tSon .Undll~•• Lr. hllbet. t:tnal ta bow mo 

11 t.t:• J111ice ot •lle\ller • pc"rt:on q•U.t!ec •. :ilr. tt.a1"l!n np1.W t.hll the •ppoSnt.'J1W 

otf:l.eer eeelde1, but h• r..11 the t. tor the l:iaher 119d1 po1tt~oa• a ... 1 ~ tectudel1n1 mould _. appotnt.ed no cnla Judce o" the cua11t1at'\!ona or 1pp11md8 tor 

prHoullr Jot:a. _ t:r. lulllaek aalted whether p9ople ·~~d7 ·1nnat~a\ oa J~be would 

mve t.o hew t.t•I• .-11ne1uon1 neon•h!el't'd 11 a nblllt. • M1I' ••t. or •telll!ard• to 

tho CG11Dl•1Son1 •eo L"r. ttsrltn :re;>lSed tl•.rt the,r wodt! 11D1•11 th• Cond••ton 1lvea 

u1 'bllnkt'\ aatborttr to tnn.t•r t'WJTOm to io'HdvlC' f.. :i:r. Rowlett. lmiler.t.ed tbat. 

be teel1 a 1haul~ eontlnue tc r.o alon&;- c:oununc. e17pt esport.aee ~out1• •• • Ila.,. Sn 

tho ..... Jt •• •rree t.hrt. tr I !11 aett..tnc up .... •t.Bad•~· ... •111· d11.-1Uy ball 

i.l:e pnp!e er 1lnt1d7 hr.vo, it 1·ould 1:e· 'better fro acmt.lnve wltb pz'l"•ent atatH!•rd•. Lr. 

Slnluw n• excu1ed fl'OD tt-.e •••t!ng to keep en appotnt.11ent and \!le mt.ter or qaU.ti• 

cation •t.sarcie ne tebla! ua~~l ttaa next ••e\J111. 

'· Al'ID1il.L Ustl!fti fllmDJ: 

lt as 1nale1 t.cd \lat t.t:c ater:Sal an \he ap\1t.ue te1ttna pngns tut a be• baakec! 

\call mest:era of tt.e EaaK ant 11 !ID• Sn tt.c hl~I or Col. frler. i:,.. Starlin. a11ced 

tor dS•ca•11cm or th~ eub3cri. ar.d :r. llof;l•t.t rec.-ndlN! thlt w forgot the pror.raa 

car.pl•tel7. '11:11 to;Sc aa slac table&! unt:ll tt.c nnt. reC"t.!ne: • 

.... {)I -(J 

I./).~ .t~ .V ........ 

• , ·. • • • ..,, f'•