REF ID:A44417 

SECRET 

N 0491 

7 FE~ 1861 

MIKOBAHDJK roa !BB SJmlllJ.'AJll, lClLl'fABX' COlll.CCNrIOl&-&IC'l!BOIXCS 

IOARD • JODe ~ 1lABl'AD P.Alll. 

am.JECT: ADlGndllents hopoae4 by FJuoe to J.Cf 178 (Jfar.ltime Blectrom.c 

Warfare Inatru.cUou) iet-

~: 

Item. 

lote 

llo. 

b;y tbe 

c-141) 

Secfttaries 

cltcl 24 OatoHr 

to hold.era 

l96o 

of C/fM lil!b/3/D ~ 

:t. With regard to the amendmt!nta to ACI! 178 which &1'e pzopoeed 

in the "Jxtract or French ~· enclosed v:l.th retWenee and now 

being ~ by a vorld.ng group Of the Joint ~c lfartan 

Panel.1 BIA propoaes the following position be taken b;y the u. s. Membez-,, 

CEC, on the at.tbpuagnphe indicatech 

·a. • l.a., b. 1 and c. l&:mecusary in vlev "1fl canmenta 

OD l.d. below• 

b. - l..d. lecaaend nat accept Frueh amendment. Chapter 5 o~ ACP 178 as nov written does allude to some advantages which can be 

derived t.raa intercepting and studying an enea;y•a radio communications. 

These are presented, however,, in the context ot caut1on.irJ8 the reeder 

that consideration must be given to these adVantagea &CCl'Uing to an 

eUEll!l;1 wen ve are :f'onmllating our own electronic mission policy. 

a. 0n the other hBd the paragraphs 4o8-4.l6 vbich the French 

have proposed. diacu&s in sane deta:U procedures tor analyzing radio 

co11euai cations. These pan.graphs are permissive rather than cautt.onary 

in nature and anit arrr raation ot the special care which MC 64/2 provides 

mwst be taken to eateguard the source at or iutormatiou pertaining to 

intel 1 igence derived from 1ntercepte4 radio carmnm1caticme. 

3. The matter Of~ of mdio communications as proposed 

by the French 1a outaide the aeope of ACP 178 but is one proper~ to 

be COD&idered 1Jl 1mpl.enientation 0£ tbe "lfM.'O CCMJ1f.r an4 BLDrl Policy,• 

vb.tch is nov being prepared 'by 8B'APE and SAClAE tor presentation to 

the steading Group ad. ul.timate iaautu:l.ce .. 6ll ti: ~. MCl.Al.r 

has recently 41acussect this 4raf'tt ;policy with the Q. aa a Stcd:111g 

Group member. We urute:rstazld tmt SBAPB v.Ul. cUawn 1 t v.t th the mt 

eclassified and approved for release by NSA on 10-22-2013 pursuant to E.O. 

3526 
REF ID:A44417 

N 0491 

JIM proposes 

4. In cozmection 

tbe toll.owing 

with 

conceming 

parag.raph 2. 

the 

r4 

1J141cate4 

the r.rencb 

pangra.pba: 

~ 

a. Del.ete only l.08c. - IUbparagrapba a. and. b. et.lll 

pertinent. 

b. Couidering the Fl'ench proposed Chapter 6 eaUtle4 

"Blectronio Bn1aaion Seeuri t7," and not.ins that it COD:ta1Da pr1mari.ly 

COlllJIICM'lOllS transmiaaiOD security mater.I.al, 1ISA suggat8 tbat A 

revised Chapter ;, as attacbed at 1nc.l.oeure hereto• be 1Datead. 

propoaed by the U. s. member to be incl.w!N in ACF 178. In dratting 

the atta.ched Chapter 5, lfSA baa brce4ened the scope ot the r.tench 

material by including it 1n a reviaion of t.he e:iatiag ACP 178, 

Chapter 5, entitled "ll.ectronics lbiasi.on Policy." 

5. This revised Chapter 5 include& three eectiona; tbs f1rst 

two of which cover the material in the present Chapter 5 and tbe 

last. of which covers the material. the French proposed 1n their revised 

Chapter 6. It is accord1ngl.y believed that attachment sbou1d theref'ore 

meet the French requirements. 

Incl: 

a/s 

cc: 

Readi 

PROD-03 

CSEC DOC ( 

ii/J:: H. FROST ·--~~· 

L. a. nosl' 

Vice Admiral, USN 

m.rector 

M/R: Self-explanatory. Coordinated with PROD-03 (Mrs. Brewer), CSEC DOC 

(Mr. Dochez). 

OPS/4994s/23 Jan 6l/ej 
-.. ;"-

':1.:· 

......... ,:. 

:_.:·.,_. 

-~ .~·. . 

,.·.· 

.... -"~ .. 

";.: .. ·· 

REF ID:A44417 

0 

~ .··'- : . 

~8 lo --l~W@§~~~~~~o ~m~@g'~~~ 

©~~@@.§ ~~© ·~~ «mi.~~~ IDDE ~ ~@ @£@ @l@© 

~§~'W.@@1» ~ ~ ~ m ~~ ~~@:@§ ~~@§ ~ 

«~» ~ @ m ~'\Ml,@Ql @ffi ~§ [®'I /}C;} J11@ Tu&' @, ~~ ~ ~'© 

ll@!,U~ ©~t~ ~'\M!,@©§o ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ 2bt© ~~ 

~@ ~ ~ «~.!f»o ~@ Wi© ~ @§!~§ @m ~ ~.g'gf) ~ 

~~~~~~©m@2f\lj,""@@~@o A~~~ 

~'!§ ~~ ~@ ·m:i f§i@t'@ ~~im' ~§ ~@'§( ~ ~ ~ 

~@)1\ ~ @@.111 ~ ~gQ!,o 

®o ~J!,©:!f·"®~~§~@§~~~ 

@ff /JC';} 11@ «~001 ~ ~;!!,@ ~ ~ ~~ ~;il~@@ 

~§~Ml§» i§:@ ~ *'@ ~~m (;!, r~K~i@'\Mb©m (§lQ), :n~§ iOO' 

©~QJ,~001 ~§~@ffi&F)o ~ ~©ffi ~W@ID ~oo-~t ~ J.b~ 

«~ ~» ~ ~@ <{g@ 00~~§ ~_m~ @@@·. 'i9l@ @Tu)~ 

Tuw ~§ ~ ~§~~nJo , 

~o ~@@2f~~@~§~§t@~t@~ 

~~ ~~@ ~§~@m ~~~<JO ~ ~ 'Wi@ .&,@~ J11@o ~~ 

§~~ ~ M'f 1~ ©i2l W:.@ -~~ ~§ ©l©~o .. ~~f) ~ ~ ~ 2b@ ~t@@l ~ ~ ~ ~~-@@iomm,1l~~ 

~§§2!,@]l ~~o Lif,,Y£ ;!!,@ ~~ ~ ~§ Tux§ ~ 'W@ @lQ'i 

~~@ ~@@2b©m ~"'®,~o '·,..__ 

~ 

~o ~§ ;!!,r;i· 'M2l@ ®@@ml@l ~ @'Wi~ t@ ~ ~ ~©2'1 ~ 

~ ~·iii©~~ full~ !~o ~§ ~~ ~ ~ ~ 

;!!,~~ .fu2l ~· ~'\g, @,§) £.t 'W@i§ ~ ~ ~ ~~ 

~Tuw~M«~~1~o ~~~~~~~~WiG ~~~t~'©®~m~~§~~§@~ 

@~@@,~@m@ ~&'.8§~~ 'm§ [1~0 ~~ ~ 1]';~ ffi.9~ ~ ~ 

'@© 

~ 

@~ ~ ~ O~u ~o @:Ql§!~l@ ~f,~ Wi®.S@ 

19w ~ ~@)2§@ @t ~t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~dlw ~ 

~~~!M@~o ~~wlJ!,~~~~~~ 

~ ~<jg,~ ~§ mmt~©dbo 

PL ~6':036/50·USC 3605 

EO 3.3(h)(2) 

.. ··:. _,,· !·"··· 

. : . :;:_-.~{'.~; .:". 
~·--~---

.;·, 

·. -~~:. :· .-

, . ._.;··. 

. : .. "; .... 

· .. : .. ··. 

··. :..:· 

;.:· ·.;_. 

~-·.. -./~ ~ .. : ,,,"';;;.. ·, :~ . . :~: ~-· ···Y ~ .. 

<·.:..~-·-·_:f. ,,.·'.---~ :':" -· .-· ;.;~: 

·. ·i;:-.· . : ;..:/~ 

. ···~ '.: 

. :.:.,, ·-· ,· -'i. •. 

•.· .• ~c-

· .. --.... : 

'. -~ 

-·~·-· .-~·.:. 

.. -.. 

:./. :.·•-·· ··- . .... -~- ... 

.. · ,~-

·'· ... ~ : .. _. 

REF ID:A44417 

0 0 

E03,3(h)(2) 

PL 86-36/SOUSC 3605 

. .,. (§o ~~ w£~ ~ «~§o ~»/) @m@ ~ «~o ~~»o 

.;.. ~- ... '"· .. -· .. ,_; 

:;,.,,. -,.,. __ ;.-.J;,, __ 

·"?··' - ~-. 

... ·: ·-:"• . ··,·,· .. 

··. ~--

···:·• ··,.,,. 

. :· ... 

..· . . . . ~; - : 

·-·~: . :,:_. 

, ;··1t•r ~ ,. , • 

I n,• 

. < 

.. - . , '< . ' ... ··._.-.:;--·· · .. _.; .. 

..