### Requested **Documents -- Proposed**  **MACT Rule**  **for Polyvinyl**  **Chloride and**  **Copolymer (PVC)Production**  **Higgins, Cortney**  **to Jodi**  **Howard 04/06f2011**  **01:1 0**  **PM Cc:**  **Penny Lassiter**  **History: This**  **message has**  **been forwarded.** 

**Hi Jodi,**  **Can you**  **send us**  **the following**  **documents? let**  **me know**  **when they**  **will be**  **ready: If**  **they are**  **not yet**  **ready, please** 

**MACT Floor**  **Analysis for**  **the Polyvinyl**  **Chloride (P** **VC) and**  **Copolymers Production**  **Source Category**  **(79, other**  **pages) Analysis**  **for the**  **PVC Production**  **Source Category**  **(p 94)**  **MACT Floor**  **Analysis for**  **the PVC**  **Production Source**  **Category (p**  **96, 99)**  **Analysis of**  **Beyond MACT**  **Floor Controls**  **for the**  **PVC Production**  **Source Category**  **(101) Costs**  **and Emission Reductions**  **of the**  **MACT Floor**  **Level of**  **Control for**  **the PVC**  **Production Source**  **Category (149)**  **Secondary Impacts**  **of the**  **Proposed Level**  **of Control**  **for the**  **PVC Production**  **Source Category**  **(156) Economic**  **Impact Analysis**  **(156) Cost**  **and Impacts**  **of the**  **PVC and**  **Copolymers Proposed**  **Standard (157)**  **ICR Supporting**  **Statement (163)**  **Regards, Cortney**  **202.395.7856 -----Original**  **Message----­ From:**  **Higgins, Cortney**  **Sent: Friday,**  **April 01,**  **2011 12:17**  **PM To:**  **Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov Cc:**  **Lassiter.Penny@epamail.epa.gov Subject:**  **RE: Proposed**  **MACT Rule**  **for Polyvinyl**  **Chloride and**  **Copolymer ( P** **VC) Production**  **Hi Jodi,**  **Thanks for**  **the email.**  **This rule**  **has a**  **settlement agreement**  **deadline of**  **4/15? We**  **are available**  **at the**  **following times**  **next week**  **-- can**  **we schedule**  **an hour**  **for a**  **briefing call?**  **Also, could**  **you please**  **send briefing**  **slides before**  **the call**  **that include**  **the costs**  **and the**  **estimated emissions**  **reductions? 4/4:**  **10-11, 1-2,**  **3-5 4/5:**  **10-2, 3-4**  **4/6: 10-12:30,**  **3-5**
**Thanks, Cortney**  **-----Original Message-----**  **From: Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov**  **[mailto:Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov] Sent:**  **Thursday, March**  **31, 2011**  **4:14 PM**  **To: Higgins, Cortney**  **Subject: Proposed**  **MACT Rule**  **for Polyvinyl**  **Chloride and**  **Copolymer ( P** **VC) Production** **Hi, I'm**  **the project**  **manager for**  **the PVC**  **MACT rule**  **that was**  **sent to**  **OMS this**  **morning. Penny**  **Lassiter, Bill**  **Ni c** **ke r** **s o** **n ,**  **Mark Kataoka,**  **and I**  **would like**  **to talk**  **to you about the**  **rule, so**  **please let**  **me know**  **if we**  **could meet**  **sometime early**  **next week.**  **Thanks. Jodi**  **Howard**

********�***************�*************************************** **Jodi Howard, Environmental**  **Engineer U.S.**  **EPA -**  **Office of**  **Air Quality**  **Planning and**  **Standards Sector**  **Policies and**  **Progra.m Divisions**  **Refining and**  **Chemicals Group**  **Mail Code:**  **E143-01 Research**  **Triangle Park,**  **NC 27711**  **Phone: 919-541-4607**  **Fax: 919-541-0246** **His(c;ry:**



### Hi P**e**

### n

### n**y ,**  

### PVC **Memos**

**H i** **ggins ,**  **Cortney** 

# �o **Penny** 

### Lassiter **Cc: Jodi**  **Howard This**  **message has**  **been replied**  **to and**  **forwarded. 04/08/2011**  **11 :54**  **AM**



### I w**an te** 

### d **to check**  

### in **and see**  

### if**t**

### h**e memo** **s/documents listed**  

### below **can be**  **sent to**  

### us **today?** 

### If **not t** 

### oda**y ,**  

### when **will they**  **be** 

### do

### n**e? Thanks,**  **Cortney** 

### MACT **Floor Analysis**  **for the**  **Polyvinyl Chloride**  **(PVC) and**  **Copolymers Production**  **Source Category**  **(79� other**  **pages) Analysis**  **for the**  **PVC Production**  **Source Category**  **(p 94)**  **MACT Floor**  **Analysis for**  **the PVC**  **Production Source**  **Category (p**  **96� 99)**  **Analysis of**  **Beyond MACT**  **Floor Controls**  **for the**  **PVC Production**  **Source Category**  

## (lel) **Costs and**  **Emission Reductions**  **of the**  **MACT Floor**  **Level of**  **Control for**  **the PVC**  **Production Source**  **Category (149)**  **Secondary Impacts**  **of the**  **Proposed Level**  **of Control**  **for the**  **PVC Production Source**  **Category (156)**  **Economic**

**. Impact**  **Analysis (156)**  **Cost and**  **Impacts of**  **the PVC**  **and Copolymers**  **Proposed Standard**  **(157) ICR**  **Supporting Statement**  **(163)**

### Referenced **materials In**  **PVC memos**  **Higgins. Cortney**  

# �o **Jodi Howard**  **Cc:** 

### Penny **Lassiter 04/12/2011**  **10:38 AM** **----------- -------------------------------------------------------**  **I hstory·**  

### This **message has** **been forwarded.** 



### Hi **Jodi,** 

### The **baseline emission**  **memo on**  **page 2**  **has a**  **footnote "2"**  **that points**  **to** 

### the **determination of**  

### HAP **concentrations,** 

### which **is in a**  **separate memo.**  **Can you**  **send that**  **memo, and**  **can the**  **source** 

### be **added to**  **the memo?**  **I can't**  

### find **what footnote**  **2 references.**  **Regards, Cortney** 

### RE: **Revised PVC**  **Memos Higgins,**  **Cortney to**  **Jodi Howard**  **Cc: Penny**  **Lassiter, Mark**  **Kataoka, William**  **Nickerson**

**--- History·**  **This message**  **has been**  **replied to**  **and forwarded.** 

**Thanks! Do**  **you also**  **have a**  **copy of**  **the EJ**  **analysis? Regards,**  **Cortney -----Original**  **Message----- 04/12/2011**  **11 :42**  **AM**

**From: Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov**  **[mailto:Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov] Sent:**  **Tuesday, April**  **12, 2011**  **11:41 AM**  **To: Higgi** **ns, Cortney**  **Cc: Lassiter**  **.Penny@epamail.epa.gov; Kataoka.Mark@epamail.epa.gov;**  **Nickerson.William@epamail.epa.gov Subject:**  **Revised PVC**  **Memos Cortney,**  **Attached are**  **the revised**  **MACT floor,**  **Secondary Impacts,**  **and Floor**  **Reductions and**  **Costs memos.**  **The Beyond-the-Floor**  **memo was**  **not amended.**  **I will**  **be sending**  **you the**  **revised preamble**  **and Economic**  **Impacts memo**  **shortly. Thanks.**  **(See attached**  **file: Memo**  **PVC Secondary**  **Impacts DRAFT**  **201100411.pdf) (See**  **attached file:**  **Memo PVC**  **MACT-Floor DRAFT**  **20110411.pdf) (See**  **attached file:**  **Memo**

**_ PVC_MAC** **T**

# =**Floor**

**_ Red** **u ct** **i ons_Cos** **t S** 

**_ DRA** **F T** 

**_ 20110411.pd** **f )** 

************* ******************************************************* **Jodi Howard,**  **Environmental Engineer**  **u.s. EPA**  **- Office**  **of Air**  **Quality Planning**  **and Standards**  **Sector Policies**  **and Program Divisions**  **Refining and**  **Chemicals Group**  **Mail Code:**  **E143-01 Research**  **Triangle Park,**  **NC 27711**  **Phone: 919-541-4607**  **Fax: 919-541-0246** **History:**

**Hi Jodi,**  

### RE: **Revised PVC**  **proposal package** 

**Higgins, Cortney**  

# �o **Jodi Howard**  **Cc: Penny**  **Lassiter, Mark**  **Kataoka, Janet**  **Eck, "Kymn,**  **Christine J."**  **This message**  **has been**  **replied to**  **and forwarded.**  **04/12/2011 10:22**  **PM**

**I have**  **no additional**  **comments --**  **can you**  **send a**  **clean version to**  **Christine (copied**  **above)? Thanks,**  **Cortney**
**-----Original Message-----**  **Sent: Tuesday,**  **April 12,**  **2011 6:39**  **PM To:**  **Higgins, Cortney**  **Cc: lassiter.penny@epa.gov;**  **kataoka. ma** **rk@epa.gov; eck.**  **janet@epa.gov Subject:**  **Revised PVC**  **proposal package**  **Cortney, Our**  **server is**  **down, so**  **I'm sending**  **you the**  **revised package**  **with OGC**  **and OMB**  **comments/edits addressed**  **from my**  **personal email**  **address. We**  **still need**  **to check**  **cross references**  **and do**  **a few**  **other minor**  **edits to**  **the package.**  **Thanks. Jodi**  **Howard howard.jodi@epa.gov**  **919-541-4607**

# � **PVC**

### Package**04·12·11 v3.doc** **Jodi ,**  

## OIRA **Review Concluded,**  **EPA NPR** **M: NESHAP:**  **Polyvinyl Chloride**  **and Copolymers**  **Production, Amendme** 

**. nts**  **Kymn, Christine**  **J.** 

# �o **Jodi Howard**  **04/14/2011 06:23**  

### PM **Cc: "Higgins, Co.rtney",**  **Penny Lassiter,**  **Darryl Adams**  **This message**  **has been**  **forwarded.**

**OIRA has**  **concluded review**  **of EPA**  **' s**  

### NPRM, **NESHAP: Polyvinyl**  **Chloride and**  **Copolymers Production**  **, Amendments.**  

### Pl**ea**

### s**e** 

### let **us know**  **if you**  **have any**  **questions. Thank**  **you,** 

### Christine**History:** 

### EO **12866 13563**  

### Review: **Revised PVC**  **proposal package**  **Kymn, Chri** **stine** 

### J. **to** 

### Jodi **Howard Cc;**  **"Higgins, Cortney",**  **Penny Lassiter**  **This message**  **has been**  **replied to**  **and forwarded.** 
**Thanks, Jodi.**  **On the**  **two edits:**  **04/14/2011 12:29**  **PM**

**1) The**  **sentence of**  **most import**  **that I**  **do not**  **see in**  **the la** **test draft**  **is: "We**  **further solicit**  **comment on**  **whether we**  **should issue**  **MACT standards**  **under CAA**  **section 112(d)**  **(2) and**  **(3) in**  **lieu of**  **GACT standards**  **under section**  **112 (d)**  **(5) given**  **the significant**  **amount of**  **additional information**  **on the**  **one area**  **source that**  **was not**  **availa ble**  **to EPA**  **at the**  **time of**  **the 2007**  **area source**  **GACT promul** **gation." 2)**  **On the**  **GACT same**  **as MACT**  **sentences, I**  **saw the**  **changes but**  **noted that**  **there is**  **one less**  **occurrence of**  **a version**  **of this**  **sentence. I**  **don't think**  **this need**  **be a**  **huge issue.**  **On item**  **1 above,**  **I could**  **not find**  **that sentence**  **anywhere in**  **the la** **test draft.**  **I'll give**  **you a**  **quick call**  **on this.**  **Thanks, Christine**  **-----Original Message-----**  **From: Howard.Jodi@epamail**  **.epa.gov [mail** **to:Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov] Sent:**  **Thursday, April**  **14, 2011**  **12:07 PM**  **To: Kymn, Christine**  **J. Cc:**  **Higgins, Cortney;**  **Lassiter. Penny@epamail.epa.gov**  **Subject: RE:**  **Revised PVC**  **proposal package**  **Christine, I**  **have answers**  **to your**  **two questions**  **about changes**  **on the**  **PVC package**  **that I**  **sent to**  **Cortney on**  **Tuesday evening**  **(with OGC**  **and OMB**  **revisions) p.**  **86 of**  **the redline**  **version: the**  **following sentence**  **was modified**  **from**

**- "As**  **explained explained**  **in greater**  **detail below,**  **we determined**  **that GACT**  **is the**  **same as**  **MACT based**  **on" to**  **"As explained**  **in greater**  **detail below,**  **we determined**  **that GACT**  **standards for**  **area sources**  **should be**  **the same**  **as the**  **major source**  **MACT standards**  **based on"**  **p. 90**  **of the**  **redline version:**  **The "we**  **solicit comments"**  **sentence is**  **on page**  **78 of**  **the version**  **that I**  **sent to**  **you last**  **night. Pl** **ease let**  **me know**  **if you**  **have any**  **other questions.**  **Thanks.**

**************************************************************** **Jodi Howard,**  **Environmental Engineer**  **u.s. EPA**  **- Office**  **of Air**  **Quality Planning**  **and Standards**  **Sector Policies**  **and Program**  **Divisions Refining**  **and Chemicals**  **Group Mail**  **Code: E143-01**  **Research Triangle**  **Park, NC**  **27711 Phone:**  **919-541-4607 Fax:**  **919-541-0246**

**From: "Kymn,**  **Christine J.**  **" <Christine_J.** **_Kymn@ornb.e op.**  **gov> To:**  **Jodi Howard/RTP/USE** **PA/US@EPA Cc:**  **"Higgins, Cortney"**  **<Cortney**

**_ Higgins@ornb.eop.gov>,**  **Penny Lassit** **er/RTP/ USEPA/US@EPA**  **Date: 04/14/2011**  **11:04 AM**  **Subject: RE:**  **Revised PVC**  **proposal package** 

**Thanks, Jodi.**  **I ' m**  **reviewing. Looks**  **like there**  **are some**  **language changes**  **as compared**  **to the**  **last redline?**  **Maybe we**  **can chat**  **briefly once**  **I' m**  **done going**  **through it**  **all. From:**  **Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.gov [mailto:Howard.Jodi@epamail.epa.**  **gov] Sent:**  **Wednesday, April**  **13, 2011**  **9:32 PM**  **To: Kymn,**  **Christine J.**  **Cc: Higgins,**  **Cortney; Lassiter.Penny@epamail.**  **epa. gov**  **Subject: RE:**  **Revised PVC**  **proposal package**  **Chri stine,**  **Attached is**  **the clean**  **version of**  **the PVC**  **proposal package.**  **Please let**  **me know**  **if you**  **have any**  **questions. Thanks.**  **Jodi**

**************************************************************** **Jodi Howard,**  **Environmental Engineer U.**  **S. EPA**  **- Office**  **of Air**  **Quality Planning**  **and Standards Sector**  **Policies and**  **Program Divisions**  **Refining and**  **Chemicals Group**  **Mail Code: E143-01**  **Research Triangle**  **Park, NC**  **27711 Phone:**  **919-541-4607 Fax:**  **919-541-0246 History:**  

### RE: **Revised PVC**  **proposal package**  **Kymn,** 

### Christine **J .**  **to** 

### Jodi **Howard Cc:**  **"Higgins, Cortney", Penny**  **Lassiter This**  **message has**  **been replied**  **to and**  **forwarded. 04/14/201**  **1 11** **:04 AM** 

**Thanks, Jodi.**  

### I'm **reviewing. Looks**  **like there**  **are some**  **language changes**  **as compared**  **to the**  **last redline?**  **Maybe we**  **can chat**  **briefly once**  **I'm done**  **going through**  **it all.**  

### From: **HowardJodi@epama il.epa.gov**  **[mai lt** **o:Howard .Jodi@epama** **i l.** **epa.gov]** 

## Sent: **Wednesday, April 13,**  **2011 9:32**  **PM** 

### To: **Kymn ,**  **Ch ri** **stine J.**  

### Cc: **Higgins, Co** **rtney; Lassiter.Pe** **nn y@epama** **il. epa.gov**  

## Subject: **RE: Rev** **ised PVC**  **pr oposal**  **package Ch** **ristin e,**  **Attached is**  **the cl** **ea n**  **v e rsion**  **of the**  **PV C**  **prop osal**  **p a cka** **g e.**  **Please le** **t me**  **kn ow**  **if you ha** **ve any**  **questions. Than** **ks. Jodi** 

**************************************************************** 

### Jodi **How ar** **d, En** **vironmental En** **gi nee** **r U.S.**  **EPA -**  **Offi ce**  **of Air**  **Qual it** **y Planning and**  **Stan da** **rds Sec** **tor Polici** **es and**  **Program Di** **visions Refining and**  **Chemicals Group**  **Mail Co** **de: E143-01**  **Resea rch**  **Triang le**  **Par k,**  **NC 2 7** **711 Ph** **one: 919** **-541-4607 Fax:**  **919-541-02 46**