Correlation Assessments

Metal Emissions verses Particulate Matter Emissions, Metals in Coal, Ash Content

The following pages provide the results of assessments relating the correlations of

Metals emissions to a variety of other measured parameters. All of the data were the reported

test data submitted to EPA as part of the third Information Collection Request. Metals

emissions and the majority of the filterable particulate emissions were the three run average

results of source emissions test using EPA Method 29. Total PM2.5 data were mostly the three

run average result of a combination of OTM‐27 (comparable to the December 2010

promulgated EPA Method 201A) and OTM‐28 (comparable to the December 2010 promulgated

EPA Method 202). Total PM data were mostly the three run average results of the filterable PM

from EPA Method 29 and OTM‐28. The metals content of coal and the ash content of coal were

the averages of data reported in the ICR response.  

Initial exploratory analysis were performed for the purpose of providing a national

emissions factor to represent coal fired utility boilers which were not part of the Part III ICR test

program. Corresponding emissions results for each metal, filterable particulate matter, total

particulate matter, total PM2.5, metals content of the combusted coal and ash content of the

combusted coal were arranged in a table. Next, the data were log transformed in preparation of

performing a regression analysis using the “Data Analysis” add in function of Excel.  The data

were sorted such that a regression analysis could be performed on the maximum number of

facilities. The following table provides a summary of the results of the regression analysis:

Metal

Highest

Correlation Best PM Indicator Comparable Indicators

Arsenic 48% TPM & As in Coal FPM & As in Coal, TPM, FPM

Beryllium 38% FPM & Be in Coal/FPM TPM & Be in Coal/TPM

Cadmium 21% TPM & Cd in Coal FPM & Cd in Coal, TPM, FPM

Chromium 29% FPM & Cr in Coal TPM & Cr in Coal

Cobalt 31% TPM FPM

Lead 13% FPM

TPM/FPM & Lead in Coal/TPM &

Lead in Coal

Manganese 26% FPM TPM

Nickel 18% FPM TPM

Selenium 25% TPM2.5/TPM

Sum of Metals 19% TPM2.5/TPM FPM

Detailed regression results and the underlying data are provided in the following pages. I

addition, the Excel spreadsheet which generated the attached pages is attached to this PDF.
Regression Results ‐ Arsenic Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal arsenic content, Coal ash etc.

As, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.554006992

R Square 0.306923748

Adjusted R Square 0.300790329

Standard Error 1.426638346

Observations 115

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 101.8487501 101.8488 50.04122324 1.33937E‐10

Residual 113 229.9885577 2.035297

Total 114 331.8373078

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.55121628 0.479847775 ‐21.98867 1.24749E‐42 ‐11.50188124 ‐9.6005513 ‐11.5018812 ‐9.600551326

LN FPM 0.660641291 0.093390297 7.073982 1.33937E‐10 0.475618275 0.84566431 0.475618275 0.845664307

SUMMARY OUTPUT

As, All Data w/ TPM

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.622517454

R Square 0.38752798

Adjusted R Square 0.382107874

Standard Error 1.341116515

Observations 115

ANOVA

df SS MS F Sig f ni icance F

Regression 1 128.5962416 128.5962 71.49822413 1.10887E‐13

Residual 113 203.2410662 1.798594

Total 114 331.8373078

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.604044924 0.513190077 ‐18.7144 2.06745E‐36 ‐10.62076699 ‐8.5873229 ‐10.620767 ‐8.587322856

LN TPM #/mmBtu 1.06814721 0.126323306 8.455662 1.10887E‐13 0.817877965 1.31841645 0.817877965 1.318416455

All Data w/ FPM &Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.653703181

R Square 0.427327848

Adjusted R Square 0.415143334

Standard Error 1.387182866

Observations 97

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 134.9740928 67.48705 35.07139086 4.18394E‐12

Residual 94 180.8819727 1.924276

Total 96 315.8560655

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.01284383 0.555364281 ‐19.82995 2.3623E‐35 ‐12.1155326 ‐9.9101551 ‐12.1155326 ‐9.910155055

LN FPM 0.662725323 0.098599882 6.72136 1.37712E‐09 0.46695295 0.8584977 0.46695295 0.858497696

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.484336764 0.130512282 3.711044 0.000349515 0.225201576 0.74347195 0.225201576 0.743471953
Regression Results ‐ Arsenic Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal arsenic content, Coal ash etc.

All Data w/ TPM &Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.694315017

R Square 0.482073344

Adjusted R Square 0.471053627

Standard Error 1.319212676

Observations 97

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 152.2657896 76.13289 43.7464395 3.72056E‐14

Residual 94 163.5902759 1.740322

Total 96 315.8560655

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.30857911 0.573454681 ‐17.97628 3.56292E‐32 ‐11.4471868 ‐9.1699714 ‐11.4471868 ‐9.16997143

LN TPM #/mmBtu 1.012890548 0.130886008 7.738723 1.12389E‐11 0.753013317 1.27276778 0.753013317 1.27276778

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.482999154 0.123814652 3.900985 0.000179855 0.237162267 0.72883604 0.237162267 0.728836042

All Data w/ TPM2.5 &Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.631376727

R Square 0.398636572

Adjusted R Square 0.385841605

Standard Error 1.421507614

Observations 97

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 125.9117791 62.95589 31.15573379 4.16332E‐11

Residual 94 189.9442863 2.020684

Total 96 315.8560655

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.51485954 0.67298664 ‐15.62417 7.14867E‐28 ‐11.85109026 ‐9.1786288 ‐11.8510903 ‐9.178628819

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.863075389 0.139031286 6.207778 1.44301E‐08 0.587025518 1.13912526 0.587025518 1.139125259

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.493543395 0.133719063 3.690898 0.000374571 0.228041067 0.75904572 0.228041067 0.759045722
Regression Results ‐ Arsenic Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal arsenic content, Coal ash etc.

All Data w/ TPM, Metals Content, Coal Ash

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.615233172

R Square 0.378511856

Adjusted R Square 0.311923841

Standard Error 1.560703273

Observations 32

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 3 41.5379781 13.84599 5.684384098 0.003598354

Residual 28 68.20225181 2.435795

Total 31 109.7402299

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.18740494 1.408672697 ‐7.941806 1.19356E‐08 ‐14.07294012 ‐8.3018698 ‐14.0729401 ‐8.301869767

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.732278162 0.306144208 2.391939 0.023715999 0.105170188 1.35938614 0.105170188 1.359386136

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.635233718 0.26457283 2.400979 0.023238071 0.093280851 1.17718659 0.093280851 1.177186586

LN Coal ash Content (%) 0.129130939 0.107591606 1.200195 0.240119961 ‐0.091260471 0.34952235 ‐0.09126047 0.34952235

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ As EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.455321513

R Square 0.207317681

Adjusted R Square 0.157775036

Standard Error 1.414658601

Observations 35

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 16.74905995 8.37453 4.184630853 0.024298907

Residual 32 64.04028662 2.001259

Total 34 80.78934657

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.28735398 1.619885097 ‐7.585324 1.21758E‐08 ‐15.58695193 ‐8.987756 ‐15.5869519 ‐8.987756026

LN FPM 0.53613308 0.253879626 2.111761 0.042606685 0.018997207 1.05326895 0.018997207 1.053268953

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.333584461 0.344046317 0.969592 0.339521963 ‐0.36721495 1.03438387 ‐0.36721495 1.034383872
Regression Results ‐ Arsenic Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal arsenic content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ As EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.454077269

R Square 0.206186166

Adjusted R Square 0.156572801

Standard Error 1.415667918

Observations 35

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 16.65764561 8.328823 4.15585936 0.024859856

Residual 32 64.13170096 2.004116

Total 34 80.78934657

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.24570455 1.648250871 ‐7.429515 1.87264E‐08 ‐15.60308169 ‐8.8883274 ‐15.6030817 ‐8.888327403

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.707900223 0.337188474 2.09942 0.043755135 0.021069781 1.39473067 0.021069781 1.394730665

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.497765623 0.321301839 1.549215 0.131164574 ‐0.156704804 1.15223605 ‐0.1567048 1.152236049
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal ID

'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

TPM#/mmBtu

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%)

PM‐AcidControl LN As LN FPM

Arsenic 1471 2.75E‐04 1.33E‐02 1.82E‐02 9.36E‐03 36.5333 9.7% ESP ‐8.1987 ‐4.31999 

Arsenic 1154 1.94E‐06 3.19E‐02 3.67E‐02 1.64E‐02 1.5337 7.8% ESP ‐13.153 ‐3.44515 

Arsenic 1141 5.29E‐06 8.12E‐02 8.30E‐02 2.27E‐02 1.1167 7.8% ESP ‐12.15 ‐2.51084 

Arsenic 1558 2.87E‐06 2.41E‐02 2.69E‐02 2.88E‐03 1.2000 9.7% ESP‐Wet ‐12.761 ‐3.72697 

Arsenic 1330 1.32E‐05 1.47E‐02 4.10E‐02 2.63E‐02 24.2833 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐11.235 ‐4.21991 

Arsenic 1177 3.52E‐06 2.11E‐02 8.02E‐02 6.02E‐02 5.0417 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐12.557 ‐3.85848 

Arsenic 1276 1.85E‐07 4.69E‐02 5.95E‐02 1.26E‐02 4.5633 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐15.503 ‐3.05974 

Arsenic 1310 7.11E‐07 4.38E‐02 4.76E‐02 1.16E‐02 2.3333 7.8% FF ‐14.157 ‐3.12812 

Arsenic 1244 6.66E‐07 7.40E‐03 2.45E‐02 1.97E‐02 0.8217 7.8% FF ‐14.221 ‐4.90621 

Arsenic 1189 1.64E‐07 4.69E‐04 3.08E‐03 3.85E‐03 0.3440 7.8% FF ‐15.623 ‐7.66491 

Arsenic 1190 3.68E‐07 4.09E‐03 7.49E‐03 4.52E‐03 0.3440 7.8% FF ‐14.815 ‐5.49921 

Arsenic 1597 1.53E‐06 4.18E‐03 9.93E‐03 7.35E‐03 1.1403 6.6% FF ‐13.39 ‐5.47744 

Arsenic 1563 3.83E‐07 3.68E‐03 1.11E‐02 1.12E‐02 16.4972 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐14.775 ‐5.60484 

Arsenic 1488 1.11E‐07 8.28E‐04 2.05E‐02 1.96E‐02 1.6333 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐16.014 ‐7.0965 

A i rsen c 1568 2 01E . ‐07 5 61E . ‐03 1 13E . ‐02 8 21E . ‐03 1 3143 . 9 7%. FF‐Dry ‐15 42 . ‐5 1832 . Arsenic 1507 2.36E‐07 6.86E‐04 4.51E‐03 4.14E‐03 0.8541 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐15.259 ‐7.28463 

Arsenic 1249 1.14E‐07 3.62E‐03 3.20E‐02 2.91E‐02 4.6667 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐15.987 ‐5.62128 

Arsenic 1349 7.12E‐07 2.35E‐03 4.47E‐03 2.12E‐03 4.4583 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐14.155 ‐6.05334 

Arsenic 1133 3.75E‐07 5.86E‐04 2.78E‐02 2.75E‐02 1.4000 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐14.795 ‐7.44269 

Arsenic 1398 3.03E‐07 1.10E‐03 8.82E‐03 8.46E‐03 1.3222 7.6% FF‐Dry ‐15.01 ‐6.81245 

Arsenic 1515 2.47E‐07 2.72E‐03 5.35E‐03 2.63E‐03 1.5450 9.7% FF‐Wet ‐15.214 ‐5.90712 

Arsenic 1176 8.32E‐07 2.56E‐02 3.12E‐02 5.56E‐03 2.4167 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐13.999 ‐3.66516 

Arsenic 1307 1.41E‐06 2.76E‐03 6.12E‐03 3.36E‐03 1.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐13.472 ‐5.89252 

Arsenic 1327 2.93E‐07 4.57E‐03 6.98E‐03 2.41E‐03 1.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐15.043 ‐5.38824 

Arsenic 22791 2.33E‐07 5.55E‐03 1.69E‐02 1.19E‐02 6.5500 0.0% ESP ‐15.271 ‐5.19436 

Arsenic 21351 5.47E‐06 1.13E‐02 5.06E‐02 6.15E‐02 1.3143 0.0% ESP ‐12.116 ‐4.48295 

Arsenic 1636 3.22E‐05 1.10E‐01 2.01E‐01 1.46E‐01 14.8333 0.0% ESP ‐10.344 ‐2.20727 

Arsenic 1906 5.01E‐06 2.19E‐02 5.83E‐02 4.06E‐02 8.6667 0.0% ESP ‐12.204 ‐3.82127 

Arsenic 2279 7.00E‐07 5.67E‐03 1.07E‐02 6.62E‐03 6.5500 0.0% ESP ‐14.173 ‐5.17213 

Arsenic 3197 3.70E‐07 4.15E‐03 6.54E‐03 4.16E‐03 5.7367 0.0% ESP ‐14.81 ‐5.48465 

Arsenic 1854 2.57E‐07 5.59E‐03 1.64E‐02 1.32E‐02 5.0417 0.0% ESP ‐15.174 ‐5.18678 

Arsenic Arsenic 1845 3 35E . ‐05 6 45E . ‐02 1 68E . ‐01 1 41E . ‐01 5 0417 . 0 0%. ESP ‐10 304 . ‐2 74109 2.74109 Arsenic 2274 1.75E‐07 1.14E‐02 2.96E‐02 2.20E‐02 4.0000 0.0% ESP ‐15.558 ‐4.47414 

Arsenic 2276 5.87E‐07 2.40E‐02 4.42E‐02 2.92E‐02 4.0000 0.0% ESP ‐14.348 ‐3.7297 

Arsenic 1809 1.62E‐05 3.32E‐02 9.11E‐02 5.79E‐02 3.9533 0.0% ESP ‐11.03 ‐3.40521 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal ID

'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

TPM#/mmBtu

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%)

PM‐AcidControl LN As LN FPM

Arsenic 1642 1.50E‐06 1.11E‐02 1.41E‐02 1.10E‐02 3.3333 0.0% ESP ‐13.41 ‐4.50081 

Arsenic 2161 1.09E‐06 4.90E‐04 7.87E‐02 7.82E‐02 3.0300 0.0% ESP ‐13.729 ‐7.62111 

Arsenic 2195 1.47E‐06 1.66E‐03 7.50E‐03 6.84E‐03 2.4233 0.0% ESP ‐13.43 ‐6.40094 

Arsenic 2302 1.10E‐06 1.52E‐02 3.50E‐02 3.12E‐02 2.0000 0.0% ESP ‐13.72 ‐4.18646 

Arsenic 2009 2.83E‐06 5.88E‐02 6.33E‐02 2.10E‐02 1.5337 0.0% ESP ‐12.775 ‐2.83361 

Arsenic 1902 2.24E‐06 9.12E‐03 1.53E‐02 1.20E‐02 1.4175 0.0% ESP ‐13.009 ‐4.69729 

Arsenic 2135 2.08E‐06 1.94E‐02 4.55E‐02 4.06E‐02 1.3143 0.0% ESP ‐13.083 ‐3.94248 

Arsenic 1989 1.90E‐06 2.84E‐02 3.36E‐02 5.16E‐03 1.0000 0.0% ESP ‐13.174 ‐3.56137 

Arsenic 979 3.93E‐06 4.02E‐02 1.02E‐01 6.83E‐02 16.3083 #N/A ESP ‐12.447 ‐3.21389 

Arsenic 1113 8.85E‐06 9.95E‐03 7.65E‐02 7.82E‐02 15.6289 #N/A ESP ‐11.635 ‐4.61018 

Arsenic 902 2.37E‐05 2.84E‐02 6.76E‐02 5.29E‐02 8.9800 #N/A ESP ‐10.65 ‐3.56137 

Arsenic 903 2.70E‐05 1.05E‐01 1.50E‐01 8.72E‐02 8.9800 #N/A ESP ‐10.52 ‐2.25379 

Arsenic 828 2.38E‐05 1.00E‐01 1.70E‐01 1.05E‐01 5.0417 #N/A ESP ‐10.646 ‐2.30259 

Arsenic 993 5.26E‐06 1.29E‐02 2.57E‐02 2.55E‐02 4.4756 #N/A ESP ‐12.155 ‐4.35053 

Arsenic 894 1.79E‐06 9.20E‐03 2.87E‐02 2.32E‐02 1.5333 #N/A ESP ‐13.233 ‐4.68855 

Arsenic 892 6.79E‐06 1.29E‐01 1.36E‐01 3.90E‐02 1.1333 #N/A ESP ‐11.9 ‐2.04794 

Arsenic 1021 2.40E‐07 1.30E‐03 7.07E‐03 7.27E‐03 0.6917 #N/A ESP ‐15.244 ‐6.64294 

Arsenic 975 1.04E‐05 1.47E‐01 1.71E‐01 5.15E‐02 0.0909 #N/A ESP ‐11.474 ‐1.91732 

Arsenic 18261 5.47E‐06 1.13E‐02 2.42E‐02 1.29E‐02 12.5333 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.116 ‐4.48295 

Arsenic 1743 3.15E‐06 3.59E‐03 9.89E‐03 6.30E‐03 20.2078 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.668 ‐5.6296 

Arsenic 1738 2.45E‐06 3.02E‐03 1.22E‐02 9.20E‐03 20.2078 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.919 ‐5.8025 

Arsenic 1826 3.68E‐06 2.57E‐02 4.30E‐02 1.73E‐02 12.5333 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.513 ‐3.66126 

Arsenic 1638 2.48E‐06 3.83E‐03 1.38E‐02 9.93E‐03 11.3000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.907 ‐5.56444 

Arsenic 1637 2.01E‐06 5.86E‐03 1.67E‐02 1.08E‐02 11.3000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.117 ‐5.13879 

Arsenic 2055 3.70E‐06 8.72E‐03 2.83E‐02 1.96E‐02 7.8033 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.507 ‐4.74214 

Arsenic 1915 1.40E‐06 3.35E‐03 1.86E‐02 1.89E‐02 1.3143 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.479 ‐5.69879 

Arsenic 2239 6.32E‐07 3.27E‐03 6.41E‐03 3.14E‐03 0.7000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐14.274 ‐5.72297 

Arsenic 900 7.28E‐07 4.11E‐03 7.82E‐03 3.71E‐03 7.6500 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐14.133 ‐5.49433 

Arsenic 966 2.31E‐05 1.84E‐02 2.61E‐02 7.67E‐03 6.6075 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐10.676 ‐3.9954 

Arsenic 1120 1.99E‐06 3.23E‐02 3.42E‐02 1.95E‐03 3.4883 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐13.127 ‐3.43269 

Arsenic 63254 4.11E‐06 1.40E‐02 2.57E‐02 1.42E‐02 12.3333 0.0% FF ‐12.402 ‐4.2687 

Arsenic 879456 2.18E‐06 4.53E‐02 7.74E‐02 8.49E‐02 1.6667 0.0% FF ‐13.036 ‐3.09445 

Arsenic 2095 3.26E‐06 9.09E‐05 3.61E‐03 3.53E‐03 9.2950 0.0% FF ‐12.634 ‐9.30575 

Arsenic 1606 4.24E‐07 6.64E‐03 1.52E‐02 9.55E‐03 2.6833 0.0% FF ‐14.674 ‐5.01464 

Arsenic 1841 7.24E‐07 1.34E‐03 7.28E‐03 6.54E‐03 1.6000 0.0% FF ‐14.138 ‐6.61509 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal ID

'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

TPM#/mmBtu

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%)

PM‐AcidControl LN As LN FPM

Arsenic 2170 2.35E‐07 7.21E‐04 5.49E‐03 4.90E‐03 1.0000 0.0% FF ‐15.262 ‐7.23482 

Arsenic 1835 2.64E‐07 8.07E‐04 2.03E‐02 1.99E‐02 1.0000 0.0% FF ‐15.147 ‐7.12165 

Arsenic 524 1.65E‐06 1.08E‐02 1.78E‐02 1.06E‐02 50.4667 #N/A FF ‐13.315 ‐4.52821 

Arsenic 735 3.00E‐07 2.43E‐03 1.42E‐02 1.28E‐02 0.8217 #N/A FF ‐15.02 ‐6.02156 

Arsenic 1942 1.00E‐07 3.56E‐03 6.18E‐03 2.64E‐03 10.0100 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐16.118 ‐5.63799 

Arsenic 2021 8.54E‐07 2.14E‐02 4.06E‐02 2.88E‐02 7.5000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.973 ‐3.84436 

Arsenic 8761 2.33E‐05 4.48E‐03 1.18E‐02 9.88E‐03 5.3333 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐10.667 ‐5.40813 

Arsenic 8761 1.46E‐05 4.48E‐03 1.18E‐02 9.88E‐03 5.3333 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐11.134 ‐5.40813 

Arsenic 2022 3.99E‐06 1.94E‐02 2.84E‐02 2.40E‐02 4.7500 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐12.432 ‐3.94248 

Arsenic 1734 4.53E‐07 5.47E‐03 1.14E‐02 1.01E‐02 4.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐14.607 ‐5.20848 

Arsenic 1735 1.25E‐06 2.01E‐02 2.73E‐02 2.06E‐02 4.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.591 ‐3.90704 

Arsenic 1611 2.01E‐07 2.11E‐03 6.85E‐03 5.05E‐03 2.6833 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐15.42 ‐6.16107 

Arsenic 1938 1.75E‐06 2.09E‐02 3.56E‐02 3.14E‐02 1.6000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.256 ‐3.86801 

Arsenic 2206 3.00E‐07 4.51E‐03 1.35E‐02 9.53E‐03 1.4000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐15.019 ‐5.40146 

Arsenic 1726 1.88E‐07 4.50E‐04 3.83E‐03 3.66E‐03 1.2049 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐15.487 ‐7.70626 

Arsenic 1909 6.08E‐08 1.39E‐03 4.65E‐03 4.41E‐03 0.8541 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐16.616 ‐6.57845 

Arsenic 1052 1.18E‐07 1.10E‐02 2.30E‐02 1.48E‐02 2.3000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐15.953 ‐4.50986 

Arsenic 1129 1.14E‐07 8.05E‐04 3.73E‐03 3.32E‐03 1.4000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐15.986 ‐7.12438 

Arsenic 947 7.29E‐08 2.28E‐03 1.64E‐02 1.43E‐02 1.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐16.434 ‐6.08358 

Arsenic 23152 2.34E‐08 1.36E‐03 4.37E‐03 3.01E‐03 1.9906 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐17.571 ‐6.60027 

Arsenic 23153 8.25E‐08 3.21E‐03 6.28E‐03 3.07E‐03 1.9906 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐16.31 ‐5.74148 

Arsenic 23151 4.63E‐08 4.68E‐03 8.80E‐03 4.12E‐03 1.9906 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐16.888 ‐5.36446 

Arsenic 2319 2.90E‐07 3.50E‐03 5.22E‐03 5.22E‐03 8.1667 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐15.053 ‐5.65499 

Arsenic 1648 2.01E‐07 2.92E‐03 6.66E‐03 3.74E‐03 5.8000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐15.42 ‐5.83617 

Arsenic 2259 2.58E‐07 3.33E‐03 7.36E‐03 4.03E‐03 5.3333 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐15.17 ‐5.70478 

Arsenic 1972 4.05E‐08 1.92E‐03 4.32E‐03 3.44E‐03 2.6000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐17.022 ‐6.25543 

Arsenic 2315 4.78E‐08 3.77E‐03 8.16E‐03 4.39E‐03 1.9906 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐16.856 ‐5.58068 

Arsenic 1833 6.12E‐07 5.15E‐04 6.55E‐03 6.18E‐03 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐14.307 ‐7.57134 

Arsenic 1832 5.82E‐07 9.36E‐04 8.96E‐03 8.03E‐03 0.0000 6.0% FF ‐14.357 ‐6.9739 

Arsenic 2088 8.29E‐07 3.91E‐03 1.02E‐02 1.31E‐02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐14.003 ‐5.54422 

Arsenic 13461 3.42E‐07 8.45E‐03 1.05E‐02 5.41E‐03 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐14.888 ‐4.77359 

Arsenic 1346 3.33E‐07 1.08E‐02 1.30E‐02 4.27E‐03 0.0000 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐14.915 ‐4.52821 

Arsenic 1654 6.62E‐07 9.10E‐03 2.40E‐02 2.00E‐02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐14.228 ‐4.69948 

Arsenic 2103 3.50E‐07 1.13E‐02 2.68E‐02 1.71E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐14.865 ‐4.48295 

Arsenic 1185 6.49E‐07 1.07E‐02 2.88E‐02 1.81E‐02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐14.248 ‐4.53751 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal ID

'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

TPM#/mmBtu

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%)

PM‐AcidControl LN As LN FPM

Arsenic 1346111 9.77E‐07 2.71E‐02 2.91E‐02 6.51E‐03 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.839 ‐3.60822 

Arsenic 1187 5.68E‐07 1.66E‐02 2.92E‐02 1.26E‐02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐14.381 ‐4.09835 

Arsenic 2011 1.09E‐06 2.88E‐02 3.42E‐02 1.81E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐13.729 ‐3.54738 

Arsenic 134611 1.39E‐06 3.57E‐02 3.79E‐02 4.71E‐03 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.486 ‐3.3326 

Arsenic 2278 3.97E‐07 3.93E‐02 4.95E‐02 1.31E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐14.739 ‐3.23653 

Arsenic 2013 3.05E‐06 5.17E‐02 6.35E‐02 3.02E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐12.7 ‐2.9623 

Arsenic 736 2.97E‐07 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF ‐15.03 ‐5.71195 

Arsenic 731 1.26E‐06 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐13.584 ‐4.49268 

Arsenic 734 5.36E‐07 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF ‐14.438 ‐6.21535 

Arsenic 632 1.39E‐05 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐11.184 ‐4.30075 

Arsenic 12861 1.64E‐06 5.27E‐03 2.0000 7.9% ESP ‐13.321 ‐5.24572 

Arsenic 10040002 9.81E‐07 5.31E‐02 4.3333 0.0% ESP ‐13.835 ‐2.93558 

Arsenic 1004 8.20E‐07 1.14E‐02 6.0000 #N/A ESP ‐14.014 ‐4.47414 

Arsenic 550002 6.59E‐07 4.91E‐02 13.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐14.232 ‐3.0139 

Arsenic 560 8.20E‐08 3.88E‐03 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐16.317 ‐5.55192 

Arsenic 565 7.76E‐08 2.75E‐03 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐16.372 ‐5.89615 

Arsenic 1449 3.71E‐07 1.20E‐03 0.0000 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐14.807 ‐6.72543 

Arsenic 10040004 1.73E‐07 7.52E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐15.57 ‐4.89019 

Arsenic 2070 8.24E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 5.0417 0.0% ESP ‐14.009 #N/A 

Arsenic 1647 1.33E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 5.8000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐15.833 #N/A Arsenic 698 3.72E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 8.2667 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐14.804 #N/A Arsenic 1118 2.55E-06 #N/A #N/A #N/A 9.6878 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐12.879 #N/A 

Arsenic 1119 3.53E‐06 #N/A #N/A #N/A 9.6878 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐12.554 #N/A 

Arsenic 1117 5.07E‐06 #N/A #N/A #N/A 9.6878 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐12.192 #N/A 

Arsenic 541 3.52E‐06 #N/A #N/A #N/A 14.6000 #N/A FF‐Wet ‐12.557 #N/A 

Arsenic 1111 3.34E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A 15.6289 #N/A ESP ‐10.307 #N/A 

Arsenic 994 4.87E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 16.4972 #N/A FF‐Wet ‐14.535 #N/A 

Arsenic 995 3.89E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 16.4972 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐14.76 #N/A 

845 3.10E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A 0.0000 #N/A FF ‐14.987 #N/A 
Regression Results ‐ Berylium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Berylium content, Coal ash etc.

Be, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.607135882

R Square 0.368613979

Adjusted R Square 0.363308214

Standard Error 1.112168399

Observations 121

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 1 85.93397506 85.93398 69.47424 1.55E‐13

Residual 119 147.1933072 1.236919

Total 120 233.1272823

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.35970547 0.36497859 ‐36.6041 1.31E‐66 ‐14.0824 ‐12.637 ‐14.0824 ‐12.637

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.595068913 0.071392956 8.335121 1.55E‐13 0.453704 0.736434 0.453704 0.736434

Be, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.580724717

R Square 0.337241197

Adjusted R Square 0.331270397

Standard Error 1.129533703

Observations 113

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 1 72.06202868 72.06203 56.48174 1.56E‐11

Residual 111 141.618949 1.275846

Total 112 213.6809776

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.09242618 0.43759664 ‐29.9189 5.9E‐55 ‐13.9596 ‐12.2253 ‐13.9596 ‐12.2253

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.81551928 0.108512604 7.515434 1.56E‐11 0.600494 1.030544 0.600494 1.030544

All Data w/ FPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.61539626

R Square 0.378712556

Adjusted R Square 0.36257522

Standard Error 1.12192682

Observations 80

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 2 59.0795139 29.53976 23.4681 1.1E‐08

Residual 77 96.92142377 1.25872

Total 79 156.0009377

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.1132274 0.510195971 ‐25.7023 1.58E‐39 ‐14.1292 ‐12.0973 ‐14.1292 ‐12.0973

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.641488554 0.100419693 6.388075 1.17E‐08 0.441527 0.84145 0.441527 0.84145

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.00509712 0.120004271 ‐0.04247 0.96623 ‐0.24406 0.233862 ‐0.24406 0.233862
Regression Results ‐ Berylium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Berylium content, Coal ash etc.

Be, All Data w/ FPM

All Data w/ TPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.562841406

R Square 0.316790449

Adjusted R Square 0.299044746

Standard Error 1.176508872

Observations 80

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 2 49.41960706 24.7098 17.85167 4.27E‐07

Residual 77 106.5813306 1.384173

Total 79 156.0009377

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.07346775 0.597326858 ‐21.8866 8.56E‐35 ‐14.2629 ‐11.884 ‐14.2629 ‐11.884

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.808355076 0.147265737 5.489091 4.99E‐07 0.515112 1.101599 0.515112 1.101599

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.110172738 0.120906197 0.911225 0.365021 ‐0.13058 0.350928 ‐0.13058 0.350928

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Be EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.655980363

R Square 0.430310236

Adjusted R Square 0.391021287

Standard Error 1.033339708

Observations 32

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 2 23.38985316 11.69493 10.95245 0.000286

Residual 29 30.96593761 1.067791

Total 31 54.35579077

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.18362617 0.961966274 ‐13.7049 3.37E‐14 ‐15.1511 ‐11.2162 ‐15.1511 ‐11.2162

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.689423582 0.172617798 3.993931 0.000407 0.336381 1.042467 0.336381 1.042467

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.123466553 0.173374903 0.712136 0.482071 ‐0.23112 0.478058 ‐0.23112 0.478058
Regression Results ‐ Berylium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Berylium content, Coal ash etc.

Be, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Be EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.392856661

R Square 0.154336356

Adjusted R Square 0.096014725

Standard Error 1.258991333

Observations 32

ANOVA

df SS MS F ignificance F

Regression 2 8.389074673 4.194537 2.646297 0.087976

Residual 29 45.9667161 1.585059

Total 31 54.35579077

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% ower 95.0%Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐15.39845228 1.393167217 ‐11.0528 6.5E‐12 ‐18.2478 ‐12.5491 ‐18.2478 ‐12.5491

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.351434472 0.310382649 1.132262 0.2668 ‐0.28337 0.986238 ‐0.28337 0.986238

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.348902075 0.198322713 1.759264 0.089081 ‐0.05671 0.754518 ‐0.05671 0.754518
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal_id 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent(ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐

ug/g)

Coal ashContent(%) Controls LN Be EF

Beryllium 21351 2.87E‐07 1.13E‐02 0.4126 5.06E‐02 0.4126 6.15E‐02 0.4126 0.0% ESP ‐1.51E+0

Beryllium 1154 1.37E‐07 3.19E‐02 0.2511 3.67E‐02 0.2511 1.64E‐02 0.2511 7.8% ESP ‐1.58E+0

Beryllium 1471 2.39E‐07 1.33E‐02 2.0400 1.82E‐02 2.0400 9.36E‐03 2.0400 9.7% ESP ‐1.52E+0

Beryllium 18261 2.87E‐07 1.13E‐02 2.6667 2.42E‐02 2.6667 1.29E‐02 2.6667 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.51E+0

Beryllium 1177 2.06E‐07 2.11E‐02 2.3917 8.02E‐02 2.3917 6.02E‐02 2.3917 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1.54E+0

Beryllium 1330 1.51E‐07 1.47E‐02 2.1333 4.10E‐02 2.1333 2.63E‐02 2.1333 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1.57E+0

Beryllium 63254 2.14E‐07 1.40E‐02 1.5333 2.57E‐02 1.5333 1.42E‐02 1.5333 0.0% FF ‐1.54E+0

Beryllium 879456 3.09E‐07 4.53E‐02 0.4875 7.74E‐02 0.4875 8.49E‐02 0.4875 0.0% FF ‐1.50E+0

Beryllium 1832 1.46E‐07 9.36E‐04 0.2000 8.96E‐03 0.2000 8.03E‐03 0.2000 6.0% FF ‐1.57E+0

Beryllium 1597 3.85E‐08 4.18E‐03 0.2510 9.93E‐03 0.2510 7.35E‐03 0.2510 6.6% FF ‐1.71E+0

Beryllium 1310 4.84E‐07 4.38E‐02 2.0000 4.76E‐02 2.0000 1.16E‐02 2.0000 7.8% FF ‐1.45E+0

Beryllium 1244 1.67E‐07 7.40E‐03 0.5417 2.45E‐02 0.5417 1.97E‐02 0.5417 7.8% FF ‐1.56E+0

Beryllium 13461 8.96E‐08 8.45E‐03 3.9667 1.05E‐02 3.9667 5.41E‐03 3.9667 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.62E+0

Beryllium 1346111 1.78E‐07 2.71E‐02 3.9667 2.91E‐02 3.9667 6.51E‐03 3.9667 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.55E+0

Beryllium 134611 3.95E‐07 3.57E‐02 3.9667 3.79E‐02 3.9667 4.71E‐03 3.9667 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.47E+0

Beryllium 1346 1.55E‐07 1.08E‐02 3.9667 1.30E‐02 3.9667 4.27E‐03 3.9667 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1.57E+0

Beryllium 1249 1.17E‐08 3.62E‐03 2.1333 3.20E‐02 2.1333 2.91E‐02 2.1333 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1.83E+0

Beryllium 1349 1.59E‐08 2.35E‐03 1.9833 4.47E‐03 1.9833 2.12E‐03 1.9833 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 1133 3.22E‐09 5.86E‐04 0.3067 2.78E‐02 0.3067 2.75E‐02 0.3067 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1.96E+0

Beryllium 1563 9.26E‐08 3.68E‐03 2.3428 1.11E‐02 2.3428 1.12E‐02 2.3428 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.62E+0

Beryllium 1563 7.76E‐08 3.68E‐03 2.3428 1.11E‐02 2.3428 1.12E‐02 2.3428 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.64E+0

Beryllium 1563 8.46E‐08 3.68E‐03 2.3428 1.11E‐02 2.3428 1.12E‐02 2.3428 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.63E+0

Beryllium 1507 5.56E‐08 6.86E‐04 0.4500 4.51E‐03 0.4500 4.14E‐03 0.4500 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.67E+0

Beryllium 1488 4.39E‐09 8.28E‐04 0.3333 2.05E‐02 0.3333 1.96E‐02 0.3333 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.92E+0

Beryllium 1568 4.85E‐08 5.61E‐03 0.2286 1.13E‐02 0.2286 8.21E‐03 0.2286 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1176 1.51E‐07 2.56E‐02 0.0400 3.12E‐02 0.0400 5.56E‐03 0.0400 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐1.57E+0

Beryllium 979 9.51E‐08 4.02E‐02 2.8433 1.02E‐01 2.8433 6.83E‐02 2.8433 #N/A ESP ‐1.62E+0

Beryllium 993 9.09E‐07 1.29E‐02 2.3400 2.57E‐02 2.3400 2.55E‐02 2.3400 #N/A ESP ‐1.39E+0

Beryllium 902 6.82E‐07 2.84E‐02 2.2133 6.76E‐02 2.2133 5.29E‐02 2.2133 #N/A ESP ‐1.42E+0

Beryllium 903 2.60E‐06 1.05E‐01 2.2133 1.50E‐01 2.2133 8.72E‐02 2.2133 #N/A ESP ‐1.29E+0

Beryllium 1113 2.92E‐07 9.95E‐03 1.5350 7.65E‐02 1.5350 7.82E‐02 1.5350 #N/A ESP ‐1.50E+0

Beryllium 892 4.96E‐07 1.29E‐01 0.4000 1.36E‐01 0.4000 3.90E‐02 0.4000 #N/A ESP ‐1.45E+0

Beryllium 894 4.98E‐08 9.20E‐03 0.3000 2.87E‐02 0.3000 2.32E‐02 0.3000 #N/A ESP ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1021 5.99E‐08 1.30E‐03 0.2217 7.07E‐03 0.2217 7.27E‐03 0.2217 #N/A ESP ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 1854 1.65E‐09 5.59E‐03 2.3917 1.64E‐02 2.3917 1.32E‐02 2.3917 0.0% ESP ‐2.02E+0

Beryllium 1845 1.04E‐06 6.45E‐02 2.3917 1.68E‐01 2.3917 1.41E‐01 2.3917 0.0% ESP ‐1.38E+0

Beryllium 1636 1.25E‐06 1.10E‐01 2.2267 2.01E‐01 2.2267 1.46E‐01 2.2267 0.0% ESP ‐1.36E+0

Beryllium 1906 2.95E‐07 2.19E‐02 2.0667 5.83E‐02 2.0667 4.06E‐02 2.0667 0.0% ESP ‐1.50E+0
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal_id 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent(ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐

ug/g)

Coal ashContent(%) Controls LN Be EF

Beryllium 2195 3.66E‐07 1.66E‐03 1.8400 7.50E‐03 1.8400 6.84E‐03 1.8400 0.0% ESP ‐1.48E+0

Beryllium 1642 2.23E‐07 1.11E‐02 0.9000 1.41E‐02 0.9000 1.10E‐02 0.9000 0.0% ESP ‐1.53E+0

Beryllium 2274 5.62E‐08 1.14E‐02 0.4433 2.96E‐02 0.4433 2.20E‐02 0.4433 0.0% ESP ‐1.67E+0

Beryllium 2276 1.02E‐07 2.40E‐02 0.4433 4.42E‐02 0.4433 2.92E‐02 0.4433 0.0% ESP ‐1.61E+0

Beryllium 2135 2.65E‐07 1.94E‐02 0.4126 4.55E‐02 0.4126 4.06E‐02 0.4126 0.0% ESP ‐1.51E+0

Beryllium 2011 1.87E‐07 2.88E‐02 0.3000 3.42E‐02 0.3000 1.81E‐02 0.3000 0.0% ESP ‐1.55E+0

Beryllium 1902 4.56E‐08 9.12E‐03 0.2540 1.53E‐02 0.2540 1.20E‐02 0.2540 0.0% ESP ‐1.69E+0

Beryllium 2103 2.01E‐07 1.13E‐02 0.2333 2.68E‐02 0.2333 1.71E‐02 0.2333 0.0% ESP ‐1.54E+0

Beryllium 2013 3.24E‐07 5.17E‐02 0.2111 6.35E‐02 0.2111 3.02E‐02 0.2111 0.0% ESP ‐1.49E+0

Beryllium 3197 3.10E‐08 4.15E‐03 0.1433 6.54E‐03 0.1433 4.16E‐03 0.1433 0.0% ESP ‐1.73E+0

Beryllium 900 1.85E‐08 4.11E‐03 2.4167 7.82E‐03 2.4167 3.71E‐03 2.4167 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.78E+0

Beryllium 966 4.88E‐07 1.84E‐02 0.7655 2.61E‐02 0.7655 7.67E‐03 0.7655 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.45E+0

Beryllium 1826 2.04E‐07 2.57E‐02 2.6667 4.30E‐02 2.6667 1.73E‐02 2.6667 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.54E+0

Beryllium 1638 4.33E‐08 3.83E‐03 2.2000 1.38E‐02 2.2000 9.93E‐03 2.2000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.70E+0

Beryllium 1637 4.31E‐08 5.86E‐03 2.2000 1.67E‐02 2.2000 1.08E‐02 2.2000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.70E+0

Beryllium 2055 4.38E‐08 8.72E‐03 1.0733 2.83E‐02 1.0733 1.96E‐02 1.0733 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.69E+0

Beryllium 1915 1.78E‐08 3.35E‐03 0.4126 1.86E‐02 0.4126 1.89E‐02 0.4126 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.78E+0

Beryllium 2239 1.57E‐08 3.27E‐03 0.2667 6.41E‐03 0.2667 3.14E‐03 0.2667 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 524 6.20E‐08 1.08E‐02 2.0633 1.78E‐02 2.0633 1.06E‐02 2.0633 #N/A FF ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 735 7.50E‐08 2.43E‐03 0.5417 1.42E‐02 0.5417 1.28E‐02 0.5417 #N/A FF ‐1.64E+0

Beryllium 2088 1.37E‐07 3.91E‐03 3.9667 1.02E‐02 3.9667 1.31E‐02 3.9667 0.0% FF ‐1.58E+0

Beryllium 1606 4.95E‐08 6.64E‐03 0.4580 1.52E‐02 0.4580 9.55E‐03 0.4580 0.0% FF ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1841 3.59E‐08 1.34E‐03 0.3000 7.28E‐03 0.3000 6.54E‐03 0.3000 0.0% FF ‐1.71E+0

Beryllium 1833 1.53E‐07 5.15E‐04 0.2000 6.55E‐03 0.2000 6.18E‐03 0.2000 0.0% FF ‐1.57E+0

Beryllium 2095 5.17E‐08 9.09E‐05 0.0250 3.61E‐03 0.0250 3.53E‐03 0.0250 0.0% FF ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1052 2.04E‐08 1.10E‐02 2.2000 2.30E‐02 2.2000 1.48E‐02 2.2000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.77E+0

Beryllium 947 1.11E‐08 2.28E‐03 0.3429 1.64E‐02 0.3429 1.43E‐02 0.3429 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.83E+0

Beryllium 1129 2.85E‐08 8.05E‐04 0.3067 3.73E‐03 0.3067 3.32E‐03 0.3067 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.74E+0

Beryllium 2021 1.29E‐07 2.14E‐02 3.8095 4.06E‐02 3.8095 2.88E‐02 3.8095 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.59E+0

Beryllium 2022 7.67E‐07 1.94E‐02 3.7813 2.84E‐02 3.7813 2.40E‐02 3.7813 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.41E+0

Beryllium 8761 6.02E‐08 4.48E‐03 2.2167 1.18E‐02 2.2167 9.88E‐03 2.2167 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 8761 1.57E‐08 4.48E‐03 2.2167 1.18E‐02 2.2167 9.88E‐03 2.2167 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 1942 2.46E‐08 3.56E‐03 1.1620 6.18E‐03 1.1620 2.64E‐03 1.1620 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.75E+0

Beryllium 1611 5.03E‐08 2.11E‐03 0.4580 6.85E‐03 0.4580 5.05E‐03 0.4580 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1909 5.89E‐08 1.39E‐03 0.4500 4.65E‐03 0.4500 4.41E‐03 0.4500 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 1734 1.66E‐07 5.47E‐03 0.3167 1.14E‐02 0.3167 1.01E‐02 0.3167 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.56E+0

Beryllium 1735 1.04E‐07 2.01E‐02 0.3167 2.73E‐02 0.3167 2.06E‐02 0.3167 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.61E+0

Beryllium 2206 4.54E‐09 4.51E‐03 0.3000 1.35E‐02 0.3000 9.53E‐03 0.3000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.92E+0
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal_id 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent(ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐

ug/g)

Coal ashContent(%) Controls LN Be EF

Beryllium 1726 3.28E‐08 4.50E‐04 0.2922 3.83E‐03 0.2922 3.66E‐03 0.2922 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.72E+0

Beryllium 2259 6.44E‐08 3.33E‐03 1.4667 7.36E‐03 1.4667 4.03E‐03 1.4667 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 2319 4.14E‐08 3.50E‐03 1.0000 5.22E‐03 1.0000 5.22E‐03 1.0000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1.70E+0

Beryllium 1648 9.55E‐09 2.92E‐03 0.9000 6.66E‐03 0.9000 3.74E‐03 0.9000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1.85E+0

Beryllium 1972 6.16E‐09 1.92E‐03 0.6364 4.32E‐03 0.6364 3.44E‐03 0.6364 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1.89E+0

Beryllium 1189 1.07E‐08 4.69E‐04 0.0000 3.08E‐03 0.0000 3.85E‐03 0.0000 7.8% FF ‐1.84E+0

Beryllium 1515 6.16E‐08 2.72E‐03 0.0000 5.35E‐03 0.0000 2.63E‐03 0.0000 9.7% FF‐Wet ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 2170 5.89E‐08 7.21E‐04 0.0000 5.49E‐03 0.0000 4.90E‐03 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐1.66E+0

Beryllium 1190 1.76E‐08 4.09E‐03 0.0000 7.49E‐03 0.0000 4.52E‐03 0.0000 7.8% FF ‐1.79E+0

Beryllium 1743 2.92E‐08 3.59E‐03 0.0000 9.89E‐03 0.0000 6.30E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.73E+0

Beryllium 2279 1.64E‐08 5.67E‐03 0.0000 1.07E‐02 0.0000 6.62E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.79E+0

Beryllium 1738 1.94E‐08 3.02E‐03 0.0000 1.22E‐02 0.0000 9.20E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1.78E+0

Beryllium 22791 2.24E‐08 5.55E‐03 0.0000 1.69E‐02 0.0000 1.19E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.76E+0

Beryllium 1835 6.60E‐08 8.07E‐04 0.0000 2.03E‐02 0.0000 1.99E‐02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐1.65E+0

Beryllium 1654 1.88E‐08 9.10E‐03 0.0000 2.40E‐02 0.0000 2.00E‐02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐1.78E+0

Beryllium 1185 1.62E‐07 1.07E‐02 0.0000 2.88E‐02 0.0000 1.81E‐02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1.56E+0

Beryllium 1187 1.42E‐07 1.66E‐02 0.0000 2.92E‐02 0.0000 1.26E‐02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1.58E+0

Beryllium 1989 2.68E‐07 2.84E‐02 0.0000 3.36E‐02 0.0000 5.16E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.51E+0

Beryllium 2161 4.99E‐08 4.90E‐04 0.0000 7.87E‐02 0.0000 7.82E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.68E+0

Beryllium 1809 1.04E‐06 3.32E‐02 0.0000 9.11E‐02 0.0000 5.79E‐02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.38E+0

Beryllium 975 1.17E‐06 1.47E‐01 0.0000 1.71E‐01 0.0000 5.15E‐02 0.0000 #N/A ESP ‐1.37E+0

Beryllium 736 7.42E‐08 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF ‐1.64E+0

Beryllium 731 9.20E‐08 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐1.62E+0

Beryllium 734 1.34E‐07 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF ‐1.58E+0Beryllium 632 6.57E‐07 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐1.42E+0

Beryllium 1307 2.68E‐07 2.76E‐03 6.12E‐03 3.36E‐03 0.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐1.51E+0

Beryllium 1327 7.31E‐08 4.57E‐03 6.98E‐03 2.41E‐03 0.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐1.64E+0

Beryllium 1398 7.41E‐08 1.10E‐03 8.82E‐03 8.46E‐03 0.2333 7.6% FF‐Dry ‐1.64E+0

Beryllium 1558 1.13E‐07 2.41E‐02 2.69E‐02 2.88E‐03 0.5679 9.7% ESP‐Wet ‐1.60E+0

Beryllium 1120 4.78E‐08 3.23E‐02 3.42E‐02 1.95E‐03 0.7615 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.69E+0

Beryllium 2302 6.87E‐08 1.52E‐02 3.50E‐02 3.12E‐02 0.3667 0.0% ESP ‐1.65E+0

Beryllium 1938 7.99E‐08 2.09E‐02 3.56E‐02 3.14E‐02 0.3000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.63E+0

Beryllium 2278 8.28E‐08 3.93E‐02 4.95E‐02 1.31E‐02 0.2240 0.0% ESP ‐1.63E+0

Beryllium 1276 1.20E‐08 4.69E‐02 5.95E‐02 1.26E‐02 0.4500 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1.82E+0

Beryllium 2009 2.35E‐07 5.88E‐02 6.33E‐02 2.10E‐02 0.2511 0.0% ESP ‐1.53E+0

Beryllium 1141 2.44E‐07 8.12E‐02 8.30E‐02 2.27E‐02 0.1550 7.8% ESP ‐1.52E+0

Beryllium 828 8.88E‐07 1.00E‐01 1.70E‐01 1.05E‐01 2.3917 #N/A ESP ‐1.39E+0

Beryllium 1449 3.07E‐08 1.20E‐03 0.3000 0.3000 0.3000 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1.73E+0
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

PollName submittal_id 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent(ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐ ug/g)

TPM2.5#/mmBtu

MetalsContent (ppm ‐

ug/g)

Coal ashContent(%) Controls LN Be EF

Beryllium 565 1.49E‐08 2.75E‐03 0.5571 0.5571 0.5571 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 560 1.69E‐08 3.88E‐03 0.5571 0.5571 0.5571 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.79E+0

Beryllium 12861 2.41E‐07 5.27E‐03 0.0000 7.9% ESP ‐1.52E+0

Beryllium 10040004 3.18E‐08 7.52E‐03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1.73E+0

Beryllium 1004 1.20E‐07 1.14E‐02 2.0000 2.0000 2.0000 #N/A ESP ‐1.59E+0

Beryllium 550002 2.00E‐06 4.91E‐02 2.2333 2.2333 2.2333 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1.31E+0

Beryllium 10040002 1.87E‐07 5.31E‐02 1.6000 1.6000 1.6000 0.0% ESP ‐1.55E+0

Beryllium 541 1.23E‐07 #N/A 2.3000 #N/A 2.3000 #N/A 2.3000 #N/A FF‐Wet ‐1.59E+0Beryllium 698 9.78E‐08 #N/A 3.3333 #N/A 3.3333 #N/A 3.3333 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1.61E+0Beryllium 845 4.24E‐08 #N/A #N/A #N/A 0.3056 #N/A FF ‐1.70E+0

Beryllium 1111 2.22E‐06 #N/A 1.5350 #N/A 1.5350 #N/A 1.5350 #N/A ESP ‐1.30E+0Beryllium 1117 1.45E‐08 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 1117 1.45E‐08 #N/A 2.3917 #N/A 2.3917 #N/A 2.3917 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.80E+0

Beryllium 1118 9.45E‐09 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.85E+0

Beryllium 1119 1.01E‐08 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A 0.8538 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1.84E+0

Beryllium 1647 4.21E‐09 #N/A 0.9000 #N/A 0.9000 #N/A 0.9000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1.93E+0

Beryllium 2070 2.02E‐08 #N/A #N/A #N/A 2.3917 0.0% ESP ‐1.77E+0
Regression Results ‐ Cadmium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cadmium content, Coal ash etc.

Cd, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.381144804

R Square 0.145271362

Adjusted R Square 0.138322348

Standard Error 0.90237278

Observations 125

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 17.02271528 17.02272 20.90532 1.15868E‐05

Residual 123 100.1560259 0.814277

Total 124 117.1787412

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐14.24671394 0.295100866 ‐48.2774 8.36E‐82 ‐14.830848 ‐13.66257988 ‐14.830848 ‐13.66257988

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.262649271 0.057444409 4.572234 1.16E‐05 0.148941586 0.376356956 0.148941586 0.376356956

Cd, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.42261635

R Square 0.178604579

Adjusted R Square 0.171462011

Standard Error 0.886630173

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 19.65726836 19.65727 25.00565 2.06911E‐06

Residual 115 90.40300237 0.786113

Total 116 110.0602707

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.90932197 0.339012677 ‐41.0289 1.66E‐70 ‐14.58084082 ‐13.23780313 ‐14.58084082 ‐13.23780313

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.416489501 0.083288489 5.000565 2.07E‐06 0.25151104 0.581467961 0.25151104 0.581467961

Cd, All Data w/ TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.36675433

R Square 0.134508739

Adjusted R Square 0.126982728

Standard Error 0.910118017

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 14.80406822 14.80407 17.87251 4.75977E‐05

Residual 115 95.25620251 0.828315

Total 116 110.0602707

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.97194153 0.383628841 ‐36.4205 5.59E‐65 ‐14.7318364 ‐13.21204665 ‐14.7318364 ‐13.21204665

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.357917759 0.08466237 4.22759 4.76E‐05 0.190217904 0.525617613 0.190217904 0.525617613
Regression Results ‐ Cadmium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cadmium content, Coal ash etc.

Cd, All Data w/ FPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.421105838

R Square 0.177330127

Adjusted R Square 0.153825274

Standard Error 0.84541865

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 10.78446537 5.392233 7.544405 0.001078688

Residual 70 50.03128856 0.714733

Total 72 60.81575393

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐14.253581 0.367201726 ‐38.8168 4.41E‐49 ‐14.98594174 ‐13.52122026 ‐14.98594174 ‐13.52122026

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.236095768 0.066253707 3.56351 0.000664 0.103956918 0.368234617 0.103956918 0.368234617

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.102126454 0.086688387 1.178087 0.242752 ‐0.07076808 0.275020988 ‐0.07076808 0.275020988

Cd, All Data w/ TPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.46137262

R Square 0.212864694

Adjusted R Square 0.190375114

Standard Error 0.826958516

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Sig f ni icance F

Regression 2 12.94552688 6.472763 9.465036 0.00023

Residual 70 47.87022706 0.68386

Total 72 60.81575393

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.91975361 0.40404982 ‐34.4506 1.24E‐45 ‐14.72560556 ‐13.11390166 ‐14.72560556 ‐13.11390166

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.388842166 0.095924291 4.053636 0.000129 0.197527203 0.580157128 0.197527203 0.580157128

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.078274448 0.085448188 0.916046 0.362788 ‐0.092146588 0.248695484 ‐0.092146588 0.248695484

Cd, All Data w/ TPM2.5 & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.390516419

R Square 0.152503074

Adjusted R Square 0.128288876

Standard Error 0.85808062

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 9.274589401 4.637295 6.298085 0.003053758

Residual 70 51.54116453 0.736302

Total 72 60.81575393

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐14.00549657 0.46976551 ‐29.8138 1.62E‐41 ‐14.94241433 ‐13.06857882 ‐14.94241433 ‐13.06857882

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.333598864 0.104066945 3.205618 0.002032 0.126043889 0.54115384 0.126043889 0.54115384

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.06206943 0.090315591 0.68725 0.494196 ‐0.118059335 0.242198194 ‐0.118059335 0.242198194
Regression Results ‐ Cadmium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cadmium content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Cd EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.180478823

R Square 0.032572606

Adjusted R Square ‐0.048046344

Standard Error 0.941069114

Observations 27

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 0.715629774 0.357815 0.404032 0.672079382

Residual 24 21.25466584 0.885611

Total 26 21.97029562

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐15.1291894 0.974945095 ‐15.518 5.17E‐14 ‐17.14137717 ‐13.11700164 ‐17.14137717 ‐13.11700164

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.13128 0.147591536 0.889482 0.382574 ‐0.173333956 0.435893957 ‐0.173333956 0.435893957

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.032457164 0.249295458 0.130196 0.897497 ‐0.482063369 0.546977697 ‐0.482063369 0.546977697

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Cd EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.03420156

R Square 0.001169747

Adjusted R Square ‐0.082066108

Standard Error 0.956220772

Observations 27

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression Regression 2 0.02569968 0.02569968 0.01285 0.01285 0.014053 0.014053 0.986052997 0.986052997

Residual 24 21.94459594 0.914358

Total 26 21.97029562

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐15.73731523 1.305479643 ‐12.0548 1.14E‐11 ‐18.43169276 ‐13.04293769 ‐18.43169276 ‐13.04293769

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.027690412 0.255425928 0.108409 0.914573 ‐0.499482789 0.554863614 ‐0.499482789 0.554863614

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.034124482 0.25381155 0.134448 0.894169 ‐0.489716806 0.557965771 ‐0.489716806 0.557965771
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controlls L

2319 Cadmium 7.36E‐08 3.50E-03 0.1133 5.22E-03 0.1133 5.22E-03 0.1133 0.0% Wet ‐

23152 Cadmium 1.07E-07 1.36E-03 0.0868 4.37E-03 0.0868 3.01E-03 0.0868 0.0% Wet ‐

23153 Cadmium 2.95E-07 3.21E-03 0.0868 6.28E-03 0.0868 3.07E-03 0.0868 0.0% Wet ‐

2315 Cadmium 2.40E-07 3.77E-03 0.0868 8.16E-03 0.0868 4.39E-03 0.0868 0.0% Wet ‐

23151 Cadmium 8.50E-08 4.68E-03 0.0868 8.80E-03 0.0868 4.12E-03 0.0868 0.0% Wet ‐

1558 Cadmium 5.71E‐07 2.41E-02 0.0596 2.69E-02 0.0596 2.88E-03 0.0596 9.7% Wet ‐1176 Cadmium 1.52E-07 2.56E-02 0.0500 3.12E-02 0.0500 5.56E-03 0.0500 7.8% Wet ‐1942 Cadmium 9.07E‐07 3.56E-03 1.4050 6.18E-03 1.4050 2.64E-03 1.4050 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1129 Cadmium 1.17E‐07 8.05E-04 0.2933 3.73E-03 0.2933 3.32E-03 0.2933 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1133 Cadmium 7.86E‐08 5.86E-04 0.2933 2.78E-02 0.2933 2.75E-02 0.2933 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐

1563 Cadmium 1.06E-07 3.68E-03 0.2833 1.11E-02 0.2833 1.12E-02 0.2833 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1563 Cadmium 7.81E-08 3.68E-03 0.2833 1.11E-02 0.2833 1.12E-02 0.2833 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1563 Cadmium 1.07E-07 3.68E-03 0.2833 1.11E-02 0.2833 1.12E-02 0.2833 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐

13461 Cadmium 6.02E‐08 8.45E-03 0.2722 1.05E-02 0.2722 5.41E-03 0.2722 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1346 Cadmium 6.57E‐08 1.08E-02 0.2722 1.30E-02 0.2722 4.27E-03 0.2722 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐

1346111 Cadmium 7.18E‐08 2.71E-02 0.2722 2.91E-02 0.2722 6.51E-03 0.2722 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

134611 Cadmium 1.15E‐07 3.57E-02 0.2722 3.79E-02 0.2722 4.71E-03 0.2722 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1349 Cadmium 6.60E‐08 2.35E-03 0.2125 4.47E-03 0.2125 2.12E-03 0.2125 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐

1611 Cadmium 2.73E-08 2.11E-03 0.1109 6.85E-03 0.1109 5.05E-03 0.1109 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1507 Cadmium 1.85E‐07 6.86E-04 0.1018 4.51E-03 0.1018 4.14E-03 0.1018 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1909 Cadmium 3.53E‐07 1.39E-03 0.1018 4.65E-03 0.1018 4.41E-03 0.1018 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1726 Cadmium 3.28E-08 4.50E-04 0.0973 3.83E-03 0.0973 3.66E-03 0.0973 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1398 Cadmium 3.58E-07 1.10E-03 0.0967 8.82E-03 0.0967 8.46E-03 0.0967 7.6% FF‐Dry ‐2206 Cadmium 2.48E‐08 4.51E-03 0.0900 1.35E-02 0.0900 9.53E-03 0.0900 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1568 Cadmium 4.16E‐07 5.61E-03 0.0800 1.13E-02 0.0800 8.21E-03 0.0800 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1938 Cadmium 2.48E‐07 2.09E-02 0.0800 3.56E-02 0.0800 3.14E-02 0.0800 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1488 Cadmium 4.65E‐08 8.28E-04 0.0767 2.05E-02 0.0767 1.96E-02 0.0767 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐

1638 Cadmium 1.29E‐07 3.83E-03 2.6100 1.38E-02 2.6100 9.93E-03 2.6100 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

1637 Cadmium 4.04E‐07 5.86E-03 2.6100 1.67E-02 2.6100 1.08E-02 2.6100 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

2055 Cadmium 3.17E-07 8.72E-03 1.4900 2.83E-02 1.4900 1.96E-02 1.4900 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

1330 Cadmium 4.89E-07 1.47E-02 1.2767 4.10E-02 1.2767 2.63E-02 1.2767 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1177 Cadmium 3.34E-07 2.11E-02 1.1189 8.02E-02 1.1189 6.02E-02 1.1189 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐

1276 Cadmium 8.39E‐08 4.69E-02 0.2033 5.95E-02 0.2033 1.26E-02 0.2033 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐

18261 Cadmium 1.84E-07 1.13E-02 0.2017 2.42E-02 0.2017 1.29E-02 0.2017 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

1826 Cadmium 1.88E-07 2.57E-02 0.2017 4.30E-02 0.2017 1.73E-02 0.2017 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

966 Cadmium 3.15E‐07 1.84E-02 0.1025 2.61E-02 0.1025 7.67E-03 0.1025 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐

1743 Cadmium 5.23E‐08 3.59E-03 0.0967 9.89E-03 0.0967 6.30E-03 0.0967 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1738 Cadmium 1.46E‐07 3.02E-03 0.0967 1.22E-02 0.0967 9.20E-03 0.0967 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controlls L

1915 Cadmium 4.91E-08 3.35E-03 0.0922 1.86E-02 0.0922 1.89E-02 0.0922 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

1120 Cadmium 2.44E-07 3.23E-02 0.0617 3.42E-02 0.0617 1.95E-03 0.0617 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

2239 Cadmium 6.35E-08 3.27E-03 0.0500 6.41E-03 0.0500 3.14E-03 0.0500 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐

524 Cadmium 2.39E‐07 1.08E-02 0.3000 1.78E-02 0.3000 1.06E-02 0.3000 #N/A FF 

1189 Cadmium 6.75E-08 4.69E-04 0.3000 3.08E-03 0.3000 3.85E-03 0.3000 7.8% FF ‐

1190 Cadmium 2.28E-07 4.09E-03 0.3000 7.49E-03 0.3000 4.52E-03 0.3000 7.8% FF ‐

2088 Cadmium 1.62E‐07 3.91E-03 0.2722 1.02E-02 0.2722 1.31E-02 0.2722 0.0% FF ‐

1833 Cadmium 1.63E-07 5.15E-04 0.2000 6.55E-03 0.2000 6.18E-03 0.2000 0.0% FF ‐1832 Cadmium 1.54E-07 9.36E-04 0.2000 8.96E-03 0.2000 8.03E-03 0.2000 6.0% FF ‐

735 Cadmium 1.03E-07 2.43E-03 0.1342 1.42E-02 0.1342 1.28E-02 0.1342 #N/A FF ‐

1244 Cadmium 4.90E-07 7.40E-03 0.1342 2.45E-02 0.1342 1.97E-02 0.1342 7.8% FF ‐1606 Cadmium 3.62E-08 6.64E-03 0.1109 1.52E-02 0.1109 9.55E-03 0.1109 0.0% FF ‐1841 Cadmium 9.80E-08 1.34E-03 0.0800 7.28E-03 0.0800 6.54E-03 0.0800 0.0% FF 

1597 Cadmium 1.93E-08 4.18E-03 0.0765 9.93E-03 0.0765 7.35E-03 0.0765 6.6% FF ‐

2095 Cadmium 1.52E-07 9.09E-05 0.0300 3.61E-03 0.0300 3.53E-03 0.0300 0.0% FF ‐

1636 Cadmium 1.87E‐07 1.10E-01 1.5240 2.01E-01 1.5240 1.46E-01 1.5240 0.0% ESP ‐1854 Cadmium 8.72E-08 5.59E-03 1.1189 1.64E-02 1.1189 1.32E-02 1.1189 0.0% ESP ‐1845 Cadmium 1.03E-06 6.45E-02 1.1189 1.68E-01 1.1189 1.41E-01 1.1189 0.0% ESP ‐

828 Cadmium 2.14E-07 1.00E-01 1.1189 1.70E-01 1.1189 1.05E-01 1.1189 #N/A ESP ‐

2274 Cadmium 7.06E-07 1.14E-02 0.9833 2.96E-02 0.9833 2.20E-02 0.9833 0.0% ESP ‐

2276 Cadmium 2.90E-07 2.40E-02 0.9833 4.42E-02 0.9833 2.92E-02 0.9833 0.0% ESP ‐1113 Cadmium 1.55E-06 9.95E-03 0.2306 7.65E-02 0.2306 7.82E-02 0.2306 #N/A ESP ‐1471 Cadmium 2.66E-07 1.33E-02 0.1733 1.82E-02 0.1733 9.36E-03 0.1733 9.7% ESP ‐

892 Cadmium 4.72E-07 1.29E-01 0.1100 1.36E-01 0.1100 3.90E-02 0.1100 #N/A ESP ‐

3197 Cadmium 8.56E-08 4.15E-03 0.0933 6.54E-03 0.0933 4.16E-03 0.0933 0.0% ESP ‐

2135 Cadmium 5.99E-07 1.94E-02 0.0922 4.55E-02 0.0922 4.06E-02 0.0922 0.0% ESP 

21351 Cadmium 1.84E-07 1.13E-02 0.0922 5.06E-02 0.0922 6.15E-02 0.0922 0.0% ESP ‐

1902 Cadmium 1.39E-07 9.12E-03 0.0889 1.53E-02 0.0889 1.20E-02 0.0889 0.0% ESP ‐

894 Cadmium 8.87E-08 9.20E-03 0.0700 2.87E-02 0.0700 2.32E-02 0.0700 #N/A ESP ‐

1021 Cadmium 2.67E-07 1.30E-03 0.0688 7.07E-03 0.0688 7.27E-03 0.0688 #N/A ESP ‐

1154 Cadmium 1.70E-07 3.19E-02 0.0636 3.67E-02 0.0636 1.64E-02 0.0636 7.8% ESP ‐2009 Cadmium 5.57E-07 5.88E-02 0.0636 6.33E-02 0.0636 2.10E-02 0.0636 0.0% ESP 

1141 Cadmium 3.93E-07 8.12E-02 0.0550 8.30E-02 0.0550 2.27E-02 0.0550 7.8% ESP ‐

993 Cadmium Cadmium 3 17E-07 3.17E-07 1 29E-02 1.29E-02 0 0100 . 2 57E-02 2.57E-02 0 0100 . 2 55E-02 2.55E-02 0 0100 . #N/A ESP ‐975 Cadmium 4.06E-07 1.47E-01 0.0099 1.71E-01 0.0099 5.15E-02 0.0099 #N/A ESP ‐

1972 Cadmium 1.98E-08 1.92E-03 0.0000 4.32E-03 0.0000 3.44E-03 0.0000 0.0% Wet ‐

1515 Cadmium 2.28E‐07 2.72E-03 0.0000 5.35E-03 0.0000 2.63E-03 0.0000 9.7% Wet ‐

2170 Cadmium 4.17E‐07 7.21E-04 0.0000 5.49E-03 0.0000 4.90E-03 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controlls L

1307 Cadmium 2.22E-07 2.76E-03 0.0000 6.12E-03 0.0000 3.36E-03 0.0000 7.8% Wet ‐

1648 Cadmium 1.79E-08 2.92E-03 0.0000 6.66E-03 0.0000 3.74E-03 0.0000 0.0% Wet ‐

1327 Cadmium 1.18E-07 4.57E-03 0.0000 6.98E-03 0.0000 2.41E-03 0.0000 7.8% Wet ‐

2259 Cadmium 8.75E-08 3.33E-03 0.0000 7.36E-03 0.0000 4.03E-03 0.0000 0.0% Wet ‐

2195 Cadmium 3.66E-07 1.66E-03 0.0000 7.50E-03 0.0000 6.84E-03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

900 Cadmium 8.97E‐08 4.11E-03 0.0000 7.82E-03 0.0000 3.71E-03 0.0000 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

2279 Cadmium 1.70E-08 5.67E-03 0.0000 1.07E-02 0.0000 6.62E-03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1734 Cadmium 2.20E‐07 5.47E-03 0.0000 1.14E-02 0.0000 1.01E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP‐Dry ‐8761 Cadmium 1.75E-06 4.48E-03 0.0000 1.18E-02 0.0000 9.88E-03 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐8761 Cadmium 1.06E-07 4.48E-03 0.0000 1.18E-02 0.0000 9.88E-03 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1642 Cadmium 2.63E‐07 1.11E-02 0.0000 1.41E-02 0.0000 1.10E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

947 Cadmium 8.02E‐08 2.28E-03 0.0000 1.64E-02 0.0000 1.43E-02 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐

22791 Cadmium 6.95E-08 5.55E-03 0.0000 1.69E-02 0.0000 1.19E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1835 Cadmium 4.80E‐07 8.07E-04 0.0000 2.03E-02 0.0000 1.99E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐

1052 Cadmium 1.42E‐07 1.10E-02 0.0000 2.30E-02 0.0000 1.48E-02 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1654 Cadmium 1.49E‐07 9.10E-03 0.0000 2.40E-02 0.0000 2.00E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐

63254 Cadmium 4.44E-07 1.40E-02 0.0000 2.57E-02 0.0000 1.42E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐

2103 Cadmium 2.94E‐07 1.13E-02 0.0000 2.68E-02 0.0000 1.71E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1735 Cadmium 1.56E‐07 2.01E-02 0.0000 2.73E-02 0.0000 2.06E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP‐Dry ‐2022 Cadmium 4.79E‐07 1.94E-02 0.0000 2.84E-02 0.0000 2.40E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐

1185 Cadmium 4.89E-07 1.07E-02 0.0000 2.88E-02 0.0000 1.81E-02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1187 Cadmium 2.51E-07 1.66E-02 0.0000 2.92E-02 0.0000 1.26E-02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐

1249 Cadmium 5.39E‐08 3.62E-03 0.0000 3.20E-02 0.0000 2.91E-02 0.0000 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1989 Cadmium 2.83E‐07 2.84E-02 0.0000 3.36E-02 0.0000 5.16E-03 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

2011 Cadmium 1.93E-07 2.88E-02 0.0000 3.42E-02 0.0000 1.81E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐2302 Cadmium 1.85E‐07 1.52E-02 0.0000 3.50E-02 0.0000 3.12E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐2021 Cadmium 2.29E‐07 2.14E-02 0.0000 4.06E-02 0.0000 2.88E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1310 Cadmium 1.69E‐07 4.38E-02 0.0000 4.76E-02 0.0000 1.16E-02 0.0000 7.8% FF ‐

2278 Cadmium 7.72E-07 3.93E-02 0.0000 4.95E-02 0.0000 1.31E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1906 Cadmium 3.45E‐07 2.19E-02 0.0000 5.83E-02 0.0000 4.06E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐2013 Cadmium 4.17E‐07 5.17E-02 0.0000 6.35E-02 0.0000 3.02E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

902 Cadmium 4.93E-07 2.84E-02 0.0000 6.76E-02 0.0000 5.29E-02 0.0000 #N/A ESP ‐

879456 Cadmium 2.73E‐07 4.53E-02 0.0000 7.74E-02 0.0000 8.49E-02 0.0000 0.0% FF ‐

2161 Cadmium Cadmium 3 49E . 08 - 4 90E . 04 - 0.0000 7 87E . 02 - 0.0000 7 82E . 02 - 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐1809 Cadmium 9.54E-07 3.32E-02 0.0000 9.11E-02 0.0000 5.79E-02 0.0000 0.0% ESP 

979 Cadmium 7.93E-08 4.02E-02 0.0000 1.02E-01 0.0000 6.83E-02 0.0000 #N/A ESP ‐

903 Cadmium 1.36E-06 1.05E-01 0.0000 1.50E-01 0.0000 8.72E-02 0.0000 #N/A ESP ‐736 Cadmium 7.42E-08 3.31E-03 9.12E-03 7.02E-03 #N/A FF ‐
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controlls L

731 Cadmium 2.13E‐07 1.12E-02 1.39E-02 1.12E-02 #N/A ESP ‐

734 Cadmium 5.50E-07 2.00E-03 1.44E-02 1.46E-02 #N/A FF ‐

632 Cadmium 3.69E-07 1.36E-02 5.49E-02 5.11E-02 #N/A ESP ‐

1449 Cadmium 8.54E-08 1.20E-03 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐

565 Cadmium 3.28E-07 2.75E-03 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐

560 Cadmium 8.11E-07 3.88E-03 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry 

12861 Cadmium 2.40E-07 5.27E-03 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 7.9% ESP ‐

10040004 Cadmium 7.84E‐08 7.52E-03 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1004 Cadmium 1.19E-07 1.14E-02 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 #N/A ESP ‐

550002 Cadmium 7.95E-07 4.91E-02 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0% ESP‐Dry ‐

10040002 Cadmium 7.60E-08 5.31E-02 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0% ESP ‐

1117 Cadmium 1.12E-07 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐

1118 Cadmium 4.37E-08 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1119 Cadmium 7.84E‐08 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A 0.0812 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1117 Cadmium 1.12E-07 #N/A 1.1189 #N/A 1.1189 #N/A 1.1189 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐

698 Cadmium 2.05E‐07 #N/A 0.0000 #N/A 0.0000 #N/A 0.0000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐

541 Cadmium 1.24E‐07 #N/A 0.7633 #N/A 0.7633 #N/A 0.7633 #N/A Wet ‐

1111 Cadmium 1.45E-06 #N/A 0.2306 #N/A 0.2306 #N/A 0.2306 #N/A ESP ‐1647 Cadmium 1.99E-08 #N/A 0.0000 #N/A 0.0000 #N/A 0.0000 0.0% Wet ‐

845 Cadmium 8.19E‐08 #N/A 0.0400 #N/A 0.0400 #N/A 0.0400 #N/A FF ‐

2070 Cadmium 9.12E-08 #N/A 1.1189 #N/A 1.1189 #N/A 1.1189 0.0% ESP ‐
Regression Results ‐ Chromium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Chromium content, Coal ash etc.

Cr, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.485992168

R Square 0.236188388

Adjusted R Square 0.229978537

Standard Error 1.646624034

Observations 125

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 103.1255543 103.1256 38.03447 9.17344E‐09

Residual 123 333.4985972 2.711371

Total 124 436.6241515

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.473448422 0.538491618 ‐17.5926 2.21E‐35 ‐10.53935955 ‐8.407537296 ‐10.53935955 ‐8.407537296

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.646464871 0.104822915 6.167209 9.17E‐09 0.438974341 0.853955401 0.438974341 0.853955401

Cr, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.469546664

R Square 0.22047407

Adjusted R Square 0.213695584

Standard Error 1.652518318

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 88.82134765 88.82135 32.52556 9.26737E‐08

Residual 115 314.0439309 2.730817

Total 116 402.8652786

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.195492292 0.631858328 ‐14.5531 7.63E‐28 ‐10.44708199 ‐7.943902592 ‐10.44708199 ‐7.943902592

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.88532179 0.155234682 5.703119 9.27E‐08 0.577831771 1.192811809 0.577831771 1.192811809

Cr, All Data w/ TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.43321754

R Square 0.187677437

Adjusted R Square 0.180613763

Standard Error 1.686922991

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 75.60872304 75.60872 26.56938 1.06786E‐06

Residual 115 327.2565555 2.845709

Total 116 402.8652786

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.116162962 0.71106417 ‐12.8205 6.59E‐24 ‐10.52464419 ‐7.707681738 ‐10.52464419 ‐7.707681738

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.808869873 0.156923493 5.154549 1.07E‐06 0.498034645 1.1197051 0.498034645 1.1197051
Regression Results ‐ Chromium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Chromium content, Coal ash etc.

Cr, All Data w/ FPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.539416208

R Square 0.290969846

Adjusted R Square 0.277839658

Standard Error 1.554457436

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 107.0938923 53.54695 22.16037 8.62768E‐09

Residual 108 260.9644953 2.416338

Total 110 368.0583875

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.934645612 0.675002144 ‐13.2365 2.39E‐24 ‐10.27261692 ‐7.596674301 ‐10.27261692 ‐7.596674301

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.694185624 0.104274104 6.657316 1.2E‐09 0.487496266 0.900874982 0.487496266 0.900874982

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.197068387 0.159733035 ‐1.23374 0.219979 ‐0.513686964 0.11955019 ‐0.513686964 0.11955019

Cr, All Data w/ TPM & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.526151127

R Square 0.276835008

Adjusted R Square 0.263443064

Standard Error 1.569875381

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 101.8914468 50.94572 20.67176 2.50507E‐08

Residual 108 266.1669408 2.464509

Total 110 368.0583875

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.624693607 0.736239228 ‐11.7145 5.96E‐21 ‐10.08404744 ‐7.165339776 ‐10.08404744 ‐7.165339776

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.969152209 0.150727639 6.429824 3.57E‐09 0.67038389 1.267920528 0.67038389 1.267920528

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.154884755 0.160319831 ‐0.9661 0.336153 ‐0.472666465 0.162896954 ‐0.472666465 0.162896954

Cr, All Data w/ TPM2.5 & Metals in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.473472543

R Square 0.224176249

Adjusted R Square 0.209809142

Standard Error 1.626027991

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 82.50994867 41.25497 15.60344 1.11482E‐06

Residual 108 285.5484389 2.643967

Total 110 368.0583875

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.580341001 0.835822712 ‐10.2657 1.16E‐17 ‐10.23708657 ‐6.923595434 ‐10.23708657 ‐6.923595434

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.869320035 0.155618139 5.586238 1.75E‐07 0.560857896 1.177782175 0.560857896 1.177782175

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.165601371 0.166860742 ‐0.99245 0.323195 ‐0.496348299 0.165145556 ‐0.496348299 0.165145556

SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Results ‐ Chromium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Chromium content, Coal ash etc.

FF acid gas control ‐ Cr EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.529686628

R Square 0.280567924

Adjusted R Square 0.240599476

Standard Error 1.349016087

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 25.54965146 12.77483 7.019735 0.002665731

Residual 36 65.51439849 1.819844

Total 38 91.06404995

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.262087258 1.599483935 ‐5.16547 9.05E‐06 ‐11.50599101 ‐5.018183508 ‐11.50599101 ‐5.018183508

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.825687526 0.223864237 3.68834 0.00074 0.371669813 1.279705238 0.371669813 1.279705238

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.282140925 0.270360052 ‐1.04357 0.30364 ‐0.83045652 0.26617467 ‐0.83045652 0.26617467

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Cr EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.338016733

R Square 0.114255312

Adjusted R Square 0.065047274

Standard Error 1.496843888

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 10.40455144 5.202276 2.321883 0.112604051

Residual 36 80.65949851 2.240542

Total 38 91.06404995

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.836521495 2.008906095 ‐4.89646 2.06E‐05 ‐13.91077187 ‐5.762271124 ‐13.91077187 ‐5.762271124

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.756972643 0.365472181 2.071218 0.045565 0.01576071 1.498184576 0.01576071 1.498184576

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.088896994 0.294514291 ‐0.30184 0.764509 ‐0.686199656 0.508405668 ‐0.686199656 0.508405668
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Control 

2259 Chromium 6.89E-07 3.33E-03 18.3333 7.36E-03 18.3333 4.03E-03 18.3333 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

1176 Chromium 4.62E-06 2.56E-02 14.2167 3.12E-02 14.2167 5.56E-03 14.2167 7.8% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

2319 Chromium 2.26E‐06 3.50E-03 14.0000 5.22E-03 14.0000 5.22E-03 14.0000 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

1972 Chromium 2.76E-07 1.92E-03 10.5455 4.32E-03 10.5455 3.44E-03 10.5455 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 1648 Chromium 5.14E-07 2.92E-03 8.6000 6.66E-03 8.6000 3.74E-03 8.6000 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

1515 Chromium 2.60E‐07 2.72E-03 5.7167 5.35E-03 5.7167 2.63E-03 5.7167 9.7% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

23152 Chromium 1.14E-06 1.36E-03 2.6316 4.37E-03 2.6316 3.01E-03 2.6316 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 23153 Chromium 3.72E-06 3.21E-03 2.6316 6.28E-03 2.6316 3.07E-03 2.6316 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

2315 Chromium 3.73E-06 3.77E-03 2.6316 8.16E-03 2.6316 4.39E-03 2.6316 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

23151 Chromium 1.48E-06 4.68E-03 2.6316 8.80E-03 2.6316 4.12E-03 2.6316 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

1307 Chromium 2.08E-04 2.76E-03 1.0000 6.12E-03 1.0000 3.36E-03 1.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet Scrubber 

1327 Chromium 1.50E-06 4.57E-03 1.0000 6.98E-03 1.0000 2.41E-03 1.0000 7.8% FF‐Wet Scrubber 2022 Chromium 2.40E‐04 1.94E-02 33.4375 2.84E-02 33.4375 2.40E-02 33.4375 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1563 Chromium 3.78E-06 3.68E-03 24.7911 1.11E-02 24.7911 1.12E-02 24.7911 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1563 Chromium 9.49E-07 3.68E-03 24.7911 1.11E-02 24.7911 1.12E-02 24.7911 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1563 Chromium Chromium 1 51E-06 1.51E-06 3 68E 03 3.68E-03 24 7911 24.7911 1 11E 02 1.11E-02 24 7911 24.7911 1 12E 02 1.12E-02 24 7911 24.7911 9 7%. FF‐Dry Scrubber Scrubber 2021 Chromium 7.52E‐06 2.14E-02 19.7143 4.06E-02 19.7143 2.88E-02 19.7143 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

8761 Chromium 2.48E-06 4.48E-03 19.0000 1.18E-02 19.0000 9.88E-03 19.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 8761 Chromium 2.08E-06 4.48E-03 19.0000 1.18E-02 19.0000 9.88E-03 19.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 1249 Chromium 8.23E‐07 3.62E-03 18.6667 3.20E-02 18.6667 2.91E-02 18.6667 7.8% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1349 Chromium 1.51E‐06 2.35E-03 18.4167 4.47E-03 18.4167 2.12E-03 18.4167 7.8% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1942 Chromium 1.47E‐06 3.56E-03 17.4333 6.18E-03 17.4333 2.64E-03 17.4333 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

13461 Chromium 9.97E‐07 8.45E-03 16.6111 1.05E-02 16.6111 5.41E-03 16.6111 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1346 Chromium 1.02E‐06 1.08E-02 16.6111 1.30E-02 16.6111 4.27E-03 16.6111 7.8% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1346111 Chromium 1.22E‐06 2.71E-02 16.6111 2.91E-02 16.6111 6.51E-03 16.6111 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

134611 Chromium 1.86E‐06 3.57E-02 16.6111 3.79E-02 16.6111 4.71E-03 16.6111 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1052 Chromium 2.27E‐06 1.10E-02 10.6667 2.30E-02 10.6667 1.48E-02 10.6667 #N/A FF‐Dry Scrubber 

2206 Chromium 3.81E‐06 4.51E-03 6.0000 1.35E-02 6.0000 9.53E-03 6.0000 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1611 Chromium 2.51E-07 2.11E-03 5.9967 6.85E-03 5.9967 5.05E-03 5.9967 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 1938 Chromium 2.19E-06 2.09E-02 5.6667 3.56E-02 5.6667 3.14E-02 5.6667 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 1398 Chromium 1.24E-06 1.10E-03 5.4444 8.82E-03 5.4444 8.46E-03 5.4444 7.6% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1568 Chromium 2.43E‐06 5.61E-03 5.4286 1.13E-02 5.4286 8.21E-03 5.4286 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 1488 Chromium 4.40E‐07 8.28E-04 5.3333 2.05E-02 5.3333 1.96E-02 5.3333 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1129 Chromium 2.87E‐07 8.05E-04 5.1333 3.73E-03 5.1333 3.32E-03 5.1333 #N/A FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1133 Chromium 5.45E‐07 5.86E-04 5.1333 2.78E-02 5.1333 2.75E-02 5.1333 7.8% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

947 Chromium 2.90E‐07 2.28E-03 5.0952 1.64E-02 5.0952 1.43E-02 5.0952 #N/A FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1726 Chromium 3.22E-07 4.50E-04 4.3558 3.83E-03 4.3558 3.66E-03 4.3558 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1507 Chromium 1.66E‐07 6.86E-04 3.1545 4.51E-03 3.1545 4.14E-03 3.1545 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

1909 Chromium 1.40E‐07 1.39E-03 3.1545 4.65E-03 3.1545 4.41E-03 3.1545 0.0% FF‐Dry Scrubber 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Control 

524 Chromium 1.57E‐06 1.08E-02 83.1333 1.78E-02 83.1333 1.06E-02 83.1333 #N/A Fabric Filter 

1654 Chromium 1.26E‐06 9.10E-03 43.6000 2.40E-02 43.6000 2.00E-02 43.6000 0.0% Fabric Filter 

63254 Chromium 3.84E-06 1.40E-02 17.6667 2.57E-02 17.6667 1.42E-02 17.6667 0.0% Fabric Filter 

2088 Chromium 3.11E‐06 3.91E-03 16.6111 1.02E-02 16.6111 1.31E-02 16.6111 0.0% Fabric Filter 

879456 Chromium 3.43E‐05 4.53E-02 10.2222 7.74E-02 10.2222 8.49E-02 10.2222 0.0% Fabric Filter 

1310 Chromium 4.99E‐05 4.38E-02 9.6667 4.76E-02 9.6667 1.16E-02 9.6667 7.8% Fabric Filter 

1606 Chromium 8.96E-06 6.64E-03 5.9967 1.52E-02 5.9967 9.55E-03 5.9967 0.0% Fabric Filter 

1841 Chromium 2.19E-06 1.34E-03 5.6667 7.28E-03 5.6667 6.54E-03 5.6667 0.0% Fabric Filter 

1189 Chromium 1.98E-07 4.69E-04 5.2000 3.08E-03 5.2000 3.85E-03 5.2000 7.8% Fabric Filter 

1190 Chromium 7.52E-07 4.09E-03 5.2000 7.49E-03 5.2000 4.52E-03 5.2000 7.8% Fabric Filter 

1597 Chromium 5.71E-07 4.18E-03 4.2300 9.93E-03 4.2300 7.35E-03 4.2300 6.6% Fabric Filter 

735 Chromium 5.17E-04 2.43E-03 3.8667 1.42E-02 3.8667 1.28E-02 3.8667 #N/A Fabric Filter 

1244 Chromium 2.89E-04 7.40E-03 3.8667 2.45E-02 3.8667 1.97E-02 3.8667 7.8% Fabric Filter 

1833 Chromium 5.68E-07 5.15E-04 3.8333 6.55E-03 3.8333 6.18E-03 3.8333 0.0% Fabric Filter 

1832 Chromium 4.55E-07 9.36E-04 3.8333 8.96E-03 3.8333 8.03E-03 3.8333 6.0% Fabric Filter 

2170 Ch i rom um 1 77E . ‐07 7 21E 04 7.21E-04 3 3333 . 5 49E 03 5.49E-03 3 3333 . 4 90E 03 4.90E-03 3 3333 . 0 0%. F bi a r c Filter 1835 Chromium 4.17E‐07 8.07E-04 3.3333 2.03E-02 3.3333 1.99E-02 3.3333 0.0% Fabric Filter 

2095 Chromium 7.04E-07 9.09E-05 0.7000 3.61E-03 0.7000 3.53E-03 0.7000 0.0% Fabric Filter 

1638 Chromium 9.02E‐07 3.83E-03 25.1667 1.38E-02 25.1667 9.93E-03 25.1667 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1637 Chromium 8.89E‐07 5.86E-03 25.1667 1.67E-02 25.1667 1.08E-02 25.1667 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 1330 Chromium 2.14E-06 1.47E-02 24.3333 4.10E-02 24.3333 2.63E-02 24.3333 7.8% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1743 Chromium 1.40E‐06 3.59E-03 20.4150 9.89E-03 20.4150 6.30E-03 20.4150 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1738 Chromium 1.14E‐05 3.02E-03 20.4150 1.22E-02 20.4150 9.20E-03 20.4150 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

18261 Chromium 1.67E-06 1.13E-02 19.8333 2.42E-02 19.8333 1.29E-02 19.8333 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1826 Chromium 7.10E-07 2.57E-02 19.8333 4.30E-02 19.8333 1.73E-02 19.8333 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

2055 Chromium 5.82E-06 8.72E-03 18.1333 2.83E-02 18.1333 1.96E-02 18.1333 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

966 Chromium 8.65E‐06 1.84E-02 15.3500 2.61E-02 15.3500 7.67E-03 15.3500 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1120 Chromium 3.58E-06 3.23E-02 14.2000 3.42E-02 14.2000 1.95E-03 14.2000 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

900 Chromium 3.49E‐06 4.11E-03 11.3400 7.82E-03 11.3400 3.71E-03 11.3400 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1177 Chromium 5.29E-06 2.11E-02 11.0583 8.02E-02 11.0583 6.02E-02 11.0583 7.8% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1915 Chromium 5.21E-07 3.35E-03 7.5985 1.86E-02 7.5985 1.89E-02 7.5985 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1276 Chromium 4.23E‐07 4.69E-02 2.6467 5.95E-02 2.6467 1.26E-02 2.6467 7.8% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

2239 Chromium 8.88E-07 3.27E-03 2.6333 6.41E-03 2.6333 3.14E-03 2.6333 0.0% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1734 Chromium 4.76E‐07 5.47E-03 3.6667 1.14E-02 3.6667 1.01E-02 3.6667 0.0% ESP‐Dry Scrubber 1735 Chromium 1.18E‐06 2.01E-02 3.6667 2.73E-02 3.6667 2.06E-02 3.6667 0.0% ESP‐Dry Scrubber 1906 Chromium 5.97E‐06 2.19E-02 31.3333 5.83E-02 31.3333 4.06E-02 31.3333 0.0% ESP 

1113 Chromium 1.51E-05 9.95E-03 26.5722 7.65E-02 26.5722 7.82E-02 26.5722 #N/A ESP 1471 Chromium 1.75E-06 1.33E-02 23.1667 1.82E-02 23.1667 9.36E-03 23.1667 9.7% ESP 

1636 Chromium 1.10E‐05 1.10E-01 17.4144 2.01E-01 17.4144 1.46E-01 17.4144 0.0% ESP 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Control 

979 Chromium 5.84E-06 4.02E-02 17.2333 1.02E-01 17.2333 6.83E-02 17.2333 #N/A ESP 993 Chromium 1.06E-05 1.29E-02 14.9511 2.57E-02 14.9511 2.55E-02 14.9511 #N/A ESP 

1854 Chromium 1.54E-06 5.59E-03 11.0583 1.64E-02 11.0583 1.32E-02 11.0583 0.0% ESP 1845 Chromium 1.33E-04 6.45E-02 11.0583 1.68E-01 11.0583 1.41E-01 11.0583 0.0% ESP 

828 Chromium 2.20E-05 1.00E-01 11.0583 1.70E-01 11.0583 1.05E-01 11.0583 #N/A ESP 

2011 Chromium 3.25E-06 2.88E-02 10.6667 3.42E-02 10.6667 1.81E-02 10.6667 0.0% ESP 

902 Chromium 5.07E-06 2.84E-02 10.1933 6.76E-02 10.1933 5.29E-02 10.1933 #N/A ESP 

903 Chromium 1.57E-05 1.05E-01 10.1933 1.50E-01 10.1933 8.72E-02 10.1933 #N/A ESP 

1809 Chromium 1.81E-05 3.32E-02 9.9567 9.11E-02 9.9567 5.79E-02 9.9567 0.0% ESP 

1642 Chromium 1.80E‐06 1.11E-02 9.1667 1.41E-02 9.1667 1.10E-02 9.1667 0.0% ESP 2195 Chromium 8.82E-06 1.66E-03 8.8967 7.50E-03 8.8967 6.84E-03 8.8967 0.0% ESP 

892 Chromium 1.13E-05 1.29E-01 7.6667 1.36E-01 7.6667 3.90E-02 7.6667 #N/A ESP 

2135 Chromium 1.56E-04 1.94E-02 7.5985 4.55E-02 7.5985 4.06E-02 7.5985 0.0% ESP 

21351 Chromium 8.35E-04 1.13E-02 7.5985 5.06E-02 7.5985 6.15E-02 7.5985 0.0% ESP 

894 Chromium 2.05E-06 9.20E-03 7.3333 2.87E-02 7.3333 2.32E-02 7.3333 #N/A ESP 

2103 Ch i rom um 6 78E . ‐07 1 13E 02 1.13E-02 5 6667 . 2 68E 02 2.68E-02 5 6667 . 1 71E 02 1.71E-02 5 6667 . 0 0%. ESP 2161 Chromium 4.91E-07 4.90E-04 5.5900 7.87E-02 5.5900 7.82E-02 5.5900 0.0% ESP 

1902 Chromium 1.35E-06 9.12E-03 5.2200 1.53E-02 5.2200 1.20E-02 5.2200 0.0% ESP 1989 Chromium 4.00E‐06 2.84E-02 4.6667 3.36E-02 4.6667 5.16E-03 4.6667 0.0% ESP 2302 Chromium 3.32E‐06 1.52E-02 4.6667 3.50E-02 4.6667 3.12E-02 4.6667 0.0% ESP 1154 Chromium 2.04E-06 3.19E-02 4.1259 3.67E-02 4.1259 1.64E-02 4.1259 7.8% ESP 

2009 Chromium 4.81E-06 5.88E-02 4.1259 6.33E-02 4.1259 2.10E-02 4.1259 0.0% ESP 

2013 Chromium 4.78E‐06 5.17E-02 4.0000 6.35E-02 4.0000 3.02E-02 4.0000 0.0% ESP 2279 Chromium 2.61E-06 5.67E-03 3.0670 1.07E-02 3.0670 6.62E-03 3.0670 0.0% ESP 

22791 Chromium 7.85E-06 5.55E-03 3.0670 1.69E-02 3.0670 1.19E-02 3.0670 0.0% ESP 

1021 Chromium 5.70E-07 1.30E-03 3.0500 7.07E-03 3.0500 7.27E-03 3.0500 #N/A ESP 

2274 Chromium 1.61E-05 1.14E-02 2.6667 2.96E-02 2.6667 2.20E-02 2.6667 0.0% ESP 2276 Chromium 1.62E-04 2.40E-02 2.6667 4.42E-02 2.6667 2.92E-02 2.6667 0.0% ESP 2278 Chromium 2.65E-04 3.93E-02 2.3200 4.95E-02 2.3200 1.31E-02 2.3200 0.0% ESP 1141 Chromium 4.46E-06 8.12E-02 2.2567 8.30E-02 2.2567 2.27E-02 2.2567 7.8% ESP 

3197 Chromium 1.68E-06 4.15E-03 1.5233 6.54E-03 1.5233 4.16E-03 1.5233 0.0% ESP 

975 Chromium 2.36E-05 1.47E-01 0.1748 1.71E-01 0.1748 5.15E-02 0.1748 #N/A ESP 

1558 Chromium 4.23E‐06 2.41E-02 5.3929 2.69E-02 5.3929 2.88E-03 5.3929 9.7% Wet Scrubber 

1185 Chromium 3.60E-06 1.07E-02 0.0000 2.88E-02 0.0000 1.81E-02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 1187 Chromium 1.54E-06 1.66E-02 0.0000 2.92E-02 0.0000 1.26E-02 0.0000 7.8% ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

736 Chromium 1.91E-04 3.31E-03 9.12E-03 7.02E-03 #N/A Fabric Filter 

731 Chromium 1.04E‐05 1.12E-02 1.39E-02 1.12E-02 #N/A ESP 

734 Chromium 1.50E-04 2.00E-03 1.44E-02 1.46E-02 #N/A Fabric Filter 

632 Chromium 2.81E-06 1.36E-02 5.49E-02 5.11E-02 #N/A ESP 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Control 

1449 Chromium 1.50E-06 1.20E-03 5.0000 5.0000 5.0000 9.7% FF‐Dry Scrubber 

565 Chromium 1.80E-06 2.75E-03 4.4286 4.4286 4.4286 #N/A FF‐Dry Scrubber 

560 Chromium 1.09E-06 3.88E-03 4.4286 4.4286 4.4286 #N/A FF‐Dry Scrubber 

12861 Chromium 3.14E-06 5.27E-03 7.0000 7.0000 7.0000 7.9% ESP 

10040004 Chromium 2.18E‐06 7.52E-03 2.2400 2.2400 2.2400 0.0% ESP 

1004 Chromium 3.29E-06 1.14E-02 26.0000 26.0000 26.0000 #N/A ESP 

550002 Chromium 8.67E-04 4.91E-02 18.0000 18.0000 18.0000 0.0% ESP‐Dry Scrubber 

10040002 Chromium 2.91E-06 5.31E-02 20.6667 20.6667 20.6667 0.0% ESP 

1117 Chromium 9.62E-06 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1118 Chromium 5.86E-06 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 1119 Chromium 6.75E‐06 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A 5.7322 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 1647 Chromium 1.36E-07 #N/A 8.6000 #N/A 8.6000 #N/A 8.6000 0.0% FF‐Wet Scrubber 1117 Chromium 9.62E-06 #N/A 11.0583 #N/A 11.0583 #N/A 11.0583 #N/A ESP‐Wet Scrubber 

1111 Chromium 1.25E-04 #N/A 26.5722 #N/A 26.5722 #N/A 26.5722 #N/A ESP 

2070 Chromium 1.03E-06 #N/A 11.0583 #N/A 11.0583 #N/A 11.0583 0.0% ESP 

698 Ch i rom um 4 00E . ‐05 #N/A 21 4667 21.4667 #N/A 21 4667 21.4667 #N/A 21 4667 21.4667 #N/A FF‐Dry S bb cru er 845 Chromium 1.16E‐06 #N/A 3.1444 #N/A 3.1444 #N/A 3.1444 #N/A Fabric Filter 

541 Chromium 5.69E‐05 #N/A 33.3333 #N/A 33.3333 #N/A 33.3333 #N/A FF‐Wet Scrubber 
Regression Results ‐ Cobalt Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cobalt content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ FPM

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.590155686

R Square 0.348283734

Adjusted R Square 0.342897649

Standard Error 1.089014718

Observations 123

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 76.68801564 76.68802 64.66362 6.80534E‐13

Residual 121 143.5003198 1.185953

Total 122 220.1883354

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.83988833 0.35825944 ‐33.0484 2.05E‐62 ‐12.54915738 ‐11.13061928 ‐12.54915738 ‐11.13061928

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.562919655 0.070002961 8.041369 6.81E‐13 0.424330331 0.70150898 0.424330331 0.70150898

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ TPM

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.553960867

R Square 0.306872642

Adjusted R Square 0.300738772

Standard Error 1.108919088

Observations 115

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 61.5209869 61.52099 50.0292 1.34507E‐10

Residual 113 138.9562744 1.229702

Total 114 200.4772613

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.67341787 0.424316626 ‐27.5111 6.67E‐52 ‐12.51406561 ‐10.83277013 ‐12.51406561 ‐10.83277013

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.737747597 0.104302812 7.073132 1.35E‐10 0.531104922 0.944390273 0.531104922 0.944390273

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ TPM2.5

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.487543289

R Square 0.237698459

Adjusted R Square 0.230952427

Standard Error 1.162938471

Observations 115

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 47.65313598 47.65314 35.2353 3.27502E‐08

Residual 113 152.8241253 1.352426

Total 114 200.4772613

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.73989545 0.491281825 ‐23.8965 5.37E‐46 ‐12.71321332 ‐10.76657758 ‐12.71321332 ‐10.76657758

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.64322693 0.108361551 5.935933 3.28E‐08 0.42854316 0.8579107 0.42854316 0.8579107
Regression Results ‐ Cobalt Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cobalt content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ FPM & Metals in Coal

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.615249386

R Square 0.378531807

Adjusted R Square 0.365848783

Standard Error 1.08427429

Observations 101

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 70.17588005 35.08794 29.84555 7.54269E‐11

Residual 98 115.2137721 1.175651

Total 100 185.3896521

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.81382558 0.428345768 ‐27.5801 5.54E‐48 ‐12.6638638 ‐10.96378737 ‐12.6638638 ‐10.96378737

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.58177259 0.075936527 7.661301 1.33E‐11 0.431079027 0.732466152 0.431079027 0.732466152

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.015028062 0.128375003 0.117064 0.907049 ‐0.239727946 0.26978407 ‐0.239727946 0.26978407

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ TPM & Metals in Coal

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.633581442

R Square 0.401425443

Adjusted R Square 0.389209636

Standard Error 1.064115657

Observations 101

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 74.42012326 37.21006 32.86115 1.19893E‐11

Residual 98 110.9695288 1.132342

Total 100 185.3896521

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.3869169 0.458666936 ‐24.8261 4.63E‐44 ‐12.29712648 ‐10.47670732 ‐12.29712648 ‐10.47670732

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.857957485 0.106672312 8.042926 2.05E‐12 0.646269759 1.06964521 0.646269759 1.06964521

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.093865306 0.12523422 0.749518 0.455341 ‐0.154657922 0.342388533 ‐0.154657922 0.342388533

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Co, All Data w/ TPM2.5 & Metals in Coal

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.571381129

R Square 0.326476394

Adjusted R Square 0.312731014

Standard Error 1.128771714

Observations 101

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 60.52534514 30.26267 23.75172 3.88408E‐09

Residual 98 124.864307 1.274126

Total 100 185.3896521

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.24608645 0.5520605 ‐20.3711 5.31E‐37 ‐12.34163251 ‐10.15054038 ‐12.34163251 ‐10.15054038

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.791967753 0.116034006 6.825307 7.35E‐10 0.56170205 1.022233455 0.56170205 1.022233455

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.068799318 0.133046426 0.517108 0.606246 ‐0.195226977 0.332825614 ‐0.195226977 0.332825614
Regression Results ‐ Cobalt Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Cobalt content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Co EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.459533341

R Square 0.211170891

Adjusted R Square 0.156768884

Standard Error 1.177204026

Observations 32

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 10.7585217 5.379261 3.881675 0.032081337

Residual 29 40.18847022 1.385809

Total 31 50.94699192

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.7673796 1.258911663 ‐10.1416 4.79E‐11 ‐15.34214301 ‐10.19261618 ‐15.34214301 ‐10.19261618

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.475978883 0.193032299 2.465799 0.019827 0.081183509 0.870774257 0.081183509 0.870774257

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.134997148 0.27674693 0.4878 0.629359 ‐0.431013868 0.701008164 ‐0.431013868 0.701008164

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Co EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.374721433

R Square 0.140416153

Adjusted R Square 0.081134508

Standard Error 1.22886563

Observations 32

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression Regression 2 7.153780588 7.153780588 3.57689 3.57689 2.368628 2.368628 0.111475536 0.111475536

Residual 29 43.79321133 1.510111

Total 31 50.94699192

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐13.20661409 1.457470902 ‐9.06132 5.88E‐10 ‐16.18747674 ‐10.22575145 ‐16.18747674 ‐10.22575145

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.529153764 0.296147663 1.78679 0.08443 ‐0.076536206 1.134843735 ‐0.076536206 1.134843735

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.269853207 0.278219557 0.969929 0.340102 ‐0.299169669 0.838876083 ‐0.299169669 0.838876083
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controls 

1176 Cobalt 4.10E‐07 2.56E‐02 0.25 3.12E‐02 0.25 5.56E‐03 0.25 7.8% FF‐Wet 

1515 Cobalt 6.16E‐08 2.72E‐03 2.1 5.35E‐03 2.1 2.63E‐03 2.1 9.7% FF‐Wet 

1648 Cobalt 3.74E-08 2.92E‐03 3 6.66E‐03 3 3.74E‐03 3 0.0% FF‐Wet 

2319 Cobalt 7.68E-08 3.50E‐03 3.366666667 5.22E‐03 3.366666667 5.22E‐03 3.366666667 0.0% FF‐Wet 1327 Cobalt 1.13E-07 4.57E‐03 5 6.98E‐03 5 2.41E‐03 5 7.8% FF‐Wet 

1307 Cobalt 9.99E-06 2.76E‐03 5 6.12E‐03 5 3.36E‐03 5 7.8% FF‐Wet 2259 Cobalt 6.71E‐08 3.33E‐03 5.333333333 7.36E‐03 5.333333333 4.03E‐03 5.333333333 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1129 Cobalt 3.53E‐07 8.05E‐04 1.966666667 3.73E‐03 1.966666667 3.32E‐03 1.966666667 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1133 Cobalt 5.94E‐08 5.86E‐04 1.966666667 2.78E‐02 1.966666667 2.75E‐02 1.966666667 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1398 Cobalt 5.88E‐07 1.10E‐03 2 8.82E‐03 2 8.46E‐03 2 7.6% FF‐Dry 

947 Cobalt 8.37E-08 2.28E‐03 2 1.64E‐02 2 1.43E‐02 2 #N/A FF‐Dry 

2206 Cobalt 8.24E‐07 4.51E‐03 2.1 1.35E‐02 2.1 9.53E‐03 2.1 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1726 Cobalt 4.82E-08 4.50E‐04 2.327891267 3.83E‐03 2.327891267 3.66E‐03 2.327891267 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1507 Cobalt 3.94E‐07 6.86E‐04 2.375058824 4.51E‐03 2.375058824 4.14E‐03 2.375058824 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1909 Cobalt 1.84E‐07 1.39E‐03 2.375058824 2.375058824 4.65E‐03 2.375058824 2.375058824 4.41E‐03 2.375058824 2.375058824 0.0% FF‐Dry 1938 Cobalt 7.14E-07 2.09E‐02 2.4 3.56E‐02 2.4 3.14E‐02 2.4 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1611 Cobalt 5.03E-08 2.11E‐03 2.746666667 6.85E‐03 2.746666667 5.05E‐03 2.746666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 1942 Cobalt 9.11E-08 3.56E‐03 6.68 6.18E‐03 6.68 2.64E‐03 6.68 0.0% FF‐Dry 1249 Cobalt 7.70E‐08 3.62E‐03 7 3.20E‐02 7 2.91E‐02 7 7.8% FF‐Dry 

8761 Cobalt 6.30E‐07 4.48E‐03 7.333333333 1.18E‐02 7.333333333 9.88E‐03 7.333333333 0.0% FF‐Dry 

8761 Cobalt 1.74E‐07 4.48E‐03 7.333333333 1.18E‐02 7.333333333 9.88E‐03 7.333333333 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1563 Cobalt 2.79E‐07 3.68E‐03 7.808888889 1.11E‐02 7.808888889 1.12E‐02 7.808888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1563 Cobalt 2.91E-07 3.68E‐03 7.808888889 1.11E‐02 7.808888889 1.12E‐02 7.808888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1563 Cobalt 4.37E‐07 3.68E‐03 7.808888889 1.11E‐02 7.808888889 1.12E‐02 7.808888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1052 Cobalt 1.76E‐07 1.10E‐02 7.833333333 2.30E‐02 7.833333333 1.48E‐02 7.833333333 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1349 Cobalt 1.20E‐07 2.35E‐03 8.125 4.47E‐03 8.125 2.12E‐03 8.125 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1346 Cobalt 4.42E‐07 1.08E‐02 8.166666667 1.30E‐02 8.166666667 4.27E‐03 8.166666667 7.8% FF‐Dry 

134611 Cobalt 1.25E‐06 3.57E‐02 8.166666667 3.79E‐02 8.166666667 4.71E‐03 8.166666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 

13461 Cobalt 3.01E‐07 8.45E‐03 8.166666667 1.05E‐02 8.166666667 5.41E‐03 8.166666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1346111 Cobalt 6.40E‐07 2.71E‐02 8.166666667 2.91E‐02 8.166666667 6.51E‐03 8.166666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 

2021 Cobalt 6.88E‐07 2.14E‐02 10.95238095 4.06E‐02 10.95238095 2.88E‐02 10.95238095 0.0% FF‐Dry 

2022 Cobalt 3.08E‐06 1.94E‐02 12.6875 2.84E‐02 12.6875 2.40E‐02 12.6875 0.0% FF‐Dry 

2095 Cobalt 3.43E-07 9.09E‐05 0.57 3.61E‐03 0.57 3.53E‐03 0.57 0.0% FF 2170 Cobalt 5 89E 08 5.89E-08 7 21E . ‐04 1 5 49E . ‐03 1 4 90E . ‐03 1 0 0%. FF 1833 Cobalt 1.53E‐07 5.15E‐04 1 6.55E‐03 1 6.18E‐03 1 0.0% FF 

1832 Cobalt 1.46E‐07 9.36E‐04 1 8.96E‐03 1 8.03E‐03 1 6.0% FF 

1835 Cobalt 2.32E‐07 8.07E‐04 1 2.03E‐02 1 1.99E‐02 1 0.0% FF 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controls 

735 Cobalt 5.08E-06 2.43E‐03 1.325 1.42E‐02 1.325 1.28E‐02 1.325 #N/A FF 

1244 Cobalt 4.11E-06 7.40E‐03 1.325 2.45E‐02 1.325 1.97E‐02 1.325 7.8% FF 

1597 Cobalt 1.45E-07 4.18E‐03 1.686666667 9.93E‐03 1.686666667 7.35E‐03 1.686666667 6.6% FF 

1310 Cobalt 1.13E-06 4.38E‐02 2.333333333 4.76E‐02 2.333333333 1.16E‐02 2.333333333 7.8% FF 

1189 Cobalt 2.93E-08 4.69E‐04 2.36 3.08E‐03 2.36 3.85E‐03 2.36 7.8% FF 1190 Cobalt 5.44E‐08 4.09E‐03 2.36 7.49E‐03 2.36 4.52E‐03 2.36 7.8% FF 

1841 Cobalt 3.61E-07 1.34E‐03 2.4 7.28E‐03 2.4 6.54E‐03 2.4 0.0% FF 

1606 Cobalt 2.57E‐07 6.64E‐03 2.746666667 1.52E‐02 2.746666667 9.55E‐03 2.746666667 0.0% FF 

63254 Cobalt 1.16E‐06 1.40E‐02 5.333333333 2.57E‐02 5.333333333 1.42E‐02 5.333333333 0.0% FF 

2088 Cobalt 4.11E‐07 3.91E‐03 8.166666667 1.02E‐02 8.166666667 1.31E‐02 8.166666667 0.0% FF 

1654 Cobalt 1.99E-07 9.10E‐03 13 2.40E‐02 13 2.00E‐02 13 0.0% FF 

524 Cobalt 3.40E‐06 1.08E‐02 23.1 1.78E‐02 23.1 1.06E‐02 23.1 #N/A FF 

1187 Cobalt 1.83E-07 1.66E‐02 0.7888 2.92E‐02 0.7888 1.26E‐02 0.7888 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1185 Cobalt 1.15E‐07 1.07E‐02 0.7888 2.88E‐02 0.7888 1.81E‐02 0.7888 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1276 Cobalt 1 85E-07 1.85E-07 4 69E . ‐02 0 993333333 0.993333333 5 95E . ‐02 0 993333333 0.993333333 1 26E . ‐02 0 993333333 0.993333333 7 8%. ESP‐Wet 1915 Cobalt 8.48E-08 3.35E‐03 2.167380214 1.86E‐02 2.167380214 1.89E‐02 2.167380214 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

2239 Cobalt 6.03E-08 3.27E‐03 2.7 6.41E‐03 2.7 3.14E‐03 2.7 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

2055 Cobalt 1.93E‐07 8.72E‐03 3.556666667 2.83E‐02 3.556666667 1.96E‐02 3.556666667 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1120 Cobalt 1.97E-07 3.23E‐02 4.24 3.42E‐02 4.24 1.95E‐03 4.24 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1177 Cobalt 3.34E-07 2.11E‐02 4.416666667 8.02E‐02 4.416666667 6.02E‐02 4.416666667 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

966 Cobalt 5.64E-07 1.84E‐02 4.555 2.61E‐02 4.555 7.67E‐03 4.555 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

18261 Cobalt 4.10E‐07 1.13E‐02 5.533333333 2.42E‐02 5.533333333 1.29E‐02 5.533333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1826 Cobalt 4.09E-07 2.57E‐02 5.533333333 4.30E‐02 5.533333333 1.73E‐02 5.533333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1638 Cobalt 1.54E-07 3.83E‐03 5.72 1.38E‐02 5.72 9.93E‐03 5.72 0.0% ESP‐Wet 1637 Cobalt 1.43E-07 5.86E‐03 5.72 1.67E‐02 5.72 1.08E‐02 5.72 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

900 Cobalt 1.26E-07 4.11E‐03 7.026666667 7.82E‐03 7.026666667 3.71E‐03 7.026666667 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1743 Cobalt 2.94E-07 3.59E‐03 8.218333333 9.89E‐03 8.218333333 6.30E‐03 8.218333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1738 Cobalt 9.53E‐07 3.02E‐03 8.218333333 1.22E‐02 8.218333333 9.20E‐03 8.218333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1330 Cobalt 4.05E‐07 1.47E‐02 10.51666667 4.10E‐02 10.51666667 2.63E‐02 10.51666667 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1734 Cobalt 2.88E-07 5.47E‐03 1.666666667 1.14E‐02 1.666666667 1.01E‐02 1.666666667 0.0% ESP‐Dry 

1735 Cobalt 6.77E‐07 2.01E‐02 1.666666667 2.73E‐02 1.666666667 2.06E‐02 1.666666667 0.0% ESP‐Dry 

3197 Cobalt 3.00E-07 4.15E‐03 0.5 6.54E‐03 0.5 4.16E‐03 0.5 0.0% ESP 

1141 Cobalt 2.20E-06 8.12E‐02 0.746666667 8.30E‐02 0.746666667 2.27E‐02 0.746666667 7.8% ESP 

975 Cbl o a t 4 78E 06 4.78E-06 1 47E . ‐01 0 803809524 0.803809524 1 71E . ‐01 0 803809524 0.803809524 5 15E . ‐02 0 803809524 0.803809524 #N/A ESP 

2013 Cobalt 1.70E‐06 5.17E‐02 1 6.35E‐02 1 3.02E‐02 1 0.0% ESP 

2278 Cobalt 2.16E-06 3.93E‐02 1.328 4.95E‐02 1.328 1.31E‐02 1.328 0.0% ESP 

2011 Cobalt 7.63E-07 2.88E‐02 1.333333333 3.42E‐02 1.333333333 1.81E‐02 1.333333333 0.0% ESP 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controls 

1154 Cobalt 9.17E‐07 3.19E‐02 1.6515848 3.67E‐02 1.6515848 1.64E‐02 1.6515848 7.8% ESP 

2009 Cobalt 1.42E-06 5.88E‐02 1.6515848 6.33E‐02 1.6515848 2.10E‐02 1.6515848 0.0% ESP 

1021 Cobalt 1.26E-07 1.30E‐03 1.733333333 7.07E‐03 1.733333333 7.27E‐03 1.733333333 #N/A ESP 

2279 Cobalt 1.41E-06 5.67E‐03 1.785 1.07E‐02 1.785 6.62E‐03 1.785 0.0% ESP 

22791 Cobalt 3.97E‐07 5.55E‐03 1.785 1.69E‐02 1.785 1.19E‐02 1.785 0.0% ESP 

1902 Cobalt 4.44E-07 9.12E‐03 1.885 1.53E‐02 1.885 1.20E‐02 1.885 0.0% ESP 

2103 Cobalt 2.01E-06 1.13E‐02 2 2.68E‐02 2 1.71E‐02 2 0.0% ESP 2274 Cobalt 1.89E‐07 1.14E‐02 2 2.96E‐02 2 2.20E‐02 2 0.0% ESP 

2276 Cobalt 1.27E-06 2.40E‐02 2 4.42E‐02 2 2.92E‐02 2 0.0% ESP 

2302 Cobalt 5.02E‐07 1.52E‐02 2 3.50E‐02 2 3.12E‐02 2 0.0% ESP 

2135 Cobalt 4.96E-06 1.94E‐02 2.167380214 4.55E‐02 2.167380214 4.06E‐02 2.167380214 0.0% ESP 

21351 Cobalt 4.10E-07 1.13E‐02 2.167380214 5.06E‐02 2.167380214 6.15E‐02 2.167380214 0.0% ESP 

894 Cobalt 6.47E-07 9.20E‐03 2.233333333 2.87E‐02 2.233333333 2.32E‐02 2.233333333 #N/A ESP 

1809 Cobalt 1.84E‐06 3.32E‐02 2.403333333 9.11E‐02 2.403333333 5.79E‐02 2.403333333 0.0% ESP 

1636 Cobalt 2 83E . 06 - 1 10E . ‐01 2 793 . 2 01E . ‐01 2 793 . 1 46E . ‐01 2 793 . 0 0%. ESP 

892 Cobalt 6.30E-06 1.29E‐01 3.1 1.36E‐01 3.1 3.90E‐02 3.1 #N/A ESP 

1854 Cobalt 2.45E-07 5.59E‐03 4.416666667 1.64E‐02 4.416666667 1.32E‐02 4.416666667 0.0% ESP 

828 Cobalt 3.30E-06 1.00E‐01 4.416666667 1.70E‐01 4.416666667 1.05E‐01 4.416666667 #N/A ESP 

1845 Cobalt 5.00E-06 6.45E‐02 4.416666667 1.68E‐01 4.416666667 1.41E‐01 4.416666667 0.0% ESP 2195 Cobalt 4.00E-07 1.66E‐03 5.433333333 7.50E‐03 5.433333333 6.84E‐03 5.433333333 0.0% ESP 

902 Cobalt 2.82E-06 2.84E‐02 6.876666667 6.76E‐02 6.876666667 5.29E‐02 6.876666667 #N/A ESP 903 Cobalt 8.70E-06 1.05E‐01 6.876666667 1.50E‐01 6.876666667 8.72E‐02 6.876666667 #N/A ESP 993 Cobalt 3.35E-06 1.29E‐02 7.34 2.57E‐02 7.34 2.55E‐02 7.34 #N/A ESP 

1471 Cobalt 4.14E-07 1.33E‐02 8.373333333 1.82E‐02 8.373333333 9.36E‐03 8.373333333 9.7% ESP 

979 Cobalt 9.02E-07 4.02E‐02 8.53 1.02E‐01 8.53 6.83E‐02 8.53 #N/A ESP 

1906 Cobalt 1.40E-06 2.19E‐02 8.666666667 5.83E‐02 8.666666667 4.06E‐02 8.666666667 0.0% ESP 1113 Cobalt 1.18E-06 9.95E‐03 9.471666667 7.65E‐02 9.471666667 7.82E‐02 9.471666667 #N/A ESP 1558 Cobalt 3.19E‐07 2.41E‐02 0 2.69E‐02 0 2.88E‐03 0 9.7% Wet 

23152 Cobalt 2.57E‐07 1.36E‐03 0 4.37E‐03 0 3.01E‐03 0 0.0% FF‐Wet 

23153 Cobalt 5.27E‐07 3.21E‐03 0 6.28E‐03 0 3.07E‐03 0 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1972 Cobalt 1.05E-06 1.92E‐03 0 4.32E‐03 0 3.44E‐03 0 0.0% FF‐Wet 

23151 Cobalt 4.41E-07 4.68E‐03 0 8.80E‐03 0 4.12E‐03 0 0.0% FF‐Wet 

2315 Cobalt 6.91E‐07 3.77E‐03 0 8.16E‐03 0 4.39E‐03 0 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1989 Cbl o a t 1 28E 06 1.28E-06 2 84E . ‐02 0 3 36E . ‐02 0 5 16E . ‐03 0 0 0%. ESP 1642 Cobalt 6.40E‐07 1.11E‐02 0 1.41E‐02 0 1.10E‐02 0 0.0% ESP 

2161 Cobalt 6.67E‐08 4.90E‐04 0 7.87E‐02 0 7.82E‐02 0 0.0% ESP 

879456 Cobalt 1.86E‐06 4.53E‐02 0 7.74E‐02 0 8.49E‐02 0 0.0% FF 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content Controls 

736 Cobalt 2.99E‐06 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF 

731 Cobalt 7.00E‐07 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP 

734 Cobalt 1.91E-06 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF 

632 Cobalt 1.23E-06 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP 

1449 Cobalt 3.01E-07 1.20E‐03 1.5 1.5 1.5 9.7% FF‐Dry 

565 Cobalt 5.63E‐08 2.75E‐03 1 1 1 #N/A FF‐Dry 

560 Cobalt 5.82E‐08 3.88E‐03 1 1 1 #N/A FF‐Dry 

12861 Cobalt 4.16E-07 5.27E‐03 2 2 2 7.9% ESP 

10040004 Cobalt 1.28E-07 7.52E‐03 1.783333333 1.783333333 1.783333333 0.0% ESP 

1004 Cobalt 2.88E-07 1.14E‐02 7 7 7 #N/A ESP 

550002 Cobalt 9.14E‐06 4.91E‐02 4 4 4 0.0% ESP‐Dry 

10040002 Cobalt 6.09E-07 5.31E‐02 6.333333333 6.333333333 6.333333333 0.0% ESP 

1111 Cobalt 7.00E‐06 #N/A 9.471666667 #N/A 9.471666667 #N/A 9.471666667 #N/A ESP 

2070 Cobalt 4.53E‐07 #N/A 4.416666667 #N/A 4.416666667 #N/A 4.416666667 0.0% ESP 

1117 Cobalt 4 90E 07 4.90E-07 #N/A 3 075555556 3.075555556 #N/A 3 075555556 3.075555556 #N/A 3 075555556 3.075555556 #N/A ESP‐Wet 1118 Cobalt 3.21E-07 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1119 Cobalt 3.40E‐07 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A 3.075555556 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1117 Cobalt 4.90E‐07 #N/A 4.416666667 #N/A 4.416666667 #N/A 4.416666667 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

845 Cobalt 3.86E-07 #N/A 1.811111111 #N/A 1.811111111 #N/A 1.811111111 #N/A FF 

1647 Cobalt 1.43E-08 #N/A 3 #N/A 3 #N/A 3 0.0% FF‐Wet 

541 Cobalt 6.55E‐07 #N/A 5.633333333 #N/A 5.633333333 #N/A 5.633333333 #N/A FF‐Wet 
Regression Results ‐ Lead Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Lead content, Coal ash etc.

Pb, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.371860057

R Square 0.138279902

Adjusted R Square 0.131274047

Standard Error 1.744757253

Observations 125

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 60.08526431 60.08526 19.73776 1.95554E‐05

Residual 123 374.4338784 3.044178

Total 124 434.5191427

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.85795525 0.570583896 ‐19.0296 1.85E‐38 ‐11.9873911 ‐9.728519426 ‐11.98739107 ‐9.728519426

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.493452973 0.111070006 4.44272 1.96E‐05 0.27359671 0.713309237 0.27359671 0.713309237

Pb, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.336889936

R Square 0.113494829

Adjusted R Square 0.105786088

Standard Error 1.813567243

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 48.4239227 48.42392 14.72288 0.000203948

Residual 115 378.2380065 3.289026

Total 116 426.6619292

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.68778033 0.693437134 ‐15.4128 9.53E‐30 ‐12.0613458 ‐9.314214873 ‐12.06134579 ‐9.314214873

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.653690928 0.170363337 3.83704 0.000204 0.316233958 0.991147899 0.316233958 0.991147899

Pb, All Data w/ FPM & Lead content of Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.351756763

R Square 0.12373282

Adjusted R Square 0.106717923

Standard Error 1.87038808

Observations 106

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 50.88022725 25.44011 7.272029 0.001111174

Residual 103 360.3302115 3.498352

Total 105 411.2104388

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.86959398 0.82101976 ‐13.2391 5.8E‐24 ‐12.497893 ‐9.24129497 ‐12.49789298 ‐9.24129497

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.490566535 0.134085955 3.658597 0.000402 0.224638675 0.756494395 0.224638675 0.756494395

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.03369879 0.199110885 0.169246 0.865935 ‐0.36119068 0.428588258 ‐0.361190678 0.428588258
Regression Results ‐ Lead Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Lead content, Coal ash etc.

Pb, All Data w/ TPM & Lead content of Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.337104947

R Square 0.113639745

Adjusted R Square 0.096428866

Standard Error 1.881129049

Observations 106

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 46.72984944 23.36492 6.602786 0.002004145

Residual 103 364.4805893 3.538646

Total 105 411.2104388

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.79577933 0.876706818 ‐12.314 5.76E‐22 ‐12.5345205 ‐9.057038176 ‐12.53452048 ‐9.057038176

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.646410278 0.186137473 3.472757 0.000754 0.277250512 1.015570043 0.277250512 1.015570043

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.082701004 0.197755377 0.418199 0.676673 ‐0.30950013 0.474902141 ‐0.309500134 0.474902141

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Pb EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.316381064

R Square 0.100096978

Adjusted R Square 0.052733661

Standard Error 1.455676449

Observations 41

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 8.956504796 4.478252 2.113386 0.134808879

Residual 38 80.52176911 2.118994

Total 40 89.4782739

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.01376095 1.555242343 ‐7.0817 1.91E‐08 ‐14.1621844 ‐7.865337456 ‐14.16218445 ‐7.865337456

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.377343821 0.229627413 1.643287 0.108574 ‐0.08751257 0.842200212 ‐0.08751257 0.842200212

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.556619171 0.310153894 ‐1.79465 0.080667 ‐1.1844929 0.071254557 ‐1.184492899 0.071254557

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Pb EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.249766404

R Square 0.062383256

Adjusted R Square 0.013035007

Standard Error 1.485866111

Observations 41

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 5.581946107 2.790973 1.264143 0.294090997

Residual 38 83.89632779 2.207798

Total 40 89.4782739

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐11.79518339 1.667885988 ‐7.07194 1.97E‐08 ‐15.171642 ‐8.418724761 ‐15.17164202 ‐8.418724761

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.340855892 0.330553906 1.031166 0.308982 ‐0.3283155 1.010027285 ‐0.328315501 1.010027285

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) ‐0.409539967 0.295142835 ‐1.3876 0.173343 ‐1.00702539 0.18794546 ‐1.007025394 0.18794546
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

13461 Lead 5.39E‐07 8.45E‐03 7.5 1.05E‐02 7.5 5.41E‐03 7.5 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1346111 Lead 1.21E‐06 2.71E‐02 7.5 2.91E‐02 7.5 6.51E‐03 7.5 0.0% FF‐Dry 

134611 Lead 1.99E‐06 3.57E‐02 7.5 3.79E‐02 7.5 4.71E‐03 7.5 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1398 Lead 2.18E-06 1.10E‐03 2.566666667 8.82E‐03 2.566666667 8.46E‐03 2.566666667 7.6% FF‐Dry 

1349 Lead 1.55E‐06 2.35E‐03 8.083333333 4.47E‐03 8.083333333 2.12E‐03 8.083333333 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1346 Lead 7.89E‐07 1.08E‐02 7.5 1.30E‐02 7.5 4.27E‐03 7.5 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1249 Lead 2.33E‐07 3.62E‐03 7 3.20E‐02 7 2.91E‐02 7 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1133 Lead 2.61E‐07 5.86E‐04 2.333333333 2.78E‐02 2.333333333 2.75E‐02 2.333333333 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1563 Lead 3.35E-06 3.68E‐03 9.683888889 1.11E‐02 9.683888889 1.12E‐02 9.683888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1563 Lead 2.00E-05 3.68E‐03 9.683888889 1.11E‐02 9.683888889 1.12E‐02 9.683888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 1563 Lead 3.33E-06 3.68E‐03 9.683888889 1.11E‐02 9.683888889 1.12E‐02 9.683888889 9.7% FF‐Dry 1488 Lead 2.94E‐07 8.28E‐04 3.1 2.05E‐02 3.1 1.96E‐02 3.1 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1568 Lead 8.44E‐07 5.61E‐03 2.5 1.13E‐02 2.5 8.21E‐03 2.5 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1507 Lead 1.38E‐04 6.86E‐04 0.67540625 4.51E‐03 0.67540625 4.14E‐03 0.67540625 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1052 Lead 5.78E‐07 1.10E‐02 8.6 2.30E‐02 8.6 1.48E‐02 8.6 #N/A FF‐Dry 

947 Lead 1.32E‐07 2.28E‐03 2.666666667 1.64E‐02 2.666666667 1.43E‐02 2.666666667 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1129 Lead 3.53E‐07 8.05E‐04 2.333333333 3.73E‐03 2.333333333 3.32E‐03 2.333333333 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1942 Lead 3.17E‐07 3.56E‐03 57.1 6.18E‐03 57.1 2.64E‐03 57.1 0.0% FF‐Dry 

2022 Lead 4.82E‐06 1.94E‐02 13.5625 2.84E‐02 13.5625 2.40E‐02 13.5625 0.0% FF‐Dry 

2021 Lead 1.00E‐06 2.14E‐02 12.52380952 4.06E‐02 12.52380952 2.88E‐02 12.52380952 0.0% FF‐Dry 

8761 Lead 1.32E-06 4.48E‐03 8 1.18E‐02 8 9.88E‐03 8 0.0% FF‐Dry 

8761 Lead 1.02E-06 4.48E‐03 8 1.18E‐02 8 9.88E‐03 8 0.0% FF‐Dry 1611 Lead 9.98E-08 2.11E‐03 2.993333333 6.85E‐03 2.993333333 5.05E‐03 2.993333333 0.0% FF‐Dry 2206 Lead 2.06E‐06 4.51E‐03 2.9 1.35E‐02 2.9 9.53E‐03 2.9 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1726 Lead 1.55E-07 4.50E‐04 2.811842133 3.83E‐03 2.811842133 3.66E‐03 2.811842133 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1938 Lead 3.88E-06 2.09E‐02 2.466666667 3.56E‐02 2.466666667 3.14E‐02 2.466666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 1734 Lead 1.79E‐06 5.47E‐03 2.333333333 1.14E‐02 2.333333333 1.01E‐02 2.333333333 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1735 Lead 2.06E‐06 2.01E‐02 2.333333333 2.73E‐02 2.333333333 2.06E‐02 2.333333333 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1909 Lead 1.07E‐05 1.39E‐03 0.67540625 4.65E‐03 0.67540625 4.41E‐03 0.67540625 0.0% FF‐Dry 

23152 Lead 3.23E-07 1.36E‐03 8.558888889 4.37E‐03 8.558888889 3.01E‐03 8.558888889 0.0% FF‐Wet 

23153 Lead 5.87E-07 3.21E‐03 8.558888889 6.28E‐03 8.558888889 3.07E‐03 8.558888889 0.0% FF‐Wet 23151 Lead 3.79E-07 4.68E‐03 8.558888889 8.80E‐03 8.558888889 4.12E‐03 8.558888889 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1176 Lead 5.57E-07 2.56E‐02 5.248333333 3.12E‐02 5.248333333 5.56E‐03 5.248333333 7.8% FF‐Wet 1307 Lead 9.25E-07 2.76E‐03 3.666666667 6.12E‐03 3.666666667 3.36E‐03 3.666666667 7.8% FF‐Wet 1327 Lead 2.35E-07 4.57E‐03 3.666666667 6.98E‐03 3.666666667 2.41E‐03 3.666666667 7.8% FF‐Wet 1515 Lead 3.18E‐07 2.72E‐03 3.316666667 5.35E‐03 3.316666667 2.63E‐03 3.316666667 9.7% FF‐Wet 

2315 Lead 1.05E-06 3.77E‐03 8.558888889 8.16E‐03 8.558888889 4.39E‐03 8.558888889 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1648 Lead 1.83E-07 2.92E‐03 7.8 6.66E‐03 7.8 3.74E‐03 7.8 0.0% FF‐Wet 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

2259 Lead 1.42E-07 3.33E‐03 5.666666667 7.36E‐03 5.666666667 4.03E‐03 5.666666667 0.0% FF‐Wet 

2319 Lead 2.79E‐07 3.50E‐03 4.4 5.22E‐03 4.4 5.22E‐03 4.4 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1972 Lead 9.05E-08 1.92E‐03 2.454545455 4.32E‐03 2.454545455 3.44E‐03 2.454545455 0.0% FF‐Wet 

1558 Lead 4.77E‐06 2.41E‐02 5.614285714 2.69E‐02 5.614285714 2.88E‐03 5.614285714 9.7% Wet 

63254 Lead 2.12E-06 1.40E‐02 8.333333333 2.57E‐02 8.333333333 1.42E‐02 8.333333333 0.0% FF 

879456 Lead 3.80E‐06 4.53E‐02 5 7.74E‐02 5 8.49E‐02 5 0.0% FF 

1597 Lead 3.97E-07 4.18E‐03 2.723333333 9.93E‐03 2.723333333 7.35E‐03 2.723333333 6.6% FF 

1310 Lead 1.59E‐06 4.38E‐02 11.66666667 4.76E‐02 11.66666667 1.16E‐02 11.66666667 7.8% FF 

1244 Lead 2.17E-06 7.40E‐03 5.125 2.45E‐02 5.125 1.97E‐02 5.125 7.8% FF 

1189 Lead 1.07E-06 4.69E‐04 5.1 3.08E‐03 5.1 3.85E‐03 5.1 7.8% FF 1190 Lead 2.87E-06 4.09E‐03 5.1 7.49E‐03 5.1 4.52E‐03 5.1 7.8% FF 

524 Lead 6.96E‐06 1.08E‐02 33.8 1.78E‐02 33.8 1.06E‐02 33.8 #N/A FF 

735 Lead 1.17E-06 2.43E‐03 5.125 1.42E‐02 5.125 1.28E‐02 5.125 #N/A FF 

1654 Lead 2.38E‐06 9.10E‐03 24.4 2.40E‐02 24.4 2.00E‐02 24.4 0.0% FF 

2088 Lead 1.43E 088 ead .43 ‐06 3.91E‐03 7.5 1.02E 7.5 .0 ‐02 7.5 1.31E 7.5 .3 ‐02 7.5 0.0 7.5 0.0% FF 

1606 Lead 6.52E-07 6.64E‐03 2.993333333 1.52E‐02 2.993333333 9.55E‐03 2.993333333 0.0% FF 

1841 Lead 3.88E-06 1.34E‐03 2.466666667 7.28E‐03 2.466666667 6.54E‐03 2.466666667 0.0% FF 2170 Lead 4.36E‐07 7.21E‐04 2 5.49E‐03 2 4.90E‐03 2 0.0% FF 

1835 Lead 1.32E‐07 8.07E‐04 2 2.03E‐02 2 1.99E‐02 2 0.0% FF 

2095 Lead 6.59E-07 9.09E‐05 0.735 3.61E‐03 0.735 3.53E‐03 0.735 0.0% FF 

18261 Lead 7.95E-06 1.13E‐02 14.81666667 2.42E‐02 14.81666667 1.29E‐02 14.81666667 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1177 Lead 8.57E-06 2.11E‐02 9.525 8.02E‐02 9.525 6.02E‐02 9.525 7.8% ESP‐Wet 1330 Lead 1.20E-06 1.47E‐02 8.833333333 4.10E‐02 8.833333333 2.63E‐02 8.833333333 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

1276 Lead 2.36E‐07 4.69E‐02 4.613333333 5.95E‐02 4.613333333 1.26E‐02 4.613333333 7.8% ESP‐Wet 

900 Lead 1.19E-01 4.11E‐03 12.83333333 7.82E‐03 12.83333333 3.71E‐03 12.83333333 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

966 Lead 3.70E‐05 1.84E‐02 3.985 2.61E‐02 3.985 7.67E‐03 3.985 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1120 Lead 5.11E-07 3.23E‐02 3.456666667 3.42E‐02 3.456666667 1.95E‐03 3.456666667 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1826 Lead 4.77E-06 2.57E‐02 14.81666667 4.30E‐02 14.81666667 1.73E‐02 14.81666667 0.0% ESP‐Wet 1638 Lead 5.60461E‐07 3.83E‐03 14.18333333 1.38E‐02 14.18333333 9.93E‐03 14.18333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1637 Lead 3.91E‐07 5.86E‐03 14.18333333 1.67E‐02 14.18333333 1.08E‐02 14.18333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

2055 Lead 9.82E-07 8.72E‐03 6.53 2.83E‐02 6.53 1.96E‐02 6.53 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1743 Lead 2.20E‐07 3.59E‐03 4.725 9.89E‐03 4.725 6.30E‐03 4.725 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1738 Lead 4.03E‐06 3.02E‐03 4.725 1.22E‐02 4.725 9.20E‐03 4.725 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1915 Lead 5.14E 07 - 3.35E‐03 3.149674157 3.149674157 1.86E‐02 3.149674157 3.149674157 1.89E‐02 3.149674157 3.149674157 0.0% ESP‐Wet 2239 Lead 2.70E-07 3.27E‐03 2.433333333 6.41E‐03 2.433333333 3.14E‐03 2.433333333 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

21351 Lead 1.89E-05 1.13E‐02 3.149674157 5.06E‐02 3.149674157 6.15E‐02 3.149674157 0.0% ESP 

22791 Lead 6.39E-07 5.55E‐03 2.2765 1.69E‐02 2.2765 1.19E‐02 2.2765 0.0% ESP 

1154 Lead 2.33E-06 3.19E‐02 2.57878136 3.67E‐02 2.57878136 1.64E‐02 2.57878136 7.8% ESP 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

1141 Lead 4.12E-06 8.12E‐02 1.196666667 8.30E‐02 1.196666667 2.27E‐02 1.196666667 7.8% ESP 

1471 Lead 5.86E-05 1.33E‐02 11.6 1.82E‐02 11.6 9.36E‐03 11.6 9.7% ESP 

828 Lead 9.93E-06 1.00E‐01 9.525 1.70E‐01 9.525 1.05E‐01 9.525 #N/A ESP 

1113 Lead 3.06E-06 9.95E‐03 9.462222222 7.65E‐02 9.462222222 7.82E‐02 9.462222222 #N/A ESP 

902 Lead 4.93E-06 2.84E‐02 9.106666667 6.76E‐02 9.106666667 5.29E‐02 9.106666667 #N/A ESP 903 Lead 1.31E-05 1.05E‐01 9.106666667 1.50E‐01 9.106666667 8.72E‐02 9.106666667 #N/A ESP 979 Lead 1.31E-06 4.02E‐02 8.58 1.02E‐01 8.58 6.83E‐02 8.58 #N/A ESP 993 Lead 7.99E-06 1.29E‐02 4.728888889 2.57E‐02 4.728888889 2.55E‐02 4.728888889 #N/A ESP 892 Lead 2.18E-05 1.29E‐01 3.6 1.36E‐01 3.6 3.90E‐02 3.6 #N/A ESP 894 Lead 2.13E-06 9.20E‐03 3.566666667 2.87E‐02 3.566666667 2.32E‐02 3.566666667 #N/A ESP 

1021 Lead 2.89E-07 1.30E‐03 2.066666667 7.07E‐03 2.066666667 7.27E‐03 2.066666667 #N/A ESP 

975 Lead 9.61E-06 1.47E‐01 0.4 1.71E‐01 0.4 5.15E‐02 0.4 #N/A ESP 

1636 Lead 9.36E‐06 1.10E‐01 563.744 2.01E‐01 563.744 1.46E‐01 563.744 0.0% ESP 

2195 Lead 7.32E-07 1.66E‐03 42.76666667 7.50E‐03 42.76666667 6.84E‐03 42.76666667 0.0% ESP 

1906 Lead 7.21E‐06 2.19E‐02 11 5.83E‐02 11 4.06E‐02 11 0.0% ESP 

1854 Lead 4.60E-06 5.59E‐03 9.525 1.64E‐02 9.525 1.32E‐02 9.525 0.0% ESP 

1845 Lead 1.41E-05 6.45E‐02 9.525 1.68E‐01 9.525 1.41E‐01 9.525 0.0% ESP 1642 Lead 1.81E‐06 1.11E‐02 3.666666667 1.41E‐02 3.666666667 1.10E‐02 3.666666667 0.0% ESP 

2274 Lead 2.48E-06 1.14E‐02 3.366666667 2.96E‐02 3.366666667 2.20E‐02 3.366666667 0.0% ESP 

2276 Lead 2.14E-06 2.40E‐02 3.366666667 4.42E‐02 3.366666667 2.92E‐02 3.366666667 0.0% ESP 2135 Lead 2.81E-03 1.94E‐02 3.149674157 4.55E‐02 3.149674157 4.06E‐02 3.149674157 0.0% ESP 1809 Lead 7.78E-06 3.32E‐02 3.103333333 9.11E‐02 3.103333333 5.79E‐02 3.103333333 0.0% ESP 

3197 Lead 7.78E-07 4.15E‐03 3.003333333 6.54E‐03 3.003333333 4.16E‐03 3.003333333 0.0% ESP 

2011 Lead 2.25E-06 2.88E‐02 3 3.42E‐02 3 1.81E‐02 3 0.0% ESP 1902 Lead 6.67E-07 9.12E‐03 2.715 1.53E‐02 2.715 1.20E‐02 2.715 0.0% ESP 2009 Lead 6.30E-06 5.88E‐02 2.57878136 6.33E‐02 2.57878136 2.10E‐02 2.57878136 0.0% ESP 

2103 Lead 4.78E‐07 1.13E‐02 2.333333333 2.68E‐02 2.333333333 1.71E‐02 2.333333333 0.0% ESP 

2302 Lead 2.26E‐05 1.52E‐02 2.333333333 3.50E‐02 2.333333333 3.12E‐02 2.333333333 0.0% ESP 

2279 Lead 1.18E-06 5.67E‐03 2.2765 1.07E‐02 2.2765 6.62E‐03 2.2765 0.0% ESP 

2278 Lead 6.59E-07 3.93E‐02 2.144 4.95E‐02 2.144 1.31E‐02 2.144 0.0% ESP 1833 Lead 3.21E-07 5.15E‐04 0 6.55E‐03 0 6.18E‐03 0 0.0% FF 1832 Lead 2.91E-07 9.36E‐04 0 8.96E‐03 0 8.03E‐03 0 6.0% FF 

1185 Lead 6.78E-07 1.07E‐02 0 2.88E‐02 0 1.81E‐02 0 7.8% ESP‐Wet 1187 Lead 5.20E-07 1.66E‐02 0 2.92E‐02 0 1.26E‐02 0 7.8% ESP‐Wet 1989 Lead 3.93E‐06 2.84E‐02 0 3.36E‐02 0 5.16E‐03 0 0.0% ESP 

2013 Lead 4.03E‐06 5.17E‐02 0 6.35E‐02 0 3.02E‐02 0 0.0% ESP 

2161 Lead 4.97E-07 4.90E‐04 0 7.87E‐02 0 7.82E‐02 0 0.0% ESP 

736 Lead 4.29E-07 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

731 Lead 2.13E‐06 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP 

734 Lead 2.30E-06 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF 

632 Lead 6.90E-06 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP 

1449 Lead 6.81E-07 1.20E‐03 3 3 3 9.7% FF‐Dry 

565 Lead 1.07E-06 2.75E‐03 5.428571429 5.428571429 5.428571429 #N/A FF‐Dry 560 Lead 9.59E-07 3.88E‐03 5.428571429 5.428571429 5.428571429 #N/A FF‐Dry 

12861 Lead 1.47E-06 5.27E‐03 3.333333333 3.333333333 3.333333333 7.9% ESP 

10040004 Lead 3.12E‐07 7.52E‐03 0.966666667 0.966666667 0.966666667 0.0% ESP 

1004 Lead 7.02E-07 1.14E‐02 10 10 10 #N/A ESP 

550002 Lead 8.93E-06 4.91E‐02 7.666666667 7.666666667 7.666666667 0.0% FF‐Dry 

10040002 Lead 1.40E-06 5.31E‐02 8.666666667 8.666666667 8.666666667 0.0% ESP 

541 Lead 3.21E‐07 #N/A 20.03333333 #N/A 20.03333333 #N/A 20.03333333 #N/A FF‐Wet 

698 Lead 2.86E‐06 #N/A 13.53333333 #N/A 13.53333333 #N/A 13.53333333 #N/A FF‐Dry 

845 Lead 9.24E‐07 #N/A 2.377777778 #N/A 2.377777778 #N/A 2.377777778 #N/A FF 

1111 Lead 1.81E 05 - #N/A 9.462222222 9.462222222 #N/A 9.462222222 9.462222222 #N/A 9.462222222 9.462222222 #N/A ESP 1117 Lead 1.12E-06 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1117 Lead 1.12E-06 #N/A 9.525 #N/A 9.525 #N/A 9.525 #N/A ESP‐Wet 1118 Lead 4.00E-07 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A ESP‐Wet 1119 Lead 7.83E‐07 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A 4.226111111 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1647 Lead 1.01E-06 #N/A 7.8 #N/A 7.8 #N/A 7.8 0.0% FF‐Wet 

2070 Lead 9.71E-07 #N/A 9.525 #N/A 9.525 #N/A 9.525 0.0% ESP 
Regression Results ‐ Manganese Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Manganese content, Coal ash etc.

Mn, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.517897573

R Square 0.268217896

Adjusted R Square 0.262268448

Standard Error 1.298897395

Observations 125

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 76.06077927 76.06078 45.08282 6.19902E‐10

Residual 123 207.5175364 1.687134

Total 124 283.5783157

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.765067033 0.424775386 ‐22.9888 2.37E‐46 ‐10.60588385 ‐8.92425021 ‐10.60588385 ‐8.924250212

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.555190681 0.082686884 6.714374 6.2E‐10 0.391517065 0.718864296 0.391517065 0.718864296

Mn, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.453540826

R Square 0.205699281

Adjusted R Square 0.198792318

Standard Error 1.352783267

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 54.50070281 54.5007 29.78144 2.81735E‐07

Residual 115 210.4525954 1.830023

Total 116 264.9532982

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.740919019 0.517251376 ‐18.8321 6.22E‐37 ‐10.76549441 ‐8.71634363 ‐10.76549441 ‐8.716343627

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.693495306 0.127078095 5.457237 2.82E‐07 0.441778064 0.945212547 0.441778064 0.945212547

Mn, All Data w/ TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.347436932

R Square 0.120712421

Adjusted R Square 0.113066443

Standard Error 1.423315615

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 31.9831542 31.98315 15.7877 0.000124025

Residual 115 232.970144 2.025827

Total 116 264.9532982

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.15414812 0.599949578 ‐16.925 5.29E‐33 ‐11.34253273 ‐8.96576352 ‐11.34253273 ‐8.965763516

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.526081893 0.13240181 3.973374 0.000124 0.263819398 0.788344388 0.263819398 0.788344388
Regression Results ‐ Manganese Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Manganese content, Coal ash etc.

Mn, All Data w/ FPM & Mn in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.549020799

R Square 0.301423838

Adjusted R Square 0.288487242

Standard Error 1.271803269

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 75.37502387 37.68751 23.30009 3.8685E‐09

Residual 108 174.688224 1.617484

Total 110 250.0632479

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.10573724 0.635547815 ‐15.9008 4.68E‐30 ‐11.36550323 ‐8.84597125 ‐11.36550323 ‐8.845971248

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.564489562 0.083816271 6.734845 8.25E‐10 0.398351177 0.730627948 0.398351177 0.730627948

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.14030168 0.160187062 0.875861 0.383049 ‐0.177216858 0.457820218 ‐0.177216858 0.457820218

Mn, All Data w/ FPM2.5 & Mn in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.497473696

R Square 0.247480078

Adjusted R Square 0.233544524

Standard Error 1.319994303

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 61.88567217 30.94284 17.7589 2.14769E‐07

Residual 108 188.1775757 1.742385

Total 110 250.0632479

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.793209329 0.731990242 ‐13.3789 1.16E‐24 ‐11.24414093 ‐8.34227773 ‐11.24414093 ‐8.342277725

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.738235077 0.125932514 5.862148 5.04E‐08 0.488614994 0.98785516 0.488614994 0.98785516

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.073503052 0.167114083 0.439838 0.660934 ‐0.257746042 0.404752147 ‐0.257746042 0.404752147

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Mn, All Data w/ FPM, Mn in Coal & Ash content

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.549829327

R Square 0.302312289

Adjusted R Square 0.242510485

Standard Error 1.356284342

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 3 27.89743455 9.299145 5.055237 0.005156724

Residual 35 64.38275255 1.839507

Total 38 92.2801871

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.86705276 1.74104736 ‐7.39041 1.21E‐08 ‐16.40156679 ‐9.33253874 ‐16.40156679 ‐9.332538736

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.398858771 0.174379972 2.287297 0.028337 0.04484861 0.752868933 0.04484861 0.752868933

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.840022021 0.371633678 2.26035 0.030125 0.085565551 1.594478491 0.085565551 1.594478491

LN Coal ash Content (%) 0.059708082 0.084379687 0.707612 0.483872 ‐0.111591789 0.231007954 ‐0.111591789 0.231007954

SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Results ‐ Manganese Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Manganese content, Coal ash etc.

FF acid gas control ‐ Mn EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.495020396

R Square 0.245045193

Adjusted R Square 0.203103259

Standard Error 1.489504553

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 25.92456049 12.96228 5.842487 0.006347127

Residual 36 79.87045727 2.218624

Total 38 105.7950178

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.46625999 1.960544674 ‐6.35857 2.31E‐07 ‐16.44242886 ‐8.49009113 ‐16.44242886 ‐8.490091128

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.542653651 0.225139591 2.410299 0.021173 0.086049401 0.999257901 0.086049401 0.999257901

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 0.887940585 0.453673922 1.957222 0.05811 ‐0.032152767 1.808033938 ‐0.032152767 1.808033938

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Mn EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.521905971

R Square 0.272385843

Adjusted R Square 0.231962834

Standard Error 1.462284673

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 28.81706506 14.40853 6.738386 0.003267537

Residual 36 76.97795271 2.138276

Total 38 105.7950178

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐12.13203845 1.911659673 ‐6.34634 2.4E‐07 ‐16.00906394 ‐8.25501296 ‐16.00906394 ‐8.25501296

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.886119568 0.326172646 2.716719 0.010069 0.224610786 1.54762835 0.224610786 1.54762835

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ ug/g) 1.12358109 0.438564754 2.56195 0.01474 0.234130549 2.013031631 0.234130549 2.013031631
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls LN Mn E

23152 Manganese 1.88E-06 1.36E‐03 16.61 4.37E‐03 16.61 3.01E‐03 16.61 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐13.1842

23153 Manganese 1.98E-06 3.21E‐03 16.61 6.28E‐03 16.61 3.07E‐03 16.61 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐13.132423151 Manganese 2.92E-06 4.68E‐03 16.61 8.80E‐03 16.61 4.12E‐03 16.61 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐12.7439

1307 Manganese 3.67E-04 2.76E‐03 35.67 6.12E‐03 35.67 3.36E‐03 35.67 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐7.91014

1327 Manganese 2.28E-05 4.57E‐03 35.67 6.98E‐03 35.67 2.41E‐03 35.67 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐10.6887

1176 Manganese 3.37E-06 2.56E‐02 16.73 3.12E‐02 16.73 5.56E‐03 16.73 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐12.600

1515 Manganese 6.23E‐07 2.72E‐03 10.83 5.35E‐03 10.83 2.63E‐03 10.83 9.7% FF‐Wet ‐14.2887

1648 Manganese 8.95E-07 2.92E‐03 40.60 6.66E‐03 40.60 3.74E‐03 40.60 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐13.9264

2315 Manganese 4.77E-06 3.77E‐03 16.61 8.16E‐03 16.61 4.39E‐03 16.61 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐12.2532259 Manganese 4.52E-06 3.33E‐03 15.67 7.36E‐03 15.67 4.03E‐03 15.67 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐12.302319 Manganese 1.60E‐06 3.50E‐03 14.00 5.22E‐03 14.00 5.22E‐03 14.00 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐13.3455

1972 Manganese 2.59E-07 1.92E‐03 12.64 4.32E‐03 12.64 3.44E‐03 12.64 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐15.1664

13461 Manganese 8.00E‐07 8.45E‐03 12.72 1.05E‐02 12.72 5.41E‐03 12.72 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐14.0386

1346111 Manganese 1.19E‐06 2.71E‐02 12.72 2.91E‐02 12.72 6.51E‐03 12.72 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.6415

134611 Manganese 1.45E‐06 3.57E‐02 12.72 3.79E‐02 12.72 4.71E‐03 12.72 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.4439

1398 Manganese Manganese 1 27E 06 1.27E-06 1 10E . ‐03 17 33 . 8 82E . ‐03 17 33 . 8 46E . ‐03 17 33 . 7 6%. FF‐Dry ‐13 5764

13.5764

1349 Manganese 2.86E‐06 2.35E‐03 14.67 4.47E‐03 14.67 2.12E‐03 14.67 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐12.7646

1346 Manganese 7.90E‐07 1.08E‐02 12.72 1.30E‐02 12.72 4.27E‐03 12.72 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐14.0512

1249 Manganese 2.38E‐05 3.62E‐03 12.33 3.20E‐02 12.33 2.91E‐02 12.33 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐10.6458

1133 Manganese 3.04E‐06 5.86E‐04 12.10 2.78E‐02 12.10 2.75E‐02 12.10 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐12.7033

1563 Manganese 2.68E-06 3.68E‐03 47.45 1.11E‐02 47.45 1.12E‐02 47.45 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐12.8296

1563 Manganese 2.12E-06 3.68E‐03 47.45 1.11E‐02 47.45 1.12E‐02 47.45 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐13.06401563 Manganese 1.59E-06 3.68E‐03 47.45 1.11E‐02 47.45 1.12E‐02 47.45 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐13.35171568 Manganese 2.67E‐06 5.61E‐03 14.57 1.13E‐02 14.57 8.21E‐03 14.57 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐12.8334

1488 Manganese 3.81E‐07 8.28E‐04 11.33 2.05E‐02 11.33 1.96E‐02 11.33 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐14.7804

1507 Manganese 1.80E‐07 6.86E‐04 7.42 4.51E‐03 7.42 4.14E‐03 7.42 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐15.5303

1052 Manganese 4.01E‐06 1.10E‐02 36.67 2.30E‐02 36.67 1.48E‐02 36.67 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐12.4267

1129 Manganese 1.39E‐06 8.05E‐04 12.10 3.73E‐03 12.10 3.32E‐03 12.10 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐13.4859

947 Manganese 4.65E‐07 2.28E‐03 4.33 1.64E‐02 4.33 1.43E‐02 4.33 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐14.5812

1942 Manganese 8.48E‐07 3.56E‐03 39.77 6.18E‐03 39.77 2.64E‐03 39.77 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.9803

1611 Manganese 1.48E-07 2.11E‐03 21.70 6.85E‐03 21.70 5.05E‐03 21.70 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐15.7260

2022 Manganese 8.42E‐05 1.94E‐02 20.66 2.84E‐02 20.66 2.40E‐02 20.66 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐9.3823

8761 Manganese 1.46E-05 4.48E‐03 15.50 1.18E‐02 15.50 9.88E‐03 15.50 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐11.1344

8761 Manganese 1.79E-06 4.48E‐03 15.50 1.18E‐02 15.50 9.88E‐03 15.50 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐13.23322206 Manganese 6.55E‐06 4.51E‐03 15.00 1.35E‐02 15.00 9.53E‐03 15.00 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐11.9360

2021 Manganese 3.72E‐05 2.14E‐02 14.19 4.06E‐02 14.19 2.88E‐02 14.19 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐10.199

1938 Manganese 7.77E‐06 2.09E‐02 14.00 3.56E‐02 14.00 3.14E‐02 14.00 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐11.7648

1726 Manganese 3.88E-07 4.50E‐04 11.54 3.83E‐03 11.54 3.66E‐03 11.54 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐14.7622

1909 Manganese 2.10E‐07 1.39E‐03 7.42 4.65E‐03 7.42 4.41E‐03 7.42 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐15.376
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls LN Mn E

524 Manganese 1.75E‐06 1.08E‐02 139.00 1.78E‐02 139.00 1.06E‐02 139.00 #N/A FF ‐13.2558

879456 Manganese 2.21E‐05 4.53E‐02 37.11 7.74E‐02 37.11 8.49E‐02 37.11 0.0% FF ‐10.7199

63254 Manganese 7.05E-06 1.40E‐02 18.33 2.57E‐02 18.33 1.42E‐02 18.33 0.0% FF ‐11.8624

1832 Manganese 8.68E-07 9.36E‐04 22.00 8.96E‐03 22.00 8.03E‐03 22.00 6.0% FF ‐13.95701597 Manganese 1.03E-06 4.18E‐03 14.42 9.93E‐03 14.42 7.35E‐03 14.42 6.6% FF ‐13.7859

1310 Manganese 2.06E‐05 4.38E‐02 35.33 4.76E‐02 35.33 1.16E‐02 35.33 7.8% FF ‐10.7902

1244 Manganese 5.41E-05 7.40E‐03 13.13 2.45E‐02 13.13 1.97E‐02 13.13 7.8% FF ‐9.82467

1189 Manganese 2.52E-07 4.69E‐04 8.70 3.08E‐03 8.70 3.85E‐03 8.70 7.8% FF ‐15.19381190 Manganese 6.52E-07 4.09E‐03 8.70 7.49E‐03 8.70 4.52E‐03 8.70 7.8% FF ‐14.2432

735 Manganese 6.62E-05 2.43E‐03 13.13 1.42E‐02 13.13 1.28E‐02 13.13 #N/A FF ‐9.6228

1654 Manganese 2.75E‐06 9.10E‐03 40.80 2.40E‐02 40.80 2.00E‐02 40.80 0.0% FF ‐12.8039

1833 Manganese 8.78E-07 5.15E‐04 22.00 6.55E‐03 22.00 6.18E‐03 22.00 0.0% FF ‐13.9456

1606 Manganese 2.09E-06 6.64E‐03 21.70 1.52E‐02 21.70 9.55E‐03 21.70 0.0% FF ‐13.07832170 Manganese 3.66E‐07 7.21E‐04 16.00 5.49E‐03 16.00 4.90E‐03 16.00 0.0% FF ‐14.8198

1835 Manganese 4.11E‐07 8.07E‐04 16.00 2.03E‐02 16.00 1.99E‐02 16.00 0.0% FF ‐14.7054

1841 Manganese 1 83E 06 1.83E-06 1 34E . ‐03 14 00 . 7 28E . ‐03 14 00 . 6 54E . ‐03 14 00 . 0 0%. FF ‐13 211

13.211

2088 Manganese 4.37E‐06 3.91E‐03 12.72 1.02E‐02 12.72 1.31E‐02 12.72 0.0% FF ‐12.3407

2095 Manganese 1.74E-06 9.09E‐05 1.99 3.61E‐03 1.99 3.53E‐03 1.99 0.0% FF ‐13.2616

18261 Manganese 1.47E-06 1.13E‐02 19.67 2.42E‐02 19.67 1.29E‐02 19.67 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.4302

1330 Manganese 2.24E-06 1.47E‐02 46.33 4.10E‐02 46.33 2.63E‐02 46.33 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐13.00901276 Manganese 2.11E‐06 4.69E‐02 21.04 5.95E‐02 21.04 1.26E‐02 21.04 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐13.0688

1177 Manganese 4.55E-06 2.11E‐02 16.83 8.02E‐02 16.83 6.02E‐02 16.83 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐12.3003

1120 Manganese 3.15E-05 3.23E‐02 25.13 3.42E‐02 25.13 1.95E‐03 25.13 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐10.3655

900 Manganese 2.48E‐06 4.11E‐03 24.63 7.82E‐03 24.63 3.71E‐03 24.63 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐12.9072

966 Manganese 1.10E‐05 1.84E‐02 15.70 2.61E‐02 15.70 7.67E‐03 15.70 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11.4176

1743 Manganese 2.37E‐06 3.59E‐03 36.70 9.89E‐03 36.70 6.30E‐03 36.70 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.9526

1738 Manganese 7.30E‐06 3.02E‐03 36.70 1.22E‐02 36.70 9.20E‐03 36.70 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐11.8276

1826 Manganese 1.19E-06 2.57E‐02 19.67 4.30E‐02 19.67 1.73E‐02 19.67 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.6415

1915 Manganese 1.09E-06 3.35E‐03 17.30 1.86E‐02 17.30 1.89E‐02 17.30 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.7293

2055 Manganese 3.03E-06 8.72E‐03 16.67 2.83E‐02 16.67 1.96E‐02 16.67 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐12.7069

1638 Manganese 1.31E‐04 3.83E‐03 15.83 1.38E‐02 15.83 9.93E‐03 15.83 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐8.9403

1637 Manganese 4.97E‐05 5.86E‐03 15.83 1.67E‐02 15.83 1.08E‐02 15.83 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐9.90950

2239 Manganese 9.22E-07 3.27E‐03 9.97 6.41E‐03 9.97 3.14E‐03 9.97 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐13.8967

1734 Manganese 3.34E‐06 5.47E‐03 13.50 1.14E‐02 13.50 1.01E‐02 13.50 0.0% Esp‐Dry ‐12.6107

1735 Manganese 5.11E‐06 2.01E‐02 13.50 2.73E‐02 13.50 2.06E‐02 13.50 0.0% Esp‐Dry ‐12.1850

21351 Manganese 1.47E-06 1.13E‐02 17.30 5.06E‐02 17.30 6.15E‐02 17.30 0.0% ESP ‐13.4302

22791 Manganese 2.95E-06 5.55E‐03 5.39 1.69E‐02 5.39 1.19E‐02 5.39 0.0% ESP ‐12.734

1141 Manganese 2.64E-05 8.12E‐02 14.76 8.30E‐02 14.76 2.27E‐02 14.76 7.8% ESP ‐10.5421154 Manganese 4.54E-06 3.19E‐02 7.71 3.67E‐02 7.71 1.64E‐02 7.71 7.8% ESP ‐12.3025
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls LN Mn E

1471 Manganese 1.36E-05 1.33E‐02 40.83 1.82E‐02 40.83 9.36E‐03 40.83 9.7% ESP ‐11.2054

1113 Manganese 1.17E-05 9.95E‐03 27.19 7.65E‐02 27.19 7.82E‐02 27.19 #N/A ESP ‐11.3559

902 Manganese 5.35E-06 2.84E‐02 21.80 6.76E‐02 21.80 5.29E‐02 21.80 #N/A ESP ‐12.1384

903 Manganese 1.33E-05 1.05E‐01 21.80 1.50E‐01 21.80 8.72E‐02 21.80 #N/A ESP ‐11.2277828 Manganese 2.18E-05 1.00E‐01 16.83 1.70E‐01 16.83 1.05E‐01 16.83 #N/A ESP ‐10.733

979 Manganese 1.29E-05 4.02E‐02 14.61 1.02E‐01 14.61 6.83E‐02 14.61 #N/A ESP ‐11.2582

894 Manganese 2.27E-06 9.20E‐03 12.67 2.87E‐02 12.67 2.32E‐02 12.67 #N/A ESP ‐12.9957892 Manganese 7.75E-06 1.29E‐01 10.33 1.36E‐01 10.33 3.90E‐02 10.33 #N/A ESP ‐11.7678993 Manganese 5.92E-06 1.29E‐02 9.72 2.57E‐02 9.72 2.55E‐02 9.72 #N/A ESP ‐12.037

1021 Manganese 1.09E-06 1.30E‐03 7.25 7.07E‐03 7.25 7.27E‐03 7.25 #N/A ESP ‐13.7290

975 Manganese 1.21E-05 1.47E‐01 0.85 1.71E‐01 0.85 5.15E‐02 0.85 #N/A ESP ‐11.3223

2161 Manganese 6.88E-07 4.90E‐04 576.27 7.87E‐02 576.27 7.82E‐02 576.27 0.0% ESP ‐14.1894

1906 Manganese 4.70E‐06 2.19E‐02 55.67 5.83E‐02 55.67 4.06E‐02 55.67 0.0% ESP ‐12.2679

2011 Manganese 5.91E-06 2.88E‐02 43.67 3.42E‐02 43.67 1.81E‐02 43.67 0.0% ESP ‐12.0388

1636 Manganese 3.08E‐05 1.10E‐01 24.29 2.01E‐01 24.29 1.46E‐01 24.29 0.0% ESP ‐10.38

1989 Manganese 1 17E . ‐05 2 84E . ‐02 20 67 . 3 36E . ‐02 20 67 . 5 16E . ‐03 20 67 . 0 0%. ESP ‐11 3559

11.3559

2013 Manganese 1.59E‐05 5.17E‐02 17.67 6.35E‐02 17.67 3.02E‐02 17.67 0.0% ESP ‐11.049

2135 Manganese 3.83E-05 1.94E‐02 17.30 4.55E‐02 17.30 4.06E‐02 17.30 0.0% ESP ‐10.1700

1854 Manganese 8.86E-06 5.59E‐03 16.83 1.64E‐02 16.83 1.32E‐02 16.83 0.0% ESP ‐11.63391845 Manganese 1.90E-05 6.45E‐02 16.83 1.68E‐01 16.83 1.41E‐01 16.83 0.0% ESP ‐10.87101809 Manganese 9.16E-06 3.32E‐02 15.90 9.11E‐02 15.90 5.79E‐02 15.90 0.0% ESP ‐11.60061642 Manganese 6.54E‐06 1.11E‐02 15.33 1.41E‐02 15.33 1.10E‐02 15.33 0.0% ESP ‐11.9375

2195 Manganese 2.88E-06 1.66E‐03 13.46 7.50E‐03 13.46 6.84E‐03 13.46 0.0% ESP ‐12.7577

2103 Manganese 7.34E‐07 1.13E‐02 13.33 2.68E‐02 13.33 1.71E‐02 13.33 0.0% ESP ‐14.1247

1902 Manganese 2.19E-06 9.12E‐03 12.28 1.53E‐02 12.28 1.20E‐02 12.28 0.0% ESP ‐13.0316

2302 Manganese 2.99E‐06 1.52E‐02 9.00 3.50E‐02 9.00 3.12E‐02 9.00 0.0% ESP ‐12.7202

2278 Manganese 1.07E-05 3.93E‐02 8.53 4.95E‐02 8.53 1.31E‐02 8.53 0.0% ESP ‐11.4452

2274 Manganese 4.84E-06 1.14E‐02 8.37 2.96E‐02 8.37 2.20E‐02 8.37 0.0% ESP ‐12.238

2276 Manganese 2.85E-05 2.40E‐02 8.37 4.42E‐02 8.37 2.92E‐02 8.37 0.0% ESP ‐10.46562009 Manganese 1.12E-05 5.88E‐02 7.71 6.33E‐02 7.71 2.10E‐02 7.71 0.0% ESP ‐11.3993197 Manganese 1.48E-06 4.15E‐03 6.44 6.54E‐03 6.44 4.16E‐03 6.44 0.0% ESP ‐13.4234

2279 Manganese 5.69E-06 5.67E‐03 5.39 1.07E‐02 5.39 6.62E‐03 5.39 0.0% ESP ‐12.07701558 Manganese 1.70E‐05 2.41E‐02 106.36 2.69E‐02 106.36 2.88E‐03 106.36 9.7% Wet ‐10.982

1185 Manganese 1.04E-06 1.07E‐02 0.00 2.88E‐02 0.00 1.81E‐02 0.00 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐13.7762

1187 Manganese 1.05E-06 1.66E‐02 0.00 2.92E‐02 0.00 1.26E‐02 0.00 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐13.7667

736 Manganese 2.53E-05 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF ‐10.5847

731 Manganese 3.10E‐05 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐10.3823

734 Manganese 2.34E-05 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF ‐10.6627

632 Manganese 2.46E-06 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐12.9153
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - ug/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls LN Mn E

1449 Manganese 1.26E-06 1.20E‐03 19.00 19.00 19.00 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐13.584

565 Manganese 4.78E-07 2.75E‐03 7.00 7.00 7.00 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐14.5536

560 Manganese 5.35E-07 3.88E‐03 7.00 7.00 7.00 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐14.44

12861 Manganese 2.36E-06 5.27E‐03 10.00 10.00 10.00 7.9% ESP ‐12.9568

10040004 Manganese 2.37E‐06 7.52E‐03 3.77 3.77 3.77 0.0% ESP ‐12.9526

1004 Manganese 2.18E-06 1.14E‐02 17.67 17.67 17.67 #N/A ESP ‐13.036

550002 Manganese 7.11E-05 4.91E‐02 28.33 28.33 28.33 0.0% Esp‐Dry ‐9.55142

10040002 Manganese 4.44E-06 5.31E‐02 48.33 48.33 48.33 0.0% ESP ‐12.3248

541 Manganese 6.22E‐06 #N/A 48.33 #N/A 48.33 #N/A 48.33 #N/A FF‐Wet ‐11.9877

698 Manganese 3.70E‐06 #N/A 23.67 #N/A 23.67 #N/A 23.67 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐12.507

845 Manganese 2.31E‐06 #N/A 10.70 #N/A 10.70 #N/A 10.70 #N/A FF ‐12.9782

1111 Manganese 3.25E-05 #N/A 27.19 #N/A 27.19 #N/A 27.19 #N/A ESP ‐10.3342

1117 Manganese 1.30E-05 #N/A 15.86 #N/A 15.86 #N/A 15.86 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11.2505

1117 Manganese 1.30E-05 #N/A 16.83 #N/A 16.83 #N/A 16.83 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11.25051118 Manganese 1.75E-06 #N/A 15.86 #N/A 15.86 #N/A 15.86 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐13.2558

1119 Manganese 9 27E . ‐06 #N/A 15 86 . #N/A 15 86 . #N/A 15 86 . #N/A ESP‐W t e ‐11 5887

11.5887

1647 Manganese 2.59E-06 #N/A 40.60 #N/A 40.60 #N/A 40.60 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐12.8638

2070 Manganese 2.01E-05 #N/A 16.83 #N/A 16.83 #N/A 16.83 0.0% ESP ‐10.8147
Regression Results ‐ Nickel Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Nickel content, Coal ash etc.

Ni, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.42410206

R Square 0.179862558

Adjusted R Square 0.173194773

Standard Error 1.598502

Observations 125

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 68.92640134 68.9264 26.97486 8.28016E‐07

Residual 123 314.2906633 2.555209

Total 124 383.2170647

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.899923594 0.522754382 ‐18.938 2.89E‐38 ‐10.93468383 ‐8.865163362 ‐10.93468383 ‐8.865163362

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.528511674 0.1017595 5.193733 8.28E‐07 0.327084985 0.729938363 0.327084985 0.729938363

Ni, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.408105709

R Square 0.16655027

Adjusted R Square 0.159302881

Standard Error 1.585420478

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 57.7633932 57.76339 22.98073 4.93743E‐06

Residual 115 289.0591806 2.513558

Total 116 346.8225738

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.682499196 0.60620274 ‐15.9724 5.76E‐31 ‐10.88327012 ‐8.481728277 ‐10.88327012 ‐8.481728277

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.713951685 0.148931628 4.793822 4.94E‐06 0.418946802 1.008956568 0.418946802 1.008956568

Ni, All Data w/ TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.365276688

R Square 0.133427059

Adjusted R Square 0.125891642

Standard Error 1.616617666

Observations 117

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 46.27551586 46.27552 17.70666 5.13274E‐05

Residual 115 300.547058 2.613453

Total 116 346.8225738

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.704714963 0.681429387 ‐14.2417 3.8E‐27 ‐11.05449539 ‐8.35493454 ‐11.05449539 ‐8.35493454

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.632802728 0.150383445 4.207928 5.13E‐05 0.334922076 0.930683379 0.334922076 0.930683379
Regression Results ‐ Nickel Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Nickel content, Coal ash etc.

Ni, All Data w/ FPM & Ni in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.487881814

R Square 0.238028664

Adjusted R Square 0.223918084

Standard Error 1.435273786

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 69.49985302 34.74993 16.86881 4.21392E‐07

Residual 108 222.4811709 2.060011

Total 110 291.9810239

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.855697379 0.592504923 ‐16.634 1.46E‐31 ‐11.03014489 ‐8.681249866 ‐11.03014489 ‐8.681249866

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.550829044 0.09488364 5.805311 6.53E‐08 0.362753215 0.738904873 0.362753215 0.738904873

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) ‐0.03629171 0.141579768 ‐0.25633 0.798181 ‐0.316927364 0.244343943 ‐0.316927364 0.244343943

Ni, All Data w/ TPM & Ni in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.495267377

R Square 0.245289775

Adjusted R Square 0.23131366

Standard Error 1.428418785

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 71.61995967 35.80998 17.55064 2.51265E‐07

Residual 108 220.3610642 2.04038

Total 110 291.9810239

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.234618297 0.67272712 ‐13.7271 2E‐25 ‐10.56808012 ‐7.901156478 ‐10.56808012 ‐7.901156478

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.812706176 0.137245119 5.921567 3.84E‐08 0.540662549 1.084749803 0.540662549 1.084749803

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) ‐0.099246819 0.142090961 ‐0.69847 0.486382 ‐0.380895745 0.182402107 ‐0.380895745 0.182402107

Ni, All Data w/ TPM2.5 & Ni in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.427438988

R Square 0.182704089

Adjusted R Square 0.167568979

Standard Error 1.486466407

Observations 111

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 53.34612687 26.67306 12.07154 1.8556E‐05

Residual 108 238.634897 2.209582

Total 110 291.9810239

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.281430407 0.777333559 ‐11.9401 1.85E‐21 ‐10.82224033 ‐7.740620484 ‐10.82224033 ‐7.740620484

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 0.702176689 0.143005243 4.910146 3.25E‐06 0.418715497 0.985637882 0.418715497 0.985637882

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) ‐0.121384731 0.149278696 ‐0.81314 0.417926 ‐0.417280995 0.174511534 ‐0.417280995 0.174511534
Regression Results ‐ Nickel Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Nickel content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Ni EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.471051472

R Square 0.221889489

Adjusted R Square 0.178661127

Standard Error 1.254580026

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 16.15826352 8.079132 5.132961 0.010933094

Residual 36 56.66295748 1.573971

Total 38 72.821221

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.845078214 1.158179391 ‐8.50048 3.95E‐10 ‐12.19397487 ‐7.496181556 ‐12.19397487 ‐7.496181556

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.597588004 0.186720359 3.200444 0.002864 0.218901567 0.976274441 0.218901567 0.976274441

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) 0.008483062 0.19189931 0.044206 0.964985 ‐0.380706775 0.397672899 ‐0.380706775 0.397672899

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Ni EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.325994045

R Square 0.106272118

Adjusted R Square 0.056620569

Standard Error 1.344560602

Observations 39

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 7.738865362 3.869433 2.140359 0.132341341

Residual 36 65 08235564 65.08235564 1 807843 1.807843

Total 38 72.821221

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐10.38876913 1.466235954 ‐7.08533 2.54E‐08 ‐13.36243345 ‐7.415104808 ‐13.36243345 ‐7.415104808

LN TPM #/mmBtu 0.618916452 0.29984413 2.064127 0.046269 0.010804375 1.227028529 0.010804375 1.227028529

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) 0.017552598 0.205622927 0.085363 0.932446 ‐0.399470024 0.43457522 ‐0.399470024 0.43457522
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls L

23152 Nickel 2.36E-06 1.36E‐03 2.453 4.37E‐03 2.453 3.01E‐03 2.453 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

23153 Nickel 1.77E-06 3.21E‐03 2.453 6.28E‐03 2.453 3.07E‐03 2.453 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐123151 Nickel 2.55E-06 4.68E‐03 2.453 8.80E‐03 2.453 4.12E‐03 2.453 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

1176 Nickel 1.47E-05 2.56E‐02 10.082 3.12E‐02 10.082 5.56E‐03 10.082 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐11307 Nickel 1.41E-04 2.76E‐03 4.000 6.12E‐03 4.000 3.36E‐03 4.000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐81327 Nickel 1.83E-06 4.57E‐03 4.000 6.98E‐03 4.000 2.41E‐03 4.000 7.8% FF‐Wet ‐11515 Nickel 7.88E‐07 2.72E‐03 4.200 5.35E‐03 4.200 2.63E‐03 4.200 9.7% FF‐Wet ‐1

2259 Nickel 1.88E-06 3.33E‐03 13.667 7.36E‐03 13.667 4.03E‐03 13.667 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

2319 Nickel 1.79E‐06 3.50E‐03 12.000 5.22E‐03 12.000 5.22E‐03 12.000 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

1972 Nickel 3.97E-07 1.92E‐03 6.636 4.32E‐03 6.636 3.44E‐03 6.636 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

1648 Nickel 3.76E-07 2.92E‐03 4.400 6.66E‐03 4.400 3.74E‐03 4.400 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

2315 Nickel 2.99E-06 3.77E‐03 2.453 8.16E‐03 2.453 4.39E‐03 2.453 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

13461 Nickel 3.14E‐06 8.45E‐03 13.500 1.05E‐02 13.500 5.41E‐03 13.500 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

1346111 Nickel 1.70E‐06 2.71E‐02 13.500 2.91E‐02 13.500 6.51E‐03 13.500 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

134611 Nickel 2.51E‐06 3.57E‐02 13.500 3.79E‐02 13.500 4.71E‐03 13.500 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

1398 Nick l e 1 02E 06 1.02E-06 1.10E‐03 5.222 8.82E‐03 5.222 8.46E‐03 5.222 7.6% FF‐Dry ‐11349 Nickel 1.26E‐06 2.35E‐03 15.333 4.47E‐03 15.333 2.12E‐03 15.333 7.8% FF‐Dry 

1249 Nickel 7.76E‐07 3.62E‐03 14.000 3.20E‐02 14.000 2.91E‐02 14.000 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1

1346 Nickel 9.48E‐07 1.08E‐02 13.500 1.30E‐02 13.500 4.27E‐03 13.500 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1

1133 Nickel 1.61E‐06 5.86E‐04 4.833 2.78E‐02 4.833 2.75E‐02 4.833 7.8% FF‐Dry ‐1

1507 Nickel 2.24E‐07 6.86E‐04 316.791 4.51E‐03 316.791 4.14E‐03 316.791 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1

1563 Nickel 4.23E-06 3.68E‐03 18.736 1.11E‐02 18.736 1.12E‐02 18.736 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1

1563 Nickel 4.25E-06 3.68E‐03 18.736 1.11E‐02 18.736 1.12E‐02 18.736 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐11563 Nickel 1.32E-06 3.68E‐03 18.736 1.11E‐02 18.736 1.12E‐02 18.736 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐11488 Nickel 6.58E‐07 8.28E‐04 5.333 2.05E‐02 5.333 1.96E‐02 5.333 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1

1568 Nickel 1.78E‐06 5.61E‐03 4.714 1.13E‐02 4.714 8.21E‐03 4.714 9.7% FF‐Dry 

1052 Nickel 3.35E‐06 1.10E‐02 12.667 2.30E‐02 12.667 1.48E‐02 12.667 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1

947 Nickel 2.88E‐07 2.28E‐03 5.000 1.64E‐02 5.000 1.43E‐02 5.000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1

1129 Nickel 8.04E‐07 8.05E‐04 4.833 3.73E‐03 4.833 3.32E‐03 4.833 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1

1909 Nickel 3.25E‐06 1.39E‐03 316.791 4.65E‐03 316.791 4.41E‐03 316.791 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

2022 Nickel 3.41E‐05 1.94E‐02 26.938 2.84E‐02 26.938 2.40E‐02 26.938 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

8761 Nickel 7.67E-06 4.48E‐03 15.333 1.18E‐02 15.333 9.88E‐03 15.333 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

8761 Nickel 7.68E-06 4.48E‐03 15.333 1.18E‐02 15.333 9.88E‐03 15.333 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐12021 Nickel 9.72E‐06 2.14E‐02 12.810 4.06E‐02 12.810 2.88E‐02 12.810 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

1611 Nickel 1 20E . 07 - 2 11E . ‐03 8 832 . 6 85E . ‐03 8 832 . 5 05E . ‐03 8 832 . 0 0%. FF‐Dry ‐1

1

1938 Nickel 1.99E‐06 2.09E‐02 5.667 3.56E‐02 5.667 3.14E‐02 5.667 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

1942 Nickel 5.56E‐07 3.56E‐03 5.450 6.18E‐03 5.450 2.64E‐03 5.450 0.0% FF‐Dry 

1726 Nickel 3.13E-07 4.50E‐04 5.364 3.83E‐03 5.364 3.66E‐03 5.364 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1

2206 Nickel 8.82E‐06 4.51E‐03 5.000 1.35E‐02 5.000 9.53E‐03 5.000 0.0% FF‐Dry ‐1
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls L

63254 Nickel 1.81E-05 1.40E‐02 12.333 2.57E‐02 12.333 1.42E‐02 12.333 0.0% FF 

879456 Nickel 1.46E‐05 4.53E‐02 6.556 7.74E‐02 6.556 8.49E‐02 6.556 0.0% FF ‐1

1832 Nickel 7.32E-07 9.36E‐04 3.000 8.96E‐03 3.000 8.03E‐03 3.000 6.0% FF ‐1

1597 Nickel 5.70E-07 4.18E‐03 4.073 9.93E‐03 4.073 7.35E‐03 4.073 6.6% FF ‐1

1310 Nickel 3.73E‐05 4.38E‐02 7.333 4.76E‐02 7.333 1.16E‐02 7.333 7.8% FF ‐1

1244 Nickel 2.25E-04 7.40E‐03 3.883 2.45E‐02 3.883 1.97E‐02 3.883 7.8% FF 

1189 Nickel 1.54E-07 4.69E‐04 2.880 3.08E‐03 2.880 3.85E‐03 2.880 7.8% FF ‐1

1190 Nickel 3.25E-07 4.09E‐03 2.880 7.49E‐03 2.880 4.52E‐03 2.880 7.8% FF ‐1

524 Nickel 1.39E‐06 1.08E‐02 47.433 1.78E‐02 47.433 1.06E‐02 47.433 #N/A FF ‐1

735 Nickel 3.02E-04 2.43E‐03 3.883 1.42E‐02 3.883 1.28E‐02 3.883 #N/A FF ‐8

2095 Nickel 2.93E-06 9.09E‐05 134.090 3.61E‐03 134.090 3.53E‐03 134.090 0.0% FF ‐11654 Nickel 7.21E‐07 9.10E‐03 20.400 2.40E‐02 20.400 2.00E‐02 20.400 0.0% FF ‐1

2088 Nickel 2.64E‐06 3.91E‐03 13.500 1.02E‐02 13.500 1.31E‐02 13.500 0.0% FF ‐1

1606 Nickel 3.91E-06 6.64E‐03 8.832 1.52E‐02 8.832 9.55E‐03 8.832 0.0% FF ‐1

1841 Nickel 4.39E-06 1.34E‐03 5.667 7.28E‐03 5.667 6.54E‐03 5.667 0.0% FF ‐12170 Nickel 3.01E‐07 7.21E‐04 3.167 5.49E‐03 3.167 4.90E‐03 3.167 0.0% FF ‐1

1835 Nickel 4.85E‐07 8.07E‐04 3.167 2.03E‐02 3.167 1.99E‐02 3.167 0.0% FF ‐1

1833 Nickel 9.99E-07 5.15E‐04 3.000 6.55E‐03 3.000 6.18E‐03 3.000 0.0% FF ‐1

18261 Nickel 2.41E-06 1.13E‐02 24.167 2.42E‐02 24.167 1.29E‐02 24.167 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1

1330 Nickel 2.75E-06 1.47E‐02 46.500 4.10E‐02 46.500 2.63E‐02 46.500 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐11276 Nickel 2.16E‐07 4.69E‐02 37.303 5.95E‐02 37.303 1.26E‐02 37.303 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1

1177 Nickel 5.97E-06 2.11E‐02 18.583 8.02E‐02 18.583 6.02E‐02 18.583 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1

1185 Nickel 9.10E-06 1.07E‐02 16.617 2.88E‐02 16.617 1.81E‐02 16.617 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐11187 Nickel 4.14E-06 1.66E‐02 16.617 2.92E‐02 16.617 1.26E‐02 16.617 7.8% ESP‐Wet ‐1

900 Nickel 4.19E‐06 4.11E‐03 11.153 7.82E‐03 11.153 3.71E‐03 11.153 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1

966 Nickel 6.27E‐06 1.84E‐02 8.165 2.61E‐02 8.165 7.67E‐03 8.165 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1

1120 Nickel 6.43E-06 3.23E‐02 7.173 3.42E‐02 7.173 1.95E‐03 7.173 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1

1826 Nickel 1.30E-06 2.57E‐02 24.167 4.30E‐02 24.167 1.73E‐02 24.167 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐11638 Nickel 9.93E‐07 3.83E‐03 20.383 1.38E‐02 20.383 9.93E‐03 20.383 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1

1637 Nickel 1.06E‐06 5.86E‐03 20.383 1.67E‐02 20.383 1.08E‐02 20.383 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1

2055 Nickel 5.30E-06 8.72E‐03 8.853 2.83E‐02 8.853 1.96E‐02 8.853 0.0% ESP‐Wet 

1915 Nickel 2.92E-07 3.35E‐03 6.313 1.86E‐02 6.313 1.89E‐02 6.313 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1

2239 Nickel 7.62E-07 3.27E‐03 3.100 6.41E‐03 3.100 3.14E‐03 3.100 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐11734 Nickel 9.12E‐07 5.47E‐03 4.333 1.14E‐02 4.333 1.01E‐02 4.333 0.0% ESP_Dry ‐1

1735 Nickel 1 69E . ‐06 2 01E . ‐02 4 333 . 2 73E . ‐02 4 333 . 2 06E . ‐02 4 333 . 0 0%. ESP Dry ESP_Dry 

21351 Nickel 2.41E-06 1.13E‐02 6.313 5.06E‐02 6.313 6.15E‐02 6.313 0.0% ESP ‐1

22791 Nickel 9.43E-06 5.55E‐03 3.673 1.69E‐02 3.673 1.19E‐02 3.673 0.0% ESP ‐1

1154 Nickel 1.83E-06 3.19E‐02 3.857 3.67E‐02 3.857 1.64E‐02 3.857 7.8% ESP ‐11141 Nickel 3.17E-06 8.12E‐02 1.663 8.30E‐02 1.663 2.27E‐02 1.663 7.8% ESP ‐1
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls L

1471 Nickel 3.70E-07 1.33E‐02 17.800 1.82E‐02 17.800 9.36E‐03 17.800 9.7% ESP ‐1

975 Nickel 7.61E-05 1.47E‐01 19.643 1.71E‐01 19.643 5.15E‐02 19.643 #N/A ESP ‐9

828 Nickel 2.07E-05 1.00E‐01 18.583 1.70E‐01 18.583 1.05E‐01 18.583 #N/A ESP ‐1

1113 Nickel 3.09E-05 9.95E‐03 18.000 7.65E‐02 18.000 7.82E‐02 18.000 #N/A ESP ‐1

979 Nickel 5.32E-06 4.02E‐02 16.208 1.02E‐01 16.208 6.83E‐02 16.208 #N/A ESP ‐1993 Nickel 1.11E-05 1.29E‐02 14.103 2.57E‐02 14.103 2.55E‐02 14.103 #N/A ESP ‐1

902 Nickel 5.14E-06 2.84E‐02 12.433 6.76E‐02 12.433 5.29E‐02 12.433 #N/A ESP ‐1

903 Nickel 1.58E-05 1.05E‐01 12.433 1.50E‐01 12.433 8.72E‐02 12.433 #N/A ESP 

892 Nickel 1.47E-05 1.29E‐01 11.667 1.36E‐01 11.667 3.90E‐02 11.667 #N/A ESP ‐1

894 Nickel 2.37E-06 9.20E‐03 7.667 2.87E‐02 7.667 2.32E‐02 7.667 #N/A ESP ‐1

1021 Nickel 2.79E-06 1.30E‐03 2.950 7.07E‐03 2.950 7.27E‐03 2.950 #N/A ESP ‐11636 Nickel 1.19E‐05 1.10E‐01 64.831 2.01E‐01 64.831 1.46E‐01 64.831 0.0% ESP ‐1

1906 Nickel 4.65E‐06 2.19E‐02 21.000 5.83E‐02 21.000 4.06E‐02 21.000 0.0% ESP ‐1

1854 Nickel 2.55E-06 5.59E‐03 18.583 1.64E‐02 18.583 1.32E‐02 18.583 0.0% ESP ‐1

1845 Nickel 8.77E-05 6.45E‐02 18.583 1.68E‐01 18.583 1.41E‐01 18.583 0.0% ESP ‐9

2161 Nickel 1.09E-06 4.90E‐04 10.423 7.87E‐02 10.423 7.82E‐02 10.423 0.0% ESP ‐1

2195 Nickel 8.48E-06 1.66E‐03 10.307 7.50E‐03 10.307 6.84E‐03 10.307 0.0% ESP 

1642 Nickel 2.79E‐06 1.11E‐02 9.667 1.41E‐02 9.667 1.10E‐02 9.667 0.0% ESP ‐1

1809 Nickel 9.08E-06 3.32E‐02 6.487 9.11E‐02 6.487 5.79E‐02 6.487 0.0% ESP ‐1

2135 Nickel 2.04E-04 1.94E‐02 6.313 4.55E‐02 6.313 4.06E‐02 6.313 0.0% ESP ‐81902 Nickel 1.47E-06 9.12E‐03 5.330 1.53E‐02 5.330 1.20E‐02 5.330 0.0% ESP ‐1

2103 Nickel 1.89E‐06 1.13E‐02 5.000 2.68E‐02 5.000 1.71E‐02 5.000 0.0% ESP ‐1

1989 Nickel 5.63E‐06 2.84E‐02 4.667 3.36E‐02 4.667 5.16E‐03 4.667 0.0% ESP 

2011 Nickel 4.97E-06 2.88E‐02 4.667 3.42E‐02 4.667 1.81E‐02 4.667 0.0% ESP ‐1

2274 Nickel 2.00E-05 1.14E‐02 4.000 2.96E‐02 4.000 2.20E‐02 4.000 0.0% ESP ‐12302 Nickel 7.31E‐06 1.52E‐02 4.000 3.50E‐02 4.000 3.12E‐02 4.000 0.0% ESP ‐1

2276 Nickel 1.47E-04 2.40E‐02 4.000 4.42E‐02 4.000 2.92E‐02 4.000 0.0% ESP ‐8

2009 Nickel 3.63E-06 5.88E‐02 3.857 6.33E‐02 3.857 2.10E‐02 3.857 0.0% ESP ‐12013 Nickel 3.83E‐06 5.17E‐02 3.778 6.35E‐02 3.778 3.02E‐02 3.778 0.0% ESP ‐1

2279 Nickel 5.98E-06 5.67E‐03 3.673 1.07E‐02 3.673 6.62E‐03 3.673 0.0% ESP ‐1

2278 Nickel 1.50E-04 3.93E‐02 2.740 4.95E‐02 2.740 1.31E‐02 2.740 0.0% ESP ‐83197 Nickel 8.93E-07 4.15E‐03 1.077 6.54E‐03 1.077 4.16E‐03 1.077 0.0% ESP ‐11558 Nickel 4.41E‐06 2.41E‐02 2.000 2.69E‐02 2.000 2.88E‐03 2.000 9.7% Wet ‐1

1743 Nickel 3.60E‐05 3.59E‐03 0.000 9.89E‐03 0.000 6.30E‐03 0.000 0.0% ESP‐Wet ‐1

1738 Nickel 1 65E . ‐04 3 02E . ‐03 0 000 . 1 22E . ‐02 0 000 . 9 20E . ‐03 0 000 . 0 0%. ESP‐Wet ‐8 

8

736 Nickel 2.23E-04 3.31E‐03 9.12E‐03 7.02E‐03 #N/A FF ‐8

731 Nickel 2.22E‐05 1.12E‐02 1.39E‐02 1.12E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐1

734 Nickel 1.32E-04 2.00E‐03 1.44E‐02 1.46E‐02 #N/A FF ‐8

632 Nickel 6.35E-06 1.36E‐02 5.49E‐02 5.11E‐02 #N/A ESP ‐1
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls L

1449 Nickel 4.33E-07 1.20E‐03 4.333 4.333 4.333 9.7% FF‐Dry ‐1

565 Nickel 8.59E-07 2.75E‐03 3.000 3.000 3.000 #N/A FF‐Dry 

560 Nickel 4.74E-07 3.88E‐03 3.000 3.000 3.000 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1

12861 Nickel 4.43E-06 5.27E‐03 0.000 0.000 0.000 7.9% ESP ‐1

10040004 Nickel 2.30E‐06 7.52E‐03 2.110 2.110 2.110 0.0% ESP 

1004 Nickel 3.79E-06 1.14E‐02 15.000 15.000 15.000 #N/A ESP ‐1

550002 Nickel 5.57E-04 4.91E‐02 10.667 10.667 10.667 0.0% ESP_Dry ‐7

10040002 Nickel 3.07E-06 5.31E‐02 10.333 10.333 10.333 0.0% ESP ‐1

541 Nickel 4.36E‐05 #N/A 33.667 #N/A 33.667 #N/A 33.667 #N/A FF‐Wet ‐1

698 Nickel 5.11E‐06 #N/A 19.800 #N/A 19.800 #N/A 19.800 #N/A FF‐Dry ‐1

1117 Nickel 5.29E-06 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐1

1117 Nickel 5.29E-06 #N/A 18.583 #N/A 18.583 #N/A 18.583 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11118 Nickel 6.71E-06 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11119 Nickel 3.70E‐06 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A 8.261 #N/A ESP‐Wet ‐11111 Nickel 3.73E-04 #N/A 18.000 #N/A 18.000 #N/A 18.000 #N/A ESP ‐71647 Nickel 8.67E-07 #N/A 4.400 #N/A 4.400 #N/A 4.400 0.0% FF‐Wet ‐1

845 Nickel 9.12E‐07 #N/A 3.578 #N/A 3.578 #N/A 3.578 #N/A FF ‐1

2070 Nickel 1.25E-06 #N/A 18.583 #N/A 18.583 #N/A 18.583 0.0% ESP ‐1
Regression Results ‐ Selenium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Selenium content, Coal ash etc.

Se, All Data w/ FPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.39175846

R Square 0.153474691

Adjusted R Square 0.146535959

Standard Error 2.064261177

Observations 124

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 94.25099443 94.25099 22.11855 6.81287E‐06

Residual 122 519.8632531 4.261174

Total 123 614.1142475

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐9.215612904 0.680883301 ‐13.5348 4.74E‐26 ‐10.56348939 ‐7.867736422 ‐10.56348939 ‐7.867736422

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.632561987 0.134500768 4.703036 6.81E‐06 0.366304286 0.898819688 0.366304286 0.898819688

Se, All Data w/ TPM

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.500971984

R Square 0.250972929

Adjusted R Square 0.244402516

Standard Error 1.90562727

Observations 116

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 138.7107547 138.7108 38.19744 1.01985E‐08

Residual 114 413.9813435 3.631415

Total 115 552.6920982

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.897552675 0.727372719 ‐10.8576 2.75E‐19 ‐9.338472382 ‐6.456632968 ‐9.338472382 ‐6.456632968

LN TPM #/mmBtu 1.116239429 0.180609359 6.180407 1.02E‐08 0.758453692 1.474025166 0.758453692 1.474025166

Se, All Data w/ TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.530798269

R Square 0.281746803

Adjusted R Square 0.275446336

Standard Error 1.866070237

Observations 116

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 155.7192315 155.7192 44.7184 8.83791E‐10

Residual 114 396.9728668 3.482218

Total 115 552.6920982

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.180020789 0.778873322 ‐9.21847 1.84E‐15 ‐8.72296279 ‐5.637078787 ‐8.72296279 ‐5.637078787

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 1.15669002 0.17297122 6.687182 8.84E‐10 0.814035377 1.499344664 0.814035377 1.499344664
Regression Results ‐ Selenium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Selenium content, Coal ash etc.

Se, All Data w/ FPM & Se in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.407892414

R Square 0.166376221

Adjusted R Square 0.142558399

Standard Error 2.202146845

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 67.75038262 33.87519 6.985367 0.001713773

Residual 70 339.4615507 4.849451

Total 72 407.2119334

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.752006622 0.975003959 ‐8.97638 2.92E‐13 ‐10.69659068 ‐6.807422568 ‐10.69659068 ‐6.807422568

LN FPM #/mmBtu 0.715104197 0.191529657 3.733647 0.000381 0.333110346 1.097098048 0.333110346 1.097098048

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) 0.074314035 0.258709737 0.287249 0.774771 ‐0.441666259 0.59029433 ‐0.441666259 0.59029433

Se, All Data w/ TPM & Se in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.540945779

R Square 0.292622335

Adjusted R Square 0.272411545

Standard Error 2.028555526

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 119.159307 59.57965 14.47852 5.4676E‐06

Residual 70 288.0526264 4.115038

Total 72 407.2119334

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.265721667 0.961593067 ‐7.55592 1.2E‐10 ‐9.183558542 ‐5.347884792 ‐9.183558542 ‐5.347884792

LN TPM #/mmBtu 1.282534816 0.238485931 5.377822 9.43E‐07 0.806889631 1.75818 0.806889631 1.75818

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) 0.142156707 0.238888843 0.595075 0.553712 ‐0.334292061 0.618605475 ‐0.334292061 0.618605475

Se, All Data w/ TPM2.5 & Se in Coal

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.52658725

R Square 0.277294132

Adjusted R Square 0.256645393

Standard Error 2.050416173

Observations 73

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 112.9174796 56.45874 13.42911 1.15786E‐05

Residual 70 294.2944538 4.204206

Total 72 407.2119334

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐6.951426222 1.054379116 ‐6.59291 6.84E‐09 ‐9.054319032 ‐4.848533411 ‐9.054319032 ‐4.848533411

LN TPM2.5 #/mmBtu 1.190893264 0.229942859 5.179083 2.05E‐06 0.732286698 1.649499829 0.732286698 1.649499829

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) 0.01828056 0.24083147 0.075906 0.93971 ‐0.462042655 0.498603775 ‐0.462042655 0.498603775
Regression Results ‐ Selenium Emissions vs PM emissions, Coal Selenium content, Coal ash etc.

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Se EF vs FPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.492168815

R Square 0.242230143

Adjusted R Square 0.173341974

Standard Error 2.22440639

Observations 25

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 34.79700035 17.3985 3.516281 0.047305385

Residual 22 108.8556433 4.947984

Total 24 143.6526437

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐6.111491334 3.120944506 ‐1.95822 0.063004 ‐12.58393406 0.360951393 ‐12.58393406 0.360951393

LN FPM #/mmBtu 1.275408229 0.534615749 2.385654 0.026088 0.16668303 2.384133427 0.16668303 2.384133427

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) ‐0.554546313 0.446688901 ‐1.24146 0.22751 ‐1.48092239 0.371829764 ‐1.48092239 0.371829764

SUMMARY OUTPUT

FF acid gas control ‐ Se EF vs TPM & Metals

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.339270206

R Square 0.115104273

Adjusted R Square 0.034659206

Standard Error 2.403762303

Observations 25

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 2 16.53503305 8.267517 1.430843 0.260503211

Residual 22 127 1176106 127.1176106 5 778073 5.778073

Total 24 143.6526437

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐8.841599122 3.549737843 ‐2.49078 0.020781 ‐16.2033048 ‐1.479893446 ‐16.2033048 ‐1.479893446

LN TPM #/mmBtu 1.018445382 0.778107881 1.308874 0.204085 ‐0.595251588 2.632142353 ‐0.595251588 2.632142353

LN Metals Content (ppm ‐ u/g) ‐0.363964485 0.496371797 ‐0.73325 0.471148 ‐1.393376583 0.665447612 ‐1.393376583 0.665447612
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

1176 Selenium 2.32E-05 0.0256 1.14 0.0311575 1.14 0.0055575 1.14 0.077526667 FF‐Wet 

23152 Selenium 3.17E-07 0.00136 15.66 0.0043671 15.66 0.0030071 15.66 0.0002 FF‐Wet 

23153 Selenium 1.71E-07 0.00321 15.66 0.0062774 15.66 0.0030674 15.66 0.0002 FF‐Wet 

23151 Selenium 1.92E-07 0.00468 15.66 0.0087997 15.66 0.0041197 15.66 0.0002 FF‐Wet 

2315 Selenium 1.32E-07 0.00377 15.66 0.0081644 15.66 0.0043944 15.66 0 FF‐Wet 

2259 Selenium 1.30E-06 0.00333 2.67 0.0073568 2.67 0.0040268 2.67 0 FF‐Wet 1648 Selenium 1.31E-05 0.00292 2.00 0.0066628 2.00 0.0037428 2.00 0 FF‐Wet 2319 Selenium 9.77E‐07 0.0035 1.60 0.0052171 1.60 0.0052171 1.60 0 FF‐Wet 1972 Selenium 1.79E-07 0.00192 1.36 0.0043248 1.36 0.0034369 1.36 0 FF‐Wet 

1563 Selenium 1.13E-05 0.00368 3.39 0.0111349 3.39 0.0112487 3.39 0.0974 FF‐Dry 

1563 Selenium 7.70E-07 0.00368 3.39 0.0111349 3.39 0.0112487 3.39 0.0974 FF‐Dry 1563 Selenium 1.08E-06 0.00368 3.39 0.0111349 3.39 0.0112487 3.39 0.0974 FF‐Dry 1507 Selenium 3.01E‐07 0.000686 0.95 0.0045073 0.95 0.0041385 0.95 0.0974 FF‐Dry 

1568 Selenium 4.85E‐07 0.00561 0.87 0.0113154 0.87 0.0082123 0.87 0.0974 FF‐Dry 

1488 Selenium Selenium 7 87E . ‐08 0 000828 0.000828 0 87 . 0 020455 0.020455 0 87 . 0 019627 0.019627 0 87 . 0 0974 . FF‐Dry 1249 Selenium 1.18E‐07 0.00362 4.00 0.032005 4.00 0.0291484 4.00 0.077526667 FF‐Dry 

1349 Selenium 1.35E‐07 0.00235 3.63 0.0044662 3.63 0.0021162 3.63 0.077526667 FF‐Dry 

1398 Selenium 4.66E-07 0.0011 0.94 0.0088227 0.94 0.0084552 0.94 0.0759 FF‐Dry 

1942 Selenium 4.67E‐08 0.00356 11.39 0.0061832 11.39 0.0026369 11.39 0 FF‐Dry 8761 Selenium 3.32E-04 0.00448 3.33 0.0117981 3.33 0.009884 3.33 0 FF‐Dry 

8761 Selenium 2.39E-04 0.00448 3.33 0.0117981 3.33 0.009884 3.33 0 FF‐Dry 2206 Selenium 1.45E‐06 0.00451 1.30 0.0134565 1.30 0.009531 1.30 0 FF‐Dry 1909 Selenium 7.92E‐08 0.00139 0.95 0.0046546 0.95 0.0044114 0.95 0 FF‐Dry 

1938 Selenium 1.20E‐05 0.0209 0.73 0.0355769 0.73 0.0314346 0.73 0 FF‐Dry 

1052 Selenium 1.41E‐07 0.011 4.53 0.0230356 4.53 0.0148292 4.53 #N/A FF‐Dry 1310 Selenium 1.76E‐06 0.0438 2.00 0.0476102 2.00 0.0115676 2.00 0.077526667 FF 

1244 Selenium 1.05E-05 0.0074 0.98 0.0244778 0.98 0.0196731 0.98 0.077526667 FF 

1244 Selenium 3.88E-06 0.0074 0.98 0.0244778 0.98 0.0196731 0.98 0.077526667 FF 1190 Selenium 2.19E-07 0.00409 0.35 0.0074891 0.35 0.0045227 0.35 0.077526667 FF 

1190 Selenium 9.84E-07 0.00409 0.35 0.0074891 0.35 0.0045227 0.35 0.077526667 FF 

63254 Selenium 1.14E-05 0.014 3.00 0.0257447 3.00 0.0141581 3.00 0.0002 FF 

879456 Selenium 7.67E‐05 0.0453 2.44 0.0773692 2.44 0.0849388 2.44 0.0002 FF 

1841 Selenium 2.22E-06 0.00134 0.73 0.0072823 0.73 0.0065378 0.73 0 FF 

2095 Selenium 2.39E-05 9.09E‐05 0.21 0.0036101 0.21 0.0035269 0.21 0 FF 

524 Selenium 2.28E‐06 0.0108 8.35 0.0177737 8.35 0.0105945 8.35 #N/A FF 

1330 Selenium 8.35E-05 0.0147 3.70 0.0409889 3.70 0.0262889 3.70 0.077526667 ESP‐Wet 

1185 Selenium 1.14E-05 0.0107 1.84 0.0288085 1.84 0.0181085 1.84 0.077526667 ESP‐Wet 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

1187 Selenium 8.90E-06 0.0166 1.84 0.0291546 1.84 0.0125546 1.84 0.077526667 ESP‐Wet 

1276 Selenium 1.44E‐07 0.0469 0.10 0.0594889 0.10 0.0125889 0.10 0.077526667 ESP‐Wet 

18261 Selenium 1.66E-05 0.0113 2.02 0.0242133 2.02 0.0129133 2.02 0.0002 ESP‐Wet 

1743 Selenium 1.93E‐05 0.00359 2.80 0.0098925 2.80 0.0063025 2.80 0 ESP‐Wet 

1738 Selenium 1.60E‐05 0.00302 2.80 0.012217 2.80 0.009197 2.80 0 ESP‐Wet 

1826 Selenium 2.70E-05 0.0257 2.02 0.0430016 2.02 0.0173016 2.02 0 ESP‐Wet 

2239 Selenium 8.72E-06 0.00327 0.60 0.0064119 0.60 0.0031419 0.60 0 ESP‐Wet 

900 Selenium 2.38E‐05 0.00411 2.91 0.0078218 2.91 0.0037118 2.91 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

966 Selenium 8.44E‐06 0.0184 1.33 0.0260741 1.33 0.0076741 1.33 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1120 Selenium 3.43E-05 0.0323 0.66 0.0342493 0.66 0.0019493 0.66 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1471 Selenium 1.26E-04 0.0133 4.65 0.0182337 4.65 0.0093612 4.65 0.0974 ESP 

1141 Selenium 3.46E-06 0.0812 0.28 0.083031 0.28 0.0226955 0.28 0.077526667 ESP 

3197 Selenium 2.15E-07 0.00415 7.46 0.006539 7.46 0.0041615 7.46 0 ESP 

1906 Selenium 1.66E‐04 0.0219 4.67 0.0583172 4.67 0.0405582 4.67 0 ESP 

2274 Sl i e en um 2 86E 05 2.86E-05 0 0114 . 4 30 . 0 0296072 0.0296072 4 30 . 0 021979 0.021979 4 30 . 0 ESP 2276 Selenium 2.31E-05 0.024 4.30 0.0442318 4.30 0.0291571 4.30 0 ESP 

2161 Selenium 3.58E-05 0.00049 4.21 0.0786526 4.21 0.0782313 4.21 0 ESP 

2278 Selenium 3.40E-06 0.0393 2.83 0.0494776 2.83 0.0130577 2.83 0 ESP 

1642 Selenium 2.38E‐05 0.0111 2.80 0.0141168 2.80 0.0110081 2.80 0 ESP 

1854 Selenium 8.11E-06 0.00559 1.57 0.0163661 1.57 0.0131955 1.57 0 ESP 

1845 Selenium 4.09E-05 0.0645 1.57 0.1678988 1.57 0.1409161 1.57 0 ESP 

2103 Selenium 2.69E‐05 0.0113 1.00 0.026783 1.00 0.0170584 1.00 0 ESP 

902 Selenium 2.98E-04 0.0284 4.22 0.067622 4.22 0.0529421 4.22 #N/A ESP 

903 Selenium 3.34E-04 0.105 4.22 0.1502816 4.22 0.0872282 4.22 #N/A ESP 993 Selenium 1.35E-04 0.0129 3.83 0.0256991 3.83 0.0254996 3.83 #N/A ESP 

1113 Selenium 1.41E-04 0.00995 2.72 0.07645 2.72 0.078168 2.72 #N/A ESP 

1113 Selenium 5.15E-05 0.00995 2.72 0.07645 2.72 0.078168 2.72 #N/A ESP 

979 Selenium 6.42E-05 0.0402 2.46 0.102125 2.46 0.0683262 2.46 #N/A ESP 

632 Selenium 2.09E-05 0.013558 1.57 0.0549139 1.57 0.05107 1.57 #N/A ESP 

828 Selenium 2.37E-05 0.1 1.57 0.1699135 1.57 0.1050321 1.57 #N/A ESP 

894 Selenium 6.31E-06 0.0092 0.70 0.0286631 0.70 0.0232474 0.70 #N/A ESP 

1021 Selenium 1.99E-06 0.001303 0.65 0.0070703 0.65 0.0072748 0.65 #N/A ESP 

892 Selenium Selenium 2.90E 06 - 0.129 0.60 0.1356088 0.1356088 0.60 0.039039 0.039039 0.60 #N/A ESP 

1558 Selenium 1.63E‐05 0.024066 0.68 0.0269495 0.68 0.0028838 0.68 0.0974 Wet 

1735 Selenium 4.62E‐06 0.0201 1.67 0.0272992 1.67 0.0205795 1.67 0 

1735 Selenium 6.32E‐06 0.0201 1.67 0.0272992 1.67 0.0205795 1.67 0 

1726 Selenium 6.30E-07 0.00045 0.00 0.0038255 0.00 0.0036562 0.00 0 FF‐Dry 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

1515 Selenium 8.88E‐07 0.00272 0.00 0.0053513 0.00 0.0026313 0.00 0.0974 FF‐Wet 

2170 Selenium 1.18E‐06 0.000721 0.00 0.00549 0.00 0.0048989 0.00 0 FF 

2170 Selenium 1.32E‐06 0.000721 0.00 0.00549 0.00 0.0048989 0.00 0 FF 

1307 Selenium 2.06E-06 0.00276 0.00 0.0061204 0.00 0.0033604 0.00 0.077526667 FF‐Wet 

1833 Selenium 1.57E-06 0.000515 0.00 0.0065534 0.00 0.0061805 0.00 0 FF 

1833 Selenium 2.24E-06 0.000515 0.00 0.0065534 0.00 0.0061805 0.00 0 FF 1611 Selenium 2.70E-06 0.00211 0.00 0.0068505 0.00 0.0050471 0.00 0 FF‐Dry 

1611 Selenium 5.03E-07 0.00211 0.00 0.0068505 0.00 0.0050471 0.00 0 FF‐Dry 1327 Selenium 9.31E-07 0.00457 0.00 0.0069833 0.00 0.0024133 0.00 0.077526667 FF‐Wet 

2195 Selenium 4.08E-05 0.00166 0.00 0.007497 0.00 0.0068376 0.00 0 ESP 

1597 Selenium 5.29E-05 0.00418 0.00 0.009931 0.00 0.0073511 0.00 0.0657 FF 

2088 Selenium 1.45E‐06 0.00391 0.00 0.0102129 0.00 0.0131052 0.00 0 FF 

1638 Selenium 1.41E‐05 0.003832 0.00 0.0137625 0.00 0.0099308 0.00 0 ESP‐Wet 1902 Selenium 2.24E-05 0.00912 0.00 0.0152577 0.00 0.0119669 0.00 0 ESP 

947 Sl i e en um 4 07E . ‐08 0 00228 0.00228 0 00 . 0 0164479 0.0164479 0 00 . 0 0143329 0.0143329 0 00 . #N/A FF‐Dry 

1637 Selenium 1.83E‐05 0.005865 0.00 0.0166895 0.00 0.0108247 0.00 0 ESP‐Wet 

22791 Selenium 6.65E-06 0.005548 0.00 0.016945 0.00 0.0118709 0.00 0.0002 ESP 

22791 Selenium 1.49E-05 0.005548 0.00 0.016945 0.00 0.0118709 0.00 0.0002 ESP 

1915 Selenium 1.68E-05 0.00335 0.00 0.0186372 0.00 0.0189236 0.00 0 ESP‐Wet 

1654 Selenium 4.66E‐07 0.0091 0.00 0.0239819 0.00 0.0199799 0.00 0 FF 

2055 Selenium 5.11E-05 0.00872 0.00 0.0283462 0.00 0.0196262 0.00 0 ESP‐Wet 

2022 Selenium 2.29E‐06 0.0194 0.00 0.028409 0.00 0.0240041 0.00 0 FF‐Dry 

1346111 Selenium 2.97E‐07 0.0271 0.00 0.0291228 0.00 0.0065097 0.00 0.0002 FF‐Dry 

1346111 Selenium 2.34E‐07 0.0271 0.00 0.0291228 0.00 0.0065097 0.00 0.0002 FF‐Dry 

1346111 Selenium 8.94E‐07 0.0271 0.00 0.0291228 0.00 0.0065097 0.00 0.0002 FF‐Dry 

1346111 Selenium 4.28E‐07 0.0271 0.00 0.0291228 0.00 0.0065097 0.00 0.0002 FF‐Dry 

1989 Selenium 4.36E‐06 0.0284 0.00 0.0335626 0.00 0.0051626 0.00 0 ESP 

2011 Selenium 3.16E-06 0.0288 0.00 0.0341544 0.00 0.018102 0.00 0 ESP 

2302 Selenium 9.91E‐06 0.0152 0.00 0.034974 0.00 0.031241 0.00 0 ESP 

1154 Selenium 1.55E-05 0.0319 0.00 0.0366774 0.00 0.0164447 0.00 0.077526667 ESP 

2021 Selenium 1.31E‐06 0.0214 0.00 0.0406222 0.00 0.0288127 0.00 0 FF‐Dry 2135 Selenium 6.61E-06 0.0194 0.00 0.0455032 0.00 0.0405774 0.00 0 ESP 

21351 Selenium Selenium 1 66E . 05 - 0 0113 . 0 00 . 0 0506116 0.0506116 0 00 . 0 0614989 0.0614989 0 00 . 0 0002 . ESP 

2009 Selenium 3.16E-06 0.0588 0.00 0.0632819 0.00 0.0209655 0.00 0 ESP 

2013 Selenium 4.78E‐06 0.0517 0.00 0.0634583 0.00 0.030247 0.00 0 ESP 

1809 Selenium 9.21E-05 0.0332 0.00 0.0911111 0.00 0.0579111 0.00 0 ESP 

975 Selenium 1.18E-04 0.147 0.00 0.1712768 0.00 0.0514579 0.00 #N/A ESP 
Raw Test Data (metals, PM, Coal Analysis). 

submittal_id PollName 'lb/mmBtuO2'

FPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM 

#/mmBtu

Metals Content 

(ppm - u/g)

TPM2.5 

#/mmBtu

Metals 

Content 

(ppm - u/g)

Coal ash 

Content (%) Controls 

1636 Selenium 8.44E‐05 0.11 0.00 0.20085 0.00 0.1464939 0.00 0 ESP 

1021 Selenium 5.07E‐06 0.001303 0.0070703 0.0072748 #N/A ESP 

1244 Selenium 2.68E-06 0.0074 0.0244778 0.0196731 0.077526667 FF 

1244 Selenium 2.35E-06 0.0074 0.0244778 0.0196731 0.077526667 FF 

632 Selenium 1.18E-04 0.013558 0.0549139 0.05107 #N/A ESP 

1449 Selenium 2.13E-07 0.0012 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.0974 FF‐Dry 

565 Selenium 1.35E-07 0.00275 1.00 1.00 1.00 #N/A FF‐Dry 

565 Selenium 5.09E-08 0.00275 1.00 1.00 1.00 #N/A FF‐Dry 

12861 Selenium 1.45E-05 0.00527 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.078688889 ESP 

10040004 Selenium 2.63E‐06 0.00752 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.0002 ESP 

1004 Selenium 6.59E-05 0.0114 4.67 4.67 4.67 #N/A ESP 

550002 Selenium 1.16E-04 0.0491 2.67 2.67 2.67 0.0002 

10040002 Selenium 4.87E-06 0.0531 3.00 3.00 3.00 0.0002 ESP 

1117 Selenium 4.52E-05 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1119 Selenium 3.18E‐05 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1118 Selenium 2.64E-05 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A 2.51 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

1117 Selenium 4.52E-05 #N/A 1.57 #N/A 1.57 #N/A 1.57 #N/A ESP‐Wet 

541 Selenium 1.73E‐05 #N/A 2.83 #N/A 2.83 #N/A 2.83 #N/A FF‐Wet 

1140 Selenium 7.51E‐07 #N/A 1.07 #N/A 1.07 #N/A 1.07 0.077526667 FF‐Dry 

1140 Selenium 5.63E‐07 #N/A 1.07 #N/A 1.07 #N/A 1.07 0.077526667 FF‐Dry 

698 Selenium 6.58E‐07 #N/A 0.00 #N/A 0.00 #N/A 0.00 #N/A FF‐Dry 

1647 Selenium 5.46E-06 #N/A 2.00 #N/A 2.00 #N/A 2.00 0 FF‐Wet 

845 Selenium 5.54E‐07 #N/A 0.00 #N/A 0.00 #N/A 0.00 #N/A FF 

2070 Selenium 4.60E-06 #N/A 1.57 #N/A 1.57 #N/A 1.57 0 ESP 
Regression Results ‐ Sum of Metals vs FPM, TPM, TPM2.5

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Sum of Metals vs FPM

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.40711854

R Square 0.165745506

Adjusted R Square 0.158907354

Standard Error 1.596986565

Observations 124

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 61.81666365 61.81666 24.238349 2.6991E‐06

Residual 122 311.144663 2.550366

Total 123 372.9613267

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.900176549 0.526755769 ‐14.9978 1.832E‐29 ‐8.942942192 ‐6.85741091 ‐8.94294219 ‐6.857410906

LN FPM 0.512286487 0.104054624 4.923246 2.699E‐06 0.30629997 0.718273005 0.30629997 0.718273005

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Sum of Metals vs TPM

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.442553256

R Square 0.195853385

Adjusted R Square 0.188799467

Standard Error 1.557170972

Observations 116

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 67.32452427 67.32452 27.765193 6.55324E‐07

Residual 114 276.4250838 2.424781

Total 115 343.7496081

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.31526714 0.594367902 ‐12.30764 1.163E‐22 ‐8.492705339 ‐6.13782894 ‐8.49270534 ‐6.137828941

LN TPM 0.777658527 0.147583767 5.269269 6.553E‐07 0.485296231 1.070020823 0.485296231 1.070020823

SUMMARY OUTPUT

Sum of Metals vs TPM2.5

Regression Statistics

Multiple R 0.433326842

R Square 0.187772152

Adjusted R Square 0.180647346

Standard Error 1.56497577

Observations 116

ANOVA

df SS MS F Significance F

Regression 1 64.5466036 64.5466 26.354705 1.18149E‐06

Residual 114 279.2030045 2.449149

Total 115 343.7496081

Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P‐value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0% Upper 95.0%

Intercept ‐7.083777574 0.653200428 ‐10.84472 2.943E‐19 ‐8.377762548 ‐5.7897926 ‐8.37776255 ‐5.789792599

LN TPM2.5 0.744702069 0.14506194 5.133683 1.181E‐06 0.457335492 1.032068645 0.457335492 1.032068645
Raw Test Data (Sum metals, FPM, TPM, TPM2.5). Log transformed test data.

submittal_id Sum of Metals FPM TPM TPM2.5 LN Sum Metals LN FPM LN TPM LN TPM2.5

2095 3.30E‐05 9.09E‐05 0.00361 0.003527 ‐10.31792176 ‐9.30575 ‐5.62402 ‐5.6473392

1726 1.79E‐06 0.00045 0.003825 0.003656 ‐13.23452474 ‐7.70626 ‐5.56608 ‐5.6113315

1972 2.04E‐06 0.00192 0.004325 0.003437 ‐13.10160043 ‐6.25543 ‐5.4434 ‐5.6731975

23152 5.27E‐06 0.00136 0.004367 0.003007 ‐12.15397368 ‐6.60027 ‐5.43365 ‐5.8067673

1349 6.72E‐06 0.00235 0.004466 0.002116 ‐11.91058611 ‐6.05334 ‐5.41121 ‐6.1581112

1507 1.40E‐04 0.000686 0.004507 0.004138 ‐8.876904168 ‐7.28463 ‐5.40205 ‐5.4874339

1909 1.49E‐05 0.00139 0.004655 0.004411 ‐11.11442455 ‐6.57845 ‐5.36989 ‐5.4235664

2319 5.13E‐06 0.0035 0.005217 0.005217 ‐12.18083384 ‐5.65499 ‐5.25581 ‐5.2558107

1515 3.22E‐06 0.00272 0.005351 0.002631 ‐12.64762099 ‐5.90712 ‐5.23042 ‐5.9402911

2170 3.05E‐06 0.000721 0.00549 0.004899 ‐12.69934236 ‐7.23482 ‐5.20483 ‐5.3187543

2170 3.05E‐06 0.000721 0.00549 0.004899 ‐12.69934236 ‐7.23482 ‐5.20483 ‐5.3187543

1307 5.23E‐04 0.00276 0.00612 0.00336 ‐7.556168128 ‐5.89252 ‐5.09613 ‐5.6956994

1942 2.89E‐06 0.00356 0.006183 0.002637 ‐12.75411566 ‐5.63799 ‐5.08592 ‐5.9381549

23153 5.41E‐06 0.00321 0.006277 0.003067 ‐12.12679946 ‐5.74148 ‐5.0708 ‐5.7869251

2239 1.14E‐05 0.00327 0.006412 0.003142 ‐11.37791392 ‐5.72297 ‐5.0496 ‐5.762926

3197 4.15E‐06 0.00415 0.006539 0.004162 ‐12.39177591 ‐5.48465 ‐5.02998 ‐5.4818727

1833 4.85E‐06 0.000515 0.006553 0.006181 ‐12.23673806 ‐7.57134 ‐5.02777 ‐5.0863511

1833 4.85E‐06 0.000515 0.006553 0.006181 ‐12.23673806 ‐7.57134 ‐5.02777 ‐5.0863511

1648 1.48E‐05 0.00292 0.006663 0.003743 ‐11.11954306 ‐5.83617 ‐5.01121 ‐5.5879124

1611 3.40E‐06 0.00211 0.006851 0.005047 ‐12.59270619 ‐6.16107 ‐4.98343 ‐5.2889327

1611 3.40E‐06 0.00211 0.006851 0.005047 ‐12.59270619 ‐6.16107 ‐4.98343 ‐5.2889327

1327 2.64E‐05 0.00457 0.006983 0.002413 ‐10.54240795 ‐5.38824 ‐4.96424 ‐6.026778

1021 6.85E‐06 0.001303 0.00707 0.007275 ‐11.89108366 ‐6.64294 ‐4.95185 ‐4.9233364

1021 6.85E‐06 0.001303 0.00707 0.007275 ‐11.89108366 ‐6.64294 ‐4.95185 ‐4.9233364

1841 1.35E‐05 0.00134 0.007282 0.006538 ‐11.20994353 ‐6.61509 ‐4.92231 ‐5.0301558

2259 8 32E . ‐06 0 00333 0.00333 0 007357 0.007357 0 004027 0.004027 ‐11 6969685 11.6969685 ‐5 70478 5.70478 ‐4 91213 4.91213 ‐5 5147789 5.5147789

1190 4.73E‐06 0.00409 0.007489 0.004523 ‐12.26074005 ‐5.49921 ‐4.89431 ‐5.3986517

1190 4.73E‐06 0.00409 0.007489 0.004523 ‐12.26074005 ‐5.49921 ‐4.89431 ‐5.3986517

2195 5.55E‐05 0.00166 0.007497 0.006838 ‐9.799235651 ‐6.40094 ‐4.89325 ‐4.9853128

900 1.19E‐01 0.00411 0.007822 0.003712 ‐2.128367685 ‐5.49433 ‐4.85084 ‐5.5962342

2315 9.92E‐06 0.00377 0.008164 0.004394 ‐11.52087699 ‐5.58068 ‐4.80797 ‐5.4274282

23151 6.61E‐06 0.00468 0.0088 0.00412 ‐11.92642779 ‐5.36446 ‐4.73304 ‐5.4919868

1398 6.26E‐06 0.0011 0.008823 0.008455 ‐11.98147415 ‐6.81245 ‐4.73043 ‐4.7729751

1743 6.14E‐05 0.00359 0.009893 0.006303 ‐9.697848312 ‐5.6296 ‐4.61597 ‐5.0668021

1597 5.66E‐05 0.00418 0.009931 0.007351 ‐9.77897521 ‐5.47744 ‐4.6121 ‐4.9129101

2088 1.14E‐05 0.00391 0.010213 0.013105 ‐11.37935657 ‐5.54422 ‐4.5841 ‐4.3347466

1563 2.24E‐05 0.00368 0.011135 0.011249 ‐10.70553038 ‐5.60484 ‐4.49767 ‐4.4875025

1563 2.24E‐05 0.00368 0.011135 0.011249 ‐10.70553038 ‐5.60484 ‐4.49767 ‐4.4875025

1563 2.24E‐05 0.00368 0.011135 0.011249 ‐10.70553038 ‐5.60484 ‐4.49767 ‐4.4875025

1568 6.44E‐06 0.00561 0.011315 0.008212 ‐11.9522835 ‐5.1832 ‐4.48159 ‐4.802126

8761 3.81E‐04 0.00448 0.011798 0.009884 ‐7.871844892 ‐5.40813 ‐4.43982 ‐4.6168374

8761 3.81E‐04 0.00448 0.011798 0.009884 ‐7.871844892 ‐5.40813 ‐4.43982 ‐4.6168374

1738 1.96E‐04 0.00302 0.012217 0.009197 ‐8.5379144 ‐5.8025 ‐4.40492 ‐4.6888754

2206 2.00E‐05 0.00451 0.013457 0.009531 ‐10.81811267 ‐5.40146 ‐4.30829 ‐4.6532032

1638 1.49E‐04 0.003832 0.013763 0.009931 ‐8.80848336 ‐5.56444 ‐4.28581 ‐4.6121141

1642 3.76E‐05 0.0111 0.014117 0.011008 ‐10.18941117 ‐4.50081 ‐4.26039 ‐4.5091213

1902 2.96E‐05 0.00912 0.015258 0.011967 ‐10.42788486 ‐4.69729 ‐4.18267 ‐4.42561

1854 2.47E‐05 0.00559 0.016366 0.013196 ‐10.60826814 ‐5.18678 ‐4.11255 ‐4.3278785

947 1.17E‐06 0.00228 0.016448 0.014333 ‐13.65543461 ‐6.08358 ‐4.10755 ‐4.2451999

1637 7.21E‐05 0.005865 0.01669 0.010825 ‐9.538134968 ‐5.13879 ‐4.09297 ‐4.5259203

22791 2.04E‐05 0.005548 0.016945 0.011871 ‐10.80034553 ‐5.19436 ‐4.07778 ‐4.4336666
Raw Test Data (Sum metals, FPM, TPM, TPM2.5). Log transformed test data.

submittal_id Sum of Metals FPM TPM TPM2.5 LN Sum Metals LN FPM LN TPM LN TPM2.5

22791 2.04E‐05 0.005548 0.016945 0.011871 ‐10.80034553 ‐5.19436 ‐4.07778 ‐4.4336666

524 1.77E‐05 0.0108 0.017774 0.010594 ‐10.94019604 ‐4.52821 ‐4.03003 ‐4.5474232

1471 4.74E‐04 0.0133 0.018234 0.009361 ‐7.653272122 ‐4.31999 ‐4.00448 ‐4.6711785

1915 2.02E‐05 0.00335 0.018637 0.018924 ‐10.80746935 ‐5.69879 ‐3.9826 ‐3.967347

1488 1.57E‐06 0.000828 0.020455 0.019627 ‐13.36215092 ‐7.0965 ‐3.88953 ‐3.9308503

1052 8.54E‐06 0.011 0.023036 0.014829 ‐11.67128834 ‐4.50986 ‐3.77072 ‐4.2111569

1654 7.35E‐06 0.0091 0.023982 0.01998 ‐11.82138184 ‐4.69948 ‐3.73046 ‐3.9130299

18261 3.48E‐05 0.0113 0.024213 0.012913 ‐10.2664393 ‐4.48295 ‐3.72085 ‐4.3494941

1244 2.97E‐04 0.0074 0.024478 0.019673 ‐8.121106564 ‐4.90621 ‐3.70999 ‐3.9285011

1244 2.97E‐04 0.0074 0.024478 0.019673 ‐8.121106564 ‐4.90621 ‐3.70999 ‐3.9285011

1244 2.97E‐04 0.0074 0.024478 0.019673 ‐8.121106564 ‐4.90621 ‐3.70999 ‐3.9285011

1244 2.97E‐04 0.0074 0.024478 0.019673 ‐8.121106564 ‐4.90621 ‐3.70999 ‐3.9285011

993 1.70E‐04 0.0129 0.025699 0.0255 ‐8.680618414 ‐4.35053 ‐3.6613 ‐3.6690914

63254 4.46E‐05 0.014 0.025745 0.014158 ‐10.01782154 ‐4.2687 ‐3.65953 ‐4.2574658

966 8.72E‐05 0.0184 0.026074 0.007674 ‐9.347570023 ‐3.9954 ‐3.64681 ‐4.8699081

2103 3.29E‐05 0.0113 0.026783 0.017058 ‐10.32334575 ‐4.48295 ‐3.61999 ‐4.0711132

1558 4.64E‐05 0.024066 0.02695 0.002884 ‐9.979224543 ‐3.72697 ‐3.61379 ‐5.8486347

1735 1.57E‐05 0.0201 0.027299 0.02058 ‐11.06402804 ‐3.90704 ‐3.6009 ‐3.8834586

1735 1.57E‐05 0.0201 0.027299 0.02058 ‐11.06402804 ‐3.90704 ‐3.6009 ‐3.8834586

2055 6.47E‐05 0.00872 0.028346 0.019626 ‐9.64627809 ‐4.74214 ‐3.56326 ‐3.9308892

2022 1.34E‐04 0.0194 0.028409 0.024004 ‐8.919717628 ‐3.94248 ‐3.56105 ‐3.7295299

894 1.57E‐05 0.0092 0.028663 0.023247 ‐11.06468827 ‐4.68855 ‐3.55215 ‐3.7615616

1185 2.36E‐05 0.0107 0.028808 0.018108 ‐10.65286652 ‐4.53751 ‐3.54708 ‐4.0113741

1346111 6.26E‐06 0.0271 0.029123 0.00651 ‐11.98072353 ‐3.60822 ‐3.53623 ‐5.0344568

1346111 6.26E‐06 0.0271 0.029123 0.00651 ‐11.98072353 ‐3.60822 ‐3.53623 ‐5.0344568

1346111 1346111 6 26E . ‐06 0 0271 . 0 029123 0.029123 0 00651 0.00651 ‐11 98072353 11.98072353 ‐3 60822 3.60822 ‐3 53623 3.53623 ‐5 0344568 5.0344568

1346111 6.26E‐06 0.0271 0.029123 0.00651 ‐11.98072353 ‐3.60822 ‐3.53623 ‐5.0344568

1187 1.58E‐05 0.0166 0.029155 0.012555 ‐11.05841626 ‐4.09835 ‐3.53514 ‐4.3776669

2274 5.70E‐05 0.0114 0.029607 0.021979 ‐9.771649092 ‐4.47414 ‐3.51974 ‐3.817668

1176 4.34E‐05 0.0256 0.031158 0.005558 ‐10.04569649 ‐3.66516 ‐3.4687 ‐5.1925991

1249 2.52E‐05 0.00362 0.032005 0.029148 ‐10.58931757 ‐5.62128 ‐3.44186 ‐3.5353538

1989 2.94E‐05 0.0284 0.033563 0.005163 ‐10.43618394 ‐3.56137 ‐3.39434 ‐5.2663136

2011 1.85E‐05 0.0288 0.034154 0.018102 ‐10.89649735 ‐3.54738 ‐3.37686 ‐4.0117318

1120 7.52E‐05 0.0323 0.034249 0.001949 ‐9.495096064 ‐3.43269 ‐3.37409 ‐6.2402976

2302 4.47E‐05 0.0152 0.034974 0.031241 ‐10.01630469 ‐4.18646 ‐3.35315 ‐3.4660242

1938 2.84E‐05 0.0209 0.035577 0.031435 ‐10.46849016 ‐3.86801 ‐3.33606 ‐3.459847

1154 2.74E‐05 0.0319 0.036677 0.016445 ‐10.50628228 ‐3.44515 ‐3.30559 ‐4.1077515

2021 5.11E‐05 0.0214 0.040622 0.028813 ‐9.881139149 ‐3.84436 ‐3.20344 ‐3.5469381

1330 1.04E‐04 0.0147 0.040989 0.026289 ‐9.171744854 ‐4.21991 ‐3.19446 ‐3.6386103

1826 3.87E‐05 0.0257 0.043002 0.017302 ‐10.15861209 ‐3.66126 ‐3.14652 ‐4.0569546

2276 2.03E‐04 0.024 0.044232 0.029157 ‐8.502358768 ‐3.7297 ‐3.11831 ‐3.5350563

2135 3.07E‐03 0.0194 0.045503 0.040577 ‐5.787116041 ‐3.94248 ‐3.08997 ‐3.2045428

1310 6.37E‐05 0.0438 0.04761 0.011568 ‐9.660635496 ‐3.12812 ‐3.04471 ‐4.4595483

2278 1.68E‐04 0.0393 0.049478 0.013058 ‐8.690530428 ‐3.23653 ‐3.00624 ‐4.3383736

21351 4.57E‐05 0.0113 0.050612 0.061499 ‐9.992734153 ‐4.48295 ‐2.98358 ‐2.7887363

632 5.28E‐05 0.013558 0.054914 0.05107 ‐9.849643514 ‐4.30075 ‐2.90199 ‐2.9745573

632 5.28E‐05 0.013558 0.054914 0.05107 ‐9.849643514 ‐4.30075 ‐2.90199 ‐2.9745573

1906 1.90E‐04 0.0219 0.058317 0.040558 ‐8.570541227 ‐3.82127 ‐2.84186 ‐3.2050174

1276 3.17E‐06 0.0469 0.059489 0.012589 ‐12.66117978 ‐3.05974 ‐2.82197 ‐4.3749383

2009 2.93E‐05 0.0588 0.063282 0.020965 ‐10.43683149 ‐2.83361 ‐2.76016 ‐3.8648792

2013 3.40E‐05 0.0517 0.063458 0.030247 ‐10.28823868 ‐2.9623 ‐2.75737 ‐3.4983586
Raw Test Data (Sum metals, FPM, TPM, TPM2.5). Log transformed test data.

submittal_id Sum of Metals FPM TPM TPM2.5 LN Sum Metals LN FPM LN TPM LN TPM2.5

902 3.41E‐04 0.0284 0.067622 0.052942 ‐7.983290894 ‐3.56137 ‐2.69382 ‐2.9385571

1113 1.99E‐04 0.00995 0.07645 0.078168 ‐8.524560262 ‐4.61018 ‐2.57112 ‐2.5488953

1113 1.99E‐04 0.00995 0.07645 0.078168 ‐8.524560262 ‐4.61018 ‐2.57112 ‐2.5488953

879456 1.22E‐04 0.0453 0.077369 0.084939 ‐9.012949595 ‐3.09445 ‐2.55917 ‐2.4658243

2161 3.93E‐05 0.00049 0.078653 0.078231 ‐10.14386628 ‐7.62111 ‐2.54272 ‐2.5480852

1141 4.53E‐05 0.0812 0.083031 0.022696 ‐10.00271138 ‐2.51084 ‐2.48854 ‐3.785588

1809 1.38E‐04 0.0332 0.091111 0.057911 ‐8.887141553 ‐3.40521 ‐2.39568 ‐2.8488458

979 8.87E‐05 0.0402 0.102125 0.068326 ‐9.329840381 ‐3.21389 ‐2.28156 ‐2.6834622

892 6.12E‐05 0.129 0.135609 0.039039 ‐9.701232658 ‐2.04794 ‐1.99798 ‐3.2431933

903 4.16E‐04 0.105 0.150282 0.087228 ‐7.785161893 ‐2.25379 ‐1.89524 ‐2.4392272

1845 2.02E‐04 0.0645 0.167899 0.140916 ‐8.505907119 ‐2.74109 ‐1.78439 ‐1.9595903

828 1.04E‐04 0.1 0.169914 0.105032 ‐9.167932436 ‐2.30259 ‐1.77247 ‐2.2534897

975 2.33E‐04 0.147 0.171277 0.051458 ‐8.366336502 ‐1.91732 ‐1.76447 ‐2.9669922

1636 1.73E‐04 0.11 0.20085 0.146494 ‐8.662641018 ‐2.20727 ‐1.6052 ‐1.9207714

1449 3.38E‐06 0.0012 ‐12.5990856 ‐6.72543 #VALUE! #VALUE!

565 3.02E‐06 0.00275 ‐12.71065116 ‐5.89615 #VALUE! #VALUE!

565 3.02E‐06 0.00275 ‐12.71065116 ‐5.89615 #VALUE! #VALUE!

12861 2.53E‐05 0.00527 ‐10.58482475 ‐5.24572 #VALUE! #VALUE!

10040004 8.02E‐06 0.00752 ‐11.73317321 ‐4.89019 #VALUE! #VALUE!

1004 7.39E‐05 0.0114 ‐9.512540659 ‐4.47414 #VALUE! #VALUE!

550002 7.66E‐04 0.0491 ‐7.174819184 ‐3.0139 #VALUE! #VALUE!

10040002 1.56E‐05 0.0531 ‐11.06612649 ‐2.93558 #VALUE! #VALUE!

541 7.19E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐9.540749029 #N/A #N/A #N/A

698 1.30E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐11.25034584 #N/A #N/A #N/A

845 5.52E‐06 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐12.10707835 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1117 7 03E . ‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐9 562788547 9.562788547 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1117 7.03E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐9.562788547 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1118 3.82E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐10.17309005 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1119 4.95E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐9.913305592 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1140 7.51E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐14.10186019 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1140 7.51E‐07 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐14.10186019 #N/A #N/A #N/A

1647 1.01E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐11.50313257 #N/A #N/A #N/A

2070 2.83E‐05 #N/A #N/A #N/A ‐10.47231665 #N/A #N/A #N/A