...... · ~ 

USCIB: 29.5/8 

'f6P Sl!i6Rm 

TOP fiiff'l) : A61 ii.4 

., 

IWJBI.Ei YIA 09MIN'f eIIMftH!lfS eNLY 

21 February 1955 

EO 3.3(h)(2) 

PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 

MEMORANDUM FOR THE MEMBERS OF USCIBEC: 

Subject: 

Reference: USCIB 2!].5/6 of 19 January 1955. 

Enclosed herewith is a copy of certain views of the CIA member with 

regard to the reference, which will be considered at the next regular 

meeting or USCIBEC. 

Enclosure 

CIA Memo dtd 18 Feb 1955 

USCIB: 29.5/8 

APPENDED DOCDMmT CONTlt!NS 

CODitrIQRJ;) M*'fEIRIAL 

HA:NB:bE YIA 60H:EN'f euANHmS 0Nfi¥ 

24 

TOP SECRET eclassified and approved for release by NSA on 

9-26-2014 ursuantto E.O. 13526 
___ .,. TOP SECRET EtDER: 

REF ID:A614i11 .... Glll'JTRAL lN:'El.LIGENGE AGill'CY 

WASHINGTON 25, D. C. 

18 FEB 1955 

!OP SEeRE! EfBER 

Ml!MORAND~ FOR: Executive Secretary, USCIB 

SUBJECT 

REFERENCES a. USCIB z:;.5/7, 14 February 1955 

b. USCIB 2f).5/6, 19 January 1955 

Pursuant to your request, following are some of the points 

tentatively suggested for consideration by USCIBEC in connection 

with the proposed plan for negotia.tij of a/ • \ 

a. Last sentence, paragraph 3. page 2 of General 

Schow's Memorandum to Executive Secreta USCIB 

enclosure with reference b in which he states 

that "implementation of the Agreement, coordination of Service participation, and direct contact 

for the provision o~ .. ical assistance,.· lia.·/ison 

and guidance to thel_____PCJUNT Authority will• be 

the responsibility of the.Director, NSA. 11 • Ictentii'ication of NSA personnel\as such, and their.introductiop......i.nffo·. "direct contact·. " with repres.ent.· atives 

·of thel__JCOM.INT authority is believed to be an 

unnecessary security risk in view of the• known poor 

security practices of thd I 

b. Para ra h in the "Statement\ of Broad 0 · and 

General Terms of U.S. Collabor.ation with enclosure 

1 with General Schow'.s memorandum , and paragraph 4 of 

the Aide Memoire for General HUl.l (enclosure 2 with 

General Schow• s rnemorand;um), provide that "all materials 

and products will be exchanged only with the U.S. 11 In 

view of the fact that all material received by the U.S. 

~~;to see any advantage .ti.n attemp ;ng so 

since it would almost inev;i.tably evoke -- EO 3.3(h)(2) 

Enclosure with USCIB 29.5/8 dtd 21 Feb 1955. PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 

H.'\NBI:.E VIA 6lM:EN'I' 6II:ANNELS ONLY 

TOP SECRET EIDER 
.-..... 

TOP SECRE'f EIDER 

REF ID : A61 ti.4 

., 

TOP 6'1!.i6RE'f EIDER 

EO 3.3(h)(2) 

a request for a corresponding commitment from the U.S., 

impossible of fulfillment. Moreover, paragraph 1 of 

General Schow .. 'a memorandum statrs that the U.S. is to supp~ to thel _on~ such material as 

is covered im.der paragraphs 4 and 5 of Appendix P, 

UKUSA. .·Thus there would seem t .. o· he Jitt.J e likel ihqod 

that, as/a practical matter, the._I ------.---J 

would have occasion to pass itto another comtry. 

c. Minimum Security Standards for the Classification, 

Dissemination. Transmission. and Physical Secμrity 

of C<J.1.INT (enclosure 3 with General Schow' s memorand'l.Dll}: 

Since there is no intent by USCIB or by the Executive 

Agent negot,.iating the agreement to go beyond the provisions of paragraphs 4 and 5 of Appendix P, the 

applicability of some of the special provisions in the 

Mi,ni.mum Security Standards is open to question;...• --=F~o;.:r __ _, exam le 0 r ared to ive the -~ ........ ~__,,"intelligence reports and summaries ase on 

COMINT, 11 should not the last sentence of paragraph 1 be 

deleted? 

(SIGNED) 

PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 I I 

CIA Member, USCIBEC OGA 

- 2 -

TOP SECIU!;T EIDER