103!! UICD MM't1Y 

1'9 a (couinue4) 

· fOP SECRE1 ., 

to 3.3(h)(2) 

PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 

3. llUILO ..U ad41t1onal17 whether we vUh\ to\ iDolud.I J 

expl ~uiD& tb&t hiJlta lumt "bee dropped. that t.M I · lbaft approec:Md ta.. 

Bri,iall. Altlt.ouab U8CD .. ~/\&Ua ta. T1n '-' & ti1MNU10D. 

ot COMDT arraoawata vithl ~i• not. approprt&'- at thi• time, t.he 

lo.r4 _,. vie to ncouider thia action. 

-.. The WOrkin& ec-tttee mt. ca 7 1111¥ 19'4 to prepare u .a. p091tioll 

,.._..tor the torthecaiDg ccnterence. The IS4 repreaen.t&tift tabled. 

two ,..,_. propoaillc tb&t certa.in buio ata.t--.ta ot 1.ISCD pol107 be 

eauaei&ted. The CIA re,rueat&tiYe tabled & paper antiD&. torth CU.'• 

propouJ. tor a u .s. poliq ca camrr arraaawta vi~ the I CowrtriH. ...__ ___ _ 

5. Detailed 4Ucuaaioa ot theM pepera rneal.e4 b&aic point• ot 

cUtf veace vbiell will reflU1.re reaolution 'b7 UICD. 'lbeH cUtterencea 

U.ve beu linecl in ta. re,ort ot the Work1Jai ~ttee circulated u 

UICD 19*18/a. ID ad41tioa., II.A. An4 CIA haft 1Delude4 ad41t10D&l. tacta 

to subatanti&t.e the poaiticu taken b7 each. 

CUBBlft CallmDAS'lCll 

6. '1'be Wbera ot U8CIB U.ve been uke4 to conaider tbe report 

ot the WOl'kiD& Ccmi t'tee 1D ar4ar to prortcle further policy guic1ance to 

that group. 

7. 'fbe •-nt.1.al elmnta ot DA'• poaition h&Te bea detailed 

1A the zwart; ot the working Cc.witt.ee. 

8. The 41.owtaion gn tJlia it• vUl 4oubtleu be l•D&thl' an4 .... t 

leut ac:ae ot ta. -.Mra v1ll ~to lme •1Pt ot the b&aic 1..uea. 

9. !be positicm ot tbe Dlrector, DA, 1• u follows: With reepen 

to Th1rt. h:rtiu trc:a vhca, to 1tcme 4Algree1 w will obtain. C<ICDI'! •terial., 

tnere are at prettent three •tbola 4Mcribe4 &Dd tvo w.ya 811pl.OJ94 tor 

obtainin& it. 

lo. '1'b.e tvo .-tbod.a both 4eaor1be4 &D4 _,10194 are aa tollova: 

Declassified and approved for release by NSA on 05-13-2014 pursuantto E .0. 1352a 
.. ~ .. ~ '-'*-· I 

'"'RS!!! EO 3.3(h)(2) 

~ USCDI ~Hae PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 

:ttes 2 ( cazrti!iUed) 

x.. We pt CCJttif1t mnter1al. ~ ~amettta vbich ere c~lertol)'" 

OO'fCl1"t in nature.. When this ia l!ono 1 .~ Da).-CCMtJfl' Nletl pr-avail 

-4 \be collateral prov1a1ona ot the UJlISA Agreement }'ll'fia.11 Yith respeot 

to Ucbnrlao -.1 USO of trUZb C(l(OU • 

n. lb' virtue ot coo.tacts with toreign permental attic1ala, 

JliOt a.ctina aa private :JJ:X\iv1dW!l.s1 w pt C(l.ttm' mo.terio.l in retUl'll tar 

aaab, ~pmit and, on occae1cm., l.hdt.lt tseobnieal 1.nformt1on.. Thie 

~ o:t en-nJ'.\P•~/1' FY«l"md l1.r Appe:mlix P or 'OIUSA ua. JllU"U.. 4 atld 

' in ;particular •PP1Y• 

u.. 'fhen/tbera is tbn ~method tw obta1mna Cef.ttlr.r ateX'1al.1 

a Mtb.od described but not G:lployed ('rhie method has been &llPJ"OVed frlr 

...__ _ ____.jbut D0t J1i'C bcPleacntcd) I 

m. Thia .Mtbod .. tabli•hcB ml «n.'Sl:lgemetlt with a foreign 

pex.omcnt, t~ an ottlcie.l. not acttna aa a p-ivate tnaivid:ua.l, 

4ea~ to obtain OC!.J.IE -.terial. b retuTn tor Pi\)'S8Jl1i in kind 

prov1ding technical •terial go1ng beyond the Umits r4 para. 5 ot 

.Appendix P. 

12. With reaper.rt to Method :U above, we teel such aboUl.4 'bo 

conducted 'b)" a tJSClD member other then EAJ that tho relations •hould 

'M held u rl.&1411 aa :poeaible within tba teni.a ct para. IJ ot App@~ix 

1!1 Ylth tho leaat poedble uold.ng at pu-a. 5. W• don't v1•h to turther 

:rel.ex thel!le rules bece.use tbnt YOUld only lead to on 'l.UlVOrka'ble 'V&.r1ety 

or rules 'rar a variety at i:aat1cms. 

.., ~ "'" •..!' - r. 

-w ___ ._ -- -= -
122 !!!!!'! 

~USCIB~ig 

Itm 2 (continued) 

EO 3.3(h)(2) 

PL 86-36/50 USC 3605 

13· Wlth reapect to Met~ lll Gove (FOYiA~ fe?' 'but .not 

-.ployed). This Metbol 1s JIZ"OV1ded tar b7 JC"l• 6 ot A1pendilt P. It 

ta the llSA viw tmt the ti. baa como tor a to atttmqJt to ate C<Jolllf.tl 

~euents with "the.__ _________ Yithin the tema ot para. 6. 

tt this i• done, Qd. becc.uae or tho technical nntura '4\the ncb.a.nge 

at CCKm'l' materials, n fftl. that ISA i• the one member of USClB \Ud.quely 

·q.un.J.ified to mcm!tor tW.a tne of c»>eratimi e»4 lneure ~bnt Boe.rd policy 

is obl:erved • 

~A'l'I~ 

14. We want TJSCIB to ae;rea b principle that the U .a. l• ready to 

.nter into Camtr eoll.aborntian Yith tho I ~ tt a 

detailed 1nveet1.ga.t1on by the working F'O'UiP •um>orta •uch a atep. 'J!h.a 

tm"estigat10Jl would bo based on the foUO"W'iz2a crituias 

.. • \h.e country must be.ve a COOlfl' ~pniu.tion of ev..t'fiei< 

c~ence to warrant collaboraticm cm technical FOblecs. 

'b. thero voul~ 'be ao o'bjectic:m b'aa the atandpoint Of ae<nn"!t;r 

or the m.ti~ iuvolved. 

•• there are no political obJectioiis to euch collaboration 

that would ilxvalidate it. 

d- auch ciollaboro.tion could be expected to produce additional. 

CCKOli' material, 1.l(prove 1.ta queltty and apeM.to the "c:eipt ot such 

•terial. 
!9! !!Si!! 

~ ysc{! 11eet1ea 

Item 2 (continued) 

REF ID:A60472 

15~ It detailed. cona14er&t1on ot the above tacton by the 

working Group rules out collaboration with &rf¥ one ar more ot the 

nat10Jl81 USCIB ehoul.d inatruct the VorJdng Group that it viehe• to 

10 no f\u'ther then at preaent and that cona14erat1on •boul4 be Si't"en 

to the poae1'bility ot retrenchment traa our preaent poaition. otherw1n1 

it ia the conee.t1.11U• ot the Bo&'rd. that CCKIIT collaboration •hOUl.d be 

undertaken with theae tbree nations alCJna the 1111.ea l&id out by the 

Director in hi• •up:portin& paper. 

f -_ .,. • •• 

-

;: 

I' 

-

' 

~ 

c: 

-~ 

. . 

..;.