# Leftover CSAPR comments that impact ptnonipm sector in NEI2011v1

# These reductions are based on LaFarge and St. Gobain consent decrees updated by reviewing 2011 NEIv1 and supposed compliance dates

# Based on intermediate workbook Lafarge_analysis_2011v6.xlsx

# For many facilities/units, found that cdate in early 2011 or earlier did not indicate less emissions in 2011 vs 2008 NEI...

# ...therefore assumed these units remaining uncontrolled in 2011 NEI

# References:

# http://www2.epa.gov/enforcement/lafarge-north-america-inc-clean-air-act-settlement

# http://www2.epa.gov/enforcement/saint-gobain-containers-inc-clean-air-act-settlement

# All controls in place (supposedly) by December 2016

# THIS PACKET EXPORTED FROM: /garnet/home/rhc/2011v6/mk_CONTROL_LaFarge_StGobain_2011v6.sas

17031,30501402,NOX,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,7335811,,,,,! cdate=12/31/2014: Saint Gobain: Control Device= SCR -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

17031,30501402,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,7335811,,,,,! cdate=12/31/2014: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Dry Scrubber -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

17127,,NOX,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,7808811,2232913,,,,! cdate=7/31/2013: LaFarge: Control Device= SCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

18075,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8537511,464613,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERS,INC."

18075,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,8537511,464613,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2012: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERS,INC."

18075,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,8537511,464613,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2012: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERS,INC."

18075,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8537511,464613,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2012: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERS,INC."

20205,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8079411,6224613,,,,"! cdate=10/1/2012: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A. , Fredonia KS new CONTROL packet 

record"

20205,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8079411,6224613,,,,"! cdate=10/1/2012: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A. , Fredonia KS new CONTROL packet 

record"

20205,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8079411,63911413,,,,! cdate=10/1/2012: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

20205,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8079411,63911413,,,,! cdate=10/1/2012: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LafargeN.A.

25027,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2010: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674513,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674513,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674513,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

25027,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,7259211,87674513,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS -plant= STGOBAINCONTAINERS

26007,,7647010,,75,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6935813,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6935813,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6935813,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,7647010,,75,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6936213,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6936213,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6936213,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,7647010,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2014: LaFarge: Control Device= wet fgd - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2014: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,SO2,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2014: LaFarge: Control Device= wet fgd -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,7647010,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940313,,,,! cdate=3/1/2014: LaFarge: Control Device= wet fgd - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940313,,,,! cdate=3/1/2012: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,SO2,,90,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6940313,,,,! cdate=3/1/2014: LaFarge: Control Device= wet fgd -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,7647010,,75,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6945713,,,,! cdate=10/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6945713,,,,! cdate=10/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

26007,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8127411,6945713,,,,! cdate=10/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LafargeN.A.

29099,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59049513,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59049513,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP or CCSS -plant= 
SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59049513,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP or CCSS -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59049513,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS – -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59050413,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP or CCSS -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59050413,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP or CCSS -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

29099,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8112911,59050413,,,,"! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS – -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC,PEVELY"

37181,,NOX,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,8010411,4036013,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= OEAS -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC

37181,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8010411,4036413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2016: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC

37195,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,8006411,5030413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2009: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC

39125,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,7996411,6429213,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SCNR -plant= LAFARGE/SYSTECHENVIRONMENTALCORP.

39125,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,7996411,6429213,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LAFARGE/SYSTECHENVIRONMENTALCORP.

39125,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,7996411,6429313,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SCNR -plant= LAFARGE/SYSTECHENVIRONMENTALCORP.

39125,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,7996411,6429313,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LAFARGE/SYSTECHENVIRONMENTALCORP.

40131,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8416311,645913,,,,! cdate=11/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

40131,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,8416311,647013,,,,! cdate=12/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SNCR -plant= LafargeN.A.

42077,,7647010,,75,100,100,,,Y,R,6621911,18982113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA - HCL -plant= LafargeN.A.

42077,,NOX,,50,100,100,,,Y,R,6621911,18982113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= SCNR -plant= LafargeN.A.

42077,,SO2,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,6621911,18982113,,,,! cdate=1/1/2011: LaFarge: Control Device= DAA -plant= LafargeN.A.

42083,,NOX,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,6532611,19110713,,,,! cdate=12/31/2010: Saint Gobain: Control Device= OEAS -plant= SAINTGOBAINCONTAINERS/PORTALLEGANYBO

42083,,NOX,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,6532611,19110913,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= OEAS -plant= SAINTGOBAINCONTAINERS/PORTALLEGANYBO

48139,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4161211,34003113,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC.

48139,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,4161211,34003113,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC.

48139,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,4161211,34003113,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= ESP -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC.

48139,,SO2,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4161211,34003113,,,,! cdate=12/31/2013: Saint Gobain: Control Device= Semi-dry Scrubber or CCSS – -plant= 

SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC.

53033,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839213,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

53033,,PM10-PRI,,99,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839213,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= CCSS -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

53033,,PM25-PRI,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839213,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= CCSS -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

53033,,SO2,,95,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839213,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= CCSS -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

53033,,NOX,,70,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839313,,,,! cdate=12/31/2012: Saint Gobain: Control Device= OEAS -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

53033,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4985311,28839413,,,,! cdate=12/31/2016: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= Saint-GobainContainersInc

55101,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4208611,34899513,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC

55101,,NOX,,85,100,100,,,Y,R,4208611,34899613,,,,! cdate=12/31/2015: Saint Gobain: Control Device= oxyfuel -plant= SAINT-GOBAINCONTAINERSINC