Danielle Lewis - Fwd: RE: FW: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA 

HQ     QW 2009-0819 - Prompt Response Requested 

>>> "Boyce, Cari" <Cari.Boyce@duke-energy.com> 7/25/2013 9:12 AM >>>

Yes, that is the correct mailing address.  I have highlighted one addition which will expedite delivery once the 

package arrives.  Thank you for confirming the correct address.

Mr. Nathan Craig

Duke Energy

526 South Tryon Street, EC 13K

Charlotte, NC 28202

From: Thomas Finseth [mailto:Thomas.Finseth@erg.com] 

Sent: Thursday, July 25, 2013 9:07 AM

To: Boyce, Cari

Cc: Bartram, Deborah; Jordan, Ron; Craig, Nathan D; alicea.jezebele@epa.gov

Subject: RE: FW: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA HQ QW 2009-0819 - Prompt 

Response Requested

Ms. Boyce,

Thank you for resubmitting your request for information from the Steam Electric Docket and including the 

certification statement. We noted that the revised letter includes two mailing addresses for Mr. Nathan Craig 

(one of which is a PO Box).  As was stated in the recent email from Jezebele Alicea, we cannot mail the packages 

to P.O. Boxes.  Therefore, we want to confirm that the information can be mailed to the following address that 

was included in the letter:

Mr. Nathan Craig

Duke Energy

526 South Tryon Street

Charlotte, NC 28202

We want to confirm that this is the correct street address because in previous correspondence with Mr. Craig, we 

have used 526 South Church Street as the mailing address. We would appreciate if you could confirm the correct 

mailing address so we don't experience any delays in the delivery of the information.

Thanks again,

From: Thomas Finseth

To: Lewis, Danielle

Date: 7/29/2013 8:08 AM

Subject: Fwd: RE: FW: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA HQ     QW 2009-0819 - Prompt 

Response Requested

Page 1 of 4

file:///C:/Users/DLewis/AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/51F62309DOM-ChaPO1-Cha10... 7/29/2013
From: Boyce, Cari [mailto:Cari.Boyce@duke-energy.com] 

Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2013 4:04 PM

To: Alicea, Jezebele

Cc: Covington, James; Jordan, Ronald

Subject: RE: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA HQ QW 2009-0819 - Prompt Response 

Requested

Ms. Alicea-Virella,

Per your email below, attached is an updated request for information which includes the requisite certification 

regarding confidential business information.

Thank you,

Cari Boyce

From: Alicea, Jezebele [mailto:Alicea.Jezebele@epa.gov] 

Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2013 11:28 AM

To: Boyce, Cari

Cc: Covington, James; Jordan, Ronald

Subject: RE: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA HQ QW 2009-0819 - Prompt Response 

Requested

Greetings Mr. Boyce!

EPA received your request for “all information related to Duke Energy’s facilities outlined in table 

below, including information that EPA has derived from information obtained from these facilities 

and from all other sources, and including facility-specific or facility-derived information in input files 

to” certain documents found on the docket for the Steam Electric ELG rulemaking. 

EPA has made available substantial data and other information relating to the proposed rule in the 

docket for the steam electric power generating effluent guidelines rulemaking, including data relating 

to the specific facility(ies) you identified, data about other plants where that data is not claimed as 

confidential business information or could lead to the disclosure of confidential business information, 

Duke Energy Facilities

Allen Steam Station Hanging Rock Energy Facility

Belews Creek Steam Station Washington Energy Facility II

Buck Steam Station Fayette Energy Facility

Catawba Nuclear Station Asheville Steam Electric Plant

Cliffside Steam Station Brunswick Steam Electric Plant

Oconee Nuclear Station Cape Fear Steam Electric Plant

Dan River Steam Station Shearon Harris Nuclear Plant

W.S. Lee Steam Station H.F. Lee/Wayne County

Marshall Steam Station Mayo Electric Generating Plant

McGuire Nuclear Station L V Sutton Steam Electric Plant

Riverbend Steam Station W H Weatherspoon Plant

East Bend Station Roxboro Steam Plant

William H. Zimmer Station Sherwood Smith Energy Complex

Walter C. Berkjord Station H.B. Robinson

Miami Fort Station Anclote

Cayuga Generating Station P.L. Bartow

Edwardsport Generating Station Crystal River - Units 1, 2 and 3

R. Gallagher Generating Station Crystal River - 4 and 5

Gibson Generating Station Hines Energy Complex

Noblesville Generating Station Suwanne Steam Plant

Wabash River Generating Station

Page 2 of 4

file:///C:/Users/DLewis/AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/51F62309DOM-ChaPO1-Cha10... 7/29/2013
equations used to estimate several key outputs such as costs, and a description of the various 

methodologies used by EPA (e.g., costing methodologies, pollutant loadings methodologies, etc.).  In 

addition to this publicly available data, in response to your request, EPA is planning to forward under 

separate correspondence additional data that provides plant-specific compliance costs and pollutant 

removals that EPA estimated would be attributable to the proposed rule, as well as plant-specific 

input values that were used in EPA’s cost models, pollutant loadings/removal models, and 

environmental assessment models. EPA is planning to provide a description of how each plant can 

use available data to make relevant calculations, such as how to calculate pollutant loadings.  EPA 

believes these data, in addition to the publicly available data already provided in the docket, provide 

you with sufficient information to understand any effects the proposed rule may have on your 

facilities and to comment effectively on the proposed rule, and this data represents the extent of 

information that EPA can make available to you without disclosing, directly or indirectly, information 

claimed as confidential business information by other sources. 

To ensure that confidential business information is only released to an authorized official, EPA 

requires that you submit your request on company letterhead using the certification statement below.  

The certifying official must be a responsible corporate official or his/her authorized representative.

Certification Statement

“I certify under penalty of law that I am a responsible corporate official or his/her authorized representative of 

[fill in name of corporate entity] and am authorized to request confidential business information on behalf of my 

company.  I certify that [fill in name of corporate entity] is the majority owner or the operator for each facility 

(and for each unit at each facility) for which we are requesting confidential business information. I am aware 

that there may be significant penalties for submitting false information including the possibility of fines and 

imprisonment, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1001. ”

In addition, you must provide the name (if not the certifying official) and mailing address (no P.O. 

boxes) for receipt of the requested information.  Mailing addresses must be accessible to a commercial 

courier service (e.g., Federal Express).

Have a blessed day!

Sincerely,

Jezebele Alicea-Virella

Environmental Engineer

Phone No: 202-566-1755

Fax No: 202-566-1053

EPA-Office of Water/OST/EAD

Mail Code: 4303T

1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20460

From: Boyce, Cari [mailto:Cari.Boyce@duke-energy.com] 

Sent: Wednesday, June 19, 2013 10:25 AM

To: Alicea, Jezebele; Covington, James

Subject: Request for Release for Information from Docket No. EPA HQ QW 2009-0819 - Prompt Response 

Requested

Please see attached request for release of information from docket no. EPA HQ QW 2009-0819. 

Feel free to contact me with any questions.

Thanks,

Cari Boyce

Cari Boyce | Vice President, Environmental & Energy Policy | Duke Energy

Page 3 of 4

file:///C:/Users/DLewis/AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/51F62309DOM-ChaPO1-Cha10... 7/29/2013
410 S. Wilmington Street, PEB 12 A | Raleigh, NC 27601 | 919.546.7314 | cari.boyce@duke-energy.com

TJ Finseth

ERG

14555 Avion Parkway, Suite 200

Chantilly, VA 20151

(703) 633-1698 (phone)

(703) 263-7479 (fax)

thomas.finseth@erg.com

Page 4 of 4

file:///C:/Users/DLewis/AppData/Local/Temp/XPgrpwise/51F62309DOM-ChaPO1-Cha10... 7/29/2013