Comments on 2010 ADEQ Network Plan

Please update next year’s annual network plan to reflect the following comments:

• The monitor/site tables for Pb, PM10 and PM2.5on pages 66-70 in should include

the specific dates for the last two semi-annual flow audits should be included in

each applicable site report.

• The monitor/site tables for PM25should include the date ofthe last PEP audit

performed.

• The monitor/site tables for the gaseous pollutant on pages 62-65 should contain

information pertaining to the residence times, probe material used, and the date of

the last NPAP audit performed.

• The Hayden Old Jail monitor/site table on page 65 states that the SO2 monitor

operating at this site is part of the SLAMS network, while the site is also

described as a part of the Source Compliance Monitoring Network in Table 4.7-1

on page 25. Please clarify the characterization ofthe SO2monitoring at this site.

• The monitoring sites in Miami are characterized as part of ADEQ’s SIP sites and

the Source Compliance Monitoring Network. Please clarify the characterization of

monitoring at these sites. Also, Appendix A and D should include information

pertaining these sites.

• Section 4.0 should include a section describing the required Pb monitoring

requirements. For example, Pb monitoring at Globe Highway should not be

considered part of the Source Compliance Monitoring Network (Table 4.7-I)

since Pb monitoring at this location is required by the CFR not a PSD permit

requirement. This section should also describe the Pb monitoring location recently

established in Miami, AZ.
ENCLOSURE 4

Public Hearing Documentation

Public Notice

Publication Certification

Public Hearing Agenda

Public Hearing Sign-in Sheet

Public Hearing Transcript

Public Hearing Officer Certification

Responsiveness Summary
(This Page Intentional/v Left Blank)
Jaice N Qyc,nor

PUBLIC NOTICE H€s R. Oin, D,edor

ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY

30 DAY PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD AND HEARING ON THE

PROPOSED 2013 NOGALES PM NONATTAINMENT AREA PLAN

STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN REVISION

The Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) opens a thirty day public comment

period with the publication of this notice on Friday. August 2, 2013, for the proposed 2013

Nogales PM2.5Nonattainment Area Plan Arizona State Implementation Plan (SIP) Revision.

A public hearing on the proposed SIP revision will be held on Tuesday. September 3. 2013. at

1:30 p.m.. in the City of Nogales Council Chambers. 777 N. Grand Ave. Nogales. AZ 85621. All

interested parties will he given an opportunity at the public hearing to submit comments, data.

and views, orally and in writing. Written comments may be submitted prior to or during the

public hearing and must be postmarked or received at ADEQ by 5:00 p.m. on September 3,

2013.

Written comments should be addressed, faxed, or c-mailed to John Englander. Air Quality

Division. State Implementation Plan Section. Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.

1110 W. Washington St., Phoenix. AZ 85007, FAX: (602) 771-2366. E-Mail:

englander. john @ azdeg . go’

Copies of the proposed SIP are available for review, Monday through Friday, between 8:30 a.m.

and 4:30 p.m.. at the ADEQ Records Center, 1110 W. Washington St., Phoenix. AZ 85007.

(602) 771-4712. The proposed SIP can also be viewed online at

http://www.azdeq.gov/enviroiair/plan/index.html by selecting Air Quality — Public Notices.

Meetings, and Hearings.

Persons with a disability may request a reasonable accommodation such as a sign language

interpreter, by contacting Alicia Pollard. (602) 771-4791, via email ppllard.alicia@ azdeq.gov.

TDD line for hearing impaired individuals, (602) 771-4829. Requests should he made as early as

possible to allow time to arrange the accommodation.
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION

ELISA BERMtJDEZ

being first

Duly sworn, deposes and says: That (he) (she) is the Agent to the Publisher ofthe

NOGALES INTERNATIONAL newspaper printed and published two days week

in the City ofNogales, County of Santa Cruz, State ofArizona. That the notice, a

copy of which is hereto attached, described as follows:

30 DAY PUBIC C0ENT

PERIOD & HEARING ON

THE PROPOSED 2013

NOGALES PM2 .5 NON

AIAINMENT AREA PLAN

was printed and published in the regular and entire issue of said

NOGALES INTERNATIONAL for 2 issues, that the first was

made on the 2nd day of AUGUST

and the last publication thereof was made on the 9th day of

AUGUST 20 13 that said publication

was made on each ofthe following dates, to wit:

08/02/13

08/09/13

Request of EQ ARIZONA DEPARTMENT 0

NOGALES INTERNATIONAL

268 W VIEW POINT, NOGALES, AZ 85621 (520)375-5760

By

Subscribed sworn to before me this 9th day of AUGUST

20

13

Notary Public in and for the County of Santa Crez, State of Arizona

My Commission Expires:

STATE OF ARiZONA

COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ

)

)

SS

20 13
ADEQLJ

Aronrtment

1.

Public Hearing Agenda HR. Dmin. D.ect

AIR QUALITY DIVISION

HEARING ON THE PROPOSED

ARIZONA STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN REVISION FOR THE

NOGALES PM2.NONATTAINMENT AREA PLAN

Tuesday, September 3, 2013, at 1:30 p.m.

City of Nogales Council Chambers

777 N. Grand Aye, Nogales, AZ 85621

Pursuant to 40 CFR § 51.102 notice is hereby given that the above referenced meeting is open to the

public.

I. Welcome and Introductions

2. Purposes of the Oral Proceeding

3. Procedure for Making Public Comment

4. Brief Overview of the Proposed SIP Revision

5. Question and Answer Period

6. Oral Comment Period

7. Adjournment of Oral Proceeding

Copies of the proposed SIP are available for review. Monday through Friday, between 8:30 a.m. and 4.30

p.m.. at the ADEQ Records Center. 1110W. Washington St., Phoenix, AZ 85007. (602) 771-4712. The

proposed SIP can also be viewed online at http://www.azdeq.gov/environ/air/plan/index.html by

selecting Air Quality — Public Notices, Meetings. and Hearings. For additional information regarding the

hearing please call John Englander, ADEQ Air Quality Division. at (602) 771 -4781 or 1-800-234-5677,

Ext. 771-4781.

Persons with a disability may request a reasonable accommodation such as a sign language interpreter, by

contacting Alicia Pollard at (602) 771-4791. or via email: pollard.alicia@azdeq.gov. TDD line for hearing

impaired individuals, (602) 771-4829. Requests should be made as early as possible to allow time to

arrange the accommodation.
ADEQS Air Quality Division Arizona Department ofEnvironmentaIOua1itv<(!J Sign-In Sheet

Please Sign In

SUBJECT: Proposed Arizona State Implementation Plan Revision for the Nogales PM Nonattainment Area

DATE: June 21, 2013

NAME ORGANIZATION PHONE E-MAIL

(primary method of contact)

4.

5.

6.

7.
1 PROPOSED ARIZONA AIR QUALITY

2 STATE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN (SIP) REVISION FOR THE

3

4 NOGALES PM5NONATTAINMENT AREA

5

6 Oral Proceeding

7 Transcript

8

September 3. 2013

10

1 1 Amancla Stone: Good afternoon, thank you for coming. Even though there is an empty room for

12 a little bit. I now open hearing on the proposed Arizona State Implementation Plan Revision for

13 the Nogales PM25 Nonattainment Area.

14

is It is now Tuesday. September 3, 2013: at 1:35 p.m.. The location is the City of Nogales Council

16 Chambers. 777 N. Grand Ave. Nogales, AZ 85621.

17

18 My name is Amanda Stone. and I have been appointed by the Director of the Department of

19 Environmental Quality (ADEQ) to preside at this proceedings.

20

21 The purpose of this proceeding is to provide the public an opportunity to:

22

23 (1) hear about the substance of the proposed SIP revisions:

24 (2) ask questions regarding the revisions: and.

25 (3) present oral argument, data and views regarding their revisions in the form of comments in

26 the form of comments on the record.

27

28 .John Englander is here representing ADEQ from the Air Quality Division, State Implementation

29 Plan Section.

30
1 Public notice appeared in the Nogales International and on ADEQ’s website beginning August

2 2, 2013. Copies of the proposed SIP revision were made available at the ADEQ Public Records

3 Center and ADEQ’s website beginning August 2, 2013.

4

5 The procedure for making a public comment on the record is straightforward. If you wish to

6 comment, you need to fill out a speaker slip, which is available at the sign-in table, outside the

7 room here, and give it to me. Using speaker slips allows everyone an opportunity to be heard and

8 allows us to match the name on the official record with the comments. You may also submit

9 written comments to me today.

10

11 Please note, the comment period for the proposed SIP revision ends today, September 3, 2013.

12 All written comments whether they were sent via U.S. mail or via e-mail or via FAX must be

13 postmarked and or received by ADEQ by 5:00 p.m. today.

14

15 Comments made during the formal public comment period are required by law to be considered

16 by ADEQ when preparing the final SIP. This is done through the preparation of a responsiveness

17 summary in which the Department responds in writing to written and oral comments made

18 during the formal public, during the formal comment period.

19

20 The agenda for this hearing is simple. First, we will present a brief overview of the proposed

21 revision to the SIP.

22

23 Second. I will conduct a question and answer period. The purpose of the question and answer

24 period is to provide information that may help you in making comments on the proposed

25 revision.

26

27 Thirdly. I will conduct the oral comment period to call speakers in the order that I have received

28 their speaker slips.

29

2
1 Please be aware that any comments at todays hearing that you want the Department to formally

2 consider must he given either in writing or on the record at today’s hearing during the oral

3 comment period of this proceeding.

4

5 At this time, Mr. Englander will give a brief overview of the proposal.

6

*

8

9 John Englander: The Nogales Non Attainment Area was designated nonattainment for the 2006

io PM2.5 National Ambient Air Quality Standards (or NAAQS) based on monitoring data from

11 2006-2008. PM2.conditions in the region have improved since that time. On January 7. 2013.

12 subsequent to the designation. EPA finalized a clean data determination for the Nogales planning

13 area under the Clean Data Policy. This action suspended requirements to submit State

14 Implementation Plan (or SIP) elements related to attainment of the NAAQS including reasonable

15 further progress milestones, attainment demonstrations, control measures, and contingency

16 measures. This state implementation plan revision addresses the remaining Clean Air Act

17 requirements applicable to the Nogales Non Attainment area.

18

19 The document outlines general economic and demographic information of the nonattainment

20 area and Santa Cruz County, the Clean Air Act requirements for a Nonattainment Area Plan, a

21 description of the air quality monitoring network and recent ambient air quality data for the area.

22 an emissions inventory, a description of new source review and permitting requirements for the

23 area, and general conformity requirements.

24

25

26

27 Ms. Stone: This concludes the explanation period of this proceeding on the proposed revision to

28 the SIP.

29

30

31

3
1 Are there any questions before we move to oral comment period?

2

3 Hearing none, this concludes the question and answer period of this proceeding on the proposed

4 revision to the SIP.

5

6

7

8 I now open this proceeding for oral comments.

0

10 We received no speaker slips, so this concludes the oral comment period for this proceeding.

11

12

13

14 If you have not already submitted written comments, you may submit them at this time. Again,

15 the comment period for this proposed revision to the SIP ends today, September 3, 2013, at 5:00

16 p.tiL

17

18 Thank you.

19

20 And the time is now 1:40 p.m.. I now close this oral proceeding.

21

4
ADEQ

Arizona Department

of Environmental Quality ‘t?P

Air Quality Division

Public Hearing Presiding Officer Certification

I, Amanda Stone, the designated Presiding Officer, do hereby certify that the public hearing held

by the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality was conducted on September 3, 2013, at

the City of Nogales Council Chambers, 777 N. Grand Aye, Nogales, AZ 85621, in accordance

with public notice requirements by publication in the Nogales Ini’ernational beginning August 2,

2013. Furthermore, I do hereby certify that the public hearing was recorded from the opening of

the public record through concluding remarks and adjournment, and the transcript provided

contains a full, true, and correct record of the above-referenced public hearing.

Dated this 544 day of 4euJ€.

ianda Stone/

State of Arizona )

) ss.

County of Maricopa )

Subscribed and sworn to before me on this

day of 1$

Notary Public

My commission expires:

Maic County

My Comtion E*pircs

‘P’ December 18,2014
RESPONSIVENESS SUMMARY

to

Testimony Taken at Oral Proceeding and Written Comments Received on

Arizona State Implementation Plan Revision Jrthe Nogales PM2.5iVonattainment Area

The oral proceeding on the Proposed Arizona State hnp/ementation Plan Revision ,/r the

Nogales PM2.5Nonattainineni Area was held on Tuesday. September 3. 1:30 p.m., at the City of

Nogales Council Chambers. 777 N. Grand Ave. Nogales. AZ 85621. The public comment period

closed on Tuesday. September 3, 2013. No oral or written comments were received during the

coniment period. During its final review of the proposed SIP. the Arizona Department of

Environmental Quality determined no further clarifications were needed.