U N ITED STATES E N VIRO NM ENTAL P ROTECTION AGE

. NCY WASHI N GTON , D

. C 20.:00 

### AUG 1 7 2£:6

, \U : MORANDUM OFf 1 C£ OF C H £ L1 1CA L SAf,r'f' A "I O J'Ol lU llON l'REVC <J no ti

SU OJ E CT: BE .- \D Chemic .a

l Prolil< { llCI• ) for Rcgis1rn:ti o n**C\\ ~**  1 \cr o lcin (000 7 0 1 )
FROM :

T lll tl:: t'a rl**t·h~n. ol** **o~is t**  Uiologic ; 1 I t

\n n l yl\i' l\rnnch
01.·n:k U t'f'\ \'ll l J. l ! cono 1 ni st Eco n1 J rnic**\n 31** **i~** l lr n n c h 

### ll iolo g ic nl and**co on** **1i c**  

### t \na ly !"is Di\'i sio n (750J I ')

1 \mct Jone s.. Chief**~** 

### Biolosical**\nal~** :-. i..; rJnin · Diann Sirn s
.

# Ch**f** (,

# J~~**r~/--'** Science lnf o

rm : ui o n a nd**\nal~ s**  

### Branch



# ,,., · J L,,,,**~** 

### 11 /{1( 

# ltf Timothy Kiel y. Chief 

# n )

0**U.,I/.) ~**  

## L e

u uu 

## f • • timO 

# '7
Eco n o mi c**\n :i.l~** **s** ll m n ch ll iolo g ic al and I Z conornii: 

### 1 \n : · 1t

ysis 11i\ • i sion (750 3 1 

### 1 )



## · r<>:**Ke l~** **·** B:illard. Chcn 1h : : 11 Kc \'iC \\ '**~:fan:igcr** Ri s. k**~1 an:igcn** **cn 1**  n n d l11 1p l c111cntation Bran1,:h l 1)1.

"S t icidc Rt:--<\' : llu : ll i on l >l\'ision (7$0 81) ) QJ)ic c of l'es1ic i dc Pr og rarn .s ( OPP )

Pr o d1.1c1 Kt\ it\\ ' P'anrl d:atr: June 1 7

.**201~**

' fhc l iio l og ic a l nn d Ec o nom i c**\nn y~i,:;** **l)i\'i ~io** **n** (BE1\0) Chc 1 nic : 1 I Pr o l i lt

: ( li C I' ) pm\'idc s a n O

\ ' Cr\'iC\\ ' <.•ft hc p: s t 1 1 1::iJ1::ai;en 1c n1 r o l e an d**t. 1u** **;: 1n** **1i1 t1i\'c**  U Sl-lge inl C.nn .: u i o n a \ • a il nblc t O

r a pc)tt icid c:
. ln l "onn:11ion pr.J\'itl1.xl i u th is l'J (' J 1 nl:J) ' be used by !<>tnkc: ho l Jcr s ( e
. g
. . ll 'ic r s and**rcgi~ r.rnt.s)** **.** O PI

- , risk a n d lx-nc l i t**l'~ .,c..·** **~n 'S** **.** ()Pl' risk n1 :i.n:igcrs. nnd lhc i;.c n c:r. 1 1 public Jur i n t: the:**R1:i;i~1ro1ion** Re,
· ic,, · proce ss of u c ro lc:i n
.1 \crol.:in \\ ' 35 registe r ed in the U ni te d St :.) tc s in 1959

. I t is**r"~s stc** **cd** ns ;1n he r bicide :i. nd ri l gici de

, , · i th lL .;c s it es suc h as irriGation syslems

. (t i s a l so r c gistcf\.'d as :in :i ntin1ier ob i a l , ,;lh use .s ite s suc h tL$ !'>CCt) n<lu ry oi l rc eo,·e ry in je ct ion sys1e n 1s

. Fom1ulntit > n S of**it~** cu<l-usc products include prc ssurii.c J l iqu i d :i.nd sol ubl e conce nt r.uc / l iquid ('LUIS. 201 4 ). : \Cf\ )lci n e ar l be app l ied as a \\'a ter t r cau 1 1cnt u s i ng i nject i o n cqu ipn 1 cn t ( I .U IS

. 

### 20 1 -1)

. Ae r olc in i :< re gis t ered l br co n trol of aquatic ,, · ccds su' h us**bnu:~r.;: ..,** **'(( nd**  tlo lt in s , · eget:it ion

. a l ga e. a n d n1i croorgn ni sn 1 s su ..:h a-. s l inlc· I O

n11i ng fun g i and bac teri a (PPLS. 

### 2015; Nl' IR S, 

### 201 S ). l lS end.use prod u ct

.**agnJe c**  

### 1-1 Herbi c i <lc. has a l so b("cn r("gi stcreti t O

r u.'\c i n i rrig Jt i o n eanJls and rcscn · o irs u n de r F ll :R.- \ Scc 1i on 2 4 (c) i n n1ult ipl c sta t es su c h 35 Ca l iforn i a. Ind i an an
. · Oregon. :'lnJ U r nh (Nf'll { S. 20 1 5). 1 \ ero l c in ·s s ite o f ac t ion has not bee n c ln

. • --s ilieJ by 1hc 11crbicide**l~csistancc** 1 \ct i on Comn1i 11cc: o r 1 h

e \\ • \

.

-cd Science Soc iet y of i \n 1cric a ( \\ ,. SS 1 \ ) ( Hlt
· \C. 20 1 5: WSS,\. 20 1 5)

. 13E J \D p rcp ;i r e<l 1:1 s unu na.ry of ac r olci n a h em.:st i \'e S a n d a discussio n of u n ..: crto intic s i n 2008 (El" • : \

. 2008a). : \t t hat tim e. O E1 \D ,, . :JS un ub h: l <t i<lcn t i (' ' \ \ ' 01kab l c chcn 1 ica l ahema1ivcs to ncro lci n iO r '' ' cc:J Cl)l lt ro l in i rrig,n t ion can a l s. The r e '' ' ere mcchn ni cn l ruc :in s of e<l nt rol i dentified. s uch n.s chn ining c n n

n l s
. but 1 h

o s e arc**po te** **nt !~** **·** n 1 o rc e
. 1o;pc n si , · c tha n nc ro l ci n , ht:1\ ' c r isks. of a cciden ts t o , , · orkers. a nd m a ) · m a ke i i d i llicuh 1 0 n 11.• c1 '' ' a h !r**qua lit~** **·** s t andards. The su mm ll l) ' of n'-' r o h: i n :1 h.:rn a. 1i \'CS ne kn o,vl cd g c in 1ponan t u n c

ert ai nt ies. ; i nd r cquc s tc<l c o n u 11cnt' fro n 1 i

rriga ti on p rofes.s i on ; 1ls on 1hc i n1 p<i rt nncc: l' '.lf aero lei n and a1 t c n 1a t i \
· cs: t h ese '' ' e r e su n1n1 .ar i zcd in n n ot h er BE 1 \D d oc un1cn t (EP : \ 2008b). The con 1 mc:n t s i:on lirrn c:.·J t hlt mechan ic al met h ods '" ere n1on: e xpensive l h:tn ncr olci n. and eau.'\cd n1orc d an 1 :igc to earthen lint't l cu n n

l s. 14 1 !1 \I) asked a.bout n hcrn at i \'es. :i n d rc-cci,
· ed co n 1n 1 cnt s o n sc , · cr..11

. bul all of1hc-sc

,, · ere i dent ifi ed \\ i t

h < l ifficu l t i c s s u b s t ituti ng t O

r ncro l l.'in

- h ig h..:-r use rntc s
. highc r co s t l ong required c ontac t t in1c

. poo r eo n1r ol o r re<iu ir

.. "( f ho ld i ng t i 1

nc i n t he c ana l n t )cr a 1 , p 1 ic at i on \\ ' ere t ypic al**'on1p nL** **~.**

· 1

11

.. •f\.' have**co** no B E1 \ D be nefi ts asscss n1cn1 s o r l)E, , \ 0**n, '\.,"CS:-.** **'tt11:-nl~** l br 1 : 11 : R 1 \ Section I S cn1c r g c nc)· cxc r np1 i o n r l.'qucsts t O

r a crol cin i n t he Jast J 0 yea r s. \\ ' hilc :ln c n tc r t:cncy cxc n 1p 1 ion rcquc- s t nta) ' )ic ld i nfonna ti on :tbo ut :i c l 11.' 1 nical
· s in1pon:incc o r \ ' ;;t l uc t h at is nol found in (l t hc r E P 1 \ r ecords. th!! l:ick of :i F I FR.t\ Sc-ctlo n 1 S asscss 1ncnt b) '**T\1 ~1** **)** doc s n ot s pcciften l ly indicate t he rcl:il i \'c im porta n ce of t h is chc r n i ..:a l. Qu:int i tati \ • e us.age i n l

O

m1 111ion t b r nc ro ll.'i n i s no t ava i lable

. cxccp l**th~ 1** **;: ppro~i** **rn ttcl~** **'** -0nc m i lli on po u nds ofncti\
· c ingred ie nt ,, · ere sold annu ; 11ly (EP1\. :?008c). Oh 1a i ni ng t he t O

ll o\ \' i n g i n fontl:t ti on n 1 a.y i n 1

pro,·c**futu~** a ssessments r l.' l

n 1

('(( 1 0 th e tL<;c :ind im porta n ce o f ac r olcin : I) t o t

al pou n ds of ncti,
· c in grcd ic1 1 t 3pJ1 l icd per yea r on a na t iona l ; i nd / or rcg. i O n

l l ba s i s: :2) opp l icnt ion rJt("S: tyμi c
. a l an d m a.x i n 1

un 1 : 3) th.-qucney ::ind i nt e r vals of appl i c at ion: ;in d .i) e Oicac ) · i n fonn: 11i o n .' p r t-xl uct pcr fom1an c c
.REFERENCES

EP1 \

. 2008:1

. 1 \ c ro l c i n 1 \llcmnt ivcs 1 \ ss .: s.. <i> 11 1 ..:-nt Sun101 al') ' an d Un ccnain t ic s (DP #3346 S O)

. iv 1 o r

c h 16, 20 08. EP1 \ 200Sb. Re spo n ses 1 0 Ct)t nrn C"n t s J {ece i \ ' C d o n the 1 \ cro l cin Rcr ci; i str.tlio n 1 : ti g_ib ili l)' Decis i o n ( DP # 3 537 91 ). 1 \u g u s 1 27

. 2008. EP.- \

. 2008 <.:
. R cn:gis t rat ion**li gibi** **lit~ ·**  Deci s i o n · .i \c r olci n
. U ni l cd Slltlc!\ En\' i r(l nn1 1.'n to l P rol cct i o n Agency. 1 \ c c css t.'tl**l:i y**  2015 :it ht 1 p : / / \\ '\

\ '\

\ '

. c p; 1

. g o, ·/ pcsl i c i d c:v ' rc ri:g i s I r. 11 i on :' R l i l > .., ::icrQ. l c i n

_ t'-' '-Ll xi r'

. I llt 1 \ C. 20 1 5

. (' l n.o;s il ic ati on o f Herb ici de s 1 \ c c o rd i ng to S i te o f 1 \ ct i o n
. 1 lcrbi c.: i<lc**Rc ~t:lnC** **I.'** : \ ction Co1 nrn i 11cc: ( I IR 1 \ C)

. 1 \cccsscd i\l ay 20 1 5 a t ht t p: l/ hr.u:s l l'l h.1 l.c o 111 /

. I.UIS

. 201 4. Th e La b d Use l n fo nnOli o n Sysi cm (LU I S) Rcp011 for 1 \ cro lci n. Augus 1 26

. 201 4

. Bi ological and Eco n on 1 ic An:ilys i s l> iv i sio n
. E l'' J \ O t)icc o f Pcs1 icid c P rogran1s

. NPIRS. 2015

. Fl.'dcra l :ind s- 1 a cc r l.'g is 1 ra. t ion$. l\\1 ti on.:il Pest i c i d e lnt O

rm at i o n Rctricvu l S y s1 c11 1 {N l"' I R S)

. 1 \ccc ss cd**fay** 20 1 5 at hllp :!.' np i r s.c c ris

. nur J u c
. l.' ( lu. PPLS

. 20 1 5

. E P 1 \

- ;1pp r o vcd 1"- -eh n i<:i:t l C L n J**..:n u.** **~** jlroducL <;/

la

bel $ $UCh as**~· agnic** **dcT'.'.r** H ll crbi c idc an d**la ni** **Tr.t** B f\.licrob i oci d c
. The Pe s t

ici de P roduc t**:t~I** S )'$ l C lll ( PP LS). A c cessed Ma y 2015 01 hup :// \\**""" gs,** **1\ pc:** **~ti._ ci_<** **~$.'Chc: n**  M::t rch f J ' !

)Js :' O I ( 1 707 -C.>00(1Q.:!0 l -l 07 3 I

. pd f and h 11p :// \\'\\'\ \')

. cp a.g o\ '/

P£st i ci d cs / c;hc m**sc~ 1n,;J** **pp J~** **:' O**  1 0 707

- C)O O I**tl 201** **~** 1 2 1 1

. pd l'. \\

" SS: \. 20 1 5. R..: s i s t anc c 

### \\ ' e "" >.lfs. \\ 1 c-c d 

### S c i ence S o ciety of 

### 1 \n 1 c ric a ( \\ ' SS, \ ). 

### 1 \ccc-s.scd ri.
· f i. 1 y 20 1 5 ::i i h 1tp ;// ,\ ' Cc d s.c i c n cc , l"1rg.i:::ulnn 1 : 1 0 .b 11t. !f 1.r

t. '>N

.