OFFICE OF THE AHORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS



### 0 **of rtght** 

**plant by**  **HI s,**  **ken of**  **WBt Team** *



### utslitie8 **406**atn&ixpeot to illstan

it in It ir ale0my ~erstim&Sng **net** **k*prerent** **8nr** profit

**ewoat bsecum**  a eowtitor **in** l

**usb** bueincaer **Th*** log&$of enoh wastsudion in oral2 lllwtrmul by the etla(l oi 3wtton ** AmerlaanlhmeLira Ixmlmwo Go,, ms 8. f. 893 Pt. Earth Cl+. Appt. tit refussd, *herob it riraa

oodtandsll

bet rr6l.r ef 5saoW **ot one**  **lpearanee oompany**  **to another**  **vlolatedl the**  aatl-tmut ana antl4aenopoly st8tutm (sewartidliw 7486 wa 7489,'R,..Q.

8. 1985). the &.wt raittt After referring to theaq etatntee,Hanorablo Wa2tu Xunhiaont Page PI

. 1

‘y :.

;.

.. ‘

. "Xf &Whiff balow had 6otorain.d to tlisSOlYO, it outala2y had the right to de a0 w4.r the law, w the aala, ttE4.r tha ~lrouastaaoos, of it5 9X0 0**QrtiQ@** OOU~ tWt **tOlId** 80 **PPUOilt OP**  1WSOlk eompet1 'ion." To the a~&~ effoot$6 thi dooi8ion or then Tome 8tipro.i

Court in **Oater** v. Hoowr, 90 Fez. 863, 39 S. W. 1009 (qaoteU with approval

in **Lamar** T. Smith,196 8. W. 964 at 979) ~uhwdnth~eoqrtB.olandt

*XI& 

### twdu to awatitato a trust*ithinthe sumnineof the atatut~ 

### thuo **most** be a *oambination of 5a ital.skill,or aotr 

### by twcor morsrt WOW binit 4 en* ‘ as hue rued,mqans unionor l a s o o i a ti o~. **Xf** thmr~ **be no**  **onion** or @aaoqiatlon **.bf %wo** or **mwa** oi the&r *6epitol stillor aotis' then asn be aa 'oomb~tion ,' mui henorno ‘trust’ . . . When wo eonsidu tha pu~posoo for rhiah tha. Qombiaatlon~

muat bo f&ma& to bosa withinthe statute, the eaaantiel mating of the word 'aoabln**ation ’**  and the **fwt** tbat a putddmtmt Ls **prew~bra.** ~‘fo$ l aoh b y that the $rwt oontln~so in a#iataaoo, '10 arm lad .@I

the aorrolwloon

that tho malenQT arao5iatioa or ~*.a ita2.aki21 P ar aotsgdomanood irr where, the. part aa In the pwtlotiiar oaw Uoufgt104 the unitadoo-opmation of suahagoaoias, whlah mlgh*"~ve othorriao boom Wlopotioat and oompetfng, .for,tM asoompliabmo~t oi one or more of saohparposo5.* f*~.OreagoP, 52 8. w. (U4) 463, the Appw25, in 8u5talalng the va2blfty uabelr tti antbtrwt l8w~ of a oontraat of birro2utioa

6f a putnurhip whoroby oao of the ptrtnon R fop on6 year the garrslino rot a oertain 8

mod to pUrchW0 f ISing statloafrom the otherpartmrr,

6.8elar5di

“Xt’mald thu8 appearthet **it** IS not the mre fact of oumblnetloa S.n itu ortinary~ssoso

that Ia doaounad by the &at&to, .bat the tom InOltrboa **dOdRIP** on the part of th6 partlos to ogfootuate

the mmomplisbmmt of one or tire of the prohibited purpoaes~~c 409

Eenorablo **Walter** 

### Mudhlsoa, Pa& 4

wnuer the foPogoing wthoPlt1oa 1t la oar optnion thkttbo DrwoaalarlebjiN'r~ Loonto tlm **West**T~ua~illhioa rortld **aotVio%ata** tho Mtl-tnut lnwa of Taur~- then being ae demlgn

or pta olimimto r@ l o a the put of either

oom@at 8iOn in t he W l5 **of** l

leotr 0 powr thareby. r Pty to FautAOO

or
A&ii l.wJB,

B. a. s. mis, P5aaa @I) fo22owt aa8oolation

tw oorporatloa now 

### tm&ir theMm of 

### third

Sate



### purpo5*,

l.eu*,

### ~22 or oth5nlaa dimpow of 'it8 

### tnthe phnt 

### OF buaineaa 

### OF anypartthereof,

### to any other fndividtml,

8aaoalatlon **or** oorporatiaa 

### whieh,'at

tb thao~of

raid’sala, 

### lwao o? other&iposltionof 5rSd p2wt ore**bnslnoaa** or any put thuroft b doing, or law l u t b a r it y

t0 U O - a 2i I t s b tt 5ltt O e a

in**isaid** lnoorpante6 Oity, town or &2ege.. Btothhg ?iuelB ahall aM2xelzo any **eor~ttou** to -go iD my **kind** of baeinoarr net euthorlti by lta &arterP G3m&aala ours) Tha aaderlirud wrda Ln the above it&t&a oloarly inYouF5tsry **tnily** AP~ovmJUN 15, lgf’ ATTORH3YO~OFTRXAS

Walter RdCooh