Kodak

j~f.'HJ f

AIR QUAL! YPLANNING

September 9, 2010

Mr. Robert Sliwinski

Director, Bureau of Air Quality Planning

Division of Air Resources

New York State Department of

Environmental Conservation

625 Broadway

Albany, NY 12233-3250

SUBJECT: 6NYCRR 249.1(cX3)

BART Eligibility Analysis for Eastman Kodak Company Small Emission

Sources at Eastman Business Park

Dear Mr. Sliwinski:

As you are aware, Eastman Kodak Company operates BART eligible sources at

Eastman Business Park in Rochester, New York. Visibility modeling has been

completed for three iarge boilers and four package boilers which indicated that a Five

Factor BART analysis for the three large boilers is required. The BART determination

for these sources will be submitted under separate cover to the Department prior to the

regulatory deadline (October 1, 2010). The package boilers are significantly below the

0.1 delta deciview exemption criteria specified in 6NYCRR 249.1(cX3).

In addition to the boilers, Kodak also operates small BART eligible sources at Eastman

Business Park. The attached spreadsheets identify these sources and quantify the

maximum daily emissions for SO" NO, and PM,•. Maximum Daily Emissions for the

Kodak BART eiigible sources are summarized in the following table:

BART Eligible Stack Height(s) Exemption Maximum Daily

Sources from Ground Modeling Change Emissions /lbs/dav)

Level (tt) In Visibility (ddv) SO, NO, PM"

41, 42, 43 Boilers 408 - 409 > 0.1 116,400 21,200 7,200

4 Packaoe Boilers 366 < 0.006 535 186 33

Highest Emitting 29 - 126 Not Modeled 120 386 166 Non-Boiler Sources

Based on maximum daily emission levels for the non-boiler sources that are similar to

the maximum daily emission levels for the package boilers and the significantly lower

stack heights for the non-boiler sources and in accordance with 6NYCRR 249.1(c)(3), it

is Kodak's conclusion based on engineering judgment that the non-boiler sources at

Eastman Business Park do not or will not emit any combination of visibility impairing
Kodak

pollutants that results in a visibility impairment equal to or greater than 0.1 deciviews in

any Federal Class I Area and that these sources are exempt from the provisions of Part

249.

Based on an e-mail from Scott Griffin (NYSDEC) to Michael Zapkin (Kodak) dated

02/05/2010 (Subject: Applicability of BART at Kodak) and on the NYSDEC proposed

rule comment response for small emission units with negligible impacts, Kodak believes

that this anaiysis represents "other means acceptable to the Department" as specified in

6NYCRR 249.1(cX3).

If there are any questions or if you require any additionai information, please contact me

at (585) 722-5827 or michael.zapkin@kodak.com.

Sincerely,

Michael A. Zapkin

Health, Safety & Environment

Eastman Kodak Company

Rochester, NY 14652-4543

cc: Mr. Scott Griffin, NYSDEC Albany

Mr. Tom Marriott, NYSDEC Region 8
Emission

Point

~_ 30460

09503

110Al

148Xl

101A2

101A3

08101

08102

301X1

--301X2

303A8

303Xl

303X2

304A8

304X1

304X2

325X3

110C6

Kodak Non-Boiler 502 Sources At Eastman Business Park

!! DI-\f\ I Max BART Max

I Emission I Stack Max Hourly Hourly Daily

Unit IHeight (ft) (Ibs/hr) (lbslh.rl .. _ (r"b~/day) _ Comments

U·00060 65 5 5 120 ~~_':!!ll. er:!!i~sio~s_~n..!E2Iled P'y'wet scrubber,

U-00008 1 126 0.76 0.76 __ 1_~ . •. ___

U-00052 50 0.73 ... __ ,. 0.73 18 _ ._ •.. _

u·06048 .50 .. 0,5 0.5 12 __ _. ,__ ._._, .__

U-00063 _.96 0,1 __ __ _ 0.1 _ _ ? . . _"

U·00063 59 0,07 0,07 2

U-00020 109 .~.qoJ __.. - _._·'-'()'001 - .--. ---6------ -.-----.- ,.-

~~~~~~ ~o;_,__ ~::~ ~.~~~--.- .:~~=-'~~-~~- -~ ----.

U-00060 42 O.Oot" -. 0,001 . ~_-_.~. 0_ ... .-

U-00060 52 0.001 0,001 0

U-00060 52 --- -- -- 0.001 0,001 '~=~~~Q_=~_~_~ __ U:00060 44" 0.001 0.001 _._._..Q_.'_I-"'__ U-00077 45 .._ 0.001 0.001 __._.__g__ . .__ . ~_.. . _

~~:~ ~-~----- --. --~~~~.-- ~:~~~--- ---t--t-·-·------·-·----·--·· -

-U-00053 29' ~, . 0.001 0.001 -- - 0 =- ----. ---.-..----------------.--.

U-OOOOl 36 9 0 - -_.. - 0 ~- ~OWtes V'{ashers reConstructed after 1981

TOTAL 172

Page 1 of 1

Revision Date: 09f08l2010

Printed: 9/8/2010 4:38 PM
Kodak Non-Boiler NO. Sources at Easbnan Business Park

BART Max BART Mall

EmtsslOf'l SUlek Max Hourty Hourly Daily

Emission Point Unil: Height (ftl (Ibslhr) (lbs/hrl (!bslday) Comments .. iJ.OOoos ..- _..- -- -_.

0950' 120 161 16.1 _. "" --- _._- .- 101A2 & 101A3 V<JOO6' 96&59 5.83 5.83 1<0 - - - - 57 -- 1<4302 1J-00019 85 '.36 '36

50201 1J-OOOO7 - - - Pa~ Qiiefaled dOOng hE!.~!~~lLseaSO!"

" 1.88 188 .. " - 5020' 1J-OOOO7 " 1.88 1.88 " - ~clI.age Boiler~I~during heaOOg season

11002 1J-00070 55 09 0.9 22 ---~ - -- 11085 1J-0007. - 25 0.9 0.9 ~, -. - -- 110Cl LI-Q9076 '0 0.625 0.825 15 --_._- -- -- -

'0885 U...... 57 0.192 0.192 5

03809 lJ.OO()<7 155 0.14 0.14 , - -- -- ---_.._-

08105 U-00020 109 0.13 . 013 .3 - - - -- - .- - 306.. U-OOO" 57 0094 0094 , --- u-000"04 a.O? ._-_.. -------

029U8 100 0,07 , .. .--- - - 08101 U-00020 109 0.067 0.087 , - - --- ... _. --_. -_.- - 05385 U-OOOll 153 0.024 oOZ<4 1 -. --,- -- -- ... 03802 U-Q0047 12' 0.017 0.017 0 - --'-06102 0.012 - - -

U·OOO20 10' 0.012 0 . 319Cl lj·OO6S6 75 , _. 0 0 Thermal Media Machine buill In 2005

U-OooSO - - 351CB 75 0.87 0 0 Hot 011 Healer buill in 1994

749 -- . ._------- - TOTAL

Page 1 of 1

Revision Dale: 0910812010

Printed: 91812010 4:3B PM
Kodak Non-Boiler Particulate Sources at Eastman Business Park

I

Comments

Aggregate 01 simaar wet ~befS

BART Max

Daily

(Ibs/day) _

.66

122

91

90

---=-~---= ---~-'- 77

69

55

55

55

..

"

37

26

22

18

16-

-13

13

1312 .- ,

9' - ,

,

,

,

,

,

8 - - -_. 8

7

7

7

7

7

7

7

7

7

5

5

5

5

5

5

<

<

<

<---- - 3

3

3

3

2 - 2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

1

1

BART Max

Hourty

(lbslhrJ

_t_~-~6:913

I 3.81

• __ 3L4._

3.5 '--3:2 _. -

287

2.31

2.31

2.31

....

1.8

15<

1.1 .- 0.93

0.77

0.66

0.56

0.531

0.53

0.5

- 0.39

0.38

0.38

0.38

-

0.38

0.38

0.38 - .

037

0.339 - ·033

029

0.28

0.28

028

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.229

0.22

0.22

0.22

0.22

0.201

0.17

0.16

015

0.15

0136

013

0.1\6

011

0.103

0.1

0.092

0.077 -

0.074

0072

0.072

0.068

0.... 0'" 0.06

006

Max Hourty

(Ibslhrl

6.93

5.' . 3.81

3.74

3.5

3.2 - 2.87

231

2.31

2.31

....

1.8

15<

1.1

0.93 •

0.77

066

6.56

0531

0.53

0.5

0.39

038

038

038

0.38

038

038 -

037

0.339

033

029. __ I

028

0.28

028

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.28

0.229

022

0.22

0.22

0.22

0.201

017

016

015

0.15

0138

0.13

0.116

011

0103

O'

0.092

ri 077 . 0.074

0072

0.072

0068

0 ...

0 ...

0.06

006

IEmission I Stack

I Unit IH4tlght (ftl

I U-00053 I 29

lJ.OOO14 97 I U<lOO6O 52

lJ.OOO14 77

I

lJ.OOOl1 153

lJ.OOO87 45

lJ.OOO24 76

U<lOO6O " U<lOO6O 52

U<lOO6O " l)..()()(l63 59

U-00087 50

U..ooooo 65

U.()OO77 45

U-oOoa7 38

U-00060 65

U·00063 96

U·00080 79

U-00080 75

U-00080 148 . lJ.OOO23 37

U-00080 110

U-00024 67

lJ.OOO24 54

lJ.OOO24 54

U<1OO2< 5<

lJ.OOO24 54

lJ.OOO24 59

I lJ.OOO24 52

I

t lJ.OOO24 39

.,..... 50

U-00023 9

lJ.OOO25 22

lJ.OOO24 51

U-00024 51

lJ.OOO24 51

U.()OO24 51

lJ.OOO24 51

U-00024 51

U-00087 29

U-00023 31

U-OOOOI 42

U-OOUOl 42

U-OOOOl 42

U-OOOOl 42

U-00087 37

U-00012 75

U-00087 36

U-oooaO 150

U-OOOl2 ISO

U-00024 46

U.oooa7 28

lJ.OOO25 I 22

U<lOO6O 3<

U.ooo24 38

U-00060 45

U-OOOl2 60

I U-()()()8(l 7\

t

U-00011 I '5<

U-00012 75

U-00012! \49

U-00024 I 90

U-00024 9

U-00024 9

U-00017 18

U-00024 93

Emission

Point

325X3

10105

303A8

10109

05335

3<9F7

317$1

301Xl

303Xl

JO<Xl

101A3

~9A5

JO<BO

304A8

~9F8

304X2

101A2

030L4

03054

030M9

112Al

03062

317M5

317M6

317M7

317M8

317M9

317V5

317N4

317N3

148Xl

11201

30""

317Y3

317Y4

317V5

317V6

317V7

317V8

34902

103A6

11000

11001

11002

11003

349F6

030L3

3<9G5

030LO

030Nl

317T5

3<,13<

30502

30105

317U6

JO<AO

03059

OJOl'

053L8

03OM5

030'"

317W2

33501

33502

09508

317V9

Page 1 of3

Revision Dale: 0910812010

Printed: 9/812010 4:38 PM
Kodak Non·Boller Particulate Sources at Eastnlan Business Park

, BART M.x BART Max , Emission Emission I Stack Mu Hourty Hour1y Daily

Point Unit Heigtlt (ft) (lDs/tlr) (Iln/tlrl (1Ds/~YI ~omme:':'ts

U-OOO"! '"

- - - - --- 030NO 0059 005. ,

"906 - - -- .__.. u-00087 " 0.055 0.055 , - I - - 349FJ U.Q0087 20 005. 0.055 ,

304" u-0006O " 0_043 0.043 ,

03055 "u-oooao '" 00<2 0.042 1 .- -- -- ---~ ".'12 u-00078 28 0'" 0.'" ,

llOAl

._- -_.- --.. -. _._-

u-(lOO5' ,. 0'" 0.'" ,

311W4 - - -0.04 - -- - - - -- - " . - --_..-

u-ooo" '" 0.'" ,

317W6 0.04 - - . --- u-ooo" .. 0'" 1

32687 0036 - - u-00032

" 0.036 1

32589 U-00032

" 0.036 0.036 1

326C2 U--OOO32 67 00" 0.034 1

U·00087 - . - ------_._. ." - - 349FO .. 0.033 0.033 1 - -- ---t'--. ----- .- -- -_.._--_. - 03513 U·00016

" 0.032 0.032

., u·60084 - 30887 I 57 0.03 0.03 1

317W7 U·00024 .. 0.03 0.03 1 - 05431 U·OOOll 75 0,026 0.026 -- 1 ...... --..._- ._- .- .---_•..- ...- 05432 U-OOOll 75 0,026 0.026 1 -- .-_. . .._- .... -- - --- 05433 U-OOOll 75 0.026 0.026 1 .- -- - -- 05434 U·00011 75 0026 0.025 e-- .-- 1

05316

_. .- 0025 . - U·oooll "3 0025 1

34907

.,... U-00067 3 0.025 0.025 1

0.02 "

349Fl U-00087 30 0.02 0 - - 349F2 U-00087 30 002 0.02 0

03Ol2 U-OOO" 75 0018 0.018 0 +.-.- - 030N9 u-00012 75 0_018 0.018 0 - - - - 05319 u-00011 67 0.015 0015 0 -- - 101AI u-00028 • 0.014 0014 0 - .. - 317FO U-OOO" 75 0011 0,011 0 - -- ._-- - - - 05327 U--OOOll 77 00096 00096 0 -- - 317E1 U-OOO" 90 0.0095 0009. 0 . _.- _. - 05391 U-OOOll

f

90 0.0016 00076 0 ---- 05395 u-00011

" 0_006 I 0.006 0

30,.3 u-00025 22 0006 0006 0 -

317R6 U-0002o4 ,. 000. 000' 0 - - 317R7 U--OOO2o4 55 0.005 0.005 0 - -- 349EO U-(lOO67 I • 0.0039 I 0.0039 0

"903 U-00087 <2 00035 00035 0 -- 349F5 U-00087 30 0.0035 00035 0 - 059K4 U--OOO85 136 o 0033 0.0033 0 - - - 349E5 U-00087 " 00031 0.0031 0

3049EG U-00087

" 00031 0,0031 0 .. - -

110Cl U-00076 20 0,003 0,003 0 " . 317Z0 U-00024 107 0.003 0,003 ._- 0 - 059K5 U-00085 ". 0.0022 0.0022 0

104303 U·00019 72 0.002 0.002 0 -- .- 035P8 U·00016 73 0.002 0.002 0

317F4 U·000204 35 000' 000' 0

317F5 U-OOO" 35 0.002 0002 0 - "0 -- 317F6 U-00024 35 0.002 0.002 -

317F7 U-OOO" 35 000' 0.002 0

I - 317F8 U.()OO24 35 0.002 000' 0 - 317F9 U-OOO,. 35 000' 0002 0 - - -

317GO U-OOO" 35 000' 0.002 0 I "

"'OS U-(lOO67 37 00015 00015 0

I 05394 U-00011

" 0_001 0001 0 . ,.,,, U--OOO75 111 0001 , 0.001 0 " . - - 11002 U--OOO76 55 000' 0001 0

I - 030P8 U-00012 107 000' 0001 0 - - -- - "

053M7 U--OOOll 77 000' 0001 0 -_._- -- 11085 U--OOO76 25 000' 0001 0

317GI U-00024 35 0.001 0001 0 . - - 317G2 U-00024 35 000' 0.001 0

317G3 U-00024 35 000' I 0.001 0

0 --- 317G4 U-00024 35 000' 0001 - -. .- ..- 317G5 U-00024 35 0001 0001 0

Page 2 of 3

Revision Dale: 0910812010

Printed: 91812010 4:38 PM
Kodak Non·Boiler Particulate Sources at Eastman Business Park

Mixing Vessels built in 2004

-- :ianus sources relocated 10 ESP in 2001 - 2002.

Janus sources relocated to ESP in 2001 - 2002

36'7"t~achine built In mid-1990s .

Thermal Media Machine buill in 2005

Thermal Media Machine built in 2005

CPD.I !"rocass buill in 2007

CPOI Process built in 2007

cpoi ProCess built in 2007

CPOI Process built in 2007

CPOI Process built in 2007

CPDI Process built in 2007

CPOI Process built in 2007

Comments

BART Max

Daily

~b!!.~.~y) •.

_ ... a

o

o

o-- oo

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

oo--- o

o

o

'-0·

-_.. o

o

0 .•_

_._--- o _.. -- - o

o

'0

o

o

o

o

6

o

o

o

o

o

0'

o

o

BART Mu

Hourly

(Ibslhr)

O.OQ.!

0,001

0.001

- 0~001

0.001

0.001

0.001

0.001

0.001

0,001

0,001..._. 0.001

0.001

9,9E·04

9.9E-04

5.5E-04

5.5E-04

_._~:.~,§:.9.4:~ ~',~' . 2.2E·04

1.4E·04

1.4£:-04

o,oooolf ._ ... 21E-05

-'·''2,1E-05

.3.6E-06

8,4E-07 - 8.4E-07 - .. 8.4E-Oi

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

o

, EmIssion II' Stack If Max Hourly f

Unit Height (ft) _ ,<lb~/hr)

U-00024 1'}5 0.001

U-00024 35 0001

r U-00024 i 43 0001

',I U-00024 I 45 0.001

U-00024 I 38 0.001

j ~:~~~: I ~~ ~:~~~ _..

I U·00024 I 5 0001

, U·00024 1 5 ' 0,001

U-000~4 I 5 0.001

U-00024 36 0.001

U-00024 I 36 0.001 i U-00087 j 52 0.001

I U·00087' 30 9.9E-04

I U·00087 30 9.9E-Q.1

t

' U·00087 16 - ..5.5E-04

U·00087 21 5.5E·04

U·00087 21 _ ~~~-~4••

U-00087 20 2,2E..Q4

U-00087 12 l.4E..Q4

U-00087 12 - -(.4E';64 -_.

U-00017 18 0.00006

I' U-00087 15 2.1 E-05.. _..

U·00087 15 2.1 E-05

U-00087 15 ...••.. 3.~E-OO

I U·00087 15 .. 8.4E-07

U·00087 15 8.4E-07

U·00087 15 .. 6.4E·oi·

U·00084 30 2.14

U·00083 57 0.13

U·00083 55 0.032

U·00024 88 2

U.00086! 38 028

U-00086 10 j 0,0077

U-00087 36 0.073 f, U-00087 36 0,11

U-00087 36 _ 022

U-00087 36 022

U-00087 36 0,22

U-00087 36 0.0035

U-00011 18 0,0266

Emission

Point

317G6

317G7

317T9

31721

3HZ2

317Z3

3HZ4

31725

317Z6

3HZ7

317Z8

3HZ9

34900

349G2

349C3

34985 -

34986

34987

349E9

349G8

349G9

09504

349E7

349E8

34988

349E2

349E3

349E4

308B8

308C2

J08GJ

J17W1

319G4

319G6

349H4

349H5

349H6

349H7

J49H8

349H9

E1201

TOTAL 1.379

Page30f3

Revision Date: 09/0812010

Printed: 91812010 4:38 PM