,0/27/201 1 17.0 7 FAX 202493514 2 FA A' D« S aoOlAiO G 

# RECEIVE D OC T

## 1 7 W 

# ^KyKJN S UEABlNfiiJQCKE T Octobe r20 , 201 1 RE : RESPONDENT' S REPL YT O COMPLAINANT S OCTOBE R 19 , 2011 , REPL YT O RESPONDENTS ' RESPONS E T O ORDE R T O SHO WCAUS E AN D MOTIO N CONTAINE D WITHIN . FAADocke t No . CPIOSOOOOO , JUDG E RICHAR D C . GOODWIN , FDM S No . FAA-2011-0670 , FAACas e No . 2010SO70042 2 Administrativ e La wJudg e /On./ ; r \ / ' ^ P i '~''^^- ^ Th e Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwin , Offic e o fHearings , M-2 0 (^Od^ O ^ ^ ^ CX J U.S . Departmen t o fTransportatio n - ^ :.d^ ^ 120 0 Ne wJerse yAvenue , S.E . ^O" ^ Washington , DC 2059 0 ' ^ '""' ' " ' Th e Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwin , -^. - :/' j C O Thi s i s i n respons e t o Complainant' s repl yt o Respondent' s respons e t o Orde rt o Sho wCaus e an d Motio n withi n tha t move s th e Administrativ e LawJudg e t o find : ^(2 ) tha t Responden t ha s no t demonstrate d goo d caus e fo rno t filin g a timel yAnswer : (2 ) dee m a s a n admissio n o ftrut h eac h allegatio n i n th e complaint , (3 ) i fa hearin g i s stil l deeme d necessary , tha t I t shoul d b e onl yfo rth e purpos e o fdeterminin g th e amoun t o fth e sanctio n i n thi s matter . (3 ) Complainan t als o request s a n extensio n o fth e discover yperio d t o a t leas t 3 0 day s afte rther e i s a rulin g o n th e Agency' s motion . Th e Responden t replie s t o eac h numbere d paragrap h i n Complainant' s Octobe r19 , 2011 , Respons e as follows : 1 . W e disagre e wit h Complainant' s conclusion . I n ou rOctobe r5 , 20H , respons e th e Responden t state d th e rea l reaso n fo rno t respondin g t o th e Complain t wa s tha t th e Respondent' s Representativ e i n thi s manne rneve rwa s give n th e Complaint . I t wa s onl yoffere d tha t a chang e i n th e Respondent' s primar yaddres s migh t b e th e possibl e reaso n fo rth e Respondent' s Representativ e no t bein g give n a cop yo fth e complaint . Furthermore , onc e w e receive d th e Complain t i t shoul d b e note d tha t i t wa s no t serve d o n Jun e 10 , 2011 , a s claime d b yth e Complainant , bu t wa s serve d o n Jun e 16 , 2011 , 2 . O n Jun e 8 , 2011 , th e Respondent' s primar yaddres s wa s 360 0 Powe rIn n Road , Sacramento , CA .

' W e use d th e .sam e numberin g sysic m a s i n rh cCompjainanr s repl ys o ther e wil l b e n o addiuon& I confusion . 110/27/201 1 17:0 7 FA X 20249351^ 2 FA. ^ tJ" ^ 

### 3 . W e disagre e wit h Complainant' s conclusion . W e se e n o plac e withi n th e "Rule s o fPractice " a requiremen t t o submi t a chang e o faddress . Th e Responden t wishe s i t ha d provide d al l concerne d i n matte ra Notic e o fAddres s Change ; an d w e respectfull yapolog yfo rno t doin g so . However , th e Respondent' s Representativ e ha s communicate d wit h th e Agency' s Attorne yo n severa l occasion s vi a persona l telephon e an d facsimile . I n fact , th e Agency' s attorne ysen t a facsimil e t o th e Respondent' s Representativ e residence' s telephone , 541-647-1127 , o n mor e tha n on e occasion . Exhibi t 1 . O n Ma y 20 , 2011 , Geral d A . Jennings , Agency' s Progra m Analyst , mailed , b ycertifie d mail , an d signe d th e Fina l Notic e o fPropose d Civi l Penalty , Certificat e o fService , FA ACas e No . 2010SO700422 ; thi s case , t o Stev e Badge r(Respondent' s Representative ) wit h a wron g address . Th e Fina l Notic e o fPropose d Civi l Penalt y wa s receive d b yDann yL Lonne yo n Ma y23 , 2011 , a t SG B Sk yKin g Inc. , 265 9 Junipe rLane , Davie , FL 33330 . Exhibi t 2 an d 3 . T o sugges t tha t th e Responden t ha s no t demonstrate d goo d cause , i n that , th e Responden t di d no t provid e a chang e o fprimar yaddres s i s disingenuous . Th e trut h i s tha t th e Complainan t ca n contac t th e Respondent' s Representativ e a t an ytime , an d Complainan t mad e a n addres s erro ri n thi s matte rjus t lik e th e Responden t ha s mad e errors . Th e onl ydifferenc e i s tha t th e Responden t believe s thi s matte rshoul d b e resolve d o n th e merit s o fth e case , no t b yshor t cuttin g th e proces s i n th e nam e o f"Rule s o fPractice" . 4 .

. W e disagre e wit h Complaint' s conclusion . Th e Responden t neve rclaime d t o b e confuse d abou t it s responsibilit yt o fil e a n Answer ; th e Respondent' s representativ e wa s no t awar e o fthi s Orde runti l Octobe r3 , 2011 . And , o n tha t dat e th e Responden t stil l di d no t hav e a cop yo fth e Complaint . Th e Responden t answere d th e Complain t o n Octobe r8 , 2011 , immediatel yafte rbein g provide d a Facsimil e o fth e Complain t b yth e Agenc yAttorney . WHEREFORE , th e Responden t respectfull yreques t th e Administrativ e La wJudg e t o fin d tha t th e Responden t ha s demonstrate d goo d caus e fo rno t filin g a timel yAnswe ran d allo wfo rth e requeste d Hearin g s o tha t th e cas e ca n b e decide d o n it s merits . Finally , th e Responden t ha s n o objectio n t o th e Complaint' s reques t fo ra n extensio n o fth e discover y perio d t o a t leas t 3 0 day s afte rther e i s a rulin g o n th e Agency' s motion . Respectfull ySubmitte d o n JZ O da yo fOctober , 201 1

Badge r Respondent' s Representativ e_ ^ - QM S 0003/00 6 10/27/201 1 170 8 FA X 2024935U 2 ^^ ^ CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E I hereb ycertif ytha t o n Octobe rZO , 2011 , th e forgoin g Respons e t o Complainant' s repl yt o Respondent' s respons e t o Orde rt o Sho wCause , FA ADocke t NO . CPIOSOOOOO , DM S FAA02011-067 0 wa s sen t b yUnite d Parce l Servic e (UPS ) courie rto : COP Y Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washingto n D

C 2059 1 Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu rWrigh t Building—Suit e 2W100 0 ORIGINA L Th e Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwin , Administrativ e La wjudg e Offic e o fHearings , M-2 0 U.S . Departmen t o fTransportatio n 120 O Ne wJerse yAvenue , S.E . Washington , D

C 2059 0 COP Y Geral d A . Ellis , Complainant' s Counse l Attorney , Offic e o fth e Regiona l Counse l Souther n Region , ASO- 7 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n P.O . Box2063 6 Atlanta , Georgi a 3032 0

tepe n A . Badge rC / 

### ^X§teph . Respondent' s Representativ e10/27/201 1 17:0 8 FA X 20249351^ 2 FAA- DM S rttt ) Kt(^iUT^A

L COUNSE L 

# S^XH-lfcl J 1

Soultier n Regio n Offic e o ftti e Pediona l Counsel , ASO- 7 P . O Bo)c20fl3 6 AHanta . G A3032 0 (404 ) 305-520 0 (404 ) 305-522 3 FAX 12)004/00 8 PAG E 61/0 9 

# FA A

T« i Stev e Badge r Ptvm t Geral d ElUs . FAACounse l 

# Far . •iiimiii n -sy/a<C ^

M2 7 •^»9-- Pliww i Date : Jun e 9,201 1 Re : SV

yKing . FAACas e - 2010SO70042 2 CC : D Urgen t D Fo rRevfe wQ Plsac e Camme m G Pleas e Repl y 0 PlvBB * Racycl e

* vOlTKiivnto ' DearMr . Badger . Acop yo f(h e Ffra l Notic e issue d Ma y20 , 201 1 I s attached . Th e 1 5 da yperio d t p appea l woul d hav e ru n fro m May24 , 2011 . ihedayafba-(h e dat e ofreceip t Geral d Ellis , FAAAttorne y10/27/201 1 17:0 8 FA X2024935U 2 FA A^ OM S @005/00 S ,^ . — , .w. . .J..1 0 ^v^Jco-D^^ j Fii AREGIONA LCOUHSE LPAG E 07/0 9 

# ^>dt4 - /

6 ( ' 2 - You ma y pa y th e propxisedpenalty by subrnittin g acertifie dchec k o r mone y ordt r

payabl e l o th e "Federal Aviatio nAdministraiion " to th e undersigned . EDDIEL.THOMA S REGIONALCOUNSE L ORIGINA LSIGNE D a y B Y : 

### GERAL D A . ELU S Attorne y OfTic e o f th e Regional Counse l

CERTinCAT EO FSERVIC E r hereb y certif

y tha t the foregoin g Final Notic e o f Propose dCivi l Penalty ha s beenmaile db y Certifie dMai l & Regula

r Mai l to : Greg g Lukcnbill . Presiden t Sk yKin g Inc . 360 0 Power

InnRoa d Suii e H Sacramento , C A95^2 6 Dann y Looncy , Registere dAgent SG B Sk y King , Inc . 265 9 Junipe r

Lan e Davie , F L3333 0 Stev e Badger Directo r o f Safet y & Security SG B Sk y King , IIK . 265 9 Junipe r

Lan e ivie^FL3333 0 GERAL D A . JEN

l ProgramAnalys t Offic e o f th e Regional Counse l WA Y2 0 2Q " Date d10/27/201 1 17:0 8 FA X 202493514 2 

# e^H/fcf T 3 FA A^ QM S rt-. M r;tVjiuri« L ULTJNSE L @ooe/oo G P-aG E 09/0 9

SENDER : cOMPtt , I S SECTIO N Compid e item s 1 . 2 , an d 3 . Ah a campW e ite m 4 ? fReslrlrte d Deliver y« a«iiwJ , Prin t ycxj rnam g an d addres s o o th e n;vgrs e s o tha t w * ca n (Btu m lh « car ^ wyou . Anac n inr s car a t o th e cwc k o fm e m»iiptece , o ro n ffie (<vrr

t " fspac e ptirmlia . Dann yLooney . Regrstere d Agen t SG B Sk yKing , Inc . 265 9 Junipe rLan e Davie , F L 3333 0

2 . AmoleNix«*ff r P S For m 3811 . Februar y200 ^ CODPI.ETt ' Tr-\ 3 •.<EC1 ft. S>9nati" « . N ar^i'vem D . Li « dafiveryaOdre n aiHwor d t-v n iia m i ? O H •»•££ , onie ra«(l«e<YpddrBj Tbnlo* ; O N o

3 SflT^ M 1VD » P C«rtlf1a a Mal i

•vvurv X Mal l D CacKEBs >^ "

O n«1UrT i RocND TTo rMviJuvidt H n co.D . 4 . R««tHc]« d D«iiv«ry l i&rr n J=M J G vt e 701 D lfl7 D 000 2 b31 2 BSfll i Oarnesil cRetur n Recelp i •&4e4AK l

SENDER : COn)P:.eT^fcJ/ S .SECno/ J Complnt e iiBFTi s 1 . 2 . ari d 3 . Ab o complet e fTBfri 4 i fRestricte d Deliver yI s OwifBd . Pri m you rnvn e an d iddres s o n th e rev«iM 5 0 iha t W

Wc» n (»tu m tr> « car d n j you . Attac h tn( £car d t o m e bach : o ftn ^ rr»i|pi»c« , Oro n cti » (re m i fspac e permits . 1 . ATKI V AdOr^ASO a I D Stev e Baatge r Directo ro fSafet y& Securit y SG B Sfrf*fng , Inc . 265 9 Junipe rLan e Davie . F L 3333 0

2 . ArDcI O NumCe r fTrsml V fn m svrvfc e label ) ^j-on-f^a' cin'.' rFffTT^fcp/ vni^L'vra r KS^nBlui Q ^ B . Bocehrt O B y(Pi4,t ^ Nztrw ) D . I s *(Kw yaildfq Kannror n fwff i ton t ? t H irYES . OftW rd«llv«r yBEKlFVa i MiO> : • N o

3 . S«v|c e Tj<p

» •f^Corlin M Ma U O Eitra wMQ H Cr^eqlstam a C I n«tur n Rac^fp i fo rhfaiLftamfl u D Irwuffl d Ma n O C,O.D . 4 . Hisincto d Dellwffry ^ (En/ a Poo ; n ra s 

### ?D1 0 167 0 OOQ e h3^ e 33T 3 P S For m 3811 . Februar yZDD4 Oor»»r»il cRgtu m «ec«<p i mSK-a- ;