07/08/2010 17:21 FAX 2024935U2 FAA * DMS gjOOI/OOS 

•:::?• C 

••".T . 

'- 1 

"1 

•• \ j '•' '' 

2010 

•"^f*"s?^ . ^ -• • . ^ ^ 

•- 'r-:.:: i 

Mr. Josman Blythc 

629 Starboard Road, NW 

Shallotte, NC 28470 

June 21, 2010 

The Honorable Isaac D. Benkin, Adininistraiive Law Judge 

Office of Hearings, M-20 

U.S. Depaitraent of Trcinsportalion 

1200 New Jersey Avenue, S.E. 

REQUEST FOR COMPULSION 

DMSNo. FAA-2010-0318 

Dear Judge Denkin, 

On June 01, 2010, T requested from 1<"AA Counsel all documents and any other notes, e-mails, or 

other correspondence used to make this determination against me. In my June 01, 2010 letter, I 

specifically requested the following items; 

The initial incident report 

EIR folder 

All interviews conducted by any FAA investigator on this matter 

All .separate reports of the interview, including the interviewer's own Factual observations. 

On June 15, 2010, FAA Counsel sent a package containing a few documents with a letter stating 

that "Per your request, enclosed are the relcasable portions of the file...." Attached is a copy of 

my June 01, 2010 request, the FAA Counsel's respon.se, and their service list. 

We, the defendant, request a motion to compel discovery. To be reasonably and adequately able 

to defend myself against these allegations, I am once again requesting all documents and any 

other notes, e-mails, or other correspondence used to make this determination against me. 

Items specifically requested but not included in FAA Coimsel's package; 

The EIR Folder compiled by the FAA in its entirety. 

This would include, but are not limited to, ail information contained in the completed 

Enforcement Investigation Report package. 
07/08/2010 17:21 FAX 2024935142 FAA •y DMS 121002/005 

All interviews conducted by the FAA into this matter. 

These would include, but are not limited to, all individual interviews conducted by an FAA 

Investigator with members of the flight crew into this matter. 

The investigators report as outlined in FAA 2150.3B. 

These would include, but are not limited to, all of the separate reports prepared by the 

interviewer, including the interviewer's own factual observations. This report of interview is 

a separate item of proof in the EIR. 

I humbly request your intervention in obtaining this documentation as soon as possible so tliai I 

can prepare my defense. 

Sincerely, 

Josman Blythe 

Transmitted via FAX and U.S. Mail 

cc: Regional Counsel, FAA 

I .i 
07/08/201 0 17:2 1 FAX 2024935142 FAA •* DMS ©003/00 5 

Mr. Josman Blythe 

629 Starboard Road NW 

Shallotte, NC 28470-1835 

June 1,2010 

Taneesha D Marshall 

Regional Coun.sel, FAA 

P. 0. Box 20636 

Atlanta, GA 30320 

Request for Discovery 

FAA Docket: CP10SO0005 

Dear Mrs. Marshall, 

To be reasonably and adequately able to defend myself against these allegations, 1 request all 

documents and any other notes, e-mails, or other correspondence used to make thi.s 

determination against me. These include, but are not limited to, the following specific items; 

The initial incident report 

EIC folder 

All interviews conducted by any FAA investigator on this matter 

All separate reports of the interview, including the interviewer's own Factual observations. 

T am requesting that this information be delivered as soon as possible so that I have a reasonable 

amouriT of lime to prepare for the hearing. Please .send the requested information to; 

Mr Josman Blythe 

c/o Mr. Douglas Blythe 

536 Medcalf Drive SW 

Simsct Beach, NC 28468 

Sincerely, 

Josman Blythe 
07/08/2010 17:21 FAX 2024835142 FAA + DM S @|004/005 

O 

Southern Region 

Office of the Regional Counsel 

P.O. Box 20636 

Atlanta, Georgia 30320 

(404) 305-5200 

(404) 305-5223 FAX 

U.S. Department 

of Transportation 

Federal Aviation 

Administration 

JUN 1 5 2010 

Mr. Josman Blythe 

c/o Mr. Douglas Blythe 

536 Medcalf Drive SW 

Sunset Beach, NC 28468 

RE: Ca.se Number 2009SO270263 

Dear Mr. Blythc: 

Per your request, enclosed are the releasable portions of the file in the above-referenced case. 

Very truly yours, 

VTAN^EgWA Dr MARSHALL 

t6mey 

Office of the Regional Counsel 

Enclosures 
1-AA + QMS 0)005/005 

07/08/201 0 17:2 1 FAX 2024335142 FAA UMi 

SECTION C - Items of Proof 

Case Number: 2009SO270263 

1. Copy of the Northwest Airlines Electronic Inflight Incident Report filed by Purser 

Clement St. Louis, Flight Attendants Karen Robertson, Cynthia Jones-Hughes and 

Tatsuya One. 

2. Copy of the Northwest Airlines Electronic Inflight Incident Narrative Report filed by 

Flight Attendant Sue Cragg. 

3. Copy of the Northwest Airlines Electronic Inflight Incident Narrative Report filed by 

Flight Attendant Ricardo Lopez-Castillo, . .. 

4. Copy of the Northwest Airlines Electronic Inflight Incident Narrative Report filed by 

Flight Attendant Jeffrey Ferrer. 

5. Copy of email statements from Flight Attendant Nancy Nyberg. 

6. Copy of the Northwest Airlines Electronic Incident Report filed by the Captain. 

7. Copy of email communication regarding the incident from Jeffrey Worthy. DL/NW 

Corporate Security. 

8. Letter of investigation sent to Josh Blythe, dated June 29, 2009. 

9. Employee Information, obtained from FAA Directory. 

10. Mr. J. BIythe's response to the Letter of Investigation, received July 09. 2009. 

Blythe 2009SO270263 FOR OFRCIAL USE ONLY