### Appendix A: Summary of Data Corrections and Additions from Public Comments **Commenter/DCN Contact Information**  **Facility ID Unit ID**  **Fuel Category Combustor Design**  **Did Facility/Parent Company Submit**  **Comments? Summary of Changes** 

FLOsceolaFarms Boiler No. 4 Biomass Fuel Cell No E-mail from facility stated this unit does not meet the definition of a fuel cell per the rule and should instead be classified as a suspension/grate design

FLOsceolaFarms Boiler No. 5 Biomass Fuel Cell No E-mail from facility stated this unit does not meet the definition of a fuel cell per the rule and should instead be classified as a suspension/grate design ARWeyerhaeuserDierksMill SN-45 Biomass Dutch Oven/Pile Burner Yes - Parent Company Commenter indicated this unit should be classified as a Fuel Cell rather than a Dutch Oven/Pile Burner. MSWeyerhaeuserBruce AA-002 No. 2 BoilerBiomass Dutch Oven/Pile Burner Yes - Parent Company Commenter indicated this unit should be classified as a Fuel Cell rather than a Dutch Oven/Pile Burner. MNWeyerhaeuserIronton All Units

- - Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is closed and is not expected to re-open. KYWeyerhaeuserEKY All Units

- - Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is closed and is not expected to re-open. ALRock-TennDemopolis Power Boiler #3 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit should be in the wet biomass stoker subcategory instead of being classified as a coal unit. FLSmurfit-Stone Power Boiler #3 Wet Biomass Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that no such unit exists and should be removed from the major source inventory. FLSmurfit-Stone Power Boiler #4 Coal PC Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that no such unit exists and should be removed from the major source inventory. FLSmurfit-Stone 5PB Dry Biomass Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit should be in the wet biomass stoker subcategory instead of being classified as a dry biomass stoker. FLSmurfitStonePanamaCity No. 4 Combination Boiler Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit should be in the wet biomass stoker subcategory instead of being classified as a coal unit. LASmurfit-Stone Power Boiler #2 Wet Biomass Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that the control for this unit should be a wet ESP instead of a cyclone/multiclone. MISmurfitStoneOntonagon All Units

- - Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is permanently closed. MTSmurfitStone All Units

- - Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is permanently closed. VASmurfitStoneHopewell Combination BoilerCoal PC Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit should be classified as a wet biomass unit instead of a coal unit; also, the unit should be classified as a stoker/sloped grate/other instead of PC.

EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3522-A1Dean C. DeLorey The Amalgamated Sugar Co., LLC 208-383-6500 IDAmalgamatedSugarCoTwinFal ls S-B1 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states the 2006 test (PM & metals) was not a permit compliance test (i.e., not approved by the state agency including all appropriate QA/QC procedures). The commenter requests that this test be removed from consideration, and that only performance testing be applicable to setting MACT limits. VAGeorgiaPacificBrooknealGlad ys 5600 Biomass Dutch Oven/Pile Burner Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit is currently regulated as an affected source subject to the Plywood and Composite Wood Products (PCWP) MACT (40 CFR 63 Subpart DDDD) and should thus be removed from the inventory.

WVGPMtHopeOSB 5600 - Wellons Energy System Biomass Dutch Oven/Pile Burner Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this unit is currently regulated as an affected source subject to the Plywood and Composite Wood Products (PCWP) MACT (40 CFR 63 Subpart DDDD) and should thus be removed from the inventory. ORGeorgiaPacificWaunaMill EU33 - Power BoilerHeavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company E-mail from facility stated this unit is no longer permitted to burn fuel oil; the only fuel burned in this unit is NG SCGPChemRussellville FO Boiler Heavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company E-mail from facility stated this facility has been shut down and that the Title V permit has been cancelled ORGeorgiaPacificWaunaMill EU33 - Power BoilerHeavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that fuel has been removed as a permitted fuel in the Title V permit for this facility. SCGPChemRussellville FO Boiler Heavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is no longer in operation and the unit is being dismantled. NCDomtar 66-25-2050 (No. 1 Package Boiler) Light Liquid N/A No Commenter states this unit is no longer in operation and has been removed from the NC facility.
GATempleInlandThomson BW-B001 Biomass Suspension BurnerYes - Parent CompanySubmitted test report for December, 2004 testing which was flagged as nonusable since it was not a M10 test but rather an average CEMS reading. The test report provides actual M10 stack testing values to replace the values currently in the database. ARWestFraserHuttig SN-24 Wet Biomass Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other No Stack test data and full report provided. Test was conducted on November 2, 2011. Dave Buff Golder Associates Inc. DBuff@GOLDER.com N/A - e-mail to combustionsurvey@erg.com

EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3688-A2Nina E. Butler Rock-Tenn Company 770-326-8130 (Enviro. Dept.) EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3523-A1Stephen E. Woock Weyerhaeuser Company 919-538-2401 steve.woock@weyerhaeuser.com

Tim Hunt AF&PA 202-463-2588 EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3521-A1Michael Curtis Georgia Pacific MICHAEL.CURTIS@GAPAC.com EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3465-A1

Page 1 of 3

### Appendix A: Summary of Data Corrections and Additions from Public Comments **Commenter/DCN Contact Information**  **Facility ID Unit ID**  **Fuel Category Combustor Design**  **Did Facility/Parent Company Submit**  **Comments? Summary of Changes** 

B-2 Coal PC

B-3 Coal PC

B-4 Coal PC TNBowaterNewsprint Bubbling Fluidized Bed Boiler Biomass FB No Hourly CO CEMS data from 11/10/2011 to 12/27/2011 provided. MSGPNewAugusta AA-015 Power BoilerDry Biomass Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Hourly CO CEMS data from 11/19/2011 to 2/1/2012 provided. VASmurfitStoneWestpt PB08 Coal PC Yes - Parent Company Hourly CO CEMS data from 1/1/2009 to 12/31/2011 provided. FLUSSugarCorp Boiler No. 8 Biomass Suspension/GrateYes - Facility Daily CO CEMS data from 4/1/2010 to 12/30/2011 provided. Data have been formatted to append to database, but I have not yet actually added the data.

FLUSSugarCorp Boiler No. 8 Biomass Suspension/GrateYes - Facility Three separate sets of 9-run CO RATA data submitted in a tabular summary (no report provided). Test dates are 12/4/2009, 12/2/2010, and 12/1/2011. Before adding to database, would most likely want to get test report and review it.
FLOsceolaFarms

- - - No 4 fuel analysis samples provided from 12/7-8/2011. Samples were analyzed for TSM10 (As, Be, Cd, Cr, Pb, Mn, Ni, Se, Co, & Sb) as well as HHV. Sample values given in units of ppm and lb/MMBtu. Data have been formatted for database, but not yet added.
FLSugarCaneGrowersCoop

- - - No 9 fuel analysis samples provided from 1/19-27/2011. Samples were analyzed for TSM10 (As, Be, Cd, Cr, Pb, Mn, Ni, Se, Co, & Sb) as well as HHV. Sample values given in units of ppm and lb/MMBtu. Data have been formatted for database, but not yet added.
FLUSSugarCorp

- - - Yes - Facility 6 fuel analysis samples provided from 1/25/2011. Samples were analyzed for TSM10 (As, Be, Cd, Cr, Pb, Mn, Ni, Se, Co, & Sb) as well as HHV. Sample values given in units of ppm and lb/MMBtu. Data have been formatted for database, but not yet added.

HIChevronKapolei Boiler 5 & Boiler 6 Non-Continental Liquid N/A No Two runs of PM testing for each boiler provided in a tabular summary. Appears that methods 201A and 202 were used to measure PM10, PM2.5, and condensible PM. Total PM is also given. Total filterable PM is not given, but could perhaps be calculated by subracting the condensible PM from the total PM. Will request test report in order to verify test data before adding to database. Unit ID's do not match what is in our database, so we will need to get clarification on which ID's pertain to Boilers 5 & 6.

HIChevronKapolei

- - - Yes - Parent Company 1 fuel analysis sample provided from 1/31/2012. Samples were analyzed for TSM10 plus Phosphorus. Sample values given in ppb, no HHV available to standardize so the HHV from Subpart C of GHG Reporting Rule (40 CFR 63) used in standardization. Unclear if these data are on dry or as received basis. Data formatted for database, but not yet added. PAKimberlyClarkChester Boiler #10 (ID 035) Coal FB Yes - Facility Daily CO CEMS averages from 1/1/2007 to 7/31/2011 provided. PAKimberlyClarkChester Boiler #10 (ID 035) Coal FB Yes - Facility Submitted corrected CO ET values for a test conducted on 9/17/2003.

EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3676-A2Bill Perdue American Home Furnishings Alliance (AHFA) bperdue@afha.us 336-884-5000, ext 1017 WIAlgoma All Units

- - No Commenter states this facility is a synthetic minor source of HAP and all units should be removed from the major source inventory.

EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3658-A2Mark Weiss Reciprocal Energy Company [no phone or e-mail given] ? ? ? ? No Provided graphical CO CEMS data paired with steam rates for the Steam Center at Jackson Lab in Bar Harbor, Maine. The data appear to be hourly CO data from Feb 4-5 and Feb 14-19, 2012. This facility was comissioned in 2011, and is not in our database. Thus, we do not know if this is a major or area source. If this is a major source, should we request the source data for the graphs? Stack test data and full report provided. Test was conducted between late September and early October, 2011. Also provided D/F test data for each boilers; should we spend time adding these data to the database or should we ignore the data? OKGPMuskogeeMill Yes - Parent Company

Dell Majure Kimberly Clark EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3692-A2Matthew Todd (API) toddm@api.org 202-682-8319 David Friedman (AFPM) dfriedman@afpm.org 202-552-8461 EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3677 EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3505-A1Ashok K. Jain NCASI 352-331-1745

Dave Buff Golder Associates Inc. DBuff@GOLDER.com EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3504-A1

Page 2 of 3

### Appendix A: Summary of Data Corrections and Additions from Public Comments **Commenter/DCN Contact Information**  **Facility ID Unit ID**  **Fuel Category Combustor Design**  **Did Facility/Parent Company Submit**  **Comments? Summary of Changes**  ORGeorgiaPacificWaunaMill EU33 - Power BoilerHeavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that fuel has been removed as a permitted fuel in the Title V permit for this facility. SCGPChemRussellville FO Boiler Heavy Liquid N/A Yes - Parent Company Commenter states this facility is no longer in operation and the unit is being dismantled. NCDomtar 66-25-2050 (No. 1 Package Boiler) Light Liquid N/A No Commenter states this unit is no longer in operation and has been removed from the NC facility. EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3673-A2Christopher S. Colman Hess Corporation 732-750-6535 USVIHOVENSA All Units

- - Yes - Facility Commenter states that this facility is shut down.

MIMISugarSebewaing Boiler #3 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Facility submitted PM test data for a common stack between boilers 2 and 3. However, when imported into the database and corrected for the common stack issue using internal data handling methods, we show the data as pertaining to boilers 1 and 2 instead of boilers 2 and 3. The data for boiler 1 should have the unit ID changed to show the data actually pertain to boiler 3.

NDMinnDakFarmers Babcock and Wilcox Boiler #6 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter suggested some of the reported test data should pertain to this boiler instead of boiler 5. However, the reported unit ID in each tab of the ET spreadsheet is that of boiler 5. The commenter did not specify which set(s) of data should actually pertain to boiler 6.
MNAmericanCrystalCrookstonBoiler 2 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company ET spreadsheet contains a tab named "Boiler No2 - PM and Metals"; however, the unit ID entered for this data is boiler 1. Consequently, the database shows the data as pertaining to boiler 1. The commenter suggested this data should be associated with boiler 2.
MNAmericanCrystalCrookstonBoiler 3 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company ET spreadsheet contains a tab named "Boiler No3 - PM and Metals"; however, the unit ID entered for this data is boiler 1. Consequently, the database shows the data as pertaining to boiler 1. The commenter suggested this data should be associated with boiler 3.
MNAmericanCrystalMoorheadBoiler 3 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Parent Company Commenter states that the database is missing data from this unit and that the missing data are reported in the ET spreadsheet for the facility. A review of the database and ET spreadsheet does not show any missing data, so it is unclear why the commenter is concerned over the data for this facility.

MNAmericanCrystalEastGrandF orks Facility-wide Facility-wide Facility-wide Yes - Parent Company Commenter notes that the database does not contain reported test data for this facility. This is due to the fact that the facility is not in the major source boiler inventory because the facility did not answer the Answer Key question regarding major vs. area source HAP status in its initial ICR survey response. As a result, this facility is unclassified as either major or area, and the test data for its boilers were not used in the analysis.
HITesoro SG1102 Non-Continental Liquid N/A Yes - Facility Submitted new test data from a January, 2012 test for CO and PM.
HITesoro H101B Non-Continental Liquid N/A Yes - Facility Submitted new test data from a January, 2012 test for CO and PM. N/A - e-mail to combustionsurvey@erg.com Anna Beth Reitter Annabeth.Reitter@newpagecorp.comWINewPageBiron B24 Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/ Other Yes - Facility Submitted new CO CEMS hourly data for year 2011. N/A - phone conversation with ERG on 8/8/12 Lisa Fleming NJVinelandMuniElectricHowardDown Unit 9, Unit 10 Coal, Liquid Yes - Facility Unit 9 shutdown February 2010. Unit 10 ceased firing coal in 2009 and is in the process of shutdown, no later than September 1st, 2012. N/A - ERG research after facility phone contact was disconnected. N/A NYConEdHudsonAve Boilers 71, 72, 81 and 82 Liquid N/A Yes - Facility NYSDEC Permit ID 2-6101-00042/00044 indicates these four boilers permanently shutdown and ceased operation on February 7, 2011. Douglas B. Price Tesoro 210-626-6287 Douglas.B.Prices@tsocorp.com Submittal to docket - DCN not known Douglas Emerson American Crystal Sugar Co. 216-236-4400 Steven Smock Michigan Sugar Co. 989-686-0161 EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3675-A2 EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0058-3503-A1Sarah E. Amick Rubber Manufacturers Association (RMA) 202-682-4836

Page 3 of 3

## Appendix B: Units Reclassified as Major Source Boilers from CISWI and MATS **FacilityID UnitID**  **Classification Design**  **Capacity (MMBtu/hr)**  **Annual**

**Hours of Operation** **Fuel Category Combustor Design**  **Reason for Reclassification**
CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#1 Boiler 339 8202Wet BiomassStoker/SlopedGrate/Other Ceased waste combustion in 2009; reclassified from CISWI CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#2 Boiler 339 8186Wet BiomassStoker/SlopedGrate/Other Ceased waste combustion in 2009; reclassified from CISWI CAWheelabratorShasta Boiler#3 Boiler 339 8035Wet BiomassStoker/SlopedGrate/Other Ceased waste combustion in 2009; reclassified from CISWI VACogentrixHopewell 1A Boiler 200 7061Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixHopewell 1B Boiler 200 7037Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixHopewell 1C Boiler 200 7153Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixHopewell 2A Boiler 200 7400Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixHopewell 2B Boiler 200 7226Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixHopewell 2C Boiler 200 7145Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 1A Boiler 200 5981Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 1B Boiler 200 5909Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 1C Boiler 200 5896Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 2A Boiler 200 5669Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 2B Boiler 200 5566Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS VACogentrixPortsmouth 2C Boiler 200 5740Coal Stoker/SlopedGrate/Other Does not meet size threshold for classification under MATS

Page 1 of 1