BEFOR E TH E 

### ,vi:^RTMENTO F .•.;;: T

### OPERATION S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N f n £ T . . 3 O > c r WASHINGTON , D.C .

Join t Applicatio n o f ASTA RAI RCARGO , INC . an d ASTA RUSA , LL C for transfe r o f certificat e authorit y unde r 4 9 us e §4110 5 Docke t OST-2010-022 3

MOTIO N O FASTA RAI RCARGO . INC . an dASTA RUSA , LL C FO R

CONFIDENTIA LTREATMEN T UNDE RRUL E 1 2

Communication s withrespec t t o thi s documen t

shoul db e sen t

to : Stephe n P . Doyl e Elliott M . Seide n Presiden t Boies , Schille r & Flexne r

LLP ASTA RAi r

Cargo , Inc . 530 1 Wisconsi n Avenue , N W an dWashington , D C 2001 5 ASTA RUSA , LL C (202 ) 274-116 6 120 0 Brickel l Avenu e eseiden@bsfllp.co m Miami , FL3313 1 Counse l fo r ASTA RAi r Cargo , Inc . an dASTA RUSA , LL C Septembers , 201 0BEFOR E TH E DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

WASHINGTON , D.C . Join t Applicatio n o f ASTA RAI RCARGO , INC . an d ASTA RUSA , LL C for transfe r o f certificat e authorit y unde r 4 9 us e §4110 5 Docke t OST-2010-022 3

MOTIO N O FASTA RAI RCARGO , INC . an dASTA RUSA . LL C FO R

CONFIDENTIA LTREATMEN T UNDE RRUL E 1 2 O n Septembe r

3 , 2010 , pursuan t

t o Rul e 1 2 o f

th e Department s Rule s o f Practice , 1 4 C.F.R . § 302.12 , ASTA RAi r Cargo , Inc. , aNevad acorporatio n ("ASTAR" ) an d ASTA RUSA , LLC , aDelawar e limite dliabilit y compan y ("AUSA " togethe r "Join t Applicants" ) submitte daMotio n i n thi s proceedin g t o withhol dfrompubli c disclosur e certai n proprietary , commercially-sensitive , an dconfidentia l busines s an dpersona l information . Thes e include dth e Asse t Transfe r an dLegac y Cos t

Agreemen t

betwee n AUS A an dASTA RAi r

Carg o Holdings , LLC , aDelawar e limite dliability company ("Holdings" ) an dth e Ai r

Transportatio n Service s Agreemen t betwee n New Holding s and Holding s (th e "AT S Agreement") . Th e Join t Applicant s discovere drecentl y that the y ha dinadvertentl y omitte dfromth e former agreemen t

Exhibi t 5 (Th e Legac y Cos t Agreement ) an dfromth e latte r Exhibi t C pertainin g t o engin e sho p visits .Th e Join t Applicant s ar e submittin g thes e Exhibit s withthi s Motio n In accordanc e withRul e 12 , eac hpag e o f thes e confidentia l document s ha s bee n marke d "Confidential " an dar e bein g filedunde r seal i n aseale denvelop e marke d"Confidentia l Treatmen t

Requeste dUnde r

Sectio n 302.12" . A n inde x describin g th e confidentia l document s i s attache d Rul e 1 2 o f

th e Department' s Rule s o f Practic e instruct s th e Departmen t t o evaluat e request s for

confidentia l freatment

b y th e standard s o f

disclosur e se t

fort hi n th e Freedo mo f

Informatio n Act , 5 U.S.C . § 552 . Informatio n ma y b e withhel dfrom disclosur e imde r

5 U.S.C . § 552(b)(4 ) i f

i t i s (1 ) commercia l o r

financial, (2 ) obtaine d fromaperso n outsid e o f

government , an d(3 ) privilege dan dconfidentia l Gul f & Western hidus. . Inc . v . Unite dStates . 61 5 F.2 d527,52 9 (D.C . Cir . 1979) . Th e Join t Applicants ' confidentia l submission s easil y satisf y th e first tw o prong s o f

th e Gul f & Western test . Th e onl y questio n i s whethe r the y als o satisf

y th e thir dpron g o f

th e test . In considerin g th e thir dpron g o f th e test , th e Departmen t

mus t conside r whethe r "disclosur e o f

th e informatio n i s likel y t o hav e eithe r o f th e followin g effects : (1 ) impai r th e Government' s abilit y t o obtai n necessar y information ; o r (2 ) caus e substantiv e harm t o th e competitiv e positio n o f th e perso n fro mwho mth e informatio n was obtained. " Nationa l Park s & Conservatio n Associatio n v . Morton . 49 8 F.2 d765 , 77 0 (D.C . Cir . 1974) . Finally , t o b e privilege do r confidential , th e informatio n mus t no t b e o f th e typ e that i s usuall y release dt o th e public . Gul f & Western a

t 530 . Th e confidentia l exhibit s an dconfidential document s mee t thes e standard s for

protection . Th e informatio n whic hi s th e subjec t o f thi s Motion include s non-public , commerciall y sensitiv e information . Thes e document s contai n sensitiv e informatio nwhic hi f disclose dt o th e public , coul dcaus e th e Join t Applicant s substantia l competitiv e harm . Th e document s disclos e competitivel y sensitiv e financial an dbusines s informatio n o f atyp e no t

usuall y disclose dt o th e publi c an dwoul dno t b e disclose dt o th e publi c b y th e Join t Applicant s but

for th e requiremen t

t o submi t

suc hagreement s i n respons e t o th e Department' s Fitnes s Requirement s se t fort ha t 1 4 C.F.R . § 204.3 . Th e Departmen t ordinaril y afford s confidentia l freatment t o document s o f

thi s nature . See , e.g. . Ma y 9 Lette r Ruling , Docke t

No . OST-2003-14579 ; Order s 2003-2-9 ; 2000-1-25 . WHEREFORE , th e Join t Applicant s mov e th e Department , pursuan t t o 1 4 C.F.R . § 302.1 2 t o affor

dconfidentia l treatmen t

t o th e informatio n describe dherein . Respectfiill y submitted . EHfot t M . Seide n Boies , Schille r

& Flexne r

LL P 530 1 Wisconsi n Avenu e N W Washington , D C 2001 5 (202)274-116 6 eseiden@bsfllp.co m Counse l fo r

ASTA RAi r Cargo , Inc . an d ASTA RUSA , LL CJOIN T APPLICATIO N O FASTA RAI RCARGO . INC . AN D ASTA RUSA , LL C FO RTRANSFE RO FCERTIFICAT E AUTHORIT Y Motio n fo r

Confidentia l Treatmen t Inde x t o Material s INDE X O FCONFIDENTIA LDOCUMENT S

Confidentia l Document s Pag e Number s AST0135-014 5 AST014 6 Descriptio n o f Confidentia l Documen t Exhibi t 5 t o Asse t

Transfe r an dLegac y Cos t Agreemen t

(Legac y Costs ) Exhibi t C t o AT S Agreemen t

(Engin e Sho p Visits )Certificat e o f Servic e I hereb y certif

y tha t I have , thi s 8t

hda y o f September , 2010, 1 cause dacop y o f th e foregoin g motio n t o b e serve db y electroni c mai l o r regular mail , a s indicate do n al l person s liste dbelow : carl.nelson@aa.co m rbkeiner@crowell.co m hkamen@coair . co m sascha.vanderbellen@delta.co m ]"effrey.manlev@united.co m bruce.rabinovitz@wilmerhale.co m dshort @fedex . co m nssparks@fedex.co m gbleopard@fedex . co m dvaughan@kelleydrye.co m rsilverberg@sgbdc.co m jhill@dowlohnes.co m rpommer@atlasair.co m esauer@ssd.co m pmurphy@lopmurphv . co m mlbenge@zsrlaw.co m cisimpson@zsrlaw.co m recohn@hhlaw . co m prrizzi@hhlaw.co m agoerlich@ggh-airlaw.com ggarofalo@ggh-airlaw.co m howard.kass@usairways.co m beniamin.slocum@usairwavs.co m mroller@rollerbauer . co m cdonley@ssd.co m efaberman@wileyrein.co m bill@mietuslaw.co m msinick@,ssd.co m lhalloway@crowell.co m sametta.c.bamett@delta.co m bverlvir@state . go v bryan.bazemore@faa . go v john.allen@faa . go v iim.ballough@faa.go v russell.bailey@alpa.or g jrichardson@johnlrichardson.co m iamestello@earthlink.ne t kevin.montgomerv@polaraircargo.co m mfrancesconi@ups.co m anita.mosner@hklaw.co m brent.connor@froutmansanders.co m charles.hunnicutt@troutmansanders.co m jyoung@vklaw.co m slachter@lachter-clements.co m kenneth.quinn@pillsburylaw.co m bob.kneisley@wnco.co m robert.land@jetblue.co m mgoldman@sgbdc.co m rsilverberg@sgbdc.co m dhainbach@ggh-airlaw.co m mcmillin@woa . co m dpdean@ i amhof

f co m dkirstein@vklaw . co m donna . kooperstein@usdoi . go v dwight.moor@ustranscom.mi l gmurphy@cr o well . co m david.heffeman@wilmerhale.co m ldwasko@erols.co m sbaer@panyni . go v bmbinst@panynj . go v j abreu@miami-airport . co m sgardner@goaa.or gRobert

W . Kenned y Interi mGenera l Manage r Departmen t

o f Aviatio n Hartsfiel d- Jackso n Atlant aIntemationa l Airport P C Bo x 2050 9 Atlanta , GA 3032 0 Timoth y E . Zei s Chie f Operating Officer

(COO ) Kento n Count y Airport

Boar d Cincinnati/Northe mKentucky Intemationa l Airport POBo x 75200 0 Cincinnati , O H 4527 5 Jerry Spampanat o Genera l Manager

- JF K Port Authorit y o f

Ne w York

& Ne w Jerse y Buildin g 1 4 - JF K

- 2"^ * Floo r Jamaica , N Y 1143 0 Joh n S . Jacob y Genera l Manager Newark Libert y Intemationa l Airport Th e Port Authorit y o f

Ne w York

& Ne w Jerse y Administratio n Buildin g - Bld g # 1 - 2"' ' Floo r On e Conra dRoa d Newark , NJ 0711 4 Thoma s J . Kinton , Jr . Chie f Executiv e Officer

& Executiv e Directo r Logan Intemationa l Airport Suit e 20 0 Sout

h On e Harborsid e Driv e Eas t Boston , M A 02128-290 9

An n Bozma n