UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

HYUNDAI MOTOR COMPANY, et al. , Petitioners ,

v. D IRECT TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, et al. , Respondents

. Case No. 1:1 9

- mc - 00206 (TNM)

MEMORANDUM OPINION Petitioners Hyundai Motor Company and Hyundai Motor America have filed trademark infringement claims against Direct Technologies International (“DTI”) with the U.S. International Trade Commission (“ US ITC”)

. See Pet ’rs ’ Mot. 1

– 2, ECF No. 1. In pursuit of its claims, Hyundai seek s documents and deposition testimony from two C anadian residents whom Hyundai believes possess relevant information about the trademark violations

. See id . at 2. But

s ince foreign residents are beyond the U.S. courts’ jurisdictional reach , Hyundai ha s moved the
Court to issue letters rogatory for ass istance from Canada’s judicial authorities. See id . at 1. DTI opposes the motion. See Resp ’ts ’ Opp. 1

– 5, ECF. No. 5. A letter rogatory is a formal request from a domestic court to a foreign court or judge “that the testimony of a witness resident within [the foreign country] may be formally taken there under its direction and transmitted to the first court for use in the pending action.” 8A C HARLES A LAN W RIGHT , A RTHUR R. M ILLER & R ICHARD L. M ARCUS , F ED ERAL P RACTICE AND P ROCEDURE § 2083 (3 d ed. 2010 ) ; see also 28 U.S.C. § 1781 (authorizing transmittal of letters rogatory between domestic and foreign courts either directly or through the Department of State )

.2 Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 28 (b) set s a permissive standard for issuing letter s rogatory “ (A) on appropriate terms after an application and notice of it; and (B) without a showing that taking the deposition in another manner is impracticable or inconvenient.” Harmonizing that tone, the D.C. Circuit has held there must be “good reaso n” to deny a party’s request. See Zassenhaus v. Evening Star Newspaper Co. , 404 F.2d 1361, 1364 (D.C. Cir. 1968). Here, there is no good reason for denial. See id

. Accompanying Hyundai ’s motion is a recommendation from a US ITC Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) that this Court issue the letters rogatory so Hyundai can fully investigate its infringement claims against DTI. See Pet ’rs ’ Mot. Ex. 1, ECF No. 1

- 2 (“ALJ Opinion”). According to the ALJ Opinion, Mr. Denis Chegrinets and Ms. Irina Bakumenko both “perform services for DTI and have material information” about Hyundai’s claims. See id

. DTI’s contrary arguments are unconvincing. First, DTI contends that Hyundai’s request is punitive, designed “to make litigation painful, and now, personal, for DTI’s president . . . by seeking to depose his mother, Ms. Irina Bakumenko, who is not even a DTI employee.” See Resp ’ts ’ Opp. at 1. The Court disagrees. DTI concedes that Ms. Bakumenko plays a limited role assisting with DTI’s “hous ekeeping and administrative matters.” See id . at 2. Likewise, DTI does not contest that Mr. Chegrinets bears some relevance to its business. See id

. Both have enough involvement with DTI’s affairs to overcome DTI’s baseless claims.
DTI’s second challenge

— that Hyundai ’s requests are untimely

— is also unconvincing , considering that Hyundai needs the Court’s assistance to reach the Canadian residents. See id . at 2

– 4; Pet ’rs ’ Mot. at 3. Perhaps the deadline for fact discovery before the US ITC has p assed, but the ALJ Opinion offers no suggestion that Hyundai’s request is time

- barred. See generally ALJ Opinion. And even if Hyundai could have pursue d one of the three other methods for taking a3 foreign deposition before filing its motion here , see Fed . R. Civ. P. 28(b)(1)(A)

– (D), the Rule also explicitly disclaims any requirement for “a showing that taking the deposition in another manner is impracticable or inconvenient , ” Fed. R. Civ. P. 28(b)(2)(B). In view of the permissive standard for issuing let ters rogatory , the Court will grant Hyundai’s request. See Zassenhaus , 404 F.2d at 1364 ; Fed. R. Civ. P. 28(b)

. A separate Order will issue.

Dated: December 23 , 201 9 TREVOR N. M c FADDEN , U.S.D.J.