p. 1



# OAR Box 1793 Prepped by Keeia Richards



### Document

Number: 

# 6 ) ll-F-4 8 Docket Number: 

# A-90-3 7

Printed 11/3/2008 11:31:54

AM Sheet 6 of 45

# Woul dyou kindly 

# se etha t thi s get s to th erigh t person ? A-96-3 7 P. 2

OFFIC E 0 ? MAXAOBBN T AKD BUDGE T 

### orrzc z o rXHTORHATZO HAXD REGULATOR

YAFFAIR S

DATE : •*-= - SEHDER s 

# -AjL.-E5£

i

T O I 

# <4>^i ^ Cnxj->fiU ^ AOEMCYi - • FROM ! - • • - r JttCIPIEKT' S FA

X NO. ! RECIPIEN T TELEPHOH E MO . I TOTA L HUMME

RO F PAGE S XHCLUDIM

O COYA SBEETt eOXKEMT6

l • -

WOTS : I F YO

U D O KO T RECEIV

E AL L TOE PAGES , TLEASE CAL L A S SOO

K A S POSSIBLE . VERIFICATION HO. t202-395-734 0 OZR A FA X HO. I202-318-721 3P. 3

. -^2^;:^^m^TS(^&

1 2 6 •'•.• . Subcommitte e member s recommende d tha t EPAprohibi t an y

' '''•'•. " •. ' H' • H' • consideratio n o f ne wo r emerging technologie s identifie d afte r the , permi t applicatio n i s complete . Othe r member s recommende d tha t BP Ano t allo wan ylimitation s o n consideratio n o f ne Wo r emergin g technologie s prio r t o th e en d o f th e publi c commen t perio d o ha permi t application . Th e EP Ai a proposin g ne w regulator yprovision s tha t woul d authoriz e th e permittin g authority

- t o cut-of f .consideration o f technologie s tha t devolv e o r appear ' afte r th e permi t applicatio n i s complete . fcommenter provide s informatio n abou t a new , technologytha t i. s furthe r consideration . Se e propose d section s 51.16.5(a ) (2 ) (ii ) (E ) an d (a ) (7 ) (iii)- , Sl . 16 6 (j) ' ($ ) (iii ) and (q ) (3 ) and 52.2 1 (j).(5)' (iii ) an d (q ) (3 ) . •.. ' Unde r the . propose d rules , the permittin g authorit yma y requir e commenter s t o submi t a recommendation , accompanie d by .reasonably , availabl e information , regarding ne wo r emerging , contro l technologie s wit hthei r recommendations . Thi s informatio n coul d include , th e nam e and locatio n o f th e sourc e ' '.utilizin

g th e contro l technology , th e .manufacture r and typ e o f contro l device , th e dat e o n whic hth e technolog ywa s installe d and becam e operational ; and performanc e requirement s and an y• resultin g tes t o r performanc e data'available . Se e propose d section s 51.1.6 5 (a. ) (7 ) (ii ) an d 51.16 6 (q ) (2 ) . Wit hregard : t o th e implementatio n o f th e Federa l PS D requirement s at ' sectio n 52.21 , PRELIMINARY STAF F WORKING DRAF T FOR OFFIC E O F MANAGEMEN T AN D BUDGE T REVIE W* DOE S NO T REPRESENT OFFICIAL EP APOLIC Y ** * Jul y5

V 199 5 •-.--• ' [fil e name : Masters,29 ] •• * 

# - ?P. 4

•127 . .••'' • th e EP Ai s proposin g t o requir e tha t publi c commenters . includ e th e abov e informatio n alon g wit han yrecommendatio n fo r furthe r consideratio n o f ne wcontro l technolog yalternatives . Se e propose d sectio n 52.21(q)(2) . I t shoul d b e note d tha t th e existin g NS R regulation s a t sectio n 51.165(a ) d o no t contai n an explici t provisio n fo r publi c participatio n procedure s a s d o the-PS D regulation s i n parts'5 1 and 52 . Nevertheless , th e publi c participatio n procedure s se t fort hunde r 4 0 CFR 51.16 1 generall yapply ' fo r Ifldft h majo r sfft/fojjb&r

ne wsourc e revie wpermitting . I n orde r t o mak e clea r th e regulatorycontex t fo r today' s propose d provision s concernin g a cutof f dat e an d informational , requirement s fo r publi c commenters , th e EP Ai s todayproposing t o amend sectio n 51.165.t o refe r t o th e existin g requirement s a t 4 0 CFR 51.161. . < Se e propose d sectio n 51.165(a)(7) . Th e EPAintend s als o t o propos e additiona l publi c participatio n provision s fo r par t D NSR ' permit s i n a forthcomin g rulemaking designe d primaril yt o updat e th e PS D and NS R rule s consisten t wit hthe 199 0 Ac t Amendments . Th e EP Atodaypropose s t o ad d th e provisio n concerning publi c recommendation s o n ne wand emerging contro l technologie s a s par t o f th e new.provision s fo r publi c participation . Th e permittin g authorit yshall.b e responsibl e fo r evaluatin g th e supportin g documentatio n tha t ha s bee n provide d b ycommenter s asserting , ne wo r emergin g technologie s warrant , consideratio n a s 

# n* . *? . 

# 4>

PRELIMINARY STAF F WORKING DRAF T FOR OFFIC E O F MANAGEMENT AN D BUDGE T REVIE W* DOE S NO T REPRESEN T OFFICIAL EP APOLICY ** * Jul y5 , 199 5 [fil e name : Master6.29 l ** *P. 5

13 0 . thos e applicant s tha t hav e include d a- , thoroughrevie wo f contro l technologies , i n thei r permi t applications . Th e propose d regulation s woul d requir e consideratio n o f onl ythos e post completenes s emergin g technologie s whos e availabilit yan c effectivenes s ar e substantiate d t o th e satisfactio n of-th e permittin g authority . Thi s proposa l als o preserve s opportunit yfo r publi c participation . I n al l instances , the p.ubli c woul d hav e th e righ t t o submi t comment s addressing'whethe r al l contro l technologie s tha t were , i n fact , "demonstrate d i n practice " prio r t o • completeness , wer e adequatel yconsidere d i n th e permi t applicatio n and . durin g revie wb yth e permitting authority . I n addition , publi c commenter s hav e th e opportunity , t o recommend ne w o r emergin g technologie s provide d tha t recommendation s ar e accompanie d wit hsupportin g informatio n abou t th e existenc e and capabilitie s o f th e technology . The permittin g authority-woul d b e require d to'conside r timel yan d documente d publi c comment s addressin g technologie s tha t emerg e afte r completeness . ^ ' - Finally , th e EP Ai s revising it s polic ytha t set s th e permi t issuanc e dat e a s th e fina l cut-of f fo r consideratio n o f ne wand emergin g technologies . Propose d revision s t o th e Federa l regulation s would.se t th e fina l cut-of f a t the clos e o f th e publi c commen t period , unles s th e permi t i s reopene d fo r revie w

PRELIMINARY STAF F WORKINGDRAFT,FOR OFFIC E O F MANAGEMENT AND BUDGE T REVIE W* DOE S NO T REPRESEN T OFFICIAL EP APOLIC Y ** * Jul y5 , 199 5 [fil e name : Master. ? .29 ] ** *