Facility _Information facility _id utility

_code legal_owner_nam e

legl_operator_name

legal_address_ty pe

legal_address

legal_city legal_state legal_zip 1731 1731 Detroit Edison Sam e legal ownerOne Energy Plaza Detroit MI 48226 Page 1Facility _Information plant_nam e

physical_address

phyical_city

physical_state

physical_zip

ma iling_address

ma iling_city

ma iling_state

ma iling_zip Harbor Beach Power Plant

755 Huron Avenue

Harbor Beach

MI 48441 One Energy Plaza Detroit MI 48226 Page 2Facility _Information RFA_small_entity

ff_fired_coal

ff_fired_oil ff_fired_ngas ff_fired_petcoke

ff_fired_other

ff_permitted_coal

ff_permitted_oil

ff_permitted_ngas No TRUE TRUE FALSE FALSE FALSE TRUE TRUE FALSE Page 3Facility _Information ff_permitted_petcoke

ff_permitted_other

deviation_reporting

continuous_emissions

cem_provided

facility _note FALSE FALSE Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 4Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 5Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 6Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 7Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 8Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 9Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 10Facility _Information Part I --PM limit units are "lbs particulate/1000 lbs wet gas corrected to 50% XS airBoiler 'reheat temperatures" are not applicable to this particular boilerThe unit was built in the 1960s. No records were found to ascertain any control equipment guarantees.There has been no environmental control technology demonstration at this facility except on Unit 4.Part II -- The Detroit Edison submittal for Part II is too cumbersome to enter manually into the ACCESS database supplied by RTI. Accordingly , please see the separate file: "DETROIT EDISON ICR Response - Cvltr, 4-5-10.zip". This file is the compressed version of the MS W ord 7 "docx" file which describes the files submitted for Part II. Page 11facility _contacts facility _id contact_id contact_title contact_name

contact_phone1

contact_phone2

contact_email

contact_primary 1731 1 Principal Environm ental Engineer Wa yn e A. Rugenstein

3132357023

2488951060

rugensteinw@dteenergy .com

TRUE 1731 2 Supervisor - Environmental Mark J. Mullen

3138970298

3134024469

mu llenm @dteenergy .com

TRUE Page 12facility _coal_utilized facility _id coal_type percentage_mass percentage_btu

synfuel_ty pe

coal_note 1731 bitum inous 100 100 Page 13facility _oil_utilized facility _id oil_ty pe percentage_volume percentage_btu

other_type 1731 No.2 Fuel Oil (distillate) 100 100 Page 14facility _other_materials facility _id other_material

permitted_burn

actually _burn other_quantity

other_quantity

_units other_note rcra_utilize rcra_explain Page 15facility _other_materials rcra_explain Page 16boiler_information

facility _id boiler_id boiler_ty pe boiler_other bottom_design

design_fuel heat_input ma x_heat_input MW e_capacity 1731 1 Wa ll firing - front firing We t Bottom coal 1181 1181 110 Page 17boiler_information

MW e_net_capacity

design_gross_efficiency

operating_gross_efficiency

design_pressure

operating_pressure

design_temp

operating_temp

design_reheat_multiple

design_reheat_temp1 103 88.05 87.9 1450 1450 1005 1005 FALSE Page 18boiler_information

design_reheat_temp2

operating_reheat_multiple

operating_reheat_temp1

operating_reheat_temp2

hours_operated

vg_capacity

_factor applicable_NSPS

retirement_year

retirement_year_CBI FALSE 3081 16.3 N FALSE Page 19boiler_information

NOx_control

SO2_control

combustion_additives Yes No No Page 20boiler_fuels

facility _id boiler_id fuel_type fuel_year percentage_massvol percentage_btu

other_type 1731 1 coal - bituminous 2007 100 97.2 1731 1 coal - bituminous 2008 100 95.4 1731 1 coal - bituminous 2009 100 97.4 1731 1 oil - distillate 2007 100 2.8 1731 1 oil - distillate 2008 100 4.6 1731 1 oil - distillate 2009 100 2.6 Page 21boiler_control_NOx

facility _id boiler_id NOx_ty pe NOx_other NOx_online 1731 1 Low NOx Burner 4/1/2004 Page 22boiler_control_SO2

facility _id boiler_id SO2_type SO2_other SO2_online Page 23boiler_additives

facility _id boiler_id boiler_additive additive_other

additive_online Page 24facility _units facility _id unit_id 1731 HB1 Page 25unit_boilers

facility _id unit_id boiler_id 1731 HB1 1 Page 26facility _controls facility _id control_id control_group control_type

control_other

legacy _control cntrol_online

control_offline

NOx_reagent 1731 HB1-ESP PM control Electrostatic precipitator, cold side, w/o flue gas conditioning FALSE 4/1/1968 Page 27facility _controls reagent_other

NOx_ammonia

SO2_sorbent

oher_sorbent

SO2_scrubber_additive Page 28facility _sampling_ports facility _id sampling_port_id 1731 HB1-Port Page 29facility _stacks facility _id stack_id stack_height stack_diameter

sack_gas_velocity 1731 HB1-STK 300 8.83 125 Page 30configurations

facility _id configuration_id 1731 HB1-Config Page 31configuration_components

facility _id configuration_id

component_id

order component_ty pe port_near 1731 HB1-Config HB1 1 Unit 1731 HB1-Config HB1-ESP 2 PM control 1731 HB1-Config HB1-Port 3 Sam pling Port next 1731 HB1-Config HB1-STK 4 Stack Page 32configuration_pollutants1

facility _id configuration_id

pollutant_nam e

permit_ty pe_1

em lim it_1 em lim it_units_1 avg_period_1

em lim it_2 em lim it_units_2 1731 HB1-Config PM (Filterable) Fderal - Title V Operating Permit

0.19 1731 HB1-ConfigSulfur Dioxide (SO2) Federal - Title V Operating Permit

1.67 pound per million British Thermal Unit (lb/MMBtu)

3 hours Page 33configuration_pollutants1

avg_period_2

em lim it_details

test_method

em rate em rate_units guarantee_level

_explain

req_monitoring

eq_recordkeeping See Notes for PM units

EPA Method 5 or another method approved by MDNRE Unknown. See Notes

PM COMS per 40CFR75

--Recordkeeping per 40CFR75--Maintain fuel oil records for deliveries and in storage tank--Continue monitoring, logging, reporting ESP operating data.--Records of CAM exceedances, inspections, corrective acdtions, probable causes, resolution Unknown. See Notes

CEMS per 40CFR75

--Recordkeeping per 40CFR75--Maintain fuel oil records for deliveries and in storage tank--Records of CAM exceedances, inspections, corrective acdtions, probable causes, resolution Page 34configuration_pollutants1

req_reporting --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system Page 35configuration_pollutants1 --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system Page 36configuration_pollutants1 --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system --Quarterly

XS emission reports submitted within 30 days after end of quarter to MDNRE--Reports pursuant to 40CFR75--Semi-annual monitoring and deviation reports--Annual certification of compliance report--Annual reporting of emissions using the MDNRE MAERS system Page 37control_technologies

facility _id configuration_id

component_id

control_id project_title project_ty pe vendor_name

vndor_contact

vendor_phone Page 38control_technologies

vendor_address

vndor_city

vendor_state

vendor_zip actual_start_date projected_start_date

end_date sorbent chemical_additive Page 39control_technologies

injection_point

HAP_em ission_reduction

HAP_em ission_rate

HAP_em ission_rate_units

HAP_achieved_reduction

HAP_achieved_rate

HAP_achieved_rate_units

feed_rate feed_rate_units Page 40control_technologies feed_rate_units Page 41control_coal_ranks

facility _id configuration_id

component_id

control_id coal_type

Page 42control_pollutants1

facility _id configuration_id

component_id

control_id pollutant_nam e

Page 43control_costs

facility _id configuration_id

component_id

control_id boiler_retrofit boiler_new_install

total_capital_investm ent

total_operating_costs

base_year Page 44control_costs

CBI Page 45mi sc_controls

facility _id mi sc_control_id

control_description 1731 1 No Page 46mi sc_control_configurations

facility _id mi sc_control_id

configuration_id Page 47fuel_shipments

facility _id shipment_id

shipment_date

am ount_received

am ount_units

fuel_type state_country other_country

county Page 48fuel_shipments

coal_seam shipment_method Page 49fuel_shipment_configurations

facility _id shipment_id

configuration_id Page 50fuel_shipment_samples

facility _id shipment_id

sample_id am ount_fuel am ount_fuel_units

total_sulfur ash_content heating_value

hating_units Page 51fuel_shipment_samples

chlorine chlorine_units fluorine fluorine_units data_provided

data_other_specified

supplier_ty pe

supplier_name

supplier_address Page 52fuel_shipment_samples

supplier_city

supplier_state

supplier_zip

lab_nam e lab_address lab_city lab_state lab_zip analysis_copies Page 53fuel_shipment_samples analysis_copies Page 54fuel_sample_pollutants

facility _id shipment_id

sample_id fuel_pollutant pollutant_conc

pollutant_conc_units

pollutant_conc_ND

pollutant_conc_MDL Page 55test_reports

facility _id report_id report_type other_type report_description report_begin_date

report_end_date

before_control

during_deviation Page 56test_reports

deviation_reports Page 57test_report_configurations

facility _id report_id configuration_id Page 58test_report_fuels

facility _id report_id fuel_id Page 59test_report_fuel_ty pes

facility _id report_id fuel_id fuel_type percentage_massvol percentage_btu

other_type Page 60cem_data

facility _id tim e_period

cem_period_description Page 61cem_data_pollutants1

facility _id tim e_period

pollutant_nam e Page 62test_report_sampling

facility _id report_id sampling_port_id point_differ point_description befre_SO2_device

point_orientation

normal_by pass_percent

testing_by pass_percent Page 63test_report_sampling

fg_fraction Page 64sampling_runs

facility _id report_id sampling_port_id run_id start_datetime end_datetim e

unit_load net_generation fg_moisture_content Page 65sampling_runs

fg_flow_rate

fg_flow_rate_units

standard_temperature

standard_pressure

normal_temperature

normal_pressure

fg_oxygen_content

fg_CO2_content

fg_temperature Page 66sampling_runs

fg_pressure

Hg_loi test_method run_comments

fuel_id fuel_unit_load fuel_flow_rate

fuel_ash fuel_heating_value Page 67sampling_runs

fuel_sulfur Page 68sampling_run_pollutants1

facility _id report_id sampling_port_id run_id pollutant_nam e conc conc_units conc_ND conc_MDL Page 69sampling_run_pollutants1

em ission_rate

em ission_rate_units

em ission_rate_ND

em ission_rate_MDL

em ission_factor

em ission_factor_units

em ission_factor_ND

em ission_factor_MDL

run_pollutant_comment Page 70sampling_run_pollutants1 run_pollutant_comment Page 71sampling_run_fuel

facility _id report_id sampling_port_id run_id fuel_pollutant fuel_conc fuel_conc_units fuel_conc_ND

fuel_conc_MDL Page 72sampling_run_fuel fuel_conc_MDL Page 73