U.S. flag
        An official website of the United States government
          Here's how you know
        Here's how you knowDot gov**Official websites use .gov**
              
              A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
        Https**Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
              
              A **lock** (   A locked padlock
 ) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.  **
Menu


    close

        
        
                        
  
          Home
      
    
              How NIC can help
      
                
  
          **I need Training or Courses**
               Free e-courses available 24/7
              
      
                
  
          NIC Training Programs
          In-person and blended trainings
      
    
              I need Technical Assistance
          Guidance, support, advice, assessment, and/or customized training
      
    
              I'm looking for Information Assistance
          NIC publications, DVDs, FAQs, and more
      
    
              **I need other assistance from NIC**
              
      
                
  
          NIC Helpdesk
      
    
              Connect with other Corrections Professionals
          NIC Community Forums
      
    
              Funding Opportunities
          Cooperative Agreements and more
      
    
              Resources
      
                
  
          **News and Events**
              
      
                
  
          Conferences
      
    
              NIC Events
      
    
              NIC News & Media Releases
      
    
              Subscribe to NIC's News & Announcements
          Emails with NIC's latest news and initiatives
      
    
              NIC Quarterly Newsletter Archive
      
    
              **Featured Resources**
              
      
                
  
          Resources for Corrections Professionals
          Resources about correctional topics
      
    
              Topics
          Focused areas of research for Corrections Professionals
      
    
              NIC's e-courses
      
    
              Hot Topics
          Answers to questions about NIC services & resources
      
    
              FAQs
          Frequently Asked Questions
      
    
              **NIC Library**
              
      
                
  
          Search the Library Collection
      
    
              Ask a Librarian
      
    
              Free eBooks
      
    
              Sign in to the EBSCOhost Research Platform
          Free research resources provided by NIC
      
    
              Webinars and Broadcasts
          Streaming Video of NIC Trainings
      
    
              US State Statistics
          Statistics Information about US Corrections
      
    
              About NIC
      
                
  
          **About the Agency**
              
      
                
  
          Mission
      
    
              Staff Directory
      
    
              Reports to the Nation
      
    
              Funding Opportunities
      
    
              History of NIC
      
    
              Advisory Board
      
    
              **Divisions**
              
      
                
  
          Academy Division
      
    
              Community Services Division
      
    
              Jails Division
      
    
              Prisons Division
      
    
              **Strategic Plan**
              
      
                
  
          Subscribe to NIC's News & Announcements
          Emails with NIC's latest news and initiativesMy Cart
                                
                          
        
                Log in Home
                                    Transsexual Prisoners

      

                    
          
    Transsexual Prisoners
https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/ca7/18-2075/18-2075-2019-08-1...
  
            A prisoner serving a 34-year sentence for child sex abuse suffered fromgender dysphoria.  Biologically male, they identify as female. Correctional medical staff members treated the prisoner’s condition with hormone therapy. While the prisoner repeatedly requested sex-reassignment surgery, national standards of care recommend that patients undertake one year of “real life” experience as a person of their self-identified gender before resorting to irreversible surgery. That presented challenges in a sex-segregated prison. Correctional officials consulted with an outside expert, who determined that the prisoner was a potential surgical candidate if officials developed a safe, workable solution to the real-life-experience problem.Citing these concerns and department policy, correctional officials denied the surgery request. The prisoner sued for alleged deliberate indifference to her serious medical needs. A federal appeals court found that the defendants were entitled to qualified immunity. Such immunity protects officials from lawsuits for damages unless prior case law clearly puts them on notice that an action is unconstitutional. The Eighth Amendment requires correctional healthcare professionals to exercise medical judgment when making decisions about a prisoner’s treatment, and they cannot completely deny care for a serious medical condition. Those broad principles, the appeals court found, could not have warned these defendants that treating gender dysphoria with hormone therapy and deferring consideration of sex-reassignment surgery violates the Constitution. As they followed accepted medical standards, they were immune from damages liability.Campbell v. Kallas, #18-2075, 2019 U.S. App. Lexis 24655, 2019 WL 3886912 (7th Cir.).A federal appeals court upheld a permanent injunction based on the trial court’s conclusion that gender confirmation surgery (GCS) was medically necessary for the plaintiff, a male-to-female transgender prisoner in the custody of the Idaho Department of Correction, serving a sentence for the sexual abuse of a 15-year-old male at a house party. The injunction ordered the state to provide the surgery. The record showed that the plaintiff has a serious medical need, that the appropriate medical treatment is GCS, and that prison authorities have not provided that treatment despite their knowledge of the plaintiff's ongoing and extreme suffering and medical needs. Such a denial violates the Eighth Amendment. The court rejected the defendants’ depiction of a “reasoned disagreement” between qualified medical professionals. The court emphasized that its analysis was individual to the plaintiff and based on the record. The court did, however, vacate the injunction to the extent that it applied to the named defendants in their individual, as opposed to official, capacities. According to news reports after the ruling, Idaho’s governor stated that he would seek review of the decision by the U.S. Supreme Court. Edmo v. Corizon, Inc., #19-35017, 2019 U.S. App. Lexis 25330, 2019 WL 3978329 (9th Cir.).
                   Notice about external resources
    These links are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not constitute an endorsement or an approval by the National Institute of Corrections (NIC) of any of the products, services or opinions of the corporation or organization or individual. NIC bears no responsibility for the accuracy, legality or content of the external site or for that of subsequent links. Contact the external site for answers to questions regarding its content. Return to top

      About NIC

About the Agency
	Divisions
	Staff Directory
	Contact NIC

NIC Services

Training
	Technical Assistance
	Corrections Forums
	Subscribe to NIC News

Resources

Resources by Role
	Resources by Topic
	NIC News
	NIC Events
  
      Agency logo
              
                              National Institute of Corrections
        
                  NIC Legal Policies and DisclaimersNIC Privacy Policy and DisclaimersPlain Language PolicyAccessibility PolicyDOJ Links:Justice.govOpen GovernmentLegal Policies and DisclaimersInformation QualityPrivacy PolicySmall BusinessOffice of the Inspector GeneralBudget and PerformanceFOIANo FEAR Act DataVulnerability Disclosure PolicyVote.govHave a question about government services? Contact USA.govFollow NIC on X
the National institute of corrections governmental seal