7KH +RQRUDEOH -DPHV 6 *ZLQ 

WKH 1RUWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ 



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




+$5/(6 257+523

	





$9,' 5,33(77

	


 !!"#$%&
'%	%

#%&(%'(%')%#+

/01123')%' 

 ,*6 !'"

)''"6	!

-#6-88	9 :

'(%')%5*






	5##.$'(<.=	
>	%?'  + 	  =
  

$W RUDO DUJXPHQW FRXQVHO LQIRUPHG XV WKDW 3HWLWLRQHU 1RUWKURS

LV QR ORQJHU LQ SULVRQ %HFDXVH 1RUWKURS ILOHG WKLV SHWLWLRQ ZKLOH LQSULVRQ KLV UHFHQW UHOHDVH GRHV QRW GHIHDW RXU KDEHDV MXULVGLFWLRQ &DUDIDVY /DYDOHH  86    6 &W   / (G G 



,Q KLV KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ 1RUWKURS DOVR DVVHUWV D GRXEOH MHRSDUG\

FODLP XQGHU WKH )LIWK $PHQGPHQW +H GRHV QRW DSSHDO WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW¶VUHMHFWLRQ RI WKLV FODLP

 %'% +')&', # !!""   
5##.  $'(<. 
:   :=	
>	%'%+')&',# !!""%"  	%'4, 	  ==99  %'%+')&',# !!""

8
5"'?%&!''#%&)*%'@&')&

9 : 5 A'  -88	 5 B!! C "'? (!%'((%',!''







8
'(%')%5*,
%&'()((!%

?''!!%%!!"(%&'(%')%)*%>(,%#@'%#&4()!*(%=%'%'&"(%&!!*(*%%/
	D7
,%',%&!>(!%'%'%&'(%')%)*%#*%&!&4'&'(	'E%& $$%',&% % %& ##)%'? (('(%) # )*("  "%&*,& #'##%((%&%&("'*!4.%&'(%')%)*%@,%&%%&!'%)'?##)%'?(('(%)#)*("%&*(	

%&A*,$%#%&'(%')%)*%




=%'%'%&!(<("'##$&'((%%)?')%'

# !((((' # ))'   (.( &'( )?')%' )%(%4)*(&'%)'?%&##)%'?!(%%'* &'$ * %& 	'E%& $$%  
 !%')*"

 


%!!(%$%&%',%'

#'"% %& #)%*" ) %&*,((%'(#%&!%'%')

	'E%& $$%A*$)%%)&',#

?'@ # (%% A*')'" )'(')"",*( !(% !%'%'(*)) ' (*!!((', %& )?')%'
#%*%".#!*!%)'("".'#%&@(##')(""'(5)<( %%%&+')&',A*')'"(.(%$$*&?4%%
 = %&)*%>(!'''(%&%""(-?$ F,((".')$!%%G)"'$%&%& #"%)$!*"('H*(%(&'('()"'%@&"('#$%'%&%&&F4*G&'%  ! #$ H*(% 4*% @&&%?@$.%&'<4*%+)*$ & @( )%'". ' %&+%&!>()'4'"'%.@&&@'%&%&!"')
)%#',%&( )')*$(%)(  
 )%'*(4"%&%%&+')&',)


%&#(!)%#*"".'((%
I  

7KLV PDNHV LW LUUHOHYDQW ZKHWKHU %UDYHUPDQ VKRXOG KDYH

UHFRJQL]HG WKHUH ZDV DQ LQVXIILFLHQW EDVLV IRU D 7HUU\ VWRS

%&!%"&'(%%.%&%&@((<%!!)&

%&##')()?(%'))*4%@%&##')(%&%#%&$(<%&!%$!%.&'(!)<%(F'#&@*"G%&!('F(*G'(B>,
%

III5 /0/C-?$$)"&'(F!(!)%'?%%&%'$G%&!(!)%'?#$@&')&@%A*,&'()*)%)&')(II
	%I/F<',""%&'#$%'
,%'%)('%'')"*',%&@.+J%&!K".%&@.%&'(&!!
'%#"+J%&!K@(',.%&','?"*%'".&%@(%&@.
!)'?'%GB>,
%I75 /1C 

$ ,,(('?'(',&%#*"?'*( %%.$',&%%&?4(H*')<%H*%&'()"'%>()&)%'L%'#F?"*%'((G@'%&%&","#''%'?%&"(('%'(@'%&'%&$''$*$,#)$!%)%!)'?)"'$(@<@&%&%)"'$'(4()$!*"('.*@)"'%'')%(%&%&)%#".

& )*% %%( ( !%%". 4?'*( %& !() # 

'?"*%. %%' !' % %&!>( $'((' #$'A* !((((' (%%', FJ%K& '(  H*(%' %&%5)<(""'(%'%&!G %0?

@'%&%&4#'%#%.(>&'(',&%
%%&'<%&'(F H*(%'G 4*% %&'( ( 
 &? '()*((  %'".-?$ ' % !)'? %&% %& @( F H*(%'G4*%%&$%%!'$'".4)*('0!! "# "-?$)*"%".+%&!(&'(E!%%&*%& $$%4*%&)(('"."'&'$(%%&!>(@(%%#$'(%%&))'?((#%&##')(> )*)%-)*(-?$4"'?%&% (%!&%))*'%'(%*(4"%#'&'(4"'#@'%&'%&,#!#(('")$!%)&'( #'"* % #'"  (*!!((' $%' )% $% %&(%#)(%'%*%'"'##)%'?((H*'#"&4(%&!>(	'E%& $$%)"'$$*(%#'"

 

%&!(.(&'(%'")*("(&*%&))'?')##,'

 *,*(%0  .

%'%="')!%$%%&%%@ , F
(G A( *%#'% @8.&*-*(	%%''%'%&'#$%'

&%($.%'%="')

"'?""'()'?')%'!+'*%("%%&*'#$(%%' @& %&. 4(? %@%"<',   # %& $"( @()'!%'')"*'%&%'!&%&!

 (%&##')(!!)&

&'((&*"!")'%*&&'((%%%$!%%@"<!)*"(""'((%!!%&

""'(5)<(4%&(<

""'(E%(<%&!%$)$!"' #%#'',)%4""'((<%&!'#&&(!( %&! $'%% %&%()<""'(%&(%%&$'A*')

 #%(%',%&!""'

%&!&!")*&'((()&#%&4,?"",

+')&',)&,%&!@'%&

(*4(%)?$4. *%. ')*'% *% !((((',4%@707,)*%(%)%&!%',&% %%.')-?$!(%'"
  

%&! !!" &'( )?')%' '(', %& 	'E%&

 $$%)"'$&@?)('(*!!%#&'(&4(!%'%'&+')&',*%# !!"(A)%%&)"'$&+')&',	*!$*%'%&!>("?#()!!"

 #% *(*))((#*"". !!"', &'( )?')%' %&!

#'"!%'%'#@'%#&4()!*(@'%&%&
'%	%%('(%')%*%#%&(%'(%')%#+')&',?$4I/%&'(%')%)*%,%%&@'%

(!% ?' '!!%% @ !!"( %&

'(%')%)*%>(*"',





?'@%&'(%')%)*%>()'('%,%.

@'%#&4()!*(?$% 
1

/I /0 BI%& ' C  
 ( ', @ )(' %&(*4(%%'? (%( ,?', %& ?'@ # (%% )*%)'('()&"",'#"&4(!%'%'&%/

-)*( %&! #'" &'( !%'%' #%  %&

 %'%'($##)%'?%&="%. )%BF = GC(%(%&(%##"&4(?'@*/
	D7& = $%& (%# ?'@ (%#%&'/
	D7BC%!?'6

 !!"')%'#@'%#&4()!*(4&"##!(')*(%.!*(*%%%&A*,$%#%&(%%)*%(&""%4,%@'%&(!)%%.)"'$%&%@(A*')%%&$'%('	%%)*%!)',(*"(( %& A*')%' # %& )"'$ BC (*"% ' )'(' %&% @( )%. %  '?"? *(4"!!"')%'#)"".(%4"'(&""@(%$'4.%&	*!$*%#%&
'%	%%(;BC(*"%')'('%&%@(4(*(4"%$'%'#%& #)%('"',&%#%&?')!(%'%&	%%)*%!)',

 

$V WR WKH LQLWLDO TXHVWLRQLQJ WK

KHDULQJ KDV VSRNHQ WR WKHVH PDWWHUHPSKDWLFDOO\ VWDWHG 3WKDW 0U %UDYHUPD

LQWHUYLHZ ZLWK 0U >1RUWKURS@ WKDW 0U KLV SRFNHWV DGYLVHG WKDW KH >KDG@ EXG LQ KILQGLQJ ́ *LQWKHU +U¶J 9 DW  -$ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI D IDFWXDO LVVXH PDGH E\ WR EH FRUUHFW ́  86&   H 7ZH PXVW GHHP 1RUWKURS WR KDYH WROG %UDYSROLFH ZHUH YROXQWDU\ EXW LW WKHQ LPSRVGXW\ IRU FRXQVHO WR GLVEHOLHYH KLV FOLHQW ZLWK KLV FOLHQW¶V VWDWHPHQWV 2WKHUZLVH FRXQVHO ́ XQGHU 6WULFNODQG 7KH FRXUW¶V KR

WKDW D )RXUWK $PHQGPHQW FKDOOHQJH EH SDZKHUH WKHUH HYLGHQFH WR EH VXSSUHVVHG VRZKDW WKH 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW UHTXLUHV DQG WKH MXGLFLDO V\VWHP RU SURYLGH WKH DSSURSU

#?"*%',)$!"')@'%&%' ' %& (%,(% %$)*(">( )*)% 4(  @&$ %&  ) # #*%&(((($%#%%.!#$)4$%"'$'%%&'(%%')(%*)% %& )')*$(%)( )*)%  % ?"*% %& !(!)%'?%%&%'$G


 %& '##)%'?(( &'

+')&', -?$ %(%'#' %%&!>(F%%$!%%"?G-&4(<%)$?(!&'($?$%@(!$!%4.@ %< ' ))%' @'%& $J%&!K'%!!"'<H*5 7IC%&!?%"-%.',%"?&4(%!!)% ".  %&!>( 4', -?$>(!#$)
%'( ? "((  #)% %&% -?)'',@&%&%$<(*!!
  

)*%@(%%%&%F##')('%,,'.?4',))'?)%'?'%.'$<',%&(H*(%(%&%)((*")*%))*#'%&%%&'(%&',%'')%%&%%&##')()?.$((,%&%)$!"')@'%&%&'H*(%%(!<@'%&#%E$'&'(%')<%@(H*'(%!))*G'1II/BI%&'C; '()1III7 BI%&'

CBF&"%&%4)*(%&#%?"*%'".,?%&%')<%%%&##')%&##')'%#*(%%*%&%')<%%%&#%%<',%&%')<%'%)(%'%*%('L*GC

&H*(%'%&4)$(@&%?')E'(%(E'(%

%&% %& ##')(> (%%$%( )?. %& $((, %&%%&!>()$!"')@(H*'&'(@(##')5)<(H*'?)%4*%@&%&&* 

 .%&', & %&! #*( % )$!". $!5)<(>( (%%$% %&% & @*" &?  F!44".%&',G B >, 


 % 10 5  7C @'%& &'((%%$%H*%4.%&$A'%. %(.',&

@*" % &? "% %&! @"< @. *', &'('?(%',%'#)*(M?##')5)<(M<@(@&%&@*"&?'%'('((*#".!'!&"'$!%)&%%&)'()"((%&##')('(%E!"'%&%%&.& )'?%'!(<($H*(%'(H*(%%&%%&!F'#&@*"G$!%.&'(!)<%( !',  %& @. %& ##')( 4&? %&'($',&%)(%'%*%(%!4*%'%$',&%%%&!?'%"."-?$%4"'?%&%'%'%

? @ %& (*##')'% ) ?') % (*!!%

#'',   ?'"%' @  % (< % A*')%@&%& '  )*%#)%*" *'?(  (*))((#*"(*!!(('$%' )*"&?4$4.%&!'0  %&!>( !%'%' '( 4(  %& (*!!( *%%#'"* # -?$ % "'%',%  4?'*(  )'('?*%& $$%)"'$-*%4(@&%%&!%"-?$4*%&'()*%-?$&(%4"'?%&%)"'$@*"4(*))((#*"!*!((

 

&
'%	%%(	*!$*

(%%*% (!)'#')"". ((', )'('( F)%. %G  '?!!"')%'G#)"".(%4"'(&
7
	1I0	%B000C&*%E!"'%&F)%.%G)"".(%4"'(&#'?( %  ))"*(' !!('%	*!$*%K   H*(%' #)'()('##%".%&J%&(%#$%'"".''(%',*'(&4"


)%(%(%%)*%)'('

!!"')%'#)"".(%4"'(&#(%% )*%>( !!"')%' # (*)*(4"G&%0 ##'(%%A*')%'*()*%))"*(''%('!%)'('!!"')"".(%4"'(&'))%".G&%F%&4*(4"G&

& '(%')% )*% 4"@ ?'

!%'%'*!%& )?"!'(%')% )*% )*)%  ?''(%')%)*%)'(&4(!&', @ ?'@%&%'(%')% )

+$"11BF .#'',(##)%$4.%&?'@". #)"4*)'(''&4()('(4(!%'%'N((%%)*%%'"%&O )'4'"'%. %$'%'  #)%> %& '(%')% )*%N( #)%*" GCB)'%%'($'%%C;IBI%&'ICBF&'(%')%%$'%'%&!!%#'@(4(*!%&%()'!%#+?'@GC%&##)%*"#'',(
I  

7KH 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW DSSOLHV WR WKH 6WDWHV WKURXJK WKH

)RXUWHHQWK $PHQGPHQW *LGHRQ Y :DLQZULJKW  86  

 6 &W   / (G G  

/LNH WKH 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW WKH )RXUWK $PHQGPHQW DSSOLHV WR

WKH 6WDWHV WKURXJK WKH )RXUWHHQWK $PHQGPHQW 0DSS Y 2KLR  86

   6 &W   / (G G  







 &'( !%'%' %&! (.( &'( %'" )*(" ')

-?$$((('*(%&%&)(%#*)%'(%&)*(",*%*%&	'E%& $$%
	(%$3
BF
"")'$'"!()*%'(%&))*((&""A.%&',&%%&?%& ((',$%#*("#&'(#)GC'('(%(-?$')$!%%".#'"% $? #%& (*!!((' #%& ))' ?') *(,'(% &'$ % %'"  ))', % %&! %& !"')'()? %&'( ))' *',  *"@#*" ('L* ()&

&*%& $$%!&'4'%(F*(4"()&(

('L*(G
	(%$
3?'))?

#$  '""," ()& '( '$'(('4"    '1
	1/11/1	%11I7/9I7BC*%&?'))?'')%".#$'"","()&  ('L* '( "( '$'(('4" ( F#*'% # %&!'(*(%G" 'I/
	I/0

0	%11/0/97B/C;" '1
	//7/1	%09BI1C;- !,'7
	

1/711;0	%/I91B0C

-*%#%$*(%(<%&E)"*('#(*)&?')

%%'"')%!!"-)*(H*(%'(,',%&$'(('4'"'%. # %&@'( "?% ?') ("$%*)&*!%&F4(')A*(%')G#)?')%'%&	*!$*%4( *%& $$% )"'$( #$ &4( ?'@. 

	1I0I	%II

 

1RUWKULS >VLF@ GLGQ¶W KDYH WKLV EWR \RX ULJKW"$ 3:KHQ 0U 1RUWKULS >VLF@ JWKDW¶V ZKHQ , VDZ KLP NLFN LW 

7U DW  -$  HPSKDVLV DG7KLV LV FRPSOHWHO\ LQFRQVLVWHQW Z

DZD\ SULRU WR DQ\ LQWHUYLHZ 2IILFHU -DFWKUHH \HDUV ODWHU DV FRPSDULVRQ RI WKH FRZKLFK RI WKH SDUWQHUV KDG GRQH ZKDW WR ZKWHVWLPRQ\ GRHV QRW DSSHDU WR KDYH IRUPDGMXGLFDWLRQ , VHH QR UHDVRQ IRU WKH FRXWKLV YHUVLRQ RI WKH IDFWV HYHQ LI LW KDG WKH RFFXUUHG DW WKH *UH\KRXQG VWDWLRQ LV XQFHU)RUWXQDWHO\ WKH DQVZHU GRHV QRW PDWWTXHVWLRQ LV %UDYHUPDQ¶V NQRZOHGJH LQ SHUKDSV JLYHQ E\ 2IILFHU -DFNVRQ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ

# %& '(%')% )*%>( !'' @4%@"%%))*%(#%&)$<',%".F!'()*(( '   + 

#'',%&%%&##')()""%*!)$?%(@&%%&'(%')%)*%>(#)%*"#'',(&/-   I 1 104)C  %& $A'%. &( % ))*%@&')&$'%(.$%'"?%4)"".*(

 "%&*,&))"*',%&%

","))"*('%@&')&#)*%"($#'',%&%%&%&!% $!%. &'( !)<%( ##')(>%$(&@#)$!*"(' ($))*( @& !"') (< H*(%'(E$'%&''?'*">('%'#')%()&&'(&"*,,,M(")?.  $((, %&% )$!"'H*'G  70 
	  BH*%%'$<($'%%C
)
  

7KLV VKRXOG QRW EH PLVFRQVWUXHG DV D FODLP WKDW WKHUH LV QR

VXSSRUW DQ\ZKHUH IRU SHWLWLRQHU 2IILFHU -DFNVRQ¶V WHVWLPRQ\ DW WKH

*LQWKHU KHDULQJ WKUHH \HDUV DIWHU WKH LQFLGHQW DOWKRXJK UHOLHG XSRQ E\ WKHFRXUW ZDV FRQWUDGLFWHG QRW RQO\ E\ %UDYHUPDQ¶V UHFROOHFWLRQ RI ZKDW1RUWKURS WROG KLP DERXW WKH LQFLGHQW EXW DOVR E\ 2IILFHU &ROOLQV¶VWHVWLPRQ\ DW 1RUWKURS¶V WULDO D IHZ PRQWKV DIWHU WKH DUUHVW &ROOLQV VDLGUHSHDWHGO\ WKDW KLV SDUWQHU ZDV LQLWLDOO\ WDONLQJ WR 1RUWKURS ZKLOH1RUWKURS ZDV 3VLWWLQJ WKHUH ́ 7ULDO 7U DW  -$  DQG WKDW KLV SDUWQHU3EURXJKW KLP RYHU WR PH ́ 7ULDO 7U DW  -$  DIWHU &ROOLQV¶VGLVFXVVLRQ ZLWK 1RUWKURS¶V FRPSDWULRW

4 %\ 0U %UDYHUPDQ FRQWLQXLQJ 32ND\ 1RZ 0U

"'4%.#%&)'%'L@'(%)(#))'*)%(*!!%%&#'',%&%%&!@(('L='$'".%&)*%"'(%&!>(4',(%!!(&F(*,&%%"?%&G %0	)'".'%"'(%&(*!!( )$!*"(' !")  %&! % $!%. &'(!)<%(!*)&'('%'#')%'&)'(%4(%$4',**( ( % 4%& # %&( F?%(G &@? '(*##')'%#*(%"%%&)%.#)%*"#'',(#%&'(%')%)*%%&(%%)*%(

 "%&*,& !!" )"'$(%&?4

(%' #$ "?', *', &'( ''%'" (%! 4. ##')(5)<(""'(  +"&'(%')%)*%()'4(%&''%'")*%%&*(6

F##')"'?""'(%(%'#'%!%'%'>(%'"%&%=%'%'@().',4@4,&'($@&%&##') !!)& &'$ #% ##')""'(  &'(!% (< =%'%' % !!)& %&$ #H*(%'',=%'%'("'!!%&4,##&'($<')<'%*%&(%&H*(%'',))*%%%&'%.#%@.#$@&%&4,@(")%*%&(%G

B'(%%!%C&'(%')%)*%>(!''B%&?')!(%%%&!>(%'"C!?'(*!!%#%&!>()*%)"'$%&%&@((%'#$"?',%&4*((%%'@&&(%*!#$&'()&'(@%&(*$$(#%&##')( .(4"'%!%%'

 

91IB/IC;*I	%10190I

@?  &4( !%'%'

 $$%)"'$4(&'()%&(*!!(('#?')%&%(%&*%& $$%.

1I71//10I	%7(%4"'(&	'E%& $$%)"'$&'( )*(" !#$ #')'%!#$)(*"%'!A*')

II
	II/I/0	%07

%&!(.(-?$

#')'%!A*')'"%&!#$ #')'%". 4. % ())'?')(.(%&*%@,*(#E)"*',%&))%&##')('"","".()&%&%&))'%&.'()?'%&4%&!)%(%&%%&##')(4*((%%'%&##')(%%&.?@*"&?'()?4,  & ))' ))', '$'(('4"(#*'%#%&'"","

 %&!'('(%(-?$

(*"% ' !A*')  
# -(*!!((' %&! (.( %& E)"*%&))'?')!(((('

%&! '( %&'( 	'E%& $

!!"
.',%&)"'$%&+#*%&%-?$$)')&(',%%(<(*!!(('

&'(*%'()?')%&%&'()(%'%*%'"',&%%##)%'( '% '( !!% #$ %& !)*(" )(' $%'( % 
/  

@()?')#%&'()?(%'(@'%&#%%&'?(%',%'%&%(*)&$%'(@*"%4,%%&%%&$(%##)%'?%'"%)%')@(%$<%&#(%&%%&"*,,,@(%%&%#%&#%
,%',%&!>(!%'%'%&'(%')%)*%&"%&%

%&'( *"', #"" F*%('%&*'?(#!"*('4" )'4"*%)$(G&'(%')%)*%#*(4"4('(#E)*(',-?$>(#'"*%$?#(*!!(('#%&))'?') ))',%%&'(%')%)*%%&))'@((*4A)%%(*!!(('4)*(%&##')('()?'%@&'"!#$','?"'()&')'%%(%

'(, "%&*,&(E!"'4"@@##'$%&

'(%')%)*%>(,%#&4( "'#%&,*(@#' %& '(%')% )*%  ' *"', %& ##')(> ()&*)(%'%*%'"


%&*%& $$%()&4(%@%'(

! ( *(4" F(*4A)% ". %  #@ (!)'#')"".(%4"'(&@"""'%E)!%'(G.)'

1/
	117//	%7097IBIC   (*)& E)!%' '( # ()&( ')'% % "@#*"(%,,+17
	7II1/	%0119I/7BIC

&)*)%',()&')'%%(%!"')$.

()&'%$(@'%&'%&F'$$'%)%"G#%&!((%&%I1&	*!$*%&()(%*%&

@'%&'!(>('$$'%)%"%')"*%&F#$@'%&'@&')&&$',&%,'!(((('#@!(%*)%'4"?')G&

@? %& ',&% % ()&  '%$ ')'% % (%

E'(%( ? '# %&% '%$ '(  ", ))(('4" % %&#%%%&%'$#%&()& 	",(%&#%

&%&'%$@'%&'&'('$$'%)%"%&%'$#&'((%%&'%$$'((*4A)%%()&')'%%(%*%$
71
	7II70	%/I0I9I/B/CB*!&"',()&#A)<%

 







-88	')*'%5*,'((%'

)*%>())"*('%&%%&4,@(%(%@'%&%&A)%'#%#'',  ?'"%' # %& 	'E%& )('(@&"".'H*%%&)#'','##)%'?((#)*("


##'$',%&@'%'%&'()(

%&&',&4%&%&(4(%#)
#*(%##'$%&,%". #'%%.-?$%!+!!(','%!%%'*#)!(*$!%'#)%4(##%)&%&%(7
	1I% = %&E'(%)#?"'%'(%%'"@('(*##')'% .   

F". %&( &4( !%'%'(%&%%&.&?4')$!%)#%&'%%.(@'&!&!?'('(# = #(%%)'(')'%4.%&)* %74*%!!"'".')'(' # %& +')&', * 7   7 !")?&?'4*%'$!(4.

<', %& #)%( ( %&. &?

%&!)%%<%&#'(%(%!%4)*(&(%?&?)"'$4(&'(''%'")*%(%!(%4.%&)*%H*'(
0  

%&% >( !A*') %(% (%'"" !!"'( % &4(!%'%'(,$/17/7BI%&'000C

&#'((".('('()*(('-(*!!"%(%&

".('('".?."'$'%)')*$(%)(E$!"%&*,& #%N( #"(%(%'$.$',&%&?!(* %& A*. % )H*'% &'$ '% '( % #*$%"".*#'%))"*%&%&@(%!A*')4.)*("N('%#)@'%&&'('%!A*.07
	77I0I	%///91B/IC ('$'" ##)% ' -
 %& *% )' %&% %&"'<"'&#'##%*%)$%%'4*%4"%'))%'%!%%' #%&"@ @(  !%%'" F@'#""G%%&#%%&%&%&",'%'$%F!A*')G)%$!"%4.-70I
	%1I0


%&'()(@#'(%(%('%&(%(%

#%& '    # %$'', @&%&

)*(">(#')'%!#$))*(!A*')-)*(-?$>(!#$)@(!A*')'"*%&'((%@#'$'%'%&!>(	'E%& $$%)"'$


 #'', %&@'( %& +')&', *% # !!"(

*(4".!!"')"".(%4"'(&#""@&%)*%)'-?$>()'('%%(<(*!!(('#%&))'?')#""@'%&'%&4*(#(*%'"(%%,. "%&*,&@),'L%&%FJAK*')'"()*%'.#)*("N( !#$) $*(% 4 &',&". #%'"G II 
	 % I/ @ ) %&'< #  !(('4"(%%,') $'% ' ,")%', % (< %& (*!!((' #$',?')'()?#%(%!4(("".*!.$*(%'!")<',!')%'?%'"


3)"*('

%&(((%#%&4?@	

%&A*,$%

#%&'(%')%)*%

 

,Q WKLV SHWLWLRQ 1RUWKURS GRH

&RXUW RI $SSHDOV¶ DUWLFXODWLRQ RI WKH OHJ6L[WK $PHQGPHQW FODLP ,QVWHDG 1RUWKWKRVH OHJDO SULQFLSOHV LQ GHQ\LQJ KLV FO

ZKHWKHU WKH0LFKLJDQ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV XQSUHFHGHQW LQ ILQGLQJ 1RUWKURS KDG IDLOHG LQHIIHFWLYHO\

")%'?&')"@&#%'
01B*!&"',()&#%&#%&$?'%#$&'$%<H*(%'',C; '   

0 B%& ' 7C B*!&"#%@(&)*##C

 %&! & %& *##"

5)<(""'(!!)&%@&'$%&!$?%&!")'%%&'(#%""'((%!!""'( %& !") %&! *")%'&4,@(()&"


%&()')*$(%)(5)

()&%&*##"4,')'%%%& +')&', *% # !!-?$ ' % !#$ ')&"",%&()&

-*% @ ?%&"(( #' %&%

 !!"(*(4".!!"')"'.',%&!>(	'E%& $

""'( ")< (*##')'% 4('( -?$(&*"%&*(&?(*,?')'(#'"*%(!A

&*%& $$%"'$'%(!

%'''?'*"(
	(%$!!"%4()*'%&'!(('L*((&""%4?'
0  

-DFNVRQ WHVWLILHG DW WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V KHDULQJ RQ 1RUWKURS¶V

LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO FODLP 3HRSOH Y *LQWKHU  1:G

  0LFK  HVWDEOLVKLQJ VWDWH FRXUW SURFHHGLQJ IRU FODLPV RILQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO

##'))%(%''?'*"4(%!44")*('F#'!44'"'%.G%&%%&''?'*"&('%&)$$'%%'%(%)$$'%)'$'*0
	0	%7/09B/C*%&##'))%?4'#".%'''?'*"*"((%&##')(4".(*(!)%(%&''?'*"&(4'?"?')'$'")%'?'%.11
	//	

%/I/09//BI/C

& '(  H*(%' %&% 5)<(  ""'( %'

%&! "%&*,&%'$$'%".(%%&!@((*4A)%%%&%.!#4'#'?(%',%.(%!()'4'


%&	*!$*%E!"'%&%'?(%',%.

(%! ))*( @& !"') *( ($ #$ # ))'6F4?'*(".%""!("'%)*(4%@!"')$ )'%'L( '?"? ('L*( # !((  ". @& %&##')4.$(#!&.(')"#)(&@#*%&'%.&(' ($ @. (%' %& "'4%. #  )'%'L $. @))"*%&%('L*&())*G&%IB'%"

H*%%'($'%%C&%(%'(@&%&)('',""#%&)')*$(%)(F (4"!(@*" #" #%)"' %& ##')(N H*(%(  %&@'( %$'% %&)*%G&

(4"!('%&!>(!('%'@*"%

&? #"% #%%$'%%&)*%@'%& 5)<(""'(%&!(*,&%%"?%&4#5)<(')%""'(%(%!&'$5)<(&(%(%'#'%&%&@*" % &? "% %&! @"< @. F*', $.'?(%',%'#&'$G %&##')(,?%&!

)"'')%'%&%&@(%#%"?4.(<',&'$%

 


 (*!!% # %&'( ,*$% 

	*!$*%>(!'''-1I1	%/1/9%& *% #* %'" )*(">( ,,?%',#)%'%&!*!"')%"$%#%&*"'%)(%'%*%%&F!A*')G(('(%)#)*("%&%&*"%'$%*%)$$',&%&?)&

)*%( (&*" #)*(  @&%& %&%'"*"'4"!

&*(  ".('( #)*(', (%$'%'@'%&*%%%%'%&!)',@(#*$%"#)%'?(%(')?')4)*(%&*%)$@*"&?)*("N(  $. ,% %& @&')&%&"@(%%'%"&

&%1I0; 2' IC BFJ
K  %& )%E% #)"'$P,*%& $$ !'( #" &4( "'#	$%&',$*(%)""'%H*(%'%&%'">GCBH*%',

@?%&	*!$*%&

%& *%)$%$'%'? %(% ,"". %$'( @&%& %'!A*')&4(!%'%'

BF(((*)&(-#$  (%',&%#@ !!"')%'

'##)%'?((#)*("((*4(%%'?  !)*" ',&% %&'$GC;' 71

00/9I0 B00C BF$ %&% * &"', ' -".('(GC9'<@'(
/  

%&!>( ('L* (4"  *', &'( !(%%'-?$<@%&%!"')&,*4".('L%&!4( *!  $ %&   .$*( %'! @'%&*% .(*!!%', ?'#'4" %'"  ,'(% %&'( %& #'"', # $%'% (*!!((& ))$!.',%)%')" )(% (4"%%.@*"&?%(%##')(""'(5)<(>((%!

?', #* -?$>( !(%%' #')'% @

E%((@&%&-?$>(!#$)!A*')%&!   (%4"'(& !A*') %&! $*(% (&@ (4"!44'"'%.%&%F4*%#)*("N(*!#(('")*)% %& (*"% # %& !)', @*" &? 4'##%G   II 
	 % I  	!)'#')"".

FJ@K& #( )*("N( #'"* % "'%',%  *%& $$%)"'$)$!%%".'(%&!')'!""",%'#'##)%'?((%&#%$*(%"(!?%&%&'(*%& $$% )"'$ '( $'%'*(  %&% %& '( (4" !44'"'%. %&% %& ?')% @*" &? 4'##% 4(% %& E)"*4" ?') '  %$(%%)%*"!A*')G
	%17

&?".#*%&%%&!>(*%& $$%

)"'$&$'%&*(@".)''#%&?')%%%&!>( %'" F@*" &? 4 '##% 4(% %&E)"*4"?')G&

+')&', )?')% %&! # ))' !(((('

'%&*%%&'$'(('4"))'?')+')&',@*"4?'*(".&?#'"%$%'%(4*#!?',%&!!(((())'&*(-?$>(#'"*%$?#%&(*!!(('#%&))'?')!A*')%&!

-*%(!%'!!%%(.(%&!$*(%(&@

$%(%4"'(&!A*')(!%(.(-?$>(!(%%'!A*')%&!".'#'%!'?&'$##'"'4"%'"-)*(%&(*!!(('#%&@'($'(('4" ?') ( % &) %& "'4'"'%. # ?')% (!% (.( -?$>( #'"* % #'" (*!!(('$%')*"%&?!A*')%&!

 

7KH GLVVHQW FKDOOHQJHV WKLV DQG 

FRXOG UHDVRQDEO\ ILQG WKDW QR ODZ H1RUWKURS &RQWUDU\ WR WKH GLVVHQW¶V 

1RUWKURS¶V FODLP WKDW 2IILFHU &ROOLQV VWDWWHPSWHG WR H[LW WKH EXV VWDWLRQ DV 

DSSURDFKHG 7KH GLVVHQW LV DOVR ZURQDSSURDFKHG WKH 2IILFHUV DW WKH 2IILFHU¶V 

$W WKH *LQWKHU KHDULQJ 2IILFHU 4 <RX GLGQ¶W WDON WR 0U 1VHDWHG"$ 1R






4 +RZ GLG 0U 1RUWKURS $ +H VWRRG XS4 :LWKRXW \RX RU \RXU 

WHOOLQJ KLP WR VWDQG XS

$ &RUUHFW4 6R DW WKLV SRLQW SULRU 

VWDQGLQJ XS XS RQ KLSDUWQHU KDG QRW FRQ

VXUYHLOODQFH WR GHWHUPQDUFRWLF VHOOLQJ RU DQFRQGXFWHG E\ 0U 1JHQWOHPDQ LQ WKH JUHHQ 

$ 1R4 6R DIWHU 0U 1RUWK

SURFHHG WR ZDON DQ\ZK

$ <HV4 :KHUH GLG KH SURFHHG $ :DON WRZDUGV P\VHOI D

0U >2IILFHU@ &ROOLQV K

4 +DG \RX VDLG DQ\WKLQJ 

!*) '%'#')%'  %& 
  

RU \RXU SDUWQHU DW WKLV SRLQW"

$ 1R4 +DG ± VWULNH WKDW 6R GLG 0U 1RUWKURS ZDON

SDVW \RX DQG \RXU SDUWQHU"

$ 1R4 'LG DQ\RQH VWRS 0U 1RUWKURS IURP ZDONLQJ

SDVW \RX DQG \RXU SDUWQHU"

$ <HV , DGYLVHG P\ SDUWQHU WR VWRS 0U 1RUWKURS4 <RX WROG 2IILFHU &ROOLQV WR VWRS KLP"$ <HV4 'LG 2IILFHU &ROOLQV GR WKDW$ <HV4 2WKHUZLVH 0U 1RUWKURS ZRXOG KDYH NHSW RQ ZDONLQJ"$ , DVVXPH VR \HV

*LQWKHU +HDULQJ ,,, DW  -RLQW $SSHQGL[ DW  6HH DOVR *LQWKHU

+HDULQJ ,,, DW  -RLQW $SSHQGL[ DW  2IILFHU -DFNVRQWHVWLI\LQJ WKDW KH 3ZRXOGQ¶W KDYH OHW KLP OHDYH XQWLO \RX ZHUH VDWLVILHG

\RXU LQYHVWLJDWLRQ KDG EHHQ FRQFOXGHG ́

$W WKH :DLYHU WULDO RQO\ 2IILFHU &ROOLQV JDYH VXEVWDQWLYH

WHVWLPRQ\ DERXW WKH VWRS 2IILFHU -DFNVRQ GLG QRW ,Q KLV WULDO WHVWLPRQ\2IILFHU &ROOLQV GLG PDNH D JHQHUDO UHIHUHQFH WKDW 3ZKHQ ZH DVNHG 0U

1RUWKURS WR FRPH KHUH WR TXHVWLRQ KLP KH KDG , REVHUYHG KLP VOLS WKH EDJRII KLV DUP DQG SODFH LW XS XQGHU WKH VHDW ́ %XW IROORZ XS WULDO WHVWLPRQ\VKRZV WKDW 2IILFHU &ROOLQV GLG QRW REVHUYH KLV SDUWQHU 2IILFHU -DFNVRQ¶VLQLWLDO FRQWDFW ZLWK 1RUWKURS

4 $QG \RX ZHUH \RX DQG \RXU SDUWQHU ZHUH

?')4#%&+')&',*%(%&'(%')%)*%% (*!!% %& '((%>( ((%' %&% F""'( ('!%".%&%&'(!%@(''%'"".%"<',%%&!@&'"%&!@(P('%%',%&>G
#%

 

 -?$(&*"&?)

%&##')((%!!%&!4(.$*(%'!='%%&!(*,,(%(*)&%'!,"".)*"I
	%1
'!')%'? .$*( %'! *!!"' (%('()4" #$)((3-7
	%0%& !'(*( % )%' &( )?((*"%#*"@#*%/0;" 1
	%/%') %&% %& *"@#*" (%! $'$'(('4"

 %%.-?$'%#'"

('L*H*(%'',#%&!'('##')*"%%'$,'@&%%)%')A*(%'#. -?$>( )'(' % )&"",II
	!(%','##)%'?(()"'$$*(% 4 @&%& )*(">( ()('',""%&)')*$(%)(


 #'', %&% %%. -

!(%%'%&'((%"'(*!%&%&'%#"%&!@(('L*-*%(E!"'(6


% '( H*'% !"' %&% %& *%P('L*(>#%&!(@&')&%%&(%%'&*(!()*' %'%'" %$'",. 
% $@&?  !"') ##') ))(%'(&'(#$%@"<@!(

1
	%I

+'$!%%?'#)

*)%')"")%'#&'()?(%'""  % $< &'( #'"* % #
I  

$W WKH *LQWKHU KHDULQJ -DFNVRQ DFNQRZOHGJHG WKH WLS SURYLGHG

WKH RQO\ EDVLV IRU WKH VWRS

4     7KH LQIRUPDWLRQ \RX UHFHLYHG

DV D UHVXOW RI WKH UDGLR UXQ ZDV LQHIIHFW WZR EODFN PDOHV VXVSHFWHG RIVHOOLQJ QDUFRWLFV RQH GUHVVHG LQ DJUHHQ 8VHG MHDQ RXWILW"

$ <HV






4 $QG WKDW¶V DOO WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ \RX

ZHUH RSHUDWLQJ RQ"

$ <HV

'#$% ". %" %& !"') %&% %@ 4")< $"( @',!%')*"%.!#$4)"%&',@(""',*,('%&8.&*-*(	%%'&%'!'%#*%&()'4%&!'%&%'!!?'.!')%'?'#$%' % ""@ %& ##')( % (((( '%( "'4'"'%.*%&%&##')('%4(?.(*(!')'*(4&?'%&%@*"&?A*(%'#'%&(%!'!%#%&%'!

 ))',". %& ##')( ' % &? %& (4"

(*(!')')((.%(%!%&!*&'("(

*(%)'@&%&%&'('"","('L*%&))'?')'$'(('4"#'%&%'%(

 (%%&#*'%#%&!'(*(%)%'!?'(

%&% ?')'()? (%&'')% (*"%#  *%& $$% ?'"%' '( '$'(('4"   %& ##')(('L%&!'?'"%'#%&*%& $$% #%4', '"","". ('L %&! )#(( % !((((',$'A*&'($'(('"%%&!>((%@&')&!?'%&A*(%'#')%'#()&',%&*##"4,&*(%& ##')( @*" % &? '()?%& ))''%&*##"4,4(%%&!>('"","('L*&))'@(%&#'$'(('4"(#*'%#%&!'(*(%

 

QH[W WR HDFK RWKHU"

$ 0\ SDUWQHU DQG , ZHUH

:H FDPH LQ WKURXJK GL

4 2ND\ %XW \RX \RX FDP

FRPH RYHU WR ZKHU>3HWLWLRQHU 1RUWKURS@ Z

$ :KHQ , WROG ZKHQ , HQ

DVNHG 0U 1RUWKURS ,RWKHU VXEMHFW WR FRPH EHOLHYH KH ZHQW WR 0U






4 2ND\ $QG GLG \RX ZK

WKLV LQGLYLGXDO GLG \R

DQ\WKLQJ LQ UHODWLRQVKDOO"

$ , GRQ¶W UHPHPEHU , 

VXEMHFW LQ WKH JUHHQ RX

:DLYHU WULDO DW  -RLQW $SSHQGL[ DW 

-)*( %&! @( (*4A)

H*(%'%*(%@&%&5)<(A*(%'#')%'#$<',(*)&(%

="')##')($.''%'%'

'#%&.&?(4"(*(!')'   ##') $*(% 4 4"%')*"4"#)%(%,%&@'%&%'%&( #)%( %&% (4". (*,,))*'('$$'%(%& %%"'%. # %& )')*$(%)( H*'', F%')*"4" ((G 4A)%'?4('(#(*(!)%',%&)'$'" )%'?'%.G'/0	%I0II9


#$%' #$  .$*

(4"(*(!')'%)*)%
!
I
	17
  

0910B0C@?4)*(..$*('#$%(%4%&(!('4'"'%.#&?',%(@#$'('#$%'(',%&((.$*(%'!$*(%4($?')#"'4'"'%.*%(((((%&"'4'"'%.#.$*(%'!*%&%%"'%.#%&)')*$(%)(&I
	110101	%1I97B/1C.!')"".)*%(&?#*(4"(*(!')'#(%!".@&%&!"')<@%&%'!(%%4"'4"@&%&%'!)%'('!%".?'#'4"%'"((&@',<@",
"'
I 1  0 B(% ' /C B#'', (4"(*(!')' % (%! (*(!)%>( ) 4)*( %'! #$ <@"'4"'#$%!?'(!)'#')((%$<)"#) '%( ,'(%%' *$4 ()'!%' # ))*!%( ',&4&@&%&.@$<',*,!(C;'4!
I1/70 B7%&'/CB#'', (4" (*(!')' % (%! (*(!)%>( ?&')"4)*(.$*(%'!()'4!"'))4%%&?&')"'%(!'%#%.'%
'%	%%('%(*%C;'2
11IIB%&'CB#'',(4"(*(!')'%(%!'?4)*("'4"'#$%()'4(*(!)%)))%".!')%#*%*)%'C;'
1I1B'1CB#'',(4"(*(!')'%(%!''?'*"4( )4% '#$%' #$ .$*( '#$%,',''?'*">(!!)%?"!"(C

 E$!" '  %& 	*!$ *% #* 

.$*( %'! )*" (*!!%  '?(%',%. (%! ".4)*(%&%'!)%'(*##')'%!')%'?'#$%'%(&@ '%( "'4'"'%.  I 
	 % 11  & .$*('#$% %" !"') %&% %& #% @*" "? !%')*" !%$% %  !%')*" %'$ '  !%')*"?&')"%&%(&@*"4,',%!%')*"$%"%&%(& @*" 4 ' !((((' # ))'  -)*( %&'#$%'@()4%4.'!%!"')@<%&*%#*%&%@&'"F)"()(G%&.$*(%'!F()4%E&'4'%(*##')'%'')'#"'4'"'%.%A*(%'#.%&'?(%',%.(%!G&

 


(3-
7
	II

  7 B000C %& 	*!$?')%)%(4"(*(!(%!*)')*$(%)(('$'")( .$*()""!4")<$"@',!"'(&'%@4*((%!).',,*##')(@%&4")<$"(#%&!"'(&'% "%&*,&%&##')(?')%&%'((*(!')'###')(#'(<59('L,


#'',%&'((%!'"","%&

'')%',!('().',(*##')'%%A*(%'#.!"')##')!(&%&!"')#&@!'%)$#$%("". #$  )"" $ #$ *<@)""-)*('%,?%&% @*" ""@ %& ##')( <@",)'4'"'%.%&%'!""'4'"'%.%!?'%&(4"(%!6F ))*%()'!4(?4"")%'!!%&'("'$'%((6
%@'""&"!%&!!( @&$ %& %'!(% $(&@?(% (&@%&%%&))")'$'")%'?'%.G&;/1/0BI%&)( &  # %& '')' %'%'"".E$' 
%@(( .$*(
%")<%'"#?%(%&%)*"4$'%%'11BF  .$*( %'! &@? '(*!!%#'',#!44")*(

5)<(""'((%!!

  %'! #$  .$*( (*%&', 4*% %& '#$%