5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

)LOH 1DPH DS

	

		

	








1,7('

	7$7(6 2)

0(5,&$

	






(55<

/(11

26+

	















 !"#$
%&#'	##()&(#!&*#+!#

 !#$,(#!%)&(#!&*# -%#+*./#0+&(1&

234$%/5+!%

$& )&(#!&*#+'6

!6+'7%+!/3

)*&''%'&'7+%3

8 !780)9%'0:&!*+&#

+'6(






	  9&*$  9;;&  < 9==0
0+&(1& -%#+*./ ! %#  !!/ 9 +($&%6		
	

)		:0+&(1&-%#+*./ !
9&*$9;;&	*##><9==0
0+&(1&-%#+*./ !%#!!/9+($&%6%'*&		
	

3 
 

$IWHU 7RVK ZDV FRQYLFWHG E\ D MXU

VXUUHQGHU YROXQWDULO\ WR FRPPHQFH KLV VHQDQG ZDV QRW FDSWXUHG XQWLO 2FWREHU  WR WKH GLVPLVVDO RI KLV DSSHDO GXH WR D ZDQKDG QRW SHWLWLRQHG IRU D ZULW RI FHUWLRUDUL ZGLVPLVVDO KLV FRQYLFWLRQ EHFDPH ILQDO LQ 

)		:	

9'&1!'#$&%

0:@&%'80)(!#&%&%*%*+!!&%6&%@+'6"%#







-0	9

%#!!/%%($AC($ $&("#&%#*!!*#$&((%#%* !&"&% E!*'+!AB$'&(#!&5+# %' # (((( ?&#$ "!&@+% %' **&% %' ?(+5(#%*(($?(*%1&*#'5*$!6%' '&(#!&5+#&% "!&@#$**&%'&(#!&5+#&%*$!66%!1!'&*##$'&(#!&*#*+!#(&%!&(% !*%(&!*/&%**!'%#/ !%6( ! *%(&!*/ #*%*+!!%#/ # &1 /!( &% '&(#!&5+#&%##$#&" (%#%* ! *%(&!*/ # '&(#!&5+# "!&"!&(%"%#,$&($?((#&

"1'+%'!+ AB#$1&6$'&(#!&*#*+!#'%&'#$'($!6+(#$#&%&6$2'H3IAJ#$&!IIIB#$'
 
 

#$ ">&"+"%#/ !%6 ! *%(&!*&( &%11&%6**&%(('##$!%6 !"!&@+%*%(&!*&(*%#%'(#$##$'&(#!&*#*+!#($+'$1&'#$($!#!">&"+"%#/!%6 !"!&@+%*%(&!*&(5*+( #$ @+!/G( 6%! 1!'&*# ?( "5&6++( ( #?$#$! #$ @+!/ +%' ($ 6+&#/    *%(&!*/ #'&(#!&5+#"!&@+%!*%(&!*/#'&(#!&5+#**&%,	

 #$ '&(#!&*# *+!#G( '%&   ($G( "#&% #*!!*# $&( (%#%* 5*+( $&( (%#%* &( %# % &6(%#%*+%'!


	
		


($ %' #?%#/%&% *' %'%#( ?! *$!6' ?&#$

*%(&!*/#'&(#!&5+#"!&@+%%'**&%($?(*$!6'&%#?*+%#( #$&%'&*#"%##$ &!(#6&%6*%(&!*/#'&(#!&5+#%'((((?&#$&%#%##'&(#!&5+#"!&@+%%'**&%5#?%II%'I23&%1&#&% 3
	KK2H%'2HJ%'#$(*%'6&%6#$#$'&(#!&5+#'**&%%'"!&@+%&%1&#&% 3
	K2H+%#% #$&%'&*#"%#*$!6'#$&%'&1&'+(?&#$*%(&!&%6C#.%?&%6/&%#%#&%/%'+%? +/'&(#!&5+#%'((((?&#$#$&%#%##'&(#!&5+#"!&@+%	*$'+
*%#!'(+5(#%***&%	*$'+

%!*#&**%#!'(+5(#%*D&%#%'&>ACDB#2A
%'&*#"%#BA"$(&('''B+%#+! #$&%'&*#"%#*$!6'($?&#$'&(#!&5+#&%6!>&"#/H2+%'( "!&@+%%'%F+!#! %+%* **&%

($ &'!#!&"#&%(.&%6&#$! !#$*$!6(

6&%(#$&"#5'&("&(('! !#$61!%"%##&'%#& /?$&*$ *$!6 #$/ &%#%'' # +!(+L $ *&"' #$#"!&@+%%'**&%*$!6(! !'&(#&%*#&6*#&1&#&(?&#$ '& !%# %#&(  
% !(%( # #$&( "#&% #$61!%"%#'&("&(('#$*"5&%'"!&@+%%'**&%'&(#!&5+#&%*$!6A+%#+!B%'&((+'%?&%'&*#"%#*$!6&%6#$('&(#!&5+#&% %((((!#*+%#(+%#%&%#$!&6&%&%'&*#"%##$*%(&!*/*$!6! !!&%6#5#$**&%%'"!&@+%!"&%'+%#!'

H 
 

##!&#$@+!/$%'''?%

($ CM6N+&#/ ( *$!6'&%#$AO!'&*#B	*& &*/($?( &% #$ !&6&% &%'&*#"%# *%("!&@+% %' **&% %' 6+&"!&@+% *$!6 *%#&%'&%#$$?##$##&"!1&''#$#*%#!' 5/ #$ !*&( &6 *%(&!*/3
	K2HJAI2K2HJAI22B$(##+#!F+&! !*%(&!*/*%1&*#&%*+'+%&($"%# !(*!&5' ! #$  ?$&*$?(#$5@*# #$*%$+( +!(+%# # 3 
	 KK">&"+" %#/ +#$!&;' *%(&!*&( ?( &1 /!( %'#**&%'&(#!&5+#&%*%(&!*&(?(%#%*'#(!1 &1/!(%*%1&*#&%#!+%*%*+!!%#/?#$*%(&!*/*%1&*#&%

9!#$% & #%/!(#!!/



	HJJA3AB#$1$&((%#%*(#(&'#$#5*+(#$*%(&!*/*$!6%' #$ @+!/ !#+!%'  6%! 1(%#%*' **!'&%6 # #$ &1!"&##' !*%1&*#&%(&%11&%#$+6$ #$ '&(#!&*# *+!# '#!"&%1.' + AB # C*!!*# 5*+(#$+%&($"%#"#'+#A?$#) %'%#((!#(#5B#$!A)&(##B&#'#!"&%'#$#	

?+'  *##$ +%'#!&%&#$!*(*+'5&' &'#$&(#&"/
 




7KLV YHUVLRQ RI )HGHUDO 5XOH RI &ULPLQDO 3URFHGXUH  DSSOLHV RQO\

WR RIIHQVHV FRPPLWWHG SULRU WR 1RYHPEHU   ,Q  5XOH  ZDVDPHQGHG E\ 3XE /  7LWOH ,,  E  6WDW 

		

	 !"

$&(*+!#!1&?('&(#!&*#*+!#G('%& +AB

"#&% ! % 5+(   '&(*!#&%     
2'IJIIAJ#$&!IIIBA! !!&%6#+"#&%(&%6%!BL
 
(IHJH

IHJJII,0H2HI#PAJ#$&!+6IIIBA+%+5&($' !'!B A! !!&%6 (*& &*/ #  + AB"#&%BC5+( '&(*!#&%&(' &%'(' &%&#%' &!"*%1&*#&%#$##$#!&*+!#*""&##'*!!!! @+'6"%#D!"
#$%3'2AJ#$&! IIJB %  33 
	 IJ AIIB AF+##&%"&##'B#$%#&

##$#&"($?((%#%*'+AB!1&''#$#

CM#N$*+!#"/*!!*#%&6(%#%*#%/#&"D' !&" E AB AI23B  $&( !+ ?'  *!&"&%

*%1&*##*$%6#$6&#/ $&((%#%*#%/#&"5+# '&' %# !"&# *#! *$%6( # #$ #!& #$!!*'&%6(!#$*%1&*#&%&#( &
J2
	H3HHAIJ3BACMN$%!!? +%*#&% +&(#!"&#*!!*#&%#%/#&" %&6(%#%*%##!>"&%!!!(**+!!&%6##$#!&!#$!!*'&%6(!&!##$&"(&#&% (%#%*DB(#$	+!"+!#(##' &% & % &6 (%#%* &( % ?$! CM#N$+%&($"%#"#'+#?(&%>*(( #$#!(*!&5'5/#$!1%#(##+#("+#&#!"(?!&"(' !#$(" %(M!N#$#!"( #$(%#%*&#( M?!N6/!*%(#&#+#&%/&%1&'D$$+(?6!?&#$#$'&(#!&*#*+!#G(*%*+(&%#$#($!!/&%1.'#$&(!+#*$%6#$%6#$ $&((%#%*

J 
 

$V WKH JRYHUQPHQW QRWHV 7RVK IDLOV 

RQ DSSHDO DQG WKHUHIRUH ZH FRQVLGHU WKDW 3  D VHH DOVR %LFNHO Y .RUHDQ $

WK &LU  KROGLQJ WKDW GHIHQGDQW UDLVH LW LQ WKH RSHQLQJ DSSHOODWH EULHI

7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW KDV KHOG WK

MXULVGLFWLRQDO DQG WKHUHIRUH QHHG QRW EH 

:H KDYH UHFRJQL]HG WKDW WKH QRQUHMXULVGLFWLRQDO LQ WKH VHQVH WKDW IHGHUDGHFLGH WKH LVVXH VXD VSRQWH 7KXV D QRW GHFOLQH WR DSSO\ 7HDJXH LI WKH 6

LI WKH 6WDWH GRHV DUJXH WKDW WKH GHIHQQHZ UXOH RI FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ODZ WKH 

EHIRUH FRQVLGHULQJ WKH PHULWV RI WKH 

&DVSDUL Y %RKOHQ  86  EUDFNHWV DQG FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG %HFDXVWKH UHWURDFWLYLW\ LVVXH RQ DSSHDO ZH GHHP JRYHUQPHQW¶V VXEVWDQWLYH DUJXPHQW 6HH  Q WK &LU 

8 !#$'&(#!&*#*+!#($*$

(%#%*+%'!5#$%'	



*+!#5&1'#$##$!(+#&%?$#$! %? *%(#&#+#&% !+((&#+#&%!#!*#&1/#$*+!#%H2I
	322AI2IB%/(&(#'	

*+'5&'##!

'#!"&%'#$#&#$!*(*+'#$!+&#%%+%*' &#?&#$&%CQ?#!($'G!+ *!&"&%!#$*%*# !'!'&5!#/GDAF+#&%6 " H2I 
	 # '#!"&%'#$#*+'&"&*

 ($G(#!&%'#$+( &#?&#$&%

& &#?!&'&%#%'"?&#$	


#$# 	

 ( "# #$ !F+

>*#&%#$'&(#!&*#*+!#%1!#$!	

##$ *#( 
 




7RVK DUJXHV WKDW ZKLOH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW¶V IRFXV RQ IXQGDPHQWDO

IDLUQHVV LV SURSHU IRU DQDO\]LQJ WKH IDLUQHVV RI WULDOV LW LV LPSURSHU IRUDQDO\]LQJ SXQLVKPHQWV 5HO\LQJ RQ D 7KLUG &LUFXLW FDVH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y:RRGV  )G  G &LU  7RVK DVVHUWV WKDW WKH SURSHU VWDQGDUGIRU GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHQ D UXOH VKRXOG EH DSSOLHG UHWURDFWLYHO\ LQ 5XOH DFDVHV LV ZKHWKHU D 3PLVFDUULDJH RI MXVWLFH ́ ZRXOG UHVXOW ZLWKRXW VXFKDSSOLFDWLRQ :H QHHG QRW DGGUHVV WKLV GLVWLQFWLRQ EHFDXVH XQGHU HLWKHUVWDQGDUG 2 IXQGDPHQWDO IDLUQHVV RU PLVFDUULDJH RI MXVWLFH 2 ZKHQ 'DOHDQG FDVHV WKHUHDIWHU LQWHUSUHWLQJ LW DUH DSSOLHG WR 7RVK¶V VLWXDWLRQ 7RVK¶VVHQWHQFH UHPDLQV OHJDO DQG PXVW VWDQG

% &((+   +%'"%# &!%(( 5*+( ($ %1!

*$%6' #$ @+!/ &%(#!+*#&%(  $+( **!'&%6 # #$'&(#!&*#*+!#C&#*%#$! !5!(+"'#$##$@+!/?(&%(#!+*#' # *%(&'! ?$#$! ) %'%# *%(&!' #'&(#!&5+#5#$**&%%'"!&@+%&% &%'&%6$&"6+&#/(*$!6'D#2A)&(##B$*+!#*%*+''7C!+(*&1!'&*#"&6$#$15%"!*!8+##$'& !%*&% *!&#/ *$&1'5/  (*&1!'&*#&(%#  +%'"%#"%# !'!'&5!#/	&%*#$&%*#&% #$@+!/(/(#"*&1&&;'*""%?(*&#&($1!&'%6%!@+!/1!'&*#(D#2A)&(##B


% ?$&*$ ?( '*&'' +!#% /!(  #! ($G(

*%1&*#&%  @+!/ *%1&*#' #$ ' %'%#    (&%6*%(&!*/&%11&%65#$*!*.**&%%'"!&@+%+(&%66%!1!'&*#2'#H3$&(*+!#!*6%&;'#$ ?   #$ "@!&#/   *&!*+&#( ''!((&%6 #$ ("F+(#&% %' 6!'#$# C#$+%&($"%#&"(' *%%#>*' #$ ($!#(# ">&"+" %#/ +#$!&;' &% #$(##+#(*!&"&%&;&%6#$"+#&5@*#(& #$+%&($"%#+#$!&;' 5/ #$ *%(&!*/ (##+# '%'( % #$+%&($"%#!1&'' !#$(+5(#%#&1 %((?$&*$?!#$5@*#( #$*%(&!*/D$#H3

$' %'%#&%!6+'#$#5*+(#$@+!/!#+!%'

 6%! 1!'&*# 1%  #! #$ *+!# 61 % %$%*'

2 
 

7KH HQKDQFHG XQDQLPLW\ LQVWUXFWLRQ 

XQDQLPRXVO\ DJUHH DV WR ZKLFK FRQWUGHIHQGDQWV FRQVSLUHG WR GLVWULEXWH LQ RUGHPXOWLSOHREMHFW FRQVSLUDF\ ́  )G DW 

+%%&"&#/&%(#!+*#&%&#?(%#*

6+&#/ *%(&!*/&%11&%6*!5#$  %  ? '#!"&%*""&##'&%!!!?$%&#(%#">&"+" (%#%* ?5 *!*.**&%$#HH,$*$!6(' %'%#?&#$"+#&@+!/&(&%(#!+*#'#6!+%%&"+!5#$'!+6(! !!'#&%#$&%'#$ *%(&!*/ #$ ' %'%# "+*%(&!*/ &%11' %/ #$ '!+?$%#$@+!/!#+!%(1!'&*#% +%'$#H3HH9!1!5#?%#$(%#%*&%6#&%(?(+5@*##  &1/!">&"+" &%11&%6"!&@+%%' !#//%&%11&%6*!*.**&%


%  
 

3B?*!& &'G($'&%6

&%  #$ ' %'%# &%*%(&!*/ &%11&%6 "!&@+%(%#%*'**!'&%6##$(##+#$#HJ3?1!?'#!"&%5*+(&%#$@+!!(?!6&1&%(#!+*#&% %' #$ 1!'&*# %/ !*$'  +%%&"+( 1!'&*# ?&?$!(&%% %$%?(6&1%%'#$@+!/&%(#!+*#&%(#$' %'%#?(5&%6*$!6'?'&(#!&5+# "!&@+%  **&%*+!#&'%#& &'#$@+! #$*+!#G((*& &*%$%*'+%./!5"?&#$#$(%#%*&%*+!#>&%'7
 


I


%?!*6%&;'#$##$#!&*+!#G(C%$%*'+%%&"&#/D&%(#!+*#&%!F+&!'#$@+!/C#+%%&"+(/6!   % % %   #$' %'%#( *%(&!'#'&(#!&5+#&%!'!# !#+!% 6+&#/1!'&*#%#$"+#&5@*#*%(&!*/D
%'!#$( *&!*+"(#%*(#$6%!6+&#/1!'&*##'+(%/#$##$@+!!(!*$'+%%&"+(6!"%#

%#$&(&((+5+#'&''&(*(#$(*& &*6!+%'4

*!*."!&@+%!5#$4+%?$&*$#$@+!!($'6!'

$A&%#!%*&##&%"&##'B,%#'#$##$' %'%#&% %1! !F+(#' % %$%*' +%%&"&#/

&%(#!+*#&%%'"!1!#$@+!/$'"1&'%*5/?$&*$ #$/ *+' &%' #$# #$ *%(&!*/ &%11' 5#$'!+6($#HJI$+(&%#$&(*+!#$'#$#

G( !+ %/ &( ?$% #$ 6%! 1!'&*# &("5&6++((+*$#$#&#&(&"((&5#'#!"&%?$&*$ #$"+#&'!+6(#$@+!/+%%&"+(/6!'?(&%11'&%#$*%(&!*/$#H

($ *"!( #$ @+!/ &%(#!+*#&%( &%  # #$(

!1&''#$&(@+!/((!#(#$##$+6$$&(@+!/?(%#6&1%%%$%*'+%%&"&#/&%(#!+*#&%&#?(!F+&!'#6!+%%&"+(/#$#($G(&%#%#?$&&%11'&%#$*%(&!*/ ?( # '&(#!&5+# 5#$ "!&@+% %' **&%9!1!($((!#(#$#+%&.$&(1!'&*#?( "5&6++( 5*+( #$! ?! %# C!#' %'*%(&(#%#D&%(#!+*#&%( !+%%&"+(1!'&*#(#5#$'!+6(&%#$*%(&!*/%'#$!?(%#C"1&'%*D#$#$#! &*.'&%5#$*%#!'(+5(#%*(%#G(8!#AF+#&%63H'#HJIB$! !($ !6+( &# &( ((&5 #$# C#$ @+!/ +%' #$# #$6!"%# %1&(&%' #$ (   "!&@+% %/D%#G(8!#J

 
 

)RU H[DPSOH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQVWUX

:KDW WKH HYLGHQFH PXVW HVWDEOLVK EHWKDW WKH DOOHJHG FRQVSLUDF\ ZDV NQRZRU PRUH RI WKH PHDQV DQG PHWKRGV GDUH DJUHHG XSRQ WR EH XVHG LQ DQ HII

VRPH REMHFW RU SXUSRVH RI WKH FRLQGLFWPHQW

-$ DW  7ULDO 7U HPSKDVLV DGGHGKRZ DQ LQGLYLGXDO EHFRPHV D PHPEHU LQVWUXFWHG WKH MXU\ WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQW PXVIXUWKHU VRPH REMHFW RU SXUSRVH RI WKH FRQ

HPSKDVLV DGGHG

#$+6$*!#&%!1&(&%(&%

!6+5/"5&6++(&#&(%#&"

  #$ "+#& '!+6( #$ @+!/ &%11'&%#$*%(&!*/ 

$@+!!(>!((/?!&%(#!+*(&%6 *%(&!*/ &%11&%6 **@+'6 &%(#!+*#' #$ @+!!( # &%'&*#"%#?$&*$*$!6'($%%' &%#%#&%/ %' +%? ((((M&%6N ?&#$ #$ &%#%# #	*$'+
*%#!'(+5(#%*%!*#&* *%#!' (+5(#%*D A"$(&('''B9!1!#$@%'&%*!!#'#$&%'&*#"%#(#$@+'6!##$%6+6*%#$(*%#&%+/! !!'#$@+*$!6' &% #$ &%'&*#"%#D &%'&*#"%#D#I A($G(!F+(#'+!&%65%*$*% $&(&%(#!+*#&%(##$@+!/!1&'& !#$@+!/#$!#$!*&(*$ +!#$!((%#&"%# #$*
%&#'	##("+(#!1#$##$#$ *%(&!*/ ?&#$ &%#%# # '&("!&@+%D#A!&!@+!/?(&%(#!+*#'#$#&#(1!'&*#5+##$!?(%&#$!%%$%*'!F+(# !%
 
 

C @+!/G( 1!'&*# !!(%#(  &%'&%6 #$#  *!&" ?(

*""&##' ( 6'&%#$&%'&*#"%#D 


&2H23'H2AJ#$&!I22B%H22
	AI2IB((##'&%#$*+!#"+(#((+"#$##$@+!!(?!'&&6%#&% ?&%6#$!*&(&%(#!+*#&%(6&1%##$"3H'#HJI  $# (&' ($G( (&#+#&% '( %#  ?&#$&% #$+!1&? #$!(&"&!#($G(@+!/?( &%(#!+*#' % "+#& **(&%( #$# #$ (&%6*%(&!*/*$!6&%*+''5#$(+5(#%*(%'($%&#$!!F+(#'%! !*&1' % %$%*'+%%&"&#/&%(#!+*#&%**!'&%6##$&(*. %%$%*'+%%&"&#/

&%(#!+*#&% ?( #$ '&((&#&1 "%# '&(#&%6+&($&%6 #$ *#( !"#$(&%3H'

# HJI  0&.?&( ($G( *&!*+"(#%*( ! F+/'&(#&%6+&($5 !"**!'&%6/#$6%!6+&#/

1!'&*#?((+ &*&%##(+!#'#!"&%#&%#$#($?( 6+&#/   *%(&!&%6 # '&(#!&5+# 5#$ "!&@+% %'**&%%'#$'&(#!&*#*+!#G(+( #$">&"+"%#/!%6 !*%(&!*&(&%11&%6**&%?(!!




8*+(#$'&(#!&*#*+!#'&'%#5+(&#('&(*!#&%?$%

&#*%*+''#$#($G((%#%*&(%#&6?	



#$'%& $&(+AB"#&%

3 
 








0
980)&

!#%'*%*+!!&%6&%#$@+'6""$(&; #$ 1!/ &"&#' (*''!((&%6*$%6(5!+6$#+!
 +%'!(#%' #$ 	+!" +!%!!? +%*#&% +&(# %&6%%##!>#$ #!& ! #$! !*'&%6( !(%#%*D&J2
	#H*"!#$@+'6"%#&"('+(%#%*$!*&1'C	%#%*(M+N!#$(#$##$@+'6"+#$!&;D    
 (

AIHB
%#$!?!'(+C#$%/&((+?(?$#$!Q#$(%&#( *GD&J2
	#H

2
	HH2A?( *%1&*#' 5/  @+!/   C*'&(#!&5+#%'((((?&#$#$&%#   %' **&%    D   E!5#&%R""&##"%#!'!B!*&1'(%#%**""%(+!#+&%F+&!/%'(#$!

,$& 
6!?&#$#$"@!&#/

 #$&( *+!# $( % +>"&% #$ @+!/ &%(#!+*#&%( !!!!(  8#$  %'  !"#!&%'(&#?(! >"&%#!&!!!&%#$(*((!1&?&%+*((&(%!!?/ #$!+%'	+!"+!#&%#?!&#(!#/5*+(
"*%#!#"%# ($G(*&"&"&*&*!#("%( !!&(%!(#?
 
 

I21!(&% +?+'/###*."!#$%#$ *&1&'&#/ #$&!(%#%*(+(&%6C'D+