06/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 02/1 2 

# o U.S . Departmen t

Northwes t Mountai n Regio n 160 1 Lin dAvenu e S.W . O f Transportatio n Colorado , Idaho , Montan aRenton , Washingto n 9805 7 Federa l Aviatio n Oregon , Utah , Washingto n Tel : (425)227-216 1 Administratio n Wyomin g Fax:(425)227-100 7 Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l JEFFREY.HARPER@FAA.GO V Jun e 21,201 1 VI A FACSIMIL E AN D CERTIFIE D MAIL-RETURNRECEIP T REQUESTE D ; , ; , / : Attn : Hearin g Docke t

Cler k ..I j -•.'..•;' ' NTSB/Offic e o f

Judge s ., . 4^^-4 3 49 0 L'Enfan t

Plaz aEas t

S W ' ' ':'•'rr^'^ Roo m470 4 •• ' Q[^' ^ Washington , D C 2059 4 ;- j I Q Re : I n th e Matte r

o f Patric k Carty , Cas e No . 2O10AL9OO0O 4 / d-^*l ' f^^Q

A "(Ifp

- 15^ 9 | 2. 0 l l - b t^ l Enclose dherewit h pleas e fin dth e origina l an dthre e copie s o f a n Orde r o f Revocation , wliic h w e ar e issuin g a s ou r

Complain t

i n th e above-referenc e proceeding . Th e FA A request s tha t

th e hearin g i n thi s matte r h e hel di n Anchorage , Alaska , an dexpect s th e hearin g wil l las t

on e day . Fo r

schedulin g purposes , counse l for th e FA A i s unavailabl e du e t o militar y dut y o n th e followin g date s i n yea r 2011 : July S an d11 , Augus t 1 2 an d15 , Septembe r

9 an d12 , 3 0 Octobe r

3 , Novembe r

4 throug h 7 , an dDecembe r 2 an d5 , Pleas e addres s al l communication s for th e FA A t o th e undersigne dat : Federal Aviatio n Administratio n Northwes t

Mountai n Region , ANM- 7 160 1 Lin dAvenu e Southwes t Renton , Washingto n 9S05 7 Telephone : (425)227-216 1 Fax : (425)227-100 7 Sincerely , DWIGH T S . WILLIAM S Regiona l Counse l By : Jeffre

y M . Harpe r FA A Attorne y Enclosures : Reques t

for Hearin g Complain t cc : Eri n B . Marston , Esq .0B/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 03/1 2 

# o U.S . Departmen t

Northwes t Mountai n Regio n 160 1 Lin dAvenu e S.W . O f Transportatio n ' Colorado , Idaho , Montan aRentorL , Washingto n 9805 7 Federa l Aviatio n . Oregon , Utah , Washingto n Tel : (425)227-2161 . Administratio n Wyomin g Fax : (425)227-100 7 Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel . JEFFREY.HARPER@FAA.GO V SERVED ; Jun e 10,201 1 FA A Cas e No . 2010AL90000 4 VM

- REGULA RAN D CERTIFIED ' MAI L - RETUR N RECEIP T REQUESTE D Patric k Ear l Cart y P.O.Bo x 291 3 Kenai , A K

99611-291 3 . .. .



### ORDE RO F REVOCATIO N O n Marc h 10,2011 , yo u wer e advise db y mai l throug h aNotic e o f Propose dCertificat e Actio n o f th e reason s ^^ty w e propose dt o revok e you i Conomercial Pilo t Certificate ,

. Afte r consideiin g al l th e infotmatio n presentl y apar t o f thi s proceeding , includin g th e matter s • presente dat

th e informal conferenc e hel do n Ma y 6 , 2011 , i t ha s bee n determine dthat : 1 . Yo u ar e now , an da t al l times mentione dhereu i were , th e holde r o f Commercia l Pilo t • Certificat e No . 574164196 . 2 . O n o r

abou t Februar y 19 , 2010 , yo u applie dfor athir dclas s medica l certificat e from Aviatio n Medica l Examine r (AME ) TTioma

s Wiggins , M.D . o n FA A For m8500-8 . 3 . Yo u answere dBloc k 18(k ) o f th e FA A For m8500- 8 "no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a histor y of , o r presentl y hav e diabetes . 4 . Yo u aaswere dBloc k 18(u) . o f th e FA A For m8500-8

- "no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a Mstoi y o f admissio n t o ahospital . 5 . Yo u answere dBloc k 1 S(x ) o f th e FA A For m8500- 8 ''no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a histbi y of , or presentl y hav e an y othe r illness , disabilily , o r

surgery . 6 . Yo u di dnot

answe r eithe r Block s 18(v ) o r

18(w ) relatin g to your'hj,stor y o f arrest , conviction , o r

administrativ e action . 7 . Durin g your

physica l examinatiorL , Dr . Wiggin s instructe dyo u t o chang e you r answer s t o 18(k) , (u) , an d(x ) from"no " t o "yes " becaus e yo u hadbee n diagnose dwit h di,abete s an d ha dsurger y fo r

divertictiliti s m2006 . 8 . Dr . Wiggin s deferre dissuanc e o f asecon dclas s medica l pendin g completio n o f certai n laborator y studie s an drevie w b y th e Regiona l Fligh t Surgeon . 9 . O n o r

abou t Februar y 23 , 2010 , yo u applie dfor athir dclas s medica l certificate-fro m. AM E Pete r

O . Hansen , M.D . 

# COMPLAIN T0G/21/201 1 05:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 04/1 2

• Patric k Ear l Cart y - 201OAL90000

4 Jun e 10,201 1 Pag e 2 10 . Yo u answere dBloc k 1 6 " 6 1 6 2006 " indicatin g you r las t applicatio n fo r

a n FA A medica l wa s o n Jim e 16,2006 . • • 11 . Yo u answere dBloc k 18(k) o f th e FA A For m8500- 8 "no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a histor y of , o r presentl y hav e diabetes . 12 . Yo u answere dBloc k 18(u ) o f th e FA A For m8500- 8 "no, " mdicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a • histor y o f

adinissio n t o ahospital , 13 . Yo u answere dBloc k r8(x ) o f th e FA A Form8500- 8 "no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a histor y o^-o r

presentl y hav e an y othe r illness , disabiHty , o r

surgery . • 14 . " Yo u answere dBloc k 18(w ) o f th e FA A For m8 500- 8 "no, " indicatin g yo u di dno t hav e a histor y o f nontraffi c conYiction(s) , eithe r misdemeanor s o r

felonies . 15 . You r

answe r t o Bloc k 1 6 wa s false , i n tha t

you r las t applicatio n fo r

a n FA A medical wa s

. , o n Februar y 19,2010 . ' 16 . You r

answe r t o Bloc k 18(k) was false , i n tha t

yo u hav e bee n diagnose dwit h diabetes . 17 . You r

answe r t o Bloc k 18(u ) was false , i n tha t

yo u ha dbee n admitte dt o th e hospital , for • divertictiliti s surgery . •,..• . 18 . ' You i answe r

t o Bloc k 18(x ) wa s false , i n tha t

yo u ha dsurgery for

diverticulitis . 19 . You r

answe r t o Bloc k 18(w ) wa s fals e i n tha t

yo u wer e foun dguilt y o f crimina l mischie f i n th e fourt h degre e i n th e Superior/Distric t Court for th e Stat e o f

AJ,aska , Thir dJudicia l

. Distric t a t Kena i o n January 13 , 2010 .

• B y reaso n o f

th e foregoin g circurnstanoes , yo u violate dth e foUowiii g provision s o f Federa l Aviatio n Regulation s (1 4 C.F.R.) : a . Sectio n 67.40 3 (a) ( 1) , i n tha t yo u mad e or

cause dt o b e mad e afraudulent o r intentionall y fals e statemen t o n you r applicatio n fo r

amedica l certificate . • b . Hav e demonstrate dtha t yo u presenti y lac k

th e qualification s require do f th e holde r

o f a n Airma n o

r Medica l certificate . Th e Adraini^rato r

ha s determine dtha t

yo u lac k th e degre e o f

care , judgment , an dresponsibility require do f

th e holde r

o f aPrivat e Pilo t

Certificat e an dMedica l Certificate , an dtha t safet y i n ai r commerc e o r

ai r transportatio n an dth e publi c interes t requir e the.revocatio n o f an y airma

n certificate s yo u no w hold , includin g Cormnercia l Pilo t Certificat e No , 57416419 6 an dany . other ' medica l o r

airma n certificate s issue dt o you . NOW , THEREFORE , I T I S ORDERED , pursuan t to th e authority veste di n th e Administrato r b y 4 9 U.S.C. § 44709 , tinat: 

# COMPLAIN T06/21/201 1 06:4 g 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 05/1 2 

### Patric k Ear l Cart y - 201OAL9OO00

4 Jun e 10,201 1 Pag e 3 .. . L An y airma

n certificate s no w hel db y you , including Commercia l Pilo t Certificat e No . 574164196 , ar

e revoked . 2 . Th e revocatio n shal l becom e effectiv e Jul y 5,201 L 3 . Yo u mus t

surrende r you r Certificat e o n o r befor e th e .effectiv

e dat e b y mail o r deliver y t o th e Regiona

l Counse l (ANM-7) , Federa

l Aviatio n Administration , Northwes t Mountai n Region , 160 1 LindAvenu e Southwest , Renton , Washington 98057 . 4 . N o applicatio n fo

r anew certificat

e shall b e accepte

dfromyou , no r

shal l an y suc

h certificat e b e issaie dto yo u fo r aperio do f

on e yea r fromthe dais , o

f service.o f thi s order o r th e date yo

u surrende r you r Certificate , whicheve

r i s later.

- If yo u hav b an y question s regardin g this'T^ptice , ple^ e contact FA A attomeyJef

f Harpe r a t telephon e numbe r

(425 ) 227-2161 . "^

^ DWTGH T S : WILLIAM S Regiona l Counse l By : ;Hre y M . Harpe

r •FAAAttorne y ' JMH/mc cc : • Erin , B . Marston , Esquir e 82 1 Street , Suit

e 20 8 Anchorage , A

K 99501^213 6 

# COMPLAIN T06/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 06/1 2

CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E I certii y tha t

th e foregoin g Complain t ha s bee n serve dvi aFacsimile , an dCertifie dMai l - Retur n Receip t Requeste dthi s date , t o th e following ;

NTSB/Offic e o f

Judge s (origina l an dthre e copies ) 49 0 L'Enfan t

Plaz aEas t

S W Roo m470 4 Washington , D C 2059 4 TEL : 202.314.615 0 FAX : 202,314-615 8 Eri n B . Marston , Esquir e 821 N Street , Suit e 20 8 Anchorage , A K

99501-213 6 TEL : 907.277.800 1 FAX : 907.277.800 2 Date dthi s 21s t

day o f June , 201 1

MOIFAI RCHI N

Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l (ANM-7 ) Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 160 1 Lin dAve . S W Renton , WA 9805 7 425.227.216 006/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7

06/17/201 1 14:1 1 FA X 907277S00 2 ANM 7 MarstonSCDl e PAG E 07/1 2 aooz/OO B

w t ^ 

# o H & 1 ^ 7 > • ^ ' 

# s o r s B 

# 1

- +/ • <L > 

## S D O 2 1 ^ S i 

# g > l

C? i r- < «

o . 

# I Eri n B . Marsto n

La w Office s o f

Marsto n & Cole , P.O . 82 1 N Street , Suit

e 20 8 Anchorage , A K

9950 1 (907)277-800 1 Attorney s fo r

Patric k Cart y 

### UNTTE P STATE S O P AMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATION NATIONA L TRANSPORTATIO NSAFETY BOAR D I n r e Commercia l Pilo t

Certificat e No , 57416419 6 Belongin g t o Patric k

Ear l Cart y FA A Cas e No . 2010AL90000

4 NOTIC E O F APPEA L AN D OBJECTIO N T O ORDE RO F REVOCATIO N COME S NO W Patric k

Ear l Carty , fay andthroug h hi s counsel Marsto n & Cole , P.O. , ao dhereb y give s notic e o f appea l o f th e Federal Aviatio n Administration' s Orde r o f Revocatio n ("Order" ) date dJun e 10,2011 . Se e Attachmen t A

Patric k E . Cart y request s tha

t th e Order b e dismisse da s he di dno t violate Sectio n 67.403(a)(1) , i n tha t

h e di dno t

mak e or caus e t o b e mad e afraudulent

o r intentionall y fals e statemen t

on hi s applicatio n fo

r amedica l certificate , andbecaus e th e facts d o no t support th e sanction s proposed . Responden t

request s hearin g on al l unfoTunde dallegations .

Notio o o f Appeal an dObjectio n t o Ordo r o f Revocatio n I n r e ComfliercfalPilo i Cercificat c No . 57416419 6 J?ag e 1 o f

206/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7

06/17/201 1 14:1 1 FA X 907277600 2 ANM 7 Marston&Col e PAG E 08/1 2 gooa/oo B



## u p < 

## m ^ 

## o o ^ ^ . H 

# 1 o r/ 5 

## E t t . 

## o ^ < ^ ,

o a

• 1 CO •ft f J s r s « ? - H C3 v n



### - 3 r ^ O 1 

# 1 ^ o 

# 1 1 s 1 & 

## s ^ 4i ^

DATE D thi s ( i da

y o f Jun.e , 2011 , a

t Anchorage , Alaska . .^COLE^P.C . Attorney s forPa^fe k

Cart y

Eri n B . Marsto n Alask aBa r No . &511177

(;:^RTiFrcAT K

O F SKRVTC E Thi s i s t o certif

y tha t o a*ii s Ij4i ^ da

y o f iujie , M l 1

^ a tAi e im dcDiipc K cop y o f tb e fbregotn g document

vtvi S Maile d Hand-delivejc d Faxe d I D Hi afbllowing : Jeffire y Haipcr , Esq , U S DepBTtmav

t o f TionapOrtaiio a Federa l Aviatio n Adismisbralio a 160 1 Lin dAvflBU

E S W R«mon , W

A ?S05 7 

## jc/'K/Un ^

Notic e o f

Appea l an dObjectio n t o Orde r o f Rsvocstio n I n r e CommBTcial Pilc» t CJortiflcate No . 57416419 6 Pag 9 2 o f

205/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7

08/17/201 1 14:1 1 FA X 307277B00 2 ANM 7 ilarstonSCol e PAG E 09/1 2 11004/00 6

^ U.S . Department OfTranaportatio n Federa l Aviatio n AdnaJAistratiot

t 0£Bc e o f Resgifimt l Ctmnx d SERV;ED:Juii, e 10 , 201 1 Northwes t MoimtainRegio D 160 1 Lin dAvenu e S.W. Colorado , Idaho , Montan aR«itoa,.WasliingtD n 9805 7 Orego:a , Utah , Washington Tel : (425)227-2161 , 'Wyoffiin g PBX ; (425)227-100 7 JEFFREY.HARPER@FAA,.O0 y

' • FA A CascNo . 2010AL90000

4 VIA REGULA31.AN

D CEIOIFIHD'MAD

L - RETUS N EECEIP

T REQUESTE

D Patric k Ear l Cart y P.O . Bo x 291 3 KBHHi,A K 9^611-291 3 .. .



### ORDE RO F REVOCATIO N On Mani h 10 , 2011 , yo

u wer e advise db y mai l tJxcou ^ aNotic s o f Propose dCerfi5cat

e AoHo n of th e reason s ^ y W

B propose dt o revok

e you r Coimnatcia

l Pilcr t Cerdficatfi . - Afte r considerin g all th e infonnatiftn . presentl y apear t of thi s proceeding , includin g th e matters • presente da

t th e infbima

l conferenc e bel don 'Ma

y 6 , 2011 , i

t ha s bfte adstarmine dthat ; 1 . Yo u ai e now , anda

± al l time s mailions dhsmn . -were , th s holde r of Coiniaerdal Pilot Certificat e No . 574164196 . 2 . Q ao r

abou t Februar y 19 j 2010 , yo u appliedfo

r athir dclas s medica

l oertificat e dio m Aviation Medica

l Exaimne r (AME) IliorDas "Wiggms, MJD . o n FAA Fon n S500-8 . • 3 , Yo

u answorodBlock

I8(k ) o f th e FA A Foi m8500* 8 "HG, " indicatrng yo u di dnot have a histor y of j o r presentl y hav e diabetes . 4 . YD U aaswcre dBloo

k 1,8(u ) o f ih e FA A FoimSSOO-g

' "no, " indicatiii g yo u di

dao t have a histor y o f admission t o ahospital . 5 . Yo u answeredBlock

I S(x ) o f th e FA A For mSSOO- S "no, " mdicatin g yo u didno t hav e a histoi y o: £ o r presently hkv« ' aa

y othis r illaess , disability , o

r swrgcry , 6 . Yo u di dno t answe r athe r Block s 18(v) o

r 18Cw ) releliii g t o your"histor

y o f ajxest , conviction , o

r ftdminigiiative action . 7 . ' Durin g your

physica l examination , I)r . Wiggin s instructedyo u t o dhaag o ye w answer ? t o 18(k) , (u) , an

d(x ) hor n "no " t o "y^^ " becaus e yo u ha dbee n diagnose dvvit

h diabete s an

d ha dsurger y for diverticuliti s i n 2006 . S . Dr . 'WiggBi s deferre dissuanc e o

f H . secon dclas s medica

l pendin g completion o

f certai n laboraioT y studie s an

drevie w b y the ; Region ^ Fligh t Surgoon . 9 . On o r

abou t Februar y 23,2010 , yo

u appliedfo

r athir dalas s medica

l certifioat e ftom , AM E Pete r O . Hwasen , MD ,06/21/201 1 0B:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 10/1 2 OB/17/201 1 14:1 1 FA X 90727T800 2 MarstnnaCol G [gl0O5/00 G

Patric k Esr t Carty-20 1 QAL90&00

4 Jun e 10,201 1 Pige Z ' - 10 . Yo u anstvcre dBlock

1 6 "61 6 2006 " indicatin g you r las t applicatio n for

a n FA A medica l "wa s o n Jm e 16,2006 , • . 11 . Yo u answere dBlock

18(k ) o f thcFA A For

mS500- 8 "no, " indicatin g yo u didnothkvca ' histor y 0^ . o r presentl y hav e diabetes . 12 . Yo u answere dBloc k

18(u) o f the FA A For m8500- 8 "no, " indicatin g you di dno t faave t . • history o f

admission t

b ahospital , 13 . Yo u answere dBloc k

lS(x ) o f th e FA A For m8500- 8 "no» " mdicating yo u di dnot hav e a histor y o^-or'presaatl y hav e an

y othe r ilbessjdi^ahilityj-o r

surgery , • • • 14 . ' You answere dBlock 18(w) of ih e FA A For m8500- 8 "no. " indicatin g you di dno t hav e a histor y o f nontraiS © conviotbn(s) s eithe r misdemeanor s o

r fblonics . 15 . You

r answer to Bloc k 1 6 wa s faisa , i n tha t

your las t application fo

r a n FAA medica

l Wia s , „ onFobruaiyl9,20lO , • ' ' 16 . You

r answe r t o Block 18(t ) was false , i n tha

t you hav e bee

n diagdosedwit

h diabetes , 17 . You

r answe r t o Block 18(u) was fake , i n tha

t you bad ' been admitte dt o th e hospita l for diverliouliti s surgery . , . " • ' ' • . 18 . ' You

r answe r t o Block 1 S (x ) -wa s false , J n tha ; yo u ha

dfiurgery fb

r diverticulitis , 19 . You

r answe r to Bloc k 18(w ) wa s feliai n tha

t you wer e found guilt

y o f crimina l mischife f i n th e fcftirt

h degre e in thf

t Si^jerior/Distric t

Cour t for th e Stat e o f Alaska , Thir

dJudicia l Distric t atKfina i o n Jamiaiy , 13,201O . B y reaso n o f

th e foregoing circumstances , yo u violate dth e following provision s o f Federa l • Aviatio n Regulation s (1 4 G.F.R.) : a . Sectio n 67.403(aXl)jio-T^^y°^TM^^'^'^2.use dt o b e mad e afraudulent or intentionally &ls e .statemen t o n you r application fo

r " amedica l ccrtiS(fate . b . Hav e demonstratedthat yo u presentl y lac

k the qualification s require do f th e holde r o f a n Airma n to Medica

l certificate . 'XTa. e Administrator

ha s determinedtha

t yo u lack th e degree o f

cara, judgment , an

dresponsjibili^ rcqmredo f

th e holder

o f aPrivat e Pilo t Certiflcat e an dMedieva l Certificate , an

dtha t safet y J n ai r commerc e o r

ai r transportaido

n an dth e publi c interes t

requir e the.revooaHo

n of an y aimiai i ceriificats s you no w hold , includin g Commercia l PUo t Cardficat e No . 57415419 6 sndan

y othe r ' medica l or airxca n certLficates issue dto you , 1^ 0 W , TEffiRE

F ORE , I T I S ORDERER , pursuant t o th e authorit

y veste di n th e AdminLstrHto r by 4 9 U.S.C . § 44709 , tha t

' .06/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7

06/17/201 1 U:1 1 FA X 907277800 2 ANM 7 Marston&Col e PAG E 11/1 2 ®00S/O0 G

Patric k Ear l Cart y - 201OAL90000

4 Jun e ID,SO U , • ' - FagB 3 1 . An

y fi^rmffr s cerdficatK

no w hel dby you , including Commnrcia l Pilo t Certificar e No . 574164196 , ar

e revoked . 2 . Thftrevocatioashflllbeoome effective July 5,2011 . 3 . You mus t

suirendor you r Certificat e o n or befor e th e .effectivadat

e b y mai l o

r deliver y to'theRegiona l Counsel (ANM-TJ, Federa l Aviatio n Administration , •NorthWBSit:Mountai

n Region , 160 1 lin dAvenue SouJhweit , Renton , Washington 98057 . ' .^ • 4 . N o applicatio afo

r i new certificat

e shall b e acceptedfmt

o you , nor dial l any suc

h • CBTiifieat

e b e issue dt o yo u fo

r aperio dofoneyca

r fromth e dat

e o f servic e .o f thi s

- orde r o r th e dat e yo u surrende

r your Certificats j ^vhicheve

r i s later.

- I f yo u hav ^ an

y question s regardin g thi s Notice , ple&s e contact.FA

A attorney . Jef

f Harpe r .a t telephon e numbe

r (425 ) 227-2161 . DWIGHT s ; WILLIAM S Regiona l Counse l ' , , ' . ' * By : 

# /H^^^ ^

5yM . Harpe

r • FA A Attorne y • JMH/m o cc : 'Erin B . Marston , Esquire . a!2 J Street , Suit

e 20 8 Anchorage , AK

. 99501^213 6 U.S . Posia l Servic e U.S . i-'osidi--'^'-;^ ; ncpFlP T CEBTlFlEDr.nA.L,..BECEIP;^ ^

t r t r a a a C306/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 12/1 2

OG/17/201 1 14:1 1 FA X 907277800 2 Marston&Col e g]001/00 B

LA W OFFICE S O F MARSTO N & COLE , P.C . A Professicwja

l Corporatio n S2 1 N STREET , SUITE 20 8 ANCHORAGE , A K

9950 1 Telephon e (907 ) 277-800 1 Facsimil e (907 ) 277-800 2 Eri n B . Marsto n Bren t R , Col e 

# FA X COVE RSHEE T Thi s facslmil s transmissio n ma y contai n informaCio n whic h i s protecte d fay attDrney-ciien t prIvRege , {f yo u ar e no t th e intende d recipient, yo u an a hereb y notrfiec l tha t an y disclosur e o rtaldn g o f an y actio n i n reilano e o n th e content s i s shicti y prohibited . I f yo u hav e receive d thi s transmissio n i n error , pieas e contac t u s Immediatel y a

t (907 ) 277-BD0 1 s o tha t w e ma y an^ng s forretur n o f th e documents . FROM : Eri n Marsto n • DATE ; Jun e 17,201 1 TOTAL PAGE S T O B E SENT (includin g thi s iovo r sheet) ; 6 • TIM E O F TRANSMISSION : HAR D COP Y MAILEDTQYe s nN o TO : NTSB-Administrativ e Law Judge s . PAX : (202)314-615 8

Jof&e y Harper , Esq. , FAA (425 ) 227-100 7 RE : Patric k

Cart y Commercia

l Pilo t CcitifioateNo , 57416419 6 COMMENTS/NOTES ; Notic e o f Appea l an dObjection , o f

Revocatio n ; I F ALL PAGE S AJ%

E NO T RECEIVED , CONTAC T STAFF , A T 907-277-SOOl06/21/201 1 06:4 9 425227100 7 ANM 7 PAG E 01/1 2

FACSIMIL E MESSAG E FEDERA L AVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N OFFIC E O F REGIONA L COUNSE L

ANM- 7 160 1 LIN D AVENU E S.W . RENTON , WASHINGTO N 9805 7 Th e informatio n containe di n thi s facsimil e messag e i s legall y privilege dan dconfidential informatio n an di s intende donl y fo r th e us e o f

th e individua l name do n thi s cove r sheet . I f th e reade r

o f thi s messag e i s not

th e intende drecipient , yo u ar e hereb y notifie dtha t an y use , dissejnination , distribution , o r cop y o f thi s facsimil e i s strictl y prohibited . I f yo u hav e receive dthi s facsimil e i n error , pleas e immediatel y notif y u s b y telephon e a t 425-227-2007 . 

### DATE : TO : FAX NO. : PHON E NO. : RE : Jun e 21,201 1

Docke t Cler k AGC-43 0 202-493^514 2 Complain t

- FA A Cas e No.2010AL900e > Carty , Patric k NO . PAGES : ^ includin g cove r FROM : FA X NO. : 425-227-100 7 PHON E NO. : 425-227-200 7 EMAIL :