SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT

Appendix G: Alternative Emission Reduc tions for Rule 4694 December 15, 2005

G

- 1 Final Staff Report with Appendices

For Revised Proposed Rule 4694 

# APPENDIX G

Sources of Alternative Emission Reductions For

RULE 4694 (Wine Fermentation and Storage Tanks)

December 15, 2005SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT

Appendix H: Voluntary Accelerated Light

- Duty Vehicle Retirement December 15, 2005

G

- 2 Fina l Staff Report with Appendices

For Revised Proposed Rule 4694 Table

- 1 Potential Sources of Alternative NOx Reductions 1

Project Source Category Project

Life

Years Project

Cos t $ Project

NOx

Reduction

(tons/yr)

Marine Vessels (Harbor Craft) 16 197,850 121.570

Ag Irrigation Pumps 10 21,558 29.910

Marine Vessels (Harbor Craft) 16 69,288 52.760

Ag Irrigation Pumps 7 27,144 15.920

HDD Trucks Idle Reduction 5 9,883 2.980

Open Burning 10 227,182 57.200

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 23,092 5.790

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 142,190 34.900

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 48,382 11.800

Auxiliary Power Units 5 12,518 1.820

Ag non self

- propelled ICE 7 9,200 1.040

On

- Road HD Veh icles 10 88,756 10.150

Glass Melting Furnaces 10 22,120,500 2390.000

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 12,677 1.270

Ag non self

- propelled ICE 7 15,500 1.490

Small Boilers, Steam Generators, and Process Heaters 10 13,000 1.210

School Bus Replacement 20 150 ,000 13.400

Locomotives 19 1,414,286 111.671

Small Boilers, Steam Generators, and Process Heaters 10 6,000 0.330

Forklifts (Electric, ICE, SI) 5 44,457 1.950

Airport Ground Support Equipment 5 27889 1.127

Open Burning 10 185,212 5.720

Gross Polluter ID/Repair/Removal 1 3,000 0.078

Bicycle Infrastructure 15 50,000 1.200

Gross Polluter ID/Repair/Removal 3 3,000 0.059

Small Boilers, Steam Generators, and Process Heaters 10 5,000 0.090

Residential Central Furnaces 20 2,000 0.023

Commuter Subsidy 1 15 7,584 1.690

Electronic Mobility Telecommunications 5 239,402 1.950

Residential Water Heaters 10 500 0.004

Commuter Subsidy 1 15,600 0.110

On

- Road HD Vehicles 12 274,756 1.330

Commuter Subsidy 20 3,017,000 6.600

Bicycle Infrastructure 20 655,000 1.400

1 The project life presented in the table is used for calculating cost effectiveness and does not

necessarily reflect the actual life of the emission reduction. The list is for illustrative purposes only

and is not considered an exhaustive list of all sources of potential alternative emission reductions.SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT

Appendix H: Voluntary Accelerated Light

- Duty Vehicle Retirement December 15, 2005

G

- 3 Final Staff Report with Appendices

For Revised Proposed Rule 4694 Table

- 2 Potential Sources of Alternative VOC Emission Reductions 2

Project Source Category Project

Life

Years Project

Cost $ Project VOC

Reduction

(tons/yr)

Open Burning 10 227,182 66.00

Marine Vessels (Harbor Craft) 16 197,850 64.29

Marine Vessels (Ha rbor Craft) 16 69,288 5.55

Ag Irrigation Pumps 7 27,144 1.94

HDD Trucks Idle Reduction 5 9,883 0.68

Gross Polluter ID/Repair/Removal 3 3,000 0.14

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 142,190 5.26

Ag Irrigation Pumps 10 21,558 0.77

Bicycle Infrastucture 15 5 0,000 1.80

Open Burning 10 185,212 6.60

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 48,382 1.59

Auxiliary Power Units 5 12,518 0.37

Gross Polluter ID/Repair/Removal 1 3,000 0.08

Ag non self

- propelled ICE 7 9,200 0.21

Ag non self

- propelled ICE 7 15,500 0.33

Off

- R oad Vehicles/Equipment 7 23,092 0.39

Locomotives 19 1,414,286 13.84

Commuter Subsidy 1 157,584 1.46

Off

- Road Vehicles/Equipment 7 12,677 0.11

Airport Ground Support Equipment 5 27,889 0.22

Electronic Mobility Telecommunications 5 239,402 1.70

On

- Road HD Vehicles 10 88,756 0.48

Commuter Subsidy 1 15,600 0.08

Forklifts (Electric, ICE, SI) 5 44,457 0.16

Bicycle Infrastucture 20 655,000 2.00

Commuter Subsidy 20 3,017,000 5.80

Alternative Fuel/Hybrid Vehicle 10 28,000 0.02

School Bus Replacement 20 1 50,000 0.06

2 The project life presented in the table is used for calculating cost effectiveness and does not

necessarily reflect the actual life of t he emission reduction. The list is for illustrative purposes only

and is not considered an exhaustive list of all sources of potential alternative emission reductions.SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT

Appendix H: Voluntary Accelerated Light

- Duty Vehicle Retirement December 15, 2005

G

- 4 Final Staff Report with Appendices

For Revised Proposed Rule 4694 This page intentionally blank