### Consumers Energy BC Cobb - 1695 Fuel Shipment Analysis

Facility Code Shipment

ID Sample

ID Amount Received units Sulfur % % A

sh HHV units Mercury units

1695 L L090-3 10762.20tons dry 11.85 6.63 12,515 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1695 L L104-7 11202.67tons dry 13.67 4.96 12,601 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 L L094-6 14790.87tons dry 13.30 7.10 12,192 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1695 L L100-6 16006.68tons dry 13.63 6.71 12,212 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1695 M L124-7 9618.36tons dry 13.78 4.84 12,507 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 M L114-6 14067.56tons dry 13.20 6.66 12,396 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1695 M L125-6 14225.30tons dry 13.40 6.40 12,111 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1695 M L115-1 10604.63tons dry 12.06 4.07 12,933 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 N L141-3 9604.89tons dry 11.79 6.16 12,666 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1695 N L143-6 14627.11 tons dry 13.73 5.57 12,299 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1695 O L178-3 10808.17tons dry 11.30 6.39 12,584 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1695 O L183-6 14117.89tons dry 13.01 6.41 12,423 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1695 P L206-7 12213.14tons dry 7.63 6.43 13,269 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1695 P L202-6 12719.78tons dry 13.39 5.71 12,419 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 Q L245-7 10352.98tons dry 10.22 8.46 12,396 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1695 Q L246-6 15367.34tons dry 13.73 6.58 12,254 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1695 R L287-10 9760.05tons dry 9.33 7.62 12,604 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1695 R L292-6 15160.82tons dry 12.85 5.71 12,495 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 BW B-0077-2 49639.08tons dry 7.70 26.35 8,983 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1695 BW B-0101-2 49191.14tons dry 7.72 26.20 8,992 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1695 BX B-0122A12 21400.59tons dry 5.10 28.21 9,064 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1695 BX 2 27035.30tons dry 8.05 26.13 8,955 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1695 BX B-0137A12 21646.15tons dry 5.07 28.34 9,058 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 BX B-0137B2 27665.14tons dry 8.00 26.27 8,942 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1695 BX B-0152-2 49032.73tons dry 7.51 26.43 8,989 btu/lb 0.03 ppm 1695 BY 13 22598.41 tons dry 5.35 27.19 9,089 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1695 BY 2 26462.77tons dry 7.38 26.21 9,030 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1695 BY 13 21962.76tons dry 5.21 27.17 9,098 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1695 BY 2 26883.24tons dry 7.44 26.11 9,039 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1695 BZ B-0234-2 49565.93tons dry 7.49 26.04 9,033 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1695 CA B-0258-2 49892.19tons dry 7.60 26.34 9,012 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 CB B-0282-2 49082.92tons dry 7.72 26.40 8,988 btu/lb 0.16 ppm 1695 CB B-0295-2 48593.35tons dry 7.46 26.36 9,030 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1695 CB B-0307-2 48479.86tons dry 7.35 26.46 9,044 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1695 CC B-0323-2 48083.94tons dry 7.63 26.84 8,960 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1695 CC B-0335-2 49029.85tons dry 7.82 26.87 8,923 btu/lb 0.04 ppm

C:\PROGRA~1\Documentum\CTS\docbases\ProDocbase\config\temp_sessions\2642792650235236930\EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT2409.xls 4/2/10

### Consumers Energy BC Cobb - 1695 Fuel Shipment Analysis

Eastern Coal Bull Creek WV Boone 01 Elk Run / Sylvester WV Boone Liberty I WV Boone Wells WV Boone Brooks Run WV Braxton 03 Toms Fork (Samples) WV Kanawha 06 Fork Creek WV Lincoln 14 Pardee/Elk Lick WV Logan 07 Mountain Laurel Complex WV Logan Snap Creek / Phillips WV Logan West Cazy

/Ashley Kay WV Logan Birch River/Evergreen WV Nicholas 08 Bluegrass KY Perry 09 Charlene KY Perry Scotts Branch KY Pike 10 Myra KY Pike Goals WV Raleigh 11

Western Coal Absaloka MT Big Horn 02 Spring Creek MT Big Horn Black Thunder North WY Campbell 04 North Antelope / Rochelle (NARM) WY Campbell Jacobs Ranch WY Campbell Antelope WY Converse 05 Antelope/Spring Creek WY /MT Converse/Big Horn 13 Jacobs Ranch/Spring Creek WY /MT Campbell/Big Horn 12 Sample ID Suffix Code

C:\PROGRA~1\Documentum\CTS\docbases\ProDocbase\config\temp_sessions\2642792650235236930\EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT2409.xls 4/2/10