* DM S 0001/00 6 12/29/201 0 14:2 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA A

OEFARTMEMlp, ^ Befor e th * U.S . DepHrtmen t of Transpomtio n" V C V > £ / \/Pt \ ipAMSPORTAllO- V Federa l Avutiot i Administratio n^ ^ ^ •»i«f ' 

## '^^AR/W G o^sCKE T T n di e iriatte r

o f )

) Docke t

No . CPIOSOOO U M & RHELICOPTER S ) F AA Cas e No . 2009SO95043 4 ) CJiic f

Judg e Ronni e A . Yode r ) ) COMPLATNANT' S RESPONS ET O MARHELTCOPTKRiS ' MOTIO NFO R.ILIDGMKN T T O DISMISS . FAJLLR ET O RESPON D O RMEE T FILIINC ; DEADLINE S AN D RFSPONDKNT' S MO l IO N FO RJUDGMEN T T O DISMIS S 4 Complainan t

filo s thi s respons e t o Responden t M << : RHelicopters; ' (Respondent ) Motio nfor Judgmen t

t o Dismiga , Failur e t o Respon do r Mee t Filin K Deadline s an dMotio n for Judgmen t

t o Dismis s 4 . I

nit s Motions , Responden t allege s Tliii t thi s cas e shoul db e dismis-vd , becaus e th e Complainan t ha s no t responde dt o numerou s filing s an dletter s fromRespnnriRiiT . A s state dbelo w an dinpreviou s reference dresponset; , Complainan t ha s eithe r

rcspoadc dt o thes e filings , o r ajuatifiabl e an drcason-ihl c basi s exist s fo r wh y i t ha s not . Accordingly , R.espondcni' s Motion s lac k merit . DlscuKsip n I n it s Motions , Responden t <-laim s tha t Complainan t

ha s no t responde dto Octobe r 21 , Novembe r

24 , an dNovembe r

27 , 2010 , lerier s regardin g allege ddiscover y requests , includin g areques t for ahearin g transcrip t

Complaina mexplaine dwh y it lia s no t responde dt o i.hcs e letter s init s Decembe r 10 , 2010 , Respon.'s c tnM & Rrielicopters ' Motio n t o Quash , Strike , or Di.'imis s Complain t

an dMotio nt o Strik e Allc£;Htion- Mr .12/29/201 0 14:2 0 FA X 202493514 2 FAA^ DM S @002/00 G

Bake r Wa s No t nn,n . Drug/AIcoho I Progra mat pafie s 6-7 , an di nit s Decembe r 15 , 2010 , Respons e t o Motio nfo r

Depositio no f

Latony aWiUiame , Motio nt o Compe l Di.'^covrry , an dMotio n for

Judgmen t

t o Quas hat

pa£R s 2-3 . Responden t

als o allege s tha t

Complainan t

di dno t file a nobjectio no r

answe r t o Respondent' s Novembe r 27,2010 , documeti t

captione d"Preliminar y Objections. " Althoug hRespondcn i filedit s documen t captione d'Treliminflry Objections " luide r 1 4 C-F.R . 13.208(d) , that docinneD t

wa s i neffec t

a nanswe r t o th e complaint . Accordingly , i t

require dn o respons e fro mComplainant . Responden t

als o allege s tha t

Complainan t

di dno t respon dwithi nth e require d lim e t o aNovembe r

29 , 2010 , Motio nan dBrie f t o Quash . Strike , n

r Dismis. s Complaint . Responden t

serve dthi s motio nonNovembe r 30,201 0 (So e Attachmen t 1 , Certificat e o f Servic e for

Respondent' s Motio nt o Quash , Strike , o r Di.smis aComplaint) . Complainan t filedit s respons e t o thi s motio no nDe<-rmbe T 10 , 2010 , withi n1 0 day s a s require dunde r th e Rule s ofPiactic e i nFA A Civi l Penalt y Actionri . Responden t

als o allege s tha t

Complainan t

di dno t n\spon dwithi nth e require d lim e t o aNovcmhr r

30 , 2010 , Motio nt o Strilc e Allegation . Complainan t file dit s respons e t o thi s motio no nDcrembe t

10,2010 , withi n1 0 day aa s require dund^ r th e Rule s o f Practic e inFA A Civi l Penalty Actions . Responden t

als o allege s tha t

Compl^irusnt

di dno t respon dwithi n1 0 day s t o a Decembe r

1 , 2010 , Motio n for

Depositio no f

Latony aWilliams . Responden t di dno t nee dt o file amotio nrequestin g tli e Administrativ e La w Judg e i ngrtui t approva l fo r

th e depositio no f

Ms . Williams . Accordingly , i t wa s no t necessary tlia t

Complainan t

respon d12/29/201 0 14:2 0 FA X 202493514 2 fhf , - > DM S 0003/00 8

t o tha t motion . Nonetheless , Complainan t filedaTespon.^

e o nDecesmbe

r 15 , 2010 , t o ftirther arrangement s for

a . depositio na

t atim e an dlor^tio nmutuall y convfeniemfor Ms . William s an dRespondent , Responden t

als o allege s Complainan t di dno t respon dwithi n1 0 day s t o a Decembe r

2 . 2010 , Motio nt o Compe l Discovery . I nit s Motio nt o Compe l Discovery , Responden t

repeale dth e Mme- . ?irgiiment s i t mad e i nit s Motio nt o Quash , Strike , o r Dismis s Complaint . Complainan t hadalread y addresse dthes e argument s i nit s Decembe r

10 , 2010 , Re.sponset o M & Rllelicopter.'^ ' Motir> nt o Quash , Strike , o r Dismis s Complain t

an dMoxio nt o Strike Allegatio n- Mr . Bake r Wa s No t o na Dru£/A]a>ho I Program , a t page s 6-7 . Complainan t note dthi s i nit s Decembe r 15 . 2010 , Respons e t o Motio nfor

Depositio no f

Lrrtony aWilliams , Motio nto Compe l Discovery , an dMotio nfor

Judgmen t

t o Quo-s ha t page s 2-3 . So , i neffect , Complainan t ha s responde dtimel y t o Respondent' s argument s supportin g it s MoHonT O Coinpe l •Discovery . Finally , l^rsponden t

state s thai i t

doe s no t agre e t o any for

mo f continuance . Respondent'.- ) Motio nfor Judgmen t

t o Dismis s 4 ai pag e 4 . However , Complainan t ha s jaot requeste dfro mth e Offic e o f Admini.':tT-?itiv

e La w Judge s acontinuanc e i nthi s case .c/, * • > DM S 01004/OO G 12/29/201 0 14:2 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA AUM i

I f I WHRREFORE , Complainan t rcspectfiill y request s tha i th e Chie f AdminiaLrativ e 

### 1 1 I La w Judg e den y Respondent' s Motio n fo r Judgmen t

t o Dismiss , Failur e t o Respon do r y A Mee t Filin g D«?rdlinc s an dMotio nfor Judgmen t

t o Dismis s 4 . ^ Respectfull y submitted ,

• i Pete r J . T.ync h i s AsMstan t Chie f Counse l j^Iir

- Laur aPonl o Attorne y Enforcemen t

Division , AOC-30 0 Offic e o f

th e Chie f

Counse l Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washington , D C 2059 1 Pbnnc : (202)267-986 3 Facsimile : (202)267-510 6 Date : Drrrmbc r

20 , 201 0• yDM S 0005/00 6 12/29/201 0 14:2 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA A

Certificat e o f

Servic e I hereb y certif

y tha t o nthi,- ^ date . T hav e place di nth e U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , certifie drexum-reccipt , acop y o f Complainant' s Respons e t o Respondent' s Motio nfor •Tudgmcn t t o Dismiss , Failur e t o Respon do r Mee t Filin £Dr,?idline s an dMotio nfor Judgmen t t o Dismis s 4 Jr

> th e Matmr

of M & RHelicopters , Docknl No . CP l OSOOO l 1 , addresse dto : Dr . Michae l B . Scli g

Presiden t M & RIlelicoptcra , LL C 204 5 Westgai e Dr „ Suit e 20 5 Bethlehem , P A 1801 7 I n addition , 1 hfrreby certif y tha t o nthi s dat e I hav e sen t

h y th r U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , certifie dretuni-rcccip t an dfacsimil e on e cop y o f th e foregoin c di>«n.imen

t to : Tli e Honorabl e Ronnir

- A . Yode r Chie f Administrativ e La w Judg e U,S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n Offic e o f Hearings , M-20 . Room . E12-32 0 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S,E . W;=ishington , D C 2059 0 Far.siTiiilc : 202-366-753 6 I n addition , I hereb y certif y tha t o nthi s dat e 1 hav e sen t

b y th e U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , certifie dreturn-receipt , th e origina l an don e cop y o f th e foregoin g documen t

to : Federa l Aviatio nAdministratio n 60 0 Independenc e Avenue , S,W . WUbur Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2W1000 Wftshington , D,C . 205S>

] Attn. : Hrarin g Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 

### vS^^*J^<y

- ^0^1 ^ Dated : Decernbe r

20 , 201 012/29/201 0 14:2 1 FA X 202493514 2 FA A + DM S IgjOOB/OO b

U.J . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

F«<i9r d Aviatio n Administratio n Laur a Ponto , Lolony a vj^Horn s Complairinnt s M S I R Hellcoptere , LLC . Retponden t FA ACas e 2009SO9S0434 V ,

IHERPR V CERTIF Ytha t 1 hov e thi s da ysen/e d th e Foregoin g enWe(£) : RESPONDEN T S MOTIO N T O QUASH . STRIK

E O KDISMIS S COMPLAIM T RESPONDENTS BRIE F SUPPORTIN G TH E MOTIO N TO QUASH . STRIK E O R DISMIS S COMPLAIN T upo n al l partie s o f recor d I n ttil s proceedino , i n nrcordonc © v»it h th e requirement s o f Rul e 29 puriuan rt o 2 B U . S . C . § 174 ^ . Serv K ' first-ctos mail , DcwtanworePOid . addresse d a- ! follows : Federa l Aviatio n Administrn+io n 60 0 Indeperidenc e Av©nu© , S W Wilbu rWrigh t AvenuR-Sult e 2W100 0 Washington . O.C . 2059 1 Att : Hearin g Dorlre t Cleric , AGC-43 0 Laur a Ponto . feq Enforcemen t Division/AGC-30 0 Offic e n f th e Chie f Counse l FA A 60 0 Independenc e Avenun . S W Washinotop . D C 2059 1 FA X 20 2 26/510 6 

# Sll^* ^ By : fvllchae l a , Selig , MD , FACC . 28I 6 0rftfifildRoa a Alienrow a Pa . 1810

4 , ' x 610360395 3 tW'TLO'M.'- ^ Date : ^ ^

^ ^