### 07/14/201 1 TlI

U10:2 3 FA

X81 7 22 2 509 2 regiona l counse l @1001/00 3 

# Federa l Aviatio n Admihistratioj i 1 4 8 To : Glendora , AGC^3 0 Company : Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Telephone : ^^^ ' 202.493.514 2 From : Eri e E . Anderso n Title : Managin g Attorne y Southwes t Regio n Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l For t Worth . Texa s 7613 7 Package/Courie rAddres s 260 1 Meacha m Boulevar d For t Worth , Texa s 7613 7 T (817.222.5078 ) F(817.222.5945/5092 )

Date : Jul y14 , 201 1 Page s w/cover : 3 Facslnnil e 

## CP/oSbooi i

Her e ar e th e requeste d document s t o b e adde d t o ih e Complaint s alread y receive d b yyou roffice . Pleas e le t m e kno wi f yo u nee d anythin g further . Thanks. .

Pleas e Note : "Thi s messag e i s intende d oni yfo rth e us e o f th e individua l o rentit yt o whic h i t i s addresse d an d ma ycontai n informatio n tha t i s privileged , confidential , an d exemp t fro m disclosur e unde rapplicabl e law. "

U.S . Dopartmon t o f Tranoportotio n07/15/20 1 1 1 -aSP M FA X (210001/001 0

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Charle s Raley . Cynthi a Dominik , Laur a Ponto , Pete rLynch , Latony a William s Complainant s

V . Honorabl o Judfl G Richar d Goodwi n Docket : 2010-121 1 M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t CERTinCATEOFSERViC E HEREB YCERTIF Ytha t I hav e thi s da yserve d th e foregoin g entrle(s l Lette r Judg e Goodwin , Failur e t o Settl e th e Case/Tria l Schedul e MOTIO NFO RDEPOSITIO NO FLAUR A PONT O AN D

LATONY A WILLIAM S MOTIO NFO RPRE-TRIA LREVIE WB Y TH E HONORABL EJ . RANDOLP H BABBI T upo n al l partie s o f recor d i n thi s proceeding , i n accordanc e wit h th e requirement s o f Rul e 2 9 pursuan t t o 28U.S.C. § 1746 . Serviceb yfirst-cla-^

j nigil . postog e prepoid . addresse d a s follows : Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Wilbu rWright Avenue-Suit e 2W100 0 Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Att : Hearin g Docke t Cleric , AGC-43 0 FA X 20 2 49 3 514 2 Charfe s Ra.'e y Enforcemen t Division/AGC-30 0 Offic e o f th e Chie f Counse l FA A aO O Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 FA X 20 2 26 7 510 6 Th e Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwi n U S Departmen t o f Transportatio n Offic e o f Hearings , M-20 , Roo m El2-32 0 120 D Ne wJerse yAvenue . S.E . Washington , DC 2059 0 FA X 20 2 36 6 753 6 By : Mici-iae l B.'Selig , MD , FACC . 281 6 0re[iel d Roa d Allentown , Pa . 18104 610360395 3 ^

j'^^^^ U Dote : , (- A- ^ n07/15/201 1 1:33P M FA X 00002/001 0 

## MICHAE LB . SELIG , M.D. , KA.C C LifeLin e Cardiolog y

Federa l Docke t 2010-121 1 FA AFil e 2009SO95043 4 D RHelicopters , LLC . 281 6 Orcfiel dRoa d Allentown , PA- 1810 4 Jul y 15 , 201 1 Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n U S Departmen t

o f Transportatio n Offic e o f Hcai-ings , M-20 . Roo mEl2-32 0 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue . S.E . Washington , D C 2059 0 FAX 20 2 36 6 7S3 6 Re : Failur e t o Settl e th e Case / Tria l Schedul e Dea r Judg e Goodwi n Thi s lette r

i s pursuaii LL

o arecen t

furthe r attemp t

t o reconcil e thi s matte r wit hM r

RaJe y i nacas e tha t

no w ha s ite-neaj-l y J 0 0 docke t entries . Th e Honorabl e Judg e Yode r affirme dtha t

thi s cas e wa s "on e o f th e leas t

. reasonabl e case s h e ha dsee ni nhi s 3 5 year s o f bein g ajudge " i ntli e pre tria l hcai'in g transcrip t an dfirml y advise dsettlement . O nMa y 10 , 2011 , M r Rale y cam e fort ha s on e i nata g tea mo f 4 agenc y attorneys , wit hth e firs t an donl y settlemen t

offe r b y th e agenc y tha t dismisse dal l financia l penaltie s base do nth e confirme dfmancia l losses , if

the.responden t

woul dagre e tha t

th e flawedviolatio ntheor y b e entere dint o th e record . Thes e losse s als o serv e t o confir mth e lac k o f operatio n(als o i naprotracte ddivorce ) aji dn o incom e durin g an dafte r th e allege dviolatio nperiod .

. M s Rale y woul dno t agre e t o completel y dismis s th e cas e i nit s entirety , i ngoo dfait hbu t willin g t o procee dt o hearin g despit e th e ongoin g cost s t o t±i e agenc y aj:i dtaxpayer s an dsqu^mdehn g o f judicia l resource s a t tim e o f unprecedente dgovernmenta l deficits . 1 mad e afurthe r

attemp t

a t settlemen t

Jul y 6 , 2011 , b y emai l foJlowe dwit hn o direc t respons e whatsoever , onl y Jul y 12 , 201 1 letter s b y hi monl y t o confir mhi s willingnes s t o procee dforwar dwit hdiscover y request s an dhearin g dates . \f^^Tl^rfn^!!^'''''^^^^''^^' ' " ^^'^^ Westgat e Drive, Suit

e 10 1 - Bethlehem

^ Pennsylvani a18017-7474 Vce/V M 610-668.620 0 • Fa x 610-86S-U8 9 • Educatio nSemic o 610-868-620 3 . F^a/ y sa//gm@to, L07/15/201 1 1.38P M FA X 1210003/001 0

I nadditio nt o man y othe r defect s i nthi s case , th e 2 regulation s tha t th e agenc y wa s violatin g tli e responden t [or : 135.25 1 an d135.255 , wer e s o confusing , inconsistent , cbntradictoi' y an dproblemati c tha t th e FAA rul e maker s remove dthes e regulation s i nJul y 13 , 2009 , perhap s unbeknowns t b y th e complainant s o r lackin g cando r

t o th e tribunal , on e yea r befor e th e complainant s eve nfile dthei r complain t

(emphasi s supplied) . Th e Complainant' s needles s persistenc e an dconduc t i nthi s matte r appear s unreasonabl e an doutrageou s an dexceedin g th e bound s tolerate d b y decen t

societ> ^ an dha s bee ndon e willfully , maliciousl y an ddeliberatel y wit hth e inten t

t o caus e responden t

sever e harassment , menta l an d emotiona l pain , distress , an dangtiis han dlos s o f enjoymen t

o f life . Complainant s action s wer e don e wit hreckles s indifferenc e t o tli e likelihoo d tha t suc hbehavio r

woul dcaus e suc hsever e emotiona l distress , affec t hi s cardiolog y practice , furthe r puttin g hi s patient s a t ris k an dwitl i utte r disregar dfo r

th e consequence s o f suc hactions . I . believ e a s yo u revie w thi s cas e tha t yo u wil l fin dtha t

thi s cas e i s s o fa r overreachin g procedurall y an di ntheor y tha t m y reques t

tha t n o furthe r time o r resource s b e expende do nthi s cas e i s reasonabl e an d thereb y dismissin g thi s cas e wit hprejudice , prio r t o an y trial . I nth e even t

yo u believ e thi s cas e i s meritoriou s an dshoul dg o t o tria l i nth e Allentow ncourthouse , I a mavailabl e Septembe r 5-8 , 19-22 , aji do ntli e 26i^

^ a t thi s time , a s I hav e clinica l hospita l an dcommunit y obligation s t o fulfill . YouiySincerely , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H 

## ,LV.l n

\ V \07/15/20 , , r38PI. . FA X aoOO-l/OOl O 1 ...(^v - ^

», ^ ,

m s e 

## lia . From : "mseiig " <mselig@ptd.net > To : <Charl6s.Raley@faa.gov > Sent : Wednesday , Jul y08 , 201 1 10:0 7 A M Subject : Droppin g th e Cas e M r Rale y I t appear s ta x payer s wil l no w needlessl y hav e t o pa y t o transpor t peopl e t o th e Allentow nlocation.fo r ahearing . I f yo u woul dlik e t o o r fee l it i s morally , ethicall y o r professionall y appropriat e t o discus s droppin g th e cas e completely , w c ca nmak e arrangement s t o procee dL o d o so . Thnn k yo u Michae l Seli g 61 0 36 0 395 3

7/12/20 ,07/15/201 1 1.33PI- 1 FA X gl0005/001 0

Michae l Selig, . MD , FACC , CFI- H 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown , PA . 1810 4 Jul y 1 ^ 201 1



### U.S . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D,C . Federa l Aviatio nAdministratio n Charle s Raley , Laur aPonto , Latony aWilliam s . Complainant s V . M & RHelicopters , LLC . Responden t Th e Honorabl e Richar dGoodwi n Docket : 2010-121 1

MOTIO NFO RPRE-TRIA LREVIE WB Y TH E HONORABL EJ . RANDOLP H BABBI T AN D NOW , come s respondent , .MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo r

M & RHelicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l an da t financia l los s sinc e 2007 ) who maver s an dfile s th e followin g Motio nt o fo r a nindependen t

clea r loo k revie w b y th e Honorabl e J . Randol f Babbit . 1 . O nJul y 6 , 2011 . responden t emaile dM r

Rale y t o determin e i [ h e wa s willin g t o clos e th e cas e completel y instea do f incurrin g additiona l financia l cost s an dadditio ntransportatio nburde no nth e ta x payers .

- 107/15/201 1 1 ;38P M FA X 00006/001 0



### 2 . Thi s attemp t

t o clos e th e cas e a s advise db y Judg e Yode r wa s mad e i n goo dfaith , i nadditio nt o al l th e othe r argument s (non-operational , n o income ) agains t

aviabl e cas e o nth e par t o f th e agency . 3 . I nadditio ni t

wa s furthe r

discovere dtha t

th e 2 regulation s tha t th e agenc y wa s violatin g th e responden t for ; 135.25 1 an d135.255 , wer e s o conl'using , inconsistent , contradictoi y an dproblemati c tha t th e FA A rul e maker s remove dan drescinde dthes e regulation s i nJul y 13 , 2009 , on e yea r

prio r t o complainant s eve nfilin g thei r complain t agains t respoiTclerit , perhap s unbeknowns t b y th e complainant s (di d no t researc hth e currenc y o f th e regulation s cited ) o r lackin g cando r t o th e tribunal , i nattempt s t o impai r th e dignit y o

f th e court . 4 . Sinc e complainant s ar e no t intereste di nsettlin g thi s cas e an dth e cour t ha s no t take nactio nt o terminat e thi s case , wit hneedles s litigatio ncost s a t

th e taxpayer s expens e a t atim e o

f unprecedente d governmenta l debt , i t

i s respondent s positio ntha t thi s cas e ha s continue dto o long , i s interferin g wit hD r Selig s clinica l responsibilitie s an dpoisin g undu e ris k t o hi s patients , ha s alway s lacke dmeri t

an dmor e som e no w wit hth e recen t discover y o

f th e above . WHEREFORE , th e responden t Motion s tha t

th e Honorabl e J . Randolp h Babbi t independentl y review s thi s cas e befor e atrial , perhap s t o dismis s

- 2 -07/15/201 1 1.38P M FA X 12)0007/001 0



### thi s cas e wit hprejudic e i neffort s t o spar e an y adde dtrave l cost s an d litigatio nburde nt o th e agenc y an dtaxpayer s an dn o furthe r hardshi p to . D r Seli g an dhi s cardiolog y practice . Respectfull y Submitted , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC .

- 3 -07, ' 15/2 0 1 1 1 : 3SP M FA X 00003/001 0

Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFl- H 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown , PA . 1810 4 Jul y 15 , 201 1

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . Federa l Aviatio nAdministratio n Charle s Raley , Laur aPonto , Latony aWilliam s Complainant s V . M & RHelicopters , LLC . ^^^ ^ Responden t Th e Honorabl e Richar dGoodwi n Docket : 2010-121 1

MOTIO NFO RDEPOSITIO NO FLAUR A PONT O AN D

LATONY A WILLIAM S AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo r

M RHelicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l an da t financia l los s sinc e 2007 ) who maver s an dfile s th e followin g Motio nt o hav e Depositio no f

Laur aPont o an dLatony aWilliam s unde r Rul e §13.22 5 i nth e plac e o f venue . 1 . O nJul y 6 , 2011 , responden t emaile dM r

Rale y t o deterinin e i f h e wa s willin g t o clos e th e cas e completel y instea do f incurrin g additiona l

o f 307/15/201 1 1 -GSP M FAX 1^)0009/0 0 1 0



### financia l cost s an dadditio ntransportatio nburde no nth e ta x payers . 2 . Thi s attemp t

t o clos e th e cas e a s advise db y Judg e Yode r wa s mad e i n goo dfaith , i nadditio nt o al l th e othe r argument s (non-operational , n o income ) agains t

aviabl e cas e o nth e par t o f th e agency . 3 . I nadditio ni t

wa s furthe r

discovere dtha t

th e 2 regulation s tha t th e agenc y wa s violatin g th e responden t for : 135.25 1 an d135,255 , wer e s o confusittg , inconsistent , contradictor y an dproblemati c tha t th e FA A rul e maker s remove dan drescinde dthes e regulation s L nJul y 13 , 2009 . on e yea r

prio r t o complainant s eve nfilin g thei r complain t agains t respondent , perhap s unbeknowns t b y th e complainant s (di d no t researc hth e currenc y of th e regulation s cited ) o r lackin g cando r t o th e tribunal , i nattempt s t o impai r th e dignit y o

f th e court . Sinc e complainant s ar e no t

intereste di nsettlin g thi s cas e th e followin g person s ar e requeste dfor depositions . 4 . Responden t

request s th e depositio nof Latony aWilliams , 5 . Responden t

als o reques t

tha t M s William s bring s wit hher , he r trave l lo g of 200 9 an d201 0 a s requeste dearlier , 6 . Responden t

request s i nadditio ntha t Laur aPont o b e presen t for depositio nan dfor

he r t o brin g he r

credential s an dlicensin g information . WHEREFORE , th e responden t request s th e depositio no f Latony a William s an dLaur aPont o i nAllentown , PA , th e originatin g Jurisdictio n

. 2 o f 307/15/20 1 1 1:39P h FAX 12)0 0 10/0 0 1 0

an dvenu e o f

th e allege dviolation . Respectfull y Submitted , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC .

3 o f 3