west virginia department of environmental protection 

Division of Water and Waste Management 

60 I 57th Street SE 

Charleston, West Virginia 25304-2345 

Phone: 304-926-0495 

Fax: 304-926-0496 

PATRICK SMITH 

MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON, LLC 

1851 MAIN ST 

FOLLANSBEE, WV 26037 

And 

STEVEN W. SORVOLD, DIRECTOR 

August 29, 2013 

WHEELING PITTSBURGH STEEL CORP (Operator) 

ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL DEPT 

1134 MARKET STREET 

WHEELING, WV 26003-2971 

Earl Ray Tomblin, Governor 

Randy C. Huffman, Cabinet Secretary 

www.dep.wv.gov 

CERTIFIED RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED 

Dear Permittee: 

Enclosed please find WV/NPDES Permit Number WV0004499 dated August 29, 2013. 

Mountain State Carbon's (MSC) comments were received by letter dated March 22, 2013. The following is 

the agency's response to these comments regarding the draft permit that went to public notice on February 8, 

2013. 

Comment No. I : Production Rate and TBELs 

The agency believes that use of the maximum 12 month rolling average production value is appropriate and 

therefore no revision to the permit has been made. 

Comment No.2: Section 301(g) variance limits 

The agency has revised the WQBEL for ammonia at Outlet 006 since a water supply intake is not located 

downstream of the discharge. Due to this change the 30i(g) variance has been adjusted based on the revised 

WQBEL for ammonia. Section A.006 of the permit has been revised accordingly. 

Comment No. 3 : Outlet 006 truncated mixing zone and use of Outlet 005 monitoring data 

Promoting a healthy environment 
PATRICK SMITH 

Page2 

August 29, 2013 

The agency believes that limiting the size of mixing zones is critical in minimizing the potential for adverse 

impacts within the mixing zone. As such, the agency limits the size of the mixing zones granted based on 

what the discharge actually needs in order to be compliant. In limiting the size of the mixing zone being 

granted to what is needed, the agency is limiting the potential for adverse impacts to aquatic life and human 

health within the receiving stream. The agency further believes that this is consistent with antidegradation 

requirements prescribed in 60 CSR 5 of the WV Legislative Rules which were prescribed to limit degradation 

to receiving streams in the state. No revision to the mixing zone has been made. 

The agency believes that use of Outlet 005 monitoring data is appropriate in assessing effluent quality at 

Outlet 006. No data was submitted with the permit application for Outlet 006. As such, the permit writer used 

all available data to determine whether reasonable potential to exceed water quality was present. Many of the 

parameters listed at former Outlet 005 were imposed due to the presence ofthe process wastewater from 

Internal Outlet 205 since cooling water and sanitary sewage would only serve to dilute the concentrations of 

pollutants introduced by Internal Outlet 205. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume reasonable potential exists 

at Outlet 006 if reasonable potential existed at former Outlet 005. No revision to the reasonable potential 

evaluation or Section A.006 of the permit has been made. 

Comment No.4 :Outlet 006 ammonia, WAD cyanide, total residual chlorine, mercury, PAHs 

As stated above, the ammonia WQBEL has been revised. 

As stated above, the agency believes limiting mixing zones to what is necessary prevents greater impacts to 

aquatic life and human health in the environment within the mixing zone and that the use of Outlet 005 DMR 

data for Outlet 006 reasonable potential evaluations is appropriate for cyanide, total residual chlorine, 

mercury, and PAHs. No revisions have been made. 

Comment No.5 :Outlet 006 Schedule of Compliance (Nitrite-N, Total Cyanide, WAD Cyanide, Phenolics, 

Mercury, Selenium) 

Outlet 006 was constructed as the permittee's selected compliance solution for past violations and/or 

compliance issues in the permit for multiple parameters as required by Administrative Consent Order No. 

7160. The permittee believed that separating the process wastewater from Outlet 005 and obtaining a site 

specific mixing zone was the resolution needed to achieve full compliance with WV/NPDES Permit No. 

WV0004499. The agency therefore fully expects the permittee to comply with all final effluent limitations at 

Outlet 006. 
PATRICK SMITH 

Page3 

August 29, 2013 

ORSANCO contains a prohibition on mixing zones for bioaccumulative chemicals of concern (BCCs) which 

includes mercury. All mixing zones for existing discharges ofBCCs are required to be eliminated as soon as 

possible, but no later than October 16, 2013. Effluent data from former Outlet 005 reveals that mercury 

exhibits the reasonable potential to exceed water quality criteria at the end of pipe and water quality based 

effluent limitations are imposed at Outlet 006. Effluent data indicates that the permittee cannot currently 

achieve these limitations and a compliance schedule has been granted consistent with ORSANCO's deadline 

for the elimination of mixing zones. The agency does not have the authority to grant a variance or extend 

time to meet the ORSANCO requirements. If a pollutant is in the discharge at levels that reflect reasonable 

potential to exceed water quality criteria, then water quality based limitations are required by law. At the 

time of this permit issuance, the permittee has not obtained a variance from ORSANCO and the BCC 

prohibition must be imposed accordingly. The agency envisions addressing any future compliance issues 

with the 

final mercury limits through an enforcement action. 

Comment No. 6 : Outlet 006 Monitoring Requirements 

The agency believes the monitoring frequencies imposed at Outlet 006 are appropriate. As stated above, it is 

reasonable to assume the concentrations at Outlet 006 will be the same or greater in magnitude than 

concentrations observed at former Outlet 005 due to separation of the outlets. Therefore, no revisions have 

been made. After collection of a minimum number of data points, the permittee may request via the permit 

modification process that the monitoring frequency be reduced if the resultant data supports the rationale for 

such a reduction. 

Comment No. 7 : References to 205, 305, and 005 and Section C.33 

At the time of public notice of the draft permit, the permittee had not made the agency aware that the 

reconfiguration of the process wastewater discharge from Outlet 205 to Outlet 006 was complete and 

discharge had been initiated. As such, the draft permit included Outlets 205, 305, and 005. Section A.205, 

A.305, and A.005 have been deleted from the final permit and references to these outlets have been removed, 

where appropriate, in Sections B and C of the permit. 

Comment No. 8 : Outlet 004 TSS, fecal coliform, and temperature 

The TSS limit is a net limit and therefore the intake portion ofTSS in the Outlet 004 discharge should not 

affect compliance with the imposed limitation. No revision has been made. 

For the reasons stated above, the agency believes the fecal coliform limitations are appropriate. No data has 

been submitted indicating the sanitary sewage plant was the sole source of fecal coliform at former Outlet 

005 and that there will cease to be a discharge of fecal coliform at Outlet 006. As such, no revision has been 

made. After collection of a minimum number of data points the permittee may request via the permit 

modification process that frequency be reduced if the resultant data supports the rationale for such a 

reduction. 
PATRICK SMITH 

Page4 

August 29, 2013 

The temperature limitations imposed at Outlet 004 are protective of both WV (47 CSR 2 Appendix E 8.29.4) 

and ORSANCO water quality criteria. A default mixing zone was granted for temperature at this outlet since 

background temperature data was available for the Ohio River. Contrary to the comment letter the agency 

cannot grant any higher dilutions in the Ohio River without submittal of a site specific mixing zone study for 

this outlet. Also contrary to the comment letter, the permittee has not performed a biological habitat study in 

the vicinity of Outlet 004 and therefore the agency cannot make a determination on what if any thermal 

impacts are present in the Ohio River directly attributable to the Outlet 004 discharge. The agency believes 

the limitations are appropriate and no revision to the draft permit was made. The permittee may pursue a site 

specific mixing zone and/or 316(a) thermal variance if it so desires and submit a permit modification request 

in the future with the appropriate supporting rationale. If the permittee elects to pursue a 316(a) thermal 

variance, the agency strongly recommends that the permittee first discuss this with the agency to 

ensure that all of the proper information is collected and provided. 

Comment No. 9 : Outlet 004 Monitoring Requirements 

The agency believes the monitoring frequencies imposed at Outlet 004 are appropriate. No revisions have 

been made. After collection of a minimum number of data points, the permittee may request via the permit 

modification process that frequency be reduced if the resultant data supports the rationale for such a 

reduction. 

Comment No. 10: Sections C.30 and C.31 

Sections C.30 and C.31 have been revised to reflect that the permittee will perform a dye tracer study to 

verify the granted site specific mixing zone at Outlet 006. However, this still requires some sampling for 

other pollutants for verification purposes. 

Comment No. II : Section D- Intake Requirements 

The agency believes the intake requirements are consistent with 316(b) of the Clean Water Act and therefore 

no revision was made. 

Comment No. 12 : Section B. Schedule of Compliance 

The agency believes the revised schedule of compliance in Section B of the permit is appropriate and no 

revisions have been made. 

Comment No. 13 : Section C.l7 

Section C.l7 has been revised to indicate that Method OIA 1677 is an allowable method for analysis of free 

cyanide. The permittee may not however omit a free cyanide analysis when a total cyanide result is less than 

0.005 mg/1. 

Comment No. 14 : Section C.29 
PATRICK SMITH 

PageS 

August 29, 2013 

The agency agrees that the current sampling point satisfies Section C.29; however, to ensure that any changes 

to the intake configuration do not affect the collection of representative samples, no revision has been made 

to the permit. 

Comment No. 15 :Section C.32 

Based on the request in the comment letter, Section C.32 has been revised to allow up to 60 minutes between 

intake and effluent samples. 

Comment No. 17 : Outlet 097 Monitoring Requirements 

The agency believes the monitoring frequencies imposed at Outlet 097 are appropriate. After collection of a 

minimum number of data points the permittee may request via the permit modification process that frequency 

be reduced if the resultant data supports the rationale for such a reduction. 

Please note that a Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) is to be completed and submitted to this Division 

each month. 

Finally note that copies of all future correspondence regarding the permit must be forwarded to the Field 

Inspector and Field Supervisor at the following address: 

Department of Environmental Protection 

Environmental Enforcement 

601 57th St. 

Charleston, WV 25304 

Also, please note the attachment to this permit which describes the annual permit fee requirement. 

Reissuance of your permit does not change the annual fee billing cycle. 

If you have any questions, please contact John Lockhart, P.E. of this Division at (304) 926-0499 at 

extension 1028. 

,a~ Director 

SGM:jl 

Enclosures 
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 

DIVISION OF WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT 

601 57TH STREET SE 

CHARLESTON, WV 25304-2345 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

WATER POLLUTION CONTROL PERMIT 

NPDES PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 

SUBJECT: Industrial Waste 

LOCATION: FOLLANSBEE 

(City) 

See the next page for a list of Outlets. 

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: 

Brooke 

(County) 

This is to certify that: MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON, LLC 

1851 MAIN ST 

FOLLANSBEE, WV 26037 

And 

ISSUE DATE: August 29, 2013 

EFFECTIVE DATE : October 01. 2013 

EXPIRATION DATE: June 30, 2017 

SUPERSEDES: Permit No. WV0004499 

daled January 15. 2008 

Upper Ohio River 1 

(Drainage Basin) 

WHEELING PITTSBURGH STEEL CORP (OPERATOR) 

ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL DEPT 

1134 MARKET STREET 

WHEELING, WV 26003-2971 

are hereby granted a West Virginia NPDES Water Pollution Control Permit to: 

Operate and maintain treatment and disposal systems and best management practices for the direct dischatge of 

treated process wastes, groundwater, and storm water through Outlet 006 into the Ohio River at approximate 

milepoint 68.7. 

Operate and maintain treatment and disposal systems and best management practices for the direct dischatge of 

treated sanitary waste, untreated storm water, untreated non-contact cooling water, and untreated boiler 

blowdown through Outlet 004 into the Ohio River at approximately milepoint 68.85. 

Also to operate and maintain disposal systems and best management practices for the direct dischatge of 

untreated drains from freeze protection lines for the river water through Outlets 008 and 009 into the Ohio River 

at approximately Milepoint 68.9. 

Also to operate and maintain an intake system (Outlet 097) for the withdrawal of water from the Ohio River. 

This permit is subject to the following terms and conditions : 

The information submitted on and with Permit Application No. WV0004499 dated the 28th day of March 2012 

and subsequent information submitted the 7th day of September 2012 are hereby made terms and conditions of 

this Permit with like effect as if all such permit application information were set forth herein and with other 

conditions set forth in Sections A, B, C, and Appendix A. 
Page No.: 2 of 46 

Permit No. : VIN0004499 

The validity of this permit is contingent upon the payment of the applicable annual permit fee, as 

required by Chapter 22, Article 11, Section 10 ofthe Code of West Virginia. 
llnspectable UnTtli--H-ULatitude II Longitude !!Receiving Stream I, -----

Dist 

Mnn

004 40°20'47" 80°36'33" OHIO RV 006 40°20'47" 80°36'33" OHIO RV 

008 40°20'44" 80°36'33" OHIO RV -- No Monitoring Required 

009 40°20'44" 80°36'33" OHIO RV- No Monitoring Required 

097 40°20'40" 80°36'24" OHIO RV 

105 40°21'10" 80°36'30" OHIO RV 
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 9/30/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant NIA NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgd 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Suspended Solids NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only 60 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Coliform, Fecal NIA N/A NIA NIA 200 400 Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Daily 

pH N/A N/A NIA 6 N/A 9 s.u. 

(Year Round) (ML-1) lost. Min. lnsl Max. 

Ammonia Nitrogen N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day NIA RptOnly Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chlorine, Total Residual NIA N/A N/A NIA Rptonly Rpt Only ugA 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location{s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Article 

P

Pe
A.OD4 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 9130/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units other Units Units 

Copper, Total Recoverable NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Zinc, Total Recoverable N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chloride (as Cl) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (105 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

. P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/112013 and lasting through midnight 9/30/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the penmittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discha!:Qe Limitations 

Characteristic Ouantitv Units Other Units Units 

Fluoride, Total NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

Pyrene NIA NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

Benzo (A) Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpl Only Rp!Only NG!L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chrysene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluorene N/A N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ugn 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenanthrene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location{s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.OD4 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 9/30/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Acenaphthene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NGIL 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Pyrene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (105 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 9/30/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the pennittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic quantity Units Other Units Units 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Total NIA NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Naphthalene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature, F NIA N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature difference between intake upstream and discharge. 

Temperature, F NIA NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-7) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature in intake/upstream representative of the Ohio River upstream of outlet. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Summer May 1-Jan 31) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(May 1- January 31) Temperature of the discharge. 

Temperature, F NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Winter Feb 1-28/29) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(February 1 - 28/29) Temperature of the discharge. 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (105 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 9/30/2015 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Winter Mar 1-31) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(March 1 - 31) Temperature of the discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only 90.4 DEG.F 

(Winter Apr 1-30) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(April 1 - 30) Temperature ofthe discharge. 

Sulfate NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (105 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is au1horized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Ouantitv Units Other Units Units 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgd 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Suspended Solids N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only 60 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

Coliform, Fecal NIA NIA N/A N/A 200 400 Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Dally 

pH N/A NIA N/A 6 NIA 9 s.u. 

(Year Round) (ML-1) lnst Min. lnst. Max. 

Ammonia Nitrogen N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs!Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs!Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. MOnthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Copper, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Zinc, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/ 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgt 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chloride (as Cl) N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgt 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (105 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Pyrene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chrysene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoranthene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluorene N/A N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenanthrene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location{s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A-004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Acenaphthene NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Anthracene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Pyrene NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NGIL 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Total N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg!l 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Naphthalene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature, F NIA N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only 15 DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature difference between intake upstream and discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA NIA RptOnly Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-7) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature in intake/upstream representative of the Ohio River upstream of outlet. 

Temperature, F NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Summer May 1-Jan 31) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(May 1- January 31) Temperature of the discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A NIA 58.1 67.3 DEG.F 

(Winter Feb 1-28/29) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(February 1 - 28/29) Temperature of the discharge. 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location{s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Article 

P

Pe
A.004 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2015 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Cooling Water, Storm Water Runoff, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A N/A 67.1 77.6 

(Winter Mar 1-31) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(March 1 - 31) Temperature ofthe discharge. 

Temperature, F NIA NIA N/A NIA 78.1 90.4 

(Winter Apr 1-30) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

(April 1 - 30) Temperature of the discharge. 

Sulfate NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Oiland Grease, Hexane EXTR. NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 004 (Previously Internal Outlet (1 05 + 305)/005) From manhole near end of discharge pipe prior to mixing with the Ohio River. 

Units 

DEG.F DEG.F 

mg/1 mg/1 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 22B, Article 

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/15/2013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only 1.2 mgd 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Suspended Solids 1227 2371 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A N/A 200 400 Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Daily 

pH N/A N/A N/A 6 NIA 9 s.u. 

(Year Round) (ML-1) lnst. Min. lnst. Max. 

Ammonia Nitrogen 791 1591 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrate Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrite Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A 4 15.5 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max.. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously lntemal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/15/2013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) RptOnly Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only RptOnly mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgn 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A NIA N/A N/A 150 300 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Copper, Total Recoverable N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Zinc, Total Recoverable N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable N/A NIA N/A N/A 67 120 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A N/A N/A N/A 0.234 0.417 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgn 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/15/2013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units other Units Units 

Iron, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) NIA NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chloride (as Cl) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgt 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acute Tox- Ceriodaphnia Dubia N/A N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only TUa 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acute Toxicity- Pimephales N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only TUa 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Pyrene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Anthracene N/A N/A NIA NIA 6.9 19.7 ugn 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/15/2013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Chrysene NIA N/A N/A NIA 6.9 17.3 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluorene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenanthrene NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/ 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthene NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/ 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A N/A 6.9 17.8 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Article 

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/1512013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the penmittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A NIA N/A N/A 6.9 17.4 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Pyrene 0.0754 0.136 Lbs!Day N/A 6.9 19 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A 0.106 0.243 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene NIA N/A N/A N/A 6.9 18.2 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Total 25.6 36.6 Lbs!Day N/A 4.39 9.31 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable 0.29 0.47 Lbs!Day N/A 82 145 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring nequirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205) -Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Interim Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 10/15/2013 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Naphthalene 0.0759 0.137 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature of the discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature difference between upstreamflntake and discharge. 

Temperature, F NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-7) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature in intake/upstream representative of the Ohio River upstream of outlet 

Sulfate N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. 102 306 Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Artic

P
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharne Limitations 

Characteristic QuantitY Units Other Units Units 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only 1.2 mgd 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Suspended Solids 1227 2371 Lbs/Day NIA RptOnly Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A N/A 200 400 Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Mon. Gee. Mean Max. Daily 

pH N/A NIA N/A 6 N/A 9 s.u. 

(Year Round) (ML-1) lnst. Min. lnst. Max. 

Ammonia Nitrogen 791 1591 LbsiDay N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total Rpt Only Rpt Only LbsiDay N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (Ml-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrate Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrite Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A 4 15.5 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs!Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs!Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A NIA N/A 150 300 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Copper, Total Recoverable N/A N!A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Zinc, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable N/A N/A N/A N/A 67 120 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A N/A NIA NIA 0.0098 0.018 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Effective Date of Final Limitations is 10/16/2013 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location{s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Iron, Total Recoverable NIA N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) N/A N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chloride (as Cl) N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acute Tox- Ceriodaphnia Dubia N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only TUa 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acute Toxicity- Pimephales N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only TUa 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Pyrene NIA N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ugn 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA N/A N/A NIA 6.9 19.9 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205) - Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Chrysene NIA NIA N/A NIA 6.9 17.3 ug/ 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoranthene NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluorene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenanthrene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthene NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/ 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Anthracene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA N/A 6.9 17.8 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205) -Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff. Process Water. Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA N/A 6.9 17.4 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

Benzo (A) Pyrene 0.0754 0.136 Lbs/Day N/A 6.9 19 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Selenium. Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA N/A 0.106 0.243 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Arsenic. Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A N/A NIA 6.9 18.2 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Total 25.6 36.6 Lbs/Day N/A 4.39 9.31 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable 0.29 0.47 Lbs/Day N/A 82 145 ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.006 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/16/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet 

Runoff, Process Water, Other) 

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Dischame Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Naphthalene 0.0759 0.137 Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ugll 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A N/A RptOnly Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature of the discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-2) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature difference between upstreamflntake and discharge. 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-7) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature in intake/upstream representative of the Ohio River upstream of outlet. 

Sulfate N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mgll 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. 102 306 Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Outlet 006 (Previously Internal Outlet 205)- Samples shall be taken at the discharge from the process wastewater treatment system prior to discharging to the 

Outlet 006 discharge pipe. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Total Suspended Solids N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

pH NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only N/A Rpt Only s.u. 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Jnst Min. lnst Max. 

Ammonia Nitrogen NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpl Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrate N/A N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen Nitrite N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpl Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpl Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Chlorine, Total Residual NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Copper, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Zinc, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Hardness, Total (as CaC03) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Iron, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharne Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Chloride (as Cl) N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoride, Total N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Pyrene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Anthracene N/A N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Chrysene NIA NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluoranthene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Fluorene N/A N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenanthrene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharne Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Acenaphthylene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Acenaphthene N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (A) Pyrene N/A N/A NIA NIA Rp!Only Rpt Only NGIL 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Selenium, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by tlhe permittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantitv Units Other Units Units 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NG/L 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene NJA NJA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NGIL 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Benzo (GHI) Perylene NJA N/A N/A NJA Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Cyanide, Total N/A N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A NJA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Naphthalene N/A NJA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only ug/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Recov. Manganese NJA NJA N/A NJA Rpt Only Rpt Only mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NJA NJA Rpt Only Rpt Only DEG.F 

(Year Round) (ML-5) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Article 

P

Pe
A.097 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the permittee as specified below: 

Effluent 

Characteristic 

Sulfate 

(Year Round) (ML-5) 

N/A 

Quantitv 

N/A 

Discharge Limitations 

Units other Units 

N/A NIA Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following Jocation(s): 

Units 

mg/1 

Sampling shall be taken upstream of the influence of Outlet 005 in the Ohio River on the West Virginia side of the river. Refer to Section C.37 for solids sampli

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
A.105 DISCHARGE LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS: 

Final Limitations 

During the period beginning 10/1/2013 and lasting through midnight 6/30/2017 the permittee is authorized to discharge from Outlet N

Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the pennittee as specified below: 

Effluent Discharge Limitations 

Characteristic Quantity Units Other Units Units 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant N/A N/A NIA N/A 0.044 Rpt Only mgd 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

BOD, 5-Day 20 Deg.C 10 20 Lbs/Day N/A 30 60 mgn 

(Year Round) (ML-B) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Total Suspended Solids 10 20 Lbs/Day N/A 30 60 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Coliform, Fecal NIA N/A N/A NIA 200 400 Cnts/100ml 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Daily 

Ammonia Nitrogen 5 10 Lbs/Day NIA 15 30 mg/1 

(Year Round) (ML-1) Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring requirements specified above shall be taken at the following location(s): 

Internal Outlet 105 (Sanitary)- Effluent BOD samples shall be collected ala point immediately preceding disinfection. All other samples shall be collected afte

final discharge point. 

This discharge shall not cause violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3, of the West Virginia Legislative Rules issued pursuant to Chapter 228, Articl

P

Pe
Page No.: 35 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

B. SCHEDULE OF COMPLIANCE 

1. The permitee shall achieve compliance with the provisions for waste treatment and the monitoring 

requirements specified in the permit in accordance with the following schedule : 

Oct 16, 2013: The permittee shall complete the construction of necessary treatment upgrades and 

comply with the final effluent limitations for mercury at Outlet 006. 

Jan 01, 2014: 

Apr 01, 2014: 

Apr 01, 2014: 

Jul 01, 2014: 

Oct 01, 2014: 

Oct 01, 2014: 

Dec 31, 2014: 

Jan 01, 2015: 

Mar 01,2015: 

The permittee shall submit a Plan of Action on obtaining compliance with the average and 

maximum temperature limitations (February and March), average monthly temperature 

limitation {April), and temperature rise limitation at Outlet 004. 

The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

The pemittee shall submit a progress report pursuant to finalizing a study of its existing 

cooling water intake structures and the effects of fish and other aquatic organisms in 

accordance with the requirements of Section D.03. The permitttee shall submit a progress 

report pursuant to finalizing its Compliance Demonstration Work Plan in accordance with 

Section D.04 of the permit. 

The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

. March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

The pemittee shall submit a progress report pursuant to finalizing a study of its existing 

cooling water intake structures and the effects of fish and other aquatic life in accordance 

with the requirements of Section D.03. The permitttee shall submit a progress report 

pursuant to finalizing its Compliance Demonstration Work Plan in accordance with Section 

D.04 of the permit. 

The permittee shall submit the results of the mixing zone verification studies required by 

Sections C.30 and C.31 of the permit. 

The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

The permittee shall complete a study and submit a report on its existing cooling water 

intake structures and the effects of fish and other aquatic organisms in accordance with 

Section D.03 of this permit. 
Page No.: 36 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

B. SCHEDULE OF COMPLIANCE 

1. The permitee shall achieve compliance with the provisions for waste treatment and the monitoring 

requirements specified in the permit in accordance with the following schedule : 

Apr 01, 2015: The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

Apr 01, 2015: 

Jul 01, 2015: 

Oct 01, 2015: 

Oct 01, 2015: 

Apr 01, 2016: 

The permitttee shall submit a progress report pursuant to finalizing its Compliance 

Demonstration Work Plan in accordance with Section D.04 of the permit. 

The permittee shall submit a Quarterly Progress Report which summarizes the actions 

taken and any additional actions to be taken in the future to achieve the Final 

Requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations (February and 

March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and temperature rise limitation at 

Outlet 004. 

The permittee shall complete the construction of necessary treatment upgrades and 

comply with the final requirements for the average and maximum temperature limitations 

(February and March), average monthly temperature limitation (April), and the temperature 

rise limitation at Outlet 004. 

The permitttee shall submit a progress report pursuant to finalizing its Compliance 

Demonstration Work Plan in accordance with Section D.04 of the permit. 

The permittee shall submit a Compliance Demonstration Work Plan and permit 

modification application in accordance with the requirements of Section D.04 of this permit. 

2. Reports of compliance or non-compliance with, and progress reports on Interim and final requirements contained in 

the above compliance schedule, if any, shall be postmarked no later than 14 days following each schedule date. 
Section C -Other Requirements 

Page No.: 37 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

0 I. The permittee shall practice good housekeeping including maintaining the facility grounds. There shall be no 

scattered parts, equipment, debris, etc. Any and all drums shall be either stored in a covered area or kept upon 

pallets and properly sealed. 

02. The issuance of this permit shall not relieve the permittee of the obligation to comply with any other federal, state 

or local laws. Compliance with this permit does not relieve the permittee from the obligation of Section 311 of the 

Clean Water Act. This permit does not authorize spills of hazardous substances/wastes from any permitted outlet 

into waters ofthe State. Such incidents are to be reported in accordance with Sections IV.! and IV.2 of Appendix 

A of this permit. 

03. Upon review of information submitted under terms and conditions of this permit, the permit may be modified to 

require additional effluent limitations/monitoring requirements and/or improved best management practices. 

04. The permittee shall notify the Division of Water and Waste Management immediately when it becomes aware of 

any migration of any pollutant from any unpermitted source (such as contaminated groundwater and/or storm water) 

into surface waters of the State. 

05. If there is evidence indicating potential or realized impacts on water quality due to any storm water discharge 

associated with industrial activity covered by this permit, the permit may be promptly modified and/or reissued to 

include effluent limitations and/or other requirements to control such storm water discharges. 

06. The permittee shall submit each month according to the enclosed format, a Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) 

indicating in terms of concentration and/or quantities the values of the constituents listed in Section A analytically 

determined to be in the plant effluent(s). Additional information pertaining to effluent monitoring and reporting can 

be found in Section III of Appendix A. 

07. The required DMRs shall be received by the agency no later than 20 days following the end of the reporting period 

in accordance with the following requirements. The agency is now requiring the permittee to utilize our electronic 

discharge monitoring report ( eDMR) system which is now mandatory. The permittee is not required to submit hard 

copies ofthe DMRs to the addresses listed below when using eDMR. Special circumstances may result in the 

agency granting an exemption to eDMR and are considered on case by case basis. If the permittee was exempted 

by the agency from using the eDMR system, then the permittee is required to send hard copies to the addresses 

below. The permittee may contact the agency for more information about the eDMR system and potential 

exemptions from using it. Regardless, in accordance with Appendix A, Section III.6 of this permit, the permittee 

shall maintain copies ofDMRs (either hard copies or electronic copies) at the plant site and the DMRs shall be 

made readily available upon request for DEP personnel. 

a. Director 

Division of Water and Waste Management 

601 57th Street, SE 

Charleston, West Virginia 25304 

Attn: Permitting Branch 

Department of Environmental Protection 

Environmental Enforcement 

Wheeling Satellite Office (NW) 

1060 Chapline Street, Lower Lobby 

Wheeling, WV 26033-2955 

u. s. Environmental Protection Agency 

Region III, Water Protection Division 

NPDES Enforcement Branch (3WP42) 

1650 Arch Street 

Philadelphia, PA 19103 

08. For any noncompliance reports to be submitted in writing by this permit, a copy shall also be forwarded to the EPA 

at the location specified under Condition C.7 of this permit. 

09. Any "not detected (ND)" results by the permittee must be "ND" at the method detection limit (MDL) for the test 

method used for that parameter and must be reported as less than the MDL used. The permittee may not report the 

result as zero, "ND", or report the result as less than a minimum level (ML), reporting limit (RL), or practical 

quantitation limit (PQL). When averaging values of analytical results for DMR reporting purposes for monthly 

averages, the permittee should use actual analytical results when these results are greater than or equal to the MDL 

and should use zero (0) when these results are less than the MDL. If all analytical results are non-detect at the 

MDL (<MDL), then the permittee should use the actual MDL in the calculation for averaging and report the result 

as less than the average calculation. 
Section C - Other Requirements 

Page No.: 38 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

I 0. In incidences where a specific test method is not deemed, the permittee shall utilize an EPA approved method with 

a method detection limit (MDL) sensitive enough to confirm compliance with the permit effluent limit for that 

parameter. If a MDL is not sensitive enough to confirm compliance, the most sensitive approved method must be 

used. If a more sensitive EPA approved method becomes available, that method shall be used. Should the current 

and/or new method not be sensitive enough to confirm compliance with the permitted effluent limit, analytical 

results reported as "not detected" at the MDL of the most sensitive method available will be deemed compliant for 

purposes of permit compliance. Results shall be reported on the Discharge Monitoring Reports as a numeric value 

less than the MDL. 

11. The permittee shall not use alternate DMRs without prior approval from this Agency. 

12. The Groundwater Protection Plan (GPP) shall be maintained at the plant site and shall be available for inspection 

by DEP personnel. 

13. The permittee shall maintain and continue to implement its storm water pollution prevention plan (SWPPP) for the 

site. The SWPPP shall be prepared in accordance with good engineering practices. The SWPPP shall identifY 

potential sources of pollution which may reasonably be expected to affect the quality of storm water discharges 

associated with the industrial activity. In addition, the plan shall describe and ensure the implementation of 

practices which are to be used to reduce the pollutants in storm water discharges associated with the industrial 

activity at the facility and to assure compliance with the terms and conditions of this permit A copy of this 

document shall be retained at the site for review upon request. 

14. If any portion of the Permittee's discharge that is identified as being subject to Federal Effluent Guideline(s) and the 

new or revised requirements of the Federal Effluent Guideline(s) are not currently in this permit, the Director may 

reopen or reissue this permit to incorporate additional, more stringent requirements or limitations. 

15. The permittee shall perform acute effluent toxicity testing in accordance with the following. 

a. The acute effluent toxicity testing prescribed, herein, shall be 48-hour static acute toxicity tests utilizing 

Pimephales Promelas fathead minnow and Ceriodaphnia Dubia as the test species. 

b. The acute toxicity testing shall be performed on an annual (!/year) basis. The first acute toxicity testing shall 

be carried out within 6 months from the effective date of the permit for Outlet 006. There shall be a minimum 

of three (3) months between sampling events. 

c. 24-hour flow weighted composite samples of the effluent, as prescribed in Section A, shall be collected for 

testing. 

d. The dilution water should be a representative sample ofthe receiving water and should be obtained from a 

point as close as possible to but upstream or outside of the zone influenced by the effluent. If dilution water 

from the receiving stream is not suitable, some other uncontaminated, well-aerated surface or groundwater or 

commercially available media or reconstituted laboratory water can be used. 

e. Testing and reporting of the result shall be performed in accordance with 40 CFR 136 and must be submitted 

with the Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) for the month following the completion of each test. LC50 shall 

be converted into Acute Toxic Units (TUa) using the following formula: 

TUa ~ l 00/LCSO 

For example, ifLC50 is 100%, then TUa ~ 100/100 ~I. 

f. If acute effluent toxicity testing demonstrates toxicity above l TUa, the permittee shall immediately resample 

and test the effluent. This shall be performed within 30 days. Copies of the retesting results shall be provided 

to the Director immediately upon completion of the test. 

g. The Director may impose further requirements should the acute effluent toxicity testing results show toxicity. 

16. The permittee shall utilize EPA Method No. 1664 A (gravimetric analysis using the hexane extractable method 

[HEM]) for the analysis of oil and grease. 

17. For the measurement of Free Cyanide, the permittee shall use the standard method (including approved general 

method OIA 1677) for weak acid dissociable cyanide, as specified in the latest edition of Standard Methods. 
Section C - Other Requirements 

Page No.: 39 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

18. The Division has started to analyze the impacts of nutrients upon water quality and whether there is a need to 

establish nutrient water quality standards. Therefore, the Division shall impose effluent sampling for Total 

Nitrogen and Total Phosphorus in order to assist in this analysis. The Division recognizes there is not an EPA 

approved method to directly test for Total Nitrogen. The Total Nitrogen value to be reported on the permittee's 

Discharge Monitoring Reports (DMRs) shall be the sum of the following parameters; Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen, 

Nitrate and Nitrite. 

19. The Permittee shall submit the enclosed Annual Production Report summarizing the actual production from Outlet 

006 for each month. This report shall include the actual production from each unit for each month and not the 

potential production from the unit. For example, if a unit was in operation for only 2 shifts every day during a 

month, then the production reported from the unit should reflect only 2 shifts of operation for each day of the month 

and shall not include the potential third shift that was not worked. Please find the attached Annual Production 

Report that is to be used by the Permittee. An alternate report may not be used by the permittee without prior 

approval from this Agency. This report is due on or before the 20th of January each calendar year and may be 

attached to the Permittee's December DMR. 

20. The following conditions apply only to the package sewage treatment plant: 

a. The herein described treatment works, structures, electrical, and mechanical equipment shall be adequately 

protected from physical damage by the maximum expected twenty-five (25) year flood level, and operability 

shall be maintained during the ten (10) year flood level. 

b. Maintenance and operation of the listed sewage treatment facility shall be performed by, or supervised by, a 

certified operator possessing at least a Class 1-S certificate, for Waste Water Treatment Plant Operators, issued 

by the State of West Virginia. 

c. The permittee shall connect to a municipal or public service district sewage collection system, iffeasible, when 

one becomes available; however, prior to this connection, the permittee shall obtain written permission from 

the municipal or public service district sewage system authority which will receive the waste and submit a 

request along with one (I) copy of the written permission to the Division of Water and Waste Management for 

approval. 

d. Without prior approval from the agency, use of intermediates, by-products, spent solvents or any other 

materials (except commercial grade materials), containing pollutant(s) that cannot be removed by the 

wastewater treatment plant is prohibited. 

21. Should two (2) consecutive discharge monitoring reports illustrate non-compliance with any pollutant's permit 

limitations, the pe1mittee shall submit a Plan of Action outlining milestones to achieve compliance. 

22. Prior to disposing of any solids generated by the package sewage treatment plant, the permittee shall submit a letter 

of acceptance from the disposal facility to this Division. This does not apply to any normal solid wastes 

(trash/refuse) generated by the standard operation of the facility. However, those normal solid wastes shall be 

disposed of in a manner consistent with any, and all, appropriate laws and regulations. Any intentional 

discharge/disposal of any non-wastewater waste materials through any permitted discharge for the purpose of 

circumventing other regulations solely by dilution is prohibited. 

23. The permittee shall operate and maintain barge loading and unloading facilities in such a manner so as, to the 

maximum extent practicable, preclude spillage of coal, chemicals, etc. used at the facility, and shall take all actions 

necessary to clean up and control any such spill which may occur. 

24. In conformance with the requirements of Appendix A, Part II, Section 5, Removed Substances, the permittee shall 

obtain approval for the disposal of any solids generated by the wastewater treatment plant. This approval shall be 

afforded in accordance with the provisions of Title 33, Series 2, of the Legislative Rules, accordingly, and 40 CFR 

Part 503, as applicable. 

25. In accordance with Appendix A.III.6 of this permit, the permittee shall keep hard or electronic copies oflaboratory 

records on site and have readily available for review by DEP personnel. 
Section C - Other Requirements 

Page No.: 40 of46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

26. Any bilge water that is pumped out of the barges shall be pumped to the on-site collection system and properly 

treated prior to discharge, unless extreme emergency situations, such as, the imminent sinking of a barge into the 

Ohio River requires the immediate pumping of bilge water to the river to prevent a potentially worse environmental 

situation. In the case of these extreme emergency situations, the permittee shall follow the bypass provisions 

contained in Appendix A, Part II, Section 3 and the reporting requirements of Appendix A, PartlY, Section 2. 

Discharged bilge water shall not cause a violation of Title 47, Series 2, Section 3.a of the West Virginia Code of 

State Regulations. 

27. Net TSS calculations at Outlet 004 shall be calculated by subtracting the Gross TSS value at Outlet 097 from the 

Gross TSS value taken at Outlet 004. Outfall and upstream sampling (Outlet 097) for TSS shall be concurrent in 

order to calculate a representative net value. The permittee may collect a composite sample for TSS at Outlet 097 

in lieu of the required grab sample. The permittee should indicate this on the DMR accordingly. 

28. Effluent monitoring for the following pollutants shall be conducted using the most sensitive methods and detection 

levels commercially available and economically feasible. The following methods are to be used unless the 

permittee desires to use an EPA Approved Test Method with a listed lower method detection level. Regardless, it is 

recognized that detection levels can vary from analysis to analysis and that non-detect results at a different MDL for 

the specified test method would not constitute a permit violation. 

Parameter 

Copper, Total Recoverable 

Zinc, Total Recoverable 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable 

Selenium, Total Recoverable 

Benzene 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable 

Mercury, Total* 

Mercury, Total* 

Acenaphthene 

Acenaphthylene 

Anthracene 

Benzo(a)anthracene 

Benzo(b)fluoranthene 

Benzo(k)fluoranthene 

Benzo(a)pyrene 

Chrysene 

Fluoranthane 

Fluorene 

Naphthalene 

Phenanthrene 

Pyrena 

Benzo(ghi)perylene 

Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene 

Indeno(l,2,3-cd)pyrene 

EPA Method No. 

200.8 

200.8 

200.8 

200.9 

602 

420.1 

1631 

245.7 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

610 

Method Detection Level (ug/1) 

0.5 

1.8 

1 

0.6 

0.2 

5 

0.0002 

0.0018 

1.8 

2.3 

0.66 

0.01 

0.018 

0.017 

0.02 

0.15 

0.21 

0.21 

1.8 

0.64 

0.27 

0.076 

0.03 

0.04 

*The permittee may use either EPA Test Method 1631 or 245.7 for mercury. 

29. Sampling for total suspended solids at Outlet 097 shall be flow-proportional to reflect the quality of water from two 

water intakes (pump house at the Steubenville North Plant and the pump station on WV side of the river). 

30. The ZID granted for Outlet 006 extends approximately 6.0 meters downstream of Outlet 006. The CMZ for chronic 

aquatic life criteria granted for Outlet 006 extends approximately 49.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006. The CMZ 

for noncarcinogen human health criteria granted for Outlet 006 extends approximately 49.2 meters downstream of 

Outlet 006. The permittee shall conduct a mixing zone verification study per Section B of this permit. Monitoring 

for this study shall be conducted between the months of August and October. Monitoring for this study shall be 

conducted during normal operations, production, and discharge at the facility. The permittee shall attempt to 

conduct this study during low flow conditions in the Ohio River. For the purposes of this study, low flow 

conditions shall be defined as less than 7,500 cubic feet per second in the Ohio River. The Agency recognizes that 

this condition may not occur prior to the time specified in Section B ofthis permit. If this low flow condition is not 

met by the deadline in Section B of this permit, the permittee shall conduct this study between the months of August 

and October in 2014. 
Section C -Other Requirements 

Page No.: 41 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

30. a. The permittee shall monitor Outlet 006, immediately upstream and outside the influence ofthe discharge from 

Outlet 006, and the following downstream verification locations concurrently (the same day) for flow rate, 

temperature, pH, hardness, total suspended solids, total aluminum, ammonia nitrogen, total arsenic, chloride, 

total copper, free cyanide, fluoride, iron, mercury, nitrate nitrogen, nitrite nitrogen, total selenium, total 

residual chlorine, zinc, total phenolics, and total cyanide, and any other pollutant for which a mixing zone may 

be requested in the future. All monitoring shall be representative of normal operations and discharge levels at 

the facility. Monitoring for Outlet 006 shall be in accordance with its respective requirements defined in 

Sections A and C ofthis permit. Monitoring at the following verification locations shall consist of three 

depths: a surface, an approximate mid depth, and an approximate bottom sample. The depth of each sample 

shall be recorded and each sample analyzed separately. Test Methods used at the verification points shall be in 

accordance with Section C of the permit. 

b. I meter downstream of Outlet 006 and 95 meters from the stream bank. 

I meter downstream of Outlet 006 and 115 meters from the stream bank. 

I meter downstream of Outlet 006 and 125 meters from the stream bank. 

I meter downstream of Outlet 006 and 13 5 meters from the stream bank. 

I meter downstream of Outlet 006 and 145 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 95 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 115 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 125 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 135 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 145 meters from the stream bank. 

I 0 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 95 meters from the stream bank. 

I 0 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 115 meters from the stream bank. 

10 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 125 meters from the stream bank. 

I 0 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 13 5 meters from the stream bank. 

10 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 145 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 70 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 90 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 110 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 130 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 150 meters from the stream bank. 

35 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 170 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 70 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 90 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and II 0 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 130 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 150 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 170 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 70 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 90 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and II 0 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 130 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and !50 meters from the stream bank. 

72 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 170 meters from the stream bank. 

c. Upon completion, the permittee shall submit the study results including all sampling results along with 

corresponding lab sheets as specified in Section B of this permit. 

d. The permittee may elect use a dye tracer/indicator parameter in lieu of sampling for the above mentioned 

pollutants in Section C.30.a at the verification locations noted In Section C.30.a- C.30.b based on the 

following conditions. 
Section C - Other Requirements 

Page No.: 42 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

30. d. I) The permittee must select a dye tracer/indicator with a concentration in the discharge that is high enough 

to be recognized by the downstream plume study sampling locations prescribed in Section C.30.b. 

2) The dye tracer/indicator shall have been introduced into Outlet 006 at a constant concentration and 

allowed to continuously discharge for a minimum of 12 hours prior to sampling at the verification 

locations. 

3) The permittee shall still follow all other requirements identified in Section C.30 and subparts C.30.aC.30.c. 

4) The permittee shall still be required to sample the discharge from Outlet 006, immediately upstream and 

outside the influence of the discharge from Outlet 006, and at the locations listed below for all of the 

pollutants listed in Section C.30.a in order to verity that water quality criteria for these pollutants are 

being achieved at the edge of the zone of initial dilution and chronic mixing zone. All protocols identified 

in Section C.30 and Section C.30.a- C.30.c shall be followed including surface, mid-depth, and bottom 

sampling at each location. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 95 meters from the stream banlc 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 125 meters from the stream bank. 

6.2 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 145 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 70 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 120 meters from the stream bank. 

50 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 170 meters from the stream bank. 

31. The CMZ for carcinogen human health criteria granted for Outlet 006 extends approximately 1126.5 meters 

downstream of Outlet 006. The permittee shall conduct a mixing zone verification study per Section B of this 

permit. Monitoring for this study shall be conducted during normal operations, production, and discharge at the 

facility. The permittee shall attempt to conduct this study during the harmonic mean flow condition of the Ohio 

River (20,500 cfs). For the purposes of this study, acceptable flow conditions shall be defmed as between 20,500 

cfs and 23,000 cfs in the Ohio River. The Agency recognizes that this condition may not occur prior to the time 

specified in Section B of this permit. Ifthis flow range is not met by the deadline in Section B of this permit, the 

permittee shall conduct this study in 2014 at a stream flow as close as possible to the range prescribed above; 

however, the flow in the stream must be at least 20,500 cfs. 

a. The permittee shall monitor Outlet 006, immediately upstream and outside the influence of the discharge from 

Outlet 006, and the following downstream verification locations concurrently (the same day) for flow rate, 

temperature, pH, total suspended solids, benzo(a)anthracene, benzo(a)pyrene, benzo(b)fluoranthene, 

benzo(k)fluoranthene, chrysene, dibenzo(a,h)anthracene, and indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene, and any other 

carcinogen pollutant for which a mixing zone may be requested in the future. All monitoring shall be 

representative of normal operations and discharge levels at the facility. Monitoring for Outlet 006 shall be in 

accordance with its respective requirements defined in Sections A and C of this permit. Monitoring at the 

following verification locations shall consist of three depths: a surface, an approximate mid depth, and an 

approximate bottom sample. The depth of each sample shall be recorded and each sample analyzed separately. 

Test Methods used at the verification points shall be in accordance with Section C of the permit. 

b. 1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and I 0 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 20 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 40 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 80 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 95 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and II 0 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 125 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 140 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and !55 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 160 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 175 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 190 meters from the stream bank. 
Section C - Other Requirements 

Page No.: 43 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

31. c. Upon completion, the permittee shall submit the study results including all sampling results along with 

corresponding lab sheets as specified in Section B of this permit. 

d. The permittee may elect use a dye tracer/indicator parameter in lieu of sampling for the above mentioned 

pollutants in Section C.3l.a at the verification locations noted In Section C.3l.a- C.30.b based on the 

following conditions. 

l) The permittee must select a dye tracer/indicator with a concentration in the discharge that is high enough 

to be recognized by the downstream plume study sampling locations prescribed in Section C.3l.b. 

2) The dye tracer/indicator shall have been introduced into Outlet 006 at a constant concentration and 

allowed to continuously discharge for a minimum of 12 hours prior to sampling at the verification 

locations. 

3) The permittee shall still follow all other requirements identified in Section C.31 and subparts C.31.aC.3l.c. 

4) The permittee shall still be required to sample the discharge from Outlet 006, immediately upstream and 

outside the influence of the discharge from Outlet 006, and at the locations listed below for all of the 

pollutants listed in Section C.3l.a in order to verify that water quality criteria for these pollutants are 

being achieved at the edge of the zone of initial dilution and chronic mixing zone. All protocols identified 

in Section C.3l and Section C.3l.a- C.3l.c shall be followed including surface, mid-depth, and bottom 

sampling at each location. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 20 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and l 00 meters from the stream bank. 

1120 meters downstream of Outlet 006 and 190 meters from the stream bank. 

32. The temperature difference between the upstream/intake location and the discharge shall be calculated by 

subtracting the discharge temperature from the upstream/intake temperature measured in the Ohio River. The 

upstream/intake temperatures and discharge temperatures required by Section A of this permit shall be collected 

concurrently. Concurrently shall be defined as no more than 60 minutes between monitoring collected at the 

upstream/intake location in the Ohio River and the respective discharges. 

33. For purposes of identity, in this permit, Outlet No.004 refers to discharges from the combination of existing Internal 

Outlet Nos. 105 and former 305 into a new dedicated outlet at the same location as former Outlet No. 005. Outlet 

No.006 refers to discharges from the separation of former Internal Outlet No. 205 from former Outlet No. 005 to 

the new dedicated Outlet No. 006. 

Former Internal Outlet Nos. 205 and 305 and former Outlet No. 005 have been removed from the permit. 
Section D- 316 (b) Intake Requirements 

Page No.: 44 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

I. In accordance with 316(b) of the Clean Water Act, the location, design, construction, and capacity of the cooling 

water intake structures (CWIS) for the permittee's facility shall reflect the best technology available (BTA) for 

minimizing adverse environmental impact. 

2. On the basis of currently available information, the agency has determined that the BTA alternatives for this facility 

shall be one, or a combination, ofthe following: 

a. Behavioral barriers, which alter or take advantage of natural behavioral patterns to attract or repel fish and 

physical barriers, which physically block fish passage. 

b. Collection systems which actively collect fish for their return to a safe release location. 

c. Diversion systems which divert fish to bypasses for their return to safe release location. 

d. Flow reduction systems which reduce intake flow commensurate with closed cycle cooling systems. 

e. A reduction in the intake velocity such that the flow inake velocity is equal to, or less than, 0.5 feet per second. 

f. Some facilities may have existing technologies in place for their intake system and may be able to demonstrate 

that existing technologies may meet the BTA requirements of316(b) of the CW A. Similarly, some facilities 

may determine that alternate technologies than those identified in this permit may meet the BTA requirements 

of316(b) of the CWA. The agency will consider these on a case-by-case basis. 

3. The permittee shall complete a study of its existing cooling water intake structures and the effects offish and other 

aquatic organisms within 15 months after the issuance if this permit. This study shall include, but not be limited to, 

an analysis of the existing influent plume and current levels of impingement and entrainment and associated 

mortality. The permittee shall submit a comprehensive report no later than 45 days after completing its study. The 

report shall set forth the research methodologies used and the results and shall also identify and describe all 

existing intake structures at the facility including the location, stream source, design flow, average intake flow, 

percent of intake flow used for cooling water and the average intake flow velocity. 

4. The permittee shall submit a Compliance Demonstration Work Plan (CDWP) no later than 30 months after the 

issuance of this permit along with a permit modification application that identifies its selected BTA alternative(s) to 

reduce the impingement and entrainment impacts of the CWIS as required by 316(b) of the Clean Water Act. The 

CDWP shall identify the impingement and entrainment reductions which will be attained through implementation of 

the selected BTA alternatives. This CDWP shall also include, but not be limited to, the following information: 

a. A description of the proposed technologies and operational measures to be implemented at the facility. 

b. A summary of any past or ongoing consultations with appropriate Federal, State, and wildlife agencies that are 

relevant to 316(b) and a copy of written comments received as a result of such consultations 

c. A sampling plan for any new field studies proposed to be conducted in order to ensure that sufficient data 

exists to develop a scientifically valid estimate of impingement mortality and entrainment at the facility. In 

general, the sampling plan shall include methodologies of measuring impingement and entrainment reductions 

to be attained after implementation of selected BTA alternatives to verify targeted reductions are achieved. 

The sampling plan must document all methods and quality assurance/quality control procedures for sampling 

and data analysis. The sampling and data analysis methods proposed must be appropriate for a quantitative 

survey and include consideration of the methods used in other studies performed in the source waterbody. The 

sampling plan must include a description of the cooling water intake structure(s), and provide a taxonomic 

identification of the sampled or evaluated biological assemblages (including all life stages offish and shellfish). 

If the permittee decides to pursue, or already has implemented, technologies that meet the requirements fouud 

in Sections D.2.d and/or D.2.e above; then, a measurement of the flow reduction and/or intake velocity shall 

suffice as meeting impingement and entrainment reductions and the above described sampling plan is not 

necessary. 

d. A plan and schedule to implement the CDWP. 

5. The permittee shall implement the CDWP upon written approval by the Agency. The permittee shall submit 

semi-annual progress reports to the Agency, outlining progress on the obligations contained in the CDWP. The 

reports shall be submitted on or before February I and August I of each year. The reports shall include information 

relating to any delays or problems complying with the obligations in the approved CDWP. 
Section D- 316 (b) Intake Requirements 

Page No.: 45 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

6. The Agency, in consultation with EPA, will evaluate the results of the permittee's 316(b) CDWP and determine, on 

the basis of best professional judgement, whether the currently implemented and proposed technologies and other 

measures reflect BTA, as required by 316(b ). Pursuant to 40 CFR 122.62, if the Agency and/or EPA determines 

that the currently implemented technologies and other measures do not reflect BTA, the permit may be reopened 

and modified to include a 316(b) compliance schedule, which may include but not necessarily be limited to 

proposed design and construction technologies and/or operational measures identified by the permittee. Pursuant to 

40 CFR 122.62, the permit may also be reopened and modified with requirements of new regulations, standards, or 

judicial decisions relating to 316(b ). 

7. Continued and future compliance with Section 316(b) of the Clean Water Act will be determined from a successful 

implementation of the CDWP which reflects that the design and construction technologies and/or operational 

measures that the permittee has selected and installed, or will install, at the facility meet the applicable requirements 

of316(b) of the Clean Water Act including BTA. 
Page No.: 46 of 46 

Permit No.: WV0004499 

The herein-described activity is to be extended, modified, added to, made, enlarged, acquired, constructed or 

installed, and operated, used and maintained strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions of this permit, with 

the plans and specifications submitted with Permit Application No. WV0004499; with the plan of maintenance and 

method of operation thereof submitted with such application(s); and with any applicable rules and regulations 

promulgated by the Enviromnental Quality Board and the Secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection. 

Failure to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit, with the plans and specifications submitted with 

Permit Application No. WV0004499; and with the plan of maintenance and method of operation thereof submitted 

with such application( s) shall constitute grounds for the revocation or suspension of this permit and the invocation of 

all the enforcement procedures set forth in Chapter 22, Article 11, or 15 of the Code of West Virginia. 

This permit is issued in accordance with the provisions of Chapter 22, Article II and 12 and/or 15 of the Code of 

West Virginia and is transferable under the terms of Section 11 of Article II. 

~U/£1 Scott G. Mandirola, Director 
Appendix A 

I. MANAGEMENT CONDITIONS: 

1. Duty to Comply 

a) 

b) 

The permittee must comply with all conditions of this permit. Permit noncompliance constitutes a violation of the CWA and State Act and is 

grounds for enforcement action; for pennit modification, revocation and rcissuance, suspension or revocation; or for denial of a permit renewal 

application. 

The permittee shall comply with all effluent standards or prohibitions established under Section 307(a) of the CWA for toxic pollutants within 

the time provided in the regulations that establish these standards or prohibitions, even if the penn it has not yet been modified to incorporate 

the requirement. 

2. Duty to Reapply 

If the permittee wishes to continue an activity regulated by this permit after the expiration date of this permit, the pennittee must apply for a new permit at 

least 180 days prior to expiration of the permit. 

3. Duty to Mitigate 

The permittee shall take all reasonable steps to minimize or prevent any discharge in violation of this permit, which has a reasonable likelihood of 

adversely affecting human health or the environment. 

4. Permit Actions 

This permit may be modified, revoked and reissued, suspended, or revoked for cause. The filing of a request by the permittee for permit modification, 

revocation and reissuance, or revocation, or a notification of planned changes or anticipated noncompliance, does not stay any permit condition. 

5. Property Rights 

This permit does not convey any property rights of any sort or any exclusive privilege. 

6. Signatory Requirements 

All applications, reports, or information submitted to the Director shall be signed and certified as required in Title 47, Series 10, Section4.6 of the West 

Virginia Legislative Rules. 

7. Transfers 

This permit is not transferrable to any person except after notice to the Director. The Director may require modification or revocation and reissuance of the 

permit to change the name of the permittee and incorporate such other requirements as may be necessary. 

8. Duty to Provide Information 

The permittee shall furnish to the Director, within a reasonable specified time, any information which the Director may request to determine whether cause 

exists for modifying, revoking and reissuing, suspending, or revoking this permit, or to determine compliance with this permit. The permittee shall also 

furnish to the Director, upon request, copies of records required to be kept by this permit. 

9. Other Information 

Where the pennittee becomes aware that it failed to submit any relevant facts in a permit application, or submitted incorrect information in a permit 

application or in any report to the Director, it shall promptly submit such facts or information. 

10. Inspection and Entry 

The permittee shall allow the Director, or an authorized representative, upon the presentation of credentials and other documents as may be required by law, 

to: 

a) 

b) 

c) 

d) 

Enter upon the permittee's premises in which an effluent source or activity is located, or where records must be kept under the conditions of this 

pennit; 

HaVe access to and copy at reasonable times, any records that must be kept under the conditions of this permit; 

Inspect at reasonable times any facilities, equipment (including monitoring and control equipment), practices, or operations regulated or 

required under this permit; and 

Sample or monitor at reasonable times, for the purposes of assuring permit compliance or as othenvise authorized by the State Act, any 

substances or parameters at any location. 

11. Permit Modification 

This permit may be modified, suspended, or revoked in whole or in part during its term in accordance with the provisions of Chapter 22-11-12 of the 

Code of West Virginia. 

12. Water Quality 

Subject to 47 WV CSR 10.3.4.a, the effluent or effluents covered by this permit are to be of such quality so as not to cause violation of applicable water quality 

standards. 

13. Outlet Markers 

A penn anent marker at the establishment shall be posted in accordance with Title 47, Series ll, Section 9 of the West Virginia Legislative Rules. 

14. Liabilities 

a) 

b) 

c) 

d) 

Any person who violates a permit condition implementing sections 301, 302, 306, 307, 308, 318, or 405 of the Clean Water Act is subject to a 

civil penalty not to exceed $25,000 per day of such violation. Any person who willfully or negligently violates permit conditions 

implementing sections 301, 302,306,307,308 or 405 of the Clean Water Act is subject to a fine of not less than $2,500 nor more than $25,000 per 

day of violation, or by imprisonment for not more than 1 year, or both. 

Any person who falsifies, tampers with, or knowingly renders inaccurate any monitoring device or method required to be maintained under 

this permit shall, upon conviction, be punished by a fine of not more than $10,000 per violation, or by imprisonment for not more than 2 

years, or by both. 

Any person who knowingly makes any false statement, representation, or certification in any record or other document submitted or required to 

be maintained under this permit, including monitoring reports or reports of compliance or noncompliance shall, upon conviction, be punished 

by a fine of not more than $10,000 per violation, or by imprisonment for not more than 2 years, or by both. 

Nothing in 1.14 a), b), and c) shall be construed to limit or prohibit any other authority the Director may have under the State Water Pollution 

Control Act, Chapter 22, Article 11. 
II. OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE: 

l. Proper Operation and Maintenance 

The permittee shall at all times properly operate and maintain all facilities and systems of treatment and control (and related appurtenances) which are 

installed or used by the permittee to achieve compliance with the conditions of this permit. Proper operation and maintenance also includes adequate 

laboratory controls, and appropriate quality assurance procedures. Unless otherwise required by Federal or State law, this provision requires the operation 

of back-up auxiliary facilities or similar systems which are installed by the permittee only when the operation is necessary to achieve compliance with the 

conditions of the pennit. For domestic waste treatment facilities, waste treatment operators as classified by the WV Bureau of Public Health Laws, W.Va. 

Code Chapter 16-1, will be required except that in circumstances where the domestic waste treatment facility is receiving any type of industrial waste, the 

Director may require a more highly skilled operator. 

2. Need to Halt or Reduce Activity Not a Defense 

3. Bypass 

4. Upset 

It shall not be a defense for a pennittee in an enforcement action that it would have been necessary to halt or reduce the permitted activity in order to 

maintain compliance with the conditions of the permit. 

a) Definitions 

(l) "Bypass" means the intentional diversion of waste streams from any portion of a treatment facility; and 

(2) "Severe property damage" means substantial physical damage to property, damage to the treatment facilities which causes them to 

become inoperable, or substantial and permanent loss of natural resources which can reasonably be expected to occur in the absence 

of a bypass. Severe property damage does not mean economic loss caused by delays in production. 

b) Bypass not exceeding limitations. The permittee may allow any bypass to occur which does not cause effluent limitations to be exceeded, but 

only if it also is for essential maintenance to assure efficient operation. These bypasses are not subject to the provision ofll.3.c) and II.3.d) of 

this permit. 

c) (I) If the permittee knows in advance of the need for a byp'ass, it shall submit prior notice, if possible at least ten (10) days before the 

date of the bypass; 

(2) If the permittee does not know in advance of the need for bypass, notice shall be submitted as required in IV.2.b) of this pennit. 

d) Prohibition of bypass 

(l) Bypass is permitted only under the following conditions, and the Director may take enforcement action against a pennittee for a 

bypass, unless; 

(A) Bypass was unavoidable to prevent loss of life, personal injury, or severe property damage; 

(B) There were no feasible alternatives to the bypass, such as the use of auxiliary treatment facilities, retention of untreated 

wastes, or maintenance during nonnal periods of equipment downtime. This condition is not satisfied if adequate backup 

equipment should have been installed in the exercise of reasonable engineering judgement to prevent a bypass which 

occurred during normal periods of equipment downtime or preventative maintenance; and 

(C) The pennittee submitted notices as required under IIJ.c) of this pennit. 

(2) The Director may approve an anticipated bypass. after considering its adverse effects. if the Director determines that it will meet the 

three conditions listed in II.3.d.(l) of this permit. 

a) Definition. "Upset" means an exceptional incident in which there is unintentional and temporary noncompliance with technology-based permit 

effluent limitations because of factors beyond the reasonable control of the pennittee. An upset does not include noncompliance to the extent 

caused by operational error, improperly designed treatment facilities, inadequate treatment facilities, lack of preventative maintenance, or 

careless or improper operation. 

b) Effect of an upset. An upset constih1tes an affinnative defense to an action brought for noncompliance with such technology-based permit 

effluent limitation if the requirements ofll.4.c) are met. No determination made during administrative review of claims that noncompliance 

was caused by upset, and before an action for noncompliance, is final administrative action subject to judicial review. 

c) Conditions necessary for a demonstration of upset. A pennittee who wishes to establish the affirmative defense of upset shall demonstrate, 

through properly signed, contemporaneous operating logs, or other relevant evidence that 

(1) An upset occurred and that the permittee can identify the cause(s) of the upset; 

(2) The pennitted facility was at the time being properly operated; 

(3) The pennittee submitted notice of the upset as required in IV.2.b) of this permit. 

(4) The permittee complied with any remedial measures required under 1.3. of this pennit. 

d) Burden of proof. In any enforcement proceeding the permittee seeking to establish the occurrence of an upset has the burden of proof. 

5. Removed Substances 

Where removed substances arc not otherwise covered by the terms and conditions of this permit or other existing permit by the Director, any solids, sludges, 

filter backwash or other pollutants (removed in the course of treatment or control of wastewaters) and which are intended for disposal within the State, 

shall be disposed of only in a manner and at a site subject to the approval by the Director. If such substances are intended for disposal outside the State or for 

reuse, i.e., as a material used for making another product, which in turn has another use, the permittee shall notify the Director in writing of the proposed 

disposal or use of such substances, the identity of the prospective disposer or users, and the intended place of disposal or use, as appropriate. 
III. MONITORING AND REPORTING 

I. Representative Sampling 

Samples and measurements taken for the purpose of monitoring shall be representative of the monitored activity. 

2. Reporting 

a) Permittee shall submit, according to the enclosed format, a Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) indicating in terms of concentration, and/or 

quantities, the values of the constituents listed in Part A analytically detennined to be in the plant effiuent(s). DMR submissions shall be made 

in accordance with the terms contained in Section C of this permit. 

b) 

c) 

d) 

Enter reported average and maximum values under "Quantity" and "Concentration" in the units specified for each parameter, as appropriate. 

SpecifY the number of analyzed samples that exceed the allowable pennit conditions in the columns labeled "N.E." (i.e., number exceeding). 

SpecifY frequency of analysis for each parameter as number of analyses/specified period (e.g.,3/month is equivalent to 3 analyses performed 

every calendar month). If continuous, enter "Cont.". The frequency listed on format is the minimum required. 

3, Test Procedures 

Samples shall be taken, preserved and analyzed in accordance with the latest edition of 40 CFR Part 136, unless other test procedures have been specified 

elsewhere in this permit. 

4. Recording of Results 

For each measurement or sample taken pursuant to the permit, the permittee shall record the following information. 

a) The date, exact place, and time of sampling or measurement; 

b) The date(s) analyses were performed; 

c) The individual(s) who performed the sampling or measurement; 

d) The individual(s) who performed the analyses; if a commercial laboratory is used, the name and address of the laboratory; 

e) The analytical techniques or methods used, and 

f) The results of such analyses. Information not required by the DMR form is not to be submitted to this agency, but is to be retained as required 

in III.6. 

5. Additional Monitoring by Permittee 

If the permittee monitors any pollutant at any monitoring point specified in this permit more frequently than required by this permit, using approved test 

procedures or others as specified in this permit, the results of this monitoring shall be included in the calculation and reporting of the data submitted in the 

Discharge Monitoring Report Form. Such increased frequency shall also be indicated. Calculations for all limitations which require averaging of 

measurements shall utilize an arithmetic mean unless otherwise specified in the pennit. 

6. Records Retention 

7. 

The permittee shall retain records of all monitoring information, including all calibration and maintenance records and all original chart recordings for 

continuous monitoring instrumentation, copies of all reports required by this permit, and records of all data used to complete the application for the permit, 

for a period of at least three (3) years from the date of the sample, measurement, report or application. This period may be extended by request of the 

Director at any time. 

Definitions 

a) 

b) 

c) 

d) 

e) 

f) 

g) 

h) 

i) 

j) 

k) 

I) 

"Daily discharge" means the discharge of a pollutant measured during a calendar day or within any specified period that reasonably represents 

the calendar day for purposes of sampling. For pollutants with limitations expressed in units of mass, the daily discharge is calculated as the 

total mass of the pollutant discharged over the day. For pollutants with limitations expressed in other units of measurement, the daily discharge 

is calculated as the average measurement of the pollutant over the day. 

"Average monthly discharge limitation" means the highest allowable average of daily discharges over a calendar month, calculated as the sum 

of all daily discharges measured during a calendar month divided by the number of daily discharges measured during that month. 11Maximum daily discharge limitation" means the highest allowable daily discharge. 

"Composite Sample" is a combination of individual samples obtained at regular intervals over a time period. Either the volume of each 

individual sample is proportional to discharge flow rates or the sampling interval (for constant volume samples) is proportional to the flow rates 

over the time period used to produce the composite. The maximum time period between individual samples shall be two hours. 

"Grab Sample" is an individual sample collected in less than 15 minutes. 

"is" "" immersion stabilization - a calibrated device is immersed in the effluent stream until the reading is stabilized. 

The "daily average temperature" means the arithmetic average of temperature measurements made on an hourly basis, or the mean value plot of 

the record of a continuous automated temperature recording instrument, either during a calendar month, or during the operating month if flows 

are of shorter duration. 

The "daily maximum temperature" means the highest arithmetic average of the temperatures observed for any two (2) consecutive hours during 

a 24 hour day, or during the operating day if flows are of shorter duration. 

The "monthly average fecal coliform11 bacteria is the geometric average of all samples collected during the month. 

"Measured Flow" means any method of liquid volume measurement, the accuracy of which has been previously demonstrated in engineering 

practice, or which a relationship to absolute volume has been obtained. 

"Estimate" means to be based on a technical evaluation of the sources contributing to the discharge including, but not limited to pump 

capabilities, water meters and batch discharge volumes. 

"Non-contact cooling water" means the water that is contained in a leak-free system, i.e., no contact with any gas, liquid, or solid other than the 

container for transport; the water shall have no net poundage addition of any pollutant over intake water levels, exclusive of approved antifouling agents. 
IV. OTHER REPORTING 

1. Reporting Spills and Accidental Discharges 

Nothing in this permit shall be construed to preclude the institution of any legal action or relieve the permittee from any responsibilities, liabilities or 

penalties established pursuant to Title 47, Series 11, Section 2 of the West Virginia Legislative Rules promulgated pursuant to Chapter 22, Article 11. 

Attached is a copy of the West Virginia Spill Alert System for use in complying with Title 47, Series 11, Section 2 of the Legislative rules as they pertain 

to the reporting of spills and accidental discharges. 

2. Immediate Reporting 

a) The permittee shall report any noncompliance which may endanger health or the environment immediately after becoming aware of the 

circumstances by using the Agency's designated spill alert telephone number. A written submission shall be provided within five (5) days of 

the time the pennittee becomes aware of the circumstances. The written submission shall contain a description of the noncompliance and its 

cause~ the period of noncompliance, including exact dates and times, and if the noncompliance has not been corrected, the anticipated time it is 

expected to continue; and steps taken or planned to reduce, eliminate, and prevent recurrence of the noncompliance. 

b) The following shall also be reported immediately: 

(I) Any unanticipated bypass which exceeds any effluent limitation in the penn it; 

(2) Any upset which exceeds any effluent limitation in the permit; and 

(3) Violation of a maximum daily discharge limitation for any of the pollutants listed by the Director in the permit shall be reported 

immediately. This list shall include any toxic pollutant or hazardous substance, or any pollutant specifically identified as the 

method to control a toxic pollutant or hazardous substance. 

c) The Director may waive the written report on a case-by-case basis if the oral report has been received in accordance with the above. 

d) Compliance with the requirements oflV.2 of this section, shall not relieve a person of compliance with Title 47, Series ll, Section 2. 

3. Reporting Requirements 

a) Planned changes. The permittee shall give notice to the Director of any planned physical alterations or additions to the permitted facility which 

may affect the nature or quantity of the discharge. Notice is required when: 

(l) The alteration or addition to a permitted facility may meet one of the criteria for detennining whether a facility is a new source in 

Section l3.7.b of Series 10, Title 47; or 

(2) The alteration or addition could significantly change the nature or increase the quantity of pollutants discharged. This notification 

applies to pollutants which are subject neither to effluent limitations in the permit, nor to notification requirements under IV.2 of this 

section. 

b) Anticipated noncompliance. The permittee shall give advance notice to the Director of any planned changes in the permitted facility or activity 

which may result in noncompliance with pennit requirements. 

c) In addition to the above reporting requirements, all existing manufacturing, commercial, and silvicultural discharges must notify the Director in 

writing as soon as they know or have reason to believe: 

(l) That any activity has occurred or will occur which would result in the discharge, on a routine or frequent basis, or any toxic 

pollutant which is not limited in the permit, if that discharge will exceed the highest of the following "notification levels": 

(A) One hundred micrograms per liter (100 ug/1); 

(B) Two hundred micrograms per liter (200 ug/1) for acrolein and acrylonitrile; five hundred micrograms per liter (500 ugll) 

for 2,4-dinitro phenot and for 2-methyl4,6-dinitrophenol; and one milligram per liter (1 mg/1) for antimony; 

(C) Five (5) times the maximum concentration value reported for that pollutant in the permit application in accordance with 

Section 4.4.b.9 ofSerieslO, Title 47. 

(D) The level established by the Director in accordance with Section 6.3.g of Series 10, Title 47; 

(2) That any activity has occurred or will occur which would result in any discharge (on a non-routine or infrequent basis) of a toxic 

which is not limited in the permit, if that discharge will exceed the highest of the following "notification levels": 

(A) Five hundred micrograms per liter (500 ugll); 

(B) One milligram per liter (1 mg/1) for antimony; 

(C) Ten (10) times the maximum concentration value reported for that pollutant in the permit application in accordance with 

Section 4.4.b.7 of Series 10, Title 47; 

(D) The level established by the Director in accordance with Section 6.3.g of Series 10, Title 47. 

(3) That they have begun or expect to begin to use or manufacture as an intennediate or final product or by-product of any toxic 

pollutant which was not reported in the pennit application under Section 4.4.b.9 of Series 10, Title 47 and which will result in the 

discharge on a routine or frequent basis of that toxic pollutant at levels which exceed five times the detection limit for that pollutant 

under approved analytical procedure. 

( 4) That they have begun or expect to begin to use or manufacture as an intennediate or final product or by-product of any toxic 

pollutant which was not reported in the permit application under Section4.4.b.9 of Series 10, Title 47 and which will result in the 

discharge on a non-routine or infrequent basis of that toxic pollutant at levels which exceed ten times the detection limit for that 

pollutant under approved analytical procedure. 

4. Other Noncompliance 

The permittee shall report all instances of noncompliance not reported under the above paragraphs at the time monitoring reports are submitted. The 

reports shall contain the information listed in IV.2.a). Should other applicable noncompliance reporting be required, these terms and conditions will be 

found in Section C of this permit. 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLEr NO.: ,004=.. ____ _ 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

'.

·.· .. · .· ... ·.·.• ... ·.. "'t·· . ,.. - ·.·.··I - .. - <Quantity ·other Units 

I Units N.E · CEL* 

Un

50050 (ML-1) RF-A 

Flow,in Conduit or thru plant 

Year Round 

00530 (ML-2) RF-A 

Total Suspended Solids 

Year Round 

74055 (ML-1) RF-A 

Coliform, Fecal 

Year Round 

00400 (ML-1) RF-A 

pH 

Year Round 

00610 (ML-1) RF-B 

Ammonia Nitrogen 

Year Round 

00600 (ML-1) RF-B 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) 

Year Round 

00665 (ML-1) RF-B 

Phosphorus, Total 

Year Round 

50060 (ML-1) RF-B 

Chlorine, Total Residual 

Year Round 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

'Permit Limits 

Reported 

Perm it Lim its 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

* CEL = Co'TI.I2!lance Evaluation Level 

N/A NIA 

N/A NIA 

N/A Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

N/A 

NIA 

IN/A 

NIA 

lnst Min. 

NIA 

Lbs!Day N/A Lbs!Day IN/A 

N/A 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

200 

Mon. Geo. Mean 

N/A 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Avg. Monthly 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

60 

Max. Daily 

400 

Max. Daily 

9 

lnsl Max. 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

Rpt Only 

Max. Daily 

N/A lmgd 

NIA lmg/1 N/A I Cnls/

NIA IS.U. NIA lmg/1 

N/A mg/1 N/A mg/1 NIA lug/! 

Name ofPiiriCipaLEi<eeuthiedfficer ... ,. __ .. ,ce. ltify __ ·.... u ... n· P ... na_ lty. .. o. ·f. Ia. w_ th .. _at·_.th __ .is. docu ...._me __ .f!t. and a __ n atta. ch ... m ..e. n_. we_re. pre_P_. ared .. · .. · 0 t Co 1 t

1:-'nd:r my or superv1s1on 1n accordance With a systemdes1gned to assure that a e . mp e 

and.evaluate the infotrmilionsubrilitted Based on . . . .. .. ·. . •. 

j!====c=c=======c==WillY. mgu1ry. of the pers6g orper5ons.wh6 manage the System, ·or thosepersolls directly S1gnature .of P

T"rtle of.Officer . • . . . . .· . .•. <;Spoi1Siblefor galhertng the infonnation, the information submitted is; to. the best of my Authonzed Ag

· · . · . · . .1_:._d. ge·an· d. b.··. till.· e, a:cu_ ... _rate; I am ...·. aware that !.here ar.e significant Jf'<'nalties•for submitting false mfonmation mcludmg the possibility of a fine and · · 

..• imprisonmenffor knowing . . . . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: =004~-----

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

I . ' · .. ··. . ._ .... 

--

. Quantity. _,. . Other Units 

:Parameter ,· .. ·. 

. . . . . ·. 

. Units N:E. .· . . . CEL* 

01119 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Copper, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01094 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Zinc, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00718 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Perm tt Lim tts Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

71900 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01104 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00980 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01055 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00940 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Chloride (as Cl) NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

"" CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

. 

·Un

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

~arne <it Principal ExecutiVe Officer l. ce __ · -~fy ... _u_n~ .. e_r.pe __ naJty__ o.f.Ia_w th.. _at_ ~.-.. is __.d.·ocu __ ·. m_· .. e.··. ·n·t .. an· ? aU att·a· _ch_ m_ e_n __ ~ were_· __ Pr_ ep. ared Date Comple

nd.er my .d~eecl1on orsuperv1s1on m accordance with a system des1gnedto assure that · 

~pa!ifJe~ 

~e~onoel prOperty gatherand evaluate the information submitted. Based on . . . 

i!================:dl'my 1nquuy ofthe peTSOn orper.;ons who manage the system; or those persons directly S1gnature of P

Trtle of'Otlider .·· · · .. · . · · · esp6riSiple foqjat~ering_ theinformation, the informationsubmitted is, to the best of my .rA~uth_o..cnz ___ ed~_ c.

l .. · · ··· · ···· no ____ wle ___ dg. e_·an_ .·. a __ ._be. lief, .. tru····.· e, accura_ · .. ·. t. e., and, complete: I a_ m. aware_th.~atth.ere are significant ~Penalties .for submitting false. information including the posSibility of a fine and -,-,,...,-...,.-,....,-,.,-.,.-...,.----,--,--" r,rnprisonmernfor Knowing violations. .. L._-,----,----
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,;004=------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

, .... . . ·· .. ·· .. . .. · .. · . ·. . Quantitv" . ·I · ... · 

. ·Other Units 

P..rarneter .·. Units· N.E . GEL* 

.. .. ·. · ... 

. 

00951 (ML-1) RF-8 Reported 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Penn it Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34469 (ML-1) RF-8 Reported 

Pyrene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34526 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permrt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34320 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Chrysene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34376 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoranthene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34381 (ML-1) RF-8 Reported 

Fluorene NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34461 (ML-1) RF-8 Reported . 

Phenanthrene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max.. Daily 

34200 (ML-1) RF-8 Reported 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Coi!!Q!_iance Evaluation Level 

Un

mg/1 

ug/1 

NG/L 

NGJL 

ugn 

ug/1 ug/1 

ugn 

fN;ili,e of officer . l ofi<!W. thiS document all were prepared . . . Date .Comple

under myd1rection or m accordance With a system des1gnedtoassure that . . · , 

, u;;llified p.Orsonnetproperly gatherand evaluate the information submitted. Base<l,on ·. , ·. · . • . • 

•. y!inquiry.ofthe_ person pi" persons who manage_ the S}'Stern, cit those. persons directly . Slgnatllre .of P

title ofo=ifi=ce=. r='. ===========r .. esponsible for gathering the information, the. information submitted is, to the. best of my . Authonze<lAg

· · · · · nowle<lge an.d .l>elie_f, true; ae<:lirate, and complete. I am aware that there. are significant 

enaltiesfor submitting false ipfonnation including the possibility ofa fine and 

knowing violations: · · 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,00""4'-------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. . ·. . ..... ·.··. .· .. .·. · · ·• Quantitv . · .. ·····. ·Other Unffs 

Parameter . I .· • ..... . . ·.. . I.· . 

·. Units N.E. CEL* . ·· Un

•. .• .·· I. 

34205 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Acenaphthene NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NIA ug/1 Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34220 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Anthracene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA ug/1 Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34230 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo {B) Fluoranthene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A NG/L 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34242 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NIA NG/L 

Year Round Perm it lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34247 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Pyrene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA NG/L 

Year Round Permtt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00981 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A u9/l 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00978 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34556 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Dibenzo {A,H) Anthracene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A NG/L 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Evaluation Level 

Name of Piincii>CII ExecOiiVe officer. · r (;ertify underP¥lnal_ty all were prepared · Date Complet

I oder my d1recbonor superv•s•on.m accordance witt! a syS!errr des1gnedio assure that · ,...· _· """."'·. ··..

• 

qu."Jilie<! personnelproperty gath-:ran<J e\r.iiluate the1nfunmatioJ1 submitte<( Bas':<! on : . . ·.. . .. . .·. 

!!================!!'my mqUJry of the person or persons who. manage the system, or those persons dlfectly of 

Trtle ofOfficer . · · ·. infonmalion, the information submittejl is, to the .best of my 1 

· · · ·· · ·· kn6wlt>dgeand:belief,.1i"ue; accurate; and complete: I am aware that there are significant 

penafiiesfor. submitting false including the possibilffy of a fine and 

knowingyiolatiops. . .· .. · ·. · · . ... .. · . . . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'004=------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. ' ·.··.··_ .. · ........ ·.•,,·._ ... · ' • . . . . . ·· · .... ·.· ... .· .. Quan!it\t . 

. ·····.· 

. . . ·Other Units 

-

. 

Parameter . . . I . ·' . . ·. . .· .. . 

• • •• F ··. · .. · . ·.· ·Units N.E. . L_CEL*. -

34403 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00720 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Total NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

32730 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34696 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Naphthalene N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-2) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-7) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Summer May 1-Jan 31 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Winter Feb 1-28129 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

• CEL = Coll]Qiianoe Evaluation Level 

Un

NG/L 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

DEGDEGDEG

DEG

Name.MPiiildpai .. ElcecUtlve·Offider ... •. ·• r documentan?all were prepared Date Complet

lr=========-===4•1' undermy_dlfecfion or_s!Jperw;Jon 1naccordance With <t system deSJgned to assure !hat 

personnel properly galherandevaluate the submitted. BaSed on . . . . _· 

lk===:=:========::!f'·n Y in9uiiyofthe person or persons. who mah,.ge the .system, or tliose perSons directly . S•gnature of P

of Officer . ·..• . . . . .. tqr theinforrilation, the information subrllitted is,Jo the mylrA-uth'-. 

·· · ·· · . o\Niedge :;md behef,_ (rue; accurate, <3nd completa I am aware: that there :ore s_1gruficant 

., for. submittirig false information .inCluding .!lie posSibility of a fine and . . 

for knoWing Violations: · . · . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,004=._ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

' ' .......... ·· ·.Quantity· __c_.Otlier Units --'-. 

P.ar:ameter· · · ' .. · . 

.. ·.. ' .· 

. .·•. 

. . 

Units N.E. GEL* 

... •. . '· ' . · .. 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NJA 

Winter Mar 1-31 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F NIA NJA N/A Rpt Only 90.4 NIA 

Winter Apr 1-30 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

81020 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Sulfate NIA NIA NJA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00552 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. NJA NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

NIA 

N/A NIA 

NJA 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Un

DEG

DEG

mg/1 

mg/1 

lrN.=a::lll:::" e"',o"'f"'P'"'n"''O:::ci:t:l'o::al:c:·· a=·=.e<:ufiv:::··· ·."'· ,-c::•::·O::.:ifi:::oe,. <. . Date Complet

andevaluatethilinfunila!ion.subrrutted.Based on · • . . 

my ihqufry of the.persori or.personsw!Jo rilanagethesysteril, or those persons directly.. ot P

rrtla of Offieer · .· · · espom;iblefor gathering the information, the information submitte!'l is, to the best of my 

· · "nd belief, We, accur;ate, c:ompl .. te.l am aware that there are significant 

penalties for subm.itting,flilse infoJ"Il)ation includil"!g·the possit>ility bf a fine and ·.. . ·. ·· • .· 

· knowing viol3tions; . · · . . , . . . · 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: "'004""-------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

·' Quar\titv• · .. ... . ... Other Units . .. 

Param~ter 

· Units N.E. 

·. 

GEL* 

. .· ...... ·. 

. . . . . I . . 

50050 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00530 (ML-2) RF-A Reported 

Total Suspended Solids N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only 60 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

74055 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A 200 400 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Da1ly 

00400 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

pH N/A N/A 6 N/A 9 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits lost. Min. lnst Max. 

00610 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Ammonia Nitrogen NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00600 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00665 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

50060 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Un

mgd 

mg/1 

Cnts

S.U. 

mg/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

Nan\e of Prtricipal EfectiliVJ Qffi6er . I ee_~fy un~r p~alty oflav,r t~~~ ~is docume11t anp all attach men~ were.prepared Date Comple

I 

f'nder myd~reoc!•()n or sapervosoon m accordance with a system desogned to assurethat · · 

f!:ua!ifiro.per5ooinel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted~ B'l$ed on s' . . 

. . . "'Y onquny o_f the·peorson or.persons who manage. the system. or thOse persons directly . . og_na~re of 

Tolle Of Ofliber ..• ·. ·• _ . . .• . · · ... · ...,Sponsible for gathering .the information. the information s~!lmitie<l is, to the best of my rA_uth_.~o_nz

I

. · · · · ·· · · · · . ~~~~tg~~~~~~':~!~o'!".iu6~di:~a~:ti.~a~!':J~~~~~~e !d significant 

irilprisonmentfor knowing violations. . . . . . . . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: "'004=------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. .. -,: _., . .. .. ·.·.·. Quantitv · .. Othefunits --c:.: 

Parameter 

. 

Units 

·.·. ... 

. N.E. . . 

. 

CEL* 

. 

01119 (ML-1) RF-B Reported Copper, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01094 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Zinc, Total Recoverable NIA N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00718 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

71900 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01104 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00980 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01055 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

00940 (ML-1) RF-B Reported I Chloride (as Cl) NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation level 

.: 

Un

mgn 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 mg/1 mg/1 

mg/1 

EXeciJiive Offieer . · ; I. ce_rtify of law !b_at dOC(JI"I"Ieritan? all were pr-epared . · Complet

supeMslon '"· aCC()rdance with a system.desJgnea to assure that _· 

· ualified personnel properly gainer and. evaluate tbeinforrilation submitte<L Based on . · . . . 

- ..• . . ' yinquiiy oflhe;person orpersons who manage the system, e>r these persons cfrrectiy Signali:"e of P

Title ofOffleer · ,, fesponsiblefor gathering the the information submitted is .• to the best of my . .:

I

. ·· ···· · ' · ·· · . significant 

-,-,.,..,--,-..,---.,------,---'limp(isonmeritforRnowing violations. · · ..,__ ____
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC) MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'004=.. ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

' QuantitY Other Units 

..... • 

··· 

. ··. 

. 

I Units 

. 

.· 

N.E. CEl* 

. 

00951 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34469 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Pyrene N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34526 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34320 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Chrysene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34376 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoranthene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34381 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluorene NIA N/A N/A Rp!Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permtt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34461 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phenanthrene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34200 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Acenaphthylene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Un

mgn 

ugn 

NGIL 

NG/L 

ug/1 ug/1 ug/1 

ug/1 

Name 0 f]>iihcipaj &ec..rtlVe Offii:er I ce!lify oflaw. f\lis all were prepared Date Complete

¥eriTIY dJrect1on or.superviSion -m acconlance With a systemdes•gn!!d I() assure that . · .. ··. 

nualified persoimel andevaluatethe information submitted: Based on · . . • · . ·.· · 

ofthE> pers6n or persons who manage the System, orthose persons directly Signature of P

Trtle oof Offifur . ,· · .• · · • .· .•. · espprisible for gatheriryg the information, the information sUbmitted is; to.the best of my 

· · · · · ·· nowledge and.JJelief; true, accurate, and.eomplete. I am aware·thatthere are. significant 

penaltieS for submitting false infofmationJncludihg the possibility .of a :line arid 

·mprisonmeiltfor knowing violations. · 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLC) MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,.,004=-. ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

.. . 

. . ·.· . .. · ..... .... ·• auan!itv • . Other Units 

Parameter Units 

. 

N.E. CEL* 

... ... -··· 

34205 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Acenaphthene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34220 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Anthracene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34230 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permrt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34242 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34247 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Pyrene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00981 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00978 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34556 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Dibenzo (A,H) Anthracene N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = CormWance Evaluation Level 

Un

ug/1 

ug/1 

NG/L NGIL 

NG/L 

ug/1 

mg/1 

NG/L 

Nanie tit. Piirlclpal Exetuiive Officilt I oflaliit all were prepared .. . Date Complet

· ·· · nder,myd•rectionorsuperviSI()nUJaccordancewitha.systemdeslgnedtoassurethat ·. · .·, 

personnel properly gather and evaluate the infunnationsubmi)lecL8ased on · . . 

l!=============::!!fffiY inquiryoUhe persbn or persons who manage the system; or those persons directly ofP

Tille of Officer .. esponSibleJor the infunnation •. theinfonnation submitted is, to the <?fmy Authonzed Ag

, · · owledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete. I am aware that ther(il are s•gnfficant 

penalties.forsubmittingfalse including·tbepossibility of a fine. and · •• · 

.,-,.,...,--,---,-.,-,-----,---,-Jj'inptiso'1inenj for Violations. · · · · .. J. '--,--,--
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLC) MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: "'004""------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. < ·.· •.. · .•.. ·. · ..... ··•·• . • ...... 

..... 

... ·.. . Quantitv- ···.·.· .· . Other Units . .. 

. · l ....... • ... .. ·· . . . ·.··· 

... 

. 

. . 

Units N.E. 

. 

CEL* 

... ... . . ·. . 

34403 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00720 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Total N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

32730 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34696 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Naphthalene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-2) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only 15 NIA 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-7) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Summer May 1-Jan 31 PermiT Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A 58.1 67.3 N/A 

Winter Feb 1-28/29 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

. 

Un

NG/

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

DEGDEGDEG

DEG

Name of. a$Ctit;11e Offieer I ce .. ·rtify···· ... u_n .•P ... .na.lty. ·-_ .. of. Jaw fh_ d. oc .. um_._ en_t.and _al.l atta. ··chm··... . .en_ .. ___ ere. prepa.red .· Date Complet

ndermy dired1on or m accordance. with a system designed to assure that • . 

personnel pf()peliygather arid evaluate the information submitted. Based on . . . . 

l!==============:!.f'.l. yinquiry of the person or persons who manage the system, or those personsdkectly Signature of P

I

Tttle of. OffiCer . • . espons_ •. • .. I.b. ·.'" •. · e .. lin!l_ th. ·e···im.· onm_ ..·at .. ·.·. ici·n;·. th. e.iin .. o. rm_.. atio· .." ..s. ub_lll_.itted··.JS·. .to_ ... th. e ..· best .. ·. . y AuthOIJZed Ag

· · · · · ·· n()wledge and _belief, true, accutate, and complete, I. am ..ware,th?l•!here are.s1gilmcant · 

slibi"tlittill9.f8l¥Iilf()l)'nation including the ofa fine and · · 

1....,---,..,..,.___,,.-.,....,---,-..,-,......,--,-,..,--,--.---,-JIIinprisonn:Jentfor knowing violations, • .. · · · . · · • · . · . · .. ·t'---,------,--,-
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,0-"'04"---------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. ·.· .... ··•· · •·· ··· ·. · . Quantity . ... Other Units 

Parameter · ... ..... Units N.E. 1···.· . CEL* 

: . . · .. ·· . . :. : · .. 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F NIA NIA NIA 67.1 77.6 NIA 

Winter Mar 1-31 Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F NIA NIA NIA 78.1 90.4 NIA 

Winter Apr 1-30 Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

81020 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Sulfate NIA NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00552 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. NIA NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

NIA 

NIA NIA NIA 

* CEL = Evaluation Level 

Un

DEGDEG

mg/1 

mg/1 

Narne of Princlhar EXeCutive Offieer .. :_: I ce.· rt_ify ·.·. <;l_ nalty. ,_o. flaw_· .. fh_.·_ .. _a ... _t .th··. is docu_ · ..m_E!nt_· .. a_ n_ d.· . a_ r_r atta. · .. chm. ·. e.nts_ •. · .· w_ !lre_ •. pr .. epa. red . . Date Comple

under.mydJrection or.supervJsJon m accordancewllb. a system .des•gned to. assure that · . : · 

quiilified properly gather information' submitted. Based on · . .·· 

l:,:==;===;============fl'."myjnquiry<ifthepersonorpersons whc:> managethe sYstem, orthose persons directly . P

TJtle of bttici;r •• . ••··•. • . . . .·.. . .• e5f:>Onsible.for gathering the information, theinforrnati(!n submitted is,to the best ofmy . Ag

I

.· ·· · ·· · · · · . kn·ow·· .. __ ._e Cl[l ___ d.be_ .. ___ ne __ f,tnu. e ____ ;_a __C:CU __ ··.·.· _ra ___ ·_ .l·e·_· d,co_ mp._le .• te._ I. a. m_ a_-ya_ •. th•· a_J.th_· .. _erea.re_. signifiCant penalties•for.submtlting ialsaniformation mcludJng•the possli:5Jilty of:a fin<;!.and .. 

==========...,.,.__.·,, mpriS()nment for knoWing violations. • . . . .· . . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,O.e:06"--------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

.. ·.·.··.···._.······ ... · .. ···. · ... · .. ··_ .. ·.·.·.··•. -

·c·. . . . Quai:tfity .. . ·. Other Units 

.•·. . . . . 

. · .. · ... · 

Parameter .. . · .. Units 

. · 

N.E . ·. 

. ... 

I GEL* · . ·Un

50050 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Flow,in Conduit or thru plant NIA N/A IN/A Rpt Only 1.2 NIA mgd 

Year Round Permrt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00530 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Total Suspended Solids 1227 2371 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

74055 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A 200 400 NIA Cnts/

Year Round Permit Limits Mon. Geo. Mean Max. Daily 

00400 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

pH N/A N/A 6 N/A 9 NIA S.U. 

Year Round Permit Limits lnst. Min. lnst Max. 

00610 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Ammonia Nitrogen 791 1591 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only RptOnly NIA mg/ 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00625 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total RptOnly Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00620 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrate Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00615 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrite Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A 4 15.5 N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Name i:>tJ>rinciP'ltEXecuiiveOtticer l certify)Jn~er~nalty oflaw~h_at t~is document an~ all.attachtll~nts were prepared . 

ndercmy direction or superviSIOn m accordance with a system des1gnedto assure.that · 

j<!ualified personnel p.ropeny ga(her ai:td evaluate the information submitted Based on·}~.'-•. ~."". ~_.:._ .-

i==============;.==-.!!~muyinci)Jiry ofthe.person or peis<Jnswho manage the system, or tho~ ;;ersons directly . S1gnat~re of P

Trtle of Officer • · · · ·•· . . • ej;p<msibleXor gatpefing tlleiofoiJTlatiof1;lhe information submitted is, to the best ofmy .I rA~uth-'-'-o_n_z_ed_ . ...;A..

· · .· nowledgeand belief, !rue, accurate, and compiE>te • .I am aware thatthe.re are significant 

!penaltiesfor subnfrtting false information including the possibility of a fine and 

.,--,.,..,-~_,-,-...,..,...,.....,..-...,..--1fmpriSonmentfor knowingviolati6ns: · · . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,.0,.,06,_ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

.... ·· .. ·. .·. · Quantitv . .. other Units . 

. 

· Pammeter .• • untts ·NE CEL* .··. ·. .· -

00600 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00665 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

50060 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A N/A 150 300 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01119 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Copper, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01094 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Zinc, T ota1 Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00718 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA N/A N/A 67 120 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

71900 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) NIA N/A N/A 0.234 0.417 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01104 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Cor:!1QJ_iance Evaluation Level 

Uh

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 

I.Nallle 'otPrinCipilloBc~ve 6tiieer-·•.·•· .• I ce ....rti.·zy···.··un.~er •... P. ·.~·.·. ally ·o.fla .• w ..·.~ .. at ....~ ... d ......o. cu. me. nt ....•. an. ~. ·.·.II a.tta. chill en~ w.·e ..'e ..·. p. ·.'~.pa .. red. . . . . . Date Comple

11 und~rmyd1rection or l;upeMSJonm accordanc::ewllh.a sysfe'!l des•gn<:ctto assure that · · · .. • · .. · 

gu;3lified personnel properly g~her and evaluate the 1nformat1on subll).itted. Based on . . · . . 

. .. . . .. . ·•[(IY i~9u\ly of the pers?n or P<:rSon.sw.ho man~ge the ~yst .. m, or•ttiose persons directly ·.· Signa1ureof 

.'rjui;, C)f.Oifii:er ••. ·· resp()nsible fot.gathenng the mformation, the Information submitjed.1s;to ~he b~ '?f llJY , . Authonzed Ag

!1 · · · · · · ·· · ·· ···· krlo\VIeageandbel\i~f,true, ac:c~mfe, :"nd. com~lete. I am;3w~~e tJiat there are s1gmficant l penaltiasf()r submitting f<jlsemformation mcfudmg •the .poss1blltty Of anne and·· niprJs<mmentfor knoWing .viola:tions. · .. · . . · . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'00,;6,__ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

··.····<·.·· .. · ... Quantity .. ·. "• · Other Units 

Paramf!ter · 

... 

·.·. ·. 

Units N.E. CEL* 

•. . . . 

00980 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Iron, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01055 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00940 (ML-1) RF-D Reported Chloride (as Cl) NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00951 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoride, Total N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

61425 (ML-1) RF-D Reported 

Acute Tox- Ceriodaphnia Dubia N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

61427 (ML-1) RF-D Reported 

Acute Toxicity- Pimephales N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34469 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Pyrene N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34526 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA NIA NIA 6.9 19.7 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

. 

U

mg/1 

mg/1 

mgt

mg/1 

TUa TUa 

ug/1 ug/1 

1

-,.,N,a"'m"'e"'.o"'f"-•P"'.ii""nC.,'pa.,·· ··,tc:Ex:o. ,ce,.· fc_·---, ·.·.• ··1tuice,rfify of law !nat ail prf!pared .. Dale Com le

r dermy dlr¢clionorsuPf!f1l1SIOn m accordance wil/la system assure.that ·. .:.

evaluate the infonmiltiori subJ"llitted>Based on • . . .. · .· •. · .· . 

l!=============::dl'my .inquiry ofthe Pf!i"Son or pe..Si:ms WhO manage or.those .persons. dirE!CIIy · . 0 f 

frtle of.oilicer · · ·.· :· responsible for gathering the information, the inf0nmation is, to the liestofrnY AuthonzedA

· · · · ·. owledge and belief, .true, ratE!, .and complete- ,1 am a.ware. thaUherE! are sigl)ificant · 

penalties foMubmi!ting false information including the possibility of a: filleand · 

iiriprisonmentfor knowing violations. . . . . . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC) MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: :::00,6'--------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. . 

.. · ... 

· ·.• · .. · ... Quanllty Other UnitS .. 

.. I.'·. F'aia!lleter 'UnitS N . .E ... .. .·· .. CEL* 

. .·· .. . . 

. .· .. ·• . . .. . . c . .· 

34320 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Chrysene N/A N/A N/A 6.9 17.3 NIA 

Year Round Penn it Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34376 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoranthene N!A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34381 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluorene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Penn it Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34461 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phenanthrene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34200 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Acenaphthylene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34205 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Acenaphthene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34220 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Anthracene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34230 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N!A 6.9 17.8 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Coflliillance Evaluation Level 

Uni

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ugll 

,~N_,a::;m:.::e::.:' ~f_,_Pri"'-"'i:;"'ci"'p"'iii'-'Ex=ecut:::':.::·· .:e:iv:::e~0ffi~· :.::ce:::·· :=:.''-'-'·_I ce_. rt.ify un~er_p~_na_lty_ . o_:_ .. ... f _!_a_ w -~h_att~is. d. octim_ e_ nt __ a __ n~- a_ll_ajta_ chm_ ·_ en~w ___ ere P_repa ... ~-eel_ ·_. . bate Compfet 

1r under my.: direction or supeMs1on m accordance With_ a systemdestgned to assure that . -.·. · . e 

aualifi~ personnel properly gather and: evaluate the infoniiatior\ submttted. Based on , · . · _ 

i!===============""·yn· Y iJ1qufry ofthepe~on or peisoris who manage the system, or those persons. directly Slgnan.rre of P

Trtle> otoffic:er .... · . . . .. . . . . .• esponsibleforg~ering the information, the informationsubmttted is, to the b~t~fmy lr,A~· _uth_o~nz_e

. ... ... . . . . . . . DOW! edge and belief, true, accurate, and COmpletecl 3f11 aware that there ~re Significant 

pe~tJ~ 

for~ubmit!in~faj~ 

in~OITJlljtiOri 

iJ1ciUdin~ the possibilily of a iine and ·. . .. 

lll)PTJ~onrnentfor knowmg VIOI1ilions. · • . · · . . · . · · · · . . • • 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'00,6'--------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF 

.. •···· · ·•QuantitY . · . ... ·.· .. 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS 

.. · 

. .. · .. •. OtherUnits 

. ._.. . . .. ·.•··. .• . .. 

.. ·. 

·.· . Parameter · 

'·· .- .. . Units N.E. I CEL* . · .. :. ..... . .· 

34242 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene NIA N/A N/A 6.9 17.4 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max.. Daily 

34247 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Pyrene 0.0764 0.136 Lbs!Day NIA 6.9 19 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00981 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Selenium, Total Recoverable NIA N/A N/A 0.106 0.243 NIA 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00978 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34566 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34403 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Jndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene NIA N/A N/A 6.9 18.2 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00720 (ML-1) RF-A Reported Cyanide, Total 25.6 36.6 Lbs!Day NIA 4.39 9.31 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

32730 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable 0.29 0.47 Lbs!Day NIA 82 145 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL =Compliance Evaluation Level 

-U

ug/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 mg/1 

ug/1 ug/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ExeCutive Officer ... l certify docur:nent wereprepared · _ .. Date Comple

de[imy'drrection or.supervrsron maccordance with a system desrgned .to assure that ·· : 

qualified personnel properly gather .the infonnation submitted: Based on •. . . · ·. · · 

of. 'the pe..SOn or .Persons who manage tlie syStem, or those pe""'ns.<lirectly Srgnature of 

Title- ofOffieer . · · . gatheiing the. information, the information submitted is, to the best of my Authonzed A

· - - ·· · ·· · · · ·· . _ owledge and belief, true; complete: I am aware that there ate .,ignificant 

p-enalties for s.ufimitting including the posSibUiiy of a nne and ·· 

.,_.......,.,.,.,.......,.,,...,_,....,------,-..,._Jrlrri•i>riSDnnientfor knowing violations: · . . . · .. 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,00,6"---------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· 

' .....•. .. · .... · · Quantitv· ·. · . 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

··.· 

. •. Other Units 

Pararrieier · .. 

. ·_·. Units N.E . I 

. . • GEL* 

.. · ... · . ··. ... · 

34696 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Naphthalene 0.0759 0.137 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-2) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Malthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-7) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

81020 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Sulfate N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00552 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. 102 306 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A 

N/A 

---

• CEL = Comcliance Evaluation Level 

uni

ug/1 

DEG.

DEG.

DEG.

mg/1 

mg/1 

Name of .f'rinqpal Ex~ive~ . • I certify UO~E!Lp~malty oflaw ~-atl!tis document an~ all attachments were prepared . ·.· Date Complete

um~ermy direction or supervJSI()n m accordance Wltll a system designed to assure that · 

~~a!ijie~ 

p_erSonneiJ)roper~y gather and evaluate tile information ~-ub.mitted. Based on • . · · 

i!=="'C'==o==~========o==!f"Y IO(juny of~ per5on or person~who manage the system; or !J1ose personscdirectly... Slgna~re of P

'Title 6foincer · . . rrisP.onsible for gath8ring:theinformatii>n, tt1e information sub!"itted Is, toth!" best of my Aulhonzed Ag

· ·· ·· · ···· ···· · · · ·· · · I£_~. o: __ Y!l<ld·g· e_ ·_and·· .. b·e· he .. f.t. nue;. ace_._ .. u_ra_ .• t. e.; an. d.. com_ pl·e.te .. am aw_ an:. that there. ar_e s•gnificant F.oaltiestor submitting ·false information inCluding the possibility of a fine and . . 

irripiisomilentfor knowing violations. . · · · . · . . · 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,0,06.,___ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

t· . . ' . . . . . . . .. • 1: •.. 

. Quantity .. . Other UnitS. 

Parameter .··. · •. · .· 

.. 

. . . . . . 

··units, N.E. GEL* 

50050 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Flow, in Conduit or thru plant N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only 1.2 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00530 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Total Suspended Solids 1227 2371 Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

74055 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Coliform, Fecal NIA N/A N/A 200 400 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Mon. Gee. Mean Max. Daily 

00400 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

pH N/A N/A 6 N/A 9 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits lnst. Min. lnst. Max. 

00610 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Ammonia Nitrogen 791 1591 Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00625 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00620 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrate Rpt Only RptOnly Lbs/Day N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00615 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrite RptOnly Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A 4 15.5 NIA 

Year Round Permtt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Un

mgd 

mg/1 

Cnts

S.U. 

mg/1 mg/1 

mg/1 mg/1 

Name ofPnrici;:furEXecUtrvif 6ffiter •... I c;ertify .. (Jjltlait}'oflaw all prepared . Date .Comple

under my direction or superv1s1on 1n accordance with a system designed to assure that · · · · 

nualified personryelproperly, gaJber and evaluate the information submitted. Based oir · . · . •. · · 

il"lquiry of the or persons wf1o manage the system,. or tho.se persons directly of P

Trtle &t officer ·· · ·.· . . · · - respoJ1Siblefor gatlieriJ1g the the information submitted Is, to the <?f my AU!honzedAg

· · · · . knowledge <md belief, true, accura1e, ""d complete. lam a1Nl>fe thattllere are s1gnfficant · 

forsubmitliri9. inf?f!llalion inCluding the possi.bility of a fine and · · · 

. lrnPf1SOnment forlo\Owmg Vlolat•ons. _ .. _ . · .. _. 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,0"'06,_ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. . ···. •· ... . .. . ·· Quantity . .. ·· . Other·Units · . ..... 

. Parameter Units. N.E. 

' 

GEL* u 

. 

. . . .. 

.. 

. 

. 

00600 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA mgn 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00665 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Phosphorus, Total Rpt Only Rpt Only Lbs/Day NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

50060 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A N/A 150 300 NIA ug/1 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01119 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Copper, Total Recoverable N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01094 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Zinc, Total Recoverable NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00718 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA N/A N/A 67 120 NIA ug/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

71900 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Mercury, Total (as Hg) N/A N/A NIA 0.0098 0.018 N/A ug/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01104 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

Narrle officer .. l.c:eFfify of !fl_iltfi.Jis document an,d an prepared ·. · Date Comple

r'·ndermy l?Upe(VJS•on •naccordanpe \Nith a '?Ystem des•gned_ to assure that · · . 

lnumified,personnelj)rbperty galh!'rand evaluate the inroimation su001ittedc. Based on · . . • ; 

lk==================:!Jiitiy inquiiy of the persOn or persons wliomanage the system, or thoSe persons di(eC!Iy . of 

· •· 

_ 

.· .·· res·p·o. _ns. ib.l e. fo·.· r_• g. a .._lh_ e_n ·ng. th.· e. in·· .. ati_o_n·· .• __!fie i.nfo.ima .. ti·.·on ... · .. sub ___ m· itt ... ed· .. · ..·. is. •. t_.·6 .. th.e bes.. . .. t.ofm. y Authoi)Zed A

··· · · · ·· · · · noWiedge.aod belief; true, accl.lrate;.and complete. Lam awat:e.thatthere are significant 

jpenalties.fol"-sl!bmittfn_g:false infoi"riJatiC>n including the,possil>ility cifaifine and . · · . • · 

• knoWing violations ... ·.· • · . .. · ·· . · 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,oo,s'-------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

•.·.· 

. 

· .. · ouarititv . .•. Other UnitS . · . 

Pa~E!r. 

·•· 

... 

. 

.. Units. N.E. · . GEL* ·····' . .·. . · · ... . ·. 

00980 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01055 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Manganese, Total (as Mn) N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00940 (ML-1) RF-D Reported 

Chloride (as Cl) NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rp!Only NIA 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00951 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Fluoride, Total NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

61425 (ML-1) RF-D Reported 

Acute Tox- Ceriodaphnia Dubia N/A NIA NIA RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

61427 (ML-1) RF-D Reported 

Acute Toxicity- Pimephales N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34469 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Pyrene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34526 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Anthracene N/A NIA N/A 6.9 19.9 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Comoliance_Evaluation Level 

Uni

mgn 

mgn 

mg/1 

mg/1 

TUa 

TUa 

ug/1 

ug/1 

Name dtPrtnciPai &eciifute ()ffic..r . . I eertify ~n~er p~nalty of law !h.atthisdocument an~ all attaC:hmen~ ~ere prepared · . Date Complete

I 1 

... nder my dJ£eclion oLsupervJl!•on m accordance With a system des1gned to .assure that . . ·. . . 

~walified personnel proi>erly satller and evaluate the information Sllbmitted. Based on . · · •. · · 

· · y inquiry ?fthe.per5onorpersonswho manage !lie system, or those persons.directly S•gnat~re ofP

· ··· · ·• · • "bl·to·· .·.th ·· ·th "fo ·ti ·th. ·n11· · ·ti· .. ·.b."'~~· •t·th· .. bes· f · AIJthonzedAg

Trtfeofbfficer . .. respons• .e rsa,enng e•n rm~ on, e1 ()rma onsumu,cuJS, o e. .t'? my j·,r··~·-"'"··~·.

1 

... · ·· · · ·· ·· no.wled·.··.g .. e.· an.db.·E!·I.•.ef •. tru_ ... e; .. accu·. ra_te ..•. and .. complet. e.la_m_• _a_w._are.th .. a .. tther ___ e~_re.s• .. g. m_ficallt pe0aHies for submitting ·false.infon:i)ation including the possibllity.ofafirie and. ··.· · . · · 

· iinprisonin~ntfor J<nowing)liolatlcins. · · · · L-.,---,---,-
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ,00,6'-------

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

Pa~~ter 1·· .·· . · Quantity ..... · · · · I . OtlrerUnits . • 

·.· . I . I Units I N.E. I I I. GEL* I U

34320 (ML-1) RF-A 

Chrysene 

Year Round 

34376 (ML-1) RF-B 

Fluoranthene 

Year Round 

34381 (ML-1) RF-B 

Fluorene 

Year Round 

34461 (ML-1) RF-B 

Phenanthrene 

Year Round 

34200 (ML-1) RF-B 

Acenaphthylene 

Year Round 

34205 (ML-1) RF-B 

Acenaphthene 

Year Round 

34220 (ML-1) RF-B 

Anthracene 

Year Round 

34230 (ML-1) RF-A 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene 

Year Round 

Reported 

IPennit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Perm it Lim its 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

Reported 

Permit Limits 

.. CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

N/A N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A NIA 

NIA N/A 

NIA N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A N/A 

N/A 6.9 17.3 NIA lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

IN/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

IN/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A 6.9 17.8 NIA lug/1 

Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

Name ()f Pnnci~ Executive officer . .. I certif}run~er pt;!nalty of lao/ 1h.at :t\Jis document an? allattachment~ were prepared . . · Date Comple

undermy d1rection ar supervtsron m.accordance with a system des•gned toassure that f-~..,-·,-~

~IJalified peisonnelpropeily gather and ewluate the infurrl)ation submittedc Based on ~. • ··. · 

i!==============4•rny inqu.iry of the. person or persons who manage the. system, or those persons directly ··. S•gnat~re of 

·Title ()f Oflii:er .· ·. · · · esponsible for gathering theitifol11)"tion, the information submitte<Hs, to the best ofmy . · Authonzed A

· nowledge and ])<ilief, true, aceurate; and complete. I am aware.that.there are significant 

penalti6$fot $.ubmittil)g.talseiirformati<>n .including the possibirrty ()fa fine an9 · 

...,__,..,....,,...,=,._,...-,--,-_,_-,-.,.-,,...,..,J 11rnpiisohment for knoWing violations. · · · · · · ... · .,..,..,.-,-, ...-.,.--,._
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLC) MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: .::;00.,6'--------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

. ·.·.. . .:•·.· .. ·.··· . . ·:·.·· .·· · ... Quantity · •··· · · . ·.·• btherUnits · . 

P;~ra(lleter. 

·. Units N . .E. GEL* 

·. 

· .. 

·. 

34242 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene NIA N/A N/A 6.9 17.4 N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34247 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Benzo (A) Pyrene 0.0754 0.136 Lbs/Day N/A 6.9 19 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00981 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A 0.106 0.243 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00978 (ML-1) RF-B Reported 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Dairy 

34556 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Dibenzo (A,H)Anthracene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34403 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A N/A 6.9 18.2 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00720 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Cyanide, Total 25.6 36.6 Lbs/Day N/A 4.39 9.31 NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

32730 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable 0.29 0.47 Lbs/Day N/A 82 145 N/A 

Year Round 

L__ 

Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation level 

Un

ugn 

ug/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

Na(ll~flc:;ipa(Elie2UliV~ffiC:er 

.. . ..•.. I ~rti1}' ifn~er p~nalty of law~.at !~is doctiment an? an atlljchment~wete prepared . . Date Comple

Ul)dermy dtreclion or superviSIOn m acco~di!nce VJith a systemdes1gnedto assur-e tliat 1"----..,.

~uaEifiE>~ personn€)1 propeily g~the[a~d ewluate the information submitted. Based on . . .. . . · 

i!=====~=~=====:dJ· my Jnqujry:ofthe person orper>;()p~ who manage the_ system; or. tho.se persons directly Signature of P

Title Of Officer ·.. .. · .. • · . · e$POQSibleJor gatpering th<;> iriforrnatton, the Information submitted is,to th_e b~ '?f my lrA_uth~_ ~o_n_;z· ed_Ag

· · · · · · · · ·· ·· · kiloWjedgeandbehef, true, accurate, and completE). I am awarethatthere are Significant 

pemalti.eS.ior submitti[1g false infOrmation ihduding the possibility of a fine and 

1..,_,_...__,...-,.-,..----..--,-,-.,---...-'Jimprlsonmenttqrknov.tingviolaiions. · 
I 

WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'00..,6'-------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

' ·· .. ·.·• . . . · Quantity .. · · Other Uiii!S · . ?8rameier ... ·. 

. : . . . .... . .. ... .• . .·· .Units N.E. CEL* 

34696 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Naphthalene 0.0759 0.137 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-2) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-7) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

81020 (Ml-1) RF-B Reported 

Sulfate N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00552 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Oil and Grease, Hexane EXTR. 102 306 Lbs/Day N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A 

N/A 

* GEL = Cor:D.Q!_iance Evaluation Level 

Un

ug/1 

DEG

DEG

DEG

mgA 

mg/1 

Nail"le. of Principal Exe®tive.Offieer · 11 tertify ~nder pe~alty" ofJa~ !~at.l!lisdocu":lentan~ all attaCilmen~ \'lere !>'"Pared .. Date Co -let

un<lerm~.crli"eCfjon or supent1"'on m accordance with .a system des•gl1ed·to a.ssurethat • ·•• · mp .•

\l_uallfiectpersonnel properly gather and evaluate the infonriation submitted, Based on ·. , · . .· . · .. 

~================!f":· yiiiquiry of the i>ElrsOn or p¢JSons Who m~nagethe syStem; or\h9se persons direCtly ·. SJgn"h.'re of P

Trtle ofOfflter ·• · .. ,... esponsi~Ieforga!herjng \h• infom1ation, thE! infom1ation SIJb!""ittedis, to "!fie ~ '?f my . Au!honzed Ag

· · · ··· · · nowfedge andJ)ehef,true,. accurate, and complete. I am .. aware that. there.aresJgnifi.cali! 

peoalties.ft>r siJbthttting f<llseinfolll)atlon-·including-thepossibiiity·ofa1ine_and 

' ilripriSonmen!Jor knowing violations; • · · ·. · ·· . , • 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: (Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,09,_,7 _____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

· .. ·· ... · ... •. ' · .. · ... ·.· ' ' Ouantitv. .·· Oth<kUnifs 

Parameter 

·.···.· .. ··' . ·.· Units N.E. CEL* 

00530 (ML-5) RF-A Reported 

Total Suspended Solids N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

74055 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00400 (ML-5) RF-A Reported 

pH N/A N/A Rpt Only N/A Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits lnst. Min. lnst Max. 

00610 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Ammonia Nitrogen N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00625 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Kjeldahl Total N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Penm tt Lim tts Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

OQ620 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrate NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00615 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen Nitrite N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00600 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Nitrogen, Total (as N) N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Comoliance Evaluation Level 

una

mg/1 

Cn!s/1

S.U. 

mg/ 

mg/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

mg/ 

I'Name ofPnociP~ Elieeun,;e offi~f · · · ~:;d~%,~~~J~~aJ~~~J!\~n~sli~l~~a~1tta~;y~~~~~;=~~~r!!'!~that •. D~te Comple(e

~u~i~"'!i>ersonm•l propeilygatherarid evaluate ih<! information subrilitte<Ulasildor\ • . - ... · 

l!=c=~=====~======"J· my IOq!li!Y ofthe pef50n or persons. who manage the sys!em.--or those persons directly S•gnaj~re ofPn

··. · ·· • .. ··· · ·. •. ··· ·. . . •· ._.·. •• · responsible fur galhe~ng the information, the informalibf:l sub in it!~ is; to !llebE>stof rny Authonzild Ag

Title of Officer · nowledgeandbeli.,f, true; accurate, and eomplete. lam aware that there are significant 

· penalliesfpr.submitting false infot~:naji6n ini:ltraing_the pils5ioility. ofa fine and ·• I U:nt>iisoilmE>nt tQrknoWirig viol;;~liof:ls. . · · ·. ·.. . · ·. · . 
WRD 2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,09"'7'--------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

.... . . ·.. .... •·· · Quantitv .·.· ·.· . _ ... · other Units 

l"araffieter·· [ . . ·.· ·. 

... . 

· .. 

. .· 

Units N.E .. GEL* 

50060 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Chlorine, Total Residual N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01119 (ML-5) RF-B Reported Copper, Total Recoverable N/A NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01094 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Zinc, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00718 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Weak Acid Dissociable NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

71900 (ML-5) RF-D Reported 

Mercury, Total (as Hg} N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00900 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Hardness, Total (as CaC03} N/A N/A NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

01104 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Aluminum, Total Recoverable NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only RptOnly N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00980 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Iron, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

V!;;.L..- VVIII IICUI\,;1;0 L..VCUUC:UIVII L."<;;YII;i'l 

. . 

·Un

ug/1 

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 ug/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

mg/1 

Name_ofci:ioodp:;ili:Xeciiiive Officer' .. I ce.rtify Ulid_er penalty of law that this document and all attachments were prepared 

· ndermy direction orsupervision in accordance with a systeindesigned to asSure that ,. Date Comple

gather and evaluate the infoJlT)atkm submitted, Base_d on· . Signature of P

Y: who manage the system, _or thOse -personS: directly_ 

T)lle ()f · · · · espoiisible for gathellng the Information, the information submitted is, to the bestofmy Authorized Ag

nowledge and beflef, true, _accurate; and complete. I am aware that there are significant 

penidtiesfor submitting false inforination including !he possibility of a fine and • · 

• mprisonment for knowing. violations. 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: "'09,_,7 _____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

·· ....... 

. ... 

··.·. Ouantitv. .. Other Units . . 

•Parameter . · .. 

. 

. • .. · ·. • 

Units N:E. . CEL* 

00940 (ML-5) RF-D Reported 

Chloride {as Cl) NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00951 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Fluoride, Total NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34469 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Pyrene NIA NIA N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34526 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Benzo (A) Anthracene NIA N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Penmit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34320 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Chrysene NIA NIA N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34376 (ML-5) RF-D Reported 

Fluoranthene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34381 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Fluorene N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34461 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Phenanthrene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only NIA 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

L__ 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

. 

Un

mg/1 

mg/1 

ug/1 

NG/L 

NG/L 

ug/1 

ug/1 

ug/1 

Narrie·of Prlnc:il'al· E:xeclltive Ollicer I certify under penalty ()f _law thatthi~ document and all. attachments were preJ)ated D I . Cotnplet_. 

· · under my direction or supervision in. accordance With a system ·designed to assure. that 1--a_e_._-'-"·-

~ualffied perSonnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted, Based on . · . · f 

I!=============:=!Jirri}iinquil)'of the pers()ii or persons \VhO manage the system, or tho5e persons directly . Srgn<rt\'re. 0 • P

1itleof0fficer .·· . . . · re$ponsil)leforg!!l~ering the infon;nation, the infonmation submitted i~, to the~ of my .rA~ut;_h_o_n_z~e_d_A..:g_e

· · · · owledge and bebef, tr1Je, accurate, ?"d complete. I am aware thattl;lere ~ srgnificant 

· peiialliesfof Sl.lbinitting false inforrnatiorlinCiudihg the POSsibility of a fine <!rid · . . . 

'==.,.,.,.---,,..,-,--,---.,-,-,-,--,--__JJiffiPii~onmerifforkrio'o\ling violations: 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: <Mountain State Carbon LLC\ MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: _,0"'97,__ ____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

•. · ... . .. 

. . > ·. . .. . .. ·.· . Other Units · · · · 

• Parameter · .... ··. . 

. 

. .· I U . , .. · · mts N.E CEL* 

.. ·.· 

34200 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Acenaphthylene N/A N!A N!A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34205 (ML-5) RF-D Reported 

Acenaphthene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34220 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Anthracene N/A N/A N!A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34230 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Benzo (B) Fluoranthene N!A N/A N/A RptOnly Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permtt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

34242 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Benzo (K) Fluoranthene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N!A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34247 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Benzo (A) Pyrene N/A N!A N!A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00981 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Selenium, Total Recoverable N!A N!A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00978 (ML-5) RF-8 Reported 

Arsenic, Total Recoverable N!A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Comoliance Evaluation level 

U

ug/1 ug/1 

ug/1 

NG/

NG/

NG/

ug/1 

mg/1 

_.·. atrattachment;; prepared Date C ·. m le

. unqer mydJrection accordance'Yith a system deSI!:JOed to <!sSUre 1hal 

gather and evaluate the information submittedc Based on . • . · .. · · 

of!he person Or persons who manageJhe system, or those persons directly . of 

Trtle.of C>ffi&er .• · .•···· .•. · • . . gal':'ering the information, the inforii)ation is, to the of my 

.. . . .. ... . . . . . n()Vi'ledge and belief; true, aCC1Jrale; and completec I am aware !hat there "re Significant 

penalti"l' submitting false information .inCluding the possibility of a fine and · 

lfnpiisC>nmentfor knowing violations. ·. · · . · · · . 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: -"'09"-'7 _____ _ 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· 

I . <' . •·· .· .... · .. < : •. < • .. . : QuantitY ·_ .. · - .. .· _·. Other units .· .. . -:· .·. 

. . . 

"p""'inetet _· .. _ .. -·····• . ·._ .· .. . CEL * . Un

·-.-.. _.· .. •. . ·._ . · .. . Units N.E. . . . : .... _· __ . · .. ••.- . 

34556 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Dibenzo (A, H) Anthracene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A NGIL 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34403 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

lndeno (1 ,2,3-cd) Pyrene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A NG/L 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34521 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Benzo {GHI) Perylene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A ug/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00720 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Cyanide, Total N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

32730 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Phenolics, Total Recoverable N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A ug/1 

Year Round Permtt Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

34696 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Naphthalene N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A ug/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

11123 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Total Recov. Manganese N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A mg/1 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00011 (ML-5) RF-A Reported 

Temperature, F N/A N/A N/A Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A DEG

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

'Name cirf>rilli:ipa! ExecutiJte Officer _ I certify. under document all were prepared . Date Comple

I under my direction or superv•s•on m accordance w11h a system des1gnecl to assure that .• . . ·· · -. 

!Lualified properly gatherand evaluate the information submitted. Based ori _· . _ ._. 

I!================!CJ'llY lnqui,Y of the person or Persons wl)o llianagethe.system, "Dr those persons directly . of P

mii;, ·of.Offieer . · .·:. esponsible fur theinforinatjc;)n. the infonnatton .submitted is,t"O the Authonzed Ag

·· · ·· · · -· · 

_ and bEihef, true, accw-ate. lamcawarethatthere are Significant 

• penalties fi)rslilim_ itting false infolirlatt6n inCJudin_ g.the pOsSlo_·_ ility:_:ota:fine a __ ·n_ d . • mpriso11menffof"RnoWirig violations. · · · · • ·- · ·-··· ·-· .·- · ,--..,..,---.---,----,--.--,----,-,.,---,-JI' .. '- ,, . . . '" - . - - ------'--- .1 L,--,--,--
· WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: "'09,_,7'--------

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS· ~~·-· . . - . ·· ·. ·ouahtity· .. .· .. OtnerUnits 

..... · 

. 

Parameter .· Units .· N.E . 

.. 

.· 

GEL* 

. · .· ... · ·:-. . I 

81020 (ML-5) RF-B Reported 

Sulfale N/A NIA NIA Rpt Only Rpt Only N/A 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

N/A 

N/A 

N/A 

N/A 

NIA 

N/A 

N/A 

-

* CEL = Comoliance Evaluation Level 

Uni

mg/1 

Name ofi:>rlncii>aJ.Biecutive Officer.· . •.··· l•eeffify Ulld_er,p~alty of la\1\'~.af !\tis dOCIJmEmtand all <i!tafllmen~ W!lre prepmed ·.Date Complete

I 

nd<>J: 111Y" direction or superviSIOn _In_ accordance-With a. system designed to assure that 1-~-.:.·~·~-=·-· --·

k:iualifiec( persi>nnetproPElrlygatherana evaluate !he. information submitted. :Based on : . · ·. • · _· · 

·.. .• . . .. ·. . .·· ~Y inq.Jiry of the person or per,s0ns wlio manage the sy8tem; or those Persons cfir~y Signan.u-e of·Pn

lltle Ot-Oflicei . ··.. · _ ·~esponsiolefor ga~eiinl;! the information, itieinformation submitted i$,tothe be:;t ?fmy Authonzed A!i!

1 

· ····· · · · · · l<nowl~~ge a~d be~~f, trtie, ac:curate, ~nd_ com~lete..J am av:-a.r.ll th;;rt tflere are significant 

· PElnatties for.submittingtalse.mformalion Indudmgthe_ possibility ofa fine and 

mprisonmeilt for knoWing violations. · · .· · · .· 
WRD2A-82 STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA 

NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM 

DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 

FACILITY NAME: !Mountain State Carbon LLCl MOUNTAIN STATE CARBON LLC 

LOCATION OF FACILITY: FOLLANSBEE; Brooke County 

CERTIFIED LABORATORY NAME: CERTIFIED LABORATORY ADDRESS: 

PERMIT NO.: WV0004499 OUTLET NO.: ..c10,5,___ ____ _ 

WASTELOAD FOR THE MONTH OF· INDIVIDUAL PERFORMING ANALYSIS 

....... · .. · Quantitv Other Units 

Parameter · · .. 

. 

. . . >" . • .·• • . units N.E. .· . 

50050 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Flow,in Conduit or thru plant NIA N/A N/A 0.044 RptOnly 

Year Round Perm it Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Dally 

00310 (ML-B) RF-A Reported 

BOD, 5-Day 20 Deg.C 10 20 Lbs!Day N/A 30 60 

Year Round Perm tt Lim its Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

00530 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Total Suspended Solids 10 20 Lbs!Day N/A 30 60 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

74055 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Coliform, Fecal N/A N/A N/A 200 400 

Year Round Permit Limits Mon. Gee. Mean Max. Daily 

00610 (ML-1) RF-A Reported 

Ammonia Nitrogen 5 10 Lbs!Day N/A 15 30 

Year Round Permit Limits Avg. Monthly Max. Daily Avg. Monthly Max. Daily 

* CEL = Compliance Evaluation Level 

CEL• Un

N/A mgd NIA mg/1 N/A mg/1 N/A Cnts1NIA mg/1 N/A N/A N/A 

Ni3rnei>f Plihcipal Executive Officer_ ·. '\Jis document aU were prepared Date. Complet

undermydlrectron_orsupervrs•onrn accordance. with a system desrgnedtoassure that 

ualifi¢d personnel gather and evaluate the information sulirnitted,_Based on .. · •· 

. . • . y inquiiy ofthe p¢rson or persons who manage the system, or those pe'l'ons direCtly of P

Title of Officer • , espO(lSible for 9atJ:leiing the)nfoririation, the is, jo jhe ?fmy •. 

I 

·· · ·. . owlildge and complete: Jam aware that there. are srgnifican! 

• including !he · · 

I 
WV/NPDES Permit No.: WV0004499 

NOTICE TO PERMITTEES 

The 1999 regular session of the West Virginia legislature revised the Water Pollution Control Act, 

Chapter 22, Article II, Section 10 of the Code of West Virginia relating to fees associated with permits. 

This section of the Code requires all holders of a State water pollution control permit or a national 

pollutant discharge elimination system permit to be assessed an annual permit fee, based upon rules 

promulgated by the Secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection. The Secretary has 

promulgated a final rule in accordance with the code revision to this effect and these rules were effective 

May 4, 2000. The rules establish an annual permit fee based upon the relative potential to degrade the 

waters of the State which, in most instances, relate to volume of discharge. However, for sewage facilities, 

the annual permit fee is based upon the number of customers served by the facility. You may contact the 

Secretary of State's Office, State Capitol Building, Charleston, WV 25305, to obtain a copy of the rules. 

The reference is Title 47, Legislative Rules, Department of Environmental Protection, Division of Water 

Resources, Series 26 Water Pollution Control Permit Fee Schedules. 

Based upon the volume of discharge for which your facility is currently permitted, the number of 

customers served by your facility or for the category you fall within, pursuant to Section 7 of Title 4 7, 

Series 26, your annual permit fee is $5000.00. This fee is due no later than the anniversary date of permit 

issuance in each year of the term of the permit or in the case of coverage under a general permit, the fee is 

due no later than the anniversary date of your coverage under the general permit. You will be invoiced by 

this agency at the appropriate time for the fee. Failure to submit the annual fee within ninety(90) days 

of the due date will render your permit void upon the date you are mailed a certified written notice to that 

effect. 
EMERGENCY RESPONSE SPILL ALERT SYSTEM 

WEST VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 

REQUIREMENTS: 

Title 47, Series II, Section 2 of the West Virginia Legislative Rules, Environmental Protection, Water 

Resources- Waste Management, Effective July I, 1994. 

RESPONSIBILITY FOR REPORTING: 

Each and every person who may cause or be responsible for any spill or accidental discharge of pollutants 

into the waters of the State shall give immediate notification to the Division of Water and Waste Management's 

Emergency Notification Number, 1-800-642-3074. Such notification shall set forth insofar as possible and as soon 

thereafter as practical the time and place of such spill or discharge, type or types and quantity or quantities of the 

material or materials therein, action or actions taken to stop such spill or discharge and to minimize the polluting 

effect thereof, the measure or measures taken or to be taken in order to prevent a recurrence of any such spill or 

discharge and such additional information as may be requested by the Division of Water and Waste Management. 

This also applies to spills to the waters of the State resulting from accidents to common carriers by highway, rail and 

water. 

It shall be the responsibility of each industrial establishment or other entity discharging directly to a stream 

to have available the following information pertaining to those substances that are employed or handled in its 

operation in sufficiently large amounts as to constitute a hazard in case of an accidental spill or discharge into a 

public stream: 

(I) Potential toxicity in water to man, animals and aquatic life; 

(2) Details on analytical procedures for the quantitative estimation of such substances in water and 

(3) Suggestions on safeguards or other precautionary measures to nullify the toxic effects of a substance once it has 

gotten into a stream. 

Failure to furnish such information as required by Section 14, Article II, Chapter 22, Code of West 

Virginia may be punishable under Section 24, Article II, Chapter 22, and/or Section 22, Article II, Chapter 22, 

Code of West Virginia. 

It shall be the responsibility of any person who causes or contributes in any way to the spill or accidental 

discharge of any pollutant or pollutants into State waters to immediately take any and all measures necessary to 

contain such spill or discharge. It shall further be the responsibility of such person to take any and all measures 

necessary to clean-up, remove and otherwise render such spill or discharge harmless to the waters of the State. 

When the Director determines it necessary for the effective containment and abatement of spills and 

accidental discharges, the Director may require the person or persons responsible for such spill or discharge to 

monitor affected waters in a manner prescribed by the Director until the possibility of any adverse effect on the 

waters of the State no longer exists. 

VOLUNTARY REPORTING BY LAW OFFICERS, U. S. COAST GUARD, LOCK MASTERS AND 

OTHERS: 

In cases involving river and highway accidents where the responsible party may or may not be available to 

report the incident, law officers, U. S. Coast Guard, Lock Masters and other interested person(s) should make the 

report. 

WHO TO CONTACT: 

Notify the following number: 1-800-642-3074 

INFORMATION NEEDED· 

- Source of spill or discharge 

- Location of incident 

- Time of incident 

- Material spilled or discharged 

- Amount spilled or discharged 

- Toxicity of material spilled or discharged 

- Personnel at the scene 

-Actions initiated 

- Shipper/Manufacturer identification 

- Railcar/Truck identification number 

- Container type 
RIGHT OF APPEAL 

Notice is hereby given of your right to appeal the terms and conditions 

of this permit which you are aggrieved by to the Environmental Quality Board 

by filing a NOTICE OF APPEAL on the form prescribed by such Board for 

this purpose, with the Board, in accordance with the provisions of Section 21, 

Article 11, Chapter 22 of the Code of West Virginia within thirty (30) days 

after the date of receipt of the above permit.