o

f Counse l Richar dC . Forma

n Pau l E . Mart h - J l }



### Forma n • Rossab i • Blac k ATTORNEY S A T L A W

Jun e 8 , 201 0 

# ^ B

Federal Aviatio n Administratio n ATTN : Hearin g Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2W100 0 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 RE : I n th e matte r

o f Federa l Expres s Corporatio n FA A Docke t

No . CP09AL000 5 DM S No . FA A 2009-009 9 

## -;W G DOCKE T Amie l J . Rossabi * T . Keit h Blac k Jame s H . Slaughte

r Steve n E . Blac k Emil y Jeffords Meister * BarbaraL. Stewar

t TheodoraA . Vapori s t t Carole R. Albrigh

t Gavi n J . Reardon Margare t M . Chas e Michael C . Taliercio * 'als o licensedi

n N Y

' 'als o licensedi

n S C t t als o licensedi n C

A

Dea r Sir o r Madam : Enclose dare a

n origina l an don e cop y o f aMotio n t o Quas h filedo n behal f o f Ja y Romano , anon-party , t o b e filedi n th e reference dmatter . Wit hwarmes t

regards , I am Sincerely , 

# jHlLLLij.^^H ^ Amie l J . Rossab i 

## t^/t ^ AJR/ke m Enclosur e

Greensbor o Offic e Pos t Offic e Bo x 4102 7 • Greensboro , Nort h Carolin a27404-102 7 362 3 Nort h El mStreet , Suit e 20 0 • Greensboro , Nort h Carolin a2745 5 33 6 37 8 189 9 • Fa

x 33 6 37 8 185 0 • www.frb-law.co m Charlott e Offic e 30 1 McCulloug h Drive , 4t h Floo r • Charlotte , Nort h Carolin a2826 2 70 4 97 0 159 3 • www.frb-law.co m B y Appointmen t

Onl yU.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N '" ^ - ' ' . V :;'-"'^=^''^ OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D C - ,



# RECE/\/Pr > mI4 2or a (Civi l Penalty Action ) nC/HHIN Q DOCKE T I N TH E MATTE RO F FEDERA LEXPRES S CORPORATIO N FA A DOCKE T NO . CP09AL000 5 DM S No . FA A 2009-009 9

MOTIO N T O QUAS H Jay Roman o ("Mr . Romano") , b y an dthroug h hi s undersigne dcounse l an dpursuan t t o 1 4 C.F. R§302.25(f

) an dRul e 4 5 o f

th e Federa l Rule s o f

Civi l Procedure , hereb y move s t o quas h th e Subpoen apurportedl y serve dupo n Mr . Roman o o n Jun e 3 , 2010 . I n support o f suc h Motion , Mr . Roman o show s unt o th e Court a s follows : 1 . Thi s matte r

wa s commence db y th e Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n ("FAA" ) agains t Federa l Express , an dinvolve s violatio n o f severa l provision s o f

th e Hazardou s Material s Regulations . 2 . Mr . Roman o i s acitize n an dresiden t o f Nort h Carolina . 3 . O n o r

abou t May 21 , 2010 , FA A sen t alette r addresse dt o Mr . Romano , a n employe e o f

Redo x Tech , togethe r

with aSubpoena . A cop y o f th e lette r and Subpoen aar e attache dheret o a s Exhibi t A . 4 . Th e Subpoen awas delivere dt o Jacki e Satterwhite , aperso n wh o i s no t authorize d t o accep t servic e o f

aSubpoen ao n behal f

o f Mr . Romano .5 . Th e Subpoen ashoul db e quashe do n th e followin g grounds , withou t limitation : (a ) servic e wa s no t

properl y effecte dupo n Mr . Romano ; (b ) th e Subpoen a require s Mr . Romano , anon-party , t o trave l mor e tha n 10 0 mile s fro mwhere h e resides , i s employe do r

regularl y transact s business ; (c ) th e Subpoen arequire s Mr . Roman o t o b e away fromhi s famil y an dchildre n o n Father' s Day ; (d ) th e Subpoena , potentially , adversel y affect s afamil y vacatio n schedule db y Mr . Romano , beginnin g o n Jun e 24 , 2010 , du e t o hi s havin g t o mis s wor k fo r hi s attendanc e i n Alaska ; an d(e ) th e Subpoen asubject s Mr . Roman o t o undu e burden . 6 . O n Jun e 7 , 2010 , th e undersigne dcounse l contacte dMr . Glei mBrown , th e perso n wh o sen t th e Subpoen aaddresse dt o Mr . Romano , an doffere dan alternativ e t o th e onerou s Subpoen aactuall y sent . Th e emai l sen t b y th e undersigne dcounse l an drespons e b y Mr . Brow n i s attache dheret o a s Exhibi t B . WHEREFORE , Jay Roman o respectfull y request s tha t th e U.S . Administrativ e Judge : 1 . Ente r

an orde r quashin g th e subpoen at o Jay Roman o i n it s entirety or , i n th e alternative , modifyin g th e Subpoena ; an d 2 . Gran t

unt o hi msuc h othe r

an dfurther

relie f a s thi s Court

deems jus t

an dproper . Thi s th e M ^ da

y o f June , 2010 .

e l J . Rossab i

Attorne y fo r

Ja y Roman oO FCOUNSEL :

FORMA N ROSSAB I BLACK , P.A . 362 3 NorthEl mStreet , Suit e 20 0 Pos t Offic e Bo x 4102 7 Greensboro , North Carolin a27404-102 7 Telephone : (336)378-189 9SERVIC E LIS T

ORIGINA L AN D ON E COP Y Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 ATTN : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2W100 0 ON E COP Y Courtne y E . Felts , Staf

f Attorne y I I Federa l Expres s Corporatio n Regulatory Affairs , Lega l Departmen t 362 0 Hack s Cros s Roa d Buildin g B , 3' " Floo r Memphis , Tennesse e 3812 5 Telephone : (901)434-863 2 Facsimile : (901)434-828 3 Glen n H . Brown , Senio r

Attorne y Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 22 2 Wes t 7" ^ Avenu e #1 4 Anchorage , Alask a9951 3 Telephone : (907)271-521 7 Facsimile : (907)271-280 0 Th e Honorabl e Richar dG . Goodwin , Administrativ e La w Judg e Offic e o f Hearings , M-2 0 U.S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 1200 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S E Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mEl2-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 Telephone : (202 ) 366-213 9 Attorney-Adviso r

(202 ) 366-512 1 Legal Assistan t Facsimile : (202 ) 366-753 6U . S . Departmen t Alaska n Region 22 2 W . 7ihAvenu e »1 4 o f Transportatio n Ofdc e o f th e Regiona

l Counse l Anchorage , Alask a99513-758 7 Federa l Aviatio n PH : (907)271-527 1 Administratio n FAX : (907)271-280 0 W/ ^ 2 1 ^01 0 VI A HAN D DELIVERY Ja y Roman o Redox Tech , LLC 1006 Morrisvill e Parkwa

y Morrisville , N C 27560-936 7 Re : I n th e Matter

o f FedEx Expres s Corporatio n FA A Docke t No . CP09AL000 5 Dea r Sir : Th e cas e referredt

o abov e i s a

n actio n befor

e a n Administrativ e La w Judg e i n whic h w

e hav e allege dFedE

x Expres s violate dcertai n provision s o f th e Hazardou s Material s Regulation s (HMR) . I n such aproceedin g it

i s necessary , unde

r th e law , that

w e prov e th e fact s alleged . Accordingly , ahearin g i

n thi s matter

ha s bee n schedule dfo

r Jun e 21-22, 2010 , i

n Anchorage , Alaska . You r testimony will b e neede dto establis h certai n fact s regardin g th e shipment o f ahydrauli c pum p fromAttleboro , Massachusetts , to Anchorage , Alaska , o n abou t September

5 , 2007 . A subpoen acommandin g you r presenc e a

t the hearin g i s enclosed . Yo u \W1 1 be entitle dt

o witnes s fee s an dto reimbursement o f certai n trave l andmiscellaneou s expense s fro

myou r residenc e t

o th e plac e of

hearin g an

dreturn . Th e enclose dStandardFor m 115 7 (Claimfo

r Witnes s Attendanc e Fees . Travel , andMiscellaneou s Expenses ) shoul db e complete dan

dreturne dto thi s offic e wit h th e subpoen aafte

r th e hearing . Pleas e contact

ou r offic e a t th e above-liste dnumbe

r s o tha t w e ca n arrang e government-funde d airlin e tickets , a s thi s i s th e onl y mean s to ensur e you wil l b e reimburse dfor your travel expenses . W

e als o nee dl o discus s your testimony . Sincerely . Glen n H . Brown Senior Attorney Enclosure sU.S . DEPARTMEN T 01 < T1^-\.NSP0RTAT10 N FEDERA L AVIATIO N ADMINISTR.A.TIO N CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOEN A I n th e Matte r

of : Docke t No. : CP09AL000 5 FEDERA L EXPRES S CORPORATIO N DM S No. : 2009-009 9 Issue don : V^-

b 21 . 2Q1 Q To : Ja v Romano . Redo x Tec hLLC . 1QQ 6 Morrisvill e Pkwv. . Mnrrlavnie . N C 27560-936 7 Unde r 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.228(a) . YO

U AU K REQUIRED : [y | T o appea r an dtestif y befor e a n .Administrativ e La

w Judg e o f the Departineni o f

Transportatio n at : TI-S , ntfifrin f Cnitrf . 2? ? W . 7t- h AVPTIUP , Anr>im-flg» , A V QQS n i n th e cit y of Anchorag e o n the 21s t

da

y o f Jun e 2 0 j Q a t 9:0 0 a

m n T o appearan dtestifS'a

t adepositio n t

o b e conducte dby : at : i n th e cit> ' o f

o n the da y o f 20 a t a m [~ ] T o brin g wit

h you an dproduc e the following documents , records , papers , books , an dtangibl e items :

I f you hav e an

y question s abou

t thi s subpoena , contact

R 1 en n H . Rrnu n a t thi s addres s an

diclephon e number : 22 2 W. 7t h Avenue . Anchorage . A K 9951 3 Tel ; (907 ) 271-527 1



# /

'yH't/<

•d-t-,< w Stephani e McClai n Hearin " Docket

Cler k Auitwriiy : 1 4 C.r.K . 5 13.228 ; 4 9 U.S.C . S § 5121-.mi i t.47oKl) . o r 4 9 U.S. C § § 4610 4 ani l l06(gK\ ) A.N Y PKR.SO N WH O DOK S NO T OBK Y THI S SUBPOKN A I S SUBJEC T T O FIN E O K

I.MPRISON.MEN T O RBOT H UNDE R4 9 U.S. C § 46313 .RETURN O FSERVIC E

I CERTIF Y tha

t aduplicate /

a n origintil (circl e one ) ol'thi s subpoen awa s serve do n the perso n namedi

n ihc subpoen a by : at : o n th e da

y o f 2 0 _L0

_. Name o f perso n making service : OtTicia l Title :

### BPag e 1 o f 2

Amie l Rossab i From : glenn.brown@faa.go v Sent : Monday , Jun e 07 , 201 0 2:3 4 P M To : Amie l Rossab i Subject : Re : I n th e Matte ro f Federa l Expres s Corp ; DM S No . FAA2009-009 9 Mr . Rossabi , I a m no t willin g t o withdra wth e subpoena . Amotio n t o quas h i s a n avenu e availabl e t o you . Glen n

FroiTs : "Amie l Rossabi " <arossabi@frb-law,com > To : Glen n Brown/AAL/FAA@FA A Date : 06/07/201 0 10:2 8 A M Subject - ' " ^ ^

Matte rof Federa l Expres s Corp ; DM S No . FA A2009-009 9

Dea rMr . Brown , Las t Thursday , a subpoen a wa s delivere d t o m yclient' s office s a t 20 0 Quad e Driv e i n Gary , Nort h Carolin a purportedl yservin g Ja yRoman o an d demandin g hi s appearanc e o n Jun e 21 , 201 0 i n Anchorage , Alaska . Mr . Roman o wa s no t serve d wit h th e subpoena . Th e perso n wh o receive d th e subpoen a wa s Jacki e Satterwhite , th e accountan t fo rm yclient , wh o i s no t authorize d t o accep t subpoena s o n behal f o f m yclien t o rMr . Romano . Th e subpoena , therefore , shoul d b e quashe d an d I a m prepare d t o fil e suc h a motio n wit h th e Administrativ e La wJudge . A s a n aside , th e Jun e 2 1 dat e fo r appearanc e also , potentially , conflict s wit h a lon g planne d famil yvacatio n fo rMr . Romano . Rather , tha n fil e th e Motio n t o Quash , I a m willin g t o discus s wit h yo u you rvoluntarywithdrawa l o f th e subpoen a an d a n alternativ e t o Mr . Romano' s persona l appearance , whic h ma yinclud e hi s testimon yby phone , togethe rwit h th e productio n t o yo u o f th e signe d fede xslip . I n additio n t o th e hardshi p t o Mr . Roman o o f havin g t o personall yappea ri n Anchorag e o n Jun e 21 , i t woul d b e a hardshi p t o m yclien t t o los e hi m during th e day s o f tria l an d appearanc e wheneve rh e ha s t o testify . I as k yo u t o conside rthi s an d le t m e kno wimmediatel yi f thi s i s somethin g w e ca n discuss ; otherwise , I wil l fil e m yMotio n t o Quash . Than k you .

6/7/201 0Pag e 2 o f 2

Amie l J . Rossabi , Esq . FORMA N ROSSAB I BLACK , P A ATTORNEY S A T LA W Greensbor o Offices : Charlott e Offices : Pos t Offic e Bo x4102 7 30 1 McCulloug h Drive , 4t h Floo r Greensboro , Nort h Carolin a 27404-102 7 Charlotte , Nort h Carolin a 2826 2 (704)319-104 9 (336)378-189 9 arossabi@frb-law.co m Fir m We b Site : www.frb-iaw.co m Thi s e-mai l contain s confidentia l informatio n fo rth e addressee . D o no t read , cop yo rshar e thi s communicatio n unles s yo u ar e th e intende d addressee . I f yo u receiv e thi s e-mai l i n error , pleas e contac t th e sende rb yrepl ye-mai l o rb ytelephone . Than k you .

6/7/201 0