No. 04-14-00807-CV
In the Court ofAppeals for the Fourth Court ofAppeals District SanAntonio Division
BRADLEYAERY, et al., Appellants, vs. HOSKINS, INC., et al., Appellees,
FROMTHE36TH JUDICIAL DISTRICTCOURTOFMCMULLENCOUNTY,TEXAS

BRENT C. HOSKINS' JOINDER IN BRIEF OF APPELLEES C. CLIFTON HOSKINS AND HOSKINS, INC.
HORNBERGERFULLER & GARZA INCORPORATED 7373 Broadway, Suite 300 SanAntonio, Texas 78209 (210) 271-1700-Fax: (210) 271-1730 David W.Navarro State BarNo.24027683 Email: dnavarro@hfgtx.com MarkA. Randolph State BarNo. 00791484 Email: randolph@hfgtx.com Brendan C. Holm State BarNo. 24087737 Email: bholm@hfgtx.com ATTORNEYS FORAPPELLEE, BRENT C. HOSKINS ACCEPTED 04-14-00807-CV FOURTH COURT OF APPEALS SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS 5/29/2015 10:52:07 AM KEITH HOTTLE CLERKNo. 04-14-00807-CV
In the Court of Appeals for the Fourth Court ofAppeals District SanAntonio Division
BRADLEYAERY, et al., Appellants,
vs. HOSKINS, INC., et al., Appellees, FROM THE 36TMJUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF MCMULLEN COUNTY, TEXAS
BRENT C. HOSKINS' JOINDER IN BRIEF OF APPELLEES C. CLIFTON HOSKINSAND HOSKINS, INC.
TO THE HONORABLE JUSTICES OF THE COURT: COMES NOW Appellee Brent C. Hoskins and presents his joinder in Brief of Appellees C. Clifton Hoskins and Hoskins, Inc. demonstrating that the trial court correctly granted summary judgment on the dispositive legal issue in this
case. Appellee Brent C.Hoskins joins in the Brief ofAppellees CliffHoskins and Hoskins, Inc. as the trial court orderedthat the February 9, 1966 Deed from Sam E. Quinn to James L. House conveying the lands ofthe 623.93-acre Quinn Tract (Vol.95,pg.451) (the "House Deed") didnot convey Same E. Quinn's non-participating

royalty interests in the Ray Tract and Hoskins Tract, originally established and described in that certain November 7, 1963 Partition and Royalty Deed (Vol. 95, pg. 357) and subsequently conveyed to Hazel Hoskins and L.R. Hoskins by that certain February 11, 1966 Deed from Sam E. Quinn to L. R. Hoskins and Hazel Hoskins conveying his non-participating royalty interest in the Ray Tract and Hoskins Tract shouldbeupheld. Wherefore, Appellee Brent C. Hoskins respectfully requests that this Court affirm the judgment of the district court and that he have such further relief to whichhe is entitled. Respectfully submitted, HORNBERGERFULLER & GARZA INCORPORATED 7373 Broadway, Suite 300 SanAntonio, Texas 78209 (210) 271-1700 -Telephone (210) 271-1730-FacsimileBy: Davi^W^avarro 

### StatefearNo.24027683 Emaih dnavarro@hfgtx.com Mark A. Randolph State BarNo. 00791484 Email:randolph@hfgtx.com Brendan C. Holm State BarNo. 24087737 Email: bholm@hfgtx.com ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE, BRENT C. HOSKINS

CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE The undersigned certifies this Briefcomplies with the type-face and length requirements of amended rule 9.4 of the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure. Exclusive of the exempted portions stated in amended rule 9.4(i)(l), the Brief contains 250 words, as calculated by Microsoft Word 2007, the program used to preparethis document.CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing has been deliveredvia EMAIL, on thisthe day ofMay, 2015, to: Ms. Rosemarie Kanusky Attorneys for Intervenors and Mr. John W. Weber Jr. Third-Party Plaintiffs James House Family Mr. JeffreyA.Webb Mr. James Summers Fulbright & Jaworski L.L.P/ 300 Convent Street, Suite 2100 San Antonio, Texas 78205-3792 Mr. Dan Pozza Attorney for Plaintiffs Brad and Randi Aery Law Office ofDan Pozza 239 East Commerce Street SanAntonio, Texas 78205 Mr. C. David Kinder Ms. Ellen Mitchell Dykema Cox Smith 112 E. Pecan Street, Suite 1800 San Antonio, Texas 78205 Mr. Michael Sartori Law Office ofMichael C. Sartori P.O.Box 1222 502A Houston Street George West, Texas 78022 Ms. Melanie H. Phipps Attorney for Plaintiffs Brad and Randi Aery Kustoff& Phipps, LLP 4103 Parkdale Street San Antonio, Texas 78229 Mr. Marc K. Whyte Attorney for Plaintiffs Brad and Randi Aery Whyte, PLLC 209 Tuttle SanAntonio, Texas 78209 Mr. John G. George, Jr. Mr. Matthew F. Wymer Beirne, Maynard & Parsons, L.L.P. The Weston Centre 112 East Pecan Street, Suite 2750 San Antonio, Texas 78205 Attorneys forDefendants Hoskins, Inc. and C. Clifton HoskinsMrs. Julia Mann

Mr. Peter Hosey Jackson Walker L.L.P. 112 E. Pecan Street, Suite 2400 San Antonio, Texas 78205 Mr. Ezra Johnson Uhl, Fitzsimons, Jewett & Burton, PLLC 4040 Broadway, Suite 430 SanAntonio, Texas 78209 Mr. David L. Ylitalo Coats Rose, P.C. 1020Northeast Loop 410, Suite 800 San Antonio, Texas 78209 Mr. Bruce D. Oakley Mr. Robert Pillow Hogan Lovells US LLP 700 Louisiana, Suite 4300 Houston, Texas 77002 Mr. Jason A.Newman Baker Botts L.L.P. One Shell Plaza 910 Louisiana Street Houston, Texas 77002-4995 Mr. Conner R. Jackson Mr. R. Clay Hoblit Hoblit Ferguson Darling, LLP 2000 Frost Bank Plaza 802North Carancahua Corpus Christi, Texas 78401 Mr. Benjamin F.Youngblood III Benjamin F. Youngblood, III, P.L.L.C 8207 Callaghan Road, Suite 100 San Antonio, Texas 78230 Attorneys forDefendants LeeAnn Kulka, Lee Roy Hoskins, III and Andrea Jurica

Attorney for Defendant Black C. Hoskins

Attorney for Defendant Leonard K. Hoskins

Attorney for Defendants Sundance Energy, Inc., SEA Eagle Ford, LLC, and Armadillo E&P, Inc.

Attorney for Third-Party Defendant Texoz E&P I, Inc.

Attorneys for Third-Party Defendant Aurora Resources Corp.

Attorney for Jane HoskinsMr. Kevin F. Mickits

Mr. John C. Heymann Upton, Mickits & Heymann, L.L.P. 7800 IH-10 West, Suite 740 SanAntonio, Texas 78230 Attorney for Third-Party Defendant Kebo Oil & Gas, Inc.

Da\'M WANavarro Mal^JyA.Randolph Brendan C. Holm