12/07/201 0 17:0 2 FA X 202493514 2 FA A •s - DMS

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N •ti«K$TiU£r.suirt-tos ANCHORACEAKM50 1 TEL : t»«7 ) 2T<i-!t2S 7 fA>::(9l)7>2l«2S I U.S . DEPAPsTMENTO FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , DC @1001/00 S 

### vs^RTMEN TO F aNSPORMTlO N •:^r'OPERATIO N 

### -"^"c- e Aq : I nth e Matte r

of ; TG IFREIGH T ) ) )FA ADocke t

No . CP10NM001 2 )DM S NO . FAA-2010-107 9 )Judg eRICHARD C . GOODWI M AtTSWER CC3ME. S NO WTGT Freight. , l..hr-ouy hcounsel , Wiikerso n llozubin , and answer s th e Complaint , pursuan t t o 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.209 , a s follows : T . TG I Freiyh L admit s th e procedura l outlin e a s ^c t fort hi n paragrap hI o f th e Comp.Laint . II . 1 . TG I Freigh t denie s tha t th e alleqations/stcp s a s se t forLhi n paragrap hJ , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e neces-sary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r Lhe oute r packaqin q from th e manufacture r had bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , an d th e origina l documentatio n fro mth e manufacture r wa s no t available . 2 . TG I denie s tha i Unite xfro-Foxyi s a n "'adhesive. " TG I Freigh t i s withou t informatio r sufficien t t o admi t o r deny th e remainde r o f allegation. ^ i n paragrap h2 , Sectio n TT , o f th e Complain t and , therefore , denie s th e same .12/07/201 0 17:0 2 FA X202493514 2 FA A +DM S @1002/00 G

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N 31 0 K !>T1UiET , SUIT E10 5 ANCHURAUt , A K

OSSO I TtL : (W7 ) 21«iZ n FAX ; (DOT

) r7l«il!9 1 3 . TG I I''reiyh L denie s th e allegation s se t fort hi n paragrap h3 , Sectio n TI , o f th e Complaint . 4 . TG I Freigh t denie s tha t th e allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h4 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necessary , becaus e neither

- th e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g Iromth e manufacture r ha d bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , ari dth e origina l documentatio n fromth e man):facturc r wa s no t available . b . TG I Freigh t denie s tha t th e allegations/^tep s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h5 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necefifiary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r the . oute r packagin g from th e manufacture r had bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , an d th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t available . 5 . TG T Freigh t denie s tha t th e allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h6 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necessary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g fromth e manufacture r ha d bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , and th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t available , 7 . TG I Freigh t denie s tha t th e a 1.1 ega t ions/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h7 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necessary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g
Answe r 11 1 Lh e MalLe r of TC I Frr;ig_h

t Docket No . CP10NM001 712/07/201 0 17:0 2 FAX202493514 2 FA A • > DMS 2)003/00 6

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N 31 0 K S'lUU.I',.SUIT E40 5 AN QlO RACJ^. , A K

»<iao i 'I'1;L ! <!I«7 > 2T«..Y2D ; FAX : (MT ) 2T«.ft2<) l fron

i the iiianulacturer ha d bee. n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , an d th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t ava.i l able . fi, TG I Freigh t denie s tha t the.allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h8 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necessary , becaus e neithe r the inne r no r th e oute r packagin g fromth e xnanulacturc r ha d bee n m.arke d and/o r labele d correctly , an d th e origina l documentatio n fro mth e m.anufacture r wa s no t available . 9 . TG I Freigh t denie s tha t th e allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h9 , Sectio n 11 , o f th e Complain t wer e nece.y5ary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g fromth e manufacture r ha d bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , and th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t available . 10 . TG I Frei.gh

t denie s tha t th e allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h10 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e necessary , becaus e neithei

- th. e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g fromth e manufacture r ha d bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , and th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t available . 11 . TC I Freigh t denie. s Llia t the allegations/step s a s se t fort hi n paragrap h11 , Sectio n II , o f th e Complain t wer e

Answe r I n th( ; Mai:r.e

r o f I'G

l Freigh t Ooc.kfst No . CP10NM001 2 raq e H12/07/201 0 17:0 2 FAX202493514 2 FA A - > DMS g|004/00 G

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N ti u KSTRECi'

i surn : tos ANCMO B AGE , A K9950 1 TEL - p«7 ) niiS'Sf l FAX : (MT ) J7S.52V 1 necessary , becaus e neithe r th e inne r no r th e oute r packagin g

fromthe manufacture r had bee n marke d and/o r labele d correctly , and th e origina l documentatio n fromth e manufacture r wa s no t availabl e - III . 1 . TG I Freigh- : denie s th e allegation s se t fort hi n paragrap h1 , Sectio n III , o f th e Complaint , includin g subsection s (a ) through(m) . TV . 1 . TG I Freigh t denie s th e allegation s se t fort hin paragrap h1 , Sectio n TV , o f th e Complaint . 2 . TG T Freigh t denie s th e allegation s se t fort h.i n paragrap h2 , Sectio n TV , o f th e Complaint . AFFIRMATIV E DEFENSE S 1 . Failur e t o joi n an indispensabl e party . 2 . An

yallege d violatio n wa s th e result , i n whol e o r i n part , o f th e action s o f thir d partie s ove r who manswerin g responden t ha s n o righ t or dut yo f control . 3 . Th e produe t shippe d wa s no t a h''adhesive, " 4 . Th e produc t wa s a limite d quantit yand , base d o n 172.604(d ) o f th e HMR , doe s no t requir e a telephon e numbe r i n th e ."ihippin

qpapers .

An.'.wp . r I nLh eM,^T.Ter

o f TG IFr g i qh L Docke t No . CPiONMO'm';^ ' PrTo e112/07/201 0 17:0 2 FA X202493514 2 FA A •> • DM S @1005/00 G

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N ii « K ."fiRnrr , SUIT E<O 5 ANCHO RAGE . A K

.1!>S0 I T H J<9«T > 2T«-S29 5 FAX : (!WT

) 276-52S I 5 . Th e manufacture r di d no t properl ymar k o r labe l th e

inne r o r oute r packagin g whe n i t wa s shipped . 6 . TG I Freigh t reserve s th e righ t t o alleg e additiona l affirmativ e defense s a. s the ybecom e known . WHEREFORE , TG I Freigh t pray s fo r th e followin g relief : 1 . Ahearin g i n Anchorage ; 7 . Th e Complain t b e dismis.fie d wit hprejudice ; 3 . TG I Freigh t b e awarde d it s cost.' ^ and fee s incurre d i n defendin g thi s action ; an d 4 . Fo r suc hothe r relie f a s th e Cour t deem s equitable

rxt' ' DATE D thi s Z . dayo f December , 2010 . WILKERSO NHOZUBI N Attorney s fo r TG I By :
CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E Thereb y coiLil Ytha t n nLh e 2ric ldrT y o C Deccmt.".";/- , 2010 , atru< r an dcorrec - fop y o f th ef'oieqoin q wa s sorve do nth efollowing : Origina lPlu s 1 Cqpy-VI AFEDERALEXPRES S federa lAviatio nAdmLniaLratio n 60 01 (idependcnr:? ! Avenue , S.W . Washingrofi , U

C 20.'-)4 1 Attn : U^.nrin qDockiv LClerk , ACC-A3 0 Wiitiu r Wrigh t

Buil di ng-.yuit e'/iW l00 0 1 Copy-VI AFEDERAl i EXPRES S The ; Honox-sbi c Richor dC . Gnciciw^n , Adminis t r aLiv eLa w Jiirii] e U.S . Departmp.n r

o C T'ranapor'LtiLlo n Officr o o r

Hearing."? , M-2 0 !?()( ) Ne w Jor-TC- y Avenue , .S.F, . F.tj:.-ii . liuiJ.dinrj , Groun dFlyyi , !?.oo mE17-".12 0 Washinglyn , D

C '/.Ob^O An.?we r i nth eMr^tre r

o f TC IFreigh L Docke t Ny . CPlONMCloi ? PrJOl ^. 512/07/201 0 17:0 2 FA X202493514 2 FA A +DM S lOOG/00 6

WILKERSO N HOZUBI N 31 0I C STREET . SITT EM S ANCHORAGE , A K

tiSSO l T O : (507 ) 17«.52» 7 FAX : (fXir ) 2T(W>'M 1 On eCopy-VI AHAN D DEIilVER Y Howar d I. . Martin , Jr , ReG-ioiis l Counsel , Offi.c yo f Regicna i Counse l Alask a Regio n Federa l AvidLxo n Adniin i .strn n n n 22' ^Wfd'.'r-

t 7^' ^ Av e 1-

1 u c JM^ l Ancliuraqe , A

K <->'-).Sl'3-r7!,C7 On e Copy-VI AHAM D DELIVER Y Chery l M . Jonffi:' , ! " r . Attorne y Ofl"ir. e o f Regiona l Coun;-^^ ! A]i.'5kc i Keqio n federa lAy.idLiu nAdniirii.strflt i n n 22 2 Wen r

7^ " Avenu e#1 4 A nc V i0 1 dI. ) e , A K '-

J 9 ! > 1 :• ! - 7 . S M7 AAL- 7

WILKEr<-SpN

_HOZUBi N Cafo i L. ' Mt-lWi c D100,"ja?./picad/Arj3w= r

Anfiwe i Jj]_,th e Mattft r o T TG I Freigh t Docker . Nn . CP10NM001 2 Pag e 6