12/17/201 0 12:4 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D. C I N TH EMATTE RO F . 1 ^ 5 : SCENI C AVIATION . INC . " " C^^r n 

## V 

## ^§ ^ FA A Docke t

No . CP09NM001 1 i>3 og ^ (Civil Penalt

y Action ) p r 5 3 C O DM S No . FAA-2009-097 4 Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n Administrativ e La w Judg e Hearin g Location ; Sal t

Lak e City , U T Hearin g Dates ; Decembe r 13-15 , 201 0 RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O COMPLAINANT' S

MOTIO NT O COMPE LAN D CONSEN T T O CONTINUANC E COME S NOW , Sceni c Aviation , Responden t herein , b y an dthroug hundersigne dcounsel , pursuan t l o Rul e 13.22 0 o f

th e Rule s o f

Practic e (1 4 C.F.R . Par t

13) , an dhereb y respond s t o Complainant' s Moiio n t o Compe l dare dDecembe r 3 , 2010 . Complainan t

no w seek s a n Orde r fro mth e Honorabl e Administrativ e La w Judg e compellin g response s t o it s Secon dSupplementa l Discover y Requests : an dfurthe r seek s acontinuanc e o f

ih e hearin g i n orde r

t o revie w th e discover y response s provided . However , sinc e Responden t ha s full y complie dwit hComplainant' s Secon dSupplementa l Discover y Request s o nDecembe r 6 , 2010 , Complainant' s motio n t o compe l ha s bee n rendere d moot . Nevertheless , i nth e interest s o f justice . Responden t

doe s no t oppos e Complainant' s reques t fo r continuanc e i n orde r

t o revie w th e discover y response s provided .12/17/201 0 12:4 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^^' ^ * DM S 0002/00 6

STATEMEN T O FFACT S 1 . A hearin g i s presentl y schedule dt o begin on December 13 , 2010 . i

n Salt Lake City , UT . 2 . On Augus t

6 , 2010 , th e Complainant fileda n Amende dComplain t

allegin g violation s tha

t occurre do

n o r abou t Augus t 7,200 7 (i.e. , 3 year s earlier) . Se e Amende dComplain t a t para . 4 . 3

- On November

1 , 2010 , Complaint' s counse l serve dupon Respondent' s counse l vi a electroni c mail (i.e. , email) , aSecon dSupplementa l Di.scover

y Request . See Motio n l o Compe l a c pag e 5 . 4 . Th e parties , b y an

dthroug h counsel , i

n goo dfait

h negotiations , hav e exchange dsettlemen t proposal.s . Respondent' s writte n settlemen t proposa l wa s presente don December 1 , 20J0 , wit h discussion s continuin g throug h December 2 , 2010 . (Se e Exhibi t

1 ) 5 . Counse l fo

r bot h parlie s ha

dverbally agreed , i

n goo dfaith , t o withhol dfurther discover y pendin g th e outcom e o

f .settlemen t di.scussions . 6 . Althoug h n o fina

l settlemen t

ha dyet bee n reached . Responden t serve dit s response s t o Complainant' s SecondSupplementa l Discover y Request s on December

6 , 2010 . 7 . Respondent'. $ counse l serve ddiscover y response s 3 5 day s followin g receip t of Complainant' s SecondSupplementa l Discover

y Request s by emai l delivery . Neverlhcle.is , goo dcaus e existe dfo

r an y dela y i n th e respons e (i.e. . goo dfait h settlemen t

negotiations) . 8 . N o furthe

r discover y remain s outstanding

-12/17/201 0 12:4 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A

—. _ . _ . —^« « * DM S iaoo3/oo e

WHEREFORE , sinc e Respondent' s counse l continue s t o ac t in goo dfait

h toward reachin g a n amicabl e settlemen t

o f thi s matter , an dsinc e n o furthe r discover y remain s outstanding . Complainant' s Motio n t o Compel i s moo t an dshoul dmus t

denie da s such . Furthermore , sinc e Respondent doe s no t oppos e Complainant' s reques t for acontinuanc e i

n order t o revie w th e discover

y response s provided , th e Honorabl e Administrativ e La w Judg e shoul dgran t

acontinuanc e i

n (he interest s o

f ju.5tice . Dated : December

6 , 201 0 Respectfully Stl^Bwtted ,

WINTON , ESQ . i e Pdti^io n La

w Fir m 33 0 Aviatio n Wa

y Frederick . M D 2170 1 Tel : (.301 ) 294-855 0 Fax : (301 ) 294-252 5 Greg@AvLationLawExperis-co m Counse l for

Responden t12/17/201 0 12:4 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A + DM S 1^004/00 6



# EXHIBI T 112/17/201 0 12:4 5 FAX 202493514 2 FA A* DM S IgOOS/OO G Gre g Winto n From : Gre g Winto n <greg@aviationlawexperts.com > Sent : Wednesday , Decembe r01 , 201 0 1:2 9 P M To : Scott.Morris@faa.go v Subject : RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Settlemen t Agreemen t Attachments : Scot t Morri s 1 2 0 1 2010.pd f Scott : Sorr yfo rth e delay . Attache d pleas e fin d rn yclient' s respons e t o th e FAA' s settlemen t offer . Regards , Grc s Gregor yS . Winton . Esq . Th e Aviatio n Lo w Fir m 33 0 Aviyiio n Wa y 2n d Floo r Frederick . M

D 2170 1 maih.o:Greti@AviationLawEAperts,co m Toll free : I-877-4-AI RLA W Local : (301)294-85.5 0 Cell : (301 ) 529-566 0 Fax : mi ) 294-252 5 From : Scott.Morris@fa3.go v[mailto:Scott.Morrls@faa.gov ] Sent : Tuesday , Novembe r23 , 201 0 5:3 9 PM To : greg@aviationlawexperts.co m Subject : RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Settlemen t Agreemen t Greg : A s promised , her e i s th e settlemen t agreement . Pleas e review , sign , emai l m e bac k a cop yi n .pd f an d mai l th e orgina l back . Thanks , Scot t

Scot t R , Morri s FA A Enforcemen t Attorne y Northwes t Mountai n Regio n Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel , ANM-7 H 160 1 Lin d Ave . S W Renton , W

A 9805 7 (425 ) 227-141 7 (ph ) (425 ) 227-100 7 (fax ) scott.morrisCqjfaa.Qo v "Gre g Winton " wrote :12/17/201 0 12:4 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A * DM S iOOG/OO G

CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha t I hav e thi s date serve dby regula r U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , a n origina l an d on e (1 ) cop y of

th e foregoin g Repl y t o Motio n t o Compe l addresse dto : Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Suite 2W100 0 Washington , D.C . 2059 1 And , further , that

I hav e thi s dat e .serve

dvi afacsimil e an

dregula r US . mail , postag e prepaid , a cop y o f th e foregoin g Reply t

o Moiio n to Compe l addresse dto : Th e Honorabl e RichardC . Goodwi n Administrativ e La

w Judg e Offic e of Hearings . M-2 0 U.S . Departmen t

of Transportatio n 1200 New Jerse y Avenue . S.E , Hast Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mEl2-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 Tel : 202-366-213 9 Fax : 202-366-753 6 Scot t R . Morris . Esq . Offic e of Regional Coun.<;el, ANM- 7 FAA Northwes t

Mountai n Regio n 160 1 LindAvenue , S W Renton , W

A 9805 7 Tel : 42 5 227-141 7 Fax:42 5 227-100 7 Dated ; December

6 , 201 0 S . WINTON , ESQ . Aviatio n La

w Experts , LL C 33 0 Aviatio n Wa

y Frederick . M D 2170 1 Tel : (301 ) 294-855 0 Fax : (301 ) 294-252 5