5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



,&+$5'($5%(	

(520( ,61(6.,	

+$521$,5%$1.6 (11,675$8% !"#$%&' 
()& *	&!& +)+&$),&-$&#$&' !+& $()+&$),&#),').!(!& &$)&/0123 ()+ 4!. *)+&$),&-*. $.- *5-( 2 ,)* *!(*)" *5	 & %6 $/27 #$ 58
7!(*)$,-)&-*. +2
2Q 'HFHPEHU   WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW XSRQ WKH DJUHHPHQW RI WKHSDUWLHV GLVPLVVHG ZLWK SUHMXGLFH 'HIHQGDQWV &RWWRQ &RUUHFWLRQDO )DFLOLW\DQG 'XDQH / :DWHUV +RVSLWDO 'U 3ULFH DQG WKH -RKQ 'RH GHIHQGDQWVZHUH YROXQWDULO\ UHPRYHG IURP WKLV FDVH ZKHQ /H0DUEH ILOHG KLV DPHQGHGFRPSODLQW ZLWKRXW DQ\ UHIHUHQFH WR WKHVH SDUWLHV 2Q 0DUFK   WKHGLVWULFW FRXUW DFFHSWHG WKH PDJLVWUDWH MXGJH¶V UHSRUW DQG UHFRPPHQGDWLRQ'('-$6 $9: 
	 
;
	
 !(+)(.),').!(#$ ""!(&'( '	<!= $)(),').!(#$ "" 
'('-$6 $    9 :
	 
;
	
 !(+)(. ),').!( #$ ""!(& '( ' 	<!=  $)(),').!(#$ "" * ")> $ *&' )()(#&' ,-$&)(?'),'8
@)( *7A/2B* ")> $ *!+ !$!& *)++ (&)(.)()(8	)$,-)&-*. (-( // 4"!)(&)## "" ),'!$* !$6  AC !$6 DB !),').!( +&!&  $)+( $ #)" * &')+ "!?+-)& !.!)(+& &&($$ ,&)(!" !,)")&E -!(   !& $+ +)&!" 	'!$(!)$6!(=+ (()+	&$!-6 # (*!(& ""!(&$ $%)+( +=)AC$)+( +=)DB$"" (4$), !(*!'(* # (*!(&!"" .)(.&'!&&' * # (*!(&+*)+"!E ** ")6 $!&)(*)## $ (, &')++ $)-+% *),!"( *+)(>)"!&)(#')+$).'&+-(* $&' ).'&'% (*% (&-$)(.&' ,-$+ #&')+"!?+-)&!""#&' * # (*!(&+ F, &#$$)+( +=)? $  *)+%)++ * #$% &')+ !,&)( &'$-.' )&' $ >"-(&!$E*)+%)++!"$+-%%!$E@-*.% (&(!$,'2&'
WR JUDQW )DLUEDQNV¶V DQG 6WUDXE¶V PRWLRQV IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW EDVHGXSRQ TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ /H0DUEH LV QRW DSSHDOLQJ WKH GLVWULFWFRXUW¶VGHFLVLRQ RQ )DLUEDQNV¶V DQG 6WUDXE¶V PRWLRQV IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW*)+&$),& ,-$& !,, & * &'  %!.)+&$!&  @-*. G+ $ $& !(*$ ,%% (*!&)(&* (E$)+( +=)G+%&)(#$+-%%!$E@-*.% (&6!+ *-(H-!")#) *)%%-()&E$)+( +=)(?! !"+&' *)+&$),&,-$&G+* ()!"#')+%&)(#$+-%%!$E@-*.% (&  $ &'  $ !+(+ &'!& #""? ? 	

 &'*)+&$),&,-$&G+* ,)+)(	
 !$6  )+ ! +&!&  $)+( $ !& &'  &&( $$ ,&)(!"!,)")&E )( 
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
(-"E//I$)+( +=)% &?)&' !$6 !.!)(!(* 6+ $> *&'!&  !$6  C?!+(G& *)(. !+ ? "" !+ K$)+( +=)L ?!(& * K !$6 L & 6  *)(.D   !& JA)+( +=)   !&0B  !& $&'!&*!E $)+( +=) C-&*?(!(!+&$.!+&$),&-6 & %&EK !$6 G+L+&%!,'D!+ !$6  ?!+ +-## $)(. #$% +E%&%+ # (!-+ ! !(*!6*%)(!"*)+& (&)(!&JA)+( +=) !&B#& $-(+-,, ++#-""E &!=)(. &' $ +& + & $ +">   !$6 G+$6" %+ $ )+( +=) %!*  ! * ,)+)( &  $#$%F"$!&$E+-$. $E( !$6 ( -"E  //I $ )+( +=) 6 .!( & ,(*-,& !(F"$!&$E "!!$&%E (  !$6   
( (& $)(. !$6 G+ !6*% ( *-$)(. &'  "!!$&%E $)+( +=)(,-(& $ *!$F)%!& "E#)> ")& $+#!C%-**EE ""?6$?( *$" ++ #"-)*D   !& I A)+( +=)   !& 2B,,$*)(. & $ )+( +=) &'  #"-)* C"= * ")=  !+,)&),#"-)*D6-&C#$%&' ,"$#)&K' L&'-.'&)&?!+K6)")!$E#"-)*6 ,!-+ LK)L&?!+").'&"E&)(. *E ""?!(*&' $ )+(G&!(E&')(.)(&' !6*% (&'!&?-"*.)> )&&'!&,"$&' $&'!(6)" D!&IA)+( +=) !&222B$)+( +=)&' ( 6 .!( & "= #$ &'  +-$,  # &'  " !=  
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
26HH DOVR 6DQGHUIHU Y 1LFKROV  )G   WK &LU 3'HOLEHUDWH LQGLIIHUHQFH KRZHYHU GRHV QRW LQFOXGH QHJOLJHQFH LQGLDJQRVLQJ D PHGLFDO FRQGLWLRQ ́ FLWLQJ(VWHOOH  86 DW   6&W DW 6HH DOVR&KULVQHU Y&RPSOHWH $XWR 7UDQVLW ,QF  )G  Q WK &LU  3,W KDV EHHQ WKH SROLF\ RIWKLV FLUFXLW WKDW RQHSDQHO FDQQRW RYHUUXOH WKH GHFLVLRQ RI DQRWKHUSDQHODEVHQW HLWKHULQWHUYHQLQJ 6XSUHPH&RXUW DXWKRULW\ WR WKH FRQWUDU\ RU RWKHUFLUFXPVWDQFHV ZKLFK UHQGHU WKH SUHFHGHQW FOHDUO\ ZURQJ >FLWDWLRQRPLWWHG@   ,W LV P\KRSH WKDW ERWK WKH PDMRULW\
VGLVUHJDUG IRU FLUFXLWSUHFHGHQW DQG LWV PLVDQDO\VLV RI WKHEXVLQHVV QHFHVVLW\ LVVXH ZLOO EHUHJDUGHG DV DEHUUDWLRQDO ́ .HLWK - GLVVHQWLQJ2J 2//2 A/0IB  A ")6 $!&  )(*)## $ (,  * + (&)(,"-* ( ."). (, )(*)!.(+)(.!% *),!",(*)&)(B( * !$&)(. #$%!(* &'  %!@$)&E>)"!& +&' > ( $!6" $-" )(&')+,)$,-)&&'!&( !( "%!E(& > $$-"  &'  -6")+' * $ , * (& # !(&' $ !( " " &!"( &' $ , * (& +&!6")+' *6E&'  (6!(, ,-$&
 !!02*010JAI&')$/1BACKL!( "#&')+,-$&%!E(&> $$-" !$ >)-+!( "G+ * ,)+)(  ("E !( ( 6!(, ,-$& %!E > $$-"  !,)$,-)& $ , * (& !6+ (& !( )(& $> ()(. 	-$ %  -$&* ,)+)(DBA,)&)(."#
$J002*020I(JAI&')$/0B
%&' 11
	0 // 	 & 2J A/0/BB  $ !"" # &' +  $ !+(+*)++ (&2
)(# $ (, # F, ++)> $)+=,-"*6 *$!?(!(*+ ,(*&'!&$)+( +=) !,&-!""E*$ ?&'!&)(# $ (, 7-& 	!$( "" G+!##)*!>)& +)%"E $>)* + 	!$( "" G+ )()( # ?'!& $)+( +=)$!(E( ?)&'!% *),!" *-,!&)(+'-"*'!>=(?(  	!$( "" G+ !##)*!>)& &'-+ $>)* + !( 6@ ,&)>+&!(*!$*(&!+-6@ ,&)> ( !(*&')+)+?'""E)(+-##),) (&&+'?!().'&'% (*% (&>)"!&)(J	!&01	&!&/0/ACKL' ##),)!"%-+&6&'6 !?!$ ##!,&+#$%?'),'&' )(# $ (, ,-"*6 *$!?(&'!&!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$% F)+&+!(*' %-+&!"+*$!?&' )(# $ (, KL(##),)!"G+#!)"-$ &!"" >)!& !+).()#),!(& $)+=&'!&'  +'-"*'!>  $, )> *6-&*)*(&?')" (,!-+ #$,%% (*!&)(,!((&-(* $-$,!+ +6,(* %( *!+&' )(#"),&)(#-()+'% (&DB&'  F& (&&'!&&' %!@$)&E)(&+& >)* (, 6 +)* +$	!$( "" G+!##)*!>)&& +&!6")+'$)+( +=)G+!"" . ** ")6 $!&  )(*)## $ (,  
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
12/
	/0JI/0	&
J'U 7DFLD ODWHU H[SODLQHG WKDW KH GLGQ¶W 3NQRZ ZKHWKHU LW ZDV DFRPPRQ ELOH GXFW RU ZKHWKHU LW ZDV D FRPPRQ KHSDWLF GXFW ́ EHFDXVH WKHDGKHVLRQV LQ /H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZHUH VR WHUULEOH -$ DW  7DFLD'HS DW  $FFRUGLQJ WR 'U 7DFLD 3>W@KH FRPPRQ KHSDWLF GXFW LV WKHELOH GXFW WKDW H[LVWV EHIRUH WKH F\VWLF GXFW HQWHUV DQG WKH FRPPRQ ELOHGXFW LV ZKHUH WKH ELOH GXFW H[LVWV EHWZHHQ DIWHU ZKHUH WKH F\VWLF GXFW KDVHQWHUHG LW DQG ZKHUH LW HQWHUV LQWR WKH ERZHO JRHV WKURXJK WKH SDQFUHDWLFVXEVWDQFH DQG HQWHUV LQWR WKH ERZHO ́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
!&& +)&!"!(*!&&'  &$)& , )>)(.+)&!"
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
( + *)(. &'  *)+&$),& ,-$& $ ") * ' !>)"E ( &'!##)*!>)& # $ !% + 	!$( ""  ! . ( $!" +-$. ( ?'!++ $& * &'!&  !$6 G+ 6)"  " != '!* & 6  +& *)%% *)!& "E!#& $)&+*)+,> $E$	!$( ""  F"!)( *&'!&!(E. ( $!" +-$. (?-"*'!> =(?(-(*)+,> $)(.#)> ")& $+#6)" )( !$6 G+!6*% ((-"E//I&'!&&' 6)" )(&' !6*% (,!% #$%!" !=&'!&&' 6)"" !=?-"*,!-+ + $)-+ $%!( (&*!%!. & !$6 )#(&+& *&'!&6)" ?-"*,(&)(- &" !=)(& !$6 G+!6*% ()#&' 6)" " !=?!+(&+& *&'!&&' 6)" " !=( * *&6 +& *6 #$  !$6 G+ F"$!&$E+-$. $E(* *!(*&'!& !$6 '!*&6 $ # $$ *)%% *)!& "E&!+ ,)!")+&?',-"*",!& !(*+&&' " !=)#&' +-$. (?!+-(!6" &*+')%+ "#!&1A	!$( "" ##B$!$( ""  !"+ +&!& * &'!& CK&L'  $)+= # '!$% & ),'!$* !$6 (0NN/I?!+ F&$ % !(*6>)-+&!(E( ?)&'!% *),!" *-,!&)( !(*&%+&"!E " D  !&1A	!$( "" ##B		$ )+( +=) !$.- + &'!& '  )+ (&)&" * & H-!")#) *)%%-()&E6 ,!-+ ' % $ "E F $,)+ *')+% *),!"@-*.% (&)( * ,)*)(. '?&&$ !&  !$6  !(* ! *)+-&  > $&'+ ,)#), % &'* # &$ !&% (& * + (& $)+  & &'  " > " #* ")6 $!&  )(*)## $ (,   CO-!")#) * )%%-()&E )+ P!(
/6HH DOVR )DUPHU  86 DW  6 &W DW 3:H UHMHFWSHWLWLRQHU¶V LQYLWDWLRQ WR DGRSW DQ REMHFWLYH WHVW IRU GHOLEHUDWHLQGLIIHUHQFH ́
  7 *)++ (&)(.  7 ,!-+  &'%!@$)&E * !$&+ #$% -$ ( 6!(, )()( )( 
& I * IJ AI&' )$ ///B !(* 	-$ %  -$&$ , * (& 
 $ + ,&#-""E *)++ (&  
( ?  +=* #)()&)> "E & &'  H- +&)( # ?'!& =)(* # +&!(*!$*A+-6@ ,&)>  $ 6@ ,&)> B ?  %-+& !"E )( Q / ,!+ +6$-.'&6E!$)+( $')(.&!"" . !().'&'% (*% (&>)"!&)(6 ,!-+ +% $)+(##),)!"!"" . *"E!,& *?)&'* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, &?!$*+&' $)+( $G++ $)-+% *),!"( *+'!&+&!(*!$*)+-( H-)>,!""E!+-6@ ,&)> +&!(*!$*I*!&I/2AC%!= &')+,!+ 4"!)(&)##?-"*( *&+'?&'!&&' *,&$KL!,&-!""E=( ?D!6-&!(F, ++)> $)+=!(**)+$ .!$* *&'!&$)+=B$ )%$&!(&"E
)J
	2J1&/0A//1B,-"*(&'!> 6 (%$ ," !$&'!&)&)+!+-6@ ,&)> +&!(*!$*# * $!",-$&+%-+&!"E)(,!+ ++-,'!+&')+J 
	 !&2/1 	& !&/01AC')+ ,!+  $ H-)$ + -+ & * #)(  &'  & $% P* ")6 $!&)(*)## $ (, G!+? *6E$ H-)$)(.!+'?)(.&'!&&' ##),)!"?!+ *#
+!?!$ #&' $)+=DBA%'!+)+!** *B7-&!+)+," !$#$%&' %!@$)&EG+)()(&' %!@$)&E!") +!(6@ ,&)> +&!(*!$*&,(,"-* &'!&$)+( +=)%!E'!>!,& *?)&'* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, &?!$*+ !$6 G++ $)-+% *),!"( *+?' $ )+&')+%$ ," !$&'!()(&' %!@$)&EG+$ "E)(.-(!(!##)*!>)&#$%!( F $&?)&( ++$	!$( "" %!=  -& &'  +-6@ ,&)>  +'?)(. &'!& $ H-)$ +!$( "" G+!##)*!>)&?-"*'!> &+!E&'!&	!$( "" =(?+#)$+&&'!&$)+( +=)!,&-!""E=( ? #!,&+ #$%?'),'!(
&'!&!$)+(*,&$%!E F')6)&* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, 6E)(& (&)(!""E* "!E)(.!,, ++&% *),!",!$ B
$&' #$ .)(.$ !+(+? &' *)+&$),&,-$&G+* ,)+)( & * (E $ )+( +=)G+ %&)( #$ +-%%!$E@-*.% (& 6!+ * -( H-!")#) * )%%-()&E !(* $ %!(* #$#-$&' $$, *)(.+
0(&)&" % (& (& & +&!(* &$)!" $ #!,  &'  &' $ 6-$* (+ #")&).!&)(GD #
,- 
	 2	&2J2JIA2BAH-&)(.#&
+&102
	JJ2IA/JBB.> $(% (&##),)!" $#$%)(.!*)+,$ &)(!$E#-(,&)()+ (&)&" *&H-!")#) *)%%-()&E#$%!+-)&#$,)>)"*!%!. +-(" ++')+!,&)(+'!> >)"!& *!," !$"E +&!6")+' *+&!&-&$E$,(+&)&-&)(!"$).'&
.#&I2*JJAI&')$//JBA,)&)(./0
-'1J0	   A/2BB  '-+ ! "!)(&)## %-+& $>  &?#!,&$+&+'?&'!&!.> $(% (&##),)!")+(& (&)&" *&H-!")#) *)%%-()&E#$%')++-)&5AB&'!&&' #!,&+!+!"" . *6E')%+'?!>)"!&)(#!,(+&)&-&)(!"$).'&!(*A2B&'!&+-,'>)"!& *$).'&?!+," !$"E +&!6")+' * #2	&!&2JJ !7 #$ ? !**$ ++&' % $)&+#$)+( +=)G+!$.-% (&+'? > $? %-+&#)$+&!**$ ++&' H- +&)(?' &' $? '!>@-$)+*),&)(> $$)+( +=)G+! !"' 	-$ % -$&'!+ F"!)( * &'!& ! *)+&$),& ,-$&G+ * ()!" # ! ,"!)% #H-!")#) *)%%-()&E&&'  F& (&&'!&)&&-$(+(!()++- #"!?)+!(! !"!6" #)(!"* ,)+)(?)&')(&' % !()(.#2	Q2/-(* $&' ,""!& $!"$* $*,&$)( #&
+&102
	JJA/JB
(1&
1JJ	1A//JB&' 	-$ % -$&,"!$)#) *&'!&&' #&* ,)+)(?!+ F"),)&"E")%)& *&! !"+,'!"" (.)(.("E&'-$ "E" .!")++- +#?' &' $&' !"" . *#!,&+!%-(& *&! ,(+&)&-&)(!" >)"!&)( !(* ?'!& "!? ?!+ ," !$"E+&!6")+' *!(*C(&!*)+&$),&,-$&G+* & $%)(!&)(!6-&?'!&#!,&-!")++- +!$ P. (-)( GD!&AH-&)(.(',9 4 JIA,BB  ' $ #$  C)( $* $ #$ !( )(& $",-&$E! !" & 6  !$$)!&  ! * # (*!(& + =)(. H-!")#) *)%%-()&E%-+&6 ?)"")(.&,(, * &&' #!,&+!+!"" . *6E&' "!)(&)##!(**)+,-++("E&' " .!")++- +$!)+ *6E&',!+ D&&
 //*2/J2//AI&')$///B#  J 
	 2I1 A2B   )& 
.&,+$
)!'I*/J/IAI&')$///B
( &')+ ,!+  6 ,!-+  $ )+( +=) '!+ +&)-"!& * & !$6 G+> $+)(#&'  #!,&+ #$-$+ +#! !"&')++- + )( &')+ ,!+  )(>">  ("E &'  " .!" H- +&)(+ #AB?' &' $&' #!,&+!+!"" . *6E !$6 +'?!>)"!&)(# ! ,(+&)&-&)(!" $).'& !(* A2B ?' &' $ &'!& $).'& ?' (>) ? * )( &'  + ,)#), ,(& F& # &')+ ,!+  ?!+ ," !$"E+&!6")+' * #2	&!&2JI1&JJ	 !& + ! $ +-"& ? '"*&'!&&' *)+&$),& ,-$&G+* ()!" # H-!")#) * )%%-()&E )+ ! C#)(!" * ,)+)(D -(* $Q2/!(*&'!&? '!> @-$)+*),&)(&* ,)* &')+,!+ (&'% $)&+ # &'  H-!")#) * )%%-()&E )++-    
&I*IJI/AI&')$///B"#$%&''!(($ >) ?#&' % $)&+#$)+( +=)G+! !"?,(,"-*  &'!& &'  *)+&$),& ,-$& *)* (& $$ )( * (E)(. $)+( +=)G+ %&)( #$ +-%%!$E @-*.% (& 6!+ * -(H-!")#) * )%%-()&E  
( &')+ ,!+   !$6  '!+ (& ("E!"" . * #!,&+ &'!& ?-"* $>  ! >)"!&)( # (  # ')+,(+&)&-&)(!"$).'&+' '!+!"++-,, ++#-""E+'?(&'!&+-,'$).'& ?!+ ," !$"E +&!6")+' *  (&  &'!& +)(,  $)+( +=)'!++&)-"!& *& !$6 G+> $+)(#&' #!,&+#$-$+ +#&')+! !"? %-+&>) ?C&'  >)* (, !""#!,&+!(*!(E)(# $ (, +&'!&%!E6 *$!?(#$%&' #!,&+)(&'").'&%+&#!>$!6" D& !$6 &
0"+ # 220 * I/ I22 AI&' )$ 2B &&//*!&2//)* $# !%
 ! !#$+, #)$+&,(,"-* &'!& !$6 '!+!"" . *#!,&+&'!&?' (>) ? * )( ')+ #!>$ ?-"* $>  ! >)"!&)( # ')+,(+&)&-&)(!"$).'&&'!> ')++ $)-+% *),!"( *+&$ !& *?)&'-& * ")6 $!&  )(*)## $ (,   
(* $ &'  ).'&'% (*% (&!$)+( $'!+!$).'&(&&'!> $)+(##),)!"+!,& ?)&' * ")6 $!&  )(*)## $ (,  & ')+ ' !"&' !(* +!# &E 
 ) J 
	 2J 2 A//1B( 
12/
	/01A/0IB' 	-$ % -$&'!+F"!)( *&'!& C* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, * +,$)6 + ! +&!& #%)(*%$ 6"!% ?$&'E&'!(( ."). (, D!(*&'!&)& (&!)"+
0+-6+&!(&)!" $)+= # + $)-+ '!$% !(* &'!& $ )+( +=)*)+$ .!$* *+-,'$)+=6E#!)")(.&&!= &' !,&)(+' =( ?? $  ( , ++!$E & !>)* &'  & (&)!""E + $)-+ '!$% & !$6 (+ H- (&"E!(*,(+)+& (&?)&'?'"*&'!& !$6 '!+ +&!6")+' *&'!&&' #!,&+!+!"" . *6E')%+'?!,(+&)&-&)(!">)"!&)(-
$&#$(#.$,&+, !"+,(,"-* &'!& !$6 '!++-,, ++#-""E$> (&'!& &'  !"" . *"E >)"!& * $).'& ?!+ ," !$"E +&!6")+' *"&'-.' ! .> $(% (& *,&$ )+ (&)&" * & H-!")#) *)%%-()&E)#' '!+% $ "E%!* !$ !+(!6" %)+&!= )(')+% *),!"@-*.% (&' )+(& (&)&" *&+-,')%%-()&E)#',$$ ,&"E  $, )> * !"" &'  $ " >!(& #!,&+ -(* $+&* &',(+ H- (, + # +-,' #!,&+ !(* *)+$ .!$* * &'+,(+ H- (, +)(')+&$ !&% (&#!!&) (& #2	&!&2JJ/J
	!&121+&' 	-$ %-$&'!+$  !& *"E$ ,.()R *!$)+( $'!+!$).'&(&&'!> ')++ $)-+% *),!"( *+*)+$ .!$* *6E')+*,&$+(12/
	!&1++-%)(.&'!&!@-$E!,, &+&'#!,&+!+!"" . *6E !$6 !(*6 ") > +&' !##)*!>)&#$!$( "" )(?'),'$	!$( "" ,"!)% *&'!&$)+( +=)!+! $+(?)&'!% *),!" *-,!&)(%-+&'!> 6 (!?!$ #&'  $)+= + * &  !$6  &' ( $ )+( +=)G+ !,&)(+,!((& -(* $ !"" $ " >!(& $ , * (&+ $ !+(!6"E 6,(+)* $ *&6 &' $ +-"&#!% $ $ !+(!6" %)+&!= $( ."). (, 6-&("E&'  $ +-"&#!,(+,)-+*)+$ .!$* #$ !$6 G+' !"&'
&)+," !$"E +&!6")+' *&'!&)#!*,&$=(?+#!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%&!!&) (&!(*)+!?!$ &'!& '  %-+& )&' $ + =)%% *)!&  !++)+&!(,  #$%!(&' $*,&$&$ > (&#-$&' $+ $)-+'!$%$%-+&)(#$%&' !&) (&&+ =)%% *)!& !++)+&!(,  "+ ?' $ !(*&' (#!)"+&*)(!&)% "E%!(( $?'!&')+&$!)()(.)(*),!& +)+( , ++!$E&$ > (&+-,''!$%&'!&*,&$'!+&$ !& *&'!&) (&?)&'* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, J
	!&0 A+&!&)(. &'!& ! $)+( *,&$ %!E F')6)& * ")6 $!&)(*)## $ (, )#' C=(?+!(**)+$ .!$*+!( F, ++)> $)+=&)(%!& ' !"&'$+!# &EDB(12/
	!&1JA(&)(.I
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	 ,)#),!""E  !$6  '!+ +-6%)&& *$#&'!&+-$&+')+,(& (&)(&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&&' #"-)*)( !$6 G+!6*% (?!+6)" !(*&'!&&' 6)",!% #$%!" !=&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&&' 6)" " !=)# (& +& * )%% *)!& "E ?-"* F+   !$6  & !
/C+% &')(." ++&'!(!,&+$%)++)(+#$&' > $E-$+ #,!-+)(. '!$% $ ?)&' =(?" *.  &'!& '!$% ?)"" $ +-"&D J 
	 !& J( 12/ 
	 !& J AC(!,,)* (&!"&'-.')&%!E$*-, !** *!(.-)+')+(&(&'!&6!+)+!"( &6 ,'!$!,& $)R *!+?!(&()(#"),&)(#-(( , ++!$E!)(DB(+ H- (&"E!$)+(##),)!")+("EC#-(*")!6" -(* $&' ).'&'% (*% (&#$* (E)(.!()(%!&  '-%!(  ,(*)&)(+ # ,(#)( % (& K)#L &'  ##),)!"=(?+#!(**)+$ .!$*+!( F, ++)> $)+=&)(%!& ' !"&'$+!# &EDJ
	!&0+&' 	-$ % -$&F"!)( * C& #   &  0  # 0&#&&## 0&  &2& 0&#DA %'!+)+!** *B
 #J02*J0IAI&')$/0IBA(&)(.&'!&,-$&+!$ (&C& (.!.)(&' $, ++#+ ,(*.- ++)(.)( > $E,!+ &' !* H-!,E#% *),!",!$ &'!&&' +&!& $>)* +DBA,)&!&)(%)&& *BC&&
#&&3 0' 3 # *#&  0+#'### #    !(* ! #!,&#)(* $ %!E ,(,"-*  &'!& ! $)+(##),)!"=( ?#!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#$%&' > $E#!,&&'!&&'$)+= ?!+ 6>)-+D   J 
	 !& 12 A %'!+)+!** *B)
/*2J22/AI&')$//1B(&')+,!+  !$6 '!+$ + (& *#!,&-!" >)* (, ?'),'?' (>) ? *)(!").'&%+&#!>$!6" &')%?-"*$>&'!& $ )+( +=) ?!+ !?!$  # #!,&+ &'!& +-$& * !()(# $ (, #!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%& !$6 !(*&'!& $ )+( +=) '!* 6&' *$!?( !(* *)+$ .!$* * &'!&)(# $ (, ?' (' ,"+ * !$6 G++-$.),!")(,)+)((-"E//I!(*&' (#!)" *&&!= &' !,&)(&'!&')+&$!)()(.)(*),!& * ?!+ ( , ++!$E & +& &'  6)"  " != )( ! &)% "E%!(( $  + &'  	-$ %  -$& F"!)( * )( !$)+( $ C( *(& +'?&'!& K&' L$)+(##),)!" !,& *$#!)" *&!,&6 ") >)(.&'!&'!$%!,&-!""E?-"*6 #!"" K&'$)+( $&$> !>)"!&)(#')+).'&'% (*% (&$).'&L)&)+ (-.'K#$&' $)+( $&+'?L&'!&&' ##),)!"!,& *
7RVXSSRUW KLV IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV WKDW 'U :LVQHVNL NQHZ WKDW WKHIOXLG LQ /H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZDV ELOH DQG WKDW 'U :LVQHVNL NQHZ WKDW WKHELOH FDPH IURP D OHDN /H0DUEH SURYLGHG WKH IROORZLQJ HYLGHQFH/H0DUEH SUHVHQWHGGHSRVLWLRQ WHVWLPRQ\ IURP 'U 7DFLD LQ ZKLFK 'U7DFLD DVVHUWHGWKDW WKH PXGG\ \HOORZLVKEURZQ IOXLG KH HQFRXQWHUHG LQ/H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZDVFOHDUO\ELOH 'XULQJ KLV GHSRVLWLRQ 'U 7DFLDVWDWHG WKDW KH FRXOG WHOO WKH IOXLG LQ /H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZDV ELOH 3>M@XVWE\ ORRNLQJ DW LW%LOLDU\IOXLG KDV D \HOORZLVK FRORU WR LW ,W¶V VOLJKWO\WKLFN $QG WKLV ORRNHG H[DFWO\ OLNH ELOLDU\ IOXLG ́ -$ DW  7DFLD 'HSDW  $GGLWLRQDOO\ /H0DUEH SUHVHQWHG WHVWLPRQ\ IURP 'U :LVQHVNLKLPVHOI ZKLFK VXJJHVWHG WKDW 'U:LVQHVNLNQHZ WKDW WKH IOXLG LQ/H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZDV ELOH -$ DW  )RU H[DPSOH 'U :LVQHVNLDVVHUWHG WKDW WKH IOXLG 3ORRNHG OLNH DVFLWLF IOXLG ́ EXW 3IURP WKH FRORU RI LW>KH@WKRXJKW LW ZDV>ELOLDU\ IOXLG EHFDXVH@ >L@W ZDV OLJKWO\ WLQJHG \HOORZDQG WKHUH LVQ¶W DQ\WKLQJ LQ WKH DEGRPHQ WKDW ZRXOG JLYH LW WKDW FRORU RWKHUWKDQ ELOH ́ -$ DW  :LVQHVNL 'HS DW  )LQDOO\ /H0DUEH SUHVHQWHGHYLGHQFH WR VXSSRUW KLV DOOHJDWLRQ WKDW 'U :LVQHVNLNQHZ WKDW WKHELOHFDPH IURP D OHDN 6XFK HYLGHQFH LQFOXGHG DQ DIILGDYLW IURP 'U 6DUQHOOHVWDWLQJ WKDW DQ\ JHQHUDO VXUJHRQ ZKR KDG HQFRXQWHUHG WKH ILYH OLWHUV LQ/H0DUEH¶V VWRPDFK ZRXOG KDYH NQRZQ WKDW WKH 3>E@LOH ZDV OHDNLQJ IURPVRPH SODFH ́ -$ DW 6DUQHOOH $II /H0DUEH DOVR SURYLGHGGHSRVLWLRQ WHVWLPRQ\ IURP 'U :LVQHVNL ZKR WHVWLILHG WR ORRNLQJ IRU WKHVRXUFH RI WKH OHDN GXULQJ WKH -XO\  H[SORUDWRU\ VXUJHU\ DQG WRVHHNLQJ KHOS IURP 'U (LFKXP WR ILQG WKH VRXUFH RI WKH OHDN -$ DW :LVQHVNL 'HS DW  'U :LVQHVNL DOVR WHVWLILHG4 <RXZRXOG WKLQN WKDW KH KDG D ELOH OHDN RU D ELOHREVWUXFWLRQ E\ ORRNLQJ DW WKHVH ODE UHVXOWV E\ORRNLQJ DW WKH HOHYDWHG ELOLUXELQ RQ -XO\ WK "$#!)" *&!,&* +)& ')+=(?" *. #!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%DJ
	!&12# 
#
 '/,,!%&&!&%.#!#$0%& 1#'
 $!)$+& ?  ,(,"-*  &'!&  !$6  '!+ !"" . * #!,&+ &'!&?' (>) ? *)(!").'&%+&#!>$!6" &')%?-"*+'?&'!&$)+( +=)?!+!?!$ ##!,&+#$%?'),'!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+= # + $)-+ '!$% ,-"* 6  )(# $$ *   ' +  #!,&+ !$ 5AB &'!& $ )+( +=) (,-(& $ * #)>  ")& $+ # #"-)* )( !$6 G++&%!,'(-"E//I!(*=( ?&'!&&' #"-)*?!+6)" A2B&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&&' 6)" ,!% #$%!" !=AB&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&' '!*(&+& *
J).($ *GDB	)%)"!$"E&' #!,&&'!&$)+( +=) > (&-!""E$ # $$ *  !$6  & ! + ,)!")+& * + (& !-&%!&),!""E)%%-()R  $ )+( +=) #$% ")!6)")&E #$  !$6 G+)(& $> ()(. )(@-$) +  $ !+ %!(E # * $!" ,-$&+ '!>$ ,.()R * ! * ")6 $!& "E )(*)## $ (& * "!E )( .)>)(. $6&!)()(.&$ !&% (&%!E!"+!%-(&&!>)"!&)(-(* $&').'&'% (*% (&'#('
+2*212J0A&')$///B( +-% ?  ,(,"-* &'!& ?' ( >) ? *)( !").'& %+&#!>$!6" & !$6 &' #!,&+!+!"" . *!(*+-$& *6E !$6 A&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&&' #"-)*?!+6)" ?!+!?!$ #&' +-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%!+ F"!)( *6E$	!$( "" !(*#!)" *&+ =!* H-!& ' "&+&&' 6)"" !=)(!&)% "E%!(( $* +)& +-,'=(?" *. B+'?&'!&$)+( +=) ," !$"E !,& * ?)&' ! ,(+,)-+ *)+$ .!$* #$ !$6 G+' !"&'!(*+!# &E!(*>)"!& * !$6 G+).'&'% (*% (&$).'&&'!> ')++ $)-+% *),!"( *+!&& (* *&?)&'-&* ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, 
(&' $?$*+? 6 ") >&'!& !$6 '!+$!)+ *%$ &'!(@-+&!+)%" H- +&)(#?' &' $$)+( +=)%!* &'  $).'&% *),!"@-*.% (&)(&$ !&)(.')%(&'!&+ (+ ? 6 ") > &'!& !$6 G+,!+ )+$ $"E*)+&)(.-)+'!6"  #$%&')+ ,-$&G+ $ , (&"E * ,)* * ( 6!(,* ,)+)()(
&I*IJAI&')$///BA (6!(,B
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
1) '  & 
 #
+ 0 #+ #  
  
  
* &
J '!&&' 6)" " !=,-"*6 ",!& *6E!')*!+,!($$ $+&F+-$ #&' ,%%(6)"*-,& ,-"* 6  *(  *-$)(. &'  $, *-$  (0NN/II"&&# #&&&&&
0&&'2
#2&!&1A	!$( "" ##BA %'!+)+!** *B 6 ") > &'!&&')+ !##)*!>)& )# !,, & * !+ &$-  ?-"* $>  &'!& $)+( +=)G+#!)"-$ &+ =' "&+& !$6 G+6)" " !=)(! &)% "E %!(( $ ,(+&)&-& * ! ,(+,)-+ *)+$ .!$* #$ !$6 G+' !"&'J
	!&0A'"*)(.&'!&!$)+(##),)!"%!E6 ")!6" -(* $&' ).'&'% (*% (&#$* (E)(.!()(%!& '-%!( ,(*)&)(+)#' =(?+#!(**)+$ .!$*+!( F, ++)> $)+=&&' )(%!& G+' !"&'B+ 
 )'' 10J 
	 J 1 A/IB A(&)(. &'!&H-!")#) *)%%-()&EC$>)* +!%" $& ,&)(&!""6-&&'"!)("E)(,% & (&DB' #!,&&'!& !$6 ?!++ (6E$)+( +=)!(*&' $+&!##!#& $')+ F"$!&$E+-$. $E(-"E//I* +(&( , ++!$)"E )%%-()R  $ )+( +=) #$% ")!6)")&E #$ ')+!,&)(+.> $(% (&*,&$'!+!*-&E&*%$ &'!(+)%"E$>)* +% &$ !&% (&&!$)+( $?''!++ $)-+% *),!" ( *+ )(+& !* &'  *,&$ %-+& $>)*  % *),!"&$ !&% (& & &'  !&) (& ?)&'-& ,(+,)-+"E F+)(. &'!&) (&&!( F, ++)> $)+=#+ $)-+'!$%+&' 	 > (&')$,-)& $ , (&"E $ ,.()R * )(& C! $)+( $ )+ (&$ H-)$ *&+'?&'!&' ?!+")& $!""E).($ *6E&' +&!##D&$> !().'&'% (*% (&>)"!&)(("E&'!&')++ $)-+% *),!"( *+? $ ,(+,)-+"E*)+$ .!$* *&22*!&I2AC
#=(?)(.&'!&!!&) (&#!, +!+ $)-+$)+=#! (*),)&)+&' $)+(##),)!".)> +&' !&) (&!(!+)$)(!(*!( ( %!!(*+ (*+')%6!,=&')+, ""!@-$E,-"*#)(** ")6 $!& )(*)## $ (, !"&'-.'&' $)+( $?!+(&P+)%"E
$ , PHDQ WKDW¶V ZKDW , ZRXOG LQWHUSUHW WKDW DV4$QG \RX QH[W VDZ >/H0DUEH@ -XO\ WK "$ <HV4 $QG ZRXOG \RXWHOO XV ZKDW \RX FKDUWHG RQ WKDWGD\"$ , ZURWH WKH SDWLHQW LV IHHOLQJ PXFK EHWWHU WKDQ\HVWHUGD\ +LV ERZHOV DUH PRYLQJ KH¶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́ -$ DW  :LVQHVNL 'HS DW  /H0DUEH DOVR SURYLGHGHYLGHQFH WR VKRZ WKDW 'U :LVQHVNL GLG QRW UHIHU KLP WR D VSHFLDOLVW XQWLOQHDUO\ WZR ZHHNV DIWHU KLV H[SORUDWRU\ VXUJHU\ RQ $XJXVW   -$DW  :LVQHVNL 'HS DW ,Q VXSSRUW RI WKLV IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQ /H0DUEH VXEPLWWHG DQ DIILGDYLWIURP 'U 6DUQHOOH LQ ZKLFK 'U 6DUQHOOH GHFODUHG WKDW DQ\ JHQHUDO VXUJHRQZKR KDG HQFRXQWHUHG ILYH OLWHUV RI ELOH LQ /H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ ZRXOG&' 6)" " !=?' (' ,"+ * !$6 G++-$.),!")(,)+)(#$%&'  F"$!&$E +-$. $E ( -"E  //I  A1B &'!& $)+( +=)%!* ()%% *)!& "!(+&+ =' "&+&&'6)" " !=!#& $' + ? * !$6 6!,=-!(*AJB&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&)#&' " !=? $ (&&)% "E,"+ *&' 6)"?-"* ,(&)(- &" != !(* ?-"* ,!-+  !$6  + $)-+'!$%2
KDYHNQRZQ WKDW3>L@I VXUJHU\ ZDV WHUPLQDWHG DQG WKH VXUJLFDO LQFLVLRQZDV FORVHG WKH ELOH ZRXOG FRQWLQXH WR OHDN ́ DQG WKDW 3>E@LOH OHDNLQJ LQWRWKH SHULWRQHDO FDYLW\ ZRXOG FHUWDLQO\ FDXVH SDLQIXO VHYHUH DQG SHUPDQHQWLQWHUQDO LQMXULHV WR WKH SDWLHQW ́ -$ DW  6DUQHOOH $II /H0DUEH DOVRSURYLGHG GHSRVLWLRQ WHVWLPRQ\ IURP 'U :LVQHVNL LQ ZKLFK 'U :LVQHVNLDGPLWWHG WR KLVFRQFHUQV DERXW WKH IXUWKHU FROOHFWLRQ RI WKH SRWHQWLDOO\FDXVWLFELOH IOXLG LQ/H0DUEH¶V DEGRPHQ :KHQ DVNHG LI 'U :LVQHVNLZDV 3FRQFHUQHG WKDW DIWHU >KH@ VHZHG >/H0DUEH@ EDFN XS WKDW WKH IOXLGZRXOG FROOHFW DJDLQ ́ KH DQVZHUHG 3$EVROXWHO\ ́ -$ DW  :LVQHVNL'HS DW ' (>) ? *)(!").'&%+&#!>$!6" & !$6 !""#&'  !#$ % (&)( * #!,&+ A?'),'%-+&6  ,(, * *6E$)+( +=)#$&' -$+ +#&')+H-!")#) *)%%-()&E$ >) ?B?-"*$ H-)$ &' ,(,"-+)(&'!&$)+( +=)=( ?&'!&!+-6+&!(&)!" $)+=# + $)-+'!$%& !$6  F)+& * 
&)+-(*)+-& *&'!&&' +& !*E" !=#"!$. H-!(&)&) +#6)" )(& !$6 G+!6*% ($ + (& *!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%&')+' !"&'!(*&'!&+-,'!" !=,(&)(- *&$ + (&!+-6+&!(&)!" $)+= # + $)-+ '!$% &  !$6  -(&)" )& ?!++& *
(* *)(')+!##)*!>)&$	!$( "" -( H-)>,!""E* ,"!$ *CK&L' $)+=#'!$%K#$%&' 6)" " !=L&),'!$* !$6 (0NN/I?!+ F&$ % !(*
 +0&# #+

D !&1A	!$( "" ##BA %'!+)+!** *BJ
	!&12 A'"*)(.&'!&C! #!,&#)(* $%!E,(,"-* &'!&!$)+(##),)!"=( ?#!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#$%&' > $E#!,&&'!&&'$)+=?!+6>)-+DB&
'22*IJIA0&' )$ 2B A(&)(. )( ! ,!+  ?' $  &'  % *),!" +&!##+-+ ,& *! (*),&)+6-&#!)" *&&$ !&)&&'!&CK!L@-$E,-"*-(* $+&!(*&' (&!&)(P$-" -&! (*),)&)+G&% !(&'!&+-##),) (&& +&+ +'-"* 6   $#$% *& ")%)(!& &'!& !+ !& (&)!",!-+ #K&' $)+( $G+L!)(DB
(+-%? '"*&'!&  !$6  '!+ +-,, ++#-""E !"" . * #!,&+ ?'),' ?' (!,, & *!+&$- ?-"*$> &'!&$)+( +=)?!+!?!$ #&' #!,&+#$%?'),'!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%,-"*6 )(# $$ *
. #2!+,&!%&&!&%.#!#$0%& 1#'	!&+#!+,(*? ,(,"-* &'!& !$6 '!+!"" . *#!,&+?'),'?' (>) ? *)(!").'&%+&#!>$!6" &')%?-"*+'?&'!&$)+( +=)*$ ?&' )(# $ (, &'!& !$6 #!, *!+-6+&!(&)!" $)+= # + $)-+ '!$% #$% &'  6)"  " != )( ')+!6*% (!(*&'!&$)+( +=)*)+$ .!$* *+-,'$)+=?' ('   ,"+ *  !$6 G+ +-$.),!" )(,)+)( ( -"E  //I#!)" *&$ # $ !$6 +&!+ ,)!")+&?',-"*+&&' " !=!(*!"+#!)" *&)(#$% !$6 #&' #!)"-$&+&&' " !=+&'!& !$6 ,-"*&!= !(E!**)&)(!"% !+-$ +( , ++!$E&+&&' " !=+$ H- +&% *),!"&$ !&% (&#$%!+ ,)!")+&?',-"*+&&' " !=  	 ,)#),!""E  !$6  '!+ $>)* * !( !##)*!>)&#$%$	!$( "" ?'+?$ &'!&C+0&# #!(*KL+

D?' (,-(& $ *#)> ")& $+#6)" )(!!&) (&G+!6*% (?-"*'!> =(?(&'!&&' 6)")(  !$6 G+ !6*% ( ?!+ *-  & ! " != !(* &'!& +-,',(*)&)(+ *!+-6+&!(&)!"$)+=#+ $)-+'!$%& !$6)# &'  " != ?!+ (& ,"+ * $ +& * 6 #$   $%!( (&*!%!.  ,,-$$ *   !& 1 A	!$( ""  ##B A %'!+)+!** *B  
( + *)(. $ 	!$( ""  $>)* * &'  #""?)(.F"!(!&)(5+ '  ' ()(. ),'!$*  !$6 G+ $)&( !",!>)&E(0NN/I!(*+ )(.J")& $+#6)"?'),''!*!,,-%-"!& * +)(, !,'" ,E+& ,&%E ).'&*!E+ !$") $?-"*=(?5)0'
#2"&&#

&  '+ 0  !(* &'  +-$.),!")(,)+)(?!+,"+ *  '+ 0   &  '###&0 #