0 8 -2 8 2 9 -cv

N u r a l d i nv. Col u cci

1 

### U N I TED STATES C O U R T O F A P P EA LS 2 

### F O R TH E SE C O N D C IR C U IT 3 4 

### SU M M A RYORD ER 5 6 7 RULING S B Y SUM M ARY O RDER D O NO T H AVE P RECEDENTIAL EF F ECT. C I TATIO N TO A SUMM ARY O RDER 8 F ILED O N O R AF TER JANUARY 1, 200 7, IS P ERM ITTED AND IS G O VERNED B Y F EDERAL RULE O F AP P ELLATE 9 P RO CEDURE 32
. 1 AND TH IS CO URT’S LO CAL RULE 32
. 1. 1. W H EN CITI NG A SUM M ARY O RDER IN A D O CUM ENT 10 F ILEDW I T H T H I S C O UR T , A PA RT Y MUST C ITE EITHER THE F ED ER AL A P P EN DIX O R AN EL EC TR O NIC D AT ABASE 11 ( W I T H T HE N OT A T I ON “ S U MM A R Y OR D E R ” )
. A PA R T Y C I T I N G A S U MM A R Y OR D E R MU S T S E R

V E AC OPY O F 12 IT O N ANY P ARTY NO T REP RESENTED B Y CO UNSEL. 13 14 15 A t a s ta te d t e r m o f th e U ni te d S ta te s C o urt o f A pp e a l s f

o r th e Se c o nd C ir c ui t, 16 he l d at the Da nie l P atric k M oy niha n Un ite d State s Co urthous e , 500 P e arl Str e e t, in 17 the C ity o f

Ne w Y or k, on the 22 dayof April , two tho us and te n. nd 18 1 9 PR

ESEN T: 2 0 AM AL Y A L . K EAR SE, 2 1 R O B E R T D

. S AC K, 2 2 D EB R A A NN L IV IN G STO N , 23 Cir cuit Judges

. 24

______________________________________________________ 25 26 Yus uf

J

. Nural di

n , F o un der an d Pr es i den

t o f “ K AL E IDOSCOPE ” 27 (“ Z eb ra T eam ”) o n b eh al f o f h i m s el f an d all o t h er si m i l arl y s i t uat ed 2 8 Z e b ra

Te am me m b e r(s )/A s s o c i at e s (1 s t A

me n dme n t A s s o c i at i o n

R i g h t s , 2 9 w i

t h) An t ho ny Far e l l a S r

. , P o l i c e O f

f i c e r& p art

- t i

me c e nt r o e m

p l o ye e ; 30 M rs. Fe l i ci a A

. T o wn s en d, 31 32 P laintif f -A ppellant , 33 34 v
. 08-2829- cv 35 36 Ro b ert Co l

ucci Jr. , Ch ai rman , Bo ard o f

Di rect o rs, CE NTRO, Bri an M

. Sch ul t , Vi ce 37 Ch ai

rman , Bo ard o f

Di rect o rs, CE NTRO, W arr en F ran k, F o rmer CEO, CENT RO , J o e 3 8 C a l a

br e s e , Fo rme rC E O , C E N T R O , Fr ank Ko bl i s k i , Fo rme rC E O , C E N T R O , J o hn 3 9 R e n o c k , Se n i o r V P of O p e rat i o n s , C EN TR O , J o e D e g ray , V P of O p e rat i o n s , C EN TR O , 4 0 Stev e Sh are , V P of F i n a n c e , C EN TR O , R i c h ard

L e e , V P of

H uman R e s o urc e s , 4 1 C EN TR O , G ary N o rdh e i m , Em p l o ye e R e l at i o n s M an a g e r, C EN TR O , J a c k i e M u s e n g o , 4 2 B e n e f

i ts M an a g e r , C E N T R O , A u dr e y T u c k e r , L i g h

t D uty C oor d i n ator , C E N T R O , L e o 4 3 W i l l i am s , L o e a d O ut s i d e Su

p e rv i s o r, C EN TR O , D av e M i x , Su p e rv i s o r, C EN TR O , 4 4 D uk e B a ile y, S u p e rv is o r , C E N T R O , A

n g e la G h o ls t o n , S u

p e rv is o r , C E N T R O , D arryl 4 5 V an d e r

p o o l, O ut s id e S u

p e rv is o r , C E N T R O , E li

z a b e t h U n is la w s k i, P e r s o n a l S e c r e t ary

o f 4 6 Se n i o r V P J o h n R e n o c k , C EN TR O , Pat t y D i s h aw , M a

n a g e r S e rv i c e D e v e l o p me n t ,2 1 C EN TR O , J o e Sp e rat o , D i s p at c h Su p e rv i s o r, C EN TR O , C ra i g W i l li am s , F o rme r D i r. 2 o f

Human Re s o urces , CENT RO , T o m Sh all cro s s , F o rmer Ma

n ager o f all CENT RO 3 s u

p e rv is o r s , M ik e J a

b lin s k i, F o rme rE mp lo ye e R e lat io n s M an a g e r , C E N T R O , C ar l 4 B ak e r, F o rme r Em p l o ye e R e l at i o n s M an a g e r, C EN TR O , Sc o t t V an d e rp o o l , F o rme r 5 M ana g e rS u

p e rvi s o r , C E N T R O , Wave r l y Fa i s o n, S e c ur i

t y , C E N T R O , S haw n 6 M c M an

u s , B u s O p e rat o r, C EN TR O , R o b e rt C . Sp ra g u e Jr., F o rme r C h i e f A dm i n

. 7 O f

f i c e r, C EN TR O , Kat h

y F u l l e r, S u

p e rv i s o r of

R e g i o n a l Tran s p o rt at i o n

C e n t e r, 8 C EN TR O , W arre n W o o dru f

f , M an a g e r RTC , C EN TR O , A n g e li c M a s o n , Su

p e rv i s o r, 9 C E N T R O , D ave Kr i e s a l , Fo rme rS u p e rvi s o r , C E N T R O , L o n L ar g e , D i s p at c h 1 0 Su

p e rv i s o r, C EN TR O , Ed

M u e l l ar, F o rme r Un i o n

V P, F ran

k M i l l e r, F e rra

ra , F i o re nz a , 1 1 L arri s o n , B arre t t & R e i t z , P.C ., C EN TR O ` s L awF i rm , C ra i g M . A

t l a s , F e rra ra , F i o re nz a , 1 2 L arri s o n , B arre t t & R e i t z , P.C ., C EN TR O ` s L awF i rm , F e rra ra , F i o re nz a , L arri s o n , 1 3 B arre t t & R e i t z , P., C EN TR O ` s L awF i rm , M i l e s L aw l o r, F e rra ra , F i o re nz a , L arri s o n , 1 4 B arr e t t & R e it z , P

. C

. , C E N T R O ` s L awF irm, A ma lg amat e d

T r an it U n io n , I n

t e rn at io n a l 1 5 an d

/or L o c a l 5 8 0 , W arre n

G e o rg e , In

t e rn at i o n a l

U n i o n Pr e s i d e n t , J o s e p h W e l c h , 1 6 In

t e rn at i o n a l

V P, C h u c k W at s o n , B u s i

n e s s A g e n

t , Se c re t ary

Tre a s ure r, J o h

n C am p b e l l , 1 7 F o rme r Un i o n Pr e s ., D o rot h

y H un t e r, F o rme r Un i o n

V P, P re s ., M ary

N e g u e n t , F o rme r 1 8 U n i o n

Se c ., A l Pa rk e r, F o rme r Un i o n

V P, B i l l M o n t roy , U n i o n

R e p ., H o me r D av i s , 1 9 F o rme r Tri a l

C o m m i t t e e In v e s t i g at o r, B o n

n i e K re l l , U n i o n

M e m b e r, B o bF a i

rc h i l d , 2 0 U ni o n M e m

be r , M i k e C o nw ay , U ni o n M e m be r , M ary

J ane T o rt o r i c i , Fo rme rU ni o n 2 1 B o ar d

M e m be r , P e rry

T ar qu i no , R e t i r e d M e m be r , E l li o t t R o u s e , R e t i

r e d U ni o n 2 2 M e m

b e r, C arl t o n D e rb y , U n i o n

M e m b e r, Ty ron e B urk e , F o rme r C EN TR O Su p e rv i s o r, 2 3 n o wU n io n , S c o t t H amil t o n , U n io n

B o ar d M e mb e r , Ke n

n e t h O rr , F o rme rU n io n

T r ia l 2 4 C o mmi

t t e e , D an a

M c M ah o n , U n io n

T r ia l C o mmi

t t e e , B ill M in e r , U n io n

T r ia l 2 5 C o m

m i t t e e , J e f f Ke l l e r, Un i o n

Tri a l C o m m i t t e e , F ran

k C h a p man , V P, J o h

n Z i e m b a , 26 f

o rmerUn i o n

Bo ar d Mem

b er , S t eph an i e A

. Mi

n er , Bli t man &K i n g, Un i o n Lo cal 58 0`s 27 Lawyer s, N. Y. S t at e W o rker s Co m pen sat i o n Bo ar d, Kar l

A

. Hen ry , NY S t at e W o rker s 2 8 C o mp e n s at io n B o ar d , S c o t t C

. F ir e s t o n e , N YS t at e W o rk e r s C o mp e n s at io n B o ar d , C ar o l 29 G. McM an

us , NY St at e W o rker s Co m pen s at i o n Bo ard, J udge B o h er, W CB St at e 3 0 Em

p l o ye e , V an e s s a

E. J a c k s o n , C o urt Steno g ra p h e r, M i c h e l e Z a

j a c , W C B A dm

i n , 3 1 M i c h a e l

J . O ` B ri e n , W C B A

t t o rn e y , A

t t o rn e y W o o d s , C EN TR O ` s W C B L aw ye r, 32 A

t t o rn ey Ri ch mo n d, CENT RO ` s W CB L awy er, PE RM A , CENT RO ` s W CB In s uran ce 3 3 C arr i e r , J an e M ok ay , A g e n t P E RM A , RM S C O , C E N T R O ` S D i s a b i li ty N o- F a u l t 34 In s uran ce C arr i er, J an e M i l es , A gen t RM SCO, N. Y. S t at e Un em pl o y t men t In s uran ce 35 Bo ard, J an e Do e-Ch ai rper s o n NYS, Un em

pl o y men t In s uran ce B o ard, Ch ai

rper s o n NY 3 6 S tate U n e m

p l oy m e n t I n s ur an c e B oa

r d , J oh n D oe - I n tak e S p e c i a li s t N Y S U n e m p oy me n t 37 In s ura, Do n

L i v i n gs t o n , Ca s e M an ager Speci ali s t , NY St at e Un em pl o y men t In s uran ce 38 B o ard, Z uri c h A me ri c an In s uran c e C o m

pa n y , J o h n Doe- C h a i

rpe rs o n NY S 39 Un em

pl y men t In s uran ce, Ch ai

rper s o n , NY St at e Unem

pl o y men t In s uran ce B o ard, J an e 4 0 D o e - R

M SC O , C EO , RM SC O , J o h n D o e - R M SC O , C EO , RM SC O , J an e D o e 4 1 P E RM A, C E O , P E RM A, J o hn D o e - P E RM A, C E O , P E RM A, J ane D o e - Z ur i c h 4 2 A

me ri c an In s uran c e C o m

p an y , C EO , J o h

n D o e - Z uri c h

A me ri c an In s uran c e C o m

p an y , 4 3 C E O , Ad o l f

o S

. H e rnand e z , C l a i

m s E xam i ne r , C e nt r a l

N e wY o rk

T r ans p o rt at i o n 4 4 A

ut h o ri t y , C EN TR O B o ard

o f D i re c t o rs , H .J . H u

b e rt , Tre a s ure r, G . J o s e p h C h a li f o u x , 4 5 M e m

b e r, N i c h o l a s F . L a i

n o , M e m b e r, V i n c e n t A . O ` N e i l , M e m

b e r, D arl e n e D

. 46 L at t i

m o re, Secret ary , Deraux

L

. Bran ch , M em

b er, M ary

Dav i s , A dv i s o r, St at e o f New 4 7 Y o rk

U n if ie d C o urt S ys t e m, O n o n d a g a S u p r e me C o urt , O n o n d a g a

C o un t y C o urt , M ary3 1 Th o ma s o n , D e b o rah Sto l t z , M ary L o uC rowl e y , W i l li am

R . R o y , H o n o ra

b l e J u s t i c e , 2 M at t h ew E. Be rger t o n , A t t o rn ey , Sat t er & A

n drews, L L P, E l li e R

us t o n , F o rmer Out s i de 3 Su

p e rv i s o r, 4 5 Def endants -A ppellees

. 6

______________________________________________________ 7 8 F O R

APP EL L A

N T: Y u s u f

J . N ura l d i

n , pro se , L i

v erpo o l , New Y o rk. 9 10 F OR

APPE L L E E S: M i l es G. Law l o r; F err ara, F i o renza, L arr i s o n , Ba rr et t &Re i

t z; 11 E as t Sy racus e, New Yo rk, f

o r Def en dan t s -A ppell ees 12 F ran k Ko b li s ki , J o h

n Re n o ck, Jo s eph

DeGray , St ev en

Sh are, 13 an d Ri ch ard Le e. 14 15 A

ppeal f ro m t h e M ay 22, 2008 po s t -j udgmen

t o rdero f t h e Uni t ed St at es Di s t ri ct
1 6 C o urt f

o r t h e N o rt h e rn

D i s t ri c t o f

N e wY o rk

(H urd , J. ).

17 UP ON DUE CONSID ER AT I ON I T I S HERE B Y ORDE RE D, ADJUDGED,

18 AND DE CRE ED t h at t h e o rdero f t h e di s t ri ct co urt b e AFF IRM ED

. 1 9 A

p p e l l an t Y u s u f J . N ura l d i

n , pro se , appea l s f

ro m t h e di s t ri ct co urt ’ s M ay

22, 2008

2 0 p os t-

j u d g me n t or d e rd e n

y i n g h i s moti on

“ to ame n d

ormak e a d d i

ti on a l f i n d i n g s ” an d “ f or
2 1 r ec o n si d er at i o n o f j u d g ment and mo d i f

i ca t i o n o rcl ar i f i ca t i o n o f ” t h e d i st r i ct co urt ’s

22 F eb ruar y

15 , 20 08 o r derdi sm

i ssi n g h i s ci v i l r i ght s co m

pl ai n t

. W e assume t h e par t i es’

2 3 f

am i l i ari t y w i t h t h e un d e rl

y i n g f a c t s , p roce d

ura l hi s t o ry o f t h e c a s e , a

n d i s s u e s o n a p p e a l

. 2 4 Up o n d

u e c o ns i d e r at i o n o f

t he d i s t r i c t c o urt r e c o r d

and t he p art i e s ’ s u

bm i s s i o ns , w e f

i nd no
2 5 a

b u s e o f d i s c re t i o n

i n t h e d i s t ri c t c o urt ’ s d e c i s i o n

. See Se qua Cor p. v. GBJ C

or p. , 156 F

. 3d

2 6 1 3 6 , 1 4 3 (2 d

C i r. 1 9 9 8 ); Trans aero, Inc. v. L a F uer za A erea Boli viana , 162 F

. 3d 724, 729

2 7 (2 d

C i r. 1 9 9 8 ).

2 8 F o rt h e fo r e g o in g r e a s o n s , t h e o r d e ro f t h e d is t r ic t c o urt is h e r e b y AFF IRM ED

. 29 3 0 F O R TH E C O U R T: 3 1 C at h e ri n e O ’ H a g an

W o l f e , C l e rk

32